Slashdot Mirror


User: 5pp000

5pp000's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
273
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 273

  1. Re:Conflicted on WikiLeaks Publishes Afghan War Secrets · · Score: 1

    [WikiLeaks] has published private rites of Masons, Mormons and other groups that cultivate confidential relations among their members. Most or all of these groups are defenseless against WikiLeaks’ intrusions. The only weapon they have is public contempt for WikiLeaks’ ruthless violation of their freedom of association [....]

    The author of the quoted article seems to be overlooking the fact that WikiLeaks could not have published such material, except that some member of the organization in question decided it should be published. It's not clear to me why WikiLeaks would place their own judgment of the value of publication above that of the insider who leaked it to them. As you also quote:

    Assange must confront the paradox of his creation: the thing that he seems to detest most–power without accountability–is encoded in the site’s DNA [...]

    I'm not completely sure what I think of WikiLeaks either, but I do note that they have withheld some of this material on the Afghan war at the request of their source. In general, as long as their behavior toward their sources is above reproach, as it seems to be, I'm not sure they should be answerable to anyone else. So I don't agree that they have power without accountability -- but it is to their sources alone that they are accountable.

  2. Re:Incredibly useful human group dynamics experien on World of Warcraft Can Boost Your Career · · Score: 1

    Some people in management didn't quite get the math and overall picture and wanted me fired. I wasn't meeting all of the metrics that were set and that's what mattered.

    What a commentary on management: managers who insist on managing by the numbers but can't do math! Clearly it's average absolute time between calls that matters, not the percentage, as the percentage measurement rewards those who spend more time on calls and penalizes those who spend less -- a perverse result if there ever was one. Whoever decided to use that metric is the one who should be fired.

  3. It stands to reason on World of Warcraft Can Boost Your Career · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It stands to reason that you're learning something when playing a game. It's only a question of how useful that something is in the rest of your life.

  4. Re:Play time? on The Creativity Crisis · · Score: 1

    Obviously, what this proves is the importance of oscilloscopes!!

    Just kidding. Great post!

  5. Re:Play time? on The Creativity Crisis · · Score: 4, Funny

    I've worked with South Koreans once, and over three months, I couldn't find any correlation between their actions and common sense. For example, when a brand new $100 million piece of equipment malfunctions, my first thought would be to get the on-site American engineer they flew in to assemble it, and not a hammer and some duct tape.

    Right! The American engineer would know where to whack with the hammer, and where to stick the duct tape.

  6. Re:Buy local on Internet Sales Tax Gets a New Champion · · Score: 1

    Interesting that your post is modded "funny". I think the widespread death of local bookstores is very sad. I fully support some kind of interstate sales tax.

  7. Good article on secret ballot history on SCOTUS Rules Petiton Signatures Are Public Record · · Score: 1

    http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2008/10/13/081013fa_fact_lepore?currentPage=all

    Have a look!

  8. Re:So.... on Wikileaks Source Outed To Stroke Hacker's Own Ego · · Score: 1

    So we can suppose this is an operation to make people doubt the safety of going to Wikileaks?

    The problem with this idea is that it at least appears to be the case that Manning got caught solely because he stupidly bragged about his actions to a stranger. Maybe somehow that isn't what actually happened -- but it's what seems to have happened, and for PR purposes, that is all that matters.

    The salient point I would take from this, if I were in position to leak any secrets, is that there is absolutely no indication Manning would have been caught if he hadn't confessed to Lamo.

  9. Re:We promise we won't hurt you. on Pentagon Seeking Out Wikileaks Founder Julian Assange · · Score: 1

    This is the part that stands out to me -- not from the same page, but a couple of clicks away we find an edited transcript of Manning's chats with Lamo, and scrolling down we find this:

    (02:35:46 PM) Manning: was watching 15 detainees taken by the Iraqi Federal Police for printing “anti-Iraqi literature” the iraqi federal police wouldn’t cooperate with US forces, so i was instructed to investigate the matter, find out who the “bad guys” were, and how significant this was for the FPs it turned out, they had printed a scholarly critique against PM Maliki i had an interpreter read it for me and when i found out that it was a benign political critique titled “Where did the money go?” and following the corruption trail within the PM’s cabinet i immediately took that information and *ran* to the officer to explain what was going on he didn’t want to hear any of it he told me to shut up and explain how we could assist the FPs in finding *MORE* detainees (from http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/06/wikileaks-chat/)

    This, to me, is the truly incendiary accusation: that though our stated mission in Iraq is to establish a functioning democracy, in fact we are assisting the Iraqi government in functioning as a dictatorship. Documentation of this claim would be more important, IMO, than the video.

