Slashdot Mirror


Battlestar Galactica Gets Spinoff Prequel Series

It was recently announced that sci-fi remake series Battlestar Galactica is getting a whole new spinoff prequel series called "Caprica." Signed on for twenty hours worth of finished product, including a two-hour pilot, the new series is to be set 50 years prior to Battlestar Galactica, and will focus on two rival families, the Graystones and the Adamas. "Enmeshed in the burgeoning technology of artificial intelligence and robotics that will eventually lead to the creation of the Cylons, the two houses go toe-to-toe blending action with corporate conspiracy and sexual politics. 'Caprica' will deliver all of the passion, intrigue, political backbiting and family conflict in television's first science fiction family saga."

58 of 297 comments (clear)

  1. So... by wtansill · · Score: 4, Funny

    It'll be like "Dallas" or "Knot's Landing", but with spaceships? Wow!

    --
    The contest for ages has been to rescue liberty from the grasp of executive power. -- Daniel Webster
    1. Re:So... by Hal_Porter · · Score: 3, Insightful

      It'll be like "Dallas" or "Knot's Landing", but with spaceships? Wow!

      No, that was V

      --
      echo -e 'global _start\n _start:\n mov eax, 2\n int 80h\n jmp _start' > a.asm; nasm a.asm -f elf; ld a.o -o a;
    2. Re:So... by Bazzargh · · Score: 2, Informative

      It'll be like "Dallas" or "Knot's Landing", but with spaceships? Wow!

      You mean exactly like The Colbys?

    3. Re:So... by owlnation · · Score: 2, Interesting

      or worse... Like Galactica 1980.

      They already said there will be less spaceships -- thus, motorcycles is the way to go!

      Seriously though, hopefully the writing quality of this is superior to the remake of Battlestar. In that it has far fewer gaping plotholes and some sense of forward momentum. I gave up with this show during the hendrix jumping the shark moment. The scripts had poor dramatic tension up to that point, but hendrix was the final straw.

    4. Re:So... by idontgno · · Score: 2, Informative
      And, if The Register and its headline on this story can be believed, without spaceships either.

      And no hawt skinjob Cylons either. Why, exactly, would I watch this?

      --
      Welcome to the Panopticon. Used to be a prison, now it's your home.
    5. Re:So... by eos3fan · · Score: 2, Funny

      Overheard in the green room: "When you go to shoot J.R., make sure the laser's set to stun, not kill..."

    6. Re:So... by Windows_NT · · Score: 2, Funny

      Darn .. for a second i was thinking spaceballs ...

      --
      Go go Gadget Nailgun!
    7. Re:So... by Rogerborg · · Score: 4, Funny

      It'll be like "Dallas" or "Knot's Landing", but with spaceships?

      Exactly! Except, without the spaceships.

      --
      If you were blocking sigs, you wouldn't have to read this.
    8. Re:So... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative

      I gave up with this show during the hendrix jumping the shark moment. The scripts had poor dramatic tension up to that point, but hendrix was the final straw.

      You sure it wasn't the Bob Dylan moment?

    9. Re:So... by elrous0 · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Makes sense. Joan Collins' body is mostly made up of synthetics at this point. Once she gets the new hip, it'll be pretty much a done deal.

      --
      SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
    10. Re:So... by Lord+Apathy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      And, if The Register and its headline on this story can be believed, without spaceships either. And no hawt skinjob Cylons either. Why, exactly, would I watch this?

      I totally agree. Really, who cares what happened 50 years before the current series? Back biting and family bullshit is why I stopped watching BSG. I want to see space ships, hints of 13th tribe, and cylons getting their ass kicked. I don't care if Tye drunk off his ass 90% of the time, apollo is fucking starbuck or his old man. And I really really don't give a rats ass about baltars love cult.

      More spaceships, more ass kicking, and more story about earth. Fuck the rest.

      Now if they did a series about the first cylon war, that might be worth my time.

