Slashdot Mirror


Portable Mini-CD MP3 Player / Burner

An Anonymous Coward writes: "Here is a neat new toy. It is an MP3/CD portable that not only plays music files, it burns them. Called the RipGO, it was just released by Imation and runs about $400. The article includes a photo of the player."

180 comments

  1. FP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    FP

    1. Re:FP by Fecal+Troll+Matter · · Score: -1

      That FP really sucked, AC. What pleasure could you have possibly gotten out of it?

    2. Re:FP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

      The book "Live, Love and Grow Plants" has a theory which is correct, IF, you also take into account whatever sources from the -- tiny -- factor that this is the correct theory.

      Therefore and having said that, I hereby declare this to be an excellent fp.

  2. Heh, And iPod naysayers... by HerrNewton · · Score: 2

    Will be bitching because they can get a portable, more functional CDRW for a few hundred bucks cheaper.

    --

    ----
    Am I the only one who thinks Microsoft is a misnomer? Perhaps Macrosoft would be a better fit?
  3. It burns mini CDs... by swordboy · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I haven't seen any mini CD-R media laying around but I would imagine that it costs more than regular sized CD-R media. At this point, you'd be better off buying a portable CD burner and getting a separate MP3 player. Neat concept though.

    --

    Life is the leading cause of death in America.
    1. Re:It burns mini CDs... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Mini CD-R more expensive? This can't be. Anyone can transform a CD-R into a mini CD-R with a round cookie cutter and a hammer.

    2. Re:It burns mini CDs... by Tackhead · · Score: 2
      > I haven't seen any mini CD-R media laying around but I would imagine that it costs more than regular sized CD-R media. At this point, you'd be better off buying a portable CD burner and getting a separate MP3 player. Neat concept though.

      I've seen mini-CDR media at Fry's Electronics. It's not fantastic stuff, but it is available.

      But for $400, as cool as the small form factor is, I really don't need it to burn CD-Rs for me. For $400, I'll buy a CD-RW and use the money left over for a full-size (650M/disc) player-only portable unit.

      Big question left unanswered in the review: Do you rip/encode/burn the MP3s with some grotty proprietary DRM-hobbled application that ships with the device, or do you actually just shovel MP3s onto it like you would a regular CD-R?

    3. Re:It burns mini CDs... by KosovoYankee · · Score: 1

      It actually costs the same or less, as it holds less info....It's not too hard to come by.

      --
      - If This Peace Is Fictious, I Shall Destroy It
    4. Re:It burns mini CDs... by Jburkholder · · Score: 1

      I thought the same thing when I first saw this. Mini CDR isn't as rare as you might think (doesn't Sony make a stand-alone mixer/burner?)

      here's a site with media for sale ranging from $0.79 each (100 on a spindle for $79) to $1.09 each in jewel cases (pack of 5 for $10.90).

    5. Re:It burns mini CDs... by pi+radians · · Score: 1

      Actually, if you know where to go and get them in bulk, they can be really cheap. We use them all the time at the graphics firm I work at. The only problem is that they only hold 185MB.

      On a side note, the band Bullfrog has released three singles on this media.

      --

      sin(6cos(r)+5A)
    6. Re:It burns mini CDs... by Lumpy · · Score: 2

      comp-usa, best buy, everyone....
      I can buy mini-cd blanks almost anywhere... Sony forced them into the market by making that damned Digital camera that burns the mini-CD's.

      Yes they cost about a buck a CD right now (a far cry from my $0.19 a cd for standard CD-R blanks.) but are neat.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    7. Re:It burns mini CDs... by gorgon · · Score: 2

      From the Imation site it sounds like you don't have to hobble the files. " * Record six hours WMA-quality music or three hours of MP3 in less than five minutes." It also sounds like it doesn't do the encoding either - just transfers files from computers.

      --

      And I'd be a Libertarian, if they weren't all a bunch of tax-dodging professional whiners.
      Berke Breathed
    8. Re:It burns mini CDs... by psychalgia · · Score: 1

      its cheaper, but only slightly

      --

      ________________________________________________

    9. Re:It burns mini CDs... by Bonker · · Score: 3, Insightful

      ranging from $0.79 each (100 on a spindle for $79) to $1.09

      Hmmm... Regular 700MB CDR costs about $20.00/100 (or free, if you can find a good enough rebate). A MP3 CDrom player costs around $99.00 at BestBuy and a decent CDRW Drive costs about the same at the same place.

      Sure, this new toy is possibly more convenient, but not $200 convenient, especially when you figure in a higher 'cost of ownership' per MB of storage.

      Sorry, please play again.

      --
      The next Slashdot story will be ready soon, but subscribers can beat the rush and slashdot the links early!
    10. Re:It burns mini CDs... by Cheetah86 · · Score: 1

      It's because they're a novelty. I saw a 10 pack of them for 10 dollars at compusa, which is pretty expensive compared to a 100pack of name brand cdrs for 30 dollars.

  4. Is this part of the new advertising? by swv3752 · · Score: -1, Troll

    Is this a part of the new ad model for slashdot? Not so clever ads posing as not so clever articles?

    --
    Just a Tuna in the Sea of Life
  5. Hmmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Is there really a market for this?
    Also -
    "The tiny RipGO portable" - not so sure about that. Look at the picture

    1. Re:Hmmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's about the size of a regular portable CD player. You'd think that a solid-state device would be a much better tack for these companies to take.

    2. Re:Hmmm by egg+troll · · Score: -1

      No.

      --

      C - A language that combines the speed of assembly with the ease of use of assembly.
  6. RIAA will have their panties in a bunch over this! by Anton+Anatopopov · · Score: 2, Interesting
    This is the development I have been waiting for. Imagine, you take this thing round to your friends house, and he/she lets you loose on his/her CD collection. In the space of a couple of hours, the damn machine has paid for itself in the savings you could make by ripping CDs instead of buying them.

    No doubt the morons at the RIAA will complain that this device violates the DMCA, but in reality it will encourage people to buy CDs, because they will listen to the music in very low quality MP3 format, and later on they will buy the genuine CD, to get the extra sound quality.

    I just hope these guys stay under the RIAA's radar.

  7. Save your money for this stuff by D.A.R.E.+To+Get+High · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    DESCRIPTION
    GHB (gamma hydroxybutyrate) is a naturally occurring component of human cells. It is used most commonly in the form of a chemical salt (Na-GHB or K-GHB) which is taken recreationally as a depressant with effects quite similar to those of alcohol. These salts are powders but are most often mixed with water for recreational use. While GHB is most notorious for a few cases where it has been given to unsuspecting individuals, it is more commonly used as a recreational intoxicant like alcohol, as a sleep-aid, or as a supplement by body-builders.

    One of the major concerns with GHB is that the recreational dosage range is narrow and even small overdoses can cause temporary unrousable unconsciousness (a type of coma) and large overdoses (poisonings) can be life-threatening. There are two other chemicals which are used as GHB equivalents: 1,4-butanediol and gamma butyrlactone.

    Dose
    A standard recreational dose of pure GHB powder is between 1 - 3 g, though some people use as much as 4-5 grams in a single dose: especially frequent users who have developed a tolerance. Unfortunately, GHB is most frequently found in liquid form of widely variable concentration. 1 gram of GHB powder can be dissolved into as little as 1 ml of water (this makes 5 g per tsp) or a much greater volume and there is virtually no way to tell the concentration once it's in liquid form. The only way to know the concentration of liquid GHB is to know and trust information provided by the source. Users should be extremely careful about GHB dosages as even small overdoses can result in temporarily unrousable sleep.

    Price
    When purchased in single doses at a club, GHB is generally sold for a couple of dollars per dose. When purchased in larger quantities (or in kits before it became illegal) it is available for $10-$50 per 100 grams.

    Law
    GHB is illegal to possess or sell in the United States. It became schedule I (federally) in March, 2000 though it was scheduled in many states between 1997 and 1999. Gamma butyrlactone (GBL) is not federally scheduled but is now a list 1 chemical requiring that paperwork be filed for large sales. GBL is scheduled in some states.

    Chemistry
    GHB is most commonly produced by combining gamma butyrlactone and a strong base such as sodium hydroxide (lye). These two substances react chemically and form the unique chemical GHB.

    History
    GHB was developed in the early 60s as a human anesthetic, but was discontinued due to unwanted side effects. It's use as a sleep aid and body building supplement in the 80s and as a recreational psychoactive in the 90s led to it being scheduled in the U.S. in March of 2000.

    Slang
    Common Slang : GHB, G, Liquid X, Liquid E, GBH, Gamma-oh, Blue Verve
    Other names used in the media include : Grievous Bodily Harm, Georgia home boy, Goop, EZLay

    EFFECTS

    Onset
    As with alcohol and many other substances, the onset of GHB will be affected by how much and how recently one has eaten. Generally this will be between 10-20 minutes.

    Duration
    The primary effects of GHB last approximately 1 ½ hours. For many people there is an additional period of time (1-2 hrs) of more subtle effects. Some recreational users consume GHB in a manner similar to alcohol, sipping it slowly over an evening rather than drinking a full dose all at once. In this case the duration will be longer as the period of ingestion is stretched out over time.

    The Experience
    The effects of GHB at recreational doses are physically quite similar to those of alcohol. At lower doses effects include relaxation, reduction of social inhibitions, decreased motor skills, mood lift and other effects similar to mild alcohol intoxication. At higher recreational doses effects can include dizziness, difficulty focusing the eyes, positive mood changes, increased appreciation of music, dancing, and talking, slurring of speech, nausea, and grogginess. The line between high recreational dose and overdose can be a narrow one. At the overdose level, individuals may experience extreme grogginess (nodding in and out of consciousness) or unconsciousness, extreme dizziness and disorientation, and vomiting. During higher overdoses (poisonings), users may experience unconsciousness, convulsions, vomiting, and potentially depressed breathing.

