Slashdot Mirror
Battlestar Galactica DVD Movie In the Works?
Philias writes "Although Battlestar Galactica has been going down in ratings and has yet to get picked up for another season, the sales of its DVDs has got Universal thinking of a Direct-To-Video Movie. GeekMonthly.com is reporting that plans are afoot for a film that will bridge the gap between Galactica and the new spinoff 'Caprica.' The film would be shot in March during the usual hiatus between seasons. The big difference between this and the mini-series and other seasons would be that this would be sold on DVD before being aired on the SciFi channel."
What an disappointment!
Scully: Should we arrest David Copperfield?
Mulder: Yes we should, but not for this.
"plans are afoot for a film that will bridge the gap between Galactica and the new spinoff 'Caprica.' The film would be shot in March during the usual hiatus between seasons."
"Unfortunately, nobody will be paid for any part of it."
Error 407 - No creative sig found
In Solviet Slashdot, karma fucks YOU!
Cool, so we can get high quality DVD rips *before* the shitty TV rips. That'll help my ratios.
I am a huge fan of BSG, and have watched every episode since the mini series, but I am not surprised the ratings are in decline. This season has lost it's way. Baltar was great when he was among the humans with the cylon in his head frakking with his brain. Now among the cylons he is quite uninteresting.
Other than that they really seem to be pushing the preachy morality play of the week. I think the listened too much to the critics who liked them touching "real issues" and now they have gone overboard on the "real issues" and the story and characters seem to be suffering, so much so that I have a hard time buying their actions. It is just not as good this season. I hope they get back to form soon.
They shouldn't try to drag this on endlessly, when the story is over they should stop and not inject filler seasons that increasingly make it unrealistic. I would rather have 3 or 4 good season ended properly rather than dragged out mediocre 5 or 6 seasons.
I expect modding down from fans who will claim it is better than ever.
I stopped watching BSG this season after the first episode. Not because the story sucks - in fact I really liked that first episode, it was brilliant - but because the picture sucks.
I learned last year that UniversalHD runs the BSG reruns after 6 months or so, in high def. So, now I am just going to wait it out until the show is available in HD.
I think Universal is just frackin stupid to run the premier episodes in crap-def on the sci-fi channel. If there is a single demographic most likely to own HDTVs and actively seek out HD shows, it is the one that watches BSG. They need to get their shit together and simulcast the show in HD, not make us wait 6+ months for it.
When information is power, privacy is freedom.
I'm not sure what Sci-Fi expects ratings to do when they run what amounts to half a season of episodes, call it a season, and run them the better part of a year apart. TV audiences of the TiVo generation have shown that they're not content to just watch reruns for long periods of time. With decreasing new episode counts, the problem of ratings getting harder and harder to come by shouldn't be a surprise to anyone.
If Sci-Fi wants a show to succeed, they should try a novel approach: go back to a 30+ episode season. These silly little 10- and 13-episode runs are barely long enough to start getting into the action, then bam: 3 month hiatus....
Check out my sci-fi/humor trilogy at PatriotsBooks.
I just hit the scifi.com main page, and there is not ONE mention of BSG anywhere on the page. If you stop advertising the show, only the die-hards will watch and it will descend into cult status.
I love RDM's Battlestar Galactica. It's excellent science fiction. The very best we have, I'd say. With that established however, I must make the point that I can see the series dying a horrible death due to inundation. Sure, the show is great and awesome. It's a beacon in the science fiction TV realm, but apparently it's ratings are slipping. Which sucks because its such a darn good show and i'd hate to see it go. Despite the ratings drop they've announced a spinoff series before BSG even really got its gears in motion - 'Caprica' - which is 0% science fiction and 100% drama. They've announced an MMO (or a game of some sort, at any rate) and I believe a pen-and-paper RPG? (the RPG I could be wrong on...), plus this movie.
