Slashdot Mirror


Power Companies Offering Cable (TV, Net) Service

MankyD writes "CNN is running an interesting story about a power company offering cheap cable and broadband internet to its customers. What's even better is that they aren't looking to make a profit, just break even on the venture. They estimate that they've saved their customers $32 million. Furthermore, it's available in a rural area where the telecomms don't offer service anyways."

195 comments

  1. FP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    asdjklasdjkasdjklasda

    1. Re:FP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Congratulations, sir. You have succeeded where many others have failed. On behalf of all trolls worldwide, I would like to thank you for your continuing efforts to better society. Job well done.

    2. Re:FP by Omicron32 · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Screw you, troll. I get dibs on second post. As for the topic at hand... um.... yeah I'd go with that.

  2. GET SOME PRIORITIES!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    The most horrible space tragedy in recorded history occured one day ago, and all you people can do is talk about whether power company aren't looking to make a profit? My *god*, folks, get some priorities here!

    1. Re:GET SOME PRIORITIES!!! by Omicron32 · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      I think Challenger was worse. Life must go on, so people died, if you knew them, which I don't think you do, then I'd understand, but so what? There dead, and moping around about it won't change anything... This is /. not another news site. This is nerdy stuff! You want space tradgedy? Go here where there is loads of it.

    2. Re:GET SOME PRIORITIES!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll
      You know, I was going to request that you find a new line instead of dusting off an old troll.

      Until I recognized the humor value of people still biting on this shit OVER A YEAR LATER, anyway. I would have thought these folks would have been too busy helping that Nigerian fellow who needs help extracting his millions from his country.

  3. Price you spods by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    if.you.want.people.to.take.up.broadband. make.it.affordable.you.twonks

  4. Where can I sign up? by IgD · · Score: 1, Redundant

    Does anyone have contact information? Where can I sign up!!!

  5. Shoes by Want+Some+Shoes · · Score: -1

    Are they providing shoes? If not, I will be happy to offer some.

    --

    Want some shoes?

    1. Re:Shoes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What styles and sizes? And these shoes better be made by little Asian children, too!

  6. You Monsters! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    How can you care about something as trivial as cheap broadband internet when 7 astronauts are dead and our nation is on the brink of war. Is America really that heartless and indifferent? If so, I'm quickly losing what little faith in humanity I had remaining.

    1. Re:You Monsters! by jakedata · · Score: 1

      You twit!

      Do you think that 7 people inventing a new and expensive way to die is more important than the rampant death and disease we blithely ignore all over the world? Or worse, inflict on each other?

      The best thing we can do is get people communiating any way we can. If we can open the lines of communication we can save more lives in one minute than we lost in the history of space travel.

      The world moves on.

  7. cool.... by the_2nd_coming · · Score: 4, Interesting

    now there is a reason to move back to the country...cheap calbe TV and internet access.

    I am trying to get my township here to open up the cable market....Time Warner is gouging us...for basic cable and internet I pay 84 bucks....my wifes friend who lives near by in another town has 2 cable companies to choose from and pays $79 for digital calbe, free HBO that comes with the digital cable, more basic channels, and internet access. I looked tha the company website...for whay I have with Time Warner, my wife's friend would pay $54.

    --



    I am the Alpha and the Omega-3
    1. Re:cool.... by Peterus7 · · Score: 2, Informative

      I live in Tacoma, WA, and we have had something similar to the public broadband for quite a while. It's very nice, and I'm glad to see it spreading. I think broadband should be available to all, and perhaps they should ammend the constitution to make it one of the basic rights...

    2. Re:cool.... by Daniel+Quinlan · · Score: 5, Insightful
      Time Warner is gouging us...for basic cable and internet I pay 84 bucks

      That sounds like a good deal to me, actually, if you have some sort of broadband connection.

      Also, in many markets, even if you only have one cable company (like in my area), you still have the option of going to DirecTV or another satellite TV provider. I decided to completely avoid my cable company, I get both TiVo and satellite for $45 a month. My DSL line costs me about $50 a month. I'm actually paying more than you, although I suspect I have more channels, more features (see below), etc. (No HBO, though.) I believe I can also get some sort of cable internet now, but I'm more likely to switch DSL providers to get a better deal there.

      Anyway, my point is that there is some competition, even though there might be somewhat more competition in some places. "Gouging" seems like an excessive characterization considering what you are paying.

      I should also note that I can record two channels at once and watch recorded material at the same time with "DirecTiVo" and I get local channels too, but that's fairly old news. I doubt I'd even be interested in a second cable company unless they could match those features.

    3. Re:cool.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Yeah you should move into your wife's friend is she (hope female) is hot. Cheap internet and 'entertainment'. :p

    4. Re:cool.... by the_2nd_coming · · Score: 1

      can't get it satelite...to many old trees....and it is gouging when Comcast and WOW offer the same package I have for $15 less(comcast) and $30 less (WOW).

      --



      I am the Alpha and the Omega-3
    5. Re:cool.... by Senjutsu · · Score: 1

      >Time Warner is gouging us...for basic cable and internet I pay 84 bucks

      That sounds like a good deal to me, actually, if you have some sort of broadband connection.

      Good deal?! My God, man, I'm paying 64 bucks Canadian for basic cable and broadband internet. If you figure that works out to around 42 dollars US, he's paying twice what I am for exactly the same service. Time Warner is fucking him sideways at that price.

    6. Re:cool.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

      I want your balls smashed. Eat shit. Fucking American. Yankee.

      You are a waste of human flesh. One of your basic rights: smoking cock.

    7. Re:cool.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There is no way I would pay so much just to watch tv. I have better things to do with my time/money. Try netflix for cheap movies (the only thing on tv i like anyways) and team up with your neighbors for cheap broadband. Just my 0.02.

    8. Re:cool.... by Moonwick · · Score: 2, Insightful

      If this is a troll, it's a finely crafted one. Congrats.

      If you're serious... well, thanks for cheapening the Bill of Rights, and everything else this country stands for.

      --
      Only on slashdot can a posting be rated "Score -1, Insightful".
    9. Re:cool.... by nelsonal · · Score: 1

      He's serious. Tacoma owns its own cable company.

      --
      Degaussing scares the bad magnetism out of the monitor and fills it with good karma.
  8. But I want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    who wants to put my tasty nutsack in their mouth?

  9. Not a power-line network by Autonymous+Toaster · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I was somewhat disappointed that the article doesn't describe a broadband network over existing power lines - that would really be something! But it is about using lines that were already in place for power-use monitoring, which is nearly as good.

    In particular, anything that provides additional connection options for small appliances with embedded operating systems is always welcome. In this specific case there are some protocol issues concerning communication with Glasgow residents of that type - a difficult (for outsiders) "accent" if you will, but one day it will be possible to exchange the latest news and information on toast (just as an example) with one's peers. That will be a good day.

    --
    Could I interest anyone in some toast?
    1. Re:Not a power-line network by xamel · · Score: 0

      I was somewhat disappointed that the article doesn't describe a broadband network over existing power lines - that would really be something!

      I belive you are refering to this, right?

      --
      GOD DAMNIT , MODERATE ME!
    2. Re:Not a power-line network by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      I actually just spoke to power company technology representatives about this 2 days ago. They said that the technology is not yet ready, as the line noise from the electricity limits the distance the internet signal can carry unamplified, plus power equipment like transformers add even more noise and obstruction to the internet signal. Adding amplifiers and other equipment to solve these problems drives the cost up to the point of making it unviable in a competitive marketplace. Maybe someday internet over power lines will happen, but not today apparently.

    3. Re:Not a power-line network by Woodrose · · Score: 1

      Perhaps not on the power lines themselves, but the right-of-way itself is a valuable commodity. Stringing coax across power poles can be fairly cheap if you own the power poles.

      --

      Thou hast damnable iteration, and art indeed able to corrupt a saint - Henry IV, Act I scene II

    4. Re:Not a power-line network by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The far larger problem is getting any sort of data signals through a transformer. It's virtually impossible. In the U.S., new home developments typically have one transformer for every four homes. You'd need to have equipment on both sides of every transformer. Noise on the line has virtually nothing to do with the problem. A 12kv or 4kv line is very clean.

      In Europe, this is much more possible. Because of the 220v system and fact that one transformer serves many more homes, it would cost far less to implement.

    5. Re:Not a power-line network by l1_wulf · · Score: 1

      Actually, some companies have already started testing this technology (broadband over power lines that is, not news on toast :P). Read this and this or just go here and wade thru google.

  10. Just Break Even? by Eravau · · Score: 0, Redundant

    Suuure they plan to just break even...'til they corner the market. No company goes into a venture to "just break even". There's no point in it...and you can't sell that to shareholders.

    1. Re:Just Break Even? by the_2nd_coming · · Score: 2, Insightful

      think about it...they get everyone to sign up..get a box, have their TV on all the time, get that computer on 24/7 downloading MP3s they get profits from more electricity usage and they are providing a service to their customers at cost over lines they need anyhow.

      --



      I am the Alpha and the Omega-3
    2. Re:Just Break Even? by mrkurt · · Score: 4, Informative

      If you read the article about Glasgow, KY, the service is being provided by the city, so they have the voters to answer to if the price gets too dear. It makes sense that this would work out well in a small town; the big players may not be interested in serving them anyway. It'd be interesting to see what would happen if power companies all over were allowed to provide cable/internet-- it could introduce some real competition, instead of the oligopoly we have now. Or, at least, it would be an oligopoly with more players.

      --
      Always look on the briight side of life! (whistle, whistle)
    3. Re:Just Break Even? by travail_jgd · · Score: 4, Insightful

      The utility company is owned by the city, so the money consumers spend stays in the town. The city has "made" $32 million that would otherwise have gone to the cable companies and/or ISPs.

      Try reading the article. ;)

    4. Re:Just Break Even? by gunnk · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Actually, in this case there is no reason for them to do something like that. The company is owned by the town. Many communities all across the country still get their electricity from municipal companies or co-ops. These companies aren't really meant to be "for profit".

      Now, what strikes me is that usually a government-owned venture is nowhere near as competitive as the private sector. The real question here is why the heck private companies are charging so much more than these quasi-governmental companies. The private sector SHOULD see very little threat from these ventures. The fact that it can be done this way at so little cost simply reveals how badly we are being gouged by our local cable and broadband providers currently.

      --
      Life is short: void the warranty.
    5. Re:Just Break Even? by Eravau · · Score: 1

      Guess that shows how much I read. I've not ever lived in any place that had utilities (except water) run by anyone but large corporations. Didn't know they were out there. Points taken.

    6. Re:Just Break Even? by rtscts · · Score: 1
      Now, what strikes me is that usually a government-owned venture is nowhere near as competitive as the private sector.
      I suspect that's hardcore American capitalist brainwashing talking.. unless your government operations are seriously fucked up (pork problem?)

      Governments, esp. smaller local ones, don't have so much of a problem with inefficiency as large ones do. They also don't have the burden of greedy bastards (shareholders and various Officers giving themselves million dollar salaries plus perks) sucking all the money out of it. It's a closed system - any profit goes into better services or cheaper prices, rather than leaking out to 3rd parties.

    7. Re:Just Break Even? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Anyone who wants more details about the Glasgow project should go read their information at www.glasgow-ky.com/epb. This project was initiated in 1988!

  11. And in other news... by TWX_the_Linux_Zealot · · Score: 5, Funny

    Farmers are experiencing problems keeping their pigs penned up. Apparently entire pens are simply floating out into the open air, with no discernable cause. One farmer, who requested to remain anonymous, speculated that some of the new recommendations for pig feed could be to blame, but other than a little different diet, he couldn't find any reason that his pigs should be flying.

