Toshiba Going After Blu-ray?

Swifty Nifty has an adventure submitted a link to a story about Toshiba's new High Def Disc Format. No, I'm not kidding — apparently Blu-ray has a new contender. This seems to be intended as a DVD backwards-compatible format, but there's not a lot of detail.

Comments

Hello?

[Mateo_LeFou]

Could we please get ISO to fast-track one of these High Def standards so we will all know what to buy? Please?? (Hint:joke)

Re:Hello?

[Midnight Thunder]

Could we please get ISO to fast-track one of these High Def standards so we will all know what to buy? Please?? (Hint:joke)

In that can I vote, and then complain about the way I voted? ;)

Re:Hello?

[Anonymous Coward]

. . . so we will all know what to buy I didn't buy an HD-DVD player. I will not be buying a Blu-Ray player. I will not be buying a this thing. Technology is moving way too fast for me to keep replacing my hardware. As soon as I commit to buying one of these things, a new technology will have emerged, making my spanking new purchase obsolete before the year is out. I am not a sucker.

Fuck this shit. Lemme download an electronic copy to play directly from my hard drive.

Re:Hello?

[Lumpy]

I know your joking bot the death of HD-DVD was a loss for the consumer.

HD-DVD discs were easy to author on home PC so your home movies could be burned to a STANDARD DVD-5 or DVD-9 with the pretty menus and all the glitz.

Blu-Ray has horribly bad and spotty compatability with a hack of putting AVCHD encoded files on a standard DVD-5 disc. Only some players will play it and some that do play stop playing after firmware updates.

Re:Hello?

[Anonymous Coward]

Technology is moving way too fast for me to keep replacing my hardware. As soon as I commit to buying one of these things, a new technology will have emerged, making my spanking new purchase obsolete before the year is out. I am not a sucker.

Fuck this shit. Lemme download an electronic copy to play directly from my hard drive. Hard drive? That's obsolete. Everyone's using solid state these days.

Re:Hello?

[Dishevel]

In that can I vote, and then complain about the way I voted? ;) I thought that it was mandatory.

Re:Hello?

[terjeber]

Blu-Ray has horribly bad and spotty compatability with a hack of putting AVCHD encoded files on a standard DVD-5 disc

And you have tried this? I have authored AVCHD disks for about 4 months now, and my experience is directly opposite of what you are saying. I regularly take authored disks to various places like Circ City and Best Buy to test on a variety of Blu-Ray players, and I have not had a single player not play my menu-based AVCHD disk yet.

Re:Hello?

[Anonymous Coward]

"HD DVD discs were easy to author". That is pure crap. Whatta hell burning a DVD with HD content has to do with HD DVD ?!??

THERE WERE NO HD DVD discs to author because there were no working burners available ! HD DVD was complete failure when it comes to burnable disk, format simply did not work.

Sama time there were literally countless BD-R and BD-RE drives available. And nowdays BD-drive prices are constantly going down and even more drives are available (with faster read/write speeds).

Re:Hello?

[skuzzlebutt]

Solid state? Pshaw...My Neuro-Optical-Quantum PC knew you were going to type that before you even logged in this morning.

Re:Hello?

[gravis777]

Adobe Encore easily made Menus for BluRay discs. In fact, I could take my DVD menus, with HD content, and compile the same thing to either BluRay or DVD, and it just reencoded the disc for whichever format I needed

Nero easily recorded AVC files to DVD5 and DVD9, and played flawlessly on my PS3. Source was a PAL TS file that I converted to NTSC AVC. No issues whatsoever.

I have yet to see any software that would allow me to author HD-DVD. As I have both formats, I would love to see something that would let me make HD-DVD compatable discs as easily as I can make BluRay compatable discs.

Re:Hello?

[Achromatic1978]

I didn't buy an HD-DVD player. I will not be buying a Blu-Ray player. I will not be buying a this thing. Technology is moving way too fast for me to keep replacing my hardware.

And what, it's your belief that technology is only going to slow down from here?

Re:Hello?

[terjeber]

You regular take your discs to "Circ City and Best Buy" and play them?

Yes, I do. I do it for two reasons. None of them because I need a new Blu-Ray player. Let me explain.

I own a HD camcorder, and I use this to shoot at birthday parties and other family events. Often people ask me about the quality of HD camcorders (not about TVs and players). They wonder if they will actually get good quality. I like shooting and editing, and to show friends and acquaintances what the result can be, I have so far this year created AVCHD disks to show them. They ask me to assist in purchasing a camcorder, and we drop in to a store and talk. That's when they see the AVCHD disk. I have also handed out some disks, but people are interestingly a little shy about asking for permission to view at Circuit City or Best Buy, even though I tell them it has never been an issue for me to get permission.

BTW, this will change in the middle of this month since SCS is releasing their Blu-Ray authoring tool then to match my new Blu-Ray writer.

So they let you pop in a random disc into a player to see if it works?

I always ask nicely and I have so far not received a single negative answer. The closest I have gotten to that was a "You have to ask that other dude". This is also the experience from anyone I have chatted with in the video editing forums I frequent, so I am unsure as to why you think it impossible. Have you tried it and been denied?

If you go back about 12 months and read some of the video editing forums like creativecow or others you will find many curious "editors" doing exactly the same thing.

Just curious about your attitude though. Did I tear down some religious symbol you have been worshiping?

Re:Hello?

[Fred_A]

Hard drive? That's obsolete. Everyone's using solid state these days. Solid state is so passé... wait a few month before new high density tapes come out and they'll be all the rage.

Data storage on Betamax is the future, that's what insiders at a big company told me. But I've said too much already.

Re:Hello?

[Tumbleweed]

In that can I vote, and then complain about the way I voted?

Don't blame me, I voted for HD-Kodos.

Re:Hello?

[hostyle]

Logged in? Pschaw. I shall report your epic fail to my master when he returns from a round of golf.

Warning: You may be berated with some of yesterdays human slang when he returns.

regards,
    the hostyle bot

Re:Hello?

[drsquare]

I doubt it, the bandwidth and hard disk capacity isn't there. Most people could only get one or two HD films on their hard disk before they ran out of space, and they'd take days to download on most broadband connections.

Re:Hello?

[Tumbleweed]

You can pretty easily compress most movies to 700MB with the right codec, maybe double that for HD, and most people wouldn't know the difference. Most people don't have HDTVs, and most of those don't have 1080p capability either. Also, most people never seem to check out the extras on discs, either (which is *really* strange to me). Considering the state of the economy, I think people will be more open to things which cost less, and no physical media scales to lower costs a lot easier, especially considering all the marketing, packaging, display, transportation costs involved in BluRay, not to mention the cost of the players right now (though that'll obviously come down soon enough). BluRay *really* needs some sub-$100 Korean players on the market, plus they need to chop the price of the discs in half to actually compete with DVD. The problem with all of that though is that most people still can't see anything better than DVD resolution anyway.

Re:Hello?

[Tumbleweed]

We're still a few years away from eliminating the discs.

