Slashdot Mirror
Google Releases WAP Search Tool
ChrisUK writes "Google seem to have single-handedly brought html to WAP devices. WAP/Palm users can log on to www.google.com on their devices, and search through Google's web database. Furthermore, the pages that are linked to can be jumped to, and will be converted to wml on the fly. More details can be found here."
Yep, you guys were right, and I was wrong, I missed that link.
In my defense, it does not say "1-5 out of 15000" (like on the regular page) but only "1-5".
Google does have advertising, and has had it for some time now. The main thing is, the way things are set up right now, Google only shows an ad if it might be relevant. Google isn't showing random ads ("run of site" ads) on every single page. So if the things you search for don't happen to be interesting to an advertiser, Google isn't showing an ad to you. Some topics just aren't commercial enough. For example, if all you search for is pages about ancient Mayan rituals, you may not have ever seen an ad on Google. On the other hand, if you're searching for airline tickets or Mother's day flowers, you might be seeing lots of ads.
Google obviously thought it was a good idea when they saw the demo at Xift's launch party a month ago.
Funny thing they claim to be first.
Sprint uses the UP.Browser v3.1. The gateway
converts a submit of WML 1.1 to HDML so these
phones can see it. It won't do fonts / italics,
and it wants to display regular BPMs instead of
WBMPs, but it gets by.
It's true that the newer phones and certainly the 3G phones will include a GPS receiver, in fact I think the FCC have made it a requirement. The excuse for doing this is so emergency calls can be located, also it has some spin offs with WAP too, i.e. you can automatically find the nearest restaurant from your current location, or the phone will be able to produce a "you are here" type map.
There is also talk of combining this with marketing too; it seems a little farfetched at the moment though, i.e. when you pull up on a Mobile forecourt your WAP phone beeps and a discount voucher for the Shell voucher down the road appears.
Also, if you're paranoid of being tracked, don't carry a mobile at all, people can currently be tracked by triangulating the signals from three cells, obviously not as accurate as GPS though.
If that article isn't on the main page, where was it?
ass.
You must be kidding me... if you had a choice between getting HTML content in an inconvenient form, or not at all, you'd choose not at all. If you have reason to check HTML pages on the move, even if it won't be the easiest to use, it could be very handy. Could save a few people from buying another mobile device.
tangent - art and creation are a higher purpose
postmoderncore - art and creation are a higher purpose
Quios.com already has a system that sends slashdot headlines to GSM via SMS. You get two messages every day (you can define the time of day).
In Finland we our economy is greatly depending on Nokia's success.
Well, I have a Nokia communications peice, a 5110....and it doesn't seem to work properly. I tried to contact the managing director of the Nokia corporation to complain about it, but I couldn't reach him. It seems when ever I try to send SMS to a remote communications peice, it says: "Message could not be sent - This time." So I waited for a few minutes, and it came up with the same thing.
Finns make good gadgets
See above. Not really. The phone part works fine, but the SMS part is what concerns me.
Thanks, cheers.
no sig
I think HTML to WML is more a translation rather than a redistribution. A fine line, but I haven't heard of anyone sueing bablefish lately, have you?
...When a query of "nonfatal weapons" takes 0.03 seconds and thousands of matches just magically show up
Nokia's browser is pretty nice, and their developer's kit is slightly more sophisticated than Phone.com's. I don't know what Nokia phones contain their browser, but I'm fairly certain that none of them are available in the U.S. Fortunately, it seems Phone.com is giving up on HDML, as their most recent SDK (v. 4.0) does not even support it. It's WML only!
There is no gravity...the earth just sucks.
Probably I lost it somewhere... Gonna have to search for it...
The reason for this being that _all_ US-based phones currently only support HDML. I'm actually at a conference where phone.com spoke today, and they made it amply clear that their primary reason for doing this was to provide content at all in the states, due to the general lack of WML-phones out there worldwide. Phone.com isn't the only criminal out there in this regard.. apparently Nokia's wireless browser follows the WAP spec differently than Phone.com's, and thus doesn't render pages in the same way. Ahh, browser fragmentation. Just like the old days with Netscape and IE.. wait, uh. -s
---- noi non potemo aver perfetta vita senza amici -- Dante
my point is, get your fucking head out from under your rock and look around, there are analog phones everywhere and the rest are dual mode. second, this is about wap lending a device to being tracked specifically, an untruth.