      --

      Supporting World Peace Through Nuclear Pacification

    11. Re:So... by eleuthero · · Score: 2

      I found the whole series a bit strained and quit watching after two episodes--it made me go back and re-watch a couple of the old ones and I've discovered that just like star trek, old sci fi in general is good for a few laughs. You can now revoke my geek card for having a low opinion of Galactica.

    12. Re:So... by nasch · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Why do fields of study have to proceed at the same relative paces we're familiar with? What is it about building robots and giant spaceships that necessitates a cure for cancer?

    13. Re:So... by Kelbear · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I think a boy from one family and a boy from the other family would get more ratings from the shock value and resulting media frenzy.

      If you want really high ratings, use a girl from one family and a girl from the other...

    14. Re:So... by MrNiceguy_KS · · Score: 2, Interesting

      To be fair - the version they played was the Hendrix version, and yes, for me that was also the shark-jumping moment.

      Spoiler alert: If you haven't yet watched the end of season 3, skip the rest of my post. I've got some bitching to do that I'm not going to hold in for the sake of what I'm presuming is a very small subset of /.ers who care about BSG, but not enough to be caught up at this point.

      It's bad enough that a few "people" are apparently hearing Dylan/Hendrix. Never mind that we're light-years away from 1960's Earth, and they're apparently not hearing it through radio waves since nobody else can detect it. I can understand some sort of "signal" waking up the last remaining Cylon models, maybe even a musical signal, but a song from earth?

      But the identity of the 4 just pissed me off. Sam and What's-her-name, who even cares? I never did like Sam's character anyway, and Roslin's aide was never an interesting character until after she was revealed as a Cylon. Tyrol didn't really surprise me, though it does mean that his and Cally's baby is another "hybrid", meaning that Hera isn't quite as unique as most of the series has made her out to be. (The other obvious possibility is that Cally was cheating on Tyrol, and I'm surprised that possibility hasn't been dragged up and had the angst wrung out of it.)

      But Tigh? What? An old guy with a well-established history from back before the first Cylon war? At what point was this skinjob planted? How can they possibly explain this?

      I'll be honest, I thought the show had jumped the shark when they first landed on New Caprica, though they did eventually manage to redeem themselves. I didn't hate the Baltar trial as much as I thought I would, but Lee's involvement still annoys me. I really like the concept of dissension among the Cylons, particularly about whether the humans should be wiped out. But the whole "Final Five" frenzy just seemed to come out of nowhere, and then it's suddenly the main conflict in the show. The show as a whole has gotten worse, the scheduling and constant hiatuses make it hard to follow, and the constant inexplicable new plot elements make my head and stomach spin.

      For all my complaints, when the show starts back up, I will likely keep watching. Partly out of a sheer stubbornness - I hate to quit. But partly to see if the writers can manage to resurrect anything coherent out of this mess. In other words, there had better be a damn good explanation for what's happened.

      --
      Redundancy is good And also good.
    15. Re:So... by Fweeky · · Score: 3, Informative

      Never mind that we're light-years away from 1960's Earth, and they're apparently not hearing it through radio waves since nobody else can detect it. I can understand some sort of "signal" waking up the last remaining Cylon models, maybe even a musical signal, but a song from earth?

      Nope, it's not a song from Earth:

      I learned that the idea was not that Bob Dylan necessarily exists in the charactersâ(TM) universe, but that an artist on one of the colonies may have recorded a song with the exact same melody and lyrics. Perhaps this unknown performer and Dylan pulled inspiration from a common, ethereal source. Therefore, I was told to make no musical references to any âoeEarthlyâ versions, Hendrix, Dylan or any others. The arrangement needed to sound like a pop song that belonged in the Galactica universe, not our own.

    16. Re:So... by Whiteox · · Score: 2, Informative

      Damn you! I had to look that up and there goes another 5 mins of my life.
      You're right of course.
      I'm now humbled by your magnificence!

