Finnish ISP Forced To Block the Pirate Bay
Apotekaren writes "The Finnish ISP Elisa has been forced to block several domains leading to the infamous torrent-tracker site The Pirate Bay following a court case initiated by IFPI Finland... The Helsinki District Court ruled in favor of IFPI Finland in October, but the ISP resisted implementing the block until today because of the terms of the block not being specific enough. The ISP is calling the block 'temporary' and is appealing the court decision."
Analysis from Torrent Freak shows that the block is probably easily circumvented.
The block was for IP's too, so you can't just change your DNS. You have to use some proxy service, or VPN, which makes it harder. And they also blocked one of EFF Finland sites as collateral damage.
Just as a side note, before all the usual "haha it's already circumvented" comments come in. They don't care about that, they just want to make it harder for casual people to pirate. That's what DRM does, too. It's why all those "DRM can always be cracked, somehow" comments are stupid too. The main purpose is to make it harder for casual people.
I'm frankly surprised that you can still type in thepiratebay.org in the U.S. and still get anything other than "Sorry, this site has been blocked by your ISP due to legal requirements." Hell, I'm surprised it's still even legal to show it in a search engine. Years ago, I expected the blocking to start much sooner. It's still coming though. Of course, when it is blocked, this will just set off an arms race where proxy sites and government/ISP's battle it out for a while, possibly leading as far as proxy blocking and maybe even deep packet inspection. But it's nice to have it without having to hack around a block, at least for now.
And it's particularly sad to see a country like Finland, traditionally pretty strong on free speech and consumer rights, sink to this level. Of course, the Finnish reputation for has become somewhat tarnished in recent years, with the unfortunate prosecution of Jussi Halla-aho, and the government's increasing deference to the EU and U.S. on intellectual property issues.
SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
... that the matter is Finnished...
No, they're a torrent tracker. I'm sure you could compile a list of individual users and bother them, though.
AnonFinland is attacking Antipiracy.fi and more is coming, they say.
so the minority groups that are wanting to control the society for their own profit, want to remove activities of a certain group. and your solution for that is, removing that group ?
boy. i dont know what to say - lucky us, because people like you did not constitute the majority in enlightened segments of society in history so that we were able to progress............ or, stupid you, because you think that removing piratebay would make those minority groups stop trying to control you.
Read radical news here
One of the blocked addresses is http://piraattilahti.fi/ (piratebay.fi if you translate it directly). This address, however, does not direct to Pirate Bay. It directs to the same address as effi.org. This is the website of EFF's Finnish cousin, Electronic Frontier Finland.
If this hasn't changed recently, you can only ask how incompetent were the people who implemented the censorship here.
This will include those of us who dont torrent music/movies/games. Some of us torrent to correct social injustices, like having to buy a $100, 100 megabyte program to play blu-rays on the blu-ray drive I legally purchased.
piraattilahti.fi is not blocked
Analysis from Torrent Freak shows
I more than LOL'ed but not quite ROFPIMP.
"A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it." - K
I'm curious about the legality of blocking another EU site, it is contrary to the single market.
Filesharing is not inherently illegal nor immoral. I do not like the fact that the term "filesharing" is being used to mean "exchanging strictly proprietary media." If users utilize your service to exchange proprietary media, that is on them, not you. So, I'm not nitpicking, no.
So what you are saying is Blizzard and the UK government are criminal enterprises?
"A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it." - K
Brief addendum to my response: Your complaint seems to be akin to "Car owners are speeding and street racing in your vehicles. If these are criminal acts, then so is your manufacturing plant."
Actually, in the common sense or morally, file sharing is MORAL. We share everything, we share air, food, language, knowledge, laws, expeience, etc.... EVERYTHING. And what is funny is if you go to elementary schools you will see this: SHARING IS CARING, so are we teaching our kids something IMMORAL? Nevertheless, instead of calling your common sense, there is actually pretty well documented and tried argument of why sharing is good, and why the copyright was introduced into society in the first place. Translated, just for once try to read some history, and stop "sharing" your half-baked immoral ideas.
Right, and women are to blame for being raped, because they dressed provocatively, right?
Whatever pirate bay did or didn't do is irrelevant. SOPA rapes the internet.
