Slashdot Mirror


Australian ISP Unveils WiMax Like Card

krispy78 writes "If you're looking forward to the day your laptop has WiMax built in and can access wireless broadband as easily as WiFi, you're not alone. But the 802.16e mobile WiMax standard is yet to be finalized on paper, and we'll be lucky to see it the first products this side of 2007. In Australia, a wireless PCMCIA card has been released that comes close to the "WiMax ideal". It appears to Windows like a regular WiFi card (no heinous login clients to run) but can pick up wide-area wireless broadband signals. The network that runs the cards ("Navini Ripwave") is apparently being rolled out in USA and other countries too."

69 comments

  1. Ireland has had this for a while by donutface · · Score: 5, Informative

    Ireland had this for a while, and a lot of people arent happy with the service, hopefully the aussies will do a better job. If your interested check out www.irishbroadband.ie, they also sell "ripwave" modems.

    1. Re:Ireland has had this for a while by REBloomfield · · Score: 1

      I can't find too much info on that site about how they're utilising the features of wimax, but since they only seem to be offering symmetrical 512k, they're missing the best bits....

    2. Re:Ireland has had this for a while by REBloomfield · · Score: 2, Informative

      My bad, I was looking at ripwave. Breeze seems better. There is another success story in the UK: http://skylink.telabria.com/

    3. Re:Ireland has had this for a while by GekkePrutser · · Score: 2, Informative
      Exactly! I just sent my modem back, glad to get rid of it.

      Problems I had with it were:

      • VERY bad latency (variable from 200 to 2000 ms
      • Some days it dropped out every minute for at least 20 seconds
      • Throughput on busy days was below 2kbyte/s even though it was supposed to be a 512/128 connection.

      Basically it was totally not useable for SSH and Voice-Over-IP (what I wanted to use it for). Also no good for gaming. Downloading was only possible on 'good' days.

      And yes, I wasn't very close to the transmitter but some of my colleagues who had the service too had line-of-sight within 200 metres from the transmitter and their service was just as bad.

      It was also bad for them on the same days, we even used to text each other when it was fast again so we could all start a download quickly before it would drop again.

      I'm glad I switched to cable!

  2. That's some range! by intmainvoid · · Score: 5, Funny
    So this card is being released in Australia... but the network is apparently being rolled out in USA and other countries too.

    That thing must really have an amazing range!

  3. Yeah cool. by Spit · · Score: 4, Informative

    I'm using a desktop rabbit unit right now, just plug your ethernet in and your on. No phone line, no ADSL bullshit, no headache when moving.

    Also good for test when at a client site. Wireless broadband is the greatest!

    --
    POKE 36879,8
  4. Great Things About Australia by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    1) Unwired (www.unwired.com.au) unleashes this card.
    2) John Howard knows how to take care of the muzzie extremists before they strike.
    3) We will phase out analog TV before the USA.
    4) Topless beaches.
    5) 3G phone systems. How's that UTMS going you AT&T/Cingular tards?
    6) Topless beaches.
    7) It's far from America and even further from England.
    8) Car accidents are called "smashes"
    9) Drunk driving is called "drink driving"

    If you live anywhere else, WAYSA?

    1. Re:Great Things About Australia by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

      did you know

      that when you take a crap and see bits of corn in it

      it's not corn

      it's actually the "hull" or outer skin of the corn kernel

      which was not digested

      although the body digested the "meat" of the kernel, thus making it hollow

      and now the "hull" is filled with poop

      so it looks like a fully constituted corn kernel (only brown)

      just think about that

      a corn kernel filled with poop

      that is a lot cooler than australia

    2. Re:Great Things About Australia by narkotix · · Score: 2, Informative

      Hold on...the only reason why 3g phone systems are being picked up is because of the rates being offered by 1 company alone. If it was up to our national carrier and our no 2 carrier, prices would be ridicously high. In Australia, the govt hasnt had the balls and or the intelligence to see that there is obvious pricefixing between the top 3 mobile phone carriers. Its only through hutchison's actions where marginally better pricing schemes and call rates have been introduced. Now as for wireless internet, i realistically only know of 1 company in australia that offers REASONABLE pricing on wireless services (but unfortunately they are fixed position setups utilising 802.11 and a CPE). The rest dont have really good pricing in terms of data usage compared to other countries.

