Slashdot Mirror


Wireless Pedal Power Computing in Laos

An anonymous reader writes "'An innovative, pedal powered, wireless network provides Internet access to off-grid villages in Laos,' using LINUX-based software which is being localised into the Lao language. The 'Jhai Foundation's makes the Jhari computer, which consists of a single-board PC (the MZ-104 based upon the Mach-Z single-chip computer - equivalent to a 133 MHz 486 system), uses "embedded" circuit boards, the sort that are used in industrial equipment, and is devoid of moving parts such as fans or disc drives, made to operate for long periods of time without service or attention.'"

140 comments

  1. This reminds me... by Whelkman · · Score: 3, Funny

    ...of the episode of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles where Rocksteady and Bebop have to pedal to keep the Technodrome's power running. Yes it does.

    1. Re:This reminds me... by KidIcarus · · Score: 1, Funny

      [This Reminds Me] of the episode of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles where Rocksteady and Bebop have to pedal to keep the Technodrome's power running. Yes it does.

      Ladies and Gentlemen, a man who will never, ever, have sex.

    2. Re:This reminds me... by H3XA · · Score: 1

      which means he can join your "Nintendo Fan Boy" club.....

      - HeXa

    3. Re:This reminds me... by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 3, Funny
      Oyeah...the man with a nickname from an obscure Nintendo game flames the guy who watches children's cartoons.

      Ring, ring...phone's for you. They say the call is regarding pots, kettles, and the color black.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    4. Re:This reminds me... by biglig2 · · Score: 2

      I hate that phrase. I mean, the pot's own blackness doesn't make the kettle any less black, does it?

      --
      ~~~~~ BigLig2? You mean there's another one of me?
    5. Re:This reminds me... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, but it sure makes that pot a hypocrite.

    6. Re:This reminds me... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "A lot" is two words. You wouldn't say "alittle", would you?

      Spelling Nazi!

  2. Pedal computing? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    How about marketing some of these to the MMORPG players... it'd be just like real crack, get your high and lose weight!

  3. in other news by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    that's funny, but will it work?

  4. How about by MikeDX · · Score: 1

    a pedal powered UPS.. would certainly make a sensible option for long blackouts, if the battery from the UPS is dying you can just jump on the excercise bike and throw a few hundred amps through it.

    And better yet, you could employ a school leaver to do it so no need to tire yourself out! :)

    1. Re:How about by mccalli · · Score: 2
      a pedal powered UPS...

      Naah. Would never get there by 10:00am the next morning.

      Cheers,
      Ian

  5. So does anyone know... by offpath3 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    ...how much pedaling must be done to power a computer? Admittedly they mentioned they were using low power parts and all, but it seems like you would need to pedal for a while to store up enough charge in the battery to use the computer for even a short while.

    1. Re:So does anyone know... by tanveer1979 · · Score: 2
      not exactly. Consider the amount of calories burnt by human body. Lets say the efficency of the system is even 20%. Now we did such a thing as a school project. We lit a 100 W bulb. At leasurly pace pedaling we were able to generate 100 Watts., Now we had cheap local heavy equipment and efficeny must have been 5-10 % Safely we can assume with modern gearing and stuff you can generate 400 W easily. So cycling leasurly for half an hour will give you an hour of backup and having wheels under your table and doing it leasurly can provide just enough power for constant use! (200 Watts). So this is not really unfeasible.

      In developing countries of you get people to pedal 10 hours a day. Lets say 2 ppl working you can get 400W * 10 hours = 4KwH of energy... guess the cost, well about 8 dollars!
      Of course this is much higher than electrical power this can be real useful for reseach installations in remote areas.

      It may be argued that hiring people to do it is inhuman, but the fact is that in developing countries, including my own ie india, human powered transport vehicals are still in existance and source of livelyhood of many people.So this wont really start any new trend in exploitation.
      --
      My Aurora : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o91ZsGwJYyg
      FB : https://www.facebook.com/TanveersPhotography
    2. Re:So does anyone know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Now we did such a thing as a school project. We lit a 100 W bulb.

      You know, a 100 W bulb can be lit with less than 100 W of power. Was it really as bright as a twin 100 W bulb in a socket? How about you use actual measuring instruments next time.

      A Google search can probably provide better numbers.

    3. Re:So does anyone know... by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Oh, for gosh sake...hiring people to do a job is "inhuman"? Much better for the people to be without both internet access and jobs. Sigh...liberals...

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    4. Re:So does anyone know... by hitzroth · · Score: 1

      Safely we can assume with modern gearing and stuff you can generate 400 W easily.

      Um... No. This is like saying "well, I've got this bike and I can do 15 mph on it for hours and hours. So, if I get bigger gears, I can do 60 mph for hours and hours." 400 W is professional cyclist territory. And even then, I'd dare you to demand that output of them for much more than an hour. 200 W/person might be more reasonable but still a bit much. If you want more watts, you'd want to got with more people.

      You do know that you can "light" a 100 Watt bulb with less than 100 Watts, right?

      --
      In mathematics, one does not understand things, one merely gets used to them.
      --VonNeumann
    5. Re:So does anyone know... by quax · · Score: 1

      I am not sure if you can produce 100 W that easily, but the 15 W that my Netwinder consumes should be easily achievable. Lets say the circumference of the pedals are about 1 meter. You would have to push against a force of 30 Newton achieving one full revolution every 2 seconds to put out 15 Watt = (30 x 1)Nm / 1s

      Now if you assume that you loose 20 % upon conversion into electrical current you will have to pedal a little bit harder agaisnat a force of 150 Newton. That's equivalent to the weight of 15 Kg. Sounds doable to me.

    6. Re:So does anyone know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      sigh... Ann Coulter fans...

      You know, if you just call anyone you disagree with a liberal, people will think you're a bit slow. Seems to me we had a President named Carter who didn't listen to Rush or Hannity, but actually got stuff done. Was he a liberal or a good man, b/c we all know he can't be both?

      Nice link, btw. If you want to know who "stole" all your land, take a look at Reagan-era agri-business. I guess it's easier for you to blame it on Ted Turner than the "greatest president ever."

    7. Re:So does anyone know... by ahaning · · Score: 1

      In developing countries of you get people to pedal 10 hours a day.

      You do know that there's only one Lance Armstrong, right?

      And at the rate he's going, there won't be too many more ;-).

