Slashdot Mirror


Star Wars Sequel Trilogy Rumors

Stop reading if you're spoiler paranoid. ChazeFroy writes "The actor who played Chewbacca in the original Star Wars trilogy, Peter Mayhew, will be in Episode III. Of course, this has been previously reported and comes as no surprise. However, TheForce is reporting that Mayhew's contract contains a stipulation that he must also appear in Episodes 7, 8, and 9. This was first reported in the British movie magazine Hot Dog, whose December issue with this news just hit US newstands."

115 of 723 comments (clear)

  1. Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by Xeriar · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Or there will be hell to pay. Nothing else was worth reading.

    1. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by the+Man+in+Black · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I'm with seeing Thrawn & Co. up on the big screen, but only if George Lucas steps his monkey ass down as writer and director and let's someone talented handle it. He can be Executive Producer and just sit in the back eating corn chips and cackling.

    2. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by milkman_matt · · Score: 3, Funny
      People whine "OMG YOU KILLED _______" when it was actually one of the best things they could have done for the Star Wars universe.

      They killed JarJar?

      -matt

    3. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by arth1 · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Or there will be hell to pay. Nothing else was worth reading.

      A good novel seldom makes for a good movie.
      There's simply not enough time in a movie. A good novella or short story is what you really need, else you need an expert at chopping -- the better the novel is, the harder it gets, cause in a really good novel, everything is essential.

      Regards,
      --
      *Art
    4. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by ArmenTanzarian · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I think LOTR made believers out of this crowd. Proof that enough money, love, time and geekdom can pull off a quality interpretation.

      You'll never get a direct translation, even in a short story. A raised eyebrow or a sardonic smile means a lot more when written down than it would if you made a point of zooming in on it. Not to mention that imagery and metaphor are difficult to pull off without narration, which is too often a cheaply used device and completely blows the subtlety it had on the page.

    5. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by Fl1bble · · Score: 2, Funny

      People whine "OMG YOU KILLED _______" when it was actually one of the best things they could have done for the Star Wars universe.

      What??? Kenny was in Star Wars??? I think I would have noticed him!!

    6. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by NanoGator · · Score: 2, Interesting

      "People whine "OMG YOU KILLED _______" when it was actually one of the best things they could have done for the Star Wars universe."

      Uh, I read the book I think you're referring to, and the 'OMG YOU KILLED ____' whining was a result of the death of that character not being terribly interesting. The book was poorly written and the story was plain and dull. The death of that character had more to do with getting copies of the book sold than some inspired story arc.

      Of course, we could possibly be talking about two different books.

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    7. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by Total_Wimp · · Score: 4, Interesting

      "As the director, the man's actually still pretty good."

      Watch epII and Minority Report back to back. They both were made a virtually the same time so they both had the same CG technology available. Watch the big-fight-in-a-factory scene that is present in both. There is no comparison. epII is cartoony and almost amaturish by comparison to to the work of Spielberg.

      You can compare scenes throughout epI and epII to similar sceens in other movies with similar results. Lucas is a mediocre director at best. A number of good directors would produce much better movies than Lucas if they had the same high quality actors and technology available on epI & II, even if they were saddled with the same script.

      TW

    8. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by mog007 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      So let Spielberg handle the directing and Lucas handle the Producing, they've worked well enough in the past.

      Indiana Jones, anyone?

    9. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by JExtine · · Score: 2, Funny
      He can be Executive Producer and just sit in the back eating corn chips and cackling.

      Don't forget counting the money...

    10. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by kin_korn_karn · · Score: 2, Funny

      He was in Ep. 4! Owen Lars bought the droids from him!

    11. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by corbettw · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Except that Minority Report was sci-fi film noir, and so was filmed in a darker style. Star Wars has always been, and always will be, pulp sci-fi, a la Flash Gordon serials from the 30's. Lucas has said time and again the movies were inspired by those old serials, so of course they're going to have a "cartoony" feel to them.

      --
      God invented whiskey so the Irish would not rule the world.
    12. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by Grishnakh · · Score: 2, Insightful

      My view is that Lucas's best talent lies with imagining new worlds, landscapes, alien creatures, etc. For writing, he flat-out sucks. He needs to come up with an overall outline, and let other, more talented people do the storytelling, plot, dialogue, etc. When he let someone else do the writing in Empire Strikes Back, the result was excellent.

    13. Re:Better be Zahn's Trilogy. by ColdGrits · · Score: 2, Informative

      The trilogy is

      The Heir To The Empire
      Dark Force Rising
      The Last Command

      The followon two parter is in

      Spectre Of The Past
      Vision Of The Future

      I strongly recommend all 5 of them in order (and pretty much ignore most of the other Star Wars books which are nowhere near as good - indeed, many are utter crap).

      --
      People should not be afraid of their governments - Governments should be afraid of their people.
  2. Episode III better rock by mirio · · Score: 3, Insightful

    If Episode III isn't incredible, Mr. Lucas can forget about any other Episodes.

    1. Re:Episode III better rock by SpaceRook · · Score: 4, Funny

      Special Edition new scenes = sucked.

      Episode 1 = sucked.

      Episode 2 = sucked.

      Episode 3 = ?

    2. Re:Episode III better rock by Outland+Traveller · · Score: 3, Insightful



      I don't know why they even bother to make episode III. Episode II held my "worst current movie" title for a long time, until I saw the Matrix sequels.

      Episode II was so bad, that the only thing that made it watchable was to insert sarcastic comments in the style of MST3K.

      I'm afraid the Star Wars franchaise has now joined the ranks of the James Bond and other movie franchaises, where people go to see it simply as a mindless distraction, and not a single person in the audience expects to take it seriously.

    3. Re:Episode III better rock by Waffle+Iron · · Score: 5, Funny
      If Episode III isn't incredible, Mr. Lucas can forget about any other Episodes.

      I disagree. No matter how many horrible sequels he puts out, millions of dorks will shell out their money for each one just so see for themselves how bad it is. If they fail to see one, they'll miss out on all the fun when their friends bitch about how bad it was.

    4. Re:Episode III better rock by bludstone · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Thats, basically, what hes doing with the DVD release. (rumored.)

      heres a list: stolen from http://www.killermovies.com/forums/archive/index.p hp/t-20784

      Remember, these are only rumors.

      Episode IV: A New Hope

      01. The Imperial March has been added to Darth Vader's first appearance on
      Princess Leia's ship.
      02. When Obi-Wan is talking to Luke about his father Anakin's Theme plays
      in the background and then it turns into the Imperial March as he talks
      about Vader.
      03. The lightsaber effects have been redone and the frame jumps of
      lightsabers being turned on has been removed.
      04. There's a new scene which has been shot during the filming of Episode
      III in which the Emperor dissolves the Senate.
      05. In the Cantina, the Duros(green aliens guys) have been replaced with
      Neimoidians and some aliens from the prequels have been added.
      06. The bleeding arm on the floor in the Cantina has been replaced with a
      non-bleeding arm because it's now canon that lightsabers cauterize wounds.
      07. The original shooting scene between Han and Greedo has been restored.
      08. Jabba the Hutt has been given a makeover and Han no longer steps on his
      tale.
      09. In place of R2 wobbling down the stairs to the Falcon's hangar, a CG R2
      navigating the stairs like he does in Attack of the Clones was added.
      10. The white boxes around space ships have been removed and new CG shots
      have been added.
      11. The scene of the Falcon being chased by the two Star Destroyers was
      modified. The Falcon now does spinning moves, avoiding the Star Destroyers'
      fire.
      12. When the Death Star destroys Alderaan there's a new scene of Yoda's
      reaction to the disturbance in the Force that is created by all those
      deaths and then it cuts to Obi-Wan reacting to it as well.
      13. The Dianoga has gotten a CG makeover and were are now able to see more
      of the creature.
      14. The Death Star's paneling and computers have been slightly altered to
      show similar displays to those in the prequels.
      15. The words "Tractor Beam" with Aurebesh lettering.
      16. More stormtroopers have been added to the Death Star.
      17. Temuera Morrison's voice is being recorded for use with all the
      stormtroopers.
      18. The Obi-Wan/Vader duel has been spruced up. It is much more epic and
      there is much more movement. A modified version of Duel of the Fates is
      being considered for the scene.
      19. The Death Star plans that are taken from R2 have been updated. When the
      Rebels are reviewing the Death Star plans they look similar to the plans we
      see in Attack of the Clones.
      20. The Death Star battle is much more epic with more Tie Fighters and more
      Rebels being blown to bits. We get to see old Naboo starfighters being used
      by the Rebels.
      21. There's a new scene(shot during Episode III) where Darth Vader goes to
      Coruscant and lands his ship in the same building Count Dooku does at the
      end of Attack of the Clones. Except now the building is all fixed up and it
      is now Palpatine's palace. He meets with Palpatine to ask for forgiveness
      for his failure and inform him of a new potential who is strong in the Force.
      22. Chewbacca now gets a medal.

      Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back

      01. The taun-tauns are now CG.
      02. The battle of Hoth is much more epic. We see the Imperial ships land on
      Hoth and release AT-ATs. The AT-ATs have been sped up a bit. There's a
      ground battle between the Rebel soldiers and stormtroopers featuring new
      ships and vehicles.
      03. Temuera Morrison's voice is being recorded for the older Boba Fett and
      all the stormtroopers.
      04. The white boxes around space ships have been removed.
      05. The slug monster is CG.
      06. Ian McDiarmid has refilmed scenes as the Emperor. The conversations
      between Vader and Palpatine is now longer and features a few connections to
      the prequels.
      07. Yoda's face is now animated in CG allowing more _expression of emotions
      yet his movements remain the same. Also tw

      --

      no .sig
    5. Re:Episode III better rock by UrgleHoth · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I saw 4-6 in the theaters, watched them many times over again through the years. I saw 1 in the theater once. Have not watched it again. Have not seen 2. I've mostly lost interest in whatever happens next, but I'd bet money that 3 is going to suck donkey balls (or if it were a stock, I'd short it)

      Troll me if you will, but there are lots of peeps out there who like(d) SW feel the same way.

      --

      Dogma - "let's just say we'd like to avoid any empirical entanglements."
    6. Re:Episode III better rock by gamgee5273 · · Score: 4, Funny

      So, you're saying I'll see you in line, eh?

    7. Re:Episode III better rock by wideBlueSkies · · Score: 4, Funny

      My guess is that Jar Jar is destined to die on Alderaan.

      I'd love to see an extra scene in Episode 4 where Jar Jar looks to the heavens and sees the Death Star. And just as the laser fires his last words are "Mesa thinks this is very bom-bad".

      (earth shattering)KABOOM!!

      wbs.

      --
      Huh?
    8. Re:Episode III better rock by Luyseyal · · Score: 3, Funny

      I saw Episode 2 at the Discount Cinema on dollar movie night (Tuesdays) just to stick it to Lucas.

      Yoda kicking ass was worth a dollar, but I'd've paid full price to see Boba Fett torture and kill Anakin and Amidala. Twice.

      Fuck continuity.
      -l

      --
      Help cure AIDS, cancer, and more. Donate your unused computer time to worldcommunitygrid.org. Join Team Slashdot!
    9. Re:Episode III better rock by builderbob_nz · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Well if only one of these rumors can be granted, then I want the ewok music back. From a musicians perspective that was much better than the crap they used in the re-release.

      --

      Karma? Hey I just call it as I see it.
    10. Re:Episode III better rock by A55M0NKEY · · Score: 2, Insightful
      I totally agree. I tried to watch Attack of the Clones the other day on HBO and couldn't sit through it. The dialogue is just inane. I don't think story writing is Lucas's forte. He's a great scene builder. He can create the 'feeling' of a 'rebellion' or an 'evil empire' or a 'mysterious jedi cult' but the fact that Mark Hamill could star as Luke Skywalker and not completely ruin the first three movies means there was no acting involved in playing the part. No acting was required because there was no *character development*. Those movies were a plot centric amusement park ride, a cool universe you could imagine yourself in. Nobody in Star Wars 4,5,6 changed at all really if you think about it. But the universe and the ride was artfully done and I loved those movies.

      Obi Wan's character in Episode I was probably the worst thing about the movie other than Jar Jar Binks. The guy should have been identifiable as the same Obi Wan we all knew. He was just Qui Gon Jin's 'Igor-like' monk.

      In AOTC, Anakin is a badly acted whining little baby. Lucas should have hired a real writer to develop him into a believeable Darth Vader precursor. Anakin, being so important in all the movies really needs to be real.

      Lucas needs to make it less gawdy. The scenes in Mos Eisley were spare - almost desolate, which is what you would expect for a desert planet in the middle of nowhere. Then Lucas adds extra computer generated stuff to it. The desert planet in the middle of nowhere that was so boring Luke couldn't wait to leave now seemed like a happening place which detracted from the movie.

      The battles in episodes I and II are dazzlingly detailed. Rather than showing all that detail all the time just because he can, he needs to stop and consider what would actually be there and leave most of the things out that don't have a purpose. Less detail is sometimes more realistic IMO.

      --

      Eat at Joe's.

    11. Re:Episode III better rock by ArmenTanzarian · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Too soon to tell, I think all the stuff with Hayden Christenson is stupid as well as the redoing of the voices of the Stormtroopers. Taking out other people's contributions to the legend is wrong for the sake of the art and mean-spirited.

      Why would the spirit of Padme be at the end also? I thought only Jedi masters could do this before they finally joined with the force.

      Changing the music also seems like a bad idea, it again distorts the orginal art and flow of the movie. You can upgrade sound _quality_, but leave the original tracks alone.

      Come to think of it, I'll stick with my original letterbox VHS until they disintegrate. The originals were perfect, including their imperfections, it's part of what made it an incredible film. Lucas changing the films to support his lackluster plotlines and mediocre characters from the first few movies is a horrid affront to the fans and his own work.

      It was freakin' Lucas (as South Park pointed out) who lead the charge to keep movies from being colorized. I wish he could apply the same logic here.

    12. Re:Episode III better rock by jafuser · · Score: 2, Insightful

      "Meesa thinkin' dat disa gonna be muy muy bom-bad."

      I kind of like JarJar, but if this makes a lot of geeks happy and shuts them up, maybe it'll be worth it =P

      --
      Please consider making an automatic monthly recurring donation to the EFF
    13. Re:Episode III better rock by WNight · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I actually thought the Yoda fight scene was the weakest in the movie. Well, the whole movie was so weak it's hard to pick the weakest, but...

      Yoda should have been an old master, using tiny movements and his wits to beat the opponent, instead of acting like a happy-fun-ball.

      When I heard he was going to fight I pictured this old kung-foo movie I watched once where the old master defeats like three trained guys, not by being stronger or anything, but by not being where they had expected, moving just enough so they'd miss and then he'd pull them off-balance with a little tug and kick them on their way past. Didn't even break a sweat. That was class. Yoda the flubber-muppet was just sad.

    14. Re:Episode III better rock by dasmegabyte · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Agreed. I hated Episode 1. I hated Episode 2. I have even extended my hate to Return of the Jedi.

      And yet, I will see Episode 3, and I proudly GM the Star Wars d20 RPG (in a campaign based around the Old Republic era seen in KotOR, thus preventing the players from having to meet up with any damn gungans). If they make a sequel trilogy, even if it isn't based on Zahn's great books, I will go see it. Though I think they can't help but drawn on these guys...come one, Luke and Mara Jade? The tsalmiri? Leia hiding out on a planet of violent assassins, playing up her father's infamy? Even Lucas can't deny that's good stuff!

      What can I say? Star Wars is a pleasant fantasy realm that cannot be stifled even by the ineptitude of its creator. I *like* the Star Wars universe, midichlorian bullshit and all.

      --
      Hey freaks: now you're ju
    15. Re:Episode III better rock by miTTio · · Score: 2, Funny

      Yub-yub!

    16. Re:Episode III better rock by harborpirate · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Ug, how did all these rediculous rumors get modded up?

      First off, for those of you hoping the battle scenes will be updated, with more vehicles etc - don't hold your breath.

      Secondly, the removal of matte lines? You can forget about that one. They had the chance to do that in the last special editions, and they didn't. They chose to put in crappy extra scenes and wreck some of the current ones. Plan on those black lines with the Rancor monster still being there.