  10. Re:Check out the Etymotic etyBLU on Best Telephone For Datacenters? · · Score: 1

    Then definitely check out the hf2 -- it sounds better than the ER-6i (which I have also used extensively), and it has an inline mic!

  11. Check out the Etymotic etyBLU on Best Telephone For Datacenters? · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I haven't actually tried it, but I have used other Etymotic products, and they generally work very well. Here's the page.

    I'm particularly fond of their hf2 stereo headset -- they sound great!

  12. Re:What's the correct form factor for this niche? on Hands-On With Dell's Streak Android Device · · Score: 1

    I like the N810 form factor a lot. I carry mine in a hip pouch -- not in a pocket, admittedly, but I've never liked to carry a phone in my pocket either. The Streak looks slightly too large to me -- it's significantly thinner, but that doesn't really make that much difference.

    Nokia obviously thought the N810 was too big since the N900 is smaller, but the smaller size forces compromises in the slide-out keyboard design, besides just making the screen a little harder to read.

    I like the slide-out keyboard myself, but the market is moving away from them. Given that, maybe the HTC Evo hits the form factor nail on the head. Will be interesting to see.

  13. Re:It could be that... on Caffeine Addicts Get No Additional Perk, Only a Return To Baseline · · Score: 1

    I've been convinced for years that regular caffeine usage very quickly (in a few days) causes tolerance to build up to the point that the caffeine provides no benefit. My test -- difficult to quantify but clear enough to me, and unfakeable -- is my productivity in writing code.

  14. Re:Aircraft electronics on Rent an iPad For Inflight Entertainment · · Score: 2, Informative

    I distinctly recall that, in the days when analog cassette players were still around but digital devices had appeared, the instruction to turn off devices for takeoff and landing applied only to the digital ones -- use of cassette players was specifically allowed.

  15. Re:I'm a Muslim... on Pakistan Lifts Ban After Facebook Deletes Offending Page · · Score: 1

    Every time something like this comes up, I try to dig a hole and disappear best I can.

    I think you underestimate how much good you could do by speaking out instead of digging a hole. If you and others like you raised a chorus of voices saying you oppose censorship, and especially violent censorship, it would go a long way.

    I'm not asking much. All you need to do is ... exactly what you did here.

  16. Re:pathetic on Pakistan Lifts Ban After Facebook Deletes Offending Page · · Score: 1

    What say I go to Alabama, defecate on a bible, wrap it in the US flag and burn the bundle. That's free speech isn't it?

    No, it's me being an offensive dick for the sake of it.

    Actually, it depends. If you did it just to be an offensive dick that would be one thing. But suppose the US government had done something to you that, it could fairly be said, ruined your life; and suppose you had written about it, blogged about it, contacted the press, etc. etc. and had failed to get anyone to pay attention to you. (I am certain there have been a few people who have been in such a situation.) Since you mention the Bible, let's suppose that whatever was done to you had some connection to Christianity and the efforts some have made to establish it as the state religion of Alabama. I don't think that stretches the imagination much at all.

    Given all that, maybe in your frustration you might have reached a point where the only mode of expression you felt was left to you, that would make the point you were validly trying to make, was to defecate on a Bible, wrap it in the American flag and burn them. In that case I would support you in doing so. Once you got everyone's attention, maybe you could then make your point in a more conventional manner.

    Perhaps not everyone who would do such a thing has such a good reason. But it's not up to the law to evaluate their reason. The guarantee of freedom of speech means that you can do that if you want to; and then it's up to everyone else to form an opinion about your motives. If we outlaw any form of expression at all, we eliminate the valid uses of that expression, rare though they may be, along with the invalid ones.

