Slashdot Mirror


Lord of the Rings Home Marathons?

Pepebuho asks: "Given that LOTR 3 is out, how many of you have staged Home LOTR Marathons? How long did they take? Was it fun or did everybody fell asleep by the middle of the Return of the King?"

120 comments

  1. Waiting for extended version by jnicholson · · Score: 5, Insightful

    We decided not to do this until the full-length version is out. No real point doing the marathon before then, is there?

    --
    "Do not drill any holes in your cat - it will not like it."
    -- Nick Davies
    1. Re:Waiting for extended version by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Mod parent UP!!!

    2. Re:Waiting for extended version by Yrd · · Score: 1

      I was going to say that, but I see lots of other people have so I'm just going to say 'hear hear' instead.

      But then, I'm the person who hasn't seen the cinematic edition of any of them.

      --
      Miri it is whil Linux ilast...
    3. Re:Waiting for extended version by __aatgod8309 · · Score: 1

      And i'm the person who hasn't seen the cinematic or the DVD edition of any of them. (Or the video version for that matter) Maybe once a friend buys them and i can borrow them off him, but i'll save my money.

    4. Re:Waiting for extended version by Sepper · · Score: 1

      Then at least try to borrow the 4CD edition. I found the documentaries on how the movie was made and fact about the LOTR itself even more entertaining... There's a video about Tolkien himself on 'The Two Towers' that I enjoyed a lot...

      But yeah, It was kind of expensive... Might want to rent it instead...

      --
      I live in Soviet Canuckistan you insensitive clod!
    5. Re:Waiting for extended version by jnicholson · · Score: 1
      nerd... among nerds
      That's hardly true. I didn't even use the words 'first post' - a mistake a true slashdot nerd would never have made.
      --
      "Do not drill any holes in your cat - it will not like it."
      -- Nick Davies
  2. About a month. by students · · Score: 3, Interesting

    One movie each weekend. With the extra features on the DVD. And yes, some people fell asleep.

  3. gotta wait till november... by monkeyserver.com · · Score: 5, Insightful

    what's a marathon without the extended edition? You wimps gonna try it with the theatrical versions? Bah! I'm waiting for the motherload, this november it'll be me and my friends, a minifridge, 3 extended editions, and one very long day...

    --
    http://monkeyserver.com --- weeeeee
    1. Re:gotta wait till november... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      FYI: motherlode

    2. Re:gotta wait till november... by adamjaskie · · Score: 3, Funny

      MINIfridge? You pansy!

      --
      /usr/games/fortune
    3. Re:gotta wait till november... by beckett · · Score: 3, Funny

      i'm going to raise the ante with a keg and a package of "Depends" undergarments. first one to go to the toilet loses.

    4. Re:gotta wait till november... by Zero_Dogg · · Score: 1

      November? I think it's suppose to be released in August.

    5. Re:gotta wait till november... by gstoddart · · Score: 1

      Eeeew!

      Geeks in diapers drinking beer.

      And people wonder why the slashdot crowd might not be scoring with the honeys. =)

      --
      Lost at C:>. Found at C.
    6. Re:gotta wait till november... by /dev/trash · · Score: 1

      But how would you know?

    7. Re:gotta wait till november... by derkaas · · Score: 1
      i'm going to raise the ante with a keg and a package of "Depends" undergarments. first one to go to the toilet loses.

      This should add another dimension to the films by accurately reproducing the ambient smells of Mordor.

  4. Trilogy Tuesday by nes11 · · Score: 1

    Those of us that are real fans were at Trilogy Tuesday.

    1. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by dchamp · · Score: 1

      True dat.

      I survived Trilogy Tuesday!

      I'm planning to rent a copy of RoTK for a friend that hasn't seen it yet (was out of the country) but I'm not buying it until the extended version comes out.

    2. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by Vaevictis666 · · Score: 1
      Those of us that are real fans were at Trilogy Tuesday.

      and those of us that work are waiting until this november and doing an Extended Weekend :P

    3. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by SecretMethod70 · · Score: 1

      Except for those of us that were screwed over by the online ticket ordering site for the local Trilogy Tuesday theatre crashing while the tickets sold out for people getting them through non-online means which were not available to everyone. :(

    4. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      was out of the country

      Like there there isn't cinemas in the rest of the world. Your friends probarly din't give a damn about the movies..

    5. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by TheGatekeeper · · Score: 1, Funny

      I survived Trilogy Tuesday and all I got was this Ring...

