Slashdot Mirror


Nintendo To Sell Old Consoles To China?

drfishy writes "An interview with Nintendo president Satoru Iwata on IGN hints at the possibility of Nintendo entering the Chinese market with their products soon. The most curious part of the interview is that Satoru Iwata says Nintendo is considering releasing older generation hardware to combat piracy, could this mean the big N is going to start making Super Nintendos again? Will there be new games? How would this fight piracy?"

118 of 299 comments (clear)

  1. how do you fight piracy with this? by stonebeat.org · · Score: 2

    how i wouldnt mind buying a older nintendo, if it is 1/3 of the price....

    1. Re:how do you fight piracy with this? by vasqzr · · Score: 2, Informative


      Well, go over to FuncoLand and buy one!

      Use the store locator, they've been selling and buying used systems and games for quite a while.

      Once in a while I'll buy an older system and a few games, then discover they weren't as fun as I remembered.

      It's either that or start finding ROM's and emulators.

  2. Piracy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The cartdrige systems are harder to pirate because it requires more hardware than a CD burner. That alone prevents casual copying of games.

    They are using the older (N64 I assume) generation because it was the last cartdrige based system.

  3. Re:Cartridges by tchueh · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Doesn't matter how good the products are, if people want to pirate them, they will.

    Now, if the packaging is sweetass, that's a different issue.

  4. Look at all the SNES games for GBA by benzapp · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The Gameboy Advance is clearly based on the Super Nintendo. Given that many Chinese probably do not even have televisions, having an all in one unit like the GBA is probably a great idea. I doubt we will see the actual console as it once was, the unit will probably be very much like gameboy advance. Perhaps it will have a TV out or something of the kind.

    --
    I don't read or respond to AC posts
    1. Re:Look at all the SNES games for GBA by Lord+Zelgadis · · Score: 2, Insightful

      hey, don't casually assume that the Chinese people aren't technologically advanced. GBA's are already available in China, also. So I do think that the big N is going to ship older consoles, if at all.

    2. Re:Look at all the SNES games for GBA by Vinson+Massif · · Score: 4, Interesting

      [quote]
      "Given that many Chinese probably do not even have televisions..."

      Did you pull that one out of your ass?

      China has roughly 300 million televisions. The US has around 215 million.
      [/quote]

      China has 1.5 billion people, the US has 300 million. I beleve he's accurate

      --
      "Remember, any tool can be the right tool." -- Red Green
    3. Re:Look at all the SNES games for GBA by MyHair · · Score: 2

      Grandparent post: The US has around 215 million. [TVs]

      Parent post: ...the US has 300 million. [people]

      I find that hard to believe there are fewer TVs than people in the US. I think I have about 2 million PCs in my house alone. I think you all can relate.

    4. Re:Look at all the SNES games for GBA by benzapp · · Score: 2

      He wasn't accurate, he said: "Given that many Chinese probably do not even have televisions". In reality 300 million Chinese HAVE televisions (compared to 215 million in US). Thus market for consoles is larger in China than in US.

      Ahh I love the slasdot AC semantics crowd. By the posters own admission, 80% of Chinese do NOT own televisions wheras at least 80% of Americans do. How can one say there is a larger market for consoles FOR televisions in China than in the United States. 80% of Chinese do not have televisions and probably WANT to play video games. Rather than make them own a television FIRST you can just have them buy a Gameboy Advance. Problem solved.

      I was never comparing the Chinese market to the American market or anywhere else. However, anyone who is selling something, from video games to opium would much rather sell it to every Chinaman in China. Thus it is EASIER to sell a device such as a gameboy advance than an SNES IN CHINA.

      Think people. Please.

      --
      I don't read or respond to AC posts
  5. Yeah... by Jaysyn · · Score: 5, Funny

    ... cause it's so easy to copy a GameCube Game.

    Jayysn

    --
    There is a war going on for your mind.
    1. Re:Yeah... by vslashg · · Score: 2, Funny

      Now who's the retard?

      Everyone who posted in this thread. Except for me, of course.

  6. "Fighting" piracy by mrbrown1602 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    By re-releasing older consoles, Nintendo can shutdown ROM piracy by claiming that the games are actively on the market.

    1. Re:"Fighting" piracy by entrippy · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Nintendo are the one company (at least that springs to mind) that can completely legitimately claim that it still gets use out of its ROMs.

      Now, whether or not you think "abandonware" is a valid concept, you have to agree that if the software is still doing the rounds then it's not "keeping old software from dying" it's "piracy". Now, where you stand on piracy is a different matter, but the FACT of the matter is that Nintendo use thier old ROM's.

      Recent examples include the E-Reader for the GBA that lets you play old games and the various unlockable ROMs in Animal Crossing.

      Why, by the way, do you think Nintendo would want to shutdown ROM piracy just for the hell of it? Why do you think they would spend the money to deploy SNES's into China *just* to crackdown on ROM piracy?

      Nintendo cracks down on ROM piracy because they plan to use the IP as they see fit (bonuses for other games, deploying old hardware into new regions) and because they therefore view it as piracy, pure and simple.

      You don't get some god-given right to copy software just because it's a few years old. You might like to, but that's not the way it is. If you wanna pirate, that's your call - but don't call it anything else.

      This is not a critique of MrBrown, by the by, just an expansion of the points he brought up.

    2. Re:"Fighting" piracy by artemis67 · · Score: 2

      By re-releasing older consoles, Nintendo can shutdown ROM piracy by claiming that the games are actively on the market.

      Actually, they're already doing that with their E-Cards for GBA. The 2-D, 16-bit games, anyway.

      Perhaps they're thinking that the cartridge system of the Nintendo 64 is preferable to the CD system of the GameCube, because it's a lot harder to duplicate a cartridge.

    3. Re:"Fighting" piracy by giel · · Score: 2

      Hm. It says that they are dumping old hardware onthe chinese market. I can't see how I'd be fighting piracy dumping my old hardware on a junkyard. Not even if it's configured in such a way it would nly run my own legacy trash.

      Can anyone explain the idea?

      --
      giel.y contains 2 shift/reduce conflicts
    4. Re:"Fighting" piracy by farnsworth · · Score: 5, Interesting
      By re-releasing older consoles, Nintendo can shutdown ROM piracy by claiming that the games are actively on the market.

      By not re-releasing older consoles, Nintendo has nothing to lose by people pirating roms because the games are not on the market.

      More than likely, they are counting on the difficulty of copying cartridge media.

      --

      There aint no pancake so thin it doesn't have two sides.

    5. Re:"Fighting" piracy by Huogo · · Score: 2, Informative

      Gamecube uses a propritary disk, I don't see how you could easily copy it. It uses a mini 1.5 GB dvd type thing. I don't know anyone that can copy those, but I do know it is VERY possible to get blank cartridges, some hardware at radio shack, and some parts from a SNES and make your own carts.

    6. Re:"Fighting" piracy by Paladin128 · · Score: 5, Funny

      If you wanna pirate, that's your call - but don't call it anything else.

      I'll keep that in mind... if I want to commit robbery at sea, I'll make sure to refer to it as piracy.