I agree, but what that means in practical terms is that DVD is still the disc to beat. DVD will be around long after BD, cuz BD is going nowhere fast.

It's too bad noone really came out with affordable 480p widescreen TVs - most people never saw what DVD was really capable of before HDTV came out. And really, a large-ish 720p set with source upconverted from DVD is a pretty nice picture, and way more affordable than HD source and 1080 display. The US economy is going to prevent a lot of upgrades, though, so I think DVD is going to be 'the' disc for a few more years, yet, until better more people have true broadband connections, and the infrastructure is upgraded to *feed* those broadband connections. Too many people are paying the cost of a new BD player every month on gas right now to afford new electronic toys.

Re:Hello?

[hairyfeet]

I have to agree. And until they can come out with a burner that isn't crippled with DRM with media that is even close to being as affordable as DVD so I can backup and hand out software without needing to worry about getting it back I'll also have to pass. I personally am hoping that those hologram discs will become affordable,as have 1Tb or more in a hard to damage cartridge makes for a VERY appealing backup solution. Until then I'll stick with DVD. but that is my 02c,YMMV

Re:Hello?

[zippthorne]

No way, moon-bounce delay line memory is where it's at.

Re:Hello?

[kesuki]

"And what, it's your belief that technology is only going to slow down from here?"

I've heard that some people believe the price of gasoline will go up around a dollar every year because of the post peak problem. if energy prices do go up, then technology, which depends on energy, and the availability of cheap energy will slow down. it takes a lot of money to 'research' new technologies, using technology already researched is cheap. for an example, consider modern CPU pricing, multi-core designed processors have allowed cpu vendors to rely on the same basic die technology for their cores, even while following moore's law. this is why a high end quad core costs only $400 while long ago far away in the past a 'brand spanking new' 1 ghz chip cost over $1,200. designing new chips has been hit or miss, the itanium is a perfect example of how redesigning something, doesn't always create a viable product.

the point being, if energy prices go up and up, people will have less disposable income, making technology higher and higher risk. making existing technology work better will always be cheaper and safer, than designing new technology.

to keep energy costs lower(and thus keep technology moving at a rapid pace), there are 3 solutions i can think of, off hand.

1. Under Sea Drilling platforms off both arctic and antarctic coasts (under sea so they don't break when the ice forms every winter) the cons are, that nobody (that i know of) has a working undersea drilling platform that is practical. you could go with a telescoping design only producing oil in summer months, or have undersea pipelines to beyond the icy region where tankers can fill up so the 'undersea platforms' can produce year round, underneath the sea.. and possibly a few ideas i haven't though of, the problem with this is it's still dependence on fossil fuels, and putting more co2 into the environment is the last thing we need to be doing.

2. bio-fuels could start taking up the slack, this is really only feasible if large scale bio-fuel from algae is started, and so far at least one texas energy company is starting a major bio-fuel from algae product cycle. How that company does, might drastically change the face of bio-fuel as an alternative to fossil fuels, if they're successful and profitable.

3. use less energy. it's simple, just push aside the American car safety standards, so vehicles can be lighter, and use cheaper engines, and mandate fuel efficiency. sure, a lighter car is a death trap if you hit a big truck, or a heavy car, but if all the cars on the road have to meet higher fuel economy targets (like they have to in japan and china) then they're only more dangerous when hitting old 'legacy' vehicles.

you can easily design an ultralight car that would get well over 120 mpg(without being a hybrid) these guys did. http://www.treehugger.com/files/2007/10/loremo_lives_su.php

i don't know how the car does for safety, in crashes. in general, concept cars that get over 120 mpg tend to be labeled as 'death traps' in a crash with conventional cars, and some use expensive technology that will never scale to the mass market.

cars aren't the only place where we can save energy, but they are a big one, if we'd just say cars can be a lot lighter, even if they're not as safe, just to get better fuel economy. when i owned cars i owned the kind that would have been fatal in any highway collision, yet the type of car accidents i did have, were generally ones involving only me, with 3 exceptions (1 was completely not my fault) and the 3 i did have were at city speeds, not highway.

the point is we could stop the rise in gasoline prices, just by pushing fuel economy.

Re:Hello?

[glitch23]

I didn't buy an HD-DVD player. I will not be buying a Blu-Ray player. I will not be buying a this thing. Technology is moving way too fast for me to keep replacing my hardware. As soon as I commit to buying one of these things, a new technology will have emerged, making my spanking new purchase obsolete before the year is out. I am not a sucker.

What you have is only obsolete if you want to make it obsolete by always buying the next thing (which may or may not be the best). The same issue occurs with CPUs. You can't buy every single generation of CPU. I usually skip a generation because I don't need every generation nor do I want to spend the money. I don't consider the next generation to make my current generation obsolete unless I have a reason to need that next generation. This is the nature of technology. We are making leaps and bounds. As someone already asked, do you actually think the situation is going to get better? Taken as a whole, the last decade has seen so much innovation in varous fields of research and development compared to the last century that it is mind boggling. Innovation will only continue to speed up from here.

Standards

[youthoftoday]

How many standards do we need? The ISO should wade in and sort this out ... no wait.

Re:Standards

[Sponge Bath]

... no wait

Too late. Standard Approved.

Includes Section 12.4.56.2 Option 'PlayLike1970-8Track'

This has GOT to be a hoax!

[sirwired]

After the multi-billion dollar (err... Yen) shellacking that Toshiba just took over HD-DVD, I cannot imagine in their wildest dreams that they would try again. The article notes that this is an unconfirmed rumor, and I fully expect that it is just that, a rumor, and one with absolutely no basis in fact.

SirWired

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[mrbluze]

I cannot imagine in their wildest dreams that they would try again. There are probably animated films in japan depicting the kind of repetitive self flagelation that Toshiba is demonstrating. Probably illegal in most countries too.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[evilviper]

The article notes that this is an unconfirmed rumor, and I fully expect that it is just that, a rumor, and one with absolutely no basis in fact.

My money's on this being the result of some moron tech writer who completely misunderstood what was going on when Toshiba announced something like a new line of up-converting DVD players...

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Anonymous Coward]

I've read about this before. What Toshiba is concentrating on is enhancing standard DVD's through various extensions to discs that would still play on regular players. The idea is to take over the low end market where most of the action is by putting this content into regular priced DVD's and giving the consumer the choice of when to upgrade their player.
It's not entirely a bad idea, but I doubt Toshiba is in a position to pull this off at this point.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Enderandrew]

My PS3 is a rather nice upscaler, and replaced a $250 upscaler I bought a few years back. Both BluRay and DVDs look great on it, and I'm not throwing away my collection of 350 DVD's anytime soon. So no, BluRay owners don't just want DVDs to disappear. We just want the price on BluRay movies to come down to $20 or less.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[BUL2294]

My money's on this being the result of some moron tech writer who completely misunderstood what was going on when Toshiba announced something like a new line of up-converting DVD players...