      --
      Don't be apathetic. Procrastinate!
  2. Recently announced? by clickclickdrone · · Score: 2, Interesting

    They've been talking about Caprice since season 2 or 3. I suppose this is more a case of 'it's now got budget/go ahead' than anything that's going to surprise any fan that's been paying attention.

    --
    I want a list of atrocities done in your name - Recoil
    1. Re:Recently announced? by Fallingcow · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Yeah, I even thought I saw a trailer for the series as much as a year ago.

      As I recall, it was entirely impossible to tell from watching the trailer that it was in any way related to BSG, aside from the title. Looked boring.

  3. Not good... by DoofusOfDeath · · Score: 3, Insightful

    This probably should wait until George Lucas is dead, just to be safe.

    1. Re:Not good... by clickclickdrone · · Score: 5, Funny

      >This probably should wait until George Lucas is dead, just to be safe.
      1. GreyStones Wars
      2. Revenge of the Adamas
      3. The Greystones Strike Back
      4. Profit!
      Shudder.....

      --
      I want a list of atrocities done in your name - Recoil
    2. Re:Not good... by cashman73 · · Score: 4, Funny

      If this new series involves a dagget with big, floppy ears, that talks like a Jamaican, I can no longer be a BSG fan. See ya!

    3. Re:Not good... by genner · · Score: 4, Funny

      This probably should wait until George Lucas is dead, just to be safe.

      Good, idea......I'll be right back.

  4. Really? by Wolfmandan72 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    FRACK!

  5. Remember 1980 by Templar · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Presumably they're doing this because the last Galactica spinoff went so well? Invisible ships and flying motorcycles. How ever can they top that?

    1. Re:Remember 1980 by elrous0 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Both have something already in common. They're both being sold to their networks as cheaper-to-produce versions of their predecessors. SciFi is probably thinking "If we set it on a planet and forgo all the FX, it will attract the same old Galactica audience but be a lot cheaper to make." Unfortunately for them, that is exactly what NBC execs told themselves about Galactica 1980. The audience won't follow over if the material is crap, Galactica name or not.

      --
      SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
    2. Re:Remember 1980 by maxume · · Score: 2, Funny

      How do you explain season 3?

      Bender: WhooooOOOOOooooooo!

      --
      Nerd rage is the funniest rage.
    3. Re:Remember 1980 by girlintraining · · Score: 5, Funny

      The First Rule of BSG Fan Club Is You Don't Talk about 1980. The second rule is WE DO NOT TALK ABOUT 1980! It never happened. That series doesn't exist. It vanished into a black hole like disco okay? Eye bleach, neeeeeeed! It's the BSG fan equivalent of Nemesis. It didn't happen, okay? Did. Not. Happen.

      --
      #fuckbeta #iamslashdot #dicemustdie
    4. Re:Remember 1980 by vidarh · · Score: 2, Insightful

      You might find yourself drinking profusely for weeks to forget all about it.

    5. Re:Remember 1980 by girlintraining · · Score: 5, Funny

      Nah, but I have a friend who's dad is a BSG fan too; Has all the DVDs, so we went over and I found 1980. So I borrowed it. I'm soooo sorry. It was worse than eating three chili cheese burritoes and a Vault while on the rag. It just... omg.

      --
      #fuckbeta #iamslashdot #dicemustdie
    6. Re:Remember 1980 by bigstrat2003 · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Simple. Season 3 was good, and people are just whiners.

      The show has, imnsho, been extremely high quality from start to finish. I never have understood, and probably never will understand, where people get this idea that the show has gone downhill.

      --
      "16MB (fuck off, MiB fascists)" - The Mighty Buzzard
    7. Re:Remember 1980 by genner · · Score: 2, Interesting

      It's easily one of the worst sci-fi shows I've ever the displeasure of watching.

      Worse than the Star Wars Christmas Special?