      --
      Withdrawal before climax is very ineffective and those who try this are usually called "parents."
  6. Why am I not doing this? by JanMark · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It seems to me the project isn't finished by far. But I feel envious, here are people doing good for a large group of people that need it the most. Other goups come to mind. Why don't *I* do something like this? It would make the world a better place and I would have fun doning it. Infact, why are we not all do something like this?

    --
    -- (:> jms cs.vu.nl (_) --"---
    1. Re:Why am I not doing this? by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 1
      Because using a 486 would suck. Plus, shipping the Jhari computer to where you live would be prohibitively expensive.

      But hey, none of this matters...what matters is appealing to one's own sense of political correctness, yes?

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    2. Re:Why am I not doing this? by pubjames · · Score: 2

      [..] Why don't *I* do something like this? It would make the world a better place and I would have fun doing it. Infact, why are we not all do something like this?

      Well, some people do. Most people don't. Moving from don't to do is the hardest thing.

    3. Re:Why am I not doing this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well, using a 486 for Mozilla would suck...but it doesn't have to be that way!

    4. Re:Why am I not doing this? by Quixote · · Score: 2
      Why don't *I* do something like this?

      Well, why don't you? This project is not finished, as you said so yourself. Just go to the Jhai Foundation's webpage and start asking questions and volunteer! Thats the best part about this line of work: unless you're working on the hardware, you can work from basically any corner of the world!

    5. Re:Why am I not doing this? by lattice · · Score: 1

      I for one am not doing this because hill-tribe Laotians are not, as you suggest "a large group of people that need it the most." Too often, these technology projects don't think about the social implications of introducing, no, forcing computers into communities where the most advanced technology in use is an hydraulic rice-thresher. How are computers and KDE going to help them with their swidden agriculture, or the growing problem of opium addiction? What about prostitution, or the road infrastructure?

      Yes, self-advocacy is a Good Thing(tm), but how useful is communicating with the outside world if the outside world doesn't speak your language? The highland groups that are being involved with this project don't even speak Lao, let alone Thai or English! When dam construction starts in one of their villages, they might start talking, but no-one will be able to listen.

      So much good could be done with technology, but it really seems like the people out there implementing it don't think much further than the gadget factor, and certainly don't think of the real implications for the people on whom they're imposing these technologies.

    6. Re:Why am I not doing this? by rapidweather · · Score: 1

      Hide not your talents, they for use were made. What's a sundial in the shade?
      --Benjamin Franklin

  7. KDE on a 486? by EugeneK · · Score: 1

    "The team in Rochester is hard at work localising Linux and the KDE environment for the Lao language"

    I like using KDE, but I don't think it would be useable on a 486...good luck to them regardless.

    1. Re:KDE on a 486? by Gekke+Eekhoorn · · Score: 1

      Well, I guess that depends.

      A 133MHz 486? Let's say that the Pentium chips are more efficient so that this translates to a 100MHz Pentium II. KDE2 ran on my Pentium 133MHz laptop and it was useable.

      Remember that window managers are event driven, so it might take a while to open a window, but eventually it will be there, and then you can use it almost normally.

      A bigger problem will be memory and disk space.

      I you strip out enough stuff from KDE3, and go easy on the theming, I guess you could keep the memory consumption low. These systems will have 96MB flash disks, so I guess swap space is out :)

      Qt-3.0.5 is 13MB worth of libs on my system. My full installation of KDE3 has 86MB of libs, and 230MB total. I think that the 96MB will be cramped. Maybe with network mounting? Put a normal pc on the mountaintop, work from that? 11Mbps will be good, I guess.

      But all in all, I think it will be doable. Even the voice stuff they want to do will work. My Pentium 133 can play mp3s with 6% cpu (and realvideo at 2 frames per second :-) )

      Browsing the web will suck bigtime, though. And in 10 years, who knows what technology will be predominant on the web?

    2. Re:KDE on a 486? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      agreed. I installed debian on a DX4/120MHz for my sis lately. Under any theme whatsoever, kde was nothing short of perfectly unusable and pure frustration. Only afterstep or fvwm would roughly do.
      Moreover, I find it quite displeasing to notice the gap between the responsiveness of menus, explorers, etc..of either kde or gnome and that of the other north-north-west american OS.

  8. This is brilliant by jukal · · Score: 2
    This is one of the best projects I have seen in many years. They use extremely simple but still very innovative solutions - which are based on technologies that have already proved working - put the together and voila!

    Basically, this system could work without maintenance or electricity in any of it's elements for many years. And that is just amazing.

    "The equipment will be powered by electricity stored in a car battery charged by "foot cranks" which are essentially bicycle wheels and pedals hooked to a small generator. The generator is connected to a car battery and the car battery is connected to the computer. Connection with each computer to the others will be by radio local area network (LAN). Each village will connect to one repeater station powered by a solar means on the ridge near the river valley. That station will then send the radio signal to the microwave tower nearby and eventually to a server in Vientiane that will connect the villages to the internet."

    1. Re:This is brilliant by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 2
      Yeah - I can't wait until the most remote, hitherto untouched by technology regions of the world get internet access. Yes, life is not complete until they have access to receive (and send) spam, access to online gambling, addictive online games (imagine mom putting her kids to work on the cycle so she can play a MUD all day instead of harvesting crops), racist propaganda, intolerant flame wars in forums, and access to as many transvestite tearoom webcams as possible.

      Oh, and a credit card to pay for it all. Or at least someone else's credit card number.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    2. Re:This is brilliant by BushDiverOne · · Score: 1

      Is this not a rather narrow minded and arrogant view - that only people in first world countries have the maturity to handle Internet access?

    3. Re:This is brilliant by jukal · · Score: 2
      > racist propaganda

      I believe your expertize in this area is enough for the whole world.

    4. Re:This is brilliant by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 1

      No, it means a heretofore unspoiled area will be polluted by the Western world's cultural waste. You can't be expected to have a fulfilling life without popup ads, spyware, and KDE crashes, yes? What happens the first time the Laotians fall for an online pyramid scheme, and mail off a year's wages to a mail drop in Singapore? More technology creates problems, it never solves them.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    5. Re:This is brilliant by Lshmael · · Score: 1

      You're making out technology to be this evil demon that is the single most important reaon life sucks or something like that. The fact is, almost everything has a good and bad side. Sure, the Internet has given us porn and popup ads, but it has only caused webblogs, increased communications, Google, Slashdot, etc. etc.

      And another thing, pyramid schemes do not only exist online...

