Slashdot Mirror


Cartoon Network Serves Up More Anime

E-Rock-23 writes "Anime News Network has the scoop on more Anime series Cartoon Network plans to bring to the Adult Swim block next year. Witch Hunter Robin (2) has been confirmed for a February run. On the "Probably" list are Wolf's Rain in April and Ghost in the Shell in July, though they didn't specify if it'd be the Mamoru Oshii film or the Stand Alone Complex TV series. Either way, the latter will most likely have to be rather heavily edited for TV. Looks like I have a few more reasons to stay up past my bedtime..." Or get a tivo. Witch Hunter Robin & Wolf's Rain are both really excellent shows- it's very cool to see them hit mainstream TV.

331 comments

  1. I just want to know... by halivar · · Score: 4, Insightful

    ...when we're going to get past this dubbing thing and see some subs.

    1. Re:I just want to know... by gabec · · Score: 2, Interesting
      erm.... never? when was the last time you saw anything on mainstream media subtitled? Sure, I've seen a few foreign films (e.g. those up for oscars for best foreign film or something) but they have been at "that" theatre that is specifically known for showing oddities. ;) and on TV? on cartoon network??

      Dunno, Maybe on the Anime Network late at night. who knows. ;)

    2. Re:I just want to know... by Beardydog · · Score: 0

      is when my cable company will bother picking up the anime network. I love Cartoon Network in general, and Adult Swim in specific is my TV God, I think there's a large void to be filled where I live.

    3. Re:I just want to know... by Handpaper · · Score: 1

      When the average Cartoon Network viewer learns to read.

      Yes, I have been known to watch Cartoon Network (Chuck Jones, we miss you), but I'm not the target audience.

    4. Re:I just want to know... by minasoko · · Score: 2, Funny
      ...when we're going to get past this dubbing thing and see some subs.

      When the ambient temperature in Hades drops below zero degrees Centigrade.

    5. Re:I just want to know... by p4ul13 · · Score: 5, Interesting

      God I really freakin' can't stand this old complaint. The subtitled text is interpreted into our language just as the dubbed dialog would be, so no matter what, unless you speak the native language of the show, you're getting an interpretation of it in english.

      If your complaint instead has to do with the quality of the voice acting, well I still think it's lame in that you won't fully get to know how good the original voice acting was if you can't understand what words they're actually emphasizing.

      Sit back and enjoy the show. If you're that much of a purist, rent the DvDs when they come and they'll probably have an original language track with subtitles.

      --
      Paul Lenhart writes words!
    6. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Flamebait
      What's so great about subtitles? You spend half your time reading them and not watching what is going on. If you don't like the interpretation of the voices they selected, you're still at the mercy of the interpretation of the interpreter who did the subtitle.

      The request smacks of snobbery and sounds like an attempt to appear sophisticated when it isn't warranted.

    7. Re:I just want to know... by pinkboi · · Score: 1

      First of all, imagine how much of an atrocity seeing Amelie dubbed would be!

      Actually, the translations tend to differ, with the translation for the dub making less sense.

      --
      "The absurd is clear reasoning recognizing its limits"
      -Albert Camus
    8. Re:I just want to know... by Jorrit · · Score: 1

      In Belgium where I live we speak Dutch. Dubbing is NEVER ever done and I'm very glad it isn't. We always have subtitling for all foreign movies. The *only* exception is for movies that are specifically for kids who cannot read fast enough to see the subtitles.

      Greetings,

      --
      Project Manager of Crystal Space (http://www.crystalspace3d.org). Support CS at http://tinyurl.com/cb3x4
    9. Re:I just want to know... by AnswerIs42 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I would just be happy if they actually FINISH some of the series... I am STILL waiting for the final episode of "Big O" ..they did a repeat when it should have shown, then nothing for 2 weeks.. now they are playing all the episodes again. Yu Yu has been pulled, moved, restarted so many times I have no idea when or where it's on (I think it's of now). Same with several other shows they have on there. CN does a REALLY good job of irking me when it comes to the anime they show... at least I still have TechTV's Anime Unleashed. Now, to just get Directv to carry the Anime Network..

    10. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It might never be done in Belgium, but I still don't understand why it is supposedly superior.

    11. Re:I just want to know... by tuffy · · Score: 2, Interesting
      I would just be happy if they actually FINISH some of the series... I am STILL waiting for the final episode of "Big O" ..they did a repeat when it should have shown, then nothing for 2 weeks..

      The Cartoon Network played the final episode the week after they mixed up and played a repeat. They pushed their special "Family Guy" episode back just so they could fix their mistake and so fans only had to wait two weeks to see the final Big O episode. Sorry you missed it - it was very trippy.

      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

    12. Re:I just want to know... by sklib · · Score: 0, Troll

      Joe Millionaire 2 is about as mainstream as you can get, and since the none of the girls speak english very well, all of their speech was subtitled.

      The problem with the cartoon network is that a major part of its target market segment is children who can't read, so you're right, that will probably never be subtitled.

      --
      -S
    13. Re:I just want to know... by Beardydog · · Score: 1, Informative

      Dup translations have to worry about mouth movements. Even the best will have to be selective at some point jsut to prevent overlap of lines. Subs can translate directly if they want to, no worries.

    14. Re:I just want to know... by gabec · · Score: 5, Insightful
      It's not really the quality of the english voice acting, it's the casting and direction of european voice actors that often doesn't fit. For example, in the series Rurouni Kenshin (Samurai X), the Japanese version had a woman doing the voice of Kenshin and it was convincing. In the english version they had a guy sounding like he'd been kicked in the balls and perpetually on happy pills do the voice acting.

      If you're six years old then the latter is probably more interesting (for example who can stand the sound of Barney's voice for more than a minute except a six year old?), but to me I prefer the more natural voice (even though it was from a woman, her voice was rather ambiguous in that way and it did seem to fit Kenshin).

    15. Re:I just want to know... by Beardydog · · Score: 0

      I wanted to see more Yu Yu Hakusho. It was a silly show, and there's no good reason I should have liked it, but I did... Me and my crew did some searching for more episodes online, and there seemed to be a lot more, but oddly enough they were all in French.

    16. Re:I just want to know... by Fancia · · Score: 1, Offtopic
      when was the last time you saw anything on mainstream media subtitled?
      A bit obscure, to be sure, but a PBS station in California apparently ran for quite awhile the anime Urusei Yatsura, uncensored and subtitled.
      --

      Bít, zabít, jen proto, ze su liska!
    17. Re:I just want to know... by Jorrit · · Score: 1

      Well in my case my native language (and the language of my country) is Dutch. But I do understand English and I prefer to have the movie in the original language instead of dubbed in Dutch.

      Greetings,

      --
      Project Manager of Crystal Space (http://www.crystalspace3d.org). Support CS at http://tinyurl.com/cb3x4
    18. Re:I just want to know... by tuffy · · Score: 1
      I wanted to see more Yu Yu Hakusho.

      More is coming. Funimation is bringing it out as fast as they can. Expect all of it to air on the Cartoon Network eventually.

      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

    19. Re:I just want to know... by The+Almighty+Dave · · Score: 1, Redundant

      The Adult Swim start around midnight. The target audience are adults, as implied by the name.

    20. Re:I just want to know... by NiteHaqr · · Score: 1

      Solution in 2 words

      Bittorrented Fan-subs.

    21. Re:I just want to know... by gl4ss · · Score: 1

      you get the quality of the original voices.the actors you see in movies are afterall real actors(like, come oon, what if you didn't know how arnold speaks? you'd lose all the jokes!).

      it's much cheaper too, so you can do it with low budget. have you seen really sucky subs? and anything that isn't the box office hitter thing is going to get sucky dubs. doing high quality dubs can be fucking expensive so you don't often see them done around here(except for high class childrens movies, usually disneys, which usually have high grade actors doing the speeches but it is expensive of course.). however, tolerable subs can be done by almost anybody who somewhat knows the both languages.

      you learn to read.
      you learn foreign languages.
      if you know the language then you can watch it without reading and suffering from sucky translator. after seeing them for a while you just read them without thinking anyways..
      and you can watch them in total quietness at home(many people do this for late night tv.. no need for headphones).

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    22. Re:I just want to know... by Chibi · · Score: 4, Interesting
      ...when we're going to get past this dubbing thing and see some subs.


      I'm not sure if they'd made any progress on this, but I believe ADV has at least tossed the idea around a bit for their Anime Channel. It'd have to use a combination of closed captioning and SAP, but it's not impossible. Just have to figure out if the demand is high enough and what the related costs are. I feel that, for the most part, the US anime industry has a much better connection with their fans than a lot of more mainstream entertainment entities (RIAA, MPAA, etc).

      --
      If all you have are silver bullets, everything looks like a werewolf.
    23. Re:I just want to know... by zeroclip · · Score: 1

      aff.. tell me about it I'm still trying to get over that HORRIBLE Noir dub. Anyway dubbing is alright aslong as it's done RIGHT like in the orginal Ghost In the Shell.

    24. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In Belgium where I live we speak Dutch. Dubbing is NEVER ever done and I'm very glad it isn't. We always have subtitling for all foreign movies. The *only* exception is for movies that are specifically for kids who cannot read fast enough to see the subtitles.

      Keep in mind that a) this is the US we're talking about, most people there don't speak other languages than English and b) surprising amount of people in the US are illiterate or just barely literate.

    25. Re:I just want to know... by Mononoke · · Score: 2, Informative
      God I really freakin' can't stand this old complaint. The subtitled text is interpreted into our language just as the dubbed dialog would be, so no matter what, unless you speak the native language of the show, you're getting an interpretation of it in english.
      God I really freakin' can't stand this old excuse.

      Dub scripts are always edited to match the mouth movements of the animation. Dubbed vocal inflection is always ruined by attempts to make the words fit the mouth movements. Subtitles are not subject to these limitations.

      Subtitle scripts are limited only by the talent of the translators. Dubs are limited by the casting directors, voice directors, and actors.

      Another essential difference in the voice acting quality: Japanese voice acting is an honored craft. Those that get hired do so because they are the best among many. In America voice acting is what you do when you can't get hired as a real actor, in most cases.

      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
    26. Re:I just want to know... by Kassiopeia · · Score: 2, Informative

      Dubbing does have its sides, if it's done right. If you're from a culture where dubbing is the standard (say, Germany), subtitles would be horrible. Sometimes the dub even gets better than the original Japanese audio, but that's usually if the series doesn't take place in Japan per se (example: Cowboy Bebop).

      If you're from a smaller lingual area of influence, say, Finland, it's far more likely that you've grown up watching foreign TV series subtitled. Therefore it feels much more jarring to see people who are supposed to be Japanese speaking any other language than Japanese. Of course, Finland is still in the stage where animation is considered a medium for pre-teens only, and children films are often dubbed here, so things can get complicated. The local DVD release of Spirited Away has Japanese sound and Finnish subtitles, fortunately.

      As far as I know dubbing outside animation is somewhat popular in the US, plus people's literacy can be weaker, which is completely understandable as English for English-speaking people is more difficult to grok than Finnish for Finnish-speaking people. Then again, it might be because Finns grow up reading a lot even when just watching the telly...

      Anyway, dubbing shouldn't be dismissed off-hand. Anime has been a niche market, so dubbing work has been quite poor, resulting in some prejudice. I'd never watch dubbed anime if I'd a choice though.

    27. Re:I just want to know... by rembem · · Score: 1
      surprising amount of people in the US are illiterate or just barely literate.

      Makes you wonder ... Would that be because US people hardly ever have to read subtitles?

    28. Re:I just want to know... by vidnet · · Score: 1
      when was the last time you saw anything on mainstream media subtitled?

      Yesterday, the day before that, and the one before that, etc. Here in Norway, the only things that are dubbed are programs and movies for children under 11-12 and often the narration on documentaries. Other than that, every foreign piece of video is subtitled.

      It's quite amusing, since so very few shows are dubbed, the same people are recurring. You can hear Papa Smurf (played by Harald Maele) in most of them :)

    29. Re:I just want to know... by |_uke · · Score: 1

      I have two real complains with dubs personally.

      The largest is probably the... horible casting. It just feels... wrong... to watch some japanese woman with a US southern accent. Mind you, if she was a japanese woman who LIVED in the southern US states it would be different... (Ive heard some hard core North American accents from some very asian faces before.)

      The other issue I have,... and mind you this is not always an issue... But the subs tend to take a lot of liberties. Generally in the form of quips or cuss words. Some times its bad enough that the entire scene has a different feel to it.

      I dont know if its the best example... but look at Demon City Shinjuku... If I remember right, (I could be wrong, its been a while since I watched it)... the dubs end up being different than the subs in many places... (A lot of times with just... a retarted amount of liberty taken with the voice acting) On top of that, they just picked some really really horible choices for voice actors (IMHO).

      Of course, the quality of more recent dubs have improved quite a bit. But you get the idea =)

      Oh... then again... subs some times are not all that great either. The problem I noticed is that some of the translations end up not makeing a huge amount of since in some parts. (Some times the translations DO require a little liberty to make the translation make since to english speaking minds)

      So I guess the only way to truly be happy is to learn japanese =) LOL

      One thing I noticed that kindof happens to me when I watch a subed movie... is that the subs become somewhat transparent. By the end of the movie, I almost forget that I have been reading sub titles... and it almost feels like Im actually 'understanding' the voices.

      --
      Luke
    30. Re:I just want to know... by illuminatedwax · · Score: 1

      In addition to the sister post, things are also usually made a lot clearer when the actual dialogue talks about/plays with the Japanese language. For example, often times there's a lot of wordplay or dialectical issues that are difficult/impossible to translate correctly (ie a Kansai accent being translated as a Southern drawl...wtf is that?). e.g. FLCL is a show that doesn't dub into English very well.
      Back to the point about voice actors sounding different - most American movies that are exported have subtitles. The ones that don't are usually cheesy action movies. I remember seeing "Face/Off" where the voice actor for John Travolta was played by a Japanese man with a voice deeper than Barry White's. That's just wrong, folks.

      Regardless, Witch Hunter Robin won't sound too bad dubbed if they get good actors, because it's a very dramatic show.

      --Stephen
      Make sure you watch past episode 12!

      --
      Did you ever notice that *nix doesn't even cover Linux?
    31. Re:I just want to know... by Fishstick · · Score: 1

      >I have two real complains with dubs personally.

      Really? I have three:


      Billy

      Bob

      Thornton

      (mind, minnie driver was pretty distracting as well. I finally bought the DVD with Japanese soundtrack and literal english subtitles and I'm fine. In fact, now that I've watched it a couple more times, it's very enjoyable with no subtitles at all)

      --

      There is much cruelty in the universe, John.
      Yeah, we seem to have the tour map.

    32. Re:I just want to know... by CaptRespect · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      Just turn off the sound and turn on the Closed Captions and stop your whining.

    33. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "this tastes like super-donkey piss!"

      What a classic!

    34. Re:I just want to know... by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      In America voice acting is what you do when you can't get hired as a real actor, in most cases.

      There's a few exceptions of course. Primarily the big-name stars Disney brings into their Ghilbi translations.

      Your namesake, for example, was entirely decent until electro-reverb Gillian Anderson showed up. "Kikki's Delivery Service" was also quite tolerable, even though they inserted a stream of new sidekick chatter everytime the characters were offscreen.

    35. Re:I just want to know... by afedaken · · Score: 1

      So all of a sudden, voice acting isn't "Acting"?

      I'm pretty sure the SAG would argue with you on that point.

      Granted, you don't have to been seen when you're doing voice work, but (ESPECIALLY FOR ANIME) the types of roles you end up playing and the action so f the characters vary wildly when compared to "traditonal" acting. IMHO, you do a disservice to Dub voice actors by insinuating that they all do a lesser job than thier japanese counterparts.

      --
      If there's a castle floating upside down in the sky, then there's a castle floating upside down in the sky.
    36. Re:I just want to know... by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      I've seen worse, but the GITS movie included some seriously wrong dubbing. Whenever a character goes of on a quasi-mystical subconcious monologue, the English actors just couldn't keep up.

    37. Re:I just want to know... by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      I just accidentally rented a new dubbed translation of fist of legend on DVD - not anime, not even Japanese I know, but bear with me. In the original the Judge spoke English and he said something to the effect of "These proceedings are ridiculous. And anyway, I have a cricket game to go to. Case dismissed." And I guess they felt that even "reverse" racism isn't ok because they changed even that, took out the cricket game... They still overdubbed him! I was pissed. I'm still pissed, actually. And I get just as pissed off when I am forced to sit through a badly translated dubbing, and even more annoyed when it ends up being a craptacular job. Like, for example, Elizabeth Berkeley. She can't even fake an orgasm, who decided she could be a voice actor?

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    38. Re:I just want to know... by gpinzone · · Score: 1

      Considering that this is animation...animation where they don't take a lot of care to animate the mouth movements to the sounds the characters are making...is it that big of a deal as long as the dub is well done? Most problems with dubs I've seen is the poor quality and casting of voice actors.

    39. Re:I just want to know... by sangfroid · · Score: 2, Insightful

      There actually is a big difference and it's all about timing .

      See, different languages have different words and syntax and thus it can take varying amounts of time to say the same thing in Japanese and in English.

      So, a dubbed film must fit all the voice acting into the same amount of time as the original meaning that you not only have to translate the text but you have to make it fit. So, if it takes 130 seconds to say the equivelant of "I love you" in Japanese, an English Dub will have to fill that space with something really horrible like "My heart is filled with the most [cheesy emotion] a man could feel."

      However, a subtitled version can put the best, most meaningful translation on screen instead and keep it there long enough for you to read and understand. With all the differences in culture, idioms, etc a good dub is a lot harder than a good sub. A perfect dub is nigh impossible.

      So yes, you're getting "an" interpretation of it in english... but it's really hard to fit the timing and stay true to the original meaning. Think back to the old school badly dubbed samurai flicks.

    40. Re:I just want to know... by Ondo · · Score: 1

      Dub scripts are always edited to match the mouth movements of the animation. Dubbed vocal inflection is always ruined by attempts to make the words fit the mouth movements. Subtitles are not subject to these limitations.

