Slashdot Mirror


The iPad As In-Car Entertainment System Killer

theodp writes "Cars.com's David Thomas speculates that the iPad could prove to be a serious problem for automakers that charge a ransom for rear entertainment systems. The base iPad, Thomas notes, costs far less than most DVD options offered by automakers. Ford charges $1,995 for a dual-headrest-mounted DVD system in its Flex crossover. In the Acura MDX, its single-screen system, with three wireless headsets and a 9-inch screen, costs $1,900. At $500 a pop, giving two kids their own iPads would cost far less than what the automakers charge for an ICE system. The Cars.com article mentions some of the advantages of ICE, including being weather-tested to work from -5 to 160 degrees F (-20 to 71 C), and being far less prone to breakage."

415 comments

  1. hmm by mapkinase · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I thought mounted entertainment systems were killed by portable $100 DVD players already...

    --
    I do not believe in karma. "Funny"=-6. Do good and forbid evil. Yours, Oft-Offtopic Flamebaiting Troll.
    1. Re:hmm by sjpadbury · · Score: 1

      I paid about $40 for the last one I got.
      Before that I got a dual-screen one that was about $70, the player died, but the second screen still works and I use a video out cable for my iPod to play movies on it.

      --
      We're all full up on Crazy here...
    2. Re:hmm by poetmatt · · Score: 2, Interesting

      they were. some people are stupid enough to buy the dvd systems in the car. I used to sell cars and seeing someone buy one of these meant a: they were stupid and b: you were making a major profit.

      ps: the $2000 ish units? They cost around $300 including installation.

    3. Re:hmm by Eraesr · · Score: 1, Flamebait

      Most people would probably not know how to rip their latest Disney DVD's to a format the iPad can play.
      People buy DVD systems because it's as easy as just popping the disc in there and pushing the play button.

    4. Re:hmm by mysidia · · Score: 2, Informative

      It doesn't matter, as sometime in the future they will probably be able to re-buy their Disney DVDs for the iPad.

      Subject to DRM, preventing them from taking the content anywhere other than their iPad (without buying again), of course.

    5. Re:hmm by acromosh · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      I mounted an entertainment system once. Let me tell you, it was very impressed.

    6. Re:hmm by AliasMarlowe · · Score: 1

      I thought mounted entertainment systems were killed by portable $100 DVD players already...

      The portable unit one we got cost about euro120, but it has dual displays which attach to the headrests and provide independent volume controls. It can play almost anything, including DivX movies and MP3 music as well as regular DVDs and CDs. The headphones are not wireless, but I don't see that as justifying an additional euro1500+ for the automaker's system.

      --
      Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities. - Voltaire
    7. Re:hmm by rolfwind · · Score: 1

      Plus good luck fixing it. At least a non-integrated unit can be easily replace (at least much more cheaply) and is also upgradeable.... for instance, what if you start buying Blu-ray, what good is that DVD player in the car.

      These days, what often brakes in cars are the electronics, of course some manufacturers are better than others although some are surprisingly bad (Mercedes) -- and when you have to fix problems out of warranty, it can be as expensive as any mechanical problem.

      I restrict my electronic cars options to windows/locks, a/c, and radio, and whatever else is standard because it should be well-tested.

    8. Re:hmm by jedidiah · · Score: 1

      ...or other video players with big hard drives.

      If you can't shove in an extra disk, 16G probably isn't going to cut it here. 64G might.

      Apple really hasn't changed the landscape here.

      --
      A Pirate and a Puritan look the same on a balance sheet.
    9. Re:hmm by chowdahhead · · Score: 1

      Maybe, provided they're not locked away in the "Disney vault".

    10. Re:hmm by Lumpy · · Score: 1

      Exactly, this is nothing but sensationalism. I got my daughter a Archos 404 back when she was 12-13 and jammed it with a ton of videos and TV shows. It was far cheaper than any flipdown or headrest player and did far more. No carrying discs around, ran and charged off the car, worked perfect.

      the iPad will do this only for the people that had their heads in the sand for the past decade and paid no attention to what has been available for cheaper with higher capacity.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    11. Re:hmm by dhammond · · Score: 1

      I thought mounted entertainment systems were killed by portable $100 DVD players already...

      Um, yeah. Thanks for stating the obvious for me.

      When we bought our Sienna in 2004, we had one child and another on the way. The salesmen told us we "need" the dvd entertainment system. We didn't really think we did, and besides had seen cheap portable DVD players at Cosco. Even back then it was easy to see that we could buy two portable DVD players for less than the price of the integrated system.

      Anyway, it's 2010, and we never bought the DVD players, and our kids are just fine on long car rides.

    12. Re:hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      These days, what often brakes in cars are the electronics,

      If the electronics are braking then what are the brakes doing? Or would that be the Toyota brakes?

    13. Re:hmm by rwa2 · · Score: 1

      Heck, a $200 netbook would work better for entertainment.

      However, the missed story is that this is probably the largest screen you can run Google Maps Mobile on.

      I hate all things Apple with all of their intentional design restrictions, but I would have to contend that the iPad would make a very slick platform for GPS / Google Maps Mobile. But only because Google apparently refuses to make a port of GMM for notebooks / netbooks.

      Google Earth works OK on netbooks, but the GPS support is abysmal.

    14. Re:hmm by Comboman · · Score: 1

      sometime in the future they will probably be able to re-buy their Disney DVDs for the iPad.

      The future is now (actually, since 2006).

      --
      Support Right To Repair Legislation.
    15. Re:hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      However, the missed story is that this is probably the largest screen you can run Google Maps Mobile on.

      Oh, wait, it doesn't have a real GPS? And I bet there's no way to pair it with a bluetooth GPS (yep, look at all those forum posts saying the iPad doesn't recognize GPSs, and even if it did it would be able to provide power them via a USB port)...

      OK sorry, I take it all back... I thought I had found an interesting use for an iPad but I was yet again geekblocked by Apple :P

    16. Re:hmm by vegiVamp · · Score: 1

      It's called Handbrake, and exists for all three major desktop OSes. Insert disk, click title you want, click "rip".

      There's also something called makemkv, which is even simpler: insert disk, click "rip". It automatically rips every title longer than 10 minutes with every available sound and sub track to mkv. The downside to that one, is that it does no scaling - the rips can be large.

      --
      What a depressingly stupid machine.
    17. Re:hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Disney in particular (and others) release DVDs with (DRM-enabled) digital formats; if my wife can get Twilight on her iPod then most people can get the movie on the iPad.

    18. Re:hmm by johnlcallaway · · Score: 1

      I used to install my own exhaust pipes, change my own oil, and do other car maintenance. Now that I make 6 figures, I don't do it anymore. Sure .. it's stupid paying someone a couple hundred bucks to do something I could do. But it makes my life easier. And I don't waste 3 hours doing something they can do in an hour because they have lifts and all the right tools.

      That is what in-car DVD systems do. Mom and dad can just plug in the DVD and go. The kids can't throw the player onto the floor, and it's not a missile in a crash. No one has to plug it or worry about keeping the batteries charged.

      It would be easy for me to talk down in-car DVD systems because my kids are all grown and I grew up in the days sitting in the middle in the back seat for hours with three brothers and no seat belts. So I could put on my 'get off my lawn' hat and talk about how easy kids have it these days. But if it helps kids actually enjoy a trip and if it makes mom and dad's life easier to not have to deal with a portable DVD player, then why not.

      Money doesn't buy power .. it buys choices. People are still paying to buy cheap-ass headphones and watch movies on planes.....you would think someone that can afford a $400 plane ticket a few times a year could afford a portable DVD player. Or load video on their iPhone. My wife has an iTouch and loaded games and a video on it for a recent plane flight. I noticed there was a charge on the credit card for $6 and asked what it was (because we check our accounts daily to make sure no one has stolen the numbers) and she had bought a movie. I teased her about it, but the reality was she had the $6 and got tired of using the iTouch.

      --
      I rarely read replies, it's my opinion and if you thought about your opinion a little more, I'm OK with that.
    19. Re:hmm by T-Bone-T · · Score: 1

      From the Handbrake website -
      "HandBrake is not a ripper. It converts video, it does not rip it byte by byte. It does not crack the latest DVD copy protection schemes hatched by the studios.

      It converts video from nearly any format to a handful of modern ones—that's it. "

    20. Re:hmm by mapkinase · · Score: 1

      Modern cars have auxilliary audio input (looks like standard audio output jack for headphones). Audiocable costs $9 at the dealership, may be even less in a general electronic store.

      --
      I do not believe in karma. "Funny"=-6. Do good and forbid evil. Yours, Oft-Offtopic Flamebaiting Troll.
    21. Re:hmm by b0bby · · Score: 1

      I was "stupid enough" to buy the built in system in 2002, and I haven't regretted it even though it cost $1500. The system is well integrated, so it's easy for the driver to control, which was important when the kids were toddlers. Fiddling around with portable players gets old fast; we've used both DVD & PMP players on trips abroad & they're a much bigger pain. When we got the system we thought we'd use it mostly for long trips, but in actuality we we use it more for the 20 minute around town type stuff, which is where the convenience really pays for itself. It has worked well for 8 years now, and judging by the prices used head units go for on ebay (~$75) no one else is having any problems either (the one in our Odyssey is made by Pioneer) - that's not bad for something that endures a lot of shocks and temperature extremes. Sure, now that the kids are older, if we were buying a new vehicle I'd weigh the options, but especially with really young kids the built in systems are really worth paying a little more for.

    22. Re:hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Considering there's a Netflix app (among others) that lets you download movies on demand, people don't need to rip DVDs and incur the wrath of the RIAA.

    23. Re:hmm by b0bby · · Score: 1

      Oh, and the higher up the screen is mounted, the less likely the viewers are to get carsick; having the screen on the ceiling or headrest is better than looking down at an ipad in your lap.

    24. Re:hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I got your 13 yr old something with a few more inches to it. I told her not to cry and that it was our little secret.

    25. Re:hmm by Richy_T · · Score: 1

      With kids, wired headsets is a feature, not a bug.

    26. Re:hmm by King_TJ · · Score: 1

      I agree that the stuff is way overpriced, but to be fair - some of those buyers may not have been "stupid", as much as they simply wanted an integrated, clean solution - and wanted the whole thing ready to go when they took delivery of the vehicle.

      That's always been the problem, really. If you buy an aftermarket GPS unit, for example, you can get one for as little as $99 or so, or for maybe $200-400, get one that has a lifetime subscription to traffic updates, a bigger display, and can even display a photo collection, act as a display for a reverse backup camera and play MP3s. If you buy one that comes integrated with the car or truck? You're probably looking at $1500 or more, for something with far less functionality. BUT, there's no dangling wires going to an adapter tying up the cigarette lighter plug. There's no suction cup leaving marks on the windshield. There's no tempting theft target in clear view of everyone, every time you forget to take the thing down and hide it someplace or carry it with you.

      Factory integration is a really big benefit. It's just a shame auto-makers take so much advantage of it as a ridiculous profit-maker.

    27. Re:hmm by theshowmecanuck · · Score: 1

      Not everyone makes six figures. In fact, most don't.

      --
      -- I ignore anonymous replies to my comments and postings.
    28. Re:hmm by CecilPL · · Score: 3, Funny

      These days, what often brakes in cars are the electronics

      Unless it's a Toyota.

    29. Re:hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Many times people don't get a choice. The car comes with the entertainment systems pre-installed. I doubt many people actually request to have one installed.

      Just like a GPS, I would prefer a portable dash-mounted system I can use in any vehicle I happen to be in at the time and take with me when I'm not in a vehicle. However, rentals and luxury cars and SUVs still have them pre-installed. These days I just use a GPS app on my iPhone. Its not as good as the standalone systems you can buy (GPS radio doesn't even compare), but I always have it with me.

    30. Re:hmm by Gilmoure · · Score: 1

      Disney already sells DVD's with digital content included. Is a pain, having to find the code in all the case papers. Easier for me to rip. Also, I doubt my Mom or Dad would even know to look for this option.

      --
      I drank what? -- Socrates
    31. Re:hmm by Gilmoure · · Score: 1

      I insert a DVD, Handbrake opens, Apple TV's already picked for format and I click run. Out pops a .mp4 file that gets filed in to my iTunes home media server and then sync'd out to Apple TV. Works for me.

      Now, Handbrake does require VLC to be installed so yeah, technically, it's not a ripper. It's also good for converting Doctor Who 720p .mkv's to .mp4 files. Just sayin'.

      --
      I drank what? -- Socrates
    32. Re:hmm by johnlcallaway · · Score: 1

      Did you have a point .. or did you just miss mine.....

      --
      I rarely read replies, it's my opinion and if you thought about your opinion a little more, I'm OK with that.
    33. Re:hmm by T-Bone-T · · Score: 1

      Actually, VLC is not required to run Handbrake. VLC is what does the ripping.

    34. Re:hmm by ncc74656 · · Score: 1

      HandBrake is not a ripper. It converts video, it does not rip it byte by byte. It does not crack the latest DVD copy protection schemes hatched by the studios.

      On Linux, it still functions as a ripper. That functionality might not be in whatever binary builds the HandBrake devs provide, but the binary I built with the Gentoo ebuild for 0.94 (not in Portage, but retrieved from bugs.gentoo.org) has ripped most movies I've thrown at it.

      --
      20 January 2017: the End of an Error.
    35. Re:hmm by poetmatt · · Score: 1

      Okay, lets see. give them a dvd player, tell them to put in the DVD and press play. You think that's harder for them to understand than paying $2000 for something you can't even take with you in 5 years?

      good grief. Money buys choices but it can't save you from making a poor choice.

    36. Re:hmm by poetmatt · · Score: 1

      I never said Ipad was a good choice in any stretch. I'm just saying getting that dealer installed is the worst decision you can make. Doing it aftermarket usually enables better options, saves money, and still is a bad decision.

      Just because they won't get carsick from looking down doesn't mean people won't get nautious from staring at that tiny ass screen.

    37. Re:hmm by LanMan04 · · Score: 1

      I JUST did this to set up video for my 2.5 year old in the car:

      $29 on eBay: Coby TF-DVD7377 7 in. Portable DVD Player with Screen (about 480x272 resolution)
      Yes, this is a DVD player (which I'll never use), but it also has USB and SD card ports.
      Plays a variety of codecs (likes AVI containers, but has no problem with mpeg4/h264 video and mp3/aac audio)
      Also has a spin-around-and-lay-flat screen for easy mounting or desktop use.
      Also has infrared remote control, VERY handy from the front seat.

      $15: 8GB USB drive filled with rips of kids shows (mainly from my TiVo/the internet)

      That's it. It works freaking amazingly, and cost less than $50 to set up. This assumes you don't care about HD video, but I can assure you my 2 year old is much more interested in Handy Manny and Yo Gabba Gabba than in lines of resolution.

      --
      With the first link, the chain is forged.
    38. Re:hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Perhaps he was just (unintentionally) illustrating why you make six figures and he doesn't.

    39. Re:hmm by AmigaMMC · · Score: 1
      mentions some of the advantages of ICE, including being weather-tested to work from -5 to 160 degrees F (-20 to 71 C),

      [...]

      That point is moot: how many people drive with the temperature inside their car being -20C or 71C? All you have to do is bring the iPad inside the house after your trip.

    40. Re:hmm by GonzoPhysicist · · Score: 1

      I heard the Toyota issue was most likely an electronics problem, not mechanical.

      --
      horror vacui
    41. Re:hmm by theshowmecanuck · · Score: 1

      It just seems like you wanted to blather on about how you have lots of money and don't need to buy cheaper ways to watch movies in your vehicles, nor have to fix your cars because you can pay someone to do that, and pay people to do all the other things. Why don't you post your bank account balance while your at it. My point is that just because you make a lot of money, who the fuck cares? If people want to buy an iPad as a cheaper means of entertaining their passengers than what you can afford to, it isn't an invitation to ask you to tell us all how you are so well off.

      --
      -- I ignore anonymous replies to my comments and postings.
    42. Re:hmm by CecilPL · · Score: 1

      Hence the joke?

      The electronics usually brake the car, unless it's a Toyota, in which case they don't brake the car since they're broken.

    43. Re:hmm by mysidia · · Score: 1

      The Disney vault is entirely in Disney's control.

      I doubt they would pass up the opportunity to sell their content all over again on a new medium, however (e.g. the iPad).

      And then put it back in their metaphorical vault.

    44. Re:hmm by vegiVamp · · Score: 1

      Technically true. However, most people - and especially the non-techie people this was about - equal "rip" with "play from harddisk".

      --
      What a depressingly stupid machine.
    45. Re:hmm by poetmatt · · Score: 1

      There's also no taking the thing with you in a new car, either.

      Buy a $300 GPS unit? Take it with you.

      Although most people these days call that a cellphone, and leaving it in the car would be a bad idea.

      I agree that factory integration could be substantially more productive, but don't expect auto mfr's to care about that as they don't understand that it can add business.

  2. Sick and tired by vikingpower · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Really. I am sick and tired of seeing posts on /. on the Ipad. It's a waste of our time. Wasn't /. supposed to be "news for nerds, stuff that matters"? Ipads are not news for nerds, nor are they stuff that matters. Yuck.

    --
    Religous speak to God. Insane are spoken to by God. When all shut up, one can finally hear Shostakovich in peace
    1. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Ipads are news for the USA's middle class conspicuous consumers. You know, being "cool".

      It is not hard to go to a country that is not the USA and see editorial pieces in mainstream papers openly mocking people in their own country who buy Apple products. (I am in New Zealand, and the NZ Herald had a cartoon about this recently.)

    2. Re:Sick and tired by vikingpower · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      Holy shit - i got trolled ! One more accomplishment...

      --
      Religous speak to God. Insane are spoken to by God. When all shut up, one can finally hear Shostakovich in peace
    3. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I am with you.

      IPAD, because the average non-technical user wants to DECSS his DVD collection, rip down 1 movie (more if you buy the more expensive IPAD) and then struggle to copy / play it vs simply bringing the DVD collection and letting the kids watch what they want.

      Enough with the IPAD ads disguised as "news".

    4. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      To be trolled, it is you who needs to be responding to the troll, not the other way around.

      No, you were not being trolled. Sorry.

    5. Re:Sick and tired by jo_ham · · Score: 4, Informative

      Well, the stories that appear on slashdot are submitted by slashdot readers, so clearly some people are interested.

      They're obviously news for someone. Might I suggest submitting stories that *are* news for nerds if you think the iPad is not worth it to you.

      Or just turn off the "Apple" section in your preferences, which is much more effective than moaning about it on the actual story, as many people seem to do.

    6. Re:Sick and tired by OnlyJedi · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Yes, bringing a collection of a hundred DVDs is far easier than storing those hundred on 64GB of flash memory.

      Seriously though, if you know what software to use (Handbrake has built-in presets for ipod and Apple TV; iPad is only a matter of time if those don't work) it is a piece of cake to DeCSS a movie and convert it to H.264. From there, just drag into iTunes and sync. For a one-time viewing, a portable DVD player may be more convenient. But if you plan ahead or have movies that your kids want to watch often in the back seat, storing a substantial portion of your movie library on the iPad wouldn't be so hard.

      The biggest hurdle to this that I can see is one of security. How do you keep your kids out of your private documents/email? I've seen this mentioned elsewhere; unlike the iPhone which is a more personal device, the iPad is much more geared as a shared entertainment device that also happens to do email and documents. Without some sort of user login to differentiate between family members may cause problems. But none of that has anything to do with the ease of getting DVDs onto the device.

      Blu-ray now; that's another story. But find me a portable Blu-ray player first...

    7. Re:Sick and tired by jo_ham · · Score: 1

      I meant "readers", as I stated in the post.

    8. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If 'nerds' are writing software for the iPad and making lots of money doing it then I think this is newsworthy.

    9. Re:Sick and tired by mysidia · · Score: 1

      I will grant they are not news at this point. But "nor are they stuff that matters" is not true.

      Of course they matter. They are the latest product of one of the largest, well-known computer manufacturers.

