Slashdot Mirror
Facebook Enabled Advertisers To Reach 'Jew Haters' (propublica.org)
ProPublica is reporting that Facebook "enabled advertisers to direct their pitches to the news feeds of almost 2,300 people who expressed interest in the topics of 'Jew hater,' 'How to burn jews,' or, 'History of why jews ruin the world.'" The organization even went so far as to test these ad categories by paying $30 to target those groups with three "promoted posts" -- in which a ProPublica article or post was displayed in their news feeds. Facebook reportedly approved all three ads within 15 minutes. From the report: After we contacted Facebook, it removed the anti-Semitic categories -- which were created by an algorithm rather than by people -- and said it would explore ways to fix the problem, such as limiting the number of categories available or scrutinizing them before they are displayed to buyers. In all likelihood, the ad categories that we spotted were automatically generated because people had listed those anti-Semitic themes on their Facebook profiles as an interest, an employer or a "field of study." Facebook's algorithm automatically transforms people's declared interests into advertising categories. [ProPublica provides a screenshot of their ad buying process on the company's advertising portal.]
"There are times where content is surfaced on our platform that violates our standards," said Rob Leathern, product management director at Facebook. "In this case, we've removed the associated targeting fields in question. We know we have more work to do, so we're also building new guardrails in our product and review processes to prevent other issues like this from happening in the future."
"There are times where content is surfaced on our platform that violates our standards," said Rob Leathern, product management director at Facebook. "In this case, we've removed the associated targeting fields in question. We know we have more work to do, so we're also building new guardrails in our product and review processes to prevent other issues like this from happening in the future."
Who lists "Jew hater" as their occupation on Facebook? Why do I feel like 4chan figured out how their algorithms work and did this to troll FB?
Every left wing progressive who hates Israel was targeted.
It's nice to know that everything can be monetized somehow. A few black-out drunken rants later and for some reason I keep getting advertisements for swastika flags and replica WWII gear.
eric cartman
If they didn't the whole "hating jews" thing would die and they're not finished exploiting the past. Gotta keep up the horse and pony show.
It's not that Facebook is targeting any group; it's this "advertiser" putting in a string which matched.
Much as I dislike Facebook for their intrusiveness, I wouldn't go so far to say that they would have this as a category.
Any word on what they were selling to "jew haters?"
He was already using Fiver.
Twitter, Facebook, Google and other companies keep blaming some sir or madamn called "algorithm" for everything they do wrong these days?
The devil is in the details:
You are welcome on my lawn.
Ever heard of a self fulfilling prophecy? As soon as you pigeon hole yourself as being persecuted you instantly become persecuted by no one but yourself. Make your own opportunities and learn to compete if you want to get anywhere in this world.
Why shouldn't Propublica be allowed to counter antisemitism with ads? It sounds like an optimistic use of the ad platform. Since the ads are clearly marked it should be appreciated by the prospective antisemites as above-board discussion and not fuel the (increasingly valid, TBQH) complaints of a Jewish censorship conspiracy infiltrating Silicon Valley.
I'm not saying I think Jews are a problem, but I am saying that maybe buying ads is a better approach to countering antisemitism than getting Nazi Troll websites kicked off the Internet via sketchy backdoor deals with registrars and DDoS companies. The latter strategy will probably turn out to be counterproductive, but ads sound more like redirectmethod.org, an approach I think has more hope than liberal censorship.
It's not grouped by political affiliation, it's more or less whether they believe in Jewish conspiracy run from Israel or not. And that in turn depends on the media they consume. (which usually is fringe stuff).
If you flip it over, turn "Jew" to "Muslim", then its very similar with small groups believing that all muslims are somehow controlled by ISIS.
of antisemitism there, but none the incidence have been traced to left leaning groups and the staff has consistently denounced antisemitism even if they don't outright ban it. As for why banning it isn't helpful, well there's a good reason why right here. Letting them hold their little rallies and seeing how few show up to rally is way more productive then banning them.
