Slashdot Mirror


On the Possible Handtop Paradigm Shift

captainJam writes "Handtops.com has a piece about the effects of handtops (text version) such as the OQO, FlipStart and others on the computing experience. With a physical size that's slightly larger than a PDA, a handtop has the power of a standard ultra-portable laptop - 1GHz, 256-512MB RAM, USB, FireWire, etc. These factors, coupled with a dock (plug in a monitor, keyboard and mouse) allow one to imagine a world where maybe they won't need a desktop, or laptop, or mp3 player, video jukebox, digicam, etc. Maybe one day companies might even be willing to pay for part of your handtop, knowing that they would have to invest less in upgrading? It's not all rosy, the devices are still under $2000 and aren't due out until later this fall (OQO) or Q1-2 2005 (FlipStart), but this is an important shift worth letting the mind ponder." Of course, the OQO has been in development for a while, now.

188 comments

  1. We may indeed establish an entirely new paradigm! by Scoria · · Score: 3, Funny

    Paradigm Shift

    So, who hijacked the time machine and transported us all to 1998?

    --
    Do you like German cars?
  2. Stupid form factor by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What's the point of these? They're still too big to carry in your pocket. If you're carrying a bag anyway, you're better off with an ultra-portable.

    1. Re:Stupid form factor by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, I'm waiting for the kneetops, fingertops, or eyelashtops, myself.

  3. So,,, by ArmenTanzarian · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Handtops.com has a piece about the revolutionary effect of the new handtops? You don't say...

    There's a lot of technology that goes nowhere, even with a vocal group of geeks behind it.

    1. Re:So,,, by EvilTwinSkippy · · Score: 1
      My 12" iBook is about as small as a computer can go and still be functional. I have a Clie with a color screen, and while balsy, it's really only good as a datebook and a way subject my victims to rolls of photographs of my infant daughter.

      I've tried the Clie for bus schedules. (SEPTA lets you pull them off the website in PDF) I either have to zoom out to the point that the text is illegable, or zoom in to the point that you are constantly scrolling to figure out which column is my stop. I actually find it faster to just keep the iBook in my laptop in sleep mode, and call up the schedules on screen.

      And of course, there is the matter of the keyboard...

      --
      "Learning is not compulsory... neither is survival."
      --Dr.W.Edwards Deming
    2. Re:So,,, by ArmenTanzarian · · Score: 1

      Exactly, not really "paradigm shifting" kinda stuff. I had a palm for a while, but with a desktop and a light laptop, I was like, why do I need more devices and one that waaaay underperforms?

    3. Re:So,,, by jdray · · Score: 1

      A true "paradigm shift" (blech!) will come when we have a way to get rid of keyboards all together, or at least for all but the most complicated tasks, and screens are virtualized, appearing in the air in front of us without some gum pack-thing hanging off of our temple. When my entire hardware kit can be dropped in my pocket like my cell phone -- for that matter, is embedded in my cell phone -- and I don't need to take it out of my pocket to use it, then I'll believe we've had a paradigm shift. Until then, it's evolutionary rather than revolutionary.

      --
      The Spoon
      Updated 6/28/2011
    4. Re:So,,, by janbjurstrom · · Score: 1
      My 12" iBook is about as small as a computer can go and still be functional.

      I've been looking at the 12" PowerBook, and thought the same way. But the Gizmodo people kind of changed that belief with this Panasonic R3 review. (That's a 12" PowerBook next to it in the picture... Tiiiny.)

      --
      668.5
  4. It won't replace the desktop by wheany · · Score: 2, Funny

    It won't replace the desktop at least as long as my fingers are not ultra portable as well.

    1. Re:It won't replace the desktop by Matrix_X · · Score: 1, Funny

      How are your fingers not ultra portable?
      I can take mine wherever I go, in fact, I have to take them wherever I go.

  5. Input by pedestrian+crossing · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The problem always comes back to the input device. Sure, you have your keyboard/mouse when you're docked, but when you're not, input just plain sucks...

    --
    A house divided against itself cannot stand.
    1. Re:Input by Timesprout · · Score: 2, Funny

      The solution is easy. If I am going to be away from my keyboard I carry a small philipino child around in my rucksack. When I need to something typed I just dictate to the kid and voila, tiny fingers do the typing.

      Note, kids require air food and water (not included with rucksack or handtop)

      --
      Do not try to read the dupe, thats impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth
      What truth?
      There is no dupe
    2. Re:Input by CommanderData · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Both the OQO and Flipstart have keyboards and a pointing device (trackstick and touchscreen on the OQO, touchpad and trackstick on the Flipstart). I know these aren't full size keyboards, but there are tons of people who type on even smaller, less functional ones. Look at the keyboards on Pocket PCs, Palms, and the Blackberry.

      --
      Urge to post... fading... fading... RISING!... fading... fading... gone.
    3. Re:Input by Zzootnik · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Actually, its not just that...there's one other part that needs improvement...the display. They could put a 9 ghz Opteron and Geforce 99999 in it, but watching on the dinky little screen would be a pain.
      I've read ebooks on a pda before and yes- it does work, but I'd really like to see some big innovation in display- like a small holograpic generator...I seem to recall seeing something about a micro projector that might work well even... combine that with that laser-traced displayed keyboard that you can display on any surface and use it, and there might be something pretty keen...Of course you'd have somewhere around 5 minutes of battery life... One problem at a time I guess.

      --
      Sig currently under construction. Mind the gap....
    4. Re:Input by halowolf · · Score: 3, Interesting
      What I think might help, but probably wouldn't take off is the fact that the keyboards on these types of devices are focused on replicating many keys on a standard keyboard when in practicality less keys than that are needed to perform the same job.

      Phones have the entire alphabet and extra characters mapped to 10 buttons and I personally hate putting in SMS messages with them. But there is no arguing that once you are proficient at it you can put them in quite fast. Though nowhere near as proficiently as if that person had the same capability with a full sized keyboard.

      What I think might help is if there was a standardized mini keyboard with multifunction keys that can represent a number of characters, similar to what a standard keyboard does but with a alot of thought put into efficient and fast typing with fewer keys. That way there are fewer keys required and they could be bigger for those big fingered folk. And since it would be a standardized layout there would be more chance of the design, catching on. Though the current situation of the patent world would proabably put the kibosh on that wishful thinking.

      However I have no illusion on a fantasy like this happening anytime soon, or if its even practical.

    5. Re:Input by Lumpy · · Score: 1, Insightful

      and they will fail miserably because of one thing...

      Vendor lock in mentaility. Until these "new" systems are based on a 100% open system they will fail. eBooks fail because everyone and theri brother hasto have their own format. So when Danny and his old RocketEbook part ways and he buy's a new-fangled ebook he now has to RE-BUY every one of his books. I'm not about to do that with my data and software. If I rely on a expense tracking system that holds it's data in a special XYZ file and then switch to a different brand of palmtop that now runs a completely different OS, I have to re-buy all my software just to access my data!

      Bull, make these things run a standard OS... windows if it has to be using a "popular" OS.

      This is one reason I settled on a Sharp zaurus, my data is 100% open and I can access it on my pda, my PC and elsewhere if I need to. and in 40 years that data is still readable by me.

      These things will be a failure until we start getting cooperation and open standard implimented.

      The concept is great, if I could snag my palmtop on my way out of the house, it has my music, the morning tribune, my schedule, mapping data, email etc.. that will allow me to listen to some music while I read the morning paper and alert or even innterupt me about important appointments that morning it would be great. The technology to do this wonderful information convergence is here today, but companies absolutely REFUSE to use open standards to make this happen.

      the hardware means nothing, It's in the stupid tricks companies try with these portables that lock a device to a specific vendor that kills them.

      and I do not see that changing within the next 10 years.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    6. Re:Input by ducman · · Score: 1

      I've been asking why something like this didn't exist for years. The reason that it still doesn't (really) exist is clear from these comments--nobody seems to "get it."

      I'm a consultant, and travel 100% of the time. I carry a laptop with me, but I virtually never actually use it on the plane. Instead, I go into a client office each day, and hook my laptop up to their monitor and network, and plug in the mouse I carry with me. I sit at that desk and work until late in the evening, then put the laptop in my bag and carry it back to the hotel.

      I would LOVE something the size of a paperback book that included a mid-range CPU, 512Mb of RAM, a 2.5" hard disk, and standard VGA, USB, 100 base T and PS/2 connectors. Then, most of the time, all I'd have to carry would be that little "brick." I'd have my own monitor, keyboard, and mouse at home, and make use of the monitor, keyboard and mouse on my desk at the client site.

      Of course, if I really needed to be able to use the thing on a flight, it seems like it would be easy for someone to design a laptop-type peripheral that you plugged the brick into.

