Slashdot Mirror


User: Lockejaw

Lockejaw's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
535
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 535

  1. Re:in (real) defense of the RIAA: on RIAA Campaign Against Students Hits Stormier Seas · · Score: 1

    How exactly does copyright law prevent people from building upon previously existing ideas?
    By extending to restrict derivative works.

    You are looking at IP not as restrictions on copying, rather as the prohibition of copying.
    Yeah, it's not like any copyright holders are trying to prohibit any copying they don't explicitly authorize....

    We have a compromise between copyright holders and the public, with a limited copyright term, and limited powers for the copyright holders (fair use).
    Limited term? Strictly speaking, yes, but that doesn't really matter much when the works won't be in the public domain for another 50-100 years.

    Just like an unmoderated adherence to the information wants to be free ideology would be similarly disastrous for our culture.
    Sometimes I have to wonder just how little would actually be produced in that situation.
  2. Re:in (real) defense of the RIAA: on RIAA Campaign Against Students Hits Stormier Seas · · Score: 1

    The RIAA seem to have morality, justice, fairness (not that there's much difference between them), reason, and the law on their side. Y'know, they risk their bucks on artists, they reap a portion of the rewards.
    We're not talking about ASCAP here. High-profile recording labels don't just take a small cut. Musicians pretty much only get a good percentage from performances. Signing with a major label is basically a deal with the devil: sign your soul away, and we'll make you rich famous. If they didn't offer that, nobody would sign.
    Take a look at the outcry from the record labels when Prince released some of his music for free. There's no serious externalities there -- the recording industry is not a party to this. Even so, they feel deprived enough to make a lot of noise about it.

    It also should be stated that abolishing copyrights, or forcing copyright law to be unenforceable is NOT progress, rather the opposite.
    You're coming dangerously close to strawman here. The "abolish copyright" crowd is not a large percentage of the population, or even of slashdotters. On the whole, /. wants shorter copyright terms and some fair use rights.
  3. Re:You forgot... on RIAA Campaign Against Students Hits Stormier Seas · · Score: 1

    Now, when was the last time you found someone who couldn't do but could teach?

  4. Re:state==public domain? on DUI Defendant Wins Source Code to Breathalyzer · · Score: 1

    Yeah, it's not like poeple die in DUI crashes in real life. That just happens in made-for-tv movies!

  5. Re:state==public domain? on DUI Defendant Wins Source Code to Breathalyzer · · Score: 1

    If you refuse the test you are denying them evidence to use against you in a criminal proceeding. You will have to deal with the civil punishment from DMV (typically a suspended license for a period of time and some civil $$$ penalties) but you are denying the state evidence to use against you at a criminal proceeding.
    Unless, of course, the state makes it a crime to refuse the test after giving the "implied consent."
  6. Re:Overwhelming Support on Dell Considers Bundling Virtualization on Mobos · · Score: 1

    In response to closures like that, I've heard of cities adding a stipulation that says the company has to pay fees, back taxes, etc. if they close up and move out.

  7. Re:Overwhelming Support on Dell Considers Bundling Virtualization on Mobos · · Score: 1

    Was anyone with a clue actually calling Dell's call centers anyway?
    I don't care if anyone with a clue is calling. I really only care whether anyone with a clue is answering!
  8. Re:Consumer participation required? on Pay-For-Visit Advertising · · Score: 1

    But why would a consumer, given the relatively low prices of cell phones, tariffs and contracts, accept this?
    If nobody offers plans without this, the only way to get a cell plan is to accept this.
  9. Re:no thanks on Pay-For-Visit Advertising · · Score: 2, Insightful

    You are being tacked as a number and that number is rairly connected to you personally.
    Nope, just to my shipping info... but that includes my name. Then that info is available to anyone willing to pay for it. And then the credit card company sees where all my payments go and can sell that data.
    Seriously, if you want anonymity, buy stuff at a brick-and-mortar store, and pay cash. The whole town doesn't know your spending habits. There's just some guy at xyz who knows that tall skinny guy with graying hair bought a lot of cereal half an hour ago. Of course, the chance that he cares enough to remember the purchase half an hour later is slim.
  10. Re:New iMac keyboard on Apple Updates iMac, iLife, .Mac · · Score: 1

    You mean these?

