Slashdot Mirror


Ever Smell T-Rex's Breath?

Jim Hawkins writes "Well, in case you never have the chance of getting up close and personal with a T.Rex, Dale Air, a company who 'nose' its smells, has recreated Tyrannosaurus Rex's breath for London's Natural History Museum. Seems people made a stink about the rotting flesh smell that would exist on T-Rex's breath - guess someone forgot to tell him to brush his teeth."

51 of 151 comments (clear)

  1. and this is useful because? by bunburyist · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Still waiting for that cure for cancer.

    1. Re:and this is useful because? by Lurker+McLurker · · Score: 5, Informative

      Actually, (to take a bit of a tangent) I read somewhere that it may one day be possible to detect cancer by smelling someone's breath with an electronic nose.

      --
      Mod parent up!
    2. Re:and this is useful because? by AndroidCat · · Score: 4, Informative

      Wasn't there a story about training dogs to do that?

      --
      One line blog. I hear that they're called Twitters now.
    3. Re:and this is useful because? by blahlemon · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Actually, the first poster has a valid point. What the hell it the point of this story? It's neither interesting or important. So they made a smell that they *think* is the same as a T-Rex. They don't have any point of reference, for all we know the T-Rex's mouth could have smelt like a dozen roses, or it could have smelt like ass.

      --
      It take more faith to believe in evolution than it takes to believe in God
  2. T-Rex breath by birdwax2k · · Score: 5, Funny

    Supposedly it smells a lot like T-Rex ass.

    1. Re:T-Rex breath by arivanov · · Score: 2, Funny
      More likely like xenofobia:

      Notice the article URL: http://www.cnn.com/2004/WORLD/europe/06/27/britain .smells.reut/index.html

      --
      Baker's Law: Misery no longer loves company. Nowadays it insists on it
      http://www.sigsegv.cx/
  3. This is not news! by tehcyder · · Score: 5, Informative

    It's been there since 2001.

    --
    To have a right to do a thing is not at all the same as to be right in doing it
    1. Re:This is not news! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      Actually, I think it's been there since 200.000.000 BC. :p

    2. Re:This is not news! by Atrax · · Score: 2, Informative

      technically, T-Rex was around more like 65 million years ago.

      200 million would land you somewhere in the triassic. T-Rex was Cretaceous

      (yeah, I know, pedant)

      --
      Screw you all! I'm off to the pub
  4. Re:So... by Paleomacus · · Score: 2, Funny

    Yeah but the chicken's heads they bit off were way bigger.

  5. "news for nerds" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    "stuff that matters"

    1. Re:"news for nerds" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Format change today: "nose for nerds - sniff that matters"

  6. Nothing new is it? by GrahamCox · · Score: 4, Informative

    I'm sure this has been there for several years - in fact I saw it when I was in London and I've since emigrated! I heard that the smell they recreated was actually a lot tamer than the original would have done, since obviously they didn't want people keeling over or being sick - so the smell they have there is more like vaguely rotting cabbage than the stench of rancid meat. Certainly when I saw it it didn't smell all that bad.

    1. Re:Nothing new is it? by orthogonal · · Score: 2, Funny
      Certainly when I saw it [the simulated Tyrannosaurus Rex breath] didn't smell all that bad.

      Not to you, perhaps.

      But since you post of Slashdot, you've no doubt had many more opportunities to build up resistance to much more devastating scents:
      • unwashed geek with a beard full of Dorito crumbs,
      • Mountain Dew fermenting in a shag carpet laid down in 1976,
      • "magic-user" feet after a twelve-hour D&D marathon,
      • the reek of Mom's basement after that dot-com "opportunity" fell through and an impoverished and dispirited Perl hacker moved home too depressed to shower.
      And not to mention the full sensory assault of a GNU/noisome Richard Stallman.

      (I keed, I keed!)
  7. Geek's version by nacturation · · Score: 2, Funny

    This article should take you back to the dot-com glory days. The opening paragraph:

    "After an uncomfortable pause, he looked straight into the eyes of the woman he'd loved for years. As he moved in for the kiss, he caught a whiff of her shoulder and immediately thought of his computer."

    --
    Want to improve your Karma? Instead of "Post Anonymously", try the "Post Humously" option.
  8. Obvious joke. by ideatrack · · Score: 5, Funny

    guess someone forgot to tell him to brush his teeth

    Well it is in England...

