Slashdot Mirror


Ubuntu Feisty Fawn Drawing Near

daria42 writes "Ubuntu developers are finalizing preparations for the release of the next version — dubbed Feisty Fawn — of the popular Linux distribution in mid-April. Overnight, Ubuntu developer Tollef Fog Heen announced Ubuntu's main software repository had been frozen — with no changes allowed to the code — as developers got ready to issue a fifth major test version ("Herd 5") of the next version of Ubuntu."

66 of 331 comments (clear)

  1. AWW damn!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Fuck, I just spent $399 on Vista Ultimate!!!!

    1. Re:AWW damn!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

      I think you forgot to include the cost of Office 2007 Ultimate? - $679!

      You do know that Ubuntu comes standard with OpenOffice and all the other essential applications most Windows users miss out on (unless they pay extra)?

    2. Re:AWW damn!! by MartinG · · Score: 4, Informative

      No.

      What is illegal is abusing monopoly power in one area to force your way into another.

      So bundling MS office with Windows would be illegal because they own and control both and are a monopoly. Ubuntu is nowhere near a monopoly.

      --
      -- MartinG To mail me: echo kewyjlcxyzvjfxbqwh | tr bcefhjklqvwxyz .@adgimnoprstu
    3. Re:AWW damn!! by IANAAC · · Score: 2, Insightful
      Openoffice and Ubuntu are completey separate entities, owned by two completely different companies.

      Windows and MS Office come from the same corporation.

      But even if you don't consider that, I doubt that Microsoft would ever just throw in Office for free (even if it were bundled, you be paying a premium). Office is their main cash cow.

    4. Re:AWW damn!! by snottgoblin · · Score: 2, Informative

      Its been a while since I used windows, but I don't think MS Office was ever bundled with windows. There used to be a trial version of Word and Powerpoint but MS Office was always a separate product.

      While it is true that Microsoft use their monopoly to push windows onto many unsuspecting users, I'm not sure they really bundle any software with windows that stifles competition (perhaps their new AV software is..but I don't really sympathize with their competitors on that one!)

    5. Re:AWW damn!! by Short+Circuit · · Score: 2, Interesting

      The bundling is done by OEMs rather than Microsoft themselves. Even then, you either get Microsoft Works (an incompatible piece of crap) or a teaser version of MS Office that you have to feed a credit card to in order to unlock.

      What's really ironic, though, is that, since the days of Windows 3.1, Write (or, "WordPad" since Win95) has more than enough features for average home use. Granted, that doesn't give you spreadsheet abilities. WordPad is even capable of reading most Microsoft Word documents.

    6. Re:AWW damn!! by FrostDust · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Yeah, that's what I used to say, but care to venture a guess as to why Wordpad can't read .DOC's in Vista?

    7. Re:AWW damn!! by Stooshie · · Score: 2, Informative

      I think it was setting IE as the default browser that caused the Monopoly problem,not Office

      --
      America, Home of the Brave. ... .and the Squaw.
    8. Re:AWW damn!! by lixee · · Score: 3, Funny

      why is it illegal for microsoft to include office in windows yet it's ok for linux to include openoffice with it?
      What on Earth is this guy doing on /.?
      --
      Res publica non dominetur
    9. Re:AWW damn!! by mabinogi · · Score: 2, Informative

      no, it was setting IE as default and then preventing OEMs from making Netscape default under threat of losing their right to distribute Windows.

      Merely including a product for free is not illegal.

      --
      Advanced users are users too!
  2. I'm using feisty since herd 1 by vivaoporto · · Score: 5, Interesting

    And I can say is that Feisty is a big improvement over Edgy, both in hardware support and software "smoothness". It is a pity that Xorg 7.2 will not be ready for Feisty launch, but this is certainly a candidate to bring an alternative to Windows on the Desktop.

    1. Re:I'm using feisty since herd 1 by ACS+Solver · · Score: 2, Informative

      Using since Herd3 here, and it is indeed a big improvement over Edgy. Edgy was, well, edgy for me. On the 64-bit version, many minor things, such as not having the boot splash, or CPU timing sometimes screwed up. Herd4, which was recently released, was quite surprisingly stable, although there remained issues with running 32-bit apps on the 64-bit version. Now, if only they had 1.2.3.1 in Feisty, saving me the need to compile & install it.

