Slashdot Mirror


Twitter Says Americans Are Happier In the Morning

DWF3046 writes "There are lots of things you can infer from Twitter. But while we're learning what we're eating or where we're flying, we haven't been able to use Twitter to determine how we're feeling. Researchers at Harvard and Northwestern have created a video that shows the mood in the US, as inferred using over 300 million tweets, over the course of the day. The results? The early morning and late evening appear to provide the highest levels of happiness. Geographically, the data points to a significantly happier west coast, which is consistently three hours behind the east coast."

63 of 88 comments (clear)

  1. North Americans are retarded by kyrio · · Score: 2, Informative

    I'm happy all day long.

    1. Re:North Americans are retarded by AnonymousClown · · Score: 1
      You got that right! It's a good thing I'm right here in America; otherwise, I'd be really insulted by what you said and I'd flame you real bad!

      Instead I'm agreeing with you.

      --
      RIP America

      July 4, 1776 - September 11, 2001

    2. Re:North Americans are retarded by Dashiva+Dan · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I think it's much more likely that people try to be more optomistic in the morning, but gradually become more realistic as they finally 'wake up and 'smell the coffee'

      --
      "lt;dr" is the correct response to most of my posts.
    3. Re:North Americans are retarded by kyrio · · Score: 3, Interesting
    4. Re:North Americans are retarded by ElectricTurtle · · Score: 1

      We were talking about mood, remember? Not alertness, and that was the only thing objectively tested by that study. The mood portions were done by participant-selected confidence scores, which would skew baselines for adjusted persons (the new normal).

      As mentioned in the discussion of that topic, there are also health effects of tea and coffee to be considered.

      That is all unimportant to me though. I consume what I want because it is satisfying, not because of benefit or detriment, so long as my consumption habits are diverse and moderate, I have no problems.

      --
      I support the Slashcott and will not be reading or commenting from 2/10/14 to 2/17/14. Beta is steaming pile of dog shit
    5. Re:North Americans are retarded by tsalmark · · Score: 1

      A few in denial caffeine addicts seem to have mod points.

    6. Re:North Americans are retarded by fuzzyfuzzyfungus · · Score: 1

      It could just be that those goddamn perky "morning people" are up bright and early and polluting the dataset while sensible humans are still asleep, or wishing that they were...

    7. Re:North Americans are retarded by Dashiva+Dan · · Score: 1

      I put 'wake up and smell the coffee' in quotes. (with an extra quote in the middle as I wasn't yet fully woken/smellerized when I posted it)
      a) I wasn't literally implying a caffeine fix, just that their thinking become clearer throughout the day (in fact, this process has become slightly slower for me since I quit caffeine)
      b) Even if I did mean it literally, I don't think inhaling the scent of coffee gives you much of a caffeine fix/addiction

      If I was modded up for suggesting caffeine as the cause, you can take it off (although I guess there may be a little truth in that aspect); If I was modded up for the actual meaning of the observation, then 'Glad someone read and understood my post'.

      --
      "lt;dr" is the correct response to most of my posts.
  2. Before and after work by locallyunscene · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Now where's my grant money?

    1. Re:Before and after work by Monkeedude1212 · · Score: 1

      HEY. It took A LOT of people with A LOT of money with A LOT of time to do A LOT of work to INFER any results that you or I could have come up with using common sense.

      Don't rain on their parade.

    2. Re:Before and after work by geekmux · · Score: 3, Funny

      HEY. It took A LOT of people with A LOT of money with A LOT of time to do A LOT of work to INFER any results that you or I could have come up with using common sense.

      Don't rain on their parade.

      Uh, rain? That's not water I'm smelling over here coming from this huge steaming pile of "grant justification"...

      Besides, I'm failing to see how they determined "happiness" from the typical "taking my morning shit" and "I hate blueberries in my oatmeal" tweets.

    3. Re:Before and after work by dkleinsc · · Score: 1

      We here at the Slashdot Institute of Slowly and Painfully Working Out the Surprisingly Obvious resent your implication that your non-rigorous "common sense" could possibly outweigh improperly organized research.