Now granted, it's a great show, and a direct-to-DVD movie isn't really uncommon, but doesn't anybody think it's a little TOO much? Almost like SciFi, RDM and Eick are riding the marketing a little too hard? Babylon 5 was probably the most famous for direct-to-DVD movies. Most of them were not really on par with the overall quality of the show (except for In The Beginning... which was just... unbelievable.) even though they were nice little departures.
Maybe it wouldn't kill the show per-se, but it seems like they're jumping the gun a little early on this one.
Farscape suffered a similar untimely fate. The show was wonderous and innovative to most who saw it, yet in the middle of season four Sciffy announced that the second half of season four was actually season five, and killed the show with a final movie (after much hellraising from Farscape fans).
that comes as a surprise to me. 3 out of the 4 latest shows have been incredibly good (hero, unfinished business, the eye of jupiter). I suggest checking them out if you haven't yet.
I'll be honest; the ratings in the UK would be a lot higher if we didn't have such a huge wait. Whilst you in the US are enjoying Series 3, we haven't even started yet.
I watch the US versions, a day after they air. You can work out the rest for yourself. But there is no point viewing on Sci-Fi UK when I've already seen it. If we had parity with the US, or at least something more sensible like a week, the viewing figures would be much higher!
Here's how I see it.
The cylon bayships are showing WAY TOO MUCH. Its like going into Darth Vaders bathroom and watching him take off his mask and slap on some aftershave. Cylons were more interesting when it was a mystery what is going on inside there. When we knew just as much of the cylons as the humans did. Now we are watching the cylons run around in their underwear, and the bayships seem like a pretty cush place no?The scariest thing going on there is the digital lights that are unnecessarily being flashed in the cylon faces to make it look FUTURISTIC, OOOOOH.
Why does Baltar still have Caprica(cylon) in his head? Shes right there!!!! What's the point? Hurry up and get done with the whole cylon/human hybrid baby, Sharon wants her baby storyline. Its really lame and unnecessary. First of all its just Madam President making another mistake cause really WHY tell the mother the kid died? So the cylons wont know she exists and take her and do experiments on her? Sorry but thats ridiculous. They would blow up gallactica before hoping onboard and kidnapping a baby.
How about Base Ships?
"The X Files" series ended shortly after the movie. The box office failure of "Serenity" insured that the "Firefly" series would not be brought back. I suspect "The Simpsons" movie may prove to be a swan song also.
Loss of stargate as a lead-in is pulling the ratings down.
...changing the time slot like they did is a death sentence for the show, IMHO. Very sad, for it is one of the best sci-fi shows currently aired that is done well. We all know that studio executives have always lacked intelligence anyway, so it was expected.
"This is America... where the will of the few outweigh the outrage of the many..." - Unknown
Now I know people will correct me and say it's not a war show but is instead a drama. But still, compared to the miniseries and most of the earlier seasons the action has been lacking (for example "33" was awesome). I think the drama/action balance was better in previous seasons. Currently it's almost all drama save for a few sequences here and there and there's all that crap left from the "New Caprica" arc with main characters getting married and all sorts of touchy feely junk.
The whole "new Caprica" arc was what really killed the show for me. They skipped something like 10 years which just left a bad taste in my mouth and ruined the storyline. The lead up to it just didn't make any sense (Commander Lee Adama anyone?).
Don't get me wrong, I still love the show. It's actually one of the few things worth watching on TV and the last episode wasn't too bad but I hope they pull the show back in the direction of the original arc.
The ratio of people to cake is too big
The problem I have is both sides seem less interesting now. The Baltar dynamic has been removed from the humans and replaced with melodrama; who will Starbuck Frak next? Yippee: Days of our Battlestar lives.
A lot of the sense of mystery has been removed from the cylons with Baltar wandering among them.
As far as it being the best Drama on TV, "Deadwood", and "The Wire" were/are much better dramas which much more believable characters. I am sure other people can list more. As a drama it would not be high on my list.
