Slashdot Mirror


User: Proteus

Proteus's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
607
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 607

  1. Re:Fanboy attack on Alan Kay Says iPad Betrays Xerox PARC Vision · · Score: 1

    It has to go through Apple. I needs to meet Apples arbitrary corporate 'standard'

    Only if it's a native app. If it's an HTML5 app, then you can make it available -- and installable -- instantly with no review from Apple. The only problem is that the HTML5 apps don't give you access to the complete capabilities of the device.

  2. Re:Fanboy attack on Alan Kay Says iPad Betrays Xerox PARC Vision · · Score: 1

    There's no doubt that the iPad is optimized as a consumption machine. But I think the focus on the walled App Store is a little misleading. It's true that creating and sharing a native iOS app is onerous -- but Apple has excellent support for offline-capable, "installable" HTML5-based apps. People seem to forget that a lot

    Now, I'm not saying that the good support for HTML5 apps absolves Apple of the problems with the App Store; but it does mean that saying "you can't use an iPad to create and share an app with your friends" is inaccurate.

  3. Re:In English on Code.org Documentary Serving Multiple Agendas? · · Score: 1

    It's poorly-phrased. I think that the author meant that people found it strange that when these two collaborated again, they used students from Gates' "model school" as an example of failure.

  4. Isn't this just Google Notebook? on Google Launches 'Keep' To Rival Evernote · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I mean, a slightly different interface, but substantially the same. And Google killed that product; why do we think this time around will be better?

  5. Re:Cloud This! on Google Launches 'Keep' To Rival Evernote · · Score: 4, Insightful
    Well, Google's interest is certainly in getting data; but they wouldn't be able if there weren't a market for it. Why? I don't just use one device, so I want easy, transparent access to my data no matter what I'm using. And some of my devices are quite tiny; I don't want to lose my data when I lose my device, so I'd at least want some kind of automatic remote backup...

    Not to mention that things like Evernote do a lot of processing on the data you send them that would be onerous on a portable device. For example, if I snap a pic of a business card, the text on that card is OCR'd and made searchable. That would suck hard on a phone; it's much easier to offload that capability (and corpus!) to the cloud. This saves me precious battery and improves the quality of my results.

    The issue isn't network-based computing, it's that we don't have the controls in place to assert control of our data on a provider's equipment; we are forced to trust that they won't do Bad Things. And that's a problem.

  6. Re:screw google! on Google Launches 'Keep' To Rival Evernote · · Score: 2

    Maybe some compensation for all that personal data and advertising revenue they got from his use of Gmail? It's not like Gmail is provided at no value to Google (same with Reader, actually).

  7. Re:That's a "No" from me too on Ask Slashdot: Can Quickoffice On Chromebooks Topple Microsoft's Office? · · Score: 1
    OOXML has some serious problems, but "proprietary" isn't really one of them. OOXML is actually two standards: OOXML Transitional and OOXML Strict. OOXML Strict is, by most accounts, a reasonable standard -- some bits open enough to interpretation that there will still be some problems between implementations, but HTML has the same issues.

    OOXML Transitional, on the other hand, is filled with specified items that are just holdovers from MS's native implementation(s) of Office file formats. This is, more-or-less, the original submission from MS, and it was roundly rejected on its own. OOXML Strict solved enough of the problems that the standards bodies were willing to accept the dual standard -- OOXML Transitional used only for documents that are converted from old formats, and OOXML Strict used for new documents.

    The problem with corporate-sponsored standards, though, is that the sponsoring organization usually has the first or leading implementation -- and the implementation itself becomes more of a de facto standard than the published standard. In the case of OOXML, Microsoft shipped OOXML-Transitional capable systems pretty quickly. But they still haven't shipped a product that reliably writes OOXML Strict documents (though Office 2013 does read such documents accurately).

    Because the leading implementation is so... odd... the other "big players" haven't made a significant commitment to OOXML.

  8. Re:OK... Next question: on New Study Links Caffeinated Coffee To Vision Loss · · Score: 1

    This is why I hate science reporting. This kind of study exists entirely to obtain funding for higher-quality research. But it's getting reported as though it were conclusive. The way research of most types works is that you do a cheap, low-quality study that tells you whether there's an interesting enough thing happening to warrant a more-expensive, more-thorough study. In this case, the conclusion is basically "hey, it's possible that caffeine intake might be a factor in glaucoma; we should really do more than just case review and self-reporting to see if it's real." But all we're going to hear about from the media now is how coffee makes you blind.

