Slashdot Mirror


Lazy Musicians Spawn Robot Ukulele

densetsu writes: "Three weeks ago, instead of forking over 5 whole bucks for an actual ukelele instruction booklet, I decided to teach myself for free using internet resources. Now that my will (and fingers) have been broken, these guys offer a faustian shortcut. They built a Lego Mindstorms-powered REMOTE CONTROLLED self-playing ukulele. The site has some nice photos and mindstorms code. Rock super-stardom, here I come!"

117 comments

  1. mp3s by Blue+1ce · · Score: 1

    Too bad they haven't provided mp3s. I would love to hear it play...

  2. And it's a clean, well designed web page too. by AltGrendel · · Score: 2

    Can't wait for the tour.

    --
    The simple truth is that interstellar distances will not fit into the human imagination

    - Douglas Adams

  3. Ukulele used to play reggae? by captainstupid · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    I'm not a big reggae fan, so correct me if I'm wrong, but since when does reggae music include ukulelies (sp)? Could you imagine "No Woman, No Cry" (the only reggae song I know) played with a ukulele?

    Very odd...

    --
    "Anyway, long story short... is a phrase whose origins are complicated and rambling...." - Abraham Simpson
    1. Re:Ukulele used to play reggae? by wichtolosaurus · · Score: 1

      Nope, reggae music only seldomly includes ukulelis.
      Just imagine a sound clash where the winning soundsystem would be the one featuring the best-programmed mindstorms ukulele....

      The future will send loads of reggae mcs and djs into unemployment.

    2. Re:Ukulele used to play reggae? by captainstupid · · Score: 0

      Just an addition to my post, they played Bob Marley tunes with this thing (Trenchtown Rock is Marley album). That's why I asked the question.

      --
      "Anyway, long story short... is a phrase whose origins are complicated and rambling...." - Abraham Simpson
  4. Ah yes... by CoderByBirth · · Score: 3, Funny

    ... all well and good. But the question remains; why would you want to play an ukulele?

    Bah!

    1. Re:Ah yes... by scott1853 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Tiny Tim tribute?

      Of course from the article it sounds like the ukulele has easier chord formations than a guitar (add 2 less strings) so it was probably easier to program.

      I want to see a full sized lego drummer though.

    2. Re:Ah yes... by SquierStrat · · Score: 2

      Less possible chord formations also, iirc. :-)

      I'd like to see a robot bass player...bass players are hard to find these days, particularly half-way decent ones.

      --
      Derek Greene
    3. Re:Ah yes... by Observer · · Score: 1
      ... I'd like to see a robot bass player ...
      Third black box from the left in your average techno/ dance music combo.
    4. Re:Ah yes... by Bob+McCown · · Score: 1


      The Horse Flies, an alternative/bluegrass/whateverthehelltheyare band, has a banjo-uke player. Its an even more unique sound than just a uke. Go find music from "In the Dance Tent" and give it a listen.

    5. Re:Ah yes... by cafebabe · · Score: 2

      Eddie Vedder from Pearl Jam has been writing some stuff for ukulele. One of my friends who is a huge Pearl Jam fan said that the band is even doing a "fan art" contest where they want people to submit ukulele inspired creations.

      --
      When violence rules the world outside / And the headlines make me want to cry / It's not the time to just keep quiet
    6. Re:Ah yes... by SquierStrat · · Score: 2

      who want's a box playing bass in your punk/ska band though? I sure don't!

      --
      Derek Greene
    7. Re:Ah yes... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ... all well and good. But the question remains; why would you want to play an ukulele?

      That's the whole point - let the robot play!

    8. Re:Ah yes... by Buck2 · · Score: 2, Funny

      Who wants a ska band? I sure don't!

