Slashdot Mirror


Make the Debian CDs Better by Installing popcon

JayBonci writes "Not popcorn, popcon! (Short for popularity-contest) According to a recent message posted to debian-devel-announce, popcon numbers are being used to determine how things get arranged on the 13 CDs of the upcoming Debian stable release. Participation so far has been good, but the project could use more numbers from a broader user base. Please take a moment to install the package 'popularity-contest,' and help us make the distro better by allowing it to send us anonymous package usage statistics. You can see the results at Popularity Contest page."

378 comments

  1. Don't forget... by SCO$699FeeTroll · · Score: -1

    ...to pay your $699 licensing fee you cock-smoking teabaggers.

  2. Freedopws Owns by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Freedows! The best OS ever! Puts linux to shame!
    http://sourceforge.net/projects/freedows

    1. Re:Freedopws Owns by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
      From the page:

      This Project Has Not Released Any Files


      RELEASE SOMETHING DIPSHIT! At least Linus released SOMETHING.

    2. Re:Freedopws Owns by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      OMFG!!! I Thoguht freedows died back in 1999!!!!!!!

  3. John "Eff'ing" Kerry by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    KERRY CALLED SECRET SERVICE AGENT 'SON OF A BITCH' AFTER SLOPE SPILL

    Dem presidential candidate John Kerry called his secret service agent a "son of a bitch" after the agent inadvertently moved into his path during a ski mishap in Idaho, sending Kerry falling into the snow.

    When asked a moment later about the incident by a reporter on the ski run, Kerry said sharply, "I don't fall down," the "son of a b*itch knocked me over."

    The Secret Service agent in question has complained about Kerry's treatment, top sources tell the DRUDGE REPORT.

    Last month, Kerry began receiving Secret Service protection.

    "Obviously, the complications and burden of being monitored 24-hours a day is not just an a simple inconvenience," a government source explained Friday. "But Senator Kerry should understand agents are working for his safety and well-being."

    On Friday, Kerry, his snowboard strapped to his back, hiked past 9,000 feet on Durrance Peak, then snowboarded down the mountain, taking repeated tumbles. Reporters counted six falls, although Kerry was out of sight for part of the descent.

  4. 3rd post, bitch!!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    3rd post, bitch!!!!

  5. I have this... by byolinux · · Score: 5, Funny

    Here's hoping I can get xbill to the top of the list.

    1. Re:I have this... by tmillard · · Score: 3, Funny

      I love xbill. You just shoot tomatotes at Mr. Gates.

      It remindes me of a dart game I saw on the Apple OS.

    2. Re:I have this... by webtre · · Score: 0

      LNG is Not GNU

      --
      litigious bastards
      suck it sco!
    3. Re:I have this... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      It says the fact that people have been over Bill. Now they are waiting for someone to come up an xdarl sort of thing.

    4. Re:I have this... by T-Ranger · · Score: 1

      Except that everything starts out as Linux, and Darl walks around taking them down. Hmm.. The Anti-XBill.

    5. Re:I have this... by Emperor+Tiberius · · Score: 1

      In xdarl, Darl and Bill would operate together in the shadows. You'd have a large Linux network, Darl will go off in the shadows, get $86 million from Bill, and come back with licenses and lawyers. Actually, in retrospect, it would be cool if someone actually coded this.

  6. This is a really good idea by dealsites · · Score: 5, Insightful

    As a Linux newbie (currently don't have Linux installed, but have used it and plan to install it soon), it would be nice to know which are the most popular packages. Most people would like to have an idea of what the more experienced users use, and thus would like to try it themselves. In addition to knowing the most popular packages, it would probably be a quicker install be having the best ones at the beginning of the installation process instead of having to swap CDs too many times.

    --
    Real time deal updates from all the major deal sites. Search easy and quickly!

    1. Re:This is a really good idea by Rosco+P.+Coltrane · · Score: 1, Funny

      As a Linux newbie (currently don't have Linux installed, but have used it and plan to install it soon), it would be nice to know which are the most popular packages

      I think kernel-image*.deb and libc6*.dev rate quite high.

      --
      "A door is what a dog is perpetually on the wrong side of" - Ogden Nash
    2. Re:This is a really good idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

      The most used stuff=the stuff that's installed by default.

      else check freshmeat's popularity ranking

    3. Re:This is a really good idea by byolinux · · Score: 0, Interesting

      Just make sure you install gnome and emacs. Someone is bound to say KDE and vi, but real people who actually want to work, I feel KDE is too much like eye candy.

      Gnome 2.6 is where it's at.

      emacs is the editor for the GNU generation. Real work gets done in it, though I guess it can be bulky if you just wanna edit a .conf

    4. Re:This is a really good idea by ameoba · · Score: 5, Insightful

      The thing about the Debian install process is that you don't need all 13 CDs. After you do the base install, you scan the CDs that you feel like using and they get added to your local list of available packages (be it none, 1,2 or all 13). The first 2 CDs cover most of the stuff that you need to get the system working; by the time you get to the last disc, we're talking about some pretty obscure stuff that only has 3 users (2 of them are the devs and the 3rd is the guy making the package).

      This is already a pretty reasonable distibution of files on the first 2 discs (the installer, OTOH still needs a lot of work; the new installer is a bit nicer than the old one but it doesn't really work all the time & there's some inconsistancies in it (like when you're partitioning drives, the drive labels in fdisk aren't the same as the names you see when you're assigning mountpoints to drives (which isn't even able to recognize swap devices as such & call them swap by default))) but it could always be perfected a bit. I have to wonder why they can't extract this from the logs on the mirrors tho...

      --
      my sig's at the bottom of the page.
    5. Re:This is a really good idea by C10H14N2 · · Score: 4, Funny

      It's pretty easy. 90% of the packages are installed by less, usually FAR less, than half the users. Although, I must admit I found it humorous that the package tracking the usage was installed by less than the total number of users ostensibly reporting.

      WTF?

    6. Re:This is a really good idea by Mr.+Darl+McBride · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      Rosco P. Coltrane, you are a wit! Git git git hee hee hee! Now GET them DUKE boys!!!

    7. Re:This is a really good idea by BiggerIsBetter · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Uh, I have never used Tex. And it's installed (and updated) by default by every version of Debian I've tried.

      --
      Forget thrust, drag, lift and weight. Airplanes fly because of money.
    8. Re:This is a really good idea by Penguinshit · · Score: 5, Informative


      Actually, the best way is to just use Disc 1, get the base installation, and then do the rest via network (assuming you're on broadband - I shudder to think what an installation would be like over dialup).

      This way you get the latest "stable" (oxymoron, I know) and all of the security updates as well.

      I install Debian this way all the time (well, every time I'm doing a fresh installation).

    9. Re:This is a really good idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Peronally, I'd be very interested in a pure console-based install (including framebuffer & svgalib support). I imagine it would fit in only a couple CDs, and would work well for servers also.

    10. Re:This is a really good idea by adamshelley · · Score: 1

      If you are using KDE, the apps page, has a feedback option. It doesn't automatically guess what packages are better but the more people who use it the better it'll be.

    11. Re:This is a really good idea by Orgazmus · · Score: 1, Funny

      Or if you want to do your work without having too boot up at 6 in the morning for gnome and emacs to be ready at 8, you use xfce4 and jed ;)

      --
      The system had the verbosity of HTML combined with all the readability of compiled assembly viewed as bitmap images
    12. Re:This is a really good idea by byolinux · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      what hardware you running there? i'm on an old p3-500 with 128mb and it's all booted and ready in like 4-5 mins.

    13. Re:This is a really good idea by ticklemeozmo · · Score: 1

      My only issue is:

      The part-timers or learners may have chosen a "default" install, which installs packages that never gets used but are included for "posterity" sake.

      Unless I'm wrong (and please correct me), one of the packages that gets installed by default in all redhat/fedora (where most people start from) seems to be "isdn-utils". And (again, unless I'm wrong), there really is no need for them to be in any default install these days, nor on the 1st CD of anything.

      --
      When modding "Informative", please make sure it both has a source and IS actually informative.
    14. Re:This is a really good idea by Orgazmus · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      And of course, I didnt fatten up the times a bit to make a point.
      Gnome feels sluggish.

      --
      The system had the verbosity of HTML combined with all the readability of compiled assembly viewed as bitmap images
    15. Re:This is a really good idea by Orgazmus · · Score: 1

      Well, it cant be PERFECT, can it? ;)

      --
      The system had the verbosity of HTML combined with all the readability of compiled assembly viewed as bitmap images
    16. Re:This is a really good idea by Avihson · · Score: 1

      That is why I always chose custom for redhat and fedora. Even as a newbie, I was concerned about installing "the wrong thing".

      I'm now playing with mepis, a debian based distro and it installs ADSL/PPPOE on a laptop that only has a wireless Nic.

      I find it amazing that it can see through two routers and figure out that we connect via DSL, but not know that PPOE is not an option on my business lines!

      Other than that, mepis is a great learner system.

    17. Re:This is a really good idea by gabebear · · Score: 1

      I've installed a stabel base and then upgraded to unstable over dialup. It took it about 12 hours to get the packages I wanted.

    18. Re:This is a really good idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And you're the entire linux population, aren't you!!!

    19. Re:This is a really good idea by Imperator · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Bad idea. Reasons:

      • Debian users might not be representative of Linux users. Certainly not newbies.
      • The most popular packages are the ones you don't really have a choice about. (For example, tar.)
      • For a newbie, the vast majority of packages are ones that even if you install, you'll never use directly in the way you think of using a program on Windows. (For example, ncurses.)
      • Where choices do exist, many people will use an older package out of familiarity and habit. (For example, some people swear that their lives have improved dramatically since they stopped using vixie-cron, but I still use it over the alternatives.)

      I encourage you to install Linux, and Debian is a fine distribution for you if you're interested in learning. But don't look at package popularity. If you need help choosing between different packages that do the same thing, there are better places to look.

      --

      Gates' Law: Every 18 months, the speed of software halves.
    20. Re:This is a really good idea by HeTTaR · · Score: 1

      It is slow realllly reallly slow. I have done it several times, takes about 2 - 3 days to get sid all up and running on a 56k modem =o( Luckly I have ADSL in a week or so =o)

      --
      Hettar.
    21. Re:This is a really good idea by Drantin · · Score: 1

      hm... the way I've done it twice recently is to get to the point where it's about to fetch things to install, alt-f2 over to another tty and have it include testing and unstable...(that way there's nearly no replacing of packages...)

      --
      Actio personalis moritur cum persona. (Dead men don't sue)
    22. Re:This is a really good idea by fracex · · Score: 2, Interesting

      One time I was planning on doing a network install, after installing the first cd, over dial-up. Unfortunantly I could not get the modem driver to work no matter what. On second though maybe it was for the better.

    23. Re:This is a really good idea by AxelBoldt · · Score: 1

      It would comfortably fit on a floppy disk (tomsrtbt).

    24. Re:This is a really good idea by zerocool^ · · Score: 2, Informative

      Actually, the best way is to just use Disc 1, get the base installation, and then do the rest via network (assuming you're on broadband - I shudder to think what an installation would be like over dialup).


      Where I work, we have a local 100Mbit Debian stable mirror. When ever we install debian on a customer's machine, or one of our own, we obviously set the apt-sources to use the local. It's usually faster than installing off of multiple CD's (all I've ever seen is debian CD1, I wasn't even aware that there were 13 of them). Interesting to think that, for a lot of things, a 48x cdrom is slower than ethernet... but whatever. Plus we get lots of "Hey, what the heck mirror am I using, it's fast!?!?", and it makes us smile.

      HTTP is the way to go for local mirrors, by the way, especially when getting multiple packages (like, say, "base system"?). That is, you're using vsftp, because you obviously care about security, and you're also too lazy to set up something that tells vsftp (or is it xinetd) to shut up, no that's not someone DDoSing the connection, those are real transfers. And by you, I mean me.

      ~Will

      --
      sig?
    25. Re:This is a really good idea by lspd · · Score: 4, Informative

      Actually, the best way is to just use Disc 1, get the base installation, and then do the rest via network (assuming you're on broadband - I shudder to think what an installation would be like over dialup).

      When you can get a DVD+-R to work in another computer, the DVD's (1 for stable, 2 for testing or unstable) are quite nice. If you have hard-drive space to burn you can also grab the ISO's and mount them using loopback devices.

    26. Re:This is a really good idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Everyone's downloaded a kernel on dialup. C'mon.

    27. Re:This is a really good idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      When you can get a DVD+-R to work in another computer, the DVD's (1 for stable, 2 for testing or unstable) are quite nice. If you have hard-drive space to burn you can also grab the ISO's and mount them using loopback devices.

      But like he said, why bother, especially if you have a local mirror of Debian. It's much faster to install over the network. Actually, now that I think about it, I've never installed Debian any other way. I start with a small 38 meg base net install CD and build my system from that. 95% of the packages in testing or unstable would be obsolete within 2 weeks of burning the DVD anyway, so why waste the time?

    28. Re:This is a really good idea by lspd · · Score: 1

      95% of the packages in testing or unstable would be obsolete within 2 weeks of burning the DVD anyway, so why waste the time?