    PROBLEMS
    Unfortunately, GHB has a few prominent problems which, in combination, can be quite dangerous. The difference between a recreational dose and a mild overdose (temporarily unrousable sleep) can be as little as 1-2 grams, the equivalent of a single dosage unit. Combining GHB with alcohol can lead to overdoses at even lower levels. Also, because GHB generally comes in liquid form and because the concentration of this liquid is difficult to determine, it is relatively common for people to accidentally take a larger dose of GHB than they think they are taking. Everyone thinks it can't happen to them, but people should be extremely careful about knowing the concentration of the material they use and about measurement techniques. GHB should be stored in a container which could never be mistaken for a beverage container and liquid GHB should be colored blue so it can not be mistaken for water. Powdered GHB is much less likely to be accidentally ingested.

    In addition to the problems around dosage, GHB also has a problem with the specific effects of an overdose. At higher overdose levels, GHB can produce both unconsciousness and vomiting. This can be an extremely dangerous combination. Vomiting while laying unconscious on one's back can lead to aspiration (inhalation) of the vomit which can cause suffocation. Individuals who are unconscious and vomiting should be turned on their side and their airway cleared so they do not inhale their vomit, and should be constantly monitored until help arrives or they become conscious. People who find themselves alone in this situation should try to position themselves so vomit inhalation can not happen if they fall unconscious.

    Beyond the respiration of vomit, it has been suggested that GHB poisonings (high overdoses) can cause death but this is not a well understood or researched issue. The DEA reports over 60 GHB related deaths in the U.S. over the past 5 years, about 2/3 of these are poly-drug mortalities while 1/3 are GHB only.

    Another problem associated with GHB is the issue of rape & assault that goes along with chemicals which can be added to drinks and given to unsuspecting victims.

    Addiction Potential
    The addiction potential of GHB is not well known, but from reports it appears that GHB can be both physically addicting and mentally habituating for a small percentage of users. We have received reports from a few individuals of severe withdrawal symptoms lasting for several days following repeated daily use. These symptoms include a strong desire to repeat the experience, difficulty sleeping, vertigo, and worrisome chest pains. We have not received any reports from users who find it difficult to stay off GHB once the withdrawal period is over.

    Contraindications

    Do not mix GHB with Alcohol. This can be an extremely dangerous combination.

    Avoid mixing GHB with other depressants such as sleep aids and opiates.

  8. Sounds like it has potential by blumpy · · Score: 2, Interesting

    But 185mb doesn't sound like it's enough to really hold that much. Also a CD-RW version would be a little nicer. They're probably saving that for v2.

    1. Re:Sounds like it has potential by ekrout · · Score: 1, Flamebait

      Awww, come on man, 160kbps is pretty good quality and is pretty much error-free as far as the majority of non-audiophiles are concerned. A "workout cd" of 40 songs, or a "day trip cd" or two of 40 songs is fine with me, and should please most people. Hey, it beats an iPod if nothing else in terms of all its features.

      --

      If you celebrate Xmas, befriend me (538
    2. Re:Sounds like it has potential by phloda · · Score: 1

      ?? "...beats an iPod if nothing else..."???

      Jeeze, why not trot out some more tangentially related to bash Apple with?

      Product is a piece of crap:
      1. Can't play miniCD format in your car changer.
      2. Hooking it up to stereo negates purpose of putting the music bytes onto plastic CD bits.
      3. Using USB mass storage is like Chinese water torture.
      4. RipGo requires special fruity colored and $10 ea. media.
      5. Add another brick to the powerstrip Ma! Is not bus powered.

      Links:
      http://www.tomshardware.com/technews/technews-20 01 1025.html
      http://www.imation.com/en_US/products/product_ge ne ric_1.jhtml?Id=IM_PRD341

    3. Re:Sounds like it has potential by turbine216 · · Score: 2

      damn...do some research!!

      1. Can't play miniCD format in your car changer

      ...you most certainly can! a miniCD can be played using a full-size adapter in ANY (read: ANY) CD player, be it tray-loading, slot-loading, or magazine-loading.

      4. RipGo requires special fruity colored and $10 ea. media

      ...not so. Memorex sells miniCD's in 5 packs for $10, and in 50-packs for $35. That's to say nothing of the prices to be found on Pricewatch.

  9. Cool gadget by crumbz · · Score: 1

    Unlike the Sony MD player, this one is truly digital. Can you say bye-bye RIAA. I want one that also does DVDs. Maybe X-mas 2002?

    1. Re:Cool gadget by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      im not really sure what you mean there.

      cut&paste: http://www.minidisc.org/very_faq.html#dontget

      i dont usually post here, but i see uninformed stuff like this and it kind of ticks me off

    2. Re:Cool gadget by crumbz · · Score: 1

      My understanding of the ATRAC format (Sony's compression system) is that it converts the digital signal to an analog format. Hence the copying time of the MD player is the same playing time of the music. I.e. if you record 65 minuted of music, it takes 65 minutes to record it to the player.

      As written in the FAQ you so pointed to, the MD ATRAC format does not support data unless you use the MD-10 with a SCSI interface.

      That was the point I was making. It does not reproduce the audio fidelity digitally. It simply stores an analog input in a digital format. What you get out is not necessarily what you put in.

    3. Re:Cool gadget by YouAreFatMan · · Score: 1
      One question: does it have mic input?

      I bought a MD recorder for live recording. I would much rather have something that I could pop into my CD-ROM drive rather than having to record it from my MD to my PC in real time. At the time, I looked all over the net for a portable standalone CD-R with mic input. A bit too late for me, I suppose...

      --
      Robotiq.com is heavily tested on animals
    4. Re:Cool gadget by Rashomon · · Score: 0

      uhm.... you can record digital to digital if you have a deck with optical i/o. Alas the newer ones aren't shipping with optical out unless you get a high end one.

    5. Re:Cool gadget by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It depends what model you use. Both the MD recorders that I have owned have had optical digital inputs, I just rip stright from my CD player to MD - optical digital all the way. To my poor old wrecked ears, the sound sound is as good as the original, far better than any MP3 that I've heard, and the disks are for all practical purposes infinitely re-recordable at about $2 a piece.

    6. Re:Cool gadget by Rashomon · · Score: 0

      Well, I was talking about optical outputs. I bought one of the first ones that Sony made. It had a digital output as well. If my memory serves me right, I think that it didn't allow you to make a second generation digital copy. Then again, if one copies from MD to MP3, the sound will degrade anyways, so analog output is good enough.

  10. Really? by usermilk · · Score: 2, Insightful

    As far as I can tell, this device sells for $400 (same price as the iPod) and holds 185 MB per cd versus the iPod's 5 GB. I am not saying that the iPod is worth it's price but it can also be used as a portable FW hard drive. I think that this device is much less useful than an iPod. I personally use a 16x FW CD burner and my Rio Volt and am fine with that, this device like the iPod is a little overpriced.

  11. I'm Not Impressed, Really... ;-) by ekrout · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    If Apple(TM)(R) had made this, it would be either translucent indigo or arctic white, and cost a mere $19.95 a month for 20 months, or, if you act now, $9.95 a month for 39 months. ;-)

    --

    If you celebrate Xmas, befriend me (538
  12. Bah, I'd rather have the iPod... by Nijika · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Although it's still too expensive as well. My portable MP3 player right now consists of a 10 year old walkman with a tape deck.

    --
    Luck favors the prepared, darling.
  13. And this is better than iPod, how? by dnorman · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Posts slamming Apple for releasing a $399US 5GB Firewire hard drive-based MP3 player that weighs 6 ounces...

    Posts lauding a mini-CD-burning 160MB player that does... Oh, wait, that's all it does. For $400US...

    I'll gladly take an iPod, thanks... And thanks to the Firewire Disk mode, I can write it off as capital equipment that I can use while consulting... Tax writeoff = free... Wait, I guess I could do that with this teeny CD burner, too... Or is it MP3 only?

    --


    It is pitch dark. You are likely to be eaten by a grue.
    1. Re:And this is better than iPod, how? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Uh, unless you're in the 100% income bracket, tax writeoff != free.

    2. Re:And this is better than iPod, how? by RollingThunder · · Score: 2

      I agree on the Apple comments, but a quick perusal of the article does answer the last question you posed:

      The unit is not limited to digital music files, allowing it to simultaneously serve as a backup unit for your PC

      That makes it a bit handier for the techie-on-the-go, as Firewire is nowhere near as ubiquitous as USB, and these CD's should play in anything. Wonder if you can burn a (small) ISO or other bootable CD on 'em?

    3. Re:And this is better than iPod, how? by dnorman · · Score: 1

      True... Although, you can write off 1/3 of the value of the equipment per year, so after 3 years... == free

      --


      It is pitch dark. You are likely to be eaten by a grue.
    4. Re:And this is better than iPod, how? by gorgon · · Score: 2
      Wonder if you can burn a (small) ISO or other bootable CD on 'em?
      Yes, you can. One example is the Bootable Business Card and its sibling the Linuxcare Bootable Toolbox.
      --

      And I'd be a Libertarian, if they weren't all a bunch of tax-dodging professional whiners.
      Berke Breathed
    5. Re:And this is better than iPod, how? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That is correct, but you forgot to point out that dnorman == poofter.

