Some Retailers Criticize Amazon's Recall of Eclipse Glasses (kgw.com)
An anonymous reader quotes Portland TV station KGW:
Amazon issued a widespread recall for solar eclipse glasses early Saturday morning, one week before the August 21 eclipse. That move stunned some sellers who say their glasses are verified safe.... "We recommend that you DO NOT use this product to view the sun or the eclipse," Amazon wrote... "Out of an abundance of caution, we have proactively reached out to customers and provided refunds for eclipse glasses that may not comply with industry standards." At least a dozen KGW viewers said they received recall notices from Amazon Saturday... KGW viewer Heather Andersen said she bought two separate sets of solar glasses and learned both were not verified. "I give up," she tweeted...
Manish Panjwani's Los Angeles-based astronomy product business, AgenaAstro, has sold three times its average monthly revenue in the past month. Ninety-five percent is related to the solar eclipse... Panjwani's eclipse glasses come from two NASA-approved sellers: Thousand Oaks Optical in Arizona and Baader Planetarium in Germany. He said he provided documentation to Amazon proving the products' authenticity weeks ago, with no response from Amazon. On Saturday morning, he woke up to 100 emails from customers after Amazon issued a recall for his products. "People have some of the best glasses in the world in their hands right now and they don't believe in that product," he said. "They're out there looking for something inferior." Panjwani said Amazon is temporarily retaining some of his profits because of the recall. He also has almost 5,000 glasses at an Amazon warehouse, which customers can no longer purchase. "That's just sitting there. I cannot sell it and I cannot get it back in time for the eclipse," he said.
Manish Panjwani's Los Angeles-based astronomy product business, AgenaAstro, has sold three times its average monthly revenue in the past month. Ninety-five percent is related to the solar eclipse... Panjwani's eclipse glasses come from two NASA-approved sellers: Thousand Oaks Optical in Arizona and Baader Planetarium in Germany. He said he provided documentation to Amazon proving the products' authenticity weeks ago, with no response from Amazon. On Saturday morning, he woke up to 100 emails from customers after Amazon issued a recall for his products. "People have some of the best glasses in the world in their hands right now and they don't believe in that product," he said. "They're out there looking for something inferior." Panjwani said Amazon is temporarily retaining some of his profits because of the recall. He also has almost 5,000 glasses at an Amazon warehouse, which customers can no longer purchase. "That's just sitting there. I cannot sell it and I cannot get it back in time for the eclipse," he said.
News At 11
Reality is a slackware box running on a 386 tucked away in god's sock drawer.
Both Thousand Oaks Optical and Baader are really well-known in the astro community. They both have been making solar filters for a long time and I doubt they would jeopardize customers safety and their brand recognition like this.
These glasses are not safe for viewing the eclipse. Unless you want to qualify for the Darwin Award by wearing them and finding some way to get yourself killed while viewing the eclipse.
I realize it's asking a lot but RTFA.
Wow, if you're that scared about losing your job you must have close to nothing of value to offer employers.
it just means you do nothing of real value at your job and can be easily be replaced by someone in a 3rd world shit hole, be happy they dont say yes, and off shore the entire plant
What is a real kick in the pants is that the "unapproved" glasses I bought a few weeks ago were $15 for three pairs. Now the cheapest comparable glasses on Amazon are on the order of $35 to $50.
the lessons here are for small business owners, do not bet on amazon (or any other on-line retailers) to carry your business. Unless you are selling direct to the customer you have given up control to a middleman.
I feel sorry for the owner of the store, but he should have realized that adding another entity to his supply chain is reducing his control over his process. Hopefully he was diversified in his supplychain and also sold through other entities (ebay, shopify and a personal online store for example)
Yup - if you were selling good merchandise, then you should have warranted it as good, rather than putting up big disclaimers saying not to watch the eclipse with it.
We stop acting like children thinking a solar eclipse is a once in a life time event.
There's another one crossing the US in 2024 (south to north) by the way. And being in the path of totality is nothing special. Believe me I've been there, it's nothing to write home about.