Yeah, they're called HD-DVD players. Seriously, the R&D has already been done--the hardware has been developed, a base format's in place. My personal feeling is that a firmware update is all that's needed for existing HD-DVD players to support this new format. (After all, the compression would probably be less intense than HD-DVD or Blu-Ray).

Toshiba's R&D costs may be limited to programming a new firmware for existing hardware... Pennies, in the grand scheme of things.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Enderandrew]

First off, if you don't pay for content, then don't be outraged when that content disappears. The PC gaming industry gets worse and worse every year due to piracy. All of my favorite PC game houses went bankrupt.

Next, how much time does it take to rip that DVD, convert it to fit on a single layer disc, burn it, label it, etc?

Most of my DVDs I buy used from Hollywood Video or Blockbuster. They pretty much always have a 3 for $25 deal. I'm paying $8 for a movie to own it legally.

My time is worth far more than $8 an hour, so even if it only takes 1 hour to pirate a DVD, then it really is a huge waste.

I'd happily pay $20 for BluRay movies at this point. And while Wal*Mart, Best Buy and the like are trying to sell movies for $35 a pop (and wondering why sales are so low) Amazon.com sells tons of BluRay movies for $20 or less.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[MasaMuneCyrus]

Based on fact or not, this article has reasonably solid-backing -- this story was run a couple day ago in the Yomiuri Shinbun, which is not only a major newspaper in Japan, but it has the highest newspaper circulation in the world.

Here's the original article for those that read Japanese:
http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/net/news/20080529nt05.htm

Here's a translated article for those that don't:
http://www.excite.co.jp/world/english/web/?wb_lp=JAEN&wb_dis=2&wb_url=http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/net/news/20080529nt05.htm

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Leonard Fedorov]

Could you care to name which PC gaming houses you like went bankrupt? And some sort of evidence that this was due to piracy?

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Enderandrew]

Origin, Looking Glass Studios, Black Isle come immediately to mind. LucasArts also went bankrupt, and laid everyone off. There is a company today called LucasArts, but it is a new company that operates out of ILM. Some companies like Maxis and Sierra are shells of their former selves, with the parent company folded basically, and a large publisher buying the name.

And talk to any game dev. I used to be a real forum rat for various game development forums. There is a reason that game houses prefer to develop for consoles. Sales on consoles are higher, not because there are more consoles on the market than PCs, but because PC higher is far higher than console piracy.

Console piracy exists, but is far more difficult.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[adolf]

1 hour to pirate a DVD?

Sheeeit.

It takes about 3 minutes of my time (including scribbling a label on the disc with a Sharpie) to dupe a DVD. It takes the computer between 20 minutes and a couple of hours, depending on a few things like quality options and the condition of the source material.

Note the distinction between human time and machine time. I don't need to sit and babysit the computer while it rips a DVD, nor (with the abundance of cheap RAM and CPU power these days) does it interrupt my other computer activities.

It goes like this:

1. Decide to dupe a DVD.
2. Insert DVD.
3. Load DVD Shrink.
4. Wait for DVD Shrink to get done with its first-pass analysis (I can do other things during this time, but if I'm being impatient it takes about 2 minutes to finish this step).
5. Remove Spanish, French, and other non-English content
6. Remove noise from menus (!).
6a (optional). Tweak compression ratios to shrink the trailers and credits more, and the main movie less.
7. Push the go button
8. Label and insert blank DVD into other drive.
9. Return in an hour or so to find one freshly-burned DVD.

No problem. And certainly not an hour, either.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Jah-Wren Ryel]

Sales on consoles are higher, not because there are more consoles on the market than PCs, but because PC [piracy] is far higher than console piracy. That's an awful big leap of logic on your part, got some supporting evidence for it?

The only thing you can do with a console is play games, thus anyone who has one is going to buy games and nothing else. Whereas most PCs never even run a game beyond solitare. Even the home PCs that are used for games are only used that way part time - I think you would be hard pressed to find a PC that was used for games more than it was used for general web-browsing never mind word-processing and other home-pc tasks.

In other words, the competition on PCs is much greater than it is on consoles because not only do you compete with all the other games, you also compete with all the other uses for a PC.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[stickyc]

First off, if you don't pay for content, then don't be outraged when that content disappears. The PC gaming industry gets worse and worse every year due to piracy. All of my favorite PC game houses went bankrupt.

Next, how much time does it take to rip that DVD, convert it to fit on a single layer disc, burn it, label it, etc?

Most of my DVDs I buy used from Hollywood Video or Blockbuster. They pretty much always have a 3 for $25 deal. I'm paying $8 for a movie to own it legally.

Okay, this argument doesn't really work. When you buy used like that, guess who gets 100% of that revenue? Blockbuster and Hollywood Video. Not the publishers. As far as they're concerned, you might as well be pirating the movies. If you search around, you'll find the publishing houses (movies, music, and games) blame their losses on the used market just as much as piracy (example here).

My time is worth far more than $8 an hour, so even if it only takes 1 hour to pirate a DVD, then it really is a huge waste.

If it's taking you more than 5 minutes of your time, you're doing it wrong. Insert DVD, launch ripper app, click "Rip", go do whatever it is that's more "worth your time".

I don't know many folks who actually re-burn DVD rips anymore, especially when the new consoles can play media from a USB drive or even network shares. Even if you did, if it's taking you more than 3 minutes to swap disks, fire up your burning software, start the burn, eject, and scribble a title, you're doing it wrong again. NOTE - If you're sitting there watching the ripping or burning parts, you probably actually aren't worth more than $8/hr.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Enderandrew]

The direct stated opinions of several game devs who said they stopped developing for PCs because of piracy.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Danse]

The PC gaming industry gets worse and worse every year due to piracy. All of my favorite PC game houses went bankrupt. The PC gaming industry gets worse and worse because consoles have gotten so huge. Now every publisher wants to publish on all platforms so that they can make the most money possible. This leads to shitty, lowest-common denominator games that the console crowd thinks are awesome. PC gamers are used to different kinds of games, but those kinds mostly don't get made now, or get turned into consolized crap. They may try to blame piracy, but that's mostly bullshit. Some of them even admit that. I can't blame people for not wanting to buy most of the PC games that have come out in the last few years. They've butchered a lot of formerly great franchises.

Then there's the fact that piracy on consoles is even easier than it is on PCs. No messing with drive emulators or firewalls. Just buy an adapter that costs about as much as a game, flip a switch and you can play copies of any game you like.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Wdomburg]

And Oldsmobile didn't get any money when I bought my car. Does that mean it was "just a step up" from theft?

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Gr8Apes]

Reasons for low sales?

Let's see - $20-40 for a BD movie, $500+ for a BD player, or $4-14 for a DVD movie and $30-50 for a DVD Player with a much larger selection (and those would be new movies, btw, not used.)

There's also the issue that for a BD movie to actually be better, you also need a $2K+ TV, which the vast majority does not own. BTW, if you happen to own an older HDTV (prior to HDMI/DVI) odds are that the electronics in it are going to give you a nice upconverted picture without having to buy an upconverting DVD player.