      --
      'The staff in the hand of a wizard may be more than a prop for age,' -Hamá, the doorward
    6. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > and those of us that work are waiting until this
      > november and doing an Extended Weekend :P

      I work and I made it to TT. In a different state. GOD I can't stand people who pull this "Well I have to work. Well I have to pay bills." crap all the time.

      Get over yourself. You didn't want to see the films enough to get a day off work. Don't try the high and mighty routing because you have a job. Billions do.

    7. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by Kaimelar · · Score: 1
      Those of us that are real fans were at Trilogy Tuesday.

      Let me tell you, after waking up at four in the morning, standing all morning in the cold Denver weather, and then watching 12 hours of LotR, seeing Shelob come after Frodo was bloody scary. When I got home, my wife asked me how the movie was. Apparently, the only thing I said before crashing into bed was, "It was good. Spiders are frightening. Shelob was huge."

      I enjoyed RotK much more the second time, when my senses weren't numbed by sleep depravation and cold. I'm sure we'll do a home showing of all three films when the extended RotK comes out, but I think spreading them out over three nights or weekends will make them easier to appreciate. Thirteen hours of movie is just hard to take, even really good movies.

      That said, I'm extremely proud I was at Trilogy Tuesday, and enjoyed it immensely.

    8. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by stanmann · · Score: 1

      Some of us don't wish to drive 2 hours and get a hotel room to prove our fandom, you are 733t3r than me.

      --
      Food not Bombs is a nice platitude but it breaks down when you notice that the Bombees are usually well fed
    9. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by Nephilium · · Score: 2, Interesting

      The opposite happened here... the movie theater didn't seem to understand what they were getting into... They had *one* booth open to buy tickets... and they sold out in under an hour (good on-line sales...)...

      And memory from that day that sticks the longest was the massive boo-ing that occurred during the Mask 2 preview (which I haven't seen since)... turning towards the New Line Rep, and seeing them taking furious notes on a clipboard.

      Nephilium
      It is possible that mankind is on the threshold of a golden age; but, if so, it will be necessary first to slay the dragon that guards the door, and this dragon is religion. -- Bertrand Russell

    10. Re:Trilogy Tuesday by The+Ultimate+Fartkno · · Score: 1


      > turning towards the New Line Rep, and seeing them taking furious notes on a clipboard.

      They got away with just *notes?* You sorry bastards missed a perfect opportunity.

      [door to studio exec's office opens and in walks the press flack from the premiere. He has been "tarred & feathered" with a noxious mixture of melted Milk Duds, nacho cheese, and rancid popcorn.]

      Exec: So how was the premiere? Did they go ape for the "Mask 2" trailer? [he looks up] Jesus! What happened to you?!

      Flack [weakly]: Well sir, they did go ape. In a manner of speaking.

      Exec: What do you mean?

      Flack: Well, the "Harry Potter" trailer had everybody really excited, the "Spider Man" had them at a fever pitch, and by the time the teaser for the new "Bat Man" next year had them leaping for joy in the aisles. They were frothing, sir. Literally frothing.

      Exec: Yeah? So then what?

      Flack: And then another trailer rolled. Coming after that holy trifecta of sequels I guess they were hoping for something colossal, something beyond words - "Office Space 2" or something. And then...

      Exec: And then what?

      Flack: And then there was this green baby. This whirling, luminescent character that just...

      Exec: Just *what*?

      Flack: ...that just reeked of accountants looking at past profits and assuming that somehow that instantly translates into "something the moviegoing public *must* want a sequel to even though it's five years past too late, doesn't feature *any* of the original actors, and probably will be one of those cinematic 'brought to you by the people who bought the rights to an old favorite of yours from a bankrupt company' abortions."

      Exec [fuming]: Do I need to remind you just who pays your salary, you little shit!

      Flack: Not my words, sir. The geeks said it. Well, they wrote it. On my clipboard.

      Exec: GRR! Dammit, they'll *love* that movie! It's been field-tested on retarded schoolchildren in six cities! We've done the math! The account... er, the director and the twelve writers *assure* me it's a masterpiece of profitee... filmmaking!

      Flack: Sorry sir. That's what the geeks said.

      Exec: Horseshit! Someone had to love it! Let me see the clipboard!

      Flack: Sir, I have cheese burns.

      Exec: Gimme!

      Flack: I can't move my arms. They're glued to my sides with duds.

      Exec: NOW!

      Flack: You'll have to pull it out yourself.

      [the press flack bends over, his ass towards the exec. Fade.]

  5. That's Impossible! by Landaras · · Score: 4, Funny

    A Lord of the Rings marathon?