    2. Re:I'm using feisty since herd 1 by Short+Circuit · · Score: 3, Funny

      I misread your post as saying Hurd 3 was here. Queue "WTF" reaction...

    3. Re:I'm using feisty since herd 1 by daff2k · · Score: 2, Informative

      Probably feeding a troll here, but "Feisty Fawn" is the code name for the project that is officially called "Ubuntu 7.04". Just like Windows Vista was dubbed "Longhorn" for the longest time. Read up a little before posting crap.

      --
      And which parallel universe did you crawl out of?
    4. Re:I'm using feisty since herd 1 by thegux · · Score: 3, Informative
      Heh, sorry about that then. Yeah, it's the version number of the kernel. I don't know if you have the 2.6.20-6 version of the kernel installed - you should have it installed if you had Herd 3. To check, run this command:

      ls /boot | grep 2.6.20-6
      If you have it installed, it should output something like this:

      abi-2.6.20-6-powerpc
      config-2.6.20-6-powerpc
      ini trd.img-2.6.20-6-powerpc
      initrd.img-2.6.20-6-powe rpc.bak
      System.map-2.6.20-6-powerpc
      vmlinux-2.6. 20-6-powerpc
      If you don't have it installed, install it with this command:

      sudo apt-get install linux-image-2.6.20-6-powerpc
      Once you have this installed, run these commands:

      sudo rm /boot/initrd.img.old /boot/vmlinux.old
      sudo ln -s /boot/initrd.img-2.6.20-6-powerpc /boot/initrd.img.old
      sudo ln -s /boot/vmlinux-2.6.20-6-powerpc /boot/vmlinux.old
      Be careful with these commands, make sure you follow them exactly, if you don't, you could mess things up pretty badly. Once you've got all this done, this should allow you to boot into the old kernel when you turn on your iBook - y'know when it asks do you want to run from a CD or Linux? You press "l" as usual there - but in the next prompt, you'd usually hit return, right? Well, don't do that. Instead, type "old", and then press return. This'll boot into the old kernel, which has working wireless drivers. (I presume you already have the firmware for those drivers installed, if not, well then install the bcm43xx-fwcutter package. I can't remember if that's in the Ubuntu repos or not - if it isn't then Google around for a .deb). Hope that helps.
  3. No changes allowed by Bob54321 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Ubuntu's main software repository had been frozen -- with no changes allowed to the code

    As opposed to freezes where you are allowed to change things...
    --
    :(){ :|:& };:
    1. Re:No changes allowed by plover · · Score: 4, Funny
      Our standard joke regarding code freezes at work is "If this is a freeze, I wouldn't walk on it."

      But I suppose you have to be from a place where they do a lot of ice fishing before that joke makes any sense at all.

      --
      John
    2. Re:No changes allowed by jeevesbond · · Score: 5, Insightful

      This might sound harsh, but they don't care whether you know what a code freeze is. In fact if you don't know what that is why are you reading Slashdot?!

      It's not like Microsoft, Canonical didn't create some press-release to tell everyone: 'We're freezing our codebase! Make sure all technical journals know!'

      This story got on to Slashdot because of geeks avidly following Ubuntu's development process, which--unlike Windows--is totally open. If you don't know what a code freeze is: don't worry, just wait for the release. The fact you don't know is not Canonical's fault or problem.

      If you do want to know: first imagine all the software projects Ubuntu uses (the Synaptic package manager on my system tells me I've currently got access to 20,304 bits of software, so much for the old: 'There isn't any software available for Linux' argument). When the devs start working on a release they use the newest versions of whatever software is available. As the new version of Ubuntu nears release though they have to be certain all the software will work together, so they do what's called a 'code freeze'.

      A code freeze means they don't use any newer versions of software that are made available. They just make sure that whatever is now in the software repositories works. The reason for this is to stop any unforseen incompatibilities creeping in when a new version of a software package is used.