    8. Re:Remember 1980 by sl0ppy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      hulu has it:

      http://www.hulu.com/galactica-1980

      may you forget quickly and are able to heal.

  6. Re:How faithful to the 1970s series will it be? by way2trivial · · Score: 4, Informative

    watch the pilot again- first minute.

    The colonial officer is perusing plans of the original cylon model-- that looks like the original series model.

    --
    every day http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random
  7. Spinoff + Prequel by jellomizer · · Score: 3, Funny

    Spinoff + Prequel all we need is an alien life form or a ghost that only the main character can see and talk to who only heckles the main character to make it a truly horrible idea.

    --
    If something is so important that you feel the need to post it on the internet... It probably isn't that important.
  8. Late in the game by MBGMorden · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Honestly, it's hard for me to drum up any interest in this at this point. The new BSG was one of my favorite TV shows of all time. It was truly amazing and I have loved it. HOWEVER, the Sci-fi channel has done almost everything in their power to crush my interest in the show. The between season and mid-season breaks since season 2 ended have just been utterly ridiculous. It's an exaggeration, but I swear it feels like I'm watching the last 2 seasons of this show at a rate of 3-4 episodes per year. I'll finish out what's left of the show at this point because I'm already embroiled. I'm not sure I want to endure getting involved in another series that Sci-fi controls though.

    Personally, I'm far more interested in sticking with Terminator: TSCC so long as it maintains sufficient ratings to avoid cancellation. I only have room in my schedule to keep up with a few shows at a time anyways.

    --
    "People who think they know everything are very annoying to those of us who do."-Mark Twain
    1. Re:Late in the game by budcub · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I agree. Too bad they can't turn over the show to HBO or Showtime and have them do it right.

    2. Re:Late in the game by Xelios · · Score: 2, Interesting

      It seems like sci-fi shows get mishandled by their networks more often than not, then they blame the show when it gets mediocre ratings. The few episodes of BSG in season 3 that seemed like one-offs came about because the network decided the long story arc made it too hard for people to get into the show. The producers were pressured to create one-off episodes (like Star Trek used to be) and look what happened. Those episodes were by far the worst episodes in BSG (The Woman King?).

      Lets not even get into what FOX did to Firefly...

      --
      Murphey's fighting Occam, and we're in the stands.
    3. Re:Late in the game by Jah-Wren+Ryel · · Score: 3, Informative

      Personally, I'm far more interested in sticking with Terminator: TSCC

      TSCC is the new BSG. They even have Bear McCreary doing the score.

      --
      When information is power, privacy is freedom.
    4. Re:Late in the game by servognome · · Score: 2, Interesting

      If BSG had been on HBO, it probably wouldn't have made it past the second season. With rare exceptions like The Sopranos, HBO has a long history of canceling great shows at about the 2nd season mark.

      HBO is all about pushing subscription sales. Yes they have really awesome shows, but unless they are "mainstream" enough to convince new subscribers it just isn't worth it for them. Deadwood and Rome were awesome, but they didn't have the same kind of audience appeal as Entourage and Sopranos where you're left out of the water cooler conversation on monday unless you have a subscription.

      --
      D6 63 0D 70 89 81 BB 8E 7B 7C 5F 5D 54 EA AB 73
  9. oh hell. by girlintraining · · Score: 5, Funny

    It's reality TV from the fuuuuuuture. I can haaardly wait.

    Episode 1: It begins with a street fight between the Adamas and the Capule--I mean Capricas. They try to marry off the young future commander adama but is turned down for not being gay enough for Baltar's grandfather.

    Episode 2: Adama is asked to wait a few years and then go to a bar, where he'll meet his future lover, Tye, who unfortunately is also a Caprican. Angst results.

    Episode 3: Adama professes his love while standing on a balcony having a conversation with his mother about toaster studels. Tye overhears this, and they agree to a civil union. The rest of the Adama family hears of this and declare war on the Capricas. They're so distracted that they fail to realize the toasters have become sentient. A trail of burnt strudel leads to the outskirts of town.

