Slashdot Mirror


A5: All Apple, Part Mystery

PabloSandoval48 submitted a fairly lengthy story running on the EE Times about the A5 processor that powers the iPad 2. The story talks a bit about the A4 and A5, the IP issues surrounding the chip, and more. The real question now is what comes next.

87 of 124 comments (clear)

  1. What comes next by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    The A6?

    1. Re:What comes next by goombah99 · · Score: 2

      A6? you cant get rock hard abs in 6 minutes. it's 7 minute abs.

      --
      Some drink at the fountain of knowledge. Others just gargle.
    2. Re:What comes next by Reverand+Dave · · Score: 1

      Step into my office.

      --
      I got here through a series of tubes
    3. Re:What comes next by jd · · Score: 1

      Don't see ab excercises on the list.

      --
      It's a small world and it smells funny; I'd buy another if it wasn't for the money; Take back what I paid (SoM)
    4. Re:What comes next by ailnlv · · Score: 1

      that's what she said

    5. Re:What comes next by master5o1 · · Score: 1

      And what comes next? Hey Bust-A-Move!

      --
      signature is pants
  2. Wild Guess... by MarcQuadra · · Score: 5, Funny

    The real question now is what comes next.

    Here's a hint: It will be faster, and it will probably be called 'A6'. Just a guess.

    --
    "Sometimes, I think Trent just needs a cup of hot chocolate and a blankie." -Tori Amos on Nine Inch Nails
    1. Re:Wild Guess... by rjstanford · · Score: 2

      Or possibly the A5.1, OSX being what it is.

      --
      You're special forces then? That's great! I just love your olympics!
    2. Re:Wild Guess... by MarcQuadra · · Score: 1

      2012: "Powered by the new Apple Rattlesnake chip!"

      2014: "Powered by the new Apple Cobra chip!"

      2016: "Powered by the new Apple Water Moccasin chip!"

      --
      "Sometimes, I think Trent just needs a cup of hot chocolate and a blankie." -Tori Amos on Nine Inch Nails
    3. Re:Wild Guess... by rcamans · · Score: 1

      Or possibly the A.pple

      --
      wake up and hold your nose
    4. Re:Wild Guess... by treeves · · Score: 1

      ...The new Apple Black Mamba chip, or BM chip for short.

      --
      ...the future crusty old bastards are already drinking the Kool-Aid.
  3. The real question now is what comes next. by wiredog · · Score: 2

    The A6 Quattro?

    1. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by M4n · · Score: 1

      The A6-3D Quad Core Infinichip

      --
      In space no-one can hear your vuvuzela.
    2. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by MikeDirnt69 · · Score: 1

      Sounds much more interesting for me!

      --
      Am I eval()? - http://www.monst3r.com.br
    3. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by bhcompy · · Score: 2

      A6 Intruder.

    4. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by imadoofus · · Score: 1

      A5 Championship Edition?

      --
      "pr0n": An anagram of "porn," possibly indicating the use of pornography. - www.microsoft.com
    5. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by Pax681 · · Score: 1

      the A6 Quad Core Walled Garden - Higher Wall Edition

    6. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by M4n · · Score: 1

      Locked Gate edition

      --
      In space no-one can hear your vuvuzela.
    7. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by RockoTDF · · Score: 1

      Followed by the A7 Corsair.

      --
      There is more to science than physics!

      www.iomalfunction.blogspot.com
    8. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by Duradin · · Score: 2

      Can't wait for the A10 in that case. I wonder what the DU will cost in the app store.

    9. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by JesseDegenerate · · Score: 1

      you must mean the android version, right?

    10. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by PixetaledPikachu · · Score: 1

      A5 Championship Edition?

      with 3 new features that are basically a palette swap of one of the first chip's feature

    11. Re:The real question now is what comes next. by Paul1969 · · Score: 1

      Can't wait for the A10 in that case.

      Warthog love!

  4. Awful article by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    The authors of the article and the editor who approved it should be ashamed of themselves. Five pages saying exactly nothing.

    1. Re:Awful article by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      If I had mod points I'd vote you up in a second. That was one of the worst written things I've ever tried to read.

    2. Re:Awful article by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Ah, ah, ah. Not five pages saying exactly nothing. Five pages of saying exactly nothing about Apple. This makes it far more important and trendy than all the other pages of nothing in the world.

    3. Re:Awful article by oldhack · · Score: 1

      Mod the parent up - I ran out of mod points.