As for copying a DVD - it has nothing to do with piracy, and everything to do with those damn UOPs. I rip my own so I can actually get to the movie instead of watching 4-10m of BS crap you can't forward through. I only do that for the incredibly small set of disks I buy that I will watch more than once in 5 years - namely - disks my kids watch. Also prevents destruction of original disks. A nice bonus.

Re:This has GOT to be a hoax!

[Mr2001]

When they say "piracy", what they really mean is "poor sales". They see that their game isn't selling well, they see a lot of people playing it for free, and they assume that if only they could've stopped those pirates from playing for free, the game would've sold more copies. But, as we know from basic economics, that isn't how it really works.

Seriously

[Rik Sweeney]

Who the hell is going to buy this? Even if it proves to be a superior format, Toshiba have already shot themselves in the foot by dropping HD-DVD which they helped create. What's to say they won't drop this format too?

Re:Seriously

[JasterBobaMereel]

The same people who have bought HD-DVD and BluRay

Is the film plot any different than on DVD? No
Is the film characters any different than on DVD? No

A bad movie with special effects is a bad movie, a bad movie on BluRay is a bad movie ...

Gah

[TPJ-Basin]

Worst. Idea. Evar.

good news for microsoft

[OrochimaruVoldemort]

they can cancel their blu-ray player order and just get one of these.

What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[ergo98]

There were some pretty passionate debates on here, however many of the Blu-ray supporters cheered on the demise of HD-DVD, surmising that it would accelerate acceptance, reduce prices, simplify things, allow retailers to focus.

Here's what happened since HD-DVD caved in-

• Blu-ray players have gotten more expensive. In some cases, a lot more expensive
• Blu-ray sales, paradoxically, have collapsed
• High definition media gets almost no attention
• Retailers that used to push both Blu-ray and HD-DVD now push....nothing. I find it hard even finding a single Blu-ray player for sale.

Just thought it worthwhile to take a moment to point out how things actually turned out. It's pretty remarkable, really, but even Blu-ray did better when it had an opponent to fight. After the battle, most just hung up their cares and said "Meh...upscaled DVD is fine".

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[rob1980]

After the battle, most just hung up their cares and said "Meh...upscaled DVD is fine".

Yeah - having a single high-def format is fine, but to rehash what a lot of people said while the format war was in progress I still don't think it's a killer app for most people the way DVD was over VHS. It's no surprise that Blu-Ray still hasn't taken off the way some had hoped/expected it would.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[SithGod]

While there is no doubt that some of those factors, notably the price, can be chalked up to the decrease of competition, I would say that the new 2.0 Blu-Ray standard is playing a significant role is the lack of players that you're seeing. Most companies don't want to release a player that will be obsolete within a matter of months. The complaints from people about "their player not working like it should" alone should be enough.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[samkass]

The PS3 remains the most popular Blu-Ray player by far and sales appear to be accelerating. Blu-Ray's win appears to be what vaulted the PS3 to second place and relegated the XBox360 to third in monthly sales. Sales of Blu-Ray discs tripled in early 2008 after HD-DVD disappeared.

It's true you don't hear about it as much because it's not as new anymore, but I can't find any source that corroborates your assertions.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[WarwickRyan]

Please could you post references for your assertion? Then you can be modded up and the parent modded down (assuming you're right).

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[SputnikPanic]

HD-DVD is dead and buried, and if Blu-Ray prices don't go down -- substantially and soon -- Blu-Ray will wither on the vine. I was at Costco this weekend and the two Blu-Ray players for sale there were $379 and $449 for Sony and Panasonic models respectively. At Costco! Not many folks I know going to buy at those prices, especially when the gas station is hitting them for $60 every week...

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[ergo98]

The PS3 remains the most popular Blu-Ray player by far and sales appear to be accelerating. Blu-Ray's win appears to be what vaulted the PS3 to second place and relegated the XBox360 to third in monthly sales.

No doubt about that -- it is a huge advantage of the PS3. I'm now seeing new XBox 360s for sale sub-$260 (while the PS3 is at the same $399 that it's been at for well over a year), so while Microsoft claimed it wouldn't impact them when HD-DVD failed, I suspect it's going to cost them dearly as they need to try to get sales through price cuts.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[Anonymous Coward]

Unbelieveable bull.

Over here in EU what has happened:

- Player prices have dropped, several manufacturers have come up with new devices and many of them are fast, silent and possess a great upscaler for old movies.
- BluRay disc sales have multiplied in the past 6 first months of this year.
- HD gets constant attention, especially in combination with new flat screen tvs, digital television and PS3/X360.
- I keep getting "Get new BluRay player" and "PS3 with BluRay!" ALL the time from almost every imaginable media from print to TV to radio.

I don't know where you live in but over here BluRay is doing just fine and things are picking up nicely.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[spectrokid]

Remember the floppy disc? As it became more older and senile, there was a frantic rush to find a replacement. The Zip drive was the closest contestant, but Iomega refused to let a tidal wave of cheap OEM drives loose on the public. So the floppy was replaced by ... nothing. CD's, were used for software distribution, tape for backup, the net for sneakernet and the memory stick for booting. Expect the same to happen here. UPNP media players and the net will kick Blue-ray's ass.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[ergo98]

Unbelieveable bull.

Here's what happened after Blu-ray won.

Player prices have dropped? Maybe your stronger Euro is misleading you, but there have been no price drops. Quite the opposite. Blu-ray players used to be freebies with sets, and you'd get a bunch of discs, and there were endless promotions and price cuts. Last I can see, there's zero promotions, and prices average over $400.

BluRay disc sales have multiplied in the past 6 first months of this year

I Am Legend almost singlehandedly accounted for a spike in the minuscule sales totals for Blu-ray.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[Anonymous Coward]

Recession plays an obvious part in discretionary spending on things like hi-def

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[brunes69]

This is what really sucks about BD. The constantly changing profile spec.

What is essentially a "movie appliance" should not need to be firmware-upgraded to play a disc. It is just STUPID.

HDDVD got that right - build all the features into the minimum spec from the get-go.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[CastrTroy]

And the Wii, which can't even play DVD, is outselling both of them. I think Nintendo was smart to stay out of this race.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[engun]

Agreed. I see that as one of two main reasons for blue-ray not being adopted as fast as DVD.

1. DVD media offered great improvement over VHS (no random access, media wear) and VCDs (Poor picture quality, no menus). But what "must have" feature does Blu-Ray offer over DVD? (Sure, the quality is stunning, but DVD quality doesn't exactly make you want to poke your eyes out).

2. You need high-def TVs to really enjoy blu-ray. That costs a boatload of cash. This is my main personal reason for not even thinking about blu-ray at this point. DVD did not make your existing TV obsolete.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[fyrie]

I'd like to see that too. From everything I have read, BluRay has only claimed a small part of HDDVD's sales, and the actual ratio of DVD to HD content has swayed in DVD's direction since the demise of HDDVD.