      --
      We played dungeons and dragons for 3 hours.....then i was slain by an elf
    3. Re:Great Things About Australia by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Believe me, the English and the Americans are pretty happy about Number 7 too.

    4. Re:Great Things About Australia by frinkacheese · · Score: 1

      What is this? Seasame Street? -- Brought to you by the number 8 and the letter F

    5. Re:Great Things About Australia by domukun367 · · Score: 1

      10) We don't suffer from NIH (Not Invented Here) Syndrome

      --
      Please don't send a Word document when a text file will do the job.
  5. Australian Angle by Marlor · · Score: 0

    As an Aussie, I'm sick of seeing submissions on Slashdot from other Australians that hype the Australian angle to every story. This is typical Australian insecurity. Since we are isolated down here at the opposite end of the world to the USA and Europe, most Australians see a need to shout "Don't forget about us!!" constantly, as if to remind the world that we are still here.

    If this technology was being trialled by an ISP in any other country, the story would primarily be about the technology, maybe with a note about where it was being trialled. But since this is being trialled in Australia first, the headline and summary hype up the Australian angle. Hopefully one day us Australians will be secure enough that we can stop constantly worrying about what everyone else thinks about us.

    1. Re:Australian Angle by FinestLittleSpace · · Score: 4, Funny

      You aussies have computers?!

    2. Re:Australian Angle by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      You aussies have computers?!

      Yeah, but we run into problems, because the endianness switches once you are south of the equator.

    3. Re:Australian Angle by Chuck+Chunder · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Hyped up the Australian angle? It mentioned the word "Australia" once as the place the card was available.

      Maybe someday Australians won't suffer from cultural cringe and feel the need to wince whenever their country is mentioned in public.....

      --
      Boffoonery - downloadable Comedy Benefit for Bletchley Park
    4. Re:Australian Angle by log0 · · Score: 1

      On the plus side, it allows us to run MacOS on our AMD/Intel beige boxes.

    5. Re:Australian Angle by DeafByBeheading · · Score: 2, Funny

      (My deepest apologies, but I can't pass up the opportunity)

      I think the submission only makes such a big deal out of it because it must have been really tough to develop this while fighting off dingos and kangaroos and crocodiles and throwing boomerangs around and playing didgeridoos.

      --
      Telltale Games: Bone, Sam and Max
    6. Re:Australian Angle by mikek3332002 · · Score: 1, Funny

      That would only stop once the USA finally shot Irwin.
      "Cricky would you look at the bullet"

    7. Re:Australian Angle by glowworm · · Score: 0

      while fighting off dingos

      We don't have to. They are too busy hunting babies.

      And... you forgot to say "dodging Drop Bears".

      --
      Orationem pulchram non habens, scribo ista linea in lingua Latina
    8. Re:Australian Angle by Marlor · · Score: 1

      The WiMax card was not developed by an Australian ISP, they are just one ISP participating in the trial. Why say "Australian ISP Unveils WiMax Like Card" when the card was developed by a Texan company, and the ISP just happen to be using it.

    9. Re:Australian Angle by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, the headline should read "US Company Unveils WiMax Like Card", as the Aussie ISP appears to just be buying the card from Navini.

    10. Re:Australian Angle by megrims · · Score: 1

      No, I think it's fair.
      We also wince when your country is mentioned. :)
      (Though not so much as we do 'their' country, ugh.)

    11. Re:Australian Angle by megrims · · Score: 1

      Yeah yeah, I know grandparent is an Aussie...

    12. Re:Australian Angle by Quirk · · Score: 1
      throwing boomerangs around

      if you throw a boomerang and it doesn't come back,
      what do you call it?

      .

      .

