Slashdot Mirror


User: JamesP

JamesP's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
1,838
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 1,838

  1. Re:Impressive on Acupuncture May Trigger a Natural Painkiller · · Score: 1

    So, poking the skin with a sharp object triggers the release of painkillers by the body?
    I'm impressed.

    Yes, but please let's keep homeopatic on this one ok.

    Don't try this with a sword, it won't be better than a needle.

  2. Re:Where's your pseudoscience now! on Acupuncture May Trigger a Natural Painkiller · · Score: 1

    I'm saying they're CONFLICTING , nothing more, nothing less. It means something's up with something, and unless you've got some method of deal with this conflict (with supporting evidence, of course), it's quite early to go "LOL ALL YOU 'SKEPTICS' SURE WERE WRONG HUH"

    Oh, ok. But as I said, the way to solve this conflicts is to look at the scope of the conclusion. Either that, or someone messed up.

    Now, I left something important out of my first post (yikes). The title is meant to be trollish and exaggerated. It's not a Nelson laugh!

    Again, you are leaping to the conclusion that skepticism against acupuncture was unwarranted based on the results of a single study which conflicts with multiple existing studies.

    Hum... No. Not unwarranted. But as this study shows you can always discover something new where many thought 'there was nothing there'. And that's the good thing about science.

    You most certainly do not know how science works. You don't just pick and choose studies and go "welp I like the results of this one more so it's way more important than the others".

    There's a field of studies called meta-analysis just for that. To see if they're picking only the studies they like.

    Funny how you think you know more about science and didn't provide examples or knew about meta-analysis

  3. Re:Where's your pseudoscience now! on Acupuncture May Trigger a Natural Painkiller · · Score: 2, Informative

    Did you even read the rest of the summary, particularly the part about existing studies that conflict with this one?

    So, what you're saying is that studies that contradict this one are more important?? That they should be taken more seriously, because everybody knows "acupunture is BS" right?!

    As it is, there's not a whole lot of research on acupuncture, and much of it appears to conflict each other.

    They usually don't, but it looks like that due to people exaggerating the scope of the conclusions.

    If you're suddenly rushing to mock skeptics ...you either don't understand how this "science" thing works at all,

    No, it's the "skeptics" that don't understand how this 'science' thing works. And worse, don't know squat about the history of science.

    As the example I gave in my post, most of the initial development of electromagnetism/electricity was called BS for a long time

    The discovery of Helicobacter pylori and appropriate treatment also was hampered by those 'skeptics'. But it's ok I'm sure only a few people died because of that.

    Also I'm sure not a lot of people died or got maimed because that thing called X-Ray is no good as a diagnosis help.

    Also, it's easier to come up with results that match previous WRONG results www.lhup.edu/~DSIMANEK/cargocul.htm (search Millikan)

    So yeah, I'm in no position to question that, sir because obviously I don't know anything about science or history of science...

  4. Re:Where's your pseudoscience now! on Acupuncture May Trigger a Natural Painkiller · · Score: 1

    For example, we didn't understand the underlying mechanism for aspirin until 1971, but before that salicylates had been used for centuries.

    Exactly! Thank you!

  5. Where's your pseudoscience now! on Acupuncture May Trigger a Natural Painkiller · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    Now that I have your attention bear with me...

    It's one thing to say "this is BS"

    It's another to say "we don't know how this may work, thus it doesn't mean that it works BUT IT ALSO DOESN'T MEAN IT DOESN'T"

    There are skeptics and there are "skeptics". "skeptics" make their first reaction to everything "this is BS"

    "Look, arteries may not have air inside them after all" "this is BS"
    "hey maybe interactions between charged particles can be abstracted by using 'a field'" "this is BS"

    It's ok to be skeptic, just keep your mind open before calling BS on everything. Good thing is these people never come up with a new theory or a new experiment usually.

  6. Re:Idiots on Bangladesh Blocks Facebook Over Muhammad Cartoons · · Score: 2, Informative

    And that's the Religion of peace and understanding, everybody...

  7. Re:Solution. on BP Says "Top Kill" Operation Has Failed · · Score: 1

    I hear fat executives make a really good well plug

  8. Re:Amazing on BP Says "Top Kill" Operation Has Failed · · Score: 1

    From what I heard, the company wanted to drill in a specific way, and the BP "manager" (of course) said "No, let's driil this another way"

    (sorry, can't find the source but it was in the news a couple of days ago)

  9. An idea on What Scientists Really Think About Religion · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This shouldn't absolutely be a 'don't ask don't tell' thing, but if the guy does his job properly leave him be...