    6. Re:This is brilliant by SpaceJunkie · · Score: 1

      I think its great to open up the opportunity for any walk of life to have access to this technology- but I think the guy is trying to say not to force it upon them. There are still areas of Africa where there are tribes who have a life, with although it may seem terrible to us, they are very happy with-they find food, have shelter, have kids and sing and dance. Their biggest issue is that farms are destroying and fencing off the land which they use and ruining this lifestyle. If they are so happy with there lifestyle- then who are we to decide it needs to change. Offer them the intenet yes- but dont discount anyone not taking that offer as simple. You know-in many ways I envied how happy and carefree those people appeared to be. The life was tough but much more rewarding than the mundane cube-life most of us over here(including me) live. Not everyone lives for technology. I certainly do-but there have been times I have wondered...

      --
      OrionRobots.co.uk - Robots From sol
    7. Re:This is brilliant by SpaceJunkie · · Score: 1

      But door to door salesmen and junk-mail posters are less likely to succeed in delivering their message anyway.. So this would be the pyramid schemes opportunity to buttin there. I dont think technology is an evil demon. Like I said- everyone should have access to it- but also the choice not to access it if that is their way.

      --
      OrionRobots.co.uk - Robots From sol
  9. pedaling power? by drendite · · Score: 2, Funny

    When will my hamster be able to lose fat and power my linux box at the same time?

    1. Re:pedaling power? by Dannon · · Score: 2

      Must... resist... comment! Can't resist! Sigh...

      Depending on your power requirements, you may want to look into a beowulf cluster of hamsters.

      (Actually, I remember seeing an episode of Dexter's Lab with a massive hamster-array power source....)

      --
      Good judgment comes from experience.
      Experience comes from bad judgment.
  10. Why they by af_robot · · Score: 1, Redundant

    just can't buy a simple generator which will be working on coal or some other sort of energy?!
    But * pedals *?!!! Come one! It is the new millenium already!

    1. Re:Why they by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      hey... some people in this millenium can't afford things common to us. if they can und must save energy... why not? No need for oil out of OPEC and gas out of Russia.

      Seems a little bit more modest and a kind of smarter way. Maybe that's the new millenium ;-P

      And ... anyway... the Roman Empire will fall. Sooner or later... so please keep the head up in the sky, drink oil and feel modern. Cheers...

      Chris

    2. Re:Why they by floydigus · · Score: 1

      Perhaps they think that it would be better to use renewable energy?

      Thousands of people in the West use stationary bicycles several times a week. The only difference is that in gyms the energy is wasted as heat rather than converted into something useful.

      --

      All things in moderation; including moderation

    3. Re:Why they by Dokta_C · · Score: 1

      Because they don't have lots of manufactured infrastructure.

      Wheras I'm sure they have lots of folks to turn the crank.

      Infrastructure = expensive
      People = cheap
      (at least in Laos)

    4. Re:Why they by tomknight · · Score: 2
      coal or some other sort of energy

      I guess this is why the US is against renewable energy - they just haven't a clue!

      Tom.

      --
      Oh arse
    5. Re:Why they by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      The only difference is that in gyms the energy is wasted as heat rather than converted into something useful.
      I think you may have hit upon a wonderful idea there...Quick, go and sell it to some fitness centres!
    6. Re:Why they by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Considering the rate of obesity in the US, we should be doing this.

  11. Great...just what we needed by Kaz+Riprock · · Score: 1
    From the article:
    The system is being configured to provide a 'telegraph' (email) and telephone (VOIP communication) among the villages, via the Lao phone system, and worldwide through Internet telephony.
    And this leads to:
    (ring, ring) Hello. I am calling from a small Laotian village to tell you about the great savings you can get by subscribing to Time magazine for only pennies a day...(hangup)

    Or this:
    ("You have mail") These small village Laotian girls are waiting for you! Just click here to see hot wild natives going crazy for you live!

    --
    Mordor...a magical, mythical land where women are more rare than dragons--but where every man would rather find a dragon
    1. Re:Great...just what we needed by ourtongue · · Score: 1

      That's the it goes, honey. Some sick brains in the US are able to do this.

      Some sick brains in Laos are able to do this.... so what?

      Freedom and equality... eeer, hold on, has there been something going on in the last centuries... eeeer...

      I don't want to protect spam. But it's just a fact to deal with... from Laos or anywhere.

      cheers

    2. Re:Great...just what we needed by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 2

      Spam is not a "fact of life", nor any kind of "natural" force. It is an anomaly, an effect of the fact that the recipient pays the cost of the message, nothing more. Buh.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    3. Re:Great...just what we needed by ourtongue · · Score: 1

      Ok. I agree :-P

      1. to protect recipients of e-mail, Third World shouldn't be connected to the Internet.

      2. When I'll be reborn with English as my mothertongue, I will join your discussion again. :-P Thanks for pointing out my errors to get myself smarter.

      but please:
      spam exists. I want to attack spam. But still I don't get the clue with "Laos Village has more evil teenagers than US/European teenagers who wants to earn quick money"?

      cheers to tolerance and reality ;)

  12. pump *you* up by Alien+Being · · Score: 2, Funny

    Hans: dat compudah is for da girly-man.
    Franz: ya, mine is a beowulf cluster.
    Hans: ya, of Crays.
    Franz: ya, und they are overclocked.

    1. Re:pump *you* up by reduced · · Score: 1

      hahaha mod parent up!!!

  13. Not just pedal power operations by neksys · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I can see other uses for lower power consumption computer devices. The fact of the matter is that computers and their associated equipment suck up a lot of power - people or groups interested in limiting their power usage could utilize these to great benefit. Public schools are always interested in lowering their costs - our local high school, for example, has hundreds of computers running at any given time. The electricity costs to the district as a whole must be astronomical. For basic websurfing and word processing, which is the primary function of most school computers, these would be ideal, and I can imagine that the cost savings in terms of the power bill would quickly pay off the initial investment. *shrug* Just a thought.

    1. Re:Not just pedal power operations by psamuels · · Score: 1
      Public schools are always interested in lowering their costs - our local high school, for example, has hundreds of computers running at any given time. The electricity costs to the district as a whole must be astronomical.

      Don't even think about it. (:

      Kids these^UAmericans these days. All it would take is for one lazy slob to come crying home after the "hard" gym class workout and his yuppie mom sics her sleazy lawyer on the school board to hyperventilate about "slave labor" and "exploiting our children".