  9. Re:Ya we had that problem on Adopt the Cloud, Kill Your IT Career · · Score: 1

    In other words, as it has been since time immemorial, IT decisions are being made without completing full due diligence. Including understanding and planning for support, training, and related costs.

  10. Re:bullcrap on Countering a DMCA Takedown In the Magnet Wars · · Score: 1

    You don't know how this works, clearly. Lands End is a manufacturer. Walmart is not. They each have different goals and different business processes. Now it's possible that LE uses the same cheap labor that some (if not most) of Walmart's suppliers use; I don't have any information either way, but it's entirely feasible that you're right. However, the process and materials probably vary quite a bit. Walmart ends up carrying cheap stuff because they leverage their large potential market to negotiate ridiculously low wholesale prices with manufacturers, and reducing them each year. Mfg's end up having to make a choice at some point: sacrifice quality, or lose out on the huge volume Walmart offers. Lots of Mfg's feel that sacrificing quality is the right call, and do so: but their products that get sold at higher prices to competing sellers are often of the original, higher quality. Lands End makes their money by using higher-quality, more-durable fabrics and processes than many of their competitors, and selling fewer items at a higher margin than Mfg's who sell to Walmart. There is a profitable market in people who will pay $40 for a $3 (cost) item that's twice as durable as a $2 (cost) item that retails for $15; just as there is a profitable market in doing the opposite.

  11. Re:Home School on US Students Struggle With Understanding of the 'Equal' Sign · · Score: 1

    But home schooling pretty much fails to develop a kid's social skills.

    This bit of misinformation seriously undermines discussion about the real issues with home-schooling. Yes, some parents home-school to "protect" their kids from the bad, evil world. Those kids will have social problems no matter what. The majority of the home-schooling community solved that problem a long time ago by, you know, getting together on a regular basis with other families. That's arguably healthier for the kids, as they'll interact with a broader age range than they would in a standard public school.

    The most serious issues with home schooling are a lack of enforcable standards -- which mean that some parents end up with kids that are even more ignorant than public-school-educated kids -- lack of advanced knowledge, and lack of facility. The first could possibly be addressed with a well-designed standardized test suite (though the government typically sucks at creating good standardized tests).

    The last two -- challenges in finding appropriately-experienced parents in advanced subjects; and the difficulty in getting access to e.g., proper lab equipment -- are much tougher crack. In grade school, this is less of an issue, but many middle- and high-school students who are home-schooled end up with significant gaps in knowledge when it comes to certain advanced topics, and this makes their post-secondary education more challenging.

    On top of this, pulling the brightest children out of public schools only further deprives the schools of funding and positive peer models, creating a self-fulfilling prophecy of public schools as failures. There are real issues with the way public schools are managed -- not the least of which is that the policies for managing them are created largely by groups who have absolutely no qualifications in education or childhood development -- but home-schooling is not the solution.

  12. Re:Don't know what () means on US Students Struggle With Understanding of the 'Equal' Sign · · Score: 1

    I have college diplomas in the fields of mechanical and electronic engineering (technologist and technician for the Canadians). I also took all advanced math, physics and chemistry classes in high school. I don't remember ever seeing the notation "4+3+2=( )+2" before.

    Didn't all of that education teach you to learn what solutions others have used before you decide you have a unique problem? As many others have pointed out above, the parenthesis are an artifact of the reporting in the TFA; the actual test questions (as seen in the associated videos) used a blank space. This is a common technique, well-supported by research, to introduced pre-teens to algebraic concepts before using named variables (like 'x').

    This test shows, IMO, that students who were tested don't see '=' in a way we'd expect: they are reading equations as "problems", and the '=' as a "solution" indicator. This is probably reinforced by early math problems of the type "4+3 = ?", and the behavior of the '=' key on calculators (which are now used extensively in grade-school math programs).

    The notation was not the problem, because that's not the notation that was used.

  13. Re:Well, that explains things. on US Students Struggle With Understanding of the 'Equal' Sign · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Now, now. Just because these youngsters need pictures of the food on their cash-register buttons in order to do their job doesn't mean they're stupid. :-)

    You're absolutely correct, it doesn't. And, in fact, they don't need them at all. Comments like this just show your ignorance of how organizations work at large scale. The pictures are there because they are universal.

