Slashdot Mirror


Build Your Own Mac

DaytonCIM writes "TechTV has a great article by Kevin Rose on how to build your own Mac: 'When it comes to PCs, geeks usually make a decision between buying a prebuilt computer or building one, component by component. This isn't true when it comes to Macintoshes. You're stuck with whatever Apple has to offer, with only a few measly dollars differentiating the products from retailer to retailer.' It will be broadcast on The Screen Savers today."

151 of 372 comments (clear)

  1. Hmmmm.... Haven't I seen this before? by Spy4MS · · Score: 5, Informative
    1. Re:Hmmmm.... Haven't I seen this before? by mgs1000 · · Score: 2

      Yeah, I think this particular story was on Slashdot before. It's just thatThe Screen Savers is just a few months slower.

    2. Re:Hmmmm.... Haven't I seen this before? by DaytonCIM · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Great article and yes the Screen Saver story is redundant and old. But so is every other "Build Your Own [blah blah blah].

      For those Mac Addicts out there that want to try this, but might not be the best at building computers or working with electronics, I highly recommend checking out Kevin on Screen Savers. He's pretty knowledgeable and keeps things simple.

      Just my 2cents.

    3. Re:Hmmmm.... Haven't I seen this before? by Target+Drone · · Score: 5, Informative
      Ya, the article was titled Build a Macintosh From Scratch back in September

      and it also appeared as an answer to an Ask slashdot back in October

  2. Honestly? by RyuuzakiTetsuya · · Score: 3, Insightful

    prebuilt, or open building isn't holding me back from using a Mac, the lack of software(*coughgamescough*) is. Geez, get it right. :)

    --
    Non impediti ratione cogitationus.
  3. Build your own computer.... by nother_nix_hacker · · Score: 5, Funny

    I made my own but found I kept dropping the transistors on the carpet and losing them.

    1. Re:Build your own computer.... by Anonvmous+Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      "I made my own but found I kept dropping the transistors on the carpet and losing them."

      I'm still waiting for my Macintosh to grow. Portland doesn't get a lot of sunlight.

    2. Re:Build your own computer.... by poot_rootbeer · · Score: 3, Funny


      That's why I build MY computers using good old-fashioned vacuum tubes instead. No pesky transistors to lose!

    3. Re:Build your own computer.... by hickmott · · Score: 2, Informative

      That's what linoleum is for.

    4. Re:Build your own computer.... by Zordak · · Score: 2

      And it's rad-hardened to boot!

      --

      Today's Sesame Street was brought to you by the number e.
    5. Re:Build your own computer.... by Anonvmous+Coward · · Score: 2

      "I hear from my friends in Portland that growlights and hydroponic irrigation systems are plentiful."

      Ha! hehe. That made me laugh. Heh heh that was cool.

  4. All I want to know... by Mitreya · · Score: 3, Funny

    ... is why a desk lamp is missing from the list of components :) These lamp-like macs would probably be the most fun ones to build...

  5. EBay..... by Kenja · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I was able to build a 500mhz G3 based iMac for under 300$ from parts I picked up on e-bay. I then installed it into a Marathon iRack 1U case.

    --

    "Have you ever thought about just turning off the TV, sitting down with your kids, and hitting them?"
    1. Re:EBay..... by Numeric · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Did you get one of these off eBay or had it laying around?

      --

      Marathon iRack(TM)
      Supports only tray-loading iMacs.
      Price: US$399 plus shipping.

      http://www.marathoncomputer.com/irac1.html

      --
      -- ladies and gentlemen we are floating in space!
    2. Re:EBay..... by SlamMan · · Score: 2

      So you bought an iMac for $350, and then put it in a $400 case?

      --
      Mod point free since 2001
    3. Re:EBay..... by Kenja · · Score: 2

      No I built a 650$ 1U Macintosh.

      --

      "Have you ever thought about just turning off the TV, sitting down with your kids, and hitting them?"
    4. Re:EBay..... by Kenja · · Score: 3, Informative
      I got the case new. However I've seen them on ebay from time to time.

      Bottom line is I built a 1U Macintosh for under 650$.

      --

      "Have you ever thought about just turning off the TV, sitting down with your kids, and hitting them?"
    5. Re:EBay..... by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 2

      That still adds up to a $350 computer in a $300 case, friend. You wasted some good money there.

      --

      I write in my journal
  6. It's not that hard... by Elbereth · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I did what this article describes. In an effort to minimize my investment, I bought the components individually from ebay and online stores, put it all together, and had a custom PowerMac. The problem is that some of those components aren't brand new, and they may very well fail. Then you're left with a cheap-ass PowerMac that needs a new power supply. And one of the PCI slots is a little flakey. And...

    It's easier to just buy a used PowerMac on ebay (or from a friend), which is what I ended up doing after I pieced together the parts individually. I still play around with that Frankenstein Mac, but it's not as useful as the used PowerMac.

    However, if you invest in newer parts, I think you'll have better success than me. The stuff I bought was pretty old (and damn cheap).

    1. Re:It's not that hard... by mehip2001 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Come on spill.....
      How much dit it cost?

      --
      Just for the record, there is NO "off the record" record.
      Make a record of that.
    2. Re:It's not that hard... by Jeff+DeMaagd · · Score: 3, Funny

      I am more partial to "FrankenTosh".

    3. Re:It's not that hard... by Elbereth · · Score: 3, Informative

      To tell the truth, I don't really remember. I spent a lot of money on buying 512MB RAM, a SCSI card, video card, chassis, etc. I guess altogether, it was probably around $300 for a 266 MHz G3. I was planning on taking it a lot higher, of course, but the low end G3 CPU let me test the components and make sure everything was working. And it was only $20 shipped. However, Apple then announced the 1 GHz PowerMac, and my 266 MHz CPU seemed very, very puny indeed. Well, suffice to say, I stopped investing money in that computer and decided to save up for something a little more powerful.

  7. Save yourself $8.29 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    This 480 hours of labor saves you all sorts of money, even after you have to spend $20 on tools and junk that you need to jimmy the stuff together.

    1. Re:Save yourself $8.29 by dirvish · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I think this is more for the enthusiast than the bargain hunter with no time to spare. Someone who is into piecing computers together will have the tools allready. It isn't that much different than building your own PC...there are only 3 or 4 proprietary parts.

  8. MacResQ - Availability:Limited Stock by SmegTheLight · · Score: 3, Funny

    This topic should be called:

    "How you COULD have built your own Mac, before the info got Slashdotted"

    --
    Time travel is possible. We are quickly heading for 1984.
  9. CAT Mac by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

    In the old days these were called CAT Macs. or catalog Macs.(circa 1987-1994) There wer a few companies that specalized in building custom enclosures for Mac IIs and such. ATS or Atlanta Technical Specalists built a great product. John Yaeger came up with the design and production of cutting up PC AT cases and mounting custom power supplies, logic board plates and port covers to give enough room to make some killer Macs of the day.
    Those were the days when Larry Pina was king.

    1. Re:CAT Mac by shivianzealot · · Score: 2, Informative

      Applefritter has a pretty good section on these. Here's the direct link: http://www.applefritter.com/macclones/index.html

      Note to moderators: I feel +5, Informative is only fair :)

      --

      Bored with karma, be a fan/freak

  10. gah! by BigBir3d · · Score: 5, Interesting

    For the price of the processor you can have a reasonable PC.

    This is not a troll, just a note of what happens when hardware is made in small quantities, and is not actively updated as fast as the competition.

    In the land of PC's, people that want the absolute best, or the absolute cheapest build their own.

    In the land of Apple, if you want the best, buy it directly from Apple. Cheapest? Probably eBay.

  11. Can I have a.... by rolfwind · · Score: 3, Insightful

    dual 1GHz, internal dvd, internal zip, heavy on the ram, some Mac OsX, printer and scanner on the side. Oh, and a large tower to go with that! Thank you! Seriously, is this going to save anybody money? No. If it's for internal component, I like external ones better. Why not just buy the external components, they're SCSI right. Portable computer to computer. The only benefit I see is the possibility of making one computer out of two broken ones or something similiar. Can you even by PPC chips seperately?

    1. Re:Can I have a.... by Chas · · Score: 3, Informative
      Why not just buy the external components

      Speaking from a PC-centric POV, and having attended lots of LAN parties. Because it's a pain in the nuts hooking up all the cable and lugging everything with you.

      Not to mention the fact that, for the most part, external components:

      1. Cost more
      2. Require additional power connectors
      3. Are a damned nuisance when space is limited.
      --


      Chas - The one, the only.
      THANK GOD!!!
  12. Better the second time around, eh? by unicorn · · Score: 2

    So this is a link to a very limited 1 page summary, of an article that was covered on /. in September.