      And you arent' going to be able to go back and forth between CG and "real" Yodas, R2D2s, Obi-Wans, Vaders, cantina aliens, taun-tauns, ewoks, Jabbas, etc, etc, etc - without disjointing the movie. I'm sorry, but even as good as CG is these days, it still isn't perfect. Maybe you recall, in the Matrix trilogy, Neos fight against the zillion Smiths? Yeah, take a look at Neos clothing during the fight, tell me if you think it looks realistic the whole time...

      Here's what I'd like to see:

      Release the original movies, on DVD, with no extra special crap whatsoever. No CG. Release them exactly as they played when they first came out.

      Release them as they were, and leave them alone. If the old movies don't match the new, its George's fault. He knew when he created "prequels" that he needed to maintain continuity with his other movies. "Fixing" the old movies to match the new ones is wrong.

      I'm convinced that the more Lucas tries to "fix" his original triology, the worse it'll get.

      --
      // harborpirate
      // Slashbots off the starboard bow!
    17. Re:Episode III better rock by visgoth · · Score: 2, Interesting
      I remember reading somewhere way back, about a year before ep2 came out that Lucas said somthing to the effect of ".. and you will see why Yoda is the Jedi master.". The first thought that came to my mind was "oh shit... he's gonna have Yoda bounce around like some sort of hyperactive superball".

      Sadly my fears were proven correct. That whole fight is a total farce. Nowhere before did Yoda move in any sort of rapid manner, its been established that he's a slow moving little guy. To have him suddenly break out the kung-fu (ugh those stances he assumed were cheesy) and fly around screaming was so utterly ridiculous both me and my brother burst out laughing when we saw it in the theater.

      He absolutely should have moved like the parent suggested. I would have gone so far as to have him beat down Saruman unarmed using a fighting style something like Akido.

      --
      My patience is infinite, my time is not.
    18. Re:Episode III better rock by pyros · · Score: 5, Funny
      Yoda should have been an old master, using tiny movements and his wits to beat the opponent, instead of acting like a happy-fun-ball.

      Hey! Do not taunt happy-fun-ball!

    19. Re:Episode III better rock by Christopher+Whitt · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Release them as they were, and leave them alone. If the old movies don't match the new, its George's fault. He knew when he created "prequels" that he needed to maintain continuity with his other movies. "Fixing" the old movies to match the new ones is wrong.

      Dude. I understand your appreciation for the original cuts, but get a grip. They're just movies. And they're Lucas' movies, at that. He can do what he wants with them. Vote with your wallet.

      Christopher

    20. Re:Episode III better rock by damien_kane · · Score: 3, Funny

      Another way to look at it...

      Special Edition new scenes = poison...
      Episode 1 = poison...
      Episode 2 = poison...
      Episode 3 = ... tastyfish?

    21. Re:Episode III better rock by wideBlueSkies · · Score: 2, Funny

      >>The rumors (see earlier post in this topic) say he will be seen celebrating on Naboo after the Empire is overthrown at the end of the movie. Sorry to disappoint those who would love to see Jar-Jar get whacked!

      I forgot about that rumor. You're right.

      But it would still be a cool scene, looking up at the Death Star from the planet surface.

      wbs.

      --
      Huh?
    22. Re:Episode III better rock by ObiWanKenblowme · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I disagree, and along with the Matrix I think these are being subjected to the kind of pile-on-and-pick-at-its-faults mentality everywhere these days.

      Now I won't claim that it's ground-breaking cinema, but I definitely thought EpII was entertaining, for what it was. Maybe 20 years of buildup have obscured the fact that a lot of the OT was badly acted as well, with hoakey dialogue.

      The guy should have been identifiable as the same Obi Wan we all knew.
      One paragraph after you complain about a lack of character development, you complain that Obi-Wan isn't the same 40 or 50 years earlier? Find me someone who acts the same at 20 as they do at 60 and I'll show you someone with some big developmental or emotional problems.

      The scenes in Mos Eisley were spare...
      I've never heard this from anywhere "official," but my take was that during the prequels galactic culture is at its peak, everything is new and bright and vibrant. But after 30 or so years of war and opression, things don't look so nice and clean anymore. Especially in the backwater places, where most of the original trilogy took place. We never see Naboo or Coruscant during IV, V, and VI, which is where all the gawdiness was coming from.

      Sorry to go off on a rant, but I'd rather try and focus on the good points, rather than pick apart any movie that comes out because it doesn't meet my expectations.

      --
      Obvious exits are NORTH, SOUTH, and DENNIS.
    23. Re:Episode III better rock by clem · · Score: 3, Funny

      Meanwhile on the Millennium Falcon...

      "I felt a great disturbance in the Force, as if a jibbering idiot suddenly squeeled in terror and was suddenly silenced."

      --
      Your courageous and selfless spelling corrections have made me a better person.
    24. Re:Episode III better rock by JaredOfEuropa · · Score: 2, Funny

      And last but not least... all weapons have been digitally replaced with walkie-talkies!!

      --
      If construction was anything like programming, an incorrectly fitted lock would bring down the entire building...
    25. Re:Episode III better rock by denks · · Score: 3, Funny

      While Lucas is at it destroying the movies, how about Jar Jar turning to the dark side in Ep 4.
      We get a scene of Darth Vader telling Jar Jar to lash out with his anger and Jar Jar goes ballistic and runs around killing anything he can get his hands on.
      Then, in ROTJ, when we see the Emperor, it is actually Jar Jar wearing a hooded robe, he is the new emperor
      Me Sa thinks you should lash out with your anger. Then me sa thinks your transition to the dark side will be complete.
      Honestly, what better way to make Luke lash out than hearing that whiny voice!

      I guess with more ewoks at least we get to see more of them die.

      --

      I am Monkey, the Great Sage, equal of heaven!
  3. Sequel Names... by H0NGK0NGPH00EY · · Score: 5, Funny

    Star Wars Episode 7: Milking the Cash Cow
    Star Wars Episode 8: Beating a Dead Horse
    Star Wars Episode 9: Please God, Make it Stop Already!

    --
    Do not read this sig.
    1. Re:Sequel Names... by poopie · · Score: 3, Funny

      If Episode 2 naming is any judge:

      Star Wars Episode 7: Revenge of the Mutant Ewoks
      Star Wars Episode 8: The 20-Foot Tall Love Slave from Venus
      Star Wars Episode 9: Jar Jar Binks vs. The Lost Dragon Vampire Ninjas

      Jedi Binks?

  4. Who cares by Microsift · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Episode VI, I and II have all been mediocre, so why would anyone even bother seeing episode III much less VII, VIII, or IX?

    --
    My other sig is extremely clever...
  5. force powers by bludstone · · Score: 4, Funny

    The force is strong with me. I see these movies coming out, and thousands of voices scream out in excitement, followed by anger.

    The future is always cloudy.

    --

    no .sig
    1. Re:force powers by Glog · · Score: 2, Funny

      Foolish you are, yes, padawan. Sentence structure invert you must, hrmm. I feel not the force in you.

  6. Oh great by wizarddc · · Score: 4, Funny

    7, 8 and 9? I must be one uninformed geek. I thought I only had 1 more disapointing movie left to watch.

    --
    Th
  7. 3 times the crap! by Sean80 · · Score: 4, Insightful
    I'm sorry but I'm just sick of George Lucas raping my fond childhood memories of the first 3 Star Wars movies, and my wallet. Isn't it enough that he's created 2 incredibly bad movies in a row?

    I have to say, as much as I love Star Wars, I will have to seriously think about even going to see Episode 3. I'm not terribly hopeful. 3 more movies just doesn't fill me with any joy any more. From a worldwide love to a worldwide joke. Now -that's- a screwup.

    1. Re:3 times the crap! by happyfrogcow · · Score: 2, Interesting

      me too, but it's all about branding. you don't buy MS products because they're good, you buy them because they're well known

      So how many people will probably see episode 3 even though 1 and 2 sucked? I probably will. How many will see 7, 8, and 9? i might, might not... I feel 6 wrapped things up enough that I wouldn't be needing to see 7, 8, or 9 to satiate my curiosity. but Star Wars is a popular brand, so a lot of people will see them.