I watched it initially because it was a great SciFi show with gritty feel, great unfolding cyclon mystery and good tension with traitor/crazy Baltar among the humans. Now most of that has been lost to be replaced with more melodrama. I think this is a result of them running out of ideas and trying to stretch for more seasons. Sad.
Get it off the crappolla SciFi channel.
Even going high definition tv would not suffice, since I like others have only standard. I watch only two shows: BSG and House M.D. Until recently when he got smacked down I was on the course to drop the latter.
Going straight to DVD is great, I will buy it just to avoid the stupid ads and previews for the upcoming shows. SciFi insults its viewers by running miniclips while the current show is nearing its end. I hate SciFi Channel and I have nearly no interest in watching any of their shows, particularly the ones they push when BSG is on.
While I tend to read science fiction, I have always found most sci. fi. movies and tv series painful to watch. With BSG I may disagree with the story line or at times think parts were done badly, I still like to watch their attempts even when they fail. At least, most times they are not talking down to the audience.
One feature I now avoid is the podcasts, even the ones on the DVDs, there is too much stress on their own visceral response to their creation rather than the logic in the story line. That might be due to the need to avoid giving away future plot lines. Valid reason (somewhat), however, I had learned well in advance about the first 5 to 6 episodes of season 3 from reading a fan magazine. Actually I was disappointed I expected better execution of the ideas in the plots. So the discussions of the episodes do yield nothing positive for me, though other comments here found them of value.
I suggest: just produce the DVDs, run it afterward on TV. I suspect there will be a market for both, but with the shows timing on a shitty channel with idiots running it there is only so much any audience will bear. NBC could have done better, both for themselves and for the show.
I should state that the humans interest me less than machine intelligence, but religious nuts? Where did that come from? Mass murder followed by the tepid attempts to show the humans the right path, that's just too hard a sell. I would really like to know the rationale for the robots behaviour. And other questions, why were their more organic forms stopped so abruptly? Why are they scientific klutzes? This all hints that the core of the murderous rage and their frailty is human based. I am hoping Caprica might follow that logic, however, I do not have high hopes.
Nonetheless, I will continue to watch both, but preferably straight off of DVDs. I will still watch, because one is still the best of its genre and I have hopes the new series will do as well, at least in quality.
I call Bullshit with the "BSG ratings are falling" crowd
y .jsp?vnu_content_id=1003223846 :
From http://www.mediaweek.com/mw/search/article_displa
-Respectable Start for Sci Fi's Battlestar Galactica:
The two-hour, third-season premiere of Sci Fi Channel's Battlestar Galactica was the top-rated cable series on Friday, Oct. 6, with a 1.8 household rating and 2.2 million viewers. Comparatively, however, that was still down by 900,000 viewers from the season two opener in July 2005 (3.1 million).
So, they lost almost a million viewers...and they are still on top. I think that they are gambling that a move to Sunday night might help. I think that the long gaps between seasons helped to kill ratings...not the day of the week.
Worked for Voyager, right? Oh wait.....
I watched the first two seasons, found some of it ok, but decided to bail out this season. It's essentially boring, the characters are stereotypes, it's cruel, it's militaristic. How the system can sustain a show like this while Firefly lives a short life, it's beyond me.
I am hard core science fiction, it takes a lot to get me to turn my back on a show like BSG, but it's too low to bear watching.
Enterprise decided to follow the same storyline. They started bringing in moral elements of what is happening in the world around us. After 9/11, Enterprise had a whole season that mirrored everything that was happening because of 9/11.
The new season of BSG did the exact same thing. They started focusing on the morality of the world around us. They had terriosts and suicide bombers.
I'm sorry, but I watch SciFi because I want to escape from the problems we face in the world today. Didn't Universal learn anything from the ratings dive Enterprise took when they did this?
Then again, this is the same channel that is cancelling Stargate SG1, even though it's one of their highest rated shows.
RTFG - Read The F#$%ing Google!