    --
    "Politicians are interested in people. Not that this is always a virtue. Fleas are interested in dogs." P.J. O'Rourke
  13. Attack of the Dupes! by Wind_Walker · · Score: 2
    You could also look here at the last Slashdot story that told you how to build a Mac.

    I think somewhere along the line, Slashdot.org: The Techie Menace became Slashdot.org: Attack of the Dupes...

  14. Hmmm.... by Aggrazel · · Score: 5, Funny

    Build my own mac?

    I used to do that all the time, was easy...

    2 all beef patties, special sauce, lettuce, cheese ...

    1. Re:Hmmm.... by Zordak · · Score: 2

      Dang monopolists with your proprietary hamburgers...

      --

      Today's Sesame Street was brought to you by the number e.
  15. Just an FYI....NO FLAME by greymond · · Score: 5, Informative

    I know a lot of MAC enthusiasts here will start commenting that "See you can build a mac just like you can a pc!" and I myself don't wish to start a flame war here but Building a MAC is no where near the ease of building a PC.

    For a PC you need 2 main things the parts and 1 Screwdriver.

    Building a MAC on the otherhand requires the parts, a Screwdriver, a Wire cutter, Dremel and cutting discs, 4" nylon wire ties, Electrical tape, Die, tap, and drill - (see the macoptz link on the article if you don't believe me)

    The reason for this is because Apple - although they sell parts separately DOES NOT SELL THE MAC CASES BY THEMSELVES - so in order to make your powersuply and mac board work with a pc case requires all the time and effort of making a custom mod of your pc box. IMHO a very time consuming process unless you do that sort of thing on a regular basis and have all your stuff readily at hand.

    I'm totally in favor of people trying this - just be forwarned that this is not a simple buy the parts slap the pieces together turn it on project - it's time consuming and requires a lot more tools and skill than needed for pc building.

    1. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by Mononoke · · Score: 4, Funny
      I'm totally in favor of people trying this - just be forwarned that this is not a simple buy the parts slap the pieces together turn it on project - it's time consuming and requires a lot more tools and skill than needed for pc building.
      That's what gets me every time I hear someone crowing about how they "Built their PC from scratch." No they didn't. They bought about 10 items and put them together like some snap-together kit (Place Tab A in Slot B). Certainly something some people could be proud of, but not really that impressive in the long run.

      Whenever someone comes to me claiming to have built their PC, I ask them to describe their technique for etching multi-layer circuit boards.

      Then they stomp on my foot. I don't know why.

      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
    2. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Could it be they think you are being obtuse? While you're at it, when anyone in the world, says they've "made" something, do you jump on them since matter can't be created or destroyed? I bet you don't

    3. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by jpt.d · · Score: 2

      Where does apple sell the parts?

      --
      What we see depends on mainly what we look for. -- John Lubbock Now search for that bug slave!
    4. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by tbmaddux · · Score: 2

      Buy a case on eBay. I did a search for "g4 tower case" and there was one selling w/ power supply right now.

      --
      Can't you see that everyone is buying station wagons?
    5. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by CoughDropAddict · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Oh please. You know perfectly well what people mean when they say they built their PC "from scratch," they mean they didn't buy a pre-assembled package from a retailer. They mean they chose each part and then assembled it.

      Whenever someone comes to me claiming to have built their PC, I ask them to describe their technique for etching multi-layer circuit boards.

      How enlightened you are. You must also ask your mother her technique for grinding flour and raising chickens when she bakes your birthday cake "from scratch."

    6. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by Bios_Hakr · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Just like car enthusiasts:

      Some people buy from a dealer. Some buy parts from JC Whittney. Some hand polish the cylinder walls themselves.

      If I buy a video card and then rip off the heatsink to replace it with another, then I have done more work than most. If I spend days looking at charts and graphs to decide which MoBo is the best, I have done more work than most. If I take the time to tiewrap power cables and ensure good airflow, then I have done more work than most.

      Like sex, there is a lot more to "building a PC" than "insert tab A into slot B". Or at least there can be if you do it right.

      --
      I'd rather you do it wrong, than for me to have to do it at all.
    7. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by shepd · · Score: 2, Informative

      >Whenever someone comes to me claiming to have built their PC, I ask them to describe their technique for etching multi-layer circuit boards.

      Well, since you asked...

      Personally I prefer positive photoetch and 3M 77 myself (if I were to do anything past 2 layer, that is), but this guy has better plans.

      (You came to the wrong place to ask that question. ;-) And I hate Ferric Chloride. Yech. Stains worse than anything. And the smell...)

      --
      If you could be told what you can see or read, then it follows that you could be told what to say or think - BoC
    8. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by spacefrog · · Score: 2, Funny
      • You must also ask your mother her technique for grinding flour and
      • raising chickens when she bakes your birthday cake "from scratch."

      What parts of the chicken are used in the birthday cake???????

    9. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by Yosho · · Score: 4, Funny

      I'll tell you about my etching techniques if you tell me about how you refined the minerals you mined to make your circuit boards. ;-)

      --
      Karma: Terrifying (mostly affected by atrocities you've committed)
    10. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by Teflik · · Score: 2, Informative

      The egg.

    11. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by lucifuge31337 · · Score: 2

      Eggs you moron.

      --
      Do not fold, spindle or mutilate.
    12. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by SoupIsGoodFood_42 · · Score: 2
      What parts of the chicken are used in the birthday cake???????

      Eggs?

    13. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by kesuki · · Score: 2

      perhaps they were thinking of this?
      But seriously, eggs are seperated, and often the whites only or in some recipies both the whites and the yolks are called for. Some recipies may call for using the yolks in the batter while using the whites in the frosting. It just depends on the recipie of cake.

    14. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by cmallinson · · Score: 2
      What parts of the chicken are used in the birthday cake???????

      The egg parts.

      Unless you are talking about chicken wing cake.

    15. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by mlknowle · · Score: 3, Informative

      For God's sake, it's

      "Mac"

      Which is short for Macintosh. Not "MAC." It's not an acronym. It doesn't stand for something; "PC is an acronym for "Personal Computer." You don't write "WINDOWS" or "LINUX" or "GATEWAY" so why "MAC"? Becausee it is so short? Jeez.

      An incredibly trivial point... but I had to make it!

    16. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by jcoy42 · · Score: 2
      How enlightened you are. You must also ask your mother her technique for grinding flour and raising chickens when she bakes your birthday cake "from scratch."

      To make apple pie from scratch, you must first create the universe.
      -Carl Sagan
      --
      Never trust an atom. They make up everything.
    17. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by kalidasa · · Score: 2

      I know a lot of MAC enthusiasts here will start commenting that "See you can build a mac just like you can a pc!

      Funny, I don't know any Mac people who would say that. What they're more likely to say is "Sure, if I want a homebuilt job, I'll just do an Intel box and throw Linux on it. Should work well, and be damned powerful if I want to spend the $$$. But it won't be as sweet as my PowerBook|iBook|PowerMac|iMac."

    18. Re:Just an FYI....NO FLAME by kalidasa · · Score: 2

      Real Mac users miss OS 9.2.1, it's only the people with Mac's GUI envy that have migrated to OS-X or Mac people who refuse to use Windows (can't blame them). There are very few Mac users who really understand and appreciate the value of Linux or building your own machine.

      Yeah, right, this is the kind of user who's going to want to build their own Mac. Wake up and smell the coffee.

  16. Still not really custom by stratjakt · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I RTFA, but you basically buy *the* proc, *the* mobo and put it together yourself.

    You still don't have all that much variety in your new 'mac'.. No more than if you bought a prebuilt and changed the videocard.

    When I have time I'll crunch the numbers, but I doubt that all-told its any cheaper. I was under the impression that aftermarket Mac mobo's were quite pricy.

    It's nice for that 'look what I did' feeling, but it'd be much nicer to see cheaper commodity hardware.

    Then I might be interested in putting one together to see what OSX is all about, as I'd never pay so much for any pre-built desktop. Unless it had a creamy nougat center. Mmmmm.. Nougat.

    --
    I don't need no instructions to know how to rock!!!!
    1. Re:Still not really custom by Decimal · · Score: 2

      I RTFA,

      You Read The F*cking Annual?

      --

      Remember "Bring 'em on"? *sigh
  17. Can't resist by Strange+Ranger · · Score: 2, Funny


    If I build it, does that make it an iMac?

    --

    Operator, give me the number for 911!
    1. Re: Can't resist by Antity · · Score: 2

      "If you build it, they will come."