      --
      I am officially gone from /. Long live http://www.soylentnews.com/
    4. Re:Before and after work by nomadic · · Score: 1

      Huh? How is that common sense? Intuitively you'd think people are happier AFTER work than before it. I know I am.

    5. Re:Before and after work by Monkeedude1212 · · Score: 1

      Intuitively, could you agree that people are generally happier when they are NOT at work?

      They said Early morning and Late evening.

    6. Re:Before and after work by ImNotAtWork · · Score: 1

      Yes and no. Immediately after work some people are stressed because of whatever reason their work environment sucks. After an hour or so when they have had time to decompress and possibly vent to a significant other then they can relax and be happier.

      --
      open source sub sim. I might start coding again for this. http://dangerdeep.sourceforge.net/contribute/
    7. Re:Before and after work by selven · · Score: 1

      Why did you waste time putting something in the comment box? Your sig would have made a perfectly good and insightful post here by itself.

  3. I know why by Pojut · · Score: 1

    Because people are twitter shitters

  4. Happier in the morning... by Vanderhoth · · Score: 1

    I'd hate to see them in the afternoon.

  5. Why is New York so pissed off? by mikeleb · · Score: 1

    Louisiana, the Dakotas, and New York seem to be pretty unhappy all day long.

    1. Re:Why is New York so pissed off? by e2d2 · · Score: 1

      Have you ever been to NY city? The only thing missing is a terminator walking over the skeletons of fallen humans. No compassion there.

      Ever been to the Dakotas? The only thing missing is.. everything!

      As for Louisiana, I think they've been in one big predicament for the last 5 years.

  6. Always pissed? by alta · · Score: 1

    New Mexico, Mississippi, West VA and Montana are pissed of 24 hours a day.

    Wonder why?
    When was this taken? I would like to see this on a matrix with some current events...
    How was mississippi/Loisiana before the oil spill?
    Is New Mexico Jealous they didn't get an immigration law like arizona?
    Is montana just sick of mountains?

    I noticed that the flyover states are generally more angry than the coasts... What did they look like before obama care? Before Obama?

    --
    Do not meddle in the affairs of sysadmins, for they are subtle, and quick to anger.
    1. Re:Always pissed? by ShadoHawk · · Score: 1

      Delaware seems thrilled most of the time. I guess because it's a small state with no sales tax and some gambling!

  7. Am not. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Fuck twitter. I hate mornings.

    1. Re:Am not. by Jetrel · · Score: 1

      Sounds like someone has a case of the Mondays? Hmmmmm?!?!

      --
      If it isn't broke, tinker with it till it is!
  8. This kind of pap by jimmydevice · · Score: 1

    Is not unexpected. A recent study showed that "morning people" were more successful and happy with their lot in life. Late risers were more likely to abuse alcohol and drugs, watch too much TV and masturbate.

    1. Re:This kind of pap by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      Late risers were more likely to abuse alcohol and drugs, watch too much TV and masturbate.

      Study was written by a morning person. Hidden camera footage revealed just as much masturbation among morning people... only they did it in the morning so the late-risers wouldn't find out about it.

    2. Re:This kind of pap by Rufty · · Score: 1
      --
      Red to red, black to black. Switch it on, but stand well back.
    3. Re:This kind of pap by geekgirlandrea · · Score: 1

      Yes. The foul morningoids have rigged the world in their favor. Of course they're happy. At least, until the revolution comes and anyone found awake between 6 AM and noon is liable to be shot.

    4. Re:This kind of pap by Actually,+I+do+RTFA · · Score: 1

      At least, until the revolution comes and anyone found awake between 6 AM and noon is liable to be shot.

      Who will be up to shoot them?

      --
      Your ad here. Ask me how!
  9. This just in - Twitter discovers that work sucks! by BobMcD · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Sorry to interrupt your regularly scheduled slashdot, but we have breaking news. Scientists at Twitter, Inc, have just published the shocking results from their study of the moods of their posters. They have some to the shocking conclusion that they do not like being at work. Stay with this station for more breaking news on this exciting topic!

  10. I'm confused about one thing... by Winchestershire · · Score: 1

    Why are the states so disfigured in that video?