The only reason to pay attention to this is if you're a scientist doing research. If you're not, you will be very disappointed.
can't get the day off, so this doesn't affect hard workers so I have trouble caring. My employer here in Seattle said we get no time off that entire week, so I'm not sympathetic to lazy people that don't want to work.
There's a difference between a "real" job, and a good job.
A good job means you can take vacation whenever you want to, because you work for an employer who understands work/life balance, and respects employee requests for time off.
I work hard to earn my time off, so I'm not sympathetic to that fucking pathetic "lazy" excuse of yours. The fact is your employer is a greedy bitch who's looking to maximize revenue at the expense of every employee. Enjoy that real job of yours. I'll be on vacation having trouble caring.
A massively hyped, one-time event that people know they need special equipment for but most have no idea what they actually need or how to verify what they have is legitimate. It's a scenario that's tailor made for scammers. I think someone at Amazon realized this, the potential liability issues and wisely decided to pull the plug even if there was a one time PR hit. Almost everything we buy that's not a consumable comes from Amazon but I wouldn't touch any of the glasses on Amazon, even if they say they're from a reputable manufacturer.
I'm upset about this mostly because of how close Amazon cut it. This could have been done a month ago (I've got a friend who bough some in early July and got one of these e-mails). Like some said above, that makes this look like profiteering now that prices for "Safe" ones are bumped up. Finding retailers that have them in stock, and can deliver before the eclipse is a problem at this point.
...As someone that has worked for twelve years without a single day off, I have no respect for their kind.
I have no respect or sympathy for robotic idiots who think that working twelve years without a single day off should impress the rest of the sane people on the planet.
Our kind is not lazy for wanting a day off. It's called being human. You should wake up and try it sometime. Might stop you from looking back on your life in utter disgust, since there is far more to life than working every fucking day.
I use amazon far too much. I rarely ever have problems with them, so I use them for almost everything. But eclipse glasses didn't work out. Got mine on walmart.com with no issues. In stock, no wait, far cheaper. Advertised as ISO certified. Delivered ISO certified. Made in the USA. They are no longer listed as available, but I am sure that when they can ship some more, they will show up again. Their supply chain apparently handles dynamic demand a bit better than amazon.
I have two friends that sell on amazon (other products, not solar glasses) and both have had bad experiences where amazon (with no warning) decides to just mess them over in random ways and denies their appeals. If you sell on Amazon, Amazon holds all the power and there is really nothing you can do when they decide to mess you over on a whim. You are completely at their mercy.
I bought a pack of 4 eclipse glasses. The listing on Amazon claimed they were ISO certified. However, before they arrived, I had some doubt about the glasses because the manufacturer was not listed as a supplier of safe glasses. When I went to look at the listing again, it had been taken down (not just zero available, but the product was not found).
When they arrived, there was no ISO marking on the glasses. In fact, there was a marking "Do not use for Sun glasses".
So, they went back, then about a day later, I received the email from Amazon warning me about these glasses.
The real "Libtards" are the Libertarians!
Because both customers AND suppliers gave it to them.
That's actually terrible advice - during the eclipse, the sun does not appear to be as bright, so it will be more "comfortable" to look directly at it, but there's still more than enough UV light to permanently damage your eyes.
A good job means you can take vacation whenever you want to, because you work for an employer who understands work/life balance, and respects employee requests for time off
A great many employers do not have the luxury of offering their employees unrestricted vacation time. If UPS or the post office told people there would be no deliveries on monday, because the entire workforce wanted the day off to watch the eclipse, there would be open riots in the streets.
Or, what is your opinion of the power company having un-staffed nuclear plants because everyone wants to watch the eclipse?