    6. Re:And this is better than iPod, how? by RollingThunder · · Score: 2

      Sorry, didn't mean "is is possible to make a bootable miniCD", I meant "can this player burn a bootable miniCD itself, or is it crippled in some way". My bad, I wasn't precise. :)

    7. Re:And this is better than iPod, how? by MrEfficient · · Score: 2
      Well, this thing is better because you don't have to have a mac to use it. It looks like it should work with linux, mac, or windows. So it should appeal to a much wider audience. Now, if the ipod would work with other OSes, then this cd burner would either have to die or drop it's price drasticly to survive. I think the ipod is a really cool device, but as long as it's mac only, it's useless to most people.

      I think this burner is supposed to transfer any type of file, not just mp3s.

      --
      Check out AbiWord.
    8. Re:And this is better than iPod, how? by vanguard · · Score: 1

      Aren't you the same troll who said I couldn't pass the CPA exam?

      Do a little research before you put your ignorance on display. You can write off 20% of the cost of the good per year over five years. However, a writeoff is not a credit. If you spend $1 on this thing you'll get about 20% of $0.28 per year for five years. (assuming 28% tax bracket)

      After five years (not three) you'll have $0.28 back, not your dollar.

      --
      That which does not kill me only makes me whinier
  14. Usefulness? by Ian_Bailey · · Score: 1

    This seems like yet another device where more things are rolled into one. Given the fact that market is already saturated, and that the number of people without burners is on the decline, and the fact that they use a special Mini-CD format (which means that it probably won't be compatible 100% or the time or it won't have a very large capacity - this is just speculation, of course) means that this might not be the best product right now...

    Is anyone else reminded of the Kodak Digital Camera/MP3 Player? Granted, this thing has more features for the same purpose now, but...

    1. Re:Usefulness? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

      what do you mean this is just speculation, read the damn article. The discs have a 185 meg capacity. I hate you idiots who can't read.

  15. Re:RIAA will have their panties in a bunch over th by crumbz · · Score: 1

    Nothing stays under their radar for long. I'd like to see this gadget for sale at Coconuts or Musicland.
    Vinyl is the way to go anyway....

  16. Sony by atrowe · · Score: 4, Informative
    Sony has had a similar product out for a while now.

    And their's is only $250.

    --

    -atrowe: Card-carrying Mensa member. I have no toleranse for stupidity.

    1. Re:Sony by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The problem with a Sony product is that when I think Sony, I think of gonads. And penii.

    2. Re:Sony by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And, it works like a charm under Linux!

    3. Re:Sony by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      No tolerance for stupidity--but apparently you're fine with bad grammar. ("theirs" is a possive pronoun, "their's" is nonsense)

    4. Re:Sony by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sony Digital Relay: full-size CD, 650 MB, under 1 pound, 3 hour battery life, $250
      Imation RipGO!: mini-CD, 185 MB, 8 ounces, 5 hour battery life, $400

      Both: USB (4x / 4x / 6x max), WMA, MP3, CDDA.

      Apple iPod: hard drive, 5 GB, 6 ounces, 10 hour battery life, $400

      iPod: FireWire ( 32x ), MP3, VBR, WAV, AIFF.
      (Firmware upgradable to future formats. Built-in video games. Charges over FireWire.)

    5. Re:Sony by sacherjj · · Score: 1

      Does that work as a stand alone MP3 player? There really isn't any info for that feature on the site you listed.

  17. this will never sell by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    sweet jesus in a birchbark canoe!!! why on earth would I pay $400 for 185MB of storage, when i can get 6GB for $250?! Even with a cd burner for my home unit, I still come out ahead!

  18. not-really - i use a lathe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    and grind down regular cdr discs into mini cdr discs

  19. Durability? by KosovoYankee · · Score: 3, Interesting

    How long will the writer last if it is constantly being dropped, banged against your thigh when you walk/jog, or piled under a stack of books on a desk or a schoolbag? I mean, the mechanism to write cd's must be fairly delicate....

    --
    - If This Peace Is Fictious, I Shall Destroy It
    1. Re:Durability? by Monte · · Score: 1

      How long will the writer last if it is constantly being dropped, banged against your thigh when you walk/jog, or piled under a stack of books on a desk or a schoolbag?

      That's why you buy the no-questions-asked "extended warranty" from the retailer for another 20 or 30 bucks. You're right, something like can become trash with one little mishap.

      My rule of thumb: never get the extended warranty on something that's going to sit on a shelf all it's life. Do get it if what you're buying is small, expensive and meant to be carried around, because eventually you'll probably drop it.

      Then again, maybe I'm just clumsy...

  20. i'll wait until the reviews come out, thanks by krog · · Score: 2, Interesting

    seeing the issues all the current portable mp3 tech seems to have (some combination of: not enough space, not fast enough to reload, 2-sec gap between songs, bitrate restrictions, etc), i would certainly recommend waiting for a few reviews to come out.

    i hate thinking, "this would have been so cool had they taken another four days to design it!"

  21. Crap... by atrowe · · Score: 0
    From the article: "By leveraging the mini CD format, Imation was able to keep the player's size down for those who want to use it as their main portable player. The cost is smaller disk capacity - 185 MB versus the 600+ MB a standard CD can hold - but that still holds plenty of tunes when your on the go. "

    Sounds just like a minidisc player to me. What is the advantage of this over 10-year-old minidisc technology?

    --

    -atrowe: Card-carrying Mensa member. I have no toleranse for stupidity.

    1. Re:Crap... by M_Talon · · Score: 2

      What is the advantage of this over 10-year-old minidisc technology?

      The difference is mini-cds can be played in a regular CD player too. Ever noticed the indention in the middle of a CD player's tray? That's for a mini-CD. Minidisc is proprietary and requires you use a Sony licensed player.

      --
      Electronic Frontier Foundation for online civil rights information
    2. Re:Crap... by RAruler · · Score: 2

      Minidisc is proprietary and requires you use a Sony licensed player.
      It's not as if Sony is forcing you to use a Sony Player/Recorder.. far from it... there Panasonic/JVC/Awia/Sharp minidisc players/recorders.. if Sony was really evil, they'd start saying that you couldn't play minidiscs correctly because you don't have Sony MiniDisc Explorer 6.. err.. :)

      --

      --
      Insert Witty Sig Here
    3. Re:Crap... by John_Booty · · Score: 2

      The difference is mini-cds can be played in a regular CD player too

      My car has a slot-load CD player. Guess that's not "regular"....

      --

      OtakuBooty.com: Smart, funny, sexy nerds.
    4. Re:Crap... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Check the manufacturer's documentation for your slot-load CD player. You'd be surprised ... a lot of slotloaders DO accept the 3-inch mini-CD format. But check your manual BEFORE trying ... it'd suck if it turned out yours wasn't one of them.

    5. Re:Crap... by jooniqzb1tch · · Score: 1

      well, AFAIK MD devices only play back ATRAC encoded music, if someone comes up with a tiny MD player that plays 300 mb of mp3 it would be a success, but I doubt this is even possible considering how cripled the MD storage system is ..

    6. Re:Crap... by Kris_J · · Score: 2

      The small discs also won't work in those old caddy-loading CD drives, although there is an adapter that comes with the Sony CDr cameras that may cope with slot-loading and caddy-loading drivers...

  22. Re:RIAA will have their panties in a bunch over th by Anton+Anatopopov · · Score: 1
    Vinyl sounds better, but the problem is that it deterioirates over time, as you get dust and scratches on it.

    The best audio format would be some kind of analog laser disc, which would combine the indestructability of the CD with the analog 'warmth and humanity' of vinyl.

    Mind you, looks like the dumb consumer has spoken. I cannot remember the last time I saw a mainstream release (apart from dance music) come out on vinyl. I think vinyl is all but dead.

    SACD seems to be the latest pretender to the vinyl throne, but with players costing over $1000 I think they make take time to catch on.

  23. Does it work with Win2k? by guru_steve · · Score: 1

    Called the RipGO mini CD-R burner and digital audio player, the unit works on both Macintosh and Windows (except 95 and NT), machines.

    So let's get this straight... It doesn't work with Windows 95. Nor does it work with NT. Win2k is based on NT. So I guess you need Win98, or ME. Ick.

    1. Re:Does it work with Win2k? by CmdrPaco · · Score: 2, Interesting

      It doesn't (yet) work with Linux, BSD, QNX, or Amiga, it seems...

      --
      I bet this is not "First Post."
    2. Re:Does it work with Win2k? by giverson · · Score: 1

      According to the article, it uses USB to connect to the computer. I would guess that is the reason why it doesn't work with NT and 95. USB support with Win95OSR2 is pretty horrible and it is nonexistant with other revisions.

      In Conclusion, Win2000 is supported. I'm 98% certain.

      Prove me wrong.

      --

      Capitalism does not lead to corruption, lack of character does.
  24. Compatibility? by Ssolstice · · Score: 4, Funny

    the unit works on both Macintosh and Windows (except 95 and NT)

    So, it only works on XP and WFW 3.11?

    1. Re:Compatibility? by Publicus · · Score: 1

      Ha, that's funny. Wish I could mod you up. But wait, isn't XP just a collection of bug fixes on 95 and added NTFS support?

      --

      My Karma was at 49, then they switched to words. All that work for nothing!

    2. Re:Compatibility? by FigWig · · Score: 1

      Actually it should work on any windows that supports USB. That includes win 98, win 2k, win me, and win xp.

