Slashdot Mirror


Build Your Own Weather Balloon

Leeji writes "Here is an interesting read about one geek's project to build and launch a weather balloon. The flight recorder is a small $200 Soekris Engineering computer running Bering Linux. It also uses a Garmin GPS, HAM packet radio, an automated Aiptek Pencam Trio digital camera, army surplus batteries, and lots of geek duct tape."

120 comments

  1. other options to a weather ballon by adamruck · · Score: -1, Troll

    or if you really wanted to know the weather, you just could just look outside, or even watch the weather channel..

    --
    Selling software wont make you money, selling a service will.
    1. Re:other options to a weather ballon by Stinson · · Score: 1

      well the weather channel partially gets their data from weather balloons, inaddition to satelites

    2. Re:other options to a weather ballon by larry+bagina · · Score: 0, Offtopic
      That doesn't get you on slashdot, though...

      2003-02-22 05:25:12 I can use linux and mozilla to check the weather! (articles,news) (rejected)

      --
      Do you even lift?

      These aren't the 'roids you're looking for.

    3. Re:other options to a weather ballon by adamruck · · Score: 3, Interesting

      no seriously... why would you want to undertake a project like this? I highly dought its for the weather aspect of the project. More likely, I think the builder created the whole project just as a large experiment(as he said several times in the article), and this sort of thing I can relate to and encourage.

      So lets think, if I was going to create a large complicated experiment, that involves fairly delacate equipment, would I want to have it floating nearly 80,000 feet in the sky? Thereby greatly increasing the chances of not getting the equipment back in one peice?

      Now if it was up to me, I would choose an experiment that wasn't so prone to breaking things(or landing things on the middle of a freeway). For example I would mod my car with some sterio/radio/computer equipment... or set up a large wireless network in my neighborhood... or something to that effect.

      Just becuase I made the first post doesn't mean that im a troll...

      --
      Selling software wont make you money, selling a service will.
    4. Re:other options to a weather ballon by JustAnOtherCodeSerf · · Score: 1

      "We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard, because that goal will serve to organize and measure the best of our energies and skills, because that challenge is one that we are willing to accept." -JFK

      Not to say that there isn't wisdom in questioning "do I really want to launch a couple hundred dollars worth of equipment into the air", but it alone shouldn't stop you.

      --
      -=sig=-
    5. Re:other options to a weather ballon by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That sounds like you're going to check out www.weather.com.

      "Hey guys check this out, Linux and Mozilla now support TCP/IP! WOO WOO!"

    6. Re:other options to a weather ballon by adamruck · · Score: 1

      good point.. but there is a differnce between JFK pushing a nation to go to the moon, and a single person dropping money and time into a project that has been done countless times before.

      --
      Selling software wont make you money, selling a service will.
    7. Re:other options to a weather ballon by JustAnOtherCodeSerf · · Score: 1

      Absolutely.
      I'm sure he learned a lot and had fun doing it though... even if he just learned not to launch $200 worth of equipment ;)

      Cheers
      Jim

      --
      -=sig=-
  2. FRIST by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    prost. suckaz.

  3. weather ballon? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    man get a life!

    PS - first post

  4. alert level: Orange by rnd() · · Score: 3, Funny

    This might not be the best idea during the Orange Alert.

    --

    Amazing magic tricks

    1. Re:alert level: Orange by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny
      This might not be the best idea during the Orange Alert.


      Yes, it would be better to wait until it is lowered to Banana.

    2. Re:alert level: Orange by MrEd · · Score: 0, Troll
      You're right. That there should be an Orange Alert is the laughable part.... Duck and cover, you sheep! Your draft-dodging, cokehead Enron president is leading you to war against evil! Ignore that sucking sound in your pockets!


      hee hee. why be anonymous when you can be cheeky?

      --

      Wah!

    3. Re:alert level: Orange by DriceX · · Score: 0, Troll

      Your right! American citizen should bend over and take it up the ass.

    4. Re:alert level: Orange by JustAnOtherCodeSerf · · Score: 3, Interesting

      You've just got to be kidding me.
      When sending up weather balloons, flying model airplanes/rockets, making robots or building home computers in your garage are cause for suspicion, then perhaps it's time to re-evaluate what a "free society" is. Hrm, maybe the Canadian winter is worth it... wait, Mexico's warm!

      Now shut up and hand over that those Lego Mindstorms!

      --
      -=sig=-
    5. Re:alert level: Orange by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Upon examination, that sucking sound turns out to be your wife. Damn, I ain't been Hoovered like that in a long time.

    6. Re:alert level: Orange by danish · · Score: 1
      This might not be the best idea during the Orange Alert.

      Yes, it would be better to wait until it is lowered to Banana.

      No, no, you've got it all wrong. You should wait until they lower the Terror Alert to Mauve, or at least Burgundy.

  5. I would have first post... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    If it weren't for that damn twenty second rule. Blah.

  6. And fake your own alien coverups! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Just like the US Military!

  7. dupe by Stinson · · Score: 5, Informative

    This is a dupe of the creators original post http://science.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=03/01/1 5/1829244&mode=thread just the website is on a different server (tho the original one exists)

    1. Re:dupe by lyle_hanson · · Score: 3, Insightful
      I'm not one to jump all over the editors for posting dupes; I can sympathize with the amount of stuff they probably wade through. But over the last couple weeks, my sympathy is waning.

      Could it be that hard to at least glance through each day's stories so you know when dupes come in? If you did, wouldn't a "build your own weather baloon" story stand out in your mind at all? If I'm missing something here, please point it out to me.

      On the side of reason, if you see a dupe, big deal. So don't read it the second time. It's like deleting spam; no reason to get worked up over it.... except sometimes it gets friggin' ridiculous.

