Slashdot Mirror


Microsoft Cuts Xbox One Price To $249 - Would You Buy or Recommend One? (theverge.com)

Tom Warren, writing for The Verge: Microsoft is cutting the price of its Xbox One console to $249. The new price marks the third price cut in less than two months, ahead of the new Xbox One S launch on August 2nd. 500GB versions of the Xbox One are now $249, and this includes bundles with games like Gears of War: Ultimate Edition, Quantum Break, Forza Motorsport 6, Rise of the Tomb Raider, and Rare Replay. Retailers like Best Buy and Amazon will be selling Microsoft's Xbox One console at the new $249 price point immediately, and the software giant says the consoles will be available at $249 "while supplies last." Microsoft's aggressive Xbox One pricing follows a sales gap between its console and Sony's PlayStation 4. Sony has sold more than 40 million PS4s, but it's not clear exactly how many Xbox Ones have been sold as Microsoft hasn't provided sales figures for quite some time. EA previously revealed Microsoft had sold 19 million Xbox One consoles back in January.

90 of 140 comments (clear)

  1. No, and no by damn_registrars · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It's still a Microsoft product. It still mostly plays games of a genre that I don't care about (doom clones). Maybe if I was a single guy with money to burn and time to kill, I would be interested but there is no room in my life for a Microsoft or Sony console right now at any price.

    --
    Damn_registrars has no butt-hole. Damn_registrars has no use for a butt-hole.
    1. Re:No, and no by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      The OP asked if HE should get an Xbone, not if YOU should get one. But, of course, everything is about YOU.

    2. Re:No, and no by jellomizer · · Score: 1

      I wouldn't worry so much if it was a Microsoft Product or not. The big concern with getting a gaming system when there is a new one expected to be released is the ability to get new games for the system. I am not a gamer so I don't know he details. However if the XBox One and the XBox One S will run the same games going forwards towards the life of the product, and the only difference is being able to run on 1080p vs 4k and you have no plans on getting a 4k TV. Then you are probably good.
      However if the One S games will be incompatible with the One on any screen resolution than you may not considering the cheaper price for a shorter useful life on the product.

      --
      If something is so important that you feel the need to post it on the internet... It probably isn't that important.
    3. Re:No, and no by cloud.pt · · Score: 1

      Indeed. He still made a valid point for a dense demographic of this site. See the bigger picture instead of being in defense mode 24/7. Stationary, non-casual consoles aren't for everyone, no matter the price, and the genre focus of the XB1 is very, VERY obvious.

    4. Re:No, and no by cloud.pt · · Score: 1

      And the question is definitely in the second person: "would you buy..."

    5. Re:No, and no by supremebob · · Score: 5, Informative

      The XBox One doesn't really have the graphics horsepower to play games at 1080p. Most of them are rendered at 900p and upscaled.

      I'm not sure if the XBox One S will be any faster, or they'll just be updating the upscaler to allow 4k display resolutions.

    6. Re:No, and no by damn_registrars · · Score: 3, Informative

      The OP asked if HE should get an Xbone, not if YOU should get one. But, of course, everything is about YOU.

      Did you read the subject line here? It reads

      Would You Buy or Recommend One?

      And I would neither buy nor recommend one.

      --
      Damn_registrars has no butt-hole. Damn_registrars has no use for a butt-hole.
    7. Re: No, and no by thundercattt · · Score: 1

      They do this every console. Xbox, Xbox 360, now Xbox One. Once they fall behind in the market, Nintendo start making good ground MS gets desperate and cuts it's price drastically. I've never liked Xbox consoles because of their controller setup. But I also never bought one because of the high DOA from out of box. I considered an Xbox Original, issues. Considered an Xbox 360, during price drop a few years back. Online store reviews were 1 out of 2 out of box were duds during sale. I simply have 0 trust from any MS product. Also, I just think they have some sneaky trick up their sleeve to tie it in with 10 somehow.

    8. Re:No, and no by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      It's still a Microsoft product.

      The implied choice is between MS and Sony. You'd pick a rootkit designed to harm *you* personally, over monopoly abuses that hurt the market, but not the consumers (other than the theoretical damage of a monopoly, which XBone doesn't have).

      It still mostly plays games of a genre that I don't care about (doom clones).

      That their most famous exclusive is an FPS doesn't excuse the massive multi-platrform titles available on both. The exclusives for PS are reducing, though PS still has the Japanese-only games, and many of their sequels.

      Maybe if I was a single guy with money to burn and time to kill, I would be interested but there is no room in my life for a Microsoft or Sony console right now at any price.

      So you recomend against all consoles. Then why not lead with that, and leave the rest out. You have two MS-only complaints, then the "I wouldn't pick any" disclaimer. Seems hollow when you single out one console to bash.

      XBone has many exclusive features. PS4 integrates with PSVita only. If you want to buy into Sony's monoculture. XBone works with the number 1 OS on the planet. Cast to/from XBone/PC. Use your PC as a DVR/media player, playing from your PC to your XBone. Watch your children play games from your PC in the other room. XBone actually tries to be usable. PS4 is "for players". XBone is for people, especially families. Kinect is great. Voice commands, fun games that have you moving.

      But picking PS4 because you like rootkits seems a silly differentiator between two companies with bad corporate track-records.

