Slashdot Mirror


Newest Mandrake Linux Delayed

Jens Lönn writes: "Linux seller MandrakeSoft has had to delay shipment of its newest version of Linux because of problems in moving manufacturing to the United States. Mandrake Linux 8.1 is available as a download, but the first CDs of the product were supposed to ship by the end of September. "Getting 8.1 production up and running in North America has been a slow and expensive process," the company said in a e-mail message to those who have ordered the CD." Since Mandrake makes certains things so easy (smooth installation), I hope they soon get their newest release again on Walmart shelves across the U.S.

179 comments

  1. It royally by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    made me go back to Mdk80....

    Not because it is bad, but because the Network-FTP ruined my original Mdk80. It must be some sort of feature I am not used to.

  2. Slow and expensive? by AndroidCat · · Score: 1

    I wouldn't think that setting up a CD production line would be that slow or expensive.

    Obviously I don't understand the problem. :^) Hopefully they'll get it all sorted out soon.

    --
    One line blog. I hear that they're called Twitters now.
    1. Re:Slow and expensive? by Kruemelmo · · Score: 1

      I'd assume "slow and expensive" refers to contract / business / condition rather than technical problems. After all, the iso images and all should be the same for France or the US...

    2. Re:Slow and expensive? by humps · · Score: 1

      "contract / business / condition rather than technical problems"
      that seems logical, may be mandrake should turn to those in the far east for (i)legal CD production(duplication), I know they're pretty fast :)

      humps

    3. Re:Slow and expensive? by JM · · Score: 4, Insightful
      It *is* slow, believe me


      1) Get quotes and find the right supplier

      2) Fill in the credit application form

      3) Hit voicemail

      4) Get the iso images burned on a CD-R and tested on a few machines to make sure the media is OK

      5) Get the artwork in a format that's readable by the film-maker (sorry, gotta use QuarkXpress)

      6) Get the artwork to a print bureau and check the output for any errors

      7) Get the address where to send all the materials

      8) Send them

      9) Make sure all they received is okay

      10) Hit the voice mail

      11) It's weekend, so it will have to wait until monday

      12) The CD plant received all the documents

      13) They make the film for printing

      14) They fax you a copy

      15) You approve the copy and send it back

      16) They call to ask it you want a white background or leave it silvery. They hit your voicemail

      17) You call them back and tell them to leave it silvery

      18) They start manufacturing

      19) A couple of days later, your CDs are ready, they ship it to you via UPS/Fedex/Whatever

      20) You receive them in your warehouse and have to ship thousands of CDs one-by-one

    4. Re:Slow and expensive? by AndroidCat · · Score: 1

      You left out all the government paperwork involved in hiring employees, allowing people from France to work in the U.S., permits for manufacturing, environmental impact, lawyers and accountants, and so on, and so on...

      Those must have been big tarrifs!

      --
      One line blog. I hear that they're called Twitters now.
    5. Re:Slow and expensive? by JM · · Score: 1

      The paperwork you're talking about is only if Mandrake would have built their own CD plant, which is not the case.

    6. Re:Slow and expensive? by AndroidCat · · Score: 1

      That depends on how the government defines manufacturing. Sticking CDs and a manual into a box and plastic wrapping it might qualify. Who knows when the government sets the rules?

      The paperwork for employees and work permits for aliens still apply.

      --
      One line blog. I hear that they're called Twitters now.
    7. Re:Slow and expensive? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This is why things are so slow in America.

      A professional would have given the precise specifications and not wast time playing phone tag on voice mail.

      And printing only takes 3-4 days including film approval and 4 color print process.

      Pressing CD's is a matter of a week.

      you could be shiping these in under 14 days.

    8. Re:Slow and expensive? by Araneas · · Score: 1
      There was a big push on in Canada about 15+ years ago to "Buy Canadian". I was in the Bay (Hudson's Bay Company, quintessential Canadian store) when I noticed a snowblower plastered with a big Made In Canada sticker. Closer examination revealed, the engine was American the tires German and much of the metalwork Japanese.

      I guess assembling a few bits does count as manufacturing.

  3. Is this related to the poor reviews by typical+geek · · Score: 2, Funny

    at Adequacy and other outlets? Really, Mandrake can't let their critics get to them.

    1. Re:Is this related to the poor reviews by choose-two · · Score: 1

      What 'other sites' reviewed Linux Mandrake 8.1 badly? I've just installed it - my first experience with a non-M$ OS since CP/M - and it's great!

    2. Re:Is this related to the poor reviews by Unknown+Bovine+Group · · Score: 5, Funny
      For those who don't know adequacy is a humorous, sarcastic site and the Mandrake "review" seems to be an in-depth attempt at satire. However from the discussion underneath I think many people missed that. Some of the better part of the review:

      the release of Linux Mandrake 8.1, aggressively timed to coincide with that of Microsoft's much vaunted Windows XP, marks the start of the final battle for domination of the computer industry.

      The Linux operating system was born in 1991 and was created by one man, a Finnish student coincidentally named Linux Torvalds.

      Previous versions of Linux have been named Red Hat, Slack Ware, Storm and Coral. In stark contrast to the mundane names such as 98, ME or NT preferred by Microsoft, the crazy names of each Linux release hint at its renegade nature.

      why isn't the industry standard web browser, Internet Explorer, included with Linux? Despite the best efforts of the experts at the Internet Engineering Task Force to encourage adoption of the Internet Explorer standard, the creators of Linux seem to think that they know better.

      But here's the dead giveaway:
      Computer security is also an area that seems to have been overlooked by the developers of Linux. In these times when hacking and viruses are commonplace, it defies belief to learn that no anti-virus software is available for Linux. To add insult to injury, there is no Linux version of the popular ZoneAlarm firewall. By using Linux, you are issuing an open invitation to the hordes of ne'er-do-wells on the Internet.

      The shortcomings of Linux are obvious. Without even installing Linux Mandrake, I have exposed several fundamental flaws.

      As with most Satire, the danger lies in the unwashed masses taking it literally...

      --
      m00.
    3. Re:Is this related to the poor reviews by jrockway · · Score: 1

      That reviewer must have been legally retarded! Where did he get his facts?

      --
      My other car is first.
    4. Re:Is this related to the poor reviews by Afrosheen · · Score: 1

      Yeah that article was hilarious. Intentional misspellings, broad-ranging comments, etc. The bit about Internet Explorer was funny as hell. As an aside, and I don't know how many of you 'Drake users have noticed this yet, but Konqueror in Mandrake has a link to adequacy.org. Even the people at mandrakeforum didn't realize this was a joke..all you have to do is read adequacy's mission statement and you can decide from there.

  4. Smooth Installation... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Very smooth installation...until you mistakingly think the grey colored stars meant selected and format the wrong hard drives :(

    1. Re:Smooth Installation... by Solidblu · · Score: 2, Informative

      I know what you mean I almost did that at least 5 times, call me stupid but I think a white box with a check or no check should be a standard for selecting or not selecting things because if you don't understand that you are too stupid to be deciding something

    2. Re:Smooth Installation... by Jaysyn · · Score: 3, Informative

      Ok stupid ;).

      If you change the theme of the Installer GUI (bottom left hand corner) it does have little silver & black checkboxes. Of course, it would have been nice if they made that theme the default.

      Jaysyn

      --
      There is a war going on for your mind.
    3. Re:Smooth Installation... by xanadu-xtroot.com · · Score: 1

      NO KIDDING!

      I've been using MDK for a couple years now. I just slapped my MDK 8.1 Install CD in a box to test this. I honestly didn't know those little colored bars at the bottom DID anything...
      Thanx for the tip!

      --
      I'm not a prophet or a stone-age man,
      I'm just a mortal with potential of a super man.
    4. Re:Smooth Installation... by ThatComputerGuy · · Score: 3, Interesting

      A themeable installer? What the hell is the world coming to? That's just about as useless as the music in XP's setup (aside from the rest of XP's setup, which is useless as well).

      --
      XML is like violence. If it doesn't solve the problem, use more.
    5. Re:Smooth Installation... by bonzoesc · · Score: 2

      Don't dis the generic techno. It provides fun if you install XP with musically inclined friends nearby. That, and it sounds just like the generic techno in all your favorite movie scenes: the train station in Unbreakable, whatever scene it was in the Matrix with generic techno (I distinctly remember that from my last viewing, but I forget which scene,) and a scene from Office Space IIRC.

    6. Re:Smooth Installation... by Jaysyn · · Score: 1

      The ironic part is that I'm a Linux newbie, and Mandrake 8.1 was only my 2nd successful linux install, the first being Icepack. I couldn't deal with working in 640x480 so I tried out Mandrake and fell in love....

