Slashdot Mirror


User: TuringTest

TuringTest's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
1,679
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 1,679

  1. Check your science on 60% Of U.S. Believe Life Exists On Other Planets · · Score: 1


    The binding energies of the carbon atom are neither too strong nor too weak to allow the required complexity of molecules for life functions...
    as we understand them.

    molecules based on silicon are much more difficult to break apart and re-assemble in the myriads of configurations that are constantly happening in all..
    earthling life forms

    it is very safe to assert that no
    earth-like life forms can be based on anything other than the element carbon.

  2. Re:meh on IT Giants Accused of Exploiting Open Source · · Score: 1

    So proprietry code is the Dark Side of Source?

  3. Re:What about gay children? on Genetic Testing For Geekiness? · · Score: 1


    It's also not enough to rely on people's subjective experience of why they are gay or not.


    Trust me, hornyness is quite an objective experience. And it's not chosen.

  4. Solaris on 60% Of U.S. Believe Life Exists On Other Planets · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Any physical life forms, obeying the laws of physics as we know them cannot be too radically different from life on earth.

    That's a anthropocentric prejudice, similar to thinking that Earth is the center of the universe (isn't it obvious?). Also your phrase "Because the laws of physics appear to operate uniformly throughout the Universe as far as we have observed until now, the only physical life allowed must be based on carbon, just like life on Earth" is more a guess than an established fact.

    Have you seen Solaris? (the novel, not the movies). It described an alien intelligent life in the form of a whole planet: the ocean itself had evolved to react to the environment in order to sustain its existence.

    That lifeform wouldn't have a need to "communicate", "feed" itself or any other action that we usually relate to life. This kind of "alien" life is what the previous poster was arguing. It has nothing to do with spirituality, the Bible or alternate planes of existence.

  5. Re:Lucas will screw it up, I'd wager... on Spielberg & Lucas Approve Indy 4 Script · · Score: 1

    Oh, so you have formed an opinion on the prequels without actually having seen them all. Suddenly, the incessant whining around here makes a little more sense.

    You mean, he can't have a separate opinion on each one of them?

    I did the same thing, and have watched Episode II last week for the first time. The story was a little bit better than in Episode I (not difficult, because it haven't any story at all). But the movie was boring, the FX were plain and the acting was as bad as everybody had previously told me.

    So yes, one can have a very good sense of what a movie will be by only seeing other works from the same director.

  6. Re:Why Do Smart People Defend Bad Ideas? on Why Smart People Defend Bad Ideas · · Score: 1

    There is no need for a beggining og God.

    Yes, but also the Aquinas argument doesn't prove that God's existence is necessary. Which was the original point.

  7. Begging the question on Why Smart People Defend Bad Ideas · · Score: 2, Informative

    But if you do that in this context then you're falling to the "begging the question" fallacy (the "What created God" is relevant in terms of the Thomas Aquinas demonstration of the existence of God, explained in the GP's post).

    If you state that God exists by definition, then you can't use their properties to demonstrate the existence of God. Either you accept (as you do) that God is a definition and not a proven fact, or you admit that Aquinas' logic is not sound because God fails to conform to the laws of physics (and thus a physical reasoning can't prove its existence).

  8. Re:Another Trilogy? on Another Star Wars Prequel? · · Score: 1

    ...but then how are you going to make a trilogy?

    0
    00
    000

  9. A long, long... on Another Star Wars Prequel? · · Score: 1

    long, long, long, long, long, long, long, long time ago...

  10. Re:Obligatory on Blank Keyboard · · Score: 1


    That's the beauty of it! Any key can be the 'any' key!


    Better yet, on this keyboard ALL keys are the 'any' key!

  11. Re:Human physics on Review: Star Wars Episode III · · Score: 1

    You should know that "mundane" also means "relating to this world" (from latin mundus, "world").

    So by definition all physics is mundane, in a very literal way. You could see this as the honor of recognicing the very nature of this science.

  12. Makes you wonder... on "Get the Facts" Campaign Working · · Score: 5, Insightful

    what are the percentages of IT managers and CIO who were not interested in Linux, were not sure about Linux, and planned to evaluate Linux before the Get the Facts campaign started?