      That was five minutes of my life I'll never get back.

      --
      Fuck systemd. Fuck Redhat. Fuck Soylent, too. Wait, scratch the last one.
    4. Re:Awful article by thsths · · Score: 1

      > Five pages saying exactly nothing.

      True. But if I also block CmdrTaco, there will not be anything left to read on Slashdot...

      And to be fair, usually his stories are at least worth looking at.

    5. Re:Awful article by cfriedt · · Score: 1

      that's exactly what I thought.

    6. Re:Awful article by EraserMouseMan · · Score: 1

      Exactly. I was expecting to see a comparison between the A5 and the ARM A9. That would be an worthwhile comparison.

    7. Re:Awful article by MobileTatsu-NJG · · Score: 2

      The authors of the article and the editor who approved it should be ashamed of themselves. Five pages saying exactly nothing.

      They did very little work and generated lots of ad views. They should be pumping their fists in the air with the Final Fantasy victory tune playing.

      --

      "I like to lick butts!" by MobileTatsu-NJG (#32700246) (Score:5, Informative)

    8. Re:Awful article by hitmark · · Score: 1

      The thing about ARM based chips is that unless we are talking Qualcomm or Marvell there is effectively zero difference. That is, as long as one is only looking at the cpu. The difference happens in that they are more often then not SoCs, and so have not just the cpu, but also the gpu and the chipset on the same physical chip. The differences between the products will be in the gpu and chipset features, and how they are interconnected (driving Torvalds up the wall in the process).

      --
      comment first, facts later. http://chem.tufts.edu/AnswersInScience/RelativityofWrong.htm
  5. And after that? by Lunaritian · · Score: 5, Interesting

    "The A[3+n] processor will be included in Apple iPad [n], which will be released in [2009+n]."

    I just saved you the trouble of thinking

    1. Re:And after that? by O('_')O_Bush · · Score: 5, Funny

      "When n is an integer greater than 0"

      Patched for accuracy.

      --
      while(1) attack(People.Sandy);
    2. Re:And after that? by Lunaritian · · Score: 1

      Oh, by the way, could someone create a clever Perl script which produces an endless stream of news from this? Bonus points if you can make it look like the Apple logo.

    3. Re:And after that? by UnknowingFool · · Score: 2

      "Only for very large values of 0"

      We apologize. The persons responsible for patching have been patched.

      --
      Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
  6. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by DanTheStone · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It's not the advertisements that tend to make people link to the print version, it's when they spread the article out over several pages. I don't mind advertisements at all, but I hate the online equivalent of turning to several different newspaper pages to finish a single article.

  7. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by MightyYar · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I might side with you if there were any content. The article consisted of some micrographs and a lot of "duh" speculation. I came away with very little new information. It took them a huge block of text to tell me that they don't know what 60% of the chip does.

    --
    W..w..W - Willy Waterloo washes Warren Wiggins who is washing Waldo Woo.
  8. Knowing apple.... by Lumpy · · Score: 3, Insightful

    In about 2 years a new line of Desktops and laptops will be announced that used the new A10 processor, this processor will be used to get rid of all those ooky older intel based devices by having the new OS not compatible with it. Thus purging the world of the old product forcibly. Just like how those disgusting old G5 quad core towers still linger about now...

    Using old hardware makes Jobs angry.... you wont like him when he's angry....

    --
    Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    1. Re:Knowing apple.... by grub · · Score: 2


      Apple would be cutting its own throat to move the Mac line to non-Intel chips.

      They could include a simulator/emulator much like how Xcode already has. Or embed an A-whatever chip on the boards as a secondary processor for that type of thing.

      --
      Trolling is a art,
    2. Re:Knowing apple.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

      You're not "nerds," just idiots. And those come in all sorts of varieties,

    3. Re:Knowing apple.... by UnknowingFool · · Score: 4, Insightful

      The move to Intel was more for logistical reasons as opposed to a dick move to screw people. At the time both Motorola and IBM had problems supplying Apple with enough CPUs. Despite being a big name customer, Apple was really a small customer (in terms of volume) ordering a custom part for both companies. No one wants to carry excess inventory so when Apple kept ordering more chips the two companies had trouble keeping up. By switching to Intel, the supply of chips would be more reliable because the part was now a stock part. If Apple upped their forecasts and didn't end up buying chips, Intel could sell to one of their other customers.