      :-)

      --
      42. Easy. What is 32 + 8 + 2?
  18. That's all well and good... by daeley · · Score: 4, Informative

    ...just don't try to install GNU-Darwin on it. ;D

    BTW, Mac OS X 10.2.3 was just released via Software Update. Check my journal for more info.

    --
    I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser gate.
  19. Refurbished mobo? by benzapp · · Score: 4, Informative

    The link for the motherboard in the story points to a refurbished motherboard which also costs $200!

    I have built systems for the last ten years not because of the geek factor, but because most premanufactured systems are crap, and the ones that aren't cost way too much money.

    given that I think most are looking for quality, who would put a refurbished motherboard in their system, let a lone a $200 one.

    --
    I don't read or respond to AC posts
  20. Re:TECH TV = Microsoft by jridley · · Score: 2

    I caught like 2 minutes of the end of Call 4 Help the other day; they had a guest on for the woman's spot over on the desk - the guy seemed really disappointed when he asked what browser she ran, and the woman said, somewhat sheepishly, "I must admit, I run internet explorer." The guy was like, "oh." - it was pretty funny, you'd have though she'd just said she only bathes once a week.

  21. pointless by asv108 · · Score: 3, Redundant
    When building a mac you loose a lot of the benefits of constructing your own PC: Vast array of components to choose from, low cost, and configurations you can't get from standard pc makers. You also loose one of the main benefits of choosing an Apple system, excellent support and replacement policies.

    The processor costs $700! For the price of the processor alone, anyone can build a complete Athlon XP2400+ nforce2 system.

    1. Re:pointless by Klaruz · · Score: 2

      That's not just a chip, it's more like a processor card. Chip, external cache, system interface, etc. Not only that, it's a processor card that not many mac owners buy. That's why it's so pricey.

      The real cost of a g3/4 chip is around the cost of a p3/4.

    2. Re:pointless by mehip2001 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      So, is it not possible to just go out a purchase a chip and drop it in? Or is this the only way to do it yourself?

      --
      Just for the record, there is NO "off the record" record.
      Make a record of that.
    3. Re:pointless by leviramsey · · Score: 2, Informative
      That's not just a chip, it's more like a processor card. Chip, external cache, system interface, etc. Not only that, it's a processor card that not many mac owners buy. That's why it's so pricey.

      So what? That doesn't change the fact that a part (ie not a standalone system) of a Mac is at least as expensive as a pretty damn fast PC.

  22. Create Your Own (Big) Mac by webword · · Score: 5, Funny

    TOP SECRET RECIPE

    INGREDIENTS

    1 sesame-seed hamburger bun
    Half of an additional hamburger bun
    1/4 pound ground beef
    Dash salt
    1 tablespoon Kraft Thousand Island dressing
    1 teaspoon finely diced onion
    1/2 cup chopped lettuce
    1 slice American cheese
    2 to 3 dill pickle slices

    INSTRUCTIONS

    1. With a serrated knife, cut the top off the extra bun half, leaving about a 3/4-inch-thick slice. This will be the middle bun in your sandwich.

    2. Place the three bun halves on a hot pan or griddle, face down, and toast them to a light brown. Set aside, but keep the pan hot.

    3. Divide the ground beef in half and press into two thin patties slightly larger than the bun.

    4. Cook the patties in the hot pan over medium heat for 2 to 3 minutes on each side. Salt lightly.

    5. Build the burger in the following stacking order from the bottom up:

    bottom bun
    half of dressing
    half of onion
    half of lettuce
    American cheese
    beef patty
    middle bun
    remainder of dressing
    remainder of onion
    remainder of lettuce
    pickle slices
    beef patty
    top bun

    1. Re:Create Your Own (Big) Mac by kin_korn_karn · · Score: 2

      It's ironic. One story is an Apple contractor giving away trade secrets. The one about building clones of Macs has someone giving away trade secrets of McDonald's. I'm wondering if someone from Wendy's is going to post a story about black market Segways in China or something..

    2. Re:Create Your Own (Big) Mac by sharkey · · Score: 2

      Divide the ground beef in half and press into two thin patties slightly larger than the bun.

      Umm, you misspelled much smaller.

      --

      --
      "Outlook not so good." That magic 8-ball knows everything! I'll ask about Exchange Server next.
  23. Architecture Issues by Massacrifice · · Score: 5, Insightful

    As both a Mac and PC owner :

    One of the main points (beside price) of building your own computer is to be able to choose your components, which you dont really have when it comes down to building a Mac since the supported hardware list is so small. _Drivers_ are the biggest hurdle to putting your own Mac together. Unless you want to run Yellow Dog Linux on it, but then it's not a Mac anymore, is it?

    You cannot even use standard PC video cards on a Mac, since the Mac architecture expects extension cards to have OpenFirmware compliant firmware. Hence, nice Mac-specific NVidia AGP cards that wont fit anywhere else. Again, there are ways around that, but reliabiality suffers.

    --
    -- Home is where you eat your heart out.
  24. CONFUCIUS SAY by PD · · Score: 5, Funny

    Drop one transistor on carpet and it is lost. But drop a million and you say "look at all those damn transistors."

    1. Re:CONFUCIUS SAY by Dirtside · · Score: 2
      Drop one transistor on carpet and it is lost. But drop a million and you say "look at all those damn transistors."
      Eh, I save time and just drop entire CPUs on the carpet, instead.
      --
      "Destroy science and religion. Science would re-emerge exactly the same; but not religion." - Penn Jillette, paraphrased
  25. processor prices Re:gah! by johnpaul191 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    there is a weird thing with PPC processors these days. it has something to do with the IMB/Moto design and manufacturing thing. also the "processor" is not just a bare chip like a PC user may think. it's a whole processor card, including the backside cache bla bla bla. not that it really narrows the gap, but there is a lot more than a bare chip.

    Moto makes the chips that Apple currently uses in machines, IBM makes a lot of the ones that are used for upgrades. there is some agreement over pricing and speed. the rumors have long said IBM can outclock Moto's chips, but are not allowed to sell them because they are held back because of contractual agreements. rumors, but interesting because it seems IBM will be making the new Apple super-chip in mid/late 2003 when the 970s roll out.

    also of note, a $399 PC is a piece of junk compared to any Mac. i am talking about the physical components. everything from power supply to ram, it will not have gigabit ethernet, it will not have firewire with individual busses for each port. things like that where the prices of Macs add up.

  26. Re:Duh by unicron · · Score: 4, Funny

    Then why does Mc'D's keep canning your ass?

    --
    Finally, math books without any of that base 6 crap in them.
  27. The prices are not so good by goombah99 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Logic board: $200 Sonnet CPU: $700 Video card : $220 Memory: $200 hard drive: $150 pro keyboard/optical mouse: 99 Operating system: 129 ___________ Not including any shipping thats' 1730 $ for a SINGLE PROCESSOR MACHINE already without a case, power supply, cd/dvd drive, or even any cables or power cords. Or you can get a DUAL CPU system assembled with an air port card, extra memory, and operaing system from mac mall for $1690

    --
    Some drink at the fountain of knowledge. Others just gargle.
    1. Re:The prices are not so good by inode_buddha · · Score: 2

      For the same $1730 you mentioned, I built the box I'm typing this with.

      Dual P3 Coppermines @1GHz, 1Gb pc133 ram, dual 80 Gb drives, Plextor CD-burner, n-Vidia GeForce4, 10/100 base-T, and 19" 1600x1200 ViewSonic CRT. Full-tower case and 450-watt power supply; runs cool and quiet.

      All brand-new parts.

      Oh yeah, and Linux ;)

      --
      C|N>K
    2. Re:The prices are not so good by NetFu · · Score: 2

      I think you are missing the point here -- from a PC-geek's point of view. Most of us PC-geeks (and Mac-geeks, I guess, since I was the same when I used only Macs), have most of these components laying around everywhere waiting to be used. The point of building a PC instead of buying a pre-built one is that it's a cheaper entry into getting another computer (not your first one) using your old components. I would still argue that a put-together PC is way better than many cheaper pre-built PC's, but that's my opinion.

      So, if you want to get into a second (or third or fourth or nth computer ... like at my house) computer as cheaply as possible, you put together a Franken-puter from orphaned parts you have left over from upgrades to your primary computer. With this information in the article, I can put together a cheap G4 Mac for about $700 (cheaper 800MHz G4 CPU is $500, and the M/B is $200) and use parts that would otherwise collect dust in my house.

      At least it gives me the option if I want, because I can tell you right now I'm not paying $1000 more out-of-pocket for a pretty Apple G4 Mac when I don't have to. Ex-Mac users, curious PC users, and even budget-minded Mac users will all find this information useful...

