Slashdot Mirror


Gestures For The Linux Desktop

geoffsmith writes "Just stumbled upon a gesture system for the linux desktop called 'wayV'. It works similarly to Mozilla gestures, except at windowing system level. For example, hold down the middle mouse button and draw an 'N' and netscape pops up, or draw a slash through a window and it kills the window's process. There are .debs available and the author is currently porting it to win32."

175 comments

  1. obscene by gripdamage · · Score: 4, Funny

    I guess I thought this software always came with my distribution. I've been making a certain gesture at the Linux desktop for some time with no effect.

    1. Re:obscene by boy_afraid · · Score: 1

      Yeah, my gesture involved my hand with only the middle finger extended while the others were clenched.

  2. lol by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I wish I had mod points.. I am a linux user but I have humor.. stupid zealots will mod this down but it was funny.. :)

    1. Re:lol by Joey7F · · Score: 1

      I wish I had mod points.. I am a linux user but I have humor.. stupid zealots will mod this down but it was funny.. :)

      Well just to prove you wrong I will unload my points and blindly mod the above funny.

      Hmmmpff...

      --Joey

    2. Re:lol by gregstoll · · Score: 1

      Is your point that you're a stupid zealot?

  3. Whatever happened to Popmouse for Windows? by Katravax · · Score: 3, Interesting

    A couple years ago there was a similar app for Windows called Popmouse. I cannnot find it now. Does anyone know what became of that software, or Pointix, the company that made it?

    1. Re:Whatever happened to Popmouse for Windows? by Aldreis · · Score: 2, Informative

      You could take a look at Sensiva. It has been around for years, and could even record actions as a macro and assign it to a custom gesture.

    2. Re:Whatever happened to Popmouse for Windows? by wcb4 · · Score: 1

      This is truly useful on a laptop with a touchpad (I have also used it on a desktop with a tablet, but it just does nto feel as natural). Its a piece of sotware that is actually very useful. The only drawback, and this may have been corrected, is taht it hooks into the right click (you have to click and hold the right mouse button to gesture) and this is how you bring up context sensitive menus, such as display/desktop properties. When running sensiva, you have to do anything that uses the right mouse button the long way (through menus or control panels) One of those opportunities where a 3 button mouse would be really useful.

      --
      I reject your reality ... and substitute my own.
    3. Re:Whatever happened to Popmouse for Windows? by chavo+valdez · · Score: 1

      I have a copy of Popmouse. It's usually one of the first things I install on a new windows install.
      Popmouse is way cooler than any gesture program. You just shake the mouse or move it to a screen edge, completely configurable of course. I just give my mouse a quick counter-clockwise shake to go back or slam it against the right side of screen to got to top of page. It even came with a bunch of it's own utilities, calculator, file manager, alarm clock, scheduler, notepad etc. You can set up menus to popup with the shake of a mouse. It will execute keystrokes and will change configurations depending on which app has focus. All configurable with a gui.
      I wonder what happened to them. I'll be happy to upload it somewhere if someone would like to host it. My server wouldn't take a decent slashdotting. I have a crack of course, since the company is gone.

  4. In related news.... by telstar · · Score: 4, Funny

    No word yet on what gestures the Linux port of "Leisure Suit Larry" will support.

    1. Re:In related news.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Is Sierra porting Leisure Suit Larry to Linux? Why would they do that?

  5. Pointless by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Thats utterly freakin stupid It takes longer to draw an "N" than it does to click the freakin icon, not to mention that there's probably hundreds of apps that start with the letter "N".

    The "mouse gestures" idea is pointless.

    1. Re:Pointless by moonbender · · Score: 2, Informative

      Not true: to click on an icon, the cursor has to be at a specific point on the GUI; furthermore the icon has to be visible, eg it must not be covered by a window.
      (And yes, I am aware the parent was troll more than anything, but it's on-topic, and I'm sure some people could think the same without being malevolent.)

      --
      Switch back to Slashdot's D1 system.
    2. Re:Pointless by op51n · · Score: 1

      I used Sensiva for a while, and it worked well with the graphics tablet I have. But I found since upgrading my system and being able to have both mouse and tablet plugged in at the same time it is just as easy to swap to the mouse to do things that I could do with a gesture. It was good for things like back and forward in browsers, and you could customize it do more elaborate things which was somewhat useful.

    3. Re:Pointless by Sunda666 · · Score: 1

      I concur it must be kinda useless for a desktop/notebook,
      but it is pretty cool software for a touchscreen environment
      like Opie. So don't dismiss it so fast, dude.

      cheers

      --


      ``If a program can't rewrite its own code, what good is it?'' - Mel
    4. Re:Pointless by be-fan · · Score: 1

      What icon? The one behind the window I'm working on? That icon?

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
    5. Re:Pointless by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      yeah that icon - right next to the empty desktop you need to draw your stupid 'N' on, which is also covered by your window...

  6. here's a thought by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    what would "ctrl-alt-del" move be

  7. apt-get install from Debian by CAPSLOCK2000 · · Score: 4, Informative

    This software is allready in Debian, so all you Debian heads, save the author's website, and install with:
    # apt-get install wayv

    (well, actually sudo aptitude install wayv for me, but that's beside the point)

    1. Re:apt-get install from Debian by taviso · · Score: 3, Informative

      fvwm has had this functionality using libstroke since version 2.3.4 (2.5.5 is the latest release)

      --
      ex$$
    2. Re:apt-get install from Debian by aed · · Score: 2, Funny

      Isn't there a gesture for that procedure? ;)

    3. Re:apt-get install from Debian by yandros · · Score: 1

      wayV is an attempt to make libstroke more widely avaialble than `in fvwm', so this is hardly surprising...

  8. Oh puhleeze. by CoolVibe · · Score: 4, Interesting
    People think "gestures" are the best thing since powdered milk. I don't. I'm not a believer. Heck, I'm a keyboard using heretic. I loove KDE because everything can be assigned to a hotkey.

    To me, gestures is a violation of POLA (Principle of least astonishment). When gestures are on in Opera, they get in the way, because I sometimes 'randomly' select text when I browse/read (it helps me read faster, dunno why).

    So make me a believer. Tell me _why_ gesturing (as the scourge that it is to me) should haunt me even on my desktop?

    No, I'm not trolling, I'm generally curious about why people think this RSI inducing "input method" is useful, and why I should use it instead of my well-optimized keyboard shortcut scheme.

    1. Re:Oh puhleeze. by Katravax · · Score: 4, Informative

      Liar. You're just trying to sound like a keyboard snob. Opera gestures don't happen by themselves -- you have to hold the right mouse button down. I also highlight text to break pages apart to make them easier to read, and I have never accidentally kicked off an Opera gesture, and Opera is my primary browser. In addition, you can turn the gestures off. There is no way for gestures in Opera to "get in the way".

    2. Re:Oh puhleeze. by irc.goatse.cx+troll · · Score: 1

      Because you installed them? If you don't like it, don't use it.

      Personaly, I'd rather use vi style (map commands to keys), But mouse gestures beat the hell out of popup menus. Once you get used to them its hard to back to actually paying attention where the cursor is in relation to toolbar.

      Also, selecting text dosnt effect it. Most mouse gestures use mouse2, or can be configured to. I like to highlight text to mark place if im going afk for a sec, or to invert color on badly made pages, and it never bothered me.

      --
      Pain lasts, kid. Its how you know you're alive. Sometimes I think this growing up thing is just pain management-TheMaxx
    3. Re:Oh puhleeze. by Erik+Hollensbe · · Score: 1

      You should take a look at fluxbox. The Keybinding/Chording system allows for a significantly larger number of hotkeys. Any emacs user would be happy with a bunch of keys bound to the useless windows key on your keyboard :)

      And the tabs rock, too.

      Did I mention it was fast? :)

    4. Re:Oh puhleeze. by CoolVibe · · Score: 1
      Nah, I once installed it to see what the fuss is about. After 5 minutes I deemed it unworkable and went back to keyboard shortcuts and mousing.

      It's perfect that way, with my left hand I can cut, paste, kill windows, minimize/maximize/close windows, select windows and pop up menu's and with my right hand I can use my mouse with the mouse wheel to scroll. read and select text.

      To the people who say it isn't possible to kick off a gesture event accidentally: It happened to me a couple of times. I don't know the exact circumstances (or what the fuck I did), but it was triggered nonetheless.

      Still no solid arguments as to why mouse gesturing is the way to go. I'll stick to my keyboard hotkey setup and mouse, thanks.

    5. Re:Oh puhleeze. by CoolVibe · · Score: 1
      Yep, I know about fluxbox. It is nice, but still, I want eyecandy. So KDE it is :)

      Also, ion is also pretty nice if you're in a minimalist mood. It also has tabbing and is fully controllable by the keyboard. It is way cool.