      --
      Scuttlemonkey is a troll
    3. Re:Compatibility? by Kris_J · · Score: 2

      Win 95b w/OSR2.x and Win 95c both support USB and I have gotten such things as USB scanners and Palm USB adapters running under 95, however USB support was dramatically improved under 98 and few companies bother to write 95 drivers for their USB devices (which is a shame).

  25. INteresting "target audience" by Sawbones · · Score: 1

    The article/ad says the target audience is people who haven't yet bought a CD Burner or don't have space in their computers. I can't imagine anyone with 200+ megs of MP3s to trade not already having a better way to shuffle bits around.

    I wonder how the RIAA feels about a company marketing to those damned illegal Traders.

    --

    Ad in classifieds: Pandora's Box (no box) $5
  26. ******* GET READY FOR TROLL TUESDAY ******* by Deir+de+AsuL · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Prepare the Rob 'CmdrTaco' Malda stories, Troll Tuesday is just around the corner.

    I know mine is nearly complete....

    --------------
    Deir de AsuL

  27. It's weakness is USB by Mustang+Matt · · Score: 3, Informative

    Do you guys think USB is too slow for stuff like this? I know USB 2.0 is quicker but I assume this is using USB 1.0.

    It seems like devices like this would benefit a ton from firewire. USB 1.0 works great for mice and printers and other low bandwidth devices but in my experiences, it seems too slow for transferring large amounts of data.

    That being said, I have noticed that my Sony PIII 650 MHz laptop running WinME is quicker than my Athlon at 550 MHz running Win2k, so maybe chipset or OS has more to do with it than anything.

    --
    The man who trades freedom for security does not deserve nor will he ever receive either. - Benjamin Franklin
    1. Re:It's weakness is USB by gorilla · · Score: 3, Informative

      I don't see it to be a problem. The bottleneck in terms of speed here will be the burner, not the host connection.

    2. Re:It's weakness is USB by nsrbrake · · Score: 1

      Single spin cd players tranfer data at 150KB/s so let's go out on a limb and say that this thing is a 4x burner, that's a whole 600KB/s. I think USB will hold up just fine under that...

      Out of curiosity when did Sony start making PIIIs?
      Sorry had to...

      Oh and here is the url for the Imation site...
      http://www.imation.com/en_US/products/product_ge ne ric_1.jhtml?Id=IM_PRD341

      --

      Bah!
    3. Re:It's weakness is USB by jooniqzb1tch · · Score: 1

      I'll take a slower but more standard format anyday for a mobile device .. I'd hate having firewire only and not beeing able to use it AT ALL when I need it because the box doesn't support it.

    4. Re:It's weakness is USB by morcheeba · · Score: 2

      I've got a 4x USB CD burner - that seems to be the top speed for USB. So, a 150MB disc will take (at 600KB/sec) 250 seconds, or, in other words, about 4 1/2 minutes is the most you'll have to wait to burn a disc.

  28. Re:******* GET READY FOR TROLL TUESDAY ******* by D.A.R.E.+To+Get+High · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    DESCRIPTION
    Methamphetamine is a synthetic stimulant commonly used as a recreational drug. It is legally prescribed as a treatment for ADD under the brand name Desoxyn, for both children and adults. On the street, it is generally found as an odorless, white or off-white, bitter-tasting powder, though it is also found in pills, capsules and larger crystals. It is frequently snorted, but is also used orally, smoked, and injected.

    Methamphetamine production is a relatively simple process, especially when compared to many other recreational drugs. It is frequently reported on in the media when home meth-producing labs are busted.

    Law
    Methamphetamine is Schedule II in the United States, meaning that it is illegal to buy, sell, or possess without a prescription. It is legally controlled in most countries, although it has medical uses, so it is also available by prescription in many places.

    Chemistry
    Powder methamphetamine is the hydrochloride salt form which is strongly hydrophilic (absorbs water from the air quickly). The HCl salt is smokable as is. Crystal meth "Crystal Meth" or "Ice" refer to methamphetamine grown into crystals. Though many people believe that Crystal Meth is the freebase form of methamphetamie HCl, this is not true. Methamphetamine is smokable in its normal HCL form, but taking the time to grow it into crystals makes it easier to smoke. Meth in visible crystals (rather than powder) is likely to be relatively pure as it is difficult to grow crystals from impure material. Methamphetamine freebase is an oil and is uncommon on the street.

    Production
    The production of Methamphetamine is a fairly simple process which makes it easy to produce in makeshift home laboratories.

    History
    While Amphetamine was first synthesized in 1887 in Germany, methamphetamine wasn't synthesized until 1919 in Japan.

    Slang
    The Substance : methamphetamine, meth, crystal meth, speed, ice, crank, glass, uppers, yaba, shabu shabu
    The Experience :

    EFFECTS

    Onset
    Oral use takes about half an hour to produce effects. When smoked, effects are almost instantaneous, and nearly as quick when snorted.

    Duration
    4-8 hours when smoked.

    The Experience

    PROBLEMS
    Methamphetamine use generally increases the heart rate, blood pressure, body temperature, and rate of breathing of the user. Chronic use can lead to what is called 'Amphetamine Psychosis', resulting in paranoia, auditory and visual hallucinations, self-absorption, irritability, aggressive and erratic behavior, and picking at the skin. This can be magnified by lack of sleep which often accompanies heavy use of meth.

    Methamphetamine is an anorexant, meaning it causes most people to lose interest in food. This is considered a benefit for many light users, but in regular or heavy users can lead to malnutrition. Methamphetamine is also believed to be neurotoxic.

    Addiction Potential
    Methamphetamine causes significant tolerance, as well as psychological dependence. This combination can be particularly bad because the user is likely to have strong cravings for more meth, while at the same time being unable to reach a satisfactory high. Withdrawal from high doses can produce severe depression.

    Contraindications

    Do not take Methamphetamine if you are currently taking an MAOI. MAOIs are most commonly found in the prescription anti-depressants Nardil (phenelzine), Parnate (tranylcypromine), Marplan (isocarboxazid), Eldepryl (l-deprenyl), and Aurorex or Manerix (moclobemide). Ayahuasca also contains MAOIs (harmine and harmaline). MAOIs and Methamphetamin are a potentially dangerous combination. Check with your doctor if you are not sure whether your prescription medication is an MAOI.

    Individuals with heart disease (i.e. erteriosclerosis, hypertension) should be extremely careful as Methamphetamine use can be hard on the heart.

    Research shows that amphetamines used during pregnancy may decrease the birthweight of the baby as well as increasing the liklihood of cardiac abnormalities (heart problems) and possibly other birth defects.

    Methamphetamine is believed to be transferred through breast milk, so use while breast feeding is a bad idea.

  29. Fragility and Utility by nyquist_theorem · · Score: 5, Interesting

    First thing, its a CDR drive. In my experience, CDR drives are fragile and flaky and prone to sudden death even while standing still (I'm on my 8th in 5 years). MP3 players are also fragile and flaky and prone to sudden death (scratch two PMP300s and two NJBs - my RioVolt shows up next week along with the replacement HD for my NJB).

    Second thing, related to the first. Who makes it? Assuming IMation has OEM'd the thing out, who did the fab? I would suspect the thing is far from durable.

    Third thing, I have seen mini CDR media but no mini CDRW. Who wants to backup their stuff onto a 180MB mini CDR? I mean once in a while its cool, but if you can't use your CDR to back up CDs, whats the point? The mini media is nice, but a mini burner that wont take fullsize media at all is useless IMHO.

    Fourth thing, its $400. That's enough for an NJB($220), a RioVolt 90 ($89, for when the NJB breaks) and an internal CDR for your computer ($89).

    Based on point four - what advantage does this thing really have over the NJB+Riovolt+CDR-in-your-computer? And if you don't have room in your computer for a CDR, and you're gonna buy this contraption, could you not just buy a USB CDRW and a Riovolt for less? Of course you could. And that way you're not banging your CDR drive around.

    Seems like a silly idea to me. Now if only it had restrictive rights management! :)

    --
    -- "Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge." (Charles Darwin)
    1. Re:Fragility and Utility by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      CDR drives are fragile and flaky and prone to sudden death even while standing still (I'm on my 8th in 5 years) .

      You eat them for breakfast or what?

    2. Re:Fragility and Utility by Dino-Bob · · Score: 1

      If you have not seen miniature CD-RW discs, you obviously have not looked at all. Point 3 invalidated.

      --
      "There is no surer way to ruin a good discussion than to contaminate it with the facts." -- Cecil Adams
    3. Re:Fragility and Utility by Mike+the+Mac+Geek · · Score: 1

      CDRW Minis are out there. I picked up another spindle today at Best Buy. 20$ for a 10 pack of 185MB 21minute CDRW's. Not bad, Memorex makes em.

      --
      -------------------------------------------------- ---- The man, the myth, the something or other.
    4. Re:Fragility and Utility by Kris_J · · Score: 2
      I have seen mini CDR media but no mini CDRW. Who wants to backup their stuff onto a 180MB mini CDR? I mean once in a while its cool, but if you can't use your CDR to back up CDs, whats the point? The mini media is nice, but a mini burner that wont take fullsize media at all is useless IMHO.
      That would be me. As I collect data from the 'Net (MP3s, images, web pages, programs, etc) and as I create my own content (digital photos, personal multimedia projects), I group the files into 180MB volumes and then use a friend's burner to burn them onto 8cm CDr discs. I don't have any desire to copy complete CDs and I have an ultralight portable with limited expansion options. For me, this is the idea CD-burner, even before you get to the point where it can play MP3s.

      However, while I am without a job, the US$400 price tag is way out of my budget.