      Subtitle scripts are limited only by the talent of the translators. Dubs are limited by the casting directors, voice directors, and actors.


      Subtitles have to be readable in the time alloted, and they do make them more concise to achieve that. Dubs are not subject to that limitation.

    41. Re:I just want to know... by Jeff+DeMaagd · · Score: 1

      Dubs and subs are interpretations, but with dubs they have to fiddle with it so it fits the mouth flap timing.

      Some dub writers even change parts of the story to suit their whims or to regear it to a different (usu. younger) audience. By many accounts that seem to have a decent understanding of Japanese, this happens to the subtitles far less often.

    42. Re:I just want to know... by Mononoke · · Score: 1
      There's a few exceptions of course. Primarily the big-name stars Disney brings into their Ghilbi translations.
      Yes, but that illustrates a large part of the problem: Rather than bringing in capable voice actors for the dubs, they bring in names that look good on the posters.

      Voice acting is a subset of acting that requires specialized talents. Some can do it (Mike Meyers, etc.) and some can't (Billy Bob, etc.)

      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
    43. Re:I just want to know... by MoneyT · · Score: 1

      One would think the target audience of *Adult* Swim would know how to read.

      --
      T Money
      World Domination with a plastic spoon since 1984
    44. Re:I just want to know... by MoFoQ · · Score: 1

      interpreted?! more like butchered like hell....I'd rather get info from the Iraqi Information Minister (whatever happened to that bastard anyways?) than get anime from CN. Hell...you can't even call it anime, 'cuz CN does the chopping and the re-wording, thus changing the entire story. One guy said it best on some late nite show (I think it was on Jay Leno), the made for TV version of ScarFace just isn't right (paraphrased).

      Anyways...if u'r a purist...get the original Japanese DVDs, especially since when they release US DVDs of anime, they for some unknown reason (just like how the Iraqi info Minister would give weird info) process the video feed for the worse. In most cases, they screw up the color and the contrast. Hence I go for the non-US DVDs. If u need help understanding, ask me politely and I might translate it for you.

      Besides....CN can actually air most of it (the subbed version) without too much editing, especially since it's not aired during the day. If PBS can do it, so can they. (The local PBS [KTEH] shows anime subbed for the most part...and they don't go choptastic with it....in fact, I don't think they even touched it nudity and all....gotta love PBS...if I wasn't a broke college student, I would donate something).
      And I've been suggesting that they make it so they air both the original language and the dub and the subs using the SAP (second audio program) and closed-captioning. Then it becomes more educational. O well....like I always say bureaucracy; if it makes sense, it ain't gonna happen.

      (note: don't worry....my pitchfork and flaming torch is reserved for sco and "associates")

    45. Re:I just want to know... by RTCW_Monkey · · Score: 1

      Um, have you guys ever seen Most Extreme Elimination Challenge on Spike TV? Best dubbing ever! If anime were dubbed like MXC I would watch it more.

    46. Re:I just want to know... by dr00g911 · · Score: 3, Informative
      Dub scripts are always edited to match the mouth movements of the animation. Dubbed vocal inflection isalways ruined by attempts to make the words fit the mouth movements. Subtitles are not subject to these limitations.


      Always is a pretty harsh term. Sometimes the dubbing house gets stuff right. Like, say, Cowboy Bebop? Big O? (pretty much the same US voice cast).

      I'll have to agree that for the vast majority of anime, I've always preferred subbed vs. dubbed versions. Something about Bebop... I actually preferred the dubbed version over subtitles. The characters' voices seemed better matched to me -- and the acting was good enough to make me cry like a baby during the final episode.

      I have a theory: the more anime becomes mainstream in the US (ever look at the anime aisle in Best Buy?), the more likely we are to have good dubs vs. the Speed Racer / Pokemon dreck. Meaning that the dub houses are going to spend time and energy getting them right.

      But, you have to admit, if it's going to be shown on a network -- you've got your 99% chance of it *needing* to be dubbed. Cartoon Network, especially. You're dealing with a) kids and b) people who rent Crouching Tiger and take it back because they've gotta read and c) people who treat the material a little more seriously.

      We're part of group C, but the minority.

      It is changing, though. Slowly.
    47. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Subtitled anime isn't really worthwhile unless one understand Japanese to begin with. A good example is "Ranma 1/2", there's an episode in which Ryoga (one of Ranma's many foes) is introduced. Ryoga is wandering around rural Japan looking for Ranma. In the dubbed version, the farmers Ryoga meets speak in a "hick" accent, a slurred southern accent. That's in contrast to Ryoga's city Japanese, which in the dub is the standard Canadian/US Midwest tv English. In the subtitled version, there's no way for me to pick up on that unless I'm familiar with regional Japanese accents and idiom. Also, the English talent is (to my ears) a lot more interesting than the Japanese talent in the Ranma 1/2 series (especially the screeching Japanese girl-type Ranma).
      Call me a heritic if you like, but I would much rather anime be dubbed so I can watch what's going on, rather than have to parse both the subtitles and the visuals at the same time. Then I can use two different parts of my brain.

    48. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Now if only I could spell "heretic". :)

    49. Re:I just want to know... by antiMStroll · · Score: 1

      " If your complaint instead has to do with the quality of the voice acting, well I still think it's lame in that you won't fully get to know how good the original voice acting was if you can't understand what words they're actually emphasizing."

      The first part is exactly the problem, voice actors are usually horrible and cast by people who 'market the product for American audiences.' Rent the Cowboy Bebop movie and watch the interview extras at the end. Pay close attention to the two women who voiced Fae's character. They came to it from completely different perspectives and the results aren't subtle. To my ear the subbed version turns Fae into a gum-cracking grocery store clerk on the loose, cheapening and flattening the character into another Hollywood cliche. The last half of your objection is just strange. True the language difference means subtuitles don't convey 100% of the intent, but the emotional payload of the original voice comes through loud and clear. Even that is lost with an overdub.

    50. Re:I just want to know... by Mr.Zong · · Score: 1

      Not any thing time soon. Do you realize how hard it is for me to read the tv when im baked out of my gord? I want mindless entertainment, damnit.

    51. Re:I just want to know... by qeveren · · Score: 1

      It always seemed to me that English-speaking voice 'actors', can't. At least those they dig up to dub anime, anyway. With perhaps the sole exception of Disney and their deal with Ghibli...

      Gaw, did I just say something nice about Disney? I have to go shower now.

      And of course they'd have to edit the hell out of Stand Alone Complex; God forbid the American audience sees something mature and intelligent in animation...

      --
      Don't just stand there, get that other dog!
    52. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That makes no sense. It takes longer to speak/hear than to read and subtitles can last the whole movie, if they need to. Subs never need to be longer.

    53. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ...when are we going to get past these stuped "adults" watching cartoons?

    54. Re:I just want to know... by protogoogoo69 · · Score: 1

      Consider the discrepancies between the dubbing and subtitles in cowboy bebop, for example. Since the correctness of translating one language to another is dependant on dictionary compatibility, and the integrity of dictionaries are relative to the year, locale, and publisher, it is no wonder there are so many versions of the the Old Testament and the Bible. Now back to dubbed vs. subbed anime: after a japanese translator writes the subtitles in english, its not unusual for him/her to fix mistakes because of differences in japanese and english interpretations of english sentences. Take, for example, the sentences: "You look like a good man" and "You are a good-looking man", which may in fact look the same to your average japanese student trying to learn english. Now, the question is whether or not these changes, when converting the subtitles to a dubbed script, are changed because the english subtitles infer some bad english/american connotations or if there were "better" english words to convey the meanings of the original japanese script. These may sound like they are the same thing, but what if an american word has a bad slang or cursing connotation as one of its meanings and simultaneously providing the single best meaning to convey the point of the japanese script? Then chances are, you won't find a better word in english. Now if the distributors of the dub-version choose to replace the word because of its slang connotation, then this represents a situation in which a sub->dub conversion can be corrupted. Hence, the subtitles will provide the non-native speaker with a better meaning.

      But you probably already knew that. The real question the parent (i think / i hope) intended was whether or not providing a dubbed version is a good comprimise between preserving japanese culture and getting more sales. I mean, its all good to live, speak, and drink "american", but it seems to me that "americans" are starting to expect everything handed to them in english. Not that that is a bad thing, but the animation was not created in the U.S., which, I might add, does NOT have a national language. (Here is an interesting ACLU paper with more discussion on this.) Now as more and more international corporations start to embrace this standard and treat english as the "language of commerce", we will probably start to see this trait get passed down to local, private businesses in the vicinity of those same corporations. Which means that eventually, the city (or even the country) will start to embrace it because they must deal with or work for these same private businesses, which means more awareness of the "language of commerce".

      Since humans are more prone to finding an easier way to live, then we may not be far from the point when people are going to start speaking only ONE language. Which language? Probably english. While japanese will bite the dust because it didnt catch on in the stock market as the "language of champions". I'm sure there will be (bi-/tri-/n-)linguals, but only so long as the other language(s) serve a purpose. The only purpose I can think of is culture, unless someone finds a way of quantifying the efficiency of language, which would then provide an actual value to languages. But if, for some reason, japanese cultural awareness starts to decline, then the japanese language will end up like cobol. Not that cobol is dead...yet.

      Anyway, IANAL (I Am Not a Linguist), but I'd hope this is why there are purists you speak of, because they are embracing the culture from which sprang forth the anime. But I'm sure there also exist anal retentives who just like purity for pureness-sake, in which case you're right, they should probably have a few drinks, sit back, and enjoy the show.

      --
      ...small furry creatures from Alpha Centauri...
    55. Re:I just want to know... by cryptochrome · · Score: 1

      If they were to do such a thing, it would make more sense to show the same show twice, once english dubbed in one set of timeblocks, and once hard subbed with japanese. SAP and close-captioning support (or rather, the ease of using such features) is too sketchy to make that an integral part of the scheme. They'd be showing the same show multiple times a week anyway, why not mix it up a bit. I'd say show subbed first in a late night time slot and then the next day dubbed in a prime-time slot. If you really wanted to, you could put Japanese SAP on the dubbed so people could do "raw" if they wanted.

      --

      ---If you can't trust a nerd, who can you trust?

    56. Re:I just want to know... by aardvarkjoe · · Score: 1

      It is if you're an elitist snob who wants to follow the crowd of rebels who make fun of "society." If subtitled anime was the norm, and dubbed anime wasn't mainstream, these same people would be coming up with nonsense reasons why dubbing is better than subtitling.

      --

      How can we continue to believe in a just universe and freedom to eat crackers if we have no ale?
    57. Re:I just want to know... by rembem · · Score: 1

      I've seen cowboys speak german, nazis speak enlish, klingons speak french. Something just isn't right about that.

    58. Re:I just want to know... by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      " ...when we're going to get past this dubbing thing and see some subs."

      Never. The mainstream audience wants and always will want dubbed products. Reading is just too much work for both.

      Now with the case of Witch Hunter Robin, I can assure you that the dub is quite good. I've seen the series in its entirety in Japanese and the first five episodes on the official DVD and the dub is pretty impressive compared to what you typically get with north american released anime. The second official DVD is slated for a Dec 02 release. My pre-order is already in!

    59. Re:I just want to know... by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      "Regardless, Witch Hunter Robin won't sound too bad dubbed if they get good actors, because it's a very dramatic show."

      I already have the first Official DVD and the English dub is actually much better than the average fare for anime. (I've already seen the entire series in Japanese with subtitles.) I am now collecting the official DVDs as they come out.

      I have to agree that it's a very dramatic show. My only worry is that people will start to lose interest before episode 11. For those who don't know, the first 10 episodes are quite episodic. It's a monster of the week type affair whose main purpose is to introduce you to the world and the characters. And then in episodes 11-12 the real plot kicks in and then there is no turning back.

    60. Re:I just want to know... by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      " What's so great about subtitles? You spend half your time reading them and not watching what is going on. If you don't like the interpretation of the voices they selected, you're still at the mercy of the interpretation of the interpreter who did the subtitle."

      Watching subtitles is a skill. When you start out, you do spend half the time watching the subtitle and not the show. When I first started watching anime I was pausing the show every 10 seconds but I stuck with it. But now I can watch the subtitle and the show because I am good at it.

      As to "still at the mercy of the interpretation of the interpreter who did the subtitle," how is that any different than the dub? You're still at the mercy of the translator who wrote the script in your native language. When it comes to anime, I always listen to the Japanese dialogue as well as reading the dub. I am by no means fluent in the language but I can often catch the real vs. the translated meanings and those little jokes that you simply can't translate into english.

      So when it comes to being at the mercy if the translator, I don't think you have a case. It's the same with the dub. When it comes to not watching the screen, it means that you're not skilled at watching subtitles. If you don't want to watch develop that skill then it's your choice. In that case the dub is for you.

    61. Re:I just want to know... by Kaenneth · · Score: 1

      Scoop?

      ummm...

      they advertized it this weekend...

    62. Re:I just want to know... by More+Karma+Than+God · · Score: 1

      Solution in one word:

      Bittorrented-fan-subs

      --
      Go here to create your own Slashdot dis
    63. Re:I just want to know... by qeveren · · Score: 1

      That, and for the most part the English voice actors just came across sounding wooden, at least to me. No real... feeling in anything they said.

      That and the stupid little script changes in the dub. How exactly does the Japanese version 'It must be that time of the month' translate to the English 'It must be a loose wire'?

      --
      Don't just stand there, get that other dog!
    64. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      0, Offtopic? LOL, fucking idiot mods.

    65. Re:I just want to know... by p4ul13 · · Score: 1

      Just try to read All the dialog in a show such as "Fooly Cooly". It simply can't be done and see any of the actual animation as well. For myself, I'll watch the animation and listen to the dubbed dialog. The animation and story itself is what I'm watching for, so the dub will do the trick nicely enough.

      --
      Paul Lenhart writes words!
    66. Re:I just want to know... by Nadesico_God · · Score: 0

      When i first started watching anime it was back in the day of vivo fansubs, and I have to say I would much rather have a sub then a dub. I don't speak japanese, but i can understand it, you listen to the tones of the voice and pick out the words you do know, i still read the subs (kind of, it wierd how i do it now, i don't look directly at them, but still kind of read them...). The quality of most dubbed anime in the US is at best good. Not all anime has good original voice acting either, and i do notice, but there are allot of series that they can't recreate. Someone mentioned Kenshin, thats a good example of a poor job, a good one that for some reason i liked was Ranma 1/2, it was a good job. Subs are also good for another thing, you learn to read fast. I had a friend that struggled with reading, when he got hooked on some series on Cartoon Network I moved him to fansubs I had, he does fine now. So, its educational, conveys the emotions of the charector better, and we like it. I don't force subs on other people, and normally i don't bitch about anti-anti-subs arguements.

    67. Re:I just want to know... by Ondo · · Score: 1

      That makes no sense.

      Maybe not to you. Regardless, it's true. Watch something with subtitles and dub both turned on and you'll see the subtitles are more concise.

      It takes longer to speak/hear than to read

      For you and me, maybe. Not for everyone, and they want to leave time for you to look at what's happening as well.

      and subtitles can last the whole movie, if they need to.

      They pretty much have to match when the person is speaking, so you know what the subtitles are for.

    68. Re:I just want to know... by Suiren · · Score: 1

      Yeah, as long as it's on Cartoon Network, everything is probably going to be dubbed. It sucks but that's probably how it's always going to be. Unless enough people complain or ask about it. But then again maybe that might not even work. I guess dubbed isn't too bad, right?

    69. Re:I just want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just because someone can read proficiently, does not mean they want to get their reading glasses out everytime their shows come on.

  2. Hands across the Tivo by bluethundr · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Looks like I have a few more reasons to stay up past my bedtime..." Or get a tivo.

    *upper lip trembling* you mean there are poor souls out there that actually lack this essential technology? ;P

    Seriously, if it weren't for Tivo I'd never catch my fix of Twilight Zone reruns and Enterprise. I do Tivo Anime Crash on TechTV, but some of the Anime they show is a little esoteric for my tastes. So, a lot of that gets deleted before I have a chance to watch it.

    My friend Mike got slashdotted recently pointing out that Time Warner cable is rolling out Tivo to their users for something on the order of less than $10 a month...and at no cost to the subscriber for the box!Pretty sweet deal considering that I paid slightly over $400 for the Sony DirctTV/Tivo combo box. That particular combination is a pretty sweet deal. I guess I could regret having shelled out that much money in light of Mike's cable deal. But...naaahhh. How can you regret shelling out for such a life-affirming technology?

    I just checked with my registrar and it looks like tivoaid.com is still open. I think I may buy that domain to start a worthy cause....

    --
    Quod scripsi, scripsi.
    1. Re:Hands across the Tivo by Trolling4Columbine · · Score: 0, Insightful

      It's pathetic posts like the parent that really exemplifies the term "electronic teat".

      While normal people are out with friends being social or (heaven forbid) spending time in the great outdoors, people like you are constantly searching ways to get more of that addictive mother's milk, that sweet nectar you call television (the idiot box).

      "Life-affirming technology"? That doesn't say much about your life, my friend.

      --
      Socialism: A feeling of discontent and resentment caused by a desire for the possessions or qualities of another.
    2. Re:Hands across the Tivo by JoeD · · Score: 0

      No, he's just trolling. Or he just doesn't get it. Or both.

      Tivo breaks you free from the TV. You no longer have to be there when the show is on, or do the constant shuffling of tapes and schedules on a VCR.

      It gives your time back to you and allows you to watch what you want when you feel like watching rather than when someone at the network decides you should be. You are free to get out of the house and do what you want at any time. And when you don't have anything else going on, or just feel like relaxing for a bit, your shows are there waiting for you.

    3. Re:Hands across the Tivo by TrollBridge · · Score: 1, Insightful
      "It gives your time back to you"

      Tivo doesn't give you a second of your life "back"; all it does is allow you to shuffle television around your life, instead of your life around television. Who is in control of when you watch television doesn't change the fact that the television is still the one in control.

      "You no longer have to be there when the show is on, or do the constant shuffling of tapes and schedules on a VCR."

      You don't need a Tivo for that; try turning the fucking thing off. It's cheaper than Tivo too!