    10. Re:Sick and tired by killmenow · · Score: 1

      To be fair, the stories that appear on slashdot are submitted by brazillians of "promoters" looking to get coverage. Slashdot is well read after all. It used to be the majority of stories were submitted by regular readers. But now that almost every f***ing web page has a "share on facebook|twitter|del.icio.us|slashdot|reddit|digg|stumbleupon|etc." button on it I think it's fair to say stories on all kinds of irrelevant topics are submitted to slashdot daily (if not hourly) and it's the editors who so clearly are interested.

      Probably because they know all the inevitable frothing at the mouth amongst the "GOD I F***ING HATE APPLE!!!!eleven!!!1!" and "PLEASE CAN I SUCK STEVE JOBS OFF?!?!?!" crowds make for a lot of comments and page hits.

    11. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Typical /. response.
      The /. crowd wants embedded devices to run UNIX. Apple delivers an iPhone and iPad than run UNIX. Consumers go *CRAZY* over these devices. They are the most functional and easiest devices to use ever!

      The /. crowd complains that the devices aren't "open" enough or that Apple is a bad company despite Apple putting UNIX in to the mainstream and really making a dent in the Win32 market.

      Yeesh, can't make some people happy.

    12. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Like it or not, iPad is still a significant topic. Personally, I don't care for a super-sized iPod. But it is of great consumer interest and is causing changes and controversies in the workplace, playspace and learnspace.

    13. Re:Sick and tired by Xest · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Yes, bringing a collection of a hundred DVDs is far easier than storing those hundred on 64GB of flash memory.

      Pray tell what kind of quality you'd have to rip down to to get 100 movies onto 64gb of flash memory, some of which is already used by the OS and apps.

      I think most people would rather keep their cheap, rather small, perfectly portable DVD wallets and not end up with abysmal quality, and have to spend hours and hours and hours for the privalage I'm afraid.

      I could understand your argument if anyone actually carried their DVDs around in their original standard DVD sized cases, or if anyone owned an automatic disc loading and ripping device, or had the will to literally spend days manually loading, unloading, and ripping their DVDs. But right now, it's far too time consuming and dull a job, for most, particularly when you can just buy a cheap DVD wallet to carry the lot around with you.

      Your sarcasm was misplaced- carrying a hundred DVDs around really is easier than ripping them to flash memory, and you wont have to try and destroy the quality to squeeze them into 64gb of storage either.

    14. Re:Sick and tired by bit01 · · Score: 1

      I meant "readers", as I stated in the post.

      Then you are being deliberately dishonest. You know full well almost all product stories are being spammed at the editors by marketing parasites until one gets through, not ordinary readers. Apple is one of the worst.

      ---

      You're a fool if you think advertising or insurance pays for anything at all.

    15. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well, the stories that appear on slashdot are submitted by slashdot readers, so clearly some people are interested.

      But this one is so obvious slashvertisment!

    16. Re:Sick and tired by xaxa · · Score: 1

      64GB / 100 = 640MB. That's 10MB less than a standard CD, so the quality could be something like what we used to share before DVD-Rs were widespread. Using a more modern codec would get better quality. They'll be watched on a small screen anyway, it's probably not a problem.

      I wouldn't want to leave 100 DVDs in a wallet in a car anyway. They're susceptible to heat/sun damage, and could be stolen very easily.

    17. Re:Sick and tired by Amarantine · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Who is going to carry around 100 of their original, expensive dvd's in their car? Waiting for them to get stolen, damaged by kids, scratched in the player when you take a speedbump? If you want to carry around so many movies, i think most people want to carry around copies, which involves de-css'ing them anyway. And then, carrying them around in the flash memory of a player seems suddenly a whole lot easier than burning them on physical media.

      Besides, the way i understand it, most people don't buy dvd's anyway, but download them in the first place, making it even easier.

    18. Re:Sick and tired by jedidiah · · Score: 1

      As much of a fan as I am of ripping DVDs, I must admit that it is not something I would expect the common user to do.

      Big Content has made sure that this is somewhat of an underground activity.

      H*ll, the Apple talking heads will even shout you down if you suggest something like embedding DVD audio into a media file.

      This is certainly not something that fits within the "iTunes media management mindset".

      --
      A Pirate and a Puritan look the same on a balance sheet.
    19. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      submitting news that are not about the iPad is pretty useless at this point, especially if it's about other tablets. I submitted 2 joojoo board stories since April the 1st, and guess what? never made it to the front page, even though they are still ~blue~. I love it how, as soon as someone complains it's the 5th or so apple story in the last 10 hours tons of (probably not-even-paid) marketeer fanbois come on and say "then turn off the apple category". It's not like people are not interested in Apple. They are just interested in stuff that fucking MATTERS about apple. not how the iPad saved your marriage and increased your penis AND breastsize!

    20. Re:Sick and tired by jo_ham · · Score: 1

      "Apple is one of the worst" - if by that you mean "tech blogs desperate for advertising hits who will post any/all rumours about Apple products" are one of the worst then perhaps you might be right.

      There is no doubting that Apple is like Marmite when it comes to news and rumours.

    21. Re:Sick and tired by jedidiah · · Score: 1

      Sure. Of course the Slashdot crowd is going to rag on the iPad. You can't even "manage" one with Linux.

      They are certainly not the most "functional".

      --
      A Pirate and a Puritan look the same on a balance sheet.
    22. Re:Sick and tired by jo_ham · · Score: 1

      So you're saying advertisers don't read slashdot?

    23. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, bringing a collection of a hundred DVDs is far easier than storing those hundred on 64GB of flash memory.

      Are you counting the time it takes to rip those "hundred DVDs" so you can store them on the flash memory?

      it is a piece of cake to DeCSS a movie and convert it to H.264

      OK, now do it a hundred times. That's a lot more time consuming than the amount it times to pop a DVD in the drive and hit play.

    24. Re:Sick and tired by Steauengeglase · · Score: 1

      What really galls me with half of these Apple iPad stories (and now iPad retrospectives) are the adjectives. Apple doesn't have engineers who must sign NDAs, they have brilliant geniuses who work under conditions of absolute secrecy. If you took some of these stories seriously you would think that Cupertino was the new Oak Ridge.

    25. Re:Sick and tired by MattSausage · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Just out of curiosity, isn't storing two iPads in the car the same sort of conundrum? And if you mean to remove the iPads every time you leave your car, why can't you do that with a dvd wallet?

    26. Re:Sick and tired by umghhh · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      hmm - I copy my media library into the HDs gradually but do it for iPad or whatever Apple wants me to pay for would be well silly. They have some nice products like iPods with preset sound level limits but for my kids a book and conversation is still main way of communication. This may change of course. I was wondering about this copying of movies to other media. I tend to have movies made in other languages that ones I speak (I speak fluently 3) and use subtitles. Last time I checked (admittedly longtime ago) this was an obstacle esp. if one wanted to have a choice w/ or w/o subtitles (for different audiences). Then again I do not spend too much time watching movies. Why should I?

    27. Re:Sick and tired by Lumpy · · Score: 1

      I agree, the 1080p I get out of that 7 inch complete crap quality screen in the car is AMAZING!

      a bad rip on an ipad will be 80X better than a bluray played on the garbage screen in any car.

      yes even if you bought the best screen you can get, it's still utter crap compared to the screen on the iPad or even a 15" cheapie PC monitor. Car monitors are barely 320X240 resolution. High end ones are 640X420

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    28. Re:Sick and tired by stewbacca · · Score: 1

      Ipads are not news for nerds, nor are they stuff that matters. Yuck.

      Egocentric much? I have absolutely NO interest in owning an iPad, but I don't pretend that they aren't big news.

    29. Re:Sick and tired by countach · · Score: 1

      Sure, if you already own the DVDs. But if you've got your collection ripped, its easier to sync.

    30. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Cite?

    31. Re:Sick and tired by StripedCow · · Score: 1

      You are right, the iPad is not geeky.

      However, when I'm reading news about the iPad on my iPad, it becomes a little geeky, no?

      --
      If Pandora's box is destined to be opened, *I* want to be the one to open it.
    32. Re:Sick and tired by babyrat · · Score: 1

      Ripping to a quality that is sufficient for viewing on a 9" screen, would require just about no degradation in quality to fit 100 movies in 64GB. Especially if you're talking about kids movies which tend to have less complicated scenes than the typical effects heavy sci-fi movie,

      carrying a hundred DVDs around really is easier than ripping them to flash memory, and you wont have to try and destroy the quality

      Yep- why destroy the quality with a rip when you can destroy the complete original disk by carrying it around in the car with you.

    33. Re:Sick and tired by Xest · · Score: 1

      "64GB / 100 = 640MB. That's 10MB less than a standard CD, so the quality could be something like what we used to share before DVD-Rs were widespread. Using a more modern codec would get better quality. They'll be watched on a small screen anyway, it's probably not a problem."

      I've not seen 650mb CDs in years, they were rare even a decade ago, 700mb has been standard for a long long time, and even then people would generally overburn or use 800mb discs. The quality issue isn't really one of amount of pixels, but amount of blurring away of detail that occurs with greater compression and that certainly is noticeable. A lot of rips nowadays are done as 2x 700mb or around that mark for the noticable quality increase, so around 1.4gb has been fairly standard for a while now.

      "I wouldn't want to leave 100 DVDs in a wallet in a car anyway. They're susceptible to heat/sun damage, and could be stolen very easily." ...unlike iPads?

      If they're in a wallet under the seat, or in the glove compartment, they're less susceptible to either of those two things than an iPad or two.

    34. Re:Sick and tired by babyrat · · Score: 1

      And if you mean to remove the iPads every time you leave your car, why can't you do that with a dvd wallet?

      Compare the size and weight of a 100 DVD wallet with the size and weight of a portable player (iPad, Archos, whatever new whizbang small tablet). Also consider that 100 DVDs cost double that of an iPad, and significantly more than double that of a cheaper alternative.

      Also, the iPad, or player of your choice will likely be taken out of the car anyways to be used for another purpose. When I get home, I'm probably going to bring the iPad in to surf the web or do other iPaddy things, while the dvd case would likely not have a reason to be brought in.

    35. Re:Sick and tired by CAIMLAS · · Score: 1

      Absolutely. Every once in a while there's an article of interest - maybe one or two a day - but compare it to the slashdot of 10 years ago:

      * lots of stuff on matchbox PCs
      * generally cool wearables and project sites
      * good space articles
      * the occasional link to esoteric HOWTOs and "look what I did"
      * links to fun/interesting/cheap hardware (today, we'd have links to the latest/greatest dual core Atom boards and interesting/cheap ARM boards, per chance)
      * cryptography, weapons and communication tech
      * indepth insights about archeology
      * start-up companies with something interesting/innovative/fringe improvements
      * crazy benchmarks on overclocked hardware and esoteric/fringe/interesting setups

      Of course, we had the Hellmouth self-sympathizing crap back then, too. But still! Maybe tech in general was cooler a decade ago than it is now, but it seems that 2/3 front page postings on /. these days is something about Apple, new product news releases, corporate purchases and dealings, rumors, and generally un-geeky things which only impact us in a cursory fashion.

      Just take a look at slashdot from today in 2000. And that was after Slashdot already started to suck.

      Slashdot was more interesting before it started shilling Apple nonsense, to be sure.

      --
      ~/ssh slashdot.org ssh: connect to host slashdot.org port 22: too many beers
    36. Re:Sick and tired by Xest · · Score: 1

      "Ripping to a quality that is sufficient for viewing on a 9" screen, would require just about no degradation in quality to fit 100 movies in 64GB. Especially if you're talking about kids movies which tend to have less complicated scenes than the typical effects heavy sci-fi movie,"

      I suppose it depends what's acceptable, certainly I wouldn't be happy with roughly 600mb rips, when I'm used to the quality of the typical ~1.4gb DVD rips, or simply DVD quality itself.

      "Yep- why destroy the quality with a rip when you can destroy the complete original disk by carrying it around in the car with you."

      How do you plan to destroy the original disc exactly? by being careless with it? by going over bumps or general bad driving or similar? Is the iPad magically invulnerable to damage in similar circumstances? Is an iPad less prone to theft than a small dull looking wallet?

      Most people's DVD collection can be replaced largely out of £2 bargain bins nowadays, I doubt people will have 100 brand new full price releases hanging around with them- I'm not sure there even are that many full price releases at any one time due to the fact that DVDs drop so quick in price now. Even if you did manage to break 1 or 2 discs through carelessness, it's a negligible replacement cost, especially considering the amount you'd save over buying a 64gb model of the iPad, even more so with the higher risk of theft of an iPad.

    37. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Really. I am sick and tired of seeing posts on /. on the Ipad. It's a waste of our time. Wasn't /. supposed to be "news for nerds, stuff that matters"? Ipads are not news for nerds, nor are they stuff that matters. Yuck.

      Ya know you can skip over the articles that say iPad in them?

      Let me clue you in a bit. You can't read everything see. You don't have to click and read every freaking article. You can just look at the head lines and if it's something that interest's you, you just click on the link.

      Think of the time your going to save not having to click through all of those subjects that you don't care about. Wow, buddy, I just made your day didn't I?

    38. Re:Sick and tired by PPalmgren · · Score: 1

      Everyone is watching like a hawk for the rager who posts his Giant List of Apple Greivances, and the ever important fanboy reply to it praising something completely unrelated and ignoring the criticism entirely. It gets me laughing every time, and I'm sure I'm not the only one. Even people not interested in Apple products will read Apple news stories because that kind of entertainment can't be bought.

      The only comments sections I can laugh at on a consistent basis are Evolution on CNN and Apple on Slashdot.

    39. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, I read "Apple shills" too.

    40. Re:Sick and tired by e3m4n · · Score: 2, Informative

      Who is going to carry around 100 of their original, expensive dvd's in their car?

      this was my thought too. My wife has a dodge grand caravan with a dvd system in it with a 5 disc changer. Personally I think it was worth every penny and has kept our road trips less stressful. Having the controls up front lets us manage playback which was great when my daughter was too young to operate the controls and once my son gets old enough to face forward in a vehicle I am sure I will re-appreciate the parent operated controls.

      The system in the minivan uses a 5-disc changer. Usually thats the maximum number of movies we have at any given time unless we're going on vacation and the kids want to pack a few extra. Aside from the fact that 5 kid movies is approximately 7hrs anyway... I cant express the fact enough the replay value a single movie seems to have with children. Watching a show 2, 3, even 4 times in a row has and will likely happen again. I can quote, in sync, just about every line to shrek (1 and 2), madagascar 1 and 2, all the pixar movies, and shark tales.

      I couldnt fathom a selection of 100 movies, I think the kids would still watch the same one 3 times in a row.

    41. Re:Sick and tired by viridari · · Score: 1

      A real nerd would have a Mac Mini in the car with 100+ DVD's on an actual hard disk, serving up movies from iTunes to all of the iPads in the car over wireless.

    42. Re:Sick and tired by Pigeon451 · · Score: 1

      A 2 hour movie can be compressed to 700 MB with very excellent quality (for low def). 100 movies x 700 MB is 70 GB, not far from 64 GB. Keep in mind these movies are being watched on a small screen, so you could probably increase the compression or reduce the image size and it would still look fine. 100 movies on 40 GB with decent quality is not unrealistic.

      Ripping them all would be tedious, agreed. You could d/l them instead, but, I suppose that's another can of worms.

    43. Re:Sick and tired by Xest · · Score: 1

      "Ripping them all would be tedious, agreed. You could d/l them instead, but, I suppose that's another can of worms."

      Actually I think it's a fair point, and as I said to someone else above, if we're starting from digital content in the first place I'd tend to agree it's a decent option, but I was merely pointing out in my above post that if you've got to rip them to start with then it's certainly not more effort than carrying around DVDs.

      I think the digital route is the future, but your average consumer already has hundreds of DVDs, and I don't think ripping or even often downloading them is really an option for the average joe right now. Most people I know with DVD collections have one of those DVD wallets for their collection for when they travel, because it's quick, cheap, easy, and because portable DVD players cost nothing, and DVD players in general are commonplace- taking the wallet to a friends house to watch a movie is quick and easy, more so than ripping/downloading.

    44. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's great for you, Humpty Dumpty.

    45. Re:Sick and tired by AshtangiMan · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      It's true. I now have a 10" dick and double D moobs.

    46. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Pray tell what kind of quality you'd have to rip down to to get 100 movies onto 64gb of flash memory, some of which is already used by the OS and apps.

      Don't forget that lots of stuff can be streamed from hulu, netflix, amazon, and a myriad of other sites over the interwebs - negating the requirement to have ripped every single piece of content you watch on the 'pad. (no I don't have one)
       
      Oh, wait, the ipad doesn't do flash. Shoot, I guess you're hosed then until the entire internet redesigns itself to accommodate the ipad. Never mind.
       
      (ducks and runs)

    47. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      I think most people would rather keep their cheap, rather small, perfectly portable DVD wallets and not end up with abysmal quality,

      You've clearly never mixed kids with DVDs, particularly in a car where they're even less likely to stay in their nice wallets when not in the player.

      I don't think my three (aged 4, 6 & 8) are unrepresentative; CDs/DVDs go from new to unplayable in about 2 months in the car.

    48. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Quality isn't an issue. For years now, 700MB DivX files of movies at DVD resolution look great.

    49. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      We rip our movies and put 'em on our lan. Once converted they're about 2GB w/ decent quality. You can't carry 100 movies on 64gb but you can get about 30 on there. That's 2.5 days worth...

      I'd rather carry an iPad than a bunch of CD/DVDs.

    50. Re:Sick and tired by ClosedSource · · Score: 1

      "Yes, bringing a collection of a hundred DVDs is far easier than storing those hundred on 64GB of flash memory."

      A hundred DVDs! What part of the Solar System to you intend to drive to?

    51. Re:Sick and tired by Richy_T · · Score: 1

      Ever seen the look on the face of someone who's had their DVD or CD collection stolen?

    52. Re:Sick and tired by Gilmoure · · Score: 1

      It took me about 3 months to rip around 350 DVD's to .mp4's for AppleTV. Now that the standing collection is done, is no problem keeping up with current purchases. But yeah, I can't see many regular folks doing this.

      Am waiting for someone to come up with a hard drive case that incorporates a wireless server for the iPad. Would be great for car trips. I hate having to sync media files to my iPhone; I like streaming stuff to it from my Mac server around the house.

      --
      I drank what? -- Socrates
    53. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Agree. Do you think any schmuck that would pay $2000 for an in car entertainment system would a.) have even the slightest clue on how to rip a DVD or b.) spend the time to do such a thing on all the DVDs the kiddies want to watch? Sure you can download movies form iTunes, but then you're asking him to figure out how to play those movies on his brand new LCD TV (which while look like crap anyway).

    54. Re:Sick and tired by ya+really · · Score: 1

      Or just turn off the "Apple" section in your preferences, which is much more effective than moaning about it on the actual story, as many people seem to do.

      Perhaps the parent is like me and doesn't want to turn off the Apple postings because maybe 1 in 8 isnt about the ipad/iphone/iwhatever and is actually newsworthy and perhaps interesting. It would be nice if slashdot made some sort of way to filter out iCrap and keep the other postings about Apple.

    55. Re:Sick and tired by Xest · · Score: 1

      No, probably slightly less concerned look than having an iPad stolen I would imagine though.

    56. Re:Sick and tired by c_forq · · Score: 1

      Opposite. Do you know how much new CDs and DVDs cost? Just a few dozen and you get close to the cost of an iPad. They get stolen and they're gone, however when the iPad is stolen it's backed up on my computer (hypothetically, I don't own an iPad yet).

      --
      Computers allow humans to make mistakes at the fastest speeds known, with the possible exception of tequila and handguns
    57. Re:Sick and tired by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's 640MB per film. Standard DVD rip size a few years ago (rip and burn to a CD, how naughty), sure there may be a few rough edges, but on a small screen? More than enough.

