Slashdot Mirror


User: Sacarino

Sacarino's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
88
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 88

  1. Re:Welcome to my money pit! on What is the Current State of Home Automation? · · Score: 1

    http://cliste.sailwhatcom.com/ is a guy in Washington that imports from the manufacturer in HK, so you'd get it quicker if you order from him... he sells stuff in enclosures though, so there's a bit of a markup for the middleman and final assembly bit.

    If you want to order direct from the mfg and don't care about finished enclosures, they have an ebay site at http://stores.shop.ebay.com/Ananiah-Electronics where I believe they also sell the enclosures as separate purchases. Seller is on the level and has provided excellent support for me.

    The RF40315T-x model can take either 6v or 9v-40v DC through a stepdown transformer, so you can directly wire it to a battery in the car. Works pretty well, although you'll get drop-outs from time to time so don't use any logic that trips based on the first "I'm not here any more" signal. I don't know if your software currently supports them but the protocol is fairly easy to figure out so you could roll your own if needed.

    Good luck!

  2. Re:Why not use automation already proven on What is the Current State of Home Automation? · · Score: 1

    You can definitely do this, and in fact I have a automation-geared PLC called an Ocelot (made by Applied Digital) which I use for mission critical applications... My garage door, for instance, is tied into the Ocelot so I know exactly what position it's in and if it's in transit or not. My lawn irrigation setup is another thing that ties into the Ocelot. For the things that must go right, I highly recommend a PLC of some sort. The Ocelot also has features that I wouldn't expect to find elsewhere (IR recognition & transmission capabilities, for instance) but any PLC that can provide contact closure information would work.

    The benefit of using a software based controller for the higher level functions really comes into play with the convergence side of things. Let's say that when the wife gets home, she likes the thermostat set on a certain setting, a particular genre of music in the background, and the lighting set in a particular scene. But when I get home, we have a compromise programmed with the thermostat and the lighting. If she leaves, then the house readjusts to just my settings - which includes ditching her music in favor of my own. Or, if we're both "away" and a door is opened or motion detected, we get emails with attached images from the cameras in those locations. You could probably do a great deal of that with just a PLC but controlling playback of a MP3 player or sending emails starts putting you in the realm of esoteric hardware interfaces... at least for me. The downside of software controllers is the pricing. When I bought into Homeseer with v1.6, it was a fraction of what it costs now. They have competition with other pricing schemas but the software costs in a niche market like this are an interesting economics lesson. An open source alternative like Misterhouse is certainly an option but it's hard to argue against the availability of hardware and software for the wintel platform.

    Having said all that, I would have to take a real hard look at my options if I was starting from scratch. A lot of these HA software guys seem to think that I'm their piggy bank and they can rape my wallet accordingly. I understand that they spend a lot of time as a code monkey to get it right but annual licensing (CQC) doesn't sit well, nor does nickle-and-dime you on features/plugins (Homeseer).

  3. Re:$2000 in and counting on What is the Current State of Home Automation? · · Score: 1

    Using some ir-controlled home made window blind controllers I built, the blinds on the first floor of the house are controlled by the computer. Most notably, it shuts them when the sun goes down, so I don't have to worry about people seeing into the house after dark. I got real used to that real fast, let me tell ya.

    Don't suppose you'd like to share some technical details about that, would you? I would love to tie my blinds into the system but there's no way I'm paying Somfy-esq prices for the capability.

  4. Re:Welcome to my money pit! on What is the Current State of Home Automation? · · Score: 1

    I haven't looked at the reliability of Insteon in my current setup as a result of my X-10 install here. I have a lot of devices that really affect the signal-to-noise either by adding noise to the powerline or by sucking the signal out of it... my 2 remaining X-10 devices are on a dedicated circuit with a noise filter at the end of it, so they work fine. Having to identify and isolate things that are generating noise on the power line is a PITA and not what I consider fun, so I vowed to migrate away from it.

    I know there are many people that are happy with their powerline setup, but I didn't want to spend money to find that I wind up with the same problems. I've heard that newer powerline protocols actually have the capability to analyze the operating environment but I have no experience with that. Additionally, the ability of Z-wave to create and route through a mesh network really sold it for me... If you're trying to reach from A to C and B isn't responding, it'll use A to D to C instead. It's also quite fast - I noticed a couple second delays via X-10 from command to execution that just aren't there via Z-wave.

    Regarding occupancy, I have a couple logic gates that make the house "occupied" or not. An active RFID transmitter in the cars is one, motion sensors and pressure pads (http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/Displayitem.taf?itemnumber=96481 - very DIY but works great to detect a sleeper!) are another, and a really ingenious idea I found at http://www.cocoontech.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=11317 allows me to track individual keychains.

  5. Welcome to my money pit! on What is the Current State of Home Automation? · · Score: 4, Informative
    The problem with "home automation" systems is that it is VERY loosely defined. Some say it's the ability to control your lights, others say it's HVAC, still others say it's distributed audio/video. Since it's such a generic term, somewhat consequentially there are a variety of vendors and products that claim to be home automation. If you want to bridge technologies, you have to find a product that'll do that natively or allow you to expand it yourself.