Speaking of prices, I'm shocked that the retail price of HDDVDs hasn't gone to fire sale levels. Often Amazon sells the BluRay version for less than the HDDVD version. What up with that?

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[ivan256]

It's the same thing that happened with laserdisc after it was discontinued. No new content is being made, and old content is getting scarce. People with those players are willing to pay a premium to get the content before it's no longer available.

A secondary factor is that distributors are giving volume discounts to resellers for BluRay, but HD-DVD isn't selling enough anymore to qualify.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[ColdWetDog]

According to the grape-wine information

Never trust a group of drunken sods for your high tech information.

Go with the caffeine addicts. We're smarter.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[TheGratefulNet]

What is essentially a "movie appliance" should not need to be firmware-upgraded to play a disc. It is just STUPID.

you do realize, though, that EVERY time you watch a movie - that 1 minute delay of 'loading the disc' is really loading and RUNNING executable code, checking for 'bad hardware' that should be REVOKED (ie, your hardware that some corp. entity NOW thinks should be disabled, perhaps even permanently). then finally, once its done being 'undercover cop' it then lets you view the movie. want to see the movie again? same 'cop behavior' all over again.

I don't own BD and never will. I was at best buy recently and I ejected and reinserted a BD disc. it took nearly a minute to load. I LAUGHED MY ASS OFF. people accept this? really??

it turns out that any BD drive connected to your network or computer is now the least secure thing ON your network. its all black box and you can't know what damage it might WANT to do to some of your hardware. completely untrusted and there's no 'permit/allow' ability if you are even the system owner - you MUST accept whatever damage the BD software wants to do to your system.

and all that just to watch a simple movie. it should be a crime, how they conned innocent people into accepting this 'virus-in-a-box' called BD.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[Jeremy Erwin]

I can barely stand to watch SDTV now.

Does that extend to DVDs?

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[DrXym]

* Blu-ray players have gotten more expensive. In some cases, a lot more expensive / *Blu-ray sales, paradoxically, have collapsed / * High definition media gets almost no attention / * Retailers that used to push both Blu-ray and HD-DVD now push....nothing. I find it hard even finding a single Blu-ray player for sale.

I can summarise the above far more succinctly for you:

• January, February, March, April and May happened.

As shocking as this may seem. Sales of consumer electronics take a dump in the first half of the year. Stores don't offer discounts, no new models come out, releases start to dry up and there are no advertising or other promotions. It is no wonder that sales in that period are low. Sales of DVD players are historically 2, 3 or even 4 times higher in the latter half of the year.

June is where things start to happen. That's when model & titles releases occur, promotions and deals kick off properly for Father's day and keep on going to Christmas. It is around about now that things get interesting for Blu Ray. If sales don't pick up then it might be in trouble. But if DVD's experiences are any indicator, things are going to improve markedly starting about now.

Re:What Happened When HD-DVD Gave Up

[Sentry21]

This reminds me of what happened with DVDs when they first came out. Ever seen an early DVD disc? One of the ones with four or five movie previews at the start, which publishers configured to be unskippable? So you have to watch them over, and over, every time you want to watch the movie?

This is also similar to the ads that all HD-DVD discs I've played contain... ads for HD-DVD. 'The look and sound of perfect!' Great, except I already have a damn HD-DVD player! I'm already sold!.

It seems like studios just don't get it sometimes.

Details

[whisper_jeff]

...but there's not a lot of details.

Which, of course, means it's a perfect candidate for a Slashdot article...

Really, what's the use?

[cp.tar]

DVDs are way more sensitive to damage than CDs, which were not that robust in the first place. It seems to me that every new optical format will be progressively more sensitive to scratches and other kinds of surface damage/warping.

While my need for high-capacity data storage is ever-growing, just like everybody else's, I don't put much hope into optical media anymore.
I just buy a new hard drive, swap it out and put stuff on it.
It's faster, more reliable and takes up less space. It's just a bit less portable, is all.

The only way I'm getting a Blu-Ray or any other contender format, current or future, is if my new laptop comes with a compatible drive. Otherwise... I don't really care, and I doubt it that I ever will.

Re:Really, what's the use?

[cosinezero]

"DVDs are way more sensitive to damage than CDs, which were not that robust in the first place."

-->I keep hearing this from people... do you all not remember magnetic tape?

CDs and DVDs are virtually invincable, compared to VHS and cassette that they replace. And really, if you take care of it, it is quite robust.

Re:Really, what's the use?

[Arccot]

CDs and DVDs are virtually invincable, compared to VHS and cassette that they replace. And really, if you take care of it, it is quite robust.

As robust and durable as a HDD?

I drop cds and dvds all the time. A standard hard drive wouldn't be able to take that kind of punishment. Even portable HDs just aren't all that durable.

Personally, I think flash storage may be the best way to store portable data in all formats, if the price can ever get low enough.

Re:Really, what's the use?

[bilbravo]

6mm on each side? Really?

Re:Really, what's the use?

[cozziewozzie]

DVDs are way more sensitive to damage than CDs, which were not that robust in the first place. It seems to me that every new optical format will be progressively more sensitive to scratches and other kinds of surface damage/warping. 1. Make a sensitive product
2. Make backing up your movies/music/data illegal
3. Wait for the first scratch
4. ...
5. You have to buy that Disney movie your kids love so much over and over again.

It's a crappy business plan, IMHO, but it seems to be headed in that direction.

Re:Really, what's the use?

[muzicman]

I prefer 9mm.... Wait that is a different type of hardware.

Note to Hillary and Toshiba

[SputnikPanic]

It's over. Move on.

Re:Note to Hillary and Toshiba

[Anonymous Coward]

You do realize that Move On was formed to keep Clinton in power, right? Well, really it was founded to close the Clinton impeachment trial. They proposed a plan to congressional censor the President, and 'move on' with the country's business. Really it represented the first liberal response to the permanent campaign tactics, which the Republican party adapted in the 90's.

About time

[Erich]

You can easily fit HD video on DVD media using H.264 compression. The only reason you need the storage of HD-DVD or Blu-Ray is if you:

1. Want to force customers to buy new, expensive players instead of minor DSP/Firmware upgrades to existing player designs
2. Want to force customers to have a difficult time making their own HD media because Blu-Ray writable media and burners are too expensive.
3. Believe that by making the size larger that pirates can't figure out how to transcode to a smaller formant before posting on the internet (and that 30G images are too big to download)
4. Want to be able to ship many movies on a single disc... but that doesn't seem to be happening

The companies could have come up with a new format using better compression. Players would be marginally more expensive because of increased decode processing, but in general I think you'd see $30 DVD players become $35 DVD/HD players very fast because of the very marginal increase in capabilities needed.

Oh well.

Re:About time

[stormguard2099]

Great points. People are drawn to the latest and greatest of technology but I think Blu-ray is just a bit too expensive to take advantage of this. The leap is just too far to justify it in the minds of most people. I think an increase in quality for a slight increase in price might be able to hit a sweet spot that more consumers would be willing to go for that otherwise would just stick with standard dvds.