      Of course, if everyone would just switch to Macs, I wouldn't need the whole computer in the brick, I could just use my external 2.5" firewire disk. But Windows won't run programs off the external disk without installing them....

      --
      "We have nothing in common, your attitude annoys me, and your political views are appalling."
    7. Re:Input by CommanderData · · Score: 2, Informative

      Um, I apologize if I mis-understood your post, but the OQO and Flipstart ARE full IBM-compatible PCs which last time I checked was a 100% open standard. The both run Windows XP. You could install Linux on them if you wanted to as well (as long as drivers are available for their video/audio chips). Granted they are not available just yet, but working systems have been shown to the public.

      These devices are meant as a single replacement for both your Zaurus and your desktop PC. Why have two devices, constantly syncing data or not having the applications you need on hand? At least that's the theory. I believe this first generation will be too underpowered to be of use to me.

      --
      Urge to post... fading... fading... RISING!... fading... fading... gone.
    8. Re:Input by geekboy2k · · Score: 1

      Yeah. I remember seeing that too somewhere... Oh yeah, here:

      http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0280674/

      (I keed, I keed!)

    9. Re:Input by Hognoxious · · Score: 1
      standardized mini keyboard with multifunction keys that can represent a number of characters
      So it would be bigger than a GSM number pad, but still less easy/intuitive than a proper keyboard. What a winner!
      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
    10. Re:Input by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      If I rely on a expense tracking system that holds it's data in a special XYZ file and then switch to a different brand of palmtop that now runs a completely different OS, I have to re-buy all my software just to access my data!
      You'd probably have to buy new software anyway if you changed OS. In any case, most software supports several different data formats. If you have one in common between the od & the new, fine. Alternatively you could do a one-off conversion.

      You, sir, are talking shite.

    11. Re:Input by nuggetman · · Score: 1

      Have you considered a Cappuccino PC? Most are about the size of your average CDROM drive.

      --
      ...and that's all there is to it.
    12. Re:Input by L.+VeGas · · Score: 1

      What a coincidence! I have one too. (not for typing)
      ------
      Michael Jackson

    13. Re:Input by Cpt_Kirks · · Score: 1

      If VIA ever gets off their ass and releases the nano-itx motherboards, what you want could be built fairly cheaply.

      The nano-itx is only 120mm on a side. I have plans for several of them (computer "brick", boom-box, portable DVD player, etc.).

    14. Re:Input by Zzootnik · · Score: 1

      ??? WTF? Never heard of that one... I was thinking more along the lines of that cool wrist computer from the final fantasy movie...
      http://www.rpgamer.com/games/ff/affw/ffmov/screens /ffm3.jpg (Wrist shot)

      --
      Sig currently under construction. Mind the gap....
    15. Re:Input by Gollum · · Score: 1

      How's this?

      http://www.digitwireless.com/

  6. not really close to desktop computing power by ecklesweb · · Score: 4, Insightful

    These handheld devices are getting more powerful and more useful, but with the specs listed (1GHz, 256-512 RAM), you're not really talking desktop or even normal laptop computing power. That's especially true given that these devices aren't coming out until the Fall or early 2005 (yeah, I'll believe it when I see it).

    Post a story when they pack computing power equivalent to a six-month old desktop into a handlheld form factor.

    1. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by wed128 · · Score: 2, Funny

      true...but 1Ghz is enough for menial tasks like office and webbrowsing...

      i do however think these things should run something like palmos, a tailored linux distro, or winCE to keep the memory/horsepower footprint down.

    2. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by Jeff+DeMaagd · · Score: 1

      I think you underestimate the power a 1GHz system can have.

      No, you won't be able to play DOOM 3 on it. But only hardcore gamers are playing that. Outside of specialized tasks, currently the rest of the world can do pretty well with 500MHz. My sister is using Windows XP, Open Office.org on a 300MHz PII laptop, and it runs pretty well.

      The power of a six month old desktop shouldn't be put into a portable device unless desktops suddenly became 5x more efficient. The desktop replacement devices are IMO worthless, and puting such a wasteful device in a handheld is silly.

    3. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by jcenters · · Score: 2, Insightful
      true...but 1Ghz is enough for menial tasks like office and webbrowsing...

      Huh? 500 mhz was more than enough for menial tasks like office and webbrowsing!

      Geez, I have an 800 mhz iBook that I use for Quark, Photoshop, software compilations, etc. Not to mention word processing, webbrowsing, music, and email.

      Talk about software bloat. What are you running, a beta copy of Longhorn?

      --

      vi ~/.emacs

    4. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by civilizedINTENSITY · · Score: 1

      My 800Mhz athlon/640MB PC-100 RAM, is slated for at least a couple more years of use. I dualboot linux and winxp, and run winxp under vmware under linux. Personally, I'd rather double my RAM than double my Mhz.

      In terms of formfactor, as a student, I wish I'd bought a laptop. But really what I need is PIM, notetaking (with adv. math symbols), and maxima & octave & emacs. I can wait to get back to my dorm to do heavy keyboarding, but I want/need to replace my HP-48. So a handheld looks very interesting...

    5. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      WTF? why is this modded as funny? I mean, aside from his sig...

    6. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by wed128 · · Score: 0, Redundant

      i'm running slackware on my 400mhz laptop, and i'm perfectly happy with it. But have you seen XP lately? BLOATBLOATBLOAT

    7. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      why? you dont need it.

      when do you need to compile software extremely fast while you are walking?? I can play back any multimedia and do 99% of your tasks with a 600mhz processor and with acceptable preformance.

      why do people think that faster = better? because it is not.

    8. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by fr0dicus · · Score: 1

      I'm not sure about anyone else but I can't think of anything that I'd want to do on a small machine like that that requires any more power than that. My only 'Wintel' PC is a 533Mhz C3 Mini-ITX Via box, and it runs Windows XP nicely with 512MB of Ram (minus a bit for shared graphics!).

    9. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Post a story when they pack computing power equivalent to a six-month old desktop into a handlheld form factor.

      No progress will ever take place if everyone adopts your "wait 'til it improves" POV, because the economy would stall and crash in the mean time. You're second-handing it, IOW, waiting for others to pay their fair share into the market to drive progress towards such devices, and complaining about it on the way. You're a dick.

      Anyway - given the increasing ubiquity of the 'net, your demands are asinine. Why not let your desktop do the CPU-intensive tasks... and direct it to do so using your ultra thin client? Why must the client be a mini-desktop when its primary design criteria is portability and mobile usability? Having contradictory primary design goals is a good way to produce a failed project. But failure's probably nothing new to you.

      In summary, stfu and die slowly. Thanks.

    10. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by CountBrass · · Score: 1

      Yes but those are magic PowerPC MHz: far superior to nasty old Intel MHz.

      Dual processing on a G5 since 2003 ;-) (Did I mention I also have a 23" widescreen: it impresses the ladies.)

      --
      Bad analogies are like waxing a monkey with a rainbow.
    11. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by jcenters · · Score: 1

      Well, that may be true, but there's simply no (logical) reason why anyone should need a whole 1 ghz for simple stuff.

      *sigh* Just imagine how far ahead we would be if it weren't for all this bloat. I could at least understand the bloat if these programs added a lot of extra functionality, but they don't.

      --

      vi ~/.emacs

    12. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by Hognoxious · · Score: 1
      "i do however think these things should run something like palmos, a tailored linux distro, or winCE to keep the memory/horsepower footprint down."

      Cough. Symbian. Cough.

      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
    13. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      but with the specs listed (1GHz, 256-512 RAM), you're not really talking desktop or even normal laptop computing power.

      Hey... So you're saying my 600MHz machine isn't really desktop computing power? Ok, so I've got more RAM than that (256+512 MB actually), but still...

      Compile speed: fast enough
      Playes video: yep (at 80-90% CPU...)
      UT2004 plays: smoothly, if ugly
      Posts to /.: checking...

    14. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by chrish · · Score: 1

      Bah. I run XP on a P2 333MHz laptop and it's just fine. Runs better there than Mandrake did, and uses less RAM as well.

      --
      - chrish
    15. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Bullshit.

    16. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by poot_rootbeer · · Score: 1

      with the specs listed (1GHz, 256-512 RAM), you're not really talking desktop or even normal laptop computing power.

      Yes, the downside is that they're only as powerful as a 2-3 year old notebook computer.

      The upside is that they're an order of magnitude more powerful than the average PDA currently on the market.

    17. Re:not really close to desktop computing power by aonaran · · Score: 1

      especially on the U70 which had a 1 Ghz Pentium M
      People severely underestimate the Pentium M because they are stuck on comparing Ghz ratings rather than real benchmarks.

      1Ghz is pretty standard for the new "Centrino" Pantium M laptops. 1.8Ghz is I think the highest they go, but they are good fast machines at that speed.