    3. Re:The prices are not so good by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 4, Funny

      Oh yeah, and Linux ;)

      See? You knew there had to be a down-side, right?

      --

      I write in my journal
    4. Re:The prices are not so good by neuroticia · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Hah! But it wouldn't be a MAC. ;) We must remember that Macs are the bestest things in the world, and worth the additional $1k for a slower machine. =]

      It's the EXPERIENCE, man. The experience! ;)

      -Sara

    5. Re:The prices are not so good by SensitiveMale · · Score: 5, Interesting
      Logic board: $200 Sonnet CPU: $700 Video card : $220 Memory: $200 hard drive: $150 pro keyboard/optical mouse: 99 Operating system: 129


      Dude, where are you buying stuff?


      I just got a Sonnet dual proc card for $400 NEW.

      ATi 8500 for $170 and you can even a GeForce2MX than supports dual displays for $40.

      1 Gig of RAM $65

      Just bought a 60 Gig 7200 RPM drive for $50

      Wireless USB keyboard/mouse $40 or get a decent keyboard for $40 and a Logitech mx700 for $42

      Jaguar OS $79

      CDRW 40X $40

      I understand your point and yes, it is better to buy a complete Mac, but you can always find quality parts for a discount if you look.

    6. Re:The prices are not so good by inode_buddha · · Score: 2

      Er? What downside? AFAIC, it rocks. The only downside for me is that I couldn't afford to do the same on a RISC platform (such as, er, MAC).

      --
      C|N>K
    7. Re:The prices are not so good by diamondc · · Score: 2

      Yeah.. the only price competitive product Apple has is the newer iBooks. Sure they're a bit slower than a 1000 dollar laptop, but when I'm using my laptop I accept the little bit of slowdown in exchange for longer lasting battery power and less heat dissipation. Plus they run Mac OS X!

      --
      "I keep looking in the want-ads under 'revolutionary' but there don't seem to be any listings.. "
    8. Re:The prices are not so good by Decimal · · Score: 2

      Just bought a 60 Gig 7200 RPM drive for $50

      New? Good god man, where? Tell me now for I must buy!

      --

      Remember "Bring 'em on"? *sigh
    9. Re:The prices are not so good by axxackall · · Score: 2
      lus they run Mac OS X!

      That's certainly a downside! :)

      --

      Less is more !
    10. Re:The prices are not so good by SensitiveMale · · Score: 2

      It was new at OfficeMax.

      It was a WD 7200 60 gig drive for $100. $20 instant savings and $30 rebate.

      The offer was pulled the next day. Sorry.

    11. Re:The prices are not so good by IamTheRealMike · · Score: 2
      What a brilliant troll Sara :) I can't believe you got 2 Insightful and 1 Informative, when really it should have been +3 funny!

      How could anybody not see the sarcasm in that? It says a lot about some of the mods here on slashdot I think.

    12. Re:The prices are not so good by neuroticia · · Score: 2

      Heh. Im stuck on my Mac this week becuase my computer is in use by someone else in the office who needs a PC. for some work-stuff.

      Nothing sucks worse than being stuck on a G3 350 running OS X when you've got an Athlon 2700, Soyo Dragon SY-KT400 with 1.5GB DDR(400) sitting in the other room. With that machine, I'd even hate being on a 1.25G4. =]

      I have to say, though, that OS X isn't as bad as I was thinking it was. Now that I've been on it for two days, most of my major complaints aren't as major anymore. I think the biggest complaint I have is that the OS works from the upper-left corner-diagonally. I MUCH prefer the lower-right-corner-diagonally workflow of OS 9 and Windows.

      I don't see why people worship OS X so much. It's not horrible, but it's a step in the wrong direction.

      -Sara

    13. Re:The prices are not so good by IamTheRealMike · · Score: 2
      I would try baiting mac users, I do it all the time with a machead friend of mine, but I think my sig would give the game away. Still, fun to watch, in a slightly sick "wow, you guys take it seriously don't you" kind of way.

      Well, I waste enough time on slashdot as it is... there's work to be done and readymeals to be bought.... till next time

    14. Re:The prices are not so good by inode_buddha · · Score: 2

      Gigabyte GA-6VXDC7, uses VIA Apollo 694X AGPset.

      Bummer, they recently discontinued it, but I bet there's loads of new ones being sold dirt cheap as retailers try to clear out their stock.

      --
      C|N>K
  28. Wow. Cutting Edge... by trcooper · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Is anyone surprised you can pick up a refurbished mainboard, and a processor upgrade on the internet? Whoopee.

    Sure, you CAN build a Mac. But why? By the time you get done paying shipping from 10 different online merchants, you may as well have bought the real thing.

    I understand building PC's, but I do that because the hardware is plentiful, I can get everything at one place usually, and end up saving quite a bit of money in the long run.

    If you want to build a Mac, order yourself a Dual 866 G4, have someone tear it apart and put it in boxes, and put it back together...

  29. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by ivan256 · · Score: 4, Informative

    the rumors have long said IBM can outclock Moto's chips, but are not allowed to sell them because they are held back because of contractual agreements.

    It really is just a rumor. Not only can IBM make chips that clock faster than motorola's chips, they do make them and they do sell them, so whatever contract you may have heard of wasn't or is no longer true.

    Also, I believe that the current iBooks use IBM G3s. The 750CXe I think.

  30. Modding Down by CleverNickName · · Score: 5, Funny

    Somebody on Slashdot modding down Wil Wheaton, yeah right! :)

    Heh. I think it's a hobby for some people to take their mod points and burn them hitting me -1 five times in a row.

    Hey, at least this time it's for a good reason. :)

    1. Re:Modding Down by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 2

      I get that every once in a while, Wil. There was a span a few months back when somebody hit me with five "-1, Troll" mods right in a row on three or four separate occasions, even going so far as to dig up old posts of mine just to down-moderate them.

      You seem to be a pretty easygoing guy, humble and inoffensive. Me, on the other hand... if I haven't pissed somebody off, I must not be telling it like it is.

      --

      I write in my journal
    2. Re:Modding Down by Kymermosst · · Score: 2

      Heh. I think it's a hobby for some people to take their mod points and burn them hitting me -1 five times in a row.

      It seems they've been developing new hobbies regarding you, lately:

      http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=48400&cid=49 27 118

      This should take you there.

      I've gotten hit with the 5 mod downs before, as well... of course, I know who did it. The only person on my "freaks" list.

      --
      "Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives" should be a convenience store, not a government agency.
    3. Re:Modding Down by Jippy_ · · Score: 2

      Eh Wil,

      I modded you +1 Funny there just so I could say that in some small, insignificant way, I touched The Wil.

    4. Re:Modding Down by kalidasa · · Score: 2

      You seem to be a pretty easygoing guy, humble and inoffensive. Me, on the other hand... if I haven't pissed somebody off, I must not be telling it like it is.

      I'm sure that's part of the reason mod points are set to 5 only: to prevent vendettas.

      I have to wonder what kind of loser gets his jollies off modding anyone down for the sake of saying they modded that person down, though. Regardless of what their rep is.

  31. Re:Create Your Own Thousand Island Dressing by Moses+Lawn · · Score: 2

    No, that's just Russian dressing. You need to add pickle relish to make it Thousand Island. Or is it the other way around? Mmm Mmm Good - white trash food!

    --

    What if life is just a side effect of some other process and God has no idea we exist?

  32. Re:Kevin Rose by LostCluster · · Score: 2

    No, that was regular series host Patrick Norton, and that was a kilt.

    The kilt was actually a point of contraversy for fans of the show because Patrick used to wear his kilt on a weekly basis, until TechTV management decided that it made bad first impressions and ordered that he stop. He complied, but fan protests demanded the kilt be reinstated. This as led to managment declaring an all-kilt episode where every cast member wore a kilt. Wil's episode was the first time in months Patrick has worn the kilt without a big deal being made of it.

  33. What I really want to know is by drinkypoo · · Score: 2
    Where do I get the mac cases? Bondi blue or titanium, I don't care, but I Want one of the neat new mac cases with the handles on the corners, and I want it to not be all scratched up. I'd pay a hundred bucks or so for one of those (reasonable for a used case I'd think), without a power supply.

    I want to make one into an ATX case (I know that some of the important parts are on the wrong side, I'll get it worked out, don't worry) and slap my athlon into it. I don't even mind the big apple on the side. It's really a shame that no one makes a copy of it that is anywhere near the same quality.