      --
      :q!
    2. Re:dupe by dotgain · · Score: 0

      Sure it's a dupe, but that's not what I'm trolling about.
      IT'S NOT A FSCKING WEATHER BALOON!!! RTFA anyone? For what it's worth I thought he put a lot of work into it, and anybody interested in digital photography, embedded linux systems, or physics in general might find it quite interesting.
      Anybody wanting to know anything about the weather, however, would be bitterly disappointed. You can tell it was a little cloudy on the day he launched (read: two months ago).
      I agree dupe posts are only human, but in this case the blurb has nothing to do with the article.

    3. Re:Dupe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      that was REALLY, REALLY poor.. . I like it :) (BTW: for those that didn't catch it, sing along)

    4. Re:dupe by Ivo · · Score: 1

      A system where we could moderate postings would be nice. If more than x people (with moderator privileges) find a story to be a dupe, it could automatically be hidden.

      And I agree that auto dupe checking might also work.

  8. Dupe by topace · · Score: -1, Redundant

    This is a dupe from a month or so ago.

  9. Shouldn't this be called... by FosterKanig · · Score: -1, Redundant

    Build Your Own Fake UFO Sightings?

  10. Just do it by Branc0 · · Score: 3, Funny

    And don't forguet to drop one in roswell...

    --

    rm -rf /home/leia

    1. Re:Just do it by penguin_punk · · Score: 1

      fheeeww! When I saw '46 of 58 comments', I was hoping someone would crack a Roswell joke.

      Props to you.

      --
      HURD - Hurd's Under Research & Development
    2. Re:Just do it by Branc0 · · Score: 1

      glad i could help you out

      --

      rm -rf /home/leia

  11. One thing's for sure by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    Linux is on the rise.

    =)

    1. Re:One thing's for sure by martingunnarsson · · Score: 1

      Looks like it crashed though...so much for great uptime.

      --
      Martin
  12. Does it prevent you from leaving The Village? by RMH101 · · Score: 2, Funny

    I want one that can stop Number 6 escaping by air, road or water in a bad-special-effects kind of way

  13. Dupe by Syris · · Score: 1, Redundant
    Dupe, Dupe, Dupe... Dupe of URL

  14. repost by pizza_milkshake · · Score: 3, Funny

    this is a repost. which begs the question, is a first post on a dupe article really a first post?

    1. Re:repost by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Do you know what "begs the question" means?

      Your post begs the above question.

    2. Re:repost by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Using the GP as an example of just how moronic a human being can become, begs the question of whether abortion should be not be made illegal.

  15. Hey, Stinson! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Why don't you just change your nick to DupeNazi, huh?! That's what you are, you dupe nazi!!!!

    1. Re:Hey, Stinson! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      No dupe for you! NEXT!

  16. Dupe. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Redundant

    Interesting story, but it is essentially a dupe of this story. Still a really neat thing to do though.

    _
    Best Windows Cursors Ever!

  17. Pencam by Big+Mark · · Score: 4, Informative

    I have one and it eats power as if it were popcorn, as it keeps it's CCD in an "always on" state so it can respond instantly to requests for picture takage.

    One enhancement I would suggest would be to modify the camera in some way so that its power drain was less, even if only for the engineering challenge (he hooked it up to some great big huge massive LiIon cells that would keep a cyclotron going for a while)...

    -Mark

    1. Re:Pencam by GoRK · · Score: 1

      A little correction -- he hooked it to (non-rechargable) Lithium cells which completely kick the ass of LiIon rechargables.

    2. Re:Pencam by GroovBird · · Score: 1

      The Pencam uses a CMOS sensor, not a CCD. There's a big difference in quality as well as power consumption.

      Dave

  18. A month is a long time.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    for Taco et al.

  19. Oh great- by kevcol · · Score: 5, Funny

    The photo gallery of the launch has close ups of the launch director's butt crack! Warning, please! Blech!

  20. OT: Ham radio by mr100percent · · Score: 1

    Why do they call it HAM radio anyways?

    1. Re:OT: Ham radio by toxcspdrmn · · Score: 1

      It's a "contraction" of (h)amateur.

      --
      "E pur si muove!" - attributed to Galileo Galilei, 1564-1642
    2. Re:OT: Ham radio by Nogami_Saeko · · Score: 1

      Sounds like something our prime minister would say ;P

      N.

      --
      "Nothing strengthens authority so much as silence." - Charles de Gaulle
    3. Re:OT: Ham radio by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      Two versions:

      http://www.arrl.org/whyham.html
      http://members.aol.com/wd1j/wd1jpage2.htm

  21. It won't be long . . . by GMontag · · Score: -1, Troll

    With this progress it won't be long until the larger baloon clubs can launch something like this. "We choose to go to the weather baloon.

  22. Sure it is fun BUT! by Bender+Unit+22 · · Score: 3, Funny

    Correct me if I am wrong,
    I think it is just a bunch of hot air.

    1. Re:Sure it is fun BUT! by joshuac · · Score: 1

      Ok, your wrong. It's a bunch of helium :)

  23. The Point! by Amsterdam+Vallon · · Score: 0

    "The point isn't that it is running Linux, the point is that he made a really cool project that floated to 80,000 feet and took pictures, AND he got the whole thing back to retrieve the pictures. To me that is awfully impressive. The fact that it runs Linux was just one cool part of the project." -- chris AT massconnections DOT com

    --

    Reply or e-mail; don't vaguely moderate. Ex-O'Reilly/MIT employee, now a full-time Google employee.
    1. Re:The Point! by Leeji · · Score: 1

      The fact that it runs Linux was just one cool part of the project

      Exactly. That's why my summary also mentions the GPS, HAM Radio, Digital camera, surplus batteries, and Perl!