Ouch. I had assumed they had a full story arc in mind, especially when the tag line for the Cylons is "and they have a plan".
It is pretty sad that the writers don't.
This sucks. Except for Doctor Who, there's nothing else on television that I enjoy. I own all the BSG DVDs and will get the latest when it's issued. Anyhoo, there are a few problems I see the writers/producers having:
1) The episodes are less balanced. I.e., they are more standalone episodes than before. IMHO, getting new viewers is very difficult if there's a lot of backstory needed to understand new episodes. For example, when X-Files was good it relied on some backstory. Regular viewers could be very interested. At some point they made it a freak-of-the-week show. Maybe this was at the direction of the marketing folks who said that they needed to appeal to non-regular viewers. Who knows. BSG seems to be heading in the freak-of-the-week direction...
2) Too much morality preaching. This is coming from someone who enjoyed watching Starbuck interview the Cylon because of the psychology war. Now it seems to be more about adding current topics to the storyline to make it, ummm, topical. Sure, science fiction always has a dose of morality, but don't beat us to death with it.
3) Not enough explosions. Seriously. My favorite movie is Apocalypse Now. I can appreciate the deep mind-fuck and the near-perfect understanding of Conrad's story, but it had lots of guns too. BSG is getting way too touchy-feely to appeal to the 25-45 male demographic.
4) Cylons are too human. No mystery, no intrigue. They're just human now and that makes it really boring. I.e., if it looks like a duck and talks like a duck, call it a duck. It was interesting that they could not die, but now they can, so the morality question of, "Does mortality make us human" just blows away. They're too human and too weak as a result. That's why the Borg was so terrifying at first. Then they became human and that just made them weak.
And for God's sake, please don't do any time travel or evil twin episodes..
"bridge the gap between Galactica and the new spinoff 'Caprica'"
There's one problem right there. Why is there a gap? Why is there a spinoff? Did the events on Caprica really warrant a spinoff? Could the Caprica story, in no way, remain integrated with the main storyline in some way? And if it couldn't, and it didn't really warrant a spinoff, why not just let it be and move on?
Too many spinoffs these days - in the end, it merely divides focus (and money!) on the end of producers, actors, and audience alike. I'd like to see how many spinoffs+series remained doing as well separately, as the original did on its own. My guess: not many.
I've borrowed the DVDs of the series from friends, but I have to say that I think they are way overpriced. I find is especially dorky that they release each half season for essentially the full price of other shows. I can buy a whole season of Stargate SG-1, an excellent show that has been on for 10 years, and it costs less than half of a season of BSG.
I won't do it. It's a great show, and I'm glad to borrow it from people willing to fork out the dough. But it isn't worth it to me. And I think it's probably not worth it to other people either.
BSG is on broadcast TV?
:)
I'm in Canada. Every one of my friends watches BSG religiously. Every single week.
But not a single one of them watches it on Space. BSG is the reason for bittorrent. What's the adjusted ratings for bittorent users?
As for the ratings discussion...they are not that bad nor at any sort of critical stage. Leave it to the Slashdot crowd to ignore the Direct To Video movie discussion and seize on the ratings speculation one-liner.
As for the Iraq war parallels. They were strong, solid scripts. The ranting about those issues regarding the show come from American viewers - not those from other countries. Methinks your flag is getting in the way of your enjoyment of the best show on TV.
.Robert
I've heard Ronald D. Moore (the show's executive producer) say that his team does not own the film rights to Battlestar Galactica. The guys who owned the rights to the crappy 70s show sold off the TV rights but held on to the film rights for some reason. As a result RDM has publicly ruled out the possibility of making a BSG film in the past. I don't know if this applies to Direct to Video films, but if it does it makes this story unlikely.
"Although Battlestar Galactica has been going down in ratings and has yet to get picked up for another season"
Here's a tip... move the story along already!!
