Slashdot Mirror


Flash Mobs: Peaceable Assembly for Spontaneous Fun

Schmendr1ck writes "The Orlando Sentinel is carrying a story on the growing trend of 'creating a crowd on a moment's notice for no particular reason' knows as a flash mob. Recent flash mobs (sometimes hundreds of people) have wandered into into an upscale NYC shoe store acting like confused tourists from Maryland, gathered at the Hyatt near Grand Central Station for 15 seconds of spontaneous applause, and converged on the Macy's carpet department to debate the quality of the rugs for sale. Check cheesebikini? for pictures and info on past mobs, as well as links to sites that organize these events. Sounds like a fun, harmless, and Constitutionally-protected way of blowing off a little steam."

30 of 543 comments (clear)

  1. Constitutional protection! Ha! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Just wait until someone high up views this as a threat and that Constitution guarantee gets brushed aside as something from a "different era" like concerns about quartering soldiers.

    1. Re:Constitutional protection! Ha! by MrLint · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Perhaps you will recall the "kmart" incident. This is where the cops took it upon themselves to hold a 'raid' on people in the in the parking lot of a 24 hour kmart and a fast food restaurant. There was no complaint by kmart and the cops arrested people who has just exited both the kmart and the fast food joint without cause, under the auspices of 'loitering' or something else equally as stupid.

      Im going to end my commentary here.before i get more irritated. It might please you to know that the cops got in a shit load of trouble and all the people were un-arrested.

    2. Re:Constitutional protection! Ha! by ScottGant · · Score: 4, Interesting

      If you were to actually go to the newspaper site and READ what really happened, you would be singing a different story.

      Here is a quote from one of the newspaper stories about this incident:

      "Houston cops planned for weeks to swoop down on a parking lot and nab a bunch of drag racers but couldn't find any when they got there. So, what the heck, they just rounded up everyone in the parking lot outside a 24-hour Kmart and a Sonic Drive-In and charged the whole bunch with trespassing. No joke."

      Here's the address of the story...I suggest you read through it and find that the police chief was fired and went through a trial and the entire police dept of Houston got slapped down pretty hard.

      http://www.chron.com/cs/CDA/story.hts/special/ra id /1542463

      --

      "Music is everybody's possession. It's only publishers who think that people own it." - John Lennon.
    3. Re:Constitutional protection! Ha! by LS · · Score: 2, Interesting

      How do you differentiate between a mobber and a shopper? Should the store owners and cops learn how to read minds? These people do not know each other. There is no central organization. How do you know who is in the store legitimately?

      LS

      --
      There is a fine line between being a cultivated citizen and being someone else's crop. - A. J. Patrick Liszkie
    4. Re:Constitutional protection! Ha! by NoData · · Score: 2, Interesting

      or the right of the people peaceably to assemble , and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

      Aschroft: "Define peaceably. Define assemble. Define petition. Define redress."

      Or has the First Amendment been repealed already?

      Alas, define repeal.

  2. Constitutionally Protected in some places... by NoTheory · · Score: 5, Interesting

    However in places like columbus ohio, as far as i'm aware, it's illegal to gather more than 6 people in public places with out a permit from the city. So i guess it's protected so long as you jump through the proper hoops. Sort of cuts down on the spontinaity thing. (although, i don't think i've ever heard of such a regulation being enforced)

    --
    There are lives at stake here!
    1. Re:Constitutionally Protected in some places... by Tony+Hoyle · · Score: 2, Interesting

      nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws

      Haven't they already deleted that bit? I mean they're currently holding a bunch of people without access to representation and just about to execute half of them without trial....

  3. Flash mob flash by felonious · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Maybe they could further exploit this phenomenon by incorporating Stuart Tunic's (sp?) work?

    Flash mob flashing people....you know...whole shit like that

    --
    You aren't free to do anything, until you've lost everything.
  4. Life imitates fiction? by Turbofish · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Anyone else think of Larry Niven when they read this? Thank goodness quantum teleportation won't work on people... yet. (see http://www.wordspy.com/words/flashcrowd.asp if you don't know what I mean.)

  5. NYC by Triv · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I was a part of one of these, and let me tell you it was a riot. One of the rules was you couldn't initiate conversation with anyone and that answers to questions were scripted. We stayed together for 5 minutes and dispersed, no one having said a word. It was surreal but wonderful, especially the looks on the normal people's faces, trying to figure out exactly what was going on.