      --
      "How can you claim that you are anti-crack, while still writing a window manager?" — Metacity README
    2. Re:Not just pedal power operations by SpaceJunkie · · Score: 1

      Hey but it would be a cure for fat-kids. If they want to surf, watch tv/movies or phone their freinds- they gotta pedal... I like it... We could do with more ideas like that....

      AS for mothers- someone should explain to them that there kids wasteline doesnt need to compete with the girth of the channel tunnel anyway....

      --
      OrionRobots.co.uk - Robots From sol
  14. why would anyone in a third world country need it by Billly+Gates · · Score: 0, Troll

    Your lucky if they can read let alone need or care about a computer.

  15. Linux wins again by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Linux keeps on keepin' on. Very Cool. Kudos to all involved!

  16. Do they really need a GUI? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Seems like a waste to use a resource-hogging GUI like KDE for this project. CLI's aren't that heard to learn, and there's always the curses library to make apps user- and mouse- friendly.

    If they insist on a GUI they should go for something with less bloat like fvwm or LiteStep.

  17. Re:This is brilliant [not] by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    In a poor country like Laos where food is scarse, powering equipment with food is revolting. What would be the slogan, "steal a child's meal, pedal your way to the net"? Surely there are other sources of energy.

  18. Theory Flawed? by RichWest · · Score: 0

    I tried this at home and it doesn't work... Every time I cycle power my machine just reboots :(

    Thank you, I shall be here all week!

  19. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by Ubi_NL · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Just an american (european) way of thinking that anyone who is not in the US / europe must be living in straw huts and hunt wild animals for a living.

    There are actually educated people in the 'third' world (*wow*). The fact that they come up with a method of running PCs without burning fossile fuels is something we should envy. Especially now with a completely flopped 'sustainable world' congres in south AFRICA.
    I would love to have one of those spring-powered radios but the fact is our 'first world' society is so fixed on CO2 production we can't get them here.

    --

    If an experiment works, something has gone wrong.
  20. Hmmmmm by phunhippy · · Score: 1, Troll

    Hmmmm Equiv to a 133mhz 486..probably486sx no damn fpu!!.... while this is noble and all none of these "computers" as they call them.... can not be used for all the MMORPG now out there.. how can we expect our economy to survive if we can't hook people living in huts in 3rd world countries on money makers like evercrack and DAoC..

    they should really have more modern pc's and ahve the pedal power hooked up to teams of 10 kids at a time!!!

  21. one problem by hype7 · · Score: 1

    in my experience computer geeks have pretty bad bo (body odour).

    Can you imagine how much this would compound the problem?

    -- james

  22. how fast? by rde · · Score: 1

    equivalent to a 133 MHz 486 system
    lessee.. 133MHz. That's over a million cycles a second. Damn, they can move fast over there.

    1. Re:how fast? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, it's one hundred thirty-three million cycles per second, to be precise.

  23. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by buswolley · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Perhaps, it is for that very reason, my friend. Education and ideas are severely limited in poor parts of the world. With such 'poor man' technology remote villages can develope learning programs through 'net resources freely available. And perhaps, if written English in unknown to anyone in the village, on of our resourceful people can write a web page translator from English to "..." remote language. the point is. The sooner poor continents like Africa get wired, the sooner they will take command of their lives from the last vestiges of colonialism. Education can save them from Aids, kick start the economy, and provide people a way they can network against warlords. Who knows? But it is a resource they must have. You have been flamed. The Mayor has spoken.

    --

    A Good Troll is better than a Bad Human.

  24. In Other News by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Golden Triangle Druglords go bankrupt, due to increased competition from poppy farmers selling their product via the internet. One anonymous farmer was quoted as saying 'With e-commerce, the cost of transaction per customer dwindles to almost nothing--pennies. Eliminate the middleman. Sell directly to your customers, and you too can become a cash money millionaire.' Who said e-commerce doesn't work?

  25. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by Graspee_Leemoor · · Score: 1

    " Your lucky if they can read let alone need or care about a computer."

    Gosh, and I bet they are so primitive they can't use apostrophes either!

    ("Your"/"You're").

    Dumbass.

    graspee

  26. P.E. and websurfing? by buswolley · · Score: 1

    perhaps, finally Physical Ed and web surfing come together. One class pedals on the machine for the exercise while another class uses the computer technology.

    --

    A Good Troll is better than a Bad Human.

  27. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Oh well - I am in a third-world country (1) . Reading Slashdot. Typing a reply to your troll. Is there something wrong with me? Am I going to go blind?

    (1) South Africa - yes we have not technically come up the ranks if you're out of the big cities. Large parts of SA would benifit from portable power that does not require walking 100km to the nearest petrol/diesel/coal/paraffin depot.
    __
    cs

  28. LINUX... by rbruels · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    doesn't stand for anything! It's called Linux. Thank you.

    --

    "All your base are belong to this file I send in order to have your advice."
  29. Laotian Supermen? by este · · Score: 1

    Wow, a group of individuals who actually get in better shape the more they surf the internet. With this level of constant exercise and limitless access to knowledge, who knows?--The Laotians may soon be our superiors! Almost like puling a rickshaw down the information superhighway...

    --
    [este]
  30. Re:This is brilliant [not] by jukal · · Score: 2
    > "steal a child's meal, pedal your way to the net"

    Uh? Like how does it make you steal a child's meal if your village gets a generator which can be used to generate electricity by foot pedals? Instead, they could use the SAME generator and battery for warming up the food. Just if Anonymous Cowards started surfing the whole day, it might become a problem

    Providing the villages with access to information and with means of communication can instead change something in the long run too. Or?? Did you have a point, if so please explain - your comment did not make any sense to me.

  31. This is nothing new... by Polo · · Score: 3, Funny


    This is nothing new...

    Gilligan did this years ago for the Professor.

  32. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by Billly+Gates · · Score: 1

    Actually I have volunteered at peace corps and worked in Peru and I have visited many parts of Central America. I can tell you that %85-%90 of the population can barely even put food on the table for their families. They typically make maybe a few hundred dollars a year. If I were one of the Peruvians, I would much rather prefer modern farming equipment, food and a better education for my children then a machine which would give me none of my needs. The few educated and upper class Peruvians already have computers in their offices and homes. I admit reliable power is a problem but most have generators or they just put up with the outages. I for one agree that more proper resources should be spent for the third world for things like food and medical vacinations then computers.

