Slashdot Mirror


User: schwnj

schwnj's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
21
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 21

  1. Re:Psychology is a science. on Dutch Psychologist Faked Data In At Least 30 Scientific Papers · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Your comment betrays you. Why on earth do you think that psychology does not involve controlled and reproducible experiments? Why do you think it is based on post-hoc reasoning? Like I said, you need to merely look into psychological research to see your error.

  2. Psychology is a science. on Dutch Psychologist Faked Data In At Least 30 Scientific Papers · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Every time a story appears that involves psychological research, numerous people make comments about how psychology is a sham, not a science, fluffy, or some other degrading adjective. I usually find that these people haven't the foggiest idea what psychology actually is. I'm willing to bet that many people here that are claiming psychology as a non-science are thinking about what is actually therapy or counseling. I suggest any doubters read actual psychology journals before they make such claims. Much of the advancement in our understanding of neurophysiology, sensory systems, cognitive processing, decision-making, social behavior, and human development is due to research conducted under the umbrella of psychology. The problem is that the public isn't aware of psychology's breadth.

  3. Re:Professors, not high school teachers on Teacher Union Tries To Block Online Courses · · Score: 2

    I'm all for well-paid educators, but I have no use for the dead weight whose focus is their research and paper-writing. If you want to do pure research, find a lab some where, don't drain the university and college systems. With the many thousands of dollars students pay for their education, they deserve better.

    I think you're overlooking the fact that 1) teaching oriented schools usually focus on professors who can teach and who do very little research 2) research oriented schools are necessary for graduate education, which involves levels of complexity and skill beyond the realm of simply being a "good teacher." Some people have proposed separating graduate professors/researchers from undergraduate professors. That is something that could work, but at the same time, I would hope that undergrads would want to learn from accomplished researchers, even if the material is dry. That being said, there are still deadwood types who are bad at both teaching and research, who should have never been tenured in the first place.

  4. Re:Unions College educated people on Teacher Union Tries To Block Online Courses · · Score: 4, Informative

    Community colleges are subsidized by property taxes, which is why the course fees don't add up. The idea of community colleges is that the bulk of the education is subsidized with only a nominal fee/tuition attached so as to encourage people to gain job skills.

  5. Re:Experiments performed only on 3 test subjects on Cancer Cured By HIV · · Score: 1

    Funding agencies are very concerned with making sure that whatever experiment you propose will work. As a research professor, I have to spend a ridiculous amount of effort in a grant application convincing the agency that my research will produce the expected results. In this case, I 100% buy into the fact that the funding agencies didn't want to pay for such a risky study. Another article I read about this said that the researchers now have money being thrown at them from many different agencies (including NIH/NCI), so I'm guessing the results are strong enough to warrant a much bigger trial.

  6. For business only? on 29 Universities Seek High-Speed Networks · · Score: 1

    I was initially excited by this as I thought I might be able to get in on it -- however, this looks to be more along the lines of a business partnership (i.e., businesses can pay for the fiber, and the universities will provide the net access.

  7. Re:You're already using unblockable tracking on Researchers Expose Tracking Service That Can't Be Dodged · · Score: 2

    That's what I thought this article would be about. It looks to me that the font list provides the most identifying information. Anyone know a way to tell your browser to not report your installed fonts?

  8. Journal of questionable reputation on New NASA Data Casts Doubt On Global Warming Models · · Score: 2

    I thought I'd look into this journal to see its impact factor and other metrics that would let me know if it is a reputable source. It is not indexed by ISI/Web of Science, so it has no published impact factor. Google scholar only picks up a few articles from this journal, most of which have been cited 0 or 1 time only. While this doesn't automatically negate the authors' findings, it says to me that no reputable journal wanted to publish it.

  9. Re:Higher Education is in a Massive Bubble on What's Your College Major Worth? · · Score: 1

    The effect of a bubble burst is pretty clear to me. High prestige schools will still charge whatever they want and get it from the hordes of people who will pay whatever for an Ivy degree. Most public universities will go on as normal, as the tuition they charge (in most cases under 10K/yr) is not all that outrageous. The losers? Low-prestige private schools (the category to which which all for-profits belong) will start to go belly-up as their enrollments drastically decline. (Meanwhile, lots of public universities are offering flexible & online programs that will steal the students from the for-profits.)

  10. Re:Uh oh on Pirated Android App Shames Freeloaders · · Score: 3, Insightful

    This is what I was thinking. Although I'm sympathize with the developer, this is the wrong way to go about dealing with privacy. Aside from the text costs associated with the "pirate" sending all of those text messages, it is likely the case that many of the recipients of those messages will also have to pay for receiving them. If the app permissions don't specify automatically sending text messages, then this developer could get into hot water.

  11. Nook Color could satiate desire for iPads on Turning Your E-Reader Into a Cheap Tablet · · Score: 2

    I had been thinking about getting an iPad for a long time. Eventually, decided to hold out for the iPad 2. But one day I was walking through Barnes and Noble, and took a good look at the Nook Color. After reading up on the rooting instructions, I bought the NC for $250, rooted it, and, after a month, my desire for the iPad is gone. I suppose that there will always be people like me who want an iPad but will actually be just as happy with something else. (And the 50% discount from the iPad helps too.) I should also reiterate the fact that there are three flavors of the Nook Color, but not all will suffice as a tablet:

    STOCK: Right now, the stock NC has a browser and could serve as a basic tablet for someone. But B&N is soon going to be updating the NC with Froyo and the app market, which will make it much more like a tablet.