      Jaysyn

      --
      There is a war going on for your mind.
  5. Maybe a delay is a good thing? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    There have been lots of troubles all around w/ this MDK release - devfs causing headaches, a kernel level security issue ... maybe a delay could give them time to apply fixes so that the Wal-Mart crowd won't be left wondering, "Just what is this kernel thing anyway ... "

    1. Re:Maybe a delay is a good thing? by gordon_schumway · · Score: 1

      Indeed, the kernel security issue and the devfs headaches are one and the same. http://www.linux-mandrake.com/en/security/2001/MDK SA-2001-079.php3?dis=8.1

      --

      Ha! I kill me!

  6. Seems strange to me by CaptainAlbert · · Score: 2

    When you buy a CD (music or data) in the UK, nine times out of ten it will have been manufactured in Germany, or somewhere else in Europe. We have import costs very similar to those of the US, yet it's still cheaper for foreign companies (like US-based record labels!) to have their manufacturing offshore - even when they're selling to a completely different country.

    I suspect that it's just easier for Mandrakesoft to get someone else organising their North American manufacturing and distribution all at once, rather than managing the supply chain from Europe.

    --
    These sigs are more interesting tha
    1. Re:Seems strange to me by nusuth · · Score: 1

      Ever heard of European Union? Transportation is the only cost factor for imports within EU.In fact, it is not even called "import" as the whole EU is a single market.

      --

      Gentlemen, you can't fight in here, this is the War Room!

  7. amazing nonetheless by Festering+Leper · · Score: 1, Funny

    5 yrs ago who would have thought that one could buy linux at Walmart?

    --
    if you want people to think you know what you are talking about, just put ".com" at the end of everything you say.com
    1. Re:amazing nonetheless by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What was more amazing was the Quake CDs selling at 7-11.

  8. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 1

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  9. Of course... by Greylin · · Score: 4, Informative

    There is always the availability of CDs via Cheap*Bytes

    All three CDs (two install and the supplemental) including shipping for $10 US

    --
    there are doorways I haven't opened, and windows I've yet to look through. Going forward may not be the answer..
    1. Re:Of course... by SilentChris · · Score: 2

      Except that was delayed until recently, as well. I was expecting my CDs over 2 weeks ago.

  10. wal-mart shelves? by TechnoVooDooDaddy · · Score: 2, Insightful
    You must consider the wal-mart crowd mentality tho.


    "Who in their right mind would pay for another OS when one came with the system i bought FOR FREE?!"


    It's not really a market i see happening. If you MUST have a Mandrake CD at 2am, most likely you can d/l and burn one yourself..

    1. Re:wal-mart shelves? by Solidblu · · Score: 1

      True True if you have a fast connection, but if you have a modem wtf you going to do download it at 2 am till 2am 2 days later?? Having it at a wal-mart is a convience and also supports the cause monetarily.

    2. Re:wal-mart shelves? by mrpengin · · Score: 5, Funny
      That's funny...

      I have a friend who was employed in the "electronics" department at Wal-Fart.
      While stocking shelves one day, a co-slave looked at him and said

      "What the H*LL is this [the Mandrake box]."

      My friend attempted to explain

      "So it's like Windows. Isn't that illegal."

      My friend now works at Pizza-Hut.

      --

    3. Re:wal-mart shelves? by Doc+Hopper · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Just so you know, there is a pretty significant difference between versions of packages marketed by Mandrake. The "download edition" doesn't nearly include all the software, or even quite the same install, as the commercial versions, which bundle Star Office, Real Player, and a host of other useful, but non-free, applications.

      I highly recommend buying an off-the-shelf version and comparing it to the version you downloaded. It's rather enlightening, and it's tough to go back to the "download edition" afterward.

    4. Re:wal-mart shelves? by nvrrobx · · Score: 1

      If you MUST have a Mandrake CD at 2 am, it's probably quicker to drive to your local Walmart and shell out some $$$ than it is to download it over your DSL/cable/modem/whatever... ISO images aren't exactly small.

      Spending money to support development of your favorite distro isn't a bad idea either.

  11. This bodes not well... by fmaxwell · · Score: 5, Insightful

    There is no shortage of U.S. firms capable of packaging software and Mandrake's delay in getting their product to market could have dire consequences. The entire Linux distribution market is in a precarious position. Their business model is predicated on most potential customers not having the bandwidth to download multiple CDs, but with cable modems (and DSL connections) finding their way into more and more homes, many people are finding that downloading 1-5 CDs is no big deal. Start it up, wait a few hours or go to bed, burn them the next day.

    Add a delay to the availability of a boxed distribution and suddenly people are asking their friends with high-speed connections to download and burn a set of CDs for them. Some that would have paid for a retail copy will now download it themselves rather than wait for it to appear on store shelves.

    The only hope that I see for the Linux distro market in the near future is to switch over to DVDs since most people currently lack the capability of burning DVDs from images.

    1. Re:This bodes not well... by Laszarus · · Score: 1

      Hmm, it would be interesting if distro's only offered iso's in a dvd format. That would certainly encourage purchasing boxed sets with dvd's in them.

      btw, 2 of the 4 Mandrake 8.1 offerings supply dvd's in them.

    2. Re:This bodes not well... by leviramsey · · Score: 1
      The other option is including commercial applications only on the boxed editions. For instance, Mandrake gives the boxed users )among other things):
      • Opera
      • RealPlayer
      • Adobe Acrobat
      • StarOffice
      • A few closed-source drivers
      I think, in the same vein, it might be a good idea for RedHat or Mandrake to distribute a Loki game or two in their boxed versions. For $69, you get all the previously listed apps, plus all the GPL/BSD/etc. apps you could think of, and a copy of SimCity! That's not much more than SimCity sells for by itself.
    3. Re:This bodes not well... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Insightful? Mandrake Linux 8.1 is being offered as a DVD. Also many coporations will buy linux regardless or at least linux support.

    4. Re:This bodes not well... by Chas · · Score: 2

      The problem isn't that there are no firms capable of producing the CD's.

      But Mandrake had intended, originally, to produce them overseas and ship them to the US.

      Apparently a capacity issue at their overseas facility is what prompted them to move US production into the US, rather than wait for their overseas facility to begin turning out the CDs.

      --


      Chas - The one, the only.
      THANK GOD!!!
    5. Re:This bodes not well... by moonboy · · Score: 3, Interesting



      Back when I first got DSL and downloaded my first .iso images I wondered myself how the companies that centered their business model around the compilation of a Linux distribution and the distributing of that distribution would make it in the "future" where bandwidth would be available in larger quantities and CD burners would be ubiquitous.

      Certainly we should all support our favorite distribution by purchasing a packaged product once in awhile. This isn't too hard when most are priced between $30 and $50 dollars.

      However, I do not see how these companies can continue to survive much longer without venturing into different product areas as Red Hat has done. I really don't think their revenue streams can support them for much longer. Suse has had troubles recently for some of the same reasons (IMHO).

      --

      Co-founder and designer at Music Nearby: http://musicnearby.com
    6. Re:This bodes not well... by Junta · · Score: 2

      If a distro could ship all that for $69 dollars that would be one hell of a loss somewhere, considering the price of Acrobat alone... I assume you don't mean the reader, but full application. If you mean the reader, I don't see the big deal... Throw in the Codeweavers commercial Windows-Plugin thing and you might have something... Or that commercial DVD player that ships with that IBM laptop...

      --
      XML is like violence. If it doesn't solve the problem, use more.
    7. Re:This bodes not well... by Doc+Hopper · · Score: 3, Interesting

      This is not quite correct. If I recall correctly, Mandrake has some pretty signficant bundling deals with (I think) MacMillan to distribute Mandrake with their books, and that gives them a positive revenue stream. Additionally, it seems like when Linux Mandrake gets store shelf space, it disappears very quickly. My local Wal-Mart sold out of Mandrake 8.0 boxes within a few weeks of their arrival on store shelves, and hasn't been able to keep them in stock. (Yes, that's purely anecdotal evidence which does not prove causation; it's merely an observation.)

      Contrary to some "dot-bomb" companies of recent times, it seems like the guys who make Mandrake Linux 8.1 are conservative in their approach to selling their product, and drop non-revenue-generating offerings very quickly. They started a whole portal thing for the release of 7.2, then dropped it fairly quickly since it didn't look like it would make money. As a user of Linux-Mandrake since version 5.2 (the first version), I've seen them grow the package from a small offshoot of a stock RedHat install to a robust and up-to-date distribution with an enormous developer base. Subscribe to the "cooker" mailing list for a few weeks; the volume of mail is just incredible, and package announcements come in almost daily. Yeah, the products are pushed out a little early, without incredibly robust quality assurance. I hate to say it, but the strategy worked for Microsoft, and it works for Mandrake: People (like me!)*want* the latest and greatest, and put up with problems in exchange for benefits, so put it out there early and bugfix it later. Mandrake Linux, IIRC, is not yet a publicly traded company, but it seems to me that they have their act together, and know how to market the product so they stay in the black.

