Slashdot Mirror


Mass OLPC Production Begins

eldavojohn writes to tell us that mass production of the first XO laptops has officially started. "The commencement of mass production means children in developing nations could have the rugged, open-source laptops in hand starting this month. The OLPC has already announced orders for kids in Uruguay and Mongolia. (Residents of the U.S. and Canada participating in the Give 1 Get 1 program--which donates an XO to a child in a developing nation for every machine sold online--are expected to start getting laptops in December.)"

167 comments

  1. And since I'm fat... by RandoX · · Score: 4, Funny

    ...I'll still be around to get mine!

    1. Re:And since I'm fat... by DaSmoove · · Score: 1

      Not sure if it's been brought up before but shouldn't developing countries be concerned with having electricity in all of their cities and towns? Crap...I think kids should be taught to read first before they get a computer in the States!

    2. Re:And since I'm fat... by Anomolous+Cowturd · · Score: 2, Insightful

      To get electricity into all their towns they're going to need electricians, draughtsmen, civil engineers, town planners, surveyors, miscellaneous paper-shufflers and so on. To get those they're going to need education.

      --
      Software patents delenda est.
    3. Re:And since I'm fat... by cHiphead · · Score: 1

      In educated kapitalist Amerika, computer teaches kid to read. (really, they do, edubuntu and gCompris played a big part in teaching my son before kindergarten ever came around)

      Cheers.

      --

      This is my sig. There are many like it, but this one is mine.
    4. Re:And since I'm fat... by mrbluze · · Score: 4, Funny

      To get electricity into all their towns they're going to need electricians, draughtsmen, civil engineers, town planners, surveyors, miscellaneous paper-shufflers and so on. To get those they're going to need education. Not to mention accountants and lawyers, but if they get those before they get electricity, then they are probably never going to get anything, because it would have been deemed too expensive and illegal in any case.
      --
      Do it yourself, because no one else will do it yourself. [beta blockade 10-17 Feb]
    5. Re:And since I'm fat... by Zaatxe · · Score: 2, Informative

      Not sure if it's been brought up before but...
      Yes, it's been brought before, a million times every single time OLPC was mentioned.

      ...shouldn't developing countries be concerned with having electricity in all of their cities and towns?
      I've never been to Uruguay, although I live less than 1000 Km from it, but I have friends who have been there and based on what they say, I'm pretty sure there is electricity all over the country. And (who would say that?) they even have some nice stuff like cellphones and TV sets!

      --
      So say we all
    6. Re:And since I'm fat... by RyuuzakiTetsuya · · Score: 3, Funny

      nuh uh

      my tech tree says Metallurgy, Magnetism, Gunpowder, Physics, Invention, University, Navigation, Engineering, Philosophy, Astronomy, Construction, Literacy, Mathematics, Mysticism, Currency, Iron Working, Code of Laws, Writing, Map Making, The Wheel, Masonry, Ceremonial Burial, Bronze Working, Alphabet

      --
      Non impediti ratione cogitationus.
    7. Re:And since I'm fat... by galoise · · Score: 2, Insightful

      i laugh my ass off everytime i see this kind of comment. It would seem that people form the "developed world" think that everywhere else people live in the jungle sorrounded by monkeys. Electricity!? pleeeease.

      Now, of course there ARE people living in huts in the jungle in some "developing" countries, but these ARE NOT the target population of the OLPC initiative, they are the UN's peace keeping operations and humanitarian initiatives target population

      --
      entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem
  2. How about by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Interesting

    Give 2, get 0. Why would anyone want one of these other than for novelty? It'll sit in your closet after you mess around with it for an hour.

    1. Re:How about by sm62704 · · Score: 4, Funny

      Yes, but imagine a beowolf cluster of... OW! OW! STOP HITTING ME!

      --
      mcgrew's razor: Never attribute to stupidity that which can be explained by greedy self-interest
    2. Re:How about by jay-be-em · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I agree, I probably wouldn't want one much for myself, but I am considering doing
      this and giving one to my 8yo niece who is starting to mess around with computers.

      I need to do a bit more research about what exactly she could do with the machine
      though...

      --
      "Orthodoxy means not thinking--not needing to think. Orthodoxy is unconsciousness." --Eric Blair
    3. Re:How about by schwaang · · Score: 3, Informative

      They do have a donation-only option, so you can do that if you want.

      But plenty of geeks could use the XO for more than a toy. It's screen would make a good e-book reader. It's fast resume and long battery life, light weight, and solid state disk make it better than a standard laptop for grab-and-go type uses.

      I won't drag my laptop everywhere, and my cellphone is too small and keyboard-less to use for much web/email or ssh. The XO fits nicely between the two. It looks very useful to me.

    4. Re:How about by blindd0t · · Score: 3, Funny

      Yes, I can definitely imagine that. Running a large cluster off the hand-cranks would quite a nice exercise routine.

    5. Re:How about by DrXym · · Score: 1, Insightful

      That depends on what is loaded on it. If it's Sugar and all that then I agree. If it's flashed (or can be flashed) with a cut down Fedora, Firefox, OpenOffice etc. then it's an enormously useful, rugged, mobile computer, perfect for travel, lectures, coffee shops etc. Having said that, I ordered my Eee PC today since it appears more consumer oriented than the OLPC.

    6. Re:How about by pdxdada · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I'm buying one of these because I want to have a computer I don't have to worry about. This thing is designed to be dropped, to have stuff spilled on it, to thrown in a bag. I'm buying one of these because I travel a lot and when I travel all I want to do is check my e-mail, read some documents, and maybe take some notes and not worry that every bump or drop of my bag will spell doom for my laptop. And finally I'm buying one because it can do all those things and if I do manage to kill it, lose it or it gets stollen at $400 it's not the end of the world. Call it a toy if you want, but I've wanted something similar for quite a while and I do plan to get a lot of use out of mine.

      --
      Don't mess with the bunny, outsideworld.org
    7. Re:How about by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why would anyone want one of these other than for novelty? It'll sit in your closet after you mess around with it for an hour.

      Not really, for example: a lot of the work I do requires only a Web browser, Web server, PHP MySQL (or SQLite if resources are tight) and Vim. The OLPC can handle that nicely. One other thing that really appeals to me is the reading mode. Documentation can be read on the road without worrying that the battery will run out. Have a look at the hardware specs:

      This Liquid-crystal display is the basis of our extremely low power architecture. The XO is usable while the CPU and much of the motherboard is regularly turned off (and on) so quickly that it's imperceptible to the user. Huge power savings are harvested in this way (e.g. by turning stuff on the motherboard off when it's not being used (if even for a few seconds), while keeping the display on)

      Even if you don't buy one, the XO has advanced laptop technology in some interesting ways.

    8. Re:How about by hedwards · · Score: 1

      Honestly, I've considered it. As somebody that is pretty into photography, the ability to view images on a respectable screen in the middle of nowhere is actually surprisingly helpful. Trust me the screens on those is infinitely better than even the biggest screens on a quality dslr.

      All one would need would be something to charge the camera, and an external storage device, and it would mean that one wouldn't have to come in for months at a time. I don't think that most would want to stay out that long, but one could.

    9. Re:How about by bfields · · Score: 1

      I got to play with one for a few minutes recently. I wasn't convinced it would be a great general-purpose computer for an adult: the keys aren't designed for full-sized fingers, and it seemed slow.

      But I have to admit, it's absolutely adorable.

    10. Re:How about by mrbluze · · Score: 1

      Give 2, get 0. Why would anyone want one of these other than for novelty? It'll sit in your closet after you mess around with it for an hour. I want two for my kids. That way I don't have to worry about them trashing my fancynancy uberpriced mac.
      --
      Do it yourself, because no one else will do it yourself. [beta blockade 10-17 Feb]
    11. Re:How about by psychicsword · · Score: 1

      I would go for the Eee for that though

    12. Re:How about by ILuvRamen · · Score: 1

      Why would anyone want one of these other than for novelty
      PORN! Didn't you read the previous article a couple months ago about how all the kids with OLPC's were using them to download porn....which brings up my other point, if they're only just producing them now, where did the ones from before come from? If I remember correctly, A LOT had been distrubted. As in enough to be considered mass production.
      --
      Google's Super Secret Search Algorithm: SELECT @search_results FROM internet WHERE @search_results = 'good'
    13. Re:How about by evilviper · · Score: 1

      The XO fits nicely between the two. It looks very useful to me.

      Really? It looks like a flattened watermelon to me...
      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    14. Re:How about by helifex · · Score: 1

      I'd love to get my hands on these for internal business use. I have an excellent application for them.

    15. Re:How about by RealGrouchy · · Score: 2, Funny

      OW! OW! STOP HITTING ME! Too bad. Hitting you recharges my XO laptop battery.