    9. Re:No, and no by damn_registrars · · Score: 1

      The implied choice is between MS and Sony

      I disagree. The question was "Would You Buy or Recommend One?". I don't see how this makes "none of the above" an invalid choice. For me the WiiU is a vastly superior choice to either, though I still prefer none of the above right now.

      So you recomend against all consoles. Then why not lead with that, and leave the rest out.

      Because I started by answering the question that was posed by the title of the article.

      XBone is for people, especially families

      I think you have that confused with the Wii and WiiU. Just because XBOne has a component that allows you to play a dozen or so games without the traditional controller does not mean they are actively trying to get families involved in gaming. Look no further than the game sales volumes and you'll see where their real interests are; the top selling titles for both the Sony and MS consoles are of the same genre, and with the exception of the console-exclusive titles they are the same games.

      But picking PS4 because you like

      Maybe someone else preferred the PS4 in this thread, but not me. I don't want the MS or Sony consoles, period. No generation of either has ever been in my home, and I can't see a reason to change that.

      --
      Damn_registrars has no butt-hole. Damn_registrars has no use for a butt-hole.
  2. Re:Would you edit? by Big+Hairy+Ian · · Score: 1

    Just assume this thread is an advert

    --

    Build a Man a Fire, and He'll Be Warm for a Day. Set a Man on Fire, and He'll Be Warm for the Rest of His Life.

  3. I would pay more! by jimtheowl · · Score: 1

    I might pay double if they would drop the data collection.

    Triple if I can play with my friends over the Internet with an open source server.

    1. Re:I would pay more! by jimtheowl · · Score: 1

      You would, and can.

  4. I own Xbox one and a PS4 & various mobile devi by tacroy · · Score: 4, Interesting

    My xbone gets the most use out of my gaming devices. Partially because of the games, but also because it actually makes a surprisingly good streaming hub also as a window 10 OS it in theory could get apps and other neat things from windows.

    Media Stuff:
    I use Netflix, Amazon, Hulu, and various other premium channel apps (HBO, CW, etc). While the ps4 does many of those, I have to open each app and hunt for the shows I want. the xbone lets me do a search via voice and then asks what app to open the show in. Way more convenient. The xbox also does live TV and has tv guide and all that stuff. Basically, it replaces the features of a smart TV+

    Game specific stuff:
    Exclusive wise, Sony still has an edge, but it's pretty small. That's when I typically use my ps4. Quantum Break is good, but short. Tomb Raider is amazing, but will likely be coming to PS4 in the next year. I'm also a bit a halo fanboy, so that helps.
    Both consoles give free games each month if you have their premium account thing.
    Xbox one however has backwards compatibility with a bunch of 360 games, so I'm using that a lot as well.

    Other Stuff:
    You can also use the xbox as a miracast receiver, which I use fairly often and works well. Granted you can get a standalone receiver for WAY cheaper, so don't buy it for that.
    I loved xbox fitness, but they are killing it... Still a bit frustrated at that.
    Xbox can be targeted with universal windows app, since it's a windows 10 machine at the core. So the preview program has just started getting actual windows 10 apps on it. Which I'm very curious if that will be awesome or horrible; to early to tell.

  5. blatant ad by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    fuck your ads

  6. I wouldn't. So shouldn't most by cloud.pt · · Score: 1

    You can get PS4's for cheap. Loads of hardcore gamers are getting rid of their A and B-type chassis for the more silent and power efficient C models. The news about the slim version is also driving used and new prices down, even though it's all rumors. So why bring the PS4 into the XB1 topic? Because you can't recommend one without mentioning its main competitor, which is, to my own tastes and of most, a much better product with a far nicer environment and game library. Much like you should probably get a PC over any of the two if you're going for VR, most RTS/FPS games or if you have a solid steam library.

    For someone who doesn't have ANY console, I would still say the PS4 is king, unless you really want to spend those bucks for a US company, which I wouldn't be surprised many would in this site. You will get loads of fun with any, but you wil surely get a lot more value, and lend or be lent a lot more games between most friends who likely have a PS4. Worth 100 dollars or even more if you ask me. My two cents.

    1. Re:I wouldn't. So shouldn't most by tacroy · · Score: 1

      Can you give me a bit more info about these Chassis you speak of? I have a launch day ps4 and am curious. Thanks!

    2. Re:I wouldn't. So shouldn't most by cloud.pt · · Score: 1
  7. Amusing Conjunction by SuperKendall · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Headline on the story just below this one:

    "Microsoft Can't Shield User Data From Government, Says Government"

    That certainly does make for a ringing endorsement that you should buy an Xbox one and attach an always on microphone...

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
    1. Re:Amusing Conjunction by jittles · · Score: 1

      Headline on the story just below this one:

      "Microsoft Can't Shield User Data From Government, Says Government"

      That certainly does make for a ringing endorsement that you should buy an Xbox one and attach an always on microphone...

      They no longer bundle the Kinect with the Xbox. In fact, they also freed up the resources that they had dedicated to the kinect to allow developers to have more horsepower. Not only that, but the article you're referencing is the government's claim that Microsoft cannot shield the data, not Microsoft's actual position on the matter.

  8. What a bargain by 110010001000 · · Score: 1

    It was such a bargain I bought five!!! They make excellent stocking stuffers. Plus I need to buy some for my house in the Hamptons and my ski house in the French Alps.

    1. Re:What a bargain by SScorpio · · Score: 1

      If you pay month to month. Both Xbox Live and PS+ are available for $50/yr, and you can find it them on sale for $35-40/yr.