      --
      It all goes downhill from first post ...
  24. Let me get this straight by arvindn · · Score: 2, Funny
    If there was something around the house that needed to be fixed or wasn't right (at least in my mind), I couldn't think about anything else except solving that problem. My father would sometimes call this a "wild hair." I guess you could say that building and launching a weather balloon became a wild hair of mine...

    So one day the weather wasn't right, and this guy decided to build and launch a weather balloon to fix it?

  25. Quick! by dolo666 · · Score: 1

    Let's make some weather-balloons, crash them in the desert, send a bunch of military personnel wearing spacey looking nuclear suits to guard the weather-balloons, and then tell the world they are weather-balloons, not alien spacecraft and that UFOs do not exist!

  26. Just what we need by Hao+Wu · · Score: 0

    Who will we get mad at when it's wrong?! We need someone to blame, that's the whole point of a weatherman!

    --
    I suggest you read Slashdot
  27. SELECT =) FROM things_that_make_dumb_stuff_funny by MySQL+Troll · · Score: 0

    That one would've gotten groaned out of existence in real life. The interweb sure is a funny place! ;)

    --
    "Linux is for geeks, beos is for nobody, Mac OS is for actors, XP is for people" - Anonymous Coward
  28. Other amateur balloons by kennykb · · Score: 5, Informative

    The radio hams have been doing high-altitude ballooning for years. The original poster will probably be quite interested in the site that maintains the unofficial records. Perhaps the most active organization in the area is Edge of Space Sciences, which has conducted 63 amateur balloon flights to date, and knows well how to grease the skids with the FAA.

    1. Re:Other amateur balloons by rnd() · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Hams have also frequently used these balloons for lifting massive quantities of wire for 160M antenna farms.

      --

      Amazing magic tricks

  29. another thing's for sure... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    ...I'm so tired of these 'clever' puns and half-witted comments on linux and it's sub-culture from people who installed mandrake last week and have a degree in business managment.
    So, one thing is for sure this rant has helped me immensly, because it sure ain't stopping these sheep to keep posting 'we're beating M$ guys, yay!!' and 'does it run linux?' from some dolt who has never had....ahh fuck it -- i'm done

  30. Actually, by sawilson · · Score: 1, Interesting

    The weather channel gets their data from hourly
    observations taken by weather observers. Every hour
    on the hour, everywhere around the world, weather
    observers all go outside at roughly the same time
    and measure temp, dewpoint, wind direction and
    speed, cloud coverage, ceiling, etc. and put it
    into an "observation" that is sent to one of the
    weather hubs. Then big computers generate surface
    charts. Other big computers run analysis on that
    data and spit out forcast models. Those models are
    then sent out to people that want them. There are
    usually really lame errors like weather fronts
    being truncated or way off. The "forecaster" then
    modifies these projected models and incorporates
    then into his forecast, then sents his forecast
    for his area back out to the big computers. The
    weather channel then pays to steal that forecast
    information from the big computer, and put it on
    their screen doing little to no actual work in
    the process. They also buy their pretty satellite
    images from someone like kavouris probably.
    Weather balloons, along with PIREPS or "Pilot
    Reports" fill in some of the blanks in the upper
    atmosphere and over the oceans, but I'd hazard
    to guess that doppler radar technology that allows
    you to know wind direction and speed at a great
    distance away and great altitude is slowly filling
    at least part of that.

    1. Re:Actually, by rusty0101 · · Score: 1

      The primary reason that weather baloons are used is not to collect the high altitude information, it is to collect information about the weather at all altitudes that it passes through.

      Dopler radar tends to work best when there is liquid water in the air, as it uses the reflection from those droplets to determine whether the air is moving that water toward or away from the receiver. It works across a cone, and can not tell if the signal it is receiving is coming from water in the air 100 feet above you, or 10,000 feet above someone closer to the antena than you are, or 5,000 feet up on a line perpendicular to the line between you and the antena a bit closer to you. than the 10,000 foot reading.

      NexGen radar is a bit better about positioning, but even it needs liquid water to reflect off of, so cold dry air is harder to measure than warm moist air.

      I suspect that weather baloons will continue to be part of the weather monitoring system for several more decades.

      -Rusty

      --
      You never know...
  31. even better idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://www.weather.com/

  32. FIRST First Post DUPE! by j0nkatz · · Score: -1

    or if you really wanted to know the weather, you just could just look outside, or even watch the weather channel..
    --pardon the bad spelling--

    --
    Don't mod me, bro'!!!!
  33. old by boulat · · Score: 0

    this is god damn old.

  34. This is news? by bplipschitz · · Score: 2, Informative

    Ham radio geeks have been launching baloons [and rockets] with smart payloads for years. Launching is the easy part. Tracking it down and recovering it is the hard part.

  35. Existentialism by Zenjive · · Score: 1

    if a dupe falls in the forest and nobody is there to first post it, was it really a fish in the first place?

    --


    A vacuum is a hell of a lot better than some of the stuff that nature replaces it with. - Tennessee Williams
  36. Nothing has changed... by ringbarer · · Score: -1

    From the archives...

    Visitors to the website slashdot.org will by now have surely heard of the act of Moderation. This is where a contributor's post can be 'Moderated' either positively or negatively, depending on how the Moderator perceives the value of the post. There is a sliding scale of total moderation points, from -1 to 5, along with snappy summaries of the reason for moderation, such as "Funny", "Insightful", or the ever popular "Troll". An additional benefit offered to Moderators is the ability to ban a poster from contributing, by negatively moderating enough of his postings in a 24 hour period.

    In order to retain some level of fairness for the Slashdot population, the Slashdot Editors (adopting the role of 'Benevolent Dictators') have implemented a scheme whereby regular users of Slashdot, chosen essentially at random, are given the ability to act as Moderators.