  7. Most Companies Will Not 'Go-Halfsies' by grunt107 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Maybe one day companies might even be willing to pay for part of your handtop, knowing that they would have to invest less in upgrading?

    Most companies want their information/apps locked into their computers - some even to the point of assigning a company laptop to perform off-site work.

    For small/medium companies with less sensitive data protection needs, it could help some of their bottom line. But employee expenses will be their major reduction focus.

  8. Still UNDER $2000? by Elecore · · Score: 2, Funny

    Shame... I mean, I can't wait until the prices rises. I'm not buying one until they are AT LEAST $5000.

  9. No, it's not time.. by sporty · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Each of my hands, (I have two), in a relatively relaxed open position, are somewhere between 4 and 5 inches wide, from thumb to pinky (narf). When my eyes are tired, focusing on distant objects becomes "hard".

    Tiny screen plus uber small keybaord? No tnx. If i have the realestate, I rather have my 18" or however wide keyboard it is + a 19" monitor. For travelling, I rather have something big enough but not outweigh an every-day text book plus wide enough that I'm not squinting and can see my screen, w/o carrying around a full sized monitor.

    --

    -
    ping -f 255.255.255.255 # if only

  10. AH!!! by kinema · · Score: 3, Funny

    That was way too much hype and marketing speak this early in the morning.

  11. One Device for everything by Noizemonger · · Score: 1

    I personal long for the time when i will have just ONE portable device for everything (phone, email, calendar, Word prcessing, Internet etc) and one central server at home. I think this would be possible already, but the main problem is the lack of good design and innovative IO-Solutions (wheres my foldable Keyboard?).

    1. Re:One Device for everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      Here. The Bluetooth version is very cool.

  12. Heat by oasis3582 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I have a really tough time believing that these things remain at a bearable temperature. Laptops with these same processors can still get hot on the old lap. Does anyone have the Sony or know what sort of thermal protection these have? (if any) Might be a nice feature to have in a $2k gadget. Also, how quiet are these things?

  13. OQO-due1Q2045 by Overzeetop · · Score: 1, Funny

    OQO has been in "next quarter" status for, what, 3 years now? They get /.'ed about every 6 months with their "any day now" press releases. Don't call me until is ships.

    No, I take that back.

    Don't call me until version 3 actually arrives. Anything with so many delays (usu the result of design or production difficulties) is going to be crap on its first two releases.

    --
    Is it just my observation, or are there way too many stupid people in the world?
  14. invest less in upgrading? by Gothmolly · · Score: 4, Informative

    You'll invest MORE in upgrading, since these little überdevices are completely closed, from a platform, and probably source/OS perspective. Need the new wireless standard? Sorry. Need a RAM upgrade to run Longhorn? Sorry. Need a dual-head video card for a special project? Sorry. Neat PDA though, can you watch Seinfeld on the way to work?
    I predict that the more this appeals to someone in your office, the less work that person does to begin with.

    --
    I want to delete my account but Slashdot doesn't allow it.
    1. Re:invest less in upgrading? by HeyLaughingBoy · · Score: 2, Insightful
      You'll invest MORE in upgrading

      I don't think that's really an issue; in 6 years of S/W development at this job, I have *never* had a computer upgraded piecemeal: IT just rolls out completely new PCs every 2 years (or earlier if we complain about something). Right now we have 1.6GHz Thinkpads with 512M ram running Win2k Pro and that'll be just fine for a few more years development.

      But I don't see the need for any more portability in the office environment. If I have to take my notepad to a meeting, I just eject it from a docking station and go to the meeting where it will automatically connect to the wireless network if I don't plug it into a network outlet. If I had a smaller device, now I'd need to also take along a full size keyboard to use it efficiently and that would defeat the whole portability issue.
      Where I do see these things taking off is in lab and service use. There have been many times I've wished for a tiny PC that I could use to snoop on a serial line as I'm integrating a new device our EE dept just built, instead of having to balance a full size PC and monitor on a lab cart. Service people could connect to a machine with a tiny handheld device that could have service manuals and extensive diagnostics. This is where it would be really useful in my world.

  15. Handjob? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

    Gee, I'd rather stay in the blowjob paradigm, thank you very much.

  16. goggles to eliminate the lcd screen by klang · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Is there any PDA, labtop or the like without any form of screen, only with a set of goggles or a head-up display?

    I want the big screen, but I don't want to carry it around .. I would say that a set of high definition LCD goggles would do the trick .. and be less power consuming as they wouldn't have to be very big?

    1. Re:goggles to eliminate the lcd screen by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, search google for "virtual boy".

    2. Re:goggles to eliminate the lcd screen by oasis3582 · · Score: 1

      plus, you'd look REALLY cool on the train going to work!

    3. Re:goggles to eliminate the lcd screen by way2trivial · · Score: 1

      no, search for sony glasstrons.. they made a VGA model...

      --
      every day http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random
    4. Re:goggles to eliminate the lcd screen by salah67 · · Score: 1

      you may check Xybernaut website they have nice HUD computer. But they mostly target workers that need hands-free operation.

    5. Re:goggles to eliminate the lcd screen by klang · · Score: 1

      well, I do want both hands free for the keyboard anyway, so this might be an idea :-)

    6. Re:goggles to eliminate the lcd screen by klang · · Score: 1

      theese are nice, but resolusion is limited to 600x800 ..

  17. Yeah right. by Dark+Lord+Seth · · Score: 1

    My bullshit detector just went through a Paradigm Shift.

    - Seth

  18. Old idea, new (possibly better) implementation? by Solra+Bizna · · Score: 1

    This sounds [vaguely] similiar to what the PowerBook Duo was supposed to become. The Duo had several problems that prevented it from catching on; will these "handtops" go the same way?
    -:sigma.SB

    --
    WARN
    THERE IS ANOTHER SYSTEM
  19. doom3 by fulana_lover · · Score: 2, Funny

    This must be the pda the doom3 guy was carrying! They really need to put a flashlight on it though.

    1. Re:doom3 by SurryMt · · Score: 1

      Enter the OQO Duct Tape Mod!!!

  20. Skip the article by mst76 · · Score: 1

    Save your time, the "article" reads like a blatant piece of astroturfing with an unhealthy dose of wishful thinking. Unless the price of these "handtops" drop under $1000 fast, they'll be an even bigger flop than the Tablet-PC.

    1. Re:Skip the article by lucabrasi999 · · Score: 1
      a blatant piece of astroturfing with an unhealthy dose of wishful thinking

      Are you sure you aren't reading my project deliverable?

    2. Re:Skip the article by wed128 · · Score: 1

      the tablet PC hasn't flopped...it is still used in industry and niche fields. This is exactly where a device like this is headed. It will drop off the public scope and exist only within it's niche of usefullness.

    3. Re:Skip the article by tabrnaker · · Score: 1

      Have you ever met a chinese person??? You have a very incorrect and disrespectful sig.

    4. Re:Skip the article by wed128 · · Score: 1

      I'm sorry if I have offended you. I didn't mean it, i was merely quoting Monty Python. I have changed my sig. Have a nice day!

  21. Of course by laserbeak · · Score: 1, Funny

    The PDA's will be supplied by the UAC- 'brining you a better future!'

  22. Why companies should pay for a 'handtop' by Supp0rtLinux · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Here's my company's current standard for mobile users:

    $1700.00 - IBM Thinkpad T41
    $150.00 - Port replicator
    $80.00 - Extra battery
    $200.00 - Motorola T720/T730 Cell phone
    $350.00 - Palm or Sony PDA
    $800.00 - Software... PDA sync software add-ons, cell phone addy book sync software, etc.
    -------
    $3300.00 approx

    Compared to the OQO alternative:
    $2000.00 - OQO
    $200.00 - Cell phone with bluetooth and GPRS for all-time internet access
    --------
    $2200.00 approx + added productivity capabilities.
    So... in the near future it would seem we could save $1000.00 per user and get increased productivity. Not much justifying and convincing to do it would seem...

    1. Re:Why companies should pay for a 'handtop' by Xugumad · · Score: 4, Funny

      Realising the device you left on the train contained absolutely everything... priceless :)

    2. Re:Why companies should pay for a 'handtop' by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It gets even better when you consider "semi-mobile" users who not only have the Laptop and Palm PDA, but also have a full desktop unit in their office that gets used about twice a week. The OQO is expected to be used at your desk and on the go by office workers, so no desktop needed (just the docking stand and monitor, keyboard and mouse).

      Add another $1000 to $1500 for that to your original $3300 estimate and you can really see a cost savings for the OQO in a business setting. Of course the OQO specs are woefully inadequate for anything other than Microsoft Office, e-mail and web browsing, so it may not appeal to your average /. reader.