      It's not nearly that bad. Most of the packages in Debian are rarely updated, so it's fairly easy to keep the ISOs up to date with Jigdo. The real advantage is that it makes installation go faster and you can give a copy to someone with dial-up access.

    29. Re:This is a really good idea by martin-boundary · · Score: 2, Funny

      Maybe one of the package's source code contributors is a Diebold employee?

    30. Re:This is a really good idea by alienmole · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I have a Debian server rented at a hosting company that gets 30Mbps actual throughput to various Debian mirrors and other download sites. Who needs a local mirror, all you need are fat pipes! ;)

    31. Re:This is a really good idea by discogravy · · Score: 1
      Debian users might not be representative of Linux users. Certainly not newbies.

      but they're representative of debian users. and this is a poll to determine the needs of debian users. newbies....well, they shouldn't be installing debian by themselves until debian decides that a GUI installer might not be a bad thing. I'm guessing it'll get into stable by 2011. Maybe.

    32. Re:This is a really good idea by deinol · · Score: 2, Interesting

      How does it determine popularity?

      Does it actually look at what gets used, or just what is installed?

      I have 357 packages installed on my debian machine. Most of those are just there due to my distribution's base install. I was lazy and used knoppix. I don't even use X on that system.

      Now, the packages I actually use on it are:

      vi
      gcc
      perl
      exim
      ssh
      nethack
      apache
      wuftp
      samba
      ices
      icecast

      I'm sure there are a few others, but that is about it really.

      So does it take actually usage into consideration, or just the fact that it is installed?

      --
      Got Apathy?
    33. Re:This is a really good idea by gujo-odori · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I use KDE and vi, and think Gnome was a lot better back in the days when Enlightenment was the usual window manager (never liked Sawfish), but why was this modded Flamebait?

      Now, I don't much care for Gnome and if I thought it was important to change his mind (it's not; I think it's important that he use whatever works best for him) I could rattle off a bunch of reasons why (IMO) KDE is better. However, the fact that I disagree with him doesn't make his opinion flamebait.

      Oh, wait, sorry. I forgot where I was. "Flamebait" and "troll" both mean "Something I personally disagree with."

      Never mind :-)

    34. Re:This is a really good idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, yes I am.

    35. Re:This is a really good idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Debian users might not be representative of Linux users. Certainly not newbies.

      Debian users aren't representative of all linux users, but they do tend to represent those who know what they're doing. It's pretty hard to set up a debian system so that it works, and not figure out what it is that you're doing. It's relatively easy to install say mandrake or suse and not understand a thing about what you just did.

      The most popular packages are the ones you don't really have a choice about. (For example, tar.)

      If you don't have a choice about a package, then it's one you need sooner or later. Newbies would do well to become aware of these packages. I know in my early linux days it would have helped a lot had there been a list of "programs you should know about".

      For a newbie, the vast majority of packages are ones that even if you install, you'll never use directly in the way you think of using a program on Windows. (For example, ncurses.)

      Try running a linux system without ncurses, it's not so easy. Sure, the user will see no benefit from installing it, but they're going to need it eventually.

      Where choices do exist, many people will use an older package out of familiarity and habit.

      In that case you have the benefit of a wide user community, who will help you with problems, even if you have more of them than if you were using something more modern.

    36. Re:This is a really good idea by Ben+Hutchings · · Score: 1

      It looks at the access times on each package's files (but it ignores files whose names don't match /\.*bin/|/sbin/|^/usr/games/|\.[ah]$).

    37. Re:This is a really good idea by lee7guy · · Score: 1

      Please note that popularity != quality, more often than not the inverse is closer to the truth. This applies to software as much as to other phenomenons, such as music or art. Imho that makes exercises like this pretty pointless.

      --
      Ceterum censeo Microsoftem esse delendam
    38. Re:This is a really good idea by cbiltcliffe · · Score: 1
      Actually, the best way is to just use Disc 1, get the base installation, and then do the rest via network (assuming you're on broadband - I shudder to think what an installation would be like over dialup).


      When I first started using Debian (back in 1997) I did the install over what, if I remember rightly, was a 14.4 modem. I'd run dselect, pick the packages I wanted to install, get up to 50 or so MB to download, then quit dselect without downloading anything. At night, just before I went to bed, I'd connect to the internet, and start the install process. When I got up in the morning, everything would be downloaded, I could disconnect from the net, and let the computer get to configuring stuff after I'd answered the configuration questions.

      If I remember rightly, it was somewhere on the order of two weeks of this process to get a reasonable system going. Now I have DSL, and can download all the .iso images in a matter of a day. With wget, of course.....
      --
      "City hall" in German is "Rathaus" Kinda explains a few things......
    39. Re:This is a really good idea by Imperator · · Score: 1
      Try running a linux system without ncurses, it's not so easy. Sure, the user will see no benefit from installing it, but they're going to need it eventually.

      Who sits there in dselect (or for other distros, in their usable installation programs) and says "I need ncurses"? No one. Rather, you install it when it's a dependency of some other package you want.

      --

      Gates' Law: Every 18 months, the speed of software halves.
    40. Re:This is a really good idea by byolinux · · Score: 1

      Heh, thanks for sticking up for me.

      I'd be interested to hear your reasons about KDE, I use GNOME because it's what I'm used to, and what seems to run faster. Also, they seem to be getting good with usability.

    41. Re:This is a really good idea by Paul+Crowley · · Score: 1

      Not on Debian sarge/testing. I've installed it several times in the last three days, I know :-)

  7. 13 CD's!? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Why not just make 2 DVD's?

    1. Re:13 CD's!? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because they're delusional =D

    2. Re:13 CD's!? by byolinux · · Score: 1, Funny

      I don't have a DVD ROM drive you insensitive clod!

    3. Re:13 CD's!? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because noone has volunteered to make them. Do you care to volunteer?

    4. Re:13 CD's!? by tloh · · Score: 4, Insightful

      There are many boxes, particularly older hardware, which does not have a DVD-ROM drive.

      --
      Stay sentient. Don't drink bad milk.
    5. Re:13 CD's!? by raindown · · Score: 4, Informative

      I asked myself this question when buying Unreal Tournament 2004 the other day and when the employee of the store told me they didn't receive any of the Special Edition DVD version. I was kind of baffled as to why they didn't make it a DVD only release, but it kind of makes sense to me.. It's not entirely safe to assume that that many people have DVD-ROMs, at least from a manufacturing perspective. I think that when you register the game you can send your system specs in thus allowing th company to know... Sorry for getting kind of off-topic but the same concept stands true in this case I think. Think of how many people have cd-burners compared to dvd-burners? Probably a big ratio.. so it makes more sense to put everything on a format that almost everyone has access to. (Note: ALMOST)

    6. Re:13 CD's!? by iminplaya · · Score: 1

      Hey, it beats the hell out the 40(!) floppies that came with the Video Toaster back in ninteeeee....four? And the install required all of them. I suppose I'll never realize how lucky I was that all those disks survived five installs, when now, I see disks that don't live more than six months(high humidity down here) or five or six read/writes.

      --
      What?
    7. Re:13 CD's!? by Shazow · · Score: 1

      Be grateful it isn't 6035 floppies. ;-)

      - shazow

    8. Re:13 CD's!? by Sean+Umphlet · · Score: 1

      You could just use jigdo to create the DVD images, right?

      --
      -- Sean "nosebleed"
    9. Re:13 CD's!? by cbreaker · · Score: 1

      I'd say "make both."

      A lot (most?) server boxes don't have DVD drives either.

      --
      - It's not the Macs I hate. It's Digg users. -
    10. Re:13 CD's!? by afidel · · Score: 1

      Most of the Dell and IBM Xseries servers I've installed in the last couple years have had DVD drives in them, when even a slimline DVD drive costs only $50 there really is no reason not to include them.

      --
      There are 4 boxes to use in the defense of liberty: soap, ballot, jury, ammo. Use in that order. Starting now.
    11. Re:13 CD's!? by gabebear · · Score: 2, Informative
      I think Debian is still the only OS you can download DVDs for.

      You have to use jigdo, and you can't use Windows to download the image, but it's there.

    12. Re:13 CD's!? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Yes but a computer with no DVD drive probably has zero chance of running UT2004 anyway.

    13. Re:13 CD's!? by deinol · · Score: 1

      In danger of straying further off-topic:

      What PC with the horsepower to handle Unreal Tournament 2004 doesn't have a DVD drive?

      They are so cheap now, and come standard with most machines.

      Now, to bring it back on topic, I want that Knoppix DVD! It's my favorite install of Debian!

      --
      Got Apathy?
    14. Re:13 CD's!? by tepples · · Score: 2, Interesting

      [DVD-ROM drives] are so cheap now

      My grandma's computer has a CD-RW and does not have a second front-accessible drive bay to add a DVD-ROM. New cases for Dell motherboards are not necessarily "so cheap now."

    15. Re:13 CD's!? by lspd · · Score: 1

      I've burned Debian Woody DVDs using DVD+R, DVD-R and DVD+RW, and the compatability seems to be very bad with older DVD drives. Hopefully one of the Linux magazines will put out the 2 DVD set for Sarge once it's released. DVD recordables just don't cut it and CD sets are getting too large.

    16. Re:13 CD's!? by cbreaker · · Score: 1

      Well, that's good news. It's been my experience that although companies may spend ten or twenty large on a server, they often won't opt for the extra $30 for a DVD drive when there's no immediate need.

      If they come standard, however, then that's a Good Thing.

      Personally I just can't believe that DVD drives aren't absolute standard these days. I guess it's because there's so many CDR drives and not so many DVDR drives. Sure, a DVD reader will read both but the majority of people only read CD's... same old problem of migrating to any new tech.

      --
      - It's not the Macs I hate. It's Digg users. -
    17. Re:13 CD's!? by yack0 · · Score: 1

      I know the toaster was out in about 1991 - 1992. The newly created Collge TV station/club bought one. S-VHS decks, an Amiga, IIRC, and Video Toaster. :)

      What was that girls name that did the cartwheels for the wipes? Can't remember, but they named the wipe after her. [1]

      [1] not to be confused with the Chem lab where you dried your glassware with 'Kim-wipes'. Heh.

      --
      -- There is no sig line, only Zuul.
    18. Re:13 CD's!? by Alien_Phreak · · Score: 1

      anything that has no DVD drive, probably can't handle 13 CDs worth of data either. and If you have a computer with.. (let's say 13 CDs at 650 comes just under 10 gb plus compression, let's say 20 gb) I would still say u can afford the 30 bucks for a DVD drive. or NFS.

    19. Re:13 CD's!? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, and I bet she can't wait for Unreal Tournament 2004 either. Learn to read, moron.

    20. Re:13 CD's!? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Like all modern OSs, Debian gives you the choice NOT to install every @#)( thing on the install media. In particular, if your computer sucks, or if you are sane, you will not install more than about 20% of Debian.

    21. Re:13 CD's!? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm not her only grandchild. Quit making assumptions.

    22. Re:13 CD's!? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      I have 240 gigs of local storage, and yet I don't have a DVD drive, so I would appreciate it if they don't drop the cd based distributions.

    23. Re:13 CD's!? by some+guy+I+know · · Score: 1

      Does this mean that they don't distribute Debian on floppies any more?

      --
      Those who sacrifice security to condemn liberty deserve to repeat history or something. - Benjamin Santayana
    24. Re:13 CD's!? by Crazy+Eight · · Score: 1

      The jigdo system provides DVDs.

    25. Re:13 CD's!? by pe1chl · · Score: 1

      SuSE Linux has been released on DVD, then on 2 DVDs and the 9.0 version is on a double-sided DVD.

    26. Re:13 CD's!? by koali · · Score: 1

      Kiki Stockhammer

    27. Re:13 CD's!? by toddestan · · Score: 1

      I got tired of Windows crashing in the middle of playing back a movie on my computer, so when my sister's DVD drive broke I pulled mine and gave it to her. So my high end Athlon system just has a CD-RW. I haven't missed the DVD drive either.

      However, if I wanted to play UT2004, I wouldn't have a problem spending $30-$40 to get a DVD drive.

    28. Re:13 CD's!? by Explo · · Score: 1

      Perhaps I just feel that I don't need DVD drive for anything, especially because the bare bones system can easily be installed from one CD and the rest via broadband?

      --
      Everyone who makes generalizations should be shot.
    29. Re:13 CD's!? by Jagasian · · Score: 1

      The fact that the full Debian distro is 13 CDs is a great thing! You really only need one CD and the rest can be installed over the net. In addition, having every piece of software you would ever want packaged and available from a huge variety of standardized apt-get'able servers makes software installation, maintenance, and removal extremely easy!

    30. Re:13 CD's!? by Trejkaz · · Score: 1

      We have one. The DVD drive which used to work fried and we can't afford any kind of replacement yet.

      Even then, I don't see why game companies can't ship with both the CD and DVD. In an age when a CD key uniquely identifies each user, and for a game which is predominantly for online play, you wouldn't think the piracy issue would even exist.

      --
      Karma: It's all a bunch of tree-huggin' hippy crap!
    31. Re:13 CD's!? by sfsp · · Score: 1

      FYI, Debian DOES offer DVD ISOs. Begin here (http://www.debian.org/CD/faq/#dvd) and start digging.