    2. Re:3 times the crap! by gamgee5273 · · Score: 4, Insightful
      Your childhood memories? I was four when the first movie came out. I saw it in the theaters (hell, I saw the Star Wars Holiday Special when it premiered on TV). And you know what? The new movies are the same calibur as the old ones. if you can't watch the old ones for what they are - a schlocky space opera - then you're doing a disservice to all of the movies and just shouldn't go any longer.

      I, on the other hand, have no problem letting ANOTHER person tell HIS story the way he sees fit. I either like it or dislike it - I don't take it as a personal attack on my childhood.

    3. Re:3 times the crap! by sebi · · Score: 3, Interesting
      Enough with the "rape-of-childhood-memories" bullshit already! I am so fucking sick of all the drama queens pretending that somehow a film they saw at the age of x+20 has the power to erase both the joy experienced at the age of x and the times spent pretending to be Han Solo.

      That has already happened and unless George Lucas goes around lobotomising his audience there is no way it can un-happen. If you feel that your wallet has been raped then maybe you shouldn't have bought the DVD or the action figures. Spending money on a movie ticket is like forced sex to you? Someone has to get their sense of perspective checked and it is not me.

      Needed to get this off my chest. So much in fact that I will throw in an extra point for the moderators to take away from me.

    4. Re:3 times the crap! by Wister285 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      While the Star Wars movies are definitely some of my favorite movies of all time, I don't know how great everyone's acting was in all of the movies. Harrison Ford was very consistant. When I think of Mark Hamill, all I can think about is him on Bespine yelling, "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!" with that terrible look on his face. It was and still is very strange.

      Just because you think that the new films aren't as great as the old ones are, there is a simple reason for this. All of the new ones have been hyped to no end and they will never live up to your expectations. Also, you know what's coming, the ideas aren't as original as they used to be. Don't forget that I'm sure your standard for film has been raised over the years, so the Star Wars films just don't seem as great as they once were because you expect so much.

      If you just watch the movies for what they are, you won't be disappointed and might enjoy yourself. At least Star Wars makes sense. Don't get me started on the Matrix: Revolutions.

  8. ...because of LotR by nphinit · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Realizing I through III will not turn out to be the worshipped saga he had hoped for, and since LotR now defines the high-quality fantasy saga, George wants another shot to redeem it all?

  9. Sequence by nightsweat · · Score: 2, Funny
    First, was IV, then V, then VI, then of course, I, next II, and soon III.

    Now VI, VII, and VII. Star Wars - teaching Roman numerals to whole new generation.

    --

    the major advances in civilization are processes which all but wreck the societies in which they occur - A.N. White
    1. Re:Sequence by zapp · · Score: 2, Funny

      Crap! I read that wrong

      you actually said the sequence was:
      4,5,6
      1,2,3
      5,6,6

      --
      no comment
    2. Re:Sequence by strictnein · · Score: 2, Funny

      Apparantely you both missed a lesson, he originally said:

      First, was IV, then V, then VI, then of course, I, next II, and soon III.
      Now VI, VII, and VII. Star Wars - teaching Roman numerals to whole new generation.


      Then you said:

      Apparently you missed a lesson.
      You just said the sequence is:
      4, 5, 6
      1, 2, 3
      6, 7, 8


      But he really originaly said:

      4, 5, 6
      1, 2, 3
      6, 7, 7

  10. StarWars.com USED to show eps VII, VIII and IX by bluethundr · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I remember back in around 1996 seeing slots for eps I,II,III,IV,V,VI and VII,VIII,IX on the StarWars.com homepage. Though a recent trip to the WayBack Machine seems to refute that memory. But they only go back to Dec 30th of '96 and my memory of VII,VIII,IX is a pretty clear one I'm adamant of having seen. But, interestingly enough Lucas had made some pretty clear statements that he NEVER intended to make a VII,VIII,IX trilogy. But I chalk those statements up to the same sort of Soviet revisionist history that made Greedo shoot first.

    However, as we all know, the prequels don't hold a CANDEL to the originals. Maybe Lucas is FINALLY starting to realize this and hoping to restore the franchise to it's former glory, removing the tarnish of eps I and II. If that be the case, I truly hope that he can. Truly.

    --
    Quod scripsi, scripsi.
    1. Re:StarWars.com USED to show eps VII, VIII and IX by Complicity · · Score: 3, Interesting
      Thank you, groups.google.com ...

      "Revenge of the Jedi"... Episode 6 in the Star Wars saga, has
      just finished filming, according to some friends I have down in
      Arizona.

      The release date for us humans that want to see it is
      still the summer of 1983. I guess it takes that long to score
      all the music, do all the film-editing, prepare all the promo
      material, and all that junk.

      I wish Lucas & Co. would get the thing going a little faster.
      I can't really imagine waiting until 1997 to see all nine parts
      of the Star Wars series.

      Yeah, me neither... :)
      --
      - c -
  11. Original Trilogy DVDs by Complicity · · Score: 3, Funny

    If you thought that you were going to have to wait a long time to get the original trilogy DVDs before...

    --
    - c -
  12. Contracts... by Whispers_in_the_dark · · Score: 5, Insightful

    However, TheForce is reporting that Mayhew's contract contains a stipulation that he must also appear in Episodes 7, 8, and 9.

    IMNAAA (not an acting agent), but isn't this just the sort of thing that gets tossed into lower-paid actor's contracts when a studio is simply hedging its bets? I like the 'bacca as well as the next dude, but he is probably paid less than, say Harrison Ford, on average. It seems likely to me that it wouldn't cost the studio much (if anything) to obligate him in this regard.

    Now, if the face-time Ep. 6 folks (Ford, Fisher, Hamilton, et al.) start getting signed into contracts like this then we would be talking.

  13. Too Old by jlechem · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I wouldn't take stock in this. How old is George Lucas now, 55 60? It takes him roughly 8-10 years a trilogy. He'ld be in a wheelchair by the time he finished the next ones if he even lived that long. I would think he wants to move on and do other things. And who would play all the original roles. All the main actors have not aged well and it would be very shitty to not have Mark Hammil reprise his role as Luke Skywalker or Harrison Ford play Han Solo.

    --
    Hold up, wait a minute, let me put some pimpin in it
    1. Re:Too Old by Flunitrazepam · · Score: 2, Informative

      In the original drafts of all 9 episodes, they were grouped by threes, and the only recurring characters (from one trilogy to the next) were supposed r2d2 and c3p0.

      --
      1) Your analysis is based on bad assumptions so your result is way off. 2) You're a sick bastard for fucking a horse.
    2. Re:Too Old by steveha · · Score: 5, Insightful

      All the main actors have not aged well

      Funny you should say that. I remember, years ago (around the time of Episode V), George Lucas was asked if the main actors would be back for episodes VII, VIII, and IX; his reply was "sure, if they can be made to look old enough." The implication was that he wanted to set the final trilogy a few decades after the end of Episode VI.

      On the other hand, his more recent comment was that he "Never really had a story" for the final trilogy.

      On the gripping hand, it's clear that not having a story never really stops him. I refuse to believe that he planned all along for young Skywalker to build C-3PO, for example. I refuse to believe that during filming of Episode IV that he had already planned that Darth Vader would have grown up on Tattooine. I strongly suspect that the whole Luke/Leia being brother/sister was invented after he already had finished Episode IV. He just makes stuff up and sticks it on.

      Star Wars is great not because of George Lucas, who got the ball rolling, but because of the contributions of so many people. The sets, costumes, and effects represent man-years of work by many people. At this point you could take Star Wars out of George Lucas's hands and make new movies. (Sadly, they might be better movies for that; George Lucas's recent track record isn't great.)

      I predict we'll see Episodes VII, VIII, and IX someday, no matter what George Lucas says now. And we'll probably see other movies as well. (I'd like to see some "Jedi Academy" movies.)

      steveha

      --
      lf(1): it's like ls(1) but sorts filenames by extension, tersely
    3. Re:Too Old by floppy+ears · · Score: 2, Funny

      I predict we'll see Episodes VII, VIII, and IX someday, no matter what George Lucas says now. And we'll probably see other movies as well. (I'd like to see some "Jedi Academy" movies.)

