Slashdot Mirror


User: mtrachtenberg

mtrachtenberg's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
245
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 245

  1. Confidence versus rational confidence on Researchers Devise Voting System That Seems Secure, But Is Hard To Use · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It is conceivable that the World's Cleverest People (WCP) will devise a system that reliably enables people to vote over the internet. And researchers tell us America is no longer a democracy, so I suppose it doesn't really matter that only the WCP will have rational reason to have confidence in the system.

    But for those of us who think people should be able to prove to their own satisfaction that their vote was counted as cast, paper inserted into witnessed boxes and then counted in public seems like a better idea. It will never make Microsoft rich, though, so I doubt Microsoft Research will admit this.

  2. This is a disgrace. In America, only the NSA, other secret police type organizations, and J. Edgar Hoover are entitled to this data. I'll bet this is Snowden's fault. SCHULTZ!!!

  3. Re:Last Sentence... the point of this exercise. on Tesla's Household Battery: Costs, Prices, and Tradeoffs · · Score: 2

    No, the easiest way to bring battery prices down is to use a different chemistry. Li ion is spectacularly unsuited to a stationary battery.

  4. inappropriate technology[ was Re:Gamechanger] on Tesla Announces Home Battery System · · Score: 1

    Lithium ion batteries are great for mobile. They are far from the best available solution for stationary power. There are a lot of battery companies out there with safer, less-expensive, but less energy-dense battery chemistries.

    Elon Musk needs to sell a lot of lithium ion batteries as part of his business model, and he understands how to work the system incredibly well. I just hope that this prettily-packaged bad solution to a real problem doesn't damage the ability of others to build good solutions.

    Cogeneration is a great example of a naturally home-based or factory-based solution, because it captures heat that would otherwise be wasted, puts it to work, and eliminates distribution losses. And battery backup is needed to make the grid more flexible, but should be done with appropriate tech. Power shifting from one time slot to another would be much more sensibly done with batteries designed for stationary use. And, except for the advantage in a power failure, there is little reason to locate batteries in people's homes. To the extent anyone wants batteries at home, I hope they'll at least choose more appropriate batteries than lithium ion.

  5. Re:Batteries on Tesla Announces Home Battery System · · Score: 1

    Lithium ion batteries are great for mobile. They are far from the best available solution for stationary power. Check out Aquion, as one example aimed at stationary storage.

    Elon Musk needs to sell a lot of lithium ion batteries as part of his business model, and he understands how to work the system incredibly well. I just hope that this prettily-packaged bad solution to a real problem doesn't damage the ability of others to build good solutions.

    Cogeneration is a great example of a naturally home-based or factory-based solution, because it captures heat that would otherwise be wasted, puts it to work, and eliminates distribution losses. And battery backup is needed to make the grid more flexible, but should be done with appropriate tech. Power shifting from one time slot to another would be much more sensibly done with batteries designed for stationary use. And, except for the advantage in a power failure, there is little reason to locate batteries in people's homes. To the extent anyone wants batteries at home, I hope they'll at least choose more appropriate batteries than lithium ion.

  6. A Spectacular Political Statement on Seattle CEO Cuts $1 Million Salary To $70K, Raises Employee Salaries · · Score: 1

    This is not just a good thing for Gravity's employees, it is also an enormously thought-provoking action at a time when such actions are rare.

    Even imagining that high tech is a true meritocracy, which is a fairly dubious imagining, American companies are still floating in the sea of American business. And America has been heading towards historic levels of income inequality, higher than the levels that preceded the great depression. We tend not to learn our lessons until we shoot ourselves in the foot or higher. This CEO is demonstrating the obvious -- once you are making a ton of money, you can begin to share it with the people who have helped, are helping, and will continue to help you make even more, and this can have a positive impact not just on the people you are sharing with, but on YOURSELF as well, and on your society.

    A positive impact on yourself, because you will be appreciated and honored for doing a very decent thing.

    And, if your society were to pick up on your lesson, all sorts of good things could happen: it would be less likely that your children will get an infectious disease, because other children would be healthier; you would be less likely to have to pay for more prisons, because people are less likely to turn to crime when they are able to participate in a flourishing economy; you would not need to invest quite so much in alarm systems for your mansions. You might find the public schools improving because there would be fewer people going to private schools. You might even need to invest less in a military because with less income inequality, the politicians' focus might change from protecting our billionaire class' stolen overseas assets to protecting our country while aiding the poor in our own and other countries.