      - RG>
      --
      Hey pal, this isn't a pleasantforest, so don't waste my time with pleasantries!
    16. Re:How about by Hamoohead · · Score: 2, Funny

      Yes, but does it run Li. . .OW! OW! Hit him! Hit him!

      --
      "If your parents never had children, chances are you wonât either." -Dick Cavett
    17. Re:How about by corsec67 · · Score: 2, Informative

      None of those are a problem for an ebook reader with some extras. The sunlight readable display is very useful compared to most laptop screens.

      If I got one, I would use it for reading books out in the field when I am doing some Wildland Firefighting. Low power consumption, nice display, and durability are of more use there than the keyboard layout.

      --
      If I have nothing to hide, don't search me
    18. Re:How about by ggeens · · Score: 1

      Why would anyone want one of these other than for novelty?

      My 3 year old daughter wanted one the first time she saw it. Sadly, I can't get one here in Europe...

      --
      WWTTD?
    19. Re:How about by petermgreen · · Score: 1

      My 3 year old daughter wanted one the first time she saw it. Sadly, I can't get one here in Europe...
      I'm sure they will show up on ebay once the "give one get one" shipments start.

      Presumablly there will be a color difference or something so that you can tell the machine is one sold to a first worlder and not stolen from a third world kid.

      --
      note: i'm known as plugwash most places but i screwd up registering that here somehow in the past and now can't register
    20. Re:How about by AVee · · Score: 1

      Anyone buying one should do so for some child somewhere. It looks like it's not going to be available in Europe, but i've got a kid here who would have more fun with this then a PS3, and frankly, I'd rather give hime a XO laptop too.

      The thing is aimed at children from the very beginning, when there is no child to use it it will indeed end up in the closet somewhere. It's just another useless toy for most geeks, but it's supposed to be usefull and fun for any child anywhere.

  3. Internet by dslmodem · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Do they come with free internet? Or a low cost internet option?

    --

    ^(oo)^pig~

    1. Re:Internet by physicsboy500 · · Score: 5, Informative

      Do they come with free internet? Or a low cost internet option? yes

      From that article:
      However, the latest twist in the story is nothing but positive. T-Mobile is now offering a year of free Hot Spot Wi-Fi access, good at nearly 8,500 public T-Mobile Hot Spot locations throughout the country, including Starbucks coffee shops, Borders bookstores, and more than 70 major airports across the United States.

      The offer is only good from November 12 to 26, and considering a 12-month T-Mobile Hot Spot plan would cost $359 on its own, we can see how this could lead to a lot of OLPC purchases. OLPC has set up a Web site, laptopgiving.org, which has more details.
      --
      The original generic sig.
    2. Re:Internet by jay-be-em · · Score: 1

      No thanks, I'll just head down the street to the locally owned place and use their net
      for free, on my spacious thinkpad keyboard.

      disclaimer: Probably getting an OLPC.

      --
      "Orthodoxy means not thinking--not needing to think. Orthodoxy is unconsciousness." --Eric Blair
    3. Re:Internet by dslmodem · · Score: 1

      Thanks. I am also interested in the similar offers in those countries where OLPC should make bigger impact.

      Who gave my post a "flamebeit" mark?

      --

      ^(oo)^pig~

    4. Re:Internet by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Physicsboy500 as AC:
      Unfortunately /. mod system doesn't allow anyone to see who modded what, but know that a "flamebait" modding was undeserved.

      As for free internet elsewhere, I know that OLPC was at one point making an effort to develop a peer-to-peer system where if there was only one connection available and a lot of XO PC's in an area, they would form a network p2p cluster to share the bandwidth. I'm not sure on the development status or if it was implemented, but for the developing nations this is targeted to it's great because an entire village only needs 1 or 2 high-speed connections. The result won't be a particularly fast internet experience, but it should get the job done in the meantime.

    5. Re:Internet by DragonWriter · · Score: 1

      As for free internet elsewhere, I know that OLPC was at one point making an effort to develop a peer-to-peer system where if there was only one connection available and a lot of XO PC's in an area, they would form a network p2p cluster to share the bandwidth.


      That's the OLPC's Mesh Networking feature. Also, the project, IIRC, received donations of satellite time from a company that was providing low-cost satellite uplink stations so that remote villages with school servers could connect to the internet. With that and the mesh networking capability, you've got a link from the laptop to the internet, at least in the immediate surroundings of the school server.

      Lots of the networking "activities" of the OLPC are designed around working with a local ad hoc network without relying on connecting to the internet, too.
  4. If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    OLPC is a thinly-veiled attempt by corporations to create the next generation of IT "professionals" they can ship in to work for a third of what you charge. They're really laughing it up that they can do this is under the guise of a humanitarian gesture and get all the tax breaks to boot. There will be no Americans in IT in 20 years.

    1. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by $RANDOMLUSER · · Score: 5, Insightful

      OLPC is a thinly-veiled attempt by corporations to create the next generation of IT "professionals" they can ship in to work for a third of what you charge. They're really laughing it up that they can do this is under the guise of a humanitarian gesture and get all the tax breaks to boot. There will be no Americans in IT in 20 years.
      Not with an attitude like that. You're not entitled to a high-paying job, you have to compete for it. The way to compete is to stay educated. Provide more value than "someone working for a third of what you do now".

      But a nice troll, nonetheless.
      --
      No folly is more costly than the folly of intolerant idealism. - Winston Churchill
    2. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by jay-be-em · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I remain at a loss as to why so many of my fellow Americans seem to believe
      that by being born within these borders they deserve a job.

      Having lived and worked in a developing African country I would much rather
      see jobs go to people who work their asses off with few educational and
      technical resources than to lazy Americans who don't even appreciate
      the educational opportunities available here.

      Fortunately not all Americans are as such, and those few will remain
      competitive, by working their asses off, just as it should be, not by
      being born with the national silver spoon in their mouths.

      --
      "Orthodoxy means not thinking--not needing to think. Orthodoxy is unconsciousness." --Eric Blair
    3. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So they're going to outsource my dbadmin/business analyst position to someone who can't speak english? Unlikely.

    4. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by sjf · · Score: 1
      Note for the approximately six billion people who DON'T live in the US. He means "if you work in IT in the United States in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC".
      Otherwise welcome this aid to competiting with your most valuable resource: the minds of your people.

      There will be no Americans in IT in 20 years

      Pssh, let me sell you some long term options then.

    5. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Prosperity brings with it the fear of losing prosperity.

      However, if anyone is going to fleece American's of their prosperity it's the people who already have power, not the ones with a crank-driven laptop.

    6. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Frankly if you're finding that people in developing countries are able to
      duplicate your skill-set, that's probably a sign that you need to spend
      more time enriching yours.

    7. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by sm62704 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Or thought much about it, or knows what a third world country is like. How can I compete with someone who only pays $30 a month for rent, can take his family to a nice restaraunt for a dollar, or ride anywhere in the country for a nickle? Not even by doing away with such luxuries like electricity and running water could I compete with that!

      That was what Thailand was like in 1974 (USAF at the end of the Vietnam war). You can't compete with "dirt cheap".

      -mcgrew

      --
      mcgrew's razor: Never attribute to stupidity that which can be explained by greedy self-interest
    8. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Not to worry. Without a Microsoft OS, nobody can get an MCSE using these things. You should be safe :-)

    9. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by xappax · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Outsourcing is shitty, but the solution isn't to keep third world kids stupid and computer-illiterate. We need to demand that US corporations take more responsibility for the local workers and towns who have carried them this far. Big business will screw over local workers as much as they can get away with, but we can reign them in as a society simply by demanding more than low, low prices. Support local businesses, boycott unethical/irresponsible companies. We don't need to resort to sabotaging the educational systems of other countries.

    10. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by cthulu_mt · · Score: 0

      You can't compete with "dirt cheap". Target is doing a good job of competing with Wal-Mart at the moment. To compete with low cost you have add value to your product.

      For example my company has a programming group in India that may all be unemployeed soon. They have gotten sloppy and lazy. If you don't have a quality product price advantage won't last.

      Not that high price is good; look at the American auto companies.
      --
      Virginia is for lovers. EVE is for griefers.
    11. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by _KiTA_ · · Score: 1

      Not with an attitude like that. You're not entitled to a high-paying job, you have to compete for it. The way to compete is to stay educated. Provide more value than "someone working for a third of what you do now".

      But a nice troll, nonetheless.


      I shouldn't have to compete with every twit in every 3rd world country willing to work for the cost of a soda a day.

      Globalization is a horrible, horrible idea for everyone involved -- except the corporations.