    --

    IBM had PL/1, with syntax worse than JOSS,
    And everywhere the language went, it was a total loss...
    1. Re:And in other news... by swordboy · · Score: 1

      We would normally have live coverage but our on-site reporter is currently busy trying to catch all the monkeys that are flying out of his butt.

      --

      Life is the leading cause of death in America.
    2. Re:And in other news... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      lol!

  12. Ah cool, maybe I can get some real service now by Kethinov · · Score: 2, Informative

    My house gets electricity and all the essentials, but no cable and no DSL. My options for internet have always been satellite and wireless. I opt for wireless only because it pings better. Both services generally suck and are subject to many downages and bottlenecks.

    If our power company offered us cable internet service I'd be in an eternal bliss, because I could drop my horrible provider. I hope this idea spreads.

    --
    You're right, I wouldn't steal a car. But if it were possible, I sure as hell would download one!
    1. Re:Ah cool, maybe I can get some real service now by DonaldBeckman817 · · Score: 1

      who is you wireless provider? We run a wISP in the Fort worth Texas area and have better than 99% uptime for 95% of our users. If you let me know who it is I may be able to get help for you through the wISP trade groups. Wireless should have uptimes BETTER than wired if properly installed and supported.

    2. Re:Ah cool, maybe I can get some real service now by Kethinov · · Score: 1

      I live in southeastern Kansas, my provider is called Nautilus. The service has improved over the months, but its all around terrible. Each user is crammed onto a single IP, too. Hundreds of people on the same IP. When some kid gets himself IP banned from a popular service, the entire ISP's customer base suffers.

      I've reported them to the BBB and haven't gotten many results. Is it so much to ask for a stable connection and my own IP?

      --
      You're right, I wouldn't steal a car. But if it were possible, I sure as hell would download one!
    3. Re:Ah cool, maybe I can get some real service now by domninus.DDR · · Score: 1

      how far into northeast tarrant do you offer service?

    4. Re:Ah cool, maybe I can get some real service now by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      http://newgenwireless.net/coverage.htm

      we are switching out web servers tonight so it may not be up for a little bit...

    5. Re:Ah cool, maybe I can get some real service now by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      http://www.nautilus.net
      is this them?

  13. Just wondering... by Darwin+X · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Any slashdotters subscribe to this service at all? I'd love to hear some real world stories from the community.

    1. Re:Just wondering... by bombarde · · Score: 5, Informative

      A dozen miles south of Boston, Braintree Electric http://www.beld.com has been providing power to my town for 100 years and started offering cable TV and high speed internet a few years ago. It's a town owned utility with a reputation for service reliability and low rates. Beld.net service has been excellent; it's easy to get the right person on the phone if you need to fix something, and you can go over and yell at them in person should the need ever arise -- it has not. AT&T Broadband is also available in town, and I don't know anyone who still uses it.

    2. Re:Just wondering... by dzym · · Score: 2, Funny
      "slashdot" and "real world"?

      Excuse me? :)

  14. Dear Pedernales Electric Company by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    All over-charges, made up late fees FOR AUTOMATIC CHECKING ACCOUNT WITHDRAWL (If YOU are late getting money from my account that I have you permission to access on a monthly basis, how is it MY fault??), rude phone calls, etc will be forgiven if you do something like this.

    Your friendly customer.

    Anonymous Coward

    1. Re:Dear Pedernales Electric Company by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Does PEC offer service in Austin or are you outside the area?

  15. Damn it feels good to be a gangster.... by crumbz · · Score: 3, Interesting

    and shaft the local telcos. They been rippin' me off for too loong now.

    1. Re:Damn it feels good to be a gangster.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Damned right! I say let this take over then the people can be free. Make sure to keep a CLOSE eye on the utility companies though. Both eyes peeled!

  16. Let me get this straight... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    The worst spacial incident in recorded history occurred less than one day ago and you people are talking about power companies offering cable service?!?! My GOD, people, GET SOME BLOODY PRIORITIES!

    1. Re:Let me get this straight... by willum448 · · Score: 1

      If it means so much to you, why dont you use your reall name?

    2. Re:Let me get this straight... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      what the hell do you want us to do? do you expect us to dwell on some accident forever? so what they died there is nothing we can do now, it is already the past.

      what the hell you doing here reading this article and even posting if you feel so strongly?

      GET A BLOODY LIFE! and stop dwelling on death

      please mark this post and the parent -1 offtopic

    3. Re:Let me get this straight... by Dopeskills · · Score: 0

      Oh right... I forgot that we are not allowed to talk about anything else and move on with our lives.

    4. Re:Let me get this straight... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

      Dozens of people wre killed in an explosion in Nigeria and all you can talk about is a space accident? My GOD, people, GET SOME BLOODY PRIORITIES!

    5. Re:Let me get this straight... by Woodrose · · Score: 1

      It's not just the people, but the hopes of millions of people they represent, people who want to think we can leave the egg when the yolk runs out. A lot of emotion was invested, not just dollars and people. Get a hope.

      --

      Thou hast damnable iteration, and art indeed able to corrupt a saint - Henry IV, Act I scene II

    6. Re:Let me get this straight... by miu · · Score: 3, Funny
      The worst spacial incident in recorded history occurred less than one day ago

      You apparently have yet to run incident II.

      --

      [Set Cain on fire and steal his lute.]
    7. Re:Let me get this straight... by kwik_mart · · Score: -1, Troll

      Seven people died in an avalanche in western Canada -- it's just not as exciting to you because they didn't burst into flames! Big news for you: people die every day! It's just not always on such a high profile -- and regardless of their contributions to society, it's still tragic! Everyone feels bad when good people die, especially when they were doing important work, but for god's sake the world can't just stop moving! If all we did was talk about all the people that die everyday, we'd never have a chance to talk about something like cheap broadband, because people like you would whine everytime someone types out anything not related to the tragedy. Your heart only bleeds when the media tells you it should. Check YOUR fucking priorities.

    8. Re:Let me get this straight... by Chris+Tucker · · Score: 1

      So this braindead A.C. spews:

      "The worst spacial incident in recorded history occurred less than one day ago and you people are talking about power companies offering cable service?!?! My GOD, people, GET SOME BLOODY PRIORITIES!"

      "Recorded history" apparently begins for this meatsack sometime after January 28, 1986.

      Said meatsack obviously missed the thread about the disaster right here on Slashdot.

      Dear meatsack: please die. Thank you kindly!

      Yes, meatsack. It IS a tragedy. But life goes on. If I tell the PhoneCo and CableCo to get some bloody priorities and stop sending me bills, I won't have a phone or cable TV.

      I can mourn the passing of STS-107, as well as be interested in cheap cable, telephone and highspeed internet access.

      The two are not mutually exclusive.

      And, finally. Yes, I know that meatsack is a troll, and not a very good one, either.

      --
      Guaranteed! This comment 100% Anthrax free!
    9. Re:Let me get this straight... by Anonvmous+Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

      "The worst spacial incident in recorded history occurred less than one day ago and you people are talking about power companies offering cable service?!?! My GOD, people, GET SOME BLOODY PRIORITIES!"

      The people that died in the pursuit of science would be honored if we continued on our pursuit of science.

    10. Re:Let me get this straight... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Anonvmous Coward, I would have expected more from you than to fall for this troll.

    11. Re:Let me get this straight... by jDinK · · Score: 1

      Didn't I see you on here right after September 11th?

    12. Re:Let me get this straight... by evilviper · · Score: 1
      The worst spacial incident in recorded history occurred less than one day ago

      It's not the worst space-travel incident in history, it's only possibly "as bad" as the challenger incident that happened less than 20 years ago.

      Besides that, my life does not stand still when 7 people die. Hey, 3000 people were killed a while back, and that didn't stop anything. At most, some things were stopped for the rest of the day.

      It wasn't long ago that real wars were happening, and the number of people dying each day was astronomical.

      I believe the average is around 40,000 people die every day around the world, and around 5,000 in the US alone. 6 Billion people should stop everything they are doing (for days?) because 7 people died?

      You need to get some priorities. If you can't handle it, form a support group, and stay away from everyone else that is getting on with their lives.

      I know this was just a stupid troll, but I heard this same thing WAY too much (days and weeks) after the destruction of the World Trade Center as well.
      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
  17. This is not new... by joeboo · · Score: 5, Informative

    The company that I work for, Cedar Falls Utilities was a 3 service utility (gas, water, and electric) that started to provide communications services (cable tv, high speed data, and dedicated facilities) in 1997. Broadband Bob has a report from Jan of 1997 here.

    --
    Joseph W. Breu
    1. Re:This is not new... by puetzc · · Score: 1

      I live next door to Cedar Falls, but not in their service area. High speed Internet was introduced there first. After a referendum to allow fund a study to allow competition was turned down in my town, my bill went up by $10/month. It appears that competition is working well.

  18. Bzzzz. (Reason: Too much repetition.) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    That must be some filter to filter out that 50Hz mains hum :o) (Or is it 60 over there?)