    And I'm English before anyone gets upset ;)

    1. Re:Obvious joke. by jjjefff · · Score: 3, Funny

      I'm not sure the stereotype is "from nowhere." Take a look at what some Brits have to say on the subject:

      Until the NHS started up, and before the availability of fluoride in toothpaste (or water), our British teeth were spectacularly ugly. Look at any film footage of average Britons before about 1945, and weep. The standard of living of the contemporary American probably afforded them better dental care; and, I suspect, a certain cultural austerity would have meant that corrective procedures such as braces would be regarded by us Brits as extravagance and vanity.
      - Simon Gilman, London UK

      I think Simon Gilman has put it best. Having spent my first 20 years in America and 14 years since living in the UK, I find that the average Brit is satisfied with teeth that might be crooked, stained, even slightly rotten, if they aren't causing much discomfort to their owner. Average Americans have much higher standards of expectation in the state of their dental health -- regardless of whether they have to pay for dental treatment or not, they feel very strongly that good teeth are a wise investment in looks and health. Many visits to the dentist by average Brits happen only after something has gone horribly wrong with their teeth, whilst Americans take an actively preventative approach with semi-annual dental checkups and intervention before any problems become severe. As a result of the greater amount of attention that Americans pay to their teeth, they are far more likely to notice and comment on the state of other people's teeth.
      - Wendy James, London UK

      And this is just too funny not to include:

      I don't know about the States, but here in Mexico the common phrase to describle 'wonky' teeth is 'dientes ingles' (English teeth).
      - Iain Pearson, Mexico City Mexico

  9. Britain Smells? by upside · · Score: 3, Funny

    Look at the URL. Those wisecracks at CNN couldn't resist a jibe, could they?

    --
    I'm sorry if I haven't offended anyone
  10. Ever Smell T-Rex's Breath? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    No.

    And I prefer to keep it that way, ta.

    1. Re:Ever Smell T-Rex's Breath? by gregger · · Score: 2, Insightful

      My friends on the Atkins diet have breath that smells just like what I would expect the T-Rex's to smell like...

      ewww...
      TTFN

  11. My T-Rex by Timesprout · · Score: 2, Funny

    Brushes and flosses regularly, then rinses with 5 gallons of Listerine. He say its worth it cos the ladies like good teeth. He does say he is struggling to find a decent scale moisturiser though. He's such a vain beast.

    --
    Do not try to read the dupe, thats impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth
    What truth?
    There is no dupe
    1. Re:My T-Rex by Mr.+Bad+Example · · Score: 4, Funny

      > He's such a vain beast.

      Obviously he's a Mesozoicsexual.

  12. The smell of newbie in the morning by AndroidCat · · Score: 4, Funny
    "Say you've got help desk staff who are getting tense and frustrated -- they can press a button to get an aroma to help calm them down," Knight said.

    And what aroma would that be? Luser eaten by a t-rex?

    --
    One line blog. I hear that they're called Twitters now.
  13. Reptiles and poor dental hygiene by N+Monkey · · Score: 4, Informative

    "-Rex's breath - guess someone forgot to tell him to brush his teeth."

    I used to catch beared dragons when I was a kid. They didn't have bad breath (that I can remember) but if they bit you the bacteria on their teeth could be nasty.

  14. Smell o Vision by Osgyth · · Score: 2, Funny

    I'm just waiting for the horrid day where you are able to smell the programs on TV. Or sure, sounds great for the cooking shows, but what the "secret doorway" in Desperado? (FYI, it was a bathroom stall with shit spread all over the walls)

    1. Re:Smell o Vision by Mononoke · · Score: 2, Funny
      I'm just waiting for the horrid day where you are able to smell the programs on TV.
      I'll be leaving the room during the Kotex commercials.

      She'll be leaving the room during the locker room interviews.

      We'll both be leaving the room during the State of the Union address.

      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
  15. Just to answer the pressing question by GillBates0 · · Score: 5, Informative

    Yes, they do have the fart smell. It's listed as "Flatulence #9668" in their catalog.

    --
    An Indian-American Hindu committed to non-violent thought/speech/action alarmed by the global explosion of radical Islam
    1. Re:Just to answer the pressing question by asr_man · · Score: 2, Funny

      And what about...

      Aromas of Football - Changing Room

      I'm not making this up, you know.

  16. Opportunist Cleaners? by Mazem · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I wonder if small opportunist creatures cleaned the T-Rex, like Egyptian Plovers clean crocodile teeth and various fish eat the parasites on sharks.

  17. Considering it's diet ... by dledeaux · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I recently saw a very interesting program on Discovery that hinted at T-Rex actually being a scavenger, not a hunter.