      --
      Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
    4. Re:Knowing apple.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Reminds me of the days when I used to do things like that. I was eleven. I gave myself so many laughs!

    5. Re:Knowing apple.... by ceoyoyo · · Score: 2

      Yeah, Windows 7 won't run on my 486 either. Wah.

    6. Re:Knowing apple.... by JonJ · · Score: 2

      We were walking in the mall in Orland Park, IL so just for fun we go into the apple store and change the back grounds on about half a dozen laptops to the microsoft logo, and the homepages to microsoft.com. Yes we are all nerds.

      Fuck you, you're not nerds. Astroturfers and stupid MS-fanboys maybe, but you're not nerds. Go buy yourself a decent operating system.

      --
      -- Linux user #369862
    7. Re:Knowing apple.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      I thought it had to do with the fact that IBM etal couldn't build a low power version of the G5 that wouldn't melt a laptop. Leaving the Powerbook woefully underpowered compared to competing windows machines.

    8. Re:Knowing apple.... by painandgreed · · Score: 1

      That and that they wanted Apple to take on more and more of the cost of developing new chips which were already lagging behind the x86 ones.Not enough parts. Not enough quality in the parts they were getting. Increasing costs with diminishing returns. They all added up to switching to the same chips that everybody else was using and went from a small customer using custom chips to the largest customer they had in a large market.

    9. Re:Knowing apple.... by UnknowingFool · · Score: 1

      Mobile chip performance was another reason but the underlying cause was the same. IBM could have competed with Intel on mobile if they were willing to put on time, effort, and money. The main reason they didn't was all of that R&D would be for one customer and a custom part. It wasn't as if IBM could have used that technology for many other customers.

      --
      Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
    10. Re:Knowing apple.... by Relayman · · Score: 1

      Not couldn't but wouldn't.

      --
      If I used a sig over again, would anyone notice?
    11. Re:Knowing apple.... by mjwx · · Score: 1

      That and that they wanted Apple to take on more and more of the cost of developing new chips which were already lagging behind the x86 ones.Not enough parts. Not enough quality in the parts they were getting. Increasing costs with diminishing returns.

      In other words. No money in it for IBM.

      Meanwhile, IBM had secured the contracts to build the processors for the Wii, Xbox360 and PS3. Apple became a very small fish.

      --
      Calling someone a "hater" only means you can not rationally rebut their argument.
    12. Re:Knowing apple.... by nobodie · · Score: 1

      MMM, the IBM part is a little off as I heard it: IBM made the P6, it rocked. But they had a number of customers for it, Sony, Nintendo, even MS as well as Apple. The talks with Apple broke down over how much IBM had to change it so that they could "sell" the whole chip to apple (including the IP) and then still sell the "P6" chip to other companies as well. Apple just wanted to own the whole thing, they didn't want to pay for the complete development of course. The final decision involved accepting the Intel chip, a cheaper price and giving up control of the IP. The core 2 chip couldn't touch the P6 (which runs your PS3 and most of the IBM supercomputers) but Apple never really cared about that aspect of it. The only advantage for them would be that they could slow it down for temp control and therefore not have noisy fans running in their stuff, which was a Jobs thing. They accepted the core 2, slowed it down and still, using hardware control of the HDD and other peripherals, manged to keep things at an acceptable speed. I'm sure most of you guys know that the Apple intel kit is not that fast and has fallen behind at about the same rate as other intel stuff: as opposed to the older ppc macs that kept up or ahead of intel for a few years after purchase.

      --
      Subversion of spatial scale luxury decoration ideas.
    13. Re:Knowing apple.... by UnknowingFool · · Score: 1

      Look at this from IBM's perspective. The problem isn't a matter of ability. It was a matter of priority. Apple was always going to be a small customer compared to MS and Sony. They might order at most 3 million chips for their desktops a year while Sony and MS had far more potential sales reaching into the tens of millions a year. And every year, Apple was going to want changes and upgrades to the chip while the Xbox and PS3 processor hasn't really changed. Instead IBM could focus efforts on moving to a smaller resolution going from 65nm to 45nm to save costs.

      Now IBM could get more sales from Apple if they were willing sink a ton of money into R&D for a mobile G5. But after all that it would only be good for Apple as IBM couldn't really sell that chip to another customer as they don't have anyone else making PPC laptops for consumers. IBM itself doesn't make PPC desktops for consumers. They use PPC for workstations and servers which are willing to pay more per chip.