    58. Re:Sick and tired by Xest · · Score: 1

      Around £2/£3 for the majority of DVDs in someone's collection, so even mixing in say some new releases, and some are mid-age at say £5 then you're looking at:

      50x £3
      30x £5
      20x £10

      That's a pretty unrealistic breakdown, most people wont have 20 new releases per 100 CDs, and even 30 at £5 is a push with the speed at which DVDs drop in price, but even with this rather unrealistic mix that's biased towards your theory that DVD collections are more expensive it's still only £500. In contrast, a 64gb iPad is set to be at least £700. There's going to be a few hundred pound gap either way, the only way your argument would hold any sway is if every DVD in the collection was a new release, but I'm not sure there are even enough full priced new releases at any one time to fill a wallet, and it usually only takes a couple of weeks before the price of them drops to around the £5 mark, so even assuming you bought 100 new releases at full price and had them stolen that day, you'd only need a few weeks to be able to replace them at less than you paid originally, and still at far less than the cost of a 64gb iPad- even in the most hypothetical unrealistic scenario your argument doesn't hold any real weight largely because the iPads cost will remain high for a much longer period.

      Of course, an iPad is a much more likely target than a dull looking wallet, and when you lose your iPad you could be losing more than just your movie collection- personal data and the likes, this even brings the possibility of being at risk of further crimes like identity fraud.

      So no, it's really not the opposite.

    59. Re:Sick and tired by Dog-Cow · · Score: 1

      Yeah, because visual quality is the overriding concern for kids in the backseat of a car. You aren't all that bright. I almost feel pity for you.

    60. Re:Sick and tired by Holmwood · · Score: 1

      Pray tell what kind of quality you'd have to rip down to to get 100 movies onto 64gb of flash memory, some of which is already used by the OS and apps.

      I think most people would rather keep their cheap, rather small, perfectly portable DVD wallets and not end up with abysmal quality

      Seriously? You do understand NTSC DVDs are limited to 480p (less than that if you want uniform square pixels and are talking most movies these days)? We're talking something a real like 24 Hz, 405p for the video channel for a typical film. (Yes, the DVD may run at near 30Hz, but almost all films originate at 24).

      You are unlikely to need more than stereo 128 kbit MP3 for mobile film audio. (Again, remember, we're comparing to an ICE). So we're talking about 90 minutes (typical film), 128kbit audio, that works out to 82 MiB for the audio channel.

      64GiB (we're talking flash, not HDD) will give you 655 MiB average for each of 100 films. You don't need to install an OS or applications, we're talking data media here. That leave 573 MiB for the video channel.

      From years of video work (no, not a euphemism for pirating movies; I studied video compression techniques in grad school, and did some professional CODEC work thereafter), a few hundred megs will give you barely adequate (soft) video with H.264 for a typical movie. 573-some will give you respectable video with MPEG-4 Part 2, and very nice mobile (or even very basic home theatre) performance for H.264, assuming your CODEC is good and carefully tuned. Again, I'm talking strictly the video channel here.

      So, no, I'd rather carry around a flash drive or two than 100 DVD's. For the application the whole thread is discussing, the available memory per film would be just fine. You would genuinely prefer 100 DVDs scratched, smeared with peanut butter, and dropped randomly into your car at the worst possible moment to a USB key sitting in the glovebox? (We're talking about ICE applications, and, overwhelmingly that's for kids in the back seat. If you haven't seen what kids do to DVD's, I should invite you on a road trip...)

      Is it what I'd encode my DVDs at for home theatre use? Nope. I'd want twice the space per DVD, so I'd only get about 50 per 64GB, but I'd be happy to see you try to tell the difference between those and the original encodes.

      Your sarcasm was misplaced-

      And, respectfully, your condescension towards the GP was misplaced. His point was reasonable and correct, and he's just fine in quality for mobile use. Even adequate (though not great) for basic home viewing.

      -Holmwood

  3. I do not get it... by betterunixthanunix · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Can someone explain the appeal of these "in car entertainment" systems? Seriously, this sounds like another way to not pay attention to your kids, even while you are within 2 feet of them.

    --
    Palm trees and 8
    1. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      Best use is for long journeys.

      Granted, if you're not driving far they're pretty needless, but I've got portable 2 screen system that I hook up when we're going long ways.

      Just a few weeks ago we drove about 12 hours, 3 times. Kids would have gone nuts without being able to watch some stuff now and again.

    2. Re:I do not get it... by wiredog · · Score: 4, Insightful

      No, you get it. That's the purpose.

    3. Re:I do not get it... by Parlett316 · · Score: 3, Funny

      Dick waving contest. I always love driving behind a car that has two tvs in the headrests that are on and no one in the backseat.

    4. Re:I do not get it... by alen · · Score: 1

      it takes a few minutes for kids to get sick of their parents and start screaming for entertainment

    5. Re:I do not get it... by $RANDOMLUSER · · Score: 5, Funny

      Damn right!

      Kids these days with their "in car entertainment" and their "iPods" and whatnot; when I was their age all we had to do in the back of the station wagon was fight with our brothers and sisters and make faces at the cars behind us! And we were damn glad to do it!

      Now get off my lawn!

      --
      No folly is more costly than the folly of intolerant idealism. - Winston Churchill
    6. Re:I do not get it... by selven · · Score: 1

      Have you ever tried to survive a 10 hour car ride as a kid? Unless you have entertainment (and no, talking to your parents doesn't count for more than 15 minutes), you will get extremely bored before you're even halfway through.

    7. Re:I do not get it... by mungtor · · Score: 2, Insightful

      They're awesome ways to keep kids entertained when you're on an 8-hour road trip to take them to visit family and stuff. It's not a matter of "not paying attention" to them since they only come out in preparation for a long trip (at least in our case). They're not necessary, but it makes a trip much more enjoyable for everybody and significantly cheaper than flying. Often it's my wife and the kids in the back watching a movie together, talking, and basically hanging out while I'm driving.

    8. Re:I do not get it... by antifoidulus · · Score: 1

      Didn't you see Homer's concept car? Nobody wants to deal with their kids!

    9. Re:I do not get it... by betterunixthanunix · · Score: 2

      Actually, I survived many such trips as an only child in a one parent home, and the only electronic entertainment was music. It was not that bad, I did not get bored speaking to my mom and looking at the various oddities in the rural regions between New York City and Toronto.

      It was not just my own mother; I have seen plenty of parents who are able to keep their children engaged, even on very long trips.

      --
      Palm trees and 8
    10. Re:I do not get it... by jo_ham · · Score: 1

      So the kids listen to the iPod built into it, or the built in audio part of the car entertainment system. Or read a book.

      I think it's a huge (and totally disingenuous) leap to go from "has ICE" to "does not pay attention or know how to engage their kids". It is just one of several options available to parents, or even as a perk for adult passengers on a long road trip.

      Just because they have a system like this does not make them bad parents, which seems to be the inference here.

    11. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Should've thought of that before you made 'em.

    12. Re:I do not get it... by betterunixthanunix · · Score: 1

      Well keep in mind that the "music" I was referring was a radio, which actually led to a lot of fun in the rural areas (at least for city folk like us).

      In any case, it really depends on how people use these systems. Someone mentioned that his wife sits in the back seat with the kids watching a movie -- not such a bad use case. On the other hand, people seem to be talking about giving each kid an iPad, which sounds like "leave them alone with their electronic toys."

      --
      Palm trees and 8
    13. Re:I do not get it... by ProppaT · · Score: 1

      I agree. I think portable DVD players, gameboys (I know they're DS/DSi/DSiXXXL and PSPs now, but still), etc. have their place on long car trips...but it is a shame how many parents pop in the DVD for their kid when they're just running to the store for milk, etc. These are the times to engage your child. Long trips are the times when you pop in the movie or whatever to keep them from getting into fights.

      --
      Wise men say, "Forgiveness is divine, but never pay full price for late pizza."
    14. Re:I do not get it... by danerthomas · · Score: 1

      Our kids are 15 and 12 and have traveled as with us by plane, train, automobile and ship both domestically and internationally for all of their lives. When traveling by car they like to have their iPods and a Nintendo DS, but we also like to listen to books (started with tapes, then CD's, now an iPod played through the car's sound system). On our trip from Stockholm to Northern Norway and back a few years ago we also got the kids interested in following our progress on the road maps so they could understand where we were, see what was coming up and make suggestions on what they were interested in seeing, where we might want to stop for lunch and so on. The same would work with a GPS. Make them an active part of the trip, not just baggage to be transported. Everybody gets more out of it that way.

    15. Re:I do not get it... by jocknerd · · Score: 1

      You don't have kids, do you? We bought our kids portable DVD players for our trip to Florida a couple of years ago. Well worth the money. This year, we'll be bringing the iPad along for the ride. Wife and I need some entertainment for the road too.

    16. Re:I do not get it... by Calinous · · Score: 1

      I can't dedicate much attention span to anything else while I drive. As such, keeping a child entertained during even a couple of hours drive is very difficult for me. My solution? Drive at night, when the kid sleeps

    17. Re:I do not get it... by xgr3gx · · Score: 3, Interesting

      What we need to do is stop bombarding kids with constant streams of electronic entertainment.
      If a kid always has a screen with moving pictures (be it a dvd player, game or whatever) in front of his face, how do you expect them to sit still when you take it away. It like digital crack.
      Yes, kids can be a pain - but part of being a parent is dealing with those situations by interacting with them in a positive way.
      I'm not saying no TV ever, but people wonder why kids have attention deficit disorder. I'm sure most of those kids can hold their attention perfectly fine when it's focused on a TV. How is a teacher supposed to teach a class when most of the kids are used to constant electronic entertainment?

      --
      Shameless plug alert: Game server control panel
    18. Re:I do not get it... by sharkey · · Score: 2, Informative

      You're forgetting the semis! Anyone who could make an unsuspecting dad shit his pants by getting a trucker to blow their horn at the right moment was the clear winner.

      --

      --
      "Outlook not so good." That magic 8-ball knows everything! I'll ask about Exchange Server next.
    19. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      When I was a kid on a long road trip there were these things called BOOKs. With all the in car entertainment systems one would think they quit making them, but both of my kids seem to like them as they are more reliable than anything electronic.

      Then again, as the eldest now has a learner's permit... The youngest and I sat on the back seat watching Hannibal Lecter movies on the laptop on the last road trip. Laptops have an added bonus over ipads and portable DVD players, run the wireless in AP mode and pretend to be a free wireless provider at gas stations and rest areas...

    20. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It depends on how they are used. Our senna has a built in system, but we only allow our kids to use it for trips over 45 minutes, short trips around town we talk. For longer trips getting kids to keep still and not get bored is a challenge. With the in car entertainment system it turns the longer trips into a fun peaceful experience. Our girls watch the built in system in the second row and our son uses a portable on in the third row. Sometimes they watch shows the entire trip, other times they watch a little and then talk. Seeing my son munching on Va diner peanuts and laughing his head off at the 3 stooges or little rascals is priceless.

      That said trips around town the kids are not allowed to use the entertainment systems. Because we reserve them for long trips they retain the novelty and keep traditional family interaction when driving around town.

      It works well for us. My wife and I had many discussions on how best to use these before we introduced them to the kids.

    21. Re:I do not get it... by jo_ham · · Score: 5, Informative

      As any parent with a kid will (or should!) tell you, giving them access to things like that is all part of a managed activity schedule, much like access to TV or the computer. You can set aside times when your children can use these things, and for how long, and various other rules. In car entertainment is just another medium where this occurs.

      in the same way that multiple TV sets in homes added more flexibility for families where someone wants to watch channel A while others watch channel B, the in car systems mean not everyone has to listen to the radio, which can be a total blessing if your kids really want to listen to the high school musical soundtrack *again*, or the Bob the Builder greatest hits.

      Like anything involving parenting though, not everyone makes good parents, but allowing kids access to things like this doesn't automatically put people into that category.

    22. Re:I do not get it... by jittles · · Score: 1

      I'm pretty sure most people on here were children at some point and probably are quite familiar with the situation you are describing. If our parents survived without in-car entertainment systems surely modern day parents can as well?

    23. Re:I do not get it... by Dan+East · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Sure. I have a just-turned-2 year old. Legally he cannot be placed in the front seat (even with a proper carrier), so his car seat is in the row of seats behind me, where I cannot even physically touch him. I cannot read to him, or play with him, or do anything but say words out of my mouth. Last week we made a 14 hour round trip (and Mom couldn't go), and I was very, very thankful that he enjoys watching Curious George and Elmo on the integrated entertainment system, because otherwise he would have been miserable - bored out of his mind, screaming his head off, and stressing me out and taking my concentration away from driving.

      We stopped and grabbed a couple DVDs out of a RedBox for a buck a piece, and returned them the next day at our local RedBox when we got home.

      We even have a TV and DVD player at our house too. More than one, believe it or not.

      --
      Better known as 318230.
    24. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Seriously, this sounds like another way to not pay attention to your kids, even while you are within 2 feet of them.

      When operating an automobile, you should be paying attention to:

      A) Your iPad

      B) Your kids

      C) The road

      D) Cowboy Neal

    25. Re:I do not get it... by CrimsonAvenger · · Score: 1

      Have you ever tried to survive a 10 hour car ride as a kid? Unless you have entertainment (and no, talking to your parents doesn't count for more than 15 minutes), you will get extremely bored before you're even halfway through.

      Once upon a time, many years ago when I was a kid, we used to use books for our in-car entertainment. Worked quite well, really.

      --

      "I do not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it"
    26. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Try a 6 hour trip with 4 kids under the age of 9 and let me know how it works out for you.

    27. Re:I do not get it... by killmenow · · Score: 1

      Distracted driving is a factor a lot of accidents. So is sleepiness. Kids are a frequent distraction and long trips make drivers sleepy. It's a recipe for disaster. What we do on long trips (usually take a couple 13+ hr drives each year) is plan ahead. The kids get a few new books to read during the trip. They each get one new video/movie to watch on the trip. They each get a new music CD to listen to. I've bought refurb MP3 players off woot.com for less than $10/ea and we recently found portable DVD players for $19.99/ea.

      So, during those long trips, to keep things interesting, they have options and I can focus on driving. We still turn everything off and talk during parts of our trips and even play games (alphabet games, love bug, I spy, etc.) but when I know I need to focus, their Mom can take the lead and read to them or get them a DVD going or whatever and I can pay proper attention to the road.

      Older kids are a different story. Our teenagers often would rather sit quietly in the back with headphones on listening to music, reading a book, and texting their friends than talk or play stupid road games with their parents. Which is why it's so much fun for us to force them to interact with us anyway.

    28. Re:I do not get it... by Andy+Dodd · · Score: 1

      When you're behind the wheel, there are only two things you should be paying attention to:
      The road and whatever may be present on that road outside of your vehicle.

      Kids who are not entertained get noisy. Noisy kids distract you from the road. Distraction from the road can get you and your child killed.

      --
      retrorocket.o not found, launch anyway?
    29. Re:I do not get it... by Ukab+the+Great · · Score: 1

      Sometimes you need an alternative to the fistfight that breaks out in your backseat when you pass the Shoney's informally hosting the local VW Beetle owners club.

    30. Re:I do not get it... by Psmylie · · Score: 5, Funny

      No kidding! We made our own entertainment as kids. We played games, and not just the tame ones like "I spy" and the like. We made our OWN games, thus increasing our creativity! We played games like, "What's that smell?" and "Does this hurt?" and "Let's make the veins pop out on the driver's forehead"! And, of course, the ever popular "I'm not touching you!" while waggling a finger mere millimeters away from your siblings body after being instructed not to touch them. This last game was a real challenge, as a pothole or sudden change of direction could jostle you just enough to come into contact with your sibling, and therefore breaking the "rules" and getting you into trouble.

      Ah, good times. Good times.

      --

      psmylie's dictionary: Godzillion (noun) Any number large enough to destroy Tokyo

    31. Re:I do not get it... by hal2814 · · Score: 1

      I don't know any parents who didn't have some form of in-car entertainment system. That system only recently includes video as an option, but there was certainly a system of some sort. In my childhood, our in-car entertainment system generally included action figures, activity books, reading books, and music. My kids have DVD players, activity books, and toys as their in-car entertainment system.

    32. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Can someone explain the appeal of these "in car entertainment" systems? Seriously, this sounds like another way to not pay attention to your kids, even while you are within 2 feet of them.

      Some of us think that you should pay attention to the road and other vehicles when you are driving.

      In fact, I think that many legislatures think so too.

    33. Re:I do not get it... by $RANDOMLUSER · · Score: 2, Funny

      LOL. I swear to God, one time my kids got into a fight because "SHE'S LOOKING OUT MY WINDOW!!!".

      --
      No folly is more costly than the folly of intolerant idealism. - Winston Churchill
    34. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ah, I used to dreeeaaam about having brothers or sisters to fight with! When my stepdad and stepmom used to let me out of the cage in the basement and actually wanted me in the car they put me in the trunk and I had to suck air in from the broken tail-light.

    35. Re:I do not get it... by xaxa · · Score: 1

      My parents were similar when I was 13, 14 and 16 on our USA road trips. I navigated pretty much the entire time, since it meant I got to sit in the front :-). My brother brought Harry Potter (taped from the radio), which was useful if we got bored of the music.

      But, it depends what style of road trip you do. Motorways are almost always boring, if you want to see interesting things you need to take the smaller roads that go through the towns and villages. Since my parents live pretty much in the middle of England the longest non-stop motorway trip we ever did was about five hours -- after that we either reached the sea, or ran out of fast road (i.e. Scotland, Wales, SW England etc). I can see it would get really boring on a 10-hour motorway trip. Seemingly endless tiny roads are dull (or even frustrating) too, if the scenery isn't changing and there aren't any settlements.

      How did the trip to Northern Norway go? Interesting? My dad doesn't like visiting cities and wants to see Norway, but my mum is yet to be convinced it's worthwhile. She once went on the train as far as you can go, and says it's just endless forest with the occasional glimpse of something. (This sounds like my dad's idea of fun, TBH.) None of the Norwegian or Swedish people I know have visited the north of their countries.

    36. Re:I do not get it... by Lumpy · · Score: 2, Funny

      what was fun was mooning and flipping people off from the back seat in the station wagon. Dad cant see what you are doing and he wonder why everyone passing is honking at him and flipping him off.

      P.S. doing it to a cop will get you in trouble.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    37. Re:I do not get it... by bytestorm · · Score: 1

      Not just kids, this is how I get when you take away my /.

    38. Re:I do not get it... by stewbacca · · Score: 1

      It's even better when they are playing porn.

    39. Re:I do not get it... by dwillden · · Score: 1

      When driving you should NOT be paying attention to your kids, you should be paying attention to the road. So having a way to entertain the kids (not all are old enough to read, and not all kids enjoy reading), to keep them from fighting which will distract you from driving.

      Are these for everyone? No. Are they an invaluable tool for many parents trying to safely drive somewhere? Absolutely.

      --
      I'm too lazy to compose a creative sig.
    40. Re:I do not get it... by dwillden · · Score: 1

      You like to read, so books worked great for you (ditto for me). Not all kids like to read, or are old enough to read. Yet there are a wide variety of video's out there to enable the entertainment (and thus peaceful safe travel) of said kids.

      --
      I'm too lazy to compose a creative sig.
    41. Re:I do not get it... by Azghoul · · Score: 1

      Some kids, like me, get pretty ill when reading in a moving car. Books were not an option for me.

    42. Re:I do not get it... by tnk1 · · Score: 1

      I love books, but reading books on road trips makes me really, really car sick. I usually think these TVs in cars are a gigantic waste of money, and even a little disturbing when used to keep kids quiet, but I can't deny that they may have uses in the more extreme cases.

    43. Re:I do not get it... by stewbacca · · Score: 1

      It takes even less time to smack kids who start screaming for entertainment.

    44. Re:I do not get it... by stewbacca · · Score: 1

      No kidding! I actually had to rewind my tapes, and up until about 1986, I actually had to flip the tape over on my own!

    45. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I am curious: how is "extremely bored" the same as "not surviving?"

    46. Re:I do not get it... by MadKeithV · · Score: 1

      Are we there yet?

    47. Re:I do not get it... by istartedi · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Yeah, do kids even play the "license plate game" anymore? They'll never know the reward of hours in the car, and then the majesty of the Delaware Memorial Bridge looming up on the horizon. "Daddy, is that the golden gate?" "No. This is Delaware". I bet they just look up from their gadget and go "hmph" if the 'rents point out the landmarks. Are these kids going to be so overstimulated that the only thing to turn them on will be something truly dangerous?