  19. Send this down your powerline by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    1.618033988749894848204586834365638117720309179805 762862135448622705
    260462818902449707207204189391 13748475408807538689 175212663386222353
    693179318006076672635443338908 65959395829056383226 613199282902678806
    752087668925017116962070322210 43216269548626296313 614438149758701220
    340805887954454749246185695364 86444924104432077134 494704956584678850
    987433944221254487706647809158 84607499887124007652 170575179788341662
    562494075890697040002812104276 21771117778053153171 410117046665991466
    979873176135600670874807101317 95236894275219484353 056783002287856997
    829778347845878228911097625003 02696156170025046433 824377648610283831
    268330372429267526311653392473 16711121158818638513 316203840052221657
    912866752946549068113171599343 23597349498509040947 621322298101726107
    059611645629909816290555208524 79035240602017279974 717534277759277862
    561943208275051312181562855122 24809394712341451702 237358057727861600
    868838295230459264787801788992 19902707769038953219 681986151437803149
    974110692608867429622675756052 31727775203536139362 107673893764556060
    605921658946675955190040055590 89502295309423124823 552122124154440064
    703405657347976639723949499465 84578873039623090375 033993856210242369
    025138680414577995698122445747 17803417312645322041 639723213404444948
    730231541767689375210306873788 03441700939544096279 558986787232095124
    268935573097045095956844017555 19881921802064052905 518934947592600734
    852282101088194644544222318891 31929468962200230144 377026992300780308
    526118075451928877050210968424 93627135925187607778 846658361502389134
    933331223105339232136243192637 28910670503399282265 263556209029798642
    472759772565508615487543574826 47181414512700060238 901620777322449943
    530889990950168032811219432048 19643876758633147985 719113978153978074
    761507722117508269458639320456 52098969855567814106 968372884058746103
    378105444390943683583581381131 16899385557697548414 914453415091295407
    005019477548616307542264172939 46803673198058618339 183285991303960720
    144559504497792120761247856459 16160837059498786006 970189409886400764
    436170933417270919143365013715 76601148038143062623 805143211734815100
    559013456101180079050638142152 70930858809287570345 050780814545881990
    633612982798141174533927312080 92897279222132980642 946878242748740174
    505540677875708323731097591511 77629784432847479081 765180977872684161
    176325038612112914368343767023 50371116330725869883 258710336322238109
    809012110198991768414917512331 34015273384383723450 093478604979294599
    158220125810459823092552872124 13704361491020547185 549611808764265765
    110605458814756044317847985845 39731286301625448761 148520217064404111
    660766950597757832570395110878 23082710647893902111 569103927683845386
    333321565829659773103436032322 54574363720412440640 888267375843395367
    959312322134373209957498894699 56564736007295999839 128810319742631251
    797141432012311279551894778172 69141589117799195648 125580018455065632
    952859859100090862180297756378 92599916499464281930 222935523466747593
    269516542140210913630181947227 07890122087287361707 348649998156255472
    811373479871656952748900814438 40532748378137824669 174442296349147081
    570073525457070897726754693438 22619546861533120953 357923801460927351
    021011919021836067509730895752 89577468142295433943 854931553396303807
    291691758461014609950550648036 79304147236572039860 073550760902317312
    501613204843583648177048481810 99160244252327167219 018933459637860878
    752870173935930301335901123710 23917126590470263494 028307668767436386
    513271062803231740693173344823 43564531850581353108 549733350759966778
    712449058363675413289086240632 45639535721252426117 027802865604323494
    283730172557440583727826799603 17393640132876277012 436798311446436947
    670531272492410471670013824783 12865650649343418039 004101780533950587
    724586655755229391582397084177 29833728231152569260 929959422400005606
    266786743579239724540848176519 73436265268944888552 720274778747335983
    536727761407591712051326934483 75299164998093602461 784426757277679001
    919190703805220461232482391326 10432719168451230602 362789354543246176
    997575368904176365025478513824 63146583363833760235 778992672988632161
    858395903639981838458276449124 59809370430555596137 973432613483049494
    968681089535696348281781288625 36460842033946538194 419457142666823718
    394918323709085748502665680398 97440662105360306400 260817112665995419
    936873160945722888109207788227 72036366844815325617 284117690979266665
    522384688311371852991921631905 20156863122282071559 987646842355205928
    537175780765605036773130975191 22397388722468258057 159744574048429878
    073522159842667662578077062019 43040054255015831250 301753409411719101
    929890384472503329880245014367 96844169479595453045 910313811621870456
    799786636617460595700034459701 13525181346006565535 203478881174149941
    274826415213556776394039071038 70881823380680335003 804680017480822059
    109684420264464021877053401003 18028816644153091393 948156403192822785
    482414510503188825189970074862 28794215589574282021 665706218809057808
    805032467699129728721038707369 74064356674589202586 565739785608595665
    341070359978320446336346485489 49766388535104552729 824229069984885369
    682804645974576265143435905093 83212437433338705166 571490059071056702
    488798580437181512610044038148 80407252440616429022 478227152724112085
    065788838712493635106806365166 74322232776775579739 927037623191470473
    239551206070550399208844260370 87908433342618384135 970781648295537143
    219611895037977146300075559753 79570355227144931913 217255644012830918
    050450089921870512118606933573 15389593507903007367 270233141653204234
    015537414426871540551164796114 33230248544040940691 145613987302603951
    828168034482525432673857590056 04320245372719291248 645813334416985299
    391357478698957986439498023047 11696715736228391201 812731291658995275
    991922031837235682727938563733 12654799859124632750 300605925674549794
    350881192950568549325935531872 91418011364121874707 526281068698301357
    605247194455932195535961045283 03148839117693011965 858343144248948985
    655842508341094295027719758335 22442912573649380754 171137392437601435
    068298784932712997512286881960 49835775158771780410 697131966753477194
    792263651901633977128473907933 61111914089983056033 610609871717830554
    354035608952929081846414371392 94378135604820389479 125745077075575103
    002420726629001809042293424942 59060666141332287226 980690145994511995
    478016399151412612525728280664 33126165746938819510 644216738718000110
    042184830258091654338374923641 18388856468514315006 373190429514814694
    243146089525470720374055669130 69220990804819452975 110650464281054177
    552590951871318883591476599604 13179602094153085855 332387725380232727
    632977372143127968216716234421 18320180288141274744 316884721845939278
    143547409999907223320305926297 66112383279833169882 539312620065037028
    844782866694044730794710476125 58658375298623625099 982323359715507233
    838332440815257781933642626304 33026589581708004512 788731159355877472
    172564947000516366725771539209 84095032745112153687 300912199629522765
    913163709396860727134269262315 47533043799331658110 736964314217197943
    405639155121081081362626888569 74806806011691894175 027229874158699179
    145349946244419401219785860137 36608286907223651477 139126874209665137
    875620591854328888341742920901 56313328319357562208 971376563097850156
    315498245644586542479293572282 87506084814533513521 817295879329911710
    032476222052194645105362450512 98843087134443950724 426735146286179918
    323364598369637632722575691597 23954383052086647474 238151107927349483
    695239647926899369832491799950 27895000604596613134 633630249499514808
    053290179029751825158750490074 35187983511836032722 772601717404535571
    658855578297291061958193517105 54825793070910057635 869901929721799516
    873117556314448564810022001425 45405542927345883711 602099479457208237
    804368718944805636891825802444 99631878342027491015 335791072733625328
    906933474123802222011626277119 30854485029541913200 400999865566651775
    664095365619789781838045103035 65101315894589028718 610869058939471368
    014845700183664956472032943343 74298946427412551435 905843484091954870
    152361403173913903616440198455 05104912116979200120 199960506994966403
    035086369290394100701945053201 62348727632327324494 396304808905542513
    797233147518520709102506368598 16795304818100739424 531700238804759834
    323450414258431406361272109602 28242337822809027976 596077710849391517
    488731687771352239009117117350 91860065462009902497 585277925427816597
    038349505801062615533369109378 46597710529750223173 074121778344189411
    845965861029801877874274456386 69661277245038458605 264151030408982577
    775447411533207640758816775149 75538047116296677710 058766461595496776
    927054962393985709255070274069 97814084312496536307 186653371806058742
    242598165307052573834541577054 29216299811491750861 131176577317209561
    565647869547448927132060806354 57794624145310669837 421137981689638235
    333044778831693397287289181036 64083269856988254438 516675862289930696
    434684897514840879039647604203 61020602171739447026 348763365439319522
    907738361673898117812424836557 81050341694515636260 430036657431084766
    548777801285779236454185224472 36171374229255841593 135612866371670328
    072171553392646325730673063910 85410886808574283858 828060230334140855
    039097353872613451196292641599 52127893113544314601 527309025538271043
    259662267439037455636122861390 78319433570590038148 700898661315398195
    857442330441970856696722293142 73074138488278897558 886079973870447020
    316683485694199096548029824931 98176579268298556297 230106827772351627
    407838074318778273182119196952 80051608791572128826 337968231272562870
    001500182929757729993579094919 64076344286157571354 442789838304045470
    271019458004258202120234458063 03450336581472185492 036799899729353539
    196812133195165379745399111494 24445183033858841290 401817818821376006
    659284941367754317451605409387 11036871521164040582 193447120448277596
    054169486453987832626954801391 50190389959313067031 866167066371964025
    692867138871466311891926856826 91995276457997718278 759460961617218868
    109454651578869122410609814197 26861925547878992631 535947292282508054
    251690681401078179602188533076 23055638163164019224 545032576567392599
    765175308014271607143087188628 59836037465057134204 670083432754230277
    047793311183666903232885306873 87990713590074030490 745988951364768760
    867844323824821893061757031956 38032308197193635672 741964387262587061
    543307296370381275151704060050 57594882723856345156 390526577104264594
    760405569509598408889037620799 56638801786185591594 411172509231327977
    113803

    gnu bc makes a great crapflood tool.

  20. Cheap Broadband means more advertising? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    With cheaper broadband coming out it will almost certainly cause a huge rush of AOL advertising ploys and of course wretched MSN advertisements. AOL will most certainly drop its BYOA fees to 10 a month so they can continue to sign people up for their quarterly numbers and MSN will continue to preach their parental controls which by the way are easily circumvented.

    Not related to article: For you posters who are speaking of the astronauts. Yes it is a tragedy, it is very sad. Yet, you come here and say our priorities are screwed up? Obviously you visit this page and are aware about how to post here. So are you that heartless as to come here and insult us when you should be reflecting on current events?

    1. Re:Cheap Broadband means more advertising? by plague3106 · · Score: 1

      AOL will most certainly drop its BYOA fees to 10 a month

      Hmm, i've only paid 4.95/month for that since 97.

  21. RTFA - 1st paragraph even by tshak · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Because the city-owned electric utility provides cable TV and Internet access over wires that also monitor power usage in the town of 14,000. The utility isn't trying to profit from the service -- just recover its costs.

    --

    There is no longer anything that can be done with computers that is nontrivial and clearly legal. -- Paul Phillips
  22. Solution for cheap cable TV and internet access. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Start by purchasing a home without a connection to the cable system (this may be difficult, but most fixer-uppers fall into this category).

    Then, call the cable company and order cable internet access from them.

    Cross your fingers that when the cable guy comes to install the cable, he doesn't work directly for the cable company - he's just a contractor. Put your hands together and pray that he doesn't put the filter on the line to block the TV channels.

    When he leaves, take the cable from your cable modem and plug it into the back of your TV. If all goes well, you have full cable, except for digitally scrambled stations, at the cost of just cable internet access (and the extra $10 a month for the modem rental, because you're not a cable TV customer).

    Finally, when they call to offer you basic cable at an introductory rate of $10 per month, make sure you turn them down!

  23. anyone in Dallas [ot] by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    actually see or hear what happened yesterday morning? i didn't find out about it until later.

  24. Cheaper Broadband means more advertising? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    With cheaper broadband coming out it will almost certainly cause a huge rush of AOL advertising ploys and of course wretched MSN advertisements. AOL will most certainly drop its BYOA fees to 10 a month so they can continue to sign people up for their quarterly numbers and MSN will continue to preach their parental controls which by the way are easily circumvented.

    Not related to article: For you posters who are speaking of the astronauts. Yes it is a tragedy, it is very sad. Yet, you come here and say our priorities are screwed up? Obviously you visit this page and are aware about how to post here. So are you that heartless as to come here and insult us when you should be reflecting on current events?

  25. Sneaky by teslatug · · Score: 4, Funny

    Yes, but what we didn't tell them is that their power consumption increased one hundred-fold...mauhahahaha

  26. this would be great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...to have in my area. Right now I'm paying $43/month for cable modem internet (no TV) and now ATT is raising the price to about $60/month for new subscribers. I guess to recover their costs or something.

    I'm posting this anon because I'd probably be violating some weird licence agreement statement by saying the above.

  27. Yes, just break even. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

    There are no shareholders. The power company is owned by the city. Local goverment is running this operation and are going to be their own customers. There's no incentive to rip anyone off.

    This is an excellent idea to treat internet and cable TV as what they are - utilities - and charge fairly for them. Bravo to them, I wish I could live in such a town.

    I would subscribe to cable TV if I could get it for $17 a month (price quoted in the article). I disconnected my cable TV 2 years ago after the constant price hikes.

    As it is, AT&T is now bombarding me with offers for packages that cost $90 a month. NINETY DOLLARS! That is a significant proportion of my disposable income. For something that I'd watch for about an hour a week and is stuffed with commercials? And they wonder why I haven't taken them up any of their offers yet..

    1. Re:Yes, just break even. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And if it works for Internet access, why not extend the idea to other services? Public, non-profit entities are more efficient than private profit seeking corporations. We can concentrate on providing quality services that are environmentally and socially responsible and keep our local tax money from flying off to an offshore tax shelter.

      If I had this choice in my area I would love to drop my greedy Internet provider, even if they were the same price because at least I know that my money is staying in my community. However, due to ridiculous laws and bribing/threatening/whining corporations I only have a "choice" between 2 profit oriented gougers!

  28. Nothing new here.... by DMaster0 · · Score: 5, Informative

    unless you're stuck in a massive metro area where it's unprofitable to replace and/or add fiber lines in the entire city.

    We had this in another town in Kentucky (Murray, which is probably on par with Glasgow) and were the 2nd town in the US (Canada being one large rural area seemed to have a lot more broadband at the time) back in late 1996, early 1997.