    Triv

  6. Properly formatted version by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    cheesebikini?
    July 24, 2003
    Flash Mob in Central Park

    Fred Hoysted was first to chime in with a report and a photo from the Fifth New York Flash Mob. SatansLaundromat.com was quick on Fred's heels with a report and a nice group of photos, including a larger version of the cropped shot to the right.

    They seem to have carried out a fantastic, bizarre idea: make a bunch of increasingly surreal "nature sounds" in Central Park.

    Did anyone make an audio recording? Please let me know if you did.
    Filed under flash mobs at 05:12 PM | Comments (5) | TrackBack (2) | Permalink

    Europe's First Flash Mob

    A flash mob went down today in Rome, as an estimated 100 to 300 people flooded a books and music megastore. They asked employees for nonexistent books. They broke into a round of spontaneous applause. Then they dispersed.

    Here's coverage in Italian from the newspaper la Repubblica, and here's a clumsy English translation. The photo, courtesy of la Repubblica, shows mobbers evacuating the megastore.

    In the comments attached to this posting, you'll find a report from our Senior Rome Correspondent "JJFlash."

    If you have more photos, please send them (or links to them) to photos[at]cheesebikini.com. More to come.
    Filed under flash mobs at 03:28 PM | Comments (3) | TrackBack (0) | Permalink

    July 23, 2003
    Flash Mob News from Minnesota, Texas, Austria

    Minneapolis organizers put together an event (or rather, a series of events staged in different locations) at a huge shopping mall. Participant turnout was estimated at 50, but perhaps reduced secrecy about the next Minneapolis event will spur a larger crowd?

    New flash mobs are brewing in Vienna, Austria and in Dallas. (Here's an English version of the Austrian flash mob page, as automatically translated by babelfish.altavista.com.

    Flash mobs are a widespread phenomenon now with lots of people around the world taking part, so from now on when I mention flash mobs I'm going to focus on the most compelling flash mob coverage and opinion. For more exhaustive listings of the numerous local flash mob announcements, groups, sites and press coverage, check out flashmob.info, where anyone can sign up for an account and submit mob news or a link to a new mob group, or mob(b)log, whose creator "Alex" is doing a good job of listing media coverage but strangely fails to provide any way to reach him or to comment on his postings. In the meantime, Rob Zazueta is designing a site to make it easier for people to organize what he calls "flocks;" it's not done yet but you can keep track of it at flocksmart.com. Thanks for the resources, people!

    (By the way; have you seen The Word Spy's entry for the term "flash mob?")
    Filed under flash mobs at 05:18 PM | Comments (3) | TrackBack (0) | Permalink

    July 19, 2003
    The First Italian Flash Mob

    Londoners have been talking about organizing a flash mob for weeks and weeks. Now, with minimal talk, it seems the Romans will beat the Brits to the punch and create Europe's first flash mob.

    Our Senior Rome Correspondent "J. Jack Flash" reports that a flash mob has been planned in Rome next Thursday, July 24. Here's the invitation: in Italian and in English.

    In other news: Flash mobs are arising in Boston and in Phoenix, Arizona.
    Filed under flash mobs at 10:15 AM | Comments (21) | TrackBack (0) | Permalink

    July 18, 2003
    Invitation: Manhattan Flash Mob #5

    Below is the invitation to the fifth New York flash mob as it was e-mailed to me. It's scheduled to take place next Thursday evening, July 24th.

    (If you're wondering what a flash mob is, see this entry for an explanation.)
    more...

    Filed under flash mobs at 12:14 PM | Comments (5) | TrackBack (1) | Permalink

    Ma che diavolo è un Flashmob?

    "J. Jack Flash" in Rome, Italy republished most of cheesebikini's flash mob coverage, after translating it into Italian. (For real fun see the translation back into English, courtes

  7. Looks like the San Francisco Cacophony Society by ebusinessmedia1 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    This looks a lot like some of the behavior engaged in the past (and present) by the the San Francisco Cacophony Society http://sf.cacophony.org/

    The increasing capacity for spontaneous social expression via the network is going to get a boost, now that *everyone* who is within proximity of a prank has a chance to participate.

    Yet another example of new social behaviors that emerge spontaneously at the 'edge' of the network.

    It's be interesting to see what new kinds of mass social behavior develop, and which ones manage to survive, and become institutionalized.