    I happen to have a pretty robust system that uses Homeseer as the backend engine. This allows me to leverage strengths from various hardware providers due to the extensibility of their software, plus I have the ability to roll my own .NET code and have it integrate into the system. I currently utilize some very specific X-10 devices for a narrow niche (wireless door and window sensors) and a thermostat (if it ain't broke!), but the great majority of my stuff has been converted to Z-wave. The beauty of Z-wave over X-10 is the signal confirmation... with X-10, I'd send a signal into the ether and hope it'd get there, but with Z-wave, I get delivery confirmation so the system knows that a desired action hasn't been completed. There are additional technologies out there like Insteon, ZigBee, and UPB, but they have issues I don't like or the squeeze isn't worth the juice. Some of this crap is exceedingly pricey and I just can't justify spending it.

    I use Cinemar's MainLobby for integration with my theater gear, which also provides the sexy touchscreen frontend that everyone looks for in a system. Homeseer has also deployed a software with similar capabilities called HSTouch, but it isn't as powerful for my A/V setup just yet.

    Just a quick rundown of some things that I've got my system setup to do:
    • Occupancy detection - if vacant, it goes into an energy savings mode and shuts off lights and adjusts thermostat setpoints.
    • Exterior lighting is automatic based on sunset/sunrise, plus only brightens to 100% when motion detected or doors are opened.
    • Certain actions at certain times trigger sequences: when I open my bedroom door in the morning, the kitchen light kicks on and the TV flips on and tunes to the news channel I like.
    • Caller ID is screened and/or announced for me, in addition to displaying on television screens.
    • Freezer and fridge doors trip alarms if they're left open for too long.
    • Exhaust fans in the bathrooms are based on humidity conditions.
    • Yard irrigation is controlled both by wind conditions and zoned soil wetness conditions.
    • When the doorbell is rung, the touchscreens all show a live camera feed for that door from my ZoneMinder server.

    There's tons more that I currently do, I've got a list as long as my arm of things I plan to do, and there's a lot of options out there for things I could do. If you're interested in HA, you really need to figure out what it is for you by detailing out what you want and how you want to get there. My route is a lot of DIY because I'm happy hacking my way through a problem... If you've got more money than brains, you can certainly take the vendor lock-in approach of something like Crestron.

  6. Re:Hmmmmmm on A New Twist On Skywriting · · Score: 3, Informative

    You might wanna check the altitude again.

    While your point in general is correct about VFR flight, this guy was cruising at FL400 - Class A airspace.

    He would definitely had to have an IFR plan on file, otherwise he'd get a message from the tower to call a phone number when he landed... and that would be the end of his days as a pilot. That's assuming he didn't have a fighter come along to say hello beforehand.

    I would have liked to hear DEN Center asking wtf they were up to when it came time for that little loopy bit and back-track for the bottom of the "G"

  7. Re:Lookup in the Sky on A New Twist On Skywriting · · Score: 2, Informative

    On the sidebar, there's a Flight/Tail # input box. You'd put your airline's ICAO/IATA code in there along with the flight #

    For instance, DAL1237 (or DL1237) will give you Delta flight 1237 from Atlanta (ATL) to Orlando (MCO)

    A quick and dirty lookup is at this website, although you can find 'em all over the place

  8. Re:The Netherlands on If Not America, Then Where? · · Score: 1

    *You* wanted to move to this country, so *you* should make an effort of blending into society.

    When an American says this, they're branded as intolerant.

  9. Better than Wal-Mart on Google Striking Fear into the Corporate Masses · · Score: 5, Funny

    Hell, I can tell you a better place to buy crap than Wally World... It's called Costco.

    They don't treat their employees like EA coders, and you can still buy cheap.

    I didn't even need Google for that.

  10. Re:If you deal in garbage, you might attract flies on Air Canada Sues Over Misuse Of Employee Password · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Of course, the critical mistake was that in order for somebody to know if there's going to be space-availalbe, they have to publish on this site how full or not full the plane currently is.


    Sorry, wrong!

    Many airlines when you call to wait-list yourself on a flight will do just that.... You don't get any details about how full the flight is.

    If you want to get particular, this is called Non-Revenue Space-Available. I can list myself on a flight that operates 4 months from now that may only have 4 people booked on it. Or, I can list myself on a flight that departs in 15 minutes that's oversold by 2 seats. If there's enough no-shows on the flight, I get a seat. The whole concept of non-rev travel means that if there's an open seat and you're ready to go, you can get it.

    The value of that empty seat is $0 the moment the aircraft door closes, hence the airlines willingness to to allow employees or interline agreement employees to travel for free.

    The ability to get listed on a flight is a totally seperate event from letting the guy have access to their reservations/booking system. That's just piss poor security procedures on the part of Air Canada.