    This underlines an inherent flaw in the system. Psychological studies have shown that in any community, no matter how small, should a random sampling of people be given the slightest grasp of power, they will immediately abuse it. There is a primal, evolutionary desire in Man to place himself higher than his peers by whatever measurement they can muster. Slashdot Moderation provides the ideal means for which a man can prove himself more equal than others.

    At the risk of invoking Godwin's Law at such an early point in my thesis, I have no choice but to compare Slashdot Moderation to the systematic genocide of the Jewish community in 1930's Germany.

    A bold statement, I admit, and deliberately designed to shock, but I feel the statement is necessary. I shall now offer a more rational explanation, as well as a comparison of the parallels between Slashdot Culture, and the National Socialist regime.

    First, some history. National Socialism did not spring up overnight. It grew from a feeling of national bitterness and resentment at the war reparations Germany was forced to make after World War One. Germany was a broken country, populated by desperate starving people. And to the desperate, an extreme ideology begins to seem like a rational choice.

    The advent of new technology forces a paradigm shift in the way the beholders of that technology think. The Christianity Meme was made wide spread by the invention of the Gutenberg press. And the rise of National Socialism was made popular because of the invention of Cinema. Here we had a new means to control the flow of information to the populace, that they are willing to unquestioningly listen to due to the 'novelty factor' of moving pictures. It is no coincidence that some of the best Cinematography of the early 20th Century came out of the National Socialist propaganda machine.

    Why is this the case? It is yet another fault of man that a new means of distributing memes is perceived, due to the 'newness' of the medium, to have a greater 'validity' than older media. Those harnessing new inventions have the power to win control of the hearts and minds of others.

    With the tools in place, who should the National Socialists target? Clearly, as a counterpoint to Man's desire to hold power over others, there is also a desire to resent the success of others. If someone is successful, they reduce the self-worth of their beholders. Although times were harsh in Germany in the prelude to World War II, there were still successful inhabitants of that country. Possessing shrewd business acumen as well as the contacts in other countries needed to maintain support in such a poverty stricken and broken land, who else should deserve the wrath of the populace more than the Jews?

    Fast-forward to the latter quarter of the 20th Century. Computing technology is focused in niche markets, and limited to big successful companies like IBM and Microsoft. As the markets were limited, there were also limited opportunities for employment. This gave rise to a rising number of college dropouts, seething with resentment and unable to relate to society beyond the staccato clatter of keyboards and the pallid green glow of an 80x24 text display, and lacking the basic business skills (and a smart suit) needed to secure employment at one of these companies.

    At this time, a new invention was beginning to take hold in College campuses throughout the world. The Internet. As with the Gutenberg press and Cinema beforehand, this new technology would grow to spread one of the most virulent memes of the modern age - Open Source Software, created as the antithesis of successful business practise.

    So, the parallels between the birth of Anti-Semetic National Socialism and the birth of Open Source Software have been made. Of course, it is easy to claim that A=B without providing further logical evidence in support. So, the next task of my thesis is to provide further parallels, and bring this discourse back to the initial focus on Slashdot Moderation.

    Slashdot was conceived, in it's original 'Chips 'n' Dips' incarnation, as a vehemently anti-corporate Open Source website. Roughly 10-15 years down the line from the birth of Open Source, it has become saturated with propaganda, and now forms the centrepiece of the Open Source Development Network. An authority in it's field, Slashdot's success is in no small part due to the ability of the editors to 'pick and choose' valid news articles submitted by users, and present the same old tired "Open Source Good / Closed Source Bad" rhetoric time and time again, dabbling with anti-copyright and the right of the 'common man' to remove an artist's ability to gain compensation for the work. In essence, this is similar to the 'paring down' of artistic worth in 1930's Germany. If no-one is willing to contribute valid and vibrant art to the community, then all art shall become harsh and functional, possessing a certain intimidating aesthetic.

    Which leads onto Open Source's shining achievement - Linux. This diatribe is not aimed towards Linux in particular, as it is a well-oiled, well-tuned machine. A technically adept Operating System, it is worthy of admiration by any rational man. The point of this thesis is not to attack the art produced by Open Source coders, which in itself is worthy, but to enlighten all as to the political processes behind the OSS movement.

    By the same scale, it is hard to fault Mercedes for the technical excellence of the vehicles which were used by the National Socialist party. But the politics behind the party are what taint the image of Mercedes' vehicles of the era. The Swastika itself is a benign symbol, found this day in such diverse locations as Pokemon cards, but is permanently tainted with the history of the acts made under its auspice. In the same way, companies switching to Open Source solutions will begin to regard the Penguin with the same trepidation as their profits fall.

    It should be worth noting at this point that IBM, previously one of the world's greatest companies, has begun reporting servere financial losses, no doubt due to its adoption of Open Source practises. This epoch-making event was NOT reported on Slashdot, even though articles were submitted.

    And what of the other great company mentioned above? Microsoft, aka Micro$oft, Mickeysoft, Microshaft, Kro$oft, and many other derogatory and undeserved names. Throughout the previous 25 years, Microsoft has grown from strength to strength, again possessing shrewd business acumen as well as providing products that people want. This makes them the number one target for the OSS movement. Incapable of standing by their own merits, the OSS zealot would rather attack Microsoft as a priority than produce anything of worth for their community.

    Slashdot Moderators, crazed with their limited new-found power, exhibit this behavior. It is a sad state of affairs that the majority of article moderations are negative. Where is the positive feedback and sense of social contribution? Nowhere to be found. Moderators are too focused on putting their peers down to make themselves appear superior, rather than doing the hard work and becoming better on their own terms.

    As the National Socialists required a scapegoat, Slashdot Moderators require a constant stream of Postings to label '-1, Inferior'. Once a posting is reduced to the score of -1, it becomes invisible to the casual user. Again, this is a parallel to the Ghettoization of Germany upon the election of Hitler.