      --
      For all intensive purposes, "whom" is no longer a word. That begs the question, "who cares"?
    48. Re:I do not get it... by xgr3gx · · Score: 1

      Ha! ;)

      --
      Shameless plug alert: Game server control panel
    49. Re:I do not get it... by babyrat · · Score: 1

      If our parents survived without in-car entertainment systems surely modern day parents can as well?

      My great great grandparents survived without automobiles, electricity and many other things we have today. Should we do away with those as well?

      The answer of course is yes we could survive without them, but why would we want to give them up?

    50. Re:I do not get it... by demi · · Score: 1

      Some of us on here are even parents, believe it or not. I just finished a 8200-mile, five-week cross-country road trip with my six-year-old. He had loads of toys in the backseat, there were two parents, and he did have a portable DVD player as well as a Leapster (that's like a "semi-educational" portable game thing).

      The DVD player stopped working in the first week and he never really showed much interest in the Leapster. Most of the toys he brought didn't appeal much in the car and for the parent who wasn't driving, keeping up a constant show of entertainment wasn't an option. What really made the difference is that he's just really well-adjusted on road trips, which we have been taking him on since he was very young. Probably the most effective "entertainments" were the same silly road games we all remember playing: eye spy, twenty questions, categories, car-counting games and, of course, just having conversations about what we were seeing and doing.

      There's no moral stand here, all kids are different and need different things in a car. An in-car DVD system would have been better than what we had because it wouldn't have been as fragile and wouldn't have been another item of clutter in an enormously packed car; but I don't think we would have used it that much more. We got the DVD player working again, basically, about halfway through, but he only watched another couple of movies out of the many many hours of driving.

      For those people who think absolute attention is a necessity for safe driving: Ideally, maybe; but only race car drivers actually drive that way. For normal driving, one's attention is constantly divided. Even when alone, you're thinking about things other than driving, such as where you're going, what you're doing that day and whether to make a side stop. Part of being a safe driver is being able to carry out normal activities compatible with safe driving, such as having a conversation or making plans about where you're going.

      --
      demi
    51. Re:I do not get it... by CAIMLAS · · Score: 1

      Do you have children? Have you taken a long car trip with them?

      An hour in the car is a long time for kids. A very long time. When I was a kid, we'd take a 5-hour trip once a year to visit my grandparents: my dad would pack the minivan early, go to bed early, and then wake up at 4am to start the trip. Hed bundle us up (it was usually Thanksgiving/Christmas time, and cold), and package us in the van, hoping we'd stay asleep until we got there. Even still, we were awake for 2-3 hours of the trip each time, and it seemed like an eternity.

      I've taken several long trips with my kids (and my definition of 'long' is slightly longer than the measly 5 hours): I've done a 2-day 1800 mile trip with them and my wife in a Ford Focus. (Yes, it sucked.) There would have been no way to get through the trip in anything less than 4 or 5 days if it wasn't for having a laptop with movies on it. Yes, we gave them books, and when we weren't shift-sleeping (one person would drive and the other would sleep), we were reading books to them, playing games with them (I spy, I'm thinking of..., stupid songs, etc.), and talking with them.

      The general rules with kids on a long trip is "if they're in touching distance, they're fighting. If they can see each other, they're fighting." Either that, or they're playing (loudly). It makes any sort of driving difficult.

      Leave it to a (probably) childless person to criticize parents for something like this.

      --
      ~/ssh slashdot.org ssh: connect to host slashdot.org port 22: too many beers
    52. Re:I do not get it... by CAIMLAS · · Score: 1

      It largely depends on the child. More active children are a nightmare on a long trip, particularly if you've got two of them. I've found a car trip is easily 3-4 times more difficult with multiple children than it is with just one - even if you've got a second adult to help. A single child is pretty easy to handle, really (provided they're over the age of 2).

      The problem isn't even so much keeping the kids engaged; it's keeping them engaged and not causing trouble. When you're driving on a busy interstate, the last thing you need is to be hit in the back of the head with a flying toy or have your blood curdled by a scream.

      --
      ~/ssh slashdot.org ssh: connect to host slashdot.org port 22: too many beers
    53. Re:I do not get it... by b0bby · · Score: 1

      When I'm driving, I try to pay attention to the road. If we're going to be in the car for 30 minutes on the DC beltway, why not let them watch something while I concentrate? They don't watch much TV at home, there are no ads on our dvds, and we're generally on our way to do something as a family. I think it's a perfect time for them to watch something. On longer trips we tend to listen to books on cd etc, because you can't watch tv for that long, but for running around town the dvd is great.

    54. Re:I do not get it... by Chysn · · Score: 1

      When I was a kid on a long road trip there were these things called BOOKs.

      Your backinmyday story sounds dreadful. You know they murdered trees and dumped dioxin into the environment to make those things, right? Good riddance, I say!

      --
      --I'm so big, my sig has its own sig.
      -- See?
    55. Re:I do not get it... by Xsydon · · Score: 1

      Oh honey he's teasing you...nobody has two tv sets...!

    56. Re:I do not get it... by Lxy · · Score: 1

      Do you have young children, and have you ever spent more than 2 hours in a minivan with them? Law requires me to be in the driver's seat, kids in the back seat. Kinda hard to entertain small children that way.

      I agree that there may be other more worthwile forms of entertainment (books and travel games), which I have, but even those fade in time. A headrest monitor with DVD/whatever else capability is another tool in the box to keep your journey sane.

      Now, as for the iPadd "killing" this, really??? I've seen dual monitor DVD kits for under $200, not sure how a $500 piece of hardware "kills" that. Shoot, I paid $400 for a laptop that often gets used a a backseat entertainment system, and has a lot more functionality than this Apple contraption.

      * iPadd is a reflection of the fact that Apple has finally built a Star Trek TNG padd-like device that can actually be used as such for managing server farms. For this I give them credit.

      --

      There is no reasonable defense against an idiot with an agenda
      :wq
    57. Re:I do not get it... by rider_prider · · Score: 1

      I have one in my van, we don't use it all the time, but we do use it for longer trips (2 hours+). It's just one more option (including books, travel games, talking) that makes trips a little less boring. We live in western Canada travel more than 40,000 km's per year, for work, sports, visiting family, vacations,... Sitting in vehicle for 8 hours of driving over a weekend, is a lot to ask from little kids.

    58. Re:I do not get it... by dr2chase · · Score: 1

      Books on tape. Harry Potter, Jim Dale, he's pretty good. Avoid Redwall. We tried a The Hobbit BoT once, the reader was a tad ponderous.

    59. Re:I do not get it... by xaxa · · Score: 1

      What's the "license plate game"? I don't remember being able to do anything more than count off states on the USA road trip my family did.

      UK number plates have various orderings (when one system runs out of numbers a new one is created). The usual game is to spot the next one in the order, e.g. if the previous person sees F___ ___ then you need to see G___ ___. On especially long trips you can do it with the numbers -- _145 ___ is followed by _146 ___.

      (The equivalent of see-all-the-states is to see cars with either EU or international tags, e.g. D, F, GB, IRL, CH etc. In Britain this isn't much good though, especially outside the south-east, as there are generally not many foreign-registered cars around.)

    60. Re:I do not get it... by LordKronos · · Score: 1

      Kids would have gone nuts without being able to watch some stuff now and again.

      When I was a kid, we used to do tons of driving. 8 hour drives to new york. 20 hour drives to florida and colorado. 3 day drives to washington. Somehow, I managed to never go nuts. When I was a teen, we made some of these trips with various nieces/nephews between the ages of 2 and 7 and they all managed to survive just fine.

    61. Re:I do not get it... by troll8901 · · Score: 1

      When operating an automobile, you should be paying attention to:

      The girls walking beside the road.

      Especially the 22 year olds wearing sexy form-fitting blouses and hot curvy pants. Or preferably lacy négligée-like blouses with spaghetti straps, and non-denim shorts that really emphasize their curves and bring attention to their perfectly-shaped legs ...

    62. Re:I do not get it... by lowrydr310 · · Score: 1

      I took my wife, my two year old daughter, and seven year old nephew on a road trip from NYC to Huntsville, AL and back, all over the course of four days. We brought a portable DVD player, but ended up not using it at all. Don't ask me how, but the kids had a wonderful time enjoying the scenery and engaging in interesting conversation with us.

      I guess the fact that we're always driving somewhere on the weekends helps since they're used to being in the car.

    63. Re:I do not get it... by xaxa · · Score: 1

      When I was that young my parents would take the train on a trip that long, if possible (i.e. if we were just visiting a city and wouldn't need our own car, or if we were visiting family/friends who would lend us their car -- we couldn't have afforded to rent one). We'd take colouring books, a pack of cards, perhaps some food and a book to read. Nowadays some children I see on intercity trains have MP3 players or games systems, but plenty still just have books, comics, games etc. (Actually, they all have phones, which usually includes games and music...)

      Stuff that works on trains often isn't really an option in a car though. I can't read in a car without feeling queasy, but I have no problem reading on a train. Playing board/card games is difficult in a car: the bits get lost. Talking isn't as easy: one adult is supposed to be driving, another sometimes navigating, or in any case facing the wrong way. Sitting in mum's lap for a bit is illegal. Cars are uncomfortable -- you can stand up on a train, walk around, go to the toilet, there's no seat belt, the seat is massive, there's no petrol fumes. There's also certainty about the journey. "Are we nearly there yet?" "We'll be there at 14:09, here, you can have my watch."

    64. Re:I do not get it... by troll8901 · · Score: 1

      By "TV" he must have meant monitor, and "DVD player" must be referring to a CD-ROM drive.
      Nobody has two TVs and two DVD players!

      ---
      "When I was your age I never chased a boy, or called a boy, or sat in a parked car with a boy." - Lorraine Baines

    65. Re:I do not get it... by LordKronos · · Score: 1

      Wait...so looking at a book makes you sick but looking at a screen doesn't? Very odd. That doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me. I was always under the impression that the illness was cause by not seeing the scenery outside moving by, and thus your brain freaks out because it feels the movement but doesn't see it.

    66. Re:I do not get it... by not+flu · · Score: 1

      Same here - then again I think watching a DVD or playing a game would have a similar effect. There's always windows, the image quality is far superior and looking at the view doesn't cause motion sickness. MP3 players are fine also.

    67. Re:I do not get it... by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Kids these days with their "in car entertainment" and their "iPods" and whatnot; when I was their age all we had to do in the back of the station wagon was fight with our brothers and sisters and make faces at the cars behind us!

      Being serious now, I do feel bad for today's kids. When I was growing up, you could sleep across the back seat or climb up front to hang out with the parents. On quiet stretches of the interstate, Dad would let me sit on his lap and steer while he worked the pedals. Sure, it was unsafe as hell, but it beat being continuously strapped down as is mandated now. I can't blame the kids for wanting their DSes and iPods because they're stuck in their seats for 8 hours at a time.

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
    68. Re:I do not get it... by demonlapin · · Score: 1

      I'm going to go out on a limb here, but I'm betting you're at least 30. Back then, you could let your kids roam around in the back of the car legally. My sister and I divvied up the back of the station wagon - I got the back seat, she got the very back - and we could more or less do as we wished on trips.

      Fast forward to now - you have to keep your kids strapped in at all times by law. It's a lot harder now. And frankly, I'd have LOVED being able to watch movies while we traveled - especially when it got too dark to read.

    69. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Legally he cannot be placed in the front seat (even with a proper carrier), so his car seat is in the row of seats behind me, where I cannot even physically touch him. I cannot read to him, or play with him, or do anything but say words out of my mouth.

      You're restricted to driving while driving? How horrible, the damned laws taking away your rights to play with your child while driving all in the name of protecting your child from your idiotic ways. At least you can still text and chat on the phone while you drive.

    70. Re:I do not get it... by demonlapin · · Score: 1

      Until it got dark, and your dad told you to turn the light off because it was messing with his night vision.

    71. Re:I do not get it... by LanMan04 · · Score: 1

      I live in America. Have you ever been on a 3 week, 3000 mile (4800km) road trip with children under the age of 10?

      Yeah, I thought so.

      --
      With the first link, the chain is forged.
    72. Re:I do not get it... by LanMan04 · · Score: 1

      My family took a 3000 mile, 3 week roadtrip back in about 1990 (in a big-ass minivan). Here's what my Dad did (I was about 11).

      1) Build a wooden stand that fit between the two front seats to hold a 10" color TV (well-secured so as not to kill people in an accident)
      2) Buy a DC/AC inverter
      3) Stuff a Nintendo (NES) and VCR under the bench seat.

      What a great trip that was. Playing MegaMan 3 while blasting across Wyoming is a fucking awesome.

      --
      With the first link, the chain is forged.
    73. Re:I do not get it... by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 1

      +1 on the inverter. It opens so many possibilities! We have a portable DVD player with composite inputs, and used it with a GameCube on a cross-country trip.

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
    74. Re:I do not get it... by Hatta · · Score: 1

      Better solution is to just stop having kids. That way you don't have to buy expensive entertainment devices for them, AND you don't have to deal with their hyperactivity. Win-win.

      --
      Give me Classic Slashdot or give me death!
    75. Re:I do not get it... by selven · · Score: 1

      And in what way are books superior to electronic entertainment in terms of parent-child interaction? Different tech, same problem.

    76. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      With any luck, they won't even react to the dangerous stuff and remove themselves from the gene pool.

    77. Re:I do not get it... by istartedi · · Score: 1

      I believe there are several variations of the license plate game, but ours was collecting states. Whoever had the most states won. We weren't quite sure what to do with Canadian plates, but they were rare. We never got to 50 on any trip. The coveted Alaska and Hawaii were out there somewhere. I don't believe it was until I was an adult, just recently in California, that I actually saw a Hawaii plate. I assume that they are only on the car for a few months after you get your car shipped.

      You could also play the numbes/letters on the plats of course, or forget about the plates and play car models or colors.

      --
      For all intensive purposes, "whom" is no longer a word. That begs the question, "who cares"?
    78. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Man, you had brothers and sisters? well I only had sisters - and I wasn't even allowed to fight with them. Kids these days.

    79. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you must not have any kids

    80. Re:I do not get it... by ptbarnett · · Score: 1

      +1 on the inverter. It opens so many possibilities!

      +3 on the inverter.

      I've recommended that all my friends to get an inexpensive one from Fry's or Radio Shack and toss it in the trunk. You never know when you will need it.

      Lately, the primary use for mine has been to plug in a cell-phone or iPod charger on a long trip, before the battery dies. I have a car adapter/charger for my phone, but an inverter is a "universal" adapter for anyone else that has their AC charge cord.

      I've also seen a couple of cars that have inverters already installed, and provide a 110-volt outlet for low-amperage purposes.

    81. Re:I do not get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You should be paying attention to your driving when you are driving the car, not a baby in the seat next to you. What is the better option: Have your kid cry because you can't give them attention, or give them attention then crash the car because you weren't paying attention to the road? Now, I don't know about you but I'd rather have my kid cry for a bit than die in a car accident.

    82. Re:I do not get it... by danerthomas · · Score: 1

      If she went on the train as far north as possible she went to Narvik, but the vast majority of that trip goes through Northern Sweden. Norway is much more mountainous with better scenery and slower, more twisty roads. Norway is very expensive, but it can be amazingly scenic. Our trips were in August (1991) and late June (2007) and the waterfalls and snowfields were more impressive in June. As far as your parents are concerned if they wanted to take a week of so they might look into flying to Oslo, renting a car to go up to Lillehammer, Geiranger, Trollstigen and on to Trondheim. Two cities with lots of history for mum and several days of amazing scenery and countryside for dad. If they want to stay longer or see more they could fly or take the Hurtigrutan boat up the coast to the Lofoten archipelago. That area is simply amazing from a geological and natural standpoint. Pics from our trip up there: http://gallery.mac.com/drt#100023

  4. People are less like to smash your car windows... by Assmasher · · Score: 4, Insightful

    ...to steal the factory installed DVD system than they are to grab the two iPads in your back seat.

    --
    Loading...
  5. Why would this be different from navsystems? by TomHandy · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Automakers still seem to charge ridiculous amounts for integrated navigation systems - the fact that you can pick up a GPS unit for under $100 doesn't seem to prevent them from charging $500-2000 for nav systems. Somehow I doubt they'll change anything here either. I figure that the thinking is they can charge a huge premium for the benefit of having a system integrated vs. just a separate device.

    1. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by alen · · Score: 1, Interesting

      less than $100 for the TomTom and Navigon apps in the app store. New Android phones ship with the same capability built in. some people would rather pay the higher car payment than get a smartphone and pay the $30 a month data charge.

    2. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by fuzzyfuzzyfungus · · Score: 5, Insightful

      The worst thing about the integrated sat-navs is that they are often worse in every way(except the awkward cigarette-lighter-for-power and suction cup mount aspect) than even substantially cheaper discrete units.

      Standalone GPS units live in a brutal darwinian hell-world, where only the strong or the super-cheap survive. Integrated units live sheltered lives; bundled with much more expensive objects. The difference shows.

    3. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by TomHandy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Yeah, that's always seemed like the craziest thing to me. Whenever I've been driving with someone with a luxury car and some expensive $2000 nav system built in, I've been kind of blown away that the system seems like something from 10 years ago, incredibly inferior to even the base model Garmin or TomTom units you can get for under $100. It really does seem like the only thing they have going for them is being integrated into the dash rather than a unit you have to put above your dash, but still...

    4. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by L4t3r4lu5 · · Score: 1

      Indeed! So, Let's take a TomTom Go Live 740 (The most expensive one listed under car navigation) at $349.95. That's SatNav and one year of map updates free. One year of map updates is $39.80. That's a total of 389.75 for two years of SatNav and updated maps.

      Take an average Sat-Nav capable phone (purposefully not choosing iPhone): HTC Pure on AT&T is $49.99 before you even start choosing your tariff, and requires a two year $30 per month data contract. That's already $769.99, and we haven't paid the $100 for your navigation app yet. Oh, and we also don't have the extra year of map updates.

      I can't see the plans for this phone, as I'm not a US citizen, but already I can see that getting a smartphone for satnav capabilities is just idiotic. If you have other uses for the smartphone, then yes you're saving money.

      Don't ever think that using your mobile phone as satellite navigation is the cheap option, though.

      --
      Finally had enough. Come see us over at https://soylentnews.org/
    5. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by fermion · · Score: 1
      The thing with built in nav systems is many people do not use a nav system outside of the car. If one uses it outside the car, one often wants a much smaller unit. The smaller screen size does not make it easy to use in the car. For instance, I hardly every need a nav unit, so I use my phone when I do need one, but it is hardly an easy option.

      I suspect that parents that use these things to distract their kids tend to want to distract the kids even when they are outside of the car. While a phone is good, it seems that a single device that can keep a kid continuously distracted 24 hours a day, seamlessly, without interruption, would be a superior solution.

      As far as not playing DVDs, DVD is added mass when traveling, and the selection must be made before hand. With the iPad, the well off parent can not only preload a selection, but also buy new movies on the fly, or, if they are in a WiFi area, such as an airport, stream on netflix. Perhaps the money that would be spent on the entertainment system can be spent on the more general mobile hotspot so the parents can also enjoy the internet access on their phones.

      --
      "She's a scientist and a lesbian. She's not going to let it slide." Orphan Black
    6. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by fuzzyfuzzyfungus · · Score: 1

      What I don't know is whether the suckitude of the integrated systems is down to genuine, good-faith incompetence(assuming that automotive engineers can hack it as sat-nav UI designers, or contracting it out to the wrong guys, or just suffering from the rather longer product lifecycle imposed by being part of a car) or whether it is just a "We don't even have to care because what are you going to do, stick a suction cup mount to your windshield and have a cigarette lighter adapter flopping around, exactly like the guy driving the beater civic who earns a factor of ten less than you?"

      I could imagine either (or both) being the case. Bad things happen when people underestimate the difficultly of things outside their area of expertise. However, it is also the case that, whenever multiple items are bundled, all the members of the bundle that aren't selling points have a nasty habit of atrophying to the point where they are pretty much good enough to fill the checkbox, and no better.