    --
    "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    1. Re:What I really want to know is by Cyph · · Score: 2

      I'm actually looking into getting a Cube case, myself. I want to fit it with a Mini-ITX motherboard and use it as a Linux gateway/firewall. It'll be neat, I tell you. NEAT!

  34. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by BigBir3d · · Score: 5, Insightful

    also of note, a $399 PC is a piece of junk compared to any Mac

    Your price reference is for the processor alone (my original intention). For that money one can purchase a high quality AMD processor and motherboard of your choice. When looking at total cost of the PC vs homemade Mac, you can get far nicer, all brand new, components for the PC. And it will be the latest generation.

    Note that the motherboard referred to in the article was $199 and it was a refurbished unit. High quality or not, for that much scratch, I want new stuff.

    Gigabit ethernet is useless for 99% of Mac users, other than for bragging rights. A Gigabit solution is just now getting to the point of being affordable. It is still useless if you are mainly concerned with internet usage.

    The 970's, if they do come down the pipeline, sound really cool.

    In reality, the Macintosh market is not one of customization, it is one of reliability and ease of use. Something the PC still can't do.

  35. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by elmegil · · Score: 2

    And I need gigabit ethernet and firewire with individual busses WHY? I thought Mac was all about the user, and I can't think of any user outside of really specialized industries that might possibly need those features.

    --
    7 November 2006: The day Americans realized corruption and incompetence weren't addressing 11 September 2001
  36. Re:Kevin Rose by Morgahastu · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Woz was alright, for the first 30-45 minutes he was really awkward and stuttering as he read the cue cards but towards the end of the show he relaxed and did a decent job. Give him a few more shots and I am sure he'll be great.

    Just look at how megan or morgan are sometimes...

    Even Patrick is a little rough sometimes, it seems like he gets too nervous or excited and runs out of breah while hes talking. PACE YOURSELF!

    Like a fat kid slurping down an extra large milkshake...

  37. Re:Thats Stupid by Moses+Lawn · · Score: 4, Funny

    No no no... If you're going to troll, do it right: You'd misspell "preferably", you wouldn't put the apostrophes in "world's" (twice), you certainly wouldn't get the "it's" usage right. I like the letter transpositions and the "WIndows", though - those were a nice touch. The lack of line breaks is excellent. But "cheep"? No, too obvious. You certainly shouldn't get the distinction between Unix and Linux.

    Nice try, though. I give it a "B". Keep working at it - you have real troll potential.

    --

    What if life is just a side effect of some other process and God has no idea we exist?

  38. Re:TECH TV = Microsoft by LostCluster · · Score: 4, Interesting

    If you're going to bash TechTV for a connection to Microsoft, get the facts straight.

    TechTV is owned by Vulcan Ventures, who's primary investor is Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen. TechTV disclaims this ownership whenever they report on Charter Cable or Allen's America's Cup team, but they do not disclaim it when they talk about Microsoft since Paul Allen doesn't control that company, Bill Gates does.

  39. Re:Kevin Rose by mgs1000 · · Score: 2
    That show with Woz and Kevin Mitnick was terrible. I was pleasantly surprised when Wil kicked ass on Monday.

    I don't have G4 anymore since I dumped cable for DirecTV. Is he still hosting Arena?

  40. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by EvilAlien · · Score: 2
    Actually, I'd have to say that Gigabit ethernet is useless for 99% of users, other than for bragging rights. Mac or no Mac has nothing to do with it. Sure, it sounds cool to have, but unless you also want to invest in a gig switch for your Mac LAN, you are paying for something of relatively little value (like Firewire a year or so ago).

    Apple could really carve themselves a bigger market if they'd carve more off prices. The UNIXy goodness in Mac OS X actually makes me wish that I had a new Mac to play with, and that is saying something. I was an Apple user back before the Mac launched, but deviated slightly before and saw no compelling reason to take the platform seriously until Mac OS X.

    It will take lower costs of pre-built systems, or greater availability of DIY hardware to get me to re-expand my horizons beyond Intel/AMD based workstations and Intel/AMD/Sparc based servers. Otherwise, Apple simply offers no wins to lure my money or my recommendation for budget in the corporate world.

    --
    perl -e 'print $i=pack(c5, (41*2), sqrt(7056), (unpack(c,H)-2), oct(115), 10)'
  41. Rate of Failure by Bios_Hakr · · Score: 2

    You said older parts are more likely to fail. I have to disagree. After a part has been in use for 6 months, the rate of failure drops signifigantly. This is due to all the parts being put under load for the first time as a unit. A transistor may pass it's own QoS test, but it may fail when it is combined with the heat produced by other components.

    After having worked in the telecom industry for about 10 years, I am more wary of a router fresh off the boat from Cisco than an old Cabletron Switch that has been in place longer than I have. I have DSFUs (telephone signalling equipment) that have been processing calls longer than I have been alive. But the new (still just as old, but never been out of the box) DSFUs that fail tend to do so within the first month.

    I'll trust the old video card I pull out of the bottom of my parts bin (which is currently stacked higher than most men stand) over a brand new GeForceFX any day. As long as the part wasn't crap to begin with, after 6 months of use, it'll last forever.

    --
    I'd rather you do it wrong, than for me to have to do it at all.
    1. Re:Rate of Failure by AKnightCowboy · · Score: 2, Informative

      Of course, when you're talking about power supplies that's another story. As long as you NEVER shut them off they may run forever, but a couple power cycles on an old power supply and it may never start again (usually after a loud bang-pop noise). We had many FDDI concentrators that were under ten years old that you knew if you lost power you needed to replace the power supply on them when power was restored. It was just a given. Course, maybe they were just crap. :-)

  42. Redundant Repost by jericho4.0 · · Score: 2
    Hmmmm, nobody seems to have noticed that this is a repost. The posted link simply links to the previosly posted link. Oh well.

    Anyway, when the computer you're building requires a 'refurbished' motherboard made by Apple, it's not quite the same thing, is it? It's interesting, but wake me up when someone gets Auqa running on a generic G4 reference board.

    --
    "A language that doesn't affect the way you think about programming, is not worth knowing" - Alan Perlis
  43. Re:Mac Cases? by perfessor+multigeek · · Score: 2

    Well, as somebody who has done long pro-mac parts posts of every one of these threds, I've got to say, yeah, I've wondered about that myself. I've been looking for a good place online to buy empty Mac cases since 1996 and I have yet to find *one*. Very odd. And I do, by now suspect that this is yet another case [sic] of the Rabid Lawyers Of The Mighty Steve (RLOTMS, coming soon on videocassette and DVD) going after folks doing perfectly innocent stuff.
    I do know that the techs as a major New York Mac place used to have *piles* of bevels sitting around and weren't allowed to sell them. A friend of mine got enough to build a computer case covered in pretty blue tiles but his supply had to, shall we say, exit through the back door.
    Sometimes being a serious Mac person is like being in love with an amazing woman who alternates periods of entrancing brilliance, weeks of beautiful lucidity, and occasional psychotic fits during which she is convinced that the space aliens are about to get her and can only be calmed down by being allowed to throw things at occasional passers by. You live for the good days, and make your peace with occasional afternoons spent running after complete strangers and explaining that you're very sorry and yes, you will pay for the cost of their new lambswool coat and no, she's not always like this.
    *sigh*
    Bleeding six colors since 1984 (first mac bought August '84 model 0001),
    Rustin

    --
    Data is the lever, rigor the fulcrum, brains the force that drives it all.
  44. Cautionary tale by Enahs · · Score: 2
    I tried doing just this a while back. A wonky PS from some overly-religious seller managed to fry every component I had bought for the project--and I was out $400.

    Word to the wise (from the foolish): don't build your own Mac. Just don't. If you're going to build a computer, build a PC or some other machine you can build out of parts that are all under warranty.

    --
    Stating on Slashdot that I like cheese since 1997.
  45. Re:build you own mac laptop? by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 2

    Of course this voids the warrenty

    No, it doesn't. Apple dropped that sealed-case warranty thing years and years ago. You can replace whatever replaceable parts in your Mac you like without worrying one bit about the warranty.

    --

    I write in my journal
  46. yeah, like an education. by twitter · · Score: 2
    ...you have to spend $20 on tools and junk

    Just like a good education, some people don't get it. Who needs to spend time learning? Why put money into tools? I'm happier ignorant and helpless, thanks AC for the words of wizzdom.

    --

    Friends don't help friends install M$ junk.

    1. Re:yeah, like an education. by Golias · · Score: 2
      not owning tools for building PC's != ignorance.

      The greatest strength of the post-industrial West is that we maximize economies of scale though diverse specialization.