    2. Re:What a bargain by tepples · · Score: 1

      When you have to pay $10/mo for Xbox Live, you're out another $120/year.

      Both Xbox Live and PS+ are available for $50/yr, and you can find it them on sale for $35-40/yr.

      When you have three people in the house and have to pay $40/yr for PS+ or Live on each of their consoles, you're out another $120/year.

    3. Re:What a bargain by jittles · · Score: 1

      When you have to pay $10/mo for Xbox Live, you're out another $120/year.

      Both Xbox Live and PS+ are available for $50/yr, and you can find it them on sale for $35-40/yr.

      When you have three people in the house and have to pay $40/yr for PS+ or Live on each of their consoles, you're out another $120/year.

      I believe that MIcrosoft has a family plan that allows 5 accounts to all be connected simultaneously for $80 or $100 a year. I'm not sure the exact price or the exact number of users but I had considered doing it with friends as it is cheaper than the discounted prices you'll find.

    4. Re:What a bargain by CronoCloud · · Score: 1

      I'm not sure what you're getting at? Do you mean 3 adults or what? If it is a shared household of 3 adults then they can pay for their OWN PS+. If it is an adult and kids, then the adult can decided if they want their kids to have online multiplayer, or not.

      But PS+ accounts are per user, so it depends on WHO the devices are owned by and how many.

      For example, I have ONE PS4 and it's set as the "Primary" and I'm a PS+ user. Any sub account on the system has access to multiplayer on this system.

      If I had a second PS4 that was NOT set to primary, sub accounts wouldn't have access to multiplayer. (except for those games that don't require PS+ for multiplayer) But I could use multiplayer on that system while others used multiplayer on the Primary.

      I have a friend with a PS4, while he currently has PS+ there are times he hasn't. Now if I was to go to his house and login as "Me" on that system, I would have full access to PS+ services on his machine whether he has PS+ or not since PS+ is per user.

      https://www.playstation.com/en...

  9. Nintendo got you covered... by cloud.pt · · Score: 2

    As long as you don't connect it to the internet, Nintendo will likely never prompt to download anything. You migth still have to update firmware, but much like you had to for PS3's/PSPs - the game disc which needed a specific firmware brought it on-disc and it would be a 20min affair sans-data spending. And Nintendo still has the focus on family gaming in mind - this is the reason I bought one for my parent's and lil' 4yo sister's living room.

  10. Consoles are too limiting by Stormwatch · · Score: 1

    Current consoles don't allow KB/M (minus rare exceptions or using an adapter), which makes FPS games borderline unplayable. How does anyone finds this bullshit acceptable in this day and age? Seriously, even the Dreamcast had KB/M.

    1. Re:Consoles are too limiting by CronoCloud · · Score: 1

      Just a reminder that FPS's aren't the only genre but every console since the PS2 has USB ports for a reason. It's not a case of "allow" but rather "do the developers want to take the time and effort to implement/test/troubleshoot a keyboard + mouse control system alongside the standard controller"

      And often they don't bother to...but....sometimes they do. And I have console games within 10 feet of me with keyboard and/or mouse support. Sometimes the support won't be listed on the box, you have to check.

  11. Can you play Xbox 360 games on it? by swb · · Score: 1

    We won an Xbox 360 in a school raffle two years ago. The Xbox One had just been released. But because it had and the 360 had been on the market for a while, we were able to walk out of a pawn shop with a half-dozen games for less than $50.

    I think our total game investment is maybe $100 up to now, and the count is probably 15 or more.

    If you can play 360 games on the One, it might make a decent Christmas present if we don't lose the games we own or have to maintain two systems.

    1. Re:Can you play Xbox 360 games on it? by tacroy · · Score: 1

      You can play "Some" 360 games on it. Basically companies need to give permission to let their game play on the xbone. List is here: http://www.xbox.com/en-US/xbox...

    2. Re:Can you play Xbox 360 games on it? by ET3D · · Score: 2

      Easier to browse the list here or here.

    3. Re:Can you play Xbox 360 games on it? by UnknowingFool · · Score: 1

      By "some" the actual number is 0. You can't play any Xbox 360 games on it. What you can do is play games in which the manufacturer has made an Xbox One port. So "by permission", it is a smokescreen for the fact that the Xbox One cannot run 360 games at all. They are trying to make it sound like the manufacturer is being obstinate when it is the same as it has been for new platforms; your old software isn't compatible.

      --
      Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
  12. Re:Would you edit? by in10se · · Score: 2

    Because social media/blog/web site best practices tell you that if you ask a question in your post you tend to get more responses. That means more page views. That means more ad views. And it worked - you commented. Sucker.

    Oh, you asked a question and I answered too. Sucker.

    --
    Popisms.com - Connecting pop culture
  13. No wireless speed wheel, no xbox one by GrumpyOldMan · · Score: 2

    I am a HUGE fan of the Forza series. But I hate playing racing games with a joystick, and I don't have the space for a real steering wheel & pedals. So the XBox 360's "Wireless Speed Wheel" was perfect for me.

    Microsoft lost a customer when they released XBox One without support for XBox 360 controllers and no replacement for the 360's wireless speed wheel. Leaving behind the XBox360 controllers was a blatant money grab, but if they'd have come out with a replacement for the WSW, I'd probably have paid full price & bought the box on launch day. As it is, I still play the original Forza on my 360. And when I needed a next-gen console, there was no reason not to buy the PS4.