You live in a fantasy world jackass, get off your horse and take a look around you
Prick
I wish I had a good sig, but all the good ones are copyrighted
I hope people don't listen to your advice. They may permanently damage their eyes. As a result, they may sue you. From https://eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/... :
The only time that the Sun can be viewed safely with the naked eye is during a total eclipse, when the Moon completely covers the disk of the Sun. It is never safe to look at a partial or annular eclipse, or the partial phases of a total solar eclipse, without the proper equipment and techniques. Even when 99% of the Sun's surface (the photosphere) is obscured during the partial phases of a solar eclipse, the remaining crescent Sun is still intense enough to cause a retinal burn, even though illumination levels are comparable to twilight [Chou, 1981, 1996; Marsh, 1982]. Failure to use proper observing methods may result in permanent eye damage or severe visual loss. This can have important adverse effects on career choices and earning potential, since it has been shown that most individuals who sustain eclipse-related eye injuries are children and young adults [Penner and McNair, 1966; Chou and Krailo, 1981].
No he is absolutely right - for the actual total eclipse. If you use solar filters for that you will not see anything.
Starships were meant to fly, Hands up and touch the sky - Nicky Minaj
Glasses? Bah!
We kids applied smoke from a candle to glass microscope slides and watched the eclipse through that back in 1968 or so.
How about welding glasses?
This. Real jobs can't allow people time off. That's why I've never had more than a single contiguous day off since I started working after graduating college in 1986. Going 31 years without a real vacation sucks, but it means I know I'm valuable.
No, it's the other way around. My company would die if I don't work. Only useless people are allowed time off.
Going 31 years without a real vacation sucks, but it means I know I'm valuable.
It doesn't mean you're valuable... it means you are a slave to your job and have little value of your own time. It mean's you're a fucking idiot. I can 110% guarantee you that you're employer doesn't value you as much as you think they do.
As others have already point out, despite the PR hit, Amazon is smart to do a recall now and play it safe.
With co-mingling inventory, one inferior product can spoil the whole bunch. That's likely some of the issue. The other aspect is there seems to be no simple way for Amazon nor customers to verify glasses actually meet safe view requirements.
While most counterfeit / mislabeled products present little to no danger to customers, faulty eclipse glasses very well can. I can already foresee news stories of eclipse related eye injuries along with talk of litigation, etc. If Amazon was only a venue, more akin to eBay, they'd likely not have taken the blanket recall action they did.
Yup. Been sitting by a river all day playing guitar after quitting work this summer. One of my best days in a long time.
I'm going to view the eclipse by filming it. I don't care if glasses are "certified solar eclipse safe", I am not risking my eyesight over it.
All this, PLUS the eclipse heralds the start of WW3!
Jesus CHRIST, what next!!??!!
LOL@vword: "obscures"
And I'm going to watch those videos people put online for the same reason.
Should be I think -8 or somewhere close (not common), I use a -4 with dichroic coating as well as an additional layer of an active welding filter. Even a scratch can be problematic. I would never trust a 1/1000" plastic filter for anything not replaceable even though the active filter may only be 1/10^100th thick on either..
Let me repeat what others have already posted: Agena Astro is a great place to buy astronomy equipment. Thousand Oaks Optical solar filters have been some of the best for decades. Baader Optical solar products have been some of the best since they have been sold, (I'm not sure how long, but about 20 years in the US and maybe longer in Europe).
To me this is evidence that Amazon is incompetent.
I wouldn't be surprised is Amazon refuses to return the products back the the sellers.
If Amazon was interested in reality, they would come clean that the owner's real name is Bozo.
We are witnessing the birth of corporate fascism: the age where singlencorporations weild the kind of economic and political power that governments can only dream of.
When a government can regulate and directly control price and action on behalf of entire industries we call it "national socialism", aka fascism.
Amazon, Alibaba, Airbnb, Uber and these new "market platform" corporations now have more power over markets than even the Nazi party did.
The problem Amazon faces is true of all safety equipment. If some fly-by-night or foreign vendor puts sunglasses on the store as being fit for solar eclipse viewing Amazon is on hook for injuries. The same will be true of any other safety equipment that fails. As the only deep pocket left in sight, Amazon will bear the hole burden. It is the result of making sure the injured person is compensated if someone is more responsible than the injured person. Our system encourages knee-jerk decisions just like this to prevent injuries.
It's the American way. Once you move away from caveat emptor, it is the only logical stopping place.
The Google CEO was on vacation when he flew back into the Valley to fire that redpilled shitlord. The Google CEO takes vacations, are you saying you are more valuable than the CEO of Google? Impressive.