I pretty much gave up on the slow moving show but then decided to give it one more chance. So, the next time I caught an episode... I see an hour of retarded boxing? Dear Lord, how boring can they force the show to be?? At least that stupid Kat vs Starbuck bickering is finally gone.
I torrent some of them, and use media center to record the others.
:)
Here in Canada, Season 2 was aired several weeks later than in the US, so we pretty much HAD to download if we didn't want some asshole at work to spoil it for us! Things are a little better now, but they still aren't getting any advertising into me thanks to media center
Jeremy
I'll up that wager, I'll trade you getting Battlestar Galactica at the same time as the USA for getting Doctor Who AND Torchwood at the same time as the UK.
Unfortunately, the reason Torchwood would never come to the US is because the censors in the US would throw a fit about the content of the show. Way to much swearing and sex. The show would have to pull a sex and the city, and be picked up by HBO, not very likely for a sci fi show...
Sci Fi doesn't care. Unless you're putting eyeballs on advertisements, you're irrelevant in their calculus. That's the way TV works.
The Mongrel Dogs Who Teach
Three things have made me kinda less enthused about BSG.
This entire character driven story arch lately. Especially the shit between Starbuck and Apollo. Don't get me wrong I wanted to see them together since the Mini Series, but my god...that one boxing episode it was like one giant emo trip. All Apollo needed was a myspace to record his feelings on and the plot line would have been complete. They didn't need to dedicate an entire episode to boxing. Run it in the background along some other story arcs that ya know, go with the "oh shit we're being chased by killer fucking robots" idea.
And yea the idea of being chased by Cylons is like, gone. I think the last real time they had to worry about it, was the attack on the Ressurrection Ship. Sure, the Cylons found them on New Caprica, held them against their will etc But in the end what did they do? Sack'ed the Pegasus, which we all knew was coming, for a very short brief action sequence that basically was the equal of them getting people off the planet and running away, again. Since then there's been no real "omg we're in danger" aspect. Sure they ran out of food and such but it's been kinda a subdued role of the Cylons really being this threat. It just seems like Season 3 has been about them running this parallel course to get to Earth, not really attacking them.
Cost is the real killer for me. After I had seen the majority of Season 1 reruns, I went out and bought BSG S1 on DVD, which included the mini series. Well worth my $40 for it. Now I enjoyed Season 2 as well. But over $80 for it? I can get 2 seasons of basically any other show for that. Hell if I wanna buy "slimcase" editions of X-Files, Buffy or Angel for example I could get 3 seasons of those for the price of BSG Season 2 ($45 for each part, two parts).. That's god damn highway robbery. Don't get me wrong, other tv shows are just as bad. Doctor Who is upwards of $83 (Best Buy price) for 13 episodes of content...I love science fiction, it's my life. I just can't give it an arm, a leg, a first born child and a soul to buy some dvds.
Aw Frell this
Some of the drama stuff might turn our stomachs, but I think RDM will take audience wherever they can get it. I dont think they are really fucking up the show with all that, but I could do with more stuff like Pegasus, and less nonsense from the base ship. The Sharon baby stuff is getting old, get it over with and move on, dammit.
Someone needs to develop a new weapon, some new anti-baseship tactics, stuff like that. Pegasus was supposedly hunting cylons, so how about showing us some of what they were doing through flashbacks or whatever?
More space, less face, bitches!
Bill
bamph
I haven't listened to the RDM podcasts, partially for fear of spoilers, but perhaps I should. Thanks for bringing up this interesting info.
In "Home, Part 2" (s2e07), didn't the revelation at the tomb of Athena show clearly that the different colonies were each situated in their own star systems, within their respective constellations as seen from Earth and/or Kobol?
Or were those constellations merely patterns that are on the flags of each colony, irrespective of the colonies' locations? Now that I consider this more, in light of the miniseries and jumping beyond "the red line" into uncharted space, it would make more sense for the colonies to be either orbiting the same star, or more plausibly within the same group of stars in fairly close proximity to each other.