    3. Re:Why companies should pay for a 'handtop' by lucabrasi999 · · Score: 3, Insightful
      So... in the near future it would seem we could save $1000.00 per user and get increased productivity. Not much justifying and convincing to do it would seem...

      Yes, but today, the laptop actually works.

    4. Re:Why companies should pay for a 'handtop' by garcia · · Score: 1

      $200.00 - Cell phone with bluetooth and GPRS for all-time internet access

      Or, depending on your needs, a PCMCIA card that accept the GPRS slice.

    5. Re:Why companies should pay for a 'handtop' by CommanderData · · Score: 1

      $200.00 - Cell phone with bluetooth and GPRS for all-time internet access
      Or, depending on your needs, a PCMCIA card that accept the GPRS slice.


      Except that the OQO and Flipstart are lacking PCMCIA slots. No CompactFlash slot either... Too bad they crippled them like that.

      --
      Urge to post... fading... fading... RISING!... fading... fading... gone.
    6. Re:Why companies should pay for a 'handtop' by sehryan · · Score: 1

      Um, if they are going to dock the OQO, why don't they just dock their laptop? All the power, files they worked on during travel all ready available, and no extra cost.

      --
      The world moves for love. It kneels before it in awe.
    7. Re:Why companies should pay for a 'handtop' by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      tell me something...how many dicks in your life you suck?

  23. Re:We may indeed establish an entirely new paradig by lucabrasi999 · · Score: 3, Funny
    Paradigm Shift

    BINGO!!!!

  24. XP Home by oasis3582 · · Score: 1

    Here's a funny thing: You have to figure that the vast majority of people buying these are going to be the corporate types trying to replace their Blackberries with something even more functional. So why do most of these damn things have XP Home on them?!?!

  25. Yes, But.... by cflorio · · Score: 0

    What's the Battery life like?

    1. Re:Yes, But.... by nuggetman · · Score: 1

      And can it run Linux?

      --
      ...and that's all there is to it.
  26. Newton! by imag0 · · Score: 1

    Shift your Paradigm's till your fucking blue in the face. I want newton '05.

    1. Re:Newton! by oasis3582 · · Score: 1

      No shit right? I cant believe that Apple is staying out of the PDA/ handtop business so long. Think how much people would pay for a PDA that looked like an iPod.

    2. Re:Newton! by Daniel+Dvorkin · · Score: 2, Insightful

      A mix of politics and once-bitten, I think. The Newton was a beautiful piece of hardware that turned out to be a financial disaster -- and right when it was showing signs of not being a disaster was when Jobs came back to Apple, and IIRC the Newton was one of the first things to get "Steved." Which is really too bad, because if they'd stuck with it, it could have captured the mindshare (and market share) Palm did a couple of years later. Now, I suspect that anyone who suggests any kind of handheld computer at Apple is greeted with a mix of disdain and horror.

      --
      The correlation between ignorance of statistics and using "correlation is not causation" as an argument is close to 1.
    3. Re:Newton! by oasis3582 · · Score: 1

      Very well said. However, I think that we are in an age where techies have a great deal of disposable income, and would like nothing better than to own an Apple iPDA or an iCellPhone. Sexiness in design is becoming almost as important as functionality, and few take note of that as much as Apple. Also, the more they branch out into other sectors, the more computers (read: OSX copies) they will sell. I'd be interested to see how many people bought their first Apple computer after they got their iPods.

    4. Re:Newton! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Really I agree, but just want to add that Apple was in serious financial trouble at the time... without cutting the Newton, R&D for os X would not have been possible. Now that they are doing better, prototypes of the next small thing are in development. Steve is waiting for the fuel cell and other hardware though.

  27. not something I'm interested in by Pidder · · Score: 3, Interesting
    These factors, coupled with a dock (plug in a monitor, keyboard and mouse) allow one to imagine a world where maybe they won't need a desktop, or laptop, or mp3 player, video jukebox, digicam, etc.

    Multifunctional devices are all dandy but I don't see how they could compete with devices designed for one thing only. Sure, things develop and multifunctional devices get better people might say but so does the single purpose device. There are mp3 players you connect to your mobile phone but will they ever get as good or compete with say, the iPod?

    Will the camera in most mobile phones ever get as good as a good digital camera? I doubt it.

    It's just too expensive and difficult to bring the best of everything into a device of this kind. You compromise and hope that someone REALLY NEEDS all these things in small package enough to be willing to pay alot of money for it. I certainly won't.

    1. Re:not something I'm interested in by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This is not the same as putting an mp3 player or a camera on a phone. This is taking that multi-function general-purpose computer sitting on your desk and making it ultra-portable. Last I checked, PCs have been doing really well as multi-function devices. If you can shrink it down and manage to lose no more functionality than a >800x600 interface, I see no reason a handtop wouldn't be just as useful. A system with the same functionality as a PC but with more portability than a laptop seems like an instant win to me.

    2. Re:not something I'm interested in by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      There are mp3 players you connect to your mobile phone but will they ever get as good or compete with say, the iPod?
      If you can buy faggoty white headphones for them, then yes.
    3. Re:not something I'm interested in by Lumpy · · Score: 1

      expensive is not even the word....

      sony has the U70 out and you can actually buy it.

      want to upgrade from 256 to 512 meg of ram? the ram module costs $400.00

      want a battery that lasts longer than the silly 2 hour battery? Shell out another $350.00

      oh that dock?? it's a pricey $700.00

      hell the leatherette case for it costs $150!!!

      thes ethings are nothing but Executive toys. they are tablet Pc's that are scaled down too far. and their cost is insane.

      call me when the battery is 2X the life and 1/2 the price.

      in otherwords... never.

      the same fate kills ebooks, readers are $300 - $500 US until they are discontinued, then people start buying them (the ones that have an open content platform so you can upload your own books) at the price they would pay... $50.00 - $150.00

      I picked up a few ebookman EBM-911's for $50.00 each with all accessories for gifts this year. nobody in their right mind would buy them at their retail $295.00

      same goes for these "palmtops" get a tablet PC and pay less for more functionality.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
  28. Useful? by RAMMS+EIN · · Score: 1

    ``With a physical size that's slightly larger than a PDA, a handtop has the power of a standard ultra-portable laptop - 1GHz, 256-512MB RAM''

    Reading that made me feel a bit icky. It has the size of a device one would like to use on the road, but specifications that likely make that unfeasable (battery life?). So it's not good for on the road, maybe it's good on the desktop? Well, I doubt whether such machines will use standard parts, so upgrades/customizations will be expensive if not impossible.

    Handtops may still be useful for those who travel a lot, but not that long that they would need stellar battery life. However, PDAs have not been crazily successful, and one step up there is Apple's iBook, which is very hard to beat.

    Now, of course, if someone made cheap, really low power computers with standard network, storage, and input interfaces, that would be something.

    --
    Please correct me if I got my facts wrong.
    1. Re:Useful? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The site's down (big surprise), so I don't know. Do you know what kind of processor it is? If it's a 1GHz P4, you've got a point. If it's a 1GHz P4M, then that's not so bad. If it's something even more energy efficient such as a Transmeta or C3, then my concern about battery life shifts to the hard drive.

    2. Re:Useful? by captainJam · · Score: 1

      the battery life is one of the shortcomings. currently, handtop mfg's are quoting a life of anywhere from 2 to 5 hours. with the latter figure for the extended batteries. if you intend to use it 2-3 hours NONSTOP, then no, it might not be great for you just yet. but if you use it 2-3 hours total over the course of your day (like you might do with a cellphone) it would work fine in standby mode. the ibook looks fine, there are even smaller laptops, but they're LAPtops. you can't just stop in the middle of the road and whip out your laptop, you can't hang out in chapters or indigo and do price comparisons online with amazon.ca, etc etc.

  29. They're not out yet, by Threni · · Score: 1

    but this press release states quite clearly that these things will replace home PCs...

    Yeah, sure they will.

    1. Re:They're not out yet, by captainJam · · Score: 1

      it's not a press release, it's an op-ed piece. and nowhere does it say that handtops will replace home pc's. RTFA please.

    2. Re:They're not out yet, by Threni · · Score: 1

      > nowhere does it say that handtops will replace home pc's.

      It says precisely that:

      > With a physical size that's slightly larger than a PDA, a handtop has the power
      > of a standard ultra-portable laptop - 1GHz, 256-512MB RAM, USB, FireWire, etc.
      > These factors, coupled with a dock (plug in a monitor, keyboard and mouse)
      > allow one to imagine a world where maybe they won't need a desktop, or laptop,
      > or mp3 player, video jukebox, digicam, etc

  30. Portable hard disk by Xugumad · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Would seem more useful to me, to have a portable hard disk. Cheaper, and about as easy to type on...