    Infact, I recall seeing a story here on slashdot several months ago about all the donated pc's going to Asia just being thrown out in a dump. No one really wanted them.

  33. Report from Laos by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting
    I've been there twice over the past few years, including some visits to the remote regions. They would definitely use this. Some of the villages have generators which they run for a few hours in the evening so they can watch Thai TV. They definitely would use email if they had it. Right now they use something called a "bush telegraph" which is astonishingly effective. It would be even more effective if it were wireless. Most of them are not literate but there are literate people (monks especially) in every village. Also the Lao writing system does not take long to learn, unlike other Asian languages such as Chinese.

    One thing that would be awesome is if there were some form of e-banking available through this sytem. Right now all their "savings" are in Lao kip, which is about as worthless as a third world currency can be. They would be very happy if they could save in dollars.

    Some of you may laugh at the idea of using 486s, but I can tell you I saw a lot of Lao hunters out using muzzle loader muskets that must have been 150 years old. If the technology works and it's available, it doesn't matter how outdated it is.

  34. It's just the first step. by NeoSeo · · Score: 1

    Imagine if we would add generators to all those useless stationary bikes, stair masters, and treadmills at the health clubs. Why, a couple thousand alone could power all the tofu makers in California.

  35. Laotian power sources by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    These guys are thinking about pedal power, but the Laotians will use their creative powers to come up with other power sources. I'm sure these things will be adapted to use water power and animal power. All Laotian villages are built on rivers or streams, and all already use animal power sources for various things, especially pumping water. These things could also be solar. Laos has a lot of sunlight.

  36. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    Hey hey...we don't need anyone's real-world experience here. The fact is, Westerners are evil and third world are virtuous. Anyone offering a viewpoint that contradicts this dogma is a heretic, and is eligible to be moderated as flamebait.

    --
    Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
  37. Parts of the USA by pommiekiwifruit · · Score: 1
    (like Detroit) have worse health care systems/infant mortality rates than Libya, for example (despite the US sanctions), yet still many USians connect to the internet.

    Other third world countries no doubt have higher literacy rates than many 1st world countries. For example education is compulsory in Thailand (right next to Laos) until the age of 18.

    1. Re:Parts of the USA by Latent+IT · · Score: 2

      (like Detroit) have worse health care systems/infant mortality rates than Libya, for example (despite the US sanctions), yet still many USians connect to the internet.

      I guarantee you that the mothers in Detroit that give birth to babies already addicted to crack are *not* the same people that spend a great deal of time on the internet.

      One more time, ladies and gentlemen. The internet is not *all* it's cracked up to be. It is not a hot bowl of soup, nor is it your teacher. It's certainly not your parents, and it really shouldn't be your friend. It's a tool. And, a lot like a wrench, it's not the answer to every problem.

    2. Re:Parts of the USA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Do you realize how politically incorrect it is to publicize the fact that American cities with large African-American populations are more primitive than Libya? Bash the U.S. if you must, but stay the hell away from outright racism.

    3. Re:Parts of the USA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hey, I thought that capitalism pulls all social categories up to higher levels ?

      How come the USA has these problems ?

      does this mean that right wing christian corporatism
      DOESN'T WORK ?

  38. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by prefect42 · · Score: 1

    Just to defend my little island, you can get them no problem in Great Britain in a couple of different types.

    And I'd reckon we're slightly less confused about the state of the rest of the world. One of the benefits of our previous colonialist policies is that we have much closer ties with these third world countries than many other nations.

    jh

    --

    jh

  39. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by rillian · · Score: 2

    I would love to have one of those spring-powered radios but the fact is our 'first world' society is so fixed on CO2 production we can't get them here.

    Of course they are available. For example, see wind up radio, here or any other link from google.

  40. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by psamuels · · Score: 1
    Education can save them from Aids, kick start the economy, and provide people a way they can network against warlords. Who knows? But it is a resource they must have.

    I don't know about Laos. I've never been that far east, and I like to talk only of what I know (you know, like everyone here on Slashdot). But the Internet is not what people need in the jungles of central Africa.

    Bill Clinton once came to Africa and decided that what the schools all needed was to be wired. I have no idea whatever came of his plans for this, but the point is, I really didn't understand how he could possibly think the Internet would offer a higher ROI than, say, a few textbooks. Or pencils. Or teachers who had better than a 3rd-world high-school education themselves.

    The Onion got it. Not so farfetched as it sounds.

    --
    "How can you claim that you are anti-crack, while still writing a window manager?" — Metacity README
  41. Why pedal power? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Why not use wind or solar, because all that pedaling is going to old pretty quickly.

  42. This is good stuff by Trane+Francks · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Sure, a 486-class system will be sluggish with KDE, but as long as it has a healthy dose of RAM, it'll do fine.

    As for the banal comments about Laotian/third-world intelligence, the fact is that these people are human beings with the very same potential that we all have. The difference is that many of them have simply not had the same opportunities. This project aims to rectify that problem. A Cisco and Dilbert 2-thumbs up!

    While watching Discovery Channel here in Tokyo a month ago or so (I admit it, I'm a Discovery junkie), an interesting comment regarding mammoth-hunting early homo sapiens was made. The jist of it was that if you took one of these early homo sapiens and raised them in our world, they'd have just as much potential for success as any of us.

    I would hope that might make folks who spew "third-world-stupid" comments think twice before doing so. Opportunistically challenged does not equate with stupid. Unless, of course, you're married to your sister and live in a trailor park somewhere in the South. :-P

    --
    ...a FreeDOS contributor: http://www.freedos.org/
    1. Re:This is good stuff by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 2

      You realize, of course, that the trailer park comment completely negated your entire argument? I would say that rural trailer trash are pretty darn "opportunistically challenged", as much so as any rural Laotian. Of course, I forget it's completely acceptable among the university-educated to make such bigoted comments.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    2. Re:This is good stuff by Trane+Francks · · Score: 1

      > You realize, of course, that the trailer park
      > comment completely negated your entire argument?

      I apologize for the comment. It was uncalled for.

      That said, I disagree that truth is negated by stupidity. While *my* credibility may have been compromised, the meat of the original post stands up to scrutiny on its own merit.

      --
      ...a FreeDOS contributor: http://www.freedos.org/
    3. Re:This is good stuff by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 2

      It really screws up a comment to say with one breath that these people are human beings with the very same potential that we all have, and turn right around and say, no, I'm kidding, these people are NOT in fact equal humans, but subhumans who practice incest and do not have any potential whatsoever. As long as you're ridiculing American Southerners, it's OK though. Taking cheap shots at the expense of the white underclass has been socially acceptable for centuries, and such people are certainly unprotected by politically correct thought.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    4. Re:This is good stuff by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You damn liberals.