I wonder when they are issuing a general recall on most welding goggles/masks?
After all, you can get more damage, more quickly, if those are not up to standards.
Well? Amazon?
No, didnt think so..
Oh well, I am sure a pack of lawyers will have a whole lot of rather profitable fun from this.
"My employer here in Seattle..."
Seattle Misery
For the totality yes you don't need glasses for that time, but he was saying you don't need any eye protection before and after or outside of the path of totality. That is completely wrong.
According to Meade, my EclipseView glasses meet all relevant standards. Amazon needs to calm down. Who elected them official Eclipse Safety Gods?
I take exception to the statement "The only time that the Sun can be viewed safely with the naked eye is during a total eclipse, when the Moon completely covers the disk of the Sun."
When the Moon completely covers the disk of the Sun, you can't view the Sun at all. So, safe, OK, but misleading.
Clearly you're one of the useless ones then. If the company is that dependent upon a few non-owners, then they need to do something to fix the problem. If they think taking a day off, or really morning, to view the eclipse is that dangerous to their ability to stay in business, then what happens if you get hit by a car or a bus?
Taking the day off would be doing them a favor.
Not really, even the CEO can take weekends off if he's got things running properly. If you're that busy, it's because you aren't in the habit of saying no to unreasonable requests. You shouldn't have to do more than explain that by having weekends off that you'll be more productive the next week than if you were in on the weekend.
If that isn't sufficient, I'd recommend finding a job elsewhere that's competently managed. Sure, people can punch the clock for 60+ hours a week on a regular basis, but even if they aren't overtly goofing off during that time, it doesn't mean that all that time is being used productively. There's only so much time that a person can work without the quality being reduced to nothing. Chances are those last 10 or so hours aren't productive and dragging productivity for the rest of the day down the shitter.
Precisely. A CEO on vacation might have to break it off early if something important needs to be done, but if you've got no time for regular weekends or at least a week or two off a year, that's a sign that something isn't working out right.
People in that situation should start looking for other work and talk with the boss about getting days off to rest up so as to be more productive the next week. People who take no time off are shit workers that don't get anywhere near as much done as those that have reasonable numbers of days off to have a life.
Tbh
You'll see the corona. It's the best thing to look at.
Merit has gone out the door.
organizations with 'power' get to choose what is successful or not, based on facts or falsehoods.
Sorry, but most good employers know when people take time off and plan around it. You may be surprised, but not too many people are going to see the eclipse.
You put in your request for time off in advance, maybe a few months to a few weeks, and they'll likely approve it because it can be slotted into the work. The more time you give, the easier they will at approving your request. Do it last minute and results can be iffy, but even so most employers will provide for short term leave, if possible.
For the eclipse, most people probably don't care. Or since it happens on a work day, they might take 10 minutes from their day to go outside and take a look, then head back in later. Given smokers take smoke breaks, that's all it's really going to amount to - a bunch of people taking a smoke break. Most people will just see a partial eclipse. Those who are going to travel to see the full eclipse have put in their vacation requests weeks ahead of schedule, because they needed to book hotels and other things.
And while people are expecting chaos near the total eclipse path, it's not as bad as you think - maybe a million people total over the entire band, out of a population of over 300 million is not going to seriously affect anything.
Ans UPS and USPS and others not doing deliveries? I'm sure they have more than a few people taking the day off. They either have replacement workers ready to cover (easy to do when you plan ahead), or plan for reduced throughput that day, because honestly, most packages will not be missed if they were delivered on a Tuesday instead of Monday. And if they were, then perhaps you should've paid for (guaranteed) express delivery instead of economy.
The world doesn't stop turning when people take vacations. Good employers plan for it - they know Thanksgiving is going to be an odd week, so they plan for reduced workforce around it - either delaying deadlines, hiring coverage workers, or just planning for reduced productivity. Same goes around the winter break. And summer too - employers plan for a good chunk of people to simply take time off during the summer. Hell, in China, Chinese New Year means the entire country is off a couple of weeks. If Foxconn and others can plan on their entire workforce going on holidays for two whole weeks, planning on a handful of employees missing every day isn't difficult.