    As long as no one gets hurt, we could use a little levity.

    As stated on the SF Cacophony site: "The Cacophony Society is a randomly gathered network of individuals united in the pursuit of experiences beyond the pale of mainstream society through subversion, pranks, art, fringe explorations and meaningless madness. "

    Here's an excerpt about one past activity:

    Mad Santa Crawl:
    "each year at christmastime a crowd of santas descends upon one of san francisco's most-touristed neighborhoods to get drunk, to hand out disturbing gifts, and to frighten tourists.

    on december 16, 2000 a santa faction drove to a ranch in petaluma, spent the afternoon discharging firearms, then joined the rest of the santas for the evening's festivities in san francisco. about 150 santas took over grant street in chinatown, and they eventually headed up into north beach."

    1. Re:Looks like the San Francisco Cacophony Society by CSharpMinor · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Re-post with the proper fomratting this time. Sorry--forgot to check that little "HTML Formatted" thing which was hidden right next to the post button.

      I actually found something about the Cacophany Society from whilst researching Chuck Palahniuk, author of Fight Club. (Don't ask, it's an Ingrish Lit thing.)

      Straight from the horse's mouth:

      There's usually one host city that different chapters from around the world go to for one
      weekend, usually about two weeks before Christmas. Everybody arrives dressed as Santa Claus,
      using the name "Santa Claus," and the host city usually has two to three days of continuous
      events. People drink and party and sing, and disrupt big benefit parties, and are basically public
      nuisances. But the fact that there's 400 of them all in red makes them this stunning sort of moving
      artwork. They call it "The Red Tide." It's really beautiful. When I did it in '96, at one point it was all
      these Santas against this SWAT team of cops, because the Santas wanted to get into a shopping
      center that was private property. It was so beautiful to see all these blue policemen juxtaposed
      with all these red Santas, and all these crying kids that were like, "Why are you beating up on
      Santa?" This year, they're talking about Tijuana as the host city, but no one wants to get busted in
      Tijuana.

      --

      Whatever it is I'm complaining about, I'm sure the Republicans did it. This is /., after all.
  8. Distraction by firewrought · · Score: 5, Interesting
    This article reminds me of Bruce Sterling's Distraction, in which a mob spontaneously forms to attack and overrun a corrupt bank w/o any apparent source of centralized organization or communication.

    It makes me wonder if we are on the verge of creating a trans-human intelligence capable of consciousness. Too bad we don't have any formal idea of what intelligence and conciousness is, or we could analyze the situation more closely...

    --
    -1, Too Many Layers Of Abstraction
  9. okay, this is what bugs me about this. by YllabianBitPipe · · Score: 0, Interesting

    There are plenty of things worth protesting these days. Besides the war in Iraq, what about globalization, outsourcing, mass layoffs, health care, the states' budget deficit, the federal budget deficit, the disparity between rich and poor, the "walmartization" of america, the obesity epidemic, heck, the crappy Matrix sequel, the scourge of reality television, etc. etc. etc.

    I'm just thinking, people who have nothing better to do than organize and stand around and admit theres no point? That's just embarassing. Do none of these people believe in anything that might be worth gathering for? Do they have nothing going on in their lives that they'd get together with a bunch of random strangers and do nothing? This country is totally going down the crapper, when there's all this ridiculous, unfair, unjust stuff going on and people are organizing these pointless stand ins.

    argh.

  10. New Category Suggestion: TFH by simetra · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Tin Foil Hat

    This would be for these types of stories that get the paranoid wackos to remind us of how our rights are gone, the government is after us, etc.

    Or at least store these on tfh.slashdot.org

    --

    "Would it kill you to put down the toilet seat?" -- Maya Angelou
  11. Critical Mass by TheViewFromTheGround · · Score: 4, Interesting

    All over the world, there's been a movement called Critical Mass that gets folks together to take over the streets on bike rides on a semi-regular basis. Here in Chicago, it's been really successful -- hundreds go on the main ride every month, even in the dead of winter. In the summer months, there have been around a thousand riders. Critical Mass is a sort of anarchic protest against the domination of our streets by cars but without a specific, directed agenda. The idea is that having fun and taking over streets, no matter what one's political orientation is, is a good way to make a statement. What's interesting is that now that almost everybody has some direct connection to the Net, Critical Mass rides are getting organized overnight. When the war in Iraq broke out, the next day a group of Critical Massers against the war (not all CM folks are) organized a very effective ride within a half a day and people have been now talking about organizing within a few hours. I have to wonder about flash crowds becoming flash protests or flash rides and what the potential benefits and problems of this will be. Speaking of which, this effect also happened in the South Korean election recently in a close race.