      On a side note: I noticed Linux-Mandrake changed the name to "Mandrake Linux" with version 8.1. I wonder if that's a step towards calling it "Mandrake GNU/Linux" with version 8.2?

    8. Re:This bodes not well... by jrockway · · Score: 1

      You can make pdf files with LaTeX and ps2pdf, both of which are free. (Actually you can make anything a pdf with ps2pdf and a2ps :)

      --
      My other car is first.
    9. Re:This bodes not well... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      For people on modem this is very attraction to not have download all the popular commercial linux software and have it instead on 1 dvd.

    10. Re:This bodes not well... by Galvatron · · Score: 2

      They are publicly traded. They're on the French Marche Libre (or something like that), and the symbol is MAKE.PA. Their website shows current prices.

      --
      "The question of whether a computer can think is no more interesting than that of whether a submarine can swim" -EWD
    11. Re:This bodes not well... by tarkin · · Score: 1

      Haven't you heard ? ( read ? )
      Broadband is dead according to Cringely :

      http://www.pbs.org/cringely/pulpit/pulpit20011011. html

      --
      blaah !
    12. Re:This bodes not well... by GrenDel+Fuego · · Score: 2

      From the article:

      MandrakeSoft moved North American production to the United States because tariff laws for imported products effectively increased the manufacturing cost by a factor of two or three, said Jean Mar, business operations manager.

      The overseas company could probably have handled the capacity fine, but importing the CDs to america is expensive.

    13. Re:This bodes not well... by phutureboy · · Score: 2

      MandrakeSoft moved North American production to the United States because tariff laws for imported products effectively increased the manufacturing cost by a factor of two or three, said Jean Mar, business operations manager.

      Chalk another one up for regulation.

  12. Mandrake 8.1 is great by Ripat · · Score: 1, Informative

    Mandrake 8.1 really works great for me. It has gotten much better since the last few versions.

    KDE 2.2.1 and mozilla 0.94 is included, which is very nice, and I can really recommend this version!

    1. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by Publicus · · Score: 1

      That is nice to hear. I can't say I had as much luck with it. I couldn't determine what device was my floppy drive (it wasn't fd0, like it should be) and was unable to mount floppies. It wasn't much of a problem, because I do most of my archiving to ftp, but a pretty important flaw nonetheless. When I went to look for help in the #mandrake chat rooms all I ended up doing was answering questions on installing programs and such.

      For anyone whose been using Linux for awhile, but still considers himself a newbie, I would say don't hesitate to try Slackware or Debian. The installs are not all that hard, and speaking from experience the lack of 'user friendly tools' makes a lot of things easier if you just use your head. I used Redhat, then Mandrake, then Debian, and now Slackware. I wouldn't go back to Redhat/Mandrake ever again. I know Mandrake has its niche, and I think its great what the company is doing for Linux, but if you're reading /., you should be, IMHO, be using something like Slack or Debian.

      --

      My Karma was at 49, then they switched to words. All that work for nothing!

    2. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by iplayfast · · Score: 0, Redundant

      I agree. I've used Mandrake since 7 and it has gotten better and better. Right now the usability is on par with win98 (or better). Last night I had 3d graphics working and was doing some serious development (3d wise). Totally cool! It's also fast. The biggest difference that I notice between Linux and Windows, is the time to load the programs. Once they are loaded they seem as fast or faster then their windows counterparts. (I develop using Kylix on Linux and Delphi on windows and they two products are very close to each other).

    3. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by SilentChris · · Score: 2
      I wanted to use Mandrake since 7 but was held back on laptop incompatibilites. I've used RedHat since the dawn of time, not because it was the best distro per se but that it always seemed to identify my hardware correctly. They were always behind the times with KDE and usability, though.

      Hopefully 8.1 will work with my laptop.

    4. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by update() · · Score: 1
      I couldn't determine what device was my floppy drive (it wasn't fd0, like it should be) and was unable to mount floppies.

      I had the same thing -- a post on Usenet explained that 8.1 (the download version, anyway) installs a broken /etc/fstab.

      On the whole, I've been impressed with Mandrake. I recently built my first x86 box (need a dual boot with Windows on this one) and took the opportunity to try out Debian and Mandrake. The Debian install was just godawful. Could I have managed it? Sure, I've been installing Linux since Red Hat 4 / MkLinux DR2. But I have things to do with my time. Mandrake did a great job with hardware detection and setup. Windows 98, on the other hand, which I've used occasionally but never installed or admined just sucked. It correctly detected far fewer devices than did Mandrake and required a reinstall when I added a modem and again when I switched monitors.

      Now, if only I could get that modem to work under Mandrake...

    5. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Uh... who died and made you the grand poobah of Linux distro's.

      I'm a 5 year Linux veteran and an open source developer and I use Mandrake because I like it. Plain and simple. You should use what you like and buy it directly from the company to support them, IMHO.

      I find it disturbing that people like you try to make it into some macho thing, which quite frankly turns me off from even trying Slackware or Debian. An operating system/Linux Distro is simply a tool which lets me get the job done, not an extension of my penis.

      I wonder, seriously, can you tell me how old you are?

    6. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by powerlinekid · · Score: 1

      How is this informative? It would be like saying that windows xp is great because it includes ie, whatever revision of explorer.exe they're on and that its better than windows Me.

      --

      can't sleep slashdot will eat me
    7. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative


      sorry, but i have to disagree -- mandrake 8.1 has TONS of problems related mainly to the new GUI wizards they included for all kinds of setups.

      i'm referring here specifically to their "Internet Connection Sharing" wizard (ugh, what's with that Windows nomenclature), which is supposed to setup up proper IP forwarding and some firewalling features, but falls furstratingly flat on its face. the anti-aliased KDE is pretty and obviously they spent lots of time on fluffiness and likeability, but they need to work harder on the tools they came up with.

      there's a long way to go in this respect, especially with regard to the inclusion of like fifteen different tools to do the same thing in a *standard* installation, which will surely confuse many of the newbies this product is aimed at.

      on mandrakeforum.com the consensus has been that this 'final release' should've been nothing more than an 'RC', since day 2.

      peace

      -p

    8. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      5 years makes you a veteran now? Open source developer?

      Man, the inmates ARE running the asylum...

    9. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by javacowboy · · Score: 1

      I've had some real problems with 8.1, and decided to downgrade to 8.0. I had real problems getting my CDROM and Floppy to mount automatically. I had to mount them manually everytime I wanted to use them. I couldn't get my CDWriter to work at ALL.

      At one point, I couldn't view my desktop, or any of the icons, in either GNOME or KDE.

      Finally, I just said the hell with it and went back to 8.0. Hopefully, they will have fixed the bugs by 8.2.

      --
      This space left intentionally blank.
    10. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      With regards to running Linux, yes, 5 years makes me a veteran. I would wager most Linux users have come on board the past couple years.

      If you want to know my programming credentials I can tell you that I'm an old man, having graduated in 1986, back when we were writing code on a big old Vax running VMS. Which makes me feel pretty silly defending myself to some snot nosed 15 year old who thinks running slack or debian makes him cool.

      Rock on dude :)

    11. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by virid · · Score: 1

      Mandrake is based off of Red Hat. It's basically a customized Red Hat.

      --
      "The world only exists in your eyes. You can make it as big or as small as you want." - F Scott Fitzgerald
    12. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by ZxCv · · Score: 2

      I'd give 8.1 a try with your laptop.

      I have a Sony VAIO which I had a wide variety of problems getting any distro to install correctly on. Mandrake 8 was the first that installed where it was all useable (ie X config OK, sound working, networking working, etc). I had problems getting my wlan card to work under 8, but the installer for 8.1 detected and configured it without a hitch.

      I've got 4 machines (including the laptop) running Mandrake 8.1 now. I've been running various flavors of Linux on those same 4 machines for a long time and Mandrake 8.1 is the first I ever remember that installed flawlessly on each of the machines.

      As someone who's been using Linux desktops since the days of Red Hat 4, it's pretty incredible to me how far Linux on the desktop has come, especially on laptops.

      --

      Perl - $Just @when->$you ${thought} s/yn/tax/ &couldn\'t %get $worse;
    13. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by ZxCv · · Score: 2

      This was certainly true back when Mandrake was first formed, but not so much anymore. It's not as if every time Red Hat comes out with a new distro, Mandrake adds their touch and calls it their own. They started with Red Hat but have kinda gone off in their own direction with it, creating something that is, while similar in its roots, very different in its appearance and function.

      --

      Perl - $Just @when->$you ${thought} s/yn/tax/ &couldn\'t %get $worse;
    14. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by Ripat · · Score: 1

      Hmm... ok...