    7. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by mapkinase · · Score: 1

      My suction cup mount sucks so much! ... that's why I am so happy about it.

      --
      I do not believe in karma. "Funny"=-6. Do good and forbid evil. Yours, Oft-Offtopic Flamebaiting Troll.
    8. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by demonlapin · · Score: 1

      "We don't even have to care because what are you going to do, stick a suction cup mount to your windshield and have a cigarette lighter adapter flopping around, exactly like the guy driving the beater civic who earns a factor of ten less than you?"

      We have a winner! Integrated looks nicer, it's always there, it doesn't need a charger. It also is part of a package that includes a better stereo, hands-free Bluetooth, improved climate control, etc. It's not nearly as good as the best stereo I could buy, the best GPS I could buy, and the best video player I could buy - but it's a lot less hassle.

      I'm waiting for the day that there is a single plug-in system for audio, video, and touch input so that I can plug my smartphone into the car display and use the constantly-updated software on it through the larger, better-looking screen in my car.

    9. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by LanMan04 · · Score: 1

      "We don't even have to care because what are you going to do, stick a suction cup mount to your windshield and have a cigarette lighter adapter flopping around, exactly like the guy driving the beater civic who earns a factor of ten less than you?"

      Bingo.

      --
      With the first link, the chain is forged.
    10. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Having recently attempted to use a Garmin with a 3" screen and seemingly no useful features, I am again reminded why I willingly pay Honda $2000 for my car's factory unit with a 7" screen and tons of features. For one thing, the Garmin was essentially useless because it could only be powered by its mount, which can only be secured with a suction cup. Since the suction cup didn't suck (ironic, I know), there was no way to keep it from falling off the dashboard and tumbling onto the floor, whereupon it would detach from its mount, causing it to lose power. What am I supposed to do with it -- hold it in my lap? Furthermore it was missing seemingly obvious features, like a way to scroll the map (important on a tiny screen!), a way to see a list of driving directions, or a distance scale.

      Meanwhile, the built-in system is full of features that you can't have on a cheap add-on system, such as a large screen, dedicated buttons (for things like panning, zooming, and switching views), the ability to attenuate the sound system when speaking directions, and the ability to do dead reckoning when no GPS signal is available. I also like the "features" it doesn't have, like attempting to pronounce names of streets and locations. Since they're all proper nouns you can never expect them to follow any particular pronunciation rules, so they're usually going to be wrong. My Honda avoids this whole problem by not even trying: it says "turn left in 2 miles" or "make the second right turn" rather than trying to tell me that I'm looking for "us 17" (meaning U.S. 17) which I'll never find because it's labeled Johnnycake Road.

      dom

    11. Re:Why would this be different from navsystems? by Zebedeu · · Score: 1

      Exactly. Besides, with the integrated unit the risk of getting it stolen is much lower (though the consequences are much higher).

      I'm still waiting for an integrated Android system to replace the crappy cd player that came with my car.

  6. duh by alen · · Score: 5, Insightful

    i figured that out when the iPad was first announced. $2000 for a glorified $300 DVD system vs $500 for a dumbed down computer that can play movies and games and you don't need to take shiny discs with you that scratch easily

    and you can use the ipad outside the car as well. and if you're an IT geek with kids, the App Store has tons of IT management apps to give you console and any kind of remote access to almost any platform from anywhere. just in case you get a call while on vacation that something is wrong

    1. Re:duh by $RANDOMLUSER · · Score: 5, Funny

      If you're an IT geek you probably aren't buying Apple products.

      No, but if IT geeks work for you, you probably are. :(

      --
      No folly is more costly than the folly of intolerant idealism. - Winston Churchill
    2. Re:duh by AnonymousClown · · Score: 1

      $2000 for a glorified $300 DVD system vs $500 for a dumbed down computer that can play movies and games and you don't need to take shiny discs with you that scratch easily

      To add: The history of quality with Apple is pretty good; whereas the history of quality with Ford is?

      --
      RIP America

      July 4, 1776 - September 11, 2001

    3. Re:duh by Dare+nMc · · Score: 0

      and you can use the ipad outside the car as well

      only in your home, or office not outside, based on Apple's other products; Only If your in Southern California or it's not winter or Summer will you want to use them outside, and you better not leave them in a hot/cold car. The temperature/weatherproofing of apple laptop type products are about the worst in the industry.

    4. Re:duh by DCheesi · · Score: 0

      i figured that out when the iPad was first announced. $2000 for a glorified $300 DVD system vs $500 for a dumbed down computer that can play movies and games and you don't need to take shiny discs with you that scratch easily

      Nope, instead you just take your one shiny $500 device that scratches easily...

    5. Re:duh by supssa · · Score: 0

      I develop on linux, usually daemon code for network services, and I enjoy my macbooks, iMac and iPhone. I have no need for an iPad but I think its a cool device. Fortunately for me $99/year to sign my own code and sign other peoples code isn't exactly that bad.

      --
      Hatin' on products I don't like and getting modded up talking about tech I totally don't understand like it was 2005!
    6. Re:duh by alen · · Score: 1

      great support - check
      OS is built on Open Source - check
      good build quality - check
      works with MS Exchange out of the box - check
      tons of server/network management apps available - check
      gives me console/RDP access to any server i manage - check
      OS 3 is up to 176 apps and OS 4 will max it to over 2000 apps on an iphone. Android and blackberry are crippled in the amount of apps you can install on them
      plenty of games available for the train ride
      my son loves it and tons of kids games on it
      i can teach my son to code on it

      what exactly can you do with an android phone other than gmail and internet?

    7. Re:duh by capnkr · · Score: 1

      So from this post we learn that AnonClown has never bought much in the way of Apple hardware... ;)

      The 'high quality' of Apple products seems to me to almost be urban myth, I have seen many examples which tell another story. AppleDefects.com has a "pretty good" list of their historical quality issues, although I do find it puzzling that their IBook G4 page has no entries, considering how many people suffered through the kernel panic issues they had thanks to faulty design of the wireless card socket* (fixed in gen2, of course).

      Mod me down, fanboys, but as an Apple Outsider my impressions of their 'quality', and the very poor way in which they deal with it at times - especially considering the premium that their clientele pay - is what gives me this impression.

      *(like the G4 wireless issue, their solution was to buy a new mobo - for ~$800 - when it could be fixed like I have several times with a folded sheet of paper)

      --
      "...there are some things that can beat smartness and foresight. Awkwardness and stupidity can." ~ Mark Twain
    8. Re:duh by CAIMLAS · · Score: 1

      ... vs. an integrated home-brew system capable of playing DVDs, ripped DVDs, surfing the Internet, GPS tracking, listening to MP3s, etc. for right around $550 (and about $120 if you want to add a second head for multiple viewers).

      The tech for this is cheap. Very cheap. Doing it yourself is pretty trivial: small Atom system with disk = under $200. DVD = $20. Smaller LCD = $100 (whether it's a 7" touchscreen or a 19" widescreen). GPS and WiFi (or WiMax)/cellular card = $100. Software = another $150 or so, depending on what you want (if anything).

      Honestly, for in-car viewing, I don't really see what this iPad offers over a normal laptop or netbook. It costs more? That's hardly a selling point. And I can see kids quickly bitching about having to hold the iPad to watch a movie.

      --
      ~/ssh slashdot.org ssh: connect to host slashdot.org port 22: too many beers
    9. Re:duh by Mr.+No+Skills · · Score: 1

      Most of us don't buy enough hardware to have a good sense of manufacturing defects directly. We get this indirectly from media sources, and human nature amplifies dissatisfaction more than satisfaction. I'm a somewhat recent Apple convert (about 5 years now), and a long time purchaser of computers of all kinds. While there have been some well known issues (the 24 inch screens currently, and I personally had to deal with the "expanding capacitor" issue on my iMac G5), my opinion of Apple is much higher than all the other personal computer manufacturers for build quality, service, and design. Admittedly, Apple doesn't really bother with the low-end market, so comparing the engineering art in an iMac to a mass market Dell desktop isn't a fair fight. But, I think "urban myth" is really too strong a description. My one motherboard issue was superbly handled by Apple Care, and my Apple laptops have lasted much longer than comparable Dell or Sony products I have purchased. I don't think my experience as been atypical, and any other PC manufacturer would have a list of quality snafus to point to - in most cases many more.

      It's also interesting to look at the trigger for your comment. Even if you buy into the argument that Apple's quality is the best, comparing it to the quality of Ford is funny. Even the best personal computers last on average three years? Cars sit outside for years and years, have long term warranties, and lots of legislation controlling defect repair. The smallest manufacturing defect (Toyota comes to mind) get magnified into horrible PR nightmares that cost millions and millions to resolve. I'm guessing Apple wouldn't hold up well in a real comparison to Ford, or any other car company.

      PS: Great Twain quote.

      --
      Sleep is for the Weak
    10. Re:duh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If you're an IT geek you probably aren't buying Apple products.

      Quite the opposite.

      I'm in IT, and after dealing with complex SAN, Unix, routers, etc. stuff at work, I want simple things at home. If I want to do something more complex I can always open Terminal.app (or iTerm) and do hack-ish stuff it Darwin Ports or pkgsrc.

      Best of both world's really.

  7. And, guess what? by msauve · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Unlike the iPad, they too can play DVDs!

    --
    "National Security is the chief cause of national insecurity." - Celine's First Law
    1. Re:And, guess what? by nomorecwrd · · Score: 1

      ....AND DivX, Mp4... even donughts...
      Just carry the DVDs (or USB pendrives.... or SD carrds) and insert the one with the video.... not worring or wasting time loading it to the thing.

      And yes, all this features for around $100.

    2. Re:And, guess what? by rolfwind · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I would prefer the iPad, because I personally hate a bunch of shit in the car, including a mound of DVDs. They just clutter up the whole car, and usually become unplayable either through sticky fingers or scratches from going all around uncased, and what not. Not to mention that in an accident, shit flying all around can cause problems. Heck, it can cause an accident just from sliding around and somehow ending between your feet and the brake.

      In fact, unless it's a real car trip, I hate the thought of bringing up kids conditioned not to be away from a screen for a minute, being fed it nonstop. Not too long ago, once you got out of the house, you got to escape the TV at least.

      At least a portable gaming system is interactive. The iPad wouldn't be too bad either, with movie downloads and whatnot, especially netflix. But I won't be buying downloaded movies from apple or anyone else until the sell DRM-less versions just like the music now. They might as well, people just convert and upload the DVDs/Blu-Ray without problems as it is.

      But I do wish a simple book would be adequate these days. And I'm saying this as a frequent flyer who appreciate the personal entertainment systems in the seats these days, and their role in shutting the brats up.

    3. Re:And, guess what? by netsharc · · Score: 4, Informative

      There's a cool app on the App Store called "Air Video", it requires a server app on your normal PC (Windows/Mac), and a client App on the phone, the server reads your videos from its disk, converts it on the fly to an iPhone-compatible format, and streams it over WiFi (or 3G if your 3G is good enough) to the phone.

      I suppose for the ultimate in-car entertainment hackery, one could store an SSD-disked PC in the trunk, with WiFi that can connect to the "MyGarage" SSID, as well as offering in-car WiFi (or would that have to go the other way around, the home PC/server connecting to the "MyCar" SSID?), and with a network drive so you can just drag&drop stuff from your home PC "into" your "car". Maybe cron-job too for TV episodes. Add Wake-on-Bluetooth too so you can just click a button to turn on the in-car PC from the comfort of your own desk.

      Would surely save a lot of time compared to doing an offline conversion/USB sync...

      --
      What time is it/will be over there? Check with my iPhone app!
    4. Re:And, guess what? by Lumpy · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Buddy of mine ripped the DVD player out of his and left the screen. he built a XBMC to feed the screen and headphones and carries 250 gigs of movies and TV shows in the car with no cluttler at all.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    5. Re:And, guess what? by Karlt1 · · Score: 1

      But I won't be buying downloaded movies from apple or anyone else until the sell DRM-less versions just like the music now. They might as well, people just convert and upload the DVDs/Blu-Ray without problems as it is.

      So you buy DVD's and Blu-Ray disc....which also have DRM.

      But what's wrong with renting video with DRM? You know in advanced that you're not buying it.

    6. Re:And, guess what? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Please post links on how...interested

    7. Re:And, guess what? by 2obvious4u · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I bought a WD TV mini and burned my movie collection onto a 500GB USB drive. I didn't rip out the old DVD player I just connected the WD TV to the existing AV ports. We still use the DVD player for movies we haven't converted yet, but have access to the rest of our movie catalog while in the car. The best part is that the DVD's aren't constantly getting scratched up by the kids. Oh and it frees up a lot of space in the glove box where we had a case of DVD's now there is just a USB drive and the very very small WD TV box.

    8. Re:And, guess what? by RoccamOccam · · Score: 1

      Interesting. Was it reasonably easy to set up power? How do you manage the remote control?

    9. Re:And, guess what? by Richy_T · · Score: 4, Funny

      Heck, it can cause an accident just from sliding around and somehow ending between your feet and the brake.

      Is that you, Toyota?

    10. Re:And, guess what? by Xsydon · · Score: 1

      Tversity (PC) is free, and gives you a web-based method of accessing your media. No apps required, just open your browser. I've used to to play videos of just about any format, to my iPhone, PS3 and Xbox.

    11. Re:And, guess what? by rfuilrez · · Score: 1

      That would be a really neat idea. Just put 2 WiFi cards in it. One set up to be an Access point, the other to connect to a wireless network.

      http://www.globalscaletechnologies.com/p-32-guruplug-server-plus.aspx This looks like it could fit the bill. Would just have to hack it up a bit to take the cars 12v instead of a home 120vAC. Or I guess a DC->AC Converter. Slap a pair of WiFi USB connectors, and a eSATA drive. Good to Go.

    12. Re:And, guess what? by lowrydr310 · · Score: 2, Informative

      XBMC is one awesome approach that provides movies and gaming. I too have a friend who did this.

      Another friend of mine had an interesting setup with a custom touchscreen in the center of the dash and two more in the headrests for the rear passengers that were connected to a microATX PC in the trunk. mp3car.com provides a ton of resources for the project. In this friend's case, he had a media center, GPS receiver with navigation software, an OBDII diagnostics utility, and a few other neat utilities. It was a cool setup, but as with any 'custom' solution it can be a chore to troubleshoot any problems that may arise. In my experience, the manufacturer-provided ICE systems usually 'just work' without much trouble.

    13. Re:And, guess what? by cayenne8 · · Score: 1
      "In fact, unless it's a real car trip, I hate the thought of bringing up kids conditioned not to be away from a screen for a minute, being fed it nonstop. Not too long ago, once you got out of the house, you got to escape the TV at least."

      I've often wondered the same thing.

      I grew up LONG before iPods, gameboys, etc. I entertained myself in the backseat of the car on long trips with reading books, playing with toy soldiers/hot wheels....etc. Do kids actually use their imaginations these days anymore? Heck, if nothing else...I'd lay down and sleep some too.

      --
      Light travels faster than sound. This is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.........
    14. Re:And, guess what? by gstoddart · · Score: 1

      In fact, unless it's a real car trip, I hate the thought of bringing up kids conditioned not to be away from a screen for a minute, being fed it nonstop.

      True and noble as that statement might be ... I'm sure I know several sets of parents who are just happy to have something that will shut up the little monsters. :-P

      They're already conditioned to being always in front of some kind of screen -- the trip to Grandma's place is too late to try to sort that one out.

      Cheer

      --
      Lost at C:>. Found at C.
    15. Re:And, guess what? by Gilmoure · · Score: 1

      I have an ElGato USB tv tuner on my home Mac server. It streams tv channels to my iPhone over wireless and 3G. You can select the channel to watch from the iPhone so you don't have to record shows ahead of time. It can also stream recorded shows as well, though. Was amazed that local news channel, streamed over 3G was only 2 minutes behind actual broadcast time (looking at tv in bar).

      Will have to check out the Air Video service as I have all our DVD's at home ripped to Mac. Not having to sync stuff before leaving on a trip would be nice. Daughter will think I'm a tech god.

      --
      I drank what? -- Socrates
    16. Re:And, guess what? by eln · · Score: 1

      We've never had any sort of passive entertainment device in our car other than the radio, and I refuse to put one in or buy a car that includes one. We regularly go on 10-hour road trips to visit the grandparents, and we have two kids (8 and 10). It was a little difficult with the occasional tantrums when they were younger, but they've now done exactly what I hoped they would do: learned to entertain themselves. They have their journals, sketchpads, puzzle books, coloring books, and regular old reading books, and they can keep themselves busy the entire time. I much prefer this to having them being zombified by a stack of DVDs for 10 hours straight.

    17. Re:And, guess what? by ckaminski · · Score: 1

      Counter-argument: if I take care of things well, odds are my DVDs will last 20+ years, and my BluRay just as long. My very first DVDs ever are over 10 years old now, and still play just like I bought them new.

      How long did it take Microsoft to renege on PlaysForSure? 4 years. It is perhaps auspicious that the backlash they faced in light of this decision caused them to change their mind and it continues to this day. But seriously, four years. That is why I rebel against digital-only media. It's nice that iTMS and probably Microsoft give you options to burn to CD, but not yet with Movies (and for good reason - casual distribution would skyrocket).

    18. Re:And, guess what? by node+3 · · Score: 1

      And hold fifty to a hundred movies and play games and browse the web and read books and do art and play music and...

      Well, at least DVD players can do that last one.

    19. Re:And, guess what? by yurtinus · · Score: 1

      Woah, way too much work into that one bro. Clearly you're doing it wrong!

      --
      +1 Disagree
    20. Re:And, guess what? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Or maybe just buying something that doesn't come from the iCrap factory...

    21. Re:And, guess what? by poopdeville · · Score: 1

      I have one of these ElGato things too. I'm not a big fan of theirs. They failed to re-secure a contract with TitanTV (a TV data supplier), found an alternative supplier, and expect people to upgrade to the latest version to use it, at something like 49$. Their software/driver (for my model, at least) has a bug that often causes it to report that the tuner is attached to a USB 1.1 bus, and refuses to work. They denied the problem even existed, for over a year (until after most peoples' warranties were up) Now they admit to it. Their solution? Spend 49$ to upgrade to the latest version. (Gee, thanks for selling me a defective product)

      --
      After all, I am strangely colored.
    22. Re:And, guess what? by nomadic · · Score: 1

      I grew up LONG before iPods, gameboys, etc. I entertained myself in the backseat of the car on long trips with reading books, playing with toy soldiers/hot wheels....etc. Do kids actually use their imaginations these days anymore? Heck, if nothing else...I'd lay down and sleep some too.

      I grew up long before ipods, gameboys, etc., and I have very vivid memories of the crushing boredom of long trips. If I can spare any kids I eventually have from that, then good. Once we get to the beach/park/wherever they can turn them in and go engage in imaginative play.

    23. Re:And, guess what? by Golddess · · Score: 1

      The difference is that the DVD and BluRay DRM is easier to circumvent.

      And nothing's wrong with renting, but we aren't talking about renting. I admit I haven't checked, but it was my understanding that iTunes does not do video rentals, only video sales.

      --
      "I'm not sure I like the fugnutish tone you used in your post!" -RogL (608926)-
    24. Re:And, guess what? by 2obvious4u · · Score: 1

      Yeah, plug the WD TV into a cig lighter socket. The WD TV powers the USB drive. Also my Samsung LED TV also uses the USB drives to watch movies directly on the TV.

    25. Re:And, guess what? by kkwst2 · · Score: 1

      So, that answer seems a bit glib, perhaps to be expected from your user name. The unit comes with an AC adapter, correct? So, is there a DC accessory, are you using an inverter, is the output of the wall wart 12V such that you can just cut it off and wire it directly to the auto DC power? Because your answer suggests that you have not actually done what you describe.

    26. Re:And, guess what? by Karlt1 · · Score: 1

      And nothing's wrong with renting, but we aren't talking about renting. I admit I haven't checked, but it was my understanding that iTunes does not do video rentals, only video sales.