      --

      As my father lik@(munch munch)... ....
    9. Re:Ah yes... by RFC959 · · Score: 1

      I'd like to see a robot bass player...
      Yeah, but how do you make a robot chew gum and look bored? (Sorry, old joke...had to be said.)
    10. Re:Ah yes... by Observer · · Score: 1

      If the Volkwagen automobile group diversified into musical instruments, would their robot bass player be an Audi Quattro?

  5. Look out boy-bands by Tinfoil · · Score: 4, Funny

    .. and Sum41. The robot ukulele already has more talent than all of them put together.

    1. Re:Look out boy-bands by EverDense · · Score: 1

      More talent than Tiny Tim as well; at the moment.

      --
      http://jesus.everdense.com/
    2. Re:Look out boy-bands by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ...and Sum41.

      You've never even seen a guitar before, have you?

    3. Re:Look out boy-bands by Tinfoil · · Score: 1

      heh. I see we have a Sum41 fan.

      Yes, I have seen one. I have been playing bass and guitar for longer than you have been on this earth.

    4. Re:Look out boy-bands by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not necessarily a fan, but I can recognize talent when I hear it...seeing as I've played with a wide spectrum of talented (and nontalented) musicians in the past.

  6. no mp3s? by jflash · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I think they're lying - why else would they provide no MP3's? It's not like the Late Great Bob is going to file suit under the DMCA. ** Got to work out why these things can LOOK like they may work, but everyone wants to hear 'em!

    1. Re:no mp3s? by billbaggins · · Score: 1
      Right. You're going something that looks cool, something that geeks are going to be interested in.... in sort, something that's begging to get slashdotted... and you think "Gee, I want to put up some big fat sound files so that visitors can suck up even more bandwidth!"

      The better to melt your server, my dear...

      --
      "The best argument against democracy is a five minute chat with the average voter."
      --Winston Churchill
    2. Re:no mp3s? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Anyone can make a sound file using the real fingers - I need an AVI with audio

  7. The Secret is out by maynard-lag · · Score: 5, Funny

    So this is where all the Back Street boys/n-sync/Brittany Spears music is coming from.

    Now let's see which is more sexy... Brittany or a Ukelelie playing lego robot...

    hrmmm dilemmas dilemmas.

    --
    Have you hugged your Karma Whore today?
    1. Re:The Secret is out by scott1853 · · Score: 4, Funny

      Nothing that advanced is creating their music.

    2. Re:The Secret is out by ryanvm · · Score: 2

      which is more sexy... Brittany or a Ukelelie playing lego robot?

      Or, a Ukulele playing robot Britney?

    3. Re:The Secret is out by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That must be why success in the music business has eluded me: it's supposed to be sexy. Damn, I should have thought of that!

      Steven Strauss
      Improving pitch one string at a atime

  8. Change in EULA by zipC · · Score: 4, Funny

    Strings We Be, the string manufacturer, hereby announce a change to the EULA. Should our strings be installed in any instrument, they should only be played by human hands. This excludes all chimpanzees, robots, and individuals with prostetic hands. We apologize for any inconvenience.

    --
    Madness is only a state of mind
  9. learn to spell you fool by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


    It's Britney, not 'Brittany'.

  10. Singing by prof187 · · Score: 0

    Now all we need are robots that can sing and sound like our favorite artists and screw the RIAA.

    --

    My other sig is an import.
  11. The hard choices one is forced to make. by Treeluvinhippy · · Score: 1

    Now let's see which is more sexy... Brittany or a Ukelelie playing lego robot...

    Well they're both made of plastic and since Britany makes obnoxious noises from her mouth on her own, while a lego robot has to be programmed for it, I say go with the robot.

    --
    >
  12. All well and good . . . by micromoog · · Score: 5, Informative

    . . . but not new. And these guys actually have sound samples, too . . .

    1. Re:All well and good . . . by jimberini · · Score: 1

      Why don't they actually show a detailed picture on their web site (yes, I know they have their patent document, and a fuzzy prototype pic.), or actual songs, just strange audio clips. They also say that they are going into production in December 2000. Where are they?