  43. Memo to "Homeland Security Office" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


    This seems like something Al Queda would enjoy
    making use of...

  44. "steal a child's meal" - hey what? by BushDiverOne · · Score: 1

    I think AC is missing the point somewhere. The main reason food is scarse (and your beloved childen are eating cold food) is because the USA spent so many years bombing Laos in the name of freedom. Then again maybe you are right - better not to "let" them have Internet access or they may get to see how the first world lives.

    1. Re:"steal a child's meal" - hey what? by TastesLikeChicken · · Score: 1

      While I don't disagree that bombing Laos was a very bad thing to do. It did happen a while ago. And there's plenty of food problems in countries that we haven't bombed. If they can use the internet to find more efficient ways to raise crops and increase yields 10%, I'm sure that would more than pay for the energy used in getting the information.

      --
      Until our children are no longer molded into castrated sheep democracy remains a fake and a danger. -A. S. Neill
  45. Re:Hmmmmm - Beowulf Cluster? by ites · · Score: 0, Troll

    Actually, if one person can power a single 133mhz 486,
    Then a Beowulf cluster of the things might actually be useful.

    --
    Sig for sale or rent. One previous user. Inquire within.
  46. So I guess.. by CreatorOfSmallTruths · · Score: 1

    .. this means the lao's hackers are not into pizza while coding...

  47. KDE on a 133MHz 486??? by g4dget · · Score: 2

    Some simpler X11-based toolkits should run fine on that kind of machine, but KDE and Gnome are both pretty resource hungry.

  48. Oh God I can see it now! by evilviper · · Score: 2
    It won't be long before we see:
    Frist post fro m a pedelpowerd pc in Laos! (sic)


    Hmm, pedal-powered computers you say? And you thought you got upset that a file was taking so long to download!
    Come on. This naked picture of Natalie Portman is taking forever. Can't go on... pedaling.... much.... longer... THUD!


    But seriously. Why not use a $200 800MHz PC from Walmart, and just swap the hard drive with some solid-state storage? I'm sure it would be a much lower-cost solution, and shouldn't use up signficantly more power (especially if you underclocked the CPU).
    --
    Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
    1. Re:Oh God I can see it now! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Are you kidding? They don't have Walmart in Laos, man! It's a communist country, with _very_ restrictive laws. Go there and see for yourself..

    2. Re:Oh God I can see it now! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because a Walmart PC is not designed to withstand the harsh conditions, hot and humid with lots of rain.

    3. Re:Oh God I can see it now! by Suppafly · · Score: 2

      I'm sure it would be a much lower-cost solution, and shouldn't use up signficantly more power (especially if you underclocked the CPU).

      And I'm sure you're wrong.

    4. Re:Oh God I can see it now! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hot and humid is not a problem for a PC. Avoid direct rain.

      The point was the disposable nature of the PCs. For $200, you could give them more than one.

  49. How about an army of mice? by brejc8 · · Score: 3, Informative

    Here is how I used a mouse to power an ARM based CPU. I cant see it taking a whole human to power a PC.
    Maybe they should use lower power chips?

  50. As if! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    As if the Laotians need PC's! They are too busy supplying opium to the world to need PC's. In the Laotian language, shit, let's keep them in the stoned age! Heaven's Gate forbid they learn English. Doh!

    1. Re:As if! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      so, what have you got against a little bit of opium now and then ?
      plus, it's less bad for your health than hollywood cinema, even without the CIA...

    2. Re:As if! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh, come on now, opium is no more hazardous to your health than a steady diet of cigarettes, coffee and junk food!

    3. Re:As if! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      what makes you think they WANT to learn english ?

      do you think you are in some way superior ?

      it sure doesn't sound like it....

  51. the mean machine by BritInParis · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Wouldn't it be interesting to have a race for the "most usable minimalist machine for daily use", instead of the biggest, brightest, prettiest, etc.

    I mean, what does it take to browse the internet, receive email, write a letter, do kitchen maths, and some coding ?
    It would make a change from hyping the latest graphics card and fastest cpu and prettiest casings....

  52. Import Coal to Laos? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yeah! Lets export coal to Laos! Yeah! That's the ticket!

  53. Chief Software Architect! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Now here is an area where the real Billy Gates, the great philanthropist, could shine.

    He could support a project like this with a tenth of a per cent of his annual income!

  54. Unstable supply (chips not power...;-) by mainr · · Score: 2, Informative

    ZFMicro (maker of the MachZ - now called the ZFx86 CPU) is currently involved in a lawsuit with National Semiconductor over National's commitment to act as silicon foundry for the ZF design. See http://www.zfmicro.com/pdf/InvBusDailyZFvsNSC.pdf

    From the article: "National had sales of $1.5 billion for the year ended May 27. ZF's Sales peaked at about $4 million in 2001 and have virtually ceased as a result of the dispute with National."

    Use of an embedded board based on this chip may prove to be less than prudent. Of course there are plenty of other embedded boards that will run Linux...

  55. good project, but... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It sounds like a good project if they can make a serious network with the wifi system, but to me living in the north of thailand it sounds a little bit like a technicians project to proof their skills. In Chiang Mai here you could buy a Pentium 166 mhz for about 5000 baht, that is USD 120. Is someone going to tell me that there is money for WIFI and not for pc's like this? There are a lot of NGO's operating here and the UN. I'm sure it's possible to find a little pot with money from which a network can be build of say 50 stations. Don't think btw that Laos is not connected in the cities and touristcentra there are already internetcafe's, it's just that very few people at the countryside would speak enough english or has enough knowledge to operate them besides the students in Vientenne. It's an intresting experiment but don't think to much of things like that. 95% of the people at the countryside in Thailand doesn't know how to use the internet and they advanced further. The people here need better schools and better schoolbooks. English at the countryside is being thought by people who hardly speak it themselves. You cry when you see some of the mistakes in their books.
    Best luck anyway though!

  56. Car Battery? by tRoll+with+Butter · · Score: 1

    I hope that's just a mistake made by the news reporter and not the actual team behind this project. A car battery isn't designed to survive deep discharges and will end up unable to hold a charge rather quickly. They should have checked out the car and deep cycle battery FAQ at: http://www.uuhome.de/william.darden/. A deep cycle battery is what really needs to be used.