      --
      There's a Mercedes gap too. I want one and can't afford one, but it's not government's job to do anything about it.
    4. Re:Hands across the Tivo by /dev/trash · · Score: 1

      It would take a lot more than a Tivo at 10 bucks to get me to switch from DISH to cable.

    5. Re:Hands across the Tivo by StormCrow · · Score: 1

      The Time Warner box isn't a Tivo, just a DVR. By all accounts, the Tivo has a much better interface to control what you record, especially if you watch shows that are repeated multiple times per day/week. I'm more likely to buy a second Tivo than to order the TW DVR.

    6. Re:Hands across the Tivo by eean · · Score: 1

      Or you can just get a computer, mplayer and a BitTorrent and watch anime fansubs only days after released in Japan. Granted, I don't own a TV, so its not like I have much choice, though I can't imagine every waiting for Anime to be released by Cartoon Network.

    7. Re:Hands across the Tivo by Issue9mm · · Score: 3, Informative

      I'm blowing my mod points by replying to this, but I just wanted to point out that Time Warner is not rolling out Tivo to their subscribers, but a DVR solution crafted by Scientific Atlanta. I sold my Tivo and switched, and it was the worst mistake of my life (only slight exaggeration).

      The Tivo is nice, solid, and bug-free, whereas the TW DVR crashes frequently, forgets recordings, and has a host of bugs that nobody at TW seems to care to correct.

      -9mm-

    8. Re:Hands across the Tivo by Stiletto · · Score: 1


      Why is this a troll? Is it the poster's name that gave him away?

    9. Re:Hands across the Tivo by mbourgon · · Score: 1

      It's worse than that - read the Usenet postings about it - apparently it's a piece of crap, alpha-grade software, and basically unsupported. Maybe they've fixed it in the past 6 months. Maybe not.

      --
      "Sometimes a woman is a kind of religion, she can save your soul & set you free from all your sins" - Bad Examples
    10. Re:Hands across the Tivo by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Adelphia just announced plans to roll out a similar service. Since I work for them, I'll be the first to sign up and let you all know how it goes. (The memo was internal and I didn't really write this.)

    11. Re:Hands across the Tivo by More+Karma+Than+God · · Score: 1

      It's a troll because he's not a raging anime fanatic. This is Slashdot, it's legal to randomly mod folks down if you disagree with them.

      --
      Go here to create your own Slashdot dis
  3. not for awhile by tuffy · · Score: 5, Insightful
    ...when we're going to get past this dubbing thing and see some subs.

    The market for subbed-only anime is still very small, that's why studios work hard to ensure all the DVD releases have a dub track (preferably a good one). Trying to put subbed-only anime, even on late night, isn't going to keep enough people watching to pay the advertising dollars.

    --

    Ita erat quando hic adveni.

  4. Ranma 1/2 by TheBrownShow · · Score: 3, Funny

    It's such a shame that they refuse to play Ranma 1/2... though I don't know how the censors would react to a half-guy, half-girl character who somehow always has his, er, her chest exposed.

    1. Re:Ranma 1/2 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I believe the term is "nosebleed."

    2. Re:Ranma 1/2 by Beardydog · · Score: 0

      Cowboy Bebop has a hermaphrodite.. I'm sure Ranma would be edited enough that it would put its fans out, but as far as language and suggestive dialouge and situations go, [AS] doesn't seem to be too strict. They set up a large list of shows on their board they'd never air, like Ranma, Excel Saga, Evangelion and so on, but I think cost was the main issue with most of them. Of course cost of editing probably factors in...

    3. Re:Ranma 1/2 by illuminatedwax · · Score: 1

      Or crappy Rumiko Takahashi shows.

      --
      Did you ever notice that *nix doesn't even cover Linux?
    4. Re:Ranma 1/2 by MoFoQ · · Score: 1

      one word....PBS. They'll air it if they can buy the license. Hey, my local PBS bought NukuNuku (the old one...with the nudity)....and I think they also did Key (metal idol)

    5. Re:Ranma 1/2 by genner · · Score: 1

      I find it more amazing Ranma actually ran on network television..although heavily censored.

    6. Re:Ranma 1/2 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I find it even more surprising they aired Ranma UNEDITED AT 19:00-PRIMETIME at a regional station one year ago. Even including the disputed visit to the public bath which was more or less a complete nude-episode...

    7. Re:Ranma 1/2 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's not "PBS" who buys the shows. It's the local PBS station. One of my local PBS stations (KTEH) bought Evangelion, and showed it subbed, uncensored. Unfortunatly KTEH does not show anime much anymore.

    8. Re:Ranma 1/2 by MoFoQ · · Score: 1

      DUH!

      PBS as in PBS stations.

      I did say my local PBS...and yea...KTEH doesn't buy much anymore.....it's smack dab in the middle of the Silicon Valley.....I wonder why they aren't buying much anymore (sarcasm^2)

      I'm just gonna blame Feinstein and Boxer and everyone's favorite scapegoat....Gray Davis, blamed for Gigili among other things.

  5. Little bit o' the inside scoop by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Well, I happen to know the guy who does/did the Japanese-English translation for GITS:TV (yes, it will be the tv). He also did it for Big-O, Tenchi in Tokyo and a few others, he works freelance, including a VERY sweet looking 'dieselpunk' fantasy series called Last Exile.

    From all impressions I get, editing won't be too bad. But the creepiest thing is that the series has 3 experimental spider-tank characters, who supposedly start out as a 'hive mind', but begin to develop individuality over the course of several episodes. So you have all these heavily armed, near-sentient battle robots, and THEY ALL HAVE SQEAKY JAPANESE TEENAGE GIRL VOICES! *SHUDDER* They even wave their hands around like children, very bizarre, and probably fits in well with the "feel" of the series.

    b10hazrd

    1. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by blindcoder · · Score: 1

      Well, that's the whole point of having sentient mechas (called Tachikoma in this case) in Anime:
      They just have to be either cute and heavily armed, or bulky and heavily armed.

      Personally, I'd just love to have a Tachikoma (even only as a model) but the models are so expensive here in Bavaria >_

      --
      See my blog for my free opinions.
    2. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      But the creepiest thing is that the series has 3 experimental spider-tank characters, who supposedly start out as a 'hive mind', but begin to develop individuality over the course of several episodes. So you have all these heavily armed, near-sentient battle robots, and THEY ALL HAVE SQEAKY JAPANESE TEENAGE GIRL VOICES! *SHUDDER*

      Tachikoma! don't sweat it, they kick ass.

      also watch for another killer Kanno Yoko soundtrack on this series. it is breathtaking.

    3. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by cpt+kangarooski · · Score: 1

      The Tachikomas? I don't recall that they're experimental. They are hilariously fun though, and so are the Fuchikomas (which are similar) from the manga. And there's a lot more than three of them.

      Personally, I'm still waiting on finding out why the GITS:TV Kusanagi insists on wearing that stupid one-piece all the time. Everyone else seems to just wear fairly normal clothing; why she dresses so bizarrely, I haven't a clue.

      Last Exile is also quite good, though it can be rather slow-moving at times.

      --
      -- This and all my posts are in the public domain. I am a lawyer. I am not your lawyer, and this is not legal advice.
    4. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by truenoir · · Score: 2, Informative

      The Tachikomas are like that in the original, which is similar in turn to the original manga. There's even a series of shorts that were made with just the Tachikomas sitting around postulating about various things.

    5. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by M-2 · · Score: 1

      Personally, I'm still waiting on finding out why the GITS:TV Kusanagi insists on wearing that stupid one-piece all the time. Everyone else seems to just wear fairly normal clothing; why she dresses so bizarrely, I haven't a clue.

      A friend of mine commented that if he worked for Section 9, he wouldn't get anything DONE with Maj. Kusanagi walking around in that thing all the time. That may be part of it.

      Maybe she's an exhibitionist or something. I mean, she's a full-body-replacement cyborg who apparently was designed for maximum eye candy factor, and she wants to show it off. We don't get a lot of insight into her (unlike some of the others - like Batou in the 'Jungle Cruise' ep).

    6. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by MooCows · · Score: 1

      Maybe she's an exhibitionist or something.

      Read the manga :)

      --
      The path I walk alone is endlessly long.
      30 minutes by bike, 15 by bus.
    7. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by eean · · Score: 1

      The 'cute' Tachikomas are freakin' awesome. The best GITS episodes are centered around them. Seeing them in an English dub just sounds more ridiculous.

    8. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by Intocabile · · Score: 1

      Last Exile is such a good show, the end is somewhat lackluster however. The show does have alot of sweet action and the style is great, some of the best CG integration I've seen.

    9. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by Intocabile · · Score: 1

      And by original you mean manga.

    10. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by truenoir · · Score: 1

      By that I was referring to the original Japanese language track for SAC. The original poster didn't seem to be specifying that, though in retrospect he didn't mention hearing a dub either.

    11. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by M-2 · · Score: 1

      I have. Including the parts they haven't shown in the US. Waiting for the 'uncensored' MMI release.

    12. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by qeveren · · Score: 1

      She starts changing her outfits more often as the series progresses, don't worry. She does wear that one-piece an awful lot for the first while, though. I always got the impression that she didn't really think much about her body, or showing it off, being a full-replacement cyborg from a very young age.

      I hope they don't screw up the Tachikomas in the dub. Just wait, they're going to give them some stupid-ass modulated robot voices or something.

      It's definitely nice to see some of the other characters getting a bit of development, like Togusa and Ishikawa, not to mention Batou.

      And where can I get some of that sweet thermoptic camoflage? :)

      --
      Don't just stand there, get that other dog!
    13. Re:Little bit o' the inside scoop by cpt+kangarooski · · Score: 1

      Well, I've seen a lot of the episodes. She wears the khaki uniform from time to time, she has full-body jumpsuit sorts of things (probably body armor), and that grey ensemble she wears in England.

      But most of the time she goes to work, meets with important people, and has her ass hanging out. It's crazy. The only other people dressed as wierdly seem to be the two women that get in that fight in the hotel room in ep. 7 and I suspect they're just robots. (or possibly robot hookers which are just as good, and coin-operated)

      And where can I get some of that sweet thermoptic camoflage? :)

      Where the hell did Togusa get it? In the manga at least, he was totally human other than having a cyberbrain hookup, which is pretty universal. But he didn't wear a hood in the first episode, yet managed to be completely invisible. Even given the sheer number and variety of cyborgs in GITS, a head replacement is a relatively major piece of work.

      --
      -- This and all my posts are in the public domain. I am a lawyer. I am not your lawyer, and this is not legal advice.
  6. Don't forget by yoshi_mon · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I know Taco loves his Anime but I'd also just like to send a big shout out to Cartoon Network for the great stuff they have been doing with the other part of Adult Swim.

    The new SpaceGoasts CTC have been great as well as all of the other ones. (Sealab2021, ATHF, Brak Show)

    Even after the death of Harry Goz (1932 - 2003),voice of Captin Murphy on Sealab 2021, the show has bounced back imo and did a good new ep.

    Thanks Cartoon Network. I'm not a big fan of Anime (Cowboy Beebob as one of the BIG exceptions.) but you still have given me a reason to stay up late every night.

    --

    Really, I know what I'm doing...Ohhhh, look at the shiny buttons!
    1. Re:Don't forget by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh, and Family Guy, that needs props as a good Adult Swim spot. Classic, classic humor. Damn the censors.

    2. Re:Don't forget by yoshi_mon · · Score: 2

      Yes. They have done a good job of replaying a lot of shows that have fallen off (Sometimes for very inexplicable reasons.) other networks.

      Family Guy, Futurama, Mission Hill, and even that weird one the Oblongs. All good stuff. (And I would argue that the 1st 3 should still be in production today!)

      Oh, and I do know that it is Cowboy Beebop. Heh, and I even previewed.

      --

      Really, I know what I'm doing...Ohhhh, look at the shiny buttons!
    3. Re:Don't forget by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Even after the death of Harry Goz (1932 - 2003),voice of Captin Murphy on Sealab 2021, the show has bounced back imo and did a good new ep.

      I thought it was a very good attempt, but SeaLab will never be the same without Capt. Murphy. This past Sunday's episode felt awkward and empty. I hope they can find someone who can replicate Goz's charm.

      ATHF, OTOH, was in rare form.

    4. Re:Don't forget by goldspider · · Score: 1
      "The new SpaceGoasts CTC have been great as well as all of the other ones."

      After reading that minor, humorous typo, I couldn't help but think of my sig.

      --
      "Ask not what your country can do for you." --John F. Kennedy
    5. Re:Don't forget by Cutriss · · Score: 1

      Well, that'd be pretty hard, since the episodes that are running right now were all done before Harry Goz's death. Williams Street had just wrapped up a slew of new Sealab 2021 episodes when Harry passed away, and those episodes are what are airing now.

      --
      "Mod, mod, mod...and another troll bites the dust."
    6. Re:Don't forget by Cutriss · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Even after the death of Harry Goz (1932 - 2003),voice of Captin Murphy on Sealab 2021, the show has bounced back imo and did a good new ep.

      While it is true that Harry Goz did pass away, rumors of new episodes without his voicework are exaggerated.

      Williams Street had just completed work on a new season of Sealab before Harry Goz died, and so all the episodes running in this season are his final work. They aren't put together weekly.

      --
      "Mod, mod, mod...and another troll bites the dust."
    7. Re:Don't forget by Cpt_Kirks · · Score: 1

      Yes, but will they be producing more episodes?

    8. Re:Don't forget by zero_offset · · Score: 1

      I'm glad somebody posted this. If it wasn't for TiVo, I'd have never seen these shows at all -- I thought Adult Swim was nothing but a morass of overrated anime trash until an insomniac friend at work mentioned Sealab...

      --

      Slashdot quality declines as the number of hot grits posts decreases. - Provolt's Law, Apr-09-2005

    9. Re:Don't forget by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Weird. I loved the anime on CN, but I think of all the shows you just mentioned as total crap. I find it almost painful to watch them.

      I really wish they'd just show more good anime and less of that stuff, frankly. Of course, I realize that they might have trouble adapting things like chobits, ranma, etc. C'est la vie...

    10. Re:Don't forget by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Each to their own.

    11. Re:Don't forget by shidoshi · · Score: 1

      So, wait, you're calling things like Chobits and Ranma GOOD but things like WH Robin BAD? Wow. Ranma is fanboy trash. Chobits... possibly even more so.

  7. Also unlikely... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    We will more likely see Ranma than Gunslinger Girl in the near future....

    1. Re:Also unlikely... by Jameth · · Score: 1

      There is some reason for that. Gunslinger Girl is extremely slow paced. Six eps in, it still only does backstory. It's very good, but kinda slow paced. Most Americans have very short attention spans. I assume that this is similar for the rest of the world as well, but I cannot be certain.

      However, Ranma is pretty unlikely due to the excessive nudity. Of course, they can censor that stuff, but it's also kinda old.

    2. Re:Also unlikely... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think ANN had reported a couple of months ago (during a convention? I don't go to conventions but I read ANN sometimes) that Ranma would NOT be shown. This was reported as news, from a Q&A of some panel at a convention.

  8. GitS: Stand Alone Complex won't need much editing by tuffy · · Score: 1

    The show was made for japanese TV viewing, whose standards aren't all that different from those of american TV. As such, the show features little of the gore and nudity of the feature film while still presenting plenty of action and musings about the ramifications of future technology. And besides, Bandai wants this on Adult Swim so they can sell plenty of shiny DVDs in preperation for the show's second season.

    --

    Ita erat quando hic adveni.

  9. On a sort of related note by HarveyBirdman · · Score: 1
    Seriously, if it weren't for Tivo I'd never catch my fix of Twilight Zone reruns and Enterprise.

    It was Cartoon Network's airing of Cowboy Bebop that soured me on Enterprise. After witnessing the gritty exploits of Spike, Jet, Faye, Ed and even Ein, I could no longer stomach the goody two-shoes of Enterprise. All I could remember was Captain Puss^H^H^H^H Archer curling up into a little ball as a bunch of Andorans stole his lunch money or something.

    I own the DVD boxed set of Bebop (and the movie, which was a better SF film than any recent Trek, Star Wars or Matrix film). Don't think I'll be owning any Enterprise.

    And, actually, I commend TechTV for showing some of the odder stuff, like Serial Experiment Lain, that CN might shy away from. The Starz Action Channel shows some anime as well, and it's completely uncut there. They just ran through Hellsing and Bubblegum Crisis 2040 both of which I liked more than I expected to.

    --
    --- Ban humanity.
  10. Standalone Complex by Tim+Fraser · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I don't think the Ghost in the Shell Standalone Complex TV series would have to be edited too much for US TV. I have all but the last DVD (imported from Taiwan), and I think most of the episodes are free of anything that might cause US TVs to melt down in a fit of self-righteous indignation.

    Of course, perhaps the good/bad stuff is in the last few episodes I don't have. I can't seem to get the last DVD. One of my local Anime dealers told me that this is intentional - He said that the producers of these (non-US) releases don't release the last DVD until they release the whole series as a boxed set. Their plan is to force all the fools (like myself) who bought the single DVDs to buy them all again in the boxed set in order to get the last episodes.

    Can anyone confirm or debunk this theory?

    - Tim

    1. Re:Standalone Complex by MooCows · · Score: 1

      Can anyone confirm or debunk this theory?

      Could be, if I were you I'd just buy either the Japanese R2's (quite a few new releases have english subs on them) or wait for the (usually superior to R3) release of the R1's.

      That's alot of regions ;)

      --
      The path I walk alone is endlessly long.
      30 minutes by bike, 15 by bus.
    2. Re:Standalone Complex by Jameth · · Score: 1

      I have seen the entire series. It is clean of anything. No nudity, very low violence. Easily on par with Cowboy Bebop as it was shown on Adult Swim.

      The show is not about violence.

    3. Re:Standalone Complex by Chibi · · Score: 1

      Can you post some more info on the set that you purchased? You mentioned that they are imported from Taiwan, so that makes me wonder if they are, in fact, bootlegs. There are some legitimate Taiwanese releases, so I don't want to make a huge assumption, but this idea of forcing someone to re-purchase the entire series just to get the ending doesn't sound quite right to me. I could possibly understand if this was done and two different sets had different extras, but restricting access to the shows itself sounds a bit odd...