Fast Search and Transfer ASA has had a WAP search engine up for quite some time at http://wap.fast.no/ and it's very fast; they use pattern matching hardware.
I just connected, entered 'slashdot' as a search term, started reading articles.
On a mobile phone screen there's a LOT of scrolling. Each page also goes through the banner, header, sidebar (faq|code|awards|etc), Sections and (for articles) the login box. After all that though, you _do_ get the meat of the page. Nice!
Unfortunately the forms are not translated - so you can not log in, you can not enter searches, and you can not post/reply. This will limit its usefulness for the types of searches you'd use a mobile phone for - an example here: What's the number for a taxi? Google will take you to a taxi locator web page, but you wont be able to tell the web page where you are so that it can give you a local taxi firm's number.
Still, it's nice - better than most wap pages I've come across so far.
Cederic
ps: In trying to access the 'reply' page to respond to a comment through the phone it "crashed" and didn't reset until I received a text message (which by coincidence arrived as I was typing this sentence - I was planning to post then yank the battery - no need now!) The "crash" took the form of a message saying 'Connecting' and none of the phone's buttons responding.
I just attended a WAP seminar last week and the presented said that Google was completely unusuable on WAP devices because the information was presented so poorly.
I haven't seen it in action myself -- can anyone confirm?
Yes, I remember when google was just a child. I started using google when it was still a science project then stopped using it for a while. How happy I got when I heard that they had gotten a real web site; and now they have gone so fast as to go past many of the other sites. I hope that google can put an end to those portals and allow us to go back to the old plain search engines. (I heard that altavista has a plain version; is that beacause of google?)
Anyone remember what issue of new scientist that had a story about search engines in summer-autumn of 1998? I remember that they mentioned how google works, and I'd really like to read it again. (at least I think it was new scientist)
Unless I am mistaken, most of the wireless networks around here (here in Ohio anyway...) use HDML (Handheld Device Markup Language) rather than WAP. That goes for Sprint PCS's wireless internet phone browsers and also Verizon(SUCKS!) [Formerly Airtouch]. So what good does this do us?
------
Populus Vult Decipi, Ergo Decipiatur.
MadPoetSociety.org
------
Fuck you all.
How can *this* be insightful? This is also totally misleading post - google.com *does* advertising, not in ridiculously obvious way though. Try this link to check that out. And who dares to claim that the guys (verio.com) who got priority for their link to display on top have not paid google? Now, I am all for google to succeed and make money, however, making statements like above is a sure way to have your mind rotten. yeagh, blame me for spelling/grammar now.
Not long ago I noticed that sometimes when searching on google the pages are returned in different orders even though I used the same search terms. After investigating a bit I realized that I was using the same terms but in different orders. I emailed google to ask about this, and they said that the default search is a phrase search. If that doesn't work they then try and AND search.
Further, if you check out googles search tips regarding phrase searching you will find that if you use quatation marks around your search terms you will be doing a phrase search.
No more metacrawler
Need a website host? Try out http://WebQualityHost.net
--
The shareholder is always right.
its an optional filter. its not mandatory. in any event, it doesnt seem to be implemented yet..when i searched for linux video software several porno sites turned up.
So Xift based their whole company's concept on something that google could get going in a month (from scratch)? Either this whole thing is nothing special or the Google guys are pretty damn smart/fast.
...Or maybe your insinuation that they stole the idea from Xift is just off-base and bitter on your part.
ha ha
except you are confusing WAP with WOP.
...................
...................
...................
When or how can I get /. on my Plam via AvantGo? Productivity wise I think this could be the worst possibel thing to happen to me... if only my boss new! I could be reading /. while some idiot suit babbles on in one of a dozen or so corporate meetings I am forced to attend. Any help in furthering my /. addiction would be appriciated.
----------
No army can withstand the strength of an idea whose time has come.
- Victor Hugo
And it looked great. I had to bookmark it on my cellular phone.
/. ?