      Here's a scenario:

      The devs are working on the new version of Ubuntu: Happy Hippo. A new version of Firefox (no pedants, I am aware of the policy regarding Firefox, this is just a common software package and something the reader will identify with. No corrections needed!) has been created since the last release, so they import it into the software repositories. Call it: Version 2.

      Before the code freeze a new version of Firefox is released (v2.1), with an autoPr0n feature many people love. This is imported into the new version of Ubuntu: Happy Hippo.

      The code freeze happens... But a new version of Firefox is released afterwards (v2.2), with an enhanced autoPr0n feature (many people are calling this the next 'killer app'). Unfortunately, this is after the code freeze, so the new version of Firefox does not get imported.

      Imagine if the devs didn't do the code freeze, and the new enhanced autoPr0n feature (in v2.2) caused a problem with The GIMP. But the devs had already checked Firefox, but not the latest version.

      So the code freeze is necessary, although you don't necessarily need to know about it. :)

      --
      I'm going to transform myself into a mighty hawk. Either that or I'll just go and work at Dixons, haven't decided yet.
    3. Re:No changes allowed by John+Nowak · · Score: 3, Funny

      You sure sound like a bunch of fun guys. :-)

    4. Re:No changes allowed by Jeff+Carr · · Score: 2, Funny

      the Synaptic package manager on my system tells me I've currently got access to 20,304 bits of software Hmm, you might want to add some new repositories, that's less than 2.5 Kilobytes of software!
      Unless you've installed all the rest? 0_o
      --
      The television will not be revolutionized.
  4. X.org 7.2 will (perhaps) be in feisty by MrvFD · · Score: 5, Informative

    Actually Xorg 7.2 is currently on its way to feisty, thanks to efforts by a community member, working together with Debian and helped by some Ubuntu core developers: https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-devel/200 7-February/023252.html

    The xserver-xorg-core is already version at 7.2 (or "1.2") now, with the rest of the modules going in gradually. With the modularity of X.org nowadays, it's not certain that all the newest driver work will be in, though. For example the ati driver has seen only some important patches backported to feisty, while there has been a lot of development and reworking without a proper release of xserver-xorg-video-ati lately.

    1. Re:X.org 7.2 will (perhaps) be in feisty by lavid · · Score: 4, Informative

      I'm pretty sure the X.org 7.2 merge is pretty close to complete. It borked a bunch of stuff, beryl, compiz, 3d stuffs, when they only half merged it with the repos last week. From what I see right now all the X.org drivers (except fglrx, ATI's proprietary driver) are at 7.2 as are the xorg server bins. I'm sure there are some modules still to be upgraded especially since Compiz hasn't worked for me since last week. There are plenty of threads about this on http://www.ubuntuforums.org/.

      --
      If Bush wants to kill the terrorists, he should jump off a cliff.
  5. Why Xorg 7.2 is so important? by pato101 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Please would you point major features of Xorg 7.2 so it is a pity it does not get included? (not pretending to troll, I'm just ignorant).

    1. Re:Why Xorg 7.2 is so important? by squiggleslash · · Score: 5, Funny

      I've never used it, but I believe the usual pattern is that the latest version of something contains the device drivers for the one device you need support for, except that it's actually for a similarly named chipset from the same company and doesn't actually work with your card, but it does feel slightly faster, but has a whopping great memory leak that means you have to reboot your computer every few days.

      --
      You are not alone. This is not normal. None of this is normal.
    2. Re:Why Xorg 7.2 is so important? by jeevesbond · · Score: 5, Informative

      There are some details on the release page on the Freedesktop wiki.

      From that page:

      X11R7.2 supports Linux, BSD, Solaris, Microsoft Windows and GNU Hurd systems. It incorporates significant stability and correctness fixes, including improved autoconfiguration heuristics, enhanced support for GL-based compositing managers such as Compiz and Beryl, and improved support for PCI systems with multiple domains. It also incorporates the new, more extensible XACE security policy framework.