    The only notable thing, is that as this sort of thing gets widespread, cable companies will have to either add more value to the service (free PPV perhaps, or more digital channels) or price it cheaper. Competition is a wonderful thing. I paid $25/month for a cablemodem capable of 512k down/256k up in a city that had competing cable tv, internet and even local/longdistance telephone service. The existing cable company (Charter) had to drastically reduce prices, hurry out their digital tier services, and price them competitively, as in the course of a summer the Electric Company had started offering a cable package with 10 more channels than the Cable Company, for around 12 bucks a month, compared to the cable company's 25. They're still fighting and the person who will end up winning, is the consumer.

    My cable bill in Kentucky was 55/month. This included digital cable and a cable modem. Now I move to a large city, and I'm paying 50/month just for DSL, cable was just as expensive, and I can't afford the digital cable at all, as that's another 50/month. Things were much different in a small town with two providers, and they're doing very well, and I have hope that the idea will catch on everywhere else eventually and the cable monopoly will get bumped aside in favor of fair prices and better service.

    1. Re:Nothing new here.... by joeboo · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Let me preface this by saying that I work for the local muni.

      Mediacom, who is the local competitor to our local municipal cable/data product is trying to get the law changed in Iowa to prevent the formation of new Communications utilities and severly limit the ability of the already formed utilities to do business. The link to the legislation is here.

      In Iowa, like most states, there are open meetings and open records laws. Mediacom has, in the past, requested and received all of our financial data including customer counts, contracts with providers, etc. We, on the other hand, can not ask them for any of that information which results in an unlevel playing field.

      Our product costs less because we don't have to pay off stock holders and the like. All that we have to pay off is our municipal bonds that were floated on the creation of the utility.

      --
      Joseph W. Breu
    2. Re:Nothing new here.... by Jardine · · Score: 3, Funny

      Wait a minute. Are you saying that your cable company is actually having to compete with someone? My cable company, phone company, and the satellitte providers all seem to enjoy working together to maximize their profits. Where's my fibre to my door for cheap?

    3. Re:Nothing new here.... by nougatmachine · · Score: 1
      The only notable thing, is that as this sort of thing gets widespread, cable companies will have to either add more value to the service ( free PPV perhaps, or more digital channels) or price it cheaper.

      Great idea! We can call it...penny picher video.

  29. Personal account... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This page has some comments in the middle that are rather interesting. Apparently, not all its cracked up to be, although at half price how could it meet everybody's expectations?

  30. Just hope they don't go the other way round... by Boss,+Pointy+Haired · · Score: 4, Funny

    because I don't want ntl: meddlin' with electricity. They're dangerous enough in charge of a cable system.

    (UK in-joke, sorry)

  31. Putting all your eggs in one basket by Sophrosyne · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I Love new technology, and I think its great that power companies are making the most efficient use of their technologies.
    My issue is putting all your eggs in one basket... A few years back when there was a giant ice storm in Quebec, we were reminded of how dependant people have become on electricity. Now lets just say that using the power grid to access information becomes popular- power grids are already very central to survival in the modern age.
    if something happens to the grid you're not going to have power, so it wont matter if you can access the net; slowly the infastructure can be repaired and the chances of taking out all power lines at once is very slim. On the other hand if you were to take out a couple power stations you could disrupt the flow of information, as well as disrupt the lives of people for a considerable amount of time. It would be much harder to replace a power plant than wires and transformers.

    1. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by Senior+Frac · · Score: 4, Funny

      My issue is putting all your eggs in one basket... A few years back when there was a giant ice storm in Quebec, we were reminded of how dependant people have become on electricity. Now lets just say that using the power grid to access information becomes popular- power grids are already very central to survival in the modern age.

      Gosh. You're right! Since they're line sharing internet access and power, if the power goes out, they won't be able to access the internet either!

      Oh... wait...

    2. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by Blue+Stone · · Score: 4, Funny

      That's why it's imperative we develop a new information delivery device that runs on gas.

      --
      Corporation, n. An ingenious device for obtaining individual profit without individual responsibility. - Ambrose Bierce
    3. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by MikeFM · · Score: 2, Interesting

      This reminds me, a few years ago we had an ice storm that knocked the utility electricity off for a week. I was very amussed to see the local tv station broadcasting a 'If you do not have power please call us at..' line on the bottom of the screen. Lots of people without power obviously are watching tv.

      I've been working on moving my computers towards more energy effecient technology and using alternatie energy to offset the utilty bill. It's amazing how your utility bill drops if you do something as simple as move your lan to solar/wind power. It also makes your network more stable as it isn't often you have outages of public utilities, sunlight, and wind all at once.

      --
      At what price learning? At what cost wisdom? The price is a man's peace of mind, and the cost is his life.
    4. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      DSL and cable, being high speed - and hence electrically high frequency, can only travel so far down a fat power line. Once it hits a power transformer, be it in the street or at the sub station, it will be choked off by the high impedance of the transformers. These are tuned for low freq power (50/60Hz), and act rather like the inline DSL filters on phones.

      Hence power companies run power line DSL only down the length of the average suburban street - no further. They take off the customers high freq DSL/Cable and patch it into the telephone network at set points on each street, for example. So its not too different from traditional DSL service.

      (newbie)

    5. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by Savatte · · Score: 1

      That's why it's imperative we develop a new information delivery device that runs on gas.

      I don't know, with the possibility of a war on iraq looming, gas prices may skyrocket. Maybe a steam-powered information delievery system is the way to go.

    6. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by nelsonal · · Score: 1

      One of the gas companies was testing fiber to the home using their gas lines. They had delivery worked out, but I think the corrosive nature of natural gas was eating the fiber. Either that or they shuttered the program to save some money, I think it was El Paso, but it could have been Dynegy, neither one is really an example of great finacial health these days.

      --
      Degaussing scares the bad magnetism out of the monitor and fills it with good karma.
    7. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Lots of people without power obviously are watching tv."

      Of course they are. We were watching lots of TV after hurricane Iniki knocked out the power grid for several months.

      Thank Ghod for generators!

    8. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by MikeFM · · Score: 1

      Exactly. The only people watching tv after such an outage is those that thought ahead and had their own source of power available. During an emergency you might not have enough power to run your fridge but kicking on a radio or laptop to get some emergency coverage is very possible. If your Internet goes down because of poor disaster planning then obviously your SOL for the later method. Storms are good evidence of why having your own power source is a good thing. They could make quite the case for a city-wide wireless network (MAN).

      --
      At what price learning? At what cost wisdom? The price is a man's peace of mind, and the cost is his life.
    9. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by Talez · · Score: 1

      Either that or figure out a way to browse the internet by candlelight.

    10. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by lizrd · · Score: 1

      My gas-powered information delivery is telling me that I ate too much spicy food last night.

      --
      I don't want free as in beer. I just want free beer.
    11. Re:Putting all your eggs in one basket by buck_wild · · Score: 1

      I'll bet you're thinking of Sempra. One of our subsidiaries (I work for Sempra Corporate Center) is relegated to distribute fiber "the last mile" via gas lines. I'm not aware of any troubles with corosives.

      --
      If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
  32. Not really. by Blaede · · Score: 4, Informative

    2 years ago (here in Memphis), when getting cable net access, you also got TV cable as well. Well, not anymore. I asked why, and it was explained that back then, the local TimeWarner had no way of offering either net or TV signals by themselves, so they just bundled it. They eventually sorted out the techical problems, and now they can only let you have what you only order.

    Your "trick" only applies in areas where they haven't gotten complete control of their system.

  33. isn't trying to profit from the service by automag_6 · · Score: 1

    if that line doesn't make you skeptical, I don't know what does. Is the power company trying to earn itself some Karma, or else these poor rural folk might use the OTHER available power company? Hmmmmm, call me a skeptic.

    Also, they say ~$45 gets them cable TV and fast Inet access, which is 'half the national average', well, that's exactly what I pay here in the metro Detroit, MI area for both as well for basic cable package plus thier 1.5 Mb cable modem servise (Wide Open West provided). My other option was Comcast, but Wide Open West blows thier doors off in pricing, and I like thier channels better.

    -me

    1. Re:isn't trying to profit from the service by jandrese · · Score: 1
      half the national average


      You undermined your very point by noting that Wide Open West (apparently a very good local deal for you) "blows thier[sic] doors off in pricing" compared to Comcast, but in most of the nation national carriers like Comcast are the only choice, so the power company is probably correct.
      --

      I read the internet for the articles.
    2. Re:isn't trying to profit from the service by wilpig · · Score: 1

      if that line doesn't make you skeptical, I don't know what does. Is the power company trying to earn itself some Karma, or else these poor rural folk might use the OTHER available power company? Hmmmmm, call me a skeptic.

      automag this is because the power company has a natural monopoly over the industry and is thus controlled by the government to ensure that they aren't gouging the customers. The reason that this type of monopoly is allowed to exist is the simple fact that you don't want to have 20 sets of power lines for different companies in one location. I am forced to think back to my economics classes where we were shown pictures of New York City with hundreds of different phone lines going down the streets and across the buildings.

      but this article isn't directed at poor rural folk that only have one choice in everything. this is directed at small towns that could benefit from a little competition.

    3. Re:isn't trying to profit from the service by rmarll · · Score: 1

      It's the municipality that's providing the services. They don't have to show a profit, if the locals want it that way.

    4. Re:isn't trying to profit from the service by fenix+down · · Score: 1

      Well, I'm paying a little over 100 a month for basic cable and cable net (Cablevision/Optimum), so I guess I make up for you. We have the worst of both worlds here, though. Deregulation AND a monopoly.

  34. Let the lawsuits begin! by kmahan · · Score: 1

    I'm sure the cable companies will be suing soon enough over the power company "infringing on the cable company's government supported monopoly."

    --
    Invalid Checksum. Retrying.
  35. Priorities ARE straight pinhead by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Those creatures down in Nigeria and related countries are sub-human and don't warrant the waste of resources they use.. Good riddens.

  36. Damn, got me all excited by the+kfc+avenger · · Score: 2, Interesting

    When I first read the title I assumed they were delevering the service over the powerlines themselves. This was of great intrest to me as I live 20 miles from the nearest [small] town. From the article they push the content over the usage monitoring lines. Alas, no broadband for this country folk.

  37. Re:Solution for cheap cable TV and internet access by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Hey if you're really smart pay off the contractor, or make friends with a cable installer- get him to remove the filter.
    I've heard people having trouble splitting the cable so they can watch their TV and surf the net...

  38. Awesome... but the power company? by Ajaxamander · · Score: 4, Interesting

    This sounds incredibly cool, especially since I'm the one who pays both the Cable and the Electric bills at my college rental, however, at least in our area (University of Michigan) our power is from a huge Detroit conglomerate, DTE Energy, and even getting our electricity taken care when we moved in was more than they could handle. The previous tennants had defaulted 2+ months in a row, and the power company handed us a bill for $414, while a technician went to turn off the juice. Frankly, I would love to pay less for our internet, but I don't trust the power company further than I can spit.

  39. Using ADSL modem by modme2 · · Score: 1

    I read somewhere that this technology (net over power lines not this one specifically) offers an adapater that you plug your current "broadband modem" into.

    does anyone know if an ADSL modem will work with this? :)

    1. Re:Using ADSL modem by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think data over power lines might be a bad idea.

      I mean, I'm sitting here in my computer room, and my lights are occassionally flickering from the funky power.

      Even assuming that a decent power-line modem can deal with dirty power like this, putting data over power lines sounds like it would make the power even dirtier.

      At best, it might adversely affect the power itself. I'm not an electrician, but it seems that messing with the flow so that it transmits data means that the flow might lower, or even be wasted more than it currently is.

