Slashdot Mirror


Linux On The Dell Axim

An anonymous reader points to this interesting project to run the Familiar Linux distribution on the Dell Axim. "It includes a picture of the Axim running Linux and directions for loading Linux on the Dell Axim from the CF card. Looks like a good start to this project." It's limited for now (crashes after 15 minutes, must be loaded through the installed version of Windows), but everything starts out that way.

126 comments

  1. Is that Linux in your pocket... by Joey+Patterson · · Score: 5, Funny

    or are you just happy to see me?

    1. Re:Is that Linux in your pocket... by the-build-chicken · · Score: 1

      Junit is a testing tool, not a refactoring tool ...mod parent down, sig redundant ;)

    2. Re:Is that Linux in your pocket... by Joey+Patterson · · Score: 1

      Actually, my sig is a reference to this comment that I made a while back.

  2. 404? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Why does it give me a 404 saying the article doesn't exist? Come on, get some database consistency going!

    1. Re:404? by shione · · Score: 0, Redundant

      ah, the magic of slashdot :)

  3. here are the instructions... by rkz · · Score: 0, Redundant

    step by step guide to installing linux on the axim for dummies.

    Have fun.

  4. linux on everything by jnguy · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Why is the goal now to run linux on everything, from your xbox to your "Pocket PC" I understand the xbox, but will running linux on your pocket pc really be useful? is it even worth the effort, or is it just something cool.

    1. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      You're new around here, aren't you?

    2. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Interesting

      Definitely COOL at first, USEFUL maybe later...

    3. Re:linux on everything by Erwos · · Score: 3, Interesting

      As someone who's done a Linux install on his iPaq 3150, the answer is an unequivocal yes.

      You get far more flexibility, device support, and free software with Linux than PocketPC. Perhaps the only niggle is that you can't really get a browser into 16mb of RAM without constant crashes, but the Axim and newer iPaqs do not suffer from this problem. A nice side effect of storing everything in flash is that running out of battery only resets your clock, not your data.

      It's not for everyone, but I think it was worth my time...

      -Erwos

      --
      Plausible conjecture should not be misrepresented as proof positive.
    4. Re:linux on everything by Surak · · Score: 5, Insightful

      In a way, it's kind of useful from an advocacy point of view. We can truly say that we have an operating system that scales to virtually any device, large or small, and can run on virtually any processor technology. Linux runs on anything from PDAs and small embedded devices to IBM mainframes today. You can't say that about *any* of its competition.

    5. Re:linux on everything by rkz · · Score: 1

      NetBSD?

    6. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      When you grok this, you won't need to ask that question anymore.

    7. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

      Linux runs on anything from PDAs and small embedded devices to IBM mainframes today. You can't say that about *any* of its competition.

      Does it run on Itanium3? No, only windows does.
      Does it run on 8-way Xeon servers? No, only windows does.
      Does it run on Xbox? No, only windows does.

    8. Re:linux on everything by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      It's just an attempt to run on netbsd, which is reputed to run on everything from univac to a beehive (if you add the proper terminals.)

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    9. Re:linux on everything by be-fan · · Score: 2, Informative

      NetBSD doesn't scale to large way SMP machines.

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
    10. Re:linux on everything by Surak · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Admittedly, while NetBSD *does* provides support for a wide range of processor platforms, it's still not as scalable as Linux, and hasn't been ported to nearly as many devices in a useable form. Not that I'm trivializing NetBSD -- it is very scalable and runs on a lot of stuff -- but Linux is a lot more versatile thanks to the support of a lot of dedicated developers and the commercial support given to them from big companies like IBM.

    11. Re:linux on everything by TobySmurf · · Score: 3, Informative

      Haha, > Does it run on Itanium3? No, only windows does. Wait until the I3 actually ships before you claim things like that. I have used it on I2s and it works (and works well). > Does it run on 8-way Xeon servers? No, only windows does. Yup. Installed it, played with it, wished I could take it home (Dell 8450 Server) > Does it run on Xbox? No, only windows does. http://xbox-linux.sourceforge.net/ :-)

    12. Re:linux on everything by Surak · · Score: 2, Informative

      In addition to what TobySmurf said (all of which is true), it's not fair to call Windows CE and Windows NT/2000/XP the same OS. The two systems are entirely different codebases. Even the APIs have signficant differences.

    13. Re:linux on everything by dubStylee · · Score: 5, Interesting

      will running linux on your pocket pc really be useful?

