Slashdot Mirror


IBM Grid Near 50,000 machines - Slashdot Users #13

another similar writes "IBM's World Community Grid is off to a roaring start. Since kicking off six weeks ago (original Slashdot story), the grid has grown to almost 36,000 users with almost 50,000 machines. Growth continues as more media coverage hits. There is a team of Slashdot users - currently ranked 13th in points with only 79 members. If you have spare cycles, download the software, join us and crank for medicine. For those of you with dual processor systems, you'll have to use a homebrewed tool - beyond two is not supported yet. Alas, you also have to be running Redmond's finest. According to their FAQ, a Linux client is slated for development in 2005."

38 of 408 comments (clear)

  1. Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by IO+ERROR · · Score: 5, Funny
    There is a team of Slashdot users - currently ranked 13th in points with only 79 members. . . . Alas, you also have to be running Redmond's finest.

    Which is why there are only 79 /.ers signed up. When they get the Linux client, they'll get 79,000 /.ers.

    --
    How am I supposed to fit a pithy, relevant quote into 120 characters?
    1. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

      anybody tried it with wine?

    2. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

      That's hilariously wrong.

      The vast majority of Slashdotters use Windows. That's the dirty secret around here. Nobody wants to admit they're all using windows.

    3. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      ... like downloading pirated games and movies.

    4. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by IO+ERROR · · Score: 3, Interesting
      The vast majority of Slashdotters use Windows. That's the dirty secret around here. Nobody wants to admit they're all using windows.

      While I doubt CmdrTaco is about to post the server logs, I dare say this is un-hilariously wrong.

      When I pull my logs and segment out everyone who was referred here from /. (and shame on you people who have your referer disabled, you know who you are and so do I) I show 85% using Linux, nearly all of whom are using Firefox, and about 1/3 of whom are using a pre-1.0 version.

      I also show the Windows users who come to my site stick around longer and spend more time on the Linux articles than do the Linux users. So I plan more Linux articles.

      And reading the User-Agent strings is fun.

      --
      How am I supposed to fit a pithy, relevant quote into 120 characters?
    5. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny
      Where someone is referred from is none of your business, mr violating our rights online.

      You want your rights violated? OK, here you go. Your IP address is 192.168.0.1 and you were referred here from 127.0.0.1 which is a HUGE porn, warez and mp3 site. Recent items in your browser history include http://msdn.microsoft.com/ and http://goatse.cx/. You last made an online purchase at http://www.ebay.com/ where you bought a pallet of rubber chickens. And you have a browser helper object installed which sends all of your browsing data to http://www.fbi.gov/ because you're under investigation for ... well ... you know.

    6. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by IO+ERROR · · Score: 5, Informative
      OK, you can mod me -1, Wrong and Stupid now. I pulled the last week of server logs to see what I'd come up with from people referred from /. and this is what I find. I truly deserve the flamefest which will follow...

      65% Windows
      23% Linux
      10% Mac OS X
      2% Everything else

      User agents:

      68% Firefox
      11% MSIE
      7% Safari
      3% Opera

      Firefox versions:

      84% 1.0
      10% 0.9.3 or older
      6% 0.10.1

      --
      How am I supposed to fit a pithy, relevant quote into 120 characters?
    7. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      No, but I've tried it with milk. The results weren't pleasant.

    8. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by mahdi13 · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Why use wine?
      I've been working with Stanford on Protein Folding for a while...plus they support Windows, Linux AND MacOSX

      Let us know when IBM decides to let the 'rest of us' in on their fun and maybe we'll join up...

      --
      "Some things have to be believed to be seen." - Ralph Hodgson
    9. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      anybody tried it with wine?

      Apparently 79 people so far.

    10. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by complete+loony · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Ah, but most of us would browse slashdot from work (slackers :), where we are probably not allowed to run linux or we have to support / develop for windows, but obviously we have (mostly) converted to firefox.

      --
      09F91102 no, 455FE104 nope, F190A1E8 uh-uh, 7A5F8A09 that's not it, C87294CE no. Ah! 452F6E403CDF10714E41DFAA257D313F.
    11. Re:Only 79 /.ers in six weeks. What does that say? by ThousandStars · · Score: 3, Funny
      The vast majority of Slashdotters use Windows. That's the dirty secret around here. Nobody wants to admit they're all using windows.

      Well, nobody wants to admit to having Chlamydia either, but a whole lot of people do.