      To bad for all of you who have had problem with 8.1.

      On my computer it works a lot better than 8.0, and feels like a more polished product.

    15. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you should be, IMHO, be using something like Slack or Debian

      IMHO stands for "in my humble opinion." I'm happy that you like Mandrake. Keep using it. My point was that slashdotters shouldn't be worried about trying Slackware or Debian because they're supposedly too hard to use. They really aren't. That perception kept me from trying them for a long time. I'm glad I got the confidence to try them though, because I've now found that I prefer them. That's all I'm saying. Use Mandrake if you like it. I still recommend it to anyone who is just looking to get into Linux.

      BTW (that stands for 'by the way'), I don't see where you get the penis size thing. Everybody knows that the guys with the really big dicks are using BSD. Come on!

  13. dumb theory... by crazney · · Score: 0, Troll

    maybe they're moving to america so they are another business in america that relies on linux for their income and can help stop the government introducing the SSSCA :-)

    --
    stuff
  14. Tariff by Matthias+Wiesmann · · Score: 3, Interesting
    The story is funny in some sense, and shows that the realitiy is quite different from the internet mystics. Basically, it shows that
    1. the physical medium and its related problems (time to manufacture and setup the manufacture) are still around.
    2. that for all the talks about global economy, there are import taxes on software - I find it very ironic that there are taxes en free software.
    1. Re:Tariff by linuxpng · · Score: 1, Offtopic

      how about the fact that you go to the store to buy free software, then pay sales tax on that free software.

    2. Re:Tariff by powerlinekid · · Score: 1

      your getting free mixed up... free as in speech does not imply free as in beer in any way. The US govt doesn't care about free as in speech, at least not in the software sense for its taxes. Linux may be free as in speech and the isos may be free as in beer, but store bought distributions are not free as in beer. They cost money and in the US, money is taxed. IMHO of course.

      --

      can't sleep slashdot will eat me
  15. How about... by gazbo · · Score: 2, Funny

    Heinz have had to delay bringing their new type of beans to market, as they are having difficulty getting the cans in time.

    Slashdot: So?

    s/Heinz/Mandrake/
    s/beans/Linux/
    s/cans/CDs/

    Slashdot: Quick! Hot news!
    Hmm. I know how useful sed is, but I never realised it was powerful enough to turn boring tripe into news in just 3 simple commands. Maybe I should read the man more carefully.

    1. Re:How about... by Roblimo · · Score: 1

      The "bean story" would be a lead item at (hypothetical) "Canned Goods Retailing" or "Modern Supermarket Managmenent" or "Restaurant Purchasing," none of which would give a rat's ass about Mandrake. And general circulation pubs would/will ignore either story.

      This is why we have niche media, okay?

      - Robin

    2. Re:How about... by gazbo · · Score: 0, Redundant

      Well obviously I was exaggerating the whole thing for effect, but my point of view hardly differs from yours:
      /. is 'news for nerds, stuff that matters' a general discussion board, but restricted to the (not exactly small) field of geekery. As you said, such a general board should ignore this story. However, /. has a subsection for stories about Linux, and there will be some die hard Linux geeks who want to read this story (which really is of little interest to most geeks who could just download anyway). However, my (unclear) point was that it is hardly front page material. The /. front page should cover stories of interest for geeks, not stories of interest to a minority of geeks interested in *any* Linux story, no matter how trite.

      A little opinionated, I realise...

  16. Only affects America by kiwaiti · · Score: 1
    It appears only their production for America was being moved to the US, so we shouldn't see any problems over here.
    :o)

    Kiwaiti

    --
    Member of the Legion Of Microsoft Haters
    1. Re:Only affects America by MartinG · · Score: 2

      This seems true, as I recieved my 3-cd set from Mandrake yesterday.

      --
      -- MartinG To mail me: echo kewyjlcxyzvjfxbqwh | tr bcefhjklqvwxyz .@adgimnoprstu
  17. Please take this opportunity... by flez · · Score: 2, Interesting

    ... and extra time to fix this distro. I've decided to delay my upgrade until 8.2. Until recently, I was planning on making the upgrade to 8.1. The reports I've read, however, have convinced me to wait. Now that you have the extra time, why not box an 8.1.1?

    1. Re:Please take this opportunity... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've been running this distro for about two weeks now and it seriously kicks butt. The fact that they backported all the major journaling filesystems into the kernel makes this a keeper. I can now run my machine with stock JFS :-)

      In the mood to try something new? Give this distro a shot.

    2. Re:Please take this opportunity... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      What reviews have you read that have made you come to this decision ?

      I am interested as I'm considering buying this distro.

    3. Re:Please take this opportunity... by flez · · Score: 2, Informative

      Well, for one.

      Also, read through some of the past articles on Mandrakeforum starting with this.

  18. RedHat have the same problems by geirt · · Score: 4, Offtopic

    I believe RedHat have the same problems, since RedHat 7.2 has been ready (even on the mirrors) for some time now, but they will not distibute it (ie. add the everyone-read bit to the file permissions) until they have the CDs ready.

    The RedHat 7.2 relase is available trough rsync ....

    $ rsync -av csociety-ftp.ecn.purdue.edu::pub/redhat/redhat/lin ux/7.2/en/iso

    *** Welcome to the Purdue University Computer Society RSYNC Server
    *** Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN
    http://csociety.ecn.purdue.edu/

    This archive is available via FTP, HTTP, and RSYNC at:
    ftp://csociety-ftp.ecn.purdue.edu/pub/
    http://csociety-ftp.ecn.purdue.edu/pub/
    rsync://csociety-ftp.ecn.purdue.edu/pub/

    Report problems to ftp@csociety.ecn.purdue.edu

    receiving file list ... done
    dr-x------ 4096 2001/10/05 01:54:02 iso
    dr-x------ 4096 2001/10/04 02:01:50 iso/doc
    -rw-r--r-- 50 2001/10/04 02:02:00 iso/doc/MD5SUM
    -rw-r--r-- 624476160 2001/10/04 00:35:00 iso/doc/enigma-docs.iso
    dr-x------ 4096 2001/10/04 02:03:42 iso/i386
    -rw-r--r-- 226 2001/10/04 02:04:22 iso/i386/MD5SUM
    -rw-r--r-- 680282112 2001/10/04 00:27:19 iso/i386/enigma-SRPMS-disc1.iso
    -rw-r--r-- 542537728 2001/10/04 00:29:25 iso/i386/enigma-SRPMS-disc2.iso
    -rw-r--r-- 677961728 2001/10/04 00:22:08 iso/i386/enigma-i386-disc1.iso
    -rw-r--r-- 669429760 2001/10/04 00:24:42 iso/i386/enigma-i386-disc2.iso
    wrote 94 bytes read 691 bytes 314.00 bytes/sec
    total size is 3194687764 speedup is 4069665.94


    $ rsync -av csociety-ftp.ecn.purdue.edu::pub/redhat/redhat/lin ux/7.2/en/iso/i386/MD5SUM .

    *** Welcome to the Purdue University Computer Society RSYNC Server
    *** Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN
    http://csociety.ecn.purdue.edu/

    This archive is available via FTP, HTTP, and RSYNC at:
    ftp://csociety-ftp.ecn.purdue.edu/pub/
    http://csociety-ftp.ecn.purdue.edu/pub/
    rsync://csociety-ftp.ecn.purdue.edu/pub/

    Report problems to ftp@csociety.ecn.purdue.edu

    receiving file list ... done
    wrote 106 bytes read 500 bytes 242.40 bytes/sec
    total size is 226 speedup is 0.37


    $ cat MD5SUM
    efab549656a1a85ab8fa39eb873eff0e enigma-SRPMS-disc1.iso
    70703897af7703b40e41777a3aa186c3 enigma-SRPMS-disc2.iso
    cf7bce0c1cdbfedfae29e60aef202f6f enigma-i386-disc1.iso
    fd705b3e5d0e37a828db35d21195a9f6 enigma-i386-disc2.iso

    Note that the files are dated 2001/10/04

    --

    RFC1925
    1. Re:RedHat have the same problems by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They also need to get the mirrors
      synced so the mirrors getting it first don't get completely flooded, get the webpages/announcements
      written etc.

  19. Again? by briggsb · · Score: 2, Funny

    No doubt, Microsoft is at it again.

  20. You can only preorder it by MongooseCN · · Score: 2

    Same as with the Mandrake site.

  21. Mandrake and Walmart by centurion · · Score: 0

    I'm still wondering if he was being slightly sarcastic about Mandrake's smooth install and having the distro available in Walmart.

    Personally, I like Mandrake better than any other distro I've used (I started with Slackware about 5 years ago, and it still owns me :-D

    The fact that its easy to use and that you can get to the more advanced parts of linux without much hassle makes it a great distro.