    In essence this would not be so bad, were postings to be evaluated on their own terms. However, alongside the moderation of their postings, each user has a 'Karma' value, namely the sum of their worth to the Slashdot community. As a user's posts are moderated up or down, so their Karma fluctuates. As Karma becomes negative, a user's default posting score is reduced, until they are posting at a default of -1. Again, ghettoizing PEOPLE, not just their opinions.

    This ghettoization is reinforced with the often fake belief that a negatively moderated post, and therefore the poster, is a "Troll". (Is it any wonder that such a name has been chosen to describe these people, invoking mental imagery of facial disfigurement and hooked noses?) As the Jews were accused of fraud, dishonesty and being subhuman animals, so too are Trolls accused of FUD, Crapflooding, and obfuscated goatse.cx links. Quite often, these 'undesirables' are capable of providing a valid insightful comment on a topic, but because it is in opposition to the Political dogma of Slashdot they are moderated back into their ghetto. The person becomes moderated, not their opinion.

    This is just the thin end of the wedge. Although, as memes are transient, it is difficult to silence an opinion, it is trivial to silence a person. Upon the rise of National Socialism in Germany, the populace were motivated by propaganda into entering the Jewish Ghettos en masse with the sole purpose of causing as much damage as possible to Jewish businesses and residences. The infamous Krystalnacht. This parallels far too accurately with the Slashdot Editor's non-discouragement of the act of IP-banning. As mentioned above, this occurs when an individual user's postings are repeatedly moderated down in a short period. They then become incapable of posting any contributions themselves. In essence, they have been silenced, regardless of the worth of their postings.

    Of course, the editors claim that Meta-Moderation is the panacea to solve this clear abuse of moderating privledge. But if a Meta Moderator is presented with a list of moderations that they disagree with, such as this targetted 'silencing' mentioned above, they cannot note them as such without in turn becoming an 'Undesirable' themselves, as too many Disagreements with the Moderation groupthink also result in loss of Karma.

    Throughout all of this, the Editors have claimed a false level of detachment from the acts of moderation. In a same way, as the National Socialists gathered their power and began working on their Elite Political wing, The SS, they too remained detached from the civilians working in their name. Why? Because after inspiring the populace to such acts of violence through their propaganda, they could then claim that they were only giving the people what they want.

    And then began the next stage of the atrocities. The Gestapo, Germany's secret police, were recruited from the best and the brightest of Germany's elite. As is the case now, the best and the brightest of society were often shunned and ostracized in society. In essence, the Gestapo were a tightly controlled 'Geek Army' of intelligent young men with a burning, seething resentment of normal society. The perfect psychological profile for the cause.

    After all, give a normal man (with an active sex life) a gun and he will use it responsibly in self defence. Give a geek a gun and he will behave according to his sociopathic logic and hatred of the world he arrogantly presumes to be distant from. Ask yourself why Slashdot flat-out justified the murder of innocents at Columbine. And then ask yourself why, even for a brief moment, you almost began to sympathize with the killers after Jon Katz' manipulative and pseudo-emotive Hellmouth articles.

    How this relates to Slashdot is clear. The majority of Slashdot posters are Sociopathic OSS zealots, unable through lack of social finesse or personal hygiene to mate regularly. Sexually and emotionally frustrated and with grudges to bear, incapable in their blinkered sense of self-righteousness of accepting any dissenting opinion than the OSS cause. Now give these people the opportunity to Moderate these dissenting opinions. Of course they are going to want to silence them, by any means necessary.

    Now, the Slashdot Editors have admitted taking this silence of opinion into the next stage, by moderating whole swathes of 'undesirable' posts negatively. And then permanently banning anyone who moderates said posts back up from moderating EVER again! The result of this new policy? The few Moderators with any sense of fairness and decency are removed from the moderation pool, leaving the power ENTIRELY in the hands of the zealots. Clearly, positive moderation is discouraged under this regime, which is a direct parallel with the way the National Socialists moved their own sympathisers into positions of power throughout Europe.

    So how does this compare to the genocide performed in Auschwitz and their ilk? I would like at this point to explain that in NO way do I wish to belittle the horrors that were performed in the name of National Socialism. The six million innocents killed were a cry of anguish from which humanity may never recover. And a vast distance in time and scope from a few banned posters on some shitty "My Favourite Links - now with comments" website. But these stories need to be retold before the horror is lost forever.

    For the only thing that we learn from history is that we never learn anything from history. Time and time again, the St. Vitus dance is played out, we make the same mistakes, and we perpetually fail to see the warning signs.

    So, moderators, the next time you moderate a rational, insightful post down, maybe because you disagree with it or because it's posted by a 'Known Troll', just ask yourself this...

    "Am I really contributing to the Slashdot Community, or selfishly destroying it?"
    --
    "Why did they cancel my favorite Sci-Fi show? I downloaded ALL the episodes!"
    1. Re:Nothing has changed... by adamruck · · Score: 1

      I took the time to read the whole thing.. and I must say it was very good, maybe a little extreme, but very good peice of reading.

      --
      Selling software wont make you money, selling a service will.
  37. Cool by md81544 · · Score: 1
    Well, go ahead and make wisecracks... but I think this is cool. He's given me several ideas already. That small PC & his modified distro could make a rather cool in-car computer... play OGGs, read position from the GPS, whatever.

  38. What do you get when you... by chaeron · · Score: 2, Interesting
    ...combine a Radio Shack R/C Truck, onboard embedded java processor, GPS, wireless, XML, SOAP, Linux, J2EE, open source and a bunch of other stuff?

    The Mobile GPS Demonstration Platform project, which has even more geek coolosity than weather balloons. ;-)

    --
    .....Andrzej

    Chaeron Corporation
  39. Double post... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You'd think people that actually WORK for a website would know more than the people that read it. Michael is a fucking idiot though, so.