    That's impossible!

    Since clearly all of Slashdot has boycotted buying DVD's due to the rampant evil of the MPAA...

    </sarcasm>

    - Neil Wehneman

    1. Re:That's Impossible! by Cy+Guy · · Score: 1, Funny
      For those of you that aren't boycotting the MPAA, but still haven't ordered your copy, might I suggest this link: RotK $17.97.
      1) SlashDot runs gratuitous RotK thread
      2) Post gratuitous Amazon affiliate link to RotK
      3) Profit!


    2. Re:That's Impossible! by bckrispi · · Score: 4, Funny
      Who mentioned anything about buying the DVD? :)

      --
      Xenon, where's my money? -Borno
    3. Re:That's Impossible! by markxz · · Score: 1

      Why not just watch all the films end to end (as many cinemas have shown). Then all you can complain about is the highly visible anti-piracy encoding on the prints and how the multiplex who had the prints before had trashed them. You may want to wait till extended version prints have been struck

  6. DVD & Cinema Marathon by Kalixis · · Score: 5, Interesting
    Just before Return came out in the cinemas, we planned the following:
    • Watch Fellowship of the Ring.
    • Watch The Two Towers.
    • Watch Return of the King at the cinema.
    • One after the other.

    Need I tell you fellowship & towers were the extended editions?

    He who hosted the marathon had access to a digital projector - thankfully he also had a spare, large white wall to watch everything on. Someone brought along the extended editions of fellowship and towers, and we were off. Well, after about two hours of Mario Kart: Double Dash, that is. To warm up the projector. Yeah.

    In the end, sweets were consumed, chips were pulverised, bottles were emptied, LOTR was watched, fun was had. Something like 10am till about 1am all up.
    1. Re:DVD & Cinema Marathon by Photar · · Score: 1

      Pshaw, us real geeks watched the extended editions of the first two in the theater and then watched the third, all in a row. Hah!

      --
      He who knows not and knows he knows not is a wise man. He who knows not and knows not he knows not is a fool.
    2. Re:DVD & Cinema Marathon by Sparr0 · · Score: 1

      yeah, i wanted to go to that but the nearest theater doing it was like 5 hours away

    3. Re:DVD & Cinema Marathon by Photar · · Score: 1

      N00b I flew 10 hours to see it.

      --
      He who knows not and knows he knows not is a wise man. He who knows not and knows not he knows not is a fool.
    4. Re:DVD & Cinema Marathon by OblongPlatypus · · Score: 1

      I'm lucky enough to live a fifteen minute walk from the largest THX screen in the world, and on the premiere day of RotK I could go there and do just that. (I didn't, because I had an exam the next day, but anyway...)

      They also did a Kill Bill marathon on the opening day of Volume 2, and that one I did go to. There must not be enough geeks around here, because the Volume 1 screening was before a less than half full theater.

      --
      -- If no truths are spoken then no lies can hide --
    5. Re:DVD & Cinema Marathon by KDan · · Score: 1

      Flying under the influence of substances doesn't count...

      Daniel

      --
      Carpe Diem
    6. Re:DVD & Cinema Marathon by BJH · · Score: 1

      Maybe it was because Kill Bill sucked ass?

  7. LOTR Marathon... HECK YEAH!! by BigFlirt · · Score: 1

    When RotK came out, my girlfriend (who's a huge LOTR fan) and I sat down with a few six-packs and two large pizzas at around 2:30ish and were done with the first two before 10:00ish (yeah... you know chicks... having to take bathroom breaks and pausing to get up and go to the fridge every once in a while) to go stand in line and catch the midnight show on opening night. I imagine if you have plans to watch all three, just write the ENTIRE day off.

  8. Flamebait? by Landaras · · Score: 4, Funny

    I don't know if I'd mod that Flamebait.

    (-1, Capitalist Whore) perhaps.

    But not Flamebait :).

    - Neil Wehneman

  9. Friends? by Doc+Squidly · · Score: 4, Funny

    I don't have any friends you insensitive clod!

    --
    I think I think, therefore I think I am.
    1. Re:Friends? by bluestar · · Score: 2, Funny

      Or... I have a life you insensitive clod!