  8. U FAIL IT - U GOT 4th YOU DOUCHEBAG by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    1. Re:U FAIL IT - U GOT 4th YOU DOUCHEBAG by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

      3rd MOTHERFUCKER! Look again DICK HOLSTER!

  9. It's a failure. by Mr.+Darl+McBride · · Score: 5, Informative

    I hate to point it out, but the first kernel-image is in 2794th place.

    1. Re:It's a failure. by arduous · · Score: 3, Informative

      By default, Debian doesn't install a package for the kernel, just the kernel itself. Many people leave it with the default kernel that it is installed, local root expoits and all.

      Those who do update the kernel, again probably bypass the debian packages and roll their own kernel to suit their needs.

      Then there is the third group of people will just "apt-get install kernel-image-2.4.18-1-686", and let the magic happen.

      However, everyone (almost) has the adduser package installed.

      --
      "It's the smell! If there is such a thing." Agent Smith - The Matrix
    2. Re:It's a failure. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've used debian for years and I love it oh so much. But no matter what it seems easier for me personally to install my kernels manually. My laptop requires special tweaking that's all.

    3. Re:It's a failure. by arturogatti · · Score: 1

      I hope you're familiar with the Debian kernel packaging scripts. All it takes is two commands after you're done with "make *config" to automatically build a .deb of your custom kernel, ready to install.

    4. Re:It's a failure. by qtp · · Score: 2, Informative

      That's because there are several different kernel-image packages tailored for different purposes (archetecture, processor-type, special use, etc), plus many Debian people build their own custom kernel-image packages using the kernel-package package (251st place).

      --
      Read, L
    5. Re:It's a failure. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I am now.
      Thanks

  10. 13 CDs??? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    That's a whole lot of suck.

    1. Re:13 CDS??? by kidgenius · · Score: 1

      You most certainly can. Go get the "netinst" version that weighs in at around 100MB and everything will be installed via apt-get

    2. Re:13 CDS??? by Sean+Umphlet · · Score: 1

      Wouldn't you be able to use jigdo to create DVD images?

      --
      -- Sean "nosebleed"
    3. Re:13 CDS??? by reaper20 · · Score: 2, Informative

      There is also a ~30MB business-card netinstall that does the same thing.

    4. Re:13 CDS??? by manual_overide · · Score: 1

      or...

      if you have fairly common hardware, download the ide-pci disk images. I have the rescue disk and the root disk. 2 floppies. I can download the base-install from the net as well as the rest of the system. There are no other disks needed, unless you need to load drivers. Then you need a driver disk or two.

      Either way, a debian install weighs in at as little as 2.8MB worth of stuff that you must download before starting the install.

      --
      If bad puns were like deli meat, this would be the wurst
  11. And this by JoeBaldwin · · Score: 5, Funny

    Is when using Debian to install gnaughty bites you in the ass.

    1. Re:And this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm not ashamed of my porn addiction!
      (that's not why im posting as AC)

    2. Re:And this by fredzouille · · Score: 1

      and don't forget pornview :
      http://packages.debian.org/unstable/utils/pornv iew

      Debian may not be desktop ready, but it sure is prOn ready...

  12. I just installed with the Beta 3 installer by cyber_rigger · · Score: 4, Informative



    The automatic hardware detection is nice.

    http://www.debian.org/devel/debian-installer/

    1. Re:I just installed with the Beta 3 installer by witts · · Score: 1

      I just installed it too, and it failed to set up my Creative Soundblaster Live soundcard, so I'm not very impressed with it. Oh, then I tried the famed dist-upgrade procedure, and it borked my computer. Debian ain't for me...

      --
      pot.kettle(black);
    2. Re:I just installed with the Beta 3 installer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Did you submit a bug report? There is a reason it is called "BETA".

  13. Re:not only hardware... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    We believe that makes Oracle benchmarks very biased because the above benchmarks are supposed to show what a standard installation can do for a single client.

    Of course they are very biased. Since it rather hard to find any real-life application of RDBMS serving "sigle client".

    /sarcasm mode on
    And we all know how good MySQL at serving multiple clients with complex queries at once.
    /sarcasm mode off

    Neat quote tho, at least when you understand who is really biased:)

    /usd

  14. w00t by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Coffee - and coasters to put the mugs on, too! It just doesn't get better than that...:)

  15. Wireless, eh? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    With the basic functionality up and running, you can start to play around with expansion options. My first project was to give the frame a wireless connection so I could transfer new pictures without taking it off the wall.

    Wargoatseing, anyone?

  16. Re:This seems like a good idea... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    You should mean the M series, because there is a lot more to it than PM and variable clock, something the regular Pentium line has had for years. Read this article and you'll realize just how much went into it.

  17. Escape velocity by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Without their host planets, they would float off, wheareas the moon would continue orbiting the sun quite contently.

    I have been interested in Astronomy since I was about six years old. Just over forty years. I have heard what you suggest before -- but only in the last few years. And I don't understand it any more this time than I did on the earlier occasions.

    Frankly, I strongly suspect it is a false factoid, like that the internet was built to survive a Nuclear War. I strongly suspect it is a bullshit meme that keep being repeated because it sounds cool, but is completely false.

    Pray explain what you mean when you say the other 138 moons would float off ?

    I am trying to do the "thought experiment" of silently, quietly erasing the principals of those moons, mass and all. I am finding this difficult to do. I don't believe there is any way this could occur, in our Universe.

    So, instead I imagined doing something to accelerate a moon, any moon, to the escape velocity of its principal. What happens then? Well, the object accelerated to just beyond a planet's escape velocity will assume an orbit very similar to that of the Planet it just escaped from. Sometime in the last couple of years ago there was a flap about a small object that seemed to have been temporarily captured in the Earth-Moon system. But it turned out to be NASA space debris. It appeared to be the discarded upper stage of an Apollo moon shot.

  18. OS RDBMS might profit by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    If the Open Source Databases implement equeally features that some applications might need, they can profit from the situation.

    MySQL Control Center is a step in that direction (client side) if they implement some more features on server side M$ centric customers need, it could get Microsoft into trouble in the future (some years)

  19. If this were TIVO by AntiGenX · · Score: -1, Insightful


    Hmmmmmm. "allowing it to send us anonymous package usage statistics"

    It seems to me, if this were Tivo or some other "evil" corporation, slashdot would be up in arms over this "invasion of privacy."

    Yeah, I said, so I'm a troll now, what'dya gonna go about it?... Bitter party of one!

    1. Re:If this were TIVO by Throtex · · Score: 1

      If I had mod points, I'd use them to buy you a beer and/or your choice of an asian male hooker (some people are into that).

    2. Re:If this were TIVO by byolinux · · Score: 2, Informative

      This is Debian - the sources are there, you can see for yourself what it's really doing.

    3. Re:If this were TIVO by El · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Voluntarily giving up your privacy with fully informed consent is much different then sneaking in spyware without telling you about it. Those that are paranoid about privacy simply won't install it.

      --

      "Freedom means freedom for everybody" -- Dick Cheney

    4. Re:If this were TIVO by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Absolutely. This is just more spyware to clog up your system and automatically farm marketing information, just like the stuff from evil corporations Slashdot readers complain about daily.

    5. Re:If this were TIVO by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's your choice whether or not to install it smartass. Plus you know exactly what it's doing, you have the source.

    6. Re:If this were TIVO by teklob · · Score: 1

      It's not an invasion of privacy because you willingly install it. I would've thought that was obvious.

    7. Re:If this were TIVO by GarfBond · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Except, the obvious difference being is that your participation is being solicited and completely voluntary at this point. With TiVo, you're not really getting an option to opt out, even if they are pretty clear about what they're doing.

    8. Re:If this were TIVO by Imperator · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Yes, you are a troll. This is an optional package that people can choose to install. It's open source, and the use of the data is also completely in the open. It's not an invasion of privacy when someone wants to give you data and explicitly gives it to you.

      --

      Gates' Law: Every 18 months, the speed of software halves.
    9. Re:If this were TIVO by fliplap · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Debian is free. I pay for the hardware. They give me free software, source code, documentation and updates, services and they don't even profit from the hardware

      If I could send anonymous view habits to Tivo in exchange for free service I WOULD.

    10. Re:If this were TIVO by mistered · · Score: 2, Informative
      Not only do you have to install it, but before it will do anything it gives a description of what it does, and then asks if you want to participate, with a default of no.

      You can have your system anonymously e-mail the Debian developers with statistics about your most used Debian packages.

      This information helps us make decisions such as which packages should go on the first Debian CD. Also, we can improve future versions of Debian so that the most popular packages are the ones which are installed automatically for new users.

      If you choose to participate, the automatic submission script will run once every week automatically, e-mailing statistics to the Debian developers.

      You can always change your mind after making this decision: "dpkg-reconfigure popularity-contest"

      --
      Enjoy your job, make lots of money, work within the law. Choose any two.
  20. Someone has to say it.. by 3DKnight · · Score: 5, Funny

    I would still go with Popcorn.. at least their kernels taste better!

    oh, i kill me...

    1. Re:Someone has to say it.. by Orgazmus · · Score: 0

      Yeah, please do.
      Somebody? Please?

      --
      The system had the verbosity of HTML combined with all the readability of compiled assembly viewed as bitmap images
  21. Interoperability is hard to enforce by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    In theory, that's a great idea. But it would be hard indeed to force them to reveal enough to be meaningful.

    They'd have to release the formats/protocols at least six months or so before releasing the software, to prevent other developers playing continual catch-up. (Without changing them in the interim, of course.) And they'd have to be prevented somehow from hiding details that might allow subtle incompatibilities, later lock-in, or other preferential treatment. Ideally, they'd be made to release an open-source reference implementation, too.

    And they'd have to show that implementing the protocol or using the format didn't infringe any patents -- not just that a patent-free method was available, but that M$ couldn't use a better, patent-encumbered method unavailable to their competitors. And that they couldn't file such patents in the future.

    And so on. Time and time again, companies have learned that you can't play M$ on their own terms and break even, let alone win. They've learned a whole battery of techniques to steal an unfair advantage. And blocking them all is no easy task.

  22. Oh come on by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    This story is just asking for a frosty piss joke to be made!

  23. Windows needs 'distributions'! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I've said it before, and I'll say it again:

    Microsoft should not be allowed to sell Windows with any additional apps whatsoever.

    With GNAA/Linux you have different distributions, why can't Windows work on the same principle?

    You don't get Mandrake saying "Oh, we're not going to put into our distro, why should we put other people's apps in our distro's?"

    The whole point of distributions is that you get loads of apps from loads of developers, and you get to select exactly what you want from the best available apps.

    Having Windows distributions is the only way I see of overcoming Microsoft's anti-competitive monopoly.

  24. Use DVD media by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    When you get up to the 10+ CD range, it's retarded to not start pushing DVDs.

    1. Re:Use DVD media by Alien_Phreak · · Score: 1

      I wholehearthedly agree. We need DVD ISOs. make 2 DVD ISOs available for the masses, much more convenient then download 13 freaking ISOs. here's another question, I'm just curious...what exactly is there to put on 13 cds. Most distro dont come even close. Full retail of most distro dont go over 5-6 CDs and that's including source. Alien.

  25. Recipe for integration of postfix, clamav & ds by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Does anyone have a recipe for integration of postfix, dspam amd clamav (or other open source virus scanner), similar to the way amavisd and mailscanner work with spam assassin and a virus scanner of choice?

    RG

  26. Not "popcorn"? by nacturation · · Score: 1, Funny

    I was hoping to read how to get popcorn from the kernel.

    --
    Want to improve your Karma? Instead of "Post Anonymously", try the "Post Humously" option.
    1. Re:Not "popcorn"? by polymath69 · · Score: 3, Funny
      I was hoping to read how to get popcorn from the kernel.

      Popcorn comes from kernels. Just place 'em on your Athlon.

      --

      --
      I don't want to rule the world... I just want to be in charge of mayonnaise.
  27. poll by adamruck · · Score: 1

    they should just do a slashdot poll

    --
    Selling software wont make you money, selling a service will.
    1. Re:poll by IntergalacticWalrus · · Score: 1

      they should just do a slashdot poll

      That wouldn't work, as there is no package in debian called "CowboyNeal".

    2. Re:poll by iceburn · · Score: 1

      They should make a CowboyNeal.deb - it could be an empty package that depends on every other package on all of the cds. That would be rad.

      --
      A sphincter says what?
  28. I don't trust it. by Mr.+Darl+McBride · · Score: 5, Funny
    The results are rigged!!!

    emacs: (emacsen-common) -- 317th place
    vi: (nvi) -- 208th place

    I'd sooner believe we awarded Bush the popular vote!

    1. Re:I don't trust it. by bogolisk · · Score: 1, Insightful
      Check the package's priority

      • emacsen-common's priority: optional
      • nvi's priority: important
      <joke>

      $ dpkg -s kde
      Package: kde
      Priority: not-recommended
      Section: bloatware
      Installed-Size: 1666666666666666666

      </joke>
      --
      Bogus
    2. Re:I don't trust it. by DarkHelmet · · Score: 1

      So darl... Any allegations of SCO code being in "adduser"?

