Slashdot Mirror


User: wonkey_monkey

wonkey_monkey's activity in the archive.

Stories
0
Comments
8,419
First seen
Last seen
Profile
(view on slashdot.org)

Comments · 8,419

  1. Re:Uhhh... what did he just say to us? on Study: Our 3D Universe Could Have Originated From a 4D Black Hole · · Score: 1
    An astronaut - or any other object - crossing the event horizon of a large enough black hole wouldn't feel a thing (small ones are a different matter; tidal forces would tear him apart before he got that close). From the perspective of an outsider, he may for all intents and purposes no longer exist (although actually to an outside observer he'd appear to get closer and closer but never cross), but as far as he's concerned, he still does.

    If instead the chair is converted into particles smaller even than electrons

    Where'd you get that from?

  2. Re:Uhhh... what did he just say to us? on Study: Our 3D Universe Could Have Originated From a 4D Black Hole · · Score: 1

    Would you say the same about a square circle and if not why not?

    A square circle is a contradiction in terms. A 4D object is just hard (not impossible) to visualize, and pretty much by definition has a 3D surface. It can (probably, I haven't done the maths) even project a 3D shadow onto the 3D surface of another 4D object.

    A 3D surface would not seem to be a particularly useful concept even if we could imagine such a thing.

    You're just not imagining hard enough. Don't just scoff and dismiss as ridiculous that which you don't care to comprehend.

    Needless to say, like square circles, there isn't a shred of evidence for the existence of 3 dimensional surfaces.

    There's no evidence for their physical (not least because, as you may have noticed, we live in a 3D universe so such objects are impossible here), but as mathematical constructs they are perfectly cromulent. Just because you can't imagine a 3D surface of a 4D object, doesn't mean others can't. Mathematicians have been "studying" n-dimensional objects for years.

  3. Re:Two touchscreen phones on German Data Protection Expert Warns Against Using iPhone5S Fingerprint Function · · Score: 1

    Just in case you're serious (you can never tell) - no, you couldn't do that.

  4. Re:The reason for the dimensional reduction? on Study: Our 3D Universe Could Have Originated From a 4D Black Hole · · Score: 1

    Because the surface that is the event horizon has N-1 dimensions.

  5. Re:God needed? on Study: Our 3D Universe Could Have Originated From a 4D Black Hole · · Score: 1

    That is, God needs to be something that doesn't need or have an explanation.

    If you can accept the existence of a God that doesn't need or have an explanation (and wasn't created by another entity), why can't you accept a universe that doesn't need or have an explanation (and wasn't created by another entity)?

  6. Re:good summary on Study: Our 3D Universe Could Have Originated From a 4D Black Hole · · Score: 2

    If we can accept that the universe exists without demanding to know how it started

    Then you're not being very scientific about it.

    Physics needs get over this notion that when cosmology can't explain something we just gather it and put it in a bigger bag with a new label on it and call it a theory.

    What's the alternative? If we can't explain it, don't even try? No. You gather it up, you put it in a bigger bag with a new label on it, and then you let the rest of the community do their best to come up with something which explains the world better. And that's science.

    **SOMETHING** started the universe...who cares if it was God or something else...

    I care. I want to know.

  7. Re:Uhhh... what did he just say to us? on Study: Our 3D Universe Could Have Originated From a 4D Black Hole · · Score: 4, Insightful

    A surface is 2 dimensional by definition.

    No, it isn't. It's two-dimensional only by everyday common experience.

    Once something has passed the edge of the visible universe it is effectively lost to us

    Only until we build a bigger telescope.

    No, we'll never see it. The light from there will never reach us.

    It's not really the same because anything that collides with a black hole will cease to exist.

    No, it won't.

    YANAP

  8. Re:TV on Stephen Colbert and the Monster Truck of Tivos · · Score: 5, Funny

    Oh hey, you're the guy.

  9. From the dept of the bleedin' obvious on Dogs Love Robots, Prefer Humans · · Score: 1

    So dogs prefer to hang around and interact with the creatures they've been hanging around with and interacting with since birth, in the individual sense, and since domestication, as a species. Glad we cleared that one up.

