Slashdot Mirror
FFXII Scores Max In Famitsu
Famitsu, the premiere Japanese videogame magazine, evidently really likes Final Fantasy XII. From the Insert Credit post: "Meanwhile, Final Fantasy XII has scored a perfect score of 40 -- all four reviewers scoring it 10 out of 10 -- from Japanese gaming bible Famitsu. It joins the club of five perfect-scoring games, one of which is a fighting game with a sequel that's better (Soul Calibur), two of which are Zelda games (Ocarina of Time and Wind Waker), and two of which (Nintendogs and Vagrant Story) didn't even make it onto Famitsu readers' top 100 list."
How does it score at the real important list?
---- Take the Space Quiz!
now if they'll just actually release the game we might have something to really talk about...
Did you know that you can be apathetic to apathy? Not that I give a shit...
A high scoring FF game? I never thought I'd see the day!
Is this a single player game, with no online bullshit?
I'd love to see one of those again.
They unfortunately fell victim to a magazine version of a slashvertisement. Advertisements are not enough, they must promote certain games and/or systems as stated in their terms of employment. It's true! Ask Cowboy Neal.
What I've played so far of the finished version (burn the demo disc) is shockingly good.
Well, that's good news for everyone who felt a bit down after trying the demo (that would be most people from what I've heard). Instead of inspiring desire, it seemed to suck the energy out of the room. Maybe a Potion would have helped us feel better.
Anyone know if Famitsu is plagued by accusations of buying out like other gaming magazines? I loved Wind Waker, but I still wouldn't give it 10/10.
Wait, is this the same Famitsu that recently polled its readers about their favorite games, where the top 10 list included four Final Fantasy games and three DragonQuest games? The list that included every single Final Fantasy game except for FFXI?
Yeah, that really sounds like unbiased reporting there. Gee, a magazine that apparently has a hard-on for Square-Enix games rated the latest Square-Enix game perfect. That's almost as surprising as the Official PlayStation Magazine saying that the PlayStation port of a game is superior to the "lesser XBox version". It's almost as surprising as O'Reilly defending Republicans.
Wake me up when some relatively unbiased reviewers rate that game. I've played the demo, Square-Enix has a long way to go before I'll believe that the game is worth more than a coaster.
...rather than that bad blog->
http://www.ff12.com/
Or a more intersting site:
http://www.ffxii.net/
After all, this is the first FF to score this high in famitsu.
Previous famitsu scores:
FF: 8.25
FFII: 8.25
FFIII: 9
FFIV: 9
FFV: 8.5
FFVI: 9.25
FFVII: 39/40
FFVIII: 38/40
FFIX: 38/40
FFX: 38/40
FFX-2: 34/40
FFXI: 36/40
It joins the club of five perfect-scoring games, one of which is a fighting game with a sequel that's better (Soul Calibur)
Sure, if by "better" you mean "has a worse computer AI and more gimmicks." Not to say that SC2 is a bad game, but you'll find that there are many people out there that prefer the original as a technical fighter. Not to mention, of course, that reviewers are supposed to review games in the context of their competition -- the original SC blew everything in its generation and before it out of the water, but by the time SC2 came around, the rest of the genre had improved enough that it was a much closer competition.
Bear in mind that the above is only my opinion (which is really the whole point of reviews).
Karma: Terrifying (mostly affected by atrocities you've committed)
I'm playing Dragon Quest 8 right now (fun game), and it came with a demo of FF12.
"Yech" is about the only word I can come up with for it. If that demo is an accurate representation of the final game, I want to know just how big a bribe it took to get the rating these reviewers gave it.
-- "So they told me that using the download page to download something was not something they anticipated." - Bill Gates
The Germans really like David Hasselhoff.
--- As to make my comment seem, by comparison, more intelegent... doodie doodie doodie poop poop poop!
Final Fantasy XII will certainly be a decent game. However, based on what I've read of the story it looks like it will be just as contrived as all the other Final Fantasy games, and probably Japanese RPGs in general.
I realize the game is catered to a market where anyone over 18 is considered old, but still, I wish they'd stop making such feminine lead characters. At least stop making them all look like 14 year olds. These guys look like they spend more time doing their hair than training for battle. It looks like they've cast pop stars to play the lead roles.