      Right now, half the power transmitted in an a/c line from the power company is wasted in the conversion from a/c to d/c. A lot more of it is lost moving it to your house from the power company. Lower wattage loses less. Running data over high-power lines means more loss.

      I hope someone can refute me on this though, but it seems like a bad idea.

      Btw, anyone ever try one of those power-line antennas? I bought one 12 years ago. Didn't work very well. Supposedly used the entire wiring system in your house as an antenna.

    2. Re:Using ADSL modem by heff · · Score: 1

      i dont think this would be the case,
      they do data and television services over cable lines and the two systems don't interfere with one another..i would think the power lines would be similar.

      I'm no expert of course, i'm still an undergrad.

      --

      --

      |-_-| . o O ( bEef!)

  40. that's good riddance by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Learn the language.

  41. I'm gay. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Hooray!

  42. BELD - Braintree, MA. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    A friend of mine in Braintree had digital cable and internet access from www.beld.net for IIRC ~$50/month total.

    3 miles down the road (and not in Beld's area :-( ) I pay ~$90/month for Basic Cable (Analog) and internet access from mediaone/attbi/comcast.

    If that's not bad enough, Beld supplied him with a cable box that had spdif output for decent surround sound (apparantly ATTBI supply a shitty box with analogue stereo output only), and his internet download speeds rocked... consistently ~2.5Mb/s

    You know, I'm not *too* pissed off about my internet service at the moment. Mediaone/Attbi have been ok, both from the point of view of performance and reliability. They've also been reasonably friendly wrt running a web server. Yes it'd be nice if it were a bit cheaper, but it's not outrageous. Now Comcast are due to take over, I'm worried about their restrictive AUP, $45/month to be a web consumer is too much..but I digress.

    What *really* hacks me off is the $45/month for basic cable - considering that nearly all of the channels are commercial-supported, and the amount of commercials seems to increase every month. It's outrageous.

    1. Re:BELD - Braintree, MA. by joeboo · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Basic cable channels (usually the off-air channels) are not necessarily free.

      Local broadcasters have 2 methods that they can use to get their signals on your cable system. They can elect for a Must Carry (you have to carry them per FCC regulations) or a contract. The Must Carry is free. A contract of any sort is going to involve dollars.

      We are currently in renegotiations with the local NBC and ABC affiliates. The ABC affiliate wants us to pay $0.25 per subscriber per month to carry their signal. The NBC affiliate wants us to carry their signal, roll out their HDTV signal in 30 days, still provide a channel for their weather broadcasts, advertising swaps, and what the cable industry calls Most Favored Nation (i.e. they get paid what the highest local affiliate charges us to carry their local signal - in our case $0.25 per sub per month).

      HDTV alone is going to cost us about $10k a channel to add (the reason is that the UHF channel spectrum that the off-air broadcasts use is not directly transportable on a cable system without wastng channel space. The UHF channels don't match up directly with the cable channels). So, we have to either take their off air channel, upconvert it, and sell a box to the subscriber to get it. Or, we can waste channel space, and a normal HDTV ready TV would be able to watch the signal.

      That, and the ABC contract says that if we roll out HDTV for any other local broadcaster, then we have to roll theirs out too.

      Basic cable is something that cable companies are required by the FCC to carry. It isn't always as cheap as you might think.

      --
      Joseph W. Breu
  43. OT:Just Break Even? by Thomas+M+Hughes · · Score: 5, Informative
    Now, what strikes me is that usually a government-owned venture is nowhere near as competitive as the private sector. The real question here is why the heck private companies are charging so much more than these quasi-governmental companies.
    I would imagine this venture is more competitive then the huge telecommunications companies, since a town of 14,000 people makes it a whole lot easier to complain to the very upper levels of management whenever its not working right or there is a better solution. Not to mention that the customer base can do more then just "vote with their wallet", they can vote with their ballot, and have referendums to completely alter how the system is managed if it gets out of hand. Besides, even if there was a private set of ventures in this area, they would need to do everything that this small government has done, plus charge a percentage "profit" amount, which will always give the well run government agency an advantage in terms of price over the well run private corporation.

    The key word is "well run", which is something that both private companies and governments have trouble doing, especially on large scales. Private companies are immune from having inane and pointless structures that cause tons of waste, just because they're private. The market isn't magical, and it doesn't just fix this. The private sphere and the public sphere both boil down to people, and their motives. If their motives are corrupt (Private corruption "Lets bilk the entire population for everything they've got and we'll be filthy rich!" or Public "Lets just stay in office forever, and never change, I don't like change") then the result will be corrupt. However, if either have good intentions (Private "Lets offer a good product at a decent price, and make a living off of it" or Public "Lets provide something good for the public, to improve their lives") and they allow those intentions to guide them, the outcome isn't usually horrific. No one meaning well intentionally screws over the people they're trying to help.

    I think the key to this is the size of the endeavor. A small business that knows its customer base intimately will be much more sensitive to their needs and demands. A large one that must meet a projected profit every quarter will be willing to sacrifice them in order to stay in good with the stock market. Similarly, a large government (ie, Federal in the US) will lose track of its vision in all its complex infighting. However, for a small city to do something like this? They're not going to set up a government endeavor just to screw themselves, since 14,000 people isn't a population worth exploiting to that degree.

    To summarize after all that rambling: public ownership is not always evil and inefficient, nor is private ownership always good and effective. Find a balance for the situation that provides the best outcome for society. Its not always going to be the market.
  44. Power Companies Offering Cable (TV, Net) Service by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Power Companies Offering Cable (TV, Net) Service!!! more like celda

  45. I've got this, and its wonderful by jedinite · · Score: 5, Informative

    I live in Kansas City, and just about a month ago I got connected to this type of service, thanks to a local company called Everest that is owned by local utility company Aquila.

    Things that make this service fantastic:

    1) Price. No question. I consolodated my monthly phone bill (~$25) plus my monthly cable bill (~$75 for digital + two premium tiers) plus my high-speed internet bill (I was paying $125 for business-class DSL which was the only service provider with a static IP in my area) down to ~$100/month (in a single bill) to a single company

    2) Services available. For $100/month I get 1.5 MB (256 kbps upstream) cable with a single static IP, digital cable with two premium tiers (I selected HBO and Skinimax), plus local phone service with $.10/minute long distance. Everest just released a new feature I'm interested in but haven't yet taken the plunge - integrated PVR service. For an extra $20/month you can get an upgraded box with 40gb HDD and Tivo-style PVR service.

    3) Customer service. You can call their support number 24x7 and its answered immediately by a real person. Level-2 tech support people who know what they're doing.

    4) Let me ditch a few companies I'm happy not to do business with: Time Warner Cable and Southwestern Bell (SBC).

    All great stuff, in my opinion. This type of competition is just what these markets need, in my opinion... especially the cable TV market.

    --

    ---------
    There is no try at jedinite.com
  46. These systems are very beneficial by wilpig · · Score: 5, Informative

    There are many of these systems in place today, not only are they offering cable tv and internet but phone service as well. Glasgow was the model town for motorola to try out some of the new technology. Murray, KY was their next stop and they have come along way in the last two years since the initial install was made. Here is a link to the hardware used. http://broadband.motorola.com/catalog/productdetai l.asp?ProductID=211

    I pay about $20 a month for phone service with callerid, call waiting, etc. Another $27 for extended basic cable which is about 70 channels and then $19 for internet access. If I were to go with the competeing companies in town I would be paying $40 a month for cable an additional $40 for cable modem service through them, *ahem* charter *ahem* overpriced *ahem*, plus a phone line and long distance through bellsouth, at least $30 before caller id, call waiting, etc. Did I mention because of this we only pay $0.07 a minute for long distance.

    Now many people are seeing this as a very bad deal because the power company is supposed to be non-profit because they have a natural monopoly over the services. Well it doesn't have to be, the way our community handled this is that the electric company issued bonds to the community to pay for the project. In essence the community owns the service, anyone that has a problem with the service are invited to public meetings held about every six months. But the one thing you have to keep in mind is that with your local power company hosting all of your services you also have all your hard earned money going right back into your own community. Sure our previous service was based here but the profit leaves the area and goes to where ever their home office is.

    What ever you do if you hear that your local electric company is considering this goto their board meeting and hear them out. It will come to a vote eventually and your vote could be the one to make it happen for you as well.

  47. Non-profit = antitrust? by Barraketh · · Score: 2, Insightful

    A few random points that poped in my head after reading this:
    1) The telecom companies may have a point in their claims that it's anti-competitive. I mean, no private company would go into business with the goal of "breaking even". How is this much different from a monopoly selling their products at cost to drive out competition?
    2) That being said, the power companies have great potential in the telecom business if, as mentioned in the article, cable/internet could be offered over power cables. The network in the article is run over power-monitoring wires, and i'm not sure how widespread this type of wire is... Cable (and broadband interenet to a lesser extent) are so widespread now, that it may not be a bad idea to offer them as city-sponsored commodities, like power, and hopefully even run them over power lines.
    3) This is going AGAINST the trend of privatization of publicly owned ventures. That means that the only reason that this is cheaper is that the prices set by cable/telecom companies are inflated. This could lead to a huge drop in cable/internet prices... and the telecoms are trying to fight this through legal means. Fighting a new distribution model through courts - **AA anyone?

    1. Re:Non-profit = antitrust? by Edmund+Blackadder · · Score: 1

      The reason for antitrust laws is that monopolies always end up gauging the consumer, and only have low prices to drive a particular compwtitor away.

      As long as there is no gouging going on and the city does not attempt to buy out of the competing avenues of access (such as cable, telephone wires) i do not really see a problem.

    2. Re:Non-profit = antitrust? by DriceX · · Score: 1

      [...]I mean, no private company would go into business with the goal of "breaking even"[...]

      What about the red cross, goodwill, or the salvation army? I'm sure there are a lot more I'm forgetting. Not ever private company, or group wants to make a profit.

  48. Manassas VA by nolife · · Score: 1

    Manassas VA, mentioned in the linked article has been in various stages of testing this for almost a year now. They were chosen I believe because they had the physical requirements and the city government actually administors the power in the city so no power company was directly involved in the process. I was able to find a blurb in cache from the local newspaper and a press release but nothing much more, They same company providing the technology is also interested in VOIP. I would assume the other utilities were not happy with the competition or the percieved unfair advantage and are going with the legality card. Manassas was providing the internet access to select residents willing to beta test but I think that has since stopped, maybe the legal issues were to murky for the city to continue that program.

    --
    Bad boys rape our young girls but Violet gives willingly.
  49. Private Telecoms Go WAAAAAA!!! by quakeroatz · · Score: 5, Interesting

    The big brother argument (municipalities cannot control digital content) by private telcos is pure drivel. If big brother (CIA, NSA, FBI, etc.) really wants to monitor your usage they'll walk into your ISP with a carnivore system and log your activity.

    Everyone knows how cheap fiber and net access REALLY are... Cents per gig.. or pehaps fractions of cents. Consumer net access is currently overpriced, overhyped and slow. If local Hydro can provide cheap, fast internet to everyone with power, let them!

    1. Re:Private Telecoms Go WAAAAAA!!! by FireBreathingDog · · Score: 1
      >If local Hydro can provide cheap, fast internet to everyone with power, let them!

      I think what you meant to say was:

      If local Hydro can provide cheap, fast internet to everyone with power, more power to them!

  50. i like this section by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

    " Among its contentions: Municipal telecoms hurt a town's tax base and may violate the First Amendment by placing the distribution of media content under government ownership. "

    Violate First Amendment by placing distribution of content under government ownership? Aren't libraries city-owned?

    Its sad how hard business owners will try to keep hold of their profits rather than doing what's right for society..