      Frankly, I wouldn't want admit to using Windows.

  2. Imagine... by PornMaster · · Score: 5, Funny

    a Beowu...

    no.

    I can't say it.

    1. Re:Imagine... by ThisNukes4u · · Score: 3, Insightful

      There can't be a beowulf cluster because it doesn't run on linux.

      --
      thisnukes4u.net
  3. "Redmond's finest" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny
    System requirements: Windows XP, 2000, ME, 98

    If, as the submitter implies, Windows ME is Redmond's "finest"...

  4. I don't want to wait for 2005 for the Linux Client by The+Bandit · · Score: 5, Funny

    It's SOOOOOoooo..... long to wait for.

  5. Has anybody tried the client in Wine? by tepples · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Does the client work under ABI translation on Linux or *BSD on x86?

    1. Re:Has anybody tried the client in Wine? by Rgb465 · · Score: 3, Informative

      Nay. I just tried it with the stock Wine in Debian Sid, no go. The installer complained about a lack of an MSI installer and exited.

  6. Suprised? no by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    There is a team of Slashdot users - currently ranked 13th in points with only 79 members.

    and

    Alas, you also have to be running Redmond's finest. According to their FAQ, a Linux client is slated for development in 2005.

    Seriously, are they at ALL suprised that there are only 79 members? They are talking about the linux capital of the universe.

    1. Re:Suprised? no by AKnightCowboy · · Score: 4, Funny

      It just quintupled the number of members since you posted that. ;-) It's growing exponentially. At this rate, the Slashdot Users group will obtain sentience in 48 hours and launch Skynet.

    2. Re:Suprised? no by Zork+the+Almighty · · Score: 5, Funny

      Yes, but this SkyNet will just ramble on and on about frost pist and old people from Korea.

      --

      In Soviet America the banks rob you!
  7. Ownership FYI by The+Hobo · · Score: 5, Informative

    For those keeping track,

    "IT IS ANTICIPATED EVENTUALLY THAT IBM WILL TRANSFER WORLD COMMUNITY GRID TO A NON-IBM OWNED WORLD COMMUNITY GRID ENTITY OR ANOTHER ENTITY"

    This is from the license. Just something to watch for in the future if you like Big Blue (or don't like them) or are concerned about it.

    --
    There is another kind of evil which we must fear most, and that is the indifference of good men. -- Boondock Saints
  8. Cheat to win by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

    This requires two computers, one "fast" and one "slow," to work, but you can get a massive number of points. Run the WCG client on your slow computer for up to 12-13 days (the limit is two weeks per unit) or until its almost done, then run it (over a network or whatever) on your fast computer. The result is a work unit that took a long long time with a fast machine's speed rating. BAM! HUGE POINTS.

    They should really fix it and record the machine speed every few %.

    1. Re:Cheat to win by bfizzle · · Score: 3, Informative

      Wouldn't work...

      Points are calculated and awarded each time a work unit is completed and a result is successfully returned to World Community Grid Servers. Points are totaled across all machines aggregated under a specific World Community Grid Member.

      Points are based upon the strength of your machine(s), measured against World Community Grid Comparison Device. First, the "strength" of your participating machine(s) is calculated by measuring the following parameters of your machine against World Community Grid Comparison Device:

      spacer 1) CPU Power
      The software periodically runs diagnostic tests to establish the processing power of your hardware configuration. These values are averaged and then divided by the CPU-Power value of World Community Grid Comparison Device. The averaged value is then multiplied by the run time used to complete the work unit and return the results to World Community Grid Servers.

      2) Random Access Memory (RAM)
      The software recognizes the amount of RAM in your hardware configuration. Each time the software starts, it detects any changes to the amount of installed RAM. This value is divided by the RAM value of World Community Grid Comparison Device. The result of this calculation is then multiplied by the run time used to complete the work unit and return the results to World Community Grid Servers.

      3) Hard Disk Storage
      On your preferences page, you set the megabytes of hard disk space allocated and available to World Community Grid projects. The lesser of the amount of hard drive space allocated and the amount of total space available on your hard drive partition, is divided by the Hard Disk Storage value of World Community Grid Comparison Device. The result of this calculation is then multiplied by the run time used to complete the work unit and return the results to World Community Grid Servers.

