Slashdot Mirror


User: gumbi+west

gumbi+west's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
2,026
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 2,026

  1. Re:What's the problem? on Sony Patents Game Demos With Feature Erosion · · Score: 4, Funny
    This post made me think that one really should be able to mod +1 quality car analogy.

    But then we'd need -1 bad car analogy, and -1 stupid nit pick on car analogy.

  2. Re:Possibly another reason on Vivek Kundra On US Government Inefficiency · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Given your theory, can you explain why medicare is the lowest overhead medial care system in the US and the highest rated on customer satisfaction? The fact of the matter is that large organizations always have lots of efficiency loss (even super far right libertarian economists admit this) but sometimes there is also a size gain that outweighs this.

  3. Re:A slap in the face to all American veterans. on Court Rules Photo of Memorial Violates Copyright · · Score: 1

    And supreme court judges are selected by god? They are all appointees and they all have to have lots and lots of experience.

  4. Re:Payback period? on Fuel Cell Marvel "Bloom Box" Gaining Momentum · · Score: 1

    you are assuming they don't know how to do accounting. They do say they saved the money on energy costs, and methane is an energy source. They also could have included capital costs in their accounting.

  5. Re:About $2K savings per month on Fuel Cell Marvel "Bloom Box" Gaining Momentum · · Score: 2, Informative

    What time range? Checkout the returns on a 30 year bond. He is about right (if a slightly high).

  6. Re:Already have holographic storage on When Will AI Surpass Human Intelligence? · · Score: 1

    Um, no, the point is the technologies are, "holographic data storage", "fusion power stations", and "AI that passes the touring test." That is what I mean by "fusion" = fusion with Q > 1. We do not have fusion power. It's not like there are fusion power stations out there but it costs $10 per kWh. It's that there is no such thing.

  7. Re:Already have holographic storage on When Will AI Surpass Human Intelligence? · · Score: 1

    "fusion" means something with sustained output > input, we have not had that. o/w we have had fusion since the 1950s.

  8. Already have holographic storage on When Will AI Surpass Human Intelligence? · · Score: 1

    Just going to point out we already have holographic storage. There is just no commercial products that do it yet. Contrast with fusion and Turing test passing AI.

  9. Re:It might be true, but it's also irrelevent. on 95% of User-Generated Content Is Bogus · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I've registered in Chicago, and it was very easy. Voting after that registration required a drivers license though.

  10. Re:This just in on 95% of User-Generated Content Is Bogus · · Score: 2, Informative

    Nature did a study and found Wikipedia was slightly less reliable than Britannica. The editors of Britannica objected to the methods, and I'm not sure I like them ether, but I think it was an honest attempt. I think all of the articles were science articles and this is from 2005, so it is not exactly what you were asking for (its not 2010).

  11. Re:Blame XKCD for this one on New Rules May Raise Cost of Buying Gadgets Online · · Score: 1

    Since when is the civil war was recent?

  12. Re:copyright holders get to choose expression of a on Once Again, US DoJ Opposes Google Book Search · · Score: 1

    I see, so if the law isn't the way you want it to be, it is moronic. The thing is that many artists want to share their work there way. If they can not be granted that right, they will not share their work. This means that you can't republish my book after editing it or changing around the prose, even if you first buy a copy of my book for every copy of your book that you distribute. Same thing for songs. There is no automatic license to change and redistribute if you buy a CD for every CD you distribute. One example of this is that my name goes out on that book and your style of my artwork might be absolute rubbish. It isn't just about credit, it is about expression--an essential part of art. Alternately, I might have written a beautiful story with very jerky prose at points to make a political point that I want to make very clear at those points. You can't republish it after smoothing out or removing those points--I can use the work for my purpose and you can't use it for yours.

  13. Re:copyright holders get to choose expression of a on Once Again, US DoJ Opposes Google Book Search · · Score: 1

    What do you suppose is at stake in this case? Isn't storage, retrieval, and searching of the book happening? All of these are way outside of the traditional grant of fair use where someone presumably decides that the particular use does not diminish the value of the original art, or that the particular quote makes sense to quote. I agree fair use and criticism can not be excluded, but they are limited to not diminishing the value of the art. As an example, quotes as short as 300 words form books have been found to not be fair use.

  14. not talking about moral rights on Once Again, US DoJ Opposes Google Book Search · · Score: 1

    Not sure what you are saying. The copyright law grants artists right of expression, the copyright law also grants fair use. I'm arguing that the DOJ is making a valid point. Where did moral rights come from?