    I d/led the two install iso's but haven't had time to burn them and play with it :-(

    --
    ~centurion
  22. You're missing the point. by lumpenprole · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Cheap Bytes (bless their busy little hands) only dl's stuff and burns it, then sells it cheap. Nothing wrong with that, but Mandrake doesn't get a cut, as far as I know. The point of this story is that Mandrake, the orginisation, is having trouble making money because of shippiing problems.

    I for one, happen to think it would be a real shame if they went under. Mandrake and Debian are my two favorite distros.

    --
    Disclaimer: MINAA (Mummy! I'm Not An Animal!)
  23. and remember folks by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Mandrake linux is not owned by Geoff "mandrake" Harrison

  24. Re:Do0o0o0o0o0o0oom!! by Roofus · · Score: 1

    In all honesty, that's probably the best reply yet to the parent post.

  25. Interesting Politics by jhines · · Score: 1

    Lets see, the USA, promoter of free trade in the world, imposes a tariff on imported software.

    I guess the poor ol' US software industry needs the protection of imports, even though until recently they needed special rules to import more tech workers, and the DOJ is working on breaking up MS.

    1. Re:Interesting Politics by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Yes, and at the same time, they give tax breaks to Microsoft for exporting their software abroad.

      The EU recently took the US government to court over this at the WTO, on the grounds that it was an unfair subsidy. The WTO has recently ruled in the EU's favour, and the US will have to drop the subsidies or face economic sanctions.

  26. Yea... I'll buy it. by StarbuckZero · · Score: 1


    I been using Mandrake 8.1 for the last 2 weeks and let me tell you I love it. I think Mandrakesoft out done a great job putting Mandrake 8.1 together. It is so easy to configure your network, change boot loaders, install/remove software and download updates. Everything you need all in one place! Now I been a Linux user for two years and sometimes you just want junk to work without trying to figure out every little thing. I know if anyone who want to start using Linux I would give them a copy of Mandrake hell I'm going to buy Mandrake 8.1 when it hit stores. Just to show my support and even if you don't like Mandrake Linux I think everyone need to still support there disros of choice.

    --
    From Zero to Hero... Starbuck Zero
    1. Re:Yea... I'll buy it. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeh, I'm a linux user also and I'll probably buy it when it hits that little Wal-Mart shelf that stands aprox. 2 ft. overhead. The only drawback is that all the damn versions begin to........ well........ nevermind, I'll buy it just fer the hell of it.
      Some of my friends are totally dependent on WinDuhz( as am I sometimes ) and I love giving them Mandrake( that was DL'd and burnt ). After a week I return and find that thats all they want to talk about.;)

  27. Yes things are f**ked here, but vs. Europe.... by JohnTheFisherman · · Score: 2

    European government has a very hostile attitude towards smaller businesses. CE Mark, tax policies, yadda yadda yadda, it all adds up to making it very difficult to start or maintain a small business.

    They must be freaking morons at MandrakeSoft. Hey, I use Mandrake, but it's cheap and easy to get a run of CDs with whiz bang labelling, inserts, cases, shipping even large quantities is a breeze, and cheap to boot....

    They probably just didn't plan well, or just moved here without any idea how those things run here.

    And if you're worried about big brotherish laws in the US, and you're in the UK apparently - well, that makes a lot of sense.

    1. Re:Yes things are f**ked here, but vs. Europe.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      Funny where I live in New Jersey there are is only one small supermarket around me. When I went to vacation in Greece the majority of supermarkets were privately owned and not huge chains. Also the privately owned supermarkets there were much bigger than the privately owned supermarkets I see where I live as property is much cheaper in Greece. When I went to southern Italy I also noticed less large chain stores around the villages I visited than in the States.

    2. Re:Yes things are f**ked here, but vs. Europe.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There's no European Government... Each european country has it's own government...

  28. This is only a minor bump in the road by iplayfast · · Score: 1
    Mandrake has made such great strides in bringing the Linux desktop to the masses, this little bump will be trod over quickly enough. Heck I've downloaded my 2 cd set and I must say, that I'm planning on buying the bigger version when it's in the stores. (That way I get viavoice and all the other goodies).

    It's great value for the money.

  29. Good by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Maybe they would take this time to fix there damn distro. Its pretty damn broken, its non-stop problems. I think they rushed things a little tring to beat out rhs release. I think overall, rh is gonna wip them.

  30. Anyone mirroring these files? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So is there any *public* mirror of the ISOs available? When I tried to grab the 2nd file, it said "connection refused".

    1. Re:Anyone mirroring these files? by Swamp · · Score: 1

      Do you mean mirror the mirrors?

    2. Re:Anyone mirroring these files? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, mirror the mirrors, but with the read-bit set, so I can be naughty and install it before it is released.

  31. Don't worry. by binner1 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    8.2 is due tomorrow, and 8.3 on Monday.
    Seriously...where do these guys find time for quality testing...they seem too busy stuffing the next distro out the door.

    Sheesh.
    -Ben

    1. Re:Don't worry. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Test it ??? Do you seriously belive they do any QA testing these days ? Maybe they used to, but going by the way 8.2 is, they gave up.

  32. Problems by tiny69 · · Score: 5, Interesting
    They are having more than just shipping problems. This was just recently posted to the Bastille mailing list:

    Date: Fri, 12 Oct 2001 00:22:18 -0700
    From: Jay Beale
    To: bastille-linux-discuss@lists.sourceforge.net
    Subject: [Bastille-linux-discuss] Available...


    Normally, I don't use this as an announcement board, but times are tough...

    I wanted to let everyone know that I'm becoming available for hire, as a number of people on this list have, as a result of some financial issues at MandrakeSoft that have a lot to do with the poor retail and financial markets.

    I'm trying to find consulting work, though I'm open to full-time employment if it's a good match.

    With that said, here are a couple good links:

    My consulting practice:http://www.bastille-linux.org/jay/consult ing/

    My security articles: http://www.bastille-linux.org/jay/consulting/secur ity-articles-jjb.html

    - Jay Beale
    Lead Developer, Bastille Linux
    soon-to-be-ex-Security Team Director, MandrakeSoft
    --
    Go not unto/. for advice, for you will be told both yea and nay (but have nothing to do with the question)
    1. Re:Problems by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      that's bad, as Jay's work has been tremendous in the security of Mandrake, however, wouldn't someone pick up the slack? open source shouldn't rely on $ to survive and I think the whole business model of OSS companies really needs to change to survive. I think this will occur naturally, and this may just be another signpost of that change. Not to worry.

      P

    2. Re:Problems by mrcparker · · Score: 1

      That was the WRONG place to post this type of information. If he wants a new job, he should goto monster.com.

      What a jackass.

    3. Re:Problems by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I had no idea that my post on the Bastille list would go to Slashdot.

      I'm just trying to find work that matches my skills and background. It doesn't seem
      like posting to the mailling list about my availability is a bad idea -- I've actually encouraged
      other people in that community to use the list to help match themselves up with jobs.

      It's hard out there -- the economy is not so great right now and this is greatly affecting jobs. There are a whole lot of very capable people being laid off because companies need to cut their costs.

      I don't bear MandrakeSoft any ill will. Retail markets are not as strong as they were a year ago, or even a month ago. That's going to hurt everyone who gains revenue from that sector -- MandrakeSoft's doing the responsible thing by ending my salaried employment.

      Anyway, I'll still be sponsored by them, though not as a fulltime employee, for a little while, as they're able. I'll be contracting with them a bit, to whatever extent they can do it.

      - Jay Beale

    4. Re:Problems by Master+Bait · · Score: 1

      Hmm... maybe these are related. There could possible be a whole lot of palletes of Mandrake sitting at the printers waiting for payment before being shipped.

      --
      "Only in their dreams can men truly be free 'twas always thus, and always thus will be."
      --Tom Schulman
  33. Development will eventually drift into Europe by SgtChaireBourne · · Score: 2, Insightful

    The U.S. has been and is a great place. However, the crazy legal environment and corporate republic mentality will gradually cause a migration to Europe anyway for pragmatic reasons.

    In the EU there is no DMCA, no weird cryptography rules. The EU Commission, as bad as it is, even seems to be handling the Microsoft issues better.

    Recruitment will happen. The benefits are much better: lower crime, health care, 5 weeks holiday, free university, pension, and in some countries, clean rivers and lakes.

    Also, most European governments (at least the Northern European ones) make it really easy to start small businesses and provide tax major breaks and grants. The larger countries also get pretty good deals. However, the competition between companies in the same branch is often really cuttroat and dictated by who is childhood friends with whom.

    For example, regarding privacy, I automaticaly get a written statement of who has requested my credit rating and why.

