Slashdot Mirror


Highs And Lows Of Game Character Design

Thanks to an anonymous reader for pointing to a Gamers.com article discussing the best and worst character designs in videogames. The author singles out his favorite designs, including Samus Aran, Solid Snake, and Sonic The Hedgehog, and then picks Ratchet, Plok, and Boogerman as examples of characters that just don't make the grade. It may not be the final word on the subject, but it's a good starting position to answer the question: "Who became an absorbing avatar with which to explore a virtual world, and who was just plain painful to look at?"

44 comments

  1. The best is sonic of course.. by MoOsEb0y · · Score: 1

    I mean besides Mario, who else got a cartoon show?

    1. Re:The best is sonic of course.. by PaganRitual · · Score: 1

      Link did. It was called, 'The Legend of Zelda' funnily enough.

    2. Re:The best is sonic of course.. by FauxReal · · Score: 0

      Pac-Man had a cartoon way before all those guys. Pac-Man Cartoon link.

    3. Re:The best is sonic of course.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      who can forget the musical cgi nightmare of donkey kongs animated show *shudder*

    4. Re:The best is sonic of course.. by FauxReal · · Score: 0

      woops here's a link to a page about the pac-man cartoon. http://www.classicgaming.com/pac-man/Cartoon/

    5. Re:The best is sonic of course.. by Andy_R · · Score: 1

      Lara Croft got an entire movie.

      Several movies if you count the pr0n ones...

      --
      A pizza of radius z and thickness a has a volume of pi z z a
    6. Re:The best is sonic of course.. by th3space · · Score: 1

      Didn't Q-Bert get his own show at some point? Maybe an inclusion into some other cartoon show?

      --
      "How like you to drag your keyboard to a gun fight." - Aaron Bedard (BANE)
    7. Re:The best is sonic of course.. by ichimunki · · Score: 1

      The whole Pac-Family had a show.

      --
      I do not have a signature
    8. Re:The best is sonic of course.. by devnull17 · · Score: 1

      Ummm... Link/Zelda, Donkey Kong, 151 different Pokemon (more now), Digimon, Pac-Man (I shit you not)...

      Of course, only Sonic had two cartoon shows... the serious and cool Japanese version and the abominable American one featuring those two Pokemon rejects.

  2. Some of the best characters in PC games ... by PaganRitual · · Score: 4, Interesting

    ... are easily the Meccaryns (read: humans with cockney accents) from Giants : Citizen Kabuto ... one of the few games where I actually bothered to watch all the cutscenes. Those guys cracked me up. They were so well designed that while you could appreciate the humour and really get to like them, at the same time they were still impressive when they opened up with their weaponry.

    Im sure if the article didnt have such a massive console bias then it would have mentioned other cool characters such as :

    JC Denton from Deus Ex.
    Cate Archer from NOLF.
    Garret from Thief.
    Gordon Freeman from Half Life. ... but of course they all pale to ...

    THE DOOM GUY.

    sure, that was his name, and he had no voice other than a couple of grunts and a great death scream, but its one of the coolest avatars out there.

    1. Re:Some of the best characters in PC games ... by bigman2003 · · Score: 1

      Cate Archer from No One Lifes Forever (especially 2) was the hottest digital character I have ever seen. NOLF2 site at Sierra This chick is awesome!

      I love the shots of her in her cute little snow suit, the one with the fuzzy stuff around her wrists. And what about those sweet gloves?

      Cate is a hottie, and I wish there was more of her. Too bad the game is an FPS- even though I hate third-person perspectives, this is one game where it would work. Or, maybe they could have had a lot of mirrors in the game.

      What about a Cate Archer dance party? That would be good...

      This is sick- but I really do dig her. I was obsessed with her, the same way this guy ( Scary Dude ) is obsessed with Peter Pan. (No, I didn't dress up) Okay, on second thought, I don't want to be associated with that guy- he scares me.