      Apple has done video rentals for at least two years. While I agree that I would never buy a movie from iTunes because I could get a much cheaper, much more versatile used DVD cheaper, I would buy a rental in a pinch.

      It's just kind of hypocritical to take a moral stand against buying DRM'd video from iTunes and then go by a DVD. Let's just be honest, it's not DRM that /.er's are opposed to -- it's hard to circumvent DRM. It's not about a moral stance at all.

    27. Re:And, guess what? by netsharc · · Score: 1

      I suppose one AP in the car is enough, with another antenna/server in your garage that would automatically look for/connect to the SSID "MyCar".. then you can just upload files to the car's IP as long as it's connectable.

      How do UPnP AV MediaServers announce their presence on the network? Via ZeroConf?

      Well, I don't have a car and so no need for in-car entertainment, so I have no use for this idea.

      --
      What time is it/will be over there? Check with my iPhone app!
    28. Re:And, guess what? by 2obvious4u · · Score: 1

      The Toyota Sequoia has an AC outlet in the center console, that is what I plug into. You could use an inverter or you could buy a generic universal adapter and connect it at the correct voltage.

    29. Re:And, guess what? by RoccamOccam · · Score: 1

      How did you handle the remote?

    30. Re:And, guess what? by 2obvious4u · · Score: 1

      Yes, the remote is quite the conundrum. It is in the center console with the unit. It sure would be nice if the unit had controls built on to it, or if the remote was an RF remote instead of an IR. It is a pain right now because both the built in unit and the WD TV require their remotes, neither of them work without the remote (which to me is a serious design flaw).

  8. DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Though it doesn't have a key element for kids: A DVD drive or a suitable ability to play the same movies they watch at home.

    Anyone who has a kid knows if they like their kids movies then there's got to be a easy way for them to watch it. Most parents aren't going to be ripping their kid's whole collection of DVDs and putting them on an iPad. There needs to be a connection here for this to be even semi-viable for parents. That or iTunes is going to have to try to get some more kid's videos than I believe it has.

    I don't think Jr is really going to be all that excited about all the apps.

    1. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I don't think Jr is really going to be all that excited about all the apps.

      Yeah, I don't think I've met a kid yet who is interested in video games.

    2. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by Lectoid · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I don't know, my 3.5 year old daughter and 1.5 year old son love daddy's "omputer" far more than TV right now. They can draw and color wherever they touch, then send the picture to grandma. Play animal sounds by touching the picture. They can watch an awesome animated Toy Story book as it reads to them (I read to my kids everyday, but try as I might I can't make books animated). She can watch cartoons on netflix anywhere in the house. And that's just in the first few weeks, Who knows what they'll come up with months from now. I went on a trip a few weeks ago and took my iPad and my laptop. My laptop is still in it's bag.

      Now I am like some of you in that your against apple's walled garden, but it's a big damn garden and I've yet to find something I need that's not in here.

      --
      Is it just me, or do you hate it when people say "Is it just me..."?
    3. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by microcars · · Score: 1

      My 3 Grandkids are always playing App Store games on our iPhones and iPod Touches when we travel.
      They play against each other too. And if there are only 2 devices they will actually "share" (!)
      They don't "watch" anything. (movies)

      --
      I like microcars
    4. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by alen · · Score: 1

      check out the iTunes store sometime

      DVD in best buy is $15 for 4 episodes of Dora the Explorer or some other kids cartoon like Little Einsteins. On iTunes is $15-$50 for a season of 26 episodes depending on the show and the season. and they have pretty much every other kids movie or cartoon that is out on DVD

    5. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by Sandbags · · Score: 1

      Uh, you have heard of this thing called the CLOUD, right? a 3G connection, or a MiFi access point covers streaming from not only a variety of content sources (including netflix and very soon hulu), but also allows streaming of ANY content your PC can play (even if the iPad can't) via a $3 app, including controlling a TV tuner card on that PC remotely, allowing kids to even watch live TV in the car...

      Also do you take 100 DVDs with you in the car? no, you take a few dozen. Inevitably, the kid does not have the movie they want anyway with DVDs. SYNC a few dozen works just the same! The kid can control, through iTunes, very easily, what they do and don't want on the pad, up to and including automatically purging and replacing current episodes as they're watched, and configuring some content to always be on the device unless manually deleted.

      --
      There is no contest in life for which the unprepared have the advantage.
    6. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by jedidiah · · Score: 0

      If you can't beat the iTunes store by shopping retail, you simply aren't trying.

      You're trying to fail. You've got an axe to grind. You must shill for Apple.

      --
      A Pirate and a Puritan look the same on a balance sheet.
    7. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by Gulthek · · Score: 1

      You can put your DVDs in iTunes. It's actually kind nice to have a selection of movies/television to watch on a bus, even on the small screen of the iPod Touch. Lots of blu-ray movies even come with a digital version nowadays since you can't import blu-ray movies easily.

    8. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by nicktripp · · Score: 2, Interesting

      "Anyone who has a kid knows if they like their kids movies then there's got to be a easy way for them to watch it." "I don't think Jr is really going to be all that excited about all the apps." I ripped all of my kid's DVDs for an iPod Touch because it was the easiest way for him to watch them. He can operate the thing without any help and it has a ton of age-appropriate learning/edu games from the App Store on there as well. He loves them. I limit his time with it pretty heavily and I've got the parental controls enabled, but that iPod is absolutely his favorite thing in the world. He's 3 years and 7 months old.

    9. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by kisa2000 · · Score: 1

      As someone who lost a few DVD's to kids who treated them like coasters and thus they became coasters - I actually do rip every DVD that comes into the house.

      Because at AU $20 a pop, it's worth the 3 minutes starting up handbrake before I got to bed to ensure that the $20 lasts more than a week.

    10. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm not sure. I love having 100 kid friendly movies on my PC that can be streamed to my TV (apple TV) or my Bedroom (XBox), or my daughter's room (Old PC with a TV as a monitor). I did spend a lot of time ripping them into .mp4's but that time has more than paid for itself in time....especially considering the time it takes to find lost DVD's and cleaning up scattered Jewell cases from all over my Living Room. Plus, I don't have to be concerned about my 4 year old scratching the hell out of the DVD to the point that it is unreadable. The problem is I'm sure I'm in a small minority of parents that knows how to rip and encode these DVD's and make it work.

      I've actually tried to find a decent portable DVD player that will either hold a Memory card or have built in memory that I could take and swap out MP4's. The IPad would do it but I don't see why there shouldn't be a $250 portable DVD player that could do the same thing...and Play a DVD!!

    11. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Though it doesn't have a key element for kids: A DVD drive or a suitable ability to play the same movies they watch at home.Yeah, just like my AppleTV. Oh wait, I have 300 movies on iTunes on the Mac Mini it syncs to.

      If/when I get an iPad, this will be a doddle as the hard work is already done.

    12. Re:DVD Entertainment System?..sans the DVD. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Internet Radio that doesn't stop playing when you compose an email?
      Instant Messenger that doesn't pretend you're online when you're not?
      Animated Wallpaper? Photo on the homescreen?
      A virtual keyboard that doesn't have the Backspace next to the Enter key so you don't look like a 'tard and send the message prematurely instead of backspacing?

      You can't find an app that's missing if you don't know what's possible.

      I would much prefer a device that could download pictures from my camera -- especially for longer trips / vacations. Why limit myself in the number of pictures I want to take?

      What you're also going to be missing some money.
      $70-$150 battery change? ($20 for Nexus One, $40-50 at worst for most batteries - even from the big companies that rip you off)
      $20-30 for a glorified charger? ($0-15, since most new devices use standard USB to charge, you might already have a spare cable)

  9. Is there any way to filter Apple CRAP news? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Really... its starting to be annoying.

    1. Re:Is there any way to filter Apple CRAP news? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why yes; make an account, and uncheck the Apple stories.

  10. good by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ICEs and GPSs are overpriced and have horrible UI. Factory headunits too. Fucking ugly, overpriced, and lacking in options. Worst of all, they sometimes are integrated to the point that you can't remove it.

  11. iPAD vs. ICE ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I did not notice that this toy has a DVD player...

  12. plenty of people in the US too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    laugh at Apple customers.

    1. Re:plenty of people in the US too by stewbacca · · Score: 4, Insightful

      And plenty of Apple customers don't care one bit about what people think about them, or if it is "cool" or not to be using a MacBook, iPod, iPad, iPhone, or whatever.

    2. Re:plenty of people in the US too by MrHanky · · Score: 1

      Exactly. But the iPad isn't built for them.

    3. Re:plenty of people in the US too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      oh yeah, like 99% of apple customers aren't about expressing themselves and their lifestyle with their choice of plastic crap.

      the effect is not what you'd expect btw, and you can be assured that most people look upon the chimps standing on the high street stabbing at their bright iphone screens, with the utter contempt that they deserve.

      problem is that you guys are so skilled in kidding yourselves that you can always say "they're just jealous coz they can't afford one!"

      swallowing so much marketing bilge is lame but you creeps must be missing something in your lives to take on the lifestyle as well.
      truly you are the most despicable class of consumer that i've ever known. fucking vermin.

    4. Re:plenty of people in the US too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And plenty of Apple customers don't care one bit about what people think about them, or if it is "cool" or not to be using a MacBook, iPod, iPad, iPhone, or whatever.

      Hahahaha I haven't had a good laugh like this in a while!

    5. Re:plenty of people in the US too by Hatta · · Score: 1

      If you don't care what other people think about you, why are you trying to correct what people think about you?

      --
      Give me Classic Slashdot or give me death!
    6. Re:plenty of people in the US too by stewbacca · · Score: 1

      Surprise, I know, but I really really, for reals, don't care one bit what Joe Q. Public thinks about me when I'm using my MacBook at a coffee store.

      I also don't care what people think about my Mazdaspeed 3 hatchback, which I personally think is totally awesome, but I bought it for me, not for my neighbor to think things about me.

      I'm also not trying to "correct" what people think about me, because you can't "correct" opinions.

      I'm am, however, pointing out the logical fallacy of statements like "middle class consumers worry about looking cool" or whatever. I'm pointing out that, in the name of quality discourse, broad brush strokes don't belong on slashdot, and that it is really inappropriate for such vapid comments like his to be modded "Insightful" when all he is doing is propogating tired. cliched stereotypes that say more about him than the actual people he's trying to mock.

      Now where did I place my Frappmochachino and my beret?

    7. Re:plenty of people in the US too by stewbacca · · Score: 1

      oh yeah, like 99% of apple customers aren't about expressing themselves and their lifestyle with their choice of plastic crap.

      Uh, no. Really. No. Most of us are about using a device that works well and is dependable.

      you can always say "they're just jealous coz they can't afford one!"

      Related to my first post, we really don't care what YOU use either. We just find it amusing that you get so obsessed with the stuff we buy for ourselves.

      you are the most despicable class of consumer that i've ever known. fucking vermin.

      More despicable than people who believe the grossly exaggerated stereotypes you present?

    8. Re:plenty of people in the US too by stewbacca · · Score: 1

      Interestingly enough, my post was modded +5 Insightful, not +5 Funny.

    9. Re:plenty of people in the US too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're so full of shit it must be coming out of your ears. "Works well and is dependable" doesn't describe any product Apple has ever made.

  13. laptop by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I always used laptops in car. They have a DVD player (which is the #1, if not the only function of car entertainment systems), and the screen holds vertically by itself while on your lap. Two criteria that makes any $500 laptop better than an Ipad for in-car usage. I also setup an ad-hoc wireless network to play games or stream the movie to a second laptop.

    1. Re:Laptop by aicrules · · Score: 1

      and ensure that your kids don't have that pesky ability to reproduce. Regular laptops are not actually laptops but notebooks with fiery death awaiting the poor little laps of the kids who watch a two hour movie with them. Plus a laptop playing a DVD probably won't have enough power to last that long.

    2. Re:Laptop by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      You're going to need to buy a tablet PC, because a laptop doesn't mount to the dash or headrest. Warning: affiliate link: Asus Eee PC T91MT-PU17-BK 8.9-Inch Intel Atom Netbook Computer (Black) (you know what to do if you don't want to clicky... but if you wanted to just click, I wouldn't complain)

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    3. Re:Laptop by Sandbags · · Score: 1

      and just try hanging that from the back of your car seat and see how long the screen hinges last...

      This is to replace a car entertainment system, not a laptop troll.

      An ipad and a simple sling/case can easily be hung from a headrest on the drivers seat, and be strapped around it for stability, and be a very nice 10" personal screen for a kid (or hung between the 2 front seats to be shared). It easily connected via an audio jack or FM tranceiver to the car stereo, or a few pairs of bluetooth A2DP headsets (or even old school FM wireless headsets, or even older school wired headsets with a Y adapter.

      Laptops A) can't easily be suspended as such, don't cost under $500 and also play H.264 video since there are no sub-$500 laptops with descrete MPEG decoders (DVD yes, if the drive doesn't shake so much it skips), B) most don't include bluetooth at all, C) 3G plans for data streaming cost twice as much and come with contracts (an iPad could be activated for a few weeks, or even a few days, for a big trip and then disabled again), D) are not easily synced with a home library (especially if you have more than 1 of them).

      Laptops are superior to iPods, if properly equipped with wirelessN, bluetooth, and a GPU to actually BE an equivalent (pushing their price over $650 in most cases), and a decent enough processor (not a netbook), and enough storage, and if you can accept the 3G costs on top of that vs the iPad if you need that, and the TCO of software and OS upgrades and licenses for EACH machine unlike the iPad, and if you can accept the lack or portability and lower battery life, and accept the maintenance and security responsibilities, and can deal with poor at best parental controls, the difficulty in backing it up, poor streaming options from central computers (unless you run a home server), and more. Yea, they're better at some tasks, much better at others, but at media, and portability, and daily tasks, NO, laptops are NOT better.

      --
      There is no contest in life for which the unprepared have the advantage.
    4. Re:Laptop by LWATCDR · · Score: 1

      1. It will not be as sturdy as the ipad.
      2. It will not run as long on batteries.
      3. It will not have the touch screen interface.
      Over all it just will not be as convent or as good of a tool for this job.
      You could also get a desktop and mount it in your car and run it off an inverter.
      Wait a while and you will find Linux tablets soon that will compete with the iPad.
      Or you could get and Nokia tablet or an Archos tablet that will better fit the task and both run Free OSs

      --
      See my blog http://ilovecookes.blogspot.com/ for light hearted technical information.
    5. Re:Laptop by LWATCDR · · Score: 1

      He is just an Apple hater but frankly a dumb one.
      There are reasons to not like the closed nature of the iPad but just using a netbook as a replacement will not work in this case.
      So for all the Apple haters and Linux fans "I do like and use Linux" here are what you can use as a replacemnt.
      http://www.archos.com/products/imt/archos_5it/index.html?country=us&lang=en Runs Android
      And
      http://www.nokiausa.com/find-products/phones/nokia-n800-r6 runs Linux.
      There you go. Something for everybody.

      --
      See my blog http://ilovecookes.blogspot.com/ for light hearted technical information.
    6. Re:Laptop by King_TJ · · Score: 1

      Yeah, you could .... and then you'd have a device that has to be plugged in half way through a long trip, because its battery ran out, vs. an iPad that can go 8 hours + with no problem.

      You'd also, probably, have a system with a physical hard drive and a full-blown OS that can get screwed up by anything ranging from dropping the thing and causing a drive crash to getting it infected with spyware while web-surfing, to a kid accidentally deleting an important system file.

    7. Re:Laptop by mmmmbeer · · Score: 1

      You're going to need to buy a tablet PC, because a laptop doesn't mount to the dash or headrest.

      What, you've never heard of duct tape?

  14. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by nacturation · · Score: 5, Funny

    ...to steal the factory installed DVD system than they are to grab the two iPads in your back seat.

    Maybe one day Apple will develop an iPad which is portable so that it can be removed from the vehicle? One can only hope!

    --
    Want to improve your Karma? Instead of "Post Anonymously", try the "Post Humously" option.
  15. How bout this? by allaunjsilverfox2 · · Score: 1

    I know some mini-itx boards support quad cores. That would be enough to do just about anything you can think of. Emulators, movies, etc. And if your worried about bumps boot from a usb stick. Or if your hard core about storage, SSD.

    --
    Restore the madness of youth's lechery
  16. iPad for GPS and Music by Go_Ask_Alex · · Score: 4, Interesting

    As soon as I heard about the iPad 3G, the first thing I though of was velcro-attaching it to the dashboard to use as a GPS unit, with full true Google Maps functionality ("My Maps"). A couple of 3m Command Jumbo Hook "velcro" strips should hold an iPad on the dash just fine, until some company makes a decent suction mount.

    1. Re:iPad for GPS and Music by RulerOf · · Score: 1

      There's got to be a mount (or you could probably unscrew two of them and put them together) with suction cups on both sides.

      That'd get the job done.

      --
      Boot Windows, Linux, and ESX over the network for free.
    2. Re:iPad for GPS and Music by Targon · · Score: 1

      I use an air conditioner vent mount for my GPS, no need for a suction cup.

    3. Re:iPad for GPS and Music by L4t3r4lu5 · · Score: 1

      You don't need the screen when you're driving. Follow the voice prompts.

      A 10" TV screen in your field of vision will be distracting.

      --
      Finally had enough. Come see us over at https://soylentnews.org/
  17. Laptop by ickleberry · · Score: 1, Interesting

    For the price of an iPad you could just buy a laptop, with a bigger screen, an actual keyboard, a decent non-restricted OS and maybe even an optical drive.

  18. MPAA lawsuits by AnonymousClown · · Score: 1

    Most parents aren't going to be ripping their kid's whole collection of DVDs and putting them on an iPad.

    That's assuming they know how. And, I wonder if the MPAA will go after said parents who do rip DVDs for their iPads? That was a dumb question: sure they will.

    --
    RIP America

    July 4, 1776 - September 11, 2001

  19. Old news - very old news by urdak · · Score: 1

    This is ridiculous. Why say that the Ipad will kill the $2000 DVD player when.... The $100 DVD player has already killed it????

    After all, for $100-$200 you can get a fine portable player which can: 1. Connect to car or home electricity (with Ipad you need to buy more power supplies). 2. Play physical dvd's and/or movies on flash disk or memory cards (Ipad only has internal memory), 3. hang on the front sit's head rest (the ipad doesn't come with any solution for that), 4. Sit comfortably on your horizontal lap while the display is tilted (you can't do this on the flat ipad).

    So what is so new with the ipad in this sense?

    1. Re:Old news - very old news by vlm · · Score: 3, Funny

      So what is so new with the ipad in this sense?

      When you really want to buy an ipad for yourself, and you tell the wife its actually for the kids.

      --
      "Science flies us to the moon. Religion flies us into buildings." - Victor Stenger
    2. Re:Old news - very old news by Attila+Dimedici · · Score: 1

      So what is so new with the ipad in this sense?

      It's from Apple and people are desperately trying to come up with a reason why people who aren't into the Apple "cool" factor would buy one.

      --
      The truth is that all men having power ought to be mistrusted. James Madison
  20. Well played, sir! by killmenow · · Score: 1

    Now that's funny. Too bad I'm fresh out of mod points.

    1. Re:Well played, sir! by $RANDOMLUSER · · Score: 1

      I'm not sayin' I'm happy about it, I'm just sayin' that the way it seems to be.

      --
      No folly is more costly than the folly of intolerant idealism. - Winston Churchill
  21. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So the kids are going to bring their iPad into the store/mall/whatever every damn time it parks?

  22. -5 to 160 degrees? What about the kids? by Shag · · Score: 3, Funny

    The Cars.com article mentions some of the advantages of ICE, including being weather-tested to work from -5 to 160 degrees F (-20 to 71 C)

    Great! Glad to know the ridiculously expensive option allows the little tikes to enjoy their Disney fare while dying of hypothermia or heatstroke.

    --
    Village idiot in some extremely smart villages.
  23. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by wjousts · · Score: 1

    I was going to say the same thing. ICE systems are less nickable and harder to resell than the iPad. Also it's harder to accidentally leave it in a hotel room or forget to bring it with you. Not that I'd pay for an ICE system anyway. A cheap portable DVD seems like a better bet.