      Totally. If not sooner, then the day after Lucas dies his heirs will sell the rights to the Star Wars universe for $1 billion (or so) to Fox and they'll start making the movies again. They won't stop until Episode XVII (or so).

      And then after they've gotten every last dollar out of the movie seriies, they'll turn it into a 3d TV show for our grandkids. Or our grandkids' pets. Or something.

      --

      "If I could live to be several hundred
      I could take a walk and really wander, really wonder."
    4. Re:Too Old by letdownjournals · · Score: 2, Funny

      I'd like to see some "Jedi Academy" movies.

      Me too. But only if they're screwball teen sex comedies.

  14. Re:Episodes 7, 8, and 9... by Warlock7 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    No, no books yet. But back in the day Lucas always claimed that this was a nine part story.

  15. Let us never forget... by StressGuy · · Score: 2, Insightful

    The never ending "Police Academy" holocost

    --
    A goal is a dream with a deadline
  16. It just won't be the same if not... by milkman_matt · · Score: 4, Funny
    The actor who played Chewbacca in the original Star Wars trilogy, Peter Mayhew, will be in Episode III.

    Well I would HOPE SO! If anyone but Peter Mayhew played Chewbacca I just don't think it would pass... I mean, it takes some serious talent to walk around in a big furry costume for a while... And while they're at it they better get the same people for C3P0 and Vader or this movie just won't quite work!

    -matt

  17. Chewbacca? Now there's an irreplaceable actor! by Gramie2 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I don't understand it. Surely any of the actors playing a character whose face is hidden and voice isn't used (i.e. Chewbacca, R2D2, or Darth Vader) is completely dispensable. Why is it such a big deal to keep Peter Mahew? The only qualification for someone replacing him would be height!

  18. Mark Hammil responds... by TrollBridge · · Score: 3, Funny

    "Oh thank God! I'll may yet eat another meal that wasn't first deposited in a dumpster!"

    --
    There's a Mercedes gap too. I want one and can't afford one, but it's not government's job to do anything about it.
    1. Re:Mark Hammil responds... by GMFTatsujin · · Score: 2, Interesting

      He's also been quite successful on the stage. A CNN article a few months back had him saying that he was very happy with the distance he's created between Star Wars and the rest of his very-well established career as an entertainer. Not that he's not proud of his earlier work, but it's not the kind of thing an actor wants to hang his hat on forever.

    2. Re:Mark Hammil responds... by SkankhodBeeblebrox · · Score: 2, Funny

      And remember, he was in Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back too!! :P

  19. Re:Oh no! more shit from Lucas to come by fromtheblueline · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Just because Mayhew wants his part secured for future episodes does not mean that there will be future episodes. It would be no different then Elijah Wood securing his role as Frodo to keep another actor, say Keanu Reeves or Paul Reubens, from being cast in as Frodo in the future.

  20. Re:Episodes 7, 8, and 9... by schon · · Score: 3, Funny

    I thought I remember hearing Lucas never wanted to write them?

    Well, we're in luck then. They might actually be watchable. :o)

  21. CA$H by Malicious · · Score: 4, Informative
    Incase any of you didn't know, regardless of how much you/we think EP I & II may have sucked, they still raked in a wack of cash domestically:
    Episode I: $431,088,295
    Episode II: $310,675,583

    I think what we're seeing here are at least + 741,000,000 reasons Lucas is considering 7,8,9.

    --
    01101001001000000110000101101101001000000110001001 10000101110100011011010110000101101110
    1. Re:CA$H by Boing · · Score: 2, Insightful
      Episode I: $431,088,295
      Episode II: $310,675,583

      You're still right, but I'd like to clarify something... Ep 1 had a budget of $115,000,000. Ep 2 had a budget of $120,000,000. Not exactly chump change. They were both extremely profitable, but you should factor the cost of making movies of this magnitude.

      Still, the fact that they were that profitable despite the fact that I and everyone I know thinks that they're an affront to the quality of the original trilogy tells me something important (though hardly a new idea): fans of the original trilogy are no longer the target audience of the Star Wars franchise.

      Lucas isn't pleasing us these days because he's not trying to please us. And at those numbers, I can hardly blame him. Empire Strikes Back, my personal favorite, had grossed $290,158,751 as of May '97 (source). If Episode 2 grosses more in one year than Episode 5 grossed in seventeen, the old formula is a hard sell.

    2. Re:CA$H by AgentUSA · · Score: 5, Interesting

      But when you adjust for inflation:

      Star Wars - $979 million
      The Empire Strikes Back - $547 million
      Return of the Jedi - $524 million
      The Phantom Menace - $475 million
      Attack of the Clones - $310 million

  22. The Death Script by Dracolytch · · Score: 5, Funny

    "I felt a great disturbance in movie buffs... as if millions of viewers suddenly cried out in terror and were suddenly silenced."

    Most likely their own organs went into revolt. Geeks everywhere left Episode II with their brains subconciously chanting: "If you are so stupid to watch the next one, I will KILL YOU!"

    ~D

    --
    This sig has been enciphered with a one-time pad. It could say almost anything.
  23. SFX by CuriHP · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I can only hope that Lucas will at some point realize that special effects cannot save a bad story. Especially when everything is in gharish cartooney colors.

    --
    If it's not on fire, it's a software problem.
  24. didya hear that? by EvilStein · · Score: 4, Funny

    It was the sound of millions of Star Wars fans yelling "Can we FINALLY see Jar Jar DIE? Please!?" :P

  25. Re:good news? by ENOENT · · Score: 3, Funny

    I thought that Chewbacca played a key role in the OJ case.

    --
    That's "Mr. Soulless Automaton" to you, Bub.
  26. Chewbacca Strikes Back? by H8X55 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    "The actor who played Chewbacca in the original Star Wars trilogy, Peter Mayhew, will be in Episode III. Of course, this has been previously reported and comes as no surprise. However, TheForce is reporting that Mayhew's contract contains a stipulation that he must also appear in Episodes 7, 8, and 9.

    Why bother with him then? If ever a character could be played by someone else it would be Chewbacca! No recognizable voice, or face, or anything. Just a 6'6" guy in a wookie costume with sound effects added in after the fact. I don't mean to be rude to Mr. Mayhew, but what leveridge does he have?

  27. Chewbacca's speech by aquabat · · Score: 2, Informative

    Apparently, there will be a scene in episode VII where Chewbacca addresses the governing council on Cashyyyk. Mr Lucas is developing a Wookie language expressly for this purpose. The grammar and vocabulary will be available before the release so that die hard fans can follow along without reading the subtitles.

    --
    A republic cannot succeed till it contains a certain body of men imbued with the principles of justice and honour.
  28. 7,8 & 9 by ackthpt · · Score: 4, Funny
    TheForce is reporting that Mayhew's contract contains a stipulation that he must also appear in Episodes 7, 8, and 9.

    Nothing a few million $ couldn't rectify.

    So what would Episodes 7-9 be like...

    <Daydream Sequence>

    Star Wars, Episode 7: A New Threat
    Synopsis: Luke and Leia get married and head off on a honeymoon, leaving Han Solo and Chewbacca to watch over selection of the new senate. Han Solo gets bored and starts hyperspace download site of music and video content against the wishes of the immensely powerful IGRIMPAA (Inter Galactic Recording Industry and Motion Picture Artists Association), a thinly veiled group of thugs and bandits who have kept entertainers in thrall. Big cruisers appear out of hyperspace around Coruscant and Jar Jar Bings, in their employe serves subpoenas, furthering audience animosity.

    Star Wars, Episode 8: Just An Awufl Mess
    Synopsis: Luke and Leia return to Coruscant and find the IGRIMPAA firmly running things, Han Solo and Chewbacca rotting in prison and several worlds in outright rebellion. Luke procedes to reform a Jedi council, but finds space cruiser bombs going off all over the place. President Jar Jar Binks attempts to alay Luke's concerns, until it's found Leia has an ePod loaded with bootleg tunes from Naboo. Jar Jar reveals well kept secret that he is master of dark side and cuts off Luke's other hand in epic lightsabre battle. Han and Chewy come to rescue and all flee to the a distant world only to find another massive Deathstar built with IGRIMPAA profits.