      --
      "The cost of freedom is eternal vigilance." -Thomas Jefferson
  10. The TRUE fans.. by E_elven · · Score: 4, Funny
    ..will do this:
    • Fellowship of the Ring Theatrical
    • The Two Towers Theatrical
    • Return of the King Theatrical
    • -- break for 15 --
    • Fellowship of the Ring Extended
    • The Two Towers Extended
    • Return of the King Extended
    • Go out and beat people with nerf bats screaming "Die orc!" a lot
    --
    Marxist evolution is just N generations away!
    1. Re:The TRUE fans.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      The "true fans" I know didn't like the movies as they thought that the books were either disgraced or that the books shouldn't ever have been adapted.

      Needless to say, I'm not a "true fan".

    2. Re:The TRUE fans.. by E_elven · · Score: 0, Troll

      Those 'true fans' are idiots. Obviously the movies weren't going to be exactly the same. They were, however, enjoyable. What next, bitching because "that damn Jackoffson left out all the events of Silmarillion, he sucks"?

      --
      Marxist evolution is just N generations away!
    3. Re:The TRUE fans.. by meringuoid · · Score: 1
      that damn Jackoffson left out all the events of Silmarillion, he sucks

      I didn't mind that - the Quenta Silmarillion doesn't really have all that much of an effect on LotR. I was a little annoyed that the whole Akallabeth got left out, though.

      Now I'm just hoping that after they get around to filming The Hobbit they consider the tale of Turin Turambar for the next Tolkien project. I would love to see Glaurung at the sack of Nargothrond on screen.

      --
      Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
    4. Re:The TRUE fans.. by isorox · · Score: 1

      And what about the animated version?

    5. Re:The TRUE fans.. by pete-classic · · Score: 2, Funny

      I heard there is even a book . . . !

      That's a serious LotR marathon. Start with "The Hobbit" on Monday night and polish off "The Return of the King" by Sunday.

      -Peter

    6. Re:The TRUE fans.. by cloak42 · · Score: 1

      That's a serious LotR marathon. Start with "The Hobbit" on Monday night and polish off "The Return of the King" by Sunday.

      God, it's taken me the better part of a year to even get through LotR, and I'm STILL not done with it.

      Of course, I'm only reading it on the toilet, but still... :)

    7. Re:The TRUE fans.. by pete-classic · · Score: 1

      I suggest that you cut fiber out of your diet completely if you ever decide to read the Silmarillion.

      -Peter

    8. Re:The TRUE fans.. by Brandybuck · · Score: 1

      Damn cheese doodles! Better go grab my Silmarilion, because it looks like I'm going to have a long reign on the throne...

      --
      Don't blame me, I didn't vote for either of them!
    9. Re:The TRUE fans.. by Brandybuck · · Score: 1

      The "true fans" marathon will be a re-enactment of the trilogy the way it was supposed to have been filmed.

      --
      Don't blame me, I didn't vote for either of them!
    10. Re:The TRUE fans.. by Brandybuck · · Score: 1

      I was a little annoyed that the whole Akallabeth got left out, though.

      I agree. Without that part of the tale told in full, it's pretty damned hard to understand Sauron's whole motivation. I mean, how are we supposed to empathize with Sauron when we don't understand where he's coming from?

      --
      Don't blame me, I didn't vote for either of them!
    11. Re:The TRUE fans.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Nah, this is what the true fans would watch:


      Bad Taste


      Meet the Feebles


      Dead Alive


      Heavenly Creatures


      The Frighteners


      then the LoTR movies.


      I'm sure I missed a few in there.

    12. Re:The TRUE fans.. by Phil+Gregory · · Score: 1

      Don't forget The Two Towers: The Purist Edit.


      --Phil (Annoying Tolkien purist)
      --
      355/113 -- Not the famous irrational number PI, but an incredible simulation!
    13. Re:The TRUE fans.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Care to summarize for those of us without the time to pull out our unread copies and search for the tale?

  11. Glittering Prizes!!! by Noxx · · Score: 1

    (and endless compromises)

    Down here, everybody who went to the 11-hr marathon got a plastic display doohickey containing one cell from each movie. Cool.

    --
    Study everything, you'll find something you can use - Jason Bourne
    1. Re:Glittering Prizes!!! by syrinx · · Score: 1

      shatter the illusion of integrity?

      --
      Quidquid latine dictum sit, altum sonatur.
    2. Re:Glittering Prizes!!! by nes11 · · Score: 1

      I think everyone got those. We went in Oklahoma & got them too. It's actually sitting right here on my desk.

  12. Um. No. by Seumas · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Look, I liked LOTR as much as the next guy, but I have more important things to do with my time than sit down and watch 6 hours of movies that I've already seen plus 3.5 hours of the 3rd movie all at once. And no, I didn't go to the theaters to see LOTR-3. The first time I saw LOTR-3 was this past weekend on DVD on my 65" widescreen (yes, part of the reason I don't bother with theaters anymore! heh).