      I'm someone who didn't pay enough attention to that question a few months ago and is way sorry now, here's my story:

      1. I purchase the Toshiba e740 with pocketPC 2002
      for $600

      2. Six months later pocketPC 2003 comes out and Toshiba declinces to make it available to e740 users.

      I now have no possibility of any kind of upgrade for any of my software. I am stuck with what was available pre-2003 for the rest of the life of the device. Now if Toshiba leaks out enough information about their hardware to allow someone to port linux to it, I could eventually upgrade the software.

    14. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think the OSS community suffers from a mob ADD. They all hop on board some new project but after it stops being cool the only thing left is a half completed project.

    15. Re:linux on everything by Strudelkugel · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Someday M$ will announce the KitchenPC blender. It will network to your fridge so that you will know when you can make a smoothie. The instant it is announced, a collection of OSS coders will begin porting Linux to it. Six months later, M$ will drop the blender effort, but will have spent its real effort on something useful to someone (ok, another service pack!)

      Why is the OSS community so obsessed with re-inventing the wheel? (Or Unix for that matter...) Lets see another desktop model, for example, instead of Yet Another Windows Clone...

      --
      Imagine how much harder physics would be if electrons had feelings! -Feynman, maybe
    16. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I love how that comment got a +1 funny.

    17. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      " after it stops being cool the only thing left is a half completed project."

      That describes 95% of the crap on sourceforge!!!

    18. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Linux runs on anything from PDAs and small embedded devices to IBM mainframes today. You can't say that about *any* of its competition.

      Except NetBSD. ;)

    19. Re:linux on everything by SignificantBit · · Score: 2

      i'm been around linux since maybe 6 or 5 years, and have a PocketPC since 2. An Ipaq to be accurate. The point on having linux on this kind of devices are several. As other have point out, one is to be able to say "you can ran linux on a toaster". ie, linux is flexible and powerful -as a tech platform ("you CAN do with linux whatever you want") and as a development model ("you MAY di with linux whatever you want"). Other point, is options. Monopolies lead nowhere, all slashdoter know this. I know, there is Palm, but seriously, Palm aren Pocket PCs, they are PDA, and i think there is a differece. Finally, but not less important, people put linux on everything because they can. Miself, i haven't move from Windows CE to Linux because there is a severe lack of sync tools. Even inside open source software. I still depend on Outlook because of that. I want to move all my things to Evolution but but i cant cause linux or not on my PocketPC i still can't sync.

    20. Re:linux on everything by fishynet · · Score: 1

      well if you want it that bad... Just finish the project yourself :P

      --

      Cats: All your base are belong to us.
      Captain: Take off every sig !!
    21. Re:linux on everything by Webz · · Score: 1

      I'm not really sure how useful of an attribute that is. It's like the Jack of All Trades, Master of None argument. The competition is usually available on relatively few platforms but performs very well on them. Sure Linux can run everywhere, but is it good everywhere? That kind of generic... osity... may detract from the ability to be an expert type of system.

      No, I haven't used Linux, but a great many argument I've read and agree with have to be usability and nativity to the platform. If Linux isn't native to anything, then who uses it on what? When will standards be developed?

      One day I'd like to learn enough about Linux to contribute to the community on a usability level... But I'm afraid that I'll just end up as one of the many people that thinks their view of how Linux should be is better than everyone elses (hence distributions) and create my own not-so-great distro of Linux or desktop environment. Sometimes you need that One For All or Dictator attitude to get stuff done.

      So you have diversity. And?

    22. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      One word: povray. There's nothing quite satisfying like downloading a cross compiler and hacking a povray 3.1 make file to create a raytracer binary for your new toy. There's no way you could do that if you were restricted to using only closed source software.

    23. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So what? PocketPCs have been obsoleting themselves every 6 months. I guess you are pretty new with computers? This should not have surprised you.

    24. Re:linux on everything by dubStylee · · Score: 1

      I was told there would be a world shortage of things for anonymous cowards to feel self righteous about unless I bought a pocketpc, so I did. It's a tough job, but somebody's got to do it.

    25. Re:linux on everything by EvilTwinSkippy · · Score: 1

      The "push" and "pop" implementation on the beehive terminals leaves a bit to be desired.

      --
      "Learning is not compulsory... neither is survival."
      --Dr.W.Edwards Deming
    26. Re:linux on everything by The+Zody · · Score: 1

      I am new to linux but would this mean i would be able to port any application from linux to my PPC running linux?