  14. Hell no by LichtSpektren · · Score: 1

    Microsoft--and let's be fair here, also Sony to a lesser degree--both really have long histories of abusing their customers. I'm really not a Nintendo fanboy, and I have lots of bad things to say about them, but at the very least they actually recognize that their customers are human beings who play games for fun, they aren't fleshbags with coin purses.

    1. Re:Hell no by Scutter · · Score: 1

      but at the very least [Nintendo] actually recognize that their customers are human beings who play games for fun, they aren't fleshbags with coin purses.
      Really? You might wanna rethink that. If your decision to chose one technology over the other based on each one's privacy policy, you're always going to lose. You are always the product.

      --

      "Tell me doctor, with all of your defenses, are there any provisions for an attack by killer bees?"
    2. Re:Hell no by mrchaotica · · Score: 2

      Nintendo was abusing its customers back when Microsoft was still busy making Flight Simulator for DOS. There is no "nice" gaming console maker, especially since Sega left the market.

      --

      "[Regarding the 'cloud,'] ownership was what made America different than Russia." -- Woz

  15. Things you can get for $250 by sycodon · · Score: 2

    1. New brake pads and rotors for my car
    2. One month's 74 degree AC setting on my large, two story home.
    3. A twenty Seven year subscription to Netflix's streaming services
    4. Ten $25 dollar Prime steaks to grill.
    5. 4 physician co-pays
    6. Twelve and a half tanks of gas
    7. A Primo Backpack
    8. Round Trip Tickets to Vegas and a two nights at a shitty Hotel.
    9. $451.53 after 20 years of 3% interest, compounding annually.
    10. A 5/10 hooker for the night or a 10/10 hooker for 30 minutes.

    --
    When Fascism comes to America, it will call itself Anti-Fascism, and tell you to give up your guns.
    1. Re: Things you can get for $250 by Grishnakh · · Score: 1

      He never said that at all. Did you miss the bit about round-trip tickets? I could easily spend that much on round-trip tickets to Vegas, without the hotel.

    2. Re:Things you can get for $250 by sycodon · · Score: 1

      Ahh...$9 a MONTH.

      Well, I had to use the can and wanted to get that posted.

      --
      When Fascism comes to America, it will call itself Anti-Fascism, and tell you to give up your guns.
  16. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by mrchaotica · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Quit trolling. I am also an employed adult and I don't spend my time "chasing down the latest drivers or spec-ing a new video card" either. This isn't 1995 anymore; PCs "just work."

    --

    "[Regarding the 'cloud,'] ownership was what made America different than Russia." -- Woz

  17. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by mrchaotica · · Score: 1

    The only 'negative' things I can see about it are the Microsoft connection..and that it'll eventually RROD on me.

    It's also violating your privacy (especially if instead of a 360 it were an Xbone, as this topic is actually about). By using it, you are also tacitly signalling your support for Microsoft's continuing assault on property rights (by attempting to subordinate them to copyright law run amok). Those costs may not be measured in dollars, yet they are real.

    --

    "[Regarding the 'cloud,'] ownership was what made America different than Russia." -- Woz

  18. Re:Would you edit? by Frosty+Piss · · Score: 1

    Hahhaaaa... You took the Anon Troll bait!

    --
    If you want news from today, you have to come back tomorrow.
  19. No by zmaragdus · · Score: 1

    You can pry my mouse out of my cold, dead hands.

    --
    (((dB)))
  20. Still too expensive... by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 1

    I'm waiting for $100 model. I didn't get a PlayStation One until Sony came out with the $100 model.

  21. This question is paradoxical by ShooterNeo · · Score: 1

    Anyone who actually enjoys gaming on consoles would probably already have a PS4. So a cheaper Xbox One doesn't change anything.

  22. No by XxtraLarGe · · Score: 1

    I just don't like the controller, although I have to admit the XB One's controller is better than the XB 360's. I much prefer the PS3's Dual Shock. From what I understand, the PS4's Dual Shock is better than the PS3's, so a PS4 will almost certainly be my next console purchase, when or if I'm ever in the market for a new one. That probably won't be for a while, since I'd like to wait for the VR market to mature a bit, and I still have a boatload of games on my PS3 I still haven't even touched.

    --
    Taking guns away from the 99% gives the 1% 100% of the power.
  23. Stupid when new model is almost out. by Nyder · · Score: 1

    Seeing as MS is putting out a new more powerful version of the Xbox soon, I would think spending any amount of money on the Xbox One would be stupid. Unless it was a bargain price, like $100 or less.

    --
    Be seeing you...
  24. Sure (I actually have one already) by Ogive17 · · Score: 1

    It's funny that so many people who do not have an Xbox One are telling others they shouldn't get one..

    I've had mine for almost a year now. I enjoy playing the occasional game but mostly use it for streaming or watching Blu-ray moves as I only had DVD player before. It also plays the movie files I have saved on a thumb drive. I do not have the Kinect. It's a good piece of hardware and you can find some quality games for good prices if you're willing to wait a couple months after launch.

    If you want one, buy one. If you are not sure, don't buy one.

    --
    "Action without philosophy is a lethal weapon; philosophy without action is worthless."
  25. What salvageable hardware is in there? by Opportunist · · Score: 1

    At that price, the question starts to become relevant, so let's dissect that box. What can be salvaged?

