Is DIY Brainhacking Safe?
An anonymous reader writes "My colleague at IEEE Spectrum, Eliza Strickland, looked at the home transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) movement. People looking to boost creativity, or cure depression, are attaching electrodes to their heads using either DIT equipment or rigs from vendors like Foc.us. Advocates believe experimenting with the tech is safe, but a neuroscientist worries about removing the tech from lab safeguards..."
How long until the first Darwin Award is given to someone attempting this?
http://science.slashdot.org/st...
http://science.slashdot.org/st...
I deny that I have not avoided attaining the opposite of that which I do not want.
"People looking to boost creativity, or cure depression, are attaching electrodes to their heads using either DIT equipment or rigs from vendors like Foc.us."
If this tech can REALLY cure depression or boost creativity, then it is just as likely to cause depression or remove your creativity. I wouldn't take that chance with something as elementally "me" as my mind.
What could possibly go wrong?
Go ahead. Fry your brain. It's not like you're using it or anything. :(
I do not fail; I succeed at finding out what does not work.
- E. Venkman
Q.E.D.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...
No.
( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... )
Please help metamoderate.
then just jack in away.
Can we just legalize drugs instead? Most of them actually have a proven safety record, despite governmental claims (mdma, for example, is significantly less toxic than acetaminophen).
Redneck haircut
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...
"To those who are overly cautious, everything is impossible. "
what's next, self-lobotomy?
I think the quote is actually "that would have worked if you hadn't stopped me." - P. Venkman
- In Soviet Korea, only old people loose all their bases to Natalie Portman's petrified hot grits overlords.
I read on the internet that you can use an arc welder for this.
- Egon Spengler
(obligatory nod to the memory of Harold Ramis)
This post contains no rudeness or derision of any kind. All arguments are friendly. Terms and exclusions may apply.
Go for it.
Do you want to be a wirehead
Is it even possible for that to sound the least bit safe to any sane individual?
sssssCarrier lost
i ben hakin my bren its ben rely gude. i wuz werried fur a bit butt my lernins ben rely takkin off.
Look where all this talking got us, baby.
blah blah blah. It's a 9-volt battery. This is hardly the kind of thing that makes for a nightmare scenario where thousands of people around the country fry their brains.
Have you _seen_ the internet? There a hundred times more people who nail their scrotums to the chair as a hobby, and way more than that who run much more than 9-volts through their genitals.
I'm not about to do any of these things, or anything even remotely similar. But knowing the _reality_ of the crazy stuff people do really helps to put things into perspective.
Safe? Hell no.
But so what? Why should that stop people, if they want to experiment on themselves? It's their brains.
Isaac Newton stuck a bodkin in his eyeball, to observe what effect it had on his vision.
I did it last week. Setting up the electrodes was the easy part. The hard part was setting up the electrodes!
How long before you have to submit to such "modifications"? To enhance soldiers in the field perhaps?
Or once those not doing it lose their jobs for someone that's more of a "team player"?
Perhaps to ensure the kids are all at the same level in class and learn what we want them to learn instead?
If something were to go wrong you'd know it..
Doc Ostrow: Morbius was too close to the problem. The Krell had completed their project. Big machine. No instrumentalities. True creation.
Commander John J. Adams: Come on, Doc, let's have it.
Doc Ostrow: But the Krell forgot one thing.
Commander John J. Adams: Yes, what?
Doc Ostrow: Monsters, John. Monsters from the Id.
Commander John J. Adams: The Id? What's that? Talk, Doc!
[Doc slumps and dies]
Commander John J. Adams: Doc?
right? me neither...
problem is, there are tons of people willing to line up to do this...**tons**...and they will all surely blog about it in hopes of getting picked up by mainstream news publications
with this "brain mod" crap I'm getting a bad feeling...
remember back in the early days of the 'web'...say 1995 when AOL was king...we all knew that there was so much more that could be done with the internet but even then, the question was **are we willing to sacrifice privacy**
same with cell phones
i remember when the internet was new, everyone was skeptical of it & **assumed** what they did on the internet was not private...
then the commercialization effort started in earnest and before long every desk job required internet usage...
what I'm getting at is ***I feel that same feeling now***
SKEPTICAL...it's not what its made out to be...and if we ever *do* get hyper-selective brain stimulation I can only envision all the ways the tech could be misused
Thank you Dave Raggett
"The most prominent folk theory for the benefits of self-trepanation is offered by Bart Huges, alternatively spelled Bart Hughes and sometimes called "Dr. Bart Hughes", although he is not a doctor but rather a librarian by trade. He was better known for his advocacy of drug use and trepanation and in 1965 he drilled a hole in his own head with a Black and Decker power drill as a publicity stunt. Hughes claims that trepanation increases "brain blood volume" and thereby enhances cerebral metabolism in a manner similar to cerebral vasodilators such as ginkgo biloba. No published results have supported these claims."