      .

      a stick

      I love that joke. Ya, I know, I need help :-)

      --
      "Academicians are more likely to share each other's toothbrush than each other's nomenclature."
      Cohen
    13. Re:Australian Angle by DrSkwid · · Score: 1

      In insecure Australia, story goes an about AU!

      --
      There are places where the networks are not touching,and there are places where they are-Boeing's Lori Gunter
    14. Re:Australian Angle by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes we do, do you Americans have brains?

    15. Re:Australian Angle by drsmithy · · Score: 1
      You aussies have computers?!

      Yeah, but they're not as good as those one you guys have. We have to turn our monitors upside down to get a decent picture, for example, and all the electrons flow around the machine backwards.

    16. Re:Australian Angle by FinestLittleSpace · · Score: 1

      English, actually.

    17. Re:Australian Angle by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Christ.

      Even stupider.

      On an unrelated note - is there some rule in the UK that you only win the ashes every 20 years or so?

  6. Lack of info amidst marketing barrage by lightyear4 · · Score: 5, Informative

    This device works across a wide range, from 2-6ghz. WiMax, being part of the 802.16 spec, can hop all around that range.

    So then, I have question for the better informed (considering that any real information on Navini's site is very effectively obscured under a deluge of marketing babble). Does this device support the accessing of 802.11 networks as well? The article summary seem to infer it: [the card] appears to Windows like a regular WiFi card... Also, (from TFA) the card's hardware includes a range of Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGA) and Digital Signal Processing (DSP) chips. Does this mean it COULD support 802.11 with a change of firmware? I imagine this functionality would be welcomed by many.

    1. Re:Lack of info amidst marketing barrage by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      The article summary seem to infer it:

      The article summary seems to imply it. You seem to infer it.

    2. Re:Lack of info amidst marketing barrage by REBloomfield · · Score: 3, Informative

      Providing it supports the 802.16 spec as it currently stands, it will allow the integration of 802.11 networks, and the support already exists at the MAC layer...

    3. Re:Lack of info amidst marketing barrage by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Does this mean it COULD support 802.11 with a change of firmware?

      It's a different kettle of fish, but considering most laptops now have centrino who fucking cares? Lam3r.

    4. Re:Lack of info amidst marketing barrage by lightyear4 · · Score: 1


      infer (n-fûr)
      v. inferred, inferring, infers
      v. tr.

      1. To conclude from evidence or premises.
      2. To reason from circumstance; surmise: We can infer that his motive in publishing the diary was less than honorable.
      3. To lead to as a consequence or conclusion: "Socrates argued that a statue inferred the existence of a sculptor" (Academy).
      4. To hint; imply.

  7. Hyphen? by muhgcee · · Score: 0, Informative

    WiMax Like Card? What is a "Like Card"? Once we have answered this question then we can apply the other adjective to this term and figure out what a "WiMax Like Card" is.

    OH oh oh . . . you meant WiMax-Like Card . . . seriously, some proof-reading/English lessons?

  8. Another DoCoMo ? by Gopal.V · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Somehow I have this feeling that this is giving birth to yet another proprietary standard - ala NTT DoCoMo . Something that works only locally, but works very well in those local conditions.

    And how well could it work on an open platform - like GNU/Linux or FreeBSD. I use two laptops on and off, borrowed from office. They run FreeBSD or RHEL (and are re-imaged on return). I'm still wondering whether I should get a wireless WAN card for India.

  9. For those who want wireless broadband now by RzUpAnmsCwrds · · Score: 4, Informative

    For those of us who want wireless broadband today, Sprint and Verzion both offer 1x EV-DO (about 512k, 200-300ms latency) in the US for about $60. There aren't any bandwidth caps, but you probably get cut off if you download 80GB.

  10. hope it's like richochet was. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There was one thing that richochet modems had that really made them cool. you were not forced to use their portal but could connecte from serial number to serial serial number for direct modem to modem connections. This was great until the SOB's at the company turned that functionality off just before they started their death spiral.

    I would look at wimax with more of a gleaming eye if I know that I can buy my own wimax accesspoint or connect from wimax card to wimax card WITHOUT having to pay a monthly service fee. I can do that with my 56K modem that is rotting on the shelf in the storage room.