    27. Re:linux on everything by biglig2 · · Score: 1

      Well, theoretically yes, although of course hardware will limit some things. This would seem to be one of the answers to the "why bother" question; once Linux works on an Axim an enormous pile of software becomes available.

      --
      ~~~~~ BigLig2? You mean there's another one of me?
    28. Re:linux on everything by Surak · · Score: 3, Insightful

      No, I haven't used Linux, but a great many argument I've read and agree with have to be usability and nativity to the platform. If Linux isn't native to anything, then who uses it on what? When will standards be developed?

      Au contraire! Linux is native to *every* platform it runs on.

      It's important to note that the Linux kernel, along with the pieces of GNU system that you need to run with it (gcc, glibc, GNU toolchain, etc.) are written in C, which is a mostly portable language. Some parts of the kernel were written in assembler, although I *think* that has changed, and those parts originally had to be ported to each processor, but again, I think this has changed.

      In any respect, Linux is ported to each processor it runs on. Most of the work done in porting Linux to a new platform involves porting gcc and glibc, and then optimizing the kernel and those pieces to run well on that platform, including doing obvious stuff like moving from 32-bit to 64-bit, little endian vs. big endian, etc., but other things including optimizing for the way that that platform handles memory, for instance, optimizing pieces that are timing critical, and writing device drivers for different pieces of the I/O system, etc. (I've never done the work myself, so if I've missed something, hopefully someone more capable than myself will point that out, but this is basically the process as I understand it)

      So there you have it...Linux is native on every platform it runs on.

    29. Re:linux on everything by SonicBurst · · Score: 1

      Everyone remembers win ce, but almost everyone forgets nt embedded (perhaps rightly so). NT embedded was very similar to its namesake in terms of codebase. Just an FYI.

      --

      Geek used to be a four letter word. Now it's a six-figure one.
    30. Re:linux on everything by Surak · · Score: 1

      perhaps rightly so

      Mmmm hmmm... I think you just helped reinforce my original point. :)

    31. Re:linux on everything by Eccles · · Score: 1

      I understand the xbox, but will running linux on your pocket pc really be useful? is it even worth the effort, or is it just something cool.

      I think it is useful, for the simple reason that the Linux community doesn't abandon hardware like the commercial companies do. If Dell dropped their Axim line because it wasn't making a profit, the PocketPC version would probably be less useful over time as fewer and fewer new things would be available for it. But with a Linux version, new stuff should typically support it with a recompile.

      Now you may pay the price in polish (not Polish, polish), as generic apps or even generic Linux PDA apps may not be as polished as the commercial ones. So in the short run, the native platform may give a better user experience.

      --
      Ooh, a sarcasm detector. Oh, that's a real useful invention.
    32. Re:linux on everything by SlipJig · · Score: 1

      Good question, though personally I see more utility in running Linux on a PPC than on an XBox. I mean, it's a hell of a lot easier to just get a cheap PC and stick Linux on it than mod an XBox for the same effect.

      An offtopic observation: I'm waiting on a replacement Axim (dropped it. Doh!) The estimated ship date was June 10, and it's 3 weeks later now. Not a word from Dell, and their order status page just shows 'In Production'. Has anyone else been waiting on their unit?

      --
      Read my keyboard review.
    33. Re:linux on everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Axim is not a large way SMP machine.

  5. Crashes after 15min? by Eberlin · · Score: 5, Funny

    These guys are getting too good at imitating the competition!

    Relax, it was supposed to be funny.

    1. Re:Crashes after 15min? by NotAnotherReboot · · Score: 3, Funny

      If they're aiming for imitating the competition, they should write in random crashes. It always crashes after 15 minutes, but why not allow it to crash at 8 minutes, and later at 13 minutes? Keep the users on the edge of their seats!

    2. Re:Crashes after 15min? by SoSueMe · · Score: 2, Funny

      Article: "Though, beware that it currently [colon] panics after about 15 minutes, and when you do the hard reset, it boots back into Windows at factory default settings (meaning, you lose any files you might have stored on it)".

      Imitation is the sincerest form of flatulence.

    3. Re:Crashes after 15min? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And surely if you just set the machine to hibernate after fourteen minutes for just a minute or two, everything should be alright?

    4. Re:Crashes after 15min? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Or introduce a version of Clippy that goes something like...

      It looks like you're doing something important
      Would you like:
      * A BSOD
      * An obscure error message followed by a BSOD
      * A call from Doc Watson that shuts off the app
      * Info on whom all your base are belong to conveniently placed on a BSOD

    5. Re:Crashes after 15min? by Moses+Lawn · · Score: 2, Funny

      It should be configurable, preferably with an XML file and an arcane UI. If I want my Axim to crash after 12 minutes, I should be able to.