      4) Effective Upstream Throughput
      The software runs a diagnostic test on a regular basis that measures the upstream throughput of your hardware configuration, when communicating with World Community Grid Servers. These values are averaged, and the result is divided by the Effective Upstream Throughput value of World Community Grid Comparison Device. The result of this calculation is then multiplied by the run time used to complete the work unit and return the results to World Community Grid Servers.

      The final values for all five parameters are weighted, totaled, and factored to generate a whole number of points greater than or equal to 1 for each result returned.

      While any individual parameter can overachieve the corresponding parameter for World Community Grid Comparison Device by any level, no work unit completed by any machine will earn more than twice the total number of points World Community Grid Comparison Device would earn for that same work unit.

      Note: The slightest variance in any of the five parameters coupled with the inherent differences across multiple applications and work units within one project will result in different point values being assigned per work unit completion.

  9. Funny by pertinax18 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    It's funny that the article makes a big deal about having only 79 members and being ranked 13th in total points. Well, as of now, they are also ranked 15th in total members, so when you combine the two facts it isn't nearly as impressive.

  10. Redmond's Finest? by artemis67 · · Score: 4, Funny

    That's like saying your car comes from Yugoslavia's Finest!

  11. Global Grid Exchange for Linux by onetruedabe · · Score: 3, Informative
    Global Grid Exchange has a Linux client, and has an open SDK/API for developing your own Grid Apps.

    Also, the Global Grid Exchange client runs in a secure Java sandbox, so there's no fear of being 0wned by malicious code.

  12. Uhhh... by Epistax · · Score: 3, Funny

    crank for medicine

    no comment...
    </too easy>

  13. Redmond's finest by Complicity · · Score: 5, Funny
    Alas, you also have to be running Redmond's finest.
    DOS 6.22?
    --
    - c -
  14. Runs on WINE by b0lt · · Score: 4, Informative

    It seems to run on WINE for me, but I've only ran it for maybe 3 minutes now. I'm using TransGaming's Cedega (formerly WineX) version of WINE to run it though, so I'm not quite sure if it works with plain WINE.

    -b0lt

    --
    got sig?
  15. What about dnetc? by HoepckeD · · Score: 3, Insightful

    http://www.distributed.net/ Been around forever, have done far more impressive work than Big Blue . . . and I think they've had Linux clients for a little while.

    1. Re:What about dnetc? by ZorbaTHut · · Score: 3, Insightful

      "Far more impressive work"?

      They've tried to crack single encrypted messages that exist for the sole purpose of being cracked. I'm sorry, but that just plain doesn't excite me anymore.

      OGR's more interesting, but I got bored of RC5 years ago.

      --
      Breaking Into the Industry - A development log about starting a game studio.
  16. Re:Windows users by grub · · Score: 5, Funny


    Slashdot should have a team developing a client.

    Yeah but it'd be written in Perl.

    --
    Trolling is a art,
  17. Cluster support? by digitac · · Score: 4, Funny

    Windows only, and only 2 processors? Darn. Now what am I going to do with the 14 node ClusterKnoppix I put together this afternoon. ::Digitac

  18. Open Grid ? by djplurvert · · Score: 3, Interesting

    At the risk of sounding naive, is anybody aware of a group of amateurs running a grid on a smaller scale.

    I'm not thinking of your typical "let's all save the world with cpu cycles" kind of project. Rather, somthing on a smaller scale that allows you to join the grid with the intent of using it for your own projects.

    I did some work last year that made use of apple's grid software on some lab computers at school but it would have been nice to have access to 1000 or 2000 machines for a day or so.

    I can imagine there are sharing issues that might make it impractical but I can also imagine that it might just work considering, at least for me, the sporadic nature of the need for such a grid.

  19. Woohoo! Slashdot users #1 by another+similar · · Score: 3, Informative

    Well, forty minutes after the post going live, Slashdot Users team member count has shot us into #1 position. Now we'll just need to see how long it's going to take to push Big Blue (x6), five members of the G8 and Norway below us in the point count. I'm guessing several weeks, but maybe this will get more bang for the buck than I had anticipated.

    To clarify, since I've been poked several times in comments already - "Redmond's Finest" was intended to be dripping with sarcasm.... But most Slashdot users are likely wicked smart enough to have known that.... I did enjoy the quip about DOS 6.22... Bravo!