    *six month break due to writer strike -- online commentary -- this plotline SUCKS!!! It has a political agenda! Doom upon the soothsayers* ...
    Yeah, I can see it now. Now watch me get modded "-6000, damn slash fan"

    --
    #fuckbeta #iamslashdot #dicemustdie
    1. Re:oh hell. by goombah99 · · Score: 2, Funny

      It's reality TV from the fuuuuuuture. I can haaardly wait.

      Episode 1: It begins with a street fight between the Adamas and the Capule--I mean Capricas. They try to marry off the young future commander adama but is turned down for not being gay enough for Baltar's grandfather.

      Yes yes, it's the Jets versus the Sharks-with-lasers. And a cylon officer Krupke tries to keep the peace.

      Jebeezus, how many people know what the hell we're talking about! Funny thing is, it's 90% of all TV.

      your sly post cracked me up,

      --
      Some drink at the fountain of knowledge. Others just gargle.
  10. I've seen this before... by yttrstein · · Score: 2, Interesting

    "the two houses go toe-to-toe blending action with corporate conspiracy and sexual politics"

    I wonder if it's going to be as good as when it was the Harkonnens and the Atreideses.

  11. And In Today's News... by BigBlueOx · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Another brain-damaged gaggle of entertainment industry parasites have rehashed an old idea in the hopes of inflicting it on a witless populace.

    The Day The Earth Stood Still?
    King Kong?
    Star Wars XI:A New Source Of Revenue?

    No, Battlestar Galactica: The Prequel.

    pfft.

  12. Re:How faithful to the 1970s series will it be? by idontgno · · Score: 2, Informative

    Obvious "hark-backs":

    • Older-model Centurions in older-model Raiders ("manned", not cyborg) guarding the "First Hybrid" in Razor
    • Mark II Viper is a visual dead-on clone of the original series one (although, not fitted with those nifty laser weapons)
    • Pegasus and other later-model battlestars are styled more like original series ones than Galactica (see http://en.battlestarwiki.org/wiki/Image:Pegasus-Comparison.png)

    That's just off the top of my head.

    --
    Welcome to the Panopticon. Used to be a prison, now it's your home.
  13. Sounds like... by argent · · Score: 5, Funny

    Sounds like a cross between Dune and Star Wars Episode 1.

    With all the fast-moving action of the former and all the rich storytelling of the latter.

  14. Re:"recently"?! Sure is. by davidsyes · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Apparently, Slash articles need to have pre-posting supplemental research/vetting/URL-add-ons before going into the wild:

    http://www.galacticawatercooler.com/

    Then, it might have read:

    "Previously-announced BSG-Prequel 'Caprica'green-lighted"

    --
    Previously: "Linux... Toward the Sunrise..." Now: "Linux... Toward the-- No, now, part of Every Sunrise"
  15. Re:How faithful to the 1970s series will it be? by Animats · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Ever notice how the Enterprise in Enterprise looked way more advanced that the Enterprise in Star Trek.

    It got to be embarrassing. The original Star Trek bridge now looks like an outdated comm center for mall security.

    The original Battlestar Galactica bridge from the 1970s was powered by Tektronix, and many of the controls actually did something visible. This was a real problem for the actors, who had to learn how to operate the systems.

    "2001" was more futuristic. An AI took care of the details, and the crew just chatted with the AI.

  16. television's first science fiction family saga by 1u3hr · · Score: 2, Insightful
    What about Thunderbirds (1965)? Jeff Tracy and his five sons...

    Lost in Space (also 1965) -- John Robinson, his wife and three kids.

    Plenty of "families" in SF, depends how you define "saga", which on TV usually means "multi-generational soap opera". If so, not really a drawcard, I think.

  17. BSG doesn't air in "Seasons." by solios · · Score: 3, Informative

    Sure, they CALL them seasons, but if you think about it what we're really getting are UK-length series* of the show, mislabeled.