      It's all about choice, dammit!

      --

      What if life is just a side effect of some other process and God has no idea we exist?

  6. *waiting* by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Now waiting for the obligatory soon-to-be-Slashdotted "I'm running Apache on my Axim!" news item ...

    1. Re:*waiting* by dubStylee · · Score: 1

      Now waiting for the obligatory soon-to-be-Slashdotted "I'm running Apache on my Axim!" news item ...

      Why wait, Apache runs on WinCE.

    2. Re:*waiting* by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      HEATHEN! WinCE! How dare you mention that!

  7. linux remote by tobes · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Using the Axim as a X client on a wireless network would be kind of like having a kick ass linux remote control.

    1. Re:linux remote by dubStylee · · Score: 2, Informative

      Using the Axim as a X client on a wireless network would be kind of like having a kick ass linux remote control.

      You don't need linux for that. You can run VNC from pocketpc OS.

    2. Re:linux remote by Daz3d · · Score: 0

      And Palm OS :D

    3. Re:linux remote by fishynet · · Score: 1

      yes, but can you run a VNC server on PPCOS?

      --

      Cats: All your base are belong to us.
      Captain: Take off every sig !!
    4. Re:linux remote by dubStylee · · Score: 1

      yes, but can you run a VNC server on PPCOS?

      Not that I know about. There are certainly a number of other remote control/emultors that will let you run the ppc device from a remote (windows :-() box. I was just pointing out that some open source solutions exist for the platform, not implying that it is as flexible as a linux install on the same device would be.

  8. Imagine a... by Atario · · Score: 3, Funny

    ...deck of 52 of these.

    (Fooled ya, didn't I!)

    --
    "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy." --Theodore Roosevelt
  9. Re:What the point? by rune2 · · Score: 0

    Because good is dumb.

  10. Linux on this, linux on that by r84x · · Score: 4, Funny

    Well, I do congratulate this fellow on putting Linux on the Axim, but it seems to me that it has no purpose at all... If you really wanted to do something for the coolness of it all, I would like to see an Axim running Mac OS X, and burning CDs. That would be worth posting about.

    --
    Karma: Can there be a void?

    .. -. - . .-. .-. --- -...

    1. Re:Linux on this, linux on that by io333 · · Score: 1

      Someone gave that post a modpoint? Wow. No accounting for taste.

    2. Re:Linux on this, linux on that by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > Well, I do congratulate this fellow on putting Linux on the Axim, but it seems to me that it has no purpose at all...

      You really see no value in putting a user-updateable, open source OS on a handheld, making that handheld have a longer usable life? You need to read the thread above on "port Linux to everything?.." for a good set of responses.

    3. Re:Linux on this, linux on that by pdbogen · · Score: 1

      Besides the fact that (a) my university only provides a free VPN client for wifi for desktop machines (including Linux), which means I can now use my PDA to get on my campus' wireless network, (b) I can run & compile (assumable, given time) anything for Linux, which means I have a vastly improved collection of software to choose from which I do not have to pay $50 a piece for, (c) I could have Linux in my pocket, and (d) my Grenade-Launcher-Wielding-Penguin background will no longer be just fluff, no, I don't see any reason to put Linux on the Axim.

  11. Familiar Linux? by MoThugz · · Score: 4, Informative

    Before I read the article I thought the submitter was having fun poking RedHat (or in the case of slashdot... gentoo), not stating the actual distro used, but just saying that it's very familiar.

    Who would have thought (besides those who actually does dev stuff on handhelds) that there actually is such thing as Familiar Linux!

    1. Re:Familiar Linux? by pdbogen · · Score: 1

      There's also Intimate.

      Now, to go waste my paycheck buying a CF card & reader, whoop!

  12. Qtopia? by $calar · · Score: 1, Interesting

    I see that it runs Qtopia from Trolltech. Is that GPL or not? I didn't think it was, of course I could be wrong. It's great to see KDE's portable cousin on this thing.

    1. Re:Qtopia? by morbuz · · Score: 2

      Qtopia is available under the GPL;
      http://www.trolltech.com/download/qtopia/

      --
      CAPS LOCK IS LIKE CRUISE CONTROL FOR COOL!
    2. Re:Qtopia? by nadavspi · · Score: 4, Informative

      Actually, it's running Opie, or Open Palmtop Integrated Environment, which is an improved clone of Qtopia. Opie IS open source, and really much better than it's older brother.