    12. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by moderatorrater · · Score: 1

      There will be no Americans in IT in 20 years. That's one possibility. The other possibility is that, as they become more technically skilled, their standard of living will rise, the economy will build up with an influx of cash from foreign corporations, and they will become consumers of the products that IT makes as well, increasing demand in their own country until it gets to the point where they are trying to outsource to other nations.
    13. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by JewGold · · Score: 1

      News flash: many people in the 3rd world have learned English. Have you called into a tech support or customer service line this century?

      100% of IT positions don't need to be exported/given to immigrants to drag down the average wage, just enough so the supply outweighs the demand. Then the screws will really be applied (even more than it they have already) to the American worker.

      --
      Is this a news report or a trailer for a motion picture?
    14. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by jsebrech · · Score: 1

      Fortunately not all Americans are as such, and those few will remain
      competitive, by working their asses off, just as it should be, not by
      being born with the national silver spoon in their mouths.


      So, the way "it should be" according to you is that everyone has to work their asses off just to be able to make an honest living? Enjoy that life, I know I won't. There's nothing wrong with wanting time to enjoy life, time to learn to play an instrument, to play soccer with your kids, and time to watch a good movie with a friend and not have to worry about a project's deadline.

      In the west we've had the luxury of choice when it comes to how we spend our time. The challenge is to bring this choice to everyone all over the world, not to give up this choice. There is nothing wrong with wanting the choice to spend time away from work.

    15. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      By working our asses off?

      So what, we should do 80, 100 hour work weeks because a small percentage of third world schmucks are willing to?

      We should never see our families because 0.5% of Indian men don't mind never seeing theirs?

      That's fucking bullshit. Read up about the labor movements in your country. Westerners developed these tools, and we're entitledto the basic worker protections (i.e., 40 hour workweek) that our forefathers - the same ones who later developed IT - fought for.

      Just because you put your faith in the market doesn't mean we have to.

    16. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by das_magpie · · Score: 1

      Yeah you might be right but I guarantee once these people become more educated from using there new computers and acquire great jobs in the west and find out what its like to be on call 24x7 365 they will change there mind about working for the lowest rates possible.

      That is human nature. No one likes to get ripped off and everyone is fickle at times.

    17. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by torkus · · Score: 1

      Actually yes. We (meaning americans, our money, our people, etc.) built OUR COUNTRY up to the current state that it is (horrible political structure not withstanding). So yes. I DO deserve a job here over some kid in a third world country that can barely count his fingers.

      'Working your ass off' varies hugely. I might have a busy 12 hour day where I sit at my ergonomic desk in my ergonomic chair, with blinds to keep the glare of the sun up on the 51st floor on my office high-rise in financial NYC out of my eyes sending emails, making decisions, creating documentation and participating in meetings. I'd say i worked pretty hard that day. Compared to a 16 hour shift in a coal mine or scrounging garbage for metal to recycle i've got it pretty easy.

      Guess what? As one of the benefits that my parents (and ancestors) have passed on to me, i get to have a much nicer 'hard day'. Maybe some of these third world countries should try doing something other than breeding more poor, diseased, hungry children. The US managed to avoid that route after all. So have plenty of other countries.

      --
      You can get rich if you own a politician, but you have to be rich to buy one in the first place.
    18. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by MrSteveSD · · Score: 1

      It's kind of a conspiratorial diversion, but you do raise an important issue. When corporations are under threat from foreign competition, they go crying to government who then step in and protect them in various ways using our hard earned money. In contrast, when we are under threat, it is apparently tough and a case of "how dare we expect a well paid job just because we spent years studying hard".

      How can you compete with an equivalently intelligent person in a country where the cost of living is so much lower? Anything you try to do to get the upper hand, they can do too. As communications technology improves, this problem is only going to get worse. Eventually company CEOs themselves may be replaced with cheaper versions from overseas, but as amusing and satisfying as this will be, it won't help people who have lost jobs to outsourcing. Then again, perhaps when globalisation starts hurting the rich as well, we will start to see some government action over the issue.

    19. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by truesaer · · Score: 2, Insightful

      All of this babbling about hard work misses the point...if hard work was what determined value then fruit pickers would make a ton of money. It's not hard work, it's your ability to provide value that matters. As work currently done by americans is offshored we need to respond by providing higher value services. Less simple code jockeying are more software architecture and design, that kind of thing. Keep upgrading your skills, they set you apart much more than simple hard work ever can.

    20. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Ed+Avis · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I shouldn't have to compete with every twit in every 3rd world country willing to work for the cost of a soda a day.
      Maybe you think that, but the person paying the wages probably thinks otherwise. Since they are paying the bills, their opinion counts. You are, of course, free to start a company employing only workers on Western salaries if you believe that's how it should be. Let whichever provides the best service win.
      --
      -- Ed Avis ed@membled.com
    21. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by failedlogic · · Score: 1

      Denying support to the OLPC is silly. People in developing countries need modern-technologies and education if they are survive, become productive members of their own societies. If you want to be more crude, if they don't become educated and realize that 1 billion people in a food and water-poor country is a bad thing and not sustainable, we're all in for a world of hurt. And religious-rights groups sure as heck aren't helping by denying condoms and safe-sex education. But onwards with the 'tech' discussion.

      The OLPC is also a great idea because it promotes lower energy use in computing. I'm all for Quad-core pentiums and such, but my system is generally off and I use my laptop so as not to use too much power for web-browsing and such. I also turn on as many power-saving features as I can at work. I don't know that the OLPC will take-off in corporate America, but, something like the Asus EEE PC, has a good chance.

      Besides, trying to deny persons in developing countries the ability to use the OLPC for fear of "losing your job" is ludicrous. While there is a possibility, these countries will eventually I would hope, create their own I.T. support infrastructures requiring people trained in their fields. And I would hope, some software developers may come about and sell domestically or abroad. The only 'problem' I would see with this is the idea that security auditing in software, protection from financial scams during purchase and good UI design will be issues. I'd say, that as the markets mature, and laws are introduced or respected that this will self-regulate.

    22. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I shouldn't have to compete with every twit in every 3rd world country willing to work for the cost of a soda a day.
      If you can't even compete with twits willing to work for the cost of a soda a day, then you don't deserve to have cushy high-paying job anyway. If you can't do anything more than some idiot with no real education operating out of a shack in Indonesia, why should you get any more money? A fancy job isn't a right, it's a privilege, and you have to prove you deserve it by being more capable than people who are willing to work for less. If I were a customer of your employer, why should I have to pay an order of magnitude more money just so you can do a job that any moron with an internet connection will do for pennies? Provide some value or quit whining.
    23. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by vertinox · · Score: 1

      Not with an attitude like that. You're not entitled to a high-paying job, you have to compete for it. The way to compete is to stay educated. Provide more value than "someone working for a third of what you do now".

      Actually, I suspect in 10 to 20 years my job will be replaced by robots leaving me and the kid from Africa out of work.

      But seriously, people think that being educated and working hard gets you an automatic good job that you can keep, but it is really about intelligent applied effort. If your job can be automated, then you'll be out of work fairly shortly.

      The trick is to be the ones doing the automation. Doesn't matter if you live in the US, China, or Africa for that. Just focus on a job that is about creating automation in IT.

      Of course once you learn how to automate those who make the automation, then you won't need humans anymore for IT beyond initial infrastructure setup. We aren't there yet but we are getting close.

      --
      "I am the king of the Romans, and am superior to rules of grammar!"
      -Sigismund, Holy Roman Emperor (1368-1437)
    24. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by rbanffy · · Score: 1

      When you fail to understand why you lose your job to someone who costs a third of what you do, yet can do everything you do, it's time to learn something new. I suggest something around Economics 101.

      Maybe you will be jobless, but, at least, you will know why.

    25. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Antique+Geekmeister · · Score: 1

      Hey, I'll be employed as the "last guy in the country who actually knows how the silly thing really works". I make a fairly decent living showing youngsters how to really make it work, and the foreign high-tech people are often easier to impress: they're not used to disbelieving what the textbook said.

    26. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by bigstrat2003 · · Score: 1

      Except we're talking about IT here. For the part of IT that includes things like server and network administration, what you say is plausible, but for end-user support it isn't. Someone needs to be on-site to do this stuff, ie, living in the US. End-user support isn't a job that can be easily outsourced, because you need to still have the guy there who knows how the hell to insert a PCI card.

      --
      "16MB (fuck off, MiB fascists)" - The Mighty Buzzard
    27. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      More importantly, when the 3rd world has caught up with the 1st world thanks in part to things like the OLPC, they will demand similar wages as us. Getting them out of the dirt poor situation only hurts us temporarily. After they are caught up, you are just competing with peers again, and there are no dirt poor people to outsource to.

    28. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by spisska · · Score: 1

      So yes. I DO deserve a job here over some kid in a third world country that can barely count his fingers.