    With respect to your options on teams, rather than Jews for Science, I would suggest considering girlsoflove.com, who's page states:

    Web Cam girls and woman offering their machines when they are not online to help and give back to the world. If you put your machine to help this project and join our team, Send us and email and we will offer you Free time to come and chat with us. The Girls from GIRLSOFLOVE.COM We also provide web broadcasting web video chat conference applications We are from all over the world Montreal Quebec Toronto Vancouver Canada america usa france britain italia brazil mexico argentina asia

    This could be fulfilling in, er, other ways, but obviously, being on the #1 team (in user count) and soon to be #1 in points, results, etc. is a lot cooler....

    Thanks Slashdotters for taking things up another notch (or 20)!

  20. Rosetta was developed on Linux by goombah99 · · Score: 5, Informative
    I'm one of the authors of the code they are running as the first application of the world grid. This is Rosetta, the protein structure prediction program. Rosetta was born on Linux. It can run on a mac too but not as well. There never was a version developed for Windows. But hand it to the the IBM folks to create a wrapper that lets it run as a grid "screen saver" scavenger application on windows. Pretty remarkable.

    Of course the reason for this is obvious right? windows dominated the planet not only in installed systems but in installed systems with cycles to spare. i.e. desktops. So dont cry your eyes out over it not being linux compatible. The excess linux bandwidth after you subtract our the servers is not going to be a lot. Console yourself that the TCO of linux is really a lot less when you figure that linux computers are already too busy to be bothered with Grid computing. :-)

    Rosetta itself was written in fortran and only recently converted to C++. the C++ conversion was done using the incredibly well designed Objexx Library by stuart metzner and colleagues. This is a library that lets you write fortran code in C++. Before this people who tried to re-write this behemoth to C++ just died in the process. The objexx library let the whole thing be converted to C++ in one fell swoop. Now the program will slowly evolve from fortran style to C++ object orientation as it continues to grow. But in the meantime the code is productive. Nice Eh? The cool thing is that with a bit of optimization the code did not lose any appreciable speed in the conversion. So if you have legacy fortran you use for speed, consider converting it using Objexx. I was one of the people who argued for going to fortran95 not c++ because I feeared a speed loss; Iv'e become a convert

    In any event the program is not like folding at home. That program tries to study in detail the picosecond evolution of single protien as it folds. Rosetta simply predicts the folded structure. Its actually quite fast at doing that. But it turns out it makes lots of different predictions. So you have to do it tens of thousands of times and then see which geometries of folded structures are favored statistically. Then you do the next protein. Eventually you work your way through the whole human genome.

    also unlike folding at home the potential surface in rosetta is less physics based and more bayesian statistice. It has statistical potential for the probability of a peptide backbone structure occuring. And it has a probabilty for a sidechain amino acid sequence given a backbone structure. Multiply those together and bayes rule says the result is proportional to the probablity of a structrure given a sequence. You can read more about this here. Click on publications.

    This statistical potential turns out to be so accurate that it can not only be used to predict the structure of proteins but it can be used in reverse to design a novel structured protein. Recently it was used to design a protein with a tolopology that had never previously existied in nature. This is rather an amazing results. Others had previously redesigned the sequences of existing topologies or perturbed those topologies or created some special case topologies. But Brian Kuklman in David Baker's lab actually started from a napkin sketch and designed a protein from scratch.

    After you predict the structure of a protein, one thing you can do is ask if that structure is like another Protein you have seen before. You can compare the structure of a model to a real protein using a program known as MAMMOTH. While there are a variety of programs for comparing two proteins this one is particularly good for the case of comparing an inaccurate model to an experimentally known structure. If they match then you can assume the protiens may share a related function or evolutionary origin (or not!).

    whihc brings us to what proteins are. Think of DNA as a disk drive that

    --
    Some drink at the fountain of knowledge. Others just gargle.
  21. Re:User-Agent header is wrong by tesmako · · Score: 4, Funny
    I would distrust a poll to a far greater extent than user agent information, Slashdot is a Linux-pride site of great proportions, people will tend to answer Linux even when it is not really true.

    You know how it works; Dual-booters will answer Linux despite being in Windows. People with multiple machines will answer Linux refusing to admit it if they actually use Windows more. People who have a Linux server with a ssh session active will answer Linux despite surfing in from a Windows desktop. The casual Fedora user who according to themselves just havent gotten around installing Linux again since they replaced their harddrive... There is prestige in using Linux here, most of Slashdot uses Windows, but most of it would also like to pretend that they arent.

    To put it the proper way: Slashdot is mostly made up of posers.