    1. Re:I'm confused about one thing... by ElectricTurtle · · Score: 1

      They are probably adjusted in size to reflect the sample size of tweets coming from that state (which is why they shift too).

      --
      I support the Slashcott and will not be reading or commenting from 2/10/14 to 2/17/14. Beta is steaming pile of dog shit
    2. Re:I'm confused about one thing... by Winchestershire · · Score: 1

      That would make sense, thanks for the response.

  11. Florida and California by 2obvious4u · · Score: 2, Insightful

    They are almost always green. Must be the nice weather, beaches, and a getting to see people in swim suits all day.

    1. Re:Florida and California by CaseCrash · · Score: 1

      I take it you don't live here :P

      --
      No, that link you posted to a web comic we've all seen a hundred times is not "obligatory."
    2. Re:Florida and California by e2d2 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I know you said it in jest but since I moved from Washington DC to Florida my overall attitude has gotten much better. I attribute it to more sunshine and southern hospitality. People are generally pretty nice here. When I go back to DC to visit everyone seems kind of angry.

    3. Re:Florida and California by ElectricTurtle · · Score: 1

      If Californians are so happy, why couldn't they stay there and not bring all their bullshit up to Washington State? Being 3rd generation born and bred to Seattle, let me say this: sunshine blows ass. Too much heat, too much glare, and an increased chance of cancer, why does anybody like that shit? I'm happier when the weather is dark and cool, and rain is nice so long as I don't have to be outside. I moved (more or less against my will) to the greater DC metro area myself recently, and this heat, humidity, and sunshine is killing me, and the people here are so uptight and formal you could crush walnuts between their buttocks.

      People in FL are nice though. I'm definitely going to find time to get down there more during the high season when it's not so hot that people spontaneously combust.

      --
      I support the Slashcott and will not be reading or commenting from 2/10/14 to 2/17/14. Beta is steaming pile of dog shit
    4. Re:Florida and California by djconrad · · Score: 1

      I moved to Southern California a couple of years ago, and the pressure to conform (dress right, listen to the right music, have the right body - and attitude) is immense. I've never seen such a monolithic culture before. I wouldn't be surprised if miserable people were twittering happy thoughts because they don't want someone to think they aren't "chill." Admittedly this is at university, but I doubt it gets better in real life.

  12. Re:This just in - Twitter discovers that work suck by patjhal · · Score: 1

    Dam just had mod points too but they are gone. This is pretty much what I was going to say. The closer to work the unhappier people are. Woulda gave ya one for insightful.

  13. Duh. by DaveV1.0 · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Of course we are happier in the morning. We haven't gone to work, had to deal with idiots, listened to the news tell us how everything sucks.

    The best day is the day where one does not listen to the news, drive in rush hour traffic, or have to deal with one's boss or cow-irkers.

    --
    There is no "-1 offended" or "-1 you don't agree with me" mod options for a reason.
  14. Some speculation by HalAtWork · · Score: 1

    It's that little bit in the middle where you're at work that just seems to crush your soul a little bit.

  15. Yin and Yang by Sponge+Bath · · Score: 1

    Coffee in the morning (wheee!) and alcohol in the evening (wheee!).

  16. West Coast by joshdw4 · · Score: 1

    ... or does this mean the people on the west coast are a lot more sarcastic?

  17. Coffee and alcohol by MMBK · · Score: 1

    No wonder to me why morning and night are the high points. Coffee and booze.

  18. Re:Three hours behind, really? by Austerity+Empowers · · Score: 1

    The analysis is wrong twice a year too.

  19. It figures.. by JansenVT · · Score: 1

    Michigan remains angry throughout the entire day.

    1. Re:It figures.. by Godskitchen · · Score: 1

      What do you expect when you have to cheer for the Wolverines? (Go Buckeyes :))

  20. I certainly hope our time zones are consistent by Rabid9797 · · Score: 1

    If the west coast was inconsistently 3 hours behind the west coast we'd have bigger problems to worry about.

  21. Perhaps it is more of a cultural thing? by Rooked_One · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Maybe its more "in" to be positive on the west coast, and negative on the east coast.