  51. Click! Network in Tacoma, WA by forevermore · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Click! Network has been doing this for several years. It's a subsidiary of the local power company, which pulled fibre into most of the city (Tacoma's claim is that they're the most wired city in the country) in an attempt to draw some of the dotcom business away from nearby Seattle.

    It's basically city-subsidized bandwidth. I got 2048x256 Mbit cable for $25/month, and later bumped it up to 4096x512 (basically uncapped) for $80. When I had to move up to Seattle for work reasons, this was one of the hardest things to give up (since I'm now paying the same price for 768x384 DSL - granted, Speakeasy encourages their customers to run web servers, etc, and I get 2 static IP's).

    For businesses, Click! offers extremely competetive rates on connections up to an OC-48, and you can get one just about anywhere in the city. They're also expanding (slowly) into nearby cities, too (Tacoma has had a lot of internal neighborhoods become incorporated, so it's unfortunately not like they're expanding very far).

    --
    Do you really need reason for beer? Wingman Brewers
  52. Not sympathetic here by whovian · · Score: 1
    But generally, private companies say municipal telecoms create unfair competition because they have no need to make profits or pay off debts quickly, have preferential access to digging streets and other "rights of way" and are owned by cities that have regulatory power over the industry.
    Knee-jerk reaction to this is that for-profit private companies are jealous and greedy. I thought that's why companies decide to merge or buy out one another. /me shrugs. I thought we were living in the land of capitalism -- guess I was wrong.
    --
    To-do List: Receive telemarketing call during a tornado warning. Check.
    1. Re:Not sympathetic here by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      telco's generate profits , they're just fixed by regulation. Non-profit doesn't mean that they don't make profits , it means that they don't retain earnings like a private corporation. They're also able to charge people for services and upgrades that they'll never utilize , something a private competitor couldn't do legally. So BB users on telco nets are being subsidized by people who don't use the service.

  53. You Liberals are tearing this country apart! by Phredd · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    "What's even better is that they aren't looking to make a profit, just break even on the venture."

    Why is it "better" not to make a profit? Im disgusted by that statement. Liberals are destroying America with their "corporations are evil bullshit".

    Hey jackasses! It was capitalism that this country was founded on!!! HELLO!!??!

    Get with the program or move to France!!!!

    --
    Phredd - "I have found people tend to take you far less seriously once you start waving your genitals at them..."
    1. Re:You Liberals are tearing this country apart! by cranos · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Oh know, someone is trying to provide a service for the community without gouging the community, quick call the guys from Enron.

      You know not everything is about making money (I know its shocking isn't it), from the sounds of it, these people have the right idea, invest in cheap broadband access for the community and the payback could very well be a much bigger and better educated community for the future.

      You know what founded the US? It was justifiable anger at taxation without representation, thats what led to the American Revolution, not capitalism.

      Oh and one other thing, any organisation that exploits third world labour - often under age - is an evil organisation in my books.

    2. Re:You Liberals are tearing this country apart! by NineNine · · Score: 1

      I'm so tired about hearing about "The Kommunity". Little secret... no such thing. It's complete horseshit made up by hypocritical, idealistic fucks who are only out for themselves. (ie: help ME for the sake of the community). Every time I hear someone talk about the "Community", I'm instantly skeptical. I'm much more willing to trust somebody who's out to make a profit and is aboveboard about it.

    3. Re:You Liberals are tearing this country apart! by cranos · · Score: 1

      Umm nooo, the community is what human beings have been creating for the past several million years. It is called society, and can range from a small family group to a nation the size of China.

      Just because you appear to be a greedy self centered person don't assume that everybody else is.

    4. Re:You Liberals are tearing this country apart! by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 1

      'm so tired about hearing about "The Kommunity". Little secret... no such thing. It's complete horseshit made up by hypocritical, idealistic fucks who are only out for themselves. (ie: help ME for the sake of the community).

      That is effectively the position of the large cable companies: ban state-funded agencies from offering service and give us a monopoly so we can continue to gouge the public. The state-funded agencies in question are offering low prices and good service, which is what you tend to expect from public utilities (like gas and electric).

      --
      "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
  54. The Rules of Business by NeoMoose · · Score: 2, Insightful

    This is great on paper, but the future implications are there for the company to make money off of the service. There will be a point where the company could make a profit right now, and as costs go down then they will grow ever closer to turning around this 'break-even' enterprise to a profit making division of it's company.

    The rules of business are not being ignored, it's an investment for the future.

    1. Re:The Rules of Business by SagSaw · · Score: 1

      Not only that, but when the power franchises come up for renewal with the local municipalities, providing "at cost" broadband service will give them a leg up over compeating bids and help them expand into other markets.

      --
      Come test your mettle in the world of Alter Aeon!
    2. Re:The Rules of Business by nochops · · Score: 1

      Even though you didn't explicitly asy that this was a bad thing, I get the idea that's what you were inferring.

      And to that, I say who cares? Should we be angry that a company wants to *gasp!* make a profit? The people who have this available to them should be grateful that they can get it at a reduced price.

      --
      "A terrorist is someone who has a bomb but doesn't have an air force." -William Blum
    3. Re:The Rules of Business by NeoMoose · · Score: 1

      I'm not saying it's a bad thing. In fact, I think it's by far and away a genious idea if executed properly.

  55. Kinda-sorta-not-really by oGMo · · Score: 2, Insightful
    On the other hand if you were to take out a couple power stations you could disrupt the flow of information, as well as disrupt the lives of people for a considerable amount of time. It would be much harder to replace a power plant than wires and transformers.

    It's good you considered this, but given this is being used for last-mile internet (as opposed to actual infrastructure, such as backbones), this isn't really an issue. Besides, if you disrupt power, you're going to take out most people's ability to access the network anyway.

    Those who have backup power (and need it) ought to have concern for this, of course. They will probably not be using this as a solution anyway. (Probably should not.)

    --

    Don't think of it as a flame---it's more like an argument that does 3d6 fire damage

  56. To compete or not to compete... by Blue+Stone · · Score: 1

    Would all the pro-capitalist /. readers out there please explain to this somewhat socialist /. reader, why this is a bad thing, and why all those private telecom companies that have bought...er, had legislation passed favouring them...er..I mean favouring competition... are so darned wonderful for ultimately denying people very cheap broadband as a service to them rather than as an oppurtunity for personal gain?

    Just curious. :)

    --
    Corporation, n. An ingenious device for obtaining individual profit without individual responsibility. - Ambrose Bierce
    1. Re:To compete or not to compete... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I haven't read the article, but I can see several problems depending on how they did things to answer your question.

      1. Do I get a choice of ISPs? I get both of this from my cable co. and phone co. Granted it may be limited, but that's better than no choice.

      2. Similarly, what about choice of cable? I have compared the city owned cable channel lineups with private ones, and the private cable cos are beating the city owned when it comes to number of channels and diversity of channels. This could change at some point in the future, but right now the private cable is winning. If there is a choice in cable as a result than this wouldn't be a problem most likely. If not then I'm stuck with an inferior channel lineup.

      3. People with nothing better to do than to interfere with my cable/broadband. This is quite possibly the biggest problem I see. We all know about how conservatives complain that there is too much sex on TV/internet and liberals complain there is too much violence. With private cable and internet, I don't have to worry that some bored soccer mom driving a SUV while talking on a cell phone is going to complain about the sex and/or violence on cable and the internet. If that bored soccer mom complained to my private cable co about the sex or violence, they would tell her to go stuff herself. (I know of people who did try to complain to my cable co about that, and that was there response.) Similarly, the reaction would be the same if they went to my ISP or Verizon who provides the physical connection. (This is somewhat similar to Verizon's defense against the RIAA/MPAA lawsuits.) With a city owned cable/internet co, they have to take the bored soccer mom seriously since she is a resident, and now my freedom to view sex and violence is in jeopardy as a result. This would be especially problematic for me if the city owns the ISP as well as the infrastructure.

      The third reason is what makes private broadband/cable worth it if it is more expensive.

    2. Re:To compete or not to compete... by tshak · · Score: 1

      Do you choose your power company, your water company or even your telco company? In most area's you can't. Although I agree that there are some downsides to government run utilities (I generally prefer regulated private entities), but at the same time, a utility is a social service, and the Internet is becoming more of a utility then even a telephone.

      Competition has it's place, but it's also not economical. It's cheaper to run one power line to all houses, and have it managed by one organiztion. It's also cheaper to citizens since it's not for profit, but for service. It can be better for citizens because quality isn't cut for the sake of profit.

      Of course, the problem with government is that due to lack of competition, one can point out the bloat and inefficiencies in many government run organizations. However one can see that with a proper checks and balance system, and with consumers keeping these utility companies accountable, it's very possible to offer a better solution publically. In many cases this approach is not the right way to go. But again the Internet is approaching the status of Utility, which is where I think it makes sense to be a not-for-profit enterprise. I also dissagree with the power company offering cable TV, as this is, IMHO, not a utility, and should be left to the soomewhat "free market".

      --

      There is no longer anything that can be done with computers that is nontrivial and clearly legal. -- Paul Phillips
    3. Re:To compete or not to compete... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

      You're probably a eurocunt. Fuck off and die insect.

    4. Re:To compete or not to compete... by Blue+Stone · · Score: 1

      You make interesting points.
      The way I see the last point being addressed, is to seperate the infrastructure from the content, such that the nationalised medium is not responsible for the quality/nature of the private content.

      But I'm not sure it's relevant to internet supply. BT for instance in the UK has a bare bones broadband service, which just supplies access, you have to sort out your own mail provider etc.

      --
      Corporation, n. An ingenious device for obtaining individual profit without individual responsibility. - Ambrose Bierce
  57. Nothing new here, move along... by Registered+Coward+v2 · · Score: 1

    Electric Cooperatives (EMCs - an outgrowth of the rural electrication act passed mid-early last century designed to get electricity to areas utilities wouldn't service since they couldn't get the desired return on their investment) have been providing utility service to their areas for years, and have branched out into telco, gas, and internet access quite a while ago. Despite what some people think, they really do provide services at non-profit pricing to their customers (who, as part of a cooperative, are also the owners). City utilities often offer similar service/pricing models, they they are not co-ops since the city owns them, not the customers.

    One interetsing point, not in the article, is how many "Rural" co-ops are no longer rural, since many are now suburbs of major metropolitan areas, such as the EMCs surrounding Atlanta GA; areas taht private companies would gladly serve, if the EMC would only go away. That won't happen, given the political clout of the customers.

    If you really want more info, visit:

    http://www.touchstoneenergy.com

    --
    I'm a consultant - I convert gibberish into cash-flow.
  58. Re:Not sympathetic here-Same too. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Well the municipalities do have bonds to pay off.
    They also have almost all the expenses any business would. Labour,insurance,lights,heat,etc. The link is that the cable companies are forgetting is that municipalities are in essense, "owned" by their citizens (customers). Last time I checked I didn't "own" comcast cable. Companies don't realize they're in essence "fighting" their customers. The OSS crowd in another world could have been their customers. The movie and music crowd will soon find out the same.

    BTW Wasn't it the federal government that has taken away some of the "regulatory" power that local governments had over the telecom, and cable industry?

  59. Putting all your eggs in one basket-Political TV. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    " That's why it's imperative we develop a new information delivery device that runs on gas."

    Already have. It's called C-Span.

  60. Bite Me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Bet you like those fuckers down there, that were removed from my planet.

    Hopefully next time you will be included.

  61. I work for an isp that works with one of these by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    I work at www.getthewave.com, and we provide the net connection to www.netamu.com a local Utility, they have finished laying all the fiber and such. In under a year we have a little over 800 customers for the highspeed cable, and this is in a town of 2500 homes... The utility is now putting in the phone modules in their ICUs, so the telephones will be going over their fiber too. Screw qwest, and screw mediacom!! Hell yea.