      Release notes should be on the download page, they're marked 'forthcoming' at the moment, but wait a day or two and they should appear.

      --
      I'm going to transform myself into a mighty hawk. Either that or I'll just go and work at Dixons, haven't decided yet.
    3. Re:Why Xorg 7.2 is so important? by pato101 · · Score: 2, Funny

      Why don't you go read the X11R7.2 changelog?

      Because I get lost in technical acronysms (just see below)

      The inclusion of XCB is one of the major changes. It replaces the fuctionality of Xlib, but offers an Xlib compatibility layer. XCB is the way of the future, my good man.

      Sweet. When I read the changelog- thanks for the link- I didn't notice how important XCB was. You have made me follow the XCB link and understand what it is about and why it is so important. Thanks for pointing it :).

  6. Re:Frozen code? by Trip+Ericson · · Score: 4, Informative

    It merely means that the code and repos have been frozen in order to allow for anything that's broken to be fixed and made ready for a public, stable release.

    Development continues anyway, just that the code for this release has been frozen except for bug fixes.

    At least, that's my understanding of it.

  7. Re:Frozen code? by jimstapleton · · Score: 3, Insightful

    it's not perma-frozen, and the actual projects aren't stopped.

    It's the version of the code that is in the repository specifically for ubuntu that is frozen. This is a common release process to make sure everything is relatively solid and stable. It happens on most OSS OSes as they go through the final stages of testing and planning.

    --
    34486853790
    Connection too slow for X forwarding? Try "ssh -CX user@host"
  8. Yes, try Kubuntu by metamatic · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I just switched from Ubuntu to Kubuntu, because Ubuntu is infected with Mono.

    While KDE has way, way too many UI tweaks available in its preferences, I just switched the theme to Plastik and stopped fiddling with everything else. Other than that, KDE beats Gnome in every way.

    --
    GCHQ Quantum Insert installed. If only our tongues were made of glass, how much more careful we would be when we speak
  9. Re:Fast going cold on Ubuntu by Trip+Ericson · · Score: 4, Informative

    Your problems sound more like Gnome problems than Ubuntu problems; I should know, I didn't like Ubuntu on my first shot because I'm partial toward KDE (which I had going on Fedora). I made the switch to Kubuntu and haven't looked back.

    It combines the wonderful Ubuntu codebase and DEB packaging system with the KDE interface. I certainly recommend you try it.

  10. Skip this one by pkspks · · Score: 5, Funny

    I'll wait for the "zombie zebra"

    --
    667 - one step ahead of the beast.
    1. Re:Skip this one by xs650 · · Score: 2, Funny

      'I'll wait for the "zombie zebra"'

      Don't get your hopes up, I was waiting for Farty Ferret. Now it will be nearly 26 years before the Fs come back again.

  11. Re:Fast going cold on Ubuntu by hey! · · Score: 4, Insightful

    You don't need to run KDE. You just need the dependencies installed. Naturally, though, if you do use KDE stuff its going to increase your memory footprint.

    Maybe if you prefer KDE you should use Kubuntu. I haven't had your problems with Evolution because I use Thunderbird.

    I've been using Gnome on Ubuntu; I started out preferring KDE strongly, but after using Gnome for a while ... I still prefer KDE. But I understand the point of Gnome. It's not that one is perfect and the other is trash. Adjusting from one to another simply involves a series of small irritations as your unconscious expectations are violated, until you adjust. I found the Gnome file dialogs irritating at first; but they get the job done, only in a different way than I expected.

    --
    Post may contain irony: discontinue use if experiencing mood swings, nausea or elevated blood pressure.
  12. Been using it for about a month... by physicsnick · · Score: 5, Informative

    I've been beta-testing Kubuntu Feisty for about a month now, and it's amazing. It's already a huge improvement over Edgy. Everything is so intuitive and easy to use; Feisty is going to kick ass.

    Some of the new stuff they've added are a new wireless network manager by default, big improvements to the package installation system, easy codec/flash installation, lots of user interface tweaks... It looks so polished now, I love it.