    5. Re:Fragility and Utility by drinkypoo · · Score: 1
      In my experience, CDR drives are fragile and flaky and prone to sudden death even while standing still (I'm on my 8th in 5 years).

      Maybe you should be buying better hardware. I've had three in five years, and the second one was Not As Advertised; Then the company I bought it from folded. Big shock. The first was a philips omniwriter 2600, which was a wonderful drive at the time. I think I paid like $350 for it or something. The second was a reconditioned 8x yamaha, which died within two months. The third is the burner I have now, a plextor plexwriter 12/10/32S. It is by far the best burner I have ever used. I'm having a problem where it keeps underrunning under nero CD, but it has burn-proof so it doesn't matter.

      what advantage does this thing really have over the NJB+Riovolt+CDR-in-your-computer?

      Well, for one, it's only one device. It's pretty useless as a burner IMO since it's only 3", but then again, it works fine as a burner for itself.

      For two, it's more portable than your computer and accompanying CDR - If you have a friend who has some data you want, you can go to their house with a 3" CD with the drivers/software on it, put it in their CDROM, load the drivers, and burn a CD, all without even using 'net access.

      What would really make this an ideal device to me is if it had some facility for getting data from digital cameras, or even from one digital camera. That way, even an 8MB flash would be sufficient; Just offload whatever else you've got, and burn it. If there were a matching camera, I'd buy both devices. Well, if I had a job right now. The camera could cost up to $400, which is a pretty reasonable price for a multi-megapixel camera anyway.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
  30. A cheaper product.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    There is a product very similar to this, but at nearly half the price at tacoinspector.com. Check it out. :)

  31. You Go Girl!! by egg+troll · · Score: -1

    Iomega, cornerning the market on even more useless shit.

    --

    C - A language that combines the speed of assembly with the ease of use of assembly.
  32. Go see one in person. by booch · · Score: 2

    It's already in stock at CompUSA. It was in their ad this weekend.

    --
    Software sucks. Open Source sucks less.
  33. Obligitory MiniDisc Plug by FatRatBastard · · Score: 2, Interesting

    You might as well go the MiniDisc route. Cheaper/Available media, etc. Yeah yeah yeah, I know its a closed format and such, but the damn thing works, and it works well. They're (finally) making a bit of a dent here thanks to some Mp3->ATRAC software.

    I love the MD!

    1. Re:Obligitory MiniDisc Plug by Rashomon · · Score: 0

      MInidisc is much better in terms of sound quality. Also, MD now has MDLP recording mode, that will allow you to put 320 mins of music on a single disc. It does this by reducing the quality to roughly that of MP3.

  34. Player/Burner by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
  35. HELP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    quick, does anyone remember the story/post/url for the guy that could analyze html formatting and determine what editor created it?

    help me obi wans...

    1. Re:HELP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
  36. I guess the only question is by Publicus · · Score: 1

    Does it play *real* mp3s, or crippled mp3s? It's my opinion that the players that force proprietary encryption on mp3 files in order to work shouldn't get to advertise as "mp3 players," because, in reality, they aren't.

    But then, what am I going to do about it besides rant on /.?

    --

    My Karma was at 49, then they switched to words. All that work for nothing!

  37. Testify Brother!! by egg+troll · · Score: -1

    See, most Slashbots fear anything that doesn't have a command line. This is why they love Linux so much, even though it is a vastly inferior OS. This also explains their refusal to recognize OSX as the BEST FUCKING OS EVER RELEASED!!

    --

    C - A language that combines the speed of assembly with the ease of use of assembly.
  38. iPOD is probably better by kawaichan · · Score: 0

    iPOD sounds like a better deal if somoene would get it to work on PC. I mean, who needs a burner when you have a 5gb drive on to go? HD's price has gone down so much now CD just are just not that attractive no more but then again, I have 5PCs at home, none of them has a firewire port.

    --

    kawai
  39. Re:RIAA will have their panties in a bunch over th by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Imagine, you take this thing round to your friends house, and he/she lets you loose on his/her CD collection. In the space of a couple of hours, the damn machine has paid for itself in the savings you could make by ripping CDs instead of buying them.

    And if it happened in Canada, would be completely legal

  40. Re:long play minidisc's by non_linear · · Score: 1

    For the past year (6 mos?), long play encoding for minidiscs has been available. 4 hours on a 60 minute minidisc. Not too shabby! Check out http://minidisc.org/ for more info. as for minidisc being proprietary, what about MP3? ;)

    Sony is not the only source for minidisc recorders. sharp is another big supplier.

  41. Re:RIAA will have their panties in a bunch over th by Jburkholder · · Score: 1

    I wonder how well that would work, though.

    The interface to the PC is USB. How long would it really take to rip and encode a CD, transfer it to your RipGo via USB and burn a miniCDR? I'm guessing it would take quite a bit longer than a couple hours to rip/encode/transfer/burn $400 worth of CDs.

  42. Archos 6gb Recording Drive by Degobah · · Score: 2, Informative

    I just picked up this <A HREF='http://www.archos.com/us/products/product_50 0201.html'>puppy</A> that has 6 Gigs of storage and can rip directly from any audio source. And it's $350. Seems to me to be the best of the IPod and this thing, for 50 bucks less. You can take that cash and buy 2 Rocco DVD's

    1. Re:Archos 6gb Recording Drive by Tucan · · Score: 1

      Your point is good, but I hope you got the 30 day price-matching guarantee. Harmony is selling the Jukebox 6000 for $219+SH.

    2. Re:Archos 6gb Recording Drive by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It is the best of the iPod, minus Size and Firewire. 5~6gb transfer on USB must take ages compared to the 10minutes on Firewire. Also this beasty looks a lot bigger than the iPod.

    3. Re:Archos 6gb Recording Drive by pamasters · · Score: 1

      Actually, the Jukebox 6000 is a different product, without the real-time MP3 encoder (check out the specs - it has stereo out only; the recorder has analog & digital stereo in). Seems to me a real-time 160kbps encoder would be worth the extra $$

  43. you are the wind beneath my wings by Proctal+Relapse · · Score: -1
    After witnessing a number of GHB overdoses and thinking quite a bit about how to reduce the dangers associated with GHB use, we've come up with the following list of suggestions:

    1) Color your GHB blue

    One of the more common causes of GHB problems is people who accidentally take a swallow of GHB, believing it to be water. I know it sounds unlikely, but I assure you it's possible. Clear liquid in a drinking glass or bottle can easily be mistaken for water while something blue cannot. Adding a small amount of blue food coloring to liquid GHB turns it a nice shade of blue. Blue was chosen because it does not resemble juice, and green is already the color of absinthe...so blue could be an identifiable standard.

    2) Keep your GHB in a container which can not be mistaken for a drinking container.

    There are many good alternatives for containers to store GHB in. One of the better I've seen are dark brown medicine bottles like a cough syrup bottle. Something few people would take a large slug out of without thinking. Other good suggestions include a saline eye wash bottle, a vanilla extract bottle or other non-drinkable food flavoring bottles, or other opaque or tinted bottles.

    3) Keep the concentration relatively low

    If you insist on keeping your GHB in a bottle which people might accidentally drink out of, or if you'd just like to be on the safe side...keeping the concentration relatively low can help prevent the worst overdoses. Preferably a concentration where a single large swallow would not be more than 10 grams or so. This suggestion is obviously impractical in some situations where a larger volume is not feasible.

    4) Write GHB on your hand

    We've heard of too many situations where an individual passes out and those around them don't know what they took. Writing "GHB" or "G" on your hand is a simple way to inform others what you took, in the unfortunate case you're found unconscious. In low overdose situations it could save you a trip to the hospital. This is primarily for cases where people are doing GHB in public.

    5) Tell your friends what substance you're doing and how much

    A good suggestion with most entheogenic exploration. Informing those around you of what and how much you're planning to ingest, insufflate, or inject can help people decide what to do in emergency situations...as well as bringing peace of mind to your friends.

    6) Talk about what to do if a GHB overdose occurs

    Since it's a more frequent occurance that any of us would prefer...talking it through ahead of time can help those around you know what to do in case an overdose does happen.

    1.Check their breathing.
    2.Turn the individual on their side so if they vomit while unconscious they won't choke.
    3.If there is reason to think they are in danger, call help immediately. The most dangerous period is between 20 and 120 minutes after ingestion.
    4.Try to find out what else they may have taken.

    Whenever someone becomes unconscious after taking a depressant, there is a risk of death. If someone begins vomiting and convulsing after taking GHB, the person should get medical attention immediately. If there is any question about someone's health, be safe. Do not be upset at others for calling doctors or amublances if you find yourself waking up in a hospital, your friends and community have a right (and often a legal obligation) to call for help if someone's health is in danger.

    7) Measure carefully & don't mix with alcohol.

    Though these two are pretty obvious, they shouldn't be left off the list. As always, measure your dosage carefully. The line between pleasant buzz and hospital visit isn't as wide as you might hope. And never mix GHB with alcohol or other depressants. It's just not worth the risk.

    Tell your friends.

    8) Make sure there are some hot bitches drinking GHB with you

    We cannot stress this enough. If you are going to safely consume GHB, you must ensure that a steady supply of hot and horny babes comes your way. Be safe, and beware the "GHB goggles"; keep a sober friend handy to protect against your waking up next to an ugly ho.

  44. You'd know the answer to this... by PhilMills · · Score: 2, Funny

    ...if you'd just read the article.

    It's USB. Win95 or WinNT can't deal with USB in any reasonable fashion. Win2K supports USB just fine.

    Y'know, WinME was based on Win98 was based on Win95, so, by process of elimination, it looks like it'll only work on Macs.