  7. The NSA requests you stop sealing envelopes on The NSA Wants Tech Companies To Give It "Front Door" Access To Encrypted Data · · Score: 5, Insightful

    As you all know, our country is subject to terrible terrorist threats. It has come to the attention of your friends at the National Security Agency ("we put the security in the national") that terrorists have, under certain circumstances, used the United States Postal Service, United Parcel Service, and Federal Express in order to facilitate their terrorist doings. Therefore, we would appreciate it if, effective immediately, you stop sealing your parcels and envelopes, to make inspection easier.

    This is for your protection. Please don't object, or we'll have to illegally open your items and lie about it. Thank you.

  8. Re:thank God they didn't have computers.... on Florida Teen Charged With Felony Hacking For Changing Desktop Wallpaper · · Score: 1

    "we'd have to move the classes to prison"

    Hey! Wouldn't that be great for the GDP, especially if the prison were private?!

  9. "We let this man into our very own bunker, where we monitor everything that everyone says, even our bosses," said Rajesh De. "And then he went and told our bosses what we were doing. Let me tell you, it was a deep,deep sense of betrayal."

  10. Re:Millionaire Celebrity Thug and Bigot Dismissed on Jeremy Clarkson Dismissed From Top Gear · · Score: 1

    Gosh, Anonymous Coward, it looks like you understood exactly which word I was referring to, so I suppose my communication was successful.

  11. Millionaire Celebrity Thug and Bigot Dismissed on Jeremy Clarkson Dismissed From Top Gear · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The correct headline would be "Millionaire Celebrity Thug and Bigot Finally Dismissed by BBC."

    The correct subhead would be "Assault on staff last straw, after insults to Mexico and use of n-word insufficient to force BBC executives to punish their cash cow."

  12. In related news.... on Ikea Unveils Furniture That Charges Your Smartphone Wirelessly · · Score: 1

    Ikea proudly announces the first induction-heating sofa.

  13. Re:The Real Lie - faking statistics on Lawmakers Seek Information On Funding For Climate Change Critics · · Score: 1

    This is fairly hopeless, I see.

    I'm sure the IPCC, like any other bureaucracy, has problems. But you cannot take a situation where there is no consensus and fool everyone into believing that there is a 98% or 99% consensus. The consensus may be wrong, but I do believe in playing the odds.

    I'm sure there are occasional credible people who disagree with it; we are not machines. I'm sure there are people agreeing just because there is a consensus; again, we are not machines. But to suggest that the vast majority of those who have the ability to study the subject have not reached consensus about certain issues is simply to deny reality.

    You can easily see the effect of propaganda when you compare public opinion of the IPCC in countries like the UK with public opinion of the IPCC in countries like the United States. The GOP and Tea Party have succeeded in destroying belief in any neutral organizations because, as Ronald Reagan explained to us, "facts are stupid things," and, as Upton Sinclair wrote, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"

  14. Re:The Real Lie - faking statistics on Lawmakers Seek Information On Funding For Climate Change Critics · · Score: 1

    The procedures used by the IPCC to gather data and come to consensus are described here: http://www.ipcc.ch/

    I suggest you read them, because it is clear you haven't. I'd also suggest you read the lists of authors of the working group reports. Perhaps you might consider contacting a few of them to find out why they believe what they believe. Until you've done so, you're not worth taking seriously.

    Also, I notice you do not respond to the fact that United States elections may be purchased like any other commodity, according to the persons appointed to the supreme court. There is a clear and accepted correlation between expenditures on advertising buys and ad-market voting results, yet the persons appointed to the supreme court do not believe in preventing the expenditures of millions (or, for that matter, trillions) of dollars on advertising buys by the interested parties who got them appointed. That makes your own interests very clear.

  15. The Liars on Lawmakers Seek Information On Funding For Climate Change Critics · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Well, I suppose it's a good thing if it can be demonstrated that the Koch Brothers and other fossil fuel interests are behind the vanishingly small number of still-reputable scientists issuing climate change lies. But, really, when you have 98% or 99% consensus, you don't need to wonder if the 1 or 2% are lying or just wrong. There are no areas in life where we find ourselves unable to operate with a consensus of 98% or 99%.

    So the problem is not that a few scientists are wrong, or willing to be bought. The problem is that the people we elect are willing to destroy the planet for the benefit of their reelection. And the problem is that substantial numbers of voters are stupid and so incredibly self-interested that they are willing to trade their children's future for some politician's "promise" of "jobs, jobs, jobs."