It appears that the block isn't functional yet. I can normally access thepiratebay.org. It's rather hilarious, as I am greeted with a demotivational poster featuring the "sponsor" of the legal action by IFPI.
By the way, if anyone in IFPI is reading: FUCK YOU IFPI YOU USELESS PIECE OF SHIT! HOPE THE INEVITABLE NEW TIMES WIPE YOU UNDER THE GROUND WHERE YOU ALWAYS BELONGED!
Thank you for reading. Also, if you do work for IFPI, please consider a more honourable profession, such as drug trafficking or prostitution.
"The agriculture ministry is not in charge of Gundam" - Japanese ministry official.
No idea about blizzard, but otherwise yes.
Actually they're not even that, just a repository of .torrent files. The tracker has been offline for quite some time now.
Dilbert RSS feed
Funnily enough if you use google translate and enter thepiratebay.org it'll work just fine. Even translated to finnish as a bonus.
Expect them to block google next...
I don't know, but this joke sure is...
"The block was for IP's too, so you can't just change your DNS. You have to use some proxy service, or VPN, which makes it harder." - by DCTech (2545590) on Monday January 09, @10:06AM (#38637358)
IF this is implemented via DNSBL (DNS Block Lists) in addition to DNS request logs, then, this MAY work also, to "get around it":
DATA FOR HOSTS RESOLUTION of DOMAINS/SUBDOMAINS, FROM -> http://torrentfreak.com/the-pirate-bay-shows-futility-of-domain-and-dns-blocks-120109/
---
1.) "Ping" each of these:
www.piratebay.am, piratebay.net, www.piratebay.net, www.piratebay.no, piratebay.no, piratebay.se, www.piratebay.se, suprnova.com, www.suprnova.com, themusicbay.com, www.themusicbay.com, themusicbay.net, www.themusicbay.net, themusicbay.org, www.themusicbay.org, thepiratebay.am,www.thepiratebay.am, www.thepiratebay.com, thepiratebay.com, thepiratebay.gl, www.thepiratebay.gl, thepiratebay.net, www.thepiratebay.net, www.thepiratebay.se, thepiratebay.se, www.piraattilahti.fi, piraattilahti.fi, thepiratepay.org.nyud.net
To get their correct IP address...
2.) Then embed them "hardcoded" thus, in a custom HOSTS file, like so (e.g. with 1st one):
194.71.107.15 www.piratebay.am
(That's the IP address I get back from "pinging" them, your result MAY vary... so, test to be more sure!)
---
* That SHOULD work, depending on HOW they block it actually, such as DNSBL's (but, there's various methods OTHER than DNSBL too)...
APK
P.S.=> However, IF this is going on & NOT by DNSBL blocking filtering (data from SAME link above):
IP addresses to be blocked:
194.71.107.15
194.71.107.19
194.71.107.18
Then, HOSTS will not work either (they only work for host-domain names/canonical names for sites, not IP addresses), BUT, alternate DNS's still may though I'd suspect, @ least if DNSBL's are used for the blocking!
(That is, until the alternate DNS', legit ones that is, get what I suspect is being put into place in DNSBL's), or TOR etc. ...
* Still, it's BEST to NOT "pirate" music, film, etc. from online, imo @ least...
... apk
in my previous post (parent of this) I mentioned that I had still access to TPB. Well that was from our academic network - not sure who the provider is.
Now I am at home, and we use DNA (which, apparently, isn't quite the same as Elisa), and I still can access TPB without issues.
This is strange, because I was under the impression that almost all providers (DNA included) use Elisa's WAN network infrastructure.
"The agriculture ministry is not in charge of Gundam" - Japanese ministry official.
It is here at least (Elisa customer myself). But no matter, the block is trivially cirmuvented.
If that were the case, I'd imagine that the PCI folks would have something to say about that.
Using a customer's CC # for anything other than payment is likely to cause trouble.
So do I blame the internet now. I'm confused?
Now some Finns have to use one of the multitude of other Torrent trackers. Or add "type:torrent" to a Google search. Oh the humanity!
This isnt about copyrights. Its about preventing the spread of Kopimism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missionary_Church_of_Kopimism, which is now an official religion in Sweden. Its about stopping the growth of "Pirate Parties" as in Germany, where the Piratenpartei Deutschland (Pirate Party) took 8.9 percent of the vote in Berlin's recent election.