    While it would also make this project more expensive, a solar cell would be a worthwhile investment to keep the battery fully charged during periods of non-use, and to make up for people who cheat the system by using the computer but not contributing pedal power (obviously if there is a battery, this is possible).

    The other concern I'd have is what happens to these batteries after their service life is exhausted? Hopefully the members of this project will collect and recycle them. Toxic lead and acid is the last thing we need to be making these people deal with.

    --

    ---
    Siggy, siggy, siggy, can't you see? Sometimes your puns just irritate me.
  57. Indian experiment. by sankoz · · Score: 1

    Dont know if someone had posted this before, but,India, which has a much larger rural population is also experimenting something innovative. They are trying out motorbike riders who take laptops to rural areas ! More at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/sci/tech/newsid_2 124000/2124712.stm

  58. billiant by gargle · · Score: 2

    After a long, back breaking day at work, the farmers return home to pedal up some power for a relaxing evening of web surfing.

  59. Biggest is not always best by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


    Remember when we surfed the net (well crawled actually) using 386's? heck I had a compaq desk pro 286 for pulling email at one point, using pegasus and win 3.1.

    90% of the computers in use today, are grossly overpowered for the basics actually needed. Heck, word processing can be done (and was) reasonably well, on an apple 2+ or Ibm "Personal Computer".

    The difference between "need" and "want" grows greater every day here in the west.

    Bufoed Lamonte (who forgot his login password again)

  60. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Worried they'll take your job?

  61. This is old by tmjva · · Score: 1

    Read this story months ago.

    --
    Tracy Johnson
    Old fashioned text games hosted below:
    http://empire.openmpe.com/
    BT
  62. This Would Make A Great Exercise Machine by tigris · · Score: 1

    ...seriously. Given the amount of time I spend working on my computer each day, it'd be great to combine it with some exercise as well. Burn calories and get your work done at the same time.

  63. whats next by ronaldcromwell · · Score: 0

    today: using the asian masses to pedal-power a hoard of 486's
    tomorrow: matrix style baby-farms

  64. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by buswolley · · Score: 1

    rediculous. Access to educated people in some areas of the world is difficult. But once one person knows how to use a computer in a village then they can teach each other, then learn more by the great amount of info already out there.
    this is not about a misdirected fulfillment of a resource, but the tool where such places as Africa can become aware of themselves, of their civil rights, of the ways they can fight off disease, cleanliness, heck. how to smelt steel.
    this is vital. /.

    --

    A Good Troll is better than a Bad Human.

  65. Does JonKatz have any friends in Laos? by poot_rootbeer · · Score: 2


    As soon as the computer was booted up the people started downloading movie trailers -- unfortunately they were all in Commodore 64 format!

    1. Re:Does JonKatz have any friends in Laos? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Does Jon (Pedophile) Katz have any friends in Laos? Maybe. Is NAMBLA planning a trip there this year?

  66. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Last I heard, they were kicking out/killing all the white farmers and the food supplies have vaporized. What's the ETA for when everyone is dead from murder or starvation?

  67. Take a step by lysurgon · · Score: 2

    Hey, if you're like me and you don't have the skillz to hack a laotian l10n or the time/committment to travel to Laos (though this is incredibly appealing), you can always just give some of your hrrible corpulent filty soul-polluting lucre to their cause. I spend $5 on lunch without thinking about it. This is cooler than lunch.

    Two days this week I eat home-make mac'n'cheeze and the project gets the $5 I save. It's that simple. For us consumer-americans, realizing the power of our spending choices is the first step to re-taking a position of active relavence in society.

    1. Re:Take a step by lysurgon · · Score: 2


      Man! This project just gets better and better! Soon you'll be able to support these guys with your caffeine habbit. I know I will. Check the link:

      http://www.jhai.org/jhai_coffee.htm

  68. YES by g00bd0g · · Score: 1

    I work for Easy Racers (www.easyracers.com)
    It is my job to know how much power, average and athletic, people can produce. The answer is this:
    about 100 watts average sustainable (as in more than one hour) output for an average person.
    Anyone who can put more than 200 watts for an hour can pat themselves on the back. 300 watts or more for an hour and maybe you should be looking at racing bikes for a living! So assuming you have an average generator of say 80-90% efficiency, producing 100 watts on hour is probably about the max for the "general population". Which is still plenty to run an efficient laptop.

  69. Wowwww by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Imagine a Beowolf Cluster of THESE!!!

  70. Could use these in the US by anonymous_wombat · · Score: 2

    This would be great for all of those fat, donut eating programmers in the US who sorely need some exercise while they work (I am one of them.)

  71. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by psamuels · · Score: 1
    But once one person knows how to use a computer in a village then they can teach each other, then learn more by the great amount of info already out there. this is not about a misdirected fulfillment of a resource, but the tool where such places as Africa can become aware of themselves, of their civil rights, of the ways they can fight off disease, cleanliness, heck. how to smelt steel. this is vital.

    Awww, how touching. What a nice humanist outlook you have.

    I hate to question your qualification to speak on the subject, but you sound kind of naive. It would be nice if the world worked as you say, but the parts I have seen, frankly, do not. Making a lasting impression on a culture, for which both you and I see a need [and which offends many educated minds, BTW - the classic missionary vs. anthropologist battle - but that's neither here nor there], takes a lot more than shipping in a few laptops and solar panels, and rigging up a cell tower or satellite modem or something. I get the feeling you do not quite appreciate how much more.

    First there is the matter of deciding who will be responsible for the computer equipment. Remember, nobody yet has a clue how to use it, and you as an outsider don't have any way of judging the people. So you do the only possible thing: give it to the chief. The computer becomes a tool of politics - more on that below.

    Then there is the training aspect. Have you ever tried to teach someone to operate a computer whose native language doesn't have a word for "computer" or "keyboard" or "quote" or "pointer" or "icon" or "sentence" or "space" or "disk"? I have. The only way it was possible to make any progress at all was to revert to French, which neither of us spoke fluently, so it was rough going. (They do have a word for "mouse"....) Note that a language barrier is only a thin disguise for what is actually a cultural barrier. The desktop metaphor, for example, isn't as useful as you'd think when people don't work in offices.