    The other option is to phase in the European standard of living in the U.S. For ex, doesn't California provide free or inexpensive university to its residents?

    --
    Beta is broken and the link to classic doesn't work. Stop wasting our time or there won't be anybody left here.
    1. Re:Development will eventually drift into Europe by zeno4ever · · Score: 2, Funny

      > In the EU there is no DMCA, no weird cryptography rules.

      Not yet, you mean... The EU is very busy to implement the EUCA, a almost exact copy of the DMCA.

      But here (in europe that is) there is still time to act, so pick up a pen and write your political reprensatieve a deadtree letter!

      For more info visit www.eurorights.org.

  34. So long Mandrake by bryanbrunton · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It is now easy to predict that Mandrake will go down as the biggest Linux distro screw up of all time.

    (1) Their management is obviously incompetent. This group of French business dum asses handed the most popular (at least by download stats) Linux distro over to a bunch of dot-bomb e-learning idiots here in the States. They later fired that group. Who knows how much money that cost.

    (2) Mandrake has to have the worst marketing of all the Linux distros. There is a reason that no big OEMs that Mandrake seriously. This distro has attempted to sell an operating system that people will use to run their businesses while the main Mandrake marketing motif is a drunken looking goofy version of Tux. As for the Mandrake icons and graphics all I can say is it great that Gael Duval's sister has found work.

    (3) The Q&A that you see from the older distros like SuSE and RedHat just isn't there. Mandrake 8.1 uses DevFS. While an admirable technical pioneering effort, you just have to look at the Mandrake mailing lists to see that DevFS isn't ready for prime time. It is pretty much a disaster as there are significant hardware configs that DevFS can't handle. Mandrake went from the distro that has the best hardware support to the distro that has the worst. And this is supposed to be a Newbie Linux? 8.1 shipped with a kernel with a VERY broken VM. I have locked up my box many times now as the kernel after taking all 256 megs of swap dies a horrible death.

    1. Re:So long Mandrake by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I tend to agree -- Mandrake will never be taken serious by IBM and other people who are pushing out Linux as a business solution. It's goal in life seems to be Linux for the funboy dual-booter. If it compiles, Mandrake will include it.

      Anway, I thought it was funny that when RH put out 7.1, they said "Well, we weren't the first with 2.4, but everyone that beat us (Mandrake, SuSe) shipped with a known disk corruption issue - see the kernel list". Well, that's just great - pay $60 for distro and it's basically shovelware that hasn't undergone rudimentary QA or track the dev process.

    2. Re:So long Mandrake by czardonic · · Score: 1

      This group of French business dum asses

      The term is 'dumb ass', dum ass.

      --
      Takahashi Rumiko made beats! DON, taku, DON, taku. . .
  35. Mandrake 8.1 is a pig by tmark · · Score: 2

    I installed it, and it wanted to install 1.7 GB of stuff right off the bat. It took me a while to go, one-by-one, down the list to cull enough stuff so that I could actually install on a 1.5 GB partition. Also, it doesn't seem smart enough to tell that, while my root partition might have 1.5 GB, I have designated a /usr partition where much of the stuff Mandrake will install will go.

    What happened to the days when you could install a perfectly functional Linux system with X, apache, perl,gcc, etc. in less than 40 MB ?

    1. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is a pig by MrEfficient · · Score: 2
      What happened to the days when you could install a perfectly functional Linux system with X, apache, perl,gcc, etc. in less than 40 MB ?
      The same thing that happened to the days when a 486 was top of the line. If your idea of linux perfection is a 40 mb install, then Mandrake is probably not for you.

      Oh, I've only been using Linux for a little more than two years, but I find it hard to believe that you could ever install all of that in 40 mb.

      --
      Check out AbiWord.
    2. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is a pig by virid · · Score: 1

      This guy could install all of that in 40Mb because he was running XWindows with twm with no "desktop environment" no pixmaps titlebars or mouse-over graphics, with no super-duper nautilus file manager only an xterm. This guy is wondering why it takes more gas to power a Cadallac as opposed to the Civic he used to drive. X, apache, perl,gcc, etc. -- are just the bare essentials now, as opposed to the entire system. It's just a case of bigger and better.

      --
      "The world only exists in your eyes. You can make it as big or as small as you want." - F Scott Fitzgerald
  36. It's US gov't that kill the business by LittleStone · · Score: 1

    I have seen the speed of pirated VideoCD getting to the market in HK. Normally, you can find the pirated version of a movie on the street before the official release. Even if copyright owner put huge effort into protecting the master copy and the production process, pirated version can appear within 2 days. The whole process involve some retailer get the official release, send it back to mainland China (it used to be by courier, now through internet) and pressed CD would be ready in the next day.

    This story shows that technologically physical medium production may not need long time to setup. I believe the whole thing is slow because you have to go through all the process of registration (making sure you're not asking the factory to press pirated version of software), and the less competitive response time from factory because the market is protected by the government tariff.

    --
    A sig is redundant.
  37. Mandrake 8.1 by Gendou · · Score: 2

    A few days ago, I read this review of Mandrake 8.1 which was, to say the least, a bit controversial. After reading some of the comments on the story, I wonder about the accuracy of many things in the article, but you can't deny that it genuinely reflects someone's experience with Linux. It's important to keep up with reviews that AREN'T written by us UNIX gurus, because widespread adoption hinges on the experience new users have with the OS.

    Factual or not, this is how new users see the operating system. The harassment that the author of the review received in the wake of writting it will probably drive him away from Open-Source forever and only further reinforce the stereotype of the Linux Community being elitists and jerks. Another story on that site (I can't really figure out the purpose of the site; some of the stuff is really weird) reinforces the same idea: new users like the authors of these two articles are insulted and demeaned for "factual errors" because they're... gasp... new users. The irrational desire for guruism and leetness wins out over the rational desire to encourage and help new users, and ultimately the Linux Community suffers.

    Just something to think about.

    I personally find Mandrake 8.1 to be a real gem (the X configuration has improved greatly, I love the changes to the package management, and I see little changes here and there that keep making me smile), but if the review reflects the experience that most new users have, maybe it'd make more sense to examine the OS experience rather than flaming the newbies.

    1. Re:Mandrake 8.1 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Redundant

      That guy is a complete idiot and should not be allowed to use a compute. "Why isn't there IE of linux and MS Office for linux?" He is actually blaming linux and not MS here! I'm sorry but some people are too stupid.
      "Where is the any key?"

  38. Personally... by cnelzie · · Score: 1


    I can't wait until Mandrake 8.1 hits the shelves. While I have downloaded the latest version and have the 3 CD set and have also installed it. I would like to support Mandrake Financially.

    I used to be unable to afford that. With my current job, I now can afford to support Linux companies. I have been happy with Mandrake's previous releases and would like to see that OS taken more seriously in the corporate and home user markets.

    One way for this to happen is to generate real sales figures that give software houses the idea that there are enough installed Linux desktops that they could make a few bucks selling their wares.

    Now, many of you believe that Linux doesn't need commercial apps. While that is true, Linux needs no commercial apps. Unless, Linux-users want their OS of choice to be taken seriously. The average PC user (Home or Corporate), will only take Linux as a serious operating system if there are readily available commercial applications.

    I do my best to advocate Linux to as many people as possible and that is the one wall that I regularly run into. Where are the commercial apps? Where is the software on the shelves of [Insert_software_vendor_name_here]?

    If you like Linux, love Linux and use Linux. Then support Linux, by buying your distros. Not only will it be good for the state of Linux companies, it will also help raise awarness of Linux in the minds of corporate [Insert_Country_Name_Here].

    --
    .sig seperator
    --

    --
    If you ignore the other uses of a tool, does that make the tool less useful, or you less useful?
    1. Re:Personally... by joestar · · Score: 2

      If you want to support Mandrakesoft, you'd better order your pack on MandrakeStore. Why? In traditionnal distribution channels, the final reseller (the shop) and the distributor (MacMillan?) take a big margin (traditionnally the two cumulated margins can be as high as 65% of the final price). On MandrakeStore, it seems that MandrakeSoft sells directly to the consumers, so it's very likely that they earn much money through MandrakeStore than from the traditional shelves. My 2 cents.

    2. Re:Personally... by cnelzie · · Score: 1


      I can agree with that truth. However, if Wal-Mart, Best Buy, CompUSA and any other retailer doesn't sell Mandrake or any other distro. Then the likelihood of them carrying Linux Applications will decrease.

      They will think to themselves... "Why should we carry this Linux Application? We never sell that damn Operating System. Obviously, nobody anywhere wants to use the crap. Take it all off the shelves. We do better selling that Microsoft OS and all those THOUSANDS of applications that are out for it."