    I have a 15" PowerBook. It's a good size. A little small, but definitely usable. I dock it to a keyboard, mouse and monitor when at work. This suits me perfectly.

    Given that I walk wherever possible (any journey under a couple of miles, which includes my trip to work), with this laptop, and weight isn't a big issue, why would I want something smaller and less powerful?

  31. Slow? by spectrokid · · Score: 2, Insightful
    And it takes how long to boot XP? In case you meet a friend in the shopping center and quickly need to give him a phone nr... boot, Login, load Outlook, no I FUCKING KNOW I AM NOT ONLINE,...

    There was this story not long ago on a Laptop that would have primitive PIM functions in BIOS. Sounds a lot cooler to me.

    --

    10 ?"Hello World" life was simple then

    1. Re:Slow? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      The Flipstart will have PIM functions and Outlook access through a small LCD on the cover, so no need to even open the device and boot up! I think it may need to be in standby mode for that to work, but it's a start.

    2. Re:Slow? by mobby_6kl · · Score: 1

      WinXP supports the fucking standby mode! It takes my three year old laptop(900mhz PIII) about 2 seconds to go from standby mode to desktop.

    3. Re:Slow? by captainJam · · Score: 1

      right, as others point out, you can keep the device in standby mode, which is how it's intended to be used. and the FlipStart handtop comes with a LID module that has a small LCD on the top of the unit where you can access your contacts, mp3's, email, etc. without having to turn the unit on (or at least out of standby).

  32. The Sony models are neat and avavilable by Hast · · Score: 1

    I just got back from a summer in Japan and the Sony models (U-50 and U-70) were all over the place there. I never did see anyone actually using one though.

    But as a PDA/Laptop thingy they pose a good compromise. For some reason they (Sony) failed to put in Bluetooth in them which seems like a failiure of biblical proportions. Not only can I then not use it with my phone I can also not use wireless mouse and keyboard with it. For me that made it easy to decide against getting one. (Not sure if I would have otherwise, but I did get a PDA there so it's not unthinkable.)

    They are wonderful bits of technology though, I'd love to get my hands on one.

    1. Re:The Sony models are neat and avavilable by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not that I like those models, 'cuz I don't, but I wish wireless standards to always be available as add on cards. The standards are still shifting, and I'd hate to toss an expensive device because it can only use 802.11b say, or bluetooth etc.

    2. Re:The Sony models are neat and avavilable by Obfuscant · · Score: 1
      I just got back from a summer in Japan and the Sony models (U-50 and U-70) were all over the place there. I never did see anyone actually using one though.

      After reading about the U-[5|7]0, I actually bought one (the U-70). I've had it for two weeks, so I'm still aclimatizing myself to it, but here's my initial impressions.

      • The screen is REALLY SMALL. This is both a blessing and a curse. It does have sufficient resolution to read a "page", but you have to hold it close to your face. (Being old doesn't help.)
      • The battery life (rated) is short. 2.5 hours.
      • It fits in the hand really well.
      • The display rotates so it looks more like a normal portrait page.
      • Built-in wireless is handy, the ability to shut it off is handier.
      • The lack of firewire on the portable part is silly. I have portable firewire disks that I cannot use with this, and, of course, the first firewire/USB portable disk I found was a POS (not sbp2 for firewire).
      • Text input without the keyboard is a pain. It is pretty easy to poke the on-screen keyboard, but that chances damaging the touch-screen. Using the mouse is slow, but for small things, ok.
      • Lack of bluetooth is not a problem. The D-Link DBT 120 would fit in the USB on the unit without being ugly or ungainly, and it is pretty cheap (compared to the price of the whole unit!)
      • The 20Gb disk is a REAL limit. It's not big enough to keep much video, and it makes a too-expensive MP3 player.
      The most I've used it is in two situations: I was in a set of meetings where I could do real work while still being in the meeting, and at home where I could watch stuff off my PVR while sitting in my comfy chair.

      Was it worth $2800? Dunno yet. The real test is to see if it works its way into my daily routine, which is hasn't yet. That is partially because of the week of meetings, which has kept me from trying Linux on it yet.

      If I scored it on cool factor, thought, it gets A-plus. Everyone who has seen it has been impressed.

  33. Is it really superior to a Palm? by ceeam · · Score: 1

    1Ghz is surely impressive (if not hot) but it's not a question of how big is it, it's about what you can do with it. Let's see how does it improve on a typical current PDA:

    Q: Can I (easily) type on it? Using 6, 8, 10 fingers?
    Q: Can I (comfortably) watch a 16:9 movie? With surround sound?
    Q: Digicam you say? What, with optical zoom and flash?
    Q: Surely I can take it with me into the wild and the batteries last forever?

    Well - I gonna stick with a handheld instead of "handtop" I guess. No, really.

  34. *under* $2000? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    > It's not all rosy, the devices are still under $2000

    I would have thought it would be less rosy for them to be *over* $2000. I mean, my watch cost me $30 - that's less than $2000.

    Oh, you meant '*just* under $2000)? I see...

  35. Could be done today, just need a 2.5 in hard disk by GuyFawkes · · Score: 1


    SO you have a machine where everything is there EXCEPT a hard disk, it just has a pcmcia type slot, along you come with your 2.5 inch hard disk, pop it in the slot, boot up and away you go....

    Quite apart from the resiliance linux has towards changing hardware, which beats windows hands down everyone except the most crucial area of all, eg graphics cards, especially nvidia ati, linux will handle changes of motherboard / cpu / etc much better than windows, perhaps some of the EXCELLENT functionality of the knoppix hardware autodetection could be built in....

    Anyway, all you carry around is your data, plug it into a desktop, laptop, pda, whatever.

    Could make a lot of sense in a company big enough to make such a system worthwhile, only caveat is such a system would need a totally solid backup solution for when users lose or damage their laptop hard disks... such a system has many advantages and could be made pretty secure too, with the sole exception of an employee who either lost their disk and did not report it, or allowed it to be cloned.

    Could be a lot of fun to set up too. Epecially is technology moves along and we get there new 2 Tb flash drives with more useful read/write life than present flash stuff.

    --
    http://slashdot.org/~GuyFawkes/journal
  36. Simple pocket space. by SmallFurryCreature · · Score: 2, Interesting
    I got a factory job where I need ear protection for safety and listen to music for sanity (listening to machines for 8 hours would drive me MAD MAD I TELL YOU!!!!)

    With travel time that is just a little bit to much for my Nomad Zen. So I got two Mp3 player, an iGb-100 (small 1.5gb player from iRiver) in my pockter and the Zen on my belt. I got my wallet of course. Usually some small change and other stuff and my phone. Keys and the job alone adds one for the locker and one tag for signing in and out. A knife and pen. Maybe a roll of drop (candy).

    In short I need a belt just to keep my damn pants from sliding down.

    I could of course bring a book to read in the breaks or a GBA.

    Can you imagine the bulge in my pockets? I don't care about my looks and work in place where people don't care either but in a suit this doesn't look good.

    So yeah I see some sense in these multi-capabilty devices. They are not for me as the phone-mp3-game don't have the storage to play music for 8+ hours or the battery life.

    No the camera in a phone or pda will never be as good as a dedicated camera. But if you need/want to make photo and send it with your camera then I wish you luck with your external camera, good luck in finding a way to connect the two, in getting the phone to regonize the camera, in making sure the phone messaging format can be used with your camera's storage format. Etc etc etc.

    You are walking around with two devices, the guy with the cameraphone with 1. Add an mp3 player and you got 3, the guy with the supergadget still got 1. Add a game platform and you got 4 devices, the guy with supergadget still got one. Add a PDA function and you got 5 devices. The guy with the supergadget only 1.

    Sure you will beat him in functionality but he doesn't look like a geek.

    --

    MMO Quests are like orgasms:

    You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.

    1. Re:Simple pocket space. by Pidder · · Score: 1
      Sure you will beat him in functionality but he doesn't look like a geek.

      I am a geek :-)

    2. Re:Simple pocket space. by Pidder · · Score: 1

      Not enough of a geek to get the damn html right tough...

  37. Until we get better batteries... by Ragnarr · · Score: 5, Insightful

    It's super that they want to stick faster processors with better screens into smaller devices, however I think we forget the main limiting factor. Batteries have not changed in 10 years, and I think until we can develop a device that runs reasonably well (> 2 hours) on current technology we're still at the same point we are now. Give me better batteries, not faster processors!

    1. Re:Until we get better batteries... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why work on faster batteries when doing so would put decent, money-grubbing battery company executives out of their office? Hooray for an economy focused on creating as many recurring charges as possible. No, we can't just make something that will last forever, it needs to break after 3 years so we can make a quick buck!