    It's like Star Wars. I don't quite understand the desire to watch it 500 times. I have watched four of the five StarWars movies in my life time and I know what happens in them. Why would I want to see them a second time? If I'm going to spend another 10 hours in front of the television, it's at least going to be with NEW movies.

    Not to be a curmudgeon. I honestly have never understood people who claim to have seen a film 5, 10, 20, 50 times.

    1. Re:Um. No. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Amen brother. I would guess you are old enough to remember the Rocky Horror people who would go and watch it every weekend.

      I never understood them either.

    2. Re:Um. No. by Detritus · · Score: 1
      Not to be a curmudgeon. I honestly have never understood people who claim to have seen a film 5, 10, 20, 50 times.

      Try being out in the middle of nowhere, with no movie theaters or television stations, with a VCR and a few prerecorded tapes. Your entertainment choices are limited to listening to shortwave radio or watching a movie for the Nth time.

      --
      Mea navis aericumbens anguillis abundat
    3. Re:Um. No. by mikeb39 · · Score: 1

      Loser.

    4. Re:Um. No. by Seumas · · Score: 1

      I'm only 27 (soon, at least), but I know plenty of people that make frequent or even weekly trips to the Saturday night RHPS. I love RHPS, but not enough to watch it repeatedly. I went with a girlfriend to a RHPS showing one Saturday night at the Clinton Street Theater and was unimpressed. Just a bunch of unattractive people dressed up like RHPS characters replicating what was being done on the screen. By the time my girlfriend and I left after the movie, she was down to her panties and a bra, but unfortunately there wasn't anyone else there that I'd have wanted to see stripped down to their underwear. Ick.

      To each their own, I suppose, but I went once and never felt the need to go back again. It was interesting but been-there-done-that. Give me something new. Maybe people just need an excuse to get together and don't know how to say "hey lets all meet for dinner this weekend".

      Then again, I also don't comprehend the fun of cosplay or LARP. And yes, I've attended events for both before solidifying my thoughts on them. It's just really bizarre to see grown adults dressed up like vampires - often half naked - talking about the Prince of Portland and treadore this and that. Or worse, D&D LARP types running around throwing spit wads at each other yelling "LIGHTING BOLT! LIGHTING BOLT!" and thwacking one another with cardboard tubes from rolls of giftwrap shouting "TWO DAMAGE! TWO DAMAGE!".

    5. Re:Um. No. by richie2000 · · Score: 1
      And that's basically how I learned all the dialogue in Up the creek.

      Some pretty funny stuff in there. And Jennifer Runyon, of course. :-)

      --
      Money for nothing, pix for free
    6. Re:Um. No. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      I'm only 27 (soon, at least)

      So that'd make you 26 yeah?

    7. Re:Um. No. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In 12 days.

    8. Re:Um. No. by isorox · · Score: 1

      You spot new things every time you watch again. I Watched "A head in the polls", a topical (in the UK) futurama episode again last night. As well as being hilarious (my girlfriend's a fan now!), I spotted a new visual gag (Rook takes Pawnshop) that I didn't see the first 10 times.

      I take it you dont own any dvd's, just rent them from netflix or wherever?

    9. Re:Um. No. by isorox · · Score: 1

      Man I keep lying about my age. I've been 21 for 18 months. Why would you want to be older?

    10. Re:Um. No. by nathanh · · Score: 3, Funny
      Why would I want to see them a second time? If I'm going to spend another 10 hours in front of the television, it's at least going to be with NEW movies.

      Why listen to the same song more than once? Why eat the same type of meal more than once? Why have sex with the same person more than once?

      BECAUSE IT IS ENJOYABLE YOU MORON.

      I don't like Star Wars but I've watched Metropolis (Fritz Lang) a dozen times. I still enjoy watching it even though I know every single scene by heart.

      If people enjoy watching LOTR ten times then let them. Don't be a dickhead and make them feel bad about it.

    11. Re:Um. No. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hmm... You do have a long term memory and an ability to feel emotion right? I guess you must be trolling - a normal human being would understand that repeating things we already have done before can help us re-experience the original moment, the original feelings. Ever smelled cooking, or flowers or cut grass in the rain and remembered an event of the same nature some time ago?

      Ever smelled your special someone's perfume/aftershave and remembered how great you felt that summer night 3 years ago when you first met them?

      Gee, you're right. Why would anyone want to redo things over again?