      --
      /^[A-Z0-9._%+-]+@[A-Z0-9.-]+\.[A-Z]{2,4}$/i
    3. Re:I don't trust it. by joshhan · · Score: 1
      actually, 317th / 208th place is pretty high up considering that emacs / vi does not get installed by default.

      All the top ranking packages are really just base packages that have to be installed in order to have a minimum base system.

  29. Advantages of Lilypond by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    As a professional musician I use lilypond a lot. Apart from the
    excellent output quality, lilypond has a couple of advantages that
    haven't been mentioned in the discussion so far:

    • Producing text mixed with music examples (large ones between paragraphs, tiny ones in-line) is tiresome with traditional music notation packages, involving a lot of copying and pasting between notation and text processing programs. Lilypond-book makes this easy (there is only one source file that contains both text and music) An example: source which may not be everyones cup of tea) But after that, producing a new piece of sheet music is really much faster and easier than with the traditional notation packages, and the result is a lot better.

  30. Re:No fucking chance by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Of course they shouldn't, but they will anyway. Australia is pretty good at bending over for the United States, and sending one man to PITA prison is a sacrifice Australian politicians will happily make to stay in favour for the next round of trade talks.

  31. Okay by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I have a friend who went around charging 50 dollars to take the MS.Blaster worm off people's computers. This amateur computer repair field has great potential, as computers penetrate further and further into most bussinesses. Time is money, and paying some kid 50 bucks to fix a computer is often cheaper in the long run then spending 2 days doing it yourself. I plan to do the very same thing with a local company over the summer break from school.
    I want to be a Digitician when I grow up.

  32. mr mackey says by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    popcon is bad mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmkay

  33. Did You by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1
    Compile the "Dell Laptop Extensions" into the kernel? gkrellm has an i8k plugin you can use to spin the fans up to low and high when you hit certain temperature thresholds. There's also a standalone temperature monitoring utility but it's seemed a bit flakey lately.

    Of course both fans spinning will impact your battery performance but it's better than third degree burns on your... lap.

  34. Sex education by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    "It's based on the idea of what goes up has to come down. In this case, the bubbles go up more easily in the center...than on the sides because of drag from the walls."

    Is it just me, or is anyone else reminded of their sex education lessons?

    I have no idea why they called it a "bubble" though.

  35. The real problem by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    The real problem is not so much that the Yukon date has slipped, it's that Whidbey (The next version of Visual Studio.NET and the.NET framework) is slipping with it. For who knows what reason, Microsoft decided that these products must be released together. While Yukon promises some very nice features, most people would much rather have Whidbey released now and live with SQL 2000 for awhile longer.

    To top it off, MS is not even going to be releasing any service packs for Visual Studio in the meantime. There are some rather serious issues with the current version of Visual Studio that can only be fixed by calling MS for specific hotfixes. Needless to say, much of the MS developer community is up in arms.

  36. Re:Divide and conquer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    Oh well you know, just all sorts of functionality that was driven by GNAA/Linux, like finely grained SMP, support for enterprise level hardware, USB, SANE, ACPI, DRI/DRM and what have you more. And let's not get started on the apps. I mean, there's a reason why all the BSDs make an effort to run GNAA/Linux binaries, not the other way around.

    hold on cowboy...
    linux drove usb support? check your history...

    linux has better support for smp? right... 'cos the linux smp support isn't a rip of free-bsd's first smp incarnation, and free's 'new' smp code is some hack up by a big school kid is it?

    linux has better support for enterprise hardware? shall we start with... i dunno... scsi support... get your history book out and do some experimenting with old linux v's old *bsd installs - try backing up a raid and restoring, then come back and tell me how good scsi isn't fundamental enterprise computing...

    next you'll tell me that open's code auditing and goal of bug-free secure code is inferior to linux's free for all crap-code fest

    excuse my rant, i'd don't mean to bag linux - every OS has its place - even windows.

    but man... linux zealots and their damn superiority complex, re-writing history... i even heard someone try to explain the sco crap the other day... he actually said that 'unix is a brand of linux'

  37. Re:Cars, DVDs, what's the difference? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I don't see why companies don't like the idea of getting help from CUSTOMERS.:D

    Simple: Maybe they would get help from customers, maybe not. If they got help from customers, then their cars would be a little bit better (though probably not much), and their customers would be a little bit happier.

    But by keeping all this stuff secret, they create a monopoly on service and their dealerships can charge $200 for something that Joe Smith at your local garage would charge $120 for.

  38. Re:Ugh... this is like betamax by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1
    LilyPond is "never going to get off the ground"? It's been around for years and is a wonderful tool that many people use. Quite a lot of music is available from LilyPond's format, including a huge library of music in the public domain, ala Project Gutenberg. I have myself set Arban's Method for trumpet using LilyPond. Your claim is starkly in contrast with current reality.

    Furthermore, I find LilyPond's text format far faster for input than using a GUI. Like speach, music is an abstract concept that the human can nevertheless learn to set in a concrete form using a keyboard. Payware music typesetting programs also has a keyboard input mode, and most advanced users use it.

  39. Re:I know you need to be paid for your time, but.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    It also depends on what "repair" is.

    "Repair" might mean that the computer won't boot up at all, and this person has their doctoral dissertation nearly complete on it. Of course, they haven't made any backups... It would easily be worth $800 to recover that data and get the computer up and running again.

    For me, when it comes to working on people's computers, I basically tell them it will cost them $50/hour. But also that I have an "hourly" cost for certain jobs. From start to finish, installing windows and all their software may take more than 5 or 6 hours. But a lot of that is just waiting. So, for that job, I'll tell them it will be about 2 to 2 1/2 hours of billed time.

  40. Re:Why wouldn't I want windows to play back videos by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    I'm sure many businesses would love to be able to only purchase the parts of windows that they wanted.

  41. Re:Very cool, but.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    And they had an advantage that Europe also got after WW2: Their manufacturing infrastructure was completely destroyed, so they had a chance to start from scratch with cutting-edge (at the time_) technology throughout the entire process. The US was (and is) still trying to maintain their much older and less capable facilities, since that was still less expensive than starting over and there was no carpet-bombing to force them into it.

  42. A decision based on Science, or Politics? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1
    Is this a decision based on Science? Or is it based on Politics and emotion?

    Did you know that in 1998 Senator Patrick Leahy, of Vermont, got his State's largest Lake, Lake Champlain, to be reclassified as the 6th Great Lake? At least as far as the awarding of researh grants. Being considered a "Great Lake" made the academic institutions in his constituency eligible to apply for certain research grants.

    There is talk of sending a probe to Pluto. Is it possible that it is easier to sell a probe to "planet Pluto" than to send one to Kuiper-belt object Pluto?

    I remember, back in the days when I tuned in to debates as to which newsgroups should be created, the big debate as to whether a new group should be talk.acquaria, rec.acquaria or sci.acquaria.

    In Leahy's defence, these were environmental research grants, and I should probably assume he added this line to the bill to protect his constituent's natural environment -- not for the petty partisan purposes.

  43. I for one would appreciate this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    I'm a typical geek who builds custom computers for people preinstalled and preconfigured with their choice of software, and most of my clients opt for Media Player Classic rather than WMP as their default video playback thing, as far as video goes. I'm not an OEM by any means (I've only built about a dozen computers), but I'd love if customisable installs would filter down to the end users.

    For those of you who don't know, Media Player Classic is an open source clone of Media Player 6.4 (the default media player shipped with Win2k), and (with the right codec libs installed) will play DVD's, avi's, wmv's, ogm's, Real and QT streams. Very nice clean and easy to use interface, and hooks into standard DirectShow codecs, none of the irritations of WMP/Real/QT, and completely free (thanks Gabest!), although donations are always welcom I imagine.

    Being able to completely replace WMP with MPC would be a dream come true for me, and my clients. The only thing that worried me is that MS would take their ball home, and if made to remove Media Player they would probably cripple DirectShow to such an extent that I'd have to install WMP in order to get my codec libraries to work.

  44. Re:Been tried by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    RTFA. You're lightyears away from what it's about.

  45. Not a problem yet by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    It won't be an issue until they find a Kuiper object that is bigger than Pluto. Then they'll have an awkward situation. Making Pluto a planet when this bigger object isn't one doesn't make sense; nobody wants to add a new planet, because in retrospect it was a mistake to make Pluto a planet, and adding another Kuiper object would just compound it; and removing Pluto from the list of planets offends tradition.

    Everyone wants to push this off as long as possible, so if the new object is really smaller than Pluto, they'll breathe a sigh of relief and go on with things as they are.

  46. Re:A solution in search of a problem? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    Uh, except that it changes, moves, or could even be interactive given some sort of input/stimulus.

  47. Yukon's promised features by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    Not good for MS. A lot of people have been waiting on Yukon. Yukon is finally going to deliver online restoration, database mirroring with automatic failover, and support for mirrored backup sets.

    Disappointing. SQL Server had really come a long way, too. Maybe 2005 won't be too late.

  48. Re:What happened to the naming convetion? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    IANAAP, but Vulcan is already reserved, it was a theoretical planet in the early 20th century that would be closer into the Sun that Mercury's orbit that would account for irregularities in Mercury's orbital path. There was actually no planet and Mercury's behavior is proof of the special theory of relativity (IIRC).

    I'd presume that for historical reasons Vulcan would be reserved. Also recall that theres lots of trans pluto pluto sized objects that have names, I forget what the naming mechanism is for them, but I think they're roman.

  49. the usual suspects by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1

    I'll ge them out of the way all at once:
    I.. welcome bubble overlords...
    Soviet Russia... bubbles slide down you.. you know the drill.

  50. Re:Back to grade school for retraining... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    There is a simple way to decide if something is a moon or double planet. Look where the two focal points for the elipses that describe their orbits are.

    If both focal points for the orbit are contained within the volume of one body, or if one focal point is contained within the volume of one body and the other focal point outside of both bodies, then the smaller object is a moon of the larger.

    If both focal points are outside the volume of both bodies, or if one focal point is within the volume of one body and the other focal point within the other body, then the pair of objects should be considered a double planet.

    So Pluto/Charon, following this reasoning, should be considered a double planet.

  51. Re:Dammit by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Why do people despise the Mac platform so much?

    perceived levels of freedom

    Back in the day, both IBM PCs and Apple Macs were closed systems, their internel workings were undocumented to the outside world. There was, however, one crucial difference. PCs set up the hardware with the BIOS and then went to disk for the OS whereas MACs booted from an internal ROM. Compaq succeeded in cloning the IBM BIOS which meant you could put an IBM floppy in a Compaq machine and it would boot. Some companies tried to clone the Mac but were slapped with lawsuits because you couldn't copy the Apple ROM. The company that supplied IBM with the stuff on their floppies was a Washington startup called Microsoft who had cunningly retained the right to ship MS-DOS seperate from a computer.

    Consequently the PC Clone market flourished and IBM lost their control over the PC Platform driving down price while driving up incompatibility. Meanwhile Apple continued to develop their platform. It was a technically superior platform with a unified graphical user interface, used Postscript for printing and SCSI for devices. This made MACs expensive when you did CPU Cycles / $. You could walk into an Apple dealer, choose the bits, go home, plug it all together and it worked whereas you would go to a PC dealer tell him what you want and he's spend a few days building it and battling to get the bits talking to each other but when you got it home it worked.

    Because it was difficult to build and maintain PCs, their builders and maintainers looked down on the MAC, it wasn't as fast for the same $, was too easy to use, you didn't have to take the case to pieces to add a peripheral and the only people you knew who had them were too rich to deserve them.

    As the builders and maintainers of the PCs of everyone in their social circle, the non-techies trusted the techies opinion, parroting the same lame arguments in PCs vs MACs arguments the world over.

  52. Re:So by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    If dogs are flying, then that is not weed you are smoking... Tread carefully, but enjoy.

  53. Re:This is *NOT* a really good idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    I've seen the results of this when it was used in the Hurd CDs. There were absolutely retarded things like the battle.net client on CD #1, but not something simple like XFree86.

    Popularity isn't something that works terribly well for this sort of thing, especially not on the first install CD.

  54. Re:I guess that'll show em. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    I feel that from an administration standpoint with a large number of hosts it wouldn't matter if you were using RedHat, Gentoo, FreeBSD, OpenBSD, or any other *nix for that matter as long as the machines you were running were using the same distro.
    You haven't actually been an admin at a company with a large number of machines, have you? I worked for a large aerospace company and our Management (he wasn't even a PHB) wanted to know why we had an average of one admin for 20 machines when HP said one admin should be able to handle 200. Then HP explained that those 200 machines were absolutely identical -- same exact hardware, same exact OS patch level, and same exact applications. In the Real World, we had no two machines alike and thus needed the 1/20 ratio. And this was all the same brand of hardware and OS! Each department was different, which basically made vacation and illness backups a matter of "pray they don't call you." The admins who had the easiest time of it were those who worked on BSD boxes; the VR4 boxes were all over the map; even the users understood that if their admin was away, they were better off not bothering the backup on call for any more than password resets because they'd as likely break something else as fix your problem.