    6. Re:Oh puhleeze. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm not particularly interested in providing reasons for you to use mouse gestures, because frankly, I don't care what you use. I care even less when you're clearly stupid enough to accidentally hold down the right mouse button and enact mouse movements uniform enough that Opera interpreted them as a mouse gesture.

      Personally I use them for forward/back/new/close, since I can preform all of them instantly.

      If I were going to use them at a global level, I might use them for closing, shading, and iconifying windows. Then I don't have to waste time with one-handed multi-key functions.

      Maybe you should stop pretending people actually care how you choose to interact with your computer. It seems incredibly obnoxious.

    7. Re:Oh puhleeze. by Gyorg_Lavode · · Score: 1

      I think that gestures with a single input are somewhat clumsy. Things like mouse gestures are the first step of a baby walking. We need input devices that track multiple inputs and hopefully, in the future, devices that track multiple inputs in 3 dimensions to really bring gesture control to maturity.

      --
      I do security
    8. Re:Oh puhleeze. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      KDE & hotkeys? You must be joking. Have you used sawfish? It has a zillion more hotkeys than KDE, like resizing even those windows that are not normally resizable.

    9. Re:Oh puhleeze. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I wondered how the original poster got inadvertant Opera gestures from the left button too, though that is a problem in the default Mozilla config. Easily changed though. And besides, everyone knows real keyboard snobs use Ion anyway.

    10. Re:Oh puhleeze. by egreB · · Score: 1

      I don't see the point in making you "a beleiver." As long as people love and use mouse gestures, there's a market for it. Nobody forces you to make use of them (-8

      Opera's mouse gestures are really great. I open a link in the background as a new window by holding mouse2, and move my mouse down and up. I close a window by drawing and L (still with mouse2 pressed). I can open new, blank windows, reload and then some. Some of these gestures are performed just as fast with a keyboard, but not all (like the link-clicking stuff). As the mouse is the primary input device for web-surfing, it's nice to find more use for it than just clicking. Oh - I almost forgot the one I use the most. Back and forth in history can be accomplished by pressing mouse1 (for forward) or mouse2 (for backward) and press the opposite button.

      I use KDE as well - my shortcut theme is quite useful and effective. The mouse gestures are a nice addition.

    11. Re:Oh puhleeze. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thank you very much for saying what needed to be said.

    12. Re:Oh puhleeze. by Wolfkin · · Score: 1

      >I sometimes 'randomly' select text when I
      > browse/read (it helps me read faster, dunno
      > why).

      Yeah, me, too. It does seem to make reading faster, but it annoys the hell out of people trying to read over your shoulder. :)

      --
      Property law should use #'EQ, not #'EQUAL.
    13. Re:Oh puhleeze. by be-fan · · Score: 1

      The main reason is to provide the quickest access to certain features. I too am a keyboard shortcut junkie. However, a lot of the time when I'm just surfing the internet or something, I don't have any hands on the keyboard (don't get any ideas). I don't want to put my hands on the keyboard to access a program or something. So the whole idea is to have the fastest access no matter what the situation.

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
    14. Re:Oh puhleeze. by zapp · · Score: 1

      I don't use gestures asside from in Opera, but they are extremely useful for me in that aspect. This is because web browsing is a primarily mousing activity.

      For example, I pair gestures with the ctrl-shift-click (to open window in a new tab, backgrounded) to open all the links off /., then read them and gesture to close them. Good technique for any reading style with a large branching factor.

      Like I said though, I personally shy away from OS gestures. This is for several reasons - one is that most other activities are keyboard only - IM, word processing, terminal, whatever. Also, they're often too complicated. Opera's "close" gesture is left-right-left, and this is almost the only gesture i use.

      --
      no comment
    15. Re:Oh puhleeze. by Compact+Dick · · Score: 1

      When gestures are on in Opera, they get in the way, because I sometimes 'randomly' select text when I browse/read
      Press Alt+P, go to Accessibility and uncheck Left-handed back and forward gestures. You should be right now.

      Also,check out Help -> Mouse for more mouse gestures. Once you get the hang of it, they are indispensable.
    16. Re:Oh puhleeze. by ssstraub · · Score: 1

      Why don't you just use the middle mouse button to click on the links and achieve the same effect?

      That seems a lot easier than reaching for the CTRL-SHIFT and then clicking.

  9. Download it here by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    http://download.com.com/3001-2344-891022.html

  10. Mozilla gestures by Zog+The+Undeniable · · Score: 1

    So does Mozilla flip you the bird when you type http://www.microsoft.com/ie?

    --
    When I am king, you will be first against the wall.
    1. Re:Mozilla gestures by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Opera does

  11. StrokeIt. by albino+eatpod · · Score: 3, Interesting

    There's already a pretty good mouse gesture program out for Windows called StrokeIt. I tried using it for a while, but it's really not worth it unless you have an optical mouse IME - a balled mouse ended up screwing up the gestures something chronic. Since I got my Logitech optical, it's a bit more usable, but I do wonder how much more efficient it is. To close a window, you have to draw a Q, and in the same time you've done it you could have just clicked the X.

    I use the gestures in Phoenix though, moving back and forth between pages is a breeze now though - I really wouldn't recommend it for a full windows system though.

    1. Re:StrokeIt. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      you can set any gesture, pre-known or ones you "teach" to it, to do virtually anything with strokeit.
      highly configurable and customizable.

      mine has close window set to C - which is freakin fast and easy to draw. faster than closing out the normal way by far.
      examples:
      close - c
      maximize - foward slash
      minimize - reverse foward slash
      refresh - r
      back - left
      next - right
      top of the page - up
      email - E
      etc..

      and even bookmarks. i could set slashdot to S.. simple.

      this thing is a must for me while mousing with one hand.

    2. Re:StrokeIt. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The requirements for StrokeIt list the following: a joystick and a tub of vaseline.

  12. gestures standards by vistic · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I really hope that the gestures they use are the same as Mozilla's. I use the gestures a lot, and if I'm ever forced to use IE, I find myself gesturing to no avail.

    However, I recently tried using Opera which also has gestures capability. The problem I had is that a lot of the gestures are different than Mozilla's gestures, causing me to do Mozilla gestures out of habit without effect (or the wrong effect) inside Opera.

    On an operating system level this could be problematic. What if I absent-mindedly do a Mozilla gesture, but in this operating system's gestures, it causes me to lose my work before it was saved? Or some such similar disaster.

    Already I know I would have problems with the closing windows by drawing a slash through it. In Mozilla and Opera, you close it by gesturing L, R, L.

    Probably the best way to avoid all these gestures getting confused with each other ("now let's see, was that for Opera? Mozilla? or the operating system?") is to develop some sort of gesturing standard that's generally agreed upon as intuitive that we all can remember and use.

    Also, what if I have Mozilla installed on a system that also has an operating system gestures program installed? Which gesture takes priority when the same thing means two different things to two different programs that are monitoring the mouse at the same time?

    1. Re:gestures standards by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's R, L, R... not L, R, L...

    2. Re:gestures standards by TheRaven64 · · Score: 1

      The Mozilla gestures are similar to the Opera ones, because they were copied from Opera. Likewise the Black and White gesture for deselecting the current tool was the same as the Opera one for close current window. I think the Mozilla system includes some more, but I haven't used it since it is not installed by default, and it's bloated enough without downloading anything else. I agree that a standard for gestures would be a nice idea, and it's feasible (after all, meta+c copies to clipboard on almost all platforms I've used), but I suspect it will be a while before such a standard exists.

      --
      I am TheRaven on Soylent News
    3. Re:gestures standards by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I would much prefer setting gestures myself, but have them accessible at the system level. If programs wanted to register events, they would simply inform the gesture system of them, and I could set whatever gesture I want, or none if I prefer.

    4. Re:gestures standards by An+Onerous+Coward · · Score: 1

      I've got kind of the same problem. I use EMACS a lot, and sometimes I try and use Ctrl-P and Ctrl-N to scroll the screen up and down when I'm web browsing. Then I have to kill off the print dialog box.

      You're right about coming up with some sort of gesturing standards. It will be necessary if they're ever going to become popular. As to your second question (which gesture system gets priority?) I'm guessing that a good standard would address that as well.

      --

      You want the truthiness? You can't handle the truthiness!

    5. Re:gestures standards by ljaguar · · Score: 1

      I would like to mention as a long time user of Opera for linux (and thus interacts with mozilla frequently also) that Opera's gestures are more feature rich and I get frustrated by the inadequacy of mozilla's gesture all the time.

      Mozilla's people didn't quite understand what gestures were. While they made them infinitely more configurable, they couldn't get the polish or the usefulness of, say, switching windows or open in background.

