Slashdot Mirror


Embedded Linux In Onkyo's Home Music Server

IrateSurf writes "ExtremeTech has a story about a new use of embedded Linux from Onkyo, which runs a home music server. Their NAS-2.3 has a CD-player as well as an 80GB hard drive for storing music and streaming it to other players on the an Ethernet network. Also check out the web site for the NAS-2.3." If only they would make it record radio, too ...

23 of 203 comments (clear)

  1. they must be rich by Stanley+Feinbaum · · Score: 4, Interesting

    They must be rich if they can afford to have 80gigs worth of legal copies of their music...

    if each album takes 80megs about.. then the hd can hold 1000 albums... 1000 albums at 20$ an album is 20,000$ !

    Who can afford to spend that much on music?

    --

    Stanley Feinbaum, professional journalist and master debater! God bless the USA!

    1. Re:they must be rich by infolib · · Score: 3, Insightful

      They must be rich if they can afford to have 80gigs worth of legal copies of their music...

      Actually I just checked hard drive prices:
      Cheapest available 40GB drive: $93.30
      Cheapest available 40GB drive: $120.51
      (Note that these prices are converted from DKK)

      Since this is a $400 product, I wouldn't halve the storage space just to save 30 bucks.

      Stanley Feinbaum, professional journalist and master debater!

      You've come to the wrong place...

      --
      Any sufficiently advanced libertarian utopia is indistinguishable from government.
    2. Re:they must be rich by Dalroth · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I know a guy from college who worked at a *LIBRARY*. He was about 22 years old and had well over a thousand CDs.

      I have well over 500 cds myself. I *WOULD* have more if they didn't cost so much. Back in the day when they used to cost $10 I made a trip to the store every week to purchase CDs.

      Now a days, I make almost 8 times what I used to make. Maybe I'm getting cheaper in my old age (probably true), maybe new music sucks (it does but there is still a lot of stuff I like), but I can't justify $20+ for a CD I don't even know if I'll like. Were that not the case, I know I would have more. Most of my friends are the same. Between us we've got 1000's of CDs lying around our homes and apartments.

      It's not impossible, in fact, in my experience it's quite likely.

    3. Re:they must be rich by sammy.lost-angel.com · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Classical music CDs are often very cheap. $5 if you go for bargins. Some of these are even double albums, and almost always filled. Don't forgot people that work in the music industry, who get several free cds in the mail daily.

    4. Re:they must be rich by ediron2 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Spread the cost out, man... ask 'Who can afford a few grand a year?!'

      Young people. 15 to 25, no mortgage or significant debt, a job, and lots of exposure via friends to help thin out the good music from the bad before buying...

      I bought music from when I was 15 to about 28 yrs old, and didn't buy much compared to most of my music-fanatic friends. Since then, I've tapered off to a few cd's a year, plus a few more as gifts. I've got well over 100 tapes, 150 in vinyl, 250 cd's, and one 8-track (Abbey Road, don't ask why). And I repeat, I wasn't SERIOUSLY into music like several friends I had...

      So, 1000 seems quite plausible. What's more, a lot of those I got via cheap sources: rummage & yard sales, used bins, friends, etc. Nowadays, I pick up a cd when I hear a good concert or live band in a bar. Since the night's bar tab has usually cost me a lot more than the $10-15 for the CD, I consider it a tip to a good band and a chance to reminisce later.

      Round down to 15k (that's being charitable compared to your $20 per album), give me 1/5 the needed collection, and spread it over the last 30 years, and it seems laughably cheap... $100 a YEAR on average. Rich?! Shee-it, I spent more last weekend on sushi! Throw in the wife's similarly-sized music collection, not force me to waste a wall in my li'l house (not to mention portability like ipods and archos units have) and give me access to stuff that's only available on out-of-print vinyl and I'd probably start collecting old, good music like a fiend.

  2. Why not wireless? by Metalhead01 · · Score: 5, Interesting
    There are a lot of these little guys popping up on the market, yet all of them use a physical connection. Is there some inherent technical problem with using an 802.11b device to stream the music?

    --
    The only reason I keep my Windows partition is so I can mount it like the bitch that it is.
    1. Re:Why not wireless? by pummer · · Score: 3, Informative

      you should be able to use one of these for wireless. It's an adapter that plugs into ethernet ports and turns them into wireless.

    2. Re:Why not wireless? by Drakin · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Price, simple as that. They're trying to keep the price as low as possible, and adding wireless supporty would likely as $50 to $100 to the price, for functionality not everyone would use.

      The consumer base (not more geek minded users) hasn't really started to adopt wireless in a major way, while they're getting into devices like this.

  3. Archos Radio Recorders by Foxxz · · Score: 5, Informative

    "If only they would make it record radio, too ..."

    See archos for devices that record raido directly into mp3. They have a hard drive and a smart media device that does that i beleive. Plus they keep the last 30 seconds of audio in memory in case the song you want has already started you can still get the begining.

    -Foxxz

  4. does it matter what OS it's running? by rtphokie · · Score: 5, Insightful

    mod this flamebait if you must but I gotta ask, what does it really matter what OS it's running?