      Another thing I am seeing more and more are dishonest retailers. I recently bought some CDs which I thought were legitimate Japanese releases. It turns out that the discs were CDRs with really bad laser printer silk screens. The retailer went through the effort of making copies of all of the inserts, even the obis (paper sleeve). I've never heard of any bootleg quite like this. The kicker is that a lot of these CDR CDs were for out of print releases, and this retailer was even selling them at normal import prices (as opposed to the "normal" bootleg prices. The proverbial double-whammy. Anyway, the retailer was Digital Discs Anime. They lost their domain recently, but they still go to conventions. My advice to avoid them, since they are (in one way or the other) lying to their customers. Er, to get back on topic, my main point is that the guy selling you your DVDs might just be feeding you a line, trying to absolve himself of any guilt/responsibility.

      Anyway, here's the Pirate Anime FAQ, just in case.

      --
      If all you have are silver bullets, everything looks like a werewolf.
    4. Re:Standalone Complex by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well, there's at least one bit that'll need to be changed - in one episode, there's a short conversation where one person is sitting in front of a computer/TV (can't remember exactly, and haven't got time to check) and you can sort of hear the audio from the porno he's watching (and faintly see a reflection of it on his glasses). Other than that (or the Major's rather curious fashion sense), I don't recall seeing anything in the first 19 episodes that would cause concern.

    5. Re:Standalone Complex by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      http://gits.no-jutsu.com/gits/

    6. Re:Standalone Complex by Tim+Fraser · · Score: 1

      I think they aren't bootlegs, but I suppose I can't really be sure. Here's the info:

      My DVDs are region-free, Japanese audio with Chinese and English subtitles. I claim they're imported from Taiwan only because the DVD cases had additional cardboard overlays under the shrink-wrap that were apparently added by a Taiwanese distributor. These overlays had the title translated into Chinese ("something-or-other infantry"), along with contact information for the distributor and a short list of their other products.

      I don't have them with me here at work (sadly!), but at least one google-rific on-line store that's advertising DVDs with the same titles and cover art claims that the distributor is "anime cartoon".

      Oh, the horror! In my search for this information, I have found a site offering all but the last DVD for $25US each, or the boxed set with all the episodes for $80US. I will now weep quietly for a while.

      - Tim

    7. Re:Standalone Complex by DavidBrown · · Score: 2, Informative

      - He said that the producers of these (non-US) releases don't release the last DVD until they release the whole series as a boxed set. Their plan is to force all the fools (like myself) who bought the single DVDs to buy them all again in the boxed set in order to get the last episodes.

      Can anyone confirm or debunk this theory?


      I've seen where the producer will release either the first DVD (too many titles to name) or the last DVD (FLCL) in a box designed to hold all of the DVD's in the series.

      --
      144l. ph34r my 133t l3g4l 5k1lz!
    8. Re:Standalone Complex by tuffy · · Score: 3, Informative
      I think they aren't bootlegs, but I suppose I can't really be sure. Here's the info:
      Region-free DVDs with chinese subtitles are bootlegs. Legitimate import DVDs are rarely region free, never have chinese subtitles and are always quite expensive.
      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

    9. Re:Standalone Complex by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They're bootlegs.

    10. Re:Standalone Complex by Tim+Fraser · · Score: 1

      No kidding...

      I'm not sure which part makes me more angry: the fact that they sold me bootlegged DVDs, or the fact that they charged $20US each for them. As Chibi said, it's a "double-whammy".

      - Tim :^(

    11. Re:Standalone Complex by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Excellant....

    12. Re:Standalone Complex by sootman · · Score: 1

      Hard to say. This is the network, after all, that edited Futurama--a show that was originally shown at 8:30pm, then 7pm, that CN shows in the middle of the night.

      Sweet zombie Jesus! I'm sure they'll find something. :-)

      --
      Dear Slashdot: next time you want to mess with the site, add a rich-text editor for comments.
    13. Re:Standalone Complex by jnik · · Score: 1

      It's happened to the best of us....just learn from your mistakes and do your research next time. Anime on DVD's "R2 and beyond" forum is a good place to start. There are also "safe" retailers like Yesasia

    14. Re:Standalone Complex by SleazyC · · Score: 1

      The sure shot way to see if you are getting Hong Kong (HK) DVD's as they call them is to check if they have Chinese subtitles. Anything with Chinese subtitles can basically be considered bootleg. Only very rare R2 DVD's come with english subtitles.

      So if you are buying off ebay or some other sites off the internet make sure they are coming from respectable names such as Bandai, Pioneer or ADV.

    15. Re:Standalone Complex by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You know, those were the only three episodes I didn't already have. Thanks.

  11. There is a danger here ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If Cartoon Network puts more and more anime on, and it becomes more mainstream, then what will most of the aficionados do? It will be mainstream, and hence uncool. There will be lots of bitching and moaning about "selling out" and "it used to be good back in the day" (when in fact it never really changed), but I guess there is a little bit of time before that happens. Probably plenty of time to find something else that is obscure to latch on to and pretend to like just so they can claim sophistication over the unwashed masses.

    1. Re:There is a danger here ... by truenoir · · Score: 1

      You mean like music fans? Anime fans will always be able to nab fansubs well in advance of American TV or DVD release. If not that, they'll likely stick with subs not dubs for most things.

    2. Re:There is a danger here ... by Beardydog · · Score: 0

      I've got a friend who most of us call Anime Sarah who now claims to hate anime. Her reason? Liking anime has become too competetive.

    3. Re:There is a danger here ... by eean · · Score: 1

      I doubt it. A lot of the anime has always gone towards a niche audience in Japan, I don't see that changing when it comes here. Some anime is more mainstream (DBZ *shudder, and Naruto for instance), so has always been a 'sell-out'. Regardless, its corporations making the anime, so the whole notion of selling-out is pretty stupid.

      And really, anyone who watches anime for 'sophistication', well I guess if there is a low enough thershold for sophistication maybe. I watch anime because of the 13 or 26 episode format that allows character development and an actual overarching plot. Even before I watched anime, I always enjoyed mini-series, except for the fact that with some exception, the production value can be pretty cheap. Anime gets around that by using relatively-cheap (but nowadays at least) quality-looking animation techniques.

    4. Re:There is a danger here ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Exactly like music fans. Like all the pretentious crap that passed as "modern" music in the mid-20th century (the John Cage tripe and all; for an example, read the blather in this piece). Don't forget the tons of garbage in the form of paintings and sculpture being passed off as high art. Crapping in a can? Please.

      And let's not even go into "alternative" music, where the only appeal (it isn't the quality of sound) is that it isn't mainstream.

      Don't forget the gastronomical topics. For years it was the wine snobs, and the last ten years it has been the beer snobs. If it is dark and bitter, and (and this is important) comes from a small "brewery," it is always superior to anything mass-produced. I'm sorry, but bitter crap, even if "hand crafted" is still bitter crap.

      There will always be a certain group of people who latch onto something unusual to feel superior. For the most part that is fine; however, the haughty look-down-the-nose comments at "the masses" gets tiresome. Too bad most can't look in the mirror and see themselves for the pretentious assholes that they are.

    5. Re:There is a danger here ... by Thedalek · · Score: 1

      Feh. The real danger is that those who like Anime just for the sake of liking something that other people don't will have to move further into the fringe, which means the naughty tentacle stuff. That stuff makes me want to claw my eyes out.

      For those of us who genuinely like quality Anime (rather than just saying "Oooh, it's Japanese! Pretty!"), we'll simply be overjoyed to be able to buy our favorite series in Wal-Mart instead of having to hunt for months and pay silly prices for 20 minutes of a bad pirate copy, and happy that we are now able to share our enthusiasm with our friends.

      --
      Happiness is relative, Based upon the way we live.
  12. Re:Except for, that's not true.. by Lord+Bitman · · Score: 1

    I thought GitSAC was made for a Pay-per-view type service.. that's what the promotion for it said, anyway.

    --
    -- 'The' Lord and Master Bitman On High, Master Of All
  13. Re:GitS: Stand Alone Complex won't need much editi by MooCows · · Score: 1

    Yes, sadly it seems Bandai is waiting for the show to air on TV in America before releasing the DVD's.
    Many newer series than GITS: SAC are already (partly) available on DVD, while GITS: SAC isn't even announced yet. (afaik)

    --
    The path I walk alone is endlessly long.
    30 minutes by bike, 15 by bus.
  14. Re:I nailed Robin... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Oddly enough, not as offtopic as the mods seem to think. Robin, of Witch Hunter Robin really could do this to the poor man, and the Ordo condom of whch he speaks would indeed keep poor willie alive and well.

  15. When are... by homerules · · Score: 0

    The animators in Japan going to get better than the old Hanna Barbera stuff and at least up to par with South Park.

    1. Re:When are... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      When are the animators in Disney going to get up to par with the better animators in Japan?

      (Watch Princess Mononoke and the forest parts of Fantasia 2000. Disney looks shoddy in comparison.)

    2. Re:When are... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Watch Last Exile and then come back, ok thx bye.

    3. Re:When are... by MoFoQ · · Score: 1

      ooo...that's bad....that's like a single KKK member mistakenly walking into a Black Panther meeting....beat down (disregarding whether or not that KKK member deserved the beat down, of course)....or another analogy would be an average, whimpy guy gets put into a cell with a big buff guy named "tiny" and talks like he's sucking helium all day long.

      All classic cases for the ol' cyanide pill (or a ricin pill if you're that Bulgarian assassin)

  16. Re:GitS: Stand Alone Complex won't need much editi by M-2 · · Score: 1

    Well, in the first episode, Maj. Kusanagi blows a guy's foot off, but that's about a 2-second cut.

    Most of the stuff you see in GitS:SAC will, I thing, be pretty much easy for them to cut.

    (And I want the shiny DVDs!)

  17. Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by Jameth · · Score: 1

    Just my opinion, but Wolf's Rain really quite bad. The first season was impressive. It set up a lot of potential, and the second season was a total let-down. After four episodes of re-cap, they had weak character development and dumb plot-ideas. All-in-all, it's a bad show.

    Witch Hunter Robin was good right up to the end. The very last episode was a little weak, but it was not bad. It was only worse than the previous episodes in that series.

    Personally, I think the best serieses deserving a run right now are "Now and Then, Here and There" and "Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu", the first being one of the best all-around stories out there, and the second being just about the funniest thing ever.

    1. Re:Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by MooCows · · Score: 1

      "Now and Then, Here and There" .. on US TV??
      I agree that it's a great series but .. a bit too nasty for US TV.

      There's the rape of that girl, the child army, the interrogation of the main kid, kids shooting each other, etc.
      Yeah, it has a very good serious story, but I wouldn't expect it to ever air on US TV.

      (Of course they could edit it, but that would remove most of the material anyways)

      --
      The path I walk alone is endlessly long.
      30 minutes by bike, 15 by bus.
    2. Re:Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by dsnowak · · Score: 1

      There were problems part way through the production of Wolf's Rain, which led to the recaps. It also went off the air in Japan before it was finished. The last four episodes are being done as OAV's--video only releases. My bet is the recaps will be left out of the broadcast run and the four OAV episodes tacked on to make it 26 episodes. Hopefully, the OAV's bring it to a good close. We shall see...

    3. Re:Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by truenoir · · Score: 1

      Wolf's Rain was great overall I thought. I haven't seen the last 4 episodes (it's 30, not 26). Four episodes of recap was terrible though. The story really did kinda burn out near the end though. But then, so did WHR. Probably the first Full Metal Panic would be good to run rather than Fumoffu.

    4. Re:Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by tuffy · · Score: 1
      Personally, I think the best serieses deserving a run right now are "Now and Then, Here and There" and "Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu", the first being one of the best all-around stories out there, and the second being just about the funniest thing ever.

      FMP:Fumoffu has yet to be licensed. But if ADV gets it just like they got the original, it would wind up on ADV's own Anime Network rather than the Cartoon Network. It's a hilarious show, though, and superior to the original season IMHO.

      As for "Now and Then, Here and There", though not a very explicit show, its content is just too intense for american broadcast - as others have mentioned.

      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

    5. Re:Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by Jameth · · Score: 1

      Yeah, that's a good point. Last Exile, then.

    6. Re:Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by Jameth · · Score: 1

      But it did have a finalization episode, it just sucked. They'd have to change that to make it not be an ending. Still, I have a desperate hope you are correct, because the way that ended was a total let-down.

    7. Re:Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by ibmman85 · · Score: 0

      i think having the first season of full metal panic on cartoon network would work out really well.. i was actually really impressed with the battle sequences i thought they were probably some of the best ive seen however mech battles really did contrast just a little bit with the random chidori upskirt camera angle every time there was a gust of wind...

    8. Re:Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by Intocabile · · Score: 1

      Wolf's Rain had some production problems to say the least. The music kicks ass though, Yoko Kano rules!

    9. Re:Wolf's Rain, Robin, and Others by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I really can't see Now and Then, Here and There getting past any censor outside of Japan. :)

  18. Rurouni Kenshin by X-Nc · · Score: 2

    I just wish they hadn't pulled Rurouni Kenshin from the afternoon block.

    --
    --
    If I actually could spell I'd have spelled it right in the first place.
    1. Re:Rurouni Kenshin by blueZhift · · Score: 1

      Actually, I was a bit surprised that it was on during Toonami at all given the violence. Don't get me wrong, Kenshin is pretty deep, but some of the fighting is too violent (and realistic relative to DBZ) for the age group most likely to be watching that part of the day.

      You can see it on the Saturday night line (after the kiddies are in bed) up right now. They recently started over, so now's my chance to catch up! :-)

    2. Re:Rurouni Kenshin by JLSigman · · Score: 1

      I wish they had showed more episodes. They cut it off right as the Kyoto arc was starting, missing out on all the really great stuff.

      --
      -jls
      Techno-pagan
    3. Re:Rurouni Kenshin by SleazyC · · Score: 1

      Kenshin on Cartoon Network is decent but buy the DVDs if you really want a taste of what the series can give you. CN's voice actor for Kenshin is horrrible compared to the Japanese VA (who was a woman, and yes it did sound great). Also the editiing of some of the violent scenes didn't sit to well with me, but then again I did watch the original uncut episodes...

    4. Re:Rurouni Kenshin by X-Nc · · Score: 1
      Unfortunately I'm to damn old to stay up that late. :-(

      I think I need a TiVo.

      --
      --
      If I actually could spell I'd have spelled it right in the first place.
  19. Re:Except for, that's not true.. by Jameth · · Score: 1

    Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex has no nudity and virtually no gore. Only about one in every two episodes have and violence whatsoever, and much of that is not displayed in detail. The show is not about violence.

  20. cus anime is teh s uck by iamdrscience · · Score: 0, Troll

    Why talk about Adult Swim staying on and only mention the anime? That's only half of the lineup! Sealab 2021, Aquateen Hunger Force, The Brak Show, Space Ghost, Harvey Birdman, Home Movies... these are all fantastically funny shows, not to mention they're the only place to see reruns of Family Guy and Futurama, two of the funniest cartoons ever.

    Sure, anime's nice and all, but just as many people are attracted to the other shows on Adult Swim.

    Also, Venture Brothers next summer, should be awesome if the pilot is anything to guage the series on.

    1. Re:cus anime is teh s uck by perlstar · · Score: 1

      You left out Blue Gender.

    2. Re:cus anime is teh s uck by CaptRespect · · Score: 1

      Seriously.

      If anything, I would like to see less anime and more adult oriented Cartoons like Aquateen Hunger Force, Sealab 2021, and especially Home Movies.

      They should pickup Duckman from Comedy Central. Comedy Central only seems to want to show it at 2:00 AM.

    3. Re:cus anime is teh s uck by ibmman85 · · Score: 0

      i beg to differ. more anime. please. anime is the only thing i can stand watching anymore and before discovering that anime was actually good i hadnt watched tv in years since i thought it was all junk.

  21. Most anime on US TV is censored.... by escallywag · · Score: 2, Informative
    Even in slots deceptively called "Adult Swim"....

    Who wants to watch raped versions anyway ? Just stick to the original DVD's for the true anime experience.

    1. Re:Most anime on US TV is censored.... by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      Or instead, use bittorrent searches to find and subsequently download episodes of fansubbed anime which has not been released in the US. Sure sometimes the sub is so out there you find yourself thinking you could do a better job when you don't even speak Japanese, but if that bothers you so much, you probably speak Japanese, and can do your own translating.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    2. Re:Most anime on US TV is censored.... by dq5+studios · · Score: 1

      Oh please, the majority of anime unique to AS are barely touched.

      Kyle Pope's Edit List

    3. Re:Most anime on US TV is censored.... by MoFoQ · · Score: 1

      yea....like Anna Nicole Smith. ("Smitty...rimshot plz")

    4. Re:Most anime on US TV is censored.... by placeclicker · · Score: 0

      It's not up to Adult Swim, it's either raped versions or none at all.

      --

      Browse at -1, because trolls are often the most creative part of /.
  22. Re:GitS: Stand Alone Complex won't need much editi by Fancia · · Score: 1

    As I recall, Cowboy Bebop's Adult Swim run was less censored than its Japanese television run.

    --

    Bít, zabít, jen proto, ze su liska!
  23. robbIE ?serves? up more stuff that doesn't matter? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    what a surprise?

    & that's 'no going back' (not, 'no where to run', you can still run as far/fast as you think you need to?) & no where to hide, as the lights come up. tell 'em robbIE? tell 'em about the phonIE monIE & your softwar gangster advertising .contracks?

    lookout bullow. many of the creators' innocents continue to be damaged buy the order of greed/fear/ego based LIEforms.

    the daze of the felonious georgewellian fuddite corepirate nazi softwar gangster stock markup execrable is WANing into coolapps/the abyss, at the increasing speed of right/light. tell 'em robbIE? or, just .continue to pretend, if you think you must?

    consult with/trust in yOUR creator.... most of you are part of the upcoming light.

  24. Re:robbIE ?serves? up more stuff that doesn't matt by MooCows · · Score: 1

    & no where to hide, as the lights come up. tell 'em robbIE?