      'bunch of eerie sounds and a patent application do not a product make! It is enough, however, to raise many $$$ in V.C. funding!

  13. can't wait for the guitar model by tcm614ce · · Score: 0

    honestly, the ukelele is a good first step (if it in fact works as mentioned previously) and doing a guitar wouldn't be that much more difficult. Maybe 1 degree. You'd only need 4 "fingers" to do a guitar and maybe a motor to move them up and down the fretboard...You could do a lot of kewl stuff.

    But robot players will NEVER be better human players! :-)

    --
    Error: Success
    1. Re:can't wait for the guitar model by snatchitup · · Score: 1

      But Robot dancers will kick ass!

      More...

      Man, they can dance!

    2. Re:can't wait for the guitar model by Washizu · · Score: 2

      "You'd only need 4 "fingers" to do a guitar and maybe a motor to move them up and down the fretboard"

      I think it would be easier to get the robot to play open chords with 6 "fingers" than to play barred chords with 4.

      The ultimate test would be to have the ukelele play with a robotic drummer and put a robotic voice over top of it (like Dr. Sbaitso or the voice from OK Computer)

      --
      OddManIn: A Game of guns and game theory.
    3. Re:can't wait for the guitar model by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Good point. 6 fingers that can move independently. I guess the cool part of what these guys did compared to the roboguitar that someone else posted is that this was done with legos.

      I'd like to see a complete robo-band (pronounced roh-bah-band).
      - The robo-piano (a.k.a. player piano) has been around for what? > 100 years?
      - Robo drums seems like an easy one.
      - Bass would be easier than ukelele.

    4. Re:can't wait for the guitar model by dario_moreno · · Score: 2


      don't forget to play computer-generated music using the classical rules of harmony, like on this french site on an automaton

      --
      Google passes Turing test : see my journal
  14. does it come with a remote-controlled campfire? by ossammaa · · Score: 0, Redundant

    does it come with a remote-controlled campfire?

  15. such sadness by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    decades of blood, sweat and tears. Trillions of man hours. Trillions of dollars. Trillions of bugs. And after all that, we get remote controlled musical instruments.. wait a minute...

    C001, YEAH BABY!

  16. Spinal Tap by gila_monster · · Score: 1

    I want to see a full sized lego drummer though.

    Why stop there? Let's make a Lego Spinal Tap. We could have three guitarists, no, make that bassists playing "Big Bottom."

    The exploding drummer would then be trivial: just dump a pile of Legos on the floor. Setting them on fire would be optional.

    --
    Ad luna, Alicia! Ad luna!
  17. Not even remotely a new idea by No+Such+Agency · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Player pianos were made back in Victorian times, and a piano is a "stringed instrument", isn't it? This (very cool) "player ukelele" uses modern computer code, where the pianos used a punch card-like system more akin to older computers. A player piano still had to have a human operator to work foot pedals etc. to give the tune depth and "personality", but in principle this could have been automated too, once the sequence was worked out.

    I *do* wish they'd posted sound samples...

    --
    Freedom: "I won't!"
    1. Re:Not even remotely a new idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Technically, a piano is a percussion instrument since the strings are struck with a mallet instead of plucked, strummed, or bowed. (Unlike the harpsicord which is a string instrument since it's tones are generated by plucking the strings. However, a previous post mentions a similar setup with a guitar, so this isn't totally new.

    2. Re:Not even remotely a new idea by fwankypoo · · Score: 1

      Technically, a guitar is a percussion instrument too.

      --
      The time of day is 29:33.
    3. Re:Not even remotely a new idea by ryanvm · · Score: 2

      I *do* wish they'd posted sound samples...

      I dunno, something tells me it looks better than it sounds.

    4. Re:Not even remotely a new idea by Jonny+Ringo · · Score: 1

      Good point,

      and let us not forget the classic Herby Handcock video "rocket" where there was a whole fleet of robots playing instraments.