      --
      Lex orandi, lex credendi.
    7. Re:"Fighting" piracy by Sycraft-fu · · Score: 2

      Which, by the way, still happens and more often than you'd think. That's probably the thing that bothers me the most about the term piracy for copyright infringment is we are NOT talking about some ancient crime from the past, it's still a very real thing today.

    8. Re:"Fighting" piracy by LostCluster · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Also, even if Nintendo were to lose 100% of the SNES in US market to the pirates, that's not much at all to have lost compared to what they're making off the GameCube now.

      Remember, the reason for DVD region codes is so that if a copyright-lawless region started pumping out auathorized copies of the locally available DVDs, those DVDs would be useless in an American Region 1 player. (So, that's the reason why the lawless land that is Antarctica gets its own DVD region...)

      By keeping curent generation technology out of China, it's a lot harder for China to export anything that's useful to the US piracy market.

    9. Re:"Fighting" piracy by Cruciform · · Score: 2

      "Arrrrr matey! Just hand over those gold doubloons and I'll give them back as soon as I'm down downloading them."

    10. Re:"Fighting" piracy by intermodal · · Score: 2

      "The 2-D, 16-bit games, anyway."

      Last time I checked, the original nintendo was an 8-bit machine, and that's what's going on the cards. The Super Nintendo was the 16-bit.

      --
      In SOVIET RUSSIA... erm...NSA AMERICA, the Internet logs onto YOU!
    11. Re:"Fighting" piracy by Suppafly · · Score: 2

      there is no reason it has to read the data off of a dvd though. I see no reason why one can't bypass the dvd reader and put some kind of gc to pc cable on and make it read from an ide harddrive.

    12. Re:"Fighting" piracy by sean23007 · · Score: 2

      Yeah, as opposed to a proprietary and unique inch and a half wide disc...

      --

      Lack of eloquence does not denote lack of intelligence, though they often coincide.
    13. Re:"Fighting" piracy by The+Creator · · Score: 2
      Remember, the reason for DVD region codes is so that if a copyright-lawless region started pumping out auathorized copies of the locally available DVDs, those DVDs would be useless in an American Region 1 player.


      What do you think whould stop someone in a "copyright-lawless"-region from first importing an american region disc and then pumping out illegal copies of that?

      --

      FRA: STFU GTFO
    14. Re:"Fighting" piracy by derch · · Score: 2

      It will fight piracy by being cheaper. Ideally Nintendo has already recouped development costs on the systems and the games. That means they can reproduce an older system, and all that needs to be covered are manufacturing, business, and shipping expenses - all relatively low and constant. Manufacturing methods have probably also progressed so that the hardware is cheaper (look at the $20 10-in-1 Atari & Activision games). Nintendo can offer the system and games at competitive rates to pirates. So given the choice between a real $15 cartridge and a shady $10, most people will do the right thing and buy the $15. (Numbers are made up.)

    15. Re:"Fighting" piracy by Fjord · · Score: 2

      And they are releasing the 2-D 16-bit games on GBA. An example is A Link to the Past (Zelda 3 for the Super Nintendo).

      --
      -no broken link
    16. Re:"Fighting" piracy by warmcat · · Score: 2

      Actually you do get a 'God given right' to copy things that are a 'few' years old, its called the Public Domain after the copyright period expires.

    17. Re:"Fighting" piracy by PaddyM · · Score: 2

      This is quite ironic, because I would pay for the SOFTWARE ROMS but not the RE-PACKAGED HARDWARE ROMS simply because it is much more CONVENIENT to have all sorts of EMULATORS on 1 COMPUTER with all my GAMES rather than having to STORE all sorts of OLD GAMES AND OLD SYSTEMS. But apparently, with Palladium in the works, companies want us to have to BUY a NEW SYSTEM every time thier software changes.

      I'm not sure, but I think that with the current densities of hard drives, software roms are definitely more environmentally friendly than any alternative. But again, I'm not sure what the environmental impact of the 120GB harddrive is (given failure,rate, etc).

    18. Re:"Fighting" piracy by PaddyM · · Score: 2

      I believe you meant, 'their' not 'thier' you vocabulary-challenged pirate.

  7. Pricing by Apreche · · Score: 5, Interesting

    If Nintendo starts manufacturing old hardware again that will mess up the prices of used games in a big way. I we at the mall days ago and they has NESs for 40 bucks, SNES for 30 and N64s for an amount I forget, but cheap. They might have been cheaper than the NESs I dont' remember so well. Bit it was messed up! We've got like 3 NESs in the house. Well actually 1 physically here. I own one that is far away. We won one at a duck hunt tournament (people SUCK at duck hunt!) and my roomate's got one. We gave one to his brother.

    Oh yeah, that's another thing. At that very same duck hunt tournament there was a guy who was collecting Mario/Duck Hunt cartridges. He had so many he made a suit of armor out of them. However, he performed very poorly compared to us in the tourney. Apparently he collected so many that the price went from 15 cents to 95 cents a cart in his time. If nintendo manufactures more old Nintendo stuff wont that not work. I mean people can get carts for 95 cents they aren't going to pay more than that. And making more supply just lowers prices.

    I'm fairly certain Nintendo will only be manufacturing N64 stuff if anything. They aren't that stupid.

    --
    The GeekNights podcast is going strong. Listen!
    1. Re:Pricing by baba · · Score: 2, Funny

      Wow man, your English is short of the mark even by /. standards. I'm impressed.

  8. Most Chinese DO have TVs by grainofsand · · Score: 5, Informative

    Having lived in China for three years, I can assure you almost every Chinese household has a TV. Sets are cheap with a domestic 29-inch selling for around $US90.

    A Hong Kong-based market research firm recently suggested television set penetration was around 92 percent on the mainland, compared with 42 percent for refrigerators!

    All of the major consoles (inc XBox) are available in China as "grey imports". A PS2 sells for about US$200 and an XBox for about $US300. Pirate games galore and easily available for around $US2.50.

    --
    A dream is good. A plan is better.
    1. Re:Most Chinese DO have TVs by 56 · · Score: 2, Informative
      China has:

      400,000,000 Televisions:

      and

      1,284,303,705 People

      Source: The CIA World Factbook 2002

    2. Re:Most Chinese DO have TVs by grainofsand · · Score: 2, Informative

      1.3 billion divided by three (the size of the average Chinese family given the one-child policy) is roughly 400 million.

      TV set penetration is about 95% on the mainland. Per household NOT per person.

      --
      A dream is good. A plan is better.
    3. Re:Most Chinese DO have TVs by FooBarWidget · · Score: 3, Informative

      That doesn't mean most Chinese don't have a TV. A household as a whole (2 parents, 1 child, maybe 2 grandparents) can have 1 TV, which is more than enough.

    4. Re:Most Chinese DO have TVs by Kragg · · Score: 2

      I'm sorry, your figures are out of date. They now have 1,284,303,707 People.

      --
      If you can't see this, click here to enable sigs.
  9. 32mb by SHEENmaster · · Score: 5, Funny

    We all know how much harder a 32mb prom image is to toss around the internet than a 640mb sorta-but-not-quite-ISO cd image.

    GameBoy emulation on the Sharp Zaurus helps keep my sanity through certain classes <cough fake="true">English</cough>

    --
    You can't judge a book by the way it wears its hair.
  10. Re:Cartridges by entrippy · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Well, given that he said "older generation hardware" that pretty much means that carts are a given.