    PhilMills

    -Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, will be taken out of context and posted on /.

    --
    Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, will be quoted out of context on
  45. Re:long play minidisc's by M_Talon · · Score: 1

    Hmmm...MP3 is pretty much a standard, as is the CD format. Mini-CDs are just a smaller capacity version of a CD, and they play on >90% of the CD players out there. I can't put a minidisc in my standard CD-ROM drive, so that makes a difference. :)

    Thank you for correcting me on the Sony thing though. I do appreciate a level-headed correction.

    --
    Electronic Frontier Foundation for online civil rights information
  46. Yep. by megaduck · · Score: 3, Informative

    I imagine that they disqualify 98 and NT because neither of those have USB support. Any Windows released after '98 should have the requisite USB support (that includes Windows 98 and Win2K).


    Of course USB is dog slow for this kind of product. For the same amount of scratch you can get an iPod with a five gig capacity and FireWire connectivity. Just my $0.02.

    --
    This .sig for rent.
    1. Re:Yep. by mahtaaaain · · Score: 0
      "I imagine that they disqualify 98 and NT because neither of those have USB support. Any Windows released after '98 should have the requisite USB support (that includes Windows 98 and Win2K)."


      you mean 95 and NT....any windows after 95 has the usb support....

      --
      you a winna , ha ha ha
  47. Uhh... by Transcendent · · Score: 2, Informative

    What about minidisks??? They're smaller, you can burn on the go, and re-burn whenever you want. You don't have to worry about gettin the disk scratched or anything either. The capacity of an MD is pretty much the same too. So why is everybody getting all hyped up about this when MD's do it better?

    1. Re:Uhh... by Tucan · · Score: 1


      Because MDs (no matter how many times you reburn them) are limited to use in MD players.

    2. Re:Uhh... by FFFish · · Score: 2

      Yah, really.

      What I want is an all-inclusive Minidisc setup. I want a device that plays MP3, lets me xfer data, can record voice through a mic, and has a decent video stillcam. It needs a car audio interface, so I can slam it in the dash and play MP3. It needs a home stereo interface, so I can slam it in and play MP3. It needs a computer interface, so I can slam it in and record MP3 and xfer out the voice recordings, data, and images.

      If it had a bit of PDA in it, so much the better. If it also had a reliable but slow and common connection, good: I can then stuff it onto any computer and xfer data.

      --

      --
      Don't like it? Respond with words, not karma.
    3. Re:Uhh... by jooniqzb1tch · · Score: 1

      do you think this is even possible considering the rights management and the ATRAC audio encoding and such ? a MD based storage solution would be great but I wonder if the MD's file system would permit that.. anyone having some info on that ?

    4. Re:Uhh... by Transcendent · · Score: 1

      So... CD's are limited to CD players... floppy's are limited to floppy drives, tapes are limited to tape decks. The point you made was pretty weak. The real point you should have made was that MD's aren't as popular as CD's (at least in the US... Europe its great I've heard). The world needs to realise how great MD's are in terms of size verse storage capacity. You can put on 80mins of sound on a 140mb disk using the ATRAC music compression (which is just as good as CD audio... i've put it to my own personal test), and 320mins with ATRAC3... All in a 3in square that can't be scratched easily or by laying around like a CD can. The track managing is great, and labeling is easy and useful. If they made it where they could put MP3 files on it, then it would sell a whole lot better... and I'm sure that a good percentage of the world population would make the switch...

    5. Re:Uhh... by Tucan · · Score: 1

      You asked the question. You got an answer. You seem to get it now.

  48. Remember how it goes with Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Typically, with any Apple product, you can go elsewhere and find something for half the price that is fast and has a lot more extras. Might not look as good, though!

    1. Re:Remember how it goes with Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sorry, Charlie. No one else makes a FireWire MP3 player. FireWire is 32x faster than USB.

      iPod: 6 ounces, 5 GB hard drive, deck-of-cards size, 10 hour battery life, FireWire interface with built-in charging.

      Find that elswhere. At any price...

      It also doubles as an external FireWire hard drive for data transport. Think digital wallet.

  49. Re:RIAA will have their panties in a bunch over th by ichimunki · · Score: 1

    I don't know if you consider them mainstream or not, but they do get radio play, and they recorded a theme song for a recent James Bond film. Garbage's latest release "beautifulgarbage" is available on vinyl from cdnow.com. Of course, this is not a common practice. And sadly, they are on an RIAA affiliated label, so I can't recommend buying the album, no matter what format it comes on.

    --
    I do not have a signature
  50. Re:RIAA will have their panties in a bunch over th by Cujo · · Score: 1

    My guess is that it would take a couple of days, non stop. And $400 worth of CDs hardly qualifies as a collection.

    --

    Helium balloons want to be free.

  51. 185MB *each* is plenty... by krog · · Score: 1

    ...because you can easily carry 5 or 10 of these things with you in a pocket, or far more if you're packing a bag. small media is good.

    and considering the cost of CD-Rs these days, CD-RWs seem more and more needless.

  52. Someone show me a decent MP3 player by Scutter · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Oh goody. Another over-priced MP3 player with too many bells and whistles. And a price that's way higher than it should be.

    All I want is a decent MP3 player. I want one that supports some sort of smart media card, supports at least 128MB, and has USB. And most importantly, doesn't cost $400! Is that too much to ask? The Diamond Rio 500 came closest to that, but of course it's not made anymore (and cost too much anyway). Instead, SonicBlue produces the vastly inferior Rio 600 or the way over-priced 800. If I can buy a camcorder for $300, a freaking MP3 player oughta be under $100.

    I don't need a built-in CD player (that's why I have MP3's fer crissakes!) I don't need a built-in hard drive. I don't need a goddamn built-in toaster oven. I just want a little MP3 player that holds more than 5 songs that I can stick in my pocket when I go for a walk. I certainly don't need to put my entire MP3 collection on it all at once.

    Let's see a cheap MP3 player that does one thing exceptionally well, instead of an overpriced MP3 player that does half a dozen things poorly.

    --

    "Tell me doctor, with all of your defenses, are there any provisions for an attack by killer bees?"
    1. Re:Someone show me a decent MP3 player by Deslock · · Score: 2, Insightful

      The RioVolt is reasonably priced. Personally, I bought a new RIO500 for $70 on Ebay and a 128MB Smartmedia card for $40 (techbargains.com). It's a great little device:

      1. solid state!
      2. lightweight: 3 oz
      3. small size: 0.6x3.5x2.4"
      4. 13 hour battery life on a single AA
      5. 192 MB!

      Sure I can't store my whole collection on it, but I can fit 2.5 hours using VBR or 3+ hours at 128 kbps. That's more than adequate for most uses and doesn't require any screwing around with CDRs or Minidiscs.

      As far as the RipGo goes, are they on crack? It's a cool device, but at $400 I'll pass. Recording abilities or not, this thing is way overpriced... since most users don't need recording, they should come out with a player-only unit similar in price to the RIO-Volt.

    2. Re:Someone show me a decent MP3 player by Willis+Wasabi · · Score: 0
      Ok, how about a Rio One? $100 (actually I got mine free after rebate at BestBuy along with Windows XP and a trunkload of other free stuff), actually loud enough that I turn down the default startup volume cause it's too loud. Sounds pretty decent, weighs less than 3 ounces, and is deck of cards sized.

      Downside: drop the cheap-ass headphones, they sound awful, I replaced them with a pair from Philips for $10. Only 32MB of memory, but it's SmartMedia expandable to 160MB (I went to 96 over the weekend). Internal and expansion memory are separate volumes, and therefore you could lose a couple megs due to internal fragmentation. Bundled RealJukebox sucks unbelievably. Build quality leaves a little to be desired. Froze once or twice when I did stupid stuff.

      Upside: USB. Mountable under Win2k and WinXP, probably under Linux etc since there were no drivers, just USB mass storage already in both. And did I mention I got it free? :)

      Gulp, now for the embarassing part. It plays WMAs, and I can't really tell the difference between 64Kbps WMA and 128Kbps MP3, but wow, 64 Kbps MP3 is full of compression artifacts. Really, I swear I love Linux. :) Oh, well it's not like MP3s were completely unemcumbered. This will do until there's an Ogg player (and Ogg works well at 64K). Who knows, the Rio One is flashable, maybe someday.

      I have had it less than a week though, I'm sure I could still grow to loathe it.

      --
      All true wisdom can be found in sigs.
    3. Re:Someone show me a decent MP3 player by emars · · Score: 1

      Man, I read this and it seemed so familiar. Then I looked here.

      Collecting karma with the same post in different threads! Ingenious!

      --
      ...18...19...20 Submit
    4. Re:Someone show me a decent MP3 player by Scutter · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I recycled it for the same reason that /. recycled their story (they just changed the name of the MP3 player in question). Personally, I thought it was amusing that I didn't have to change a word of the post and it still fit.

      --

      "Tell me doctor, with all of your defenses, are there any provisions for an attack by killer bees?"
    5. Re:Someone show me a decent MP3 player by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Uhhh Huhh

  53. imagine this by Sexual+Asspussy · · Score: -1

    imagine my thick 7" cock working its way up your tight, dry asshole.... imagine the feeling of the cold concrete floor as i pin you to the ground and fuck you.... imagine the taste of blood and broken teeth in your mouth and the tears in your eyes when you realize that it's better for you to just give up and lie there until i'm through.... imagine the point at which you learn to start liking it, maybe rock your ass back and forth so i penetrate deeper. imagine when i come, and i pull out, and you snap out of it.

    faggot.