    Here are the Herd release announcements, containing a subset of the changes Feisty brings:
    https://wiki.kubuntu.org/FeistyFawn/Herd1/Kubuntu
    https://wiki.kubuntu.org/FeistyFawn/Herd2/Kubuntu
    https://wiki.kubuntu.org/FeistyFawn/Herd3/Kubuntu
    https://wiki.kubuntu.org/FeistyFawn/Herd4/Kubuntu

  13. Faster, Feisty, Faster! by reclusivemonkey · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Is it just me or does Feisty seem noticeably quicker than Edgy? OK, my Edgy was getting a little bloated which is one of the reasons I updated to Feisty, but is seems to boot a lot quicker and my Desktop seems to be up in seconds after logging in from GDM.

  14. Re:Fast going cold on Ubuntu by pato101 · · Score: 5, Informative
    Do not need to try Kubuntu instead: you can just install the kubuntu packages in your ubuntu install, by doing just this:

    sudo apt-get install kubuntu-desktop

    Alternatively, you may play with xfce if you like by adding xfce packages as follows:

    sudo apt-get install xubuntu-desktop

  15. Re:Tollef Fog Heen by plover · · Score: 2, Funny
    I say, boy, I say don't be makin' sport of his name, now, y'hear?

    Nice boy, but doesn't listen to a word I say.

    Sincerely,
    Foghorn Leghorn

    --
    John
  16. Mod Parent Up by physicsnick · · Score: 4, Informative

    GP, simply hop into a terminal and type:

    sudo apt-get install kubuntu-desktop
    sudo apt-get remove ubuntu-desktop
    sudo apt-get autoremove


    No need to reinstall anything; it's that easy to switch. If you liked KDE in Mandrake, you'll surely like KDE in Kubuntu.

    1. Re:Mod Parent Up by Yfrwlf · · Score: 2, Informative

      Anything you install, whether it's Gnome, KDE, XFCE, Windowmaker, or whatever, will be available as a session selection before you log in.

      --
      Promote true freedom - support standards and interoperability.
  17. Whatever happened to version numbers? by AdamHaeder · · Score: 2

    I simply can't remember what names equal what versions anymore. I guess for people that only deal with Ubuntu, that's all you know, so you remember the names. I had this problem with debian as well: which one was the newer distro, ham or potato? Whatever happened to plain old numbers?

    1. Re:Whatever happened to version numbers? by Bazman · · Score: 4, Informative

      Ubuntu version names are (now) alphabetical, so Dapper Drake preceded Edgy Eft, which precedes Feisty Fawn. The names are always Adjective Animal ('eft' is another name for a newt).

      There are also version numbers, so that Edgy Eft is 6.10 (meaning year 2006, month 10). The releases are supposed to be every six months in April and October.

      Barry

  18. Patents, patents, patents! by jotaeleemeese · · Score: 2, Funny

    Now I should throw a chair at Miguel de Icaza or something.

    --
    IANAL but write like a drunk one.
  19. Breaking news! by jotaeleemeese · · Score: 5, Funny

    Feisy Fawn is even closer as I type!

    Tollef Fog Heen came back from lunch and just turned on his screen. Now that is progress.

    Oh man, we live excilarating times.

    Please check back for updates:

    In one hour Tollef Fog Heen will finish to write an email.

    In three hours Tollef Fog Heen will complete one icon missing in one of the menus in the graphic installer.

    In 5 hours Tollef Fog Heen goes home. Nooooooo! Ubuntu development stalled! Stop the presses....

    --
    IANAL but write like a drunk one.
  20. Will Feisty Fawn be an LTS release? by ELiTeUI · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Dapper Drake (6.06) was an LTS release. Edgy Eft (6.10) was not an LTS release. Does anyone know if Feisty Fawn will be LTS or not?

    1. Re:Will Feisty Fawn be an LTS release? by physicsnick · · Score: 2, Informative

      It won't.

      The one after it might be. I've heard the release cycle as of Dapper was meant to be first an LTS release, then a release with radical new changes (ala Upstart), then a polished release-of-awesome, then back to LTS again. That's probably just speculation; take it with a large grain of salt.