  24. Devil's in the details by Dan+East · · Score: 4, Interesting

    We have two vehicles - one with an integrated dual-screen entertainment system (screens fold down from the ceiling), and another vehicle with a $100 DVD player strapped to the back of the seat (actually came with two screens, but the wires going between them got in the way too much so we only use one screen).

    Let me say there is no comparison. Having an integrated system is so much better it's not even funny. There are audio IR blasters integrated into the ceiling which allow 4 people to listen to the movie simultaneously via wireless headphones. If the movie is piped through the car's sound system then it is in full surround through the Bose audio system. My HTC Touch Pro 2 has video out, so I can plug it into the car and play Youtube, encoded videos, etc, right through the integrated system. Wired headphone jacks throughout, DVD controls on the ceiling in addition to standard IR remote.
    And the best part is the screens fold flat into the ceiling and totally disappear. Out of sight, out of mind, can't be stolen, scratched or have crap spilled on them.

    The BEST option, if money was no object, would be to purchase a vehicle with a fully integrated entertainment system, then add an "automotive" PC that can play back through that system as a secondary display (with the primary display being a touch screen in the front).

    --
    Better known as 318230.
    1. Re:Devil's in the details by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I bet you they can still be ripped out in working order.

    2. Re:Devil's in the details by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      The BEST option, if money was no object, would be to purchase a vehicle with a fully integrated entertainment system, then add an "automotive" PC that can play back through that system as a secondary display (with the primary display being a touch screen in the front).

      the BEST option, if money was no object, would be to add a display at each seat, with a slide-out VGA touch display in the dash for the driver, and with a computer to serve each seat, running whatever it is that you prefer. For instance I might opt for Windows XP with XBMC as the shell for the driver's interface, specifically so that I could run some quality navigation software without virtualization. Using a PC with 5.1 (or better) audio and simply running it into amplifiers with their own volume controls eliminates the need for a head unit, and permits mounting of the amplifiers in the trunk or other convenient location where the driver's PC is probably also located; there's no problem running VGA from one end of a car to another down the center. In a truck, there's room for all of this under the dash so long as you stick to SFF equipment. The audio for the other users can be implemented using IR headphones; you can build simple DC-DC power supplies for the transmitters with a 78xx and a couple caps. But the price of all of this (especially quality displays with touch) stacks up quickly.

      You could also probably do it with one powerful computer, but it's certainly a lot easier to do it with multiple machines.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    3. Re:Devil's in the details by sextoynazi · · Score: 1

      Actually, the BEST option would be to find a way to spend less time in your vehicle. Seriously, "money is no object" still has you sitting in a car watching a tiny screen? I think we can do better.

  25. Find something else to do with the kids in the car by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I play cube roots with my 5 year old and spelling with my 3 year old. My 1 year old can not talk very well at the moment, but he listens to classical music.

  26. Death and Taxes by whisper_jeff · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Quit bitching or go somewhere else. Lots of Apple fans read _and contribute to_ Slashdot. There are a variety of subjects I don't care about but I know numerous Slashdot readers are passionate about them so I know I'll continue to see those subjects in submissions. I just skip them. The content I want to read is interesting enough that I can just skip over the content I'm "sick and tired" of seeing. So, seriously, you have a choice - quit bitching about it or go read your geek news somewhere else. It isn't going to change so you might as well complain about death and taxes while you're at it.

    1. Re:Death and Taxes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Apple fans aren't nerds, apple fans are just plain idiots, go and take your religion somewhere else. Whats next? Articles about the benefits of Scientology?

  27. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by nacturation · · Score: 1

    So the kids are going to bring their iPad into the store/mall/whatever every damn time it parks?

    No, the parents are or they can take the risk of locking it out of sight such as in the trunk. Further, the kids don't need it for short trips to the mall and can leave it at home. Do you start playing a DVD on the in-car entertainment system for 10 minute drives?

    --
    Want to improve your Karma? Instead of "Post Anonymously", try the "Post Humously" option.
  28. For $2000 by mysidia · · Score: 1

    It seems you could buy 4 iPads.

    That allows you 3 spares in case they do break.

    Most likely, the $500 price will go down in the future, also.

    However, until you can insert your existing DVDs into an iPad and play them or Apple provides an alternative, the iPads are likely not a huge threat against DVD player systems.

    1. Re:For $2000 by SharpFang · · Score: 1

      And imagine how many etch-a-sketch could you get for that price!

      --
      45 5F E1 04 22 CA 29 C4 93 3F 95 05 2B 79 2A B2
    2. Re:For $2000 by babyrat · · Score: 1

      However, until you can insert your existing DVDs into an iPad and play them or Apple provides an alternative

      I don't have an iPad, but wouldn't you just connect to the apple store and get whatever movie you'd like? Wouldn't that count as an alternative?

  29. Apple Marketing Spammers Can't Save This Turd by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The marketplace failure of this turd of an Apple product, the iPad, is making the Apple TV failure look tame in comparison.

    Apple, and the marketing drone working for them, are getting more and more desperate trying to salvage this piece of unwanted junk.

    The more these Apple SPAM stories get posted, the worse it gets for Apple and its piece of crap tablet. The iPad has become synonymous with 'overpriced and useless piece of technology' just like the Edsel was for the automotive industry.

    Apple really needs to cut their losses with the iPad fiasco. Move on. There's nothing they can do to save the turd of a product.

    1. Re:Apple Marketing Spammers Can't Save This Turd by jo_ham · · Score: 3, Insightful

      The Edsel was actually an excellent tech testbed and spawned several ideas used in later products, despite being a financial failure as a product itself.

      Either way, I'm not sure that I can take the word of an AC on slashdot that the iPad, which has been on sale for about a month is a "dismal failure" and a "turd of a product". From what I have seen of a broad range of reviews, both positive and negative, I don't think it can really be classified as that.

      Perhaps your anti-Apple anger is making you resort to hyperbole. Perhaps that is also why you accidentally checked the "post anonymously" checkbox.

    2. Re:Apple Marketing Spammers Can't Save This Turd by AshtangiMan · · Score: 1

      I wish that the Apple TV had been something of actual use. If it had a built in HD Tuner and some PVR software on top of whatever it already has then maybe it starts to have a point (especially with a DVD player). I remember being at the Apple store looking for a TV Tuner that my G4 laptop could use and the salesman trying to sell me the Apple TV (?). I asked what it did and he told me that it was basically like an iPod, but for video (uhh, the iPod plays video) yeah, but this is for the TV. Very strange.

      Maybe saying that I wish is a little far fetched, so let me just say that I was disappointed by the pointlessness of the product. I do have a friend who bought one, and it made getting you tube onto his TV very easy . . . which is to say I don't really think it did anything at all.

  30. Are we still trying to... by f0rk · · Score: 1

    Are we still trying to figure out what this thing is for ?

    So far the only, day to day, use case i'we heard people going on about, is to use it as a portable emailer and wordprocessor. I think that's very naive, cuz once youwe had it in your hands, and tried doing some actual typeing, you quickly realize that thats never going to happen.

    1. Re:Are we still trying to... by TheKidWho · · Score: 1

      At least you would have auto-correct. You seem like you need it.

    2. Re:Are we still trying to... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      even though he is completely right apart from the spelling and grammar.

    3. Re:Are we still trying to... by TheKidWho · · Score: 1

      Why is he correct?

      I mainly use my iPad for web browsing, book reading, news reading, and playing games.

      For those uses it works very very well.

  31. My Adblocker must not be working. by singingjim1 · · Score: 1

    Because I just came across a blatant advertisement on Slashdot trying to convince me that buying an iPad instead of an in-car entertainment option was something I would be stupid not to do. I'm guessing the convenience factor of an ICE system is one of the big selling points and the fact that the components are generally designed for a decent amount of abuse. Did Steve Jobs leave this story laying on a bar somewhere?

  32. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...to steal the factory installed DVD system than they are to grab the two iPads in your back seat.

    Maybe one day Apple will develop an iPad which is portable so that it can be removed from the vehicle? One can only hope!

    Perhaps even so portable, it can fit in your pocket! They could call it the iPad Nano! REVOLUTIONARY!

  33. Car LAN by hey · · Score: 1

    Better put a file server in your trunk (loaded with DVD images) that the kids can access from their iPads with Wifi.

  34. You buy the integration, not just the DVD player by AwaxSlashdot · · Score: 1

    The only motivation to buy such an expensive integrated DVD player is ... because it's integrated.

    You don't have LCDs loosely attached to the back of your seat, sliding slowly from the head rest to the floor, with ugly and cumbersome straps. You don't have dangling wires going from the player to the screen, with the kids feet in between. You don't have the DVD player resting on the middle seat or on the floor, sliding from far right to far left every time you change direction. You don't have a 12ft power cable going the nearest power jack to the DVD player, running all around your car. And you don't have to lean back and grab the player itself to skip/pause/navigate the DVD.

    So, YES, this is VERY expensive but they are people who give a price to simplicity and ease of use.

    PS : I've custom build a headrest fixture in which I can bolt (1/4" camera thread) the screens of my Philips PET712. Now I need to find a solution for the cables. But I would gladly have paid 2 or 3 times more to get it integrated. The problem is that it's much closer from 10x times.

    --
    Sig (appended to the end of comments you post, 120 chars)
  35. Built in stuff is for the suckers! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Buying an in car entertainment system is like buying RAM from Apple. You're either ignorant or brain-dead to do so.

    Seriously. Why do people willingly pay to get something installed when we're inventive enough to do it ourselves... a LOT cheaper.
    This article was up what... 2 days after the ipad launch. Meanwhile I still can't walk into an apple store and buy a case for mine.

    http://thedidenizen.com/2010/04/diy-ipad-car-holster-free-pattern-download/

  36. Netbooks by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Or at $300 a pop, you can give them each a netbook which can do everything an iPad can and can also be closed to protect the screens when not in use.

  37. Hiding Apple stories from the front page by xaxa · · Score: 1

    Can anyone tell me how to hide Apple-section stories from the front page?

    On my preferences I can hide them from the classic index, but not the dynamic one.

  38. Kids by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yeah, but the kids won't throw the in-car system on the ground and break it, or take it to school and have it taken away for looking at porn on the neighbor's Wi-Fi. You DO know that portable DVD players are about 80 bucks at Wal-Mart, right? Any parent willing to spend 500 bucks to shut their kids up during a car ride needs shot in the face.

  39. Tell that to the dude.... by bodland · · Score: 1

    With the 42" flat panel in the backseat of his candy apple red Cutlass with the 21" spinners and 2000 watt subwoofer....crazy thing plays music videos going down the street...and crumbles buildings as it goes by...lol

  40. uhh by nomadic · · Score: 2, Funny

    At $500 a pop, giving two kids their own iPads would cost far less than what the automakers charge for an ICE system.

    And the only drawback being they can't play DVDs at all? Why not replace the ICE system with a shiny rock they can look at, even cheaper than the ipad and it can't play DVDs either.

    1. Re:uhh by Kristoph · · Score: 1

      My daughter is 3. She watches movies on an iPhone on road trips and plays - most educational - games, and generally amuses herself quite effectively. The same movies also synced with the the iPad and we now have that as an entertainment option (although, that said, for a small child an iPhone is better because it's easier to hold).

      Admittedly we don't have many DVD's and the one's we do have have been ripped and re-encoded which does, admittedly, require some skill but then, you know, this is slashdot.

  41. In an accident by Timo_UK · · Score: 1

    the iPad becomes the iMissile. INtegrated systems are crash tested extensively.

    --
    Timo's Audio Software http://www.esseraudio.com
  42. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by sorak · · Score: 1

    ...to steal the factory installed DVD system than they are to grab the two iPads in your back seat.

    Maybe one day Apple will develop an iPad which is portable so that it can be removed from the vehicle? One can only hope!

    The great thing about that is that portability is tied into the unit. It cannot be moved from an iPad, to a home PC, for example. It is the ultimate DRM!

  43. Choice/Upgradability by AwaxSlashdot · · Score: 1

    That would be great to have just a "Interaction Unit" (screen + joystick/ok/cancel + antenna) that can be plugged in GPS boxes from multiple vendors so you can pay for the integration while keeping your freedom to upgrade for the GPS unit of your choice.

    --
    Sig (appended to the end of comments you post, 120 chars)
  44. Never pay an car manufacturer to add non-car stuff by stewbacca · · Score: 1

    People who pay the ridiculous prices for stuff like premium sound and integrated video are suckers anyway. For a little more effort (i.e., being without your vehicle for a day or two) you can get three times the entertainment system in your car by going after-market.

    And before anyone says it, yes I'm aware that most people don't need three times better system. Still, you can get the exact SAME system for probably a third of the cost if you go to your local car stereo shop.

  45. STOP IT MY IBRAIN HURTS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Please PLEASE PLEASE STOP POSTING THIS CRAP
    YOUR KILLING slashdot.......No gives a flying f***ball about your inability to find real news....
    STOP MAKING FAKE NEWS STORIES UP TO PROMOTE THE PAD.

  46. Re:You buy the integration, not just the DVD playe by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

    You don't have LCDs loosely attached to the back of your seat, sliding slowly from the head rest to the floor, with ugly and cumbersome straps.

    You can get a pair of LCD-equipped headrest replacements for $200 these days, if you look around. $400 for something that won't make your car look like you accessorize at the dollar mart. You can get bare video LCDs under $100, and integrate them into your headrest pretty easily; you lay down the display, mark an area to cut, cut the area, dig out some foam... you get the idea. You can even buy 'em with a bezel, or you can add a touch overlay that has one, if you really wanna spend money. The intrepid DIYer also has the option to buy someone else's used headrest replacements that don't match anyone's car, and gut them for parts to install into the factory units.

    You don't have dangling wires going from the player to the screen, with the kids feet in between.

    It's under $200 to buy an in-dash DVD player that replaces the head unit. You can also just install one of these in some arbitrary location; a variety of kits up to and including complete enclosures are available in the aftermarket.

    You don't have a 12ft power cable going the nearest power jack to the DVD player, running all around your car.

    It's fairly trivial to run power down the length of most vehicles; it's not that much harder to get it through the firewall. Tapping the battery is usually positively trivial. Even before I knew my way around auto body and interior parts (through a combination of trial and error, and training, more or less in that order) I found it pretty easy to do things like install a stereo (which for any modern car is a plug and play affair, if you purchase the right cables) and to weasel a CD changer wire up under plastic parts and such and get it to the back of the car without showing anywhere but alongside the drive line tunnel in the back seat area someplace. And frankly, for no more than the price of installing an ordinary car stereo, you may have installed an entertainment and navigation system. Car stereo shops do this kind of thing all the time, and it's a lot cheaper than a factory integrated system. Flip-down displays are under $200 new now, and replace the dome light (they have dome lights on 'em) so the hardest part of the install is fishing the leads down.

    PS : I've custom build a headrest fixture in which I can bolt (1/4" camera thread) the screens of my Philips PET712. Now I need to find a solution for the cables. But I would gladly have paid 2 or 3 times more to get it integrated. The problem is that it's much closer from 10x times.

    Touch is spendy. Personally I'm thinking of the Asus EEE tablet, which is under $500. I also have a DT Research DT360, which is a Geode/WinCE tablet which can also run Linux. I need to put some more effort into that, I suppose. It only has USB2 and 802.11b as configured, but it has 512mB SSD + 8GB CF, so it ought to be able to handle basic navigation if not entertainment.

    --
    "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
  47. iPod Touch for me, now the iPad by leamanc · · Score: 1

    The iPod touch, with Handbrake-ripped content, has been serving this purpose for my kid for a while. It's been upgraded to an iPad lately.

    --
    :q!
  48. Re:-5 to 160 degrees? What about the kids? by elrous0 · · Score: 2, Informative

    Actually, it's more appropriate to say that it can WITHSTAND those temperature extremes. While your kids may not be in the car when it's 120+F, those players still are. Try leaving a iPad out on the seat for about a year in Arizona and see if it still works (direct sunlight at the height of summer here can melt most common plastics outright). That "ridiculously expensive" DVD system is so priced because it's built to last and survive over the long-term in an environment with extreme temperature variations and to handle daily jarring movement/vibration.

    --
    SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
  49. How about just STFU ? by Gothmolly · · Score: 1

    How does this not work? "I swear to God, if you don't stop poking your sister, I am pulling this car over and comibg back there."

    Tell your kids to shut up, sing songs, play 'Volkswagen' or give them a benadryl. Why must they be continuously entertained?

    --
    I want to delete my account but Slashdot doesn't allow it.
  50. ~1M units * $500 each = win by dazedNconfuzed · · Score: 1

    Apple really needs to cut their losses with the iPad fiasco.

    Why? Since when is moving a half-billion dollars of new product in the couple months, with a very high profit margin, a bad thing?

    --
    Can we get a "-1 Wrong" moderation option?
  51. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by O('_')O_Bush · · Score: 1

    The easy solution is to hide them. There's no reason to break into a car to check for iPads if they don't know they're in there.

    An extra thirty seconds added on to your wait to get into your hotel isn't too much of an inconvenience... especially not for a thousand dollars.

    --
    while(1) attack(People.Sandy);
  52. don't mean to state the obvious here.... by SethJohnson · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Do a Google search on the phrase, "Disney largest shareholder" and you will also answer the question of who has the keys to the "Disney Vault."

    Seth

    1. Re:don't mean to state the obvious here.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      FUCK. Yep. 2006, the 7 years before the end of the world began. Right at the end of 2012, as predicted, we're all going to die. I'm telling you this now.

    2. Re:don't mean to state the obvious here.... by HarrySquatter · · Score: 1

      Except that having only a 7% voting stake hardly amounts Steve Jobs to be able to boss around the Disney Board of Directors.

    3. Re:don't mean to state the obvious here.... by gyrogeerloose · · Score: 1

      Do a Google search on the phrase, "Disney largest shareholder" and you will also answer the question of who has the keys to the "Disney Vault."

      I'll save you the time: it's Steve Jobs. He received a boatload of Disney stock in the Pixar deal. He also sits on the Disney BoD.

      --
      This ain't rocket surgery.
    4. Re:don't mean to state the obvious here.... by DinDaddy · · Score: 1

      BEING one of the board of directors makes him a little more than just a holder of 7% of the stock . . .

      http://corporate.disney.go.com/corporate/bios/steve_jobs.html

    5. Re:don't mean to state the obvious here.... by HarrySquatter · · Score: 1

      Well of course. It still doesn't mean he can make any sort of unilateral decisions or that he has the "keys to the disney vault" anymore than any other shareholder does.

    6. Re:don't mean to state the obvious here.... by chowdahhead · · Score: 1

      Thanks, I read that somewhere before though. If tablet media devices provide a large market base, I'm sure Disney will monetize that opportunity. But Blu-Ray didn't cause a massive release of classic titles. Instead Disney is gradually releasing DVD+Blu-Ray combo packs over a period of what has now turned out to be years several and counting. That's what my comment was in reference to; we'll be able to buy or rent Beauty and the Beast (for example) when Disney wants us to. I suspect this is a calculated marketing process, which Steve wouldn't have much influence over.

  53. and for under 120.00 by night_flyer · · Score: 2, Insightful

    you can buy an after market portable DVD player designed to use in a car...

    --


    Thanks to file sharing, I purchase more CDs
    Thanks to the RIAA, I buy them used...
    1. Re:and for under 120.00 by EmagGeek · · Score: 2, Insightful

      And, unlike the iPad, it'll actually play DVDs!

  54. Another business opportunity... by HikingStick · · Score: 1

    Okay, for any of you in plastic or silcon fabrication, tell your engineers to design a housing for the iPad that includes a strap system to mount it to a headrest, or to hang it from the ceiling of the vehicle (I'll let them worry about how to mount it, but the mounting armor/sleeve should snap onto the mount and allow the display to tilt/hinge). Then design an accessory kit that includes wired or wireless speakers or headphones, and you can make a nice tidy sum selling to the iPad lovers.