  54. Format is Sony's, though by M_Talon · · Score: 2

    As far as I can tell, the format is still Sony's to control. They're just letting others use it. Technically, they could do the whole proprietary thing (as you joked), but it's really not in their best interests. One really can learn a lesson from Microsoft in how NOT to do business in the longterm :)

    --
    Electronic Frontier Foundation for online civil rights information
  55. Not really by yesthatguy · · Score: 1

    Win98 and WinME were just bug fixes and added "features" onto 95. WinXP is actually coming off of the NT Kernel, and isn't a successor (code-base-wise) to 95.

    --
    Yes! That guy!
  56. Ask Slashdot! by egg+troll · · Score: -1

    This would be a perfect question to pose to Ask Slashdot. While you could look it up yourself using Google and other search engines, you shouldn't be bothered to do such laborious work yourself. By posting to Ask Slashdot, you can cause all the other Slashbots to do your work for you! Ingenious!!

    --

    C - A language that combines the speed of assembly with the ease of use of assembly.
  57. Where's the mic input!? by sadclown · · Score: 4, Informative
    Am I the only one who misses the audio input on these things? We haven't had a new portable digital recording device superior to the DAT walkman in 15 years! Why don't they just put 1 $15 analog mic input in this thing or the iPod and give musicians, audio engineers and reporters a fantastic new toy.


    I know, minidisc does it already, but minidisc players don't have digital output for PC post-production work and actually doesn't sound as good as plain old WAV files.


    If this had a mic input, you could burn directly to MP3 and have 6 hours of digital recording - 6 times that of a minidisc.


    If the iPod had a mic input, you could burn 10 hours of uncompressed audio or 100 hours of MP3s. Portable 2 track recording studio!

  58. Burn this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Yabbo make me lose my mind


    Armpit hair, armpit hair.

  59. MOD DOWN: GOATSE.X LINK IN ABOVE KARMA WHORING by Sexual+Asspussy · · Score: -1

    you flaming dicksucker. are you proud? did posting this drool give you a "natural high"? get yourself fucked.

  60. MD by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is bull. Why would this be ANY better than MD [which is cheaper and more functional].

  61. Almost the same thing by cmoney · · Score: 1
    For $119 from Easybuy2000.com, you can get a player-only model that's just as small. Who cares about having a portable CD-R drive that only writes to 3" CDs?

    Get the small player and a regular CD-R drive that writes both large and small CDs and you save $100 and get a faster burner to boot.

  62. Ugh. by BoarderPhreak · · Score: 2
    This is about as useful as the Apple iPod...


    Who buys a $400 walkman? They're too small and fragile and easily stolen, not to mention outdated fairly quickly by the next "big thing."


    Besides, I'd rather have a burner where I can use it most efficiently - at home, attached to my RAID, where my 4,000+ MP3s are!

  63. But what if... by Mustang+Matt · · Score: 2

    What if it's a 16x burner...
    I guess if they make it burn slow enough for USB to keep up. I don't think USB 1.0 can keep up with 16x burn speeds can it?

    Call me impatient, but when I burn CDs I don't want to wait. 4x doesn't cut it. Granted, when I'm burning I'm usually not making audio cds that might be worth listening but instead I'm backing up data from a webserver. Maybe I'd be more patient if it were something fun like audio cds.

    --
    The man who trades freedom for security does not deserve nor will he ever receive either. - Benjamin Franklin
    1. Re:But what if... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thing is tho, 185MB at 4x doesn't take a lot of minutes..

  64. WARNING - GOATSE.CX LINK ABOVE by Anomymous+Coward · · Score: -1

    do not click that link. it contains a redirect to a picture of a torn anus.

    thanks.

  65. How about this one? 128MB, palm-sized, $135. by corky6921 · · Score: 2

    Check out MyDivaPlayer.com. They have a 128MB player that also supports CompactFlash for $135 shipped after discount. It is extremely small -- about 3"; fits in the palm of your hand. I haven't had any experience with it, but the few reviews I could find are raves. I plan to buy one for Christmas. The coolness factor of having a mini "Zip drive"/MP3 player/voice recorder for $135 is really what attracted me to this one. --Erica

  66. iPod = $399 + Apple PC by swordboy · · Score: 2

    The problem with iPod is that you need to buy an Apple PC to go with it. The bottom line is that Apple and Imation have subsidized their product for the sake of other interests! In the case of Imation, they are supporting an open standard so I will take their product over Apple's (technologically superior) product any day.

    --

    Life is the leading cause of death in America.
    1. Re:iPod = $399 + Apple PC by Matthew+Weigel · · Score: 2

      Bzzzt. Apple is selling it that way, but that doesn't mean that's the way it is. Wait 'til they ship, then we'll know whether you're kneejerking or on to something.

      --
      --Matthew
    2. Re:iPod = $399 + Apple PC by swordboy · · Score: 1

      There's no "bzzzt" about it. Apple lists the requirement for the Apple Computer in the specs at the official iPod site. To quote:

      Requirements - Apple computer with built-in FireWire port
      - Mac OS 9.2.1 (or later) or Mac OS X v10.1 (or later)
      - iTunes 2 software (included)

      --

      Life is the leading cause of death in America.
    3. Re:iPod = $399 + Apple PC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The iPod runs in FireWire Disk Mode (as an external FireWire hard drive) by holding down the Fwd and Rev buttons on the unit at the same time (when you turn it on). This means the iPod can be used as external hard drive with any operating system which supports external FireWire disks. The music files which the iPod plays are stored in an invisible folder on this external FireWire hard drive. Placing your MP3's from your PC into this folder is all that is necessary to get full music functionality out of the iPod. FireWire Disk Mode means you get full tax write-off functionality also, even without a Mac.

      It is amazing how much misinformation is propagating about this little device. Yes, it has a 5 GB hard drive (a 1.8 inch Toshiba). Yes, you can move MP3 files between different computers (Macintoshes even) over the iPod (by using manual mode in iTunes, or FWDM on PC's). Yes, this device rocks and is priced exactly right for the market to which it will initially sell.

      I apologize for those people who think that just because a configuration is not specifically supported, that it is not possible.

    4. Re:iPod = $399 + Apple PC by Matthew+Weigel · · Score: 2

      They also say it's a regular Firewire hard drive. No iTunes necessary to use it as such. It's entirely possible, whether they say so or not, that it just does the Right Thing with any media files stored on it (it's also possible it's proprietary and broken). Until the units are shipping, or people start really exploring their 'review' units, we don't know.

      It''s entirely possible that you're right, but web page blurbs are not the way to know.

      --
      --Matthew
    5. Re:iPod = $399 + Apple PC by sirinek · · Score: 1
      Um there is no end to hardware that only lists Windows as a compatible operating system, yet we've all found a way to run Linux using said hardware. Why should apple's ipod be any different?


      siri

  67. Have these guys ever heard of Minidisc? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    lol.

  68. 3 months? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Do I win somehting?

  69. Only about 150mb on mini CDs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...Except their Mini CDrs, whichr a lot more expensive than normal ones, and only hold 150mb, so thats like 2 Albums.
    Not that I'm bothered about RIAA, being in Euroland anyway

  70. I'm still waiting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    for one that supports CP/M.

  71. nope by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    .wav and midi files only, sorry.

  72. What about copy protection and DRM? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'm getting VERY tired of product announcements of music and video recording devices that simply do not disclose what, if any, copy protection and digital rights management (DRM) schemes they embody.

    Reviewers and consumers need to start getting assertive if we don't want to buy a pig in a poke--or, worse yet, buy a device on the basis of what reviews say it will do, then discover that a required firmware "upgrade" has disabled those capabilities. "Oh, we didn't actually SAY it would record ANY music..."

    Vendors have a perfect right to sell devices with any restrictions they like, but they need to DISCLOSE these restrictions.

    The specifications for the iPod have ALREADY mutated--to more restricted capabilities--and it isn't even out yet!

  73. but by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

    but OS X has a command line, you fucking fuck!

  74. yes by egg+troll · · Score: -1

    it does, cockwhiff, but you never need use it. unlike that piece of shit OS called Linux. i guarentee you if you use a GUI for more than a half hour it *will* crash like a terrorist-controlled airplane and you'll have to switch to a lower runlevel to fix things. OSX doesn't have such issues because APPLE FUCKING OWNS YOU LIKE A FURBY!

    --

    C - A language that combines the speed of assembly with the ease of use of assembly.
  75. "The problem is..." by mblase · · Score: 2

    The problem with iPod is that you need to buy an Apple PC to go with it.

    True, and no doubt Apple knows this is a downer. This and the price makes it obvious they're currently selling the iPod as a Mac peripheral, rather than a general-purpose MP3 player.

    However, I expect Apple will: (1) bring down the price on the device after a few months, (2) develop and/or partner for non-Apple compatability for the device. If people like it, no doubt third-party attachments for non-FireWire computers will become available. The FireWire is one of the best features about the iPod, though, so I don't expect that to ever go away.

    Just my thoughts. Sony sells all their portables with Memory Stick compatability; Apple sells for Mac compatability; Microsoft sells for Windows compatability. It's normal for the industry to at least *start* with closed compatability and open it as time goes on. Smaller companies benefit from open technologies, like MP3 CDs, because they don't have to develop as much.

    But as has been said, Apple is profitable *because* they target a niche audience, and the only reason to complain that they're focusing on that niche is if you aren't yet part of it. So I'd expect the iPod price drop and wider compatability to arrive at about the same time. Best thing you ("you" meaning "all Slashdot's readers") can do to hasten that process: WRITE APPLE AND TELL THEM YOU WANT LINUX COMPATABILITY. It's got to be easier than Microsoft compatability, right?