      And to point out the obvious, there was a very very large gap of time between the release of Opera's gesture and mozilla's plugin. Plus, mozilla's gestures were largely copied from Opera's.

    6. Re:gestures standards by vistic · · Score: 1

      I actually love the way opening in a background tab works in Mozilla. In Opera there's some gesture like U, D, U on the link or something. In Mozilla, I have it set so that I just middle-click and it goes in the background. That actually bothered me a lot about Opera at first. And for switching windows, I find it intuitive to gesture U, R to move right a tab or U, L to move left a tab.

      Different strokes (pun!) for different folks I guess.

    7. Re:gestures standards by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      in the latest version of opera, you can have the middle button do various things such as panning (if not clicked on link) and (on links) not doing anything, opening in the same window, new window or background. You can get there by control-middle click.

      Oh and I'm not sure if you are aware, but in opera, you can switch tabs by rightclick-scroll up/down.

      Just tryin' to inform.

    8. Re:gestures standards by Tyreth · · Score: 1
      If the close for the OS was the same as opera, how would you distinguish between wanting to close the current Opera/Mozilla tab and closing the entire program?

      Unless of course you use a different button for the OS compared to Opera/Mozilla.

    9. Re:gestures standards by yandros · · Score: 1

      This sort of thing used to kill me -- I use a couple different systems that call for me to enter large amounts of text into a browser textarea. Whenever I edit large chunks of multi-paragraph text in emacs (which I've been using for more than a dozen years, so it's `built into my fingers'), I habitually hit `Meta-q' to re-fill the paragraph. Since the text isn't saved anywhere, I'd generally `just lose' when Mozilla exited.

      These days I use Galeon, so changing the key binging was trivial; I've also developed a habit of just composing the text in emacs and cut-and-pasting it into the browser.

  13. FVWM by James+Lanfear · · Score: 5, Informative

    FVWM has supported gestures through LibStoke (apparently what wayV uses as well) for quite some time.

    1. Re:FVWM by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      wayV doesn't used LibStroke, it has its own implementation of a different technique.

    2. Re:FVWM by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Someone needs to update the LibStroke page then, 'cause wayV is listed there.

  14. StrokeIt by eddy · · Score: 4, Informative

    No idea, but StrokeIt sounds similar.

    Personally I feel the only gestures worth bothering with is the hold-mousebutton-click-other for navigating back/forward.

    --
    Belief is the currency of delusion.
    1. Re:StrokeIt by moonbender · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Personally I feel the only gestures worth bothering with is the hold-mousebutton-click-other for navigating back/forward.
      That'd be Opera? Or has this been implemented in Mozilla meanwhile?

      In any case, I use that gesture all the time, too. However, I also make very heavy use of "open in new window/duplicate", "reload", "new blank window". So I think mouse gestures are pretty damn sweet. On the other hand, I've never used them outside of a browser environment.
      --
      Switch back to Slashdot's D1 system.
    2. Re:StrokeIt by eddy · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Yes, like in Opera.

      The reason I see those as the most useful is because you typically do them while "off keyboard". If I open a new window it's very likely that I'm going to have to type something into it anyway, so opening the window using a guesture instead of pressing ctrl+n isn't a big win if you measure in "minimizing movement" which seems to be my optimization critera.

      A case can be made for other functions in the same way -- reload certainly is "off keyboard", but I still hit F5 or click the reload-button, probably becase I'm so very used to it in conjunction with the relative rareness of that operation (as compared to navigation)

      --
      Belief is the currency of delusion.
    3. Re:StrokeIt by moonbender · · Score: 1

      That's true. If I open a window using the mouse gesture, I usually select a bookmark subsequently, on the other hand, if I open a window to enter an URL manually, then I'll use ctrl+n to open the window, as well.

      --
      Switch back to Slashdot's D1 system.
    4. Re:StrokeIt by Ryosen · · Score: 1

      I'm constantly using it outside of Opera.

      It'll be nice to have a utility that will actually make it work, rather than my forgetting that Opera (and Mozilla) is the only application "modern" enough to include gestures.

      --

      Ryosen
      One man's "Troll, +1" is another man's "Insightful, +1".
    5. Re:StrokeIt by LilGuy · · Score: 2, Interesting

      StrokeIt is awesome. I've been using it since the last time I read a story about mouse gesturing on /. It works great! It saves me lots of time searching for the X or the -, and I can open my favorite webpages or programs with the flick of a wrist.
      Not to mention girls dig drawing all over the screen with it. ;)

      --

      You're nothing; like me.
  15. stroke it by p00ya · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Have a look at strokeit

    Fairly customizeable, and neat for a while, but eventually I decided that I could do everything more efficiently directly from emacs :p

  16. Ratpoison by leoboiko · · Score: 4, Funny

    I use ratpoison. The only gesture I do is to the mouse, not with the mouse.

    --
    Prescriptive grammar:linguistics :: alchemy:chemistry. Stop being a nazi and learn some science.
  17. I wonder... by rampant+mac · · Score: 3, Funny
    There are .debs available and the author is currently porting it to win32.

    Wonder what gesture he'll use for control-alt-delete?

    --
    I like big butts and I cannot lie.
    1. Re:I wonder... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Windows already have gestures for control-alt-delete.

      Move your mouse-cursor to the IE icon and click.

      At least that was the case when I lasted used windows, win95/98.

  18. Dollar sign by Highlordexecutioner · · Score: 1

    So what happens if you gesture a dollar sign?

    Will it format and install Windows

    --
    Where am I going and why am I in this handbasket?
    1. Re:Dollar sign by An+Onerous+Coward · · Score: 1

      No, it will automatically run "apt-get bulk-email-publisher-1.0". If you've got broadband, your financial future will then be secure.

      --

      You want the truthiness? You can't handle the truthiness!

  19. maybe for games, but not the desktop by gripdamage · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Did you ever play "Black & White". It had gestures and once you got used to them they were pretty cool. You would use your mouse to draw the gesture on any surface, and if the game engine successfully recognized it a bright white light would illuminate the path of your mouse (as well as implementing the selected command of course); usually this announced that you (being God in the game) are about to perform a miracle. There was a definite learning curve to using them, but once you got it it was genuinely useful and allowed the game to have almost no interface cluttering the screen. Though it isn't any where near the top of my list of favorite games, the gampeplay was unmistakably innovative.

    1. Re:maybe for games, but not the desktop by Tester · · Score: 1

      I think the opposite, I played B&W for quite a while and the gestures were just a pain in the ***. If they could have had keyboard shortcuts instead.. it would have been much easier.

  20. Useful? by sepluv · · Score: 3, Informative
    Although this is quite an interesting (and even humorous) idea I doubt if it will be used by many Linux users (unless it is quite simple with a few mouse gestures which are easy to make but not easy to make by mistake). I'm sure some people will like it, but, as has already been pointed out, it is probably quicker clicking the icon. Even if it does speed things up a bit, one has to learn all those gestures and make sure one does not make any by accident.

    When I had mouse gestures enabled in my browsers (Mozilla, Opera and Phoenix), I found myself making them by accident and closing the window or something. Maybe they should make them customisable (choose your own gestures - that would be cool and people probably have their own personal gestures they find it is easier/harder for them to make ;-) ) and also make it so one can choose which indivdual gestures you want installed (i.e.: not the kill the app one if your fingers slip sometimes).

    If that was done they might be more useful and mainstream (and, maybe, used in many apps and OS's), but still I (like many others, probably) just couldn't be bothered learning all the damn things and they seemed like more pain than they were worth - I know how to user my browser/OS quickly and well by pointing and clicking or by the keyboard, and I do not really need a third harder-to-learn that is of questionable value and unlikely to speed up my browsing or OS use.

    --
    Joe Llywelyn Griffith Blakesley
    [This post is in the public domain (copyright-free) unless otherwise stated]
    1. Re:Useful? by psavo · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Only because you can't handle your mouse right doesn't mean that nobody else couldn't too. I for one find mouse gestures an extremely useful thing to have. As I use mouse for clicking on links and whatnot, it never gets in the way.
      Before I learned mouse gestures (they got enabled accidentally) I did manage to do some things (close windows, bring new ones..) by accident. After I learned what moves do what, I haven't have any problems. Only that mozilla's version of mousegestures sucks ass.

      Afaik only people who bitch about mg's are those who never understood how to use them, exactly the same thing as with i9 text input system.

      --
      fucktard is a tenderhearted description
    2. Re:Useful? by sepluv · · Score: 1

      My post (the grandparent) may've sounded a tad condescending and like I was putting down MG's. This was not my intention. I'm sure many people find them useful, but I do think there are ways in which they could be improved.