    Granted, if you ran an all RedHat shop or an all Mandrake shop things would be easier than simply an all GNAA/Linux shop, but the same would be true for an all OpenBSD shop vs an all FreeBSD or NetBSD shop. But if each department is free to buy what they want I'd rather find who-knows-which-BSD on the box than who-knows-which-GNAA/Linux.

  55. Corporate cave-ins by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    I am currently in tepid water. A police officer who has no jurisdiction whatsoever where I live is currently investigating me for allegedly promoting violence against a particular spammer and criminal proxy-abuser (proxy hijacking is specifically a crime here).

    That police officer has repeatedly attempted to contact me (as a rule, I never volunteer any information to law enforcement), and has gone so far as to obtain some personal information about me. Turns-out that the ISP caved-in to his demands and provided some information about me, in clear violation of legal procedure and current privacy laws.

    This is no different from a cracker obtaining passwords/access through social engineering.

    Furthermore, the officer has repeatedly attempted to have me contact him tough threatening e-mail messages.

    My question is: should there be stiff penalties towards law-enforcement officers who manage to illegally and without due process of law get information about ISP subscribers, especially if they are well outside their police department jurisdiction?

  56. Re:Mechanics for the 21st century by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    We don't respect mechanics because we, and our friends, have been lied to by mechanics so many times. Either about what needs to be repaired, what they broke while they were repairing something else, etc.

    If computer techs started pulling the same shit that mechanics have been pulling, taking severe advantage of their greater knowledge of the subject, computer techs are going to be just as disrespected.

  57. iTunes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Given HP's recent relationship with Apple on a rebranded iPod, does that mean that 1) the tunes sold in starbucks will be AAC and/or 2) that iTunes will be involved?

  58. fining companies does nothing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic


    you think MS will reduce margins if they get fined or will they pass that cost to the customer either indirectly (format lockin/upgrades etc) or directly via product price increases ?

    doesn't really take a MBA to work out what they will do, fining them will not punish them at all, especially with the worlds richest people at the helm.

  59. Re:I don't get Congress. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Nobody's getting shut out of the DVD player business.

    Perhaps you missed the whole DeCSS issue? "Without licensed DVD players for GNAA/Linux and other operating systems, an entire class of computer users is completely cut off from viewing DVDs."

  60. Re:Different threading model by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Not exactly. All this means is that threads do not migrate preemptively, nor do they migrate while blocked or switched out while in kernel mode. Threads only migrate if (a) the thread itself wants to move to another cpu or (b) the thread is returning to user mode and the userland scheduler decides to migrate the thread to balance the load out (which only applies to threads associated with user processes since no other type of thread can 'return to usermode').

    Kernel threads almost universally stay on the cpu they were originally assigned to. High performance threaded subsystems, such as the network stack, are replicated. That is, the network stack creates multiple threads (one per cpu) and those threads do not migrate because, obviously, they do not need to.

    Generally speaking, the purpose of making thread migration explicit instead of automatic is to partition a larger data set across available cpu caches rather then cause the same data to be shared amoungst all cpu caches. The processors operate a lot more efficiently and SMP scales a lot better. Most people do not realize the horrendous cost of moving threads between cpus because the cache mastership change is invisibly handled by hardware, but the cost is still there and still very real.

    -Matt

  61. how are the choices currently made? by tloh · · Score: 1

    I had assumed this was being done all along. How are debian packages currently organized in the install set hierarchy? By the way, are there any other front-ends to apt-get in the spirit of Synaptic? Synaptic is a nice program, but seems to be still very buggy.

    --
    Stay sentient. Don't drink bad milk.
    1. Re:how are the choices currently made? by leonscape · · Score: 1

      If your using KDE you could try KPackage, I think theres one for GNOME as well... can't remeber what its called though.

      --


      If a first you don't succeed, your a programmer...
    2. Re:how are the choices currently made? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just use aptitude. Text-based, but friendly.

    3. Re:how are the choices currently made? by shallot · · Score: 1

      The popularity-contest results have been used for ordering packages on CDs for years now. This was just a reminder.

  62. Re:Old story? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Found it here.

    It's old:)

  63. Re:Pre-emptive anti-slashdotting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    The one from the logged in poster is a faithful reproduction of the article. The anonymous coward one mentions cowboyneal and male body parts.

    That probably explains why the moderation was done the way it was far more the the stated author of the article.

  64. marketing survey by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    About 6 months ago I was on the phone to some marketing company who were doing a survey on Yukon and whether or not I was contemplating deploying it.

    I said no because:

    1) it was too tighly integrated into AD/ windows server and we didn't any of that.
    2) I didn't trust it, and wouldn't till it had been in the field for at least a year.

    I think they got alot of responses like 2) (going by the marketers comments) and they prob decided to wait till the new windows server is out (2006??) and deploy on the new Trusted Computing Base thing they are wittering on about.

  65. Re:Very interesting! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    >I'm surprised people still use BSD after that
    >security fiasco last year.

    so what do u suggest windows? LOL
    sorry ;)

  66. for comparison purposes: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Pluto is 2300 km diameter, ranges from 4.3 to 7.4 billion km from the sun.

    http://www.windows.ucar.edu/tour/link=/pluto/stati stics.html

  67. Details. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Introduction

    DSPAM (as in De-Spam) is an extremely scalable, open-source statistical-algorithmic hybrid anti-spam filter. A majority of users running v2.10+ achieve filtering rates ranging from 99.92% - 99.98+%, DSPAM is currently effective as both a server-side agent for UNIX email servers and a developer's library for mail clients, other anti-spam tools, and similar projects requiring drop-in spam filtering. DSPAM has been implemented on many large and small scale systems with the largest systems being reported at about 125,000 mailboxes.

    What is a Statistical-Algorithmic Hybrid Filter?
    Present-day language classifiers bear the responsibility of maintaining accuracy in the midst of ever-increasing sample complexity. In the setting of spam filtering, many types of intentional attacks have been introduced such as obfuscation, word list injection, sample flooding, and etcetera. As the complexity of classification text continues to multiply rapidly, many filter developers today are left with conflicted feelings between increasing the complexity of their filter and wise teachings from CS class reminding them that computer science is about controlling complexity, not creating it. At the rate complexity is rising, filters will (and have already begun to) become so resource-intensive that they lose scalability, eventually leading to a second conflict of interests: where fighting spam becomes more expensive than managing it.

    DSPAM is the first Statistical-Algorithmic Hybrid filter and in being such boldly suggests that there is a better alternative to increasing the feature set of filters to match the spams they are trying to fight. By employing algorithms designed to increase the quality of existing data rather than the quantity of data with the goal of reducing the feature set rather than increasing it, DSPAM has managed to achieve nearly equal levels of accuracy with present-day Markovian-based filters and other types of filters that employ large feature sets with the added benefit of using a significantly fewer amount of resources. DSPAM presently peaks at 99.984% accuracy, which is ten times more accurate than a human being [1] and is presently being used on implementations as large as 125,000+ mailboxes.

    DSPAM's Focus
    The DSPAM project attempts to go beyond "just another statistical filter" by focusing on the following areas:

    * DSPAM has a strong focus on providing better data to already existing algorithms (Bayesian, Chi-Square, etcetera) Combination algorithms work inherently well, but depend on the quality of data. Some of the approaches deployed in DSPAM towards this goal include Chained Tokens, Inoculation Groups, Classification Groups, advanced de-obfuscation techniques, and a new noise reduction algorithm called Bayesian Noise Reduction. The goal is to incorporate processing algorithms that can withstand the long haul of ever increasing message complexity. So far we're doing a great job.
    * A strong focus on large-scale implementation support. The largest implementation of DSPAM we've heard about to-date involves 125,000 users. DSPAM has been designed to experience a very short execution time (0.03s - 0.10s on average hardware), and has been equipped with a storage driver API allowing several different storage mechanisms to be used. Depending on disk space constraints, accuracy can be traded off for additional disk space or vice-versa.
    * Empty Corpus Support and Global Dictionary Support. It is very important in a large-scale environment to allow users to build their own dictionaries starting from scratch. Why? Because system administrators haven't got the time to create 20,000 seeded dictionaries. On top of this, ISPs require out-of-the-box filtering, which DSPAM's global dictionary feature provides for end-users, with minimal centralized learning. DSPAM provides support for building corpuses from scratch without suffering many fatal training errors (false positives). When these two

    Read the rest of this comment...

  68. Inuit Contributions by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Hockey was invented somewhere in Europe or European North America in the 19th century. Lacrosse was invented by Indians near the St. Lawrence and is played on grass rather than snow, so I doubt the Inuit were involved.

    Inuit inventions include snowshoes, toboggans, dogsleds, kayaks, toggle harpoons, and various other tools for hunting and travelling in the North as well as snow and ice civil engineering techniques. Pretty impressive, I'd say, for a culture with almost no wood, rock, or metal. They've probably contributed as much as any other non-Eurasian colonialised culture, and they make some really cool art.

  69. Ugh... this is like betamax by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Guys, I am a professional musician who occasionaly makes a few hundred bucks setting out of print scores to finale or sibeleus. I also use linux, and like the open source model.

    The problem is that programmers arent creative in this department... those coders all work at apple.

    This is never going to get off the ground, and is a hindrance to the adoption of linux by musicians, when in reality things like jack, ardour, and alsa make it an excellent platform for creative types, a la Pd, miller puckette's wonderful synthesis program.

    The developers seem to be focusing on making things "right" and in a description language. Fine, but i dont see how this is going to help inspire musicians to use this arcane latex garbage to print out a set of exercises. Most of my musician friends cant even use finale well, so how can one expect the same of this program.

    On the other hand, if your objective is to create a framework for music notation software, midi in, etc, etc, then you need to work with people in that community so that you can have more attention and people drawn to that project.

    As it stands now, this software is like enlightenment 17... by the time it gets ready, all the interested people and developers will have gone elsewhere or vanished in disgust.

  70. The ACs are on fire! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Man! The tonight, with 4 / 6 of the +5 scores!

  71. Boring ... ZZZzzzzzz..... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    When are the goddamn SexBots going to be released?! My lifeless real doll ain't cutting it!

  72. MOSIX by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic


  73. Re:Market choice by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Formatting textual output &/c, in TeX is a little more adaptable for a human being, as TeX and the actual, literal, written text are pretty much close.

    However, for music, most musicians are most comfortable with writing music down in conventional music notation. Conventional music notation, in comparison, compared with LilyPond input are far apart. It's somewhat comparable to painting with a typewriter.

    I don't really find much wrong with Lilypond itself, but I don't think it'd work too well for manual input. But coupled with a decent GUI input mechanism, it would work well.

  74. Better things to do.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    I dont normally hang around in the coffee shop to listen to enough music that I would want it burnt onto disk for me. There might be an odd occasion when you come across some music playing that you might like, normally asking the guy behind the counter and then getting it where i normally get my music.

    I say its a fair bet that this service wont recover the money they need to put into it to start off, not to mention the training cost of training all those 18 year olds who barely know enough to do a decent cup of coffee.

  75. Partial list of most popular apps... by cliffiecee · · Score: 4, Funny

    gawk
    talk
    date
    wine
    grep
    unzip
    strip
    touch
    finger
    mount
    fsck
    more
    yes
    eject
    umount
    sl eep

    (Stop groaning. Someone had to do it.)

    1. Re:Partial list of most popular apps... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think gawk at the top because popcon depends on it...

  76. Re: It's a failure... no, it's a DISASTER by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I don't know if you were trying to be funny, but this has been my experience with this type of system, and with Debian in particular. You end up with absolutely useless shit like the battle.net client on CD #1, and really important things like the XFree86 (or equivelent) on like the last CDs, with desktop apps that require it on earlier CDs.

    It is madness to think that a good distribution can be made by a popularity contest when the people doing the voting know nothing about the system.

    BAD IDEA!!!

  77. Re:You're dealing with the problem too high up by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Doesn't that depend on the definition of clustered though? Clustered systems can be things like beowulf clusters. But often a collection of standalone web servers behind a http load balancers is commonly referred to as a web cluster or array.

    IMHO as someone who works in a complex web server / database server environment, there are many interdependancies brought by different software, different platforms and different applications. Whilst 100% uptime on all servers is a nice to have, it's a complex goal to achieve and requires not just expertise in the operating systems & web / database server software but an indepth understanding of the applications.

    A system such as this fault tolerant shell is actually quite a neat idea. It allows for flexibility in system performance and availability, without requiring complex (and therefore possibly error prone or difficult to maintain) management jobs. An example would be server which replicates images using rsync. If one of the targets is busy serving web pages or running another application, ftsh would allow for that kind of unforeseen error to be catered for relatively easily.

  78. Re:Woop de fucking do! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Yeah, it'll probably cost a lot to reprint all the New Age ancient traditions to include a tenth planet.

    Ten Planets? You haven't been keeping up with here astrology has been going the last twenty-fove years. I know astrologers who use twenty planets, most of which are imaginary.

    This, of course, ignores the two hundred or so asteroids which new age astrologers use. And don't forget the plethora of comets, meteor showers, deep space objects, and other things that may, or may not exist.