    3. Re:Qtopia? by fishynet · · Score: 1

      Opie rocks! It really is quite a bit better than Qtopia. (I run it on my zaurus running OpenZaurus distro.)

      --

      Cats: All your base are belong to us.
      Captain: Take off every sig !!
  13. Duh by Hatta · · Score: 3, Funny

    If you don't run linux on it, you can't make a beowulf cluster out of it.

    --
    Give me Classic Slashdot or give me death!
  14. Another day another port by lavalyn · · Score: 4, Insightful

    We've seen Linux scale from as small as wristwatches to mainframes (both courtesy of IBM, oddly enough). So porting Linux to any particular handheld with an MMC is almost blase now :|

    Now if only they could make it usable beyond 15min...

    --
    Doing the Right Thing should not be preempted by making a buck.
  15. Useful, in time. by nurb432 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Once its stable, the applications will come..

    Then you arent tied to Microsoft for your updates/licenses/applications/privacy/etc.. You can do as you please.. Its called 'freedom'..

    Unless there comes a time when the hardware agreement forbids you to run anything but what is given you ( such as Xbox.. )

    --
    ---- Booth was a patriot ----
    1. Re:Useful, in time. by Mr_Silver · · Score: 1
      Then you arent tied to Microsoft for your updates/licenses/applications/privacy/etc.. You can do as you please.. Its called 'freedom'..

      Unless you're a seasoned Linux (on a PDA) programmer with masses of free time and energy - which rules out 99% of people on the planet - you're going to be tied to someone somewhere for your updates/licenses/applications/privacy/etc..

      Otherwise being able to do "what you please" is pretty much a pipe dream.

      --
      Avantslash - View Slashdot cleanly on your mobile phone.
  16. HP vs Dell for PocketPC Linux by AngusH · · Score: 2, Interesting

    How is this likely to change the market for PDAs?

    A little, a lot?

    Is it likely that HP Ipaqs or Dell Axims will be the preferred pocket pc platform for running linux?

    If you were going to buy a new device would it already run linux?

    It seems that a Dell device that could run linux would mean lower prices for the performance, particularly for vertical applications.

    I already have a Dell Axim so my decision is made but I am curious to see how this new development will affect people who haven't bought a pocket device and already run linux.

    (And I am aware of the Sharp linux PDAs)

    1. Re:HP vs Dell for PocketPC Linux by MonMotha · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Well, currently, there are HP employees (researchers, formerly Compaq, formerly DEC employees) helping with making it work on HP iPAQ units. This helps the iPAQ porting efforts go quicker than ports to other company's handhelds. However, the product cycle time on iPAQs seems to have gotten pretty short recently, and we're having troubel keeping up with the model families as they come out (54xx support is appearing, 19xx bootldr work is in progress currently).

      Dell doesn't exactly provide info for these projects. Most of this is entirely reverse engineered (which is partially why WinCE is still needed to do HW init, but also as a bootstrap in this case). I'm amazed he's managed to get a kernel booting, let alone OPIE running!

    2. Re:HP vs Dell for PocketPC Linux by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Many iPaq models include wireless networking, while bluetooth is optional and 802.11 is third-party if available at all on the Axims. Wireless communication is a critical feature for many vertical market applications where one may prefer to run Linux on a PocketPC -- for example, controlling small robots. Price alone is not so much of an issue when such critical features (and vendor support for Linux) are missing from Dell's current product offering.

  17. Nagware Linux by SynKKnyS · · Score: 2, Funny

    Crashes after 15 minutes? Well, you have to register it of course! =P

  18. Folks that think this isn't a big deal... by AltGrendel · · Score: 3, Insightful
    ...never had walk around doing site check of a wireless network using a laptop.

    Walking around a campus checking signal strength with something like this is real nice.

    --
    The simple truth is that interstellar distances will not fit into the human imagination

    - Douglas Adams

    1. Re:Folks that think this isn't a big deal... by twos · · Score: 1
      Check this thing out from our friends at Fluke.

      We got one not to long ago and it rocks. It's a bit pricey (around $3k USD), but it's paid for it's self already.

      --
      Phear The Phat Penguin
    2. Re:Folks that think this isn't a big deal... by PetoskeyGuy · · Score: 1

      Although there are MUCH easier ways. I have 2 Axims and My D-Link DCF-660W wireless card works great on my Axim and has at least twice the range of the Dell Wireless card. Also the drivers come with a utility which shows the relative strength of the signal, as well as scanning for available networks. I've noticed it can even detect networks from the car while I drive around downtown. Imagine that. :)

      If they can't even keep the handheld from crashing I doubt the drivers for wireless cards would be working yet.