Visually it looks good. There was obviously a lot of effort put into designing the game. I like the liberal use of color, unlike the muddy, monotone worlds normally depicted in American RPGs, World of Warcraft being one of the big exceptions. The facial textures look a bit odd in all the in-game screenshots, but thats one of the only problems I see.
Visuals, however, don't make the game. I don't see how this game could possibly deserve a perfect score, especially in light of the current generation of games, and given that the game was just released. However, I would suspect the score is a marketing gimmick more than anything.
The whole thing reeks of payola. You can always find something in a game that could have been done better. I've never seen the perfect game yet so I feel a 40 is, as yet, unattainable. My opinion of course, free of charge - worth less.
Terrible karma and aiming lower, which in this environment of one-sided reason, is higher.
I've been a fan of the series for a long time. Untill 10 part 2. bleh.
Also, 11 was online only. Bleh.
The 12 demo had a somewhat confusing battle system (do i try to dodge attacks? etc.)
Since the original creator of Final Fantasy left after 10, (Nobuo Uematsu left too) and i've disliked every release since they both left, I don't have high hopes for 12.
"Yech" is about the only word I can come up with for it. If that demo is an accurate representation of the final game, I want to know just how big a bribe it took to get the rating these reviewers gave it.
FTA:
What I've played so far of the finished version (burn the demo disc) is shockingly good. [emphasis mine]
Famitsu Weekly scores are a pretty worthless benchmark of how good or bad a game is. Just like American publications, Famitsu is 99% hype - in fact, in recent years Famitsu has been known for handing out some of the most absurdly high reviews of any game magazine - for example, giving a score of 8/10 to Shadow the Hedgehog, which was panned by almost every other game critic on earth.
Yeah, I played "Ocarina of Time" and "Wind Waker" pretty much back to back, and found "Wind Waker" to be a major disappointment.
With the leap in console generation, I was expecting some kind of gameplay innovation... but it turned out "Wind Waker" was just "Ocarina" with cel shading and a boat. And the boat was kinda dull after the first half hour or so.
GCHQ Quantum Insert installed. If only our tongues were made of glass, how much more careful we would be when we speak
Here's to more bathing-suit hot spring cutscenes. //is asking for tentacles too much?
Even the Census Department likes FF12, and they've been liking it since at least 1999.
https://www.eff.org/https-everywhere
It's not every day a game gets a perfect score from Famitsu. Ocarina of Time and Wind Waker display the sort of polish that defines a "Perfect Game". I suddenly have hope for this game.
--The universe will not be altered by forum threads, even those which are very wry. --Tycho Brahe (Penny Arcade)
Golden Sun got 40/40 too.
A week from this morning (here in Japan).
Although the moon is smaller than the earth, it is farther away.
Mod OP down for failing to understand the glaringly obvious reality of the situation, and mod parent up for the correction.
KTHX
I wish they'd stop making such feminine lead characters. At least stop making them all look like 14 year olds. These guys look like they spend more time doing their hair than training for battle. It looks like they've cast pop stars to play the lead roles.
The Japanese have a very different attitude about what makes an attractive man. They have long favored androgynous, effiminate males known as bishounen (Japanese for "pretty boys"). It might surprise you to know that the more "masculine" hero types with bulging muscles and a hairy face or body is the Japanese stereotype for gay people. Look up the comedian "Hard Gay" or the shooting game "Chou Aniki" sometime to have your brain a-sploded. Zangief from Street Fighter is flamingly gay to the Japanese. This goes to the point that Japanese cross-dressers and transvestites are far more frequently portrayed for humor with heavy muscles and a 5-o'clock shadow rather than the kind of jokes about the friend who doesn't see the Adam's Apple over here.
It's a flipping of the gender stereotypes. Here, pop culture looks down on men who try to be too close to what women are like. There, pop culture looks down on men who try to be a far from women in appearance as possible. Hence, pretty boy heroes are the norm there while bulging barbarians are the norm here.
If it's for-profit but free, you're not the customer -- you're the product (e.g., the Slashdot Beta's "audience").