    Think about it.

    Series 1 : 13 episodes, Jan-April 2005

    Series 2 : 10 episodes, July-September 2005

    Series 3 : 10 episodes, Jan-March 2006 # called "season 2.5" for the DVDs and considered to be "second half" of season 2.

    Series 4 : 20 episodes, October 2006 - January 2007 # called "season 3," the only time the new BSG has run in anything approximating a traditional TV "season" form.

    Series 5 : 10 episodes, April-June 2008 # called "the first half of season 4"

    Series 6 : 10 episodes, January-?? 2009 # called "the second half of season 4"

    * UK TV shows don't run in seasons, they run in "series" (eg series 1, series 2, etc. as listed above), typically of 1-10 episodes... though for British comedies, 4-6 episodes is considered a "series" - compare to the US "season," which typically consists of 18-22 episodes. Imagine waiting 46 weeks to get your weekly dose of Red Dwarf (or No Heroics or The IT Crowd or whatever).... it kinda makes the several-month gap between BSG series look positively brief.

  18. Tag this one Flying Motorcycles. by goombah99 · · Score: 2, Funny

    next up buck rodgers. bee dee bee dee bee dee

    --
    Some drink at the fountain of knowledge. Others just gargle.
  19. Clueless Network by StormReaver · · Score: 3, Interesting

    "One of the network's frustrations with [Battlestar Galactica] has been its dark and increasingly complex mythology."

    If *that's* why the network was frustrated by the show, then the network is run by morons. The dark, complicated mythology is part of what made the show so good. Multidimensional characters with complex motivations were a great added bonus to high quality, space-based visual effects.

    The frustrations that *should* have been keeping network executives up at night involved huge downtime between seasons. That, above all else, is what caused viewership to decline. People simply lost interest in a show that appeared, for all intents and purposes, to be canceled every year. People were actually surprised when the next season began, and had already decided to watch something else.

    Granted, season 3 lost a lot of credibility when the space opera turned soap opera (that season sucked really bad), but the main problems came from scheduling mismanagement by the network.

  20. Except Deep Space 9 had Babylon 5 to compete with by markdowling · · Score: 2, Interesting

    When B5 got into its stride, DS9 got into the story arc business and largely out of the NG inherited planet of the week plot.

    While not a classic series - how could it be with the incessant mood swings of Avery Brooks and almost everything involving Quark or Jake Sisko - it had some periods approaching greatness (Improbable Cause/The Die Is Cast, Call To Arms/A Time to Stand). But then Babylon 5 disappeared onto TNT and DS9's writers had several brain farts (such as Ezri Dax and Vic Fontaine) and that was that.

    Who's going to keep Moore and Eick from making Caprica a Bionic Woman sized disaster?

  21. Watch it on Hulu.com by SilverJets · · Score: 2, Informative

    If you are in the States, watch BSG on hulu.com

  22. this is the problem with spin-offs by jollyreaper · · Score: 2, Insightful

    If you want to do a spin-off right, it should really have something to do with the original show. Now there have been exceptionally successful spin-offs, mostly American comedies. (I say successful in that they ran a long time, making no judgment on quality.) In fact, it's often surprising to find out which show they spun off from. Frasier came from Cheers, Jeffersons came from some other show that you wouldn't have thought of, Laverne and Shirley spun off of something else, Mork and Mindy was based on something else. But then there's also all of the really crappy spin-offs that simply could not stand on their own two feet, just like a band that works because of all of the members coming together and the solo acts never have that same magic after they split.

    The thing that's always funny to see is when something is spun off in a completely nonsensical way. She-Ra was a spin-off of He-Man. What were they thinking? No boy worth his salt is going to play with a girl's toy and why would the girls want to play with something tied in to a boy's toy? And as far as this goes, we're taking a spaceships and robot scifi story and spinning it off into a soap opera? I mean yeah, there are some soapy elements to BSG already but this really does sound like Dallas in Space (except they never travel off-planet.)