      As for making money off of selling software. It is nearly negligable. The mark-up on most software packages is next to nothing. The publishing house makes the biggest piece of the profit. The retail store typically has only a few dollars, as in two to three bucks, on many software packages. A few have a slightly larger mark-up, typically never much better than a good 5 to 8 percent though.

      As a for instance, the computer retail store that I work for has good distribution channels and is unable to get Norton System works for any less than a few bucks beneath the MSRP. After looking into it, the only way to increase our mark-up is to order something along the lines of 10,000 copies. We would be sitting on that for years.

      Then the small guy that makes a sweet little Linux app. finds that nobody will sell his software on their shelves. Joe Computer-User never gets a chance to see any other Operating Systems, ever.

      There is my 2 cents.

      --
      .sig seperator
      --

      --
      If you ignore the other uses of a tool, does that make the tool less useful, or you less useful?
  39. Re:Boycott the USA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It's too dangerous to visit a friend in the US? Um, no. The cops are not walking around with AK-47's picking up random people off the street. The RIAA isn't prosecuting every internet user. Unless you're coming to talk about and demonstrate an illegal (in the US) thing you did or sell tons of pirated copies of Windoze and Office, you don't have anything to fear. Yet, at least.
    More than likely, nobody will care about you if you're just visiting a friend. Just follow the laws (however unjust they are) and you have nothing to fear.

  40. Smooth install? by The+Panther! · · Score: 3, Interesting

    My ass.

    Maybe compared to the text install of Debian that I tried first, okay, I can accept that. I've been trying to jump the Windows bandwagon for a few weeks now on some test machines, and haven't been terribly lucky with everything going smoothly, not even with Mandrake 8.1.

    For instance, if you try to set up an ethernet card using the Control Panel (or whatever it's called), you cannot set up a NIC correctly without using BOTH normal AND expert mode. Reason being, in expert mode, there's no way to set the Gateway and DNS (I think?) servers... you have to go to normal mode to do that, but only if you set up a static IP. If you set up bootp or dhcp, it won't show up those boxes. So once I set those correctly, I went through the expert install and finished off the process. This took some serious tinkering to figure out their severely broken UI, and several hours to sort out because they don't even show you what the settings are unless you get to those screens by pure luck.

    If I were the typical clueless Windows user trying Linux for the first time, I'd probably have given up and installed Windows by now.

    --
    Any connection between your reality and mine is purely coincidental.
    1. Re:Smooth install? by drivers · · Score: 2

      If you are using DHCP you don't need to set manually the DNS and gateway. You're supposed to get that from DHCP, correct?

    2. Re:Smooth install? by The+Panther! · · Score: 1

      Should, yes, that's why it's broken. I set it for DHCP and it never connected. After setting those figures manually, then setting DHCP again, it worked fine. While the UI is friendly, it's still not entirely functional. But I'm sticking with it for now.

      --
      Any connection between your reality and mine is purely coincidental.
    3. Re:Smooth install? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      My ass.
      yea, if you really want to set the DNS and gateway manually on EVERY single box, you shouldn't be using dhcp anyway. That's what dhcp does. Perhaps if you'd ever managed more than tow boxes at a time you'd know that.
      I mean, if you don't even know the very basics of networking tools, why are you even commenting, and why did this get modded up? You were aware that the ability to set DNS and gateway's manually go away on win* when you select dhcp, right?
      yes, it could be more dumbed down and easily digestible. I agree. Go get redhat 5.2 or any number of earlier 'serious' distros (5.2 was probably the first to give it a real go), and just look at how far they've come. Hell redhat 6.2 is still all over the place, almost a standard in most shops, just go look at the amount of work that's been done *already*
      What you need to see is the _potential_. Why not be constructive, offer bug reports, heaven forbid you'd actually fix a bug. Of course its not there yet.
      We've always looked at linux for what it could be. Random people would find bugs, and fix them. a community effort. It was great. Now we got guys like you, moving in and blasting the whole thing over basically nothing. Just because You don't understand networking, or that MDK doesn't want to be a windows clone, so....
      nevermind.
      Slashdot sucks.

    4. Re:Smooth install? by The+Panther! · · Score: 1

      Uhm.. Right. Why don't you take your AC mask off and pretend to be constructive yourself? You don't need to make up excuses for Mandrake or the Linux community--just examine the software for yourself and form your own opinion.

      I have a cluster of 7 workstations in a rack, thankyouverymuch, and run several different distributions of Linux on them, and have a Win2k (temporarily) machine as the gateway/bridge between two separate networks. What do you run?

      I'm not clueless about networking, just relaying my experience with a broken UI and what should have been a very simple install process. Other than that, I've been pretty happy with Mandrake 8.1.

      --
      Any connection between your reality and mine is purely coincidental.
  41. Me too.. nasty problems by Vicegrip · · Score: 2, Informative

    devfs is reporting errors on bootup, my primary cdrom (which I booted and installed from) isn't being mounted despite the fstab entries...

    Something is unstable in my system and I'm not sure what it is: after a few minutes of running X the video occasionally starts to get corrupted... these things never happened to me in 8.0

    I'm going to regress back to 8.0 which was quite simply: solid. I'm simply not knowledgable enough with their distro to be able to troubleshoot the problem. All I can say is that 8.0 was great.

    p.s. installed 8.1 fresh from CDs (not an upgrade)... anyways.. for those interested, my system is an Athlon 850 Asus A7V and Matrox G400/SB Live/3COM3c905b/AcerCDRW
    Installation CDs burned after doing MD5 checksums on ISOs, and then afterwards on RPMs on CDs.

    --
    Do not spread "09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0" over the internet, thank you.
  42. Right and wrong. by Gendou · · Score: 1, Redundant

    Certainly his facts are incorrect, and I myself had to stiffle a giggle at the Internet Explorer comments, but is it really productive to blame a new user for being a new user? "New users to Open Source are stupid about Open Source." Well, no kidding: that's why they're new users.

    Does it really help the Open Source Community to call inexperienced users "idiots" rather than explaining to them how things work; for example, why there's no Internet Explorer for Linux? Now that most distros are shipping with either no manual (just a "quick install sheet"), a 12-page manual covering just the installation, or a 2000-page manual that'll never be opened, there's no way for new users to know these things -- they have to be told.

    Do you really think most users who are frustrated by their first Linux installation experience (which is a perfectly normal situation for the new user to be in if he isn't a geek guru like us) and are told that they're "useless idiots" because of it are going to make a SECOND attempt?

    I don't.

    1. Re:Right and wrong. by LMCBoy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      The Adequacy.org "review" was satire. I think most of the flames were directed at the clueless MCSE's who sprang up in the discussion...

      --
      Liberal (adj.): Free from bigotry; open to progress; tolerant of others.
  43. Dont you know what Open Source and GNU is?!?!?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0



    Its not about selling information! Its about selling services.

    The reason why people will buy a CD from a store is not because of the DATA on the cd, but because of the fact that they dont have to spend hours downloading(even on DSL and cable) 20-30 minutes burning it, 2-3 hours downloading and printing out the manuals, and then when theres a problem, have to spend 2-3 hours more trying to fix it.

    You buy service, all of this comes in a package, you get a manual, you get technical support, you get a higher quality CD or set of them, all of this you get instantly.

    your choice, spend a week installing Linux, Or spend an hour going to the store and an hour installing.

    The same reason people use ISPs when the internet is essentially free.

    1. Re:Dont you know what Open Source and GNU is?!?!?! by fmaxwell · · Score: 2

      2-3 hours downloading and printing out the manuals

      I don't know what kind of manuals you've gotten from any off-the-shelf distros lately, but I could download and print everything they supply in about 10 minutes.

      But it's all a moot point: I can (and did) download Mandrake Linux 8.1 because no stores have it in stock. I don't think that I'm so out of touch with normalcy that my reaction was unique.

      And, as the installations get easier and less problem prone, the need for manuals and support becomes less.

  44. Hard to get the newest and greatest to customers by gotan · · Score: 3, Interesting

    My feeling with the Linux distributions i've seen in stores was, that they always seemed a little dated. I know which kernel is out at the moment, and while in many cases the kernel makes as much a difference as the MHz-Number of your processor when it's between 1400 and 1600, the step from 2.2 to 2.4 was quite large, especially for folks with newer Hardware. Often the kernel-version announced on the package doesn't even tell the whole story, since the mandrake kernels even include many patches which didn't make it into the Linus kernel yet (but have a good chance to get there), but there's only so much you can print on the side of a box and not have it covered in fineprint.

    I think this is quite a problem when selling Linux on CD, since i believe many folks who think about buying Linux in the store at least know the kernel version (but probably don't bother about glibc, gcc, ...). With the fast paced and openly visible development in Open Source Software anything three month old already looks slightly dated. So the distributions must frequently issue new versions, and they must get them to the stores as fast as possible (since few people would buy 8.0 knowing 8.1 soon to be out). So when frequently issuing new versions another problem emerges: with the advent of the new version the old CDs drastically loose value, but the new ones need some time from being announced to appearing in the stores.