I knew someone who wrote many letters and emails to Black and Decker back in the 1990's requesting a recommendation for which drill bit to use for self-trepanation. It was an amusing joke. He got dozens of panicky replies and was contacted by their lawyers who informed him that they did not support him using their power tools for medical procedures. He finally did receive a reply from someone with a sense of humor though. I kept a copy of that email chain for years.. I wish I still had it, or knew where it was.
Have gnu, will travel.
Of course it's unsafe. Improper use of e-stim can kill you and DIY bainhacking is basically e-stim applied to your head. Magnetically induced is safer than direct electricity, but only because it's weaker. Once you start using the really strong magnets, then you're in danger just by being around them. Two strong magnets can snap together and completely crush that part of your hand.
Even if the levels of everything was kept very low, you're still MESSING WITH YOUR BRAIN. You're using an external force to break pass your skull and directly interfere with your neurons and other molecules moving around your brain. Are the benefits worth the unknown risks? There's plenty of proven ways to hack your brain through food, lighting, sound, exercise, breathing techniques, and meditation.
Better back up your firmware, just in case this makes you infirm.
Asdfbbb asdf asdf su lkjasld asdbbb bb blkasdf aj
Table-ized A.I.
The kind of people who actually would have the means, motivation, and wherewithal to do this probably face at least as much risk and danger in their everyday hobbies and activities. (Serious tinkerers and the like who play with electricity, fire, chemicals, metalworking tools, lasers, plasma cutters, etc. day in and day out.)
It's when the technology goes 'As Seen On TV' and Joe Six-Pack can buy himself an "Easy-peasy dew-it-yerself brain-zappery kit" that the question of safety truly becomes relevant.
Friend: "The NIC is misconfigured..." Me: "No prob, I'll just telnet in and fix it." *Silence*
Wait until someone finds out how to trigger orgasms on demand, so you can masturbate with the click of a button - all of Slashdot will be performing DIY lobotomies.
Is Lasik At Home Safe? http://www.lasikathome.com/
The Official Site of 1337 Pwnage
There's an interesting/amusing movie about trepanation on Youtube:
http://www.youtube.com/user/trepanned
Sounds like an easy way to scramble your brain and make mistakes like assuming you pushed the button on the soda machine for orange, when you actually asked for (and got) lemon-lime. Of course, you can always blame the maintenance man for that.
You don't support our policies?
Don't worry, I'm sure we can change your mind...
If you want to enhance creativity and reduce depression, why not just drop some acid instead?
Probably a lot safer and more likely to produce the desired results.
Testing in Production
Quote from the article: "Lee’s first plan was to use tDCS to learn German, but when he realized that language-learning would still be a huge time commitment, ..."
How serious can you take someone that thinks learning German is going to take a 10 minutes instead of 10 years because you strap a 9V battery to your head?
As long as foc.us will also sell me a replacement brain if something goes wrong.
Is it safe to electrocute your own brain?
This is going to be a bit of a puzzler.
Apparently foc.us makes you think wearing flat brim is cool.
Invite a few friends, connect all your tDCS to a ethernet hub, then attach to the WAN side of the hub this device for best result.
Found an alternative to Steam
Most people aren't using their brains for anything anyway.
Remember kids, this is what a crazy person looks like. If they ask you "Let's tape electrodes to your head" you respond "No".
- Woody Allen, "Sleeper"
No it's not.
The same thing we do every night, Pinky...
the preceding comment is my own and in no way reflects the opinion of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
These Canadians claim they can alleviate migraines for some patients with a magic electrical headband. But who's going to trust Canananadians?
the preceding comment is my own and in no way reflects the opinion of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
oh god, those pictures! lolololololo! Definitely need to use one of those on my okcupid profile!
Plus, everybody knows, the proper pad placement is where the crease of you buttocks joins your thigh.
the preceding comment is my own and in no way reflects the opinion of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
I remember depictions of George Nash in the Beautiful Mind movie. He never did great math after that.
http://youtu.be/spF6A2QK31s
Oh please; any joeboy can tell you you've gotta be careful what you plug into your Hosaka or you'll end up fried.
Posting this anonymously because of the sensitive nature of the content...
But after a number of years playing with very expensive gear for genital electrostimulation with no ill effects, I recently developed a problem after an accidental high dose of current resulted in irritated veinous tissue also known as phlebitis, or in this case, penile thrombophlebitis. The affected vein walls thicken, resulting in an uncomfortable and potentially hazardous situation.
As much fun as electro-play has been, the damage is relatively minor and is likely to heal. The possibility of something like this happening within the cranium, however, is devastating to consider. Strokes, permanent brain damage, potential death all outweigh the potential benefits of this.
All right, gentlemen, free your mind.
I'd like to free something.
"Foc.us. "
That's what I was thinking.
She said "focus. "
Whatever.
Please, PLEASE, somebody mod this guy up FUNNY. LOL ROFLMAO
Every rule has more than one consequence.