    12. Re:Um. No. by Seumas · · Score: 1

      Listening to music is not at all like watching a movie. Unlike a movie, you aren't following a plot line and a story and while you can tire of a song or album, it's more from repetition than simply knowing every work in the script.

      You can quote an entire movie line by line and I'm the moron. Christ...

    13. Re:Um. No. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      These are stupid comparisons. None of these things have a thing to do with repeatedly watching a same movie. How can you compare a familiar scent with watching Kill Bill for the 85th time?

      If you really do have the same experience each time you watch a movie, you probably have the brain of a fucking hamster. The enjoyment of movies is the not knowing and discovery. The tension and curiosity and the twist of the plot and the method of resolution.

      Watching the same movie over and over and over and over can't be any different than unwrapping a gift when you already know what's inside. Then again, some people are easily entertained whereas others seek new forms of entertainment or at least new material.

      Fuck, even my four year old gets tired of watching the same video.

    14. Re:Um. No. by piggy · · Score: 3, Insightful
      It depends if you watch a movie merely for the plot, or if you gain some additional sort of enjoyment from it, be it art, style, the mood it creates, or the mindless sense of abandonment of reality. Keep in mind that listening to a song just for the lyrics will grow old very quickly, but clearly that is not the only reason many people listen to music. The point is that while you may only derive pleasure from a movie's plot, someone else may enjoy other aspects.

      Your comment "You can quote an entire movie line by line and I'm the moron" makes as much sense to some people as the equivalent "You know all the lyrics to an entire song" or "You know all the lines from a play" or.... Well, I hope you get the point.

      In the end, while "listening to music is not at all like watching a movie [for Seumas]", it may be a similar experience for other people. Become a little more open minded, man.

      Russell

    15. Re:Um. No. by nathanh · · Score: 4, Funny
      You can quote an entire movie line by line and I'm the moron. Christ...

      Metropolis is a silent movie.

    16. Re:Um. No. by bluestar · · Score: 1

      I've heard "Stairway to Heaven" and I know how it sounds. Why would I want to listen to it a second time?

      --
      "The cost of freedom is eternal vigilance." -Thomas Jefferson
    17. Re:Um. No. by 01D* · · Score: 1

      If it's a good movie, I mean if it's a good movie -- you'd be amazed how much you missed the first time around...
      Even in real life: have you ever wanted to pause and really think it over? Now, a good movie can be like that but a lot faster.

      So, yes, there is a point in watching a movie more than once, given it contain a little more then dancing colors on a (65"?) widescreen.

    18. Re:Um. No. by Pfhor · · Score: 1

      Dude, that just means you have to up your perception rating, to have a higher probability of noticing "tibits".

      People still don't believe me there looks like there is a constellation of stars looking like a dog in the space cloudes of "godfellas".

    19. Re:Um. No. by Pfhor · · Score: 0

      Man, i shouldn't try replying to slashdot this early in the morning.

    20. Re:Um. No. by Alrescha · · Score: 1

      "Look, I liked LOTR as much as the next guy..."

      Um... obviously *not*...

      A.

      --
      ...bringing you cynical quips since 1998
    21. Re:Um. No. by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 1

      Good troll. Got 'em biting.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    22. Re:Um. No. by filmguru · · Score: 1

      Mmmmmm... Jennifer Runyon... One of my favorite '80s girls. Thanks for the memory. :)

      --FilmGuru

    23. Re:Um. No. by joeljkp · · Score: 1

      Dude, I saw Kill Bill Vol. 1 for the first time a couple months ago, and I loved it. So I bought the soundtrack because I dug the music. I'd see it again in a heartbeat.

      --
      WeRelate.org - wiki-based genealogy
    24. Re:Um. No. by BCoates · · Score: 1
      Metropolis is a silent movie.
      Maybe he was thinking of "Radio Ga Ga" by Queen.
    25. Re:Um. No. by quisph · · Score: 1
      I honestly have never understood people who claim to have seen a film 5, 10, 20, 50 times.
      Well, it depends on the movie. I never understood why anyone would watch something like Something's Gotta Give even once.

      But a movie like The Godfather, or Rashomon, or The Seventh Seal? That's altogether different. There's more to a good movie than the plot. Some people just don't know what to look for.

      You probably have some kind of art hanging somewhere in your home. Why would you look at it more than once?

      Do you throw photographs away after looking at them once? Why take photos in the first place?

    26. Re:Um. No. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      i never look at my photos, except when they're just developed.