  11. Re:Seems reasonable... on Vote Swapping Ruled Legal · · Score: 0

    And empower additional parties. "Everybody's second choice" would probably have trouble making it to a run-off, but would have a good chance at almost universal approval.

  12. Re:Well this sucks on LG Phillips Patents Oil and Water Display · · Score: 2, Funny

    Well, so far it seems that nobody here has seen this done before and thinks it's a pretty neat idea. So, no, you just need to get the latest groupthink patch.

  13. Finally on Apple Updates iMac, iLife, .Mac · · Score: 4, Funny

    And .Mac subscribers get 10 GB of storage.
    Yay, now there's enough space to actually put something there!
  14. Re:In a weird way, I hope that this fails on Internet Radio's 'Second Chance' Bogging Down in House · · Score: 1

    So... serious question here...
    What would/could SoundExchange sue for? Copyright infringement?

  15. Re:eMusic on Internet Radio's 'Second Chance' Bogging Down in House · · Score: 1

    OTOH, collecting royalties is also the purpose of ASCAP.

  16. Re:Hey Ted on FBI, IRS Raid Home of Sen. Ted Stevens · · Score: 1

    The difference is that the bed-ridden former nerd won't be trying to regulate the farm industry despite never having seen a farm.

  17. Re:Secret formula? on Bill Would Criminalize Attempted IP Infringement · · Score: 1

    Either the formula is a trade secret, and you are free to reverse engineer it, or the formula is patented, and there should be no need to reverse engineer it.

  18. Re:Why care? on Blow-Back From Ebert's Latest Games Assertion · · Score: 1

    Yes, but we're talking about video games. Isn't he a movie critic?

  19. Re:Bureaucracy is a force multiplier for idiocy. on Schneier Talks to the Head of TSA · · Score: 1

    And I can even go so far as to say I agree with him on his lack of specifics. There's no need to censor recipes, but there's no need to publicize them.
    We're not talking about listing ways that work. We're talking about demonstrating that they don't work.
  20. Re:Doing their job? on Schneier Talks to the Head of TSA · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I also noted that Northwest (who I refuse to fly because of their absolutely shitty customer service, horrible track record, and awful unionized staff) had major issues this weekend.
    Pilots can only work a certain number of hours per month (I forget if this is an FAA rule or just part of their collective contract). Since Northwest's scheduling is so screwy, pilots end up spending extra hours on the job because of delays. Since Northwest is stingy about hiring pilots, they end up using up all of their available pilot-hours before the end of the month. Then they have to cancel a lot of flights because they can't legally run them.
  21. Not always about being "cute" on Emoticons in the Workplace · · Score: 5, Insightful

    One of the biggest flaws of text-only communication is that it doesn't include the "side-channel" of body language. A sentence sent as an instant message or email might fit well with many different tones of voice or facial expressions, and that can affect both the meaning and the likely reaction to it.

  22. Re:Great on Comment Deadline For NYC Photography Permits · · Score: 1
    Yes, yes, I know, this is from from wikipedia, but...

    Free speech zones are created by the Secret Service for President George W. Bush and other members of his administration.


    It's about insulating politicians from dissent. It's from the same party that wants a woman seeking an abortion to have to look at ultrasound pictures of the fetus. Of course, there was also this really ugly free-speech zone at the Democratic National Convention.
  23. Re:And they're going to lose.. on ACLU Protests Police Scanning License Plates · · Score: 1

    Searching would also be valuable at the request of citizens, as it may help them prove an aliby - or just remember one:
    Sounds like a good reason to keep it classified.
  24. Re:And the problem with paper was? on Researchers Crack Every Certified CA Voting Machine · · Score: 4, Insightful

    And please, can we quit calling them "computer security researchers"? What's wrong with hackers? When did we start on the euphemism treadmill?
    When the media decided that a "hacker" is someone who secretly breaks into your computer and fills it full of spam and child porn. So we needed a word for people who break into computers without being secretive about it and don't fill it with bad stuff.
  25. Re:Surely it did on EA - Wii Caught Us By Surprise · · Score: 1

    but it didn't appeal to jock gamers in the slightest .... and it's all about how high the "badass meter" (TM) reads.
    I'm inclined to blame the use of Miis for at least some of the lack of badassery.