      They *should* make a Cate Archer movie though...mmm...mmmmmm

      (just so you know, I have a fiance (a real woman) and we have sex regularly)

      --
      No reason to lie.
    2. Re:Some of the best characters in PC games ... by saladpuncher · · Score: 1

      Since you are so obsessed over Cate you probably know that she is actually real and based on model Mitzi Martin. Do a google search on here and you can find TONS of pictures. The real women is just as hot as well :)

    3. Re:Some of the best characters in PC games ... by saladpuncher · · Score: 1

      Oops...and I forgot to mention that she plays one of the "Hot Chicks" in Dude, Where's My Car. Although I wouldn't rent the film unless I needed fuel for a bonfire.

  3. If you like the DOOM guy... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Dude, the Doom guy was great, but then came Duke Nuke'em.
    All those corny one-liners. He RAWKED man!

  4. Leaves out the greats by Traderdot · · Score: 4, Insightful
    A fairly lame article. Leaves out the greats. What about:

    (Super) Mario
    The entire cast of Street Fighter 2 characters
    Rockman/Megaman
    Link from Zelda
    Pokemon (not for me, but the kiddies like it)

    These ones are truly iconic/memorable. Esp the Street Fighter characters who had a whole backstory which you found out when you finished the game.

    1. Re:Leaves out the greats by libnatel · · Score: 1

      he didnt leave out street fighter 2, he said all american fightings games are crap. though i think street fichter 2 kicked ass. vega was a bad ass

  5. Ratchet & Clank postmortem by beders · · Score: 3, Informative

    Postmortem by the team behind Ratchet and Clank available on Gamasutra, registration may be required.

    Relevant problem, the main characer look "too cartoony", anyway, look for yourself!

  6. What about PS:Torment? by PurpleFloyd · · Score: 4, Insightful
    The best game characters I've ever seen were in Planescape: Torment. With the main character a nameless, immortal amnesiac who just woke up in the morgue, and supporting characters like Morte the wisecracking skull, an insane robot, voiced by Dan Castanella (you probably know him as Homer Simpson), or the chaste succubus who acts as madam of the Brothel of Slating Intellectual Lust, (featuring pleasures for the mind, rather than the body), all the characters tend to stick with you.

    The neatest thing about the characters in PS:Torment was that they reacted in a plausible way, given their strange situations and surroundings. Everyone has a motivation, and it's not always what you think. Take the character Morte, who I mentioned above. While he seems to be nothing more than rather cliched comic relief in the beginning, his character gains a significant amount of depth.

    And of course, who can forget Minsc from Baldur's Gate, and his miniature giant space hamster Boo? "Go for the eyes, Boo! Go for the eyes!"

    --

    That's it. I'm no longer part of Team Sanity.
  7. The Grunts from Halo are my favs by brave1 · · Score: 1

    I think that Halo has some great characters. The grunts are my favorites. They are just hilarious! They have some of the best Quotes.

    One of my favorite things is to sneak up on a group of Grunts that are sitting somewhere chilling and stick a plasma grenade to one of their backs. Sometimes they will let out an anguished "NOOOOOOooOOOOOO!!!"

    I think that the master chief is also well designed. When you're playing you feel like walking destruction with a sense of humor. I read that they purposefully never show the Master Chief's face because they want the player to be able to identify with him.

    Here's a link to a Gamasutra article on Character Design

    --
    - http://www.braveterry.com/
    1. Re:The Grunts from Halo are my favs by ArmorFiend · · Score: 1
      These guys kinda remind me of the terrans from starcraft. Can anyone beat:

      I'm ready to drop the hammer and unleash some indescriminate justice!

      Its the kind of quote that comes in handy on a daily basis. At least for me. Your job might be slightly more boring.
    2. Re:The Grunts from Halo are my favs by RealityMogul · · Score: 1

      So how's that NYC cop job working out?

  8. funny how they single out plok by joFFeman · · Score: 1

    but i'm inclined to believe they didn't even play the game, since the way plok actually plays is pretty unique and while not exceptionally FUN, you can do a hell of a lot worse. plok himself isn't a totally empty character, and he shows a good bit of emotion at the end of the level when the wrong flag is up the pole, plus there's the frontside pocket which makes plok seem to be groping himself- how can you not get a kick out of that?

    --
    "Life is great; without it, you'd be dead." -Harmony Korine
  9. Lara Croft. by Rip!ey · · Score: 1

    "Who became an absorbing avatar with which to explore a virtual world, and who was just plain painful to look at?"