    However, all the old Nintendo hardware could be pirated - it's just more expensive and time consuming than it would be with any disc based medium. Also, almost all the common methods of piracy required special hardware.

    Honestly, I think Nintendos largest concern is that releasing the GameCube there would result in massive piracy of the special mini-dvd format dics and the release of them to the rest of the world. Nintendo would hate nothing more than a stream of copied media coming out when they've worked so hard (and so far largely successfully) to keep GameCube piracy down.

  11. That's very nice of him by jsse · · Score: 5, Funny

    to think about the children in underdevelopment countries. I'm sure my nephew in China will dump his PS2 once he could have given chance to taste the power of.....an old Nintendo. The Nintendo emulator on his dual Athlon-MP 2600 definitely can't compare to a real one. However Mr. Iwata must take into consideration whether there's enough electricity to power up one Nintendo there, because people are still using dynamo to power up lightblubs.

    Exactly what parallel universe is Mr. Satoru Iwata living in?

  12. Re:Cartridges by schnell · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The only real way I can see this fighting piracy is if they want to go back to cartridge based systems, but why not just make the products good enough that people will actually buy them.

    I'm not sure, but is the implication here is that people only pirate games if they aren't good enough to buy? I can maybe see that if you're arguing a "try before you buy" attitude, but it's pretty clear that the people most interested in pirating games are going to do it regardless of how good it is ... in fact, I'd say a great game is more likely to be pirated by your average 15-year-old k3wl w4r3z d00d than a subpar game.

    Hypocrisy disclaimer: I download MP3s and will generally not buy an album unless there are at least two (for bargain CDs) or three (full-priced discs) songs on a CD by that band I like. I would, however, gladly pay for those songs if they were available singly in a DRM-free format. I don't know if there is an appropriate analog in the video game world ("I didn't pay $50 for the full game, but I'd pay $10 for just the first three levels if that was available(?)")

    Either way, I don't think it's fair to say, "I liked your game ... but not enough to pay for it. The reason I am pirating your games instead of paying you is because I wish it was better, so it's YOUR fault." That sort of reasoning is akin to blaming women for assaults because they were being "too provocative" or some s**t like that ... that train of thought is just wrong.

    --
    "95% of all Slashdot .sig quotes are incorrect or completely fabricated." -Benjamin Franklin
  13. You're missing the point... by silvaran · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I see a lot of people linking cartridges to combat piracy. This is not at all what Nintendo has in mind. People are pirating Nintendo hardware/software because they simply don't exist on the Chinese market. So if you introduce them to the market, some of the people who are pirating Nintendo merchandise will start to purchase it, and piracy will decrease. Granted, in some cases it may be cheaper to pirate, but by giving people what they want, they may be willing to pay for it.

    Cartridges are just as easy to copy as CDs with the right hardware. A friend of mine paid $300 Canadian for a blank cartridge (can hold, on average, 8 GBA games), a cartridge copier, and a GBA. He can store a bunch of games on a CD or on his hard drive, and dump them to the blank cartridge whenever he wants to play them. The games are smaller, the cartridge is rewritable (although yes, there are CR-RWs available) and hooks right up to his computer.

    Introducing their products on the market won't make copying harder; if anything, it'll make it easier. It's giving people another incentive to not pirate these products that Nintendo is after.

    1. Re:You're missing the point... by Sycraft-fu · · Score: 2

      As easy, yes, but more expensive. Blank CDs are trivially cheap. EEPROMs are not.

    2. Re:You're missing the point... by silvaran · · Score: 2

      Your post says it all, $300Ca for ONE cartridge

      A friend of mine paid $300 Canadian for a blank cartridge (can hold, on average, 8 GBA games), a cartridge copier, and a GBA.

      You should probably finish reading the entire sentence before you reply.

  14. Possibilities beyond gaming by Samir+Gupta · · Score: 5, Funny
    We've done a lot of research into uses of Nintendo consoles other than gaming, such as using it as a inexpensive terminal for Internet access, or more compellingly, education, and we have done preliminary work with various Chinese governmental bodies and NGOs to make games such as Super Marx Brothers and The Legend of Deng Xiaoping to teach Chinese youth in new and engaging dynamic ways.

    Using older game consoles such as N64 and even SNES/SFC enables schools, particularly in rural areas, to immediately gain the benefits of technology without the cost and maintainence expense associated with traditional PC platforms. We look forward to seeing the results of this experiment in China, and will likely expand to other developing countries if it goes well.

    --
    -- Samir Gupta, Ph. D. Head, New Technology Research Group, Nintendo Co. Ltd., Kyoto, Japan.
    1. Re:Possibilities beyond gaming by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      Super Marx brothers post got modded up? Yes, this is definitely Slashdot. Good troll, kind sir!

    2. Re:Possibilities beyond gaming by Klaruz · · Score: 3, Flamebait

      I thought you worked at Sega?

      How's your Smell-o-vision project going?

      Your education background is pretty impressive too.

      At least you're presistant. It looks like you've managed to fool alot of people on slashdot. It is kinda funny though. Super Marx Brothers [slaps knee]

    3. Re:Possibilities beyond gaming by Klaruz · · Score: 2

      Here's some more stuff other slashdoters looked up.

      Or is that you posting as an AC, Samir? It's a good thing you don't have to fake your headers and mess that up like you did when you 'worked' for sega.

    4. Re:Possibilities beyond gaming by Klaruz · · Score: 2

      I had an itch, I scratched it.

  15. ROMs Prevent Piracy ? What About Emulators? by syntap · · Score: 3, Insightful

    If there isn't a current working emulator for the N64, there will be (just like everything else). ROMs aren't a problem to dump, so it will actaulyl be EASIER to pirate those than to duplicate the special small GameCube titles. Not sure why Ninetnedo wants to go this route...

    Actaully, given reports of their diminishing profitability, I'm not sure why they don't flood China with GameBoys instead. Or maybe that's what "old hardware" meant...

  16. Re:Cartridges by shird · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Actually, as another poster pointed out, it is probably more to do with the fact that the games sold in China will probably be a lot cheaper - and mixed with a lot of pirated games. IF the newset console is readily available in China, the pirated games to go along with it will crop up very quick. Thus, people in USA/Australia/Europe would rather import games/pirated games from China, because the latest games for the latest console would be readily available.

    Pirating catridges isn't that difficult, and has been done for some time.

    --
    I.O.U One Sig.
  17. This Would Cause a Near-Revolution in China by John_Booty · · Score: 5, Funny

    Think about it... suppose they re-release the SNES over there.

    Now, think back to the days when *you* were playing SNES. Suppose consoles as powerful as the XBOX, PS2, and GameCube were available elsewhere in the world but they weren't available to you, thanks to your government.

    Holy crap! I'd be plotting to overthrown that bastard in a minute!

    --

    OtakuBooty.com: Smart, funny, sexy nerds.
  18. Stopping piracy by coupland · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Actually I think what he means is that in China you can get burned DVDs and CDs a dime a dozen, so they're afraid to release Gamecube in China. ROMs are much more difficult to copy so they'll release N64 instead.

    I don't think it's got to do with preventing ROM piracy since no matter how long a game's been off the market it's still technically illegal to copy it.