      It may even sound mundane or even suitish. I am as geeky as the next /.er and like trying out new features like MG's. I did this for a while but in the end I decided that (in their current form (in Mozilla and Opera)) they were more trouble than they were worth (and to some extent, I did not have the time to work out how to use them properly and, also, not make them accidentally).

      If I found I could not be bothered then I cannot see that Joe Random is going to be (i.e.: MG's - at least as they stand - are not going to become mainstream). However, this does not mean it is a useless technology or that the Linux project is useless, by any means, and I'm sure MG's will find a niche user base (and possibly niche applications).

      I think that this project should be supported as, undoubtedly, some people will find it helpful. I may even start using MG's a lot one day (if they improved or if I can be bothered learning/using them).

      --
      Joe Llywelyn Griffith Blakesley
      [This post is in the public domain (copyright-free) unless otherwise stated]
    3. Re:Useful? by Jack+Zombie · · Score: 3, Informative

      Maybe they should make them customisable (choose your own gestures - that would be cool and people probably have their own personal gestures they find it is easier/harder for them to make ;-) ) and also make it so one can choose which individual gestures you want installed (i.e.: not the kill the app one if your fingers slip sometimes).

      Actually, you can customize and choose which individual mouse gestures you want to use in Phoenix/Mozilla with the Optimoz Mouse Gestures Extension. All you need to do is go to the directory where you installed Phoenix/Mozilla (for example, C:\Program Files\mozilla.org\Mozilla), then navigate into chrome\mozgest\content\ and open the gestimp.js file (so, following the previous example, it would be C:\Program Files\mozilla.org\Mozilla\chrome\mozgest\content\g estimp.js). Now, edit whats in function initGestureTable() -- for example, edit
      addGesture("L", "g.BrowserBack", "BrowserBack();");
      to
      addGesture("LUDR", "g.BrowserBack", "BrowserBack();");
      in order to change from performing a "Left" gesture to go back one page to "Left, Up, Down, Right". You can also delete the gestures you dislike this way. Its archaic and troublesome, I know, but it works.

      Personally, I only use the "Left" for Back, "Right" for Forward, "Up" for Stop, "Down" for New Tab, and "Down, Right" for Close Tab. All the rest is bloat that gets in the way, for me at least.

      --
      "You should never doubt what nobody is sure about." -- Willy Wonka
    4. Re:Useful? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Which right-click getures in Opera caused you problems in regular use? Did you really find it that hard to memorize left-stroke-forward/right-stroke-back? How were those harder to learn than alt-leftarrow and alt-rightarrow?

    5. Re:Useful? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      it is probably quicker clicking the icon.

      Is it quicker to drag your pointer over the "next" button, aim and and click it, than drag it a bit right? Is it quicker to select "File", pull down to "Close" and click it, than "scratch" the screen (press LMB and move wiggle the mouse left-right-left ?) I doubt. Besides, you may assign any internal Mozilla's javascript functions to gestures, you're not forced to certain shortcuts. Drag down is way faster even than ctrl-N.

      Maybe they should make them customisable

      Of course! They are customizable and the first thing I after trying them out a little bit was to apply sensible settings to my needs, remove unused gestures, add "aliases" to my most common "mistakes" (rounded corners etc), add stuff I don't have "by default" (I have a mousewheel so I don't need vertical scroll but I don't have the second mousewheel so horizontal scroll was most desired feature.) and submit a few bugs on stuff I found really annoying :) Then I've drawn all the gestures I have in my file (21 total) , printed them on a vertical strip of paper and pasted the strip on the side of my monitor.

      but still I (like many others, probably) just couldn't be bothered learning all the damn things

      Well, I use commandline instead of file managers, and I didn't have problems learning cp, mv, rm, cd. I still sometimes throw a glance at the strip, to see whether "zoom in" is up or down, but in less than 3 days I remembered all the basic gestures - and stuff like "Next/Previous tab", "close tab/window", "Move up a directory" or "back" really come in handy.

  21. What about tablets by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    yeh those like drawing tablets
    guestures would work well?

  22. um... by superspoon · · Score: 1

    so... what happens when you draw a smiley?

    --


    YarrRrr
  23. Fantastic by arvindn · · Score: 3, Insightful
    This is a good thing. One of the things I think today's desktop (not just linux, mind you) needs most is for the user to be able to interact more at the level of the desktop environment/window system rather than with applications alone. For instance, one of the things I liked best about sawfish was the endless amount of keyboard interaction it allowed. I could configure shortcuts for all sorts of window operations, and stuff like SHIFT+pull with mouse for resizing a window. Heck, I even used to change the volume with sawfish (map a keysroke to the commands aumix -v +5 and aumix -v -5).

    Conversely, I'm disappointed that gnome2 in its effort to make it appeal to windows users has dumbed things down a lot. After all, once you get users to try out the linux desktop, how do you keep them? By making the desktop more powerful, of course.

    I'm looking forward to seeing this get adopted widely. Eventually, I want there to be an entire layer that looks at your both keystrokes and your mouse movements before passing it on to the application. That way, handwriting recognition would work for all applications (wayV does this somewhat). Also, I could define app-independent "macros". For instance, I could set up some mouse gesture to translate into typing, say, my name or the URL of my home page.

    1. Re:Fantastic by damiam · · Score: 1
      one of the things I liked best about sawfish ... I'm disappointed that gnome2

      So why don't you use Gnome2 with Sawfish?

      --
      It's hard to be religious when certain people are never incinerated by bolts of lightning.
    2. Re:Fantastic by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Changing from metacity to sawfish is difficult at best. And the version of sawfish with gnome2 is dumber than the version with gnome 1.4. Then why switch to gnome2 at all?

    3. Re:Fantastic by randomcrap · · Score: 1

      killall metacity; sleep 3; sawfish & simple as that (make sure you save your session on logout to keep the change)

  24. Re:by the time... by bumby · · Score: 1

    It's even faster to typ a N on your keyboard. Or mod+n or whatever... May be fun to try for a day or two, but stupid indeed.

    --
    Hey! That's my sig you're smoking there!
  25. Gestures for BeOS and MacOS X by stew77 · · Score: 4, Informative

    I wrote something similar for BeOS - it's called FourWays. Now the trick is that all BeOS applications use BMessages for communications, and that in conjunction with SpiceyKeys, you can use gestures to control any BeOS application.

    Also, theres Cocoa Gestures for MacOS X.

    1. Re:Gestures for BeOS and MacOS X by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thank you! I was hoping someone would mention somethign similar for Mac OS X. Thanks!

  26. Tech support...! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Blimey, it's hard enough training new users to use a mouse. We've all been there:

    "No, clicking twice isn't the same as a double click"

    "No, you shouldn't move the mouse between the two clicks of a double-click"

    etc etc ad nauseum.

    Gestures are going to make this even more of a pain...

  27. I thought I was the only one.... by Mustang+Matt · · Score: 1

    I too select text while I browse in order to read faster! I'm surprised to hear that other people do that as well.

    I do really love gestures though. I use them in opera and mozilla. I used to be a full time keyboard user, but ever since gestures came out (and my 5 button programmable mouse) I can do all of my most critical functions with the mouse.

    I can only imagine if my system accepted TWO independent mice! haha

    --
    The man who trades freedom for security does not deserve nor will he ever receive either. - Benjamin Franklin
    1. Re:I thought I was the only one.... by myspys · · Score: 1

      I too select text while reading, easier to keep track of where you are and if you have to switch to another program you know where you were when you go back to the browser.

      Genius :)

    2. Re:I thought I was the only one.... by An+Onerous+Coward · · Score: 1

      I do it too, but I thought it was just some sort of high-level nervous twitch.

      --

      You want the truthiness? You can't handle the truthiness!

    3. Re:I thought I was the only one.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


      I am a little surprised too - but I have done the random selection of text to make the screen readable easily and thought *I* was the only one (well....). This method helps me "anchor" the eyes back to the relative point on the screen if you look away for a second or two (especially on a 21 inch monitor). Perhaps there are some other cues that are being picked up subcousciously which are worth a human factors study. If this leads to better rendering of text (every 10 or so lines highlighted in some manner that can't be confused with other things highlights are used for), we'll all read more.

      Also, I believe the speed at which a device responds (text appearing, text scrolling, etc.) promotes learning - and there may be an optimum speed for each person, but that's another topic for another day.

  28. Re:by the time... by moonbender · · Score: 1

    It's faster to type mod+n on the keyboard IF you have one hand on the keyboard. I don't have one hand on the keyboard at all times, I do have one hand on the mouse at nearly all times (with the exception of those times, like now, when I am typing). This is especially true for surfing: the mouse is obligatory for surfing, the keyboard is only optional. (Links/lynx users in the back rows, quiet down, please.) If I'm holding a cup of coffee in my left hand, having to type mod+n is annoying, indeed, while moving the mouse up down up is effortless.