      Still I hope this project progresses enough to be a usable system soon. In the mean time for a super cheap little portable scanner, $300 would get you a Axim, Cradle and WiFi. Just beware of tech support it's a 30 to 90 minute wait to talk to people in India. It can be very frustrating.

    3. Re:Folks that think this isn't a big deal... by fathomDragon · · Score: 4, Funny

      Walking around a campus checking signal strength with something like this is real nice.

      Can you ping me now? Good.

  19. If, on the other hand, by The+Pi-Guy · · Score: 1

    you have the other 'cheap' PocketPC, I have accomplished much the same on the iPAQ h1910, of course with the support of the handhelds.org team. Come visit us on IRC on irc.freenode.net, channel #handhelds.org - and say that joshua_ sent you :)

    ~joshua

  20. Linux on Dell's Power Edge 650 by zenray · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I just happened to be on Dell's web sight looking for a low end Mircosoft 2000 Power Edge to use as a print server and noted that an OS option was "Red Hat Linux 9.0"

    --
    zenray
  21. Obligatory Zaurus quote by Gothmolly · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The Sharp Zaurus 5500 et al support Linux, in fact, they SHIP with Linux. Install OpenZaurus and you have real Linux, yet with real apps, SSH, etc. etc. And it runs longer than 15 minutes.
    I mean, this is cool, but hardly the breaking story of the decade.

    --
    I want to delete my account but Slashdot doesn't allow it.
    1. Re:Obligatory Zaurus quote by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And don't hesitate to install the latest Opie desktop, version 0.9.9. Much nicer than the the default Sharp desktop and leagues better than the early Opie releases. Fast, solid and attractive.

    2. Re:Obligatory Zaurus quote by caffeinex36 · · Score: 1

      And it runs longer than 15 minutes.

      It does!? Mine doesn't, the battery life sucks so much I stopped using it a few hours after I got it and went back to my blackberry.....

      I hope they made some improvments in the 5600, becuase the 5500 definitly was not practical.

      -Rob

  22. Why not? by gpmart · · Score: 4, Interesting
    I know that I will indeed sound like a rube, but isn't a pocket pc really just a toy anyway? I use my Axim to surf the web wirelessly and check my mail, but most of the time I use it just as a toy. Who really does word processing on these things? You can't take notes. Even surfing is pretty painful. On the toy side, however its a relatively useful device. Its multimedia capabilities are pretty good(its a good MP3 player and a good ebook reader(which allows me to read linux docs)) but I think people that have the geek positive gene wouldn't mind playing with something new simply for the toy potential. Ultimately, their are some upsides to these things:
    • SSH(which I have yet to see for ppc.
    • Coding in other languages than the M$ langs
    • xterm
    • testing embedded stuff
    Its a small, shallow pool of users but for cheap geeks who want to play with operating systems(that might be 99% of us) this is a good way to play embedded linux on a system that we use for other things.
    1. Re:Why not? by talieos · · Score: 1
      >SSH(which I have yet to see for ppc.

      Mocha Soft makes a really good SSH client for PPC. Pair it with a thumb keyboard and wireless card, and you're good to go.

      It's got a relatively nag free trial mode, and is one of the cheaper ($25) ones to boot! Two thumbs up! (Or on the keyboard.) :)

  23. Re:This is the problem with Linux by fishynet · · Score: 2, Funny

    consistent user interface? what? if I go on linux box #1 and type echo "hi" then go to linux box #2 and type echo "hi". they will both spit out the same thing! whats not consistent about that?

    --

    Cats: All your base are belong to us.
    Captain: Take off every sig !!
  24. Re:This is the problem with Linux by fishynet · · Score: 0

    BTW... great job at just writing the same flamebait over and over http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=68796&cid=6290 139

    --

    Cats: All your base are belong to us.
    Captain: Take off every sig !!
  25. As a Zaurus owner... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I have to ask...
    How is this any more useful than just going out and buying a Zaurus? I'm not being snide. I can totally understand the tinker factor. But what does it really get you over what you can already get with the current crop of embedded Linux PDAs?

  26. Why not Zaurus? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Why just don't you get Zaurus SL-5600 ? Same hardware as Axim and it has keyboard!

    The most important is that your money go to company
    supporting Linux on PDA!

    When you buy Axim - your money goes to Dell and Microsoft and neither of them suport Linux on PDAs!

