Slashdot Mirror


User: tsotha

tsotha's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
3,283
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 3,283

  1. Re:Only Republicans are stupid enough... on First Lawsuits Challenging FCC's New Net Neutrality Rules Arrive · · Score: 1

    By "classify" you mean declare them to be "common carriers"? No, I don't think they do.

  2. Re:Only Republicans are stupid enough... on First Lawsuits Challenging FCC's New Net Neutrality Rules Arrive · · Score: 1

    The debate goes beyond policy, though. The question of whether Congress gave or intended to give the bureaucracy these kinds of sweeping powers isn't an idle one. I haven't delved into the details enough to decide if I think the rules are good rules. But I have looked into it enough to know the FCC doesn't have the powers it's claiming to have. This kind of policy change needs to be enacted by the legislature.

  3. Re:Safe bet? on No Fuel In the Fukushima Reactor #1 · · Score: 1

    Yeah, great to see slashdot is keeping up the tradition of including nonsense right there in the summary so you don't have to go to the comments for it.

  4. Re:WARNING: on California Looking To Make All Bitcoin Businesses Illegal · · Score: 1

    I think the financial harm they're most concerned about has to do with tax evasion.

  5. Re:"line up in sacramento first" on California Looking To Make All Bitcoin Businesses Illegal · · Score: 1

    I live in CA too, and I agree. The businesses that are still here are here because it costs money to move. Unless you're starting up yet another Twitter clone with someone else's money you'd be daft to start you business here.

  6. Re:Reddit sure loves it's free speech. on Reddit Imposes Ban On Sexual Content Posted Without Permission · · Score: 1

    Good lord, you're an idiot. I've read it many times, and it really has nothing to say about what companies I'd like to do business with.

  7. Helmet water on Spacewalking Astronauts Finish Extensive, Tricky Cable Job · · Score: 1

    Once safely back inside, Virts reported a bit of water in his helmet again for the second time in as many spacewalks. He stressed it was “not a big deal” and said there was no need to hurry out of his suit.

    What's with the water? I thought they had this problem fixed.

  8. Re:Thrilling on Spacewalking Astronauts Finish Extensive, Tricky Cable Job · · Score: 2

    Of course it doesn't suck. You need air for suction.

  9. Of course it isn't over on Verizon Posts Message In Morse Code To Mock FCC's Net Neutrality Ruling · · Score: 1

    The FCC has been shut down by the courts twice already over this kind bureaucratic overreach. Doesn't matter whether or not net neutrality is a good idea - the bureaucracy was never given the authority to impose it by Congress. This will never survive the court challenge.

  10. Re:Reddit sure loves it's free speech. on Reddit Imposes Ban On Sexual Content Posted Without Permission · · Score: 1

    What does the constitution have to do with anything?

  11. Re:Reddit sure loves it's free speech. on Reddit Imposes Ban On Sexual Content Posted Without Permission · · Score: 1

    Are you trying to imply we should only worry about assholery promulgated by the government?

  12. Re:Not surprised on Reddit Imposes Ban On Sexual Content Posted Without Permission · · Score: 2

    There will always be a place. Reddit has simply opened the door to the next bit social media site as it slowly follows Digg (and slashdot, to some extent) into obscurity. People don't like to have their conversations constrained.

  13. Re:Reddit sure loves it's free speech. on Reddit Imposes Ban On Sexual Content Posted Without Permission · · Score: 3, Informative

    There's no free speech on reddit. They're no better than Facebook or Google.

  14. Is this new? on Crystal Pattern Matching Recovers Obliterated Serial Numbers From Metal · · Score: 3, Informative

    The FBI has been recovering filed off serial numbers for at least a decade based on the changes in metal grain that result from stamping. Is this just a more sensitive method for doing that?

  15. Re:From the grave... on Resistant Bacterial Infection Outbreak At California Hospital · · Score: 1

    I'm amazed at the number of people who feel qualified to comment on a network they've never watched and know nothing about.

  16. Re:You sunk my battleship on Will Submarines Soon Become As Obsolete As the Battleship? · · Score: 1

    Japan was doomed by the decision to go to war against the United States.