    2. Re:Until we get better batteries... by bithead2u · · Score: 1

      But they have improved--battery life is now measured in minutes instead of seconds!

  38. Re:We may indeed establish an entirely new paradig by laejoh · · Score: 2, Funny
  39. That's some crazy company by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Any company that spends that much to keep you connected is ignoring its bottom line. You don't need both a company pda and a company laptop. Make the average employee lug the laptop around--it's cheaper anyway if you just add Wi-Fi. As for the handtop, have you seen how underpowered they already are? If you're doing light enough tasks to use a handtop, you didn't need such a high-end laptop. For most people your example system doesn't need a port replicator. The sync software is either included with the PDA and phone or won't be as expensive as you think. For example, CommonTime's Lotus Notes ActiveSync product is $100 a year and Outlook syncs with PocketPCs out of the box. As for the cell phone, what's that? A free phone with service contract? WE'LL TAKE IT.
    And get the extended battery, who wants to lug around a second battery when they could use the larger battery and have it fit better?

  40. Oh no! Input-ville is in danger! by NWRefund · · Score: 1

    This sounds like a job for... http://alphagrip.com/

  41. Rosy by bestguruever · · Score: 2, Funny

    It's not all rosy, the devices are still under $2000

    Yes, things will be much more rosy when they are over $2000.

    --
    if you think this is bad, you should have seen my last sig
    1. Re:Rosy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Things will be much less italicized if you learn to close your I tags.

    2. Re:Rosy by bestguruever · · Score: 1
      </I>
      Happy now? Oddly enough, I did close it the first time around.
      --
      if you think this is bad, you should have seen my last sig
  42. I think this is totally the future by asoap · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Not now, but eventually. Especially now that we have more and more wireless products. I think with wireless this will totally be the way to go.

    Imagine carrying around this thing and it will have all your stuff on it. You get up and go to work, you toss this thing in your suit case. You get in the car and your computer's stereo starts reading your mp3s via wireless. Get to the office, toss the thing on the desk, and via wireless it's already talking to your monitor, keyboard, mouse and speakers.

    Get home, you toss this thing on it's recharge station, and you can start puterizing from home.

    Going on a bike ride? Toss this thing in your backpack, and start listening to your mp3s via wireless headphones.

    Or if you go on vacation, and you start snapping off photos with your digital camera, this computer could be automatically uploading the photos to the internet for your family to see. (hopefully you're not taking photos of yourself and some women of the night)

    I think this will totally be the future, but not yet.

    -asoap

    --
    Treat me like a marketing stat, and I'll treat your movie like a series of ones and zeros
    1. Re:I think this is totally the future by coulls · · Score: 1

      I believe they call it 'bluetooth'.

    2. Re:I think this is totally the future by asoap · · Score: 1
      That's what it's called.

      All they need now is to get it secure, and make it common enough that these things will work together easily.

      I think we are close. The pieces are there, they just have to make it all work together. Plus they have to make it faster then 1 ghz.

      I think one of the biggest issues is going to be security.

      -asoap

      --
      Treat me like a marketing stat, and I'll treat your movie like a series of ones and zeros
  43. cheap shitty gear by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    truth is i actualy like to have shitty cheap gear that just doesnt do everything. for example if i go hiking or whatever and my cell falls out of my pocket on some rocks im not worried that im going to lose all of my music, designs, etc.
    its just a cell so whatever its going to be fine, but if i had to tote along along a handheld does all unit id be a little nervouse to have fun with it in my backpack.

  44. Dude! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I found just what you are looking for! a laptop - just don't get the one called a P-P-P-Powerbook...

  45. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 1

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  46. *sigh* by Pez+Maker · · Score: 1, Insightful

    I'm so damned sick of all these stupid gadgets. I want a cell phone to be a cell phone. A computer to be a computer. wtf, quit limiting my product choices by throwing them all into one.

    Asshats

    1. Re:*sigh* by Pez+Maker · · Score: 1

      Perhaps I should have stated this differently. I'm unhappy with the trend of trying to make everything into on single gadget. I'm against mobos with everything built in, cell phones with cameras, pdas with cell phones. I don't believe my parent post is troll "worthy", but whatever. Apparently these days thinking different from the mob constitutes as being a troll.

  47. Cost by abulafia · · Score: 3, Funny
    t's not all rosy, the devices are still under $2000

    You're right. These things won't take off until they cost about $5000.

    --
    I forget what 8 was for.
  48. Won't work: see Newton by hcdejong · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Without RTFA (it's already /.ed), I'd have to say this sounds a lot like the Apple Newton. I.e. it won't work because it's too big to fit in a pocket, and to small to work comfortably on it. Until we get usable and affordable goggles, and/or plus some kind of input technology that's truly portable [1], these devices won't take off.

    1: e.g. digital paper, so I can fold an A3-sized screen/tablet into an A6 package.

    1. Re:Won't work: see Newton by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Have you seen what happens to a piece of paper in your pocket? No thanks. I'll take a frogpad and a forearm display though!

      p.s. the Newton still works for a lot of people. True it isn't for sale at compusa, but it should be.

    2. Re:Won't work: see Newton by hcdejong · · Score: 1

      Duh, that's what pocket protectors are for.

      Seriously: "digital paper" doesn't necessarily mean you have to treat it like paper. You can put it into a hard shell. It just means the display is thin enough to fold it like a sheet of paper.

    3. Re:Won't work: see Newton by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually although the Newton was unsuccessful in its early years, it was successful at the time of its cancellation and had been since the MP2000 days. Why kill a profitable product? Pick your favorite theory: the personal dislike Steve had for the pet project of his rival or the $150 million given from Microsoft to Apple just prior to the axeing...

  49. Yes, I definitely am looking forward to this... by Hanno · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I own a JVC microlaptop (which is actually built by Asus and rebranded by JVC) and I'm totally thrilled by it.

    Around 900 g, about the size of VHS tape, a keyboard that I can comfortably touchtype with (and I think my hands are pretty normal). This is a great device - it runs Linux, has a 20 GB harddisk and is fast enough to watch movies on its 16:9 display.

    I did own a normal 3 kg laptop some years ago and I'm not looking back. I don't own a car and travel by bike and bus - everything more than 1 kg is an annoyance then.

    Yes, I'd love to own an even smaller device. I once bought the Zaurus in the hopes of having a PDA-sized Linux computer, but without a harddisk and without the possibility of connecting an external keyboard, it wasn't worth using and collects dust as one of the most expensive toys I ever bought.

    I'm looking forward to a PDA-sized x86 computer with a harddisk, a decent display and good battery time. I also need connectors for an external display, keyboard and (if possible) TV. Count me in as one of their first customers.

    --

    ------------------
    You may like my a cappella music
    1. Re:Yes, I definitely am looking forward to this... by HeyLaughingBoy · · Score: 1
      I don't own a car and travel by bike and bus

      It's good to get this perspective sometimes. It's been so long since I didn't have a car I forget how inconvenient some things I take for granted can be. I like my Thinkpad T40 cause I can walk around the building with it and if I take it home, I just put it in a Targus bag and toss it in the back of the car. But if I had to take it on my bike or lug it around on the multiple busses it would take me to get home, it would be a pain: the combo of T40, external power supply, extra battery and bag gets uncomfortable real fast.
    2. Re:Yes, I definitely am looking forward to this... by Hanno · · Score: 1

      It's good to get this perspective sometimes

      I also travel by train a lot. On German speed trains, you now see lots of people using laptops. You could start lan parties with the people you just met on the trip.

      It's funny how often people in the train approach me and ask about my microlaptop. Although it's already more than 2 years old, it must still be fascinating to every nerd seing it. Some people already asked me how I like Windows CE and are surprised when they learn that it's a full-blown PC and runs KDE. :-)

      --

      ------------------
      You may like my a cappella music
    3. Re:Yes, I definitely am looking forward to this... by TurtlesAllTheWayDown · · Score: 1
      I once bought the Zaurus in the hopes of having a PDA-sized Linux computer, but without a harddisk and without the possibility of connecting an external keyboard, it wasn't worth using and collects dust as one of the most expensive toys I ever bought.

      May I ask which Zaurus you bought?

      The older, international Zauruses (SL-5000D, SL5500, SL5600) were a difficult ergonomic pickle, being rather larger and heavier than any other PDA on the market, having the advantage of a tiny keyboard and awkward, fairly dim display. The Zaurus C-series are actually a bit smaller than the 5x00, but have *much* larger keyboard and bigger, brighter screen. The keys are less responsive (membrane) but it's large enough that small (read: Japanese) fingers are able to touch-type.

      IR-based external keyboards (for other PDAs) work fine for both models, and with large enough CF and SD media, you can have a few gb of storage space (smaller than a HD, but much less fragile).