Re:About time

[Anonymous Coward]

You can easily fit HD video on DVD media using H.264 compression. The only reason you need the storage of HD-DVD or Blu-Ray is if you:

1) Want to include a higher bitrate encoding so that banding/compression artifacts are kept to a minimum
2) Want to include lossless audio

I've downloaded several movies that have been recompressed to DVD5/DVD9, and though they look pretty good, they still exhibit signs that they've been recompressed. In many cases, they're better than what you'd get via HD cable or satellite, but compared to the original HD disc source (be it HDDVD or BD), they don't hold a candle.

Re:About time

[Silverlancer]

Blu-ray discs already *use* H.264 (usually; some use VC-1). They just use absurdly high bitrates to compensate (partially) for the fact that the encoders they use are extremely inefficient.

Re:About time

[evilviper]

You can easily fit HD video on DVD media using H.264 compression.

You can easily fit ANY resolution video, on ANY sized media, using ANY lossy codec. You can have HD video on a floppy disk using MPEG-1.

With lossy codecs, the lower the bitrate, the more visual information will be discarded (quantized) to make it fit the available bitrate. There's no magic that will wipe away the 5X increase in storage size that Blu-ray has over DVD. Highdef on DVD will simply look less detailed (more smooth), with the appearance of more compression artifacts like color banding.

Re:About time

[terjeber]

You can easily fit HD video on DVD media using H.264 compression

Bzzzt! Wrong! Of course you can't. You don't need 25 or 50G to encode, but you can not encode an HD movie onto a standard DVD with any known or theoretically envisioned codec. 90 minutes of video encoded at 15Mb/s would not fit on a dual layer DVD and 15Mb/s would yield a very poor quality HD result. Good quality HD requires 20-25Mb/s bitrate, which would require media storing 15G or more.

The companies could have come up with a new format using better compression

Please enlighten us oh-wise-one, what encoders would that be, and how would they encode three times better than H.264 or VC-1? Also, if they existed, how would players decode them in real time without adding massively more expensive hardware to the mix?

Re:About time

[jedidiah]

Bullocks yourself.

Even an MPEG2 movie at 480 looks fairly spectacular on a large screen. The key difference
here is that you are getting a pristine version of a movie that's been mastered by a pro
and not just some quick hack thrown together with a few default options from some bit of
consumer grade desktop software.

h264 mastered onto a dual layer DVD by the studio would impress all but the most obstinate snob.

Re:About time

[halcyon1234]

Want to be able to ship many movies on a single disc... but that doesn't seem to be happening

Yeah, that's not ever happening until there's some serious housecleaning in the marketing department.

Masters of Horror was a series that was 13 1-hour episodes. Each episode was a different anthology-esque tale told by a different horror movie director. Because it was so diverse, not every fan liked the same episodes. But they liked the series overall. The 13th episode was ultra violent, and was either never aired (or heavily censored), creating a huge demand for that episode

The market is primed to release the season on DVD, including the "banned" episode. The fans had pretty much unanimously said that they'd buy it for that episode, plus their two or three "favorite" episodes, and to have the entire season.

Instead, marketing splits it up into single or double episode DVDs, pricing them at over $20 each. And they don't release the "banned" episode (or only release it censored

Fans DON'T buy the DVD, and make their motives clear. They'd have to buy 2-3 discs for $60 just to get the episodes they really want. They were expecting to spend $40-$55 on an entire season of 13 episodes, inline with other shows. The episode they really wanted isn't available. The DVD sales are dismal, and you can find the series in the 2/$5 at most video stores

Here comes the victor in the HD wars. BlueRay. Alright, let's get these movie-quality episodes out in HD. There's still a huge demand for it, after all.

What happens? Season 1 is released in FOUR VOLUMES! 3 episodes per disc, and close to $40 each. And they're again split up in such a way that most fans would have to buy 2 or 3 of them to get all their wanted episodes.

Even putting aside the insanity of releasing in parts when it epic-failed before-- they're putting less than 3 hours of SD quality footage on one high-capacity disc. You can practically HEAR the empty, wasted space. The entire season would have fit handsomely on one or two BlueRay discs, which could have been sold in a single package to the hungry fans. But it didn't happen. The series will go unbought-- and there's 2-3 times as much wasted packaging and plastic hanging around.

So until marketing execs can be convinced that "Season 1 vol 1" is a bankruptable offense, getting "Hellraiser: The Complete Collection" on a single BlueRay ain't happening.

Is this the same thing..?

[Kokuyo]

I didn't read TFA, but since heise.de just brought an anouncement that Toshiba is planning to kill Blu-Ray by introducing a normal DVD player with enhanced upscaling... Is this the same thing or are they betting on two horses?

The heise article is here: http://www.heise.de/newsticker/Toshiba-setzt-Kampf-gegen-Blu-ray-Disc-mit-einem-DVD-Player-fort--/meldung/108830

Re:Is this the same thing..?

[Zelos]

Enhanced upscaling? Is that going to be like in Hollywood movies where they press someone says "Enhance" and the techie guy magically turns a blurry 640x480 CCTV shot into a perfect 20 Megapixel image?

Re:Is this the same thing..?

[bloodninja]

The interpolation (or however it is called) in the Enhanced Zoom plugin for Compiz almost seems like that 'enhance' technology of the movies. Try it and see how clear 480x640 pictures can be when they fill up a 1680x1050 monitor. I'd really like to know how that works, and being open source, anybody who understands that stuff can.

Bittorrent Before Blue-Ray!

[N8F8]

It's as simple as that. I'll steal content via Bittorrent before I give a penny to Sony. I have a pretty huge DVD collection and was starting to buy HD-DVD. But I REFUSE to pay Sony for their anti-competitive practices and consumer-unfriendly products.

Re:Bittorrent Before Blue-Ray!

[db32]

You do realize that you probably just signed yourself up for some hate from the Sony Fanclub? I really liked the PS1 and PS2, but Sony seems to be back to inspecting their own colon again. Beta, Minidisk, MemoryStickDuo, and now BluRay. It's like these assholes can't get enough of themselves. Not to mention my Sony fanboy friend has a Sony digital camera on top of all his other Sony shit and that piece of crap that uses some strange video codec. I have been able to play videos off of that damned camera without headache on ONE computer out of 6 so far. Most don't have the codecs and even the "just works" Windows installs fail on finding the appropriate codec most of the time. All of this coupled with their dealings with the RIAA lawsuit mess. Oh and the PS3 flops of "oh well our stuff is so sensitive we can't make the controller vibrate cuz 6 axis is too good" when the real story was "lawsuits are kicking us in the balls and we can't do it without getting in trouble...so all of you need to forget the fact that the Wii can do everything we can't in a controller and believe our stupid lines about why it won't work". Sony really needs to pull their heads out of their collective ass and get with the program.