    Japan was pushed into it by the US. By that time oil was critical for conducting a sustained campaign, and we had orchestrated an embargo in July that cut them off from 88% of their oil supplies. Roosevelt had the US in the war already, if not officially - between the embargoes in the east and US destroyer attacks on German submarines our full participation was inevitable. That being the case, Japan felt it would be better to strike first. I probably would have done the same.

    While clearly unable to hold off the full might of the US economy as it was brought to bear, the Japanese government felt it might be able to convince the US people actually carrying on an all-out campaign at the same time we were at war with Germany would be too expensive, and a settlement could be negotiated. Germany was supposed to be their ace in the hole, soaking up enough war materials to enable Japan to survive.

    World War II broke a pattern that had held for a century. Wars weren't fought to the death - you fought until the winner was clear and then you negotiated a peace. I suspect the people in power believed the worst case would involve surrendering Manchuria and French Indochina, something they would have to do anyway as a result of the oil embargo.

  17. Re:I don't see the problem on Valve Censoring Torrent References In Steam Chat · · Score: 1

    This is the dumbest, self-serving crap I've read in a long time. You are not entitled to other peoples' work, and Congress is not obligated to set copyright terms at lengths you find convenient. They absolutely have the constitutional authority to keep extending copyright, and if you don't like it you need to get involved in the politics. Breaking the law is bad enough, but expecting Valve to help you when it's not in their interest to do so is just dumb.

  18. Re:I don't see the problem on Valve Censoring Torrent References In Steam Chat · · Score: 1

    I wish the president would stop saying that so people would stop aping him without thinking about what they're saying.

  19. Re:I don't see the problem on Valve Censoring Torrent References In Steam Chat · · Score: 1

    No, that's far less accurate. For one thing the USPS is a government sponsored monopoly.

  20. I don't see the problem on Valve Censoring Torrent References In Steam Chat · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Would you go to Walmart's site and leave links pointing to instructions for shoplifting at Walmart? Valve's site; Valve's rules.

  21. Re:You sunk my battleship on Will Submarines Soon Become As Obsolete As the Battleship? · · Score: 1

    This is dead wrong. Read the history of the Guadalcanal campaign; it was surface ships that carried the day. Aircraft were ineffective at night and are best used in an offensive role, they can't effectively protect ships bringing in troops and supplies.

    The only reason gunships look effective in Guadalcanal is we were fighting other gunships. Otherwise we would have lost. It's only dark for half the day.

  22. Betteridge's Law Applies on Will Submarines Soon Become As Obsolete As the Battleship? · · Score: 4, Informative

    The answer is "no". People who say submarines are obsolete are the same people who say "stealth doesn't work". They're missing the point. The point is not to be able to sidle up to your enemies without detection and tag their ships with slogans. The point is to gain a tactical advantage by detecting the enemy before he detects you. Detection isn't a yes/no thing - it's all about range.

  23. Re:You sunk my battleship on Will Submarines Soon Become As Obsolete As the Battleship? · · Score: 2

    The Japanese were more invested in the battleship than the USN, wasting their limited resources on two mega battleships that ultimately accomplished nothing,

    The reason they built Yamato and Musashi was because they knew they had no way to match American industrial capability and that they would always be outnumbered. So they decided to build ships that could destroy multiple enemy battleships. But remember, the ball got rolling for this in 1934, long before it was obvious battleships were obsolete.

  24. Re:You sunk my battleship on Will Submarines Soon Become As Obsolete As the Battleship? · · Score: 1

    This was always the advantage that the United States Navy had which the Japanese couldn't even dream of duplicating.

    At the outset of the war IJN doctrine was to use torpedoes against capital ships. The marriage of radar and analog targeting computers caught them somewhat flatfooted. Not that it mattered, really, since by the start of the war battleships were really only useful for providing shore bombardment and as AA platforms.

  25. Re:You sunk my battleship on Will Submarines Soon Become As Obsolete As the Battleship? · · Score: 1

    They were also used decades later in Lebanon.