  13. Hm by pudge · · Score: 5, Funny

    I started my LotR marathon today while working on some new features in the Slash code. I hope it doesn't show ...

    1. Re:Hm by Justin205 · · Score: 3, Funny

      We'll come to you if there seem to be random (Cave) Troll moderations popping up.

      --
      "Your effort to remain what you are is what limits you."
    2. Re:Hm by /dev/trash · · Score: 1

      New features? Like multiple selection polls or a moderation queue?

    3. Re:Hm by pudge · · Score: 2, Informative

      See CmdrTaco's journal. The Section/Topics stuff.

    4. Re:Hm by /dev/trash · · Score: 1

      Okay. I'll take multiple choice polls. Do you guys take patches?

    5. Re:Hm by pudge · · Score: 1

      Yes. See the Slash project page.

  14. actually the contrary by slothman32 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I actually did an anti-marathon. When I saw TFOTR I watched it in 2 1.5 hour parts. I don't know why someone would spend 20 hours watching it when they could be doing something constructive like sleeping or sitting around doing nothing.

    --
    Why don't you guys have friends or journals?
    1. Re:actually the contrary by Babbster · · Score: 2, Funny

      Or trying to sync all three movies to Dark Side of the Moon?

  15. no extended rotk == no marathon by evilkarl · · Score: 1

    Until the extended edition of the last movie comes out I won't be doing a marathon. Once it is out however I shall partake in the fun

    --
    Everyone is stupid, it is just the degree that varies
  16. Been there.. by bfandreas · · Score: 1

    ..done that. I watched a LotR triple feature in december. First two movies where full length. I gotta admit that I was this close to fleeing the cinema before the Battle of Helms Deep. But I hadn't watched RotK before, so I dragged thru. No fun.

    --
    20 minutes into the future
  17. Only LOTR? by Gadzinka · · Score: 1

    Me and my friends have beed doing this with tv series published on DVD -- one season at a time (that's about 22*40min).

    That's a challenge for real tough guys ;)

    Robert

    --
    Bastard Operator From 193.219.28.162
    1. Re:Only LOTR? by l0rd · · Score: 1

      Try watching the stand without a break. After a few hours you wanna send Mother Abagaile to Abu Ghairib.

      THAT seperates the men from the boys ;)

  18. Wait for winter, Bandini by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    My room is not fully darkenable, so I need to wait for the winter months so that the marathon can start at 16:00.

  19. self-torture by pradeepe · · Score: 2, Funny

    a fine terrapin-affiliated university on the east coast showed all three movies from 5pm to 4am. what they didn't tell us is that the first two were gonna be the extended cuts (seems like they didn't know this actually), and we winded up having a grand total of twenty minutes between each movie to get our food on... around the time the eagles landed, there were people in the theater who were laughing uncontrollably for no reason except that wait, they're eagles! hahahahah! HA! good stuff though. i'll never do it again.

    1. Re:self-torture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      around the time the eagles landed, there were people in the theater who were laughing uncontrollably for no reason except that wait, they're eagles!
      Yeah, I'd imagine I'd need a fairly sizable supply of weed to sit through a twelve hour movie myself.

      Gandalf : "All we have to decide is what to do with the time we are given."
      Merry and Pippin : I'll take the finest weed in the West Farthing, please G-Man
    2. Re:self-torture by Brandybuck · · Score: 1

      there were people in the theater who were laughing uncontrollably for no reason except that wait, they're eagles! hahahahah!

      What I thought was funniest, was after eleven hours everyone's eyeballs shrinking and imploding into puffs of flame the same time Sauron's did...

      --
      Don't blame me, I didn't vote for either of them!
  20. My uni did this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It was from about 2pm to midnight, I think I was the only one to stay for all three. And no I didn't sleep.

  21. I work by mattboston · · Score: 1

    in a NOC that has five 61" large rear projection screens. We really only need four to monitor the network. So while I'm on weekend shift, I plan on using one of them to watch all three, since my shift is 12 hours and I'm the only one on my shift :)

    1. Re:I work by JohnnyComeLately · · Score: 1
      On a Related News Note:

      Sprint network goes down for 12 hours before technician catches it and fixes it. Phone company rep stated, "Hey, he was watching RotK! You're lucky the network came up at all that day."

  22. In the next month or so... by _LORAX_ · · Score: 1

    I'm going to be screening all of them together in my just redone movie room with a 8' wide screen from DLP projector. I will have to re-arrange the furnature some in order to get 12 or so people in the room at the same time.