Personally, I still want my money for that stupid ass claim about "if you can find a PS3 on the shelves we will pay you!" In the mean time, years later and I am still having a damned hard time finding the latest Wii accessory and I am apparently some kind of luck God for just walking into a Gamestop and buying a Wii because they are STILL perpetually sold out.

Re:Bittorrent Before Blue-Ray!

[^_^x]

Irrational memes are annoying.

Poor HD-DVD, the plucky young open format backed by no particular company, its ambitions quashed by big bad Sony and their campaign to make every format unique and proprietary!

They're both proprietary formats because they're new, commercial, and DRMed. At one time CD was quite inaccessible unless you had rare expensive hardware to author them. DVD went through this too. Never mind little details like HD-DVD being pushed by Toshiba through things like bribing movie studios... or that the Blu-Ray Disc Association has 18 member companies and 66 contributors and even from its inception was formed of nine companies. It's those bullies Sony (Matsushita, Pioneer, Philips, Thomson, LG, Hitachi, Sharp, and Samsung) making a format that no one else can read. After all, the only Blu-Ray players are made by Sony, right? Oh, they're not...

Sony Sixaxis PR? Yeah, total BS like most of what they'd said about gaming the last few years... they need to fix that. Seems a bit better now but I still can't trust them easily.

Also just wondering what kind of camera your friend has? My DSC-P150 does JPEG and MPEG, though I used to have a Kodak that did FlashPix...

But hey, I must be a Sony fanboy because I'm not a Toshiba fanboy spewing hate for Sony, right? That kind of thin rationalization usually goes hand in hand with the "it's another proprietary Sony format!" argument. Toshiba working with most of the founders of Blu-Ray backed DVD when it came out and they weren't the villains simply because the technical working group demanded a single format be released and the consumers' only choice was DVD or VHS. I think most people were just mad that they were made to choose and couldn't wait for a winner before buying either.

Re:Bittorrent Before Blue-Ray!

[popeye44]

Now I'll preface this by saying first and foremost. I paid 325.00 for my PS3 with 7 games and 3 controllers. I did not pay Sony directly.
I'm pretty much like most of Slashdot and I am typically disgusted by Sony.
However as you can see below it's a nice machine.
I have dvd9 disks burnt with BDMV format and they work. "and look excellent on 1080i/720p"
I have it running Linux. Yellowdog or Ubuntu either one work good. "as far as my limited Linux experience goes.. hehe"
I have it streaming WMV, XVID and DIVX it will stream mpeg4 or H.264 too "from inside the ps3 OS not from Linux!" Not that Linux cannot.. I'm just stupid in Linux...
I can add a larger drive.
A rumor says I can rip a bd-dvd using the DD command but I don't really have a big drive to work with just yet.
It's had two updates since i owned it and so far both seem to work great.

However for the price I paid I have blu-ray support. Streaming video over gigabit. Lots and LOTS of high def support including the fact it's a great upconverter.

I also own a HD-DVD. Sadly... It's a nice player and I own a few disks. But as a format it's dead :(

So I'm not a SONY fanboy but as far as systems go it's a hell of a nice package. For what I paid it's friggin outstanding. "gotta love Craigslist!"

Ohh yea.. and it plays games..

This was gonna happen

[Midnight Thunder]

While I didn't expect Toshiba to be the company to announce the next-next generation format (especially this soon), there are certainly other formats in the wings. The future formats are based on 'holographic memory', with the 'Holographic Versatile Disc (HVD) being one of them. The HVD promises 3.9 TB of storage, but with a price tag of around $15000 for a drive and $180 for a disk, this puts it clearly in range of companies with the needs and the money.

Myself I am just sitting waiting for affordable rewritable versions (this include Blu-Ray) to become available for PCs.

RTFA - I know, I'm wierd....

[Anonymous Coward]

But I actually read the article.

Its just a DVD player with built in upscaling capabilities.

See where it says

"One Japanese report appeared to suggest that the new technology would be able produce much higher-resolution images from existing DVDs, but did not address the apparent impossibility of this claim.

The modified DVD format relies on a newly-developed large scale integrated circuit chip to rapidly convert the stored video, but no technical details were released."

Not a new format, just HD-DVD/Blu-Ray resolution output

Basically doing in the DVD Player what many TV's do internally.

Optical discs?

[Vlobulle]

I don't care anymore, SSD will probably become cheaper than Blu-Ray in a few years.

TFA misses the point

[Anonymous Coward]

It's actually about DVD players with better upscalers. There is no new format or anything like that.

Upscaling DVD player, not a new format

[68kmac]

According to heise.de (German only, sorry), Toshiba will release a DVD player equipped with a Cell processor that will upscale the DVD content. That article only talks of "DVD" all the time, there's no mention of a new format.

New name picked for high def disc format

[192939495969798999]

I hear that the new format will be called High-Definition DVD, or HD-DVD, and it will be major competition for blu-ray. At stores, you'll see them both right next to each other on the shelves, confusing consumers until some point when one of the two formats goes away.... er wait, what?

Well, I guess this is one way to do DRM

[moxley]

Well, I guess this is one way to do DRM - Just release a shitty new standard every year and watch it fail. After aother year headly anyone will be able to play the stuff, let alone take the time to track down tools to decode it.

everyone is reading the press release wrong

[circletimessquare]

toshiba is indeed creating a new DVD player, yes, this is true. and indeed, the DVD player they are making will not be blu-ray... it will be x-ray, a decepticon character for the upcoming transformers 2 movie. its gimmicky product placement

so everyone calm down, this is merely a movie technology villain, not a villain of movie technology. i mean yes, it is a technology villain from a movie, not a villainous movie tech, i mean... oh forget it

maybe not

[poetmatt]

Wasn't china working on their own High Def format?

Toshiba's name is not absent this list, so I'm guessing this is the same format.

Re:maybe not

[evilviper]

China starts lots of projects like this. They serve only to demonstrate to the world how advanced China is, and how they don't need the rest of the world. They spend tons of money to develop far inferior (but domestically developed!) alternatives to easily and cheaply available western technology. It never goes anywhere.

Their EVD (IIRC) format comes to mind. It was based on incompatible use of DVD tech to give a trivial capacity boost, and the (terribly poor performing yet lower quality than MPEG-2) AVS video codec it used. Considering that JPEG is ancient and patent-free tech, and independently re-implementing inter-frame compression is so simple I could do a halfway decent job of it myself in a week, I'm stunned by how little China has achieved despite how much money they have spent. Large retailers in their own country defy the government mandate to carry them, because demand in nil, and the higher performance and non-standard decoding hardware required is far more expensive.

I guess I'd better end this rant here...

Re:maybe not

[cozziewozzie]

China starts lots of projects like this. They serve only to demonstrate to the world how advanced China is, and how they don't need the rest of the world. They spend tons of money to develop far inferior (but domestically developed!) alternatives to easily and cheaply available western technology. It never goes anywhere. Japan started by making inferior knockoffs of Western products, then Taiwan and Korea followed, and they are all high-tech superpowers.