    It could run TRS-DOS for all I care as long as it gets the job done efficiently.

    1. Re:does it matter what OS it's running? by Erik+Hollensbe · · Score: 3, Interesting

      What about sharp (the zaurus, makers of various consumer electronics), or the empeg (who didn't make anything prior)? Or TiVO?

      Sony DOES use linux on their consoles. In fact, you can get a kit that lets you do development on PS2 hardware.

      And, Diamond got their name making video cards. Only later did they start making everything that fits in a PCI slot (this was shortly after they bought Supra).

      I just find it hard to believe, that embedded linux has been out for how many years, and we're still cheering about it being licensed?

      Lineo (or whoever owns them now) did the world a great service and may have made some money at it, and now linux is everywhere.

      But what's next, are we going to hear about the embedded linux that's in the next high tech microwave?

      At this point, it's really not the fact that /. posted this -- I'm not surprised at all. It's just that there has to be a point where you guys realize that it's already BEEN accepted in this market.

      If you guys masturbate too much, it's just not going to feel good anymore.

  5. Other sources by pompomtom · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Legal mp3's don't have to come off a $20 CD.

    Check acidplanet.com mp3.com mp3.com.au spinwarp.com etc etc etc

    --

    Buckets,

    pompomtom

    "There's an exception to every rule. Except for some rules"
  6. Article Text by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    Onkyo (www.onkyousa.com) is one of the better-known Japanese manufacturers of home theater gear. Recently, the company has begun building audio and home theater equipment with built-in Ethernet ports, rather than some proprietary connectivity scheme. PC Magazine wrote about one of Onkyo's product, the NC500 Net-Tune Receiver. However, the Net-Tune receiver is perhaps the least interesting of the products, offering the now-familiar paradigm -- the digital receiver that can route music from your PC to your home audio system. The NC500 does have a stereo amplifier, but is otherwise similar to products from Turtle Beach, Sonic Blue and others. However, Onkyo is bringing Ethernet capability to a full-fledged, Dolby Digital/DTS 7.1 receiver in it's TX-NR900, THX-Select certified home theater receiver. The TX-NR900 offers 110 watts RMS into 7 channels, supports all the major surround sound standards and can act as a Net-Tune client, allowing you to pipe the digital music from your PC directly to your home theater rack. In addition to the usual array of input and output ports is a standard, 10 megabit Ethernet port.

    That's pretty cool, but that's not all. Onkyo also sells a line of high-end gear targeted towards custom installations under its Integra brand. Onkyo offers products similar to the NC500 and TX-NR900, but with additional capabilities. What's most interesting, though, is the Integra NAS-2.3 Net-Tune Server.

    At first blush, the NAS-2.3 seems like a CD player, but it also has an embedded 80GB hard drive. So now it appears to be like any number of digital music players on the scene. But the NAS-2.3 also has a 10/100 Ethernet port, and is capable of acting as a music server to a network of Net-Tune devices. Running on the Integra product is an embedded Linux operating system, which acts as the server software.

    The NAS-2.3 can support up to 12 simultaneous streams to Net-Tune receivers or other clients. You can have different tracks playing in multiple rooms, move music to a PC, display a playlist on most types of displays (the NAS-2.3 has VGA, S-Video and composite video outputs) and can even connect up to CDDB to download track information on various CDs.

    One other interesting aspect of the NAS-2.3 is the availability of an empty drive sled inside the box, allowing users or installers to add additional hard drive space. You can't use a standard, PC-formatted hard drive, according to Eric Harper, Integra's Custom Installation and Product Manager. The formatting is somewhat different, but a knowledgeable user or installer should be able to add another drive to the server.

    So if you don't want the headache of building your own music server from a PC, then the NAS-2.3 can integrate into your home Ethernet network, co-existing quite well with your PC systems. It's an intriguing idea that embraces the PC network, rather than trying to remain isolated.

    NNY News with a twist of lime.

  7. I'd like more TIVO like functionality by SuperCal · · Score: 3, Redundant

    I'd like one to work more like a radio Tivo. Say I always listen to Neal Boortz and Sean Hanity, then maybe the machine will sugest old Rush. Or if I always listen to the new rock station, maybe save the new rock show (or what ever the call radio segments) on a different station. Of cource without any real listings of radio shows, like a radio TV Guide, all that may be asking to much...

    --
    Business News and Resources: www.usasource.net
  8. Ogg by Gyorg_Lavode · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It mentions that files must be in mp3 or pcm format. Now alot of my music is actually in ogg. First, if it's embeded linux, will there be a means by which we can install other codecs? (say ssh or such.) Second, will there be a supplied means to upgrade the hard drive? (I know you might not need 80gigs for your legal collection but my illegal collections already over that. by far.)

    --
    I do security
  9. Re:why by YrWrstNtmr · · Score: 4, Interesting

    why do they have to make these so big??

    1. space for all the connections in the back

    2. power amp cooling. Driving serious power to multiple large speakers takes power. That heat needs to be dissipated.