  21. Re:Fast going cold on Ubuntu by clark0r · · Score: 2, Informative

    Memory footprint larger in KDE? Are you sure? Maybe you should have done some research: http://ktown.kde.org/~seli/memory/desktop_benchmar k.html Now of course this is slightly bias (just look at that domain!) but I'm sure I've read this elsewhere also.

  22. Feisty Fawn shpping - Debian slipping as usual by Kjella · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I actually thought Debian was closing in on a release quite soon when they slipped their December release goal. Well, it's now March tomorrow and they still haven't even gotten RC2 out the door. Yes, I can understand the "when it's ready" but if you run into so long delays that you could have an intermediate release, then it's better than no release at all. At this rate, Ubuntu might have their next LTS version out before Debian does...

    --
    Live today, because you never know what tomorrow brings
    1. Re:Feisty Fawn shpping - Debian slipping as usual by Respect_my_Authority · · Score: 2, Informative

      Don't you worry, Etch will be out soon enough. The number of release-critical bugs is now going down nicely and the final version of the installer, RC2, will probably be announced during this week. But you don't have to wait for the Etch release. You can download and install Etch right now. It has been ready for normal use for several months now.

      http://www.debian.org/devel/debian-installer/

      The Etch release process has also significantly decreased the number of release-critical bugs in Sid -- and Ubuntu has updated their sources from the Debian pool several times during the Feisty release cycle. This means that Feisty will be more solid than several earlier Ubuntu releases, while Feisty+1 will again be a hayride to Hell for Ubuntu when Debian Sid goes bonkers after the Etch release. :-P

  23. Not sexy enough by ciaran.mchale · · Score: 4, Funny

    Feisty Fawn is not sexy enough. I'm going to wait for the Nubile Nymph release.

  24. Re:Fast going cold on Ubuntu by dos_dude · · Score: 2, Insightful

    What happens when somone using Gnome wants something like k3b is that he installs k3b and happy.

  25. Re:how about WoW? by physicsnick · · Score: 5, Informative

    Actually, WoW really does work right out of the box with Wine. It has entirely Gold or Platinum status on WineHQ:
    http://appdb.winehq.org/appview.php?iVersionId=648 2

    On that page there's a hugely overcomplicated guide on getting it working; Feisty will tremendously simplify things, especially since it comes with Wine 0.9.30. Here's how you'd install WoW in Feisty:

    1) Install your video card drivers. This involves clicking Applications->Add Applications, clicking Advanced, and choosing nvidia-glx for NVidia cards or xorg-driver-fglrx for ATI. Much simpler than on Windows.
    2) Restart X (press CTRL+ALT+BACKSPACE).
    3) Put the WoW install CD in the drive.
    4) Browse to your CD-rom (/media/cdrom) and double-click Installer.exe
    5) Do the Next-Next-Finish dance
    6) Double click the icon on your desktop to launch the game.

    So it's pretty much identical to Windows, except the CD won't autorun. :/

  26. Smoother update process? by Tarlus · · Score: 3, Informative

    I hope the upgrade-via-apt-get process goes much more smoothly this time... I had a lot of troubles going to 6.10 last fall using this method, and I noticed a number of other people did, too. I ended up having to just download the ISO and install fresh because I messed up my existing installation beyond repair just by trying to update... Either way, it was worth it, since I love the improvements that Edgy introduced. It is by far the slickest distro I've used.

    One thing to keep in mind is that if you upgrade to Feisty Fawn by just updating your list of apt repositories, do NOT do a dist-upgrade to their apt servers on release day since thousands of other people will be doing it at the same time. The load will slow it down just about to the point of timing out (at least in my experience). If you want to upgrade to it on release day, I'd recommend using bittorrent to get the ISO (faster this way) and then doing an apt-get dist-upgrade with that CD-ROM as a new apt repository.

    --
    /* No Comment */
    1. Re:Smoother update process? by radarsat1 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      If you want to upgrade to it on release day, I'd recommend using bittorrent to get the ISO (faster this way) and then doing an apt-get dist-upgrade with that CD-ROM as a new apt repository.