    And to be sure that you haven't forgotten anything, there are umpteen "Arabic Parts", Midpoints, Orbs, harmonics, ( or something like that) etc.

    In short, roughly 10^8 objects that no self-respecting astrologer would omit, if one believes in the validity of all the books on astrology that have been published.

  79. LOOK AT THE FUCKING TIMESTAMPS, KNOBSHINER by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait
    1. Re:LOOK AT THE FUCKING TIMESTAMPS, KNOBSHINER by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
      You mean like this?

      Hello, I'm WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW WIDE!

      Yes, I'm WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW WIDE!

      Very very WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW WIDE! So wonderfully, so fantabulously WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW WIDE!

      Your comment violated the "postercomment" compression filter. Try less whitespace and/or less repetition. Comment aborted.Reason: Don't use so many caps. It's like YELLING.Reason: Don't use so many caps. It's like YELLING.Reason: Don't use so many caps. It's like YELLING.Your comment violated the "postercomment" compression filter. Try less whitespace and/or less repetition. Comment aborted.Your commeYour comment violated the "postercomment" compression filter. Try less whitespace and/or less repetition. Comment aborted.nt has too few characters per line (currently 33.9).Your comment has too few characters per line (currently 33.9).Your comment has too few characters per line (currently 33.9).Your comment has too few characters per line (currently 37.3).Your comment has too few characters per line (currently 37.3).Your comment has too fewYour comment violated the "postercomment" compression filter. Try less whitespace and/or less repetition. Comment aborted. characters per line (currently 37.3).Your comment has too few characters per line (currently 37.3).Your commeYour comment violated the "postercomment" compression filter. Try less whitespace and/or less repetition. Comment aborted.nt has too few characters per line (currently 37.3).Your comment has too few characters per line (currently 37.3).Your comment has too few characters per line (currently 37.3).Your comment has too few characters per line (currently 37.3).

      Xzzy

      Preferences Subscribe Journal Logout

      Sections
      Main Apache Apple Askslashdot 10 more Books BSD Developers 3 more Games 17 more Interviews Science 6 more YRO 2 more

      Help
      FAQ Bugs

      Stories
      Old Stories Old Polls Topics Hall of Fame Submit Story

      About
      Supporters Code Awards

      Services
      Broadband Online Books Personals PriceGrabber Product News Tech Jobs

      Re:working link

      Re:working link (Score:1)
      by Mark J Tilford (186) on 09:46 PM March 19th, 2004 (#8617899)

      slashdot puts in occasional spaces to prevent people from adding overwide lines to pages.

      [ Reply to This ]

      Post Comment

      Name
      Xzzy [ Log Out ]

      Subject

      Comment

      (Use the Preview Button! Check those URLs!)

      No Karma Bonus Post Anonymously

      Allowed HTML: (Use "ECODE" instead of "PRE" or "CODE".) Important Stuff: Please try to keep posts on topic. Try to reply to other people's comments instead of starting new threads. Read other people's messages before posting your own to avoid simply duplicating what has already been said. Use a clear subject that describes what your message is about. Offtopic, Inflammatory, Inappropriate, Illegal, or Offensive comments might be moderated. (You can read everything, even moderated posts, by adjusting your threshold on the User Preferences Page)

      Problems regarding accounts or comment posting should be sent to CowboyNeal.

      Pascal is not a high-level language. -- Steven Feiner

      All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest (C) 1997-2004 OSDN.
      [ home | awards | contribute story | older articles | OSDN | advertise | self serve ad system | about | terms of service | privacy | faq | rss ]

      # Important Stuff: Please try to keep posts on topic. # Try to reply to other people's comments instead of starting new threads. # Read other people's messages before posting your own to avoid simply duplicating what has already been said. #

    2. Re:LOOK AT THE FUCKING TIMESTAMPS, KNOBSHINER by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Name
      Xzzy [ Log Out ]


      Hello Xzzy!!

  80. I for one...... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Welcome our new, jazzier, robot overlords....

    (sorry someone had to)

  81. mmmhmmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Have you ever been in some sort of establishment and said to yourself. You know? This tune is quite catchy (pinky to mouth). It would be quite excellent if I could burn this piece of innovative harmony to CD. Wouldn't it Chompsky.. hUhUhU.

    Certainly sir. Would you have me ask the young lady what specific tune?

    Sure, be on with it.. CHOP CHOP Chompsky. Put them on my ipod.. (pinky to mouth).

  82. that was useless by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Ah maaaaan, crap!
    that sucks!

    Turns out I've stopped drinking for no reason after all...

    got time to catch up with now.
    bid day ahead...

  83. Re:What about linux distributions?? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Many distributions ship with software such as XMMS, mplayer and the gimp. Should Mandrake, SuSE, Debian and the like be fined for carrying this software?

    First: no one of those distributions has a de facto monopoly in the OS market and it's trying to abuse that position to get the monopoly in other markets, such as the media players one.

    Second: on the average GNAA/Linux distro, you have twenty different text editors, a dozen media players, and another dozen graphic manipulation programs.

    So, your is, indeed, a non sequitur.

  84. Terms He Didn't Disclose... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    1. No shipping. Local pickup only. 2. To avoid stiff fees, PayPal will not be accepted. 3. Checks will be given ten days to clear. 4. Non-paying bidders without ABM defenses will be given NEGATIVE FEEDBACK.

  85. Re:"If he committed no crime in his home country" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    But if you stood across the border in Minnesota and shot the Canadian, you've committed the crime in Canada(?) and would be extradited.

  86. Let the flames start by r00zky · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Current popularity rankings:

    vi (287) beats emacs (317) :)
    gnome (333) beats kde (586) :(
    linux (251) beats hurd (13608) :o
    lynx (281) beats mozilla (378) :????

    --
    I'm a chainsmokin' alcoholic sociopath, so-ci-o-path
    1. Re:Let the flames start by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      vim is where it's at man. everyone who wants to avoid RSI (or already got RSI from emacs) uses vim, or one of ther other vi clones (there's a handful of 'em in debian).
      all desktop environments suck. they can all go to hell. console is where it's at. that's what unix is about.
      linux is nice, but the future is probably more something like hurd.
      lynx is pretty damn cool, small and fast. and you don't need to waste time blocking popups, javashit or flash junk. graphical links is also cool for those few graphical pages that actually have some worthwhile content on them. all five of them or so...

    2. Re:Let the flames start by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      lynx (281) beats mozilla (378) :????

      Probably some boxes that are servers without X11?. I think some apps also depend on lynx.

    3. Re:Let the flames start by Tony+Hoyle · · Score: 1

      That's not surprising... lynx is a good starting point for a basic install when you're tweaking, and you might fubar X.

      I prefer links myself though.

    4. Re:Let the flames start by bogolisk · · Score: 1
      • libglib1.2 at 99 (the gnome1 foundation library), far ahead of libqtxxx at 430. It'd even ahead of libstdc++ at 103 and g++ at 116
      • libglib2 (gnome2) is at 171, is ahead of libqt at 430
      • at 315, libesd is ahead of libarts at 458
      • libgnome32 (gnome1) is at 334, libgnome2-common (gnome2) is at 403, kdelibs-data is at 564. libncurses5 rules them all at 29
      • nvi at 208 is far ahead of vim and emacsen.


      Conclusion: on Debian, they like it lean and mean. terminal-ui rules; gnome1 is prefered to gnome2; KDE is barely tolerated.

      --
      --
      Bogus
    5. Re:Let the flames start by kidgenius · · Score: 1

      I know I've fubared X more than my fair share of times, and lynx was always there for me to go google to fix my problems :-)

    6. Re:Let the flames start by r00zky · · Score: 1

      Right, it works wonders when nvidia drivers get borked in kernel compiles.

      But i'm afraid you lose:
      lynx (281) beats links (970)
      :P

      --
      I'm a chainsmokin' alcoholic sociopath, so-ci-o-path
    7. Re:Let the flames start by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      you're counting gnome/kde libs, i was counting gnome/kde binaries, since libs can be installed because of dependencies of other programs

    8. Re:Let the flames start by Atzanteol · · Score: 2, Insightful

      lynx (281) beats mozilla (378) :????

      Not terribly surprising. I install it on all my machines (even the headless ones) for testing purposes. But only Mozilla only on my 'desktop' box.

      --
      "Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge"

      - Charles Darwin
    9. Re:Let the flames start by be-fan · · Score: 1

      gnome and kde are metapackages.

      libgnome2 vs kdelibs4 (to see who uses GNOME apps vs KDE apps) or kicker vs gnome-panel (to see who uses the desktop itself) would be more accurate.

      --
      A deep unwavering belief is a sure sign you're missing something...
    10. Re:Let the flames start by Red+Leader. · · Score: 1

      I use tar.gz releases of Mozilla. I can't be bothered to wait for them to trickle down...

    11. Re:Let the flames start by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      No surprise here:

      I have 3 servers and 1 desktop. The servers don't have any GUIs nor Windows, yet they do have lynx. My desktop has both lynx and mozilla.

      That means even though I use mozilla every day, I have 3 systems that don't.

    12. Re:Let the flames start by Xenographic · · Score: 1

      I run lynx even on win32, you insensitive clod!

      (and no, I'm actually not kidding here... makes me feel more at home whenever I'm using windows :)

  87. Re:Why wouldn't I want windows to play back videos by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    since they compete with similar products on the market

    .

    No, since they do not use some form of lock-in mechanism to prevent the users for using other products.

  88. popularity contest package by MrWim · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The package popularity-contest is 42nd on the list with 18 less installs than the top packages, so how did these 18 people submit thier scores to the popularity contest?

    1. Re:popularity contest package by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Maybe they didn't install the ready-made package version of it. Perhaps they manually built it from source or copied the executable from another machine.

  89. With butter? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Anyone else read that as "Popcorn"?

  90. A bit OTT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    That is so over the top. Creating an entire PC just to show a picture? That's 200 for the screen and another 200 for the computer. On top of that they are recommending a hard disk?
    My version uses a 5 quid FPGA and some junk thrown away equipment. The LCD was a 12" 9bit colour from some factory and a fiend of a friend offered them to us for a quid each. And the RAM is an old 1Mb 30simm (I have about 3kg of these). There you go. A picture displaying system with no need for a huge/noisy PC power supply (runs from one of those 12v ac/dc plug converters). The images can be sent to it via a serial cable (two wires internally so it can be passed over any old cable you have lying around).

  91. Re:Bad Idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    It's a well meaning idea, but it would cause more problems than it would solve. It would just encourage sloppy code; people would rationalize "I don't need to fix errors because it doesn't matter", which is a very bad habit to get into when programming, ignoring errors, or even warnings

    The same logic could be applied to any security system, from the automatic door lock on the front of your house to Airbags in your car. Spell checkers discourage people from learning to spell. Antibiotics prevent the growth of the immune system. Why have a lock on your trigger, if it will encourage you to leave it in a place where your kids can find it.

    The fact of the matter is, if the code works, it's good code. This is a shell scripting language we're talking about here... Not exactly assembly. Programmers would be better off spending more time thinking about the higher structure of their applications and less time hunting down trivial mistakes.

    Of course, I know that this isn't quite what the article is talking about, but it's the principle of the thing. Augmentation would be an improvement.

  92. A Healthy Alternative for MS and Its Users by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    How about requring MicroSoft to install third-party players as well as its own media player? That would provide more choices to users and the users will be able to choose whatever they like. In my opinion, this is way better than completely removing useful software from the system.

    Let the end users decide what they want. Personally, I think that Windows Media Player is a lot better than Winamp or other alternatives; however, I would not mind if everybody had a chance to compare and decide.

  93. Need protection against ourselves by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    The odds of our civilization being destroyed by asteroid impact in the next few decades is really insignificant when compared to the odds that our advancing technology -- in the hands of still primitive minds -- kills us off first.

    It would be a cosmic joke for us to have made it these past hundreds of thousands of slow years, only to be wiped out by a dumb rock in the next ~30 years or so that matter most in our evolution to post-humanity.

    --

  94. Re:Different threading model by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    No this is to do with kernel threads. The userland threading is the same as in FreeBSD 4.x atm, AFAIK. The idea is to keep the model simple, unlike in FreeBSD 5.x where they are having trouble keeping it all sane with their fine-grained mutex model. Have a look at the dragonfly.kernel newsgroup, in nntp.dragonflybsd.org for more details on the SMP model, Matt talks about it regularly earlier on.

  95. Slashdot - MySQL? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
  96. bingo by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    i think they do quite a bit in the hope of luring customers and getting them to linger to maybe buy a second round or other stuff. they play music, provide tables outside, sell newspapers, easy bwireless access.... i'm not that wild about their coffee buy will pay extra not to be told to leave right away.:)

    also i suspect starbucks feels pressure to continually reinvent itself rather be perceived as yesterday's coffee news. notice how mcdonalds introduces new items of dubious value to get some buzz and quietly drops them later. (or such is my impression, i don't eat there anymore.)

    now if only starbucks could make coffee that didn't taste burnt. i like underdogs, good luck peet's. we have an indy coffee place nearby that has *couches* and wireless..... i doubt the chains will go this far, that's just a bit too inviting.