    ROOTED STOCK: This is the best option as of today. Rooting took me only about 20 minutes, and the process is non-technical/noob friendly. Rooting will get you the market, google apps, push gmail, a new launcher (which will make it look like a true tablet), and softkeys (to replace the missing navigation keys that are on all android phones).

    CUSTOM ROM: This has the most promise, but it is not quite ready. Cyanogenmod has nightly builds of CM7 for the NC. As others said above, this will be awesome. I run CM7 on my phone, and I love it. Once it is fully ported to the NC, it will truly be a full-function tablet that can directly compete with the iPad. There are also some custom builds that you can install to a bootable microSD card that run both Froyo and Honeycomb.

  12. Re:One of these things is not like the others. on Citation Map Shows Top Science Cities · · Score: 2

    If the scientific method discovered that there was actual substance to astrology, then it would be a science. (But it doesn't, so it's not.)

  13. Re:Psychology Map May Be Incorrect on Citation Map Shows Top Science Cities · · Score: 1

    If that was the authors' intent, they didn't specify that in their paper. And, although there is plenty of fluff in psychology, some of the most highly cited journals in psychology are in social, developmental, and clinical. (In fact, the flagship social psych journal is the most often cited psych journal by articles appearing in "hard" science places like Science & PNAS -- there's some neat visualizations of this at eigenfactor.org.) If you look at the "top-tier" journals in each psychology subfield, you will find nothing but rigorous, experimental science.

  14. Psychology Map May Be Incorrect on Citation Map Shows Top Science Cities · · Score: 3, Interesting

    In looking at the psychology map, I am suspicious that the authors made a minor error in their data collection. The database they used (Web of Science, Science Citation Index) does contain a category for psychology; however, it lists only the 71 psychology journals that are in the physiological/cognitive subfields of psychology. The overwhelming majority of psychology journals (almost 500 of them) are not in those fields, so the search should have also included the Social Science Citation Index data (also part of the Web of Science, just involves clicking another box). I suspect the authors only used the Science (and not Social Science) database because the data displayed on the map seems to over-represent programs that are strong in physio/cognitive, and under-represents (or ignores) programs that are strong in social, developmental, and clinical psychology.

  15. Re:How many are paying sticker on Is Going To an Elite College Worth the Cost? · · Score: 1

    This. I've seen several articles recently decrying the "cost" of elite school, yet every single article throws around the sticker tuition prices for the elite schools. If I had a child accepted to both Harvard and my state university, it would cost me more to send them to the state school. The only people who pay sticker for the elites are rich enough to not care about the ROI length on 200,000.

  16. Re:Here is the stat that really matters on Statistical Analysis of Terrorism · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I assume you're taking into account being hit by an SUV while driving a different car. There are plenty of incidents involving SUV drivers hitting and killing others when those injuries would have been far reduced if the person was driving a smaller car. Put another way, if everyone drove mid-size cars instead of SUVs, how many lives would be saved each year? (It's certainly a non-zero number; whether it's more than terror victims I don't know.) I tried to explain this recently to my elderly mother who needed a new car. I begged her to get a nice safe sedan, but she insisted on a giant Buick SUV thing. I didn't have the heart to tell her that I wasn't worried about her safety, I was worried about everyone else's.

  17. Re:Package Penetration on Which Shipping Company Is Kindest To Your Packages? · · Score: 1

    I've noticed this a few times with OnTrac. I wondered whether the drivers were checking on the contents to see whether they'd *actually* deliver the package.

  18. Re:LOLWUT? on Newspapers Cut Wikileaks Out of Shield Law · · Score: 2, Funny

    "We must never forget that the real news is delivered on TV, by real, officially-licensed newsmen. Coming up: How do they get those dogs to talk in the beer commercials? Cowboy Steve will tell you!" - Kent Brockman

  19. Re:Any worth it? on Inside the Mechanical Turk Sweatshop · · Score: 1

    I've paid ~$2.00 for a 10-15 minute task, but it was the type of task you could only perform once. I figured that a $10/hr rate would be the least I could morally pay.

  20. Re:how do i find out if my teacher did that? on Students Settle With TurnItIn In Copyright Case · · Score: 1

    a company (college) can not force a customer (student) to give-up his rights or privileges as a precondition of service

    I'm skeptical of your claim for several reasons. 1) Courts routinely recognize that college is not a typical company-consumer organization, and they are often not treated as such. 2) Companies require you to waive rights and privileges all the time, and as a precondition of service. Want to buy a car? Arbitration and liability waiver. Want to hire a dentist? Medical waivers. etc. 3) Businesses routinely claim copyright/patent on products produced by employees (as a condition of employment) and such agreements are routinely supported in court. 4) Students do not pay the full cost of their education at just about any school, especially public ones. Their education is subsidized by taxpayers or endowment income or federal aid or whatever. That gives the college (or the state) the right to assert at least partial ownership of products resulting from a student's education. At my university, our system allows us to check for plagiarism without submitting the students' works to the database. I don't compel my students to submit their work to the database, but I do have them run it through the content check side.

  21. Re:Correction on Lecture Notes Considered Infringement · · Score: 1

    Unless they are tenured, as most professors are (at most four-year colleges). If the professor has too few students enroll in a class, he will have to make it up (i.e., it won't "count" toward the required number of courses that need to be taught), but that is usually a small number. For example, at my university, if at least 15 students enroll in a 150-person class, it will still count.

    And, if it is a research university, the school usually doesn't care what the students think of professors.