  11. Have had this in Ireland for Years.... by Shadow_139 · · Score: 0, Troll
  12. Got it in the UK too by frinkacheese · · Score: 4, Informative

    NOW Broadband www.now.com have a similar service in the UK but it's not PCMCIA yet. They use IP Wireless www.ipwireless.com which is a 3g (but for data only) type system and whom according to their website have a PCMCIA card version so maybe NOW will have PCMCIA soon too. But for now, only in London.

    1. Re:Got it in the UK too by ttys00 · · Score: 1

      We don't exactly have it in London either.

      I've been trying to get this service (I live in central London), and despite the Now salespeople flogging it in my local shopping centre for the last month, you can't actually get it in my area.

      The salespeople actually use Vodafone 3G PCMCIA cards to demonstrate it.

    2. Re:Got it in the UK too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      We're about to get this in the part of Sweden where we have our holiday house. It's IP Wireless's UMTS TDD (or whatever it's called) infrastructure built by Accelerated Wireless. The advertised 1Mbps up/down isn't much, but it's enough (depending on what the final price will be!).
      It sounds perfect for us, as we're not going to buy a plain POTS subscription or drag fiber to the vacation house, what with the little time of the year we spend there.
      But is it any good? How does it compare to other wirelss solutions?

      A Londoner (ttys00) further up this thread mentioned their net is demoed with Vodafone and not IP Wireless 3G modems. I've gotten the impression that the Swedish project I'm talking about will be built and run by Accelerated Wireless (AW), using licensed IP Wireless (IPW) technology, and then ISPs/telcos will pay AW to be allowed to sell services to end-users, who will have to buy IPW modems from AW...

      This was a project ordered by the authorities (i.e. politicians, not technicians and enterprises who have a clue) and partly funded by tax/EU money, so naturally one fears that nobody knows what they're doing and they've locked themselves to a crap system...

    3. Re:Got it in the UK too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      BTW, dear readers, try to ignore my redundant "plain" in "plain plain old telephone system"... ;) /Swedish AC

  13. I for one by Skythe · · Score: 1

    welcome our kangaroo riding boomerang wielding overlords?

  14. Range? by wondercool · · Score: 2, Interesting

    What is the range of this product? When I think WiMax I think 15 miles or so. Nowhere is there any mention of how far you can be away of the antenna.

    If the range is the same as iBurst I don't see much improvement. Only pricing will make a difference.

    1. Re:Range? by cciRRus · · Score: 1

      Just curious, is range all that important? Usually if the range is far, you would not be able to use the optimal modulation like 64 QAM for best performance due to signal attenuation, noise and interference. So, you would end up with a much lower attainable speed. IMO, it may be better to keep the range at 1 mile but give users in that covered area with more realistic throughputs.

      --
      w00t
  15. Re:FP! by BronsCon · · Score: 0

    Troll? Heh, I figured that would be an informative post.

    At any rate, until I can get it and use it... Until at least a good number of us can... it sucks. Flat out. Kinda like FIOS.

    Ability is one thing. But without availability, it's useless.

    Mod me troll again, won't bother me. I read more than I post anyway. Just keep in mind, though, I could just as easily have posted as an AC and saved my posts for karma whoring.

    --
    APK quotes people (including myself) without context and should not be trusted. Just thought you should know.
  16. Obligatory Windows Sledge by denebola · · Score: 4, Funny

    FTFA

    What's particularly impressive about Unwired's card over all other solutions is that it doesn't need any godawful proprietary software clients to log in to the network.

    Except Windows.

  17. (Australian wireless) by ivan+kk · · Score: 1

    Unwired - http://www.unwired.com.au/index.php already have a rollout with plenty of coverage around Sydney. http://www.unwired.com.au/availability/index.php
    iBurst (flash warning) - http://www.iburst.com.au/ are implementing rollout now.