    (Sidenote: mentioning mouse gestures always brings up scores of people pointing out an awarding use of the now-freed hand. But holding a cup of coffee or a phone or whatever is an option, as well.)

    --
    Switch back to Slashdot's D1 system.
  29. I thought drawing a slash by Pellelelle · · Score: 1

    ...would bring up your favorite website

  30. hello? by delong · · Score: 1

    Yeah, gestures worked great in Black and White. Why, exactly should I do something as inane as a gesture when a mouse click will do the trick? Total waste of energy.

    "Oooh look at me. I'm opening my web browser with a Big N."

    Derek

    1. Re:hello? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I like mouse gestures. Opening an xterm by drawing an "X" would be cool for me.

  31. Black & White by Orcspit · · Score: 2, Insightful

    PC game came out about 2 years ago called Black and White, the main way to cast spells in this game was through gestures. By about the second island I would have killed for icons or something to click. Many times I would be trying to create a rain spell to stop my village from being on fire, all along repeatedly failing the casting because I couldn't get the stupid gesture just right. So I'll pass on gestures for anything else.

    1. Re:Black & White by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Magic is tricky, you know....

  32. Re:by the time... by bumby · · Score: 1

    Well, that is true. I guess it's a matter of taste. If you're a mouse-user, I can understand it's a good thing to be able to emulate a keyboard with your mouse. But as a keyboard-user it's utterly pointless. Mozillas typeahead is, on the other side, a good reason for me, and probably for many other keyboard-huggers, to trash the mouse ;)

    So imho typeahead is a bigger "breakthrough" then guestures.

    --
    Hey! That's my sig you're smoking there!
  33. gesture by spoonist · · Score: 1
    The end user then makes a gesture with the mouse resulting in a pattern appearing on the screen.

    In Soviet Union, computer gesture at you.

  34. Netscape by FrostedWheat · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    draw an 'N' and netscape pops up

    People still use Netscape on Linux??

    Arh the Horror!

    1. Re:Netscape by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      >> People still use Netscape on Linux??

      Oh, yes, we do use Netscape 4.x.

      And Opera, and Mozilla, and Konqueror, and Galeon, and Links, and Dillo, and Lynx, and Netscape 7, and Phoenix, and Skipstone, and W3m, and Emacs, and IE... well, you got the picture.

      I use the first six.

      Being a Linux user brings such hard decisions... :)

    2. Re:Netscape by wadetemp · · Score: 1

      Oh, yes, we do use Netscape 4.x.

      And Opera, and Mozilla, and Konqueror, and Galeon, and Links, and Dillo, and Lynx, and Netscape 7, and Phoenix, and Skipstone, and W3m, and Emacs, and IE... well, you got the picture.

      I use the first six.


      It's always good to have lots of browsers. If you make the N gesture incorrectly odds are good that it will launch a browser anyway.

  35. Can you say accessibility by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    To all the idiots saying 'this is totally pointless, waste of time' - think about accessibility for a second.

    You do realise that there are some people whose only interface with a computer is a head controlled pointer, right?

    I hope that the gnome accesibility people consider adopting something like this for gnome2, providing 'gesture-binding' for the desktop.

    1. Re:Can you say accessibility by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Um to make gestures you *still* have to click a button. I dont see how it would be easier to wave your head around doing a gesture, when you could *look at* the icon and do a clicky.

  36. Well by Pros_n_Cons · · Score: 1

    I guess I have this installed cause every once in a while browser windows open (or die) It occured to me there should be one to update errata so even idiots can patch themselvs.

    --

    -- "of course thats just my opinion, I could be wrong." --Dennis Miller
  37. Black and White by boris_the_hacker · · Score: 1

    A simple request, but I want the fire effects you got when you pulled off a gesture in Black and White. All of these apps are good, they work and they do their thing, but I often found myself doing gestures in the game for the *click* *poof* *pretty fire effects*, made them that little bit more magical.

    --
    chris at darkrock dot co dot uk
    http colon slash slash www dot darkrock dot co dot uk
    1. Re:Black and White by Mark+(ph'x) · · Score: 1

      Oh no my village is on fire!

      Click... Mouse Swirl...Point... ... formatting hard drive, please wait.

      [user]: NO! THAT WAS FOR THE GAME YOU STUPID SYSTEM...

      --
      those who control the past, control the future. those who control the present, control the past.
  38. not mouse, tablet by terrox · · Score: 0

    gestures are great for graphics tablets, icons are usually NOT on screen unless you are one of those uber-dorks with a permanent windows-bar up all the time. why waste time porting to windows though? is it for sale?

  39. How many people use gestures by jd142 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It sounds really cool and all, and I've tried it out it Opera, but I always find myself back on the keyboard. Yeah, I hated Black and White, too.

    YMMV obviously, but when I'm at the computer, I'm normally using both hands to type and taking them off the keyboard to perform a fairly precise action with the mouse is a pita.

    Icons are actually fairly forgiving. You usually have around a 32x32 area of screen to hit your target. It seems like if you vary more than that in the gestures, then the gesture fails. And since you can increase your icon size, you can increase the allowable area for the doubleclick.

    And as others point out, in both windows and linux you can easily make key combinations to launch an app. Although I find myself using both os's autocomplete function in the run command. Type in a command once, then it's a simple win+r or alt+f2 to bring up the run box and type the first letter or two of the app's name to run it. Much faster for me than taking my hands off the keyboard, moving to the mouse and making a gesture.

    1. Re:How many people use gestures by sean23007 · · Score: 1

      Enabling mouse gestures never disables the keyboard. If you have both hands on the keyboard typing, you are in position to use the keyboard to navigate, not the mouse. On the other hand, if you are using the mouse (say, to click links in your web browser or filesystem browser), your hand is in ideal position to use a mouse gesture to pop back to the previous page if you click the wrong link.

      Ultimately, neither mouse gestures nor keyboard shortcuts should be removed just because the other has the same functionality -- they should be redundant systems, that share functionality. They should not complement each other.

      --

      Lack of eloquence does not denote lack of intelligence, though they often coincide.
    2. Re:How many people use gestures by mlk · · Score: 1

      I use a mix of gestures (in opera, & B&W, well if the rest of the game did not suck).
      So yeah, some people use them.

      --
      Wow, I should not post when knackered.
    3. Re:How many people use gestures by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Gestures are nice for those times using a mouse isn't an option. Browsing for example, I don't know of any way to follow a link in a graphical browser without using a mouse. Since this forces my hand from the keyboard, gestures are a nice extension to the mouse's utility. Increasing icon sizes is a good option if: your WM uses icons (mine doesn't), your screen is large enough that the space trade-off is worth it (not my notebook) and you don't mind the extra desktop cruft (I do.)
      I like your keyboard shortcut solution though and do the same in Ion. F3 brings up a run prompt, all my major applications have been symlinked to three letter or less starts: moz for mozilla, syl for sylpheed, lg for 'links -g'. Tied to scripts the concept is extremely powerful.

    4. Re:How many people use gestures by packman · · Score: 1

      Well - I don't know - but in a desktop environment I think you have your hand on the mouse quiet a lot. In a browser - nothing above a mouse (WITH scrollwheel) and the "holdright-clickleft" and "holdleft-clickright" mousebutton combinations in opera. That is way faster than the guestures - and most of the functionality in opera is available much faster thru keyboard shortcuts. When I started using opera - I loved the concept and used it a lot, but now - except for the mouse button combo's - I don't use mouseguestures anymore - I lost too much time when I missed one.

      In a browsing environment (i'm still talking about opera) - most of the times when you "need" a functionality available thru mouse guesture or keyboard shortcut - the next thing you will need is the keyboard anyway (wtf is the point of opening a new empty window with your mouse??) And I still have 2 hands available - like most people I hope - left hand for keyboard-shortcuts - right hand for mouse clicking, scrolling, back/forward mouse button combo's.

      In a desktop environment - I really don't see the point of using these guestures - you'll have to change the direction of your mouse multiple times - and the only thing you _would_ use it for is frequently used applications, you simply wont remember guestures for an application that you use once a month o. The frequently used apps - I put in a taskbar - which are available with one mousemove - and one click, and often I even assign them a shortcut, much faster than drawing a picture on-screen :)

    5. Re:How many people use gestures by yiingineer · · Score: 1

      I use gestures in Mozilla.

      I think mouse gestures are awesome features for a web browser. It might be a less awesome feature at the windowing system level, but it'll probably still be useful sometimes. The reason why mouse gestures are great for browsers is that a browser is a fundamentally mouse driven type of application.

