Slashdot Mirror


User: scotch

scotch's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
1,593
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 1,593

  1. Re:I don't understand on The Demise of IP? · · Score: 1
    Wow, what fantasy world do you live in? Are you really denying that reasonable people won't disagree about what is fair?

    Anarchy favors those with the best weapons.

  2. Re:Easily refuted on The Demise of IP? · · Score: 1
    In a world free of copyright, the only value in information is secrecy, which would lead to much less information sharing.

    That might be true if secrecy weren't so hard to maintain. Secrecy would still be important to some industries, but the freedom of even the binaries would completely change how markets look and make source code protection obsolete for many companies.

  3. Re:Vurt on Top 20 Geek Novels · · Score: 1

    Seconded - I've read "Vurt" and "Pixel Juice", so far. If you haven't read Vurt or any other Jeff Noon stuff, do your self a favor and give it a try. Definitely some wacky shit. Not for everyone, naturally.

  4. Re:My review on Jack Thompson vs Amazon? · · Score: 1
    It's not about the anonymity. Your observations are all correct, of course, but irrelevant. It's about the 'C', not the 'A'. You can't have a conversation with an AC. You can't tell which AC is repsonding to you. You can't look at an AC's posting history to see what kind of jerk he is (unlike with my history which clearly shows I'm a jerk). You can't assign karma modifiers to individual AC authors so that you don't have to be bother with particular jerks or so that you can pay attention to others. You can't have any hope that if you reply to an AC, they'll read you're reply. You know that often, an AC post is made by someone with a real account, but who withes not to sully that account or have some fit of nastiness tied to himself.

    The slashdot nick may not be traceable to an actual person, but it's still adequate for having some reaonable hope of a real conversation on an online forum. Having a conversation with an AC is like saying one sentence to every person you pass by as you walk down tht street.

    Imagine having nick-less usenet or email or chat or im conversations. Completetly pointless. Yet in those cases, the existence of a nick is usually no more tiable to a real person than the slashdot account.

    The GP may have different ideas, of course.

  5. Re:Gattaca! on Space.com's Top 10 Space Movies of All Time · · Score: 1

    The Rita Hayworth Redemption, IIRC.

  6. Re:And I was going to say ... on Red Hat Listed Among 50 Top Tech Companies · · Score: 3, Interesting

    How is RPM fundamentally more flawed than deb, pkg, or other common package formats? Please keep it technical, thank you.

  7. Re:If it looks like a duck and sounds like a duck. on Spyware Maker Sues Detection Firm · · Score: 1

    What about emacs?

  8. Re:Foul.... on Court Finds For Student In Web FOS Case · · Score: 1

    To bad about the relapse, but I know how it goes. You gotta keep trying to quit. There's no easy answer, but for me, quitting everyday seems better even if you fail. I'm in an enlongated quitting phase, over a month. I've done multiple years. Though I feel great about it and don't want to start again, I'm under no illusion that I won't start again someday. The key for me is a replacement activity. Running or cycling does it for me usually. Train for a marathon.

  9. Re:Was addressing both of them, but on Court Finds For Student In Web FOS Case · · Score: 1
    So how did quitting smoking go?

  10. Re:Fantastic on Court Finds For Student In Web FOS Case · · Score: 1
    secondhand smoke is one of the biggest killers in America

    This is of course untrue.

  11. Re:Like They Say... on New Discovery Disproves Quantum Theory? · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Let's make the analogy more explicit. The flat earth theory was offered because it fit the evidence:
    • the ground is flat
    • the earth doesn't look like a ball from here
    • if the earth were not flat, wouldn't people fall off?

    So after the flat earth theory, we have the new theories: the earth is a sphere (appx). The important thing is that the new theory fits the existing evidence:

    • the ground is flat because the sphere is large and locally it looks flat
    • from close up to a large shape, you can't tell what shape it is
    • gravity holds us to the earth, the sphere-ish shape is a direct consequence of gravity, as well

    In the same way, any theory that replaces QM will need to explain the myriad and complicated evidences that QM explains.

    QED

  12. Re:I don't think so... on Novell to Standardize on GNOME · · Score: 1

    Distrowatch is a pretty lousy place to go for meaninful statistics about Linux.

  13. Re:Management on Novell to Standardize on GNOME · · Score: 2, Insightful
    I think that is a valid point. Sometime I miss some bits of configurability, but gnome for the most part just makes more sense than KDE. Everytime I sit in down in front of KDE, I'm amazed at the complexity of the widgets, menus, etc. Not only is there an overwhelming amount of stuff, but it just doesn't look that good. That's entirely subjective, of course. It's a bit like the difference between simple web sites like google and complicated masses of links like amazon or other 'portal' search engines.

    YMMV, etc.

  14. Re:Why do people drink this crap? on Nestle Patents Coffee Beer · · Score: 1

    Caffeine has benefites for endurance athletes - runners, cyclists, etc. That's besides the obvious benefit of keeping you awake and alert. Not driving into a tree is good for your health. QED you fucking prude.

  15. Re:well, I doubt it will be like that anymore on IRC as a World-Changing Medium · · Score: 1

    It's not their fault that all the good nicks like "Aceticon" are taken.

  16. Re:There's an old saying... on Is There Such A Thing As A Final Cut? · · Score: 1
    but how many times did I watch Jedi when I was a kid? Tons. Probably more than twenty.

    You, sir, are a dork.

    HTH, HAND.

  17. Re:I know what I'd do... on Blue Gene/L Tops Its Own Supercomputer Record · · Score: 1

    I'll just pretend you compile with a c++ compiler instead. Has the implicit 'return 0;' at the end of main been adopted into C99 from C++?

  18. Re:We'll need a replacement for the Goodyear Blimp on The End Of The Light Bulb? · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    Note to mods: pointing out your own puns is grounds for down-modding.

  19. Re:Well... on Doubts About Future GPS Reliability · · Score: 1

    Right you are, my friend.

  20. Re:This just in on AbiWord beats OpenOffice to a Grammar Checker · · Score: 1

    We get it. You like MS word.

  21. Re:I'm starting to believe. on 2005 Will Probably be Warmest on Record · · Score: 1

    You don't get it. Log in, and we can have a discussion about divorce rates, property values, and a million other things. Otherwise, it's not a conversation, it's a series of drive-by soliloquies.

  22. Re:who pays for this... on Doubts About Future GPS Reliability · · Score: 1

    Get a room, you two.

  23. Re:Well... on Doubts About Future GPS Reliability · · Score: 1

    The US Air Force started GPS and runs it for the benefit of all branches of service as well as civilian use as deemed acceptible.

  24. Re:I'm starting to believe. on 2005 Will Probably be Warmest on Record · · Score: 1

    I was going to respond that point about divorces being is demonstratably wrong, but I'm not sure who I'm talking to, so why bother? At least you have your free anonymous speech though [scotch starts humming the national anthem] - jesus, I think I'm going to cry.

  25. Re:I'll help on 2005 Will Probably be Warmest on Record · · Score: 1
    Swoooosh .....