    Star Wars, Episode 9: Last of the Red-Hot Jedi
    Synopsis: Luke and Leia's child, Xyzzy, demonstrates great skill with the force and greater skill with the source, hacks into DeathStar and shuts it down, in a bit of a special effects let-down, just see big ball with lights go out, no explosion. Luke and Leia return to Coruscant, along with Han and Chewbacca and in a final battle Luke duels with Jar Jar, both slice each other in half and last threat is brought to an end, except for offspring of Skywalkers, who demonstrates a slight inclination to power and position and a bit of an angry streak. We've been here before, no?

    </Daydream Sequence>

    --

    A feeling of having made the same mistake before: Deja Foobar
  29. Quick Ammendment by notcreative · · Score: 2, Funny

    A few typos; it should have read:

    Star Wars Episode 7: Beating the Cash Cow
    Star Wars Episode 8: Milking a Dead Horse
    Star Wars Episode 9: If There Were A God, It Would Have Stopped Already

  30. Dialogue for Episode III: by kjdames · · Score: 5, Funny
    Peter Jackson: Your powers are weak, old man.

    George Lucas: You can't win, Peter. If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful than you can possibly imagine.

    C-3PO: R2 says that the chances of episodes 7-9 surviving are 725 to 1. Actually R2 has been known to make mistakes... from time to time... Oh dear...

    C-3PO: Sir, the possibility of successfully extending this series is approximately 3,720 to 1!

    Lucas: Never tell me the odds!

    --

    Typos... that's just how I role.

  31. These stories will come after the "New Jedi Order" by Warlock7 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Episodes 7, 8 and 9 are supposed to deal with a character that is supposed to be introduced in Episode 3. These episodes will take place after the New Jedi Order series. That allows for Lucas to use the original stars (Mark Hamill, Harrison Ford, Carrie Fisher, Peter Mayhew, etc.) and place them into the timeline approximately 30 years after A New Hope which is right around the end of the Yuuzhan Vong series (NJO). This is perfect. In 2007 these performers will be 30 years older than they were when they took the roles in the first place. This gives a lot of credibility to the whole concept.

  32. Horrible, horrible, yet we can't look away by Mr.+Neutron · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Star Wars movies are becoming like a horrific accident scene. Terrifying and excruciatingly painful, yet we feel compelled to watch. I'd like to do a survey:

    1. What percentage of geeks expect to see EpIII?
    2. Of those going to see EpIII, what percentage expect it to be anything other than a suckfest?

    Anticipated answers:

    1. 95%
    2. 1%

    If GL makes VII-IX, you KNOW everyone is going to go. How can he pass up the chance to make that much money on what amounts to another 9 years of playing with cool toys without any need to work on boring stuff like sympathetic characters or realistic dialog?

    --
    dinner: it's what's for beer
  33. This is evidence of very little ... by Unordained · · Score: 3, Interesting

    -If- there are three more movies made, -and- they need someone to play Chewie, -then- he'll be the one to do it if still around, and he can't refuse. This in no way stipulates that they -must- make three movies, or even that they -will- ... only that he would be required to play Chewie if they ever again need someone to do so.

    It's a great way to give both actors and the audience some hope for more movies, and it lets them worry a little less about the 'how' of making more movies by already having actors lined up and contracts signed. Sheesh. Can't you boys be a little more skeptical?

  34. What the fuck is WITH you people? by DesScorp · · Score: 2, Insightful

    So Lucas may do another trilogy. Good on him. But hang on....Slashdot readers dissaprove! "He's just trying to gouge us, he's destroyed my fond childhood memories", etc, etc, lather, rinse, repeat.

    Pull your heads out of your asses. If you don't like the movies, don't go see them. Star Wars belongs to Lucas. He created it, he owns the empire, and if he wants to film himself slinging handfulls of his own shit at a Slashdot logo, and call it Episode 7, he can.

    I doubt we'll ever see those movies, but I'd like to see them get made. And I wont cry on the Internet that they're not the same as the original trilogy. Which kind of makes sense, being that the original trilogy is two decades old. People change, the industry changes, ideas change, technologies change. Get over it. Go watch Lord of the Rings again if you want purity. More than likely, some of you whining peckerwoods will be watching Yet Another Tentacle Rape Hentai flick.

    --
    Life is hard, and the world is cruel
  35. i hate the prequels as much as the next guy... by *weasel · · Score: 5, Insightful

    ...but how do the prequels rape the fond memories of your childhood? I mean, sure episode 1 sucks - but episode 4 and 5 are still hella good.

    Unless you mean the prequels made you realize how lame the series already was by episode 6. How hokey episode 4 was, and how the pinnacle of the series was directed and largely rewritten by people other than Lucas. That could understandably rob you of fond memories. Of course, just watching them again older and wiser would probably have done that.

    I could also understand the anger if you were referring to the Greedo-shooting-first destruction of the original series called the 'Special Editions'. But you're not.

    my pet theory is that the special editions, and episodes 1, and 2 are precisely the kinds of movies Lucas wanted to make from the beginning.

    episode iv represented his first shot, and doubtlessly had piles of constructive criticism and rewrites. then it was proven a cash cow, and the sequel was given to a different director and featured much more rewriting. (largely hailed as the pinnacle of starwars). Then Lucas got control back, and turned out Jedi.

    After more time and money, he skull-f#cked the original trilogy with the special editions. then came episode 1 and the truth was unavoidable. episode 2 was salt on a gaping wound.

    Without actual creative criticism, Lucas just doesn't churn out the movies we always thought he wanted to make.

    It's like the Wachowskis. They probably rewrote the first Matrix a dozen times and were making huge changes even to the shooting script. But who's going to slow down the process of making sequels to a cash cow by saying 'Whoa, guys - you've got some pacing issues that need to be fixed here, and some lame ass dialogue'?

    No-one in Hollywood.

    --
    // "Can't clowns and pirates just -try- to get along?"
    1. Re:i hate the prequels as much as the next guy... by Watts+Martin · · Score: 2, Interesting

      My pet theory is that the special editions and episoes 1 and 2 are precisely the kinds of movies Lucas wanted to make from the beginning.

      Yep, I've gathered that. In early drafts of the first Star Wars script, the hero is named "Anakin Starkiller" and the plot is much, much closer to The Phantom Menace. Evidently people reading the initial script told Lucas that the story was just a big, sprawling mess that needed to have a much tighter focus around a single hero, who had to really be heroic. So Lucas went off to read Joseph Campbell and reconstructed the first script using The Hero With a Thousand Faces and Campbell's "monomyth" concept as a guidebook.

      To be fair to the first trilogy, though, Lucas always had story and production control over them. Both Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi were written and directed by different people. If Lucas had written it entirely himself, it would have combined the banal dialogue of the first one with the banal story of the third, and been even worse than it was. :)

  36. Look at him... by KermitAndLadyHoliday · · Score: 4, Funny

    he's heading for that small movie.

    H: I think I can get him before he gets there...he's almost in range.

    (the small movie begins to take on the appearance of another trilogy)

    B: That's no movie. It's Episode III.

    H: The trailer's too good to be Episode III.

    L: I have a very bad feeling about this.

    H: Yeah, I think you're right. Full reverse! Chewie, lock in the auxiliary power. (the ship begins to shudder) Chewie, lock in the auxiliary power!

    L: Why are we still moving towards it?

    H: We're caught in the Lucas beam! It's pulling us in!

    L: But there's gotta be something you can do!

    H: There's nothing I can do about it, kid, I've already seen Episodes I and II. I'm going to have to shut down. But they're not going to get me without a fight!

  37. NOOOOOOOO! That's impossible... by adrianbaugh · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Why would he do this? The whole point of a story is it has a beginning, a middle and an end. The original trilogy had that. Okay, so the beginning was a bit ropey: this ship appears from nowhere and starts blasting, and there's these two droids that we know little about.
    But that's how stories often work best - they throw you in at the deep end so it's exciting and you have to think and work out what's going on. Okay, the prequels fill out the early story a bit for the hardcore fans, but nobody in their right minds, new to the series, would sit through 6+ hours of dross just to understand what the secret plans R2 had were, or to have the "I am your father" surprise ruined for them.