There are advantages to fostering domestic high-tech development, as you need a lot of experience to play with the big boys. They are educating and employing an army of young scientists end engineer who would otherwise fuck off to the US, Japan and Germany and work for the high-tech companies there. It's a loss in the short-term, but it is the only way to develop a homebrewed high-tech industry.

You can't expect a Chinese company to catch up with a century of experience that companies like Ford, GM, Toshiba, Matsushita, etc. have. But if you don't try and tread the same path yourself, you will forever be dependent on foreign imports.

Re:maybe not

[gad_zuki!]

Theres a different between a knock-off that can potentially be sold at market and a propaganda tech "win."

So how's the Dragon PC w/ the People's Linux coming along?

Re:maybe not

[cozziewozzie]

Tell that to Sony, with their long line of tech wins which failed in the market.

You can make cheap knockoffs forever, or you can try to take initiative and do R&D. Sometimes it will work, a lot of the times, it will turn out to be rubbish, especially when you're just starting in the industry.

So how's the Dragon PC w/ the People's Linux coming along? I don't know, but Lenovo PCs running QQ are all the rage in China. You know, QQ, that tech "win". They should have just used skype. Or purchased from Dell.

The news site is down...

[cryptodan]

I guess the site which this article is about is inaccessible. Maybe the Blu-Ray people are DDoSing it?

If only FVD got more backing

[Anonymous Coward]

Back during the planning, there was a third contender backed by the taiwanese gov't: FVD. It used the plain old red laser and snazzy compression to squeeze 135 minutes of 720p into a double layer disc, which conveniently evaded many DVD patents. It is a shame that the 360 did not use it instead of plain old DVD, we could have cheap FVD players by now :(

Alternately...

[Moraelin]

Player prices have dropped? Maybe your stronger Euro is misleading you, but there have been no price drops.

Alternately, all you're seeing is the effects of your Dollar's free fall.

Look, if it were just the Euro getting strong, it would be just the Euro getting strong. The fact is that the Canadian dollar is now worth a little more than 1 US Dollar, and has been for a while. Up from a little over 60 US cents, back in early 2000's. Even an Australian Dollar is slowly aproaching parity with the USD. Up from 47 US cents in 2001. Etc.

I don't think the strength of the Euro plays that much influence in those economies.

So basically I'm just saying that if the whole rest of the world seems to be going upwards fast, it isn't. It's you going downwards.

And with or without HD-DVD competition, you'd still have a dollar in freefall. It drives all import prices up over time.

Re:Alternately...

[ergo98]

Alternately, all you're seeing is the effects of your Dollar's free fall.

I'm Canadian. Our dollar has appreciated some 40% against the greenback in the past year. Old problem is that Blu-ray prices have increased in lockstep.

I don't get it

[Charcharodon]

They should have just come out with a format of 720p instead of getting into a pissing contest over 1080p. I would have been cheaper to develop for, and for the customer to upgrade to. Hell most 720p movies would have probably easily fit on a DVD (or two, or five for LotR director's cut) once you dumped all the pointles extras that noone watches more than once.

You're average home theater customer would have been thrilled and it all would have stuck with the planned obsolescence in five/ten years to sell us 1080p

Care to back up those lies?

[SuperKendall]

Blu-ray players have gotten more expensive. In some cases, a lot more expensive

The PS3 has not got any more expensive.

The Sony BDP-S300 is not any more expensive.

You try to deceive by including the introduction of very expensive high-end Blu-Ray players from companies uncommitted before HD-DVD folded.

Blu-ray sales, paradoxically, have collapsed

Only if you think disc sales being lower from Christmas to the start of the year as an odd thing. In reality, Blu-Ray disc sales are now week to week generally about 9% of standard DVD sales and climbing. In anticipation of your next argument, Blu-Ray disc sales also long ago eclipsed online movie sales and growing more rapidly than that segment.

High definition media gets almost no attention

From who? Consumers are buying HD-TV's in droves. PS3 sales are up, along with Blu-Ray media sales. You may not care, but you are simply sticking your head in the sand to absorb the tears from the loss of your dear HD-DVD.

Retailers that used to push both Blu-ray and HD-DVD now push....nothing. I find it hard even finding a single Blu-ray player for sale.

Unless you go into Best Buy, Wal-Mart, Target, etc. Now you are just a parody of yourself as anyone with even a sliver of shopping experience has seen Blu-Ray discs and players in big box stores.

Former HD-DVD supporters are so pathetically transparent...

I myself only got a Blu-Ray player at the beginning of the year, and have but a few discs - I have no great commitment to the format myself but can realize it's the next video format, just as it was easy to do before the war even started because of studio support.

However as marginal my own interest in the format may be, I cannot let complete fabrications by those who would damage the whole HD media market with outright slander and fabrications go unchecked. As a movie lover I would prefer the HD media market remain healthy so we get more good quality transfers. If you loved movies yourself you would abate your attacks which cause only harm, and for what - revenge on Sony? So not worth your time.

MIcrosoft and Apple have it right...

[lilfields]

I don't know why Toshiba would chase this medium, it will be dead much faster than DVD...the next medium is obviously digital downloads and as of now I'd say that Microsoft and Apple both have this market close at heart right now...between iTunes and the Live Marketplace. Once we get a larger proportion of high speed internet coverage (which will probably be a result of wireless coverage [ie Google? Verizon, AT&T]) The biggest beneficiaries of this will be Microsoft and DivX, because of their compression technologies...on the hardware side, Level 3 Communications and anyone with dark fiber will benefit. Sony and Toshiba are chasing an already doomed market...if I were Toshiba I would reevaluate my position and look towards making set-top boxes for such an adaption. If anyone wonders why Microsoft hasn't pushed Blu-Ray into their Xbox line, look no further than the Live marketplace. I'd expect in the next 5 years, HD for downloads will be as common as downloading from iTunes...Blu-Ray? More like Apple TV, TiVo or Xbox.

To anyone who says that we still need a portable medium for market laggards (example: Grandparents)(other portable mediums will probably be flash based/iPod, Zune), I'd expect they'd still be buying DVDs, that market isn't going to die anytime soon...I doubt they will be upgrading to Blu-Ray

Then buy some other brand

[SuperKendall]

Blu-Ray, unlike HD-DVD, was never a one-company pony. Buy a Samsung Player if you are unable to separate your irrational hatred from practical buying decisions.

Are Japanese schools getting worse?

[supabeast!]

Weren't these guys supposed to commit suicide or at least demoted and moved to a windowless office after HD-DVD? Are the standards slipping at Japanese schools resulting in businessmen who keep on trucking after dishonoring themselves?

Re:I call BS

[Enderandrew]

Really, there is a flea market where you can buy an XBox 360, PS3 and Wii all modded to play cracked games?

Please let me know where, because I smell BS as well.

Almost everyone I have ever met in my life has pirated something on a computer. I don't a single person with a hacked console (aside from myself, and I did it more as a hobby).