    --
    We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
    1. Re:What salvageable hardware is in there? by Sneftel · · Score: 1

      Stripping it for parts? Well, there's a HD and a BluRay, of course, and a fan, and some cables; those would be worth a few bucks put together.

      Beyond that there's a couple of circuit boards with lots of chips soldered to them. If you have a BGA rework station and a steady hand, you could recover the ICs. But if you're looking for a graphics card, a socketable CPU, memory DIMMs... you're out of luck. There's no reason for MS to make the xbone a PC on the inside, and every reason for them not to.

      --
      The opinions stated herein do not necessarily represent those of anybody at all. Deal with it.
    2. Re:What salvageable hardware is in there? by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      There's no reason for MS to make the xbone a PC on the inside, and every reason for them not to.

      Making it as close to a Wintel box as possible, to unify gaming and OS OSs was a stated goal. Given that goal, you think they did what you said and deliberately made it different from the platform they are trying to unify on?

      It's an AMD-based PC, running Windows 10 Embedded (game version). It shouldn't be too hard to find the DRM chip, cut it out, and install some Linux on it or something. Though, if they are selling it for $250, it probably costs $100 to make, so you won't be gaining much.

  26. Is this Parody? Re:Mall shooting in Germany by Hasaf · · Score: 1

    The problem is that it is not articulate enough to be good parody.

    If you are serious, I would like to point out that the 2nd amendment doesn't apply in Germany. Germany dos not have a powerful Republican party (or one at all; the parliamentary system gives rise to so many small parties that I cannot say for sure without research. . . and this is slashdot, no one does research for postings here).

    I could go on; but I am hoping that your post was nothing but a poor attempt at parody; oh, and it seems a bit off topic in an article about the X-box.

  27. Problem with the S around the corner by ET3D · · Score: 1

    It's hard to recommend an older model when a Xbox One S is around the corner and expected to sell for the same price.

    In general I think that the Xbox One is an attractive console at this price for the undemanding gamer. You can buy it for $250, subscribe to Gold for $60 a year and you get about 4 games a month to keep. Great inexpensive gaming gift for a kid. With keyboard and mouse support underway, aimed at PC style game control but hopefully usable for the UI, it could likely even become a PC alternative, at least for web browsing and applications using the Edge browser. (But that's just speculation on my part.)

    Personally consoles don't get a lot of traction in my house these days. I have a Wii and a 360, and they both get some gaming, as well as LEGO games on my HTPC, but the kids and myself still normally prefer the tablets, and for console style gaming the HTPC with 360 wireless controllers works decently. Kinect does get some occasional use (in fact, it's the main use of the 360), and unfortunately Kinect games for the 360 aren't compatible with the One, or I might have been tempted to buy one. Still, even if I was planning to get one, I'd wait for the S, to have a console that's less bulky (and slightly more future proof).

    1. Re:Problem with the S around the corner by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      In general I think that the Xbox One is an attractive console at this price for the undemanding gamer.

      I think it's underrated for the non-gamer. Blu-Ray, Netflix and such. It's the media box for the home with a large, but not smart, TV.

      PS3 had more media options than PS4, so neither is the right choice for that anymore. XBone is the right choice for the non-gamer to get a media PC attached to the TV. Small, quiet, and low on power, for something that'll play DVDs, BluRay, Netflix, and even some gaming, if you decide to try it out.

  28. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by Hasaf · · Score: 1

    A lot of the respondents to this post just don't get it. At a certain point the computer is not the ends, it is a means. Consoles provide a computer that, relatively, easily plays games. No tinkering or fussing required.

    Instead of not working and expecting me to figure out what I need to do to fix the computer, they sometimes do have a update to install first. That is fine, I switch to some other task, or read, while that is happening. . . or just play a different game and instal the patch when I am done for the day.

    At a certain point, the computer ceases to be a hobby unto itself.

  29. This is what I'd need to consider buying the XBone by Qbertino · · Score: 1

    Zero-fuss Mouse + Keyboard + Homeworld Deserts of Kharak. That would make me curious.

    Basically it goes like this:
    Turn the XBox One into an affordable zero-fuss gaming PC and I'm in.

    Since that's not happening because it would directly canibalise MSes OEM market - probably the only place they still make money selling Windows - this most probably won't happen.

    So, no, I don't think I'm getting an XBone.

    Concerning consoles in general: I see their point and I do have the last edition of the XBox 360 (my very first console) + ~30 bargain-bin priced GOTY/Ultimate/Directors-Cut/Platinum Edition gaming titles that each have won multiple awards for being excellent, superb and whatnot. The whole package was dirt-cheap and I have gaming fun for years to come - so no big pressure here to get a new console.

    --
    We suffer more in our imagination than in reality. - Seneca
  30. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by tbannist · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Actually, I think you were moderated down because your post contained nothing of value. Next time try less profanity and more expository.

    --
    Fanatically anti-fanatical
  31. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by CohibaVancouver · · Score: 2

    Consoles provide a computer that, relatively, easily plays games. No tinkering or fussing required.

    They also do other stuff, relatively tinker-free, that you'd want to do near your TV & sound system -

    - Connect to streaming music & video services

    - Play CDs, DVDs & Blu-ray

    - Connect to video and audio content libraries in your home

    - Control your TV with your voice.