    I work with people from all over the US, and I would have 99% certainty that the people on the west coast are always more positive and better to work with than those on the east coast. Midwest people aren't so bad, but its really just a coin toss when it comes to the midwest or east coast.

    I can pretty much count on people in california being in a good mood no matter what time of day.

    Also to note is that if this is a "popular" thing to do, then the younger crowd is going to be more involved, so what does that say for our up and coming generation? As a gen X'er, i've been pretty scared by the notion that people that are 24 and younger couldn't live a day without their cell phone.

    1. Re:Perhaps it is more of a cultural thing? by Ryanrule · · Score: 1

      In a major coincedence, weed is nearly legal in california

  22. says more about twitter users than... by oldmac31310 · · Score: 1

    I think this says more about twitter users than Americans. Twitter users are more likely to be quite happy with themselves - if you know what I mean - while those of us who are more modest and value our privacy and thus do not use twitter are omitted from the Twitter demographic. Silly study. Mornings generally suck. Night time is the right time.

    --
    http://www.acetonestudio.com
  23. People are online in the morning by Prien715 · · Score: 1

    People who are online in the morning are going to work and stuff like that.

    In the evenings, people are playing with their kids, spending time with loved ones, and having sex. And most people don't post on twitter every time they have an orgasm.

    --
    -- Political fascism requires a Fuhrer.
    1. Re:People are online in the morning by jabberw0k · · Score: 1

      Speak for yourself; I have. Both times.

  24. Sarcasm instead of optimism? by Koreantoast · · Score: 1

    An alternative explanation is that people are more sarcastic in the morning. Then toward the end of the day, they're too tired to keep it up.

  25. Uh... by poofmeisterp · · Score: 1

    ...Duh. Tell me who didn't know this.

    Wait. I don't want to know.

  26. And the rest of the world is happier... by TheRedDuke · · Score: 1

    ...when idiots in America stop twittering.

  27. Re:This just in - Twitter discovers that work suck by BobMcD · · Score: 1

    Either that or they'd tweet miserably about that, too.

  28. Tennessee too by urusan · · Score: 1

    It's interesting that Tennessee is much greener than average too. Utah and Deleware are other outliers. None of the unusually happy states seem to be surrounded by other unusually happy states.

    I've lived in Tennessee and Northern California before. In CA the weather is amazing all year round. In TN the people are really nice and the cost of living is very low. At least those are the things I personally noticed.

    I wish they had higher resolution data though. It would be interesting to see if particular cities or regions of larger states were pulling the rest of the state with them.

    Also, two days worth of data isn't enough to draw many conclusions. Maybe the unhappy states had bad weather on those days and the happy ones had good weather? How do the seasons influence happiness?

  29. Were they monitoring the same users by Kaptain+Kruton · · Score: 1

    Were the researchers at Twitter simply monitoring all of the posts or were they paying attention to who was posting. To say if a country, as a whole, was happier in the morning, they would need to monitor and compare the posts of the same people throughout the day. However if they simply monitor all of the posts, ignoring who is posting, and then find the average level of happiness, then all they can say is the posts sampled in the morning are more positive than those posted other days. They can't say Americans are happier, because not everyone posts will post throughout the day. Will you see most high school students that are home on summer break post at 6 AM? No. He/She will most likely be asleep. However, they will be up later. Similarly the people that get up at 5AM to prepare for work are less likely to post late night because they are asleep. If you aren't tracking individual users throughout the day, then you aren't saying Americans are happier during the day... you are saying people that post at time X have more positive tweets than those that post at time Y.

  30. Mondays by MadGeek007 · · Score: 1

    They must have left out Mondays.

  31. So Insomniacs Are Unhappy? by Philomage · · Score: 1

    I notice the unhappiest tweets are in "the middle of the night" and the happiest are around the time most people wake up (or about when they've finished eating dinner).

    So... people who can't sleep for some reason make unhappy tweets? I wonder why? And people who have just awakened from a refreshing night's sleep are happy?

    Hate to sound like one of those "this is so obvious" people, but this is so obvious.

  32. Mississippi by ChrisK87 · · Score: 1

    Anyone else notice that the state of Mississippi was red for the entire video? Guess I'd be upset too if I had to live there...