      So how many languages do you speak? I've met lots of people in Africa and Asia whom you would probably judge can't 'count their fingers' but they can speak English as a fourth or fifth language.

      'Working your ass off' varies hugely. I might have a busy 12 hour day where I sit at my ergonomic desk in my ergonomic chair, with blinds to keep the glare of the sun up on the 51st floor on my office high-rise in financial NYC out of my eyes sending emails, making decisions, creating documentation and participating in meetings. I'd say i worked pretty hard that day.

      Sitting on your ass all day doing easy things is not 'working your ass off'. That's the benefit of a university education -- one can complain about a 'hard day' because one had to write some emails, make some decisions, and talk on the phone for a while. Try working a real 'hard day' and you'll see the difference. You probably interact with folks every day who work their asses off for next to nothing, but but you just don't care about that, do you. Probably too busy talking on the phone and writing emails.

      As one of the benefits that my parents (and ancestors) have passed on to me, i get to have a much nicer 'hard day'.

      Undoubtedly a though that Czar Nicholas would agree with. Things ended badly for him. You deserve nothing because of your ancestors. Prove yourself in an open marketplace. If I buy your services, I decide what you are worth.

      Maybe some of these third world countries should try doing something other than breeding more poor, diseased, hungry children. The US managed to avoid that route after all. So have plenty of other countries.

      Maybe you should realize that the 'third world' hasn't existed for quite some time, and that the inhabitants of many of these countries don't think of themselves as underprivileged. In many countries there are, in fact, fewer poor, diseased, or hungry children than in your US of A. And, if surveys are to be believed, many of them are happier than you are.

      The biggest real difference is and has been the price of and access to capital. In the US, capital has always been relatively cheap, and the penalty for default relatively benign. Education has always been encouraged, if not officially than at least through communities. Elsewhere in the world, capital has been expensive and difficult to come by, failure has meant penury, and education has been throttled by those who would prefer today's slaves to tomorrow's consumers. This is changing rather quickly.

      The America of your father is dead. The US, while still a generator of knowledge, is no longer an exporter but an importer of intellectual capital. And the country is making it harder and harder to import the knowledge it needs, and doing everything it can to encourage the growth of innovative centers elsewhere in the world.

      If you care about the future of the US then this should concern you greatly. America cannot compete on the world market in manufacturing as it had in the past because of abundant resources and cheap labor -- resources are no longer abundant and labor is no longer cheap. Therefore it must compete on quality of service and depth of knowledge. The gap between the US and the rest of the world in this respect narrows by the day.

    29. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by totally+bogus+dude · · Score: 1

      Globalization is a horrible, horrible idea for everyone involved -- except the corporations.

      I think the people that make a decent (by local standards) living from working for overseas companies would disagree with you.

      The only people that are hurt by globalisation are the rich Westerners, i.e. the people who can most afford it. If you've got somewhere to live, money for 3 good meals a day, clothing, and education, then you're pretty damn well off.

    30. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by petermgreen · · Score: 1

      End-user support isn't a job that can be easily outsourced, because you need to still have the guy there who knows how the hell to insert a PCI card.
      That works fine until the guy you are supporting is outsourced too.

      --
      note: i'm known as plugwash most places but i screwd up registering that here somehow in the past and now can't register
    31. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by noamsml · · Score: 1

      So you have more of a right to an IT job than a person in Africa or Asia? Somehow, that strikes me as racist.

    32. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by dan+the+person · · Score: 1

      Yes yes, much better to keep the rest of the world poor and illiterate. That will really shrink our export markets and protect our jobs.

      Oh wait, now i've been layed off because because our sales just shrunk, whoops!

    33. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by AVee · · Score: 1

      Maybe some of these third world countries should try doing something other than breeding more poor, diseased, hungry children. The US managed to avoid that route after all. So have plenty of other countries. Yeah, don't worry, that's being looked into right now. Looking at the US it seems it should involve moving into a land you don't own, kill most of the people who live there and bringing in cheap, disposable even, labour from somewhere you can catch^H^H^H^H^Hhire sla^H^H^H employees.

      Take a look at your at the worlds history, no civilisation ever became big without resorting to oppression, not a single one ever. The US is just another fine example of how that works.
    34. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by sm62704 · · Score: 1

      Apparently everyone on Slashdot is an idiot.

      Well, I know I am.

      There are two ways to compete. One is to offer the same product for less. The other is to offer a better product for more. Since you can't lower your price, improve your product.

      I'm not worried about MY job. I can retire in a couple of years. I'm worried about they guy who's going to put a gun in my face to take my money because he can't find a job and there are no social programs here.

      For every genius, there's someone whose only skill is asking if you want fries with that, and the cost of goods is rising so fast compared to his labor that the minimum wage worker (which is who we're talking about here) is working two jobs and still can't pay the rent.

      In 1968 you could go to McDonald's and get a hamburger, fries, and small coke for less than fifty cents. A Volkswagon beetle was $900. A Corvette was $3,000. The minimum wage was $1.60.

      Today the McLunch is four bucks (although the drinks are now large, medium, and humungous), the Volkswagon is $20,000 and the 'Vette is about $80,000. The Federal minimum wage is $5.85. And some people, like wait staff, don't even make that.

      Wealth doesn't trickle down, it flows up. Every bottom tier worker produces wealth, whether he's a fry cook at McDonalds, a phone jockey in India, or a programmer silicon valley. The wealthy don't produce wealth at all; they merely aggregate it. The working person produces the wealth. When there is such a thing as the "working poor" your society is in serious trouble.

      -mcgrew

      --
      mcgrew's razor: Never attribute to stupidity that which can be explained by greedy self-interest
    35. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by hamvil · · Score: 1

      Denying support to the OLPC is silly. People in developing countries need modern-technologies and education if they are survive, become productive members of their As many other people already pointed out, OLPC's targets do have educations. I've met people from all around the world and so far the less educated were high school students from the US. Very few of them speak a foreign language, they only know American (that means US) history and they consider everything outside the US as third world. As for example I've spoken with a high school student in Texas and she was surprised by the fact that in Italy we do have microwave ovens. So please stop talking about people that cannot even count sing their fingers

    36. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by marcosdumay · · Score: 1

      "How can I compete with someone who only pays $30 a month for rent, can take his family to a nice restaraunt for a dollar, or ride anywhere in the country for a nickle?"

      Make the Dollar worth less than a Peso. But don't worry, your governement is already fixing that problem for you.

      But, of course, that is a hipotetical situation... Or do you really belive you can ride anywhere on Uruguay for cents? It has a small area, but not that much ;)

    37. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by sm62704 · · Score: 1

      When I was in Thailand in the Air Force, you could ride about anywhere for a dollar. A Bhat bus was called that because it cost a bhat to ride. One bhat was equal to five American pennies. You could take a taxi from the extreme south where I was to Burma for three dollars. The big red bus took you to Bankok (middle of the country) for five cents.

      I took three girlfriends (who cost five bucks apiece per night) to a nice restaraunt and got change back from a 20 baht note (one dollar), and that included Pepsis for the girls and a beer for me.

      Some friends and I rented a trawler, inclucing hiring its pilot, for ten bucks for a whole day and night.

      My tealock (kind of a rented wife) cost thirty dollars a month, and came with a bungalow. That's what you're competing with.

      --
      mcgrew's razor: Never attribute to stupidity that which can be explained by greedy self-interest
    38. Re:If you work in IT, you shouldn't support OLPC by jay-be-em · · Score: 1

      Believe it or not there are many very educated people in developing countries. Many whose
      mathematics knowledge goes quite a bit beyond counting their fingers. Some may even exceed
      your skills in mathematics, yes, even you, sitting in your Manhattan high rise.

      Where did your ancestors inherit that wealth from? If you investigate it, much if it you
      may consider illegitimate and stolen -- exploitation of these now 'developing' countries
      all over the world; don't forget that our initial wealth was inherited from the British
      Empire, of which I don't need to enumerate the crimes against these civilizations.

      I don't see anything wrong in giving these people a fighting chance. I find it despicable
      that there are so many out there who would rather continue to maintain the current situation
      in the developing world, however beneficial it may be to our lives. These xenophobic ignorami
      clearly haven't spent any real time outside of their cozy clean safe world.

      --
      "Orthodoxy means not thinking--not needing to think. Orthodoxy is unconsciousness." --Eric Blair
  5. No EEE News??!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    It seems to hottest product right now is the ASUS EEE PC, a Linux based subnotebook, yet I've hardly seen a peep about it on slashdot.

    Slashdot editors are been slurping the OLPC from day one, and now its ignoring something that's better and actually available to people in developed countries. It's sad how behind the times this site is.

  6. It's about time. by Forge · · Score: 3, Interesting

    After following it's development from concept through revised designs and explanation of the rational for it's features.