    Capitalism as we see it is a complete failure, allowing 85 individuals to control equivalent assets to several billion people, and legally treating the destruction of the planet as just another externality. "Democracy" as it is practiced in the United States is a game played by advertisers and strategists; really, all you need do to understand the depth of the fraud is to realize that advertisers "buy" points with advertising buys. It's not a democracy if you've learned you can predictably alter the point spread with a "buy" of a certain size.

    There is no longer *any* legitimacy to our national-level institutions, and for the Senate or House to "investigate" fraud is a joke.

  16. Thank you, NSA on How "Omnipotent" Hackers Tied To NSA Hid For 14 Years and Were Found At Last · · Score: 1

    Thank you, National Security Agency, for doing such a truly brilliant job of damaging future prospects for the American computer hardware industry. Smart move to leave the torture to the CIA, no reason for geeks to get their hands dirty. You, along with the CIA, daily provide the rest of the world with evident of how deeply, incredibly stupid supposedly smart people can be when they don't mix with grown-ups. Congratulations!

  17. We need to teach people to think, and to use tools on Should We Really Try To Teach Everyone To Code? · · Score: 5, Informative

    Ah, the computer, that magnificent "universal machine."

    Have you ever watched as someone tries to take information from, say, Microsoft Word, and use it to do mailing labels? Especially if the information has been formatted to be "pretty." Let me tell you, it ain't pretty.

    We don't need for people to learn to "code." We also don't need for people to learn how to use particular proprietary products. We need for people to learn things like basic math, basic logic, and understand how they can use computers, with a teensy bit of effort and understanding, to accomplish their unique and specific tasks. We also need to teach people that they should not feel helpless when confronted with a computer program that doesn't do precisely what they want.

    I feel a bit Mao-ish on this subject, and truly think the best solution would be to issue a voltage surge to all existing infrastructure, and not allow anyone to buy any replacement computers until they demonstrate an understanding of their jobs (not the computers' jobs, the individual workers' jobs).

  18. Re:Smartthings on Ask Slashdot: Panic Button a Very Young Child Can Use · · Score: 1

    The "open this door" is a great idea. Another approach might be a sound sensor and/or vibration sensor that will send out the message. That way, if your two year old starts crying hysterically or your wife screams or (possibly) your wife falls hard, you'll get a notification.

  19. Don't watch if you don't want to watch on An Argument For Not Taking Down Horrific Videos · · Score: 1

    As someone who has managed to avoid watching the video of the Jordanian pilot being intentionally burned to death, I thought I would share my approach, which didn't involve removing it from the internet. I did not click, and I don't watch Fox News. Actually, I don't watch any mainstream TV news; I listen to the radio and read online sites run by newspapers (the Guardian, mainly) and other organizations (Pro Publica).

    This has saved me enormous amounts of time, and spared me from having to tut-tut when TV newsreaders working for General Electric, Westinghouse, or other large successful corporations turn out to be liars and frauds. It also prevents me from having nightmares from watching people being bombed by governments, burned to death by other terrorists, and yet I still feel relatively informed about just how disastrous 21st century capitalist fraud has been for humanity.

  20. Re:Science by democracy doesn't work? on Science By Democracy Doesn't Work · · Score: 1

    In other recent news, the United States Senate recently passed legislation requiring that all government contractors use 3 as the value for pi. Asked for comment, Sen. Inhofe stated "irrational numbers are the devil's spawn, and America is a Christian nation. We use wholesome whole numbers in this country."

  21. what's wrong with this picture on Pope Francis To Issue Encyclical On Global Warming · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I remain mystified by how such a sane and decent person has risen so high within a large institution.

  22. Re:Well, duh on The Dominant Life Form In the Cosmos Is Probably Superintelligent Robots · · Score: 1

    IIRC, they operated at EM speeds, not mechanical speeds.

  23. Re:Well, duh on The Dominant Life Form In the Cosmos Is Probably Superintelligent Robots · · Score: 2

    Peter Watts -- Blindsight. Superb.

  24. Top Management on Ask Slashdot: Can a Felon Work In IT? · · Score: 1

    Two words: Top Management.

  25. Backtracking on Shale: Good For Gas, Oil...and Nuclear Waste Disposal? · · Score: 2

    As I get older I am less impressed by the infinitesimal bit of knowledge that science has revealed and more impressed by the vast gulf of ignorance it has revealed. I hope however it is that our elites choose to bury this stuff, they invest at least a little attention to being able to dig it all up again when it turns out they were wrong about whatever.