      Normally a fab like IBM does not have a dedicated line for one custom part like the G5. It probably was fabbed on the same line that makes their other PPC chips. IBM makes enough according to Apple's forecasts. Apple ups the forecasts. IBM has to rearrange their schedules to accommodate. They will try not to hurt delivery to their other customers which include internal IBM. But in the end, they can only do so much for a small customer.

      Also the Cell processor that Sony and MS uses is not a PPC chip strictly. It is based on Power but is a slightly different architecture. IBM might have had to create a separate line just for Cell processors. If Sony or MS upped their forecasts, IBM could be more accommodating as it wouldn't hurt any other customers.

      --
      Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
    14. Re:Knowing apple.... by worx101 · · Score: 1

      Oh they couldv'e had other customers, if they had pushed hard enough.

  9. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It's merely a well planted Apple advertisement. A5 is SO powerful, so amazing, that even if you're not impressed with iPad 2, you'd be silly to actually consider an alternative instead of waiting for A6.

    We've been seeing a lot of this stuff, lately. I wonder why Apple's so worried that their zombie masses will snap out of it.

  10. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by vlm · · Score: 1

    I might side with you if there were any content. The article consisted of some micrographs and a lot of "duh" speculation. I came away with very little new information. It took them a huge block of text to tell me that they don't know what 60% of the chip does.

    60%... dual core ... what an interesting ratio... build 5 cutting edge cores and as long as at least 2 of the cores pass testing, ship it...

    --
    "Science flies us to the moon. Religion flies us into buildings." - Victor Stenger
  11. TFA is pretty clueless. by teh31337one · · Score: 2

    There was however one recent article suggesting Apple implemented hardware video accelerators in the A4.

    The comment seemed almost too easy in light of the above discussion. If this is in fact true one might question whether this is somehow associated with Apple's stance on Flash for its iOS devices. However, such an accelerator would have been one of the digital blocks. Does this imply it was also present on the S5PC110?

    Yes, Samsung do have hardware video accelerators in their hummingbird processor. It supports mpeg4, H.264, H.263, Sorenson codec, DivX HD/ XviD, VC-1 and the video formats 3GP (MPEG-4), WMV (Advanced Systems Format), AVI (divx), MKV and FLV.

    1. Re:TFA is pretty clueless. by failedlogic · · Score: 1

      Well, of course you need HW video accelerators in both CPUs and GPUs. Thanks for pointing out the obvious.

      What people might not realize however is that this is the only way to Fast Forward video in digital format. VHS and Beta were easier since it was a mechanical process. The HW acceleration concept has yet to prove how they manage rewind. If I think back to my physics classes a negative HW accelerator would work but this would prove difficult to implement and doesn't sound like a value added feature people will pay for or add silicon on the HW. I'm particularly upset that when I try to rewind or fast forward Back to the Future ... Kernel Panic!

  12. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by antime · · Score: 1

    Why would I want to support content-free filler like that?

  13. Re:Graphics Performance by teh31337one · · Score: 1

    A5 uses the PowerVR SGX543 GPU. The graphics performance is pretty decent (much improved over the PowerVR SGX535 used in iPhone 3gs and A4 SoC), and easily bests the Tegra 2. But that's because Tegra 2 is an old chip now, while 543 is a new chip. Apple don't have exclusivity on the chip, heck, a quad core 543 is used in NGP.

    A5 is top of the GPU performance heap for now, but it will be bested by newer chips.

  14. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by XxtraLarGe · · Score: 1

    There are plugins that will take care of that for you. Safari has a "reader" button by default that loads all the pages of an article into a single view.

    Safari's reader feature is great, when it works--and it does with this article. Often times, it will only load the first page, or omit graphics, which makes it a little unreliable. Still, I always try reader first before hitting the print version.

    --
    Taking guns away from the 99% gives the 1% 100% of the power.
  15. Bored by Tigger's+Pet · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I've been a /. reader for over 8 years now and have noticed the change in the type of story discussed here. I keep seeing people saying things like "Why are we talking about FB - this is suppsed to be a techie site and we should discuss techie things". I tend to find myself agreeing with them most of the time.
    Then a story like this comes along - which should be "manna from heaven" for Nerds and Geeks and I try to read TFA - only to find myself yawning and giving up coz it's dry, tedious and badly written.
    I can't even win in an argument with myself anymore - must be a sign that I'm getting old.