    Lara "They can't possibly be real" Croft.

    She fits the former group and is definitely not in the latter. Dare I admit it.

    1. Re:Lara Croft. by ichimunki · · Score: 1

      Ugh. The character, as drawn, was okay, but even the female characters in Advance Wars on GBA are more fun to look at, imho. But they're cute cartoons as opposed to virtual RealDolls. And no matter how nice Lara might have looked, that game played like garbage-- a severely mitigating factor if you ask me (which I you didn't, but I'm saying it anyway *grin*).

      --
      I do not have a signature
  10. What about SHODAN? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    The insane AI from the System Shock games.

    "Look at you hacker. A pathetic creature of meat and bone, panting and sweating as you run through my corridors. How can you chalenge a perfect immortal machine?"

    Classic.

    1. Re:What about SHODAN? by JonathanBoyd · · Score: 1

      Bah. The Marathon series had Durandal, the insane AI of the colony ship Marathon before that. He was cool.

    2. Re:What about SHODAN? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The concept is obviously ripped from HAL in 2001 anyway. I understand that Marathon is something of a sacred cow for mac heads, but its not the alpha and the omega.

      I googled some quotes from Durandal and have to say that I prefer SHODAN.

    3. Re:What about SHODAN? by Lazyhound · · Score: 1
  11. So everybody is afraid to say it ? by El_Muerte_TDS · · Score: 1

    Duke Nukem

  12. THE Duke Guy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You're damn right man!
    That duke dude was terrific!
    I can remember some hilarious quotes and the way he is speaking is so kewl! the best caricature of the tough guy going to war ever!

    "Come get someâ
    âoeHail to the king, baby"
    "What are you waiting for? Christmas?"
    "It's time to kick ass and chew bubble gum and I' m aaaaall out of gum!"
    "Now ... I'm reaaaally pissed off"
    when he picks up a shotgun : "This'll be a barrel of laughs"
    when he crosses a road in Manhattan Project :"What do you think I am? A frog? " (refering to a well known frog game;-) )
    to the girls "Do you want to test my big gun ?"
    about the cards to collect to progress in the game "These colored keycards suck"
    "damn that was annoying"
    "ooooh, thats gonna leave a mark"
    "What a mess"
    "Your face, your ass... What's the difference"
    "Bring It On"
    "Damn! Those alien bastards are gonna pay for ruining my ride"

    and so many others damn that was good!

    1. Re:THE Duke Guy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Im gonna rip your head off and shit down your throat

  13. Yoshitata Amano's Final Fantasy designs by Stephen+Williams · · Score: 1

    Yoshitaka Amano did the character designs for the Nintendo-generation Final Fantasy games, and also for FFIX, the last of the FFs on the original Playstation. His concept art has a delicate, flowing, romantic quality that is quite unlike most videogame concept art, and very different from the more down-to-earth designs that Tetsuya Nomura did for FFVII, VIII and X.

    If you've never seen any Amano art, Google for something like "yoshitaka amano final fantasy" and have a look.

    -Stephen

  14. Fairly Decent Article by Iammadmak · · Score: 1

    It could have encompassed more characters, but left out such characters as Mario and Link because they are great character designs that most people know of and require little commentary. Its good they acknowledged Bubsy as that is one of my biggest regrets of the 16 bit era

  15. Plok - is a *great* game by szyzyg · · Score: 2, Informative

    They seem to miss the point that plok is a perfect example of how you can make a generic character truly memorable. When the title screen pops up an uptempo bluesy harmonica driven soundtrack kicks in and plok drops in playing the lead, toes a tappin. The music in the game is fantastic - Tim Follin is a great composer of video game music.

    Then we have the whole presentation of plok, he runs around, jumps, spins and throws punches and kicks at the enemies. Literally, his arms and legs fly away, and sometimes you find his dismembers body bouncing along trying to recover a lost leg so he can jump again.

    And to add to the Plok family there's Grandpa Plok, which we see in a set of levels that are all sepia toned. And there's many powered up variations, helicopter, cycler, unicycler, tank, rockets, sherlok plok, super plok.