    1. Re:Stopping piracy by jasonditz · · Score: 2

      N64 piracy mechanisms have been available for years now, be they zip drives or CD-based systems. Likewise for the SNES and NES systems, piracy has been done to death.

      The Gamecube, on the other hand, his seen no piracy at all. The reason is that pirating would require the ability to read Gamecube discs on something other than a Gamecube, and would also require some medium to copy the contents onto that could then be played back on the cube.

      If Nintendo is really worried about piracy here it would seem like rather than rereleasing a system that the HK folks have pirated to death for years they'd release their as yet uncracked current system.

      More likely it seems to me that they're shipping inferior products to China because they'd be cheaper to make and sell and the Chinese don't have huge disposable incomes. Blaming it on piracy might be a way of sparing someone's feelings.

    2. Re:Stopping piracy by coupland · · Score: 2

      >N64 piracy mechanisms have been available for years now, be they zip drives or CD-based systems. Likewise for the SNES and NES systems, piracy has been done to death.

      But these are all hardware solutions so they'll always be the realm of a few enthusiasts. However when you can buy an exact copy of a game or movie, that worries the content oligarchy immensely.

      >The Gamecube, on the other hand, his seen no piracy at all.

      I don't know a lot about GameCube drives but my understanding was they were just small-format DVDs, my assumption with encryption. Well mini-CDs were uncopyable for the longest time until someone realized they were part of the redbook standard and the only issue was lack of media. I'm sure GameCube is somewhat more complicated but isn't their hardware standards-compliant? Last time I was in Beijing you could buy a stack of burned movies for $20USD on the side of the road, I think this is what worries Nintendo...

    3. Re:Stopping piracy by maxume · · Score: 2

      They spin their drive in the opposite direction of standard dvd drives...

      --
      Nerd rage is the funniest rage.
    4. Re:Stopping piracy by jasonditz · · Score: 2

      The only console ever that didn't require a hardware solution was the Sega Dreamcast. Even mod-chipping your system is something that's in the realm of a few enthusiasts.

      I don't think any piece of Nintendo hardware has ever been "standards-compliant" even going all the way back to their floppy disks for the old NES. The Gamecube disc has a similar capacity to a DVD drive, and undoubtably borrows some of the technology, but that's nowhere close to a solution to how to read the data into a PC or how to create the media which is read in the opposite direction of a DVD drive.

      I would think of Chinese (espc. HK) hackers had the ability to pirate GC games they'd already be doing so, even if the system isn't widespread available in their country.

  19. NES -- Famicom by X_Caffeine · · Score: 2

    Strangely enough, that was kind of the point of the original NES (a.k.a. Famicom - family computer) in the first place. Remember that parallel/expansion port thingy?

    --
    // I will show you fear in a handful of jellybeans.
  20. Re:Cartridges by jasonditz · · Score: 2
    Either way, I don't think it's fair to say, "I liked your game ... but not enough to pay for it. The reason I am pirating your games instead of paying you is because I wish it was better, so it's YOUR fault." That sort of reasoning is akin to blaming women for assaults because they were being "too provocative" or some s**t like that ... that train of thought is just wrong.

    actually that's not the same sort of reasoning at all. The actual analog would be a hooker taking your money and then refusing to sleep with you because you smell bad.

  21. drop me a line... by djupedal · · Score: 2

    I'll be looking into reverse exports for those with a nostagia itch. At 1/3, everyone can make a profit, I'm sure :)

  22. Re:A third of the price of what? by UnknownSoldier · · Score: 2

    > (And why did you leave the +1 bonus on your post? If used on silly little things like that you should turn it off. You only wrote 15 'words', for fuck's sake.)

    Now I've seen it all! An AC complaining about a logged in user "potentially wasting" karma. Maybe the user has been capped and doesn't care.

  23. Re:Cartridges by Squareball · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Really, I thought that the GameCube had a pretty good way to fight piracy.. they just use a non-standard propritary CD. How can you pirate something that you cannot re-create? There surely is a way, but it's not about the ability it's about the ease of it. If it's easy to pirate a lot of people will do it. If it's hard to pirate, a lot less people will.

  24. What kinds of games? by goingincirclez · · Score: 5, Interesting

    This might be a little off-topic, but I got to thinking (uh oh):

    Assuming that Nintendo (or anyone else for that matter) re-released an old console & games, what kind of editing would be necessary to make a game fit the culture?

    Take for example, the classic NES games Rush N' Attack (say it out loud) and Contra. Those were clearly marketed toward the anti-communism sentiment prevalent in the US in the 80's. How would the Chinese take to that?

    Or even something say like GTA3... which very vividly portrays a modern western society (scary thought). For the most part, that's stuff we believe the Chinese can only dream of. What would they think of it? How about games like Wall Street Kid ?

    For that matter, what kind of Chinese-only games are there? Damn, I wish I knew more about the culture... I'm sure they would have games that are pure fun in context to them, but would have no chance of being appreciated over here.

    --
    ~~~
    "The slave thinks he is released from bondage, only to find a stronger set of chains" - NIN
    1. Re:What kinds of games? by Guppy06 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      "Those were clearly marketed toward the anti-communism sentiment prevalent in the US in the 80's. How would the Chinese take to that?"

      Well, for starters, Rush N' Attack would probably be fine because the PRC hated the USSR almost as much (if not more) than we did.

      Contra should be alright because everybody hates aliens. (I mean, really, how are you going to associate a giant, disembodied beating heart thing with communism?)

      "Or even something say like GTA3... which very vividly portrays a modern western society (scary thought)."

      It will do nothing more than cement existing stereotypes. Much like it did with you.

      "For that matter, what kind of Chinese-only games are there?"

      I would suspect that they're all bad, to the point where "focusing on a Chinese theme" was designed to be their only selling point. It's really hard to put a finger on what the really good games are based on. Is Super Mario Bros. 3 centered about Japanese culture? US? Wait, there are pyramids involved, maybe it's Egyptian...

      "Damn, I wish I knew more about the culture..."

      Don't worry, it changes every few decades anyway, with bloody purges in between.

    2. Re:What kinds of games? by LostCluster · · Score: 2

      Isn't every title mentioned in the parent post a game that came from somebody other that Nintendo in the first place?

    3. Re:What kinds of games? by MyHair · · Score: 2

      Or even something say like GTA3... which very vividly portrays a modern western society. . .

      . . . where they're a character that trashes and bashes western citizens and authorities.

      I'd think that'd go over even better over there than here!

  25. Fighting piracy by autopr0n · · Score: 2

    Well, I suppose cartrages are a bit harder to pirate, but that never stopped anyone in east asia before.

    On the other hand, while the chinese economy is on fire, I doubt many people would be able to afford $100 consoles anytime soon, but SNESs could probably be made for $10-20 MSRP these days.

    My guess is there will be new games, but only in chinese from chinese 3rd parties, while nintendo puts out translations of their popular games.

    --
    autopr0n is like, down and stuff.
  26. I don't care about piracy, just give me Mario! by crashnbur · · Score: 2
    As long as I get a copy of any new Super Mario games that may be released, I will be the happiest boy on earth! (And a 22-year-old boy before any of those games saw the light of day.)