  40. Hmmm by PyroX_Pro · · Score: 3, Funny



    I hope this thing comes down close to my backyard, or maybe I could shoot it down. Thats some free hardware!

    Oh wait, gps, so he would know where it was when it disappeared...

    Seriously though, sounds like a pretty expensive wad of cash to just throw into the wind.

    1. Re:Hmmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      yea, and convetional weather ballons are UBER expensive in comparison

    2. Re:Hmmm by odyrithm · · Score: 1

      Unemployment was also a major factor. After being out of work for more than two months

      What the fuck do they pay the unemployed in America? in the UK you get £40 a week... no where near enough to pay for the amount of gear he got.. especially as allot of it he never used.. crazy.

      he may have a rich mommy and daddy though.

      --
      moo
    3. Re:Hmmm by boulat · · Score: 0

      playing around with his GPS geektool and you can send him a boogey and redirect it to, say, 200 miles away :p

    4. Re:Hmmm by dotgain · · Score: 0

      Unemployed != collecting an unemployment benefit (or whatever your ringleader calls it)
      Look at his CV, he's had jobs before and it looks like they might have paid him a few quid. Either that, or he's collecting more than one unemployment benefit, which would also make it possible.
      Crazy? Looked like fun to me. Lots of it. In fact if it came down to either watching a game of American Football, or spending $2000 or so putting a thing like that together and spending the day with a bunch of geeks chasing it in a car all night...

    5. Re:Hmmm by odyrithm · · Score: 1

      u fucking moron, read what I said.

      --
      moo
    6. Re:Hmmm by dotgain · · Score: 0

      u fucking moron, read what I said.
      Okay, for your own benefit I'll copy-and-paste what you typed.
      What the fuck do they pay the unemployed in America? in the UK you get £40 a week... no where near enough to pay for the amount of gear he got.. especially as allot of it he never used.. crazy. And then go on to suggest he's probably got a rich mommy and daddy...? Why make such a stupit statement if you're going to contradict it next sentence? That, "u fucking moron" is what you "said". Doesn't your paragraph show you've inferred he's collecting welfare and sending it to 80,000ft in a baloon?

    7. Re:Hmmm by odyrithm · · Score: 1

      OK, fuck muppet, for your benefit..

      I was aiming my thoughts towards the fact that if hes unemployed then why waste time building a weather baloon? surely theres more contructive things to be doing like finding a fucking job? instead of bitching about it and thinking "oh Ill build myself a weather baloon cause Im so fucking bored not having a job".

      My "crazy" statment was ment towards the wast of money on stuff he never even used (thats for the first muppet that replyed), nothing todo with the "cool" factor. I actualy to find it very interesting/cool.

      anyway, in the words of many before me, STFU if you have nothing more constructive to do than deconstruct my posts.

      --
      moo
    8. Re:Hmmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      rtfa, dickhead. He was bored of searching endlessly for jobs and had decided to apply himself in other ways.

      Unemployed != poor. Some people actually manage to save money. Do you understnad that concept? Like planning ahead for the future? Like not being a dickhead?

      Back to bed with you now. Go on... Shoo.

    9. Re:Hmmm by odyrithm · · Score: 1

      Shoo? hrmmm I know you ;)

      --
      moo
    10. Re:Hmmm by dotgain · · Score: 0

      I was aiming my thoughts towards the fact that if hes unemployed then why waste time building a weather baloon? surely theres more contructive things to be doing like finding a fucking job? instead of bitching about it and thinking...
      I read his site a month or so ago when it was first posted. At no stage do I remember him "bitching" about unemployment, merely explaining that because of it, he didn't have enless reserves of cash to throw at his project. Read the article? I guess not, otherwise you'd know it ain't a fscking weather baloon. Waste of time? He's carried out this experiment so throuroughly and ingenously, and at the end of the day, successfully. On the merits of this project he might well get a job.
      ...I actualy to find it very interesting/cool.
      Not only do you think it's a waste of time, it's also "interesting/cool". Uh huh.
      anyway, in the words of many before me, STFU if you have nothing more constructive to do than deconstruct my posts.
      You can say that (and maybe one day even use your own words) when you actually do construct you posts from something vaguely factual/insightful. I deconstruct your post because it i) is hogwash ii) arises out of envy (I think it's cool but since some jobless bum possibly with rich parents did it and he's got a chick it's a waste of time), not true criticism iii) is there for me to see, and comment on.

    11. Re:Hmmm by odyrithm · · Score: 1

      peace and love man. we all assholes at the end of the day.

      --
      moo
  41. hope he doesn't catch hell for it by joFFeman · · Score: 1

    what with the US government being suspicious of anything metallic (much less airborne) which beeps, whirs, clicks, or buzzes. unless, of course, they made/bought it, in which case, it's forced upon us for our own safety, regardless of our own opinions about big brother ramming GPS in every citizens ass.

    --
    "Life is great; without it, you'd be dead." -Harmony Korine
    1. Re:hope he doesn't catch hell for it by n1ywb · · Score: 1

      Actually there's a standard procedure for notifying the FAA of a weather balloon release. In fact the author talks about it. Next time read the article, or at least skim over it.

      --
      -73, de n1ywb
      www.n1ywb.com
    2. Re:hope he doesn't catch hell for it by joFFeman · · Score: 1

      i'm sorry, i didn't realize the US government had suddenly become a collection of fairly functional agencies working in conjunction with one another. the last time i checked, a vast majority of government agencies were poorly managed, ineffectient, and competitive/uncooperative with other agencies. i guess i should pay more attention to the wonderful advances in government since this new administration took office.