IBM is also creating their html -> wml transcoder and proxy combination. ( Link)
Let's see who will win this competion.
But I don't understand why three is need to have all this html, wml and xml languages. Xml should be enough?
I have seen some palm devices which has html and wml browsers on same machine. And WAP pages are not so nice looking...
Any wap/wml developers reading
[ Advertizing Banner Here ] dUb(at)lumi'dyndns'org
Quite amusing. I did a search for patent and nobody is even talking about this. did you know that google has a patent on their search technology? So, if you do something similar then you are in breach of patent laws. um. this is Bad.
for those of you who don't know,
http://www.google.com/linux
and
http://www.google.com/mac
and maybe some others give you neat little custom google frontends (what a cute penguin).
So as soon as NMP gets off its butt and delivers something that doesn't tout snap-on covers as a great technical innovation, you might have a point. Until then you sound like someone who tells people how awful cars are because people should be using personal flying machines.
Apparently when converting to something viewable under WAP, japanese text gets munged. This was the case on every page I looked at on my Sony C305S (using IDO cdmaOne).
In that constraint, this is an interesting (and maybe even useful) service
:-P
I'd say the better solution would be to use and drive sites that *DO* provide the WML based content you want, instead of relying on such a cludge. Or, since they are taking off, start your own site. It's only like 19.95 to do now adays..
Define "Web". Why should the Web be HTML only ?
I should have been more specific. I was speaking of the HTML based WWW.
and a temporary fix to the WML content shortage isn't going to hurt.
I disagree that it can't hurt. If cludges like this are used to advertise the 'capabilities' of wireless networking, it leaves a VERY bad taste in ones mouth. One person buys the phone, and uses this. It looks terrible. He doesn't like it. He tells 5 friends, and so on..
It's not perfect, but it's a handy thing until some better WML content comes along
Then we get someone else along, becouse the longer a hack like this needs to exist, the worse the technology looks. And unfortionatly, a hack like this has *nothing* to do with WAP. It is, as you said, the lack of available pages that serve WAP content. I'd rather see not much QUALITY data, then a whole lotta hacked crap.
-- I'm the root of all that's evil, but you can call me cookie..
The issue here isn't the WAP format really, but the conversation of two incompatible formats. HTML looks *HORRIBLE* converted to WML, due to WML's tag limitations. Many, *MANY* formatting tags simply do not exist in the WML specs. WML is built around a very strict idea of 'less is more'. While your Ericsson is plenty nice to display everything, that *SAME EXACT* content is also formatted in such a way to display on a 4x16 chacter screen, perhaps even without graphics capabilities..
-- I'm the root of all that's evil, but you can call me cookie..
Nice to see a webpage that is actually usefull for what its made for being pused to the public. I am tired of hearing about Yahoo, etc. All they are now is just a vehicle for overpriced stock.
...
With this functionality, I might actually get a wireless palm...
I don't think anyone else has this kind of thing in place yet...
and more browers getting varied in performance, wouldn't it make more scence for these devices to use a more exact language like XML or something like that that would still be compatable with all the other browsers out there but not have to translate 'on the fly' first?
-----
If my facts are wrong then tell me. I don't mind.
This is great news for google! It has been my search engine of choice for a while, and they continue to innovate! I still have to use metacrawler every once in a while though for phrases...
I just got packet data service (includes WAP broswer) enabled on my Motorola i1000+ with NEXTEL service in the US.
;-)
Using the default WAP broswer, with minimal HTTP content transator, included with the i1000+ phone, I was unable to read slashdot. However, going through google, I was able to read (but not login or post) with the same limitations described for the Nokia 7110e (i.e. lots of scrolling and hitting `more...' to get to the meat of the content).
Regards,
Loren
PS, the i1000+ hasn't crashed on me while trying to reply.
Disclaimer: I do work for Motorola Labs.
I always knew Google was up to something . . . hehe that is probably the best search engine I use - no advertisements. Good to see good people doing good things.
-Leo
Are there any WAP browsers for Palm V's ?
It does seem like a bit of a gimmic to me, however I suppose if I had a mobile phone then it may be more useful.