Hi! I make Firefox Plug-ins. Check 'em out @ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-mp3-podcaster/
I assume anti-white movements such as Black lives matter, Immigration, refugee and asylum advocates, Jewish people pushing for the destruction of all white societies, globalist socialist and capitalism, un-democratic hating anti-freedom-of-speech groups who don't want any white people to have a saying about their own lands and societies destinies and such are all fine to just carry on.
How many used the term and what did they try to sell?
Aah, discrimination: the cause of, and solution to, all of life's problems.
Corruption is convincing someone that the selfless ideal is the same as their selfish ideal.
"After we contacted Facebook, it removed the anti-Semitic categories -- which were created by an algorithm rather than by people"
On FB even the algorithms are Nazis, that's what we can expect from AI.
http://balder.org/judea/Hate-Speech-Laws-Immigration-Jewish-Influence-Britain.php
Anybody care to rebut anything on that webpage? Try to avoid using laughable terms like 'anti-semitic' or 'full of hate', or 'shame on you'...
Why are Jews allowed to torture baby boys? Do you know what circumcision is? Why is this even legal? What sort of sick monsters do that to a baby?
Any comments?
Finally a way to target those vaginal douches to the most deserving audience.
Slashdot social media options: AIM, ICQ, Yahoo, Jabber and Mobile Text. Why no MySpace?
So removing that category also removed them from existence and removes their profile data? Wow, who knew? In fact it magically makes racism go away by plugging your ears and pretending you don't hear it. That's SJW logic right there. By the way, "jew haters" buy products too.
One should also remember that a lot of this is just modern propaganda. Protesters are being silenced who criticise the genocide of Palestinians by the state of Israel. Since WW1 Israel has killed more palestinians than Nazis killed Jews. The area where Israel is now hold huge amount of Palestinian at the time of WW1. Their numbers have been reduced to a bare minimum, but they are still allowed to stay alive: if they are all gone, the world realises the scale of the genocide and stops supporting Israel and their allies.
All this has been OK'd by USA, UK and France and the media reflects fully their decision.
Hello Your site is very good! I like it!!. It is very helpful site. Thank you so much Please Check My Website : http://www.divit.co.in/female-...
The British Labour Party could make good use of this in targeted marketing.
Facebook Enabled Advertisers To Reach 'Jew Haters'
Well I guess someone has to sell to the muslims
Facebook is just providing a category to advertisers here. It doesn't mean at all they will allow hate speech to appear in ads. And if they do, this is another but completely unrelated matter.
TFA goes on and on about how they are outraged because they were able to submit an acceptable ad to be seen by unacceptable people. If it means that "jew haters" shouldn't be able to get ads, by all means, make me a Nazi.
Removing the category also prevent anti hate speech organizations from targeting the people they want to change. I suppose it also prevents advertisers from filtering out "jew haters". Typical bury-your-head-in-the-sand type PR move. Removing the category won't make the people go away.
And if anything, it won't stop advertisers who target these people for bad reasons. They are probably already using correlations to avoid scrutiny. As members of hate groups, they already know all they subtle ways they use to recognize each others.
If you look at the ad-buying screenshot, these categories are under "Education - Field of Study" which leads me to believe these are anthropologists as opposed to hate group members.
the Jew will always tell you about his beating, but never why.
Show the people that fall into these categories ads aimed at changing their views. Or direct them to the nearest re-education camp, or whatever
So they removed the Trump category?
YOLO DIGITS!
DIGITAL DIGIBITS IN YOUR _ANUS_
I FEEL YOLO DIGITS IN YOUR DIGITS. DIGITAL INFORMATION STREAMS.
I am Christopher McNeal and I feel the information superhighway is channeling my LOINS.
DIGITAL DIGIBIT COMPRESSOR BITLY!1!
RU INTEREST IN DIGITAL DATABITLIES
DIGITAL 3DPRINTED MACHINELEARNING FOMO
I WAS IN tHE SHRUBBERY,
once a FATEFUL night.