    1. Re:"The problem is..." by swb · · Score: 2

      Just my thoughts. Sony sells all their portables with Memory Stick compatability; Apple sells for Mac compatability; Microsoft sells for Windows compatability.

      It half makes sense, but many of Sony's products that are memory stick compatible are still usable even if you never own a memory stick as long as you live.

      I wouldn't own a Macintosh (space+money mean the 5 PCs I own and use for business must stay), but I would own an iPod. But I can't because I'm not buying a $900 computer to own a $400 MP3 player.

  76. Correction! by megaduck · · Score: 2

    I meant "Any Windows released after '95..."


    I knew that "preview" button was there for a reason!

    --
    This .sig for rent.
    1. Re:Correction! by Fredpro · · Score: 1

      Actually I believe Windows '95C had USB support, but I guess they disqualify it because 95% of Windows '95 users would be using an older version. That is, if you said "Windows 95 Revision C or later" you would probably just confuse people.

  77. I have an MD, I like it, but.... by SethJohnson · · Score: 2


    Minidisc is terrific for being able to record in the field, but the whole thing is still a closed-digital thing. Like what I mean is that if you want to load a minidisc with sound to listen to, you gotta play all the music in real-time to transfer it. And if you want track numbers in there, it requires a lot of manual intervention.

    The article, unfortunately, focuses on the size of this player and not how you get the music on the disc. I'm wondering if it's firewire or USB.. It would be very cool if this thing recorded in the field, too. That's one feature I think they could add to the iPod 2.0 to make it just a tad bit more appealing: Recording.
    1. Re:I have an MD, I like it, but.... by Tony+Hoyle · · Score: 1

      A good MD will take the track and title data off the CD automatically anyway. Even if you use analogue transfer they do a good job of automatically finding the tracks. As far as 'a lot of manual intervention' goes, in the worst case where you've used analogue to transfer the data just find the odd occasion where the automatic detection has got it wrong and add/remove the track mark. Takes about 3 seconds.
      Best thing about MD for me is 320 minutes per disk (MDLP4). At that compression I wouldn't plug it into a hifi but you can't hear the difference with a pair of bog standard headphones.

  78. Wow.. Taco is freelancing... by SethJohnson · · Score: 1, Offtopic


    still holds plenty of tunes when your on the go.


    And I thought Slashdot was the only publisher who was trying to eradicate the apostrophe from the english language.
  79. Battery Life? by jeeryg_flashaccess · · Score: 1

    I would imagine that the battery life would suck from burning cd's AND playing music!

    --
    Life is like pants... fit in or you don't fit in.
  80. Not a tax writeoff by vanguard · · Score: 1

    Well, at least not a legal one. If you use a computer for mixed personal/professional you can only write off the professional portion of the expense.

    Disclaimer: I am not a CPA but I do have an accounting degree and I've spent several years as a professional tax preparer working in a CPA's office.

    --
    That which does not kill me only makes me whinier
    1. Re:Not a tax writeoff by sunken_ehime_maru · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      oh, couldn't pass the exam, huh?

    2. Re:Not a tax writeoff by vanguard · · Score: 1

      This is a troll but I'll respond anyway.

      I never took the exam. I worked as a junior account for two years while going to school at night. I realized that I didn't like accounting and that I loved computers. I added a second major, MIS, and started coding. I've been doing that for about 8 years now and I'm almost finished my comp sci master's degree. I work as a "tech lead" in the IT dept of a huge networking company (Cisco Systems).

      I'm not an idiot that couldn't pass the exam, I made a career change.

      --
      That which does not kill me only makes me whinier
  81. OT: Kid Koala vs Bullfrog by jovlinger · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    Kid Koala kicks ass!

    I've been trying to figure out where that sample comes from: "However, as a beginner, it's often best to just kill everyone as fast as you can with the pump action"

    And now that we have halloween, the Charlie Brown sample "I got a rock!" is cool.

    I am aware that Kid Koala is more Nija Tune than Bullfrog in general, but I thought perhaps you might know.

  82. OT: Tax Writeoff Free by dgb2n · · Score: 1

    That is a major misconception.

    actually depending on your tax bracket a tax writeoff translates into a 10% - 34% reduction in the price of the item.

    For example. Your $400 iPod reduces your taxable income by $400. That decreases your tax bill by $400*Highest marginal tax rate = about $100 (in my case).

  83. New Moderation Category by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    -1, Didn't Get The Joke.

  84. Re:long play minidisc's by statusbar · · Score: 2

    yes mp3 is a standard. so is minidisc.

    The similarity is that both are proprietary standards.

    See:
    http://www.mp3licensing.com/help/developer.html

    I want to support mp3/mp3PRO in my products. Do I need a license? YES

    I have my own/third party mp3 software. Do I need a license? YES

    Do I need a license to stream mp3/mp3PRO encoded content over the Internet? YES

    Do I need a license to distribute mp3/mp3PRO encoded content? YES

    Time to read up on http://www.vorbis.org/ and support them instead.

    --jeff

    --
    ipv6 is my vpn
  85. hmm by sewagemaster · · Score: 1

    why would anyone want to bring a portable burner? isnt this what it is essentially? this really implies that the person carrying this device is going to bring with him a few blank CDs. CDs itself arent small (except mini CDs - if this device is able to burn them that would be great). and does this thing take 30 mins to burn up each CD? talk about unusability!

    1. Re:hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

      Read the article before posting you halfwit. It ONLY burns mini cd's. NOW PLEASE DIE.

  86. Whatever........ by Sean+Johnson · · Score: 1

    How is this better than say a Minidisc? As far as I can tell it is not. A Minidisc is still more versatile. THe only advantage this might have over Minidisc is a slightly higher (very slight) recording capaicity, and that it may be able to record faster tha nreal time. Granted I took a fleeting look at the article, but it didn't seem to have much REAL info at all, besides a couple of really neato! pictures. The problem is that when any company comes out with a new watch-what-I-can-do product, they don't seem to realize that the consumer needs, and wants a lot of info about the technical aspects of thier product. The consumer is more aware than ever, and they want to know exactly how and so-and-so's product is better than any others. Some lame blurb about the coolness, of fashion factor does not suit the average consumer one iota! As far as I can tell, this is a predictable manifestation stemming from the x-Pandium form factor which does nothing to improve upon what is already available through the Minidisc. I already burn all my MP3's to regular sized CD-ROM's, and have been doing so for a while. If this player can double as a general data storage medium for a computer, then it might have something going for it. As of now, I have no idea whether it can or not, but I tend to think not.

    --
    >>>>>> Chewie, take the professor in the back and plug him into the hyperdrive.
  87. DVD-RAM by pagercam · · Score: 0

    I'm not sure what the density of a 3" DVD-RAM, would be bu it would definately store enough music to be more interesting 185MB is only 3hrs at 96Kbit and many people use 128Kbit. Flash is cheap at the moment I think you can get 128MBs (memory stick, CF) for the $60-70 range if you shop arround. The battery life would be much better as well. If this is small enough people start to putv them in thier pockets, I'm not sure that I want a CD spinning up in my pocket, but it has been a while since she left me so it maynot be that bad either.

  88. portable ripper wanted by defective · · Score: 1

    i want a portable device that you can put an audio cd into and, in addition to being able to to listen to the cd, rip the cd to mp3 using the on-board storage. this way, i can go to a party and say "hey, that's a kewl song, can i borrow the cd for four minutes?" then put the cd in the portable device, rip it and hand it back.

    then when i go home, i can add it to my mp3 library, maybe even burn my own copy.

    what do you think?

  89. interesting but useful? by seda · · Score: 1

    Seems like kind of a neat gimick, buut I don't know how useful it is in real life. I mean combining a burner with your cd player doesn't seem all that important. Now I do like the size of mini cds, but you can buy a minicd player that doesn't burn for under $200 . Check out the philips for example. http://hardware.mp3.com/hardware/individual/3730.h tml THen you have normal burners being more an more ubiquitous and going for around $100. Unless you really need to burn on the go I don't see much of a need for this. Even if you need something of comparable size and portability where you can record on the go I'd rather buy something like one of the 384 ibm microdrive players which hover around the same price. You get the same size and recordign ability although you would lose the removing ability of mini cd's I'll admit. On summation it sounds like a cool device, but of limited use.

  90. Archos 6GB recorder, Creative/Nomad Jukebox, ... by Chris.Boyle · · Score: 1

    The Archos 6GB recorder mentioned further up the page does exactly that. The Creative/Nomad Jukebox also has a mic input, but (AFAIK) only records to WAV.

  91. Re:RIAA will have their panties in a bunch over th by twinpot · · Score: 1

    Well there is a laser "pickup" turntable available
    from these guys (http://www.elpj.com/). A tad expensive mind.....

  92. Re:long play minidisc's by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    miniDisc is 100% proprietary, down to not being able to make more than 1 copy of anything in miniDisc format and having to wait real-time to make those copies (Thanks Sony!)

    MP3 is proprietary if you choose to use or buy the licenses to proprietary software and codecs. You do not have to do this with the LAME MP3 encoder.

    That being said, use Ogg Vorbis.

  93. Steel by Com2Kid · · Score: 1

    Am I the only one who would rather have this made out of steel and weigh about 3 pounds? I miss steel made consumer appliances. Damnit those types of products rocked. Anything that could double as a anchor for a boat and be used to prop up a wobbly table is Ok by me.

    Darn friggin plastic small sized pieces of crud, GIVE ME STEEL!