Crispin
http://slashdot.org/article.pl?s id=00/05/13/201252
-- Don't Tase me, bro!
So, now guys can drive, drink coffee, talk on their cells, and search for "Petrified Natalie Portman" all at the same time. The roads are going to be really safe.
Seriously, the on-the-fly translation is very cool.
The PR states that it is still in beta, but www.google.com/palm returned 5 hits for 'farts', while google proper had about 15000. I would have figured that they would use the same database, so I don't really understand the difference.
This is neat, but I'm still waiting for a good, free WAP browser for my Palm III / pdqPhone. AvantGo and the pdqSuite are good for rendering real HTML, but being able to use WAP would allow access to even lighter weight sites.
.sig .sig
Joe Wells
the no
the no
In Finland we our economy is greatly depending on Nokia's success. Finns make good gadgets but no content. So we have WAP network here and phones but nobody has any use for it yet. So maybe this is really a turn for the better.
By the way the chairman of Nokia is almost like Micro$oft's lawyers. A small newspaper aimed at young people wrote (pardon me for my bad translation) "Jorma Ollila's (the chairman) shoulders are suprisingly small" (Ollila has more power in Finland than our goverment and president together...) So Ollila informs the mag that this is clearly an error... It's fun to live in a country lead by a corporation that is lot like Microsoft.
(By the way I hope Nokia will send Slashdot some mail copying their example Microsoft...)
google.com seems to be getting more and more features. I remember when i was just like "Enter Search" and you'd get your fast as hell results. Then catagories showed up, then multi languages showed up. I just hope google.com doesn't turn into yahoo.com with Yahoo! Games, Yahoo! ISP, Yahoo! Credit cards. I really like google.com and I'd hate to see it become a big bloated site with banner ads and such.
-PovRayMan
----------
Check out my blackbox styles
Metacrawler now searches . But it seems that Microsoft's homepage has dropped off the top 30 on the more evil than Satan himself scale.
Will I retire or break 10K?
Actually there are ads on google, just not banner ads. i was surprised when i saw them too, just do a search for palm, or visit this link http://www.google.c om/search?q=palm&num=10&meta=hl%3Den%26lr%3D
cristiana
I could rant (once again) about how WAP sucks, but I think this page says it quite well.
/mill
http://www.ics.uci.edu/~rohit/IEEE-L7-WAP.html
If only the telecom industry had focused on giving us GPRS instead of inventing yet another crappy 'standard'. HTML is platform agnostic anyway, but then they are catering "web designers" so...
Uh, my phone doesn't have that option... (Sprint PCS) Do you have a URL for it?
Another non-functioning site was "uncertainty.microsoft.com."
The purpose of that site was not known.
But these are all features designed to improve searching, so I don't see what the problem is. It's not like they are making "Google Games" or "MyGoogleMail" -- they are just making enhancements to searching.
At least one way is by providing services to commercial content providers. http://www.washingtonpost.com/ for example.
More info is availabe at Google of course. Try this: http://www.google.com/websearch_progr ams.html
Essentially, people pay for the right to frame customized Google results.
For all intensive purposes, "whom" is no longer a word. That begs the question, "who cares"?
hey /. stop being so damn stupid wen it comes to wireless stuff. everyone and their goddam uncle had some sort of HTML -> WML/HDML converter, spyglass, oracle, ibm, phone.com, 60 startups and a infinate number of monkeys coding in a room somewhere in silicon valley. and every one of them transcodes like shit. cauze downcasting rich content to a 4x12 character screen is not something any software and do generically and well.
Rich
Read the Mortals and Angels article in new scientist? Now check out the screensaver at
From the article: " Unlike other search engines that index only web pages that are available in WML, Google brings more than 500 million web pages to the palm of a user's hand. When a wireless user requests a traditional HTML page, Google's innovative technology translates the requested HTML document on the fly into WML."
Given the recent concerns about redistribution of copyright materials, how does this contrast with the MS concern?
Could it not be said that:
"Unlike other discussion groups that only index technical specifications, Slashdot.org brings more of the real spec into the palm of a programers hand. When a Slashdot user requests a traditional ZIP technical specification, Slashdots' innovative users translate the requested ZIP document on the fly into TXT."