I felt the tender BITLY,
the bit-structured ramming,
of the AI ROD
BITS IN BITSTREAMS, DIGITAL BITSTREAMS DATASTREAM BITS INFORMATION ENCODED BITSTREAMS
( O )( O ) :-8(
Indeed, there wasn't some employee at Facebook that said "hey, let's put these strings into our advertising system! We'll make great $$$!". It's there rudimentary "AI" system that is pulling in information from various places that determined this. It is more of a reflection of society and blame should not be laid out on Facebook. This really is a "shoot the messenger" scenario. As soon as Facebook realized what was happening, they took steps to rectify it. Their "AI" isn't really intelligent, it's just pattern matching, so GIGO.
You just described APK's entire wardrobe
The only claim I have seen making the case that Karl Marx was not an anti-Semite says that he was not saying that Jews were evil...just that self-identifying as Jewish was evil.
Marx, of course, was himself Jewish. This would make him a self-hating Jew, which is quite a different stereotype than a anti-Semite.
You might want to read Karl Marx's book "On The Jewish Question".
And you might want to as well, since you're citing it without having read it.
This is not a "bad" thing on its face. It could be used by groups like the SPLC or ADL to target advertising campaigns to people who might "need" it rather than waste their money preaching to the choir.
What is it with this deep psychological need to be perpetually offended, and to set out in the world digging for things to be offended over? These are the people that deserve to be in concentration camps, not members of any particular race or religion.
Have gnu, will travel.
See subject: The Nazi's killed members of my family (children drained of blood for their soldiers' transfusions) & imprisoned my Grandfather, Grandmother, Father, Aunt & Uncle during WWII (forced labor camps) + stole their land & business (lumber), so you are WRONG - period.
APK
P.S.=> HOWEVER - You have to ask yourselves WHY Jews are so almost universally disliked though & WHY they've been banned in @ least 10 nations throughout history (not all were Nazi Germany - Russia, Spain, England, France, Argentina, Egypt + Rome) - Search Harold Wallace Rosenthal interview & see why, from a Jew (Khazar Pharisee Talmudic jew)... apk
If you create content by a purely random process, or else get content through user input (which is like random, only malicious and sick), you must filter out the objectionable material that is guaranteed to be there! Remember Tay, Microsoft's Nazi Teen Chat Bot?.
Starships were meant to fly, Hands up and touch the sky - Nicky Minaj
See subject: The Nazi's killed members of my family (children drained of blood for their soldiers' transfusions) & imprisoned my Grandfather, Grandmother, Father, Aunt & Uncle during WWII (forced labor camps) + stole their land & business (lumber), so you are WRONG - period.
APK
P.S.=> HOWEVER - Ask WHY Jews are so almost universally disliked though & WHY they've been banned in @ least 10 nations throughout history (not all were Nazi Germany - Russia, Spain, England, France, Argentina, Egypt + Rome) - Search Harold Wallace Rosenthal interview & see why, from a Jew (Khazar Pharisee Talmudic jew)... apk
Nazis were a splinter group of socialists bred from progressivism. Mussolini was a card-carrying Communist before he formed his Black Shirts.
My best evidence is a Goebbels quote from 1925: "Lenin is the greatest man, second only to Hitler, and that the difference between Communism and the Hitler faith is very slight."
But there is much, much more.
> Except for the largest antisemitic group in history, the Nazis who were decidedly right wing.
The National Socialists were authoritarian more than anything. And there have been plenty of authoritarians of every political stripe. They both enacted socialist policies and backstabbed other socialist groups to get what they wanted. Trying to lump people you hate in with the Nazis is the oldest game on the internet.
The things that made Nazis uniquely terrible were the extermination campaign they waged in their death camps. So if you want to accuse someone of something, do it directly, rather than trying to smear people by association.
OK so a Jew is traveling and wants his search engine to find the nearest synagogue for services. Being able to find every synagogue within 30 miles in a search engine would be a huge aid to race haters. (I am aware that Jews are not a race.) But if you start eliminating information that could be very useful for innocent users you are making a huge mistake. Let the loonies rant and rave. Let them march about in their weird choice of costumes. it makes it so easy to follow them home and pay special attention to them later.
True, but Tsarist Russia and the bead-jigglers were at it for centuries. The Nazis barely had a decade.
Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
If its bad, il gladly type racist shit all over the internet if it makes facebook and google leave me alone.