    Yeah, yeah, I know you can do all this stuff with a PC as well, but with an XBOX it's set-and-forget (and, most importantly, wife-friendly).

  32. Re:This is what I'd need to consider buying the XB by ET3D · · Score: 1

    I'm not sure what you mean by zero-fuss, but MS is planning mouse + keyboard gaming support. Hopefully it will arrive this year.

  33. Re:This is what I'd need to consider buying the XB by tacroy · · Score: 1

    I wouldn't purcash based on hopeful features though... They did kill OTA DVR... Still a bit annoyed about that.

  34. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by Ogive17 · · Score: 1

    90% of the use of our xbox one is streaming. My 3 year old has to help my wife turn it off after his show is over....

    Of course, she just doesn't want to learn.. very capable woman in many instances.. except having fun.

    --
    "Action without philosophy is a lethal weapon; philosophy without action is worthless."
  35. Re:I own Xbox one and a PS4 & various mobile d by Luthair · · Score: 1

    The trouble with the Xbox One and the PS4 for media consumption is that both have very high power consumption. You're much better off using other devices like Roku, Chromecast or AppleTV.

  36. Re:Nope by Pulzar · · Score: 1

    It truly boggles my mind how Microsoft have continually screwed their own customers over for decades, and yet still all the sheep out there keep buying their products, then are shocked/outraged when their turn inevitably comes around.

    Maybe the explanation is that most of their customers don't feel like they have been "continually screwed" by them? I personally don't remember being screwed by them for at least 10 years or so.

    --
    Never underestimate the bandwidth of a 747 filled with CD-ROMs.
  37. Boring Console Generation by Luthair · · Score: 1

    Personally I have found there is a dearth of interesting games on all of the current generation systems. Definitely does not live up to previous generations

  38. Which genre do you play? by tepples · · Score: 1

    It's still a Microsoft product. It still mostly plays games of a genre that I don't care about (doom clones).

    As of the anniversary update, Xbox One runs Windows apps. What genre of game would you like to see developed as a Windows app, other than perhaps "fighting game with classic Nintendo IP"?

  39. Backwards compatibility by gsilver0 · · Score: 1

    It would really help the X1 in my eyes if they focused more effort on making XBLA-exclusives backwards compatible. As it is, they tend to go for "big" titles, which are also available on the PC, which does kind of hurt it in my eyes. As it is, my X1 is mainly a Halo box.

  40. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by tepples · · Score: 1

    - Play CDs, DVDs & Blu-ray

    CD what? Xbox One can't rip CDs, and neither the PlayStation 4 nor the Wii U can even play CDs.

    - Connect to video and audio content libraries in your home

    How-To Geek's article claims that this happens through DLNA. I seem to remember certain PlayStation products in the past being very picky about DLNA implementation, not giving the user much useful troubleshooting information. How picky is the Xbox One's DLNA client, compared to (say) a living room PC? Does it support things like WebM (MKV container, VP8 or VP9 video, and Vorbis or Opus audio)?

  41. Re:Why would I buy a computer FOR Microsoft? by tepples · · Score: 1

    Buy a computer that only some people (those who pay extra) are allowed to program? That's totally absurd.

    The standard answer is that developer qualifications improve the median quality of games. The last time everybody was allowed to program a console was the Atari 2600. The flood of crap during 1983, led by rushed licenses such as E.T. and Pac-Man as well as blatant cash-ins such as Chase the Chuck Wagon, almost brought down the North American video game industry. (Distributors going bankrupt to avoid honoring their return policies didn't help either.) It took the NES's lockout chip to revive retailers' and users' interest in video games.

    But both Microsoft and Nintendo have opened their developer programs dramatically during this console generation. Xbox One runs UWP apps with an developer mode enabler app available at no additional charge to Dev Center members, and Nintendo recently allowed individuals to become developers regardless of "industry experience". I'm guessing it's a response to the comparative openness of Apple's App Store and Google Play Store, along with the realization that reviews by third parties can filter out the crap.

  42. WASD is digital; left stick is analog by tepples · · Score: 1

    Current consoles don't allow KB/M (minus rare exceptions or using an adapter)

    And I'm told most of these exceptions are on PlayStation 2, 3, and 4. Some people like using a mouse in one hand and half of a DualShock in the other because unlike WASD, an analog stick offers analog control of the speed and direction of your movement, not just your aiming.

    1. Re:WASD is digital; left stick is analog by CronoCloud · · Score: 1

      And I'm told most of these exceptions are on PlayStation 2, 3, and 4.

      As far as I know, yes. If there are Xbox, Xbox 360, Xbox One games with such support, I'd like to know about them.

      Some people like using a mouse in one hand and half of a DualShock in the other because unlike WASD, an analog stick offers analog control of the speed and direction of your movement, not just your aiming.

      Yep, I prefer that method if I can get it. I know one player of War Thunder on PC who uses that method for tanks. I've also read of PC gamers buying up Playstation Move Navigation controllers (that's the one with the analog stick, not the glowy ball on the end of it) and using them with mice.

  43. Re:Nope by JustNiz · · Score: 1

    I guess you weren't one of those people that unrecoverably lost their entire music collection when they switched music stores (twice now), or got screwed when they forced Windows 10 updates on people, or have never realized your personal data is being collected/sold, or found out that your windows 7 phone will no longer update, or that you're being spied on by your Kinect then. The sad thing is that I could go on and on with examples, yet you will no doubt find justifications to ignore/dismiss them all.