    AT LAST, A REAL HERO!
    Plok is an irresistible, irrepressible, unstoppable, highly improbable and downright dangerous bundle of pure energy.
    Plok does not like fleas.
    Plok has the amazing ability to fire all his body parts at will.
    Plok can really 'throw' a punch.
    Plok has a very short fuse; at the slightest irritation those limbs begin to fly.
    Plok hates fleas.
    Plok is a true hero, with a heart of gold and joints of the highest-quality velcro.
    Plok is a man with a mission. He is dedicated to ridding the world of the dreaded Fleas.
    Plok is a dreamer, a wanderer, a free spirit. He's suave and elegant. He's grade-A, first-class prime cut.
    Plok really does not like Fleas.
    Plok is the king of the beautiful island called Akrillic, part of the archipelago Poly-Esta

  16. Jojo's Bizarre adventure by MyDixieWrecked · · Score: 1
    By far, the best character designs ever. The most unique and varied selection of characters I've ever seen in a game.

    although, I'd have to say that it helps that the game is based on an anime and manga.

    Try a google search for images.

    As for characters designed specifically for videogames, I'd say Mario is by far the coolest character ever.

    --



    ...spike
    Ewwwwww, coconut...
  17. Boogerman. by readpunk · · Score: 1

    Although like many I thought he was a disgusting and pointless character, I know for a fact that the boogerman SNES game sold well and did incredibly well in the rental market. So I don't think it is a good idea to classify this moronic and ultimatly dead (thankfully) character a failure. Oh and Mario > *. Don't mess with the plumber assholes.

    --

    ./revolution
  18. Get that freakin' duck away from me! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What about the "dragon" from Adventure!?

  19. Don't forget the bad guys! by cloudless.net · · Score: 1

    Don't leave out Kefka in Final Fantasy VII, the greatest bad guy in video game ever. Uweeheehee!

    And Bowser in Super Mario RPG... he actually joined Mario's team in the middle of the game as a playable character!

  20. The best ones by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Chrono Trigger.

  21. Glad to see Sonic made the grade. by BitwizeGHC · · Score: 1

    It wasn't just the spiky hair. Sonic is rendered with simple shapes and solid colors, and he has a streamlined look about him that conveys speed and grace. Combine that with the fast-twitch gameplay and smooth physics of his platformers, and you have a memorable game with a memorable hero.

    The only 16-bit knockoff character who even came close to Sonic was Konami's Sparkster the Rocket Knight. (Find an old cartridge or ROM of Rocket Knight Adventures; it's surprisingly fun.)

    Of course, Sega has always had a plethora of good character designs; consider Ulala, the heroine of Space Channel 5. It isn't often that you come across a female game character who's deliberately sexy without being shamelessly exploitative. Ulala has a style all her own... well, not really since Lady Miss Kier is suing Sega over her look, but still, she is a refreshing character.

    --
    N4st0r, trixx0r h0bb1tz0rz! Th3y st0l3 0ur pr3c10uzz!
  22. Blood! by Soul+Brother+#1 · · Score: 1

    They left out Caleb from Blood. I liked that game even more than Duke Nukem 3D.


    "Whooah! Oh...it's just me..."


    -Caleb, after looking in the mirror

    --
    All unfair meta-mods are now being meta-meta-modded as retarded.
  23. the Superhero League of Hoboken... by Myself · · Score: 1

    Had the most wonderful names for its characters. How are you gonna beat the Crimson Tape? (his special power is Organizational Charts)

    To further quote the ibiblio review, "However, the pictures are so colorful, so unique and lively that identifying with the characters is easy. Captain Excitement, Oxide Man, Princess Glovebox, they are much more memorable and interesting then any amount of warriors or mages. Every character seems to spring to life."

    How can you not love characters who turn things to rust?

  24. umm... by libnatel · · Score: 1

    i think your forgeting about mega man. he had tons of games, his own tv show, and a brand new tv show.

    p.s. he'd beat sonic and day of the week in a fight.

    1. Re:umm... by GR1NCH · · Score: 1

      The Street Fighter Gang had a movie, an anime movie, and several anime series. I think that qualifies them as well.