    Also, several nutcases in science have nothing to do with religion, like the MMR "controversy", HIV denialists, etc, etc

  10. Re:People, people everywhere on Intel Sucks Up Water Amid Drought In China · · Score: 1

    Yes, but while some whine about that some go about turning seawater into drinkable water

    You know the whole "2/3 of the planet is water"

  11. Re:Intel is a great manufacturer.. not designer. on Intel Abandons Discrete Graphics · · Score: 1

    Well, not really

    The P6 was a really good architecture. it's what AMD battled with the K7 arch (really good as well)

    Of course, that, until Intel shot itself in the foot with the Netburst architecture (AKA Pentium 4)

    A 1GHz P3 could run circles around the 1.4GHz, 1.6GHz even higher clocked Willamette P4

    But the P6 arch carried on and Core 2 is based on it (with a lot of improvements on top)

  12. Re:can they use it for ISS space? spare parts? on Shuttle Atlantis Lands Safely After Final Official Mission · · Score: 1

    Oh so that's why they got the pink flamingos up there

  13. Something to think about on Researchers Create 4nm Transistor With Seven Atoms · · Score: 1

    How does semiconductor doping works in these cases?

    In "big" transistors, silicon is doped with other elements, to a very high ratio silicon/other element (can't remember, but I recall something aroung 10E6 ratio)

    So when you have only seven atoms, what happens?? (ok, I guess this is already a problem with current tech, but still)

  14. No, really on Scientist Infects Self With Computer Virus · · Score: 3, Insightful

    What a fscking moron

    Or a show-off.

    Or better, a fscking show-off moron

    I couldn't think of anything more irrelevant, like, REALLY

    I mean, this is Uri Geller type of BS

    The mind boggles.

  15. Re:What KILLS me is... on BP's Final "Top Kill" Procedure For Gulf Oil Spill · · Score: 1

    You think Phillip Morris should be allowed to kill babies since cigarette taxes are so high?

    Yes please. Especially the screaming ones.

  16. Re:wtf? on IBM Distributes USB Malware At Security Conference · · Score: 4, Informative

    No, I'd say:

    It's a security conference, if you can't handle a USB drive with a (Windows program) virus you shouldn't be there.

  17. Re:Creative AWE64 Gold, how I miss thee on The Secret of Monkey Island Shows Evolution of PC Audio · · Score: 1

    I think these (AWE32/AWE64) were the last good Creative cards

    After that onboard audio took over and Creative jumped the shark

    With the exception of really crappy onboard cards or professional audio, 'offboard' sound cards ceased to matter

    Too bad my AWE32 (ISA!) died :/

  18. Re:Remember not to use Java.... on Would You Die To Respect a Software License? · · Score: 1

    Well, thank god, really

    I wouldn't want a java program controlling a nuclear facility!

    Or better, I wouldn't want the average java programmer making a java program that will control a nuclear facility.

  19. Re:For example, the earth has a lot of water on it on Water Not a Good Enough Guide To Find Alien Life · · Score: 1

    Yes, there is life. They're polluting the oil

  20. Re:Well on Matter-Antimatter Bias Seen In Fermilab Collisions · · Score: 1

    So it does matter... and anti-matter, and energy...

    yay

  21. Re:Uneven laws on Matter-Antimatter Bias Seen In Fermilab Collisions · · Score: 1

    Or they could be uneven in time. Maybe every 54.12 years the relation between produced matter/antimatter switches from 1:1.01 to 1.01:1.

    Funny you mention that, there are some theories that say the speed of light changed in time, so in the past (like, billions of years ago) it was slower, IIRC

  22. Re:Next steps on Apple A4 Processor Teardown · · Score: 1

    And then A5 maybe?!

  23. Re:COTS = COST on US Air Force To Suffer From PS3 Update · · Score: 1

    Or they could have gone with nVidia/ATI or something similar

    Or Cell PCI-X boards for PC (IIRC there are some)

  24. Re:Sony is a terrorist organization on US Air Force To Suffer From PS3 Update · · Score: 4, Insightful

    How about this:

    Ban them forever from selling to the US Gov.

    You know, the whole "fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me"

  25. Re:Non-issue on Do Children's E-Books Ruin Reading? · · Score: 5, Funny

    Books for wizard kids (Harry Potter) have things that speak and move for themselves and the kids seem to do just fine.