Life happens. People get sick. Often the person you need that information from either goes on holiday, gets ill, or is otherwise indisposed when you need them most. And people live.
Employers that don't allow their staff to take vacations because it impacts their deliverables are not running an efficient ship. They're running a potential disaster - if missing one employee impacts the business to the extent that the business can falter, then it is a business that will falter. Basically, your boss is squeezing everyone, probably to make a few extra bucks. Well, they can make more money by getting rid of stuff like UPSes and RAID in the server room too - it's the same thing whether it's hardware, software, or wetware. You plan for any of those to go down, at the worst possible moment, too.
And I'm going to watch a shaky vertical smartphone video recording of the eclipse being played back on youtube.
Better safe than sorry.
CLI paste? paste.pr0.tips!
People want their monopolies because everything else would be so horribly inconvenient. This is what you get in return.
American Paper Optics published a site with a guide on how to tell if you have fake APO glasses:
https://www.eclipseglasses.com...
I bought 40 pairs of supposedly APO glasses from a supposedly legitimate Amazon dealer and they are all fake. However, I did not get a recall notice from Amazon, and their site is telling me I cannot return them.
So they're recalling legit product and refusing returns for fake product. Sounds like a typical company run by a bunch of incompetent MBAs.
No. This is what we get when a large marketplace is too easily filled with knock-off goods by less than reputable sellers. As a buyer, I think Amazon should be as aggressive as possible in preventing counterfeits, especially when the counterfeits are basically hijacking the legitimate listings making it much more difficult to sort out which prices are for what. Over at eBay, where each item/seller is its own listing, this isn't a problem. I can confidently buy fakes at a vastly discounted price knowing that is what I'm doing. My last experience trying to sell on Amazon, I was trying to resell some DVDs I'd actually bought through Amazon, yet was denied the listing because of the risk of counterfeits. The aggravating part of that wasn't so much that Amazon was being safe, but that my legit goods wouldn't stand a chance against the fakes on eBay.
I do not have a signature
If you're one of those pussies who's afraid of UV light, you're probably not going to be going outside to look at it anyway.
Have you never enjoyed a day at the beach? An afternoon picnic? Are you one of those douches who wears dark sunglasses all the time?
Put them on.
Look at the sun
Do your eyes hurt, Is it too bright, or leaving spots?
--Yes- return These are garbage
--No- Pass these have been verified.
You're not a garden slug. You can tell if something is too bright to look at. If not better move into a cave.
You don't need eye protection any more than you do on a normal day. In fact you need less. Much less.
Take the amount of time you spend staring at the sun on a normal day and compare it to the amount of time you plan to spend staring at the eclipse factored by the average amount of eclipse coverage over that time. A few minutes of staring at an eclipse is nothing compared to about a century of existing on this planet. Unless you're a cave dweller. And like I said, if you're worried about it, use your built in sunglasses by squinting. If you're a pussy, use regular ol' sunglasses that block UV.
I;m not in the path of totality, and I plan to take a break during whatever the peak time is, step outside and look for a bit, say "neat", and then go back to work.
I'll let you know how my retinas fare. If you're lucky, I'll be blind and unable to shitpost on Slashdot.
The trick is for all the legit retailers to file a class action against Amazon in California. It is Amazon's own fault for letting in a massive number of no name knockoff vendors from China (or same with a single front person in the US forwarding their cheap knockoff junk with zero vetting).
Amazon should eat every penny of the losses because they are the ones that polluted their marketplace, not the legit vendors. I hate how Amazon has become a third world flea market in a lot of ways. I would much rather pay higher prices for legit, high quality products.
If you disagree, please post your argument. (-1, Overrated) isn't your personal censorship tool for views you don't like
Yes, Amazon is a knockoff centre of the internet (well maybe ebay) but they ignore emails and treat people worse.
I remember when they just sold books, but know it's any old shite.