  16. Apple's New Plant in Brazil by ColeonyxOnline · · Score: 1

    Apple opens up a new plant in Brazil. Production could start as early as November. Perhaps then, we could see the new IPad 3.

    Source:
    Report: Apple Part Maker Foxconn to Open Brazil Plant

    1. Re:Apple's New Plant in Brazil by gnasher719 · · Score: 1

      Apple opens up a new plant in Brazil. Production could start as early as November. Perhaps then, we could see the new IPad 3.

      Your reading ability seems rather low. The report that you quote says "Apple Part Maker Foxconn to Open Brazil Plant". Foxconn, not Apple. On the other hand, if that is indeed the title of the report, then that is clueless as well. Foxconn doesn't make parts for Apple. Foxconn assembles complete devices.

    2. Re:Apple's New Plant in Brazil by UnknowingFool · · Score: 2

      I don't see Apple releasing an iPad 3 just 8 months after releasing the iPad 2. They might release an iPad 2 with more storage in time for the holidays as this would require changing one chip on the board, but not a whole new product. At the moment Apple and their suppliers seem to have enough problems manufacturing enough iPad 2s much less starting a whole new line.

      --
      Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
    3. Re:Apple's New Plant in Brazil by BitZtream · · Score: 2

      Foxconn doesn't make parts for Apple.

      No, Foxconn makes parts for A LOT of technology companies, not just Apple, and they also do some assembly of devices as well.

      I doubt you'll find a motherboard made that doesn't have Foxconn components on it like the back panel ports for instance are almost certainly Foxconn components regardless of who assembled your computer, yourself or Dell.

      --
      Persistent Volume manager for Kubernetes - https://github.com/dwimsey/openshift-pvmanager
  17. How fast? by DesScorp · · Score: 1

    Since Apple's products seem to be merging somewhat... OS X Lion will incorporate some of the features from the iPad and iPhone... how fast do they think these "A chips" will get? Will they eventually replace Intel chips in whatever passes for an iMac one day? Will we see the day when Apple makes most of the parts that goes into their products themselves, rather than subbing out major systems? Will the PowerPC fanboys that so loudly cried foul! when Apple "sold out" and went to Intel rejoice? Is an ARM-based chip "think different" enough from Intel for their liking?

    --
    Life is hard, and the world is cruel
  18. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by Dishevel · · Score: 2

    Or we will see site operators that do not fluff up a 1 paragraph story to 5 pages then spread those 5 pages out to present you with ads 5 times,
    Fuck the operator that does that. I hope their sites fail. That way the cream can rise to the top and the shit heads can starve.

    --
    Why is it so hard to only have politicians for a few years, then have them go away?
  19. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by Spaseboy · · Score: 1

    AutoPagerize http://autopagerize.net/ for Chrome, Safari and Firefox.

    --
    "I don't want more choice, I just want nicer things!"
    -Jennifer Saunders as Edina Monsoon
  20. Re:A lot of speculation, very little thinking by UnknowingFool · · Score: 3, Informative

    The battery is actually slightly bigger in terms of capacity. It is 25 kWh whereas the old one was 24.8 kWh. The battery appears much larger only because it is wider but it also is thinner than the old one. As for the A5, another thing Apple did is to make the cores variable speed. They run at a max of 1GHz but clock down depending on usage probably to conserve power.

    --
    Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
  21. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by JesseDegenerate · · Score: 1

    I hate people like you, everything is a conspiracy that apple made against humanity. Hitler was actually a iMac G4 prototype. And i know, apple killed your mother and ran over your dog. i'm so freaking over it. Just use what you like.

  22. Re:It's a JOKE! by alobar72 · · Score: 1

    What I find interesting about that, is that apple is blamed for not basically revolutionising the Market with every revision of their product. I never heard a reviewer blaming dell that a new product line of notebooks was just lighter, more powerful etc. I find that totally in order . The iPad 2 is a new revision of a well received product. That is totally normal. I think that everybody who expects a revolution from apple every single year has fallen more for the "apple fanboyism" the the so called fanboys :)

  23. Video acceleration by edxwelch · · Score: 1

    Not really. The article says that the extra blocks in the A5 will probably be for video acceleration

    1. Re:Video acceleration by mabhatter654 · · Score: 1

      That's where Apple has the "Magical" built in!