    Frankly I feel like it's already part mine. Baring unavailability or some weird sales structure, I plan to get one. Or a few.

    What choice do I have when my 15 Month old is monopolizing the main desktop at home?

    --
    --= Isn't it surprising how badly I spell ?
    1. Re:It's about time. by ipjohnson · · Score: 1

      Tell him to stop surfing for porn its daddy's turn?

    2. Re:It's about time. by evilviper · · Score: 1

      What choice do I have when my 15 Month old is monopolizing the main desktop at home?

      A slightly obsolete computer, that will run Linux just fine, is absolutely dirt cheap, and you can pretty easily install the exact software programs that normally run on the OLPC if you want them.

      Unless you are in a situation where you have absolutely no infrastructure (electricity, internet, etc.), I can't see the benefit to getting an OX/OLPC.
      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    3. Re:It's about time. by jabuzz · · Score: 1

      One of the Asus EEE machines? Though they don't have the same physical robustness that the XO has. I would like to get one for my five year old niece, except being in the UK I cannot even get one on a buy one donate one option.

    4. Re:It's about time. by rbanffy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      "Unless you are in a situation where you have absolutely no infrastructure (electricity, internet, etc.), I can't see the benefit to getting an OX/OLPC."

      It's called the XO, not the OX. Apart from that it's small, portable, usable under direct sunlight, wireless, runs Linux and has great battery life.

      I want one too.

      Still, the about USD 400 buy-two-get-one price tag doesn't make much business sense...

    5. Re:It's about time. by timothy · · Score: 1

      The T-Mobile deal really does change the equation (in the happy direction), but I was already 98pct intending to get one.

      Frankly, there are things I don't like about it (I bet the keyboard may drive me crazy, and I'd much prefer it in colors other than anti-theft green), but as a certified laptop abuser (I am required to disclose certain information to all my neighbors) I hope that it can tolerate my penchant for accidental computer mayhem. The ultra-long battery life is right up there, too (in the eBook mode).

      Also, since I think the hardware seems cool enough to be worth $400, full stop, I don't mind getting a warm fuzzy or two about helping send one to Nepal or elsewhere; I'd *rather* buy two for myself (and give the 2d one to my young niece, say) for that money, or get one for $200 instead of $400, but the question of markets is What will the market bear, and at least for me, the asking price is annoyingly well set ;)

      timothy

      --
      jrnl: http://tinyurl.com/c2l8yr / foes: http://tinyurl.com/ckjno5
    6. Re:It's about time. by evilviper · · Score: 0

      it's small, portable, usable under direct sunlight, wireless, runs Linux

      All things very trivially easy to find in an older, normal laptop.

      and has great battery life.

      It has very low power consumption, but also a tiny battery due to cost, so battery life isn't significantly better than common notebooks, unless you plan on spending more money, and upgrading the battery yourself.

      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    7. Re:It's about time. by Rob+Simpson · · Score: 1

      All things very trivially easy to find in an older, normal laptop.

      You've gotta be kidding me. An "older, normal laptop" is over twice the size and twice the weight. Only a used ultraportable (or the Asus eee) could compare to the XO as far as size and portability goes - but the screen definitely wouldn't look very nice under direct sunlight (and if it were usable at all, it'd be at full brightness and power consumption, not with the backlight off for minimum power use), and it would still cost more than this, unless you bought it from a crack addict who stole it. (Wireless is common even for used computers, and what can't run Linux?)

      It has very low power consumption, but also a tiny battery due to cost, so battery life isn't significantly better than common notebooks, unless you plan on spending more money, and upgrading the battery yourself.

      4 to 6 hours per charge isn't significantly better than common notebooks? Are you joking? Not to mention the >8 hours of use as for minimal tasks such as reading e-books, or the manual generator.

    8. Re:It's about time. by evilviper · · Score: 1

      An "older, normal laptop" is over twice the size

      There are tons of smaller notebooks out there. Of course you can't be bothered to spend 60 seconds searching eBay.

      4 to 6 hours per charge isn't significantly better than common notebooks?

      No. 3 hour battery life is quite common. And those are very optimistic figures.
      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    9. Re:It's about time. by evilviper · · Score: 1

      And old Panasonic Toughbook would handle far, far more abuse, and be quite a lot cheaper, while still outperforming the XO. Plus it doesn't look like your notebook is a watermelon someone accidentally sat on...

      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    10. Re:It's about time. by Lectoid · · Score: 1

      I have a 1.5 year old child. What programs do you have your kid use? Most of the stuff I have seen are for kids in school, simple math and word games. I have an old HP tablet that I will let her play with once she can grasp what it is she's doing, but I think that will be a little while longer.

      --
      Is it just me, or do you hate it when people say "Is it just me..."?
    11. Re:It's about time. by Forge · · Score: 1

      He isn't on any particular software yet. He just fiddles with the keyboard and the mouse to see if anything happens. I created a limited user account for him to prevent damage to anything beyond the UI hardware (We had to change 2 keyboards already).

      I am still browsing for pre-kindergarten software. Care to keep in touch so we can share our discoveries?

      --
      --= Isn't it surprising how badly I spell ?
    12. Re:It's about time. by Lectoid · · Score: 1

      Sure. When I caught my girl shaking her sippy cup full of juice over my macbook pro, I then had this distant feeling that maybe a waterproof keyboard is what she needs. Which is why this OLPC sounds like a good thing. my e-mail is my handle on here using google's most excellent electronic mail service.

      --
      Is it just me, or do you hate it when people say "Is it just me..."?
    13. Re:It's about time. by Rob+Simpson · · Score: 1

      There are tons of smaller notebooks out there. Of course you can't be bothered to spend 60 seconds searching eBay.

      I did. Most are a lot more expensive than this, have moving parts, and their backlights have probably dimmed.

      No. 3 hour battery life is quite common. And those are very optimistic figures.

      I didn't say 3 hours. Maybe you are confusing it with the Asus Eee? The most pessismistic figure I could find was just over 4 hours.

    14. Re:It's about time. by evilviper · · Score: 1

      I didn't say 3 hours.

      25% longer battery life isn't "significant" especially when many people just buy a second battery. Not to mention you'll get a lot more done in that 3 hours than you will on an OLPC in 4.
      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
  7. Mods are on crack. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    What fucking racist white ass crackers modded this crap up?

    What gives you the precious ability to hold these people away from IT?

    Why SHOULDN'T they be given a chance to learn? You are a fucking racist white ass!

    Please go die, you fucking American.

    I hate Americans. God save the Queen!

  8. ASUS Eee Review Posted Last Week by vwpau227 · · Score: 2, Informative

    You can't blame Slashdot for this one, there was a post about it last week, see the link at http://hardware.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=07/10/27/1935223 for details.

    --
    These are the good old days you'll be telling your children about. Make them worthwhile.
  9. Re:Made in China? by kurokaze · · Score: 2, Informative

    That's unfair. The problem with the lead in the paint was due to the standards being changed during production. As such, toys that were made prior to the change in standards could not be magically "unmade" and had already reached the retail shelves. Admittedly, some factories in China were using the inferior paint but for those that weren't, they got a raw deal.

    Mattel simply wanted a scapegoat.

  10. Thank you OLPC by Intron · · Score: 3, Funny

    Excellent. I was getting tired of scam email from people in Nigeria. I look forward to the scams that will be coming to me from Uruguay and Mongolia.

    --
    Intron: the portion of DNA which expresses nothing useful.
    1. Re:Thank you OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In Soviet Russia, cliches use YOU.

    2. Re:Thank you OLPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Imagine a Beowulf cluster of whiny ACs...

    3. Re:Thank you OLPC by PMBjornerud · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      Actually, Natalie Portman think memes are cute.

      --
      I lost my sig.
  11. Is it just me by Critical+Facilities · · Score: 4, Funny

    Or is anyone else amused that the name for this laptop, the XO, is an emoticon for a frustrated person yelling? Seems like Microsoft would have nailed that name down. I keed, I keed.

    1. Re:Is it just me by Dogtanian · · Score: 4, Funny

      Microsoft already used the "screwed up face with tongue stuck out in disgust" in the name of their successor to Windows 2000.

      --
      "Slashdot - News and Chat Sites Deviant". (Click "homepage" link above for details).
    2. Re:Is it just me by evilviper · · Score: 1

      Microsoft already used the "screwed up face with tongue stuck out in disgust"

      What's wrong with that? Windows just wants to rock and roll all night, and party ever-ry day.
      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    3. Re:Is it just me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, and interestingly, xo is the word for 'three' in the Tushi language spoken in the Caucausian village of Tzowa...:-)

    4. Re:Is it just me by Portfolio · · Score: 1

      XO is also the name of Sanrio's Badtz-Maru's gang. In Japanese, X is the marking for "incorrect" and O is the marking for "correct" on such things as homework and tests. XO (wrong then right) is a nice metaphor for learning.