      Actually I really wish they'd incorporate bittorrent into Apt. That would be pretty cool. (Have it fail to an http server of course if bittorrent doesn't work or is too slow)

      I looked this up before and found there is at least one project trying to do it.

      I think bittorrent could be improved if it allowed a simple http server to be considered a seed, that way you could just use the bittorrent protocol and it would download from the http server if there were no seeders.
    2. Re:Smoother update process? by Quila · · Score: 4, Informative

      that way you could just use the bittorrent protocol and it would download from the http server if there were no seeders.

      Or have a server that's always seeding instead of an http server. Anyone who wants a file to be always available should have this anyway.
  27. Does Upstart = Launchd? by Kadin2048 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Is upstart based at all on Apple / MacOS X's launchd? They created that basically to speed up OS X's boot time, and it did so dramatically. I believe that it's Apache (or BSD?) licensed and Apple was hopeful that it would be included in other systems and become the standard way of doing things, although there was a lot of cynicism that the mainstream Linux/UNIX community would never give up init and rc, regardless of the technical merits of any replacements. Granted, it doesn't give you the System V-like multiple runlevels, but I'm not sure that most desktop users are ever going to care. They're either going to use the computer normally, or boot into some sort of low level recovery mode from the boot prompt if things go pear-shaped. The idea of multiple runlevels is more confusing than anything for non-technical users.

    FWIW, I was initially skeptical of launchd and launchctl after upgrading my Mac to 10.4, but I've since learned to really appreciate the design of both of them. Some serious thought went into both, and I think they both represent a rethinking of some processes that have just been carried over in other UNIX-based OSes from the days of minis and mainframes to desktops, and aren't necessarily the best way of doing things.

    I think it's natural that in the future we're going to see more differentiation between desktop Linux distros and server ones, besides the amount of software that's installed. Fast-boot systems like launchd would be one welcome addition to desktop distros (although their utility might be more questionable on servers that are rarely restarted and where the dynamic launching of services on an as-needed basis might be a misfeature).

    --
    "Ladies and gentlemen, my killbot features Lotus Notes and a machine gun. It is the finest available."
    1. Re:Does Upstart = Launchd? by mhall119 · · Score: 2, Informative

      Upstart is similar in concept to Launchd, but was written from scratch by Ubuntu. It is event-driven, not runlevel driven, which gives it some very interesting abilities that I'm sure will be exploited in creative ways in the future. I would be surprised if we don't see it included in Suse and Fedora in the near future, and a package is already in Debian experimental.

      For more on Upstart, check out its website: http://upstart.ubuntu.com/
      The original Ubuntu feature request that lead to it is here: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ReplacementInit (Discussions at the bottom as to why Launchd was not used.)

      --
      http://www.mhall119.com
  28. Actually, I'm not too excited. by DoofusOfDeath · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I find myself at a funny point now. Ubuntu is certainly my distro of choice, and its the only OS I really use. But now that it works well enough for me to focus on my work rather than having to wrestle with the OS, I don't really care that much about one upgrade to the next.

    I've did install Feisty Herd 4 (+ update) on my HP laptop to see if they fixed the ACPI issues that have always plagued me. (Won't suspend or hibernate when I close the lid.) No real improvement there (although if I manually make it suspend, it does act a little more normal after waking up than it does with Edgy.) But without that improvement, I just find myself kind of, I dunno... content with Edgy. It's a nice but slightly disappointing place to be.

  29. Oops, forgot OpenGL by physicsnick · · Score: 3, Informative

    You also need to tell Wine to use OpenGL by adding a couple lines config file. It's step 4 in the appdb link I posted. So one additional step.

  30. Must be said by Necreia · · Score: 5, Funny

    "Ubuntu Feisty Fawn Drawing Near"

    > Command? (A)ttack (S)pell (I)tem (R)un:

  31. Non-standard support? by flicman · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I have a widescreen laptop (as I expect plenty of people do) and I tried Ubuntu Live on it, but it failed to recognize the aspect ratio, and therefore everything was stretched out and ugly. Not good.