    I work in an airline dispatch office, so this is something I have some familiarity with.

  11. Ha! on Humanoid Robot Conducts Beethoven Symphony · · Score: 5, Funny

    Those little bastards dance better than I do...

  12. Re:I am actually building the hamster cage on PC Case For Hamsters, EZ Bake Oven in a Drive Bay · · Score: 1
  13. Re:Test signals.. encrypt.. mac restrict on A Wireless Network for a 4-Story Apt. Building? · · Score: 1

    Sure, as long as you're only doing research for your book.

  14. Re:Pay off debt or buy a house on A Wireless Network for a 4-Story Apt. Building? · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I really don't think this is offtopic at all. The poster wants to know if $7k is enough to do this project.

    The reply here obviously is "yes, but don't waste your money." How is that offtopic...?

    These people are not going to pay your bills for you. Don't offer to pay theirs. They want broadband, they need to shell out their cash.

    Just because a great aunt was kind enough to bestow money on you doesn't mean that you are expected to share.

    Life can be harsh, don't make it harder in the long run by giving away money now.

  15. Re:Or the low ID number on Microsoft Rolls Out New Anti-Linux Ad Campaign · · Score: 1

    Well, this is a pretty good example ;)

  16. Re:Really In Violation ? on MPlayer Alleges KISS Technology Violating GPL · · Score: 4, Informative

    Um. Not to be difficult or anything, but the last bit of the news article states...

    Every single one of their patterns match ours! This is not coincidence. This is stealing GPL code into a proprietary product! Kiss Technology failed to answer our inquiry for their source files (which they are obligated to provide), so this news entry is posted.

    Sure looks like they asked for the source to me.

  17. Re:spoiler-riffic on The Matrix Going Massively Multiplayer · · Score: 1

    I do not. You can whack the dog if you want to, though.

  18. Re:WHAT THE F$%! on Microsoft Forgets To Renew Hotmail.co.uk · · Score: 1

    It's difficult to be a good samaritan some days...

    Come on now, it's hard to get a giant's attention when you're just a gnat buzzing in the wind. ;)

  19. Re:Written a check lately? on Why Johnny Can't Handwrite · · Score: 1

    I don't think I have "written" a check... ever. I routinely print the business name and the amount without Bank of America freaking out and not cashing it. The signature is cursive just because I spent fscking years perfecting it to where I like the way it looks - but that's just vanity.

  20. Re:Anything to do with Waste... on Justin Frankel Resigns From Nullsoft · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Keep in mind that the guy is only 24. At ~19 he hit the jackpot with a "for fun" MP3 player -- a trivial app (see all the MP3 players on FreshMeat).

    Alright, I'll bite.

    Perhaps you weren't around when WinAMP was in it's infancy. I remember only one other player that even came CLOSE to the stability WinAMP provided. I even registered my copy with Nullsoft, back when it was shareware. It's not like you had "all the MP3 players on FreshMeat" to choose from. It was either WinAMP or it's crappy runner-up. Couple that with the fact that WinAMP was a) skinnable, b) had some badass graphical features, and c) impressed non-geeks. It also extended mp3 support with some attempts at backward compatability.

    I know it's been a while, but computers used to be slow. WinAMP would play on a 95 box running on a 486/dx2. That's IMPRESSIVE, my friend. You couldn't do jack-shit else while it was playing or it'd skip, but the fact that it would play this fancy new MP3 format that only took a couple megs for a song was nice. It made people take notice. What did you do that ranks anywhere near that? I know that crap I did in Comp Sci & Eng didn't land me anything like the deal he made for himself. I don't think he got lucky at all, he saw a need and he wrote something that took care of said need.

  21. uhm on Apple Clarifies 802.11g Controversy · · Score: 3, Insightful

    ...that every article posted on the Internet about this subject might not be true, or could be politically motivated.

    I'm not sure the age of the submitter, but if this comes as a surprise to anyone you really should be ashamed. Just because it's in print, on TV, or online does NOT make it true.

  22. Re:A point that has been missed so far on Mozilla's Joy Of Naming · · Score: 1

    C'mon, even freaking IBM can come up with better marketing themes

    Haha. Apparently you weren't watching when they were still trying to make a go with OS/2 Warp. I destinctly remember looking at a poster in an airport with some hippie background and the slogan "OS/2. It'll warp your computer"

    Brilliant marketing there. What's become of OS/2 now? ;)

  23. Re:The same laws should apply on Dr. Dre to pay $1.5 mil for "Illegal Sample" · · Score: 1

    A written email, eh. When did they start coming out with those?

  24. Re:Thoughts on Starship Scale Diagrams on Slashback: Hawash, Monomania, Rocketships · · Score: 1

    Don't forget the "Planet Express" ship from Futurama.

  25. Re:Down already? on The Science of the Matrix · · Score: 1

    Somebody cut the hard line.... get out, it's a trap!