      For example, let's say there's a big-shot lawyer that never changes his own oil. Your first response might be to say "hah, what a chump. Paying some quick-lube place $25 to change his oil!"... but look at it this way: It would take him about 15 minutes to change his oil, and his time is worth about $150 and hour. That's $37.50 right there. Plus about $5 for the oil, and another couple bucks for the filter (he probably drives some swanky import, so let's call it $3 if he shops hard for a good deal). That's a total of $45.50 for his oil change, and doesn't even count the hassle of hauling the used oil down the block to the very same quick-lube shop he was avoiding to have it disposed of legally. Changing his own oil would cost him over $20 more than just letting somebody else do it. Sure, he misses out on the macho feeling of being the sort of guy who changes his own oil, but he's got better things to do.

      The same applies here. Building your own Mac is flat-out not worth it, most of the time, for most people. If you somehow think that a home project like this is going to lead you to some new level of enlightenment, then go ahead and do it for the sake of learning something. I, on the other hand, already know how to install computer parts, and have no desire to do so unless the savings are substatial.

      Even in the PC world, you can save a bunch of money building your own instead of buying a new Dell... but even then, I've found that it doesn't cost that much more to have a local mom&pop PC store screwdriver it together for you, and it saves potential arguments about whether a DOA part really arrived wrecked, or was damaged by your lack of a wrist strap. (Plus, it helps keep that mom&pop store open, which is nice when you need another 512 of RAM right now.

      This is why I have forsaken pricewatch.com in favor of Tran Microcomputers here in the Twin Cities. Sure, you can roll-yer-own for maybe $50 less than I spent, but I don't care anymore. When all PC's were well in excess of $1000 it was one thing to roll your own for $700, but spending $450 instead of $400 is not as big of an obstacle.

      --

      Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

  47. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 3, Informative

    Gigabit ethernet is useless for 99% of Mac users

    Huh? Say that next time we use a $12 cable to copy gigs of stuff from my Power Mac to my friend's PowerBook G4 at over 30 MB/s.

    --

    I write in my journal
  48. On fire. by twitter · · Score: 2
    Whenever someone comes to me claiming to have built their PC, I ask them to describe their technique for etching multi-layer circuit boards....Then they stomp on my foot. I don't know why.

    Real men need two layers or less. The techinques are simple and need no further explaination than double sided pc board. Now you know.

    --

    Friends don't help friends install M$ junk.

  49. Gigabit... by unicorn · · Score: 2

    Be honest here folks.

    We're talking about homebrew PC's. There are very few businesses that want homebrew x86 boxes, made with new parts. So if you try and sell them on homebrew mac's made with grey market second hand parts, etc, you can bet the CFO won't let that fly.

    So we're bsically talking about homebrew machines for the home.

    Who in gods name, needs gigabit at home? You can basically take it to the bank, that the bottleneck any home user will have, will be their pipe to the net. Arcnet will be faster than 99% of the home net connections out there. And if you do have the $$ to get a T3+ at home, you probably won't bother building a Mac from scratch.

    Gigabit's only really a selling point, if you've got something to connect to it, that will actually USE the bandwidth. Otherwise it's just a spoiler or a Civic.

    --
    "Politicians are interested in people. Not that this is always a virtue. Fleas are interested in dogs." P.J. O'Rourke
    1. Re:Gigabit... by Frymaster · · Score: 2
      Who in gods name, needs gigabit at home?

      this sounds a lot like "64k ought to be enough for anybody"

  50. Actually... by MamasGun · · Score: 3, Interesting

    MSNBC has even been known to bash The Mothership on occasion.

    TechTV knows what side its bread is buttered on...most people run Windows (sad but true) and it follows that TSS and other TechTV shows are very Windows-centric as a result.

    However, Chris DiBona is a TSS regular, and Leo Laporte is very loud in his support of MacOS X. I don't think the rest of them are too fond of Windows but give out Windows tips because that's what the viewers use. Yoshi seems to like Windows the most because that's what's got the most games.

    Now, don't get me started on Chris Pirillo...he genuinely seems to be Borged by MS.

    --
    "But you've already got a DVD. It lasts forever....In the digital world, we don't need back-ups..."
    -- Jack Valenti
    1. Re:Actually... by LostCluster · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Pirillo got his job by being noticed for writing a newsletter about how to use Windows... Call For Help is a newbie-level show about how to use Windows, with an occaisional nod that Mac and Linux are out there. If a Linux question makes it on CFH, a plug for The Screen Savers cannot be far behind.

  51. What Apple needs to do... by emil · · Score: 2

    ...is develop a standard set of boards and enclosures that are interchangeable. Take the IBM PS2 case design concept to it's natural conclusion: a motherboard swap should be a 10-minute job requiring the release of 7 plastic snap connectors.

    Apple should then sell these individual parts together with complete systems. The products should be of utmost quality. The parts should be simple enough that anybody could modify and maintain them (I don't think that current SIMM designs, for example, are simple and fool-proof enough).

    When Apple has done this, and converted entirely to a component model, the introduction of x86 Macs with native OSX will not be so profound (actually, I would like to see a Transmeta Mac without all that code-morphing - the performance of a "native" Crusoe would be interesting).

    In short, Apple needs to become the Ikea of computers. There are lots of places that sell furniture that is cheaper than Ikea, but Ikea remains a very big player in its market. Apple's market share is restrained for a simple reason: at Ikea, there is something for everybody. Apple should adopt this as a corporate mantra.

  52. still antiquated by jafac · · Score: 2

    I looked into doing this, and frankly, it's still not a very good deal - because the best logicboard that's readily available is the Gigabit Ethernet board. That's about two years old compared to the latest power mac systems. And one of the main logic board and grey market parts suppliers just went out of business (Shreve systems - but Mac ResQ is still around).

    If I could get a more up to date logic board, or even a cube motherboard, I'd feel more compelled to pursue this. Until then, I'm still squeezing every last cycle I can out of my trusty old upgraded Beige G3. . .

    --

    These are my friends, See how they glisten. See this one shine, how he smiles in the light.
  53. Re:Why I won't buy a Mac. Ever. by veddermatic · · Score: 2, Insightful

    you have a lot of choices.... you can run Windows on build your own hardware, run windows on a pre-built system, run Linux on either of those choices, or you can run OS X on a pre built Apple made machine.

    I for one do all of the above... I don't know why some folks don't *get* that Apple controlling the OS and hardware make for a GREAT user experience. I use Win for some testing stuff, Linux for servering and some development, and a Mac for 90% of my daily activities..... why? It WORKS.

    Obviously, for you it may not be the best choice, but you DO have a choice... don't buy a Mac. Don't bitch about it.

    I'm so fucking sick of people who haven't even USED a Mac bitching about them... "Macs suck, blah blah blah, I can't build my own, blah blah blah..."

    NOBODY CARES. Build your own Win2k machine, have fun putting it together, and if it is cheap and it all works, GOOD FOR YOU!! YOU GET A GOLD STAR!!!!

    As far as being tied to ONE company... that is absolutely the STUPIDEST thing I have ever heard. Do you know what "tied" to one company in my Mac? The motherboard. That's it. And guess what... if you have a PeeCee, YOUR motherboard is tied to one company to, either Intel or AMD. I have a pinoneer CD-RW/DVD-R you can swap it in/ out of a PC. My RAM cam be put in a PC, my videocard is a GeForce, I use a MICROSOFT keyboard and mouse... my monitor is a SONY. yup, it's so tied to Apple.

    Guess what, I can run Linux on my Apple hardware!! OMFG! I have a choice!! No way!!

    If you like Winblows better, fine. But why does ever PC zelot have to talk shit our thier ass about Macs?? RUN WHAT WORKS FOR YOU AND STFU.

    --
    Department of Homeland Security: Removing the rights real patriots fought and died for since 2001
  54. Re:Could it be possible to run OS X on a PPC based by nuckin+futs · · Score: 2

    I'm pretty sure the Apple motherboards still use Open Firmware. You'll run into problems. Some of Apple's own computers won't even load the OS without the right firmware.

  55. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by ncc74656 · · Score: 2
    Gigabit ethernet is useless for 99% of Mac users

    Huh? Say that next time we use a $12 cable to copy gigs of stuff from my Power Mac to my friend's PowerBook G4 at over 30 MB/s.

    A crossover cable works fine if you have only two machines. The second you add a third machine to the mix, Gigabit Ethernet gets much more expensive. (BTW, $12 for a crossover cable? You could've made one for much less.)

    --
    20 January 2017: the End of an Error.
  56. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by jcoy42 · · Score: 2
    A Gigabit solution is just now getting to the point of being affordable.