      I absolutely agree with jd142 about it being a pain to take your hands off the keyboard to use the mouse to do a gesture and icons being relatively large, but I think you're missing the point. Taking your hands off the keyboard shouldn't be a big issue because you hardly need the keyboard at all except when you type a URL or need to enter text in a form. The great thing about mouse gestures is that you pretty much never have to move your mouse more than a little in each direction. It's much faster than non-gesture browsing.

      I'll give you an example. While browsing the front page of slashdot, I often find several stories that I find interesting and I'll open them in new tabs. This can be done quite easiliy with a gesture, using the CTRL + left mouse button, or a the middle mouse button. Once these tabs are open, I would normally have to move my mouse to the top of the screen to choose a tab and then probably move it back down later to click on a link in the text. If I have mouse gestures however, I can leave my pointer near the centre and do a mouse gesture to move to the next tab. I can also do a mouse gesture later to close the tab instead of moving the mouse. The same applies to moving forward or backward in a browser. Holding down a mouse button and doing a small quick left or right motion is much faster than moving your mouse up to the back and forward buttons or taking your hands off the mouse to do ALT + . If you have a mouse with a mouse wheel, you don't even have to move your mouse to scroll either. Although, I must admin that doing I think using large complex mouse gestures are probably slower and more prone to error than normal commands. Fortunatly, most mouse gestures in Mozilla involve two quick mouse motions instead of drawing intricate symbols.

      So you see, it's not about taking your hands off the keyboard, but it's about gestures allowing you to use your mouse more quickly and allowing you to avoid taking your hand off your mouse.

      This is fantastic for mouse driven applications, not too useful if you're typing text at a shell. Even still, I'm sure it will be useful for some applications.

    6. Re:How many people use gestures by smannell · · Score: 1

      Depends on what you are doing. I used to use a 2-D CAD system with gestures (they were called strokes back then), and it was great. The reason they were so useful is I could issue a command for a particular entity on the screen by just using the mouse. For example, I could start a gesture at a line and turn it into a construction line, or delete it, or drag it somewhere. Without gestures you have to first highlight things, and then either go click on an icon or issue keyboard commands. I've never tried to use them for OS or browser commands, but for a CAD system they are hard to beat.

    7. Re:How many people use gestures by jd142 · · Score: 1

      I don't know of any way to follow a link in a graphical browser without using a mouse

      As I said, I'm an exception in that I *really* like to type. Mozilla let's you type in the letter in the anchor text on a page and then you go to that link by hitting enter. So if you had a page like this:

      Check out the latest news, nature news and comics

      You could type n and then enter to follow the news link, or type na to go to the nature link (news would also get you to news) or c and go to the comics link. Then hit enter. Or ctrl+enter for a new tab, then ctrl+ page down and page up to navigate your tabs.

      Not everyone likes to use the keyboard as much as I do, I'm the first to admit it. And both gestures and keyboard shortcuts should be present. Not everyone has the manual dexterity to use a mouse only interface. Some people use a wand to hit the keys because they can't control their hands or arms well enough to use the mouse. Luckily, I'm pretty dexterous, which is one reason I like keyboard shortcuts.

      Now you know how to navigate links in mozilla without a mouse. And knowing is have the battle. ;)

    8. Re:How many people use gestures by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hey, thanks for the anchor tip. I know I'll find it useful.

    9. Re:How many people use gestures by jx100 · · Score: 1

      The name of the feature you're talking about is called "type ahead find"

      And it Moz 1.3b, that feature is expanded to include all the text on the page, not just the link ( actually, the default behavior is the same as before, but you can select the new behavior in the prefs)

  40. B&W by cioxx · · Score: 1

    whoa.

    No wonder I totally wrecked my island. I didn't take time to pay attention to such small details. The damn cow wouldn't grow, it kept whining all the time and demanding food. Then that Godzilla character came in, there was this bunny who struck the frikkin cow with lightning.. and all hell broke lose. I remember drowning couple of people, and after that a tornado sucked me in... at that point, I just gave up on it and uninstalled it.

    I didn't bother with Creature Isle Explansion, because I absolutely suck at that game.

    Maybe I should re-install it sometime and give it another shot. I spent well over $60 bucks on both B&W and CI expansion.

  41. not mouse gestures. by oliverthered · · Score: 2, Interesting

    mouse gestures are a bad idea, Mice are crap interface devices, ever tried drawing with a mouse, it''s like getting my brother to do the washing up.

    Now with a graphics tablet as a interface device, gestures are easy(accurate) and fast.

    --
    thank God the internet isn't a human right.
    1. Re:not mouse gestures. by Bnonn · · Score: 1

      Ever tried playing a first person shooter with a graphics tablet? Mouses are quite acceptable input devices, and in many ways operate far more effectively than any kind of tablet-based input device. If you want to draw, get a tablet, but don't slam mouses just because they're hopeless for doing something they were never designed to do.

    2. Re:not mouse gestures. by oliverthered · · Score: 1

      You get pucks with graphics tablets not just pens.

      --
      thank God the internet isn't a human right.
  42. Gesture by Whitez · · Score: 2, Interesting

    There's already a gesture recognition program for Win32. Gesture
    It's at an early stage at the moment, but shows potential.

  43. Repetitive stress? by astrashe · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I've never used gestures, so I don't know if this is true or not, but I think I remember reading somewhere that gestures tend to exacerbate repetitive stress problems.

    Is that true? Or is it just an urban legend?

    1. Re:Repetitive stress? by wadetemp · · Score: 1

      That's probably an urban legend... I don't see why it would be worse than any other mouse use. It's just as repetitive to move your mouse from a home position to the back button as it is to move your mouse from right to left on the webpage.

  44. As other replies to this post aptly demonstrate by kfg · · Score: 1

    This whole thing is clearly a practical demonstration to inveterate mouse users of the kind of crap you put touch typists through when we say things like," But I don't care if it *is* a billionth of a second faster to use the mouse. I don't *want* to take my fingers off home base."

    KFG

  45. Re:by the time... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    You sound like you're only considering what's good for the present. Sure, with current technology, typeahead seems more usefull. And today, I would certainly choose the keyboard over the mouse.

    But what about in the next 20 years? By then I hope we're using some combination of voice and hand gestures , or something even beter.

  46. Voil�... 2 mice! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    I actually do this. It is possible with X 4.
    Just edit /etc/X11/XF86Config-4 like this... ... here's the first snippet (put it where your mouse config already is):

    Section "InputDevice"
    Identifier "Mouse1"
    Driver "mouse"
    Option "Protocol" "IntelliMouse"
    # It's a wheel mouse
    Option "Device" "/dev/ttyS0"
    # serial
    Option "Resolution" "520"
    Option "ZAxisMapping" "4 5"
    # Needed for the wheel to work
    Option "SendCoreEvents"
    # Important! That makes this mouse a "main" one.
    EndSection

    Section "InputDevice"
    Identifier "Mouse2"
    Driver "mouse"
    Option "Protocol" "explorerps/2"
    # This is the config for a five-button mouse.
    # It was originally for a trackball, which
    # turned to be low-quality
    # (but it was way cheap).
    # I use it now with a normal 2-button+wheel
    # mini-mouse. It is left this way so that
    # I can go back to the trackball if I want...
    Option "Device" "/dev/psaux"
    # It's a PS/2 mouse but it should work ok
    # with a serial in /dev/ttyS1
    # Option "EmulateWheel" "On"
    # Option "EmulateWheelButton" "6"
    # Unneeded options
    Option "EmulateWheelInertia" "0"
    # Hmmm, forgot to try how this works.
    # Maybe I'll tweak it next...
    Option "ZAxisMapping" "4 5"
    # Ye olde wheel-translating config
    Option "HistorySize" "1000"
    # Can't remember what this does. Seems
    # to record the last mouse movements.
    Option "Resolution" "450"
    Option "SendDragEvents" "On"
    # Ooh. So many options, so little time.
    Option "SendCoreEvents"
    # This mouse is a "main" one, too.
    Option "Buttons" "7"
    # This makes the trackball work. It has
    # five buttons plus a wheel which
    # gives 2 more.
    EndSection ... and so it ends, the first snippet: ... now, the second snippet (at the end of the config file):

    # This is were you describe your system with the
    # components you gave previously in the
    # config file.

    Section "ServerLayout"
    Identifier "layout1"
    InputDevice "Keyboard1" "CoreKeyboard"
    InputDevice "Mouse2" "CorePointer"
    # Just one of them can be the "Corepointer"
    InputDevice "Mouse1"
    Screen "screen1"
    EndSection ... and this is the end of second snippet.

    Voilà! Two mice working at the same time! Someone with small hands here couldn't use the same mouse I do...

    Now, come to think, maybe I opened Pandora's box.