  62. Re:Solution for cheap cable TV and internet access by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Didn't they make a movie about someone who did something like that? It worked out badly, as I recall.

  63. Just started this in Provo by lobos · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I was just out visiting in Provo, Utah and they are just starting to roll this out. The power company, Provo Power, is owned by the city (and Provo has well over 100,000 residents, unlike many of the other cities that are doing this.) (Check it out at iProvo.org)

    The thing that is really nice about this is that a very large percentage of Provo is populated by students. Brigham Young University (30,000+ students) is in Provo and Utah Valley State College (~25,000 students) is 5 minutes down the road in neighboring Orem. They're actually going around and putting fibre into entire apartment and condo buildings. If that isn't great enough for college students, they're going to be running everything (power, phone, cable, internet) and all at a very nice price. There's several different options for cable and internet, depending on your requirements, and they are all nicely priced.

    One cool thing I read is that if you live in Provo and have a business there as well, you'll be able to connect to your business online at something like 50 Mbps.

    There's all sorts of cool things about doing this. I can't wait to get back to school!

    1. Re:Just started this in Provo by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh, the joys of having your cable and internet service controlled by Provo City:

      - Twice a year, you get General Conference on 75 different channels.

      - MTV is replaced with scrolling Jell-o recipes.

      - All banner ads are replaced with "Have you done your home teaching this month?"

      - Any requests for pornographic material will get you a nasty letter from Paula Houston. (She's got time to write them these days)

      - Ten percent of your packets go straight to lds.org.

      You think I'm being funny? Okay, YOU try living here!

    2. Re:Just started this in Provo by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      LOL! That's funny. Too bad no one else will understand...

  64. Don't feed the trolls... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What's with all of these replies? Wake up people... these posts have been on every topic all day.

  65. I wish these guys would come to San Francisco... by marhar · · Score: 1

    ... except for that California state law that you can't operate a utility company unless you are totally screwed up. :-/

  66. Utility companies by Jimithing+DMB · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Well, despite being marked as flamebait I'm going to bite and take your message as sarcasm instead.

    The simple fact is that in some cases natural monopolies will occur. Electric service is the classic example of this. My dad worked for a local power company for years. Trust me, the idea is NOT for them to be a non-profit. They are allowed to make a modest profit-- and they DO! It's not Microsoft or Enron style profit, but it's a good clean simple profit that keeps the shareholders happy.

    A utility is in the business of providing a service for a reasonable price. If they don't have a reaosonable price, people start voting politicians out. Politicians don't like that, so they make sure the rates are reasonable. And you know what.. it has worked JUST FINE for around a hundred years! At least, until the politicians started deciding to deregulate-- which combined with some other bad decisions allowed Enron to happen.

    Think about our phone systems. Great, we now have all these baby bells that have remerged into 2 or 3 big ass companies. None of them are in the business of providing services for a modest profit, they are in the business of gouging their consumers (note: not customers) for as much money as they can! It was mentioned on Slashdot not even a month ago that with the advent of digital telphone switching and IP telephony it has become a LOT cheaper to operate a telecommunications company.

    So why are we still paying high prices? Yes, they are lower than years past, but given the decrease in maintenance costs they should be about 10 times lower than they are now. Well, we're still being gouged because we are willing to pay it. We pay what the MARKET WILL BEAR. Telephone service is another natural monopoly. It's easier to just have one company handle it and to simply keep a leash around their neck. This is what AT&T was-- a GOVERNMENT GRANTED monopoly whose rates WERE determined by the government. The government COULD have chosen to simply regulate the shit out of AT&T. What exactly was so bad about them? They spent that money keeping people like Dennis Ritchie, Keith Thompson, and Brian Kerningham working! Working on things that (go figure) actually paved the way for IP telephony and other modern telephone systems as well as helped the entire computing community. Specifically BECAUSE AT&T didn't want to sell it because they had the telephone monopoly, they gave it away.

    Shit, they were already on track to turning the telephone system into an entirely digital one. Why? Simple, because their rates were regulated and thus if they could provide the same service for less money then they'd make KILLER profits-- at least until the regulators caught up with them.

    So someone please remind me why we're supposed to deregulate everything and allow the next Enron to happen? Why can't we simply learn from history. And just so you all know.. I consider myself to be a conservative. Not the religious zombie head-up-ass conservative that is so prevalent in politics these days. But hmm.. if we think about it.. isn't it actually the democrats that wanted the deregulation? AFAIK, Clinton was praised for his great energy policy which eventually led to Enron. And Reagan didn't make many friends keeping IBM together.. but look where we are today! IBM evolved into a company that makes a killing AND helps the computing community! Isn't that what business is SUPPOSED to be about?

    -Dave

  67. Japan by BJH · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Tokyo Denryoku, the country's largest power supplier, currently offers 100Mbps fiber connections for home use in the Tokyo area for around $US50 a month.

  68. Oh, cry me a river! by phillymjs · · Score: 1

    Listening to the telecom giants whining about "unfair competition" makes me want to retch.

    This, from companies who do everything in their power to screw their competitors and customers. Advertise high-speed, always-on internet service, but don't make guarantees as to the speed or the uptime. Grudgingly provide their infrastructure to their competitors as mandated by law, but give preferential treatment to their own services and relentlessly play the blame game when the problems lie in their network. It's pathetically laughable to hear them preaching about how the playing field must be leveled.

    ~Philly

  69. Not A Company, Not Rural by John+Hasler · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It's a local government, not a company. And a town of 14,000 is not rural.

    --
    Warning: this article may contain humor, sarcasm, parody, and perhaps even irony. Read at your own risk.
  70. We already have that by commodoresloat · · Score: 1

    They're called "cars." Just fill them up with hardcopies of your information and drive them to your destination.

  71. AACK! Socialism! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Oh, my god! It is run by a public utility! Socialism!!!

    Socialism is always bad, right?

  72. When I was a kid... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Right now, actually. 1.1Mbps SDSL, $200/mo. And that's the best price I can get.

    I cringe when I hear people bitch about the $50/mo "outrageously" priced broadband connection they have. The poor babies.

    Sign me up!!!!

  73. Evil Bondage by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Brings to mind an old classic...

    Evil Bondage
    Phucks Phrom The Third Dimension
    1987

    Written By: The Occultist

    "All is ready, Master." said my assistant, handing me my dark robe and
    rubber devil's mask.
    "Thank you. I will enter now." I responded.

    The room was dark, lit only by a small black lightbulb in one corner. I
    could see a table in the center, upon which was strapped a nubile lass, naked
    but for the leather gag in her mouth.

    From under my robe I pulled a large cat-o-nine-tails. I began to stroke
    it fondly, as I spoke, "We have captured you from your evil extistence. You will
    now submit to us. I am in charge of breaking you in, and you shall call me
    Master."

    With this I walked to the table and removed her gag.

    "Now, my lovely, will you renounce yourself as a sinner in the eyes of
    the modem god, who you so falsely deny as fantasy?"

    "Never," spat she, "for I worship the corporate god of Sprint!"

    "Then feel the wrath of a phreak scorned!" said I, raising the whip.

    With cruel abandon I brought the whip down onto the flesh of her
    breasts. She screamed as the shards of glass in it tore through her skin,
    releasing scattered drops of blood. Again I brought it onto her breasts,
    whipping them again and again, until they were thoroughly oozing the red fluid.

    "Bitch!" I screamed, as I lay another stroke upon her stomach.

    "There is no repentance! I shall have my way with you!"

    Undoing the straps on her ankles, I twisted her body over, so her naked
    ass was facing me, and again fastened the straps.

    I watched the pale globes of her ass squirm in the dim light, sweat
    dripping from the crevice between her legs. I reached out, feeling her firm
    bottom, slapping the cheeks for good measure, before raising te whip again. The
    lash rang upon her, making her scream in agony as her ass yielded under the
    blows. Her buns turned a dark shade of red, welts raising on them. I dropped the
    whip then, wanting to continue on my own.

    Climbing upon the table, I undid the clasp of my robe, dropping it to
    the floor. My cock, a slight drop of sperm oozing from the tip, was poised over
    her ass. I reached down and spanked her, hard, until she was again screaming,
    then plunged my hard cock into her cunt. The tight walls of her virgin pussy
    gripped my cock as I rode up and down, again and again plunging brutally into
    her twat. Her body shook as I punched her ass with both fists, causing her to
    grip my penis even harder. I reached under her and fondled her bleeding tits,
    squeezing and pulling their maimed exterior, before applying two nipple clamps
    to her, firmly twisting them so as to make her scream in pain, even more blood
    coursing down her chest.

    I suddenly withdrew from her and stepped down from the table. From the
    wall I pulled two lengths of electrical cord, which I wound onto the nipple clamps.
    Walking to a switch on the wall, I giggled, thinking of all the shares of stock
    this scummy bitch had owned in various long-distance companies. The lever went
    down with a twist, and the lady on the table screamed, blue bolts of electricity
    charging through both tits.

    I walked back to the table and withdrew a large rubber double dong from a
    drawer. I smashed the dildo onto her back and ass, whipping her again and again
    with the two-pound monster. Then, with a shout of glee, I inserted the tool of
    pain and pleasure into her soaked pussy, now going through electrical convulsions.
    Her pussy lips barely opened for the dong, and I had to push it all the way in by
    brute force, making her twat bleed terribly in the process. When it was firmly
    lodged inside her, I went back to the switch and turned it to the off position.

    While still at the wall, I yanked the cords from her clamps, and put them
    back. Then I opened a small, hidden closet and produced a long, thick tire iron. I
    then strode back to the table.

    Her body was limp, and she unconscious. I untied all her bonds, while
    pushing the dildo further into her, until it was no longer visible at all.

    With a heave I lifted her body onto my shoulded, and took her to another
    corner of the room, where I strapped her neck into a guitione, her head hanging
    over a basket. I then lifted her ass to a presentable position in the air, and
    removed the nipple clamps.

    I reached for a hose and turned it on. Foul waste products spewed forth,
    directly into her face. She soon awoke, trying to spit bits and pieces of fesces
    from her mouth.

    "Well, well, my dear.. your scheme to stop all phreaking hasn't worked out
    so well, has it?" I said.

    She struggled to reply, but could not, as I had once again reapplied the gag.

    I then walked behind her, where I spread her ass and applied a bit of vaseline
    to the entrance. Grasping the tire iron firmly, I placed just the tip against her
    unloosened asshole. Muffled screams came from her mouth, her last moments being filled
    with thoughts of fear.

    I applied the two-pronged end of the iron to her, and pushed.
    Her ass ripped open on the sides, the sharp edges of the iron being too much
    for mortal flesh. Blood began pulsing from the wound, and bits of shit oozed from the
    sides of the hole. The tire iron was lodged about an inch inside her ass, and I pushed
    furher, ripping what was left of her ass wide open.

    Suddenly, the gag dropped loose from her mouth and unearthly screams filled the
    air, her moans dragging far out into the street.

    "Fucking whore!" I shouted, lunging the iron all the way in her ass with my
    shoulder, thus letting her uterus fall out onto the floor. But it did no good, her
    screaming just reached a crescendoing height.

    "Take this!"

    I reached for the cord which would drop the guitione blade. Finding it, I gave
    a pull, and the heavy blade dropped into her neck, depositing her head in the basket.

    Reaching for the head, I inserted my dick into the open mouth, and pumped back
    and forth. My hands groped up to the eyes, which I yanked out and into my mouth.

    An explosion rocked the corridor outside, and the steel door to my chamber opened.
    Standing in the doorway were a squad of MCI and Sprint fone pigs, staring with agape
    mouths as I orgasmed into the lifeless head of their once-chief exec.