Back again to the tomb of Athena, what really happened there? Did the Arrow of Apollo transport people briefly to somewhere on Earth? If not, then the constellations make it appear that Kobol is in fact Earth! It's been months since I've seen this episode, so I don't remember for sure, but didn't the cylons chase the fleet away from Kobol? Kobol seemed like a more habitable place than New Caprica, so why doesn't the fleet return or send military recon expeditions back to Kobol?
After the first two or three episodes this season I can't watch it any more (though I try occasionally). The litany of issues I have with it are numerous. What started killing it was my inability to suspend disbelief any more...
It just goes on and on until it stacks so high I can't take it any more. For the first one and a half seasons plus the pilot movie, it WAS the Best Show on Television. Now they are coasting and it is starting to smell.
They should get military advisers to help the writers with military stuff and scientific advisers for the science stuff. It may take place in space, but the military is not just about fighting, it also takes a very good ability to manage people, logistics, and situations. It uses a different kind of thought process than the pie in the sky thinking that these writers are using. If you want the fighters to be realistic, get someone who can help the writers put that kind of edge on it. The writers can do what they want with the soap opera crap they keep filling the show in with, but my suggestion would be to use those scripts to fire up the fire place on those cold wet Vancouver winter nights on Boundary Road.
-- I ignore anonymous replies to my comments and postings.
I loved the original series, but can't watch the new stuff because of the excess use of shakey cam. We *get* it, yes, it seems more "real" with shakey cam. But it's also very annoying and overused. If I want to turn my head in a jerky fashion, I will, do it by making something else on the screen interesting; don't make the camera do it for me. I find it very patronizing, pretentious, and faddish and I wish producers would stop using it. Let the material show its strength, unobscured by a shaky camera.
Love many, trust a few, do harm to none.
I just hate episodes that...
* Use elections for the whole episode, make it a minor event taking 10% of air time.
* Court room type episodes are also boring, make it fast, like StarShip troopers.
* Fake Reality TV , come-on, its a fad, dont use it to add 'realism' and something to relate to.
Liberty freedom are no1, not dicks in suits.
Sci Fi doesn't care. Unless you're putting eyeballs on advertisements, you're irrelevant in their calculus. That's the way TV works.
Sci Fi doesn't, but Universal should. The torrent factor is probably one of the reasons why the DVDs sell so well - I get BSG off of BitTorrent because I hate the fixed schedules and advertising of traditional television. But I also buy the DVD sets as soon as they're released, because I want to support the series and get them in a nicer format that feels more permanent.
"...always new atoms but always doing the same dance, remembering what the dance was yesterday." -Richard Feynman
Season 1 was heart stopping from first to last. The battles and pressures were relentless. The show matched the beat of its percussive sound track. Recently, that has not been the case.
The problem with quotes on the internet, is that nobody bothers to check their veracity. -- Abraham Lincoln
They tried to make it look like it was video-taped documentury. But, IMO, it just seemed unbearably pretensious.
I don't care one bit about those of you that can't understand the complex plot lines.
I love BSG and all of its stories. It's a great show and should be picked up for another season.
scifi is trying to kill it by holding it off the air.
They're using their grammar skills there.
Oh God. Now I'm really dreading the revelation of the final five. I have a sick feeling it's going to really screw with people's heads ("HOW THE FRACK COULD THAT GUY HAVE BEEN A CYLON...HE/SHE's LIKE THE MAIN HUMAN CHARACTER"). Absolutely dreading it. :(
I would say that Minority Report then is ablatant rip off of the Guild Captains, or whatever they were in Dune, that guild that had the pilots floating in the big vats of water, spice laced so they could use the psychic powers it provided to guide the ships through space, and they orginally men but evolved into something else.