  44. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by CohibaVancouver · · Score: 1

    How picky is the Xbox One's DLNA client, compared to (say) a living room PC?

    I dunno how picky it is. We're a Windows household, so I turned on DLNA on the home PC and presto I was ready to go. Also works on my Sony Blu-ray and Sony TV.

  45. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by Maxwell · · Score: 2

    A lot of the respondents to this post just don't get it. At a certain point the computer is not the ends, it is a means. Consoles provide a computer that, relatively, easily plays games. No tinkering or fussing required.

    Instead of not working and expecting me to figure out what I need to do to fix the computer, they sometimes do have a update to install first. That is fine, I switch to some other task, or read, while that is happening. . . or just play a different game and instal the patch when I am done for the day.

    At a certain point, the computer ceases to be a hobby unto itself.

    An off the shelf PC will play games with exactly the same amount of "tinkering" as a modern console requires.

    No it won't. An off the shelf PC - DELL, Lenovo, Acer - has a 120watt power supply, an integrated intel video card that is directx 9 compatible. It won't play anything other than solitaire without a lot of tinkering. Oh, it's the buyers fault for not doing their research and buying a 'proper' PC, right? You buy a PS4, it plays PS4 games. You buy a PC...maybe. Did you check to make sure it has 8 lanes PCIe? 400 watt PSU? proper connectors? No? Toss a coin on whether that game will work or not....

  46. Re:Nope by Actually,+I+do+RTFA · · Score: 1

    Yeah, MS is always screwing customers, so screw them, buy a PS4. Like, remember when they removed the OtherOS functionality... oh wait, when they put spyware on audio CDs... no, that wasn't it, when their game network got hacked and they stored all those credit card numbers in plaintext... shoot, that wasn't them either!

    --
    Your ad here. Ask me how!
  47. I should have sold mine by MobyDisk · · Score: 1

    I should have sold my XBone as soon as I got it for free from the Microsoft Build Conference. Instead, it accumulated dust for years under the idea that "ooh, I can use the Kinect 2 as a 3D scanner!" And my kids can play Kinect games in a few years! Turns out, nobody supports Kinect 2 as a 3D scanner because it is inferior to the Kinect 1. And they never made any decent games for it. Even new, the writing was on the wall: I couldn't even trade-in my new-in-box $500 XBOX for a used $300 Wii. GameStop just didn't want the dang things since day 1.

  48. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by goose-incarnated · · Score: 1

    Consoles provide a computer that, relatively, easily plays games. No tinkering or fussing required.

    They also do other stuff, relatively tinker-free, that you'd want to do near your TV & sound system - - Connect to streaming music & video services - Play CDs, DVDs & Blu-ray - Connect to video and audio content libraries in your home - Control your TV with your voice. Yeah, yeah, I know you can do all this stuff with a PC as well, but with an XBOX it's set-and-forget (and, most importantly, wife-friendly).

    I don't need to do all that voice stuff. I've got a 10 year old beigebox running customised windowmaker and a cheapie remote for the PC. Using a couple of scripts I've put a menu on it that allows syncing to external drives (using volume lable/id to recognise previous drives), a simple remote-friendly menu system for browsing the filesystem, customised vlc to play anything selected and auto-ripping which, when selected, simply rips anything in the optical drive using the date/time and volume label to construct the rip names.

    It's got a wifi dongle in, thus I can stream from my storage elsewhere, mame/mess/fceu/some sega thing (which all, like vlc, are started when selecting a file while browsing). Simply keeping a sane starting directory and a small menu (five items) means that my wife uses it very well, as does my ten-year old. The only thing missing is a second wireless controller for the games, and both my son and I are quite enjoying playing Super Mario 2, Sonic, etc.

    One last thing: I put in a video capture device in as well, only we're not using it cause we don't watch braodcast TV

    I got the PC from my wife's workplace for $40 when they were clearing out old office equipment. Took about a day to set it up (writing all the scripts, customising WindowMaker for use with the remote, etc).

    --
    I'm a minority race. Save your vitriol for white people.
  49. Re:Nope by JustNiz · · Score: 1

    Nope sorry I don't buy any Sony (or Apple) products either.

  50. Get a NUC!!! by h4ck7h3p14n37 · · Score: 1

    Do yourself a favor and go buy an Intel NUC. It's much smaller than an XBone, runs on less power and has better media support.

  51. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by CronoCloud · · Score: 1

    Forget to set up automatic updates?

  52. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by CronoCloud · · Score: 1

    Hell I haven't updated the drivers for my videocard(sapphire 7950) since last year, and it's going along just fine with all the latest titles.

    Video card updates come along fairly frequently and one probably should update them. If you're running year old drivers, you're probably not taking advantage of your video card as much as you might. And why the heck are you, a member of the PC Master Race not keeping your Windows system updated as you SHOULD be doing.

    [sarcasm]Obviously a Windows Peasant, who probably isn't competent enough to administer a computer at all. Who knows what other updates this Windows Peasant hasn't done. They're machine is probably trojaned all to hell.[/sarcasm]

    Another supposedly "superior" build from the biased master race reddit?

    Which doesn't even include the OS, which has to be Windows for a game box, only has 4GB of RAM, not 8 and uses a Quad-core CPU (but at least it's a fast quad core)

    Not only that but it is a box you have to build yourself, it is NOT a prebuilt one that you can just head out to a big box store and just simply buy, like a PS4 or Xbox One.