    --
    I use irony whenever I can, but my shirts are still wrinkled...
  55. consider the viewing experience by SethJohnson · · Score: 1

    I don't mean to be a smart-ass here, but an Archos 404 has a 3.5" screen. The viewing experience on a small screen is something less than that of the iPad. Not to mention the inevitable stream of educational games that will be developed for the iPad. Hopefully, some young backseat passengers will use the iPad to read books, but if they were going to read, maybe actual books would be a better choice due to the lower distraction potential.

    Seth

  56. ICE works at 160 degrees? by johnthuss · · Score: 1

    Wow, my ICE starts to melt at 32 degrees. That's amazing!

  57. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by Assmasher · · Score: 1

    I agree, but women have secrets, water is wet, people are lazy...

    --
    Loading...
  58. Better alternative by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ZuneHD

  59. DVDs have no reason to exist anymore by Fastfwd · · Score: 1

    All the movies I have are either recorded from TV or ripped from a DVD that then sits unused in the case. This way my kids can have their movies at home both on the big tv via ps3 or on the computer screen via vlc. I can also copy them to my ipoh touch or my psp so they can watch in the car on long trips.

    Why anyone would prefer DVDs is beyond me just like getting a discman in the era of the mp3 player makes no sense to me.

    Now if only the media lobby would allow scientific atlanta to enable a feature to copy from my PVR to my computer I would be all set.

  60. A waste of money by GoJays · · Score: 2, Insightful

    In my day, entertainment on long drives was looking out the window and making up games as we went. Kids are already exposed to enough television and other mindless entertainment. Do they really need to have their own iPad for the occasional long drive? Maybe they should try looking out the window and experiencing the world in which they live.

    1. Re:A waste of money by ClosedSource · · Score: 1

      When looking out the window did you see any old guys waving their arms while standing on their lawn?

  61. Cars by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Typically the car isn't subjected to those conditions while occupied.

    However it might be for a short while immediately after becoming occupied.

  62. How is this specific to iPad? by Sloppy · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Doesn't the exact same thinking apply to any personal computer that isn't bundled with the car? If a $500 iPad is trouble for Ford, then a $400 laptop that can do anything, even things not approved of by Apple, is even more trouble for Ford.

    --
    As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
    1. Re:How is this specific to iPad? by RyuuzakiTetsuya · · Score: 1

      you ever try using a netbook while as a passenger in a car? By doing *everything* you mean, it doesn't rest comfortably. in your hands while in motion right?

      --
      Non impediti ratione cogitationus.
    2. Re:How is this specific to iPad? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Agree, and not just to Ford; anybody that charges $2k for such an "integration" should be in trouble.

      However, the problem is mommies and daddies who will pay anything to keep their kids happy (at least for a few minutes). As long as such beings exist, us geeks will never understand why anybody in their right might would pay $2000 for something we can do for $400.

      My kids are quite happy with their nintendoDS - for entertainment value beats any DVD solution.

  63. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Further, the kids don't need it for short trips to the mall and can leave it at home. Do you start playing a DVD on the in-car entertainment system for 10 minute drives?

    Sadly, some people do. My sister was one of them. The only reason she stopped was because the DVD player broke after being abused by a 3-year-old.

    I wish I were kidding.

  64. iPad overload by Comboman · · Score: 1

    If this article actually had some new and useful information about iPad I might agree, however this article (like most recent iPad articles) is nothing but fluff. I'm an iPhone user and had some interest in the iPad when it came out but even I am sick of the constant stream of non-news about the iPad. It's even drowning out more important Apple news like iPhoneOS4.

    --
    Support Right To Repair Legislation.
    1. Re:iPad overload by whisper_jeff · · Score: 1

      Every subject on Slashdot has its periodic articles that are nothing more than fluff. Nothing new nor special. People are getting bitchy about it because all things Apple are becoming increasingly polarized but it's no different than any of the other main subjects regularly discussed here. So, I say again, either quit bitching about it because it's not going to change or get your nerd news elsewhere. So long as Slashdot's content is based on reader contributions, it ain't going to change, be it about Apple, Linux, copyright, or whatever subject you're discussing.

  65. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by babyrat · · Score: 1

    No, the parents are or they can take the risk of locking it out of sight such as in the trunk.

    yes they can, and nobody is perfect and it seems the one time you are an imperfect human and forget to do so, is the one time that another imperfect human comes along and sneetches your stuff.

  66. Re:-5 to 160 degrees? What about the kids? by Cimexus · · Score: 1

    Good point.

    Although if we are comparing that to the iPad option, it's still not really a selling point, as you'd be pretty unlikely to leave a nice shiny toy like an iPad sitting unattended in a car. I mean you don't leave your phone or wallet or other valuables in there do you?

  67. Well yes because you are DRIVING by Sycraft-fu · · Score: 1

    So I don't know about you, but I prefer people who are driving to be, you know, concentrating on the road. Lack of concentration is a big cause for accidents. When people give their full attention to driving, they are much better equipped to be able to respond to, and avoid, problems.

    Now with kids, this is an additional challenge. See most kids, in particular younger ones, aren't entertained by simple chatter. They don't want to talk to you for hours on end. They want to do something, they want you to interact with them. That is not at all safe when driving. You do not want to be turning around taking your hands off the wheel and so on just to pay attention to your kids.

    Hence the need for things to keep kids entertained. For older kids, video games (maybe a portable like a DS, perhaps an X-box 360 hooked to an ICES) can work pretty well, as can books. For younger kids though, movies are generally the best choice. They tend to engage them quite well.

  68. Missed point... by sootman · · Score: 1

    "The Cars.com article mentions some of the advantages of ICE, including being weather-tested to work from -5 to 160 degrees"

    That is only a handy feature when the device is permanently attached to the car. Besides...
    iPad Environmental requirements:
    Operating temperature: 32 to 95 deg. F (0 to 35 deg C)
    Nonoperating temperature: -4 to 113 deg F (-20 to 45 deg C)

    The iPod classic (disk-based) shows the same specs, and I've been leaving mine in the glovebox for years, and I live in Florida.

    Anyway, this article is dumb. Is the an viable alternative to expensive built-in systems? Yes. Does it have some other advantages? Yes. Does it have some disadvantages too? Yes. Will the iPad kill the whole industry? No. Hell, it's been the case for decades that aftermarket stereos are better and cheaper than their ridiculously-overpriced dealer-installed counterparts. Did third-party stereos kill dealer-installed units? Of course not.

    --
    Dear Slashdot: next time you want to mess with the site, add a rich-text editor for comments.
  69. DVD are too scratch prone....besides... by darthium · · Score: 1

    Would you be so worried about extremedly high quality of video and audio DURING A CAR TRIP? I seriously doubt you'd notice the full fledged details when you're not in optimal condicions of silence and lighting.....isn't it?

  70. Who thoguth the former comment was 'insightful'? by darthium · · Score: 1

    Perhaps I will be punished by slashdot owners...but in many replies, the former comment labeled as 'insghtful' ad given 4 points, was shown to have more holes than swiss cheese....... Isn't this place supposed to be for very intelligent nerds and geeks, more likely to prefer some objetive evaluation rather than a subjective one?

  71. The place they really rook you is updates by alispguru · · Score: 1

    I have a 2005 Prius with a built-in navsystem (bought it used - someone else got the initial screwing).

    Toyota wants $300 for a DVD with updated maps. That level of overcharge makes the torrents look attractive.

    --

    To a Lisp hacker, XML is S-expressions in drag.
  72. LOL by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    look at the Apple customer get all huffy!

  73. The Ipad is useless as a video playback device by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Since Apple insists on supporting only a subset of video playback codecs out there. This reminds me of Apple TV vs WD live media player: Apple TV has a beautiful interface but does not support DIVX (avi) format files, unless you want to start hacking it with perian, which will probably not help since it stutters etc. I think Apple learned the wrong lesson with the ipod touch: people buy it to play illegal downloads (MP3s) and the video playback is a nice bonus, even if it requires using handbrake or whatever to convert each file. Even without the ability to play DIVX (avi) files a DVD player is way better than an Apple device that can only play x264 video that must be converted for each file.

  74. LOL2 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    look at the Apple detractor get all puffy!

  75. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Maybe one day kids will keep up with their stuff. Oh wait that will never happen.

  76. the cold side happens here every year by Chirs · · Score: 1

    There is this stuff called clothing that can be used to prevent hypothermia.

    I'd like an even lower temperature rating. We get down below -40 pretty much every winter and the car lives outside. The rated temperature means you have to drive for half an hour before the car warms up enough to use the integrated system.

  77. netbooks? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So, cars.com never of netbooks before? play movies, music, do homework, balance your budget, browse the web (today) with 3g, more storage for the buck and even skype with video, which you can't do with an iPad for at least a couple more years.

    You are giving iPads too much credit when netbooks have had more power for more than a year.

  78. iPad 3G + Netflix client, or iTunes by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    Though it doesn't have a key element for kids: A DVD drive or a suitable ability to play the same movies they watch at home.

    Sure it does, in two ways.

    One, the parents could simply buy stuff from iTunes instead of the DVD. The great thing is the digital copy never dies, and you know kids watch movies a million times so even though the cost is sometime slightly higher, it's amortized over a great number of plays and you'll never have the movie accidentally destroyed. Or, another option is some Blu-Ray discs now (Disney at least) come with versions you can load into iTunes to play on portable devices.

    Two, if you bought iPad 3G units, the kids could watch any kids movie on Netflix with the Netflix client. My sister has a Roku box and her kids pretty much just watch stuff from Netflix now instead of buying DVDs. It's $30/month for the iPad unlimited data plan, but that's the same as buying three DVD's a month...

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  79. So the iPad is a niche product ... by future+assassin · · Score: 1

    still looking for a niche market?

    --
    by TheSpoom (715771) Uncaring Linux user here. I have nothing to add to this but please continue. *munches popcorn*
  80. startling news by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Auto accessories and options are more expensive than their non-auto counterparts?!? You could buy your own leather and make an interior or your own carpet to make floormats but those options haven't mysteriously gone away, in fact you can spend hundreds on a set of floor mats.

       

  81. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by troll8901 · · Score: 1

    Perhaps even so portable, it can fit in your pocket! They could call it the iPad Nano! REVOLUTIONARY!

    You've just gave me an idea.

    I suspect they not only already thought of it, but actually are timing the release such that the demand will be high when they release it.

    (Releasing today's big form factor, will create desire in people who will wants an iPad but finds it too big. Thus creating a new market of people who wants and are willing to pay for a medium form factor.)

  82. Automakers shoud Integrate by jbezorg · · Score: 1

    Bring it into mainstream auto production.

    - Provide a docking system that allows the device to use larger displays and sound system
    - Capitalize on the lack of space restrictions that a portable device is limited to and boost wireless capabilities
    - Partner with a wireless provider for the car's wireless network access.
    - Charge a monthly access fee that would probably net them more in the long term then the profit from selling high end entertainment systems
    - Net more buyers because a small initial outlay plus a subscription is an easier sell than the high end entertainment system

    --
    I've lost all my marbles except one & It's fun to test angular & centripetal acceleration in my skull
  83. But all those things work without Flash by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    Don't forget that lots of stuff can be streamed from hulu, netflix, amazon

    Oh, wait, the ipad doesn't do flash.

    Why does that matter (the Flash)?

    There's already a Netflix iPad app. There's soon to be a Hulu iPad app.

    Amazon, eh if Netflix works. But Amazon will probably follow suit (after all they have the expertise, having an iPad Kindle app as well).

    Most other sites already switch to feeding you h.264 directly if you are browsing from the iPad, and major producers of Flash video players are altering the products to have external code to detect iPads and swap out the Flash player for an HTML5 one.

    You flash supporters can't see the winds of change, no matter how hard the trees bend in front of you...

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  84. Bigger is not better by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    For the price of an iPad you could just buy a laptop, with a bigger screen

    With lower resolution (the iPad is 1024x768)

    The iPad also has an IPS display, so you could enjoy it from off angles and just have one in the middle of the car. How is that laptop display going to work when you are not in the 1 degree field of view?

    Lastly, a laptop hanging around inside a car is a death trap if you have to brake at all hard. The iPad can easily be secured.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  85. Don't forget he's an AC by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    Why yes; make an account, and uncheck the Apple stories.

    Don't forget, he's an AC - he fundamentally lacks the intelligence required to figure out how to create an account, or use a checkbox.

    Not that YOU are not an intelligent AC - although you don't seem to have an account either... hmm.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  86. LOL! This Douchebag Actually Bought An iPad! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Right dipshit? You fucking piece of shit actually walked into the local Hipster Central Apple Store and wasted 500 bucks on the laughingstock of the computing world.

    No wonder you sound so fucking bitter and desperate to defend your idiocy. Someone needs to smack the shit out of your fucking Hipster Douchebag face.

    1. Re:LOL! This Douchebag Actually Bought An iPad! by jo_ham · · Score: 1

      The iPad is not available for sale in my country yet. So, even if I wanted to buy one I can't do so at the moment.

      I can't afford it at any rate, even if I did want to buy one.

      Again, I think your blind hate is causing you to make assumptions about me that just aren't true. So much anger from you, and such nerd rage. You should really work on calming that down. If you want to beat someone up just because they use an iPad then I would try some calming exercises or something.

    2. Re:LOL! This Douchebag Actually Bought An iPad! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Get the fuck off this site you fucking loser.

    3. Re:LOL! This Douchebag Actually Bought An iPad! by jo_ham · · Score: 1

      Why?

  87. Apple as car interface designer by Boawk · · Score: 1

    I have a late model Honda Pilot with all the entertainment (and nav) bells and whistles. The dash is a horrible amalgam of buttons and knobs. If a car maker wanted to get the jump on the competition, they would make a deal with Apple for them to design the dashboard.

  88. Not without DVD ripping by proxima · · Score: 1

    People own/rent DVDs right now, lots of them. There is no easy, legal way to rip DVDs to iTunes for use with the ipad. Easy would basically mean built-in functionality like CD ripping. Since realdvd got shut down, I don't think we're ever going to see Apple go that way. Besides - Apple wants you to buy (overpriced) movies on iTMS.

    The best video options for the ipad now (Netflix, ABC player) require an internet connection, so aren't very useful in a car (I doubt most 3G data connections have the bandwidth to use it).

    --
    "The universe seems neither benign nor hostile, merely indifferent." --Carl Sagan
    1. Re:Not without DVD ripping by LanMan04 · · Score: 1

      There is no easy, legal way to rip DVDs to iTunes for use with the ipad.

      Yeah, but there sure is an easy way.

      --
      With the first link, the chain is forged.
  89. I see another Slashdot iPad story coming by ClosedSource · · Score: 1

    If you're drunk and happen to drive into a lake or river, your children can use their iPads as flotation devices.

  90. rear entertainment system by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ... doesn't this belong in the article about that poor woman with her DoD implanted microchip(s)?

  91. Apple censorship by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I hope Steve Jobs approves the movie you wanna watch (or whatever you want to do with the ipad), otherwise "no entertainment for you!" (soup nazi voice)

  92. Internal Combustion Engine (ICE)? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I don't understand what the Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) has to do with on-board entertainment.

  93. Re:People are less like to smash your car windows. by DeadboltX · · Score: 1

    That and, you know, a dvd player can play dvds. Two iPads and a digital copy of all your kids favorite cartoons for each one will easily end up costing more than the dual built-in dvd players.

  94. Re:-5 to 160 degrees? What about the kids? by nevermore94 · · Score: 1

    When did the acronym ICE in reference to vehicles switch from Internal Combustion Engine to In-Car Entertainment anyway?

    --
    Nevermore.
  95. And that's a problem? by SanityInAnarchy · · Score: 1

    Inverters aren't terribly expensive. Plug one end into the cigarette lighter, plug the laptop into the other end.

    iPads can be infected with spyware, also. Doesn't happen often, but it happens. They can also (I hope) be locked with a password...

    And laptops can be had with SSDs.

    --
    Don't thank God, thank a doctor!
  96. You believe Kensington won't sell a locking dock? by tlambert · · Score: 1

    You believe Kensington won't sell a locking dock?

    -- Terry

  97. Aftermarket installation is still cheap by billstewart · · Score: 1

    Yeah, you probably don't want to install it yourself - but for add-on equipment like DVDs and sound systems you can still save a significant amount by going to a car audio shop as opposed to paying hopelessly inflated car-dealer prices, and get a much broader choice of equipment as well. I don't know if that also applies to in-dashboard integrated systems or not; depends on whether any car-info systems are open (or at least licenseable by vendors), which I don't know.

    --

    Bill Stewart
    New Fast-Compression-only CPR http://preview.tinyurl.com/dy575ks
  98. Are we forgeting about the tegra 2? by Dr+Max · · Score: 1

    When Nvidia built the Tegra 2 the car entertainment market was one of there largest predicted areas of profit. That’s because it can be done for dirt cheap now, one chip the size of your palm with dual core ghz chips. 3 usbs for some one to customise whatever storage solution they want (hard drive, dvd, digital radio). 1080p resolution so you can have 50 inch monitors running if you want. And if you’re not smart enough to disassemble a cheap tablet with the chip in it, I’m sure a manufacturer somewhere would charge you less than $500 for a professional version (whether they use Tegra or develop there own (given a reasonable time for the market to adapt). also any of you people that think you’ll get anything similar in function with the ipad without buying 10 accessories at an absorbitant price and a dozen or so ‘apps’ are kidding them self. The Ipad wont kill the car entertainment market it will just make it cheaper; but that’s bound to happen as we are using less and less materials to do more and more.

    --
    Rocket Surgeon.
  99. The tegra 2 and other socs by Dr+Max · · Score: 1

    what happened to my last comment i'm sure the fact that a lot of car entertainment units will be powered by tegra 2 in the near future drasticly reducing the price and increasing functionality and performance is quite relevant. also i'll say it again anyone that thinks you'll get anything like a car entertainment system without buying a bunch of accesories and apps is kidding them self.

    --
    Rocket Surgeon.
  100. It's not the tech, it's where you buy it. by LazyBoy · · Score: 1

    Innovatek HR-907DVD
    9" Headrest Hi-Resolution TFT LCD Monitor

      Headrest Monitor with Built-In DVD Player
      Disc Format: MP3/WMA/DVD/DIVX/MPEG1/2/4 /MP4/JPEG/CD/VCD/CD-R/CD-RW/DVD-R+/DVD-RW
      Built-in USB/SD/MMC Port (File Format: MP3/WMA/JPEG/MPEG1/2/4 /DIVX etc.)
      Built-in FM Modulator (87.7, 87.9, 88.1, 88.3, 88.5, 88.7, 88.9 & 89.1 Mhz)
      extra RCA output to playback the DVD/USB/SD/MMC Player on other monitors.

    $179 / headrest

    http://www.mp3playerstore.com/stuff_you_need/special/HR-907.html

    --

    If Chaos Theory has taught us anything, it's that we must kill all the butterflies.

  101. Think of it two ways by jseale · · Score: 1

    There's no 'safe' way to mount an iPod in a vehicle for GPS use IMHO. The iPad is way too new to make a dent any way. When it does mature, it'll more than likely be used for digesting larger maps and travel info, an electronic TRIPTIK of sorts.

  102. Really? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is a foolish story, is Apple going to hang the iPad on the back of the headrest. Its not a transformer, its barely a computer. Everyone is talking like this thing is changing the world. Its a giant iPhone, which is cool for some. I have an iPhone and it is the best device I have ever had. Having said that, the iPad has little real world applications at this time. If this were Star Trek, and we were carrying around touch screen computers in our hands daily to complete our work. Then iPad is the Sh*t - but were not and it's cool, but lacks real function. At least right now.

  103. LOL at the Apple customer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    he'll buy anything with an Apple logo.

  104. Re:You left out... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If you think ADB was somehow superior to USB I've got a box of ADB crap that I'll send directly to your door..

  105. Re:-5 to 160 degrees? What about the kids? by Shag · · Score: 1

    Although if we are comparing that to the iPad option, it's still not really a selling point, as you'd be pretty unlikely to leave a nice shiny toy like an iPad sitting unattended in a car.

    Yeah, this. You'll probably take the iPad with you. Some built-in seatback entertainment system, you might not be able to take with you even if you wanted to for whatever reason.

    --
    Village idiot in some extremely smart villages.