  97. Re:I guess that'll show em. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Hmm.. yeah, since a recent update I can no longer run a.out binaries from the 2.x era... but for as far as external packages and ports are concerned, thats about the first case where you can't get software for older releases to work with a current version using one of the compatxx packages.

    That said, some tools (esp those using kmem) should be kept in sync with the kernel, and when at it, why not just build a new userland, its easier then figuring out what you have to update.

    The concurrently developing BSD variatiens allow trying out a variety of low level solutions to problems while sharing a lot of their experiences.

    Such diversity doesn't really exist in GNAA/Linux despite its zillion distributions (which provide a lot of variation in user experience tho)

  98. Bah... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    It's STILL just an " automated press-deleter".

    No matter what technology it uses, neural nets, b-trees, recursion, tinkertoy logic, smell-emitting diode, leaky junction zener transistor, steam-powered aeolipiles, it only automagically presses delete, which is a pretty lame way of fighting spam.

    It's a lame way of fighting spam, because, we STILL have to pay for the fucking spam bandwitdh; we STILL have to pay for the goddammed disk space used by the spam; we STILL have to pay for the bloody time lost transmitting the spam; we STILL have to pay for the extra ISP infrastructure to carry those spams.

    Naaah. Spammers should be eradicated from the Internet, and the best way to do so is to completely BLOCK networks who host spammers (no matter what service), in order to force the collateral damage to whine to the ISP or simply vote with their feet.

  99. Re:Lies, I tell you. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Virtyally none of the diagnosic capabilities in modern cars are accessible via OBD-II.

    Every manufacturer has proprietary networks built into the car of which OBD-II is a tiny emulation layer. Its designed for emissions testing and emissions related codes, nothing else.

    You can't diagnose why your power locks aren't working with it, you can't diagnose why your HVAC controls aren't working. You can't read exhaust gas temperatures, or any other direct sensor outputs. You can't bleed ABS pumps with it, etc, etc, etc.

    There are VERY few models you can get that sort of information about. Volkswagen/Audi group cars have some diagnostic software available, but virtually 100% of the information about what you can access and what sort of tests you can run have been reverse engineered, and is very incomplete. VAG also recently changed their protocols for newer cars to block those systems from working.

    You may have watched mechanics sweat this stuff, but some of us sweat this stuff directly. This is coming from the direct experience of someone who both repairs cars and works for a internationally ranked professional racing team.

  100. A step ahead by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    I, for one, am waiting for the day when we will not require hardware to be made from metals and other hard substances.

    Most devices/machines today depend heavily on a motors/engines/circuits that are not usually flexible and need to maintain a rigid structure. Sure, we try to cover/encapsulate these devices in a pleasing exterior (car bodies, plastic casings etc) in order to protect the hardware and us from the dangerous interiors.

    Imagine cars made up of soft cushiony/rubbery material, which bounces back to absorb a collision...the metal body can dent in and absorb the force of the impact, but it works only against collisions against other cars/hard objects -- not against collisions with humans/animals and other "soft" substances.

    Ofcourse, we could have a soft covering for cars, made of a cushiony substance, but the problem has been embedding circuits/machinery in the soft exteriors, because they tend to bend and damage the interiors.

    Nature has found the perfect way to create organs/pumps/filters/wires which are made out of soft tissue, and is malleable enough to survive severe tension/distortion and bending.

    Here's to hoping that one day we will be able to create soft fuzzy machines which won't be so hard on our water-bag bodies.

  101. Oh no by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I think I speak for everyone here when I say "That's the worst idea I've ever heard, and I don't want to play."

    Hobbit's scampering about on the stage in a chorus line?

    The deadly dance of the orcs?

    Sam's love ballad to Frodo?

    I can just envision Gandalf dancing, tossing away his hat and staff for a top hat and cane.

    There are so many reasons this needs to NOT happen.

  102. Looks like "Passport" problems by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Judging fromt the description that people had problems logging in, but that things work fine once logged in, and OTOH that Messenger had problems too, I would conclude that the problem is with their Passport infrastructure.

  103. Re:Cars, DVDs, what's the difference? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    You can make bit-for-bit copies of any DVD now, complete with all the encryption on it. And the laws preventing the distribution of those DVDs (normal copyright law) has been on the books for a long, long time. If you follow the money, the bottom line is that the CSS and region codes on a DVD only help to support cartel price-fixing profits.

  104. US debut by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    The new Muramasa has been out in Japan since January. It has had some nice reviews and keeps up well with Pentium-M modells of similar clock speed (see this Japanese review). And it is much cheaper.

  105. Transmeta CPUs != longer run time by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I know it is one of their big selling points but I have yet to have used a Transmeta device that actually had a longer run time than my huge Latitude C series with second battery. Why? Because for some reason manufacturers seem to have a fetish for the 2.5 - 3 hour benchmark. Once they reach it, they concentrate on size instead. Surely I can't be the only one who would be happy with a smallish (12-13") notebook with long battery life. I certainly find that more interesting than devices that are so tiny as to be unusable yet have comparable run time to normal laptops.

  106. If I remember by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    There was a formula for predicting orbital paths that was related to Fibbunaci's sequence, I wonder if sedna falls into the sequence?

  107. 3rd party connections by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I thought they had blocked other programs again. Trillian and Gaim couldn't connect, but I installed MSN 6.1 and got right back on.

  108. Making DVD Copies by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic


    Is it legal to make and edit copies of commercial DVDs for personal use? What about loaning out the edited copies to friends?

  109. what make's the net so special? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Why is it that there "have to be" laws specific to the internet? If a spammer sends an e-mail using forged headers, why doesn't the law go after him (or her) with good old-fashioned anti-fraud laws? Does the main failing of these kinds of old laws lie in ingorance that makes law enforcement unable or unwilling to enforce the laws without further clarification, or is something else going on here?

  110. Not ready for the real world by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    From the article:

    "the researchers estimate that the wires should be able to withstand several thousand cycles of extension and contraction."

    That's no where NEAR what would be needed for any of the applications they mention. For example, at 70 beats per minute your heart beats 100,800 times per day. Assuming each step a runner takes covers 3 feet (very approximate here), then a "cycle" (back to starting configuration) is 6 ft. That's 880 "cycles" per mile. A single 6 mile run is therefore over 5000 cycles.

    Several thousand "cycles of extension and contraction" is not even close to enough for any real world app. Who wants to have that internal heart monitor replaced several times each day? How about that high-tech single use "smart" sweatshirt?

    These will need to be in the 100's of thousands to millions of cycles for their lifespan before they have any real utility.

  111. Gold hmm.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Of course they couldn't be made out of anything else than Gold could they?

    I do realise Gold has special properties such as conductivity and hypoallergenic properties, but come on!

  112. which companies? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    > How many companies these days are willing to drop money into some technology that may not turn a profit for many years?"

    Aerospace, for one. Working at one of the companies that makes commercial (and military) aircraft engines, it is jokingly quoted that: "A decision to launch a new engine program is a calculated risk to go into the hole for about 20 years" (Meaning it takes about that long to "turn profit" off all the years of design, development, testing, and certication processes.) Imagine how many times the market flops around responding to other market pressures in that length of time.

    As an interesting aside for many of you, aircraft engines have historically been sold on the razor/blades business model, so its an interesting business balance between a quality engine that airline customers will buy and the need to sell spares to eventually make money on FAR down the road.

  113. Extra-durable nerves by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Maybe they can develop nerves strong enough to let me survive my mother asking for computer help.

  114. Cnet is a day late by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Businessweek ran an item on it in their latest issue. The also said that competitors of Starbucks are looking to implement similar technology.

    Krispy Kreme and Outkast?

  115. Pack the bags! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Honey, we're moving to Washington!!!

    Imagine mapping this (your HOUSE) for a Quake / Unreal map!!

  116. Problem Solution existed in the 80's by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    ...it was called Knight Rider. Just have all the automakers create autos that can talk and tell you the diagnostic/problem information. Take it a step further....sell advertising in the information.

    "Michael, the left tire is running low and I've already told you 10 times. Why do you ignore me Michael? I let you into my hood on the first date. Oh look Michael, a Discount Tire shop; that would hit he spot, plus the tire tech has a nice big wrench...can we stop?"

  117. Re: It's a failure... no, it's a DISASTER by Mr.+Darl+McBride · · Score: 1
    People don't vote. Pop contest just looks at what you have installed.

    That said, don't bother burning 4 CDs, 7 CDs, however many the next is. Just burn the first CD and source everything off the net. Debian's good for that, and it's less of a headache. If you have a bunch of systems set up, use a web proxy with a big cache for the installs.

  118. Slow Computers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I don't know what everybody is complaining about with these being slow chips. THey should really start to look at the trade-offs. Do they want to lug around an 8 pound laptop, with 3 hourse of battery life, just so they can say they have a 2.4 GHz laptop, or would they rather carry around a 2.6 pound laptop with 6 hours of battery life (weight with extended battery), and have to run things just a tinsy bit slower. I've found that provided the system have a good amount of memory, a pentium 2 is good enough to run most applications.

  119. Since when is "copyright infringement" criminal? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I think the subject, says it all!

  120. Re: what, exactly, is being licensed? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    More to the point, does changing the medium in which content is delivered constitute a derivative work and therefore require a seperate copyright license? E.G., ripping a muic track from a CD to play on a computer, copying a track from a vinyl album to a CD or audio cassette to play in a car, etc.

  121. digital certs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Even if only for servers to keep open relays out of the loop, it may be time to mandate third-party trusted ID certs (ala SSL) for mail servers. It's proven too difficult to get most people to digitally sign their mail, but admins should be clueful enough to generate certs and have them validated externally...

  122. Re:I don't get Congress. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    There's an important difference you're overlooking: Nobody's getting shut out of the DVD player business.

    Seriously, how many legal car repair shops do you think there are? A million is most likely a conservative figure. The car computer legislation is happening because there are a lot of people in the car repair business, and have been in the car repair business for generations. But, suddenly (last few years) they've been unable to fix cars because they don't know the secret codes for the cars' computers.

    This isn't "I want everything, like MP3s and DVDs, for free". This is "I want to fsck-ing survive here.

  123. Brilliant! And on the patent app, call it...! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    It's the cord from a telephone handset.
    Now why didn't they think of that decades ago?
    Oh, wait, they did.
    Nevermind.

    Yeah, yeah, I know. It's FLAT. So maybe they've reinvented ramen noodles?

  124. Re:Predictable by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Why am I not surprised Microsoft claims its an internal problem?

    Actually, it would make more sense when Microsoft would claim it was an attack. Internal problems can be blaimed on the company (bad software design, bad system administration, etc.), external attacks can't, only for a lack of security or something like that. But in most cases, a company gets away quite well with an external attack.

  125. Leave the clothes alone by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    WHY is it, that the first real-world reference used when there's any kind of biotech advance is that it's going to be WEARABLE?

    The last thing I want geeks designing is my clothes. I'm not fond of the short-sleeve-polo-with-company-logo, okay!

  126. What about us? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    What about the vast majority of e-mail users who have Outlook [Express] on Windows. When will a plugin be designed and ported which will work with these clients?

    -- paper

  127. Re:No fucking chance by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    obtain criminals that seek refuge in a country

    (A) He's not a criminal and
    (B) he's not "seeking refuge". He's remaining at home where he's been the whole time.

    The US is getting uppity at Autralia because Australia is not prosecuting him. And the REASON Autralia is not prosecuting him is because HE DID NOT BREAK THE LAW.

    The US wants to extradite him so they can persecute him for "breaking codes", NOT for copyright infringment. "Breaking codes" is nothing but working out mathematics. And guess what? It's not a crime to do math in Australia! He's not a criminal.

    It's my dip-shit home country of America that came up with the numbskull idea of criminalizing math.

    P.S.
    The Chinese people should have a revolution and overthrow their government. OOPS! I JUST VIOLATED CHINESE LAW! I guess I'm a criminal too! Quick, someone extradite me to China!

    -

  128. Re:But who wins in the end? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Does nobody RTFA?!!

    The aim is to free computer makers to sell Windows bundled with rival audiovisual software such as RealNetworks RealPlayer or Apple's Quicktime, the sources said.

  129. Re:funny faq by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Users with relatively predictable mail behavior (such as geeks, dweebs, and freaks) have generally received very few false positives

    What about losers, dorks, and morons? Are they cursed with a high rate of false positives?

  130. Market for video playing software by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    I'm sure the average windows user wouldn't want to have to play around with selecting/installing video playback software when all they want to do is playback a clip they've downloaded.
    The same could be said for browsers, word processors, graphical tools, video editing software... hell, you could say the same for opererating systems: the average computer buyer doesn 't want the hassle of having to install Windows, just give him Windows right out of the box. What is that you say? There are alternatives to Windows? Well I never...

    Of course it's convenient to get all of that stuff included with your operating system. But if you remember, there used to be a market for things like browsers and video playback software. That market is all but gone, thanks to Microsoft including these products with their OS. I know, there is something called Mozilla for us staunch MS-haters. But good luck trying to sell (or even give) your alternative browser to the public at large.