  10. Really bad choice of article quote on The Boy Genius of Ulan Bator · · Score: 3, Insightful

    From the article: 'Battushig, playing the role of the car

    Huh? What car?

    moved into the sensor's path to show me how it worked

    How what worked?

    "The use of the long wires is very inconvenient for my users,"

    Well, obviously.

    He realized that contractors would be reluctant to install the siren in other buildings

    What siren?

    TL;DR: Next time, pick a paragraph from the article that makes sense in isolation.

  11. Re:30%? on Intel Shows 14nm Broadwell Consuming 30% Less Power Than 22nm Haswell · · Score: 5, Funny

    In other tests, one chip was shown to use 100% less power when switched off.

  12. Potential? on It Takes 2.99 Gigajoules To Vaporize a Human Body · · Score: 2

    around the same energy that a 2,000-pound car going 70 miles per hour on the highway has in potential.

    Wouldn't that be kinetic?

  13. Wow! Amazing! on Raspberry Pi As an Ad Blocking Access Point · · Score: 1

    Computer does thing other computers can do!

  14. Re:B effing S on First Gear Mechanism Discovered In Nature · · Score: 1

    My feeling is that a lot people with creationist leanings just don't understand quite how long a billion years actually is.

  15. Re:B effing S on First Gear Mechanism Discovered In Nature · · Score: 1

    The difference between my approach and that of the naturalistic scientific community is that my worldview does not require our universe to be a closed system.

    Science doesn't require anything of anything. It certainly doesn't require the universe to be a closed system. There's plenty of active scientific research and theory going on around the subject. Is our universe just an inflated patch of another universe? Are we living on the three dimensional surface of a four dimensional brane? And so on.

    and I find that a lot of things in life make a lot more sense with that approach.

    A lot of things make a lot more sense for people when they can just throw up their arms and say "God did it!" It doesn't actually get you anywhere, though. A lot of science is about saying "this doesn't make sense - why not?"

  16. Re:Faster way of reaching interstellar space on It's Official: Voyager 1 Is an Interstellar Probe · · Score: 2

    Why? Do you/"we" know the helipause isn't spherical, or did you just assume it isn't? Or are you using another definition of "interstellar space"?

  17. Correction on It's Official: Voyager 1 Is an Interstellar Probe · · Score: 1

    It's Arbitrary: Voyager 1 Is An Interstellar Probe, Probably

  18. Re:Ideas.... on Facebook Deletes Social Fixer Community Page Without Explanation · · Score: 3, Funny

    You just need a Greasemonkey script to sanitise his Greasemonkey script every time it gets an update.

  19. Re:Not Surprising at all! on Facebook Deletes Social Fixer Community Page Without Explanation · · Score: 1

    Facebook got rid of something that...

    They've only got rid of it from Facebook. It's still alive and kicking at its own website.

  20. Re:Steambox on Valve Announces Family Sharing On Steam, Can Include Friends · · Score: 3, Informative

    steambox n. pl. steam-box-es pretentious pl. steam-box-en

  21. Very sad on He Fixed 300,000+ Machines - America's Oldest Typewriter Repairman Dies At 96 · · Score: 5, Funny

    R.I.{.

  22. Re:Don't Forget Jimmy Carter on Snowden Nominated For Freedom of Thought Prize · · Score: 1

    He's history's greatest monster!

  23. And his next book is about... uh... on Meet the Guy Who Fact-Checks Stephen King On Stephen King · · Score: 3, Funny

    ...a lamp monster! Ooo-oooh!

  24. Re:Moron on Bomb Defuse Simulator 2013: a Head-Tracking Tech Demo · · Score: 1

    You're a moron.

    Who's a moron?

  25. Re:Nothing new on Wireless Charging Start-Up Claims 30-Foot Radius · · Score: 1

    Nikola Tesla demonstrated a 100 Watt light bulb being lit 92 miles away from his Colorado Springs lab about 100 years ago.

    Did he, really? Or did you pull those numbers out of thin air based on a half-remembered page you saw on Geocities once?