___
now I can finally read the wml version of slashdot.
<br><BR><BR>Slashdot.org's wml never seems to work.
http://jones.ling.indiana.edu/~prrodrig
Nearly all of the new WAP phones sold in the UK are WAP enabled now, consequently I got interested in this. I've been playing around with WAP for the last few days, I've set up a WAP site which grabs headlines from a dozen news sites (slashdot included), I've also got a translator and spell checker working. Anyway, if you wanna check it out : try http://aztech.dyndns.org in a WAP browser
It's quite a good technology to work with, it's somewhat limited when on my Nokia 7110 phone though, due to the small screen and the 14.4kbps limit on GSM. I believe GPRS is being rolled out in a couple of months, so you will be able to get constant 100kbps access without having to dialin, all we need now it a decent colour display.
It's clever how they've got HTML -> WML on-the-fly, however things would be much easier if sites adopted xHTML, it can degrade much more gracefully than standard html.
This ones cool :*) I want to see more of this kindm cause WAP sucks at the current state of development.
,)
congrat. thoric
This sounds like it really has some promise, but I really can't help from being skeptical.
I mean, I don't really have a Palm, so I can't really speak for myself, but how good are pages being viewed as WML via WAP going to look?
I mean, can it view graphics also? I hope it looks better than viewing webpages with lynx on a WYSE terminal.
The article you're thinking of is in Scientific American. It's primarily about CLEVER, a project at IBM that tries to identify "hubs" (pages with links to good information) and "authorities" (pages with good information), but it also mentions Google. It'd be interesting to see CLEVER available on the web.. the last time I looked, it was only for internal IBM use.
- Amit
If you want to see what Google's WAP service looks like, there's a really cool emulator at: http://www.yospace.com/.
--
Everything I know in life I learnt from
Rich
Read the Mortals and Angels article in new scientist? Now check out the screensaver here (It's open source too)
I don't know about that. I have a wap device, an Ericsson MC218. It's a pda with a 640x240 screen, so it's probably enough for wml since its good enough for viewing html pages. Although I've never used its wap browser, I'd imagine it should be somewhat faster than browsing regular html. (Oh yeah, my cellphone has a 9.6kbps modem. :-) )
This is quite simply the biggest waste I've ever seen.
Far from the silliest idea. It's a kludge - I doubt anyone would disagree. The current situation is though that there are starting to be reasonable numbers of WAP devices in circulation and there's still little content for them. In that constraint, this is an interesting (and maybe even useful) service.
WAP devices where *NOT BUILT* to browse the web.
Define "Web". Why should the Web be HTML only ? The Web ought to (and will) encompass a range of content formats, serving a range of devices. Of course WAP devices are built to surf the Web (what else are they for ?), and a temporary fix to the WML content shortage isn't going to hurt.
WML is syntax specific for maximum usage on small screens.
Now we're getting into the details. IMHE, WML isn't a bad syntax for placing Slashdot-sized web pages onto devices with smaller screens. What's the real killer is the tiny WAP deck size limit. Now that is really over-optimised for phone-size screens, to the point where the protocol can't even work usefully on a PDA. I have personally been bitten badly by this, enough to make me sink projects and change my career direction for several months.
practical usage? Practically zilch./em>
I think you're too hard on it. It's not perfect, but it's a handy thing until some better WML content comes along.
Taken the complaints many people have that an HTML page can not always be rendered very nicely into WML, I tried to find out search engines that searched exclusively for WML pages. I found at least four different engines. Two of them seem to be more or less bogus (Waply and WapWarp). The best one seems to be FAST Wap Search. Are the any other good WAP search engines out there?
Everybody can test this portal by using one of these wap toolkits:
Ericsson
Motorola
Nokia
phone.com
This is quite simply the biggest waste I've ever seen. WAP devices where *NOT BUILT* to browse the web. WML is syntax specific for maximum usage on small screens. Attempting to convert typical HTML pages on the fly to WML is 'quaint' at best. Neat idea, but practical usage? Practically zilch. Better to build a WAP search engine to search for WAP content..
-- I'm the root of all that's evil, but you can call me cookie..