  15. Re:Yay! on Once Again, US DoJ Opposes Google Book Search · · Score: 1
    This is a bit like saying this: I want to hike across the country from coast to coast. To do this I need to get right of way for the trip. It is difficult to find everyone to ask so I'm just going to walk the way I want and if anyone wants to, they can stop me--but the onus is on them. If I walk through their locked house (copyrighted material which says no other use is allowed) they can ask me to stop after I've entered if they notice me.

    The fact that something is difficult to do legally doesn't give you license to change the law.

  16. Re:So what books do you have? on Once Again, US DoJ Opposes Google Book Search · · Score: 1

    I think the point is actually that people who have not yet published are implicitly agreeing to this--it amounts to a change in copyright law which requires an act of congress, not google.

  17. Re:A work lost versus a work preserved... on Once Again, US DoJ Opposes Google Book Search · · Score: 2, Insightful

    You are assuming that the author only wants rights for the purpose of profit. If a band only wanted their album to appear on vinyl then sellers could not sell the vinyl with a copy on CD (the end user might be able to do this, but for personal use)--the artist gets to control not just the money making from the art but also gets some control of the expression. There are i.e. albums that are not released and just a few people have hear them--the copyright holder can do this and nobody can stop them. If you made a copy of such a work (surreptitiously) you could not legally store it even if just for the purpose of searching for phrases in it--the owner can exclude you from doing that.

  18. copyright holders get to choose expression of art on Once Again, US DoJ Opposes Google Book Search · · Score: 1
    But if I am the copyright holder, I might want my art to not appear in excerpts (say I think it destroys the feeling of the piece). Obviously this argument is stupid for a CS textbook but might make sense for a well crafted novel or a painting where I might not want others to make black and white copies of portions of it and distribute them with information about how to buy the work from me. While I can't stop excerpting for criticism, I should be able to stop it for other uses--it is my art after all.

    The point is when you create art, you have control of its expression as art. You have not only the right to exclusive sale of it but also how your work is expressed. If I own, i.e., a play and I license it, a company that produces it can not legally change the words to the play without my permission--it is my play and I can choose how it is presented.

  19. nope: its a re-bully on Studies Reveal Why Kids Get Bullied and Rejected · · Score: 1
    Bullies use power to torture you. That is exactly what the school would be doing to the student who was not the aggressor.

    Plus, if a kid spits on you, the right response is to ask him to stop and then move your body away from him, not to punch him. Punching him deserves punishment even if you were being spit on.

  20. Re:Safely. noted this one on /. before: on Woz Cites "Scary" Prius Acceleration Software Problem · · Score: 1

    Say what? If what you say is true then you must think that if you twice tap the + button on a CC twice +4 MPH is a good idea but if you hit it that third time then more than +20 MPH is a good idea? I hope you don't work in UI design.

  21. Re:But will it get you high when you snort it? on Spray-On Liquid Glass · · Score: 1

    Yes, but that is 0.0001 g/m3 * 1/60.0843 g/molecule * 6.02*10^23 molecues/mol = 10^18 molecules / cubic meter. at 10-30 atoms thick, and assuming a each molecule takes up about 10 pm square (is that right?) you get about 2*10^25 of atoms/meter. Wait, can that be right? I must have a bad assumption or math somewhere...

  22. Re:March 2010 issue of Car and Driver disagrees w/ on Toyota Pedal Issue Highlights Move To Electronics · · Score: 1

    I guess it depends on what you think might break. If you think the accelerator sensor might break then this is a good test. If you think the computer itself might break then it is a worthless test.

  23. Re: Defect scandal at Toyota grows -- without boun on Toyota Pedal Issue Highlights Move To Electronics · · Score: 1

    Worst thing in the world is FWD with a load in the back, swaying its way down the icy road.

    I'd take bucking over fish tailing down a road any day of the week. Plus if it is really that bad then you brakes aren't going to work at all and you probably should be going pretty slow.

    Even RWD enthusiast car magazines admit that they prefer AWD or even the pedestrian FWD in the snow.

  24. Re:never say never on Toyota Pedal Issue Highlights Move To Electronics · · Score: 1

    Uh, if you need to apply the break just to get moving (I've never had this happen), you should stay exactly where you are--the road is going to have spots where braking is going to be a nightmare. These spots are where other drivers have skidded, which is before and in intersections--so best to stay at home. I'm sticking with my absolute (glad you love it BTW).

  25. Re: Defect scandal at Toyota grows -- without boun on Toyota Pedal Issue Highlights Move To Electronics · · Score: 1

    It is never necessary to have your foot on both. One applies positive acceleration, the other negative acceleration. The difference is the number of wheels / balance of force. On ice, trust me, you want the balance of brakes when braking and FWD or AWD when accelerating.