    --
    Online citizen journalism from the inner city: The View From The Ground
  12. They're just ripping off Bruce Sterling. by kwashiorkor · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Read Distraction.

    --
    -- kwashiorkor --
    Leaps in Logic
    should not be confused with
    Jumping to Conclusions.
  13. The real process for constitutional protection. by sglider · · Score: 5, Interesting

    1. Fill out a 'right to peaceably assemble' permit, specifying the date, time, number of people expected, and reason for assembling. 2. Request where you'd like to peaceably assemble, keeping in mind that your local goverment may move you on a whim (Democratic National Convention, 2000). 3. Bribe 50 or so local officers so that you are not arrested for 'obstructing a sidewalk' (a la the protesters in NYC against the War in Iraq). 4. Finally, do not allow anyone to shout during said demonstration, otherwise police in riot gear that were 'hanging around' may find a reason to bust up your assembly.

    --
    War isn't about who's right. It's about who's left.
  14. Fark vs Slashdot by August_zero · · Score: 2, Interesting

    If you want to see something interesting...

    I have scanned through the responses to this subject here on slashdot, and while there are some that have been very negative, the overall vibe I get is positive. (or nuetral)

    Now, go over to FARK.com, and read through the comments that were posted after the article went up yesterday. A vast majority of them are negative, and not just negative in the "bah Im smarter than everyone else" mindset that most of the FARK message boards are built upon, but rather an honest to god "I am offended at how stupid people are that would do this sort of thing" kind of way.

    Not sure if its all that important or even on-topic but an interesting contrast of the two communities.

    --
    On Wall Street they say "buy low, sell high" On the pad we say, "buy high, sell high" Isn't that somehow better?
  15. All For It.... by MrEnigma · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I'm all for it, but what happens if a group gets out of hand and starts thrasing property, wether it be in a store, or some public place.

    I guess I wouldn't want it to get out of hand, and maybe have something like that happen. Especially since there will be all kinds of people that know about it now (well, more than before anyhow), so you'll always attract a certain bad subset. Like slashdot in trolls, it's unavoidable.

    --
    GeekWares - Buy and Download Today!
  16. Re:A semi-related topic by Alaska+Jack · · Score: 2, Interesting

    This ties in to something that still makes me laugh when I think about it.

    Me, my brother and a friend were in the tiny Liberty Theater in Seward, Alaska, to watch some Star Trek movie in the early 90s. We got there kind of late, and the theater was packed, so we had to sit down in the front, in the second row I think.

    There was a furious windstorm outside, and while we were waiting for the movie to start the power went out. Emergency lights came on, but it was still nearly pitch dark.

    So sitting there in near total darkness in the tiny but crowded theater, everyone murmuring and squirming and eating popcorn, my brother starts to whistle the theme from Star Trek. I joined in, and pretty soon this entire theater was whistling together, although by then it was kind of hard to whistle since we were all laughing so hard. It was one of the funniest damn things I've ever seen.

  17. July Jingle Bells by Tablizer · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Mad Santa Crawl: "each year at christmastime a crowd of santas descends upon one of san francisco's most-touristed neighborhoods to get drunk, to hand out disturbing gifts, and to frighten tourists.

    You want to really freak people, dress like Santa's in July and sing carols. I had a college friend who used to get drunk on a hot May night and wonder around singing xmas carols. It was a hoot.

  18. Re:One Question... by packeteer · · Score: 4, Interesting

    The only time protestors are noticed is when they become violent like in Seattle, disrupt traffic or otherwise do things that are probably counter-productive to the cause they wish to promote.

    I don't blame you for not knowing but people were not getting violent in Seattle during the WTO protest. I live near Seattle and although i was not there i know many people who were including my father was was taken into a holding cell for no reason and released when they realized he was a member of the BAR and they didn't want that.