    Discussion form for wireless isps here:
    http://forums.whirlpool.net.au/forum-threads.cfm?f =18

  18. Navini isn't WiMax (802.16) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Navini uses a proprietary MAC layer that is not 802.16 compatible. Sprint did extensive testing with them in 2002-2003. Sprint/Nextel now owns about 80% of the 2.5 GHz MMDS spectrum in the US. If anyone had a real product they would be deploying it instead of sitting on a billion plus dollar investment.

  19. confused by max+born · · Score: 1

    They claim rates of 744Kbit/s but my 802.11b cards get twice that. I know that 802.16 has the advantage of greater range but it also operates in the 10GHz+ so if data rates are proportional to signal baud then data rates should be much higher, right?

    Also, in physics there's measurement called "skin depth" which is the distance a wave travels in a non conducting medium before it's power level drops by 1/e or about 1/3 and for which the formula is (wavelength/2*pi). The higher the freq the greater the drop off.

    I'm not doubting the 20km+ claims of 802.16 but given the FCC power limits of about 10mW per channel I can't figure out how they're getting a greater range than the lower freq 802.11.

    1. Re:confused by argeybargey · · Score: 1

      The 802.16 spec specifies two RF operating ranges. Less than 11GHz for non line of sight (NLOS) channels, and 10 to 66GHz for line of sight channels. Non-line of sight would typically be for links within the urban clutter. Line of sight would typically be for fixed backhaul and hence higher capacity links.

      Assuming a constant modulation and coding scheme, the data rate is proportional to the bandwidth. The bandwidth for 10-66GHz is typically 25MHz or 28MHz, which is wider than the 802.11a/b/g standards. Greater bandwith means greater data rate. (Assuming your channel quality is equal).

      The highest order modulation scheme and coding rate for 802.16 is 256QAM and rate 7/8 coding. This gives a data rate of 113Mbits/s for a 20MHz channel.

      The other major advantage for 802.16 over 802.11 is the longer cyclic prefixes used. This enables greater multipath immunity. Multipath is caused by a reflection of the signal arriving at the receiver before or after the strongest received signal. Multipath effects become greater once you move outdoors and have increased separation between transmitter and receiver. Also, there are more obstacles for the signal to reflect off.

  20. Seconded by scsa · · Score: 1
    ...and you were a lucky bastard with latency from 200-2000ms, mine's 1000ms to infinity and beyond. A long ping to google.com usually comes back with 75%+ packet loss. It's the worst kind of net connection anyone can possibly have. There's a comfort huddle of unhappy ripwave campers here.

    That said, I suspect part of the problem is Irish BB's implementation of Ripwave - even their premium services have severe problems, so who knows? The Aussies may luck out.

    1. Re:Seconded by GekkePrutser · · Score: 1
      Yeah, I had the same problem at first. It was REALLY bad then. What I did was I moved the modem to the highest point in the attic (into a little crawlspace right under the top of the roof) and ran a network cable 2 floors down to the computer. Because of the stronger signal I had much better reception there.

      IBB apparently (TV commercial) recommend putting the modem next to the computer which wasn't sufficient in my case. If you have the opportunity (and you can't switch to another provider altogether) I would make sure to put the modem in the highest place possible, where its view is obstructed by the softest material possible. The roof is better than a wall (as long as the insulation material doesn't contain any metal, make sure you check this).

      By doing this I was able to increase my signal to the same level as my colleague's who lives very close to the transmitter. Unfortunately on most days the connection was still very lousy. But before I did this I had hardly any at all.

      Hope this helps, if you want to discuss it further, please email me at @gmail.com

  21. Re:Great Things About Australia -3G by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Totally agree ... it is absolutely hilarious to see the major carriers rushing at 3G following the success of the Hutch network, when the success is more due to the call rates being 1/3 of the GSM network rates offered by the majors. Having had a video phone for more than 2 years, can honestly say that I\\\'ve only ever made one video call, and used the net like 2 times

  22. It appears to Windows... by Caspian · · Score: 1

    That's nice.

    How does it work with (for instance) Mac OS X, Linux 2.4, Linux 2.6, or the current versions of NetBSD, OpenBSD, and FreeBSD?