    On a side note, I think that new Super Mario Bros. games should be made anyway. I want a Gamecube disc full of expanded versions of all the old side-scrolling Mario games. Man, I'd buy a Gamecube just to get at that! (Nothing beats the functionality or fun of the classic Mario games!)

    1. Re:I don't care about piracy, just give me Mario! by digitalsushi · · Score: 2

      And how long do you figure it'd take to make another 2D mario, given they keep making the 3D ones? Heck one of my backburner (okay... reaaaaly far in the back) projects is to do my own Marioworld level in Flash. 96 levels? Why can't I get a cube disc with about 512 instead? Eventually fan written tribute games are going to start getting popular, once it's easy enough. I figure it'll be able the same time Poser 7 or 8 is out and all people will do is scan any random photo of people they know, and then sit at the machine like zombies watching autogenerated porn of it. I'll be downstairs playing as Princess Peach trying to save Lenny Koopa from the environmentally-unsafe Mario and Luigi Koopa Kanning Kompany. I guess the answer is that art imitates life, cause only a game about popping mushrooms could be made by a room full of programmers popping mushrooms. Oh! and new Mariokart levels. And in that set I want playable, full scale models of real life cities. Whoa!- wouldnt it be cool if there was a method of getting current City maps, down to the weather and maybe traffic congestion, ambient lighting, et cetera, and hotdog vendors in the street, such that any game that employed it could tap into an online db and get real time city driving? Ok I'll stop rambling now. Sometimes I just like to type these things in so that they get archived and some bored game developer, looking to save his job with a cool idea, steals it and I end up with something I want 10 years after I wanted it!

      --
      slashdot: where everyone yells sarcastic metaphors to themselves to understand the issue
    2. Re:I don't care about piracy, just give me Mario! by crashnbur · · Score: 2
      Well, the idea would be to play them on the consoles themselves. I *hate* wasting my computer's resources on games. When I'm on a computer, I want to gather or process information, files, etc. I don't want to play games.

      Now... if Nintendo would sell development kits to individual software groups to develop their own SNES or N64 games in a few years, not only might they make some pocket change on the side, but the consoles might become popular again, and I'd buy one! (Mmm... Super Nintendo...)

  27. fighting piracy? a red herring, if you ask me.... by smd4985 · · Score: 2

    i don't think nintendo wants to sell old consoles in china to 'fight piracy' - plain and simple old consoles are CHEAPER. The average chinese household couldn't afford a GC, so releasing the SNES or N64 is the smart move - the consoles are cheap to make and there are plenty of great games they can re-release (and make more money on).

    --
    smd4985
  28. Piracy Reason by CarbonCopy123 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    He says:
    Due to piracy problems, we are studying several marketing methods, such as selling machines several generations old, rather than the latest models.

    Maybe I'm just thinking too simply, but it seems like he means he wants to avoid piracy, not stop what is currently happening. Nintendo's is thinking that due to high piracy in china, if they sell their newest games, they'll be copied and sold illegaly in other more lurcrative markets (US, Japan). If you only sell china old games, nobody is going to bother to pirate them. So sell them SNES and make some extra bucks with no negative effects.

  29. Okay, how's this by autopr0n · · Score: 3, Interesting

    How's this justification for you: I like the products but I don't like giving up money. So I won't, unless I like the product so much that I want to finance future development of similar products from the same people.

    --
    autopr0n is like, down and stuff.
  30. Copyright Question by crashnbur · · Score: 2

    Do the copyrights on games expire in the same way that copyrights expire on everything else? Or, since the company theoretically will still be around in [X] years, is the copyright thus interminable?

    1. Re:Copyright Question by LostCluster · · Score: 2

      Game copyrights expire like anything else, but that'll be 95 years assuming Congress doesn't change the law in the next couple decades to add more years.

    2. Re:Copyright Question by crashnbur · · Score: 2
      God! 95 years is ridiculous! What better to restrict the development of knowledge than to prohibit its use? Good job, America!

      Side note: what if someone comes up with a very similar idea, so similar that it resembles copyrighted material? Are they not allowed to develop their own creation just because someone else came up with something similar?

      Gah, America can be such a horrible place to live... except for everywhere else.

  31. The GBA is NOT based on the SNES by autopr0n · · Score: 2

    The GBA is a 32bit machine. Much more powerfull then the SNES, and not physicaly based on it at all. It's mostly designed for 2d games. but not based on the SNES's hardware.

    Remember, the SNES was slow but had a lot of acceleration. The main CPU was just 3mhz!!

    --
    autopr0n is like, down and stuff.
  32. Re:Cartridges by mjolner · · Score: 5, Informative

    The head of Microsoft's China operations actually suggested the same thing to Microsoft - sell older versions for _alot_ cheaper. Alot cheaper is often what to what people in the developing world be willing, and able, to pay for software. She figured it would create mind-space and make people used to buying legit copies. Yeah, she was fired. I have seen alot of NES-compatible game systems sold in down-scale Chinese apartment stores, and Nintendo probably figures that there is a buck to be made by going in and competing with these fly-by-night manufacturers. Makes sense to me.

  33. Re:Cartridges by nomadic · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Actually a better analogy would be to refuse to pay for some food because you claim it's awful, but still stuff your face full of it.

  34. Yeah, but won't sell in US by Sean+Clifford · · Score: 2

    Yeah, but it'll be in Chinese markets - not sold in the US. So it won't significantly impact the legacy market here. I'm sure there will be folks who'll want Chinese imports. Also, remember that we're dealing with economies of scale. A hot-selling high-priced cartrige in China might sell for the equivalent of US$4.

  35. Woo-hoo! by Guppy06 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    "The most curious part of the interview is that Satoru Iwata says Nintendo is considering releasing older generation hardware to combat piracy, could this mean the big N is going to start making Super Nintendos again? Will there be new games?"

    Who cares if there will be new games? The very concept of putting NES and SNES hardware and software back on the assembly line is teriffic news as far as I'm concerned!

    Nintendo retired these consoles because they had reached the point where their sales didn't justify the cost of manufacturing them any more. But now we have the possibility of introducing these systems to a new, relatively untouched market. A market that may very well fund the continued manufacture of these consoles and cartridges. The NES and SNES markets will (with any luck) be self-sufficient again. Especially when you consider the advances in both hardware and manufacturing in the past decade or so (ie. they're cheaper to make than ever).

    And if the cost of manufacturing the older consoles is being justified by the Chinese market, what could they possibly have to lose if they, say, start selling them in North America again? I'd finally be able to have my very own copy of EarthBound!

    (WaReZ kiddies: No, ZSNES is not the same. It lets me play the games I wish I had, but I still wish I had them. If you can't understand the difference, I truly pity you.)

    (Moral self-righteous twits: No, I will not mortgage my first-born on eBay for a used copy of the game. Nintendo makes no money off the sale of used cartridges. I'll buy it when Nintendo re-releases it.)

    1. Re:Woo-hoo! by Zebbers · · Score: 2

      god forbid you buy a used game...Nintendo wont get any money! I hope you buy ALL your cars new...heaven forbid the car manufacturers lose out....

    2. Re:Woo-hoo! by Guppy06 · · Score: 2

      I didn't say I don't buy used games (I bought a copy of Phantasy Star and a Power Base Converter even though I already had the ROM). I meant that I wasn't about to spend $100+ on a single cartridge. My spending limit on used video game equipment is the original MSRP.