    Hey, that looks like a fansub of Witch Hunter Robin episode 4.

    --
    The path I walk alone is endlessly long.
    30 minutes by bike, 15 by bus.
  25. Re:GitS: Stand Alone Complex won't need much editi by tuffy · · Score: 1
    As I recall, Cowboy Bebop's Adult Swim run was less censored than its Japanese television run.

    Only about half of Cowboy Bebop's episodes actually aired on its original japanese run. Episodes like "The Real Folk Blues" weren't shown until the second season on satellite TV. For those without satellite, the episodes went straight to video. So in this instance, american viewers got to see a lot more of the show.

    --

    Ita erat quando hic adveni.

  26. How about an Adult Swim channel? by Orne · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I, for one, welcome our new Unedited Cartoon Network... err...

    Seriously, suppose Cartoon Network spun off a sister-station, and cable networks made it an optional channel to standard packages, who's purpose was to show anime in its raw form? Parents have the option for nudity and cursing on HBO & Cinemax, and they also have the control whether they want that stuff in their home or not. If you don't want it, the cable company can block it.

    I'm not saying that we need a cartoon Spice channel (not that there's any shortage of hentai), just that there should be some medium for your average movie where you can catch the whole thing. The Cartoon Network has an image to keep as a channel for kids (the alternative to Nickelodeon), and they can't risk someones child staying up late and catching some unedited Vampire Hunter D.

    Adult Swim has this nostalgic aura about it now (GiJoe, He-Man) ... like 80s Strike Back on VH1. And mix in a bit of "here's something cool you didn't know existed"... sort of like catching Most Extreme Elimination Challenge on TNT/SpikeTV. That's what anime is to American audiences... years of shows about robots and vampires, lasers and rockets and giant aliens, fast action and a "new" visual style.

    There's something that bugs me about watching a show or movie when I know that it has been edited by some middleman... The director of the project had an artistic vision and those scenes & language capture the intent. You can't express the story of the rough mafia men in the Sopranos without the occasional trip to the strip club... this is what tells the story of men making bad choices and dealing with the consequences.

    1. Re:How about an Adult Swim channel? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      they have one in texas its not owned by cartoon network but ti stations that plays anime all the time

    2. Re:How about an Adult Swim channel? by May+Kasahara · · Score: 1

      U.S. anime distributor ADV launched an Anime Network awhile back, which is available in select digital/satellite TV markets (mainly those monopolized by Comcast, AFAIK). I suppose it's a matter of time to see how well that channel does before Adult Swim branches off into it's own thing.

      (Not that CN doesn't already have its own spinoff: there's Boomerang, which is pretty much all old Hanna Barbera stuff. Don't know how well that network's doing...)

      As for the editing issue... blame the anime companies themselves, not Cartoon Network, as the former (Bandai, Pioneer, et al) are usually the ones to do it. As a counter-example, this summer FLCL (one of the most lascivious anime in recent years) aired on Cartoon Network... with only two edits throughout six episodes. Kudos to Synch-Point for leaving the show pretty much untouched...

    3. Re:How about an Adult Swim channel? by ibmman85 · · Score: 0

      i was really hoping thats what anime network would be since having the name 'anime network' would seem to imply that but alas its not availible here and i dont have digital cable.. i dont even have techtv *tears*

    4. Re:How about an Adult Swim channel? by bigbigbison · · Score: 1

      Catoon network has already spun off one channel, "Boomerang" which is all the old cartoons. However, I don't know how sucessful it is. I used to have Time-Warner cable (the owners of Cartoon Network and Boomerang) and they didn't carry it. If you can't get one of your subsidiaries to carry you channel, I think that indicates how sucessfull the channel is.

      Thus since Boomerang does not seem to have much popularity (of course I could be totally wrong, it could be on every cable providor except the two i've had in the past 3 years) I would think that they would hesitate to spin off another channel at this point.

      --
      http://www.popularculturegaming.com -- my blog about the culture of videogame players
    5. Re:How about an Adult Swim channel? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Basically censorship sucks.

    6. Re:How about an Adult Swim channel? by sabernar · · Score: 1

      Adult Swim is too important to CartoonNetwork to spin it off. Cartoon would lose too much viewership and ad dollars. Adult Swim Network would suck off the older, and very valuable, viewership.

    7. Re:How about an Adult Swim channel? by SamSim · · Score: 1

      The United Kingdom version of Cartoon Network doesn't have Adult Swim, but does have a dedicated channel, Toonami. In addition to Justice League, Batman Beyond/Of The Future and the criminally underrated Samurai Jack, they've been known to show Cowboy Bebop, Gundam, Tenchi and Blue Submarine 6. A step in the right direction.

  27. Re:GitS: Stand Alone Complex won't need much editi by minasoko · · Score: 1
    This is true. Worryingly, it's becoming common with U.S. distributors (I think Tokyopop had the same plans for their bastardisation of Initial D).

    Slightly off topic, but being in the U.K. and not getting to see any anime on TV, I was wondering if airing shows affects people's DVD purchases.

    I'd expect that the people who'd pay for a cable channel that plays anime are hardcore enough to be downloading digisubs of shows before shelling out for DVDs anyway. So it seems the broadcasts must be aimed at non-enthusiasts in an attempt to increase the market, a development which could have good and bad consequences in my opinion.

    Does this seem correct, what do people think?

  28. Only one thing to say about this ......... by Andrewkov · · Score: 0, Offtopic
  29. sig? by t0ny · · Score: 1

    I generally dislike commenting on sigs, but didnt Mark Twain say that? or is that just a popular misconception?

    --

    Manipulate the moderator system! Mod someone as "overrated" today.

    1. Re:sig? by ductormalef · · Score: 1

      I think you are right about that quote being from Mark Twain.

      Here is a similar idea from the Bible:
      Proverbs 17:28 - Even a fool, when he holdeth his peace, is counted wise: and he that shutteth his lips is esteemed a man of understanding.

      --
      The Fat Man Walks Alone
  30. Kaitei Shonen Marien by Prince+Vegeta+SSJ4 · · Score: 1
    Bring him back, so I can relive my youth.

    for those who don't remember this show click HERE

  31. agreed by sbma44 · · Score: 1

    Home Movies is the reason I love adult swim (well, Futurama is pretty great too). But I thought new episodes were supposed to be here by now -- does anyone know what's going on w/ this? The last ep I saw was "Castaway". The site lists a season's worth of episodes past that, but I haven't seen any.

    1. Re:agreed by ClioCJS · · Score: 1
      They'll be back in January.

      www.epguides.com/homemovies

      --
      -Clio
      Karma: Bad (mostly from not giving a fuck)
      Blog: http://clintjcl.wordpress.com
  32. Re:GitS: Stand Alone Complex won't need much editi by eean · · Score: 1

    As noted, thats not true (the TV part, at least thats what I've read), but having seen most of the series, I don't know what would need to be edited. US Cable generally has lots of violence, and thats the only 'questionable' material I can think of. Cartoon Network sometimes picks odd things to edit, and odd things not to edit.

  33. Adult Swim has not been editing some shows by cyranoVR · · Score: 3, Informative

    They have been showing Blue Gender with minimal editing and FLCL with virtually none (just one word in episode 6).

    And let's not forget the latest season of Inuyasha is uncut...gory demon deaths abound...

    It is called ADULT Swim after all.

    1. Re:Adult Swim has not been editing some shows by Yosho · · Score: 2, Informative

      I would hardly call the editing of Blue Gender "minimal"... The cutting room floor is practically a bloodbath. They've also taken huge chunks out of Rurouni Kenshin, although I think they really could've shown it virtually unedited on Adult Swim.

      --
      Karma: Terrifying (mostly affected by atrocities you've committed)
    2. Re:Adult Swim has not been editing some shows by cyranoVR · · Score: 1

      The cutting room floor is practically a bloodbath.

      Ok, maybe that's a bad example - but what they left in was pretty gory! Its a far cry from the invisible blood and digital bikinis of Gundam Wing days...

    3. Re:Adult Swim has not been editing some shows by Maul · · Score: 2, Insightful

      The only editing Blue Gender needs is editing it out of existance. Bleah.

      Now, Furikuri is something I'm surprised to see on Cartoon Network. I find it hard to believe that edits were light, at least. What time are they showing that?

      I don't know what the editing in Inuyasha is like. I don't see too much that needs editing, though, since the action is so unrealistic. Maybe Jakotsu will be edited to be "not as gay" when they reach the Shichinintai story arc (after episode 100).

      --

      "You spoony bard!" -Tellah

    4. Re:Adult Swim has not been editing some shows by tuffy · · Score: 1
      Now, Furikuri is something I'm surprised to see on Cartoon Network. I find it hard to believe that edits were light, at least. What time are they showing that?

      I think it was shown at 11:30pm, CST. And it was *completely* unedited with the exception of a slightly enlarged "mosaic" over a guy's privates in one scene.

      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

    5. Re:Adult Swim has not been editing some shows by Shadwhawk · · Score: 1

      Three edits altogether, actually.
      In episode two, they muted Haruko's "Shit!" when she hears the sirens at the end of the episode. In episode six, they enlarged the mosaic over Kamon's crotch, and they cut the closing credits for time (episode six clocks in at almost exactly thirty minutes).
      All in all, pretty puny edits, especially considering Haurko's bare-assed antics in episode five, and her 'activity' with Kamon in episode 3.

    6. Re:Adult Swim has not been editing some shows by placeclicker · · Score: 0

      Nitpicking, i know, but actally two things were edited in FLCL.

      "shit" was edited out of ep. 4, and an enlarged penis was blurred out of ep. 6

      And if you want to consider it editing, due to time constraints, the credits were cut out of ep 6.

      --

      Browse at -1, because trolls are often the most creative part of /.
    7. Re:Adult Swim has not been editing some shows by Maul · · Score: 0, Troll

      IIRC, in Episode 5 one of the characters has a Swastika armband. They didn't edit that out!!?

      --

      "You spoony bard!" -Tellah

  34. Re:I've asked before by Fancia · · Score: 1

    Anime's a medium, not a genre. There are plenty of bad and mediocre anime shows and films, but there are also some absolute gems. Rose of Versailles, for instance, is a very intelligent historical-fiction show about pre-revolutionary France, focusing on Marie-Antoinette and her fictional guard Oscar Francois de Jarjayes; it's very well-written and altogether quite remarkable. Not all anime is the same homogenous and semi-erotic pap generally made. ;b

    --

    Bít, zabít, jen proto, ze su liska!
  35. Short Answer is: No by EXTomar · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Not for a cable channel that wants to target the 18-24 segement anyway. Adult Swim shows are some of the highest rated stuff floating around cable even though they are dubbed. Going sub is a giant risk since the ratings indicate that there are more now more than just Anime fans watching the block of programming.

    In Japan they have plenty of US movies and TV shows but are they subtitled? The Japanese like hearing things in their native language which is why its in Japanese in the first place. On this side of the Pacific, the US Anime Industry has advanced pretty far. The quality of scripts have gone up since translators have access to even more material than they used to (including the production staff!!!). The quality of actors has gone up since it has been shown you can make money acting. There really is no reason to ask for a sub unless you really really really want to her you favorite actress. The casual and non-fan viewers are definately not interested in that.

    I like raw shows as much as any hardcore fan but people have to realize there are many more people out there than the hardcore otaku fandom. Getting causual and non-fans to sit down and watch subtitled material is hard. Having people watch Robin and SAC is great! Its better than having these shows sit only in Anime fandom obscurity.

    1. Re:Short Answer is: No by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      I've always been lead to believe that most movies are shown in English with subtitles when it's run in Japan, but maybe that's no longer true, or it never was. Can anyone comment? Frankly I can never handle dubbed anime, I converted my girlfriend to subtitles thank goodness. Also we've been watching a lot of fansubbed stuff which hasn't been produced in the US so there's no other way to watch it.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    2. Re:Short Answer is: No by EXTomar · · Score: 1

      Take this movie. Or this TV show.

      There are number of movies like speghetti westerns that I've seen that are in Japanese. The grand point is that the Japanese like watching things in Japanese. For some odd reason its bad for Americans to watch things in English? *shrug*

      ps. Fansubs are the only way to watch shows? I beg to differ. Of course no one ever thinks about watching it off the air raw. ^_^

    3. Re:Short Answer is: No by MoFoQ · · Score: 1

      actually...most american movies in theaters in japan are subtitled (it's faster to do so). But if there is a dubbed one, they would show both the subbed and the dubbed ones (separate rooms of course...or it would be chaos).

      And for TV (the only thing they censor is below-the-belt nudity and some extreme gore), they show all and in most cases, the original english track is on the second audio channel. Hell, it wasn't until I saw Total Recall on Japanese TV that I found out about the "triplets" scene.

      You might be right about getting non-fans to watch it.....it is on late....so maybe that's their goal....'cuz it's the fans who buy the most stuff.

    4. Re:Short Answer is: No by BJH · · Score: 1

      Most movies in theatres are subtitled in Japanese. Occasionally, a dubbed version is also offered in some theatres (Shrek and LotR both had high-profile dubbed editions).

      On TV, movies are almost always dubbed, except for the occasional late-night movie.

    5. Re:Short Answer is: No by cortez · · Score: 1

      Every english movie I saw in japan was subbed. From "What Ries Beneasu" (the commercial pronounced it japanese-style) to spielberg's "duel."

      That said there are some dubs too, especially movies meant for younger audiences.

      --
      Paizurishitetai desu ka?
    6. Re:Short Answer is: No by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It has nothing to do with being hard core anime. Some people are the same way with foreign films. Actaully, I'm pretty sure one could construct and IQ test based solely on the dubbed/subtitle preference and come up with at least a 20 point differential.

      Some people can't read well. And *that* is why dumbed, er dubbed, versions are produced.

    7. Re:Short Answer is: No by shidoshi · · Score: 1

      I lived in Japan for a while, and I can assure you that 99% of Western-made movies in Japanese theaters are subtitled. The huge hits typically get two versions - a dub and a sub, both playing at the same time - but you couldn't even count on there being a Japanese dub from what I saw.

      TV was a different matter. Movies were certainly dubbed, but a number of the major channels offered the movies with both Japanese and English vocal tracks that could be switched between.

  36. this has been mentioned before by sbma44 · · Score: 1
    I know I've read articles suggesting that Cartoon Network is looking into starting a separate channel. I don't think it's a good idea.

    An AS-only channel would just be another MTV2. It'd be cool for a while before getting much worse as executives realized its audience can only be expanded so far. Oh, and I wouldn't get it from my cable provider.

    If you haven't noticed, CN airs a lot of crap. Sure, the kids-home-from-school to stoned-college-students-call-it-a-night hours have mostly good stuff. If you've perused their daytime offerings for purposes of TiVoing, you'll see that it's pretty bad.

    Also, while I admire the fact that they feel they should offer original programming, let's face it: Courage the Cowardly Dog, Ed Edd & Eddy, Grim & Evil, the Time whatever show... all are pretty weak. I have a soft spot for Dexter's Lab, and while I don't really like Samurai Jack and Powerpuff Girls, I can understand why some folks do. But a lot of their original series are not good. They could cut them and spend the freed resources to expand AS.

  37. I know I wasn't asked for an opinion.... by Dredd2Kad · · Score: 0

    ...but here it is anyway :)

    Aside from StarBlazers, I've never liked Anime.

    I just can't get like those big googly eyes they give everyone and/or the choppy animation, or everyones mouths that move like ventriloquist dummies...and the same whiney voices they use to indicate which character is supposed to be the annoying one.

    Not to mention the awful music they usually roll for the credits.

    1. Re:I know I wasn't asked for an opinion.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Starblazers! Yessss! That series rocked! My favorite is the climactic battle inside the planet before they realize how close Telezart is.

      I've been collecting the videos of the entire series one-by-one but now they are harder to come by since everything is being moved to DVD. *sigh* However, when I get to that particular epidsode I crank up the sound and let the explosions do their work. It's best viewed in a darkened room to get the nice flashing effect as the guns fire in every direction.

      Anyway, back on topic here, yes, Starblazers got me interested and while I can hardly claim to be an anime junkie I selectively choose what to watch. In addition to Starblazers I have Vampire Hunter D (gotta love a talking hand. Gives new meaning to the phrase) and regularly watch Cowboy Beebop and Reign: The Conqueror.

      Reading comments on Slashdot has gotten me interested in other anime as well but I have to say, I watched Ghost in the Shell years ago and was let down by the whole storyline. Graphics were wonderful however.

  38. Anime Network? by failedlogic · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Cartoons are becoming more popular by making them interested to wide audiences case in point: King of the Hill, The Simpsons and Futureama among others.

    Anime has the same appeal. So, whats holding the networks from making an Anime Network? Certainly, there should be enough variety and enough material to make one.

    (I'm hopeing some of it has to do with the voice dubbing. Please get better English voices, or just leave the Japanese voices in with subtitles.)

    1. Re:Anime Network? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They do have an anime network, goto www.theanimenetwork.com the problem is that most of the cabe and satellite providers aren't signing on to carrying it. A few places are but not many.

  39. Re:I've asked before by Jameth · · Score: 1

    90% of everything is crap. You've been watching the wrong 10%.

    But, in more depth:

    Anime has, in several instances, a lot more freedom than you see on American TV. The fact that it often will not pull punches when American TV does is what makes some of it more engaging.

    Also, some anime attempts to make encapsulated storylines, while most all American TV attempts to make something which can run eternally. Possibly the best thing about anime is the 13 episode series. It is a different medium than I see in the US. In the US, you have Movies, TV, and Mini-Serieses. Mini-Serieses are somewhat the same, in that they allow more subplots than Movies but still have that encapsulated nature. However, they usually require that each segment fill a two-hour block.

  40. Witch Hunter Robin by binarytoaster · · Score: 0, Troll

    Witch Hunter Robin & Wolf's Rain are both really excellent shows
    I can't speak for Wolf's Rain, having not seen it, but I've seen WHR. (The original sub, even.)

    In two words: NOTHING HAPPENS. AT ALL.

    There are spoilers as I review the four plot events in the entire 26 episode series. I want the 10 hours of my life back.