  12. Does the picture in TFA remind you of: by backbyter · · Score: 1

    1. The last 5 road construction crews you saw?

    2. The SA's desk when the network drops.

  13. Child Labor by josh61980 · · Score: 1

    Has anyone aside from me looked at TFA. The from picture is several children at the assembly. Just makes me thing of armies of child laborers in underdeveloped countries making laptops for children in other underdeveloped countries.

    1. Re:Child Labor by Anomolous+Cowturd · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Those aren't children. They're young women. Get some glasses.

      --
      Software patents delenda est.
  14. But it's helping N-squared! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    But if you go with the "buy 1 get 1", you are helping Nick Negroponte prove that his "stupid Lunix vaporware bundled with cripled and lame hardware" idea can actually... well, not succeed, but at least get out the door so he can move on to his next high profile failure.

    Now we see how when Teh FOSS Community puts there mind to something, there truly is nothing they can do!

  15. Re:Made in China? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    Even worse, the majority of the recalls were due to design flaws rather than the paint.

    "Chinese manufacturers have taken plenty of heat in the U.S. over recent widespread toy recalls, but U.S. toy maker Mattel says it's mostly to blame. The company says there were flaws in some of the toys' designs."
    "A top Mattel executive took the opportunity to apologize to his Chinese colleagues, saying they were being blamed for simply following flawed design plans."
    http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2007/09/mattel_recall4.html

    The apology from Mattel was too late and too little publicized to change the truthiness of blaming the Chinese.

  16. Wow, a lot of anger surrounding this issue by wattrlz · · Score: 1

    I, myself, will be getting one so I can remain competitive with the next generation of outsourcing going around.

  17. huge boom by tritonman · · Score: 0

    We are going to see a huge boom in downloads of bittorrent clients. Seriously, what are these kids in developing countries going to do with these laptops besides host pirated files and do "research" on wikipedia?

    1. Re:huge boom by Constantine+XVI · · Score: 1

      With the 1GB (IIRC) storage? I doubt it.

      --
      "I think an etch-a-sketch with an ethernet port would beat IE7 in web standards compliance."
  18. Re:Insightful?? by jay-be-em · · Score: 4, Interesting

    There are a lot of arguments relating to this in the book Guns, Germs and Steel.
    I'd recommend checking it out if you haven't. According to the author it comes
    down to geography and (related to geography) the availability of native domesticable
    plant and animal species -- which is the one resource that matters most. The Eurasian
    continent had them, the Americas, Africa and Australia did not.

    It's a fascinating book with loads of information. I understand the difficulty
    people have with the question you pose -- it's not at all obvious. While treating
    these peoples (Native American, South American, Native Australians, Africans ...)
    as inferiors for so long was/is not justified, it's understandable why
    so many people assumed they were an inferior subspecies -- it in fact takes a lot
    of analysis to figure out why their societies are so behind Eurasian based societies.

    Now, I agree the OLPC may not do anything. I think it depends on what is included a lot.
    I worked as a mathematics and physics teacher for a few years in West Africa. In my opinion
    if the OLPC can serve as a substitute for the relatively expensive school books students
    are expected to purchase today it would be a massive help -- and in fact cheaper, OLPC and
    co wouldn't need to give these machines away if they could show the value of them. That's
    all of course beyond the IT educational component of the thing, which seems to be the focus
    at OLPC. From what I've seen on the wiki it looks like the ebooks component of the project
    is pretty undeveloped.

    If the thing was packed full of 12 years of well made interactive textbooks, it would be
    a Godsend. I'm a bit worried though that it's going to be more of a toy that kids play
    around with -- IM, WWW, email, etc.

    Just my 2 cents.

    --
    "Orthodoxy means not thinking--not needing to think. Orthodoxy is unconsciousness." --Eric Blair
  19. Which is why I would like by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    to be able to designate where the 1 goes. In particular, I would like to see my freebie one go to a school in America. We have plenty of under and un educated kids here. We desperately need laptops like this. No more of the silly games like reader rabbit.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  20. Target competing with Walmart is a bad analogy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    as they both are on the same playing field, doing business with the same laws, economy, and regulations.

    A better comparison would be if Target was able to employ slaves paid 12 cents per day to run its cash registers, and started selling only stolen merchandise. Obviously Target would be able to sell its products far cheaper, soon putting Walmart out of business.

    In this analogy you are Walmart and Target (3rd world programmers) will be soon putting you out of business.

  21. Foolish People by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    I am sure that many of you believe that children in 3rd world countries will get one of the laptops. Reality is that they can't even use the laptop, don't have the knowledge or understanding to use it. It will probably end up in the hands of some tyrant dictator, where he will probably sell it to put $25 in his pocket for each one. The third world is a hard place to live, where fairness and honest just don't exist. Great idea, just like food for third world countries, unfortunately the people there still starve.

    1. Re:Foolish People by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I assume (could easily be wrong) that the program will only be donating the machines to nations with enough infrastructure and education to at least be familiar with this type of technology. I certainly don't think my give 1 get 1 will send one to a tribal nation in Africa straight out of "The Gods Must Be Crazy."

    2. Re:Foolish People by Anomolous+Cowturd · · Score: 1

      I hear they eat their own children too, over in that bad ol' third world.

      --
      Software patents delenda est.
  22. Geode LX-700 by Weaselmancer · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It's got a nice processor, the Geode LX-700.

    That's a lot of oomph actually. I know we're all used to our 3ghz desktops, but think about how nice 700mhz(equiv) actually is. I've got a refurbished eMachines 650 in my basement. It plays divx video with no problems.

    You could use one of these as a portable entertainment center easy. Or how about a router? The thing is designed for minimum power draw. Use one in your basement as a router that works the way you want it to work.

    A sub $200 x86 with that kind of horsepower and power specs has hundreds of uses.

    --
    Weaselmancer
    rediculous.
    1. Re:Geode LX-700 by Antique+Geekmeister · · Score: 1

      For a network probing tool or a debugging workstation, it's ideal in a whole lot of ways.

    2. Re:Geode LX-700 by bigredradio · · Score: 1

      refurbished eMachines 650 in my basement. It plays divx video with no problems Hum... what kind of videos do you think he is watching in the basement. ;-)
    3. Re:Geode LX-700 by samwichse · · Score: 1

      From the linked wiki page:
      "CPU clock speed: 433 Mhz"

      400 mhz is workable, but is definitely a little closer to the too slow category than 700.

      That said, I ran a Linux-based media pc in my living room on an old Celeron 400 mhz. Surely the Geode will do better clock for clock than the Celeron did (it did drop some frames in high-motion scenes, but not too many).

  23. Re:Insightful?? by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    If the thing was packed full of 12 years of well made interactive textbooks, it would be a Godsend. I'm a bit worried though that it's going to be more of a toy that kids play around with -- IM, WWW, email, etc.
    And the smart developer will start creating an API for doing nice text books. This is how you get around all the publishing houses. Right now, they have a strangle hold on text books and because of their prices, it causes books to be used as long a decade. Worse, the authors do not get that much (but most are college profs and this is a feather in the hat). The situation with primary education text books is actually worse than the music world; only the labels really make out.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  24. Age of entitlement. by Shivetya · · Score: 2, Insightful

    We have become a nation enslaved to our government through entitlements. The politicians daily spout that YOU deserve this and this, these people over here deserve this, and those over there get to pay for it because their too rich. When jobs are lost overseas the politicians trot out declaring evil corporations are to blame and that these entities need to be penalized; taxed more; to set the balances right.

    We are encouraged to run up debt and then disclaim responsibility for our actions. We can engage in risk behavior and blame does who don't stop us (bartenders, smoking, riding without helmets, etc). We are told constantly that so and so wasn't at fault for murdering people because society, movies, video games, Iraq, etc, made them do it.

    We are bombarded by the very people we elect to believe "It's okay, the government will make it all right" and people buy into this. Its easy to do when your not footing the bill for your actions. Unemployed because you won't learn a viable trade? Its okay, we got help for that. As such we see business practically driven overseas or the jobs go there.

    An entitlement state only exists for as long as the people stuck paying have the means to do so. We won't run out of people to vilify soon, but it is still wrong.

    No, we don't deserve jobs just because we live here, we don't deserve health care, we don't deserve cell phones, we don't deserve fancy cars, we don't deserve high speed net, we don't deserve a lot of things but it never ceases to amaze me what order people put their priorities.

    --
    * Winners compare their achievements to their goals, losers compare theirs to that of others.
    1. Re:Age of entitlement. by kestasjk · · Score: 3, Insightful

      An "entitlement state"? Is this the new buzzphrase that makes a complex situation seem really simple?