    Well, it's not like you can't have that too. Over at newegg, you can pick up a ASUS A7V8X for $144.00. Gigabit networking onboard, USB 2.0, IEEE1394, supports up to DDR400.

    Then click back to the home page and note that you can pick up a boxed AMD 2000XP for $91. Just add need memory, video card, a case, and drives.
    Memory: $137.00 for Samsung 512MB CAS 2.5. You can certainly get faster, but that's about where the price break is, and it kicks the pc133's butt. Video card $219 for the same one as in the ad (I mean article). The case is around $50 for a good screwless model, CD-RW less than $50 (I just picked on up for $20 after rebates- you might notice they didn't include a CD-RW in the article), and for a hard drive, grab the same one in the article for $100. Maybe grab some extra case fans for $4-6 each?

    So that's a *good* machine, brand new, for about $795 +shipping (which isn't going to be much) with all the extras. Gigabit networking, USB 2.0, Firewire, pretty much everything.

    But you can build the used g4 for $1730 if you prefer.

    I'd love to get a mac, but whenever I compare where I can get the most flexibility and bang for the buck, I end up with another PC. My next laptop, however, will be a powerbook.
    --
    Never trust an atom. They make up everything.
  57. Re:Why I won't buy a Mac. Ever. by veddermatic · · Score: 2

    lol, telling someone to use what works for them and not bash other platforms is flamebait?

    OK. I forgot, most /. readers use Windows =)

    --
    Department of Homeland Security: Removing the rights real patriots fought and died for since 2001
  58. Reliability and ease of use? Surely you jest! by Chas · · Score: 2

    Reliability?

    My main system is a P3 550 (was a 450 until a buddy just up and consigned a faster proc over to me). I've owned/used the system for approximately 4 years now.

    Outside of rebooting for system software upgrades, hardware upgrades, and physically moving the system between the three places I've lived in that time frame (as well as to LAN parties), my system has had approximately 1 DAY.

    Including the above, I've had approximately 5 days worth of downtime in 4 years.

    That may not be 5 9's, but it's pretty damn respectable for a Windows box. 0.3% downtime.

    Do you have any Macs with that kind of uptime?

    And don't even get me started on my Linux server.

    Ease of use? Face it. Ease of use became a moot point with the introduction of Windows95.

    Plus, the fact that when most Mac-heads talk about ease of use nowadays, what they're really talking about is familiarity. If you're more familiar with the Mac interface, it's easier for you to use than the Windows UI. And vice-versa.

    --


    Chas - The one, the only.
    THANK GOD!!!
  59. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 2

    Crossover cables are obsolete. At least, they should be. Doesn't everybody do autosense MDI-X by now?

    --

    I write in my journal
  60. It's not a Mac without the case by skington · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I'm typing this on a Mac, but with a bunch of other kit on this desk - a Microsoft mouse, an ADSL router, a TV and a video recorder. And compared to that lot, the Apple keyboard, monitor and G4 tower look resplendent - they're just better designed, they look nicer, they have nice touches like the fact that the iBook, when put to sleep, has a power light that pulses. (Freaked me out at first, when I was trying to get to sleep and wondered where that glowing pulsating light was coming from...)

    I think people who talk about building their own Mac should remember one of the most interesting things about owning a Mac - i.e., the case. And the design that comes with it.

  61. Re:Why I won't buy a Mac. Ever. by veddermatic · · Score: 2

    let's see, does your motherboard support BOTH AMD *and* Intel?

    I didn't think so.

    Idiot

    --
    Department of Homeland Security: Removing the rights real patriots fought and died for since 2001
  62. Hey, us Mac users get to make choices too you know by Ignorant+Aardvark · · Score: 2, Funny

    We get to choose between five fruity colors!

  63. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by ncc74656 · · Score: 2
    Crossover cables are obsolete. At least, they should be. Doesn't everybody do autosense MDI-X by now?

    NICs don't (whether you're dealing with cheapie Realteks or something a little more expensive, like 3Com or Intel). I have a bunch of Fast Ethernet switches that do...but while my 5-port switches cost me only $25 each, you'd be hard-pressed to find a Gigabit Ethernet switch of any kind for less than $300 (except for the $100 units that have a bunch of Fast Ethernet ports and one Gigabit Ethernet uplink port).

    --
    20 January 2017: the End of an Error.
  64. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by Nugget · · Score: 2

    Dragging this thread kicking and screaming back towards the topic, Apple NICs do. There's no need to use a crossover cable with a recent-generation Mac box or laptop.

  65. Re:Why I won't buy a Mac. Ever. by veddermatic · · Score: 2

    at least I have the balls to post replies in my own name, dildo.

    So buying a new Mobo, new processor, and then by some magic my system doesn't need a reformat, reinstall of the OS, re-drivering, etc. Yup, that's so great!!

    "I have a small penis, I bash platforms, then I make homophobic comments, because sucking cock is BAD!! Even if you are a woman or gay!!!!" I take it you, as a 12 year old, haven't had a blowjob yet. Make sure you make fun of the girl/woman/male prostitute/small animal you get it from. That will help you out a lot in life.

    --
    Department of Homeland Security: Removing the rights real patriots fought and died for since 2001
  66. Re:And yet still by veddermatic · · Score: 2

    yup, you can't do a damn thing on a Mac.

    Hold on, let me close Microsoft Office and then pop into my Bash shell and kill my Apache and MySQL processes before I fire up Quake III

    Yes, the PC has more games. No doubt. So does playstation2. that's why I have a G4 and a PS2. When I want to work, I use a Mac. When I want to play video games, I use a game console.

    Neat that a PC does a half-assed verion of both, but I like using the right tool for the job.

    --
    Department of Homeland Security: Removing the rights real patriots fought and died for since 2001
  67. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by ealar+dlanvuli · · Score: 2

    Just another one of those countless things that makes me happier and more productive using a Mac.

    All current Mac's do this, I've not seen any consumer NIC's that do this for PC land. Macs are consntly like this, not shockingly better, but just a little more convenience with every part adds up quickly.

    --
    I live in a giant bucket.
  68. What is a MAC? by BurntHombre · · Score: 3, Informative
    MAC? How would you create your own Media Access Control? Oh, wait -- you mean Mac, as in Macintosh. Got it!
    [/smartass]

    Sorry, referring to a Macintosh as a 'MAC' is one of my pet peeves.

  69. Re:Why I won't buy a Mac. Ever. by axxackall · · Score: 2
    Welcome to Gentoo PPC and other Power Pinguin mail-lists and forums. You'll get many interesting facts about Macs without any brain-wasing ads. Most (if not all) those people installed Linux PPC after they've been disappointed with Mac OS (both 9 and X).

    Many of them still use Mac OS from time to time in dual boot or in MOL (Mac-On-Linux aka vmware) - there are still situations when we need some unported program or driver. Day to day less and less often.

    Got a point? People choose Linux after realizing that they threw a big chunk of many to the window of proprietary hardware.

    Well, after all it's not that bad. Especially when it runs Linux :)

    --

    Less is more !
  70. I didn't say... by unicorn · · Score: 2

    "who will ever need..."

    But based on current usage, what home user can justify gigabit ether, and not justify the price of a "new" Mac?

    I'm thinking a gigabit switch will cost damn near as much as a new Mac. And you ain't building that from spare parts, for sure.

    --
    "Politicians are interested in people. Not that this is always a virtue. Fleas are interested in dogs." P.J. O'Rourke
  71. Re:Reliability and ease of use? Surely you jest! by Gropo · · Score: 2
    Ease of use? Face it. Ease of use became a moot point with the introduction of Windows95.
    Suuure... rummaging through a registry and/or .INI file to rectify system crash epidemics is sure "easy"... Ye lacks perspective methinks.
    Plus, the fact that when most Mac-heads talk about ease of use nowadays, what they're really talking about is familiarity. If you're more familiar with the Mac interface, it's easier for you to use than the Windows UI. And vice-versa.
    Yep, lack of perspective. Apple has always wisely maintained a loose dictatorship when it comes to simple things like menu item ubiquity and key-command ubiquity. Windows completely sucks in this respect. Completely. Utterly.
    Do you have any Macs with that kind of uptime?
    Not personally, but Apple appears to have achieved some respectable longevity. These guys seem to be having better luck with OS X than Windows 2000 for what it's worth.
    --
    I hate Grammar Nazi's
  72. just to be trite... by Frymaster · · Score: 2
    You don't write "WINDOWS" or "LINUX" or "GATEWAY"

    ... but you do write UNIX.