    3. It looks better

  10. Recording Radio.... by Penguin2212 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I would question the market viability of a device designed to copy songs from the radio. When you copy a CD that you bought and paid for, you are buying the material on the CD. You are purchasing a copy. When you hear a song on the radio, you are hearing performance of the song. An artist/record company makes money for every copy and performance made. If you buy a CD and copy it (assuming that you don't share it or anything) just to listen to it on a device such as this, you aren't taking any more than what you paid for. But if you copy from the radio, you are. In fact this was the basis for the case against radio stations streaming broadcasts over the internet, because temporary copies of songs were made on the user's hard drive therefore making it a copy. Most of you have probablly heard of that case. Most radio stations have ceased to do so because of this, and are fighting it as well. I'm not trying to defend the RIAA in any way. However, a device that would facilitate copying of music from the radio would definitely come under serious fire from the RIAA, IMHO.

  11. Input Sources by Dark+Warrior · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Maybe I missed it, but I didn't see ethernet as one of the input sources. I have that 1400 legal MP3s ripped from my CDs--I'm not sure I want to go thru that again.

  12. Running gerbilware by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Sorry for the subject line, but that's what I think whenever I see one of these embedded Linux stories--"For all I care it's powered by gerbils running in exercise wheels." Am I happy to see Linux get a little positive press? Sure, but let's not read more into this than it deserves. The rest of the world won't know this thing has "Linux Inside", nor will they care. The Linux crowd should be focused on the real battleground, the desktop, and derailing MS's monopoly.

  13. Redundant hard drives? by zerofoo · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Of all the "music server" products i've seen on the market, i've yet to see one that has redundant hard drives. Maybe these things haven't been on the market long enough, but eventually the hard drives in these devices will fail, and when they do, there are going to be some very pissed off consumers out there.

    Until recently, audio gear manufacturers never had to worry about the storage media. When you bought the music, you bought a hard copy of that media (cd, record, tape...etc). I understand that these devices still require you to purchase the "hard copy" of the music, but do you want to re-rip 500 CDs just because your hard drive went clunk-clunk?

    -ted

  14. There is a reason they choose Linux . . by MrLinuxHead · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Onkyo is smart for using Linux. Nearly all the Pacific Rim (Sony, Pioneer, Panasonic, ect.) manufacturers are testing it or are ready to deploy because they don't need to pay out royalties per unit, can share innovations with each other, and can share data with each other's units over 100Mb Ethernet or 802.11x or whatever. The most important thing to remember is they don't need to spend huge amounts on R&D. Linux will become the Linga Franca of consumer electronics, unless Microsoft buys one of the big players and twists everyone's arm to go along. Maybe not even then, as the long term gains are too big. And most Japanese electronics manufacturers are thinking very long term.

    And yes these babies are BIG! And HEAVY! At 110 RMS per CH. Thats 660 Watts out, all discrete. No output IC's. Not to mentions pre amp and video switching. Schwweett.

    Inputs:

    Audio and AV Inputs - 3/6

    HDTV-Ready Component Video Input/Output - 2/1

    Front-Panel Video Input (with S-Video) - Yes

    S-Video Compatible Jacks Input/Output - 6/3

    Digital Inputs:

    5 Optical (1 Front Panel), 3 Coaxial

    Digital Output - 2 Optical Amp In

    RS-232 Control Port

    IR In/Out - 1/1

    --
    I may be bad with names, but I'll never forget your IP address
    1. Re:There is a reason they choose Linux . . by abimelech · · Score: 3, Informative

      Your specs seem to refer to the TX-NR900 reciever. This does not run Linux, it merely plays music from a network connection. I don't think Linux is required for such basic functionality.

      http://www.imerge.co.uk/products/improductsimage s/ downloadphotos0901/S2000/S2000row34.jpg

      The Integra NAS-2.3 Net-Tune Server is the Linux based product. It's actually a rebranded Imerge product, from the UK. You can control the server via a TV, Monitor, PC, Palm, IR Pronto etc... Check out the LCD, it's just a bog standard LCD display used by many case modders - not a custom built VFD display as found on most hifi components.

  15. Re:What I'm waiting for... by seanadams.com · · Score: 3, Informative

    A rendezvous enabled wireless device that ties into my music collection (yes, iTunes).

    Slim Devices probably has what you're looking for. It doesn't use Rendezvous (yet) but does have all the things that Rendezvous has been promising (auto-discovery of server, integration with iTunes). A lot of companies are hawking auto-disocvery like it's some revoultionary technology... ummmmm it's a couple tiny UDP packets in each direction. That's it. We were doing this long before anyone had heard of Rendezvous.

    But Rendezvous is evoving into more than that... we recently showed the product at Macworld in San Francisco, and received a very enthusiastic response from the iTunes developers at Apple. They're opening up more of their system to us, so expect to see even better integration with MacOS iApps in our next software updates for the SLIMP3.

    BTW, the HomePod is about where we were two years ago. Seriously, they're good guys, and geeks like us, but don't expect them to ship anything for a few more months.