  36. It's the media cost by levin · · Score: 2, Interesting

    It's a lot cheaper to produce CD's and DVD's than it is to produce solid state storage (like a videogame cartridge). At the prices you can get pirated stuff for in China--depending on how you bargain, under 0.70USD for a DVD last time I was there--it just isn't economical for someone to produce illegal carts.

    --

    `which fortune`
  37. In China? Screw that. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Release them here. And get Sega on board - man, I would have killed to have been able to play Warsong on my actual Genesis.

    This is a question I've long had for console makers: Why not create an emulator, package a shitload of games on the same disc as it, and sell it? Hell - you could even offer the .iso through paid download.

    Sure, just like music and movies - there are people who simply wouldn't pay for it.

    There's also a lot of people who would. I'll admit, I've downloaded games whose cartridges I don't own. The problem is - I couldn't find those cartridges back in the day. They're impossible to find now.

    I have a hard time finding decent Sega CD and Saturn hardware. The games? Well, they're few and far between, aside from the massively craptastic ones. If used game places have a *good* game in stock, they'll have jacked the price up to the point where it's higher than it was when the game was new!

    That's just Sega CD. If you look for anything earlier than that, good fscking luck. You're reliant on dodging e-bay fraud and looking in the local paper's classified section.

    Selling an emulator and roms would be quite easy for game manufacturers. Hell - look at the lack of cost! No packaging, no cartridge/disc, no printed instruction manual.. Distribution? Toss it on a website and let it cook.

    Now, of course, there might be legal issues with distributing games created by another company. (See all those wonderful licensing blurbs on all console games.) However, I think the console manufacturers could throw enough weight around to get game manufacturers to join on the bandwagon if they wanted to.

  38. Wait just a goddamned minute. by Rimbo · · Score: 4, Informative

    I was in China in September, and I saw everything there. PS2's, XBoxes, GameCubes, GameBoy Advances, and all of the games.

    What's this about -entering- the Chinese market again?

    As far as I can see, they're already there.

    Somehow I don't think that their sales will increase very much as a result of this...

    1. Re:Wait just a goddamned minute. by taweili · · Score: 2, Informative

      The game consoles you saw in China are not officially released in China. Check out the games for PS2. They are either Japanese or English. None of the games is in Chinese. These machines carried back to China from oversea visits and the titles are pirated in China.

    2. Re:Wait just a goddamned minute. by hhknighter · · Score: 3, Interesting

      You are right, they already sell these consoles. But I do think they are not legally for sale here. I don't think they are officially approved by Chinese government yet. I could be wrong though.

      Also, I was told that they will offer to "mod" it or they come "modded"

      Aside from that, the prices at which they are selling for is quite high (kinda low compared to retail in US, but still high for an average Chinese citizen). Companies like Nintendo would probably have to enter the market with lower end systems that will match their spending quota. If they enter with current systems, the price will be too high, forcing them to drop prices in China. Then you get companies outside of CHina importing these units and sell at a cheaper price, hence creating a downward price spiral.

      I was there a bit before, I also did see some weird looking consoles that play games similar to SNES games.

  39. Re:The family owns a TV by tjb · · Score: 2

    Not quite.

    In eastern China, anybody who wants to watch Red TV probably watches their own TV (or 2).

    Once you get away from the coast, though, its pretty desperate rural poverty. I'd wager that most of the farming communities in central and western China don't even have a single TV in the entire village.

    Tim

  40. Contra was "THE ONE" back in 80's China by liupang · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Contra was the most popular game along with Mario in 80's china console. I still remeber having numerous fun sessions with my buddies during summer break when I was in high school.

    Maybe that will disappoint you a lot, but Chinese gamers are just like gamers around the world. They will simply pick games because it's fun to play with. And no, Government has not much influence over what people play, since 98% gamers get their games from priated market anyway.

    Regarding your question, there is not too much home-grown games in China . Piracy has simply killed off most home-grown game studios. There is a few home-grown games set up at ancient China might falls into your "pure fun in context to them, but would have no chance of being appreciated over here" category. But I think it's more a knowledge of history thing instead of Culture thing, and I've saw American players who know that part of history like those games.

    Oh, by the way, GTA III was 2002's #1 seller in China pirated console game market . And GTA III: vice city has been sold out around the country.

  41. Re:That must be by Jace+of+Fuse! · · Score: 2

    the single most nintarded idea I've ever heard

    You never seen a virtual boy, have you?

    --

    "Everything you know is wrong. (And stupid.)"

    Moderation Totals: Wrong=2, Stupid=3, Total=5.
  42. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 2

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  43. Iraq strategy by swankypimp · · Score: 2

    This is all part of a brilliant war strategy against Iraq. Remember a few years ago when Saddam Hussein was buying Sony Playstation 2s to reassemble into military computing devices? This is pretty much the same deal, only his top lieutenants will pass out from lack of oxygen when they have to blow on the Nintendos to get them to work. With them incapacitated, the U.S./Japan coalition easily prevails. For Great Justice!

    --

    --All your stolen base are belong to Rickey Henderson
  44. Price not Piracy by Phil+Wilkins · · Score: 2

    Manufacturing costs for the SNES or even the N64 are going to be incredibly low by now. Even the cartridges. Of course they'll need to be, they'll still cost a larger proportion of the average chinese salary, than the current round of consoles do of the average salary in the (more) developed world.

  45. Complete BS by Goonie · · Score: 4, Interesting
    The reason for DVD region codes was so that the studios could change different prices for DVDs in different countries without parallel imports undercutting prices, and delay cinema releases without the risk that people would import the DVD beforehand. That, and sheer bloody-mindedness.

    You probably believe Palladium is designed to protect your privacy and security, too...

    --

    Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from a rigged demo
    --Andy Finkel (J. Klass?)
  46. Re:Cartridges by dWhisper · · Score: 2, Interesting

    The largest N64 Roms were still less than 64megs, and they were also for an existing piece of Hardware that was needed (Doctor V64). The "emulators" of the time could maybe, just maybe, get off a frame every 10 minutes.

    Gamecube titles hover around 600megs-1.2gigs, and are using all of the normal Nintendo compressed texture and caching techniques. They are a non-standard disc. Beyond that, disc based media doesn't use a ROM image, like older cartrages did. They use a separate file system, and need some sort of loading system (Windows CE on the Dreamcast, 2k on the X-BOX) to play games. The Cube is no different.

  47. Re:Cartridges by jericho4.0 · · Score: 2
    Why the hell do you think this is flamebait?? Fuck!! The fucking idiots who never post but feel free to use the mod points given them to mod stuff down are killing me.

    This post is offtopic. Go ahead. Mod it. But your points are much better spent modding up.

    --
    "A language that doesn't affect the way you think about programming, is not worth knowing" - Alan Perlis
  48. Re:Cartridges by Zemran · · Score: 2

    Not true. If things are fairly priced people are happy to buy them. If a CD was $3 then why would you buy an inferior copy? It would be hard for anyone to provide a copy if they had to combat the economy of scale. The problem is that because the games/music/film industries have a cartel they can rip off the customer and that in itself creates the market and the sympathy for the underground copying. Instead of entering into a fair market these businesses try to enforce their hold by using technical and legal means but in places like Asia this simply does not work.