  73. Re:"Switching" to the Mac? by Frymaster · · Score: 4, Informative
    I find it ironic that as much as folks complain about MS' monopolistic practices, look at how much more difficult it is to piece together your own Mac

    microsoft is not a hardware company. they make software which is closed, proprietary and holds a monopoly position. apple makes both hardware (mostly closed, although in many places standards-compliant) and software (much closed, but much open).

    Apple wouldn't have had to create a "switch" campaign if they hadn't reversed their decision to license out their OS.

    why not? they still would have a different hardware architecture (whether it was made by umax or apple) and a different os.

    As I recall, Power Computing at one point sold more Mac-OS running computers than Apple did!

    which is why the macsimilies were cancelled. apple is primarily a hardware company and uses the hardware profits to subsidize the r&d costs of the os. if hardware profits are cut, the os suffers, thus decreasing the attractiveness of the entire platform and further eating marketshare.

    Their market share keeps declining, even as the quality and innovation of their products is on the upswing. How strange.

    this statement could be interpreted as meaning that market share and quality/innovation of product are somehow causally related. if this were true we'd have been watching betamax tapes and driving bmw's for the last ten years. don't trust me... trust derrick from o'reilley.

    It's eerily similar to watching socialist command economies flounder and fall, while free-market ones thrive and give consumers more choices at better prices.

    no... it's earily familiar to watching monarchies flounder and fail while revolutionaries thrive. my analogy is no better or worse than yours. both are unsubstantiated and ubsubstantiatable and serve to do little other than inflame.

  74. Custom built macs ain't any less spendy by BlueF · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Yikes, that's a lot of money for that puppy! Guess they're gonna have to run YellowDog or it's ilk on that box... after laying down all the extra green.

    But, seriously, I look forward to the day when I can run OSXX (not a typo) on my P4-7Ghz. Ah, the longing for the 'nix platform with a stable, polished (snappy) GUI (that doesn't leave you all M$ gooey)... some day. : )

    Keep up the fight!

  75. Re:Ahhem by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 2

    There was this old saying... "Mac owners have more money then brains."

    Used to be true, too. ;-) But today, buying a Mac is definitely the smartest computer investment a person can make.

    --

    I write in my journal
  76. For the fun of it tho? by unicorn · · Score: 2

    I assume you're looking at doing this, primarily "just because"? You don't have an actual valid purpose for all that bandwidth, do you?

    --
    "Politicians are interested in people. Not that this is always a virtue. Fleas are interested in dogs." P.J. O'Rourke
  77. Re:Reliability and ease of use? Surely you jest! by kalidasa · · Score: 2

    Have you EVER used a Mac, man? I used PCs from 1987 to 2001. That's 14 years. I've used Mac for 1 1/2 years. (Though in both cases I've used the other one, and UNIX, a fraction of the time. Before the PCs and UNIX, it was VMS and a VT100 terminal.) The Mac is easier to use, hands down. That's not familiarity, that's design.

    Stability? I keep my iBook on almost all the time; I sleep it closed when I'm not using it, charge it at home at night. Doesn't crash. Even though I switch back and forth between 802.11b and Ethernet.

    I think you're still thinking of System 7, which crashed every time you looked at it crosseyed. OS X is spectacular. When it comes to quality, XP:98::OSX:2(OS9) (and XP=1/2(OS X)).

  78. 2 all beef patties, special sauce, lettuce, cheese by pschmied · · Score: 2

    ... Wouldn't you rather a nice, cold shower?

    Ahh, fun with Ask Jeeves.

    -Peter

  79. Mine May Not Be Cutting-Edge, But Its Cool by thedbp · · Score: 4, Interesting

    here's the lowdown (as if anyone cares) of the Mac I've been piecing together for a few months now:

    Its a 7600 case painted gloss black w/ silver highlights on the power button, the cd eject button, and, of course, the apple logo.

    inside you'll find a beige g3 rev 3 mobo. a 350 MHz G3 clocked up to 433 w/ 1MB cache, 6MB internal Rage Pro graphics. Beefed up to 768 MB RAM. Added the A/V card that was optional on these models. Added a USB/FW combo card, a fast ethernet card, a Radeon 7000 PCI graphics card, 2 HDs(12 and 20, soon to be 12 and 80), a and a DVD-ROM for movies. This baby kills. Check out the list of ports:

    1/8" stereo audio in
    1/8" stereo audio out
    RCA stereo audio in
    RCA stereo audio out
    RCA video in
    RCA video out
    S-video in
    2x S-video out (one onboard, one on Radeon card)
    Original Apple Monitor Connector
    VGA
    DVI
    2 USB
    2 FW
    10/100 Enet
    10 Enet
    SCSI
    2x serial
    ADB
    3x Monitor support (2 off the Radeon, one off internal video - the internal video can be a monitor or television, Radeon can be any 2 of either DVI, VGA, or S-video or composite video.).

    Its not a gaming station as I'm stuck w/ PCI graphics and a 66MHz bus on this (Tomb Raider runs great but forget about Jedi Knight II), but I'm not done w/ it yet. Next up are the final 2 additions:
    -SuperDrive (found a vendor that sells a black model CHEAP, so it'll match - just bought one for my B&W G3 and it rules.)
    - Single or Dual G4. XLR8 made a dual g4 upgrade, but they're out of business. So I'm trying to find a dual 450 or 500 upgrade for this baby, and if I can't find one I'll swap in a 450 from a B&W I'm upgrading, clock it up a tad, and be done with it.

    OK, so there's the setup, now here's the use:
    computer sits by the couch/loveseat/lazyboy w/ a flat panel monitor, wireless mouse and keyboard. the computer's display is mirrored on the tv set via the Radeon. Cable TV runs directly into the TV. Cable TV also runs into a VCR, which is plugged into the Computer via S or Composite Video. Audio out from Computer (which also serves as a CD player, DVD player, networked MP3 player, CD burner, DVD burner, and PVR) goes into a reciever to speakers. Everything else is also hooked into the reciever. Reciever audio out is looped back into the Computer through 1/8" input on Computer while the VCR uses RCA audio in.
    The Computer's video is hooked into the Receiver as well, with the output going into the TV, and an auxilliary video and audio output going back into the VCR.

    This way, ABSOLUTELY EVERYTHING can be recorded both digitally and analog with live monitoring and multiple recording points. Please keep in mind that a CD-changer, record player, and tape deck are all plugged into the receiver as well. Because of the way its set up, the TV can be just a TV or have the full computer interface and due to the VCR hooked into the computer, can retain TV functionality in addition to all the other uses that a Mac has.

    The computer is running on Mac OS X Jaguar, so its a cinch to set up an audio/video file server and a limited-use user account specifically for the functions of using it as a media center. Not to mention the use of a Wacom tablet for interaction, plus all the user apps that mac Mac OS X so great - iMovie, iPhoto, etc., all integrated into a total entertainment environment. Plus, using bluetooth, if I'm watching TV and my cell rings, I'll get a nice pop-up message on my TV of who's calling with their picture. I drool when I think about it. Much cooler and more expandable/useful than MS's media center, and the components were dirt cheap. most were scavenged off eBay or are hand-me-downs from a B&W G4 that I've been upgrading as well. Fun stuff!

    Beyond that, add into the mix the Computer's ability to run things like Pro Tools or Deck. And iTunes will soon have Rendevous support, so as soon as my friends come over with their iBooks or PowerBooks, their music is available on my entertaiment system automatically. Or use a USB or FireWire TV tuner and run cable directly into the Computer as well. The sheer geekiness of it is astounding.

    The possibilities are endless, and I'm like 85% there. I really should have been chronicling all this (especially all the clocking experiments) or something, but I usually only get to work on it in the wee hours when I'm all cracked out (not literally mind you).

    Oh well, that's it. I think its cool, its been fun to build, and I hope nobody is mad cuz they read the whole damn post and feel ripped off.

  80. Re:processor prices Re:gah! by Llywelyn · · Score: 2

    It is listed as a:

    PowerPC 750CXe v3.1 (tech 3)

    --
    Integrate Keynote and LaTeX
  81. Re:+1 nutter by thedbp · · Score: 2

    sorry, not gonna sell it - its too dear to me. the grand design has been long hatching and when its done, i'm gonna use it till its absolutely dead. its going to be a killer entertainment center, and my life will finally have meaning.

  82. Re: microsoft is not a hardware company by Frymaster · · Score: 2
    While their primary product may be software, microsoft sells lots of hardware... I'd bet quite a few slashdotters have MS mice, joysticks, or even keyboards. I even saw a wireless router


    so, are you saying i can build my own opitcal intellimouse with off-the-shelf parts? or whip up an xbox in my garage?