    5. Re:Not even remotely a new idea by Buck2 · · Score: 1

      Ha, ha, you're offtopic.

      neener neener

      --

      As my father lik@(munch munch)... ....
  18. Wonderful by colmore · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Sounds cool guys, how about posting some sound files?

    You just have to love stoner geeks.

    --
    In Capitalist America, bank robs you!
  19. Ragtimewest by gCGBD · · Score: 1

    There are a number of really cool robot orchestras and bands and instruments at Ragtime Automated Music

    None of them were done in Legos though...
    --

    O=='=++
  20. Disaster Area by kennon42 · · Score: 2, Funny

    With this technology, they're well on their way to being the loudest band in the universe. Now we just need a good interplanetary internet backbone, so they can send the robot commands from orbit (preferably around a different planet).

    --
    -- Microsoft is the best becau[INVALID PAGE FAULT IN MODULE Signature.exe AT ADDRESS 0x4353]
  21. Yeah but does it... by Shant3030 · · Score: 1

    ... come with a Lego Tiny Tim??

    --
    100% Insightful
    1. Re:Yeah but does it... by cjsnell · · Score: 2


      No, just a Lego Don Ho.

  22. A technological advance by BigJimSlade · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    Wow, now we're one step closer to having giant robotic animals sing *AND* play instruments for us at Chuck E. Cheese!

  23. My dog has fleas by craw · · Score: 1

    My dog has fleas.
    My dog has fleas.
    My dog has fleas.

    I've played the ukelele since I was a little kid. I own a Kamaka ukele whose value has appreciated with time; check out these prices.

    http://www.ukes.com/kamaka.html

  24. Urkel? by yeoua · · Score: 1

    For a second there i thought it read "Lazy Musicians Spawn Robot Urkel"

    Great, all we need is an automatic "Help! I've fallen and I can't get up!"

  25. Which OS? by AndroidCat · · Score: 1

    They don't say which operating system(s) they're using. Could give new meaning to George Formby's When I'm cleaning windows.

    --
    One line blog. I hear that they're called Twitters now.
  26. Agreed.. to bad there's no email address by neilb78 · · Score: 0

    or we could ask them to record one.

    --
    © 2004 The SCO Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
  27. New Legoland exhibit! by jimberini · · Score: 1

    This would be a great addition to Legoland . They could make one of those big lego statues of Bob Marley (I would recomend the one of Bob smoking the ganja )! It could play Marley hits on the hour, and have smoke come out of the joint on the half hour.

    "Mommy hurry! I want to see Bob get stoned!!!"

  28. Lego Robots by sosentos · · Score: 4, Informative

    There was some stuff they didn't really mention on their site that people might be interested in. They used the Handyboard as their microcontroller system. You can learn more about it here.

    http://www.handyboard.com/

    This would also mean they are using Interactive C (a stripped down version of C) for their programming.

    1. Re:Lego Robots by billbaggins · · Score: 1
      This would also mean they are using Interactive C (a stripped down version of C) for their programming.
      Nope. Did you read the page (and specifically the code)? Looks to me like LegoLogo instead.

      Though, yes, handyboard would normally imply something C-like...

      --
      "The best argument against democracy is a five minute chat with the average voter."
      --Winston Churchill
  29. One man's laziness is another man's ingenuity by LeiraHoward · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Wow... For being "lazy," these guys sure put out a lot of effort for their automatic ukelele.

    Now if only someone would "be lazy" and come up with the cure to cancer...

    Seriously, though... I wonder how long til someone comes up with mods for any instrument out there... a piano wouldn't be that hard to do, you'd just need 88 fingers for your robot instead of 4...

    1. Re:One man's laziness is another man's ingenuity by Manitcor · · Score: 2

      Already done. Though it has a 4k price tag.