    Then I tried it on my main system (where I do a lot of video and photo editing, so I'm unlikely to switch full time), but came up empty when Ubuntu didn't work with three monitors.

    Is this version of the OS going to address needs like my relatively-standard non-standard display issues?

  32. The point of GNOME by metamatic · · Score: 2, Informative

    Back in the mists of time, Qt wasn't licensed under a free software license. Therefore, the GNOME project was started as a way to create a desktop environment that would be GPL/LGPL compatible. Rather than merely clone Qt as free software, the developers opted to start again from scratch.

    Then TrollTech made Qt available under the GPL. Unfortunately, GNOME continued; by that point, there were too many egos involved, and too many wheels had been reinvented. These days GNOME is mostly there (a) as an ego trip, and (b) because it's more compatible with cheapskate proprietary software developers.

    The latter needs some further explanation. Basically, GNOME and GTK+ are LGPL licensed, not GPL licensed, so you can develop proprietary closed-source software for GNOME for free. In contrast, you have to pay money to develop proprietary closed-source KDE software, because you need to negotiate a non-GPL license for Qt with TrollTech. GNOME also includes Mono as part of the core GNOME desktop, so you can use the patented proprietary Microsoft .NET technologies.

    --
    GCHQ Quantum Insert installed. If only our tongues were made of glass, how much more careful we would be when we speak
  33. Re:Fast going cold on Ubuntu (mail migrate) by MancunianMaskMan · · Score: 4, Informative

    migrate your mail: I installed my own IMAP server (courier-imap, use Maildir-format to store mail in individual users' $HOME, configure system-wide fetchmail to deliver email to users). That way you can change tour mail client on a daily basis, since they all support IMAP, and your mail stays in the same place. As an added bonus you can use email on other computers in your house if you have a laptop with WiFi ot something like that. Once you've set your IMAP up, you can darag-and-drop historic email from your "old" evolution email into IMAP, close evolution for good, and run Kmail, thunderbird, mutt, ot whatever else you like.

  34. Colour me crazy... by B5_geek · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I have been running *Ubuntu since the Warty days (as my only workstation OS), and I do love it.

    I use KDE on the backend with fluxbox as my WM.

    Will Feisty allow me to install Beryl/Compiz via apt and give my eye-candy for flux?

    (A) I LOVE with speed and configurability of Flux.
    (B) I am envious of all the neeto window-manager effects that compiz allows
    (C) I am not willing to run Gnome or KDE as my WM in-order to get the eyecandy.

    Am I crazy-insane or insane-crazy?

    --
    "The price good men pay for indifference to public affairs is to be ruled by evil men." ~Plato (427-347 BC)
  35. Windows users, take note: by ABoerma · · Score: 5, Funny

    You know you've stumbled into an *NIX-centric discussion when people say 'reboot every few days' like it's a bad thing.

  36. Oblg. Xkcd... by RyuuzakiTetsuya · · Score: 3, Funny

    "I'm sorry, I'm not really into Pokemon."

    --
    Non impediti ratione cogitationus.
  37. All I need now from Ubuntu is.. by cheros · · Score: 2, Interesting

    (1) the splash to stay 'Ubuntu' even though I use Kubuntu' - why can't I choose?
    (2) a decent server. I tried Fedora but found the interface inconsistent (maybe I should have read more docs), OpenSuSE does the job with Yast but to get cups to server printing to a couple of Windows boxes is a pain but it's so far the quickest to setup re. serving Samba, Apache, MySQL for people like me that have not so much time to plough through man pages and docs (though I'm not exactly a stranger to CLI - I've been using Linux since it came on floppies and X was an option :-). I really like what the Ubuntu guys are doing so as soon as they come up with a usable server I'll be using it.

    Now, if someone has a web way to set up Postfix + IMAP with a couple of domains and aliases I'd be interested, but that's a new question which I haven't researched yet myself :-). I guess it's time to find webmin again..

    Ubuntu: intelligent freedom..

    --
    Insert .sig here. Send no money now. Owner may sue, contents will settle. Batteries not included.