      The ability to keep my [portable] in my pocket does *wonders* for having it always-available, and I find that I use it more frequently than any laptop or larger device I've had before on account of that ubiquity.

      It seems as though you and I may be on the cusp of Zaurus useability; myself not far removed, but enough that I find the Z actually works for me. It's a full "laptop replacement" for what I use a laptop for-

      • network terminal
      • development scratchpad
      • text editor
      • game box
      • music box
      • video (though with only a few GB on CF, there's only enough space for an hour or two of)
      I get about 4-5 hours of battery life with the latter three tasks, maybe 5-8 hours for the first few. The Zaurus C-series are only available in Japan, or from importers-

      I'd probably welcome an x86-based handheld, but not if it were any larger, or runtime shorter.

    4. Re:Yes, I definitely am looking forward to this... by Hanno · · Score: 1

      May I ask which Zaurus you bought?

      I bought the SL5500 in Europe. Adding CF/SD cards, an IR keyboard, a WLAN card (which cannot be used while using a CF harddisk) makes the whole PDA experience clunky and extremely expensive. Also, I found both the original Linux distribution and the alternative Opie for the Zaurus a pain to use.

      Overall, I paid less for my JVC microlaptop than the combined cost of a Zaurus with the added devices you describe would have cost me. The Zaurus gives me a very limited Linux experience. The Linux applications aren't very stable, both the original distribution and the alternative OPIE didn't convince me. My microlaptop can run any Linux app I want, has 386 MB of Ram, a 20 GB harddisk. Granted, it has only half the battery time, but I can live with that.

      I still prefer my old greyscale PalmPilot's addressbook to the applications that the Zaurus provides. Usability of the Zaurus is very limited from my experience, both keyboard and pen input. It's true that the never Zaurus has a better keyboard, but so do these x86 PDA-sized computers described in the article.

      Again, I consider my Zaurus one of the more stupid things that I bought so far. I mainly use it to browse news sites through WLAN while sitting on the toilet. Now that's an expensive toy.

      --

      ------------------
      You may like my a cappella music
    5. Re:Yes, I definitely am looking forward to this... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Which model notebook are you using? I'm using a sony u3 currently. It's cool and real portable but it's kinda slow though..

      It has a 933mhz transmeta tm5800 and when running win xp pro I have to turn off the eye candy to get the thing to run quickly.

    6. Re:Yes, I definitely am looking forward to this... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      one word...

      xybernaut.

      what you want exists and has a great input/display setup...

  50. Portability kills Security by RU_Areo · · Score: 1

    As a person working in IT Security, this kind of thing is an absolute nightmare for companies attempting to implement or stay true to any kind of security procedure / protocol. The fact of the matter is these things will not replace desktops, because if they did it would give everyone in the company (or at least the important people) to walk out of the doors with whatever vital data they decided to work on that day, with the possibilty of that device never making it back into work for whatever reason (robbery, fire, alien death ray). The immediate cost savings over a laptop / desktop (if in fact there is one) does not begin to warrant the move to these 'handtops' when the extreme risk that is to be incurred is taken into account.

  51. This has been a long time coming by nial-in-a-box · · Score: 1

    I remember quite a few years back reading (I believe) a John Dvorak column regarding palm-sized handheld computers replacing desktops. The concept was similar, calling for docks to extend functionality while at home, but enough power to do pretty much anything, anywhere. The idea piqued my interest at the time, and seemed feasible. I think that due to the conceptual shift that is also required so-called handtops have yet to become true desktop replacements and have also yet to achieve a truly ideal performance to size ratio. I think that anyone who says this is where things are going is right on. I see a future convergence of handheld style operating systems and desktop operating systems (mainly the integration of new input features into the desktop OS), but I can't imagine that we'd see widespread desktop replacement by handtops any time in the next five years.

    --
    I am feeling fat and sassy
  52. Psion's 1997 paradigm shift by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The problem always comes back to the input device.

    That's why I love my Psions. I have a Series 7, a netbook and a series 5mx, and I'll weep on the day they're all gone. Not only are they small, light (1kg) and incredibly durable (you could toss the netbook, frisbee-like, into a brick wall and use it afterwards), they've got great battery life, touchscreens and tremendous keyboards. Not quite full-sized, but large enough for me, a ham-handed ogre, to touch-type on.

    I've been looking for suitable replacements for each for 4 years now, and none exist. Every potential replacement lacks some feature or another.

    1. Re:Psion's 1997 paradigm shift by PhillC · · Score: 1

      I have to agree that as soon as I saw the picture of the FlipStart I thought "that's my Psion 5mx". Such a shame that Psion couldn't keep producing their machines.

      I loved my 5mx and still have it, although now it's just used as my morning wake up alarm. Infact I don't use any PDA at the moment as I haven't found one that really meets my needs. I just use my mobile phone for calendar and reminder functions.

      I used an older Series 5 machine constantly when backpacking in southern Africa for about six months. I had the modem dongle connection. So while I was out and about I can write my journal or emails. Then when I got back to usually Cape Town or J'burg I could connect and send everything. I found it really useful. Unfortunately it wasn't quite as durable as your description of the Series 7 - the screen smashed when crushed in my luggage on the way home.

      I'd certainly by another "hand top" machine if it resembled the usefulness of the Psion.

      --
      Brought to you by the author of such childrens' classics as "Some Kittens can Fly!" and "All Dogs go to Hell."
    2. Re:Psion's 1997 paradigm shift by The+Conductor · · Score: 1

      My 5mx (actually Diamond Mako, the US version) just died. It appears to be a bum battery but I can't figure out how to open that bizarrely-hinged case. Though I keep a Palm IIIxe in my pocket all the time, my Psion always lived in my briefcase as a laptop substitute. With the IR modem (or even IR cellphone) it was a nice little email device and a passable web browser in a pinch.

      Now I am faced with putting in real effort to fix it, scrounging one up on Ebay, or finding a new keyboarded PDA that is small and doesn't suck. In today's market you get either a Palm-like form factor, or a clamshell with laptop-like bettery life (and price). A true PDA with the hinge along the long axis permitted the wide screen and a passable chiclet keyboard. It was Psion's unique feature.

  53. Of course, by AugstWest · · Score: 2, Interesting

    if you get a little projector and mount it in the side of one of these so that it can display a, say, 17-20" image on a flat surface.....

  54. Wake me... by JessLeah · · Score: 1

    ...when they're affordable. It took so bloody long to get color handhelds under a decent price... now these neat little toys come onto the market at prices THREE TO FOUR TIMES that of a typical desktop. WTF?

    Wake me when I can actually afford to buy one.

    1. Re:Wake me... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Agreed about price, but you made me think about monochrome. I don't think color is the be all end all. I HATE the color screen phones. Just seems wasteful... Is there room for monochrome in the future?

  55. Useless toy by phooka.de · · Score: 1

    What's it good for? It's the next step to miniaturize the laptop, notebookn, sub-notebook...

    Each step gives yoiu more mobility with less capability for a given prize. Already, many descisions in that area are trade-off's like "will the 12" PowerBook suffice? It IS easier to carry around..." These toys will just be the next extreme in the continuum somewhere between desktop and mobile phone.

  56. Not his... by FullCircle · · Score: 1

    No, check the release date slippage.

    This the the PDA Duke Nukem uses.

    --
    If tyranny and oppression come to this land, it will be in the guise of fighting a foreign enemy. - James Madison
  57. THAT'S MASSIVE POWER!!! by burnttoy · · Score: 1

    CRICKEY!!! What do you want! It would STILL run a compiler, STILL run multi channel soft synths, still even be capable of moderate video editing... that's a LOT of MIPS pumping through that thing. It will run a browser, run Javascript, emulate JAVA at a reasonable speed and has video acceleration anyway. It is fast enough to play DVDs - which is still the most taxing thing most users ever do with their PC's. It will still run my FFTs and signal processing stuff and it will definitely read my email, news and let me type up documents (hell I was doing that on my 286's and 386's) Sorry to moan but you either do fluid dynamics for a living or REALLY like running SuperPI.

    --
    Time flies like an arrow. Fruit flies like a banana.
  58. cool, but..... by Nex6 · · Score: 1

    These things are pretty cool, but i think an ultra light laptop (about 2Lbs) is far better for this typeof work. altho u could not really use it as a pda.

    i think a decent PDA and an ultra light laptop is prety much all you need.

    -Nex6

  59. Stupid page design by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Why would anyone create a page like that of the 3rd link "Others" at http://www.handtops.com/show/compare where I've a scrolling page within a scrolling web page? Now I've got to manipulate 4 scroll bars to view the thing instead of the usual 2!

  60. shocking by pizza_milkshake · · Score: 1

    a site about handtops predicts a bright future for handtops? it's almost like a news site for nerds pushing an anti-Microsoft agenda!