    Many of my friend were shot with rubber bullets and left with bruises for no reason other than being in a crowd. You might not believe me if i say this but i knew a cop who wanted to be involved just so he could shoot people doing nothing. Now im sure not al the cops there felt like that but i know there were enough to cause some trouble. There were soooo many camera's there that i would bet no act of violence was missed. When i watched on the news at night all i saw was violence but only a little but. They would loop the same two clips of people breaknig windows but it was nothing like it was portrayed on TV. EVERY single protest was peaceful and most of the police didn't do anything wrong. The problem was when someone totally unassociated with the protest went near them and starting breaking things. Then the police would go all out on the protesters. The worst part of the stores that were broken the only ones being protected were corporate stores. The assholes who were breaknig stuff did not discriminate between corporate and other stores as the media claimed. It was no protesters breaking the nike store. It was some assholes breaking anything before they were caught.

    --
    unzip; strip; touch; finger; mount; fsck; more; yes; unmount; sleep
  19. Same in the UK by p.gogarty · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Feel sorry for us UK residence it is now law that a gathering of over 7 people in a public place can be classed as a riot is it doesn't dispures when asked.

    That is just having a group larger than 7 people (unless obvoiusly you have a permit to hold a public demonstration).

    Yay to no constitution and the criminal justice bill in Britian.

    --
    Paul Gogarty
    1. Re:Same in the UK by Hittite+Creosote · · Score: 2, Interesting
      In Great Britain the Constitution is the whole body of public law, customary as well as statutory, which is continually being modified by custom, judgement in the courts as well as by the elected representatives of the country.

      The British Constitution developed from the Magna Carta and whilst it is not written down in one place, it is considered to be a strong constitution.

      Just because the UK version isn't all in one place doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Just because the US one is all down in one place, it doesn't mean the US government will uphold all of it if it things it can get away with ignoring bits it finds inconvenient.

  20. Traffic Light Game by CmdrGravy · · Score: 2, Interesting

    This was probably very sad but nonetheless.

    When my friends and I were teenagers and used to find ourselves wandering the streets at 3AM in the morning ( usually ending up at all night petrol stations ) we devised what we like to think of as street theatre.

    Usually the area of town we hung around in was as quiet as a grave and you'd hardly ever see anyone else at that time in the morning. When there was a fair sized crowd of us ( 8+ ) we would all position ourselves on various sides of the street near a set of traffic lights.

    As a car approached somone would press the lights to get the car to stop and everyone would by then be walking up to and over the traffic lights like we were all unknown to each other and just happened to all turn up at this particular set of traffic lights at the same time and carry on off in different directions.

    I always found it very amusing and luckily so the Police when we had mistaken them for a normal car and carried out this trick on two different traffic lights on the same set of road. We stopped them at both lights but the driver was seen to clap his hands in slow applause at the second.

  21. Now I Understand What I Saw The Other Day by kmilani2134 · · Score: 2, Interesting
    I left my office in SoHo (NYC) the other afternoon and saw a mob of people in the shoe store across the street. It is a fairly large shoe store and the whole front of the shoe store is all windows so you can see inside quite easily. The whole place was packed with people and there were even a fair number of people outside the place.

    There were easily half a dozen people with cameras who were holding their cameras up and taking snapshots. WhatI found strange is that they didn't seem to really be focusing their cameras on anything in particular.

    I thought for sure that there must have been some famous person shopping at the store, but that doesn't usually cause such a strange buzz in NYC (unless you are in Times Square with the tourists).

    The first I have heard about flash mobs is through this story on slashdot. And as soon as I read the story, I knew that is what I had seen. When you don't know about flash mobs, the whole thing kind of leaves you a little bit bewildered, yet it absolutely gets your attention.

    --
    Those who trade freedom for security will lose both, and deserve neither" -- Ben Franklin
  22. White House, North Fence, July 26, 1800EST by Jerk+City+Troll · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I say we get a group to go stand at the north-side fence (by Lafayette Park) of the White House and give a resounding "Boo!" for about 60 seconds while giving thumbs down (no obscene gestures), then just leaving. Absolutely peaceful, no signs, just a really vocal show of disapproval. Saturday, July 26, at 1800EST.

  23. Re:Other interesting possibilities by b1t+r0t · · Score: 2, Interesting

    How about meta flash-mobbing? As in you have a flash mob group who watches a different flash mob site to figure out what they're up to, get there at the same time, and do something else, possibly related in some way to the "official" behavior.

    --

    --
    "Open source is good." - Steve Jobs
    "Open source is evil." - Microsoft