    Plot Point 1: around eps. 6-10, we come to the realization that Robin's power makes her eyes unfocus, so it's inaccurate. She needs glasses. The end.

    Plot Point 2: around eps. 16-20, Robin finds a piece of wood which is the "Ultimate Spell". But, she already had said spell, and the piece of wood was really a Cracker Jack prize.

    Plot Point 3: around eps. 20-24, we come to the realization that ... ORBO IS MADE FROM WITCHES.

    Plot Point 4: ep26: STN-J is really run by the blandest supervillain ever created who thinks witches are an impurity of the human race, and wishes to remove them.

    The end. It was very very boring. They make a point of Robin not being sexy in any way; thus, whenever she shows any skin whatsoever, we would drink. I think we might have actually taken three shots to this rule in about five episodes.

    Pathetic. *sigh*

    1. Re:Witch Hunter Robin by illuminatedwax · · Score: 1
      I'll agree with your comment on STN-J, but the show is certainly not boring. Watch it a second time, and (like most things) it will go much quicker. Something about how people remember TV. For example:

      Plot Point 1: around eps. 6-10, we come to the realization that Robin's power makes her eyes unfocus, so it's inaccurate. She needs glasses. The end.
      Nope. This happens around episode 4.

      Plot Point 2: around eps. 16-20, Robin finds a piece of wood which is the "Ultimate Spell". But, she already had said spell, and the piece of wood was really a Cracker Jack prize.
      I believe this happens instead around episode 12.

      You also fail to mention that the other episodes are mystery dramas, like a lot of American programs. I won't give away what happens (you already have, asshole), but the latter half of the series gets much more exciting than "Witch Crime of the Week."
      --Stephen

      --
      Did you ever notice that *nix doesn't even cover Linux?
    2. Re:Witch Hunter Robin by Maul · · Score: 2, Insightful

      The end. It was very very boring. They make a point of Robin not being sexy in any way; thus, whenever she shows any skin whatsoever, we would drink. I think we might have actually taken three shots to this rule in about five episodes.

      OBVIOUSLY Robin isn't attractive whatsoever because she doesn't run around like a bimbo in a skimpy outfit or have extensive shower/hotspring/near-nude sequences.

      Not every anime is made to fuel the sexual fantasies of teenage boys. Go watch Love Hina if you want that.

      --

      "You spoony bard!" -Tellah

    3. Re:Witch Hunter Robin by binarytoaster · · Score: 1

      OBVIOUSLY Robin isn't attractive whatsoever because she doesn't run around like a bimbo in a skimpy outfit or have extensive shower/hotspring/near-nude sequences.

      I'll assume you haven't seen the series :) In a way, she's MORE attractive BECAUSE of the mystery.

      But you can't say this because she sleeps naked, although all you see is her back (and there is a bath scene) ... it doesn't matter anyway. One of my friends and I decided that they figured by going the OPPOSITE route they'd end up with a winner - i.e. show no skin at all. Which worked to a point, I suppose, but my main point stands which is that the plot sucked a lot. :\

      And, hmm... I don't remember LH actually being a big offender on the fanservice front. But since I severely dislike that series, except for the Christmas Special (and I hear LH-Again is more in line with the special) for a simple reason...

      I do NOT like that cliche plot device that involves "Hey, we love each other, but we DON'T! And every time it looks like we might be getting close, something stupid happens!" I have the same problem with Ranma, but since they don't harp on it as much I can tolerate it. (Ranma's actually one of my favorites...)

      And yes, I'm aware that LH was designed purely to make fun of that cliche, but it still bugs me. :P

      Don't assume that because of an aside-point, I'm the standard "DRAGON BAWL Z IS KEWL HEHE GOKU CAN KICK ANYONES ASS" idiot. :P I'm much more of a shoujo fan, possibly because I was introduced to anime with Sailor Moon. (Which is still dear to me, even though I know it's absolutely awful to the point of being funny)

      Gawd, long-windedness...

    4. Re:Witch Hunter Robin by binarytoaster · · Score: 1

      I won't give away what happens (you already have, asshole)

      You have just made me laugh for the first time today. :P Yeah, I knew I was overexaggerating on the episode numbers (I still hold that the glasses thing was 6) but it still seemed THAT SLOW to me. (And I watched this at the rate of 6/day.) Yes, there were a couple of interesting moments before everything goes to hell (no more spoilers I promise) with a couple of the WCOTDs, but everything felt very disjointed and there really wasn't much CONTENT to the last bit. True, at least there was no Sailormoon-deadlock (where for 40 episodes you can follow the SAME FORMULA) after that, but it was either too predictable, or the *bad* kind of "WTF?"

      's okay. Maybe I just don't like mystery genre at all (but the friend I was with as we plowed through it in four days agreed with me) but this seemed to pale in comparison with, say, Abenobashi Mahou Shoutengai. (Gainax's take on a parody anime. Eek? :P)

    5. Re:Witch Hunter Robin by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I do NOT like that cliche plot device that involves "Hey, we love each other, but we DON'T! And every time it looks like we might be getting close, something stupid happens!" I have the same problem with Ranma, but since they don't harp on it as much I can tolerate it.

      EXCUSE ME?!? That was the whole fucking POINT of Ranma - they like each other, but whenever they start getting close, something stupid happens. Were you perhaps asleep while watching your 'favorite' series?

    6. Re:Witch Hunter Robin by binarytoaster · · Score: 1

      That was the whole fucking POINT of Ranma - they like each other, but whenever they start getting close, something stupid happens.

      Maybe YOU need to watch more Ranma. Yes, that is a recurring element, but you might as well say that Kuno's constant idiocy is the point of the anime. Ranma is MANY things. Love Hina is more in line with what you say - the entire plot is based around it! With Ranma, there are many other things that go on; Cologne and Shampoo's constant meddling comes instantly to mind, the incessant martial arts challenges, new techniques; Ryouga is a storyline in himself! Takahashi kept it to a good level of "something stupid happens when they get close" - in season 1(JP, season 2 Viz, thank you for the wonderful re-ordering of episodes) when they're about to kiss and Nabiki ruins it, that had me laughing, but if it was taken to the level of Love Hina, I wouldn't like it as much.

      As it is, they're afforded more opportunity to SHOW that they love each other (well, that's my opinion. Others think Ranma pairs better with one of the others.) than in LH. I don't mind the comedy! It's not a shoujo anime for warm and fuzzy!

      Blaaah...

  41. My Take by cryptochrome · · Score: 1

    NTHT on Cartoon Network? I think not. While not as explicit as some, it's one of the more brutal series on a psychological level. Christ man, it's got kids getting raped and beating each other to death. I'd like to see Saikano, Berserk, GTO, or Initial D, but like it or not there are limits. Maybe if AS was split off onto it's own channel with it's own age standards they could get away with it, but even then...

    FMP:F deserves to go on TV though, although I found the original boring and unoriginal. I never got to the end of Wolf's Rain but based on what I saw I liked. It's from the same people who did Cowboy Bebop and has top-notch animation, so it's highly likely it'll make it regardless. GITS:SAC is a no-brainer.

    Witch Hunter Robin, IMHO, blows. I have no idea why anyone would find this boring unimaginative series with its gigantic-craniumed characters appealing. Except perhaps for really angsty people like goths. To which I say, you should read/watch more shoujo. (On a side note, where did this infinite castle thing come from anyway? It was in Get Backers also...) For some reason I feel like mentioning I hated Noir too. All style, no substance.

    In my opinion, Cartoon Network or somebody should pick up the following shows, which are all really, really good and require little to no editing (although several need to be licensed and translated, and some would perhaps be better suited for Toonami, or better yet a non-existant mid-level block): Hajime no Ippo (rocks); Jungle wa Itsumo Hale Nochi Guu (damn funny); Naruto (duh); Hellsing (blood's OK if you've got vampires); Read or Die (Original OVA and TV); Excel Saga (insane, the logical follow-up to FLCL); Hunter X Hunter (grows on you); Last Exile (awesome); Nadia (old but good); NieA_7 (wierd); and others.

    Also, if Adult Swim Anime were to stop calling itself "Action" and break out into other genres they'd have more flexibility. Onegai Teacher/Twins would draw an audience and notoriety, I guarantee it. So would Love Hina and Chobits. Some of the more crossover Shoujos might do well if given the chance and the right advertising, like Fruits Basket.

    I could go on all day, but there's not that much point. Adult swim will get what their limited budget, limited influence on the production and distribution companies, limited time slots, limited late night audience, and Standards and Practices allows, and no more. I'm sure much of what we've suggested they've already thought about and either can't afford or can't clear with S&P. Hellsing comes to mind on both counts.

    --

    ---If you can't trust a nerd, who can you trust?

    1. Re:My Take by AnyNoMouse · · Score: 1
      Witch Hunter Robin, IMHO, blows. I have no idea why anyone would find this boring unimaginative series with its gigantic-craniumed characters appealing. Except perhaps for really angsty people like goths. To which I say, you should read/watch more shoujo. (On a side note, where did this infinite castle thing come from anyway? It was in Get Backers also...) For some reason I feel like mentioning I hated Noir too. All style, no substance.

      Unfortunately, with WHR, you have to get past the first 8-10 episodes before the "Witch of the Week" syndrome wears off. I wouldn't call it an awesome series, but it's not bad. I couldn't watch Getbackers.. :-( I liked Noir, but it ended badly... as did many anime from that particular year. Fortunately, Last Exile, Scrapped Princess and Ghost in the Shell TV made up for it :-)

      --
      -Redundancy Man strikes again!
    2. Re:My Take by cryptochrome · · Score: 1

      I didn't particularly enjoy Get Backers (or a lot of series of that ilk), although I watched it. Missed scrapped princess so I can't say.

      --

      ---If you can't trust a nerd, who can you trust?

    3. Re:My Take by Maul · · Score: 1

      I don't see FMP? Fumoffu being entertaining unless the original FMP! is watched, unfortunately. Fumoffu is downright funny, but only if you understand where the extreme character personalities are coming from. I think the original FMP! is a good show too, though.

      Witch Hunter Robin is a good series, IMO, but not superb or anything. Probably about the same level of Wolf's Rain and Noir. Good but not great due to certain flaws that can get annoying.

      Last Exile is a great show though. I really like the way that show was put together. I wish more shows could be like that.

      Read or Die and R.O.D. the TV would probably do well (they'd have to edit a small bit of it on CN), since they are both pretty fun. (Waiting for Episode 13 of TV series impatiently).

      Fruits Basket is a great show, but I don't know how it is recieved here. I'm not sure how popular non-magic girl shoujo is recieved by the standard American fan. Most people immediately think of Sailor Moon or CCS when they think "shoujo," and there is much more out there. My personal underrated favorite (even though it technically isn't shoujo) is Nanaka 6/17. Nobody is out to defeat evil, it's just about a 17 year old girl who suddenly thinks she's 6.

      Among what I'm currently watching:

      1. Shingetsutan Tsukihime
      Very slow and angsty. Probably a skip if you haven't played any of the related games. I don't forsee it ever coming out here for that reason.

      2. Fullmetal Alchemist
      This would do well here, I think. Good combo of action, story, etc. I consider it a "Trigun" calibur show, and I won't be surprised if it gets lisenced her by the end of 2004 and ends up on Cartoon Network to boot. Square-Enix is also releasing a FMA game, or so I here.

      3. Peacemaker Kurogane
      I'm a Shinsengumi fan, and this is all about the Shinsengumi. I can forsee this getting shoved at the Kenshin fans simply because it shares some historical characters. It'll probably eventually get lisenced, but I'm not sure if it'd be considered TV-worthy stateside.

      4. R.O.D The TV
      As I mentioned above, it is a fun show. It will probably be lisenced soon (if it isn't already, I'm not sure). As far as putting it on CN, I can see that happening with some minor edits.

      5. Bottle Fairy
      Crack enduced cuteness. Basically just something mindless to watch. It'll probably never come out here.

      6. Mermaid's Forest
      Takahashi can do some disturbing stuff, and this is one of them. I can forsee this being lisenced eventually and then stuck with a label "from the creator of Inuyasha," even though the Mermaid stories originated before Inuyasha did.

      7. Inuyasha
      I'm on episode 132 and I feel as if I'll watch this until I'm 80 at this rate. I'm really surprised that Viz hasn't done even the first movie yet, though, since movie #3 will be out soon in Japan.

      8. Mermaid Melody Pichi Pichi Pitch
      Don't ask my why I'm watching this show. I guess it is just amusing how many mahou shoujo cliches are being thrown about in this one. This will likely never, ever be lisenced or even talked about here.

      9. Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon
      Not technically anime. More like sentai for girls. Even so it is actually better than the animated version (IMO). Unfortuantely, sentai and other "effects" shows aren't really lisenced the same way (they get butchered and turned into Power Rangers instead). BUT, because it IS Sailor Moon, I suppose that there is a very small chance that someone will lisence it and release it subtitled on DVD.

      I just finished:

      1. Ultra Maniac
      It IS mahou shoujo, but it isn't the same type of show as Sailor Moon (it isn't "combat" based). I'm not sure if something like this would be lisenced.

      2. Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu
      See above. Since FMP! was lisenced, this will probably be snagged by ADV in the near future. I think it and FMP! are showable on TV.

      --

      "You spoony bard!" -Tellah

    4. Re:My Take by tuffy · · Score: 1
      I don't see FMP? Fumoffu being entertaining unless the original FMP! is watched, unfortunately. Fumoffu is downright funny, but only if you understand where the extreme character personalities are coming from. I think the original FMP! is a good show too, though.

      I have to disagree with this. Full Metal Panic: Fumoffu makes Sousuke's fish-out-of-water scenario obvious in the first episode and the supporting cast simply appears as the stories dictate. I watched about half of it before seeing a minute of the original and wasn't confused in the slightest. Only when Tessa appears near the end would a bit of backstory be helpful.

      But this isn't going to appear on TV before the original unless someone other than ADV licenses it.

      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

    5. Re:My Take by BJH · · Score: 1

      Anybody who says they're a Shinsengumi fan based on Peacemaker Kurogane needs to get a brain transplant.

    6. Re:My Take by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Missed scrapped princess so I can't say.

      It's still unlicensed, so it's easy to get. Here are some BitTorrent links (I'd recommend the Keep+ANBU version). The main character is kind of annoying (especially at first), and the series turns into a sci-fi story halfway through, but overall I liked it.

    7. Re:My Take by Maul · · Score: 1

      No, I'm a Shinsengumi fan. So I watch Peacemaker Kurogane to see what their take on the Shinsengumi is. Not the other way around. It is just nice to see another anime representation outside of Kenshin-land.

      I'd prefer to see someone do a highly realistic and more historically accurate Shinsengumi anime. To my knowledge there isn't anything like that out there.

      --

      "You spoony bard!" -Tellah

    8. Re:My Take by BJH · · Score: 1

      Ah, OK. But if you're after accuracy, go for a decent historical novel ("Moeyo Ken" by Shiba Ryotaro is a good one).
      Or if you don't mind manga, a list of pretty much all the Shinsengumi-related manga is available here. In particular, look out for Kurogane Hiroshi's manga - it offers quite a different perspective.

    9. Re:My Take by BigFire · · Score: 1

      Tsukihime is definately coming to R1. Genon (formerly Pioneer Entertainment) co-produced the show. It'll probably never be broadcast, consider how slow pace (and sometime bloody) the show is.

  42. Re:I've asked before by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I speak Japanese -- don't ask, not my choice, it happened because of a job

    What, you woke up one day, went to work, your boss gave you a "Learn Japanese in 24 Hours" book and all of a sudden you're an expert? Suuuuure.

  43. Re:I've asked before by The+Ape+With+No+Name · · Score: 1

    I don't think I have been watching the wrong bit of Anime as my cow-orkers have 1000s of hours of this shit and pop it into the office DVD player at every chance. Just a short dip into the brantub comes up sticky, if you know what I mean. But you are right, the short series is cool. Maybe this is what attracts some people to shows like '24' that have different approach to their very manner of presentation.

    --
    Comparing it to Windows will be a moot point, since El Dorado is going to have a 40% larger code base than XP.
  44. Re:I've asked before by The+Ape+With+No+Name · · Score: 1

    The Defense Language Institute is not a Berlitz course.

    --
    Comparing it to Windows will be a moot point, since El Dorado is going to have a 40% larger code base than XP.
  45. Re:Except for, that's not true.. by BJH · · Score: 1

    Yes, it was broadcast on a per-episode PPV basis on non-network TV, so they didn't actually have to follow Japanese TV standards (which, contrary to the poster above you, are fairly lax compared to US network TV).

  46. On a related note... GTO on Showtime! by May+Kasahara · · Score: 2, Informative

    The anime show Great Teacher Onizuka (better known as GTO has been picked up to air on SHO Next. If you've never seen GTO, it's a hilarious show about a former street punk who takes on a job teaching high school.

    1. Re:On a related note... GTO on Showtime! by bugbread · · Score: 1

      Urg. GTO.

      If you can read Japanese, please just buy the manga. The show is very faithful to the comic, but the humour in the comic is largely in the background chatter of people on the street, students in the hall, etc. You also have to know about current fads and fashions to get a lot of the jokes (the G-shock fad, short-lived slang, celebrities, etc.). I remember laughing so hard at the comic that I cried. I watched about two episodes of the cartoon before realizing that I hadn't actually laughed once, and that watching was a waste of my time.

    2. Re:On a related note... GTO on Showtime! by MoFoQ · · Score: 1

      yea...it is a hilarious show...especially if you understand japanese (the fansubs for the most part didn't do it justice).

      I hope they air it in its original form (dub can be on the second audio program and subs can be on CC).

  47. Pretty wolves... by cubyrop · · Score: 1

    The artsy fartsy, psuedo-nouveau WHR I can imagine being shown on CN, but Wolf's Rain? This is a top-notch show, but has mention been made that this is basically an anime about very pretty boys basically adoring each other and bonding in a not-altogether-nonsexual way?

    Is it possible to craft a dub that leans away from the limp-pawed, disaffected bishoujo-style angsty dialogue and still maintain the essential character of this show? It really _is_ about sexily-dressed guys bonding, I don't know how well that will go over with, well, anyone...