    People here talk about the cheap copies in Asia but the legal versions there are much cheaper in order to combat copies. I buy legal DVDs for $10 in Asia, I could buy copies for less but the quality is crap. If DVDs were $10 at home no-one would even consider the cost of a DVD-R. The situation is the same with music although I can never find my taste in music for sale there. It is all Asian or pop (Britney Spears type stuff).

    Nintendo have now got the Cube which uses non-standard disks to combat copying. Although I think this is a good way for them to do it I think someone will find a way to circumvent this soon. Anyone got a lathe?

    --
    I love stacking my barbecues in the shed at the end of summer - you can't beat a bit of grill on grill action.
  49. China. by jericho4.0 · · Score: 2
    There are many comments in this thread that seem to assume China is some backward country with no tech and no money.

    China has more people under 13 than North America(including Mexico) has in total. China's productivity is growing faster than anyone elses. Chinas education system is strong in sciences. There is a big difference in living standards between the coutry and the city, but that is shinking fast.

    If Nintendo chooses to sell old hardware to China, it might work for a while, but china will be demanding the most cutting edge products very soon, and with more money than any other market.

    --
    "A language that doesn't affect the way you think about programming, is not worth knowing" - Alan Perlis
  50. Saddam Hussein and PS2s by acb · · Score: 2

    Didn't the Iraqi government buy up all the PlayStation 2s in some US cities a few Xmases ago, to use for missile guidance systems? (Or possibly to spoil US kids' Christmas, because Saddam's a meany.) Or is that more Kuwaiti-incubator-baby material?

  51. Commodore 64s in China by acb · · Score: 3, Funny

    I heard some years ago (in the late 1990s) that someone was still manufacturing Commodore 64s for sale in China (or possibly Latin America), where few people could afford modern computers. Anyone know anything about this?

    If they're making C64s for mass use these days, how closely are they keeping to the original designs, and how many cheap-enough improvements have they added? Are they building them all on one chip, or using the original small-denomination RAM chips? Do they have any funky modern enhancements, like ZIP drives which pretend to be 1541s or integrated USB ports/IP stacks or whatever?

    1. Re:Commodore 64s in China by acb · · Score: 2

      I believe that was a Dutch company, not an Asian company. The machine looked like a C64, but ran Windows 3.1, and good luck plugging your Datasette into it.

      The thing about Chinese/Mexican C64s I heard about some years earlier.

  52. Old hardware? by Saltypear · · Score: 2, Interesting

    going to start making Super Nintendos again? Actually, here in Japan you can walk into most gameshops and purchase a brand new NES or SNES. These game machines are redesigned NES and SNES machines (or should I say Famicom and Super Famicom ?), meaning they are much smaller than the originals, and are still being manufactured by Nintendo. I think the only major Nintendo console not being produced in one form or another is the N64.

    1. Re:Old hardware? by ecc0 · · Score: 2, Funny

      I think the only major Nintendo console not being produced in one form or another is the N64. What about the Virtual Boy? Tee hee.

  53. Re:Cartridges by dandelion_wine · · Score: 2

    Agreed.

    But the quantity of pirating may be related to the average quality of available merchandise.

    Let's say this friend I used to know (ahem) got his Playstation I modded and purchased a bunch of copied games for very little. One tends to be a little less choosy when the price is low, no? Go for long-shots, a few of which turn out to be great finds, most of which turn out to be complete duds. Well, when you've got 20, 30, 50 games sitting there in a pile (the mistake of parents at Christmas, even giving more than 1, and of youths with too much money), you don't spend a whole lot of time on the duds. I'm talking mere minutes, per.

    But it sure makes you think about the number of titles that seemed promising and turned out to be abolute crap, and how you're glad you didn't blow your only $50/$75/$100 (Ok, my friend is Canadian) on one game to find out it was one of the 95% of the crappy ones out there. In fact, through this method, one might decide that the only way to find quality games is to sift through a bunch of crud, which is only possible if you're rich or you're pirating.

    Having purchased some PC games at full (well, discounted price) I can tell you that my friend is now thinking about burning PC stuff, too. Directly as a result of the proportion of crap that's on the shelves.

    Now, did I go and buy the genuine article of any of the gems I found through pirating? Actually, I did, twice, but I think that's unusual (I was separated from my software for a while). Normally, I would agree. Peeps just don't pay for what they can get for free, quality or no. And that is a major problem. Damn. I meant, my friend.

  54. Who thought of this idea again? by Mulletproof · · Score: 2

    Do they really think they'll be able to confine the users to the older hardwre? LOL, hell, a majority of the next gen hardware and software is already pirated through Kowloon! They aren't gonna sit there and watch the world play PS3's and GameTriangles while Japan tries to filter them 8 bit machines...

    --
    You need a FREE iPod Nano
  55. Re:Cartridges by Psx29 · · Score: 2
    It's actually just a mini-DVD. You could make copies now that blank mini-DVDs are available.

    You know, it might be a mini-dvd however I do not think it is _just_ a mini-dvd...seeing as how I have not been able to read a gamecube disc on any computer with a DVD drive as of yet. I have also never heard of any reports of pirated gamecube games while considerable amounts of playstation 2 and xbox games are available.

  56. Fighting Piracy by l0ss · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I know Nintendo carts were pirated successfully a few years back, so I think that Nintendo's intention to fight piracy by releasing older hardware in China is probably centered on two assumptions : 1.) The technology has already been paid for by the rest of the world when it was first released so any money made rereleasing it now is gravy, and 2.) most of the big entertainment consumers (the US, Europe, Japan, and Canada) have graduated to later generations of game consoles, so there is no demand for the export of SNES priated material. China was/is notorious for suplpying the world with pirated CDs , CDROMs, and DVDs, so I'd imagine that Nintendo thinks that while this may not eliminate piracy, at least it will localize it.

  57. humbug, that's an urban myth by DABANSHEE · · Score: 2

    A billion's always been a 1000,000,000 in the British Commonwealth too.

    Afterall a thousand's not a hundred hundred, it's just ten hundred, so why do people think a billion's a million million just because a million's a thousand thousand.

    There's actually a patern to this
    10 x 10 = hundred
    10 x 100= thousand
    1000 x 1000 = million
    1000 x 1,000,000 = billion

    1. Re:humbug, that's an urban myth by Tomble · · Score: 2
      Right, firstly, as this whole thread is very very OT, I shall put my vaguely on-topic bit first (in case it vanishes off the end):
      I wonder if China is imagining making a Beowulf cluster out of those NESes? And this time, that line even has a tiny core of sense to it, as IIRC, China is blocked from buying supercomputers or PCs over a certain spec, and the slower the processors, the less relevant communications latencies are in a cluster. Now, back to the age-old argument.
      A billion's always been a 1000,000,000 in the British Commonwealth too.
      Where exactly did you drag that out from? Because I've certainly never ever heard that before, and if it is the case, then WTF was the point in the word milliard? If you have difficulty with that word, look it up. If you can't find it, you need a better dictionary.