    It's fucking sick that EVEN ON SLASHDOT, it's usually safe (and considered, by the majority, to be inoffensive) to assume that Everyone Runs Windows.

    (I guess that's why it's "News for Nerds". "Nerds" run Windows; "Geeks" run Unix, eh?)

    --
    With spending like this, exactly what are "conservatives" conserving?
  23. What About Common People? by cyberscan · · Score: 1

    Is this something that can be bought by an average person and used to set up a FreeWan Cell, or is it just another product that is going to be dominated by some large company. If this is something that used by the average person to set up a network without having to pay a fee to some company, then it just may very well be one of the greatest innovations for amnkind. Imagine being able to transfer information at high speeds and low cost without some government or corporate Kommissar monitoring your every move. This would sound very nice to me.

  24. Broadband by StarKruzr · · Score: 1

    Don't .ie and .au both have ISPs which charge per-minute or per-kilobyte fees, mostly because they can get away with it because "it's always been that way?"

    This is what I'm told the situation was like in Dublin last year (ca. middle of 2004), anyway. And I remember from being there in '99-'00 that it was easily as bad - there was essentially no such thing as broadband and the fees for dial-up were outrageous.

    --

    +++ATH0
  25. "News"? You're kidding, right? by Bandraginus · · Score: 1
    I live in Australia and for the past year I've had wireless broadband at 1024/512kbps with 12GB (shaped there-after) monthly download limit, for the princely sum of $49/month. And all of this in a tiny little town called Canberra, that's not even a major city. I have both a PCMCIA card and a desktop modem, and these let me roam to every major city in Oz.

    I'm confused how all of this is "new".

  26. I've used one in the US by yhetti · · Score: 1

    I've used one in the US at an installation, but I'm not sure exactly how much I can say about it. We were considering buying one and requested a demo of a live site by the company.

    Navini has a couple dozen, maybe 100, maybe more installations in the states. They use an antenna array, proprietary and disturbingly expensive multi-antenna controller, and some patented version of orthoganal beam forming. They also only sell one unlicensed product in the 2.4 range. The rest are from 2.1-2.3, 2.6, and a 5.x that I don't recall.

    In our real life tests on a live system, the portable USB/ethernet modem device was good for about 5-6 miles outdoors in a moving vehicle, and 2-3 miles if it was indoors. The entire backplane was 12MBps..which as anybody will tell you, under load, will barely qualify as "Broadband."

    Additionally, a telco has deployed an older Navini system where I live. It..doesn't work so well inside. It *does* work, however, with a laptop and a modem about anywhere in town (their installation is on a *very* high peak).

    Overall, we decided against the system because it just didn't perform that well. It would have been a multi-hundred-thousand dollar install, potentially, for a 12Mbit backplan to deliver rural-only broadband. Navini, though, has done amazing work and real-life data aside, the implementation is brilliantly conceived. It's not exactly WiMax. Since the WiMax 'standard' is still sort of....*shrug*...they can say about anyting they want. It's similar to the standard, and it does work in some limited fashion...but it's still wireless.

    -Y

  27. Re:"News"? You're kidding, right? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    A tiny litte town called Canberra? The nation's capital Canberra. Not a major city. FFS. You are unworthy of wirelss broadband. I'll swap you for the ONE wireless hotspot in Hobart. A phone booth. I shit you not.

  28. Re:"News"? You're kidding, right? by palndrumm · · Score: 1

    Just out of curiosity, who's that with? I didn't even know anyone did wireless broadband in Canberra...

  29. Re:"News"? You're kidding, right? by Bandraginus · · Score: 1
    It's with iBurst. I won't tell you the ISP in case they close the loophole I seem to have found ;) But I joined up in the early days when they had much larger download limits (ie, 12GB for $49/m). They've since reduced all those limits in the new plans because it must not have been sustainable for them, but they seem to have left us first few customers on their existing plans. The plans these days suck royally. I actually only pay for a 256kbps line, but I found out how to get 1024kbps out of it :)

    iBurst's coverage is really good in Canberra now. They've pretty much got most of the city covered.