Slashdot Mirror


User: geoffrobinson

geoffrobinson's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
1,637
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 1,637

  1. Re:What People Mean by 'Evolution' on Scientists Offer 'Overwhelming' Evidence Terran Life Began in Space · · Score: 1

    No. What I see is that people are letting a little imprecision in language to get around the problem of there being no plausible naturalistic scenario for the origin of life.

    Furthermore, Darwin speculated about ponds and the origin of life. Origin of life research and speculations are very much tied to evolution, since chemicals need to survive and replicate.

  2. 1984? on Manhattan 1984 · · Score: 1

    We aren't talking about graphiti and squeegee guys?

  3. What People Mean by 'Evolution' on Scientists Offer 'Overwhelming' Evidence Terran Life Began in Space · · Score: 1

    While I understand what you are saying, people are using "evolution" to represent naturalism and materialism in general. So for all practical purposes, that's what is the debate is about. Naturalism, especially the "ism" part. Criticisms in regards to naturalistic origin of life scenarios may say "evolution" but that is what they mean.

  4. I'll take you up on that on SCO Loses · · Score: 1

    Could you just give me your mother's maiden name along with the acount number?

  5. Re:The Executive was created for for secrecy on FBI Raids Home of Suspected NSA Leaker · · Score: 1

    This is what I would tell Ms. Plame:

    When trying to protect your identity, don't send your husband on a very high-profile mission.

  6. Absolutely? on A Year In Prison For a 20-Second Film Clip? · · Score: 1

    Is this statement absolutely true in all circumstances or not? Just curious.

  7. Two Operating Systems Enter... on Ubuntu Linux vs. Mac OS X · · Score: 2, Funny

    ...only one leaves.

  8. Problem w/ Firefox Comparison on Does ODF Have a Future? · · Score: 1

    HTML, etc. are open-standards. The problem here is how to get an open standard when none already exists. IE and Firefox could, by and large, display the same stuff.

    If Microsoft doesn't support ODF and most people are using Office, the hurdle is that much higher. The web allows IE and Firefox to co-exist. ODF would allow Office and other products to co-exist. But we face the problem of getting ODF supported in the first place, which wasn't the problem with HTML and other web standards.

  9. I hate Ocean City beach tags on Get Ready For the High-tech Beach · · Score: 1

    I've been going to Ocean City, NJ since I was a babe. Paying to get on the beach gets under my skin.

    I'm not too concerned about Big Brother. I don't think Ocean City is big enough or desires to go down that route.

    But they control access to who goes on the beach. And that, while probably constitutional, stinks.

  10. Not a great counter-argument on What's Keeping US Phones In the Stone Age? · · Score: 1

    Scotland may have sparse areas. America has a whole mess of it. I've driven across it. There is a whole lot of nothing all over the place.

  11. Re:Yes, we MUST catch up with China!!! on Senators Call for Universal Internet Filtering · · Score: 1

    Greater freedom causes problems. Gun violence, drunk driving, and all manner of things. But there are trade-offs we make. For instance, I go through airport screening. So no absolute freedom but a completely safe society wouldn't be worth living in either.

    Similar to the opposing concerns of usability and computer security.

  12. Politics is in Money... on Senate Majority Leader Takes On File Sharing · · Score: 1

    If politicians are going to get involved very heavily in how people make and spend money, we should expect money to try to exert influence in politics.

  13. It's Called a Dump Button + 7-second Delay on Senate Committee Passes FCC Indecency Bill · · Score: 1

    This is an issue with radio stations? They already bleep profanity.

  14. That Would Be a Very Short Class on Explosives Camp · · Score: 1

    If you pass the test, you are dead.

  15. When you take something that doesn't belong to you on SAP Admits to 'Inappropriate' Downloading of Oracle Code · · Score: 2, Insightful

    ...that's stealing. People may try to justify stealing because the laws are bad (and the laws may need to be changed) but that doesn't change the fact that we steal things that don't belong to us.

    We are stone-cold thieves. That's the human condition.

  16. Re:Evolution? on The Current State of the Malware/AntiVirus Arms Race · · Score: 5, Funny

    The viruses are intelligently designed. I'm not vouching for Microsoft Windows.

  17. Already Part of ID Arguments on Far Future Will See No Evidence of Universe's Origin · · Score: 1

    It is factored in as the Universe is designed to allow us in this window for humans to investigate. I may be mischaracterizing the argument, but the overall point remains that this factor is used in cosmology-based ID arguments.

  18. Re:Straying off topic, but I couldn't resist... on Will Linux Win the Next Presidential Election? · · Score: 1
  19. Re:Straying off topic, but I couldn't resist... on Will Linux Win the Next Presidential Election? · · Score: 1

    You just produced random genetic code. You didn't increase any information in your hypothetical example. I think you know that DNA carries genetic information.

    Known examples of random mutation cause loss of functionality and sometimes that loss of functionality causes something beneficial for survival to happen.

    Could you point me to any known experiment or observation which shows some new functionality which isn't simply a degradation of previous information?

    You call BS. I call for examples based on observation.

  20. How? on The Internet Of Things · · Score: 1

    Sorry, I couldn't resist.

  21. Re:Straying off topic, but I couldn't resist... on Will Linux Win the Next Presidential Election? · · Score: 1

    Because random mutations can't produce new information. Evolution is downhill in regards to information.

  22. Legal Reasoning? on Ban On Price Floors Abandoned, Internet Prices May Rise · · Score: 1

    Conservatives want courts to base things on the law and the Constitution. So unless you have a specific legal gripe, I don't mind that you dislike this court.

    I don't like outcome X, therefore the Court should have decided Y.

    There is no reference in your complaint to the law, the Constitution, or improper legal reasoning. And that is the general difference between liberals and conservatives regarding the Court. That's why conservatives hated the Kelo decision.

  23. Re:Straying off topic, but I couldn't resist... on Will Linux Win the Next Presidential Election? · · Score: 1

    A lot of Intelligent Design proponents believe in genetic front-loading. For example, the genes for my Labrador (friendliness, webbed feet, etc) were present originally in wolves. Same goes for Poodle genes. They just needed some reshuffling.

    Not a perfect description, but the main point is that there is breadth to the Intelligent Design movement with variant points of view. You may be thinking simply of Young Earth Creationists.

  24. You are coming to a sad realization on 6 Months On, Vista Security Still Besting Linux · · Score: 0, Troll

    Cancel or allow?

  25. Sell Debt to Loanshark on Pressure Is On IBM To Forgive Millions In IT Debt · · Score: 1

    Let someone willing to take the negative publicity deal with the school district.