    Between that and fresh stove popped corn, it should be a hit with the gang. I have already done the first two in a row before ROTK came out in theaters and I expect that this one will go the full 11-12 hrs easy.

  23. Finally seeing the third installment.... by Alpha27 · · Score: 2, Funny

    ...I doubt I would ever do a marathon of the series.

    It was plain boring in many sections of the movie that we began to improvise by doing a bit of Mystery Science Theater 3000 ourselves of the movie.

    Some things came up:
    - Hobbit love. Those guys REALLY dig each other.
    - The akwardly long glances in the end of the movie were too long to take seriously, with the causal smiles thrown by the Hobbit characters, you begin to wonder what else does that ring do to them.
    - Alot of pot references in the movie.
    - The main human character turns down the advances of a human princess. "I can't give you the love you desire" Dude, it's free *boink boink* and you're turning it down?!!? Refer to Hobbit Love.
    - It took the White Wizard nearly an hour to ride to the top of the castle. Yes we knew it was a BIG castle when we first saw the grand shots, now you take us on a roadtrip to the top.
    - Why did it take 3 movies to get to the volcano? Everytime we get to a checkpoint, we get a reminder of the volcano and see it in the distance. This is the longest roadtrip in HISTORY. What ever happened to horses? What about those HUGE birds?

    If I were to watch the movies again, it would be to write a guide on how to watch them all in less time.

    1. Re:Finally seeing the third installment.... by DocSbaitso · · Score: 1

      Hobbit love? We got really bored towards the end of the second movie, and wanted the Ents to find the Entwives just because that kind of stuff will sell on the internet!

      --
      Hello, my name is Doctor Sbaitso. I am here to help you.
  24. No by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...because I fell asleep in the middle of the first movie, never mind the third.

  25. Band of Brothers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Well... I was planning a Band of Brothers marathon but I haven't found the time yet.

    Are there any kind of health issues from being sit and still for 10 hours straight? I mean, like the people who die for being many hours sitting on a plane?

  26. for a *real* challenge... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    Watch the extended versions, and pass around a joint every time they mention 'pipeweed.' I'm not a big smoker myself (if you know what I mean) but even the real stoners in the group found it hard to keep up. The rest of us were so high, we didn't even know where the phone was. Heeeelp!

    You'll forgive me posting as anonymous coward. Employers have ears!

  27. Hehe by Punboy · · Score: 1

    We're waiting until they release the version edited so all 3 movies are run together into one big 10 hour epic :-D I actually think they're doing it... I hope they'er doing it... THEY'D BETTER BE DOING IT! *raises fist* We have watched the 3rd movie, however. We just couldn't wait to see it again.

    --
    If you like what I've said here, and want to read more, go to http://www.krillrblog.com
  28. Wait for Peter Jackson's Version by TagPopper · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I think he's going to recut the whole thing into one 14 hours long "Complete" version. Another whole weekend stuck in the house. To complete my fantasy movie series musings - Episode III will suck even more. Harry Potter will die. Hopefully not as a virgin. Support literacy. Eat alphabet crackers.

  29. Hollywood special FXathon by Peter+Cooper · · Score: 1

    Eight hours of a Hollywood special-FXathon? No thanks. If I wanted to watch actors get chased by special effects for nine hours, I'd play a computer game, where at least I could keep my actions consistent :-) (unlike that wizard in FOTR who was invincible in all those fights, then fell down a hole in the mountain!!)

    1. Re:Hollywood special FXathon by mbw314 · · Score: 1

      Hollywood special-FXathon? No thanks. If I wanted to watch actors get chased by special effects for nine hours...

      Um, you do know the movie was made entirely in New Zealand, right?

    2. Re:Hollywood special FXathon by Scooter · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Indeed - and did Mr Cooper pay attention when he watched FOTR? There was the small matter of the Balrog, who dragged "the wizard" down "the hole". He didn't just fall. The two Maiar spirits then fought for about 10 days before Olorin (who was variously known as Gandalf, Mithrandir, The Grey Pilgrim etc by the peoples of Middle Earth) finally slew the un-named Balrog (known only as "Durin's Bane").

  30. LOTR:ROTK by Oshkoshjohn · · Score: 1

    I watched the first two movies on Sunday, and then purchased and watched the third movie on Wednesday. I have read the books enough times that I could have slept through any part of it and not known I missed anything!

    --
    Goddamned kids! Get off my lawn!
  31. The Hobbit Cartoon by dmitri2060 · · Score: 1

    Just watched the Hobbit Cartoon. Does that count?