  47. probably get modded to oblivion for this, but... by Interfacer · · Score: 1

    "Probably the best way to avoid all these gestures getting confused with each other ("now let's see, was that for Opera? Mozilla? or the operating system?") is to develop some sort of gesturing standard that's generally agreed upon as intuitive that we all can remember and use."

    I'll probably be modded troll or flamebait for this, but how would you ever try to get a large group of linux users/programmers to agree on what is 'intuitive' or 'user friendly'? not to mention how it should be implemented (window or or level...)

    Int

  48. Actually... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I have an odd kind of mouse called ringmouse. It's a funny two-button infrared thing to be used in 3-D situations (a pity it's only 100dpi and must be dead by now... I haven't used it for some 5 years).

    But that would give gestures a new meaning. It would be like magic.

    Literally.

  49. People with disabilities by alofron · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I've come across software like that in the Windows platform for years, yet I failed to understand how it would improve my everyday interaction with my PC. Of course some people like it and lets face it : it is quite impressive, even 'trendy'. So people will play with it for a few hours and then pretty much forget about it (I know I have). A minority may even continue to use such a system on a regular basis but not me (or anybody I know of for that matter ...).

    Yet, for all its 'useless-ness', pointing device based gestures and similar technologies can be of importance for a particular sect of the 'computer users' population : People with disabilities. (check Google on that, and btw here are a couple of quick links http://knowltonian.net/NJIT/webaccessibility.html, http://www.cc.gatech.edu/fce/pendragon/publication s/programming-overview.html).

    I know that my post is on the verge of being moderated 'offtopic' or even 'flamebait' but the truth is that the FS/OSS community has not come up with any serious technologies to aid/help people with disabilities in their effort for satisfactory interaction with their computer. On the other hand, commercial entities/corporations (yes, like Microsoft but also Adobe, Sun etc.; in fact most of the big corps have dedicated research (or marketing ;) departments) are spending millions on that area. Sure, they're not doing it out of the goodness of their heart, they aim for profit. But they do offer a few solutions.

    And yes, I am aware of the accessability options provided by modern FS/OSS desktops. But do you think they are enough when compared to commercial solutions ?

    It is true that people with disabilities is a very small minority in the FS/OSS world (any statistics anyone ?) so it would not seem wise to 'waste' resources on the development of such software (mouse gestures, visual gesture recognition, voice recognition etc.) ... I wonder how many people would agree with that ...

    Why did I post this ?
    A few years ago I had an accident which resulted into several broken fingers. Ever tried to use a keyboard while most of your fingers are broken or cracked ? I tell you, it's a bitch.
    A friend of mine helped me by installing a Gestures kind of software and a trackball in my brand new Win95 (no 'booo' please) box. It didn't solve everything but it did seem to make my interaction easier. My 'torment' only lasted a month or so but since then I often wondered ... what if, just if, something happened and I would not be able to use my fingers anymore ? The Gestures-type-of-application (I just can't remember its name !) proved quite useful at that point. Not an adequate replacement of ones fingers but quite usefull nevertheless. Therefore, everytime I see similar software I feel a little more 'secure' and optimistic; it's silly I know ... Thats all.

  50. Why? by Masa · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I don't understand, why gestures are so popular. I tried Mozilla gestures once, but run into problems with them. At first, they seemed to be a great help, but eventually they just started to make my life difficult. For example, when I tried to paint a piece of text by dragging mouse from right to left, the gesture system decided that I wanted to go to the previous page. Well, that's just stupid. And if I remember correctly, it doesn't help to drag mouse from left to right while painting a section, because it assumes that I want to move forward a page. For me, this kind of a system just makes life harder.

    1. Re:Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why don't you just assign a different mouse button to do the gesturing?

    2. Re:Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's due to Mozilla's poor decision to default getsures to the left button. The problem is implementation, not concept. Reset it to the right button and give it another try.

    3. Re:Why? by rmohr02 · · Score: 1

      First of all, gestures do not come with Mozilla builds, and I have yet to see a link, so you can find Mozilla gestures at http://optimoz.mozdev.org/.

      Now, in reply to your comment, use your left mouse button or middle button--it's in the preferences that way. Or add a modifier key so that you have to hit Ctrl while moving the mouse. I personally use my middle mouse key for all sorts of tab functions (http://multizilla.mozdev.org/), autoscrolling (http://autoscroll.mozdev.org/) and for gestures, and have no problem with conflicts.

    4. Re:Why? by Masa · · Score: 1
      Ah, I wasn't aware of the fact that the mouse button was configurable. And now I have to be a bit more specific. I was actually using those gestures with Phoenix (I think that the package was designed for Mozilla, anyway) and at the time I was testing the gestures package, there was no way to change the configuration of any plug-in functionality.

      So, I admit my ignorance and apologize my inaccurate description of my past situation. My previous comment wasn't meant to be a troll. I was just trying to ask an innocent question about the true meaning and usefulness of the gestures.

  51. Gestures on cell phones/pDAs by jeorgen · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Maybe gestures could take off on cell phones and PDAs with their cramped space for input devices? Put in a gyro and just gesture away, no need for a keyboard. Would make it even harder though to distinguish between loonies (who walk around talking and gesturing to themselves) and ordinary cell phone users.

    /jeorgen

  52. Windows gestures... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    I've been gesturing at Windoze for years. The symbols are mostly undocumented because they are unsuitable for children.

  53. Ha! The ultimate comment! by Subjective · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Black & White had this

    Gesturing is hard

    You can do this with StrokeMe, libstroke, and XYZ (name software here)

    Ha! I've captured all the comments with only 3 lines!

    Seriously though, I think this is wayCool (ducks as piano flies over head, nearly hits. Or did it nearly miss?)
    I loves the black&white gestures (They should make it draw the gesture on the screen with you, a la Black&White)

    I've got nothing more to say to this.

    --
    My other .sig is also this bad
    1. Re:Ha! The ultimate comment! by IIRCAFAIKIANAL · · Score: 1
      ducks as piano flies over head, nearly hits. Or did it nearly miss?)


      If it nearly missed, it would have hit you.

      Christ, I hate that expression :)
      --
      Robots are everywhere, and they eat old people's medicine for fuel.
    2. Re:Ha! The ultimate comment! by krumms · · Score: 1

      what the hell?

  54. Sweet by Unregistered · · Score: 1

    I haven't had enough time to play with this, but it seems great. All i've done is map apps to letter gestures (P for Phoenix, etc,) But it can also send key commands. so C could be copy and V paste or so.

  55. Using FVWM right now... by Hubert_Shrump · · Score: 1

    Except for whatever reason, they call them 'strokes'... But I love that you get to program them yourself. It doesn't have to be hard to open a browser or whatever. Mine are all straight lines - I don't use that many different apps that I can't just call up a terminal and go from there...

    Shrink all your borders to 1 pixel, then it's just a SMOP and you've got your power user sooper desktop.

    I bind all the meta keys to window ops, so you can move windows around with a CTRL-click from anywhere. Heaven.

    --
    Keep your packets off my GNU/Girlfriend!
  56. BSOD by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Is there a gesture for BSOD?

  57. I once had the idea... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Of adapting a computer to understand handsign language, like the one used by deaf people.

    It would be easier than voice recognition, I thought at the time (circa 12 years ago).

    Recently, I learned that even handsign language is different from country to country.

    But we could have standard alternative configurations, like national keyboard layouts.

    I wonder what would be the effect of this on monkeys and other animals, since they're better equipped to deal with hand signs... would this boost their intelligence?

  58. Uh... by wadetemp · · Score: 1

    ... have you ever used a PDA? The entire interfaces are driven by pen-based gestures. They don't usually have keyboards, and those that need them for normal operation aren't PDA's anyway, they're mini-laptops with crappy keyboards.

    1. Re:Uh... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Your missing the "gyro" bit, move your hand (with the PDA in) not write on a screen/point & click on icons.

    2. Re:Uh... by wadetemp · · Score: 1

      Your missing the "gyro" bit, move your hand (with the PDA in) not write on a screen/point & click on icons.

      No I didn't. I just didn't think the gyro part was a good idea for PDAs, especially since he/she didn't list any specific application. For phones it might be OK... for example, you could hold a button on the side of the phone and shake it 5 times to dial your 5th autodial number automatically.

    3. Re:Uh... by jeorgen · · Score: 1
      have you ever used a PDA? The entire interfaces are driven by pen-based gestures

      ..what I mean is to the use the cell phone or PDA itself as the thing you're doing gestures with, in the air, hence the gyro. I am aware of the pen-based interfaces.

      Cheers /jeorgen

  59. Different actions for same gestures by tommut · · Score: 1

    I have a similar set of minimalist gestures. I like to keep them as simplistic as possible where I only have to move in one direction.
    I have left/right for back/forward, "Up" for New Tab, "Down" for Close Tab.