    Moving on. Now that some bright kid or kids have picked up the basics of how to send and receive spam, we come to maintenance, vandalism and politics. I know, I know, you probably don't believe people could possibly be so self-destructive as to steal the satellite phone, leaving the computer as basically a doorstop, if these people even had doors, which many don't. You believe that since the 486-class machines mentioned in the article (see, I'm still on topic) are designed to be robust, with no moving parts and all, that they will actually be robust and not break down when faced with the sort of humidity you find in a rain forest nine months of the year. You believe that the truck battery, which is used to power the thing, will not grow legs within two days, or that if it does stay put, that it will last longer than a year. You believe that those who have been trained to take good care of their gateway to the Internet will actually exercise proper maintenance procedures. You believe that the computer will not divide the village into haves and have-nots, and that the whole thing won't be stolen or vandalised by the have-nots - people who will have no clue how to operate any of it - out of sheer jealousy for the haves. You believe that the OS will never crash and need a reinstall (a good bet, with Linux, but still) - at which time it would most likely become a paperweight, for whoever can afford paper.

    In short, my friend, you haven't lived in central Africa. This isn't racism or cultural imperialism talking, it's experience. "Things fall apart," wrote Chinua Achebe. The great Nigerian writer knew what he was talking about.

    Finally there is the small question of money, and ROI. I guess whoever is paying for this program can do what they wish, but putting the Internet out in the middle of nowhere won't be cheap, no matter what you do. If you were to make a wish list of how these people could really benefit from Western civilisation, you might start with...

    • schools: textbooks, blackboards, chalk, pencils/pens, books - i.e. libraries, though that's getting into the "dreaming" stage. After all, in many 3rd-world cultures, the language has only recently been written down at all - so most available books will be in another language. You could start in writing and/or translating your own books and publishing them yourself, as some people I know have done. A bit tedious but you gotta start somewhere.
    • adult literacy: primers, books, teachers, child care - and see note above about books.
    • plumbing: even hand pumps would be a luxury in many places I've been. Running water would be great, if you had...
    • electricity: diesel generators are hard to operate when diesel fuel is $8/gallon and hard to get. I once thought solar panels were the answer, but they're extremely expensive and limited.
    • medicines: antibiotics, quinine, Flagyl, and aspirin would go a long way for areas that don't have them. Vaccines, too, for things like measles and polio.
    • public health: literature, public health education personnel (AIDS education is still MUCH needed out there, unlike in the West), and miscellany such as traps to eradicate tse tse fly populations (yes, such traps exist, and yes, sleeping sickness is still very much alive in this day and age). Actual doctors and nurses would be most welcome in any number of villages I could name, but those are a bit more expensive. Literacy and proper plumbing are also big parts of the public health equation - see above.
    • agriculture - introducing new crops, new methods of farming, and technology at a locally sustainable level (plows, carts, etc) - so that when the white man leaves, there is some chance of things not falling apart.
    In my book, Internet access is far down the list of things the people I've met could use from the West to improve their lives. Sure, it has a sort of Slashdot gushy excitement to it, but, like many public aid projects, it would have a lot more to do with Westerners feeling like they're making a difference than with anyone actually making a difference. Would you really rather have the 'net than the indoor john? (Don't answer that, slash-crowd! You guys are disgusting!)

    Fortunately (to get back on topic), the project the article talks about is being run partly by actual Laotians (is that the right word), so presumably they have already thought through such issues as I have presented here. As I've said before, I've never been to Asia. Maybe this project can actually be made to work.

    --
    "How can you claim that you are anti-crack, while still writing a window manager?" — Metacity README
  72. Laos by aaarrrgggh · · Score: 2

    Laos is a fantastic place, with great people. While I appreciate that it is cool to do this from a technical perspective, I would think that providing water filtration (or even running water!) to these villiages would be a more worthwhile endeavour.

    One of the most striking features of these towns (aside from the baling wire power grid) is how isolated they are. I predicted (two years ago) that I had found one spot where I could be saved from e-mail for at least another decade. Guess I was wrong.

    If anybody makes it to Xam Nua, let me know if one of my favorite places is still as beautiful with telephones and internet access! (Vang Vieng surely is not!)

  73. Re:why would anyone in a third world country need by aaarrrgggh · · Score: 2

    I would add to this that if someone is really interested in helping out, time is the most valuable donation. You don't need too many qualifications to teach (or to assist at a school), and it is rewarding.

    The costs:
    Airfare to Bangkok - $550
    Train to Vientiene - $20
    Truck to the middle of nowhere - $2
    Month's living expenses - $200

    It really isn't that hard!

  74. Agreed... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Before all of that, I'm sure Laos was a great country. Too bad we had to bomb their.... uh... I give up. Yeah, we're horrible people in America... Now I want to cry.

    Simple software for communicating with other villages and text processing for business is the order of the day in Laos.

    I can't help but wonder whether alternative energy sources wouldn't be more simple, though. I hear that Laos gets quite a bit of sun these days. Enclosed solar panels might be easier. Less peddling, at least.

  75. Thank God for Jounalized file systems! by brad3378 · · Score: 2

    Can you imagine the weight you'd lose running FSCK on a 120 gig drive?

    --

  76. You can tell the Internet heavy users from Laos by Pseudonymus+Bosch · · Score: 2

    They are the ones with enormous thighs.

    --
    __
    Men with no respect for life must never be allowed to control the ultimate instruments of death.
    GW Bu
  77. Close but not there? one block in a million by buswolley · · Score: 1

    You have many good points and I will concede that there are many difficult obstacles in Africa's future. Your point, in total, is that implementation of internet access is difficult to maintain, to use, etc., but your points do not tell us why these resources could be left out of any kind of serious plan for real progress. Notice: "part of the plan" all i pointed out is that the knowledge may be obtained through the internet that is not obtainable elswhere. One teacher may teach many. In short: Your mistake is thinking difficult=impossible=should not do. Wrong. I am truly aware of the difficulties, at least conceptually. But this little technology(topic), is just a small tool for that goal. Social divisions? sure. poverty. have/have nots. sure. truly terrible. No joke there. uess we shouldnt try anything that we can't implement all at once. wave my wand and POOF!!! everyone has a DELL! and cable access(bandwidth social classes) oh and good french. C'mon. id love to but... small implementations like public libraries, may still be benificial. at last. how can i write anything more than half intelligent so late? sorry for the ramblings. Oh. Humanist thoughts are useful. Good Will should never be looked down upon. things are often simpler than you may think, if the right solution is implemented. one key can unlock a complex crypt-lock. good evening .

    --

    A Good Troll is better than a Bad Human.