      Afterall a thousand's not a hundred hundred, it's just ten hundred, so why do people think a billion's a million million just because a million's a thousand thousand.
      That's got to be the most screwed up argument I've heard in quite some time. You might as well say, a dachsund isn't ten thousand, so why do people think a billion is even a number?
      There's actually a pattern to this
      I'm listening...
      10x10 = hundred
      10x100 = thousand
      1000x1000 = million
      1000x1,000,000,000 = billion
      Er, surely by your pattern, either 10x1000=million, or possibly, 100x1000=million. No? Sorry, it's not entirely clear what your pattern is.

      Look, ultimately, words such as ten, hundred, thousand, for little numbers that everyday people use, are Germanic in origin, because the peasants at the time of the Norman conquest of England would have used such numbers in their everyday life. Words such as million are French in origin (mille=thousand in French), because up till around the 14th century, the Norman-French kings of England hardly even spoke English, and the language of court and all official state business was not English (it was either French or Latin). True, I don't know when the word Million was first used, it might not have even been about during that time, but you can bet that when it first was, it wouldn't have been by the little people, it would have been by somebody with a million of something to count.

      The derivation of billion, is that it is bi as in 2, even though the mi in million was not originally meaning 1 (like mono-). Hence,
      1X (10^6)^1=million
      1X (10^6)^2=billion
      1X (10^6)^3=trillion
      Which looks better if you think of it in terms of just the number of zeros, as in 6*1 zeros, 6*2 zeros, 6*3 zeros.
      If you try that with the American version, you have to do:
      1000X (10^3)^1=million
      1000X (10^3)^2=billion
      1000X (10^3)^3=trillion
      Or, 3+(3*1) zeros, 3+(3*2) zeros, 3+(3*3) zeros. Doesn't quite scan, does it?

      It is true that nowadays, most of the use of the word billion in UK, for instance on the news, and in government announcements and things, is the same as the US version, but you will still find the more sensible English version (alongside the US version) in the dictionary, if your dictionary does not suck, and a good many people understand that billion can be taken to mean a million million.

      My own feeling on it, is that the words billion, trillion, etc are now broken. It's common enough for many words to have more than one meaning, but when it's a number, you really have to pick some new bloody words. I'd suggest borrowing some other language that English has ties with -after all, there are plenty out there- and maybe changing them a bit to fit in better. I'd favour getting the words from Germany or Scandinavia or somewhere like that, but hell, why not even India?? Of course, it'll never happen.

      --
      Be careful! New moon tonight.
  58. Polical ignorance by mccalli · · Score: 2
    It is kinda funny though. Super Marx Brothers [slaps knee]

    Yep. And how many people noticed The Legend of Deng Xiaoping? Deng Xiaoping? Err...you mean the key Chinese revolutionary figure and former leader?

    Cheers,
    Ian

    1. Re:Polical ignorance by Klaruz · · Score: 2

      I caught it, but the play on words wasn't as good as super marx brothers.

  59. This is a dumb idea (posting from China) by taweili · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I am expatriate living in Shanghai, China. I am posting this from a cyber cafe here. It's obvious to see why this is such a dumb idea for Nitendo and will destory Nintendo in China forever.

    For most Chinese, cyber cafe serves as their introduction to computer, Internet, and compuer games. The machine I am on right now is a PIII 800 with Nvidia GeForce. The usage cost is about US$1 for 4 hours. It's 2AM on Sunday morning and the place is packed with young people in their early 20s. Most are playing games, some are watching movies and surfing the net.

    The availabe games on this machines:

    • Counter Strike (number 1 game in China)
    • WarCraft III
    • Wolfenstein
    • Age of Empire II
    • MIR (a Korean MMORP, very popular here)
    • ...Name your state of the art PC games

    Now the picture should be clear. Chinese are introduced to computer games with flashy 3D graphics and online gaming. None of people in this room except me have any idea what games look like before 3D acceleration and Nitendo is nobody to them. With their first game experience with such hardware setup and game titles, Chiese customers would hardly be impressed even with next generation GameCube, let along the NES.

    Moreover, China and Japan have a really bad history. In general, Chinese hate Japanese. If Nitendo actually bring NES to the Chinese market, all it takes is an editorial in People's Daily provoking the memory of Sino-Japan war history and paint the sales of NES an insult for the Chinese people as second class customers. It will make Nitendo notorious in China and ultimately destory any chance for Nitendo in Chinese market.

    I really hope Nitendo be smart about Chinese market. I workship Shigeru Miyamoto. I have already pre-ordered Zelda for GameCube from the states and can't wait to play it. I hope my Chinese friends will eventually have the chance to appricate the art of the master game creator.

  60. outside in... by autopr0n · · Score: 2

    For one thing, gamecube disks read from the outside in, which makes them hard to read in regular players, and makes the data quicker to load on Constant-angular-velocity (CAV) drives.

    --
    autopr0n is like, down and stuff.
  61. The market for TVs in china is larger then america by autopr0n · · Score: 2

    1.2 billion without TVs in china compared to the few hundred thousand who replace older TVs or upgrade to HDTV or whatever in the United States. The market FOR televisions is much larger in china. A TV in china is only $12

    --
    autopr0n is like, down and stuff.
  62. Cartriges vs CDs in China by Vegan+Pagan · · Score: 2

    Most Chinese people have little money; many work for under $5 a day. That means that if Nintendo revives a cartrige based console in China, its games won't be as counterfieted as a CD based system, but they'll be more expensive, ruling out many people. Maybe Nintendo could bring back one of their old consoles, but with a CD drive so they could sell their old games for a few dollars apiece. It wouldn't cost much more than a portable CD player, require very little R&D, and the games would cost little enough to reduce counterfieting somewhat.

  63. Re:The market for TVs in china is larger then amer by benzapp · · Score: 2

    Look at what I wrote...

    How can one say there is a larger market for consoles FOR televisions in China than in the United States.

    I like you, you got a nice website. But read my post. I am talking about televisions, I don't give a rats ass about the market for televisions. The reality is Nintendo doesn't make televisions, they make video game systems. One comes with a a screen, one needs a television. The market for televisions in China may be huge, but that doesn't matter to Nintendo. The reality is 80% of chinese do NOT have televisions. That means the market for video game devices which require televisions amongst those people is small.

    We are talking about how Nintendo can get money from each and every chinaman in china. That isn't going to happen with a Super Nintendo. Hypothetically speaking however, Nintendo could put a GBA in the hands of every Chinaman in China.

    --
    I don't read or respond to AC posts
  64. Re:A third of the price of what? by UnknownSoldier · · Score: 2

    > The idea of the +1 bonus was for mature, experienced Slashdot posters that have a history of quality posts to get their better comments modded up quickly so that people browsing with high thresholds see them quicker.

    No shit, sherlock.

    > Unfortunately, people like you and the parent post come along, think that karma/post scores/+1 bonuses are all part of a penis size contest, and ignore the fact the bonus is supposed to promote good content.

    Unfortunately, you make the mistake of assuming I actually care about about karma! I've been capped for years. I'm just too lazy to turn off the +1 bonus.

    If you don't like people "wasting" their +1, maybe you should *do* something about it -- like change your Preferences | Comments, so it doesn't show up.

    > However, so many idiots (such as the parent poster, and yourself) have the +1 Bonus and always use it that it's become irrelevant.

    What? Now you have to resort to name-calling? So much for the "mature, experienced Slashdot poster" you mentioned above. LOL.

    I know, I know, don't feed the trolls...

    Cheers