    The folks at Mandrake know all this, their distributions contain all the most recent stuff, their development rpms (cooker) are really cutting edge, and they even offered to sell 8.1 as preview and send the actual CDs when they're out. I run Mandrake and am quite happy with it. I'll probably buy 8.1 just for the manual and being able to install it on some friends computer (and also since i think it's worth the money), since i think Mandrake is a great distribution to start with, and also a good one to stay with, especially if one likes to toy around with the newest stuff (no distro wars please).

    --
    "By the way if anyone here is in advertising or marketing... kill yourself." -- Bill Hicks
  45. How do you update the mandrake kernel? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0



    I tried compiling my own kernel and every time in mandrake, it ruins the entire system

  46. Documentation? by Gendou · · Score: 1, Redundant

    I read through the Adequacy website very thoroughly, and although I must admit that the site perplexes me, I see nothing that indicates the site isn't totally serious. I read through the mission statement, the FAQ, the meta page, and so forth, and I didn't see the word "Satire" anywhere. I even went so far as to e-mail one of the editors asking what was going on with the site, and once asked on their IRC channel, and every time I was told the site was completely serious.

    It's a scary thought, but the site seems to be legit, unless you can document otherwise.

    1. Re:Documentation? by Fnkmaster · · Score: 2
      Read this: mission statement. It's pretty clearly a big trollfest/flamefest site. Which makes it in a way a parody of /. etc. I mean, these absurdly pro-MS articles, etc. are all posted on a site that is running on Scoop which is Open Source, Unix-based news/board software.


      So I don't know if I'd say it's satire or what the fuck it is. But it clearly at least acknowledges how ridiculous it is.

    2. Re:Documentation? by czardonic · · Score: 1

      Maybe the editor decided to continue yanking your chain, because (much like me) he couldn't beleive someone would not be able to detect the blatantly satirical nature of the site.

      I'm just saing "maybe."

      --
      Takahashi Rumiko made beats! DON, taku, DON, taku. . .
  47. Quoting the letter I received by Fencepost · · Score: 3, Insightful
    (it's on a different and non-connected system, typos are mine)

    We have experienced some unexpected delays in production of the CD-Roms. The 8.1 sets were originally planned to be produced at our corporate headquarters in Europe. The combined delays in European production and international shipping has caused us to re-think our original plan. MandrakeSoft Inc has started production of 8.1 here in North America. Getting 8.1 production up and running in North America has been a slow and expensive process.

    We expect to have your order No [# removed] processed and shipped by mid-October.

    Depending on how they're trying to get these set up (high-volume burns vs. pressing), I don't see a 2-week delay as unreasonable considering that they probably had to:
    • find companies that could create the CDs (including labeling or possibly silkscreening),
    • get quotes from them (probably at least 3, and possibly a day or two each),
    • arrange payment (MandrakeSoft is probably considered a dot-com, and does anyone give credit to dot-coms these days?) and
    • probably all sorts of other stuff.
    It's the kind of thing that as an individual you could probably do in just a couple days, but even fast companies have more baggage to carry through the whole process.
    --
    fencepost
    just a little off
  48. Re:It's me again! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You don't phone, you don't write, you don't troll. It's over.

  49. Re:Boycott the USA by jonathan_ingram · · Score: 2

    Unless you're coming to talk about and demonstrate an illegal (in the US) thing you did or sell tons of pirated copies of Windoze and Office, you don't have anything to fear. Yet, at least.

    From the Adobe copy protection debacle, it looks like you can be arrested in the US for doing something that's legal where you live, but illegal in the US... this is an interesting precedent.

    I'm looking forward to the UK government arresting any US tourists that carry concealed weapons when they are at home in the US.

  50. Difficulties by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Just FYI, Mdk is actually firing about 10 people
    in their main office...

  51. I wonder if there's more to it... by fperez · · Score: 2, Informative
    LM 8.1 has been getting *very* negative comments (like I'd never seen before) on their forums. Just go here and see for yourself.

    Devfs is causing many people no end of grief, I wonder if Mandrake is going to actually fix a few things while their "production delays" are taken care of. If they don't, I suspect 8.1 is going to be one bumpy ride for them.

  52. Re:Use peer to peer systems by Glorat · · Score: 1

    Their business model is predicated on most potential customers not having the bandwidth to download multiple CDs

    I wonder if they could try the interesting bandwidth saving step of releasing distrobutions "early" via P2P systems such as Kaza/Morpheus, Edonkey, Gnutella or whatever. Imagine if they release a week earlier. All us junkies that won't have anything but free beer and nights keeping kernels up to date will immediately get the newest release the moment it is available wherever it is. Less techie people can download it from FTP and mirrors a week later. And the people who want to support a worthwhile company can still get their boxed set.

    Heck it happens with Microsoft, the final releases appear on P2P before they reach the shelves, isn't about time Mandrake followed suit? It's free beer after all

  53. Re:Boycott the USA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    stay out of the US, you foreign asshole

  54. Mandrake is evil by ruzel · · Score: 1

    Where is Dexter Linux!?

  55. well put! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    yah...
    I'm in Birmaingham England and have been running Mandrake 7.0 fot tha last year or so.
    Gotta love it.

    Automatic installation of hundreds if not thousands of venerable and funky *NIX toos!

    The local BIG bookstore had 7.2 but I hadda wait MONTHS To even get 8.0.
    To make matters worse, wheh I finally got 8 home, the installer went so weird on me for a week that I threw 7.0 back in and reinstalled.
    The freshness of the box content is definitely short lived.
    I hope they stick around though, They really had it right at the time of 7.

  56. Using Mandrake 8.1 and loving it. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I moved a NIC to a new PCI slot last night, and here's how my OSes handled it.

    Windows ME: decided it was a new card, didn't remove the old settings and made me setup networking all over again.

    Mandrake 8.1: It just worked. :)

  57. The first version... by joestar · · Score: 2
    was Mandrake 5.1 (Venice) See original annouce on Slashdot on July, 25th 98: "Yet Another Linux Distribution"!
    http://slashdot.org/articles/980725/117228.shtml


    Had to recall that, just for history ;-)

  58. Re:Mandrake 8.1 is great for someone else by trutwijd · · Score: 1

    I've been playing with Mandrake 8.1 since it was released. My first attempt at Linux (major newbie). Most of my experience with mdk8.1 has been bad, it's just not working on my system, for whatever reason that is. Reading the forums it seems like this release is giving many people problems, and for some it is working great. I wish I was one of those folks. I'm going to try a different distro, possibly the new SuSE and see if that works.

  59. whats the problem with the delay?!? GRAB IT or die by racme_2000 · · Score: 0

    So whats the problem with the delay?!? for several weeks (2 to be more precissely) mandrake 8.1 is available to download from an inumerous websites in US and Europe.

    I had download all 3 cds in one night, only with ma cable connection here in Portugal from an italian mirror. I installed on ma box along with ma two other flavours of linux and 2 others of openbsd and freebsd. And i got amused how big the diferences were from version 8.0.
    kernel 2.4.8, kde 2.2.1, gnome 1.4.1.
    Especially the inclusion of kde2.2.1 that had been release one week earlier

    So guys just dont understand the fuze about the delay!!
    if u are in a so rush to try/buy, grab it from theirs ftp servers
    GRAB IT or Shutup!

  60. small business (in the UK) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I ran my own company for 2 years before starting my final years at uni. It isn't difficult! Register your company - you fill in one form. VAT - don't worry at all unless turnover is >£60,000. You pay national insurance automatically (I did it by direct debit), basically no more complex than being employed by someone else. CE marks are no problem, the manufacturer of goods just has to ensure it isnt going to kill anyone and get the right to use the CE mark once.

  61. Obviously.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You obviously have never had to CE Mark an electronic product. It goes so much farther beyond just making sure it doesn't kill anyone. It also has to function perfectly in a building with a poor ground (earth) connection directly under a strong AM station - and that's just the beginning. It also has to survive something like 40 direct lightning hits (or more, depending on how you classify the product). You also generate a mountain of paperwork, and you need a consultant or a good month or two to obtain and verify that you have the latest requirements that are in effect this year, and keep track of when all the rolling grandfathering clauses expire and you need to retest to meet newer, stricter, zanier requirements.

    You can take some of the risk yourself and say it complies, but you can go to jail for that. It's maybe $10-$20K to comply anything that plugs into the wall, sometimes more, especially if it doesn't pass the first time around. But hey, why wouldn't it pass, clearly you own the $200K worth of products to test only half of features, right? You DO have an anachoic chamber on site, don't you? Farraday cage and all?