    But while the prequels just made the series a bit worse, the sequels would be awful. Even if you think the beginning of the middle trilogy requires some fleshing out, the end is very good. It's a final, definitive end: the bad guy is dead and the galaxy is on the road towards stability. But for gods' sake, we don't need to see it get there. Star Wars became a parody of itself a long time ago, and that's a crying shame because before it was spoilt it was very, very good.

    I've wasted four hours of my life on I and II: I suppose I'll waste two more on the off-chance that Boba Fett does something cool, or that Jar-Jar meets a spectacularly bloody end, but that's it. No more. If III is of the same quality as I and II I can't believe Lucas has the nerve even to bring it out, now that LoTR has shown us what can be done with the SF/fantasy epic genre.

    --
    "'I pass the test,' she said. 'I will diminish, and go into the West, and remain Galadriel.'"
    - JRR Tolkien.
  38. Re:Times running out by EricWright · · Score: 3, Interesting

    You say Lucas is 60 now (that's in 2004)... if so, then how will he be 66 in 2012, *eight* years from now?

  39. To fix Star Wars by Krieger · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Would require re-doing 1-3, and at least in my mind 6. The ewoks were an abomination, and represented a massive sell-out to "childrens" movies.

    He was right on with the first two, a G movie for all audiences, with enough plot and depth for older audiences, yet enough cool stuff to captivate children, as well as a reasonably straightforward plot arch (ala Joseph Campbell).

    So many mistakes were made in the making of the first two (and I'd wager third) that it's hard to even pretend it's the same series. What makes it the most comical is that with tweaks to each of those stories they could have been grand. My favorite example is Anakin slaughtering all of the Raiders after finding his mother seconds before her dying (way out in the realm of possibility). More realistic would have been to have him sneak in, rescue her, only to have her get shot and then die in his arms and have him return with his rage to wipe them out.

    I'm certain that thoughts like mine have been bouncing around Star Wars fans heads. Without copyright being what it is now, enterprising producers would be able to try and correct these wrongs inside of the fans lifetimes (at least with the founders copyright).

    At this point I think I'll see Star Wars III at the dollar theater, and if it's better then a steaming pile I'll rent it and watch it on someone's surround sound setup.

  40. Other movies get the same treatment by Hoi+Polloi · · Score: 5, Funny

    Casablanca: Bogart decides to stay but never gets a job. Bacall kicks his lazy ass off the couch and into the street.

    Citizen Kane: Kane finally realizes that he needs therapy and later goes to a yoga retreat in Tahiti.

    Catch-22: Most of the airbase crew are arrested and shot for insubordination. Yosarian surrenders the entire base to some Italian villagers.

    --
    It is by the juice of the coffee bean that thoughts acquire speed, the teeth acquire stains. The stains become a warning
    1. Re:Other movies get the same treatment by PateraSilk · · Score: 4, Funny
      Casablanca: Bogart decides to stay but never gets a job. Bacall kicks his lazy ass off the couch and into the street.

      Ingrid Bergman wonders what Bacall is doing in this movie and calls her agent.

      --
      Danke tres mucho, tovarishch.
  41. No mention of James Earl Jones! by dloflin · · Score: 3, Insightful

    No mention of whether James Earl Jones does the voice of Vader in any of the new/touched-up scenes. I get that it's Hayden in the un-masked scene...just as it wasn't James Earl Jones. But what about other scenes?

    And...does James Earl Jones do the (masked) voice of Darth Vader in Ep III? Or will we not see Vader (as we see him in Ep IV) in Ep III? Perhaps just a mangled Anakin, or an early version of the Darth Vader mask.

    Hmm..I remember reading long ago, either in a fan magazine or something (maybe the book version of Star Wars?) that Anakin became disfigured, requiring the mask & prostheses, when Obi Wan threw him into a volcano. I hope Lucas remembered that (if it was in the book or in any way "official").

    My main gripe about Ep I-II was the lack of continuity with Ep IV-VI -- like Lucas had forgotten the "vision" he'd come up with originally (supposedly he'd sketched out ALL NINE episodes before filming Star Wars). I guess he's fixing it now by modifying Ep IV, V, and VI. Sigh. Better than nothing I suppose...

  42. How about Peter Jackson does VII-IX? by MattW · · Score: 5, Funny

    Call me crazy, but Jackson handled LOTR with about the most love and care and achievement I could ever expect from making it into a Hollywood trilogy.

    So, if Lucas doesn't want to do VII-IX himself, that's fine, but how about he let Jackson take over? You end up with a vastly superior sequel trilogy, and we'd probably get the movies 1 year apart instead of 3.

    1. Re:How about Peter Jackson does VII-IX? by Admiral1973 · · Score: 2, Insightful
      That's an interesting idea, but I doubt it would happen. Peter Jackson will spend the rest of his life answering questions about LOTR and having the rest of his work compared to it. His filmmaking legacy is secure. I don't see why he'd want to take on another juggernaut like Star Wars and deal with the fans and the media and the hype again.

      If there are any more SW films, Lucas will make them himself. By insisting on directing the prequel trilogy films despite critical and fan reactions, he's shown that he needs to keep that control. He's not going to give it up, especially to someone like Peter Jackson, who would impose his own vision on the project. And by his ability to get actual emotive performances out of his actors, Jackson would show the audience that he's clearly the better director. It's not bad for Lucas to be outdone in a separate film genre, but he won't let it happen in his own universe.

      --
      Lousy minor setbacks! This world sucks! -- Homer Simpson
  43. Edit in Ep IV... by TheConfusedOne · · Score: 3, Funny

    [Princess Leia torture scene in Death Star]
    The floating torture droid has been removed and replaced with a TV and DVD carousel player...
    [Vader places Ep's 1-3 and 7-9 in carousel]
    Vader: [finger poised over Play button] So Princess, where is the Rebels' secret base?

    --
    --- I wish I could hear the soundtrack to my life. That way I'd know when to duck.
  44. Wasn't there just an article on rewriting by FerretFrottage · · Score: 2, Funny

    It appears that code isn't the only thing subject to re-writes. Time to opensource SW and let's make 1000 different versions of it.

    --
    "Look Lois, the two symbols of the Republican Party: an elephant, and a fat white guy who is threatened by change."
  45. Some suggestions for Mr. Lucas by nomadicGeek · · Score: 4, Interesting

    You have been disappointing us. While many of us grew up with your movies and loved them, things have been steadily going down hill.

    1. Hire some real writers. You got help with Empire and it was the best movie to date. Don't try to do it yourself, you're real talent lies elsewhere.

    2. Hire another director. Get somebody like Peter Jackson who can film the trilogy all at once. We don't like waiting years between movies. 1 year max between releases.

    3. If it's cute. Leave it out. No more muppet'y characters like the Ewoks. No more frickin' Jar Jar type characters. I just can't take it. If you would like, I will offer my services for free. You can run this stuff by me and I will tell you if it sucks.

    4. Give it an edge like Empire. Your loyal fan base is getting older. We want a real plot without all of the inconsistencies that you have written yourself into in the last two movies. Remember, we're adults now. We we love the world and the characters that you created for us but we really want to experience it on an adult level. I'll say it again. No more Jar Jar's.

    5. Concentrate on what you really do best. Keep pushing the state of the art in film production. Push ILM to make the movie better while producing it faster and cheaper than anyone has ever done. Bring the costs of producing epic style movies down to a more reasonable level so that even more young artists can expose us to their visions without having a $100 million bank roll. The less expensive it gets, the more variety we will have.

    6. Don't concentrate on making a blockbuster. Just make the best movie that you can and show it to us. We will pay to see it. You don't have to have product tie ins everywhere we go. No more cheesy market deals. No more Jar Jar's (did I already mention that?)

    7. I want the new trilogy to hit DVD before I start collecting social security. Besides if you get off your ass on this, you can sell the previous movie on DVD right before you release the next movie. Easy advertising. (Don't do like LOTR though and release a 'normal' DVD and hold out the good one for a month or two. We like that about as much as we adore Jar Jar).

    7. Use your influence and $$$ to get us completely digital theaters. We all want to see the new movies on a crystal clear screen that isn't going to be completely degraded the 3rd and 4th time we go to see it. (This assumes that you make them good).

    You know what. Forget it all. I'm still pissed about the whole Jar Jar thing.