    So for those of us who believe in freedom, being told that drawing images of Muhammed is forbidden is itself offensive. Worse, going along with that is dangerous -- once one form of expression is outlawed, it gets easier to outlaw the next one. There is a real clash of belief systems here, and I think it is critical that we make it clear that we will not be intimidated into outlawing any speech at all. (The line here is not really between Americans and Muslims; indeed, a sizable minority of Americans would love to have state-enforced censorship of various kinds -- witness, as just one example, the periodic agitation by some for a Constitutional Amendment to outlaw burning of the US flag.)

    The original motivation for the prohibition, in Islam, against images of the Prophet (or anyone else) was to discourage idolatry. I think it is fair game to show people that it has failed to do that: that Muhammed is as much an idol as Jesus. The violence of the reaction to these drawings only proves the point.

  17. Re:Not such good news, really on How To Go Broke Selling Zero-Day Exploits · · Score: 1

    Whoops, never mind... didn't RTFA...

  18. Not such good news, really on How To Go Broke Selling Zero-Day Exploits · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It means that supply is keeping up with demand.

  19. Re:Think of the constitution. on US Supreme Court Upholds Indefinite Confinement · · Score: 1
    From TFA:

    Justice Breyer took pains to make clear that the court was not ruling on the separate question of whether such confinement violated the Constitution’s due process clause.

    I think this ruling is narrower than it sounds.

    Which is not to say I'm not very concerned about it.

  20. Re:"a ways" to go? From a veteran editor... on HTML Web App Development Still Has a Ways To Go · · Score: 1

    There's no explanation. Not only is it an idiom, it's really not considered completely correct -- "informal" is what the dictionaries call it. Personally, I avoid it in writing if not in speech, but it's fairly common in the US, at least. I think it was originally dialectal, meaning it originated in one particular region of the country.

  21. Argh, "micro" and "milli" again on Nutritionist Claims His Pre-Packaged Meals Are Dangerous · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Looks like someone read "micro" and thought "milli" again (they used 1000 times too much vitamin D in the mix).

    Same thing that happened in that tragic accident that killed all those racehorses some months ago -- someone was supposed to put N micrograms of selenium in their supplement, but instead gave them N milligrams. They died a horrible death.

    Maybe we should consider changing one of these prefixes so they don't both begin with "m".

  22. Re:Oh yeah. on The PalmPilots That Never Were · · Score: 1

    Graffiti 1 is, imo, still the best quick way to get text into a portable device.

    Then you must never have tried Fitaly. This is a tap-optimized soft keyboard. I used it on a Tungsten T|3 for several years; it's easily more than twice as fast as Graffiti.

    While the layout could perhaps be improved further (another layout called Opti II is probably better), the concept is sound. It does take a little practice to get fast, but so what?

    The big problem, IMO, is that the market has decided it doesn't like styli. I don't understand why; fingers are much too large for accurate tapping. Oh well.

  23. Re:A relief... on HP To Buy Palm For $1.2 Billion · · Score: 1

    I don't think HP is a great company anymore. But they might manage not to screw this up completely.

    The alternative was for Palm to be dead in the water. No one is buying their phones (I think Sprint even stopped selling them). Who would buy a phone from a dying company? Who would write an app for such a phone?

    I'm not dancing in the streets, but I think it's a better outcome than appeared likely yesterday. HP will at least create the perception that a deep-pocketed player is committed to the business. There's some chance that will bring back some app developers who are frustrated that they can't get noticed on the iPhone app store.

    I don't know that the Pre is a "geek-attractive device" anyway. I like it well enough, but if I had wanted a phone to hack on I would have gotten an Android.

  24. A relief... on HP To Buy Palm For $1.2 Billion · · Score: 1

    As a Pre owner, I find this a relief. I was worried Palm was just going to fade away.

    And I'm glad the buyer has no existing smartphone business, so WebOS will be its sole platform.

  25. Re:Actually, it WAS stolen... on Police Seize Computers From Gizmodo Editor · · Score: 1

    So the iPhone in question was stolen property, and Gizmodo has effectively admitted to purchasing stolen property, and knowingly having purchased stolen property.

    Agreed. Ironically, in this case the crime was so public that the confiscation of the servers to look for additional evidence is probably superfluous. I don't even see how it matters if the defense manages to get said evidence suppressed.