    On a positive note, the fabulous opening sequence could be kept intact, being that it's all English (thanks to Sting-wannabe doofus Steve Conte).

    --
    If I could make this sig kill you, I would.
    1. Re:Pretty wolves... by Maul · · Score: 1

      Ehh, while the main characters are essentially "pretty boys," I find it pretty hard to find sexual innuendo between THEM present in the show.

      There are some prominent female characters who serve as love interests (or at least psuedo love interests). Heck, the whole thing pretty much has the four main characters fighting to protect Cheza (the flower girl). That and Hige "hooks up" with Blue towards the end.

      My major problem with Wolf's Rain is that the ending of Episode 26 doesn't explain a damn thing about what's really going on. Apparently they are making some sort of OAVs, so hopefully they pick up where the TV show left off, because I was extremely confused by the whole ending.

      --

      "You spoony bard!" -Tellah

  48. Re:I've asked before by Yosho · · Score: 1

    I don't think I have been watching the wrong bit of Anime as my cow-orkers have 1000s of hours of this shit and pop it into the office DVD player at every chance.

    That doesn't necessarily mean anything. I'll bet you know lots of people who like watching "Friends," too. The reason there's so much crap out there is because, sadly, crap is good enough for most people. Even asking "So, what should I watch?" here on Slashdot will get you replies that mostly list the same popular-yet-not-that-good crap over and over.

    --
    Karma: Terrifying (mostly affected by atrocities you've committed)
  49. In case you didnt know by t0ny · · Score: 1

    Not really on topic, but of interest. A few weeks ago, I noticed you can buy the DVD box sets of all three Robotech series. At $35-45 each, they are pretty cheap too, especially compared with the Gundam Wing box set (which, if memory serves, is around $135).

    --

    Manipulate the moderator system! Mod someone as "overrated" today.

    1. Re:In case you didnt know by sprekken · · Score: 1

      Robotech.. ah, nostalgia! Man, I'd wake up at 5:00 am every morning and run downstairs to catch the show before getting on the bus to junior high school. It was the get-me-up juice in my life before I started drinking coffee.

      That show I think really started the Anime revolution here in America. I mean, they actually SHOWED people getting killed, rather than parachuting out of an already exploded jet plane (GI Joe). The drama was real, and for a kid of thirteen, entirely believable. I have the greatest memories of running around the back yard pretending to be fighting of the zendradi in my mech fighter.

      I still have my little model of the SDF-1 in my basement somewhere... maybe I should pull it out and mount it above the fireplace... hmmm. I don't think my wife would approve.

    2. Re:In case you didnt know by t0ny · · Score: 1
      I agree; when Ben died during the one battle, I remember that as one of my earliest, most powerful memories of any entertainment form. To me, as a youngster, it almost felt that one of MY friends had been killed, which I realized in terms of story made it all the more compelling.

      And I compared it to GI Joe as well ;-)

      --

      Manipulate the moderator system! Mod someone as "overrated" today.

    3. Re:In case you didnt know by tuffy · · Score: 1
      Not really on topic, but of interest. A few weeks ago, I noticed you can buy the DVD box sets of all three Robotech series. At $35-45 each, they are pretty cheap too, especially compared with the Gundam Wing box set (which, if memory serves, is around $135).

      ADV is completely remastering the original Robotech series from the original film stock. In addition, the sound is being remixed to 5.1 and additional scenes (originally cut for violence, etc.) are being re-added. So if you really like Robotech, you might want to wait for the new version.

      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

    4. Re:In case you didnt know by t0ny · · Score: 1

      I just read this today on The Register. They didnt specify which series was being re-released, however. Im assuming its Macross; is any other info available?

      --

      Manipulate the moderator system! Mod someone as "overrated" today.

    5. Re:In case you didnt know by tuffy · · Score: 1
      Here's ADV's press release:
      This newest release from ADV Films features a fresh, clean digital transfer of Robotech from the original film stock, returning the series to a lovely and near-pristine state without compromising the character of the original animation. New footage featuring scenes cut from the original broadcast version of Robotech has been added and also featuring new opening and closing credits and eye catches, creating a never-before-seen version of this seminal adventure series.

      Additionally, the audio has been restored and remixed to create the highest-quality sound experience available. Robotech Remastered: Extended Edition ($29.98 SRP) will feature two new audio tracks: the original, classic English-language dub in glorious digital 5.1 sound and a Spanish-language digital 5.1 track. In addition to the upgraded audio, the release is also subtitled in English.

      ----

      The first DVD volume, which will include the first twelve episodes on two discs with a handsome art box fitting both discs, will go on sale everywhere January 27, 2004.

      It sounds like they're re-doing the whole thing. Which isn't too surprising since they help finance the digital restoration of SDF Macross, Mospeada and SDC Southern Cross.
      --

      Ita erat quando hic adveni.

  50. So... by 93+Escort+Wagon · · Score: 0, Troll

    Is this the "News for Nerds", or does it fall under "Stuff that matters"?

    --
    #DeleteChrome
  51. Re:What's so special about Anime? by shadow_slicer · · Score: 1

    There's nothing "special" about Anime. I watch it because it's different and more interesting than what's available on tv (which is boring at best and downright turgid/dumb most of the time -- not to mention these shows ALWAYS manage to get their facts wrong...even news shows and the "Discovery" channel...).

    Whether the plots are incomprehensible, or have bad character development is mostly dependent on the series. I'll admit that there are a LOT of Anime out there that just plain suck. So I try to just watch the good ones. I watch the first 4 episodes and if it sucks I don't watch more.

    For me it's not the "obvious" 'I-wanna-shag-Asian-chicks(girls) thing'. In the Anime I watch at least, the girls don't look asian (what race of girl has blue hair anyway?). I watch it because it looks cool. I like the animation style (at least of the newer stuff, the older [70s] stuff where only the mouths move is...not so good). I find the characters more realistic and complicated than those on mainstream american tv. Mainly I probably enjoy it because it's different from american tv, and is not afraid to challenge certain values (in a way that lets the viewer draw their own conclusions) that american shows seem to step around (like god, or fate, or the nature of existence).

    As for the 'Alien Tentacle Rape stuff', I haven't seen any Anime like that (I haven't looked), the closest I've come is seeing an Anime that makes fun of the tentacle rape stuff (but that was pretty disturbing on its own) and that was with "Puni Puni Poemi Episode 2" (nasty show....but f-ing hilarious). Anyway It seems that every time someone is writing an objection to Anime they bring that up as if it typifies Anime (which is really just a red herring-- like if everytime someone brought up how much they hate american tv they'd also add, "and what of that wierd S/M stuff? Just fucking disturbing"). I would agree that if all Anime had tentacle rape stuff I would not watch it, but to discount an entire medium just because a small part (which only probably exists from my perspective) is aweful seems incredibly stupid (no offense).

  52. Rubbish by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Anime is overly dramatized, high school simpleton rubbish. Yes...ALL of it. You hear me? ALL OF IT. This is only bad news. The anime that gets played on Adult Swim only carves out precious time that could be used by the MUCH BETTER, MUCH MORE CLEVER items like Sealab and the like. A pox on all that is anime.

  53. Anime Characters = White by molafson · · Score: 0

    Why are the characters in anime always white? Why don't Japanese people want to see Japanese characters on TV?

    1. Re:Anime Characters = White by E-Rock-23 · · Score: 1

      They aren't "White" in that sense. It's probably the eyes throwing you off. The big eyes in Anime are used to designate youth and beauty, unless an artist sees fit to give the larger eyes to everyone in the series (like Dragonball or Pokemon).

      Example: look at Mobile Suit Gundam. Amuro is a young kid, thus he has the larger eyes, while a character like Bright Noah has more conventional eye design.

      --
      Blog Prophyts - Right On, Man
    2. Re:Anime Characters = White by molafson · · Score: 1
      They aren't "White" in that sense. It's probably the eyes throwing you off.

      No, a lot of them have blond or light brown hair as well as blue eyes (e.g. Sailor Moon, the kids on Digimon, and a million other ones I've seen but don't know the names).

    3. Re:Anime Characters = White by BJH · · Score: 1

      Doesn't matter. They're still basically intended to be Japanese; eye and hair colouring is just used to make it easier to distinguish between characters.

      If a character's really intended to be a Caucasian, they'll have freckles and curly hair. Every time, I guarantee it.

    4. Re:Anime Characters = White by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There's an excellent essay on this, "More Animated than Life"By Sato Kenji. He calls it "Ethnic Bleaching."

    5. Re:Anime Characters = White by FooBarWidget · · Score: 1

      Because they dyed their hair.

    6. Re:Anime Characters = White by foggi3 · · Score: 1

      because the japanese think that pale skin is more beautiful than darker or tanned skin, unlike americans who tans

      Anime characters have big eyes because they are regarded as a sign of beauty. Asians are obsessed with their eye sizes. In Japan and especially Korea, many women get their eyes enlarged. (Doesn't happen in China as often because Chinese people have pretty big eyes already)

      So if you ever wanna compliment that asian chick your class, tell her she has big, beautiful eyes.

      --
      ~~
  54. A Word On "All-Anime Channels" by E-Rock-23 · · Score: 1

    I'm all for it, really. An all-Anime channel would be a godsend for both hardcore and casual fans alike. But one channel wouldn't be enough. There should be two.

    It sounds a bit redundant, I know, but there's a silver lining to running things this way. Both channels would have identical broadcast schedules. Between, say, 7am and 7pm, you get TV series such as Ranma, Gundam, Tenchi, pretty much any series you'ld like to see plugged in. And with the abundance of series out there, there's a good chance that the daily schedules could differ from day to day. After 7pm, you get movies and such, like GitS, Iria, Spirited Away, etc.

    Here's the catch. The one major difference between the two channels is one will be English dubs, while the sister channel remains Japanese language with English subtitles. This way the casual fan gets the shows in English, and the more discerning Anime fans can quench thier thirst for Anime in it's purest form (well, as pure as it can get without ditching the translation altogether).

    Hell, there's even room for our own Rob Malda to host a show a-la A&E.

    What to call these networks? Well, all I can come up with is Anime-Dub and Anime-Sub. But I'd gladly pay a few extra bucks a month for this kind of programming option. Now, if only we could successfully pitch this to a major broadcaster. Since Turner has its Williams Street crew giving up the Anime on Cartoon Network, you'ld think they'd be interested in spinning off two new networks. They could keep them seperate from the more squeaky-clean Cartoon Network and Boomerang brands.

    --
    Blog Prophyts - Right On, Man
    1. Re:A Word On "All-Anime Channels" by Junta · · Score: 1

      What a *huge* waste of resources.
      It is *easy* for a single channel to offer this stuff.

      Use SAP to allow selection of your audio language (typically done in shows to offer alternative spanish sound in the US), and use closed captioning for subtitles.

      I know, closed captioning is ugly, but no company is going to piss away the resources to allocate two channels for what is an admittedly niche group in general. Dub anime is more widespread, and making the push for Closed Captioning/SAP delivery of subtitle format is a far easier sale. Besides, it is more flexible for those who want Japanese without subs.

      --
      XML is like violence. If it doesn't solve the problem, use more.
    2. Re:A Word On "All-Anime Channels" by Anonimo+Covarde · · Score: 1

      The problem is (and not to be blunt), most people find anime mostly uninteresting and almost no one would pay for an anime channel. You get a very unrepresentative view of anime appreciation when you read places like slashdot. There are huge numbers of anime fans to begin with and on top of that, the fans favorites are quite varied. Someone's favorite series is someone elses unwatchable shit.

      For an anime network to be successful, it would have to have a unrealistically high percentage of anime fans watching it, something you'd have a hard time selling to network heads.

  55. Re:I've asked before by ibmman85 · · Score: 0

    one of the reasons i like anime so much is because there is usually more of a plot, a running plot even, in a series then anything ive seen on american tv.. and they deal with things that i find more interesting with science and technology and other stuff somone already mentioned such as existance (evangelion...) and i also find comedy in anime to be funnier than most stuff here, like ranma, full metal panic fumoffu, love hina, heck even the first few episodes of trigun...

  56. Anime offends me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Seeing western characters with exaggerated big round eyes in a Japanese cartoon is offensive to me. If it were a Western cartoon showing slanty-eyed Orientals, all hell would break loose.

    1. Re:Anime offends me by MoneyT · · Score: 1

      The purpose of the large eyes in anime (and in many other animations like simpsons and futurama) is that eyes are very expresive. A persons eyes and how they move can tell us alot about what a person is thinking or feeling, and the eyes are a central part of a person's face (in fact it's usualy one of the first things you look at) so the eyes are drawn larger to give more freedom to display emotion and thought.

      --
      T Money
      World Domination with a plastic spoon since 1984
    2. Re:Anime offends me by bugbread · · Score: 1

      Actually, the eyes are drawn larger because Osamu Tezuka, grandpa of anime, loved and emulated Disney, and because most Japanese animators/manga artists base their drawing style off of other artists, as opposed to drawing from real life (same as in America). The result is a feedback loop with noses getting smaller and smaller and eyes getting bigger and bigger. Expressiveness may have been Disney's reasoning, but for anime now, it's just a fortunate happenstance.

    3. Re:Anime offends me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What, you mean like that stupid Jackie Chan cartoon?

  57. Actually, the shows you mention suck... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Harvey Birdman and Futurama are the only two shows there I can stand to watch. The rest of them I find incredibly vapid, boring, insipid, and pointless.

    Honestly, I can't even stand to listen to Home Movies... the voices are so bland it's almost painful. Yeah, I know it's supposed to be deadpan humour, but it just isn't very funny.

    Space Ghost feels like the writers stayed up too late and were drunk and tried to write a script that no one followed, anyhow. They have nothing to talk about and try to hide that by zapping Zorak or something when they're bored. I'm bored with it right from the start.

    Sealab 2021 is just stupid. I guess it's supposed to be funny because everyone in it is an idiot, but it's not. If I wanted to see idiots on TV, I'd be watching that reality crap or waiting for the upcoming presidential debates.

    Aquateen Hunger Force? I think this show has spoiled. I know it's supposed to be some kind of spoof of some of the product-inspired toons of the past, but it's not really any better than them. At least it might, occasionally be funny, but not often enough to justify watching it.

    The Family Guy? The Brak show? Does every damn show that wants to be "funny" have to make a show that might as well be called "Idiots on Parade"? I'm afraid these fall on the wrong side of the funny/stupid line. By FAR.

    Oh well, if you count that only 2 out of those 8 are any good... 25% is better than nothing, I guess. Me? I'll stick to the anime, thanks. There's a much better S/N ratio there (and I don't know how Home Movies could be counted as anything BUT noise... I cringe whenever I hear the voices in it).

    1. Re:Actually, the shows you mention suck... by ClioCJS · · Score: 1

      You, sir, need to free your mind.

      --
      -Clio
      Karma: Bad (mostly from not giving a fuck)
      Blog: http://clintjcl.wordpress.com
  58. Inuyasha by ghostfacehallik · · Score: 1

    I'm still waiting for them to get to the end of that series. Ghost in the Shell would be a nice addition though.

    1. Re:Inuyasha by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Good luck, I'm not sure the author has ever ended a series. =D

    2. Re:Inuyasha by genner · · Score: 1

      I'm almost certain that series hasn't ended in japan yet. Will be years before it does here if they even bother to show all the episodes.

  59. fuck by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I swear I had anime filtered out.

    Fucking tentacle-rape-watching perverts.

    1. Re:fuck by shidoshi · · Score: 1

      So is anybody who watches Western live-action movies automatically a porn addict because porn movies exist?

  60. Re:I've asked before by ghostfacehallik · · Score: 1

    You have obviously never seen Cowboy Bebop or Inuyasha just to name a few of the good one out there. There is alot of Anime out there you have to sift through it to find the good stuff.

  61. HELLSING! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'm surprised no one has mentioned Hellsing. It's one of the best newer series I've seen in a long time (13 episodes total). Very good animation and some good action.

    1. Re:HELLSING! by CaptMonkeyDLuffy · · Score: 1

      First half is good, second half(after the raid on the Hellsing headquarters) goes downhill IMO... That also happens to be the point in time when the animators stopped following the original comic... Character designs and plot from there on out I find better in the comic, which is actually slated for a US release...

      Though, as far as the actual anime went, the animation quality was pretty good(particularly in the first few episodes), but it was the music that really made it work in my opinion.

    2. Re:HELLSING! by gunnm · · Score: 1

      I give it high marks for style, but the rest wasn't exactly stellar. Then again, sometimes style is all you need :)

  62. Re:I've asked before by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    2 = a few?

  63. Re:I've asked before by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Oh, you're one of them... I've met a few military personnel who thought they spoke Japanese. Good for a laugh, anyway.

  64. hmmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    well, when 4kids does subbing, expect the worst, especially when they adapt decent animes and butcher them, change dialog completely and cut out scenes, and put politically correct crap in.

    Sonic X got completely ruined here in the US by 4kids, you should see the japanese version first

    4kids not only changes the voices, but the music as well, better companies usually keep the music in.
    The music is what makes that show bad ass in japan, but here, they play music that sounds like generic made tracks for syndicated shows you see on your local station that usually suck.
    In japan, the music is original and usually bad ass.
    That's my issue with dubs.
    subs let you keep the music.
    and sometimes, the voices are so bad that you actually cringe from the lameness or the shrill of the voices.

  65. Narutaru most misadvertised show EVER by cryptochrome · · Score: 1

    I feel compelled to mention, now that we're on the subject of intense content, that Narutaru (AKA Shadow Star) is THE most misadvertised show, EVER, in all respects, and even more intense than NTHT in its own right. Superficially it looks like Pokemon-type kids-with-magic-monsters, it's broadcast on Kid Station, the opening is cutesy, the first few episodes are inoffensive.

    Then the abuse and slaughter cuts in.

    And boy, does it get nasty. By the 13th episode anyone who isn't completely dead inside will be sickened by what's happening, even if they liked the show, and appalled at how misleading the previously mentioned things are. Apparently this had to do with the manga - it wasn't doing well in its original form for elementary kids, so the authors tweaked it "a bit" for an older audience, catching the US translators and distributors unaware, among others.