      I thought the government was paralyzing us with fear, and helping the rich get richer. Isn't "state of fear" that the current anti-government line?

      The reason the western world has it better than most of the rest of the world is a complex and interesting one, that can't be boiled down to politicians telling us we deserve something or rich people paying for everything good in our lives. All that matters for your argument is that America does have a very high GDP, as does the rest of the developed world. Because we're developed we're more productive; America isn't a country of people on welfare who are all wealthy for some inexplicable reason, businesses don't thrive in the US because the government is stealing from the rich, China accepts US credit for a reason.

      If you don't think we deserve this or that modern convenience then give them up. Don't write on a laptop about how "ohh we are so terrible, we don't deserve laptops and cheese graters, damn government! No Mr Bush I don't deserve this fancy car you say I'm entitled to and that you're willing to pay for at the expense of the rich, give me a horse and buggy like they probably all use in China! I'm going to help the developing world by denying myself the cell phones and cars they manufacture."


      On outsourcing, while I'm writing: My experience with outsourcing is limited to freelance sites like rentacoder.com , where people across the world can bid on software projects. I found that the prices for bids quoted by people in India or Romania or China are right in line with prices I would quote. There are no coders living in tents that will write SQL server for a hundred US dollars.

      A lot of the outsourcing by Microsoft and the like to India Research is often done because it lets them get more done per day; as Redmond goes to sleep Bombay is getting down to work, as Bombay goes to sleep Cambridge is putting the coffee on, as Cambridge goes to sleep Redmond is checking its e-mail and seeing what progress has been made.

      If you're really scared about outsourcing rather than fight the market you should want these countries to develop as quickly as possible so that everyone is on a level playing field. India will have more IT pros, but it'll need them in their own economy.

      --
      // MD_Update(&m,buf,j);
  25. For $400 by torkus · · Score: 0, Troll

    Since you have to buy two to get one...

    I can easily get a "real" laptop for $400 and it's not even black friday. Heck, given that i actually live in a house with a roof (and running water and electricity!) I could buy a desktop. Those can be had for $300 without a big fuss.

    Remind me again why I should care? I mean other than as an excuse for some big company to get a tax write off and free press. Something that would actually help me keep up with the price of gas and heating oil and electricity.

    --
    You can get rich if you own a politician, but you have to be rich to buy one in the first place.
    1. Re:For $400 by pembo13 · · Score: 1

      Well you're actually getting two laptops and donating one. Let me know if you can do that on Black Friday for $400.

      --
      "Thanks for all the money you paid to us. We've used it to buy off ISO among other things" -Microsoft
    2. Re:For $400 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Something that would actually help me keep up with the price of gas and heating oil and electricity.
      For what it's worth, the XO uses much less electricity than other computers. According to this page, a typical laptop idles at 20 watts, while the XO idles at 1 watt.
    3. Re:For $400 by Hatta · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Does your regular laptop have a daylight readable screen? Can you chuck it in the back of your car without a second thought? Does it have a sealed keyboard so you can use it at the beach without a worry? How much does your regular laptop weigh and what is its battery life like?

      --
      Give me Classic Slashdot or give me death!
  26. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 2, Funny

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  27. Since when were we afraid of Linux? by Fryth · · Score: 1

    I'm tired of people saying that good ideas are an attempt at taking away jobs from ignorant people. This is a blatant troll, but I'm biting anyway. If it's really good enough that it'll revolutionize computing, let it happen, and let the best, not most monopolized, system win.

  28. Distribution? by duplicate-nickname · · Score: 1

    With 10's of thousands of these being ordered and shipped to third world countries, has anyone actually thought about how they are going to be distributed? It's kind of like the food programs for poor countries...it is not that there isn't enough money or food, it just nearly impossible to get the resources to the people that actually need it.

    I envision thousands of these laptops sitting in warehouses across the global, with only a handful of "showcase" schools actually receiving and using the laptops.

    Maybe I'm just cynical, but I don't think real problem here is technology or the cost of it.

    --

    ÕÕ

    1. Re:Distribution? by DragonWriter · · Score: 1

      With 10's of thousands of these being ordered and shipped to third world countries, has anyone actually thought about how they are going to be distributed?


      Hundreds of thousands, actually.

      It's kind of like the food programs for poor countries...


      Actually, its not at all like that. Unlike food programs, these aren't being distributed by well-meaning foreign governments or NGOs with no local involvement, they are being, for the most part, purchased by the recipient governments, and delivered (along with associated content, etc.) through their school systems. As has been the vision of the OLPC program from the outset.

      Presumably, the national ministries of education that have decided to spend tens of millions of dollars purchasing computers have put some thought in how they are actually going to deliver them to schools.

      I envision thousands of these laptops sitting in warehouses across the global, with only a handful of "showcase" schools actually receiving and using the laptops.


      Any reason, aside from your prejudices, supporting this image, or is it just your fantasy?

      Maybe I'm just cynical, but I don't think real problem here is technology or the cost of it.


      So, prior to the release of the XO, there was a widely available, low-cost, computer designed for the needs of the education systems in the developing world, but the problem was just the logistics of delivering the systems to end users? I think not. Clearly, whatever other real problems there might have been, the availability of appropriate technology was a real problem.
    2. Re:Distribution? by 1u3hr · · Score: 1
      With 10's of thousands of these being ordered and shipped to third world countries, has anyone actually thought about how they are going to be distributed?

      My God! Call Negroponte immediately. How could they have spent years planning this and missed that? Lucky you noticed, or they'd just have dumped them all in a landfill.

  29. It's not a matter of "entitlement" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It's a matter of people in the 8-figure-plus end of the income scale selling out America to make a buck. The middle class is rapidly, rapidly being eliminated in this country. If something doesn't change, in the near future we will be a country of lords and peasants. And guess what: you won't be one of the lords.

  30. Re:Insightful?? by evilviper · · Score: 1

    the availability of native domesticable
    plant and animal species -- which is the one resource that matters most. The Eurasian continent had them, the Americas, Africa and Australia did not.

    A specious argument that sells books. African and Asian elephants put horses and bulls to shame. America had Buffalo, which would later be domesticated by european settlers, until they became rare, but are still used in less developed countries. The author even mentions Zebras with some bullcrap claim that because they are a bit more aggressive than horses, they can't be restrained (see: bridle and bit) and eventually tamed.

    As for Australia... Now, I don't know if kangaroos can be made to pull a plow, but I'd sure like to see it!
    --
    Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
  31. Re:Insightful?? by CheeseTroll · · Score: 1

    Oh my - that's interesting, in a weird fantasy sort of way. First of all, they're BISON, not buffalo - and yes, there's a difference. I'd love to know which American settlers domesticated these bison prior to shooting down millions of them and nearly wiping them out. Bison are a heckuva lot larger and stronger than European cows, and it is only recently that anyone has been interested in raising them for slaughter. Let me know when you see one hitched to a plow! Finally, no, they are not used in less developed countries, because they *don't exist* in less developed countries.

    Or were you making a joke it just went whoosh over my head?

    --
    A post a day keeps productivity at bay.
  32. Re:Insightful?? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    A specious argument that sells books.

    And the title of the book you wrote that attempts to justify that statement is ... ?

    African and Asian elephants put horses and bulls to shame.

    You might have had an interesting argument brewing here, but with only your second sentence you've shown that you're writing about something you know nothing about. African elephants are damn hard to domesticate, even today. Asian elephants on the other hand are easier to domesticate, and that's why there's been some success in doing so for centuries -- and not just by visiting (a.k.a. conquering) Europeans, but by a host of peoples throughout southeast Asia.

    America had Buffalo, which would later be domesticated by european settlers, until they became rare, but are still used in less developed countries.

    Yeah, domesticated by European settlers WHO INTRODUCED HORSES TO NORTH AMERICA. Prior to that, no horses. (Go on, tell me I'm wrong -- show us all again how clueless you are.) I'd like to see you domesticate a buffalo on foot, chumpy.

    The author even mentions Zebras with some bullcrap claim that because they are a bit more aggressive than horses, they can't be restrained (see: bridle and bit) and eventually tamed.

    Piece of cake again, huh? With no horse to help you, right?

    As for Australia... Now, I don't know if kangaroos can be made to pull a plow, but I'd sure like to see it!

    Personally I'd like to see more jackasses pulling plows. Did you hear that? A job opening for you!

  33. Ask Slashdot: Will You Be Getting One? by timothy · · Score: 1

    I've been wiggling back and forth on it ... the $400 (buy 2 get 1) OLPC costs nearly as much (really!) as I've made in a semester of TAing for two law-school classes, but I do plan to get one with that money.

    Are you planning to get one? Why / Why not?

    timothy

    --
    jrnl: http://tinyurl.com/c2l8yr / foes: http://tinyurl.com/ckjno5
  34. Soekris instead by FranTaylor · · Score: 1

    You can get a soekris board with the same processor and 4 network ports if you want to make a router.