    They had several interesting theories to back this up. For example, T-Rex had a very bad center of gravity for one thing. This coupled with the fact that it's arms were so small meant that it would not pick itself back up if it fell. This meant that T-Rex probably didn't run because it didn't want to fall. It probably walked everywhere and in walking, the only food it would be able to catch would be already dead food.

    Other reasons that pointed out it's "scavengaristic" diet where things like it's olfactory senses. Porportionally it is the same size as a vulture.

    So, the theory that it ate already rotting flesh would greatly contribute to it's problems with halitosis!

    1. Re:Considering it's diet ... by bwy · · Score: 3, Insightful

      It is amazing that a species that can't pick itself up from a fall could survive past a single generation. But, I'm sure there are other species with this fault. It just sounds like a bad trait to have.

    2. Re:Considering it's diet ... by Moraelin · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I've read that theory too, and it's a bloody stupid idea on several counts.

      For starters it would mean that there were _no_ predators over a certain size. (They all look like they're made to walk, rather than run.) Now in and by itself, that would be unusual, but not necessarily impossible. There aren't any predators the size of an elephant nowadays.

      What it wouldn't exmplain though, is why did several of the herbivore evolve defenses. Why did the triceratops, for example, need those horns and a massive bone shield, if not for defense? Why did other species grow basically armour plates? What was the evolutionary advantage of that, in the absence of predators?

      Nature doesn't create useless stuff like that. If you want a reasonable approximation of the triceratops, take the boar. It can gore something in front with the tusks (whereas the triceratops had horns, but same idea). And while the boar doesn't have a bone shield, it rubs its shoulders to resin producing trees. The resulting hair and resin mixture is basically the same kind of material as your motherboard. It's a sort of armour. I.e., again, you have a smaller and faster equivalent of the triceratops.

      Why did it need to evolve that way? Well, for defense. The forward shield and tusks allow it to gore a wolf or two.

      The observation that "the T-Rex couldn't run, therefore it couldn't hunt" is also stupid because it only considers half the equation. Yes, the T-Rex couldn't run. Not just because of the small arms, but the bone sizes are all wrong for running. But here's the fun part: neither could its prey.

      You don't necessarily need to _run_ to be a predator. You just need to move (in whatever way) faster than your prey. Even if it's walking, or flying, or swimming, or rolling on wheels, or whatever else. What counts is whether you can catch a prey, not whether your kind of locomotion looks like what we'd call running.

      Basically the T-Rex only needed to walk faster than its intended prey. Bear in mind that we're talking a 40 ft beast. Assuming that a reasonable amount of its body mass was in leg muscles, it could likely pull up to 11 mph walking speed. As long as its big bulky victims (which again, couldn't run either) walked slower than that, the T-Rex could find a meal.

      To understand the tiny arms, you also have to understand the context of walking at that size. Body weight increases with the cube of the weight. Muscle strength increases only quadratically with their diameter. I.e., the bigger you grow, the more you have trouble moving fast.

      It's very likely that to maintain a quick stride, the T-Rex needed a _much_ higher percentage of its body mass to be concentrated in its leg muscles, than, say, a chicken would have. The body itself had to be as lightweight as possible, and the legs were massively muscular to move it. Any useless weight, such as the arms, was a _disadvantage_, so the evolutionary pressure was for them to grow smaller.

      --
      A polar bear is a cartesian bear after a coordinate transform.
    3. Re:Considering it's diet ... by gedhrel · · Score: 3, Interesting

      You ask:

      What it wouldn't explain though, is why did several of the herbivore evolve defences. Why did the triceratops, for example, need those horns and a massive bone shield, if not for defence? Why did other species grow basically armour plates? What was the evolutionary advantage of that, in the absence of predators?

      I'm not a behavioural paleobiologist, but the absence of predators doesn't seem to mean that there's the absence of reasons to fight. Maybe randy triceratops would fight over territory or a mate? Maybe girl triceratops were just turned on by massive head plates. Defence against predators isn't the only evolutionary advantage they might offer.

    4. Re:Considering it's diet ... by Hittite+Creosote · · Score: 3, Informative
      Maybe randy triceratops would fight over territory or a mate?

      A recent article in Palaeontologica Electronica (vol 7, issue 1) suggests so. A brief summary in the New Scientist news article

  18. Aroma dispenser by Anonymous+Writer · · Score: 2, Interesting

    That "smell" device mentioned in the article that's supposed to hook up to a computer has been done. I recall hearing about devices like it more than once over the past few years. Here is one example and here is another. It's a lame idea.

  19. And the even more pressing question by Zone-MR · · Score: 2, Funny

    I believe they also have the porno-themed aroma.