    Topic at hand: I wouldn't recommend a console to anyone,

    I really wouldn't recommend gaming on Windows. I know people do it, and that there are games that are PC only, but that doesn't mean people SHOULD do it.

    While being locked into a console ecosystem that punishes you

    While being locked into the Windows ecosystem of a crappy OS that punishes you. And locked into the Steam ecosystem that punishes you, or the Origin ecosystem that punishes you.

    requires you to pay for multiplayer support and basic functions that are free on the PC.

    They aren't truly "free" on the PC...somebody pays for that bandwidth. Whether it's some affluent nerd hosting some Quake-foo server, or Valve paying for their TF2 servers with the cut they take off of Steam...somebody pays, directly or indirectly.

    Besides, console gamers get things BESIDES the multiplayer with their PS+ or Xbox live subscriptions.

    And not all multiplayer in the PlayStation ecosystem requires PS+!

    Multiplayer doesn't require PS+ on the Vita, or PS3. (or the PSP and PS2 if any of their games still have multiplayer running)

    F2P games on the PS4 don't require PS+ for multiplayer. Examples being War Thunder or Neverwinter.

    Games that use a "Send a turn/PBEM" style of multiplayer, also don't require PS+

  53. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by CronoCloud · · Score: 1

    Does it support things like WebM (MKV container, VP8 or VP9 video, and Vorbis or Opus audio)?

    Have you turned into RMS? Just use h264 with AAC audio in MPEG4 containers for video and MP3 for music as the gods intended. You know damned well that "open" formats tend to be less well supported on consumer media devices so you don't even need to ask. Besides, you can have the DLNA server transcode any unsupported format, though you should just stick to the formats I listed above.

    http://manuals.playstation.net...

  54. Re:Still a proprietary, DRM'd piece of shit. by CronoCloud · · Score: 1

    Ive got a 10 year old beigebox running customised windowmaker

    Using a couple of scripts

      Took about a day to set it up (writing all the scripts, customising WindowMaker for use with the remote, etc).

    perhaps you missed the "tinker-free" part of the GP's comment. Remember, not everyone is a Linux geek. Hell, I'm a Linux user and I'm not sure I could do the scripting you've done....especially with Windowmaker.

  55. It's a spying device by zedaroca · · Score: 1

    It listens to everything you and your family are saying, all the time. Then Microsoft reports to the murderers at NSA. Even if you "have nothing to hide", on principle alone, you should refuse to buy this kind of product.
    Plus, if you have kids, you never know if they are not going to do some good deed, worth of punishment. If they say something "wrong", the FBI might send someone to turn them into "terrorists", entrap and arrest them.

    Eric and "Anna" is a short about one "eco-terrorist" made by the FBI.

    Years after McDavid's conviction, the FBI released thousands of pages of FOIA requested documents not disclosed at trial (...)
    In January 2015, after serving nearly half of his 20 year sentence, Eric McDavid was released from prison. As a condition of his release, he waived his right to sue the government for any wrongdoing in his case.

    Wouldn't you feel terrible if your kids ended up in jail because of FBI entrapment started because of something they said close to the video-game that you bought? It's not tin-foil since we know they are really doing it.

  56. Home Gold sounds similar by tepples · · Score: 1

    I'm not sure what you're getting at? Do you mean 3 adults or what? If it is a shared household of 3 adults then they can pay for their OWN PS+. If it is an adult and kids, then the adult can decided if they want their kids to have online multiplayer, or not.

    I meant either way. A lot of people quote the raw sticker price of a console in arguments but fail to take into account the additional price of online multiplayer, especially in the era of a TV in every bedroom. Do games on either current console even support LAN multiplayer?

    But PS+ accounts are per user [etc.]

    tl;dr: PS+ on PlayStation 4 covers the user's primary console and other consoles that the user logs in to. Thank you for the explanation. After a bit of research, it appears Xbox Live Gold on Xbox One works the same way, and they call it "Home Gold".

    1. Re:Home Gold sounds similar by CronoCloud · · Score: 1

      Do games on either current console even support LAN multiplayer?

      There are some few that do, yes. Diablo 3 UEE on the PS4 does. I'm not a shooter fan so I don't know which shooters on PS4 do LAN.

  57. No thanks by pinkushun · · Score: 1

    Not even if they pay me.

  58. Re:Nope by JustNiz · · Score: 1

    ...and right on cue here's another post from just today about Microsoft screwing their own custoers over yet again:

    https://games.slashdot.org/sto...

  59. Re:I own Xbox one and a PS4 & various mobile d by MercTech · · Score: 1

    Naaa, I don't trust it.

    I bought an Xbox360 mainly for the media box functions and occasionally to game. Microsoft nerfed the media box function a month after I bought the Xbox. I don't trust Microsoft not to nerf the Xbox ONE's capability on a whim. Once burned, twice shy.

    --
    NRRPT/RCT
  60. Re:This is what I'd need to consider buying the XB by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

    Sony killed it first. Sony dropped PlayTV completely from PS3 to PS4. So I dropped Sony for the XBone so I'd be able to do OTA at all (without having to buy a separate DBV-T decoder, which I don't currently have). Since PS3 had a DVr, MS promised one, but when Sony didn't deliver an OTA at all, MS stopped focusing on competing with the missing feature. MS already beats Sony for TV features, so no need to try harder.