    1. Re:shocking by captainJam · · Score: 1

      i'm not predicting a bright future for handtops, i'm prediciting an important change in computing. there's a big difference.

  61. Re:We may indeed establish an entirely new paradig by Stevyn · · Score: 1

    Make sure you pronounce it "pear-a-dig-ehm" and not "pear-a-dime"

  62. paradigms by Hognoxious · · Score: 2, Funny

    That's 20 cents, isn't it?

    --
    Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
  63. here's a link you should check out by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://www.frogpad.com/

    I can't wait 'till it becomes pervasive.

  64. Wrong price point by wytcld · · Score: 1

    What exactly do you need to do on a $2000 palm top unit that's worth the cost, when for around $700 you can get a Zaurus SL-C860 and a wireless card, install the free pdaXrom Linux/X environment, and have decently-functional note taking, word processing, mp3 playing, e-mailing, web browsing, scheduling environment? Sure it's a "slow" ARM CPU, but it's as fast as what was on your desktop a few years back, and with the money you save you can buy a really fast desktop system that you can export you Zaurus screen and apps to when you're sitting there, and have two systems for the price of one (with the redundancy that entails - always a good thing), each optimized for what it does.

    In a couple of months of having an 860, I've gotten to where I can thumb-type as quickly as I can write in a notebook (the small, paper kind), and it's as easy to carry around. (I've previously favored real notebooks over the computer kind - smaller, cheaper, more durable.) Most anything I do that really needs CPU is graphics-intensive, and although GIMP will run on the Z, I'd rather have a very large screen for that stuff anyhow.

    A full Linux handheld like the Z should go for $400-500 in a year or so, and these folks betting on selling $2000-3000 systems ... suckers required?

    --
    "with their freedom lost all virtue lose" - Milton
  65. Asinine by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Asinine. It's the new retarded.

  66. PDA, labtop or the like by Hognoxious · · Score: 1

    labtop? Are you, like, a scientist or something? Or do you just have a cold?

    --
    Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
    1. Re:PDA, labtop or the like by klang · · Score: 1

      nope, I just can't spell for shit without M-x font-lock-mode :-)

  67. Ever use a laptop on a plane? by Stone316 · · Score: 1
    Its a royal pain in the arse.. I don't even try to use mine anymore. Sony has some nice small form laptops that would be suitable for small workspaces but they are still too big to carry around.

    This palmtop on the other hand would be alot easier to carry and it would fit in at least one pocket of a jacket I wear.

    Like another poster said, some people type on blackberrys and their cell phones.. I wouldn't want to type an essay on one of these but if i'm at the mall and want to type up an email i'm sure it would be ok for that.

    --
    "Thanks to the remote control I have the attention span of a gerbil."
    1. Re:Ever use a laptop on a plane? by sporty · · Score: 1

      Get a small laptop. I use one all the time, even on planes. I use a backback since I typically carry mine a lot.

      --

      -
      ping -f 255.255.255.255 # if only

    2. Re:Ever use a laptop on a plane? by Stone316 · · Score: 1
      Sure, i'll go ahead and ask my manager for a new small form laptop right now cause I know he has tons of extra cash to spend.

      I have a laptop now, one with a fancy backpack so I can transport it while on my motorcycle. Its not the smallest but its not the biggest either. But I can still see me being able to use a palmtop in alot more places than my laptop.

      --
      "Thanks to the remote control I have the attention span of a gerbil."
  68. I have a camera phone by Stone316 · · Score: 1
    and the quality sucks BUT there are many times i've been in places where I didn't have my digital camera and was able to snap a pic. Yeah, its not great quality but the picture I got last week of my kid getting a hair cut was priceless.

    This is why these multi-function devices are nice to have. They will never be as good as a standalone device but in some situations they are good enough and in 2 years they will probably be better than the standalone product your using today. Camera phones are low quality but give it a couple of years and you'll probably have 3 mega pixel cameras in there and be able to take crappy movies.

    --
    "Thanks to the remote control I have the attention span of a gerbil."
  69. Not again by digrieze · · Score: 1

    Handtop replaces desktop, lets see where have I heard THAT before (let's go through the drawer):

    Casio Digital Diary
    PSION Organizer
    Newton Messagepad (and MP100 upgrade)
    Tandy Zoomer Z-PDA (Casio Z-7000)
    PalmPilot Professional
    Freestyle Manager (Windows Palm PC)
    Handspring (Palm OS)
    Toshiba (Mobile Windows)

    Do away with the desktop? OH YEAH, SURE!!!!!

    --
    It doesn't matter what you wrap your emotions around, Reality is a brick wall specifically designed to scramble eggs
  70. Not so practical but they make nice handwarmers! by Great_Jehovah · · Score: 1

    Seriously. Considering how warm similarly spec'd laptops can get can you imagine how hot these puppies will be? I mean the surface area is so much smaller the escaping heat is going to have be a lot more concentrated. Ouch!

  71. ultraportables.net by ultrapcs · · Score: 1

    Here is another web site that focuses on ultra portable pcs: http://ultraportables.net/

  72. Shared company / personal ownership... not good by pjrc · · Score: 1
    one day companies might even be willing to pay for part of your handtop

    Many companies have tried this with laptops. It almost always ends in frustration.

    What would be needed is some sort of dual-boot system or vitualization... where the employee would be free to install games, screensavers and other eye candy, "free" apps that include spyware, and all the other crap that individuals often load onto own computers.... which is entertaining but has a tendancy to interfere with business usage.

    As far as most companies are concerned, the potential cost savings of shared ownership ends up being "penny wise, pound foolish" once even a small portion of the employees install software that messes up the machine both makes them unproductive and ties up tech support time from whomever at their company needs to fix it for them.

  73. Wearables by sadiklis · · Score: 1

    Get rid of that small screen of a handtop and get goggles instead. Enjoy your big, hi-res virtual monitor and get an extra bonus of augmented reality.

    So i guess that wearables, not handtops will kill laptops some day.

  74. thirdhand computing by Doc+Ruby · · Score: 1

    How about the next version Treo, "Ace", due in October? It's scaled down from those "handtops", but not by much - each spec is about 1/3 that of these handtops (except for default RAM, but that accommodates the lighter PalmOS). And the Treo is built around a completely integrated phone, with a DB instead of a filesystem, while its "paradigm" is a mobile peripheral for a networked desktop, instead of making a bloated desktop kinda mobile.

    --

    --
    make install -not war

  75. These things are cool and all by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    but when can i get one with cell phone capabilities?

  76. Already Exists by Feneric · · Score: 1
    These factors... allow one to imagine a world where maybe they won't need a desktop, or laptop...

    Sounds like the Newton MessagePad 2000 or 2100. Pity they're not still being made. Imagine what the Newton would be like today if its development cycle hadn't been broken...

  77. forgotten platforms by speculatrix · · Score: 1
    along with most geeks, I love compact portable computers, but also bemoan the compromises of portability vs features vs battery life

    I have a Sony Clie N770, not the latest, but it has a decent battery life, (10 days) plays mp3, has a colour hi-res screen, but only PalmOs4. It was created before Sony (and Palm in their turn) went mad running high power battery-killing CPUs. Too many people forget these older palms could be close to the ideal handheld. Ebay is now full of people who buy the latest PDA and sell soon when disappointment sets in when the gloss of pointlessly watching tiny videos wears off.

    Then there's interesting items like the Siemens SimPad - still in demand but only available on ebay, many people feel it's a grown-up Zaurus. Originally costing over a US$1000, they're now available for less than 20% of that price.

    Remember the Audrey? Some people do, and they're still loved.

    Remember Cyrix/Geode WebPAD (TM)? Not many do.

    When the Newton was first emerging, I recall seeing a demonstration tablet made by Olivetti Research Labs here in Cambridge England. It was a full-size A4 screen, could send/receive faxes etc. Considering a 486 was state of the art, this was a miracle of engineering.

    So, whilst I welcome new computers like the OQO, Intel's personal server, the new Zaurus 6000W (unavailable outside Japan - crazy!), until I can actually find one in the stores, see 3rd party developers working with them, and hear from the early adopters, I don't hold my breath as to their practical reality.

  78. Super-lame keyboard layout by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    OQO missed the opportunity to make a nice keyboard, by leaving the tab/capslock/shift/ctrl keys and other keys on the sides. Too bad. And the really sad thing is the Taiwanese and Chinese clone manufacturers, who are brilliant in their own way, unfortunately lack the imagination to remedy this by coming up with their own layouts. So again a good idea, the small form factor PC, is doomed by a bad implementation. I may be just an AC, but mark my words on this one.

  79. Re:In Soviet Russia your fingers aren't portable. by XnR'rn · · Score: 0

    *sigh* Funny being modded down by people who don't understand the refference. :>