    "Fools! You will never destroy the phreaks of the '90s! We are a strong breed!" I
    screamed, the last drops of cum oozing from my penis onto her face.

    I backed up into the room, the horde of gestapo trying to crowd through the door.
    Liting the blade of the guitione into place, I layed my head into th chopping block and
    pulled the cord. All went black.

  74. if only this happened down under ... by wiill · · Score: 1

    If this could happen in Australia i would be a very happy chappy. At the moment Telstra own all the telecommunications infrastructure, Telstra control what happens on it. If telstra refuses to roll out DSL to a particular area (either due to cost, or the fact that alot of the population is on pair gain / RIM) ... it doesn't happen. (They can also charge what they like, but that's a different story).
    They try to force people into buying their more expensive and less convenient one-way satellite services. ugh.

    If utilities would take it upon themselves to provide where telstra doesn't, imagine the profits they could make, even at a modest markup, like another poster mentioned!

    (On a side note, i'd love to become involved with a project such as this ... but again, different story)

    1. Re:if only this happened down under ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It does happen. In Canberra, ACTEW/AGL provide internet and cable TV as part of a package. I think you pay another provider for the service, but ACTEW/AGL provide the actual hookup, and then you can choose from several different ISP's and cable TV connections.

    2. Re:if only this happened down under ... by wiill · · Score: 1

      interesting ... are the prices comparable to those mentioned in the article (taking into account exchange rates of course)?

  75. Great, Great. Freaking crap.... by n8willis · · Score: 1
    Naturally, I get all pumped about this idea, thinking who I know in my town to start asking about this, then low and behold I see the next-to-last section:

    officials in Abilene, Texas, asked the Federal Communications Commission to let them wire their own broadband network despite a 1995 Texas law banning municipal telecoms.

    But the FCC agreed with phone and cable companies ... The agency declined to overrule Texas.


    Which just happens to be where I live. Of course; an exciting new broadband prospect pops up, and I live in town center of the test case that prevents it.

    Just my luck.
    --
    -- Watch the REAL Jon Katz.
  76. No, the damage is done... by plnrtrvlr · · Score: 1

    ...when things get out of balance. I live in central New York, and our electric (which is currently being deregulated) has always been via NYSEG, no other choices.... UNLESS you lived in one of those few towns with municipal electric. A few years ago, I lived in one of those towns. They purchassed their electicity from NYSEG, and delivered it to residential customers with an eye to recovering costs, for the prices of about 3.9 cents per killowatt hour... NYSEG customers pay 14 cents for the same electricity. Many businesses are leaving the state and citing high energy costs as a primary reason, and many residential customers quite often find it difficult to pay their bills. So who is doing the damage? I somehow doubt that it's the municipal electric companies... I say "way to go" to those municipal utilities that are offering other services on top of electricity: perhaps the "big players" will get enough of a shock (but I doubt it) that they'll realize their astronomical prices and profits are more than the market should bear, or that the market WOULD bear if the customers had any other choices.

  77. Move to Saskatchewan by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Where you can get a DSL connection in Grenfell. Population: 1230 Location: Middle of fucking nowhere.

    Canada justs rocks....

  78. This Just In by AnalogDiehard · · Score: 1

    AOL/TW is offering 10 kilowatt-hours of free AC power down their cable TV lines for 45 days.

    --
    Eternity: will that be smoking, or non-smoking? I Corinthians 6:9-10
  79. Utility companies don't make a profit! by jcsehak · · Score: 1

    Geez, haven't you ever played Monopoly?

    --

    c-hack.com |
  80. Re:I wish these guys would come to San Francisco.. by heff · · Score: 1

    I agree, sf is in desperate need of something.. anything..

    The high priced sbc global dsl is a rip off.

    --

    --

    |-_-| . o O ( bEef!)

  81. Nebraska? by KlomDark · · Score: 1

    What is Nebraska going to court for? The article didn't say anything besides stating that they had a problem with it (??) for some reason.

    1. Re:Nebraska? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Alltel (the phone service provider in Lincoln Nebraska) convinced the state legislature to pass a law (LB827) prohibiting a municipal-owned entity from entering into the data communications business. This was done to stop the municipal-owned electric company (Lincoln Electric System) from leasing it's fiber network to the local independent ISPs.

      The Nebraska Supreme Court recently ruled that such a law is preempted by federal law and therefore are unconstitutional.

      This is huge because it paves the way for more competition in Lincoln. Local, independent ISPs can lease a high speed local backbone and compete with the phone company for high speed local data services. It also allows them to completely separate themselves from the phone company's data network (have to use them for the local loop to get to the backbone providers out on the net).

    2. Re:Nebraska? by Opusnbill7 · · Score: 1

      Why did you post this anonymously? This is factual and a good point. And, in my opinion, any competition is always a good thing (at least in data and telecom where the costs are somewhat fixed).

  82. Just break even? by intnsred · · Score: 1

    What's this?! They want to just break even instead of screwing their customers as hard as they can? Isn't that against the law in the US?

  83. mod parent up by io333 · · Score: 1

    I really don't understand the parent but it's funny as hell anyway. MOD UP!!!

    1. Re:mod parent up by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I believe it's refering to one of the tenets of Scientology. Something about us all being nuked on Hawaii long before that chain of islands would've actually even existed...

  84. Failure to take advantage of the medium by sporktoast · · Score: 4, Interesting

    This (AP) article on CNN.com is exactly the sort that could benefit from being on the web. As it is, it is not much more than an electronic reprint of a newspaper-style article. The only "improvements" made are that it is heavy on cruft, what with the ads, partner tie-ins, subscription offers etc..

    There's a little generic warning and associated icon at the bottom: "All external sites will open in a new browser. CNN.com does not endorse external sites." That might be helpful if it referred to a practice that was actually being used somewhere on the page. But the only "external" links seem to be to affiliates and advertisers. I guess the old media paranoia about letting us get away is still pretty strongly in effect.

    Sorry, that's enough *vague* bitching. Here are some specifics:

    What I really want to complain about is that there quite a few interesting details that were merely summarized, and not further explored; and that there were any number of jumping off points that could have been made active.

    How about at least a link to the American Public Power Association, or one of the utilitis mentioned as an example? Or better yet, fill in some of those details. Which eleven states prohibit public power companies from offereing teleco services, or force them to charge artificially high rates. (If I live in one, I want to start writing letters!) How about a list (with links, maybe?) of the "511 publicly owned utilities now provide telecom services" mentioned in the "fact box"?

    So much potential in this web medium is still wasted. Most news stories on the web just look like a slightly slicker and more colorful version of 1994, back when "old media" "didn't get it".

    --
    In a related story, the IRS has recently ruled that the cost of Windows upgrades can NOT be deducted as a gambling loss.
  85. Read it again by WinPimp2K · · Score: 1

    The city has not made 32 million.

    The people using the service would have paid 32 million more to get cable and internet from a private sector company like AOL Time Warner.

    But wait, no cable company wanted to bother with a little burg like that. To get Time Warner in, they probably would have had to agree to even higher rates.

    So the 32 million that they did not send to big cable company stayed in town. The money that they did spend (probably close to that amount) stayed in town as well - and probably helped keep overall utility costs down for everyone at the same time as they are proviing the service over wire they had to string anyways.

    Maybe "big cable co" could try and use the FCC to demand acces to that cable to sell their services on.

    --

    You either believe in rational thought or you don't
  86. Huh? by singularity · · Score: 1

    Among its contentions: Municipal telecoms hurt a town's tax base and may violate the First Amendment by placing the distribution of media content under government ownership.


    Huh?

    "You are destroying the tax base! I mean, instead of us getting the money and you, the governemnt, getting a percentage in taxes, you get it all! That is not good economics for the government!"

    Does that make any sense?

    In addition, how much tax base does a huge corporation like BellSouth or AOL/TW really create in a small town like Glasgow?

    Also, I am guessing that the residents of Glasgow have the opportunity to get cable or at least satellite television from elsewhere, meaning that the government provides media distribution, but only as one of many choices.

    As a resident of Kentucky, I am glad to see things like this going on in the state.
    --
    - (c) 2018 Hank Zimmerman
  87. Powerline Internet equipment by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    Just thought since so many people brought up that this is ran on the MONITORING wires, and they wished it was over the powerlines, I'd put a link in here to a company that actually makes the powerline stuff:
    http://www.mainnet-plc.com/
    Some background info:
    http://europe.cnn.com/2001/TECH/internet/08 /28/pow er.line.access.idg/
    have fun!

  88. Uh.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Think before you rate, how can the first post be redundant?

    1. Re:Uh.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      First of all its in Kentucky.
      Secondly, the article is hosted by CNN.

      If you want to find where to sign up, find the company name listed in the article (if there is one) and search for it in google.
      Easy as pie.

  89. http://serviSense.com by donsaklad · · Score: 1

    http://serviSense.com offered bundling of energy, telephone and cable but dropped the bundling for some reason.

  90. Rural areas need cable TV competition, badly! by aquarian · · Score: 1

    That rural areas are still way lacking in broadband access goes without saying.

    However, their cable TV service usually sucks, too. People are getting reamed like you wouldn't believe. Prices *are not* any lower than in the big cities. They're about the same, for about a third to half as much stuff. So it's really a lot more expensive for what you do get.

    The biggest problem is that you don't get a full, 24hr feed of most of the channels. Things like CNBC, USA, and even the regular on-air "big 4" networks are only on during prime time, then switch to infomercials and religious crap the rest of the time. The local cable company makes more money this way. The upshot is that you don't actually get half the stuff you got cable for to begin with.

    Furthermore, that fifty bucks a month for basic-plus service (everything but premium movie channels) is a much bigger portion of the household budget in places where $8/hr is considered good job.

    Finally, these places have virtually *no* public access programming, which can be a vital community resource.

  91. Which states? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    he said that some states bock this kind of operation. which ones?

  92. WOW by RAMMS+EIN · · Score: 1

    They have a monopoly...and they want to use it to _save_ their customers money? So there _are_ still idealists in this country...

    --
    Please correct me if I got my facts wrong.
  93. I wish I could get this.. by calethix · · Score: 2, Insightful

    if for no other reason than the simple fact that I hate Verizon and Time Warner. My electric company on the other hand has always been on my good side.

  94. Starpower by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    My ISP is Starpower (in DC Metro area), and I think they're a joint venture including Pepco (the power company) and RCN. They offer phone, cable, and cable internet.

  95. This is not new, it is being phased out here... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Maybe this is new to the USA, but it has worked like this for decades in the Netherlands.
    Local govermnent-run utilities provided electricity, gas, water and cable. A national government-run utility provided telephone service.
    This worked very well. We had reliable service at a reasonable cost. No "commercial companies" or "shareholders" to run away with your money.

    Then the European Union was invented, and they declared that this model was somehow undesirable.
    Why, we will never know. All these companies are commercialized, we are paying much more, and the quality of service is going down all the time.

  96. Re:Not a power-line network, Oh, really? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ever heard of OPGW?
    Fiber Optic Groundwire.
    Combines the grounding needed by the power company for lightning protection with several strands (24,48,96,128,256) of single-mode fiber.

    The DOE and power companies have strung this all over the midwest.

    All we need to do is get a lease and have someone set up the equipment (not a small undertaking, and it will not be done until it makes financial sense).

    As the majority of the cost on installing ground wire is in labor, it makes good sense to use a dual purpose cable.

  97. Last Post! by alpg · · Score: 0

    Sharks are as tough as those football fans who take their shirts off
    during games in Chicago in January, only more intelligent.
    -- Dave Barry, "Sex and the Single Amoeba: What Every
    Teen Should Know"

    - this post brought to you by the Automated Last Post Generator...