  35. Some background from Uruguay by Acer500 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I'm from Uruguay (the country that has actually gone out and bought the XOs), and... it's not at all like you imagine it.

    We have electricity and running water everywhere, better literacy than the US and public education for everyone (better than that of the US if Slashdot whining is to be believed !)

    On the other hand, average wages are about U$ 300/month, and so a computer is a luxury item for most, and very especially for parents of school-age children like the ones which will be the recipient of the XO.

    You can read at the unofficial Proyecto Ceibal blog (the Uruguayan OLPC initiative) about how this has the potential to be a nice step forward :)

    http://olpc-ceibal.blogspot.com/

    --
    There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics.
    1. Re:Some background from Uruguay by Scrameustache · · Score: 2, Funny

      I'm from Uruguay (the country that has actually gone out and bought the XOs), and... it's not at all like you imagine it.

      We have electricity and running water everywhere Sounds messy and dangerous! We keep our wanter and electricity in pipes and wires, it's much more orderly ;-)
      --

      You can't take the sky from me...

  36. Re:Insightful?? by evilviper · · Score: 1

    First of all, they're BISON, not buffalo - and yes, there's a difference.

    Difference species, same family. Not that big a difference. And they certainly exist in developing countries.

    Let me know when you see one hitched to a plow!

    http://www.travelblog.org/Photos/698125.html

    Go troll elsewhere.
    --
    Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
  37. What a waste of resouces, make fiddles as Rome bur by i'malawyer · · Score: 0, Troll

    s. These people don't need silicon, they need morals, ethical institutions and just governments. Especially Africa. People there are still engaged in animal worship. There problem is largely spiritual.

    --
    QQQ baby!
  38. Re:What a waste of resouces, make fiddles as Rome by Yoozer · · Score: 1

    These people don't need silicon, they need morals, ethical institutions and just governments.
    The same could be said of many other countries (including the US and Europe). What Africa needs is us to stop giving subsidies to farmers here so they have a chance to compete and to stop the help; it's not going to the right hands anyway, Bono be damned.

    People there are still engaged in animal worship. Their problem is largely spiritual.
    You're raving. As opposed to celebrity and money worship, which is not a spiritual problem?
  39. Re:Insightful?? by totally+bogus+dude · · Score: 1

    Looks to me like the buffalo's pulling a person carrying a plow. I'm not sure that counts. ;)

  40. Re:Insightful?? by lhorn · · Score: 1

    I am not worried for OLPC used as a toy, as this is how children learn. Some will be used as toys by grown children, yes, but many will be used by adults to educate themselves to their full potential, which is expensive (in books) and much more difficult (special scools) today. Go OPLC!

    --
    accept no limits but time
  41. Re:Made in China? by clay_buster · · Score: 1
    Mattel apologized because they were going to get cut off from their Chinese suppliers if they didn't. Mattel doesn't have alternative manufacturing sources so they kissed ass.

    Why is lead pain so prevalent in China? They've been having lead paint recalls for years. Eventually the Chinese government is going to have to get it together with respect to environmental controls and product safety. They are going to get a black eye on a regular basis until they get serious about this type of thing.

  42. Re:Insightful?? by CheeseTroll · · Score: 1

    Your picture is of an Asian water buffalo, not an American Bison. Like you said, different species. You seem to be under the impression that if two animals of different species are roughly the shape and size, then they're basically the same thing. Zebra = horse, bison = buffalo. Chimpanzee = human?

    --
    A post a day keeps productivity at bay.
  43. Totally and utterly WRONG by cusco · · Score: 1
    "the availability of native domesticable plant and animal species -- which is the one resource that matters most. The Eurasian continent had them, the Americas, Africa and Australia did not."

    The peoples of the Americas were far better fed with far fewer incidences of famine than the Europeans were before their arrival. Look at your current diet, and think about how much of that food actually existed in Europe before 1492. Wheat, barley, beef, mutton, cabbage, turnips, a few herbs, that was about it. Asia also had rice, onions, pork, some limited aquaculture, cotton and silk.

    From the Americas we have corn, potatoes, tomatoes, squashes, beans, peanuts, peppers, quinoa, llama, alpaca, guinea pig, large scale aquaculture, and scores of foods that the Europeans still don't know about like oca, kaniwa, kanihuaco, tayacha, etc. They also had the world's finest fibers from alpaca, vicuña, and chinchilla, and regularly wove fabrics of over 200 thread count. Their ceramic and gold work far exceeded the level of anything found on the Eurasian continent.

    What the Americas didn't have were smallpox and influenza, both of which apparently arose from the squalid living conditions of the European peasants, who slept with their livestock to keep warm in winter. Seventy to ninety percent of all people from Tierra del Fuego to Point Barrow died, leaving a small, weak, disorganized, easily dominated population living amongst the shattered ruins of the highest civilizations on the planet.

    --
    "Think about how stupid the average person is. Now, realise that half of them are dumber than that." - George Carlin
    1. Re:Totally and utterly WRONG by jay-be-em · · Score: 1

      You're right. Probably shouldn't have included the Americas in that list. Thanks for the correction.

      --
      "Orthodoxy means not thinking--not needing to think. Orthodoxy is unconsciousness." --Eric Blair
  44. maybe Negroponte can make water flow downhill now? by jselani · · Score: 1

    I find it amazing that people could laud the OLPC "initiative" for wasting millions of dollars in order to . . . get a cheaper laptop. Funny, I thought that's what the market does, year after year after year. I live in a world in which consumer electronics get cheaper every year without any work from Nick Negroponte, but maybe that's different from the world most of the posters at this blog live in.

    Funnily enough, while OLPC has worked hard to produce a laptop that finally costs about $175 plus shipping -- and that so few developing countries actually want to buy that now they want US to pay for it -- you can buy a nice Fedora Linux laptop, the Madison Celebrity, from Sweden for $150 including free shipping in the US.

    The point is that OLPC could have spent the last few years developing kick-ass SOFTWARE to run on the $100 linux boxes that we'll have by next year ANYWAY instead of wasting money and time promoting themselves and performing the magic act of creating a laptop that costs $25 more than the market created without them.

  45. Found XO-1 by yuriyg · · Score: 1

    Seems like a very good place to post this.

    I'm currently in possession of an XO-1 that was lost somewhere in New York City. If you are a rightful owner, and can accurately describe any special markings, accessories that it came with, place where you lost it, etc., I'll be happy to return it to you.

    I'll respond ONLY to legitimate claims.

  46. Web... server... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yeah, I'm sure having to crank up your OLPC web server every two hours isn't going to be tedious. Or stupidly annoying.

    Good luck with that one, Lunix d00d!

  47. A lot cheaper? by Rob+Simpson · · Score: 1
    1. Re:A lot cheaper? by evilviper · · Score: 1

      A quick search showed most to be much more expensive.

      Complete bullshit. No doubt you're looking at nearly brand new units that run circles around the OLPC to try and prove a false point. Here you go. "Buy It Now":
      $320 shipped, 800MHz/40GB Toughbook
      $195 shipped, 700MHz/20GB Toughbook
      Or you can get them much, much cheaper if you're willing to try bidding on some:
      1
      2
      3
      4
      5
      --
      Your comment has too few characters per line (currently 15.6). That's an awfully long string of characters
      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    2. Re:A lot cheaper? by Rob+Simpson · · Score: 1
      Strange... my post disappeared. Anyway, that second one is a decent deal - but the monitor would be too dim to read comfortably outside and it's very heavy (though indestructable). Not really comparable (either good or bad) to the XO-1. People are interested in the XO-1 because it's a neat fanless gadget...the same people aren't interested in the cheapest used laptop they can find. And the rest of those are a joke:

      Manufacturer: Panasonic
      Model: CF-47
      osmetics: Parts/Repair
      Test Results: Tested and does NOT power on. Offered AS-IS, with NO warranty.
      Accessories: None - sold as pictured.
      Screen Size: 13"
      Hard Drive: NOT Included
      Processor Type: PIII
      Processor Speed: Unknown
      Memory Type: NOT Included
      Drives: CD-ROM Drive, Floppy Drive
  48. And another laptop some one forgot to secure... by proto · · Score: 1
    The thought just hit me! If this post is true, some insider was carrying around model number
    • enter first batch model number here
    without securing it. The OLPC is designed with security so that the child (i.e. designated owner) types in a password to activate it. The purpose is to minimize any incentive toward theif of the device. Isn't it ironic? Only those who work inside the OLPC project could have access to this device. Some one forget to use the most important feature? Wouldn't he/she know better?

    Will Rogers quote "If Stupidity got us into this mess, then why can't it get us out?"