      --
      "Don't mess with him, he taunts the happy fun ball."
  30. I wonder... by Pig+Hogger · · Score: 0, Troll

    Does Mikefucks Jarvis, or is it Jarvis who fucks Mike???

  31. Lego Strength by jellomizer · · Score: 2

    Now if Legos Held together A little stronger. Then you can make them play Bigger instruments. Like the Double Bass. I dought the Legos will be strong enough to play Larger instruments. That take higher action. To Bad there is no mind erector sets.

    --
    If something is so important that you feel the need to post it on the internet... It probably isn't that important.
    1. Re:Lego Strength by evilempireinc · · Score: 1

      Why not just krazy glue the bricks together? I remember a post a long while back on some guy who built a lego desk through this method

      --
      we can rebuild this sig. we have the technology
    2. Re:Lego Strength by T1girl · · Score: 2

      I would recommend you start with a large bucket of Duplos. They're extra-large Legos made for younger kids with less fine-motor skills, but they are quite sturdy, they hold together better than tiny Legos, and they interconnect with the standard-size Legos. Then you could have fun like these kids.

      Moms like Duplos because they are less likely to step on them in the dark and say bad words.

  32. Iwonder ... by Pig+Hogger · · Score: 0, Troll

    Does Jarvis fucks Mike, or is it Mike who fucks Jarvis???

  33. Ian Anderson by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ian Anderson, of Jethro Tull flutist fame, credits Eric Clapton with his success. He was just thinking about starting the band, and being the guitarist when he went to see Clapton (Cream maybe, I can't remember) in concert.

    He realized he'd never be as good of a guitarist as Clapton, so decided to take up the flute as a gimmick, and it rocketted him to stardom.

    Learn that Ukulele well, and you could be the greatest band since Tull. Who, you might remember, one the first Best Rock Band grammy. They have to be a great band.

  34. Gotta love that Middlebury J-Term! by Heywood+Yabuzof · · Score: 1

    Was this their project for that J-Term Lego Robotics class they linked to? Looks like a cool class.

    For those of you that don't know - Midd (and many other liberal arts colleges) has a special winter term - the whole month of January taking just one class. Most of the classes offered are designed to be somewhat "fun" classes that allow students to get a taste of a field of study not related to their major.

    Generally, you either take a class that has fun activities or one that leaves many daylight hours free during the week for snow-related activities. Ah, gotta love college. ;-)

  35. I guess I should answer my own question: by Heywood+Yabuzof · · Score: 2, Interesting


    final projects for the class

    Of course, this means they actually did this back in January, and "the internet" is just finding out about it now. Maybe they have a full band at this point.

  36. Cute, but not the neatest by io333 · · Score: 1

    The leggo idea is uh... I just can't find the right word. But the most ambitious auto-musician project ever attempted (to date) has been the mubot

  37. potheads by igottheloot · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    damn, i guess potheads DO have some type of motivation in this world.

  38. A ukelele-playing rock star? by cschmidt · · Score: 1
    --

    Who am I to blow against the wind? -- Paul Simon
  39. $100 instead of $5 by cylcyl · · Score: 0
    So, instead of spending $5 to learn a real skill. You end up spending $100 bucks for a toy?

    Kids these days....

    :-)

  40. Rock stardom??? by wompser · · Score: 1

    Rock super-stardom, here I come!

    ummmmm.... can anyone name a rock superstar who plays the ukelele??? Tiny tim???

    --
    .....
    1. Re:Rock stardom??? by jonerik · · Score: 2

      ummmmm.... can anyone name a rock superstar who plays the ukelele??? Tiny tim???

      George Harrison was a big collector of ukeleles; particularly Gibsons and Martins. He frequently gave them to friends as gifts. I'm told that on his recent tour Paul McCartney regularly performed "Something" on ukelele as a tribute to Harrison. Seems to me that Brian May played some ukelele on a few of the mid-'70s Queen records, too.