  13. Spanish Constitution on Teacher Fired for P2P Lecture · · Score: 1

    Article 20

    1. The following rights are recognized and protected:

    a) the right to freely express and disseminate thoughts, ideas and opinions by word, in writing or by any other means of communication;

    b) the right to literary, artistic, scientific and technical production and creation;

    c) the right to academic freedom;

    d) the right to freely communicate or receive accurate information by any means of dissemination whatsoever. The law shall regulate the right to invoke personal conscience and professional secrecy in the exercise of these freedoms.

    2. The exercise of these rights may not be restricted by any form of prior censorship.

    3. The law shall regulate the organization and Parliamentary control of the social communications media under the control of the State or any public agency and shall guarantee access to such media to the main social and political groups, respecting the pluralism of society and of the various languages of Spain.

    4. These freedoms are limited by respect for the rights recognized in this Title, by the legal provisions implementing it, and especially by the right to honour, to privacy, to personal reputation and to the protection of youth and childhood.

    5. The confiscation of publications and recordings and other information media may only be carried out by means of a court order.

  14. Re:Two dilemmas on BSA Reacts to 'New' BitTorrent · · Score: 0

    Seems like you forgot to wear your tinfoil hat ;-)

  15. Re:Formatted on Google's New Personalized Homepage · · Score: 1


    I love the movie btw.


    What! Is there a Google movie? What's the title: The Found of Googling?

    I figure that they will release it first in beta...

  16. Re:OK Colin, Well done on Hyper-Threading, Linus Torvalds vs. Colin Percival · · Score: 1

    You, sir, made me laugh.

  17. Re:OK Colin, Well done on Hyper-Threading, Linus Torvalds vs. Colin Percival · · Score: 4, Insightful

    If this was about Microsoft and Bill refused to fix the vulnerability, nobody else could write a patch for the sources to solve the problem. See the difference?

  18. Re:No Way on The Video iPod is on its Way · · Score: 1

    Not to flamebait, but it would help for getting answers if you formatted your text with some whitespace in order to make it readable...

    You might want to read some insightful essays by a usability guru on this very subject, addresing the forces that affect the problem and an existing solution.

  19. Re:NSFC? Try VerySFC. on Next Step in Human Evolution · · Score: 1

    In conclusion, speciation by natural selection does occur (at least in a few cases demonstrably -- polar gulls, etc.), but I think there has to be another mechanism in there

    Congratulations, you have discovered variations due to sexed reproduction. I.e. not all variations in individuals are generated by mutations, almost all are due to gene recombination.

  20. Re:Regarding Lightsabers on The Feasibility of Star Wars Tech · · Score: 1

    Energy management in SW may be awesome, but automatic tracking system were awful - they had to aim by hand!

  21. Re:Not to be a spoilsport here... on Star Wars Sickout · · Score: 1

    So actually the Sarlaac digestive tract was a life-expander?

  22. Re:Not freedom? on Key Advantage of Open Source is Not Cost Savings · · Score: 1

    If you are a billion dollar corporation with a multi-million dollar support, you don't need that communist concept of "freedom". You have power instead. Freedom is good for the rest of us.

  23. Re:Wrong. on Cracking the Google Code... Under the GoogleScope · · Score: 1

    The "correct" design should give you results relavent to what you searched for. i.e. "Tiger" or "Tigers" should give you info about furry creatures (and potentially furry creatures in advertising and sports), because that's what you searched for.

    That's what Answers.com does. Also when you google for tigers. But the word "Tiger" is the name of an important operating system, and that's what Google should find.

  24. Re:Another Roland Piquepaille special! on Rejected Scientific Paper Recycled as an Ad · · Score: 1
    Slashdot is the proof that market forces don't provide an optimal solution.

    /. is valuable because of its attention share. Any other weblog, even with higher editing standards, can't compete with the Slashdot mindshare.

  25. First patch on Apple to Release first Tiger Update · · Score: 0, Troll

    What, they've already released Tiger? I didn't even notice and there's even a patch!