    There is so much talk about no Linux notebooks
    - here you have a very good Linux option,
    why don't you support it ?

    1. Re:Why not Zaurus? by the_Bionic_lemming · · Score: 1

      Why just don't you get Zaurus SL-5600 ? Same hardware as Axim and it has keyboard!

      Probably because it costs 40% more than an Axim and Keyboard.

      --
      _ _ _ Go for the eyes Boo! GO FOR THE EYES!
  27. Web browsing. by atheken · · Score: 2, Interesting

    IF NOTHING ELSE.. Maybe we can finally escape the "Pocket IE" crap.. how about mozilla for axim! Incidentally, anybody know what the deal with the Windows Mobile 2003 upgrade from Dell is? I got my axim a few weeks ago and I have yet to find how I can get the upgrade.

    1. Re:Web browsing. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Depending on when you got your Axim, the upgrade is either free or $30. The one you pay for doesn't ship until the end of July, which is nice: they should have a service pack ready about then.

      There's more info at the handheld support forum at support.dell.com

    2. Re:Web browsing. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Opera has an embedded version of their browser. Head and shoulders above Konqueror embedded (doesn't crash, three times the features, etc.), very nice for casual surfing.

    3. Re:Web browsing. by david614 · · Score: 1

      Go to http://www.aximsite.com, and check one of the forums. The upgrade went on sale last week, and is scheduled to ship in the third week of July for $29.99 + shipping. If you bought your Axim in the last 30 days, the upgrade may be free.

      Cheers

      --
      ELITISM: It's always lonely at the top. Uninvited company is rarely welcome.
    4. Re:Web browsing. by atheken · · Score: 1

      thanks for the post.. I was kinda hoping to find an "official" web page that says the upgrade was free. (on dell.com)

  28. Everything starts out that way.. by Peter+Cooper · · Score: 2, Funny

    It's limited for now (crashes after 15 minutes, must be loaded through the installed version of Windows), but everything starts out that way.

    Or in the case of Microsoft Windows ME Upgrade Edition, stays that way!

  29. look at that GUI by 73939133 · · Score: 1

    For that terminal application, almost half the screen is taken up by useless junk (buttons, tabs, etc.). With a GUI like that, Linux won't stand much of a chance competing against Palm or even PPC. Unfortunately, the same is true of many of the applications on my Zaurus.

    1. Re:look at that GUI by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I can help you with this. In computer terms, it's called an application, in this particular instance a multi-tab console. It has options, thingees that allow you to defeat some of the widgets you see on the screen to provide more screen space. The real estate taken up by the OS in that picture is the wee stripe to one end, less than ten percent, and it's called the taskbar.

      Hope that helped! :D

    2. Re:look at that GUI by 73939133 · · Score: 1

      I can help you with this. In computer terms, it's called an application,

      More precisely, it's called a badly designed application.

      It has options, thingees that allow you to defeat some of the widgets you see on the screen to provide more screen space.

      The real estate taken up by the OS in that picture is the wee stripe to one end, less than ten percent, and it's called the taskbar.

      The OS (Linux) isn't taking up any space in that picture at all. You have two applications operating in that image: one is a graphical environment and one is a terminal application. Together, they take up way too much screen real estate with useless buttons, tabs, menus, and task bars.

      Look at the Palm to see how much can be done with much less screen real estate. That's the kind of UI Linux needs in order to succeed on handhelds.

  30. Usability beyond 15 min by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    According to the article, the device won't crash after 15 if the suspend mode is disabled. RTFA. :)

  31. Game Console? by Cpt_Kirks · · Score: 1

    Imagine a 400mhz Axim with good game controlers and a ipod-size hard drive.

    Movies, games, emulators, with that kind of hardware the sky's the limit.

    1. Re:Game Console? by irc.goatse.cx+troll · · Score: 2, Insightful

      "with that kind of hardware the sky's the limit."

      With that kind of hardware, the battery is the limit.

      --
      Pain lasts, kid. Its how you know you're alive. Sometimes I think this growing up thing is just pain management-TheMaxx
    2. Re:Game Console? by Cpt_Kirks · · Score: 1

      With that kind of hardware, the battery is the limit.

      Fuel Cells!

      I get a shot, the pda gets a shot...

  32. Mod parent up cause he put the $ in M$ by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It was very clever... and original!

  33. wow, how useless. by pigfukr · · Score: 1

    reboot it and *poof*

    --
    pigfukr
  34. You do know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    that Linux on an Axim is not your only choice, don't you?