    2. Re:Rock stardom??? by daddymac · · Score: 1

      Duke Of Uke. He covers such songs as "Smells Like Teen Spirit" and "Anarchy in the UK". just him and his Uke, very interesting.

      --
      If something I said can be interpreted two ways, and one of the ways makes you sad or angry, I meant the other one.
    3. Re:Rock stardom??? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Eric Clapton, John Paul Jones (Led Zeppelin), Paul McCartney is in fact playing it in concert these days, George Harrison played it on the Anthology program, Neil Innes, Irving of the fantastic band Mailbox, and Chris from the St. Olaf Emergency Statue Fund often electrifies his uke and brings the house down.

      -Chris "yes, that one" Combs

  41. Schoolwork. by Kafir · · Score: 3, Informative

    I think it's worth pointing out that both the guys who did this are students at Middlebury College, where for several years now "Lego Robotics" has been offered as a J-term class.

    During the one-month January semester, or "J-term," you take just one class. Some of the classes are frivolous, though physics or foreign language majors tend to have to take things in their fields. Anyway, Lego Robotics has been one of the more sought-after courses. Partly because of the inherent appeal of Lego robots, partly because it has a schedule that allows a lot of days to be devoted to skiing.

  42. Ukulego...? by AnalogDiehard · · Score: 1

    Q: What's the definition of perfect pitch?
    A: When you throw the accordian in the dumpster and it lands square on the ukulele.

    --
    Eternity: will that be smoking, or non-smoking? I Corinthians 6:9-10
  43. Guitarmachine by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Okay, so he's not a robot, but this thing is pretty cool anyway. He plays the guitar using mechanics controlled by his feet (one strumming, one chording) and then plays dobro & banjo to accompany himself. I've seen him around Cambridge, MA on the streets & have been much impressed.

    http://www.guitarmachine.com/machine.phtml

  44. That's nothing... by sadclown · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Check this out.
    Robot saxophonist and trumpeter from Japan.

  45. Modern Player Pianos by Manitcor · · Score: 1

    Today most any piano can be converted to a player piano using similar tech as the lego player. It even uses CD-ROMS for its song data.

    I could not find a site but I have also seen full size pianos with sytems like this actually inside the piano and the CD-ROM mounted under the keyboard so that one could accompany a song running from the CD.

    --
    "Don't mess with him, he taunts the happy fun ball."
  46. Rebecca Horn by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    she has done some pretty amazing mechanical things.

    http://www.dialnsa.edu/iat97/Sculpture/horn.html

  47. IT'S BEEN DONE! by newestbob · · Score: 1
    I'm amused by the way these kids on this site think they did something "new." They didn't, but this culture we have discourages kids from asking senior members of their community about Prior Art. (After all, what do us seniors know about High-Tech?)

    Here's a robot violin, built over 65 years ago! And here's a "robot" mechanical harp, built in the 1920's.

    Want to see something more recent? Here's a mechanical MIDI-controlled BANJO and GUITAR, currently being sold by a California company called "Ragtime:".

    Sure, it's mildly interesting that they used their lego toys to get the mechanicals right, but people have been plucking string instruments with robots for at least 80 years.

  48. Nice, but can it play... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...the one-hole skin flute?

  49. How did we ever manage... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...to live without a remote controlled self-playing ukulele?

    Now our lives are complete!

  50. Captured! By Robots! by Bogatyr · · Score: 2

    Captured By Robots is this amazing one-man performance with one of the most intricate rigs I've ever seen. He's really impressive to see live, and I recommend checking his tour/shows page especially if you're on the West Coast. At least one regular slashdot poster has taken his /. handle from the guy's act (The Ape With No Name), or I'm assuming that's where it's from. s

  51. Re:uh oh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You used single quotes in your submission, buddy... that breaks buggy slashcode.

  52. Hmmm. by Pig+Hogger · · Score: 1

    I wonder if it is Jarvis who fucks Mike, or is it Mike who fucks Jarvis???