  24. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by Splab · · Score: 1

    Perhaps because Apple can't actually supply equipment for said masses - they need to keep them hungry while they figure out their supply chains.

  25. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by TheRaven64 · · Score: 3, Informative

    Not so much. The two ARM cores are pretty easy to identify on the chip, as are some of the other components. The rest is... something. No one cares enough to work out exactly what. Oh, and the two ARM cores are well under 40% of the total die size. The GPU takes up a reasonable amount of space, and then there are controllers for the various peripherals (network, audio, USB and so on), interrupt controllers, and so on.

    --
    I am TheRaven on Soylent News
  26. Re:Graphics Performance by baldass_newbie · · Score: 1

    A5 is top of the GPU performance heap for now, but it will be bested by newer chips.

    What are you basing this theory on?

    --
    The opposite of progress is congress
  27. Re:Graphics Performance by teh31337one · · Score: 1
  28. Apple will steal Ubuntu's marketing department? by denzacar · · Score: 1

    What ever for?

    --
    Mit der Dummheit kämpfen Götter selbst vergebens
  29. What's next? A tearful showdown... by BearRanger · · Score: 1

    Between A5 and its creator, Steve Jobs, who had to audacity to impress his own memory engrams on the new chip. Due to his ongoing "personal issues" the chip became unstable and slaughtered its opponents Motorola, Samsung, and RIMM. Jobs will remind A5 of how great they both are before playing dead and waiting for HP to join the fray...

    Jobs also made a point of sending his regards to Captain Dunsel. AKA Steve Ballmer.

  30. Re:A lot of speculation, very little thinking by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    The battery is actually slightly bigger in terms of capacity. It is 25 kWh whereas the old one was 24.8 kWh.

    Much as I'd like to live in a world with battery technology good enough to put a 25 kWh battery in something the size of an iPad, I suspect it's actually 25 Wh. :)

  31. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    I'm surprised you lack morals. Go steal candy from little children then instead of stealing impressions from webmasters. At least you can see the crying directly and understand the impact you are having.

    I always thought a sense of morality was ingrained. Between my down-moderation on this issue and your response, I realize now that in fact a sense of morality is something you must fight to keep in place, a fight some apparently gave up on long ago.

    At least what I got out of this is knowing I'm a damn sight better person than a lot of Slashdot posters and moderators.

    I mean, if I'm going to get modded down anyway I might as well speak truth to moral equivalence. Mod away, but you know in your heart something is wrong with re-formatting a site in a link you send to thousands of people.

    I think for instance the same thing when I see an XKCD or Oatmeal comic embedded in some other site displaying their own ads. There is no difference here. It is pulling a lot of data down from the server with zero monetary return from the site. I also think it's bullshit spreading out fluff content across several pages; In that case I wouldn't link to them. If I chose to do so I'd do the honorable thing and send viewers to the page the thing was on.

    You may have the last response; you'd only steal it for yourself anyway.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  32. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by blackpig · · Score: 1

    I bet you stay glued to the TV when the ads are on, right? That would be the ethical thing to do.

  33. Re:Graphics Performance by The+End+Of+Days · · Score: 1

    ...are you seriously in doubt or just being a dick?

  34. Re:To be fair, here is link with ads by Thing+1 · · Score: 1

    XKCD and Oatmeal can protect themselves if they want to with referrer magic. So, apparently, they welcome this use of their comics. And, getting a sense of morality out of an obligation towards advertisers? Please, consider re-thinking this moral stance.

    --
    I feel fantastic, and I'm still alive.
  35. Re:Let the people choose by Thing+1 · · Score: 1

    And with proper referrer magic, these stupid sites would not allow a print link from Slashdot. You're tilting at windmills, here.

    --
    I feel fantastic, and I'm still alive.
  36. Re:Let the people choose by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    The referrer magic is not in place; the linking to the print version actually happened. In what way is that "tilting at windmills" when the problem I point out actually exists?

    The phrase that comes to my mind as far as "referrer magic" is, closing the barn door after the horse is gone. The linking has been done, the traffic moved on.

    I hope Karma dishes out a nice reward to the entire Slashdot community that supported this action.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  37. Re:Let the people choose by Thing+1 · · Score: 1

    Yes, the horses from the past's articles have fled the barn. The site owners still have control over their site for future articles. Your wishing harm on others does not help your own "Karma"; but, of course, haters rarely look inwards.

    --
    I feel fantastic, and I'm still alive.