to quote wikipedia"The Spacing Guild has a monopoly on imperial banking and interstellar travel: with the use of melange, Guild Navigators are the only beings capable of piloting the massive Guild Heighliners safely through space. The heightened awareness and prescience the spice grants allows the navigator to plot a safe course between the stars. Contrary to popular belief, the navigators do not themselves 'fold' space, allowing a nearly instantaneous trip. The space-folding is accomplished by Holtzman drive units activated from the navigator's chamber. In the original novels by Frank Herbert, the Navigators are humans who have adapted to life in zero-gravity. They have slim builds, with large webbed hands and prehensile feet. They must spend their time in an artificial zero-gravity chamber when visiting a planetary surface, as exposure to full earth gravity would be (at best) highly uncomfortable, and potentially lethal. Whether this adaptation is the result of artificial engineering or many millenia of selective breeding is not stated in the books"
The Revolution Will Not Be Televised
I started watching because of the line:
"... and they have a plan"
I thought "Wow, another long arc series like B5 - I'M IN!"
Bullshit - they have no plan. It's all blah blah blah with no kind of plot complexity at all. I gave up somewhere around S2E10 or so.
Plan - bull, they got just a heap of junk.
I hope my stupid Comcast DVR figures that out.
Oh well, the good news is that Sci fi is hella fast getting to On Demand.
bamph
It is, sometimes, better, not to use, too many, commas.
I hadn't known there were so many idiots in the world until I started using the Internet -Stanislaw Lem
As more and more laws of physics get violated in a story, that story wanders from "Science Fiction" to "Sci-Fi" to "Fantasy".
For example, in ST-DS9, there is a changeling named Odo who can change "his" mass, e.g., turn from a normal-sized humanoid into a mouse or water glass and back again (yet for some reason he has trouble with his face).
Now, being able to change from one thing to another of the same mass and elemental composition (e.g., like Mistique from the X-Men) is Science Fiction, because we can't do it yet, but it doesn't really violate any laws of physics.
(It could probably be done on human-sized entities using nanotechnology, and can already be done by very small animals (e.g., protozoa, which can extend pseudopods and the like).)
Being able to change from one thing into another of a different elemental composition (e.g., from a water/carbon humanoid to a metal desk and back again) requires transmutation of elements, which is theoretically possible but would require so much energy that everyone around the being would be burned to death, so that wanders into the realm of Sci-Fi.
Finally, being able to change from one thing into another of different elemental composition and mass without releasing or requiring an insane amount of energy (e.g., a 200-lb. water/carbon humanoid into a 1-lb. silicon glass and back again) would totally violate the laws of physics, so that's Fantasy.
Also, science fiction is more realistic within the environment.
As a plot becomes more and more unrealistic (e.g., computer screens that display "Password" in 76-point type and flash "Password Accepted" for several seconds before going to the next screen of 76-point type), it wanders into the realm of Sci-Fi.
Movies where a twelve-year-old girl sits in front of a computer and joyfully exclaims "This is UNIX! I know this!" while a velocoraptor is trying to break into the room to eat her are Fantasy.
Movies like "Marooned" are Science Fiction.
Movies like "Space Cowboys" and "Silent Running" are Sci-Fi.
Movies like "Armageddon" and "Capricorn 1" are Fantasy (the first because a single nuke split an asteroid "the size of Texas" into exactly two pieces that barely missed the Earth but produced no tidal effects, and the second because there is no way that such a massive conspiracy could remain secret).
Movies like "Independence Day" are just stupid.
On this Science Fiction / Sci-Fi / Fantasy line, BSG hovers around Sci-Fi.
It has some Science-Fictional elements, such as space travel and the Cylons, some Sci-Fi elements, such as artificial gravity on most of the ships (except for the rotating one (What, couldn't they afford it?)) and Cylon resurrection and the Cylon-human hybrid, and some Fantasy elements, such as FTL travel and the recent relationship between Apollo and Starbuck.
Those who sacrifice security to condemn liberty deserve to repeat history or something. - Benjamin Santayana