    It's listed as "Fish Market A123511"

  20. Lifespan of developers at Dales? by farnerup · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Item 12235 in the catalouge is mustard gas.

    The chemical warfare connoisseur will be pleased to know they also offer phosgene gas aroma.

  21. How do they know? by Enlarge+Your+Penis · · Score: 2, Insightful

    His breath would be affected by the diet of the animals he ate, as well - how do they know the exact content of a herbiverous dinosaur's diet?

  22. Calming down by Anonymous+Writer · · Score: 5, Funny

    The firm is testing an aroma dispenser which plugs into a computer and is controlled from the keyboard.

    "Say you've got help desk staff who are getting tense and frustrated -- they can press a button to get an aroma to help calm them down," Knight said.

    A case mod with a built-in bong would work much better.

    1. Re:Calming down by infinite9 · · Score: 2, Funny

      A case mod with a built-in bong would work much better

      Heh, shows what I know. I thought the water was for cooling the cpu, not cooling the user.

      --
      Disconnect your television. Do your own research. Draw your own conclusions. They're probably lying. Don't be a sheep.
  23. Accurate? Isn't that a stretch? by StateOfTheUnion · · Score: 5, Insightful
    From the article:

    T-Rex breath turned out so accurate and so revolting, the curators instead opted for a milder swamp smell to evoke the creature's natural habitat.

    Revolting is beleivable, but accurate? Do we really know enough about T-Rex's to say that the synthetic breath that was created was accurate? What bacteria lived in the mouth? Did the saliva have antibodies to protect open wounds around the mouth from bacteria and infection? What was the pH of the saliva? These all affect breath . . .

    There are lots of unknowns that make me think that the journalist's use of the word accurate is more than a little presumptuous. . .

  24. Diabetes analysis is done now... by cholland · · Score: 3, Informative
    Researchers at Mississippi State University recently discovered a way to detect diabetes by using the breath of the subject. I'm sure that similar efforts are being directed at cancer.

    According to the article, it utilizes Cavity Ring-Down Spectroscopy (CRDS) to detect concentration levels of acetone in a person's breath gas.

    1. Re:Diabetes analysis is done now... by StalinsNotDead · · Score: 2, Funny

      isn't that what school is for?

      --
      Thanks to the internet, we can now all die alone together! -SomeWoman
  25. Considering T-Rex was a scavenger by earthforce_1 · · Score: 4, Funny

    I don't think I would be particularly interested.

    If you are really curious, leave a kilo of raw hamburger sitting on the kitchen counter for a couple of weeks, while you go on vacation. Your house will be filled with the lovely aroma of T-Rex breath upon your return.

    --
    My rights don't need management.
  26. Science grabs for public interest by cerebis · · Score: 3, Insightful
    I am all for scientists attracting public interest to their research but, does it strike anyone that some attempts appear to do more to trivialise the pursuit of knowledge than it does to promote its' worth?

    The degree of conjecture necessary to claim an odor represents the breath scent of a Tyrannosaurus Rex is enormous. To the point that, when all the approximations and educated guesses are accounted for, it is likely you're wrong.

    At least demonstrate the scientific process with subject matter that will stand up to modest scrutiny.

  27. Ever smell T-Rex breath by Cro+Magnon · · Score: 2, Funny

    Nope! But, to be fair, the T-Rex has never smelled my breath either!

    --
    Slow down, cowboy! It has been 4 hours since you last posted. You must wait another few hours.
  28. ". . . forgot to tell him to brush his teeth." by Jack+William+Bell · · Score: 4, Funny

    Not exactly. His parents reminded him every morning, but with those short arms...

    --
    - -
    Are you an SF Fan? Are you a Tru-Fan?
  29. Re:reason for smell by thomasa · · Score: 2, Funny

    failure of a slashdoter. Below is the link:

    here

  30. oh no... by (1)down · · Score: 2, Funny

    guess someone forgot to tell him to brush his teeth."
    This is the kind of humor that made us social outcasts in the first place....

    really though, on a thousand levels this just isn't funny..

    --
    my other sig is a commando
  31. icon by tr0p · · Score: 2, Funny

    Shouldn't the t-rex icon be on this story instead of the story above it?

    --

    My only regret... is that I have... bonitis..

  32. I'm still waiting for a Quake-Smell-O-Rama product by cmdrwhitewolf · · Score: 2, Funny

    So I don't have just imagine the smell of fresh napalm in the morning, but actually slap on the old MicroSmell game scent enhancer!

    --
    [Now, I'm off to lift my le... Um, visit... at another place.]