      --
      "Life is great; without it, you'd be dead." -Harmony Korine
  42. Almost... by sawilson · · Score: 2, Informative

    Actually, :)

    Doppler weather radar works for wind speed and
    direction pretty much always because there is
    always enough reflective material in the air no
    matter how much water vapor is present. It works
    across a "volume coverage pattern" that is made up
    of many "cones" made through repeated 360 degree
    scans at varying angles. This is how you can nail
    with extreme accuracy what distance and height
    air is moving at what speed and direction.
    Granted, I'm basing this on real world experience
    as a certified Unit Control Position administrator
    on the WSR-88D NexRAD doppler weather radar for
    3 years. :) I'm considering this radar as it's the
    one that is in place at most official reporting
    stations. The military loves the thing.
    You were close though.

  43. Orange Alert! Orange Alert! by dexter+riley · · Score: 2, Funny

    No, Orange Alert is the best time to send up a weather balloon.

    P.S. If I hear that George W. has hired a mute midget butler, I'm moving to Canada.

  44. Building a balloon is easy... by lightspawn · · Score: 1

    but can you build your own internet bubble?

  45. +1 Funny by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    no text

  46. Amateur (radio) balloon tracking by n1ywb · · Score: 4, Informative

    Amateur ballooning can be quite a bit of fun. There is a small but active ballooning sub-hobby within the ham radio hobby. Ham radio is an ideal medium for transmitting telemetry from balloons, since we have access to cheap high quality (and high power) equipment.

    I participated in a balloon tracking experiment not too long ago. The students of Timberlane Regional High School of Plaistow NH launched several high-altitude balloons carrying APRS transmitters, as a part of their CAPSAT (Coordinated Algebra (II) & Physics Simulated Satellite) project. I was able to track two of them. The balloons carried GPS receivers and ham radio Automatic Position Reporting System transmitters.

    The launch was from Hopkinton NH. The first launch went well, and we received good signals from the balloon all the way out into the Atlantic ocean. This was quite a bit farther than they expected the baloon to travel, they had planned on recovering and reusing it :o It was still cool IMHO. Check out this kick ass map of the balloon's track.

    The second launch was also a success, and the baloon only traveled about 50 miles before touchdown. Map is here.

    The third launch went up with the GPS receiver turned off :/ At last check, it was at 00.000N 000.00W. They didn't launch any more balloons that day.

    My tracking station consisted of a Kenwood TH-D7 radio and a PowerMac 7500 604e-180 running XASTIR on Yellow Dog Linux. The full results of the day (and APRS logs for the entire hamfest) are here.

    --
    -73, de n1ywb
    www.n1ywb.com
    1. Re:Amateur (radio) balloon tracking by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Check out this kick ass map of the balloon's track.

      And how did Boston feel about you traversing their class B airspace? (jk, I did note the altitude ;-)

    2. Re:Amateur (radio) balloon tracking by n1ywb · · Score: 1
      And how did Boston feel about you traversing their class B airspace?

      Well I wasn't launching the balloons, and I had no affiliation with the school that was doing the launch. I just heard that it would be happening and figured it would be fun to test my APRS setup in the field :) But I understand that they did notify the FAA and such... They certainly hadn't expected the balloon to go so far; they had recieved a grant for the electronics and had been planning to repeat the program every year. If you root through the log, you'll find this line:
      KA1GJU>APRS,N1RCA-11:WA1KAT :SRY OM looks like a H2O landing...{1
      Thats "Sorry, old man, looks like a water landing..." for you non-hams ;) I think that pretty much sums it up.

      Now what they SHOULD have done was to implement a "cut" signal, like the guy in this article did, to abort the flight. That would have saved the day.
      --
      -73, de n1ywb
      www.n1ywb.com
  47. There are two types of dupes... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Current event dupes, and anytime dupes. The first, where an article is posted twice within a few hours is pretty inexcusable. All that takes is look at the site. But, if you're talking about a month or six months or even a year, yeah, it happens. We're humans and don't have perfect memories even if we did see every story on the site.

    1. Re:There are two types of dupes... by DrInequality · · Score: 1
      Surely the slashcode should include some dupe checking?

      Doesn't seem hard to do at least a little correlation and show editors the top few matches. Would catch 90% of the dupes for 10% of the effort :-)

  48. Will my score be redendant? by SourceHammer · · Score: 0, Redundant


    Will my score show ''Redundant'' if I say that this is a DUPE.

    --



    Open source development is my way of competing with the low-cost programmers in India...
    1. Re:Will my score be redendant? by odyrithm · · Score: 1

      soon, very soon. Mods love to mod down.. wouldnt make sense to mod up the good posts would it now? duh what am I thinkin!

      --
      moo
  49. Dejavu? by wakeboard · · Score: 1

    I liked this story a lot, even more the second time I read it =]

  50. Quite an interesting article.. by WegianWarrior · · Score: 1

    ...well written, quick to load, and it gave me several ideas (that I probaly won't act out on).

    However, it seems like the gear he used should be lightweight and robust enought to pack into a rocket - espesially if you take off the strobe and beeper. Maybe upgrade the radiotransmitter (and check the reciver before launch), and send it into orbit?

    Just an idea... but what you think? That would make an interesting article on /. - "privatly launched satelite runs Linux"

    --
    Everything in the world is controlled by a small, evil group to which, unfortunately, no one you know belongs.
  51. In defense of dupes by Leeji · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I've never really understood how so many dupes show up on Slashdot. Until now.

    I stumbled on this site when I was trying to figure out how many solder points would go into a home-made modem for a bbs. I thought it was cool, and didn't recognize it as a dupe even though I read /. The page-views were in the low hundreds, so I felt safe that it hadn't seen much traffic. So I submitted it.

    Feel free to troll in response to this, because I won't reply to them anyways. But for those with an open mind, you might like to know one way a dupe can legitimately happen.