    I don't get it. The Paramount suits said they'd never do a show on a space station becuase that's like taking the wheels off the cart, you never go anywhere interesting and it would require a lot of contrivances to get interesting things to come to you. I think the more appropriate complaint would be setting a show in the Star Trek universe in a restaurant in a backwater town on Earth that doesn't get much traffic from offworlders. Yeah, look at this big neat universe we're not seeing!

    --
    Kwisatz Haderach
    Sell the spice to CHOAM
    This Mahdi took Shaddam's Throne
  23. They had to wait by Orion+Blastar · · Score: 2, Interesting

    until the final five got revealed.

    We will see human personalities downloaded into a human like Cylon after Zoe Graystone dies in a terrorist attack. Then Zoe-R will be the prototype for the human Cylons. 50 years before the fall of the Twelve Colonies.

    The Adamas will most likely be opposed to the creation of the new Cylons and feud with the Graystones who created them, but they have Graystones involved in relationships with the Adamas to make it more complex.

    --
    Remember, Slashdot does not have a -1 disagree moderation, and no, troll, flamebait, and overrated are not substitutes.
  24. I saw this - man did it suck! by K8Fan · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I was walking through the mall connecting two Las Vegas hotels with my brother a few months ago when a someone asked if we have "a few minutes to watch a program". After signing up, we were in a room with two TV sets, holding a pair of buttons on cords - press the green one when you liked what you were seeing, the red one when you didn't. That red button got quite a work-out. After the sucking stopped (nearly an hour later!), we answered an electronic questionaire where we could explain why we thought it sucked, and in what ways. I took it as the opportunity to mention other non-dreadful SF programming like the new Doctor Who. In brief, I hated every character in this show and didn't much care for the actors playing the characters. If I ever see an episode of it again, it will be far too soon./pP

    --
    "How perfectly Goddamn delightful it all is, to be sure" Charles Crumb
  25. Comparing BSG with B5 by jesterzog · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I don't think it is so much that the show got less believable, as that the rules started changing from episode to episode.

    I think this is definitely true. I don't watch a lot of TV and I bought the first 3 seasons of BSG after a friend recommended it. I've enjoyed it, mostly for the drama, and I'll probably buy S4 when it's finally available just so I can see how it ends, but there have also been a lot of inconsistencies that I've found irritating or confusing.

    This isn't exactly a new thing, though. It goes right back to the first season when we were shown that Cylons were clearly biologically different from humans (glowing read spine, etc), yet creating a "cylon detector" is such a difficult thing. I never really understood the whole Cylon Detector plot, which at the time seemed like an excuse to give Baltar something to do and create conflict with other characters. After seeing season 3, I now think that's probably exactly all that it was... lazy design of the details and hoping that things would make more sense later on. Baltar's a really fun character and it's interesting seeing him weasel his way around everything, but early on the character didn't really have much to work with so they just made up something empty.

    I think the plot problems are because the writing team never really figured out any solid rules or boundaries or what would happen to begin with. The writing of the drama and character development is often pretty interesting and it's what keeps me watching the show, but the plots and details often seem as if they were just tied together to create an excuse to be able to have something fail or work as the writers want it to. As you've said (I think), it's like technobabble solving the problem, but with all the extra meaningless dialogue to go with it. Instead, they just let crazy and irrational details get in and don't even try to explain them.

    If you compare BSG to something like Babylon 5, I think B5 would easily come out on top (at least for the first 4 seasons), despite having been one of the first series of its kind to actually experiment with a major story arc. B5 had all the strong drama and character development of BSG, but JMS also put so much effort into defining much of the relevant stuff about his universe to a needle's-width before he even produced the first episode. He knew what the rules were from the beginning, and 4-5 years in advance, he knew how all the main parts of his story would fit into the rules.