    I wouldn't be surprised the the TV Execs in Japan were fooled too, it happened before when they put Evangelion on at 5pm. The $64k question is will they make more anime or not?

    --

    ---If you can't trust a nerd, who can you trust?

  66. No. by cryptochrome · · Score: 1

    A) There's not a big enough market for it.
    B) Nobody could afford to license the TV rights for enough anime to cover a whole channel
    C) Even if you had access to every anime ever produced, it still wouldn't be enough for one channel and you'd be showing stuff over and over again once you'd gone through it all.
    D) What market the channel would have can't watch TV all day. Huge swaths of time would have essentially no viewership.
    E) That wouldn't stop the market from trying to watch as much as possible, and they'd get burnt out and stop watching.

    Bottom line - Adult Swim is actually doing the right thing here. They've got a daily time slot that keeps people coming back, and a strong brand that they can potentially expand when the time is right. Much like there is a Toonami block on KidsWB, there will probably eventually be an Adult Swim block one or two times a week on a regular channel in prime time (which is what AS needs the most), probably on the WB. In the meantime, they need to get enough of a library that they don't need to show the same things over and over again, and can do shows once a week instead of all week long to fill time.

    --

    ---If you can't trust a nerd, who can you trust?

    1. Re:No. by cryptochrome · · Score: 1

      Oh yeah. Also:
      F) What market there is would be filtered by the fact that it would be on digital cable only, as there is no longer room on the (far more widespread) analog cable spectrum for it, at least not without eliminating something else. I only got Cartoon Network itself 2 years ago on my local cable provider (Goddamn Comcast).

      --

      ---If you can't trust a nerd, who can you trust?

    2. Re:No. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      On point C, you are DEAD wrong. Get a copy of the Anime Encyclopedia. There is probably close to a million hours of anime in the can, tens of thousands of episodes. A fair amount of it has even been dubbed into English. And a fair amount has not, which leaves a lot of "brand new" material.

      So the content IS out there.

      Point D is the killer: until somebody tries it, nobody knows if there's enough eyeballs to make it work 24/7. Some of the cable channels get around it by producing one chunck of programming and just repeating it all day long (Science channel), others by simple reruns (Tech TV). But daytime ratings are low anyway. Prime time ratings are what the advertisers want.

  67. Re:I've asked before by The+Ape+With+No+Name · · Score: 1

    Yeah, you can never forget the sheer magnitude of crap in the world. That's for the correction.

    --
    Comparing it to Windows will be a moot point, since El Dorado is going to have a 40% larger code base than XP.
  68. Re:I've asked before by bugbread · · Score: 1

    I dunno about your coworkers, but my coworkers (I live in Japan) tend to only go on about the stuff they liked as kids. It's all dreadfully boring & stupid, but then if somebody came up to me and started talking GI Joe or Transformers, I'd probably be happy as a clam. For people from their late 20's to late 30's in Japan, anime is the stuff from their childhood, not all the shojo/tentacle/whathaveyou that gets produced now.

    That said, there is good anime, but there are also good books, good movies, and good musicians. That doesn't stop stores from being full of diet books, I Know What You Did Last Summer, and Brittney Spears. Any medium is mostly composed of crap. Anime and manga are the same. However, for a country that doesn't have this medium (well, America has cartoons, but not mature cartoons (and by mature I don't mean sex and violence, I just mean aimed at adults)), I can see the draw. It's like if you lived in a country with no movies: you'd think movies were awesome and you'd want movies to be imported. You might even be blinded to the fact that the Pluto Nash you're watching is absolute crap.

    I don't know your tastes, so I wouldn't know what to recommend, but stuff that I've liked (which is not necessarily the typical alpha-geek anime/manga selection) is: Silent Service (Chinmoku no kantai) about a Japanese submarine crew which steals their sub, declares independence from Japan, and has a huge huge amount of politics (well done, in that all countries positions are understandable and realistic), Naniwa Kinyudo, about how loan sharks work (written by an ex-lawyer, and very accurate), and Nausicaa (yeah, yeah, I know, typical famous manga dreck, but unlike the horrible anime version, very complex, very long, and very interesting).

    There is good stuff out there, that isn't about tentacles, junior high girls, robots, or exploding heads, but as with any medium, the majority is dreck.

    Oh, and as a rule of thumb, only take anime/manga recommendations from coworkers who also recommend good movies or good books. A Japanese worker who loved Armaggedon and Speed is going to have equally horrible tastes in anime.

  69. Re:I've asked before by The+Ape+With+No+Name · · Score: 1

    No. Not military. I could never pass one of their requirements that deals with "unit cohesion." Besides, I never said I was an expert. That's near impossible, but let's just say this: all the white dudes who would end sentences with ne when I was in Sapporo would immediately get pegged as Anime watching wackoffs. Why? Only women and children do this. I am a yo man myself, but I do conjugate suru. Still, I am no Toshiro Mifune, that's for sure.

    --
    Comparing it to Windows will be a moot point, since El Dorado is going to have a 40% larger code base than XP.
  70. off topic, sorry by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    As long as we are talking about Cartoon Network, I got to wondering, is Mainframe Entertainment ever going to bring the show Reboot back and continue the story where they left off?

  71. What I would like to see.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Is Naruto licensed and released over here by CN...I usually like the more serious anime series', but Naruto is just pain fun, and for all those who would compare it with DBZ its worlds above it..there's actually *gasp* character development...

  72. Actually, it's the former, not the latter. by jonskerr · · Score: 1

    If the sentence says Ghost in the Shell (the movie) and GitS (The TV Series), the first one in the sentence is the former, and the latter one in the sentence is the latter.

    --
    O~ Him that studies revenge keeps his own wounds green. -- Francis Bacon
  73. Witch Hunter Robin is ass by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Goddamn this series sucked hard. The animation was superb and the first few episodes were entertaining, but past that it got repetitive, stupid, and the ending was definitely not worth the trip.

    Things get really goofy and bizarre as the series progresses, and it undoes all the good stuff that it builds up in the early episodes. My advice is to watch it until Robin gets control of her Ultimate Witch Skill or whatever it is, then stop watching and pretend it was a great series that ended in an untimely manner, rather than farting out a few cliches and predictable endings later on.

  74. Re:I've asked before by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The point is that they have thousands of hours of shit. I have a lot of stuff too, but only a quick sample of most things. I only make sure to get something if it really is good.

    I know people who have thousands of hours of movies, and I almost never like what they throw on, because they are watching the medium to death.

    If you want good anime, you need to be picky. It takes a bit to learn how to recognize the good anime.

    If you like dark, powerful stories: Now and Then, Here and There.

    If you like action/sci-fi stories: Hellsing or Cowboy Bebop

    Comedy: Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu

    Sarcastic and Messed-Up Comedy: Excel Saga

    Mentally Challenging/Psychological/Action: Evangelion

    (These suggestions were from what I like, so they won't apply to a great many people)

    Basically, as with any other medium, it has something for most any taste. All things considered, I mostly watch it because I really can't stand what is on American TV. I watch anime and movies, that is all. Anime is in easy-to-consume twenty-two minute blocks which I can throw in whenever I watch something short. Movies are longer and fill longer blocks of time. Both have thought/conversation provoking material, depending on who I am watching them with.

    Also, and this likely will never apply to you, I am an artist (not too good) and do some animation (not too well) and I enjoy watching some anime purely as art (for that, try "The Wings of Honneamise"; it is truly incredible). Likewise, in some movies I appreciate the lighting and sound more than the acting and story (although it needs to have at least a decent story with okay acting, or I can't take it).

    Enough rambling.

  75. Re:Except for, that's not true.. by bbk · · Score: 1

    Well, there's the whole episode about the guy who skins people alive. That'll need some cutting - I felt quite ill after watching it, and it takes a lot to get me there..

    BBK

  76. Here's an idea? Fill the DVD. by ChaosDiscord · · Score: 1
    I've seen where the producer will release either the first DVD (too many titles to name) or the last DVD (FLCL) in a box designed to hold all of the DVD's in the series.

    How about releasing the DVDs actually filled with content instead of shipping DVDs with 50 minutes of video so I need to store piles of them.

    God, that irritates me. FLCL is a great series, but it's only 2 hours, 30 minutes long. It fits on a single DVD with space to spare. Why is FLCL spread out over three DVDs? Okay, so the publisher wants to be greedy and justify the $65 I'm going to have to spend on it ("Oooooh, look, I get three pieces of $0.50 plastic instead of just one"). Just gouge me the $65 and give me a single, easy to store DVD. You've got a government granted monopoly in the form of copyright, your customers are relatively price tolerant.

    Greedy, customer hating, fscking publishers.

    1. Re:Here's an idea? Fill the DVD. by DavidBrown · · Score: 1

      How about releasing the DVDs actually filled with content instead of shipping DVDs with 50 minutes of video so I need to store piles of them.

      God, that irritates me. FLCL is a great series, but it's only 2 hours, 30 minutes long. It fits on a single DVD with space to spare. Why is FLCL spread out over three DVDs? Okay, so the publisher wants to be greedy and justify the $65 I'm going to have to spend on it ("Oooooh, look, I get three pieces of $0.50 plastic instead of just one"). Just gouge me the $65 and give me a single, easy to store DVD. You've got a government granted monopoly in the form of copyright, your customers are relatively price tolerant.


      I absolutely agree with you, but I tend not to get angry about it if there are at least four episodes on the DVD. When I see three episodes on a DVD, I feel ripped off. It's probably just because VCR tapes could hold only two hours in SP mode and AnimEigo set the standard by selling Urusei Yatusura with four episodes per tape (I was buying anime before DVDs existed).

      Maybe what they ought to do is to release the first 2-3 episodes on a single DVD and sell it cheap enough to get people willing to risk buying it, and then cram succeeding DVDs with as many episodes as can fit, because those DVDs will be bought by people who want the whole series.

      Better yet, how about a single "teaser" DVD, sold for $10, with first episodes from six or eight different series. I'd buy that, even if I may be interested in only one or two of the programs, because it's anime and it's cheap and it may lead me to discover good anime (and buy DVD's) that I would have otherwise completely ignored.

      --
      144l. ph34r my 133t l3g4l 5k1lz!
  77. Re:Except for, that's not true.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yes, it was broadcast on a per-episode PPV basis on non-network TV, so they didn't actually have to follow Japanese TV standards (which, contrary to the poster above you, are fairly lax compared to US network TV).

    In all the fansubs I've seen, the bottom of the TV Tokyo logo is visible right before the credits. AFAIK, TV Tokyo is a broadcast network, not pay-per-view.

    Cartoon Network is a cable channel, which also has fairly lax standards compared to US network TV. So they can probably show it without editing, especially at night.

  78. Full Metal Panic 2 by chendo · · Score: 3, Informative
    I've finished watching the subbed versions, and I have to say this is one of the most hillarious anime I've ever watched.

    It's just the original Full Metal Panic, without most of the serious stuff. For those who doesn't know, the original Full Metal Panic had Sagara Souske, a professional solider/teenager (with absolutely -zero- common sense and social skills) assigned to protect Chidori Kaname from the Russians because she is one of the 'Whispered', people who are born with 'Black' technology. Sagara is part of Mithril, a self-appointed military division.
    Sosuke Sagara is an elite soldier who belongs to an independent special force named "Mithril". Mithril is a self appointed military force that fights terrorism across the globe. With technology that is far superior to that of normal nations, Mithril intercedes on behalf of justice. Sagara, a Second Lieutenant under Mithril's command, is assigned to the duty of protecting a girl named Kaname Chidori, who attends high school in Japan. To accomplish this task, he pretends to be a transfer student attending at Kaname's school. As Sagara settles into his new role as classmate, a massive plot unfolds beginning with the kidnapping of Chidori. What is Chidori's role in the conspiracy? Why does she seem to be born with knowledge of technology that has only been recently invented?
    (Taken from animenfo.com)

    Full Metal Panic 2 (Also known as Full Metal Panic : Fumoffu) is more about Sagara and Chidori than about the whole Mithril thing. I mean, he blows up his shoebox with plastic explosives because he found a hair in front of his shoebox and thought that someone sent him a mailbomb, when in fact it was a love letter.

    One of my favourite episodes was the Rugby one (ep 10), and it was aired just before the World Cup started. Turning a team of pansies into killers... bwahahahahahhaa

    Anyhow, FMP2 is a great series and I suggest you check it out while it's still unlicensed. Also, FMP3 is rumored to be in the planning and will focus more of the military-side of things. Which I find very interesting as well. And if I didn't mention it eariler, FMP contains mecha called Arm Slaves (AS), and Souske is a good pilot of it. FMP2 contains a mechanized teddy bear costume named 'Bonta-kun', that Sousuke made himself after he stole the costume from a theme park, and he absolutely kicks ASS!
    --
    Founder of Mirror Moon - Tsukihime Game Trans
  79. samurai jack? by websensei · · Score: 1

    when will they bring it back?
    why isn't it available (in its entirety) on dvd?
    sigh.

    --

    La via sola al paradiso incommincia nel inferno
  80. Canada... by drskrud · · Score: 1

    Now if only Teletoon and/or Space would catch on and start showing some more Anime! YTV has always been anime-friendly but they appear to be restricted to their Youth format and only show such things as Dragonball, Inuyasha, Cardcaptor Sakura, Beyblade, Pokemon, etc.

    Space, on the other hand, has been claiming in their FAQ for the past 4 years that they've tried showing Anime before on a weekly basis but that it didn't make much of an impact in ratings. I think it's about time they reevalutated their stance, however. Spirited Away won an Oscar, and the Animatrix is awesome bridge between the (often overlapping) realms of Sci-Fi and Anime. Meanwhile, shows like Cowboy Bebop, Outlaw Star, and movies like Ghost In The Shell exist squarely within Space station's format and I for one think that they deserve a chance at proving themselves on Canadian cable television.

  81. Might just be me by k3vmo · · Score: 0

    I like these shows and watch many of them, but I feel like I'm the only one that misses the days of Bugs Bunny, Tom & Jerry etc ...

  82. Re:I've asked before by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Not to mention InuYasha got a bit repetitive somewhere in the 20's. Wee I found another shard! Oh no, sexual angst between Inuyasha and the priestess and her reincarnation, the short-skirted schoolgirl!

  83. Re:Except for, that's not true.. by BJH · · Score: 1

    TV Tokyo helped fund the series; it didn't broadcast it.

  84. I know Mainstream is good, but... by Fallout2man · · Score: 0

    Can you quite honestly say you think it's good to set a trend of censoring all anime to broadcast it?

    Cartoon network, even in its famed adult swim, does very much so censor anime. I really don't like the trend this sets, in fact I've refused to watch their network on a whole after how horribly they butchered Tenchi Muyo! back several years ago.

    So I personally would prefer anime just not be broadcast to this, as I detest censorship of any kind and the effects it has are often very wide reaching. Tenchi Muyo had its plot blurred and obfuscated because of it, and other animes suffered a similar fate and yet more may as well if this sort of thing continues. Just say no to censorship, hold out for the ideal, uncut anime.

  85. UROSUKIDOJI!!!! by A55M0NKEY · · Score: 2, Funny
    My first anime viewing experience since Voltron.

    hhehehehe

    --

    Eat at Joe's.

  86. URL Correction by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1

    It should have been www.witchhunteronline.com. Warning - you need flash to view it.

  87. flcl by acxr+is+wasted · · Score: 1

    Does it matter? Nope... none of it does until they bring Furi Kuri back!

    --
    "Come on, let's go drink till we can't feel feelings anymore."
  88. No subtitles, no subtext, just fun! by fm6 · · Score: 1
    when was the last time you saw anything on mainstream media subtitled?
    I think it was a Klingon conversation in one of the Star Trek movies. Definitely an exception that proves the rule...

    You're quite right, American entertainment conglomerates are afraid to make their audiences do any work. Like read subtitles. Or follow complicated plots. Or deal with moral ambiguity....

  89. Re:I've asked before by gunnm · · Score: 1

    1. The laws of physics need not apply. This can make for some rather funny situations (granted, hollywood special effects are catching up here) 2. It is easy(cheap) to create fantastic settings. 3. It is possible to create some amazing costumes. 4. The director has more "control" over everything, making it easier to create a certain "feel".

  90. Re:GitS: Stand Alone Complex won't need much editi by BigFire · · Score: 1

    While most of the episode doesn't require editing, some requires major surgery. In the episode "Jungle Cruise", Boutu of Section 9 confronts his past as a CIA operative who conducts psyop warfare on a gurella forces. One of his former comrad went insane himself, and took that technique to Japan in an attempt to get Boutu to kill him. The psyop warfare technique involves skinning a women, while keeping her alive to be found by her people. I just don't see how they're going to get around the issue of skinning.

  91. BTW - Parent Editorial about FLCL on CN by cyranoVR · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Yeah, I could hardly believe the "bare-assed antics" either (especially when you realize the result is that Naota pops wood).

    Neither could this woman (she obviously doesn't understand the concept of "Adult" Swim).

    1. Re:BTW - Parent Editorial about FLCL on CN by Shadwhawk · · Score: 1

      I saw that letter; it caused quite a commotion, at least among fans. I wrote a hasty reply, but it was too long to print and I wasn't too happy with it afterwards. By then, though, the letter was already over a week old, so my reply probably wouldn't've been printed even if I had revised it. I'll be better prepared next time; I predict some parent(s) will go into a fit when Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex starts airing.

  92. 6 vs 26 by E-Rock-23 · · Score: 1

    So, you'ld rather watch the same 6 episodes of FLCL over and over again as opposed to 26 episodes of a new series? Don't get me wrong, I like FLCL and Cowboy Bebop, but damn! There are only so many repeats a guy can take! And I, for one, and ready for some new series that I haven't seen yet...

    --
    Blog Prophyts - Right On, Man
    1. Re:6 vs 26 by acxr+is+wasted · · Score: 1

      It's all a matter of drugs. So long as one never sees FLCL sober, it's a new experience every time!

      --
      "Come on, let's go drink till we can't feel feelings anymore."
  93. Re: Apparently not by Lord+Bitman · · Score: 1

    wuss

    --
    -- 'The' Lord and Master Bitman On High, Master Of All