I once brought an item and got some shit imatation instead. I hassled the dealer who did not respond, so hassled Amazon many time until I finally got a reply that they "VET" all the 3rd dealers and said this dealer was legit and selling authentic gear so I gave up in the end but eventually 2 months later I get a refund as appartently a "few" rogue dealers had managed to get into their 3rd dealership.. What a cock and bull storey.
You don't have these little things called EYES focusing the UV light.
Oh, and you might not realize but excessive UV does damage your skin. Luckily for you, skin heals quickly and easily except in extreme cases.
Your retina? Does. Not. Heal. Any damage is permanent and, while your eye will adapt and 'fill in' blank spaces of damaged retina you will forever have a demonstrable blind spot. Go google laser eye injuries for some funtastic examples of how well that goes over.
You can get rich if you own a politician, but you have to be rich to buy one in the first place.
You won't be blinded by glimpsing at the sun briefly...even if you do it a bunch of times over the years. Everyone knows that.
Staring at it for a few minutes straight? Very different story.
Kind of like the 1000's of hours of sun we all get but when we spend 6 hours straight at the beach we turn into a lobster. Skin heals. Retinas do not.
You can get rich if you own a politician, but you have to be rich to buy one in the first place.
If you (like me) bought glasses and then got a warning email from Amazon, the American Astronomical Society has a guide to checking your glasses
The glasses are so dark that for a moment, I thought I'd gotten scammed into buying opaque glasses. The sun shows up as a moderately bright disk. It's very weird to look at the sun.
You don't need eye protection any more than you do on a normal day. In fact you need less. Much less.
Take the amount of time you spend staring at the sun on a normal day and compare it to the amount of time you plan to spend staring at the eclipse factored by the average amount of eclipse coverage over that time. A few minutes of staring at an eclipse is nothing compared to about a century of existing on this planet. Unless you're a cave dweller. And like I said, if you're worried about it, use your built in sunglasses by squinting. If you're a pussy, use regular ol' sunglasses that block UV.
I know exactly what you mean! People keep telling me that I shouldn't put my hand in the gas flame of my stove, because I will get burned. But I say that the flame in my gas furnace is way bigger, and heats my whole freaking house! And yet apparently it is safe to use 5 months out of the year, even when I am asleep. But put a dinky little flame on the stove, and all of a sudden people are like "OH NOES, DON'T TOUCH THE FLAMES!". Pussies.
I've checked about 20+ retailers, and they're all sold out. Anyone have a source on where a pair of glasses can still be ordered in time for the eclipse?
Protect your browser with the Force Safe Search add-on
Yes, they didn't sell the certified products. Hoping to make a fast buck off the eclipse. Their products could in fact be safe, however because they are not certified, we don't know. And the seller doesn't really know either, but they got them and tried to sell them anyways. Too bad, so sad. But that is what you get trying to sell non-certified safety products. A warehouse of unsellable products. Next time they will learn to be more careful when trying to sell such things.
If something is so important that you feel the need to post it on the internet... It probably isn't that important.
That's why I got my time off request in in February. We're not going to close the company down, and I wanted to get it in early and beat the competition. There are places that can shut down.
If you can't get a vacation, find a real job. If your company will go broke if you take a week off, it's doomed anyway, because you're probably going to be out sick that long some time or another.
"When you have eliminated the unacceptable, whatever is left, however improbable, must be the truthiness" - Holmes
In 1979, I put down my welding glass to see totality and just stared at it. The corona was so beautiful. Then I missed Bailey's beads because they stabbed my eyes with sunlight and I automatically flinched and closed my eyes. Looking at anything other than a total eclipse during totality is a really bad idea, but most of us will react appropriately.
"When you have eliminated the unacceptable, whatever is left, however improbable, must be the truthiness" - Holmes
Not to mention the fact that Amazon outright refuses to do anything about fake reviews. Google some reviews on cheap mice and you'll see that they are fake, fake, fake. Ban the reviewer, and ban the vendor until he proves he is from the country he pretends to be from.
You can't sue someone because you did something obviously stupid like STARE DIRECTLY AT THE FUCKING SUN.
I ordered 10 from Orion Telescope with their branding on them and I can indeed see my CFL bulb from about 5 feet away. Is that of any indication they might not be safe?