    1. Re:Some suggestions for Mr. Lucas by Schnapple · · Score: 3, Insightful
      Don't do like LOTR though and release a 'normal' DVD and hold out the good one for a month or two. We like that about as much as we adore Jar Jar
      Hold on there - we're all complaining that Lucas won't put out the original Star Wars movies on DVD, just the special editions. However, Peter Jackson puts out the original and extended editions of the LOTR movies and we shit on him? Plus, we're told in advance about the extended editions, they're not sprung on us years later.
      Use your influence and $$$ to get us completely digital theaters.
      Buy a $100K projector for each of the 3,000+ screens he wants to show it on? That alone would cost $300 million at least.
  46. Idea: Make Whedon's Firefly instead! by macMaestro · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Ha! We'll never get original Star Wars DVDs. If we're lucky we might get that modified 20th aniversary crap (I'm not a fan of modified films), but it's debatable to call that lucky.

    No more madness! Stop these horrid movies! Hope Fox'll make Firefly instead.

    FIREFLY RULES!!!

  47. Has history taught us nothing... by glitch · · Score: 3, Funny

    ...about the devastating results of too many alterations?

  48. Hot Dog Website by Gossy · · Score: 2, Informative

    Has anyone noticed just quite how bad the Hot Dog site is?

    The "Current issue" and "Back Issue" link to 192.168.1.100/... addresses for crying out loud!

  49. Re:Not your father's Oldsmobile by A55M0NKEY · · Score: 2, Funny

    Year: 2038 Headline Star Wars Episode 9 Completed. Episodes I through VI redone to remove inconsistencies ( just under nuclear disaster caused by 32 bit date rollover ) 01 Anakin is now an Ewok in all episodes 02 Jabba The Hut actually molests Princess Leia 03 ... Seems Star Wars will never be finished..

    --

    Eat at Joe's.

  50. New Star Wars joke... by cmeans · · Score: 2, Funny

    Why was EP VI afraid of EP VII?

    Because VII VIII IX!

  51. Plot is NOT an issue in more SW films by belgar · · Score: 3, Insightful


    As anyone who's read the Star Wars storyline as it continues past the 4/5/6, if Lucas uses these as a baseline for more movies, rejoice your ass off.

    The stories (for the most part) have great depth, a wealth of plot scenarios to choose from (which might be the biggest stumble to what to make for sequels), and continue the stories of the principals through the next 30 years (kids, getting old, death, etc.). It actually makes the characters a helluva lot more believable.

    Hats off to the editors who have made EVERY story that followed the movies tie into one another -- their consistency checks have got to be brain numbing, they're so thorough. That alone has made the stories a lot of fun to read.

    And the authors include some well-known names in modern sci-fi, including James Luceno, Michael P. Kube-McDowell, and Michael Stackpole.

    So, go read some dead tree, and see what kind of potential there is for three (or more!) sequels from Lucas. Let's just hope he uses some of the material available to him, instead of striking off on his own.

    --
    What does it mean to wake out of a dream
    and be wearing someone else's shorts?
    BNL, Born on a Pirate Ship (1998)
  52. Pirate. by DarkHelmet · · Score: 2, Interesting
    I for one plan to download a copy of Episode III off the net to boycott it sucking.

    And if it somehow ends up being good, I will then go see it in the theatre.

    This is how I use piracy to get rid of that silly geek factor that allowed Episodes 1 and 2 to make 400 million+. I will not support a movie by paying for it if it's not any good.

    --
    /^[A-Z0-9._%+-]+@[A-Z0-9.-]+\.[A-Z]{2,4}$/i
  53. No, 4, 5, and 6 were much better by GuyMannDude · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Unless you mean the prequels made you realize how lame the series already was by episode 6. How hokey episode 4 was, and how the pinnacle of the series was directed and largely rewritten by people other than Lucas. That could understandably rob you of fond memories. Of course, just watching them again older and wiser would probably have done that.

    I hate to tell you this but I *have* watched the original trilogy since I was a kid. In fact, I probably watch the original trilogy about 3 times every year. I still enjoy them. You may argue that my positive feelings about those films are because I'm remembering my childhood or something. But I think they were substancially different than the new stuff.

    Why? The characters. The original trilogy had likeable characters who were really giving it their all to take back the galaxy. Solo was a great guy. You could feel for what Luke was going through. Leia was clearly struggling with how to give all the parts of herself equal time. The rebellion doesn't have much but, boy, do they have heart! The Jedi, on the other hand, strike me as really a bunch or arrogant elite who seem to not be doing a very good job of anything. Anakin is just a spoiled brat. Obi Wan seems to have some ability but he never gets awfully worked up about anything. Yoda and Mace just sit around looking pensive and occasionally whip out their lightsabres. I wouldn't want to sit down and have a beer with any of those guys. They're just do damn boring.

    Now let's look at the villans. Sure, in the original series the stormtroopers could never shoot straight but you knew that Vader was running the show most of the times and so it seemed like the Empire had a real chance of crushing the freedom fighters. In Ep 6 we see that Vader is starting to weaken a bit but then we're introduced to the Emperor who is even more powerful than Vader. *This* guy really knows his shit and he seems to delight in tormenting Luke. To put it simply, the bad guys were fearsome and competant. Now look at the bad guys from Ep 1 and 2. Darth Maul was cool but never really given a chance to say much. The Viceroy and the other Trade Federation weenies seem utterly incompetant. And Palpatine and Dooku have yet to do anything really horribly dispicable. It's hard to get worked up about these bad guys.

    So there you have my theory. Characters are what makes the difference between the old and the new trilogy. Basically the old one had characters you could love and hate. The new one just has a bunch of guys dancing around in a CGI videogame.

    GMD

    1. Re:No, 4, 5, and 6 were much better by stwrtpj · · Score: 4, Insightful
      The rebellion doesn't have much but, boy, do they have heart!

      Agreed.

      The Jedi, on the other hand, strike me as really a bunch or arrogant elite who seem to not be doing a very good job of anything.

      Also agree, but are you saying this made Ep I/II bad? Granted, I and II had problems, but this is not one of them. Yes, the Jedi are a bunch of stuck-up, arrogant buttheads. That's one of the main points of the movie. We're likely to see this play out more in Ep III. Much of the Jedis' downfall is by their own hand. They got too used to their power and to the status quo to see more than a few inches in front of their face. You're supposed to doubt them at this point.

      And Palpatine and Dooku have yet to do anything really horribly dispicable. It's hard to get worked up about these bad guys.

      I think that's one of the reasons why people have trouble with Ep I/II. We're essentially seeing the story out-of-sequence. We started in the middle of the story, where the battle lines were very clearly drawn, and everyone had already put on their white or black hats. In Ep I/II, this has not happened yet. The ones that become or pave the way for the great villians of the later movies have no choice but to act in secret. To me, Palpatine's machinations in the Senate echo the events of the rise of the Nazi party to power and Hitler's ascension to Chancellor (hell, even the title is the same!) in Germany circa the 1930s.

      I sometimes wonder how people might have reacted had the movies been produced and released in the actual chronological order that the events happen. It might have garnered a different reaction. Yeah, the screenplays could have been better written, but I think the overall story still plays well, and would have played better in the proper sequence.

      --
      Karma: Frotzed (mostly due to the Frobozz Magic Karma Company)
  54. I've got a great idea for an ending by character+sequence · · Score: 4, Insightful

    We could end the film where somebody - get this - in a small spaceship flies up to the big enemy ship and - this idea is so good - blows it up from the inside using minimal fire power. Oh wait, we already did that three fucking times!

    --
    Karma: Nonnegative
    1. Re:I've got a great idea for an ending by fuzzybunny · · Score: 2, Funny


      Ok, and here's some content to flesh it out:

      -An evil supervillain too arrogant to hire a 6 year old to spot obvious flaws in his plan
      -Obnoxiously saccharine aliens
      -An equally obnoxious kid
      -Bad guys who aim like drunkards
      -Good guys who can't get their shit together enough to make sure the bad guys don't keep coming back

      Stir vigorously, bake at 320 degrees and voila.

      Or, as the man said in the song, "...but there's this contract I had to sign, that I'll be making these movies till the end of time..."

      --
      Cole's Law: Thinly sliced cabbage