    I wanted the use of a few more commands, so I also hacked the mozgestOverlay.js to handle a second mouse button. (I put in this request to the mozgest authors, but in the meantime I had to modify the code myself.) So all of the previous commands are performed when holding the left mouse button. I set up the following identical commands to be performed when I press the MIDDLE mouse button:
    left/right for "Previous Tab/Next Tab" (I love that one!), "Up" for "Reload Tab", "Down" for "Add Bookmark".

    It's pretty cool. That way, I never have to make more than one movement to perform a gesture. Fast and easy. You could even modify the mozgestOverlay.js to recognize a third mouse button and add even more commands. But I only have a small subset of commands that I run, so this works for me.

  60. Draw an N in GIMP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    what happens when you draw an N or some other "gesture" shape in GIMP. Does wierd shit happen?

  61. Yeah... How About Useful Features Instead? by BigBlockMopar · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    I guess I thought this software always came with my distribution. I've been making a certain gesture at the Linux desktop for some time with no effect.

    Yeah.... thank you, thank you.

    How about some useful features instead? Integration between applications so that xine can play a video file from an Impress presentation, or any number of the other things Windows users take for granted that either don't work or aren't even under development for Linux.

    'Course, the important stuff is already taken care of. Linux applications crash more often that the Windows kernel, so we're good there. And with KDE's blistering speed, you'll approximate the lagged feeling of having a good Windows virus e-mailing all the doc files on your hard disk to everyone in your Outlook address book.

    --
    Fire and Meat. Yummy.
    1. Re:Yeah... How About Useful Features Instead? by Jellybob · · Score: 1

      This is where you enjoy the amazing'ness (yeah, I'm making up words) of OSS, and do something about it yourself if that's what you want.

      Or you could take the increasingly popular root shoving the developers a few bucks to do it for you if your not a programmer.

      Winging on /. isn't gonna get you anywhere though.

  62. That's fine and all.. by wadetemp · · Score: 1

    ... but mouse surfers can get all the same functionality that gestures usually provide for a browser with a right click menu or a context menu. Unless of course your mouse fingers are also holding a cup of coffee (which I have had be the case.) If you're doing that, though, you should seriously consider your mouse's safety... what if you were to spill coffee on it and it were damaged? Then you would be back to the old keyboard... the horrors!

    1. Re:That's fine and all.. by be-fan · · Score: 1

      How do I sart netscape with a right click menu in KOnqueror?

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
  63. Sensiva by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I've been using this for years in Windows... the application is called Sensiva, and can be found here: http://www.sensiva.com

    It's very usefull, I just draw a V to launch VB, or a W to launch Word, and so on :)

    ~Andrea

  64. Minimize mouse use by Simon+Lyngshede · · Score: 1

    If you like me is trying to minimize the use of the mouse, then this just seems like a dumb idea.

  65. Gestures = Tendinitis by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I attribute my tendinites to overusing gestures in Mozilla. If you have some pre-disposition (had it before) than I'd think twice about using gestures.

  66. Finally! by dimension6 · · Score: 1
    ...an opportunity to say "gesticulation" !!

    But really, I think that user interfaces should be as absolutely minimal as possible (for the reasonably advanced user). They should require as few keystrokes or mouse movements as can be, simply put. If a a gesture really does save time (and is accurate, mind you), then by all means it should be used.

  67. Wave of the future? Let's hope not. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ..Because it'll be more like wave of RSI.

    Gestures, in my opinion, suck. First, I'll deal with those who seem to think they should replace everything.

    Hello? Tell me, how is moving your mouse (or, as some have suggested with future technology, hand) in a floofy circle 'easier' and 'better' than, say, hitting ctrl-c? How can the keyboard, which often only requires two buttons to be pressed, be worse than the ridiculousness of moving the mouse in patterns?

    How much CPU time will be wasted on deciding when a gesture has been done, as opposed to a normal mouse movement?

    Sure, there's also those who suggest gestures could be useful to replace more complex patterns on the keyboard. Such as, opening a specific site or cutting and pasting. (So complex, four keys instead of two. ;)) Still, I believe it'd be simpler to use current technology - bookmarks, and yes, the infamous four keys.

    I'm not a doctor. I haven't played one on TV, either. However, I know plenty of people in the medical profession, and I can speak from hours of searching on Google. RSI due to the mouse is much more common than RSI due to the keyboard. I, myself, averted a case of RSI by ending my reliance on the mouse to get things done.

    The mouse, simply put, is a horrible, but necessary technology. Until we have touch-sensitive screens attached to every computer, we're most likely stuck with it. The more necessity we add to it, the more RSI we'll be seeing.

  68. Reminds me of Sensiva by Tommy+Boomfiger · · Score: 1

    I used a program called Sensiva (www.sensiva.com) for windows a while ago. it was great in windows 98 but i remember it caused problems in NT based systems so i stopped using it. but you could program it fairly easily for most applications. if you drew a symbol on the desktop it could launch an app. i loved using it in a browser because it could do all sorts of commands right in the browser window. great for full screen browsing with no taskbars.

    it looks like sensiva has stopped thier free application and is now selling a new version called Symbol Commander.

    ~Tommy Boomfiger

    --
    ~Tommy Boomfiger http://www.gotapex.com/forums
  69. Make the Gestures mappable by lommer · · Score: 1

    It shouldn't be that hard - I mean, your average shockwave game maps keyboard keys, so why cant software developers make mappable gestures? Just have a list of all the possible gestures and all the possible actions, then let the user associate them. That instantly kills all the bureaucratic overhead and ultimately makes all software more customizable for the end user. Seems like a no-brainer to me...

  70. am I the only one who hates Mozilla's gestures? by discogravy · · Score: 1
    I love Opera's gestures, but Moz's implementation is buggy as hell, and to get it to use the right mouse button you have to edit the js.prefs file (and that's never worked for me, either, I always get the mousewheel as the gestures button or I have to use both right and left buttons)...and that's just the Windows problems. Linux mozgestures are a headache because of privs...I always have to do a chmod to the whole directory to get the gestures to work, and even then, I have the same problem w/ WHICH mouse button.

    knock opera all you want, but their gestures work with no hassles beyond learning which gesture does what.

    1. Re:am I the only one who hates Mozilla's gestures? by matt_martin · · Score: 1

      Dunno, Mozilla crashed too badly after I installed it...

      --
      Lurking in the desert
  71. Gestures for any OS. by ikari-kun · · Score: 0

    Many have already seen this device, but I just got one of these keyboards, and the gesture system is amazing. It's USB and OS Independent.

  72. It has to be said by Obiwan+Kenobi · · Score: 1

    Ah, I wasn't aware of the fact that the mouse button was configurable. And now I have to be a bit more specific. I was actually using those gestures with Phoenix (I think that the package was designed for Mozilla, anyway) and at the time I was testing the gestures package, there was no way to change the configuration of any plug-in functionality.

    I hate to call this one, but you walked right into it:

    Let's note here you say "I was testing the gestures package" with a browser that isn't even up to version 1.0.

    If you truly want to see how gestures work and interact (and how they are F*cking awesome), try it with a post 1.0 version of Mozilla. Once you begin using them you'll never go back.

    1. Re:It has to be said by ssstraub · · Score: 1

      Posting from Phoenix 0.5 and been using mouse gestures since 0.3. They work fine. You just have to manually changes your user.js file for changing the mouse button, as is explained on mozilla zine forums and numerous other places, I'm sure.

  73. (kde on flux) Was:Oh puhleeze. by drini · · Score: 1

    Of course you can run KDE using other window managers (flux, metacity, icewm, etc)
    just setup the env variable KDEWM to fluxbox, login again and you're ready

    --
    Math is the weapon!!
  74. Re:by the time... by juhaz · · Score: 1

    Mouse _used_ to be obligatory for surfing, true, and for some small parts of it it still is, but type-ahead really did make that evil lot lesser.

  75. How Exactly? by LPetrazickis · · Score: 1

    Which smilie design allows one to draw it using just one curve?:)

    --
    Is this a sigs-optional kind of place? 'Cause I am totally down with that if you know what I mean.
  76. Last Post! by alpg · · Score: 0

    ... Any resemblance between the above views and those of my employer,
    my terminal, or the view out my window are purely coincidental. Any
    resemblance between the above and my own views is non-deterministic. The
    question of the existence of views in the absence of anyone to hold them
    is left as an exercise for the reader. The question of the existence of
    the reader is left as an exercise for the second god coefficient. (A
    discussion of non-orthogonal, non-integral polytheism is beyond the scope
    of this article.)

    - this post brought to you by the Automated Last Post Generator...