    --
    It all goes downhill from first post ...
    1. Re:In defense of dupes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's probably often the case, and I doubt that anyone cares about the submitters. It's not the reader's/submitter's responsiblity to check the site for duplicates, it's the editor's. I personally don't care about dupes except that it's a fun way to get free karma by pointing out past articles and new and exciting ways to say "DUPE! U R TEH SUX0R3." Nobody blames the messenger, just the messenger's mouthpiece. Or Michael. Everyone likes to blame Michael.

  52. Geeks in space by bobdotorg · · Score: 1

    More importantly, does he have plans to make a few of them and strap them (and himself) to a lawnchair? (seriously - google "lawnchair pilot")

    --
    __ Someday, but not this morning, I'll finally learn to use the preview button.
  53. repost by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is a fcuking repost you idiot

  54. ahem.. by Noodlenose · · Score: 1
    Sorry for trolling, but why did this chap had to launch the thing over one of the densest populated areas in the US?

    What happens if the thing comes down on a street, a house, or a human??

    1. Re:ahem.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If it comes down on a human, then WHAMMO! Instant borg, resistance is futile. Talk about viral licensing.

    2. Re:ahem.. by tmjva · · Score: 1

      Rover will obviously take you to The Village where you will become A Prisoner and get interrogated by Number 2!

      I will not be pushed, filed, indexed, briefed, debriefed, or numbered! (My life is my own.)

      --
      Tracy Johnson
      Old fashioned text games hosted below:
      http://empire.openmpe.com/
      BT
  55. Isn't this by ripetersen · · Score: 1

    a dupe

  56. When it crashes... by MoonRabbit · · Score: 1

    will the government come and confiscate the wreckage and bodies, then tell the public that it was just a ... oh crap.

  57. Do or die! by SlashdotTroll · · Score: -1

    [If you tell anyone you saw our balloon flying over the Walmart, we will castrate each of your relatives] and suspend your driving "privilege" as well as ...

    -U.S. Department of Helium and Aluminum Foil

    --

    I am the nightmare of nightmares.

  58. Obviously faked... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    This site is a hoax! I mean really, an unemployed slashdot reader who can spend $1000 on a computer to send up in a balloon? And his girlfriend lets him?
    Girlfriend? yeah, right.

  59. Someone send one to Area51 by cheekyboy · · Score: 0

    and transmit the live photos back.

    --
    Liberty freedom are no1, not dicks in suits.
  60. why not get it to stop at 33000ft by cheekyboy · · Score: 0

    at a common air plane 'highway' route in the sky

    --
    Liberty freedom are no1, not dicks in suits.
  61. 500gram computer, 1000gram anthrax ..... by cheekyboy · · Score: 0

    destination a sports field or the white house, and a relay to relase the payload and you could have a mighty weapon if you made 100 of em.

    --
    Liberty freedom are no1, not dicks in suits.
  62. Short Memory by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What short memories we have!

    This was originally posted 15 Jan 2003:

    http://science.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=03/01 /1 5/1829244&mode=thread

  63. cell phone? by krokodil · · Score: 1

    I was wondering - wouldn't it be possible
    to use cell phone for communications? Perhaps
    with some antennae booster. Will simplify some design. If you take smart phone, like Handpsring Treo, it could be flight computer as well.

  64. Waiting for Baloon 2.0 by anticypher · · Score: 3, Insightful

    So this geek pulled this off with a minimum of thought. I admire the fact he did it, and was able to recover the baloon. But really, if he had put a little more thought into this, he'd probably have a much better geek experiment. That's why its version 1.0

    The first time he ever tried assembling the whole thing was sitting in a park the morning of the launch. He had never weighed the whole thing until then, and then just randomly filled the balloon until it "seemed right", but that only got him about 60% of the lift he wanted.

    Aligator clips on batteries. Ugh. Plus a quick run home to solder up a permanent connection while his friends hung around the park. Some staging for the week before the flight would have eliminated lots of these little problems.

    He didn't check his ham frequency to see if others were using it, and his QRM walked all over other amateurs in the area, and their chatter kept his unit from receiving commands. Bad ham, no cookie!

    Obscure perl bugs. Wouldn't be a geek experiment without them.

    Bubble wrap for electrical insulation. ZZZZzzzzaaaaapppp!!

    Here's to hoping Balloon 2.0 makes it into slashback soon (or just another dupe from CT). With more hacked up sensors, better photos, and a flight track out past Kansas :-)

    the AC

    --
    Hemos is like...sci-fi fans;he thinks technology is cool, but he hasn't bothered to understand the science it's based on
  65. Maybe this was just a prototype for something evil by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Maybe it's not about the weather. He's already used it as a repeater station for ham radio. I'm just imagining a fleet of small disposable ones of these floating over a city to leech of 802.11 access.

    He must be stopped, but what can match the power of a linux weather balloon? Only a linux powered koolfruit cannon!

    Fear the Bane of O'donoghue
    http://robots.net/robomenu/999305224.h tml

  66. Soekris Engr'g ranking of OSS BSD's & Linux: by ivi · · Score: 1

    On this page:

    http://www.soekris.com/products.htm

    something like this (emphasis mine, &
    I've removed "available" a few times):

    FreeBSD most -powerful- x86 open source Unix
    OpenBSD most -secure- open source Unix
    NetBSD most -portable- open source Unix
    Linux most -popular- open source Unix

    Does anybody have a different idea on this? ;-)

    &, on non-x86 hardware, what's the most powerful UNIX?

  67. Last Post! by alpg · · Score: 0

    Joshu: What is the true Way?
    Nansen: Every way is the true Way.
    J: Can I study it?
    N: The more you study, the further from the Way.
    J: If I don't study it, how can I know it?
    N: The Way does not belong to things seen: nor to things unseen.
    It does not belong to things known: nor to things unknown. Do
    not seek it, study it, or name it. To find yourself on it, open
    yourself as wide as the sky.

    - this post brought to you by the Automated Last Post Generator...