    1. McDonald's (for example) is an international company, and they serve their core menu in dozens of languages. It's much easier and less error-prone for them to produce a picture-based keypad than to translate everything without error
    2. Fast food companies did research indicating that it's faster -- even for highly-literate people -- to find an item by image rather than by name. Faster means better service with fewer staff, which means more profit.
    3. Many fast food chains, and McDonald's in particular, hire people with disabilities. This is a huge win for such people -- real, productive work that can help make them at least partly independent. Many with cognitive or developmental disabilities have written-language challenges, and the picture "menus" are much easier for them to use efficiently. It doesn't make sense to have two versions of something if one works for everyone, does it?

    And those are just the three reasons that are most obvious to me. Now get off your high horse!

  14. Re:And this is different to Walmart.... on Apple Censors Ulysses App In Time For Bloomsday · · Score: 1

    It different because if you don't like Walmart's policy you can go to Target or any other store.

    And if you don't like the iBooks store, you can -- with the same Apple device even -- buy your books from Amazon's Kindle store, the Stanza stores, or a few others.

    And if you don't like any of those choices, you can buy a different computing device altogether.

    Contrary to what the Apple fanboys would have you believe, Apple is NOT the sole provider of useful things.

  15. Re:Why it's contempt on Spamming a Judge Is Contempt of Court · · Score: 1

    Well, maybe judges need to be sequestered away from society like juries if they're so easily influenced.

    Juries are not always sequestered, and when they are, it's not because they are "easily influenced", it's generally to keep them from being exposed to coverage of the case that may supply information that's inadmissible -- it's hard to forget something once you know it.

    Whether or not a jury is sequestered, it is still illegal to attempt to influence them, except through your evidence and arguments as presented in court. Just like trying to bribe a police officer is illegal, whether or not the officer takes the bribe.

    Likewise, if you take action to try to improperly influence a judge, the judge has the authority to punish you.

  16. Re:Why it's contempt on Spamming a Judge Is Contempt of Court · · Score: 1

    It's not that a judge is easily influenced, it's that he cannot prove to the other party that he was not influenced.

    +1 Clueful. Well done.

  17. Re:Untraceably? on Bank Employee Plants Malware on ATMs · · Score: 1

    Right, but he obviously failed at the "untraceable" part in some way, and the post says that he was able to withdraw cash untraceably. Obviously, that part is not true.

    Also, stop ruining my fun being pedantic. :)

  18. Why it's contempt on Spamming a Judge Is Contempt of Court · · Score: 5, Insightful
    I'm not a lawyer, blah, blah.

    All the folks on here saying "wha? But he just asked people to e-mail support, that's not spam!" are entirely missing the point.

    You are not allowed to approach the Judge, or ask anyone else to approach the Judge, outside of court and certain other specially-sanctioned venues. It's called ex parte , and is only appropriate in very specific circumstances, because - duh - that's likely to be unfair. That's the basis for the contempt charge.

    Now, if it had been a friend or two that e-mailed the judge, he might have just warned them off with a "that's not appropriate." But when enough people e-mail to fill his Inbox, it's quite clearly an attempt to influence the judge, and that's not OK .

  19. Untraceably? on Bank Employee Plants Malware on ATMs · · Score: 1

    withdrew cash untraceably

    Um, apparently not.

  20. Re:Should there be ANY government secrets? on US Intelligence Planned To Destroy WikiLeaks · · Score: 1

    should a soldier disobey orders that in his opinion are inhuman? a military officer would probably say no.

    You clearly don't know any military officers. None of the military folks I know feel an obligation to obey an order that's unlawful, much less dehumanizing. What they will explain is that sometimes you obey an order without thinking (that's how you're trained) -- and that it can be hard to blow the whistle after the fact.

    And, of course, the military is a microcosm of humanity, and so it has its own share of bastards.

  21. Re:Sure... "Feedback from our customers" on Xbox Live Now Allows Gender Expression · · Score: 1

    I don't believe for a second that they've had a sudden change of heart in the direction of equality and fairness. More likely, legal and PR informed the decision makers that they were about to be on the losing end of some pretty hefty legal action and bad press.