    Sheesh.

  35. Should I buy an Axim now? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I would like to buy the entry 300 MHz edition for personal use (mp3, streaming mpeg to it, web from my bed, etc), development (pocketpc 2003 to testbed stuff...i know there are emulators but id rather have the real deal), and to run linux on.

    The later is a big one. If I can run linux and all real linux tools on this badboy. Even if its not possible now will it be in the future with the same hardware as I buy today?

    Wouldn't mind being able to run kismet, airsnort, airtraf etc from one of these. PS can this be done with an SD memory card? I'd prefer to run it from that and have an 802.11b WiFi in my compactflash.

    thanks.

  36. aw geez by zumbojo · · Score: 1

    You said "crash" and "Linux" in the same sentence! Now /. is gonna have a week of Linuxnazis barking up poor Timothy's tree.

  37. Ultimate linux PDA? Sharp SL-C700 by Craggles · · Score: 2
    This runs linux natively, why not support Sharp for doing this. It has a full , usable keyboard, and runs in landscape mode OR portrait mode.

    I figure that portrait mode is better for the non-CLI crowd (e.g. windows users) and landscape is better for CLI users. This looks perfect, if a little big. SSH from anywhere!

    See the gadgeterr review to get an idea of the real size. http://sharp-world.com/corporate/news/021112.html
    http://www.the-gadgeteer.com/sharp-c700-review.htm l

  38. yes. fooled me. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It made me smile

  39. Re:This is the problem with Linux by pdbogen · · Score: 1

    > a consistent user interface
    bash is pretty consistent. Just because you choose a different candy coating to go around it than someone else doesn't make it not.
    > easy OS install
    If this is what you're concerned about, Redhat is reportedly easier to install than Windows. Enjoy.
    > decent media player
    mplayer and xmms. What more do you need, for chrissake?

  40. You have made an astute observation. by pr0ntab · · Score: 1

    Linux is VERY generic. But linux is both a horizontally and vertically integrated environment.

    That is, many parts of linux are specially aimed at certain target platforms and environment. Also, it helps that linux itself is a very small thing, just a device intergration framework, scheduler, and set of required libraries to help software get onto the ground floor. E

    You get app frameworks on top of it that are targetted to the platform that you run linux on.

    To backpedal, the only real thing that makes one linux the same as another is the syscall numbers, filesystem layout, and the names of structures in header files, which is all designed so that you can take C source on one machine and trivially rebuild it for another and have it work the same way. But under the hood, the code powering one architecture may be vastly different than the next.

    You'll notice if you unpack the kernel source that there are whole directories containing special-purpose files for different architectures, and many places where macros or #if statements are used to implement architecture-specific behaviors.

    As for vertical expansion:

    For example, on handhelds you have the "Familiar" linux distribution, which has specialty tools to deal with flash, a light-weight GUI, etc.

    TiVO has it's own distro, NAS boxes usually use a version of it running with security patches and a limited number of tools (if any, maybe just a stand-alone app)

    Full-fledged end-user distros come with a bazillion bells and whistles, 3d hardware support, Office suites, etc.

    --
    Fuck Beta. Fuck Dice
  41. I'm impressed! by judzillah · · Score: 1

    crashes after 15 minutes
    Wow, linux has finally acheived the stability levels of Windows!

  42. Re:wow, how useless. Read and Learn by ratfynk · · Score: 1

    Boy are you missing the point.
    The memory allocation of the Linux alows it to boot as an os even though it is not using effectively all the file storage access. Try that with a windows based os. Thump, crunch, no go! Put the Linux on its flash rom instead of pocket pc then you will have a real compact versatile os.
    The memory mapping work done by the guy who wrote it is brilliant.

    --
    OH THE SHAME I fell off the wagon and use sigs again!
  43. Re:linux on everything HERE IS WHY by ratfynk · · Score: 1

    "Why is the OSS community so obsessed with re-inventing the wheel? (Or Unix for that matter...) Lets see another desktop model, for example, instead of Yet Another Windows Clone..."


    Without re-engineering compition to Microsoft we will within 5 years have, surrendered all digital communication technology world-wide to one small consortium.

    Nothing less than this is the corporate manifesto of Microsoft. If it can't control absolutely then it perverts through lobby in Washington D.C.

    Of course MS never does any re-engineering, it just hires legions of virgins with a legal clean status to code only in their own version of C languages. It then has the dirty people tell them what bits they are to work on. Innovation? you be the judge!

    --
    OH THE SHAME I fell off the wagon and use sigs again!