Slashdot Mirror


How Pirated Software Impacts Free Software

jmglov writes "Dave Gutteridge has an unusual take on why people are not interested in saving money by using a free-as-in-beer OS like Linux or *BSD: because Windows is free. At least, that is an all-too-common perception, thanks to bundling and piracy. Bundling is a well-known problem to the adoption of open source operating systems, so Dave takes a look at the piracy issue in depth. His title may offend you, but his well-written article will most likely get you thinking hard about the question, 'how much does Windows cost?'"

14 of 530 comments (clear)

  1. Pirates don't hurt anyone by AssCork · · Score: 3, Funny

    it's the swords -

    --
    The following replies are posted by unwashed nerds.
  2. Windows is free by RLiegh · · Score: 2, Funny

    ...only if your privacy means nothing.

    1. Re:Windows is free by dave562 · · Score: 3, Funny
      Linux is free

      ....if only your time means nothing.

      Ya ya, gimme the karma hit. It was too funny and too easy to pass up.

    2. Re:Windows is free by B4D+BE4T · · Score: 2, Funny

      While we're throwing out anecdotes, here's mine:

      Over the weekend I tried installing Ubuntu on my old desktop. First I tried Ubuntu 7.04. It died trying to boot from the CD and gave an error about not being able to read from the CD. So I figured it was a bad CD. Burned the ISO on a different burner and tried again, same error. Burned it again at the slowest speed, same error. So I gave up and went for the older version, Ubuntu 6.06. Installed OK, but the desktop was stuck at 640x480 resolution. Took a few hours of scrolling through various how-tos and trying a few things like: Plugging the monitor directly into the desktop (not through the KVM switch) and then reconfiguring xorg.conf; updating nVidia drivers; changing various settings in xorg.conf; etc. Finally, after a few hours of messing with it, it turned out I needed to add HorizSync and VertRefresh settings to the monitor section of xorg.conf. Then I was free to select any resolution for the desktop. So now when I open a window, I get to see the whole window!

      Now what did it take to get the same functionality in Windows on the same desktop? Put in Windows CD 1 and select a few settings. Play Xbox. Put in CD 2. Play more Xbox. Done.

      What does all this mean? Nothing. It's just an anecdote.

  3. What? by eclectro · · Score: 4, Funny

    Pirates are hurting free software? I think we are cutting ninjas way too much slack here.

    --
    Take the cheese to sickbay, the doctor should see it as soon as possible - B'Elanna Torres, "Learning Curve"
  4. Re:Price model by roman_mir · · Score: 4, Funny

    Maybe this is just tinfoil hat stuff, but could this all be part of Microsoft's strategy? Are they that smart? - no, they are really dumb. They are only making billions while they could be making MILLIONS!

  5. Re:Very true.... by Mattintosh · · Score: 2, Funny

    Ghost had crashed as it finished the last disk, but luckily the disk was readable. How likely is that? Crashed AFTER the the last sector wrote.

    I'd say pretty darned likely. Every time I've ever run Ghost it does that. It must be buggy in the cleanup and exit code. The images are just fine, but Ghost dies with mysterious circumstances every time. Maybe that's why they call it Ghost.

  6. Re:Windows isn't free by reboot246 · · Score: 4, Funny

    I can relate to that. My girlfriend called me a couple of weeks ago and wanted me to install Windows on her daughter's computer. She had just gone out and bought the software. I said that I was 100% sure that she already had Windows on that computer. "No", she said, "Windows isn't on this computer and she needs it to type her resume." Turns out that the computer had Windows and what she had bought that day was Office. And this is a woman who is intelligent enough to date me!

  7. Re:Windows isn't free by Nimey · · Score: 3, Funny

    And this is a woman who is intelligent enough to date me!


    What does that say about you?
    --
    Hail Eris, full of mischief...

    E pluribus sanguinem
  8. Re:Price model by dave562 · · Score: 4, Funny
    That's an old drug-dealer strategy - the first time is for free, then they come to you with money.

    I want to meet one of those drug dealers. They give me the first one free, then they come to me with money after that? Where do I sign up?!

  9. Re:Very true.... by aichpvee · · Score: 2, Funny

    "Pro level stuff," huh? You windows kids do realize that you sound ridiculous, right?

    --
    The Farewell Tour II
  10. Re:Very true.... by dbIII · · Score: 5, Funny

    many people just loose their OEM disk ... How should those people be handled?

    Quite seriously for letting the things out - they could bite some kid or crap on my lawn. If they just let them loose and don't have them on a leash or behind a high enough fence they are a menace.

  11. We must be tough on all forms of piracy by MarkByers · · Score: 4, Funny

    How should those people be handled? Is Piracy still piracy if it's the same version as what was there before?

    Yes, it's absolutely piracy.

    We need to be more tough on pirates and terrorists. In the music industry we use fines of $100,000 per 5MB of illegal pirated contraband. This should be increased to $500,000 per 5MB for Windows because it is such an important piece of software. Since Windows is about 1 GB in size that means we should be fining them about a gajillion dollars per theft. If you have multiple pirated copies then we must treat it as a commercial operation, and then clearly we are talking about *much* larger numbers.

    Once the fine has been paid the pirates should then be sentenced to death by hanging. This is a good way to prevent re-offending.

    I know that some of you think this is a little harsh but we must remember what the world was like when we were too gentle with pirates and terrorists. Do you want events like 9/11 to become a regular occurrence?

    --
    I'll probably be modded down for this...
  12. Re:Very true.... by dintech · · Score: 3, Funny

    gives you the option of burning 1 (one) set of restore CD's

    And let me guess, all I need do is send $10,000 to their bank in Nigeria to get the process moving?