    And you base this on what? Microsoft's historical poor treatment of the GLBT community? Oh, right, they're on the Human Rights Campaign's Best Places to Work list.

    Just because Microsoft does some legally, socially, and ethically questionable things doesn't mean that everything they do is questionable. Given that MS has been a leader in supporting GLBT rights within their own workplace, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt that they just screwed this one up, and want to make it right.

  22. Re:Seriously flawed logic on Use Open Source? Then You're a Pirate! · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Rather than fostering a system that will allow users to benefit from the best solution available in the market, irrespective of the development model, it encourages a mindset that does not give due consideration to the value to intellectual creations.

    We can give "due consideration to the value of intellectual creations" without discriminating against open source. Maybe buy the developer a beer or send them a thank you note, or better yet, a bug report or patch?

    More to the point, open-source licenses give higher value to intellectual creations, for two reasons:

    1. Practically, because they rely on strong copyright to give them force - and violators of those copyrights and related license terms are aggressively pursued
    2. Ideologically, because they demonstrate that the creators value the creative process so highly that they explicitly encourage others to create additional intellectual work, without forcing those others to do ridiculous amounts of re-work.
  23. EyeTV on a Mac on Best PC DVR Software, For Any Platform? · · Score: 1
    I've really been pleased with my media center setup; and my doddering mother-in-law has no difficulties with it either.

    I use:

    1. Elgato's EyeTV software, with an Elgato USB tuner card (supports ATSC, ClearQAM, so tunes HD cable channels and FTA HDTV). This gives me my DVR, which dumps ATSC video at full quality without even re-encoding (std. MPEG-2 stream)
    2. FrontRow, which comes with the Mac, to watch DVDs and my media library, including music. Supports anything you can get a QuickTime plugin for (which is almost anything now, even Theora), and can browse media as files *or* in iTunes
    3. Handbrake 0.94 (64bit) for ripping DVDs to media collection. Dealing with encrypted DVDs is made possible through VLC and Fairmount (more or less transparently - again, my mother-in-law does this).

    Other than paying $600 for the Mac Mini itself, the only cost to this was the EyeTV tuner (which came with the DVR software). Very pleased with this, much better IMHO than my Media Center and MythTV experiences. I've also played with Boxee on OS X, which does everything pretty well, including netflix/hulu streaming. Very nice, though definitely still beta. At least they seem to be making better progress fixing bugs than the Myth folks.

  24. Re:Stop wasting our electricity, Fox Mulder on SETI@Home Install Leads To School Tech Supervisor's Resignation · · Score: 1
    "Are we alone?" is shorthand for "Is our species the sole intelligent life in the universe?"

    We just need to stop being dicks to each other.

    I entirely agree. We could start by not assuming that what some people are passionate about is wasteful just because we don't care. I personally think that the SETI money could be better spent elsewhere, but I don't think that the search is silly, or even that they're going about it in the wrong way. I don't even disagree that the question is important.

    I'm just a "clean your own house first" kind of guy - I'd rather see us (humanity) work to solve the problems we have where we still kill each other in huge numbers, allow some to starve while others have a great deal of surplus, and generally mismanage the natural resources available to us.

    Otherwise, what would we tell an intelligent species: "hi, we're humans; we can't even take care of ourselves"?

  25. Re:Make them pay on Easing the Job of Family Tech Support? · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Family helps Family for free. It's called being related, not being retarded. I'm pretty sure your parents spent more raising your arrogant little behind than you could ever repay by doing the occasional reformat.

    There's "helping", and then there's enabling. For example, I need to deal with a reformat/re-install about once a year for my mother. No biggy: she does pretty well, but just can't keep up with new threats, and simply isn't perfect. That's what family is for.

    On the other hand, I refuse to help one of my cousins anymore, because he refused to follow my basic advice on being safe - he insists on using IE and Outlook Express, he disables his AV to "make installs go faster", he declines AV updates, he refuses to run without admin rights, etc.. If I keep bailing him out for free, I'm not helping anymore.

    See, you can't eat your cake and still have it. If you really value me as family, you'll respect my skills and my advice, and you'll show it by trying to make it as unnecessary as possible for me to have to help you. If you refuse to do anything to make my life easier, you show that you don't respect my skills, so why should I waste them on you?