    I don't feel too bad about MS including such things with their OS, even though I am sure producers of, say, video editing software are having nightmares about MS including that functionality with Windows in a few years time. it's hard to draw the line: sure, no one would argue against operating systems needing a decent file manager, for example. Yet people used to make a living developing and selling separate file managers, a long time ago.

    What I do have a problem with, is that MS sometimes not just includes browsers and video software with the OS, but made sure that it was rather hard to install an alternative product as well. That is what they should be punished for... but this ruling doesn't really accomplish that. As far as browsers and video playback software is concerned, it's all water under the bridge, and you correctly note that it will be consumers who will be hurt by removing these from the OS. MS probably doesn't care a great deal.

    I would have preferred a big fine for MS, to make it clear what is unacceptable behaviour. It has to hurt if it's to heal.
  131. Wow. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    So do niggers when they're chained together and weighed down with cannonballs.

    I laughed when I saw that scene in Amistad. It was the feel-good comedy of 1997!

  132. Single point of failure by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    That must have been one heck of an internal problem for it to knock out Hotmail AND MSN Messenger.

    For example, the problem might have lain in the Passport login servers. Single sign-on is a single point of failure.

  133. One answer. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    "How many companies these days are willing to drop money into some technology that may not turn a profit for many years?"

    The kind that is already doing very well financially and wants to solidify a reputation of innovation. Similar to Microsoft's $1 billion donation to Africa.

  134. Re:What about linux distributions?? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    The difference is that neither Mandrake, SuSE, Debian are using a monopoly in one area (OS) to create a monopoly in another area (media), that is what is illegal even in the US. Don't you recall the AT&T situation?

  135. OOohhh... give it a rest... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    How long before people start having a backlash against LOTRs?

    4000 recent awards, the actors are plastered on every talk show, multiple console games, 3 recent highly pushed movies --shouldn't they just take a breather?

    Wouldn't waiting a few years and then bringing the story back in a different format be refreshing for the story?

    Davak

  136. How good is "Global Filtering" compared to SA? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    This looks interesting - for me especially how they've already got a system in place to automatically learn ham/spam by simply forwarding a message to a predefined email address (which apparently uses some sort of embedded "bug" to track it so it doesn't matter if the user's MUA forwards headers correctly).

    But my main concern is how well the described "Global Filtering" works with users who have no ham/spam corpuses built up yet. SpamAssassin still works reasonably well (eg, catches roughly 60-70% of spam) with no Bayesian stuff going on (just evaluating email on rules alone). Can DSPAM work equally as well?

  137. Why don't use screen? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Screen is a terminal which can survive connection problems. You can start your script, detach terminal, and then came back 10 minutes later and watch what its doing. I know, that's not "fault tolerant", but, most of the times, its enaugh.

  138. Re:Not what it is all about by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic
    Do you really need much compute power in a walk-about machine to do email, web browsing, word smithing ? In a trade off give me battery time over machine horsepower every time.

    Common sense would say so, but unfortunately, newer browsers, widget libraries, and window managers use a lot of resources. I used to use Redhat 7.1 with FVWM and Opera 6. Blazingly fast on my P3/450. Then, because of frustration with incompatible libraries for newer RPMs, I upgraded to Fedora/Opera 7. I still run Fvwm, but this new Opera version (with a newer Qt library, I presume) needs about 2 seconds of CPU time just for getting in and out of focus. If I look carefully, I can see that the borders of the windows inside the Opera window change a little bit depending on the focus. Emacs and xterm still run fine, but everything that has Gtk or Qt is slow as hell.

  139. Sharp can't compete with Fujitsu's P-Series. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Fujitsu 'did it right' with the P-Series.
    It would be nice to have a faster processor but the flexibility the P-Series (I have the 2120) is unmatched. 8 hours+ battery life and when you add in a 7200rpm drive it is not as sluggish.

    Games are best avoided here but I didn't buy it for mobile gaming just mobile working and notes taking in class.

  140. There IS a definite market for this. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    First off, I just finished ordering one, with the extended battery. Now for why:

    I use a Laptop virtually all day, every day. I currently work on a Thinkpad T23 with a 1.3GHz processor, 1GB RAM, 14" Screen, etc. I add a 802.11g card when in office and a T-Mobile wireless WAN card everywhere else. I love my laptop, but I have three complaints: 1. Weight, 2. Heat (holy crap it gets hot), and 3. battery life. I also have a Sony Picturebook which address these issues, but it's TOO small and lacks a LOT of connectivity. I use a Zaurus with Opie and love it. I have long wished that I could get a "really big Zaurus" with integrated WiFi, good storage, etc. That's essentially how I view the MM20. Of course that is predicated on my getting GNAA/Linux on it, but I am confident that given some time, that is quite doable. A 1GHz proc, half a gig of RAM, acts as a USB2 hard-drive when connected to my desktop, integrated 802.11g, 2 lbs. and a 10" screen...it's PERFECT for my needs. Anyone want to buy a Thinkpad?

  141. IP lawsuit frenzy. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    In your experience, have you found most lawsuits involving IP issues to be a waste of time/resources, or possessing merit?

  142. MIDI interfaces with GNAA/Linux by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    ***Here are some of the imdb.com reviews for "Gay Niggers From Outer Space":

    Summary: The best homosexual racial minority sci-fi film ever.

    "Morten Lindbergs classic cult short, Gay Niggers From Outer Space is one of
    the first short films to really stick to what the title suggests. From the
    time the first gay nigger walked onto the screen up until the final intense
    climax with the Tourette's Syndrome Kingdom in Outer Space, it's filled with
    dark comedy, action and plenty of suspense. "

    "Gay Niggers from Outer Space is a masterpiece of a film. No other film
    portraits emotions as majestically and stunningly since The Legend of Nigger
    Charley and Home Alone II. With a cast of all-star African niggers and a
    director with Kubrick potential, it is no wonder that Gay Niggers from Outer
    Space is marked the greatest film of all time."

    "From the very first scene where Gay Nigger Harris throws up on his own face
    and commits suicide, to the climactic scene where Nigger Ralph Nader and
    Nigger Humphrey Bogart fight over the last hashbrown and pick cotton til
    their noses bleed, Gay Niggers from Outer Space is the most magical
    portrayal of gay niggers open to the public."

    ***However, no mention is made of the hazadous lifestyle of gay niggers,
    so the following is an attempt to explain those hazards in layman's terms:

    Despite cries to the contrary in the media, AIDS is still primarily a gay
    and black disease. The media loves to report the "growing epidemic" among
    whites, when in fact the rate of infection among heterosexual whites is
    dropping off significantly year by year. The media though, reports only the
    TOTAL current infection rate, not the RELATIVE. So while there are more
    cases each year, the RATE of infection is dropping quickly. Except for the
    gay/nigger communities, where it's skyrocketing.

    Why does AIDS seem to target gays and niggers so much more so than whites
    and straights? Anal sex. The anus was not designed to accommodate vigorous
    penetration as occurs in anal sex. Unlike the vagina, the anus has very
    delicate membranes, which damage easily. Couple that with the fact that
    sperm contains immune system suppressing chemicals. That's why the sperm is
    not treated as a foreign protein in the vagina...because of the immune
    suppressing effects of the sperm cells. Without this effect, pregnancy
    could not occur, as the sperm would be attacked as a foreign protein.

    In the anus, sperm has the same immune suppressing effect. During anal sex,
    the anal wall is torn and open lesions form. Because there is little if any
    sensory nerve endings in the anus, this damage often goes unnoticed. The
    sperm then induce their immune suppressing effect, and the stage is set.
    Various bacteria both beneficial and infectious dwell in the colon, as well
    as viral matter. When the anus is ripped open, exposing the blood to the
    immune suppressing chemicals in the sperm, and the viral matter passed
    along with it, infection is virtually assured.

    ***So does the skyrocketing rate of AIDS infection mean that there are
    skyrocketing rates of gay niggers???

    ***Not exactly, because most White people don't realize that a large
    percentage of nigger males are bisexual. It's a great irony considering all
    of their macho posturing and affectations. They tend to admire the male
    physique, and when no women are present, they will hip-hop dance with each
    other. Any port in a storm will do, because da' brotha's just gots ta
    have it!!! Then they pass along the virus to their wives, girlfriends, and
    family members.

    ***Here is a story about this phenomenon from "The Village Voice":

    http://www.villagevoice.com/issues/0123/wright.p hp

    And for the Toronto Gay Niggers:

    http://www.nowtoronto.com/issues/2001-08-16/news _s tory_p.html

  143. Why don't use screen? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Screen is a terminal which can survive connection problems. You can start your script, detach terminal, and then came back 10 minutes later and watch what its doing. I know, that's not "fault tolerant", but, most of the times, its enaugh.

  144. Removing the Player Isn't the Good Part! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    "The European Commission draft requires Microsoft to share proprietary information with rival server makers"

    That's always my sticking point. I'm not as much bothered that they support video playback in their default system (they also support image playback and text playback, after all) as to their generally incompatible and excessively proprietary methods.

  145. Past tense? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    "Early adoption of Yukon in enterprises was quite strong due to the functions and features"

    How can you talk about functions and features of software that has not yet been released? How can companies "early adopt" vaporware?

    Yes, they can order in advance, but to me "adoption" means running something as a part of your business. Not "planning to maybe use it once you get it and if it turns out to be as good as you was promised it would be".

  146. 13 CDS??? by moosesocks · · Score: 1

    Great.... just when the novelty of not having to create 20 floppies to install debian began to wear off...

    But, honestly, why can't we use a system like was used in the latter days of the debian floppy installer? The 20 floppies contained a base-install with everything necessary to connect to the internet and download the rest of the system, which was a LOT less than the normal ISO image. This was a godsend for anybody on 56k.

    --
    -- If you try to fail and succeed, which have you done? - Uli's moose
  147. GNAA Press Releast: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll
    GNAA Press release:
    GNAA claims responsibility for kidnap of Olsen Twins
    By Gary Niger
    Lindon, Utah - GNAA (Gay Nigger Association of America) this afternoon announced one of their loyal members was responsible for kidnapping the twins inside a popular New York Club, Vudu Lounge (Websites).

    In a shocking announcement this afternoon, GNAA representative rkz revealed that he was the mistery gunman who penetrated high-security defenses of the Vudu Lounge and injected viral gay nigger seed deep inside the Olsen Twins, was indeed a full-time GNAA member.
    "This is serious," rkz began. This is a first event of such magnitude since GNAA opened its doors to new members in 1996. Until now, we were gathering new members by announcing our group information on a popular troll website, slashdot.org, but this is a whole new era. By injecting our holy gay nigger seed right into human females, we will be able to immediately collect thousands of members. "Make the most of the next six weeks," he added. "We will grow in numbers more than you can possibly imagine".
    Insertion of the GNAA collecting penis into their tight little vaginas came right between the consideration of Justin Timberlake to buy out the entire early saturday morning disney entertainment show's cast, and will most likely positively affect the decision. By adding all the gay niggers working for Timberlake with the gay niggers developing Mac OS X kernel source, GNAA will be all-powerful and will begin plotting our next plans to penetrate "backdoors" into the next favorite teen pop star Kelly Osborne.

    About GNAA
    GNAA (GAY NIGGER ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA) is the first organization which
    gathers GAY NIGGERS from all over America and abroad for one common goal - being GAY NIGGERS.

    Are you GAY ?
    Are you a NIGGER ?
    Are you a GAY NIGGER ?

    If you answered "Yes" to all of the above questions, then GNAA (GAY NIGGER ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA) might be exactly what you've been looking for!
    Join GNAA (GAY NIGGER ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA) today, and enjoy all the benefits of being a full-time GNAA member.
    GNAA (GAY NIGGER ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA) is the fastest-growing GAY NIGGER community with THOUSANDS of members all over United States of America. You, too, can be a part of GNAA if you join today!

    Why not? It's quick and easy - only 3 simple steps!

    First, you have to obtain a copy of GAY NIGGERS FROM OUTER SPACE THE MOVIE and watch it.

    Second, you need to succeed in posting a GNAA "first post" on slashdot.org, a popular "news for trolls" website

    Third, you need to join the official GNAA irc channel #GNAA on EFNet, and apply for membership.
    Talk to one of the ops or any of the other members in the channel to sign up today!

    If you are having trouble locating #GNAA, the official GAY NIGGER ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA irc channel, you might be on a wrong irc network. The correct network is EFNet, and you can connect to irc.secsup.org or irc.isprime.com as one of the EFNet servers.
    If you do not have an IRC client handy, you are free to use the GNAA Java IRC client by clicking here.

    About Lunix
    Lunix is an operating system. An operating system

  148. Most popular package by griffinn · · Score: 0, Redundant

    Um... since you have to install popularity-contest to participate in the contest, wouldn't that make popularity-contest the most popular package?

    1. Re:Most popular package by 110010001000 · · Score: 1

      We thought of that when we created it, so we do not transmit back popcon in the stat list.

    2. Re:Most popular package by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This brings up another issue. This ranking does not make much sense for those packages essential to every installation. Which Debian installation wouldn't have 'add-user', and 'libc6'?

      They should do the statistics on optional packages only. For example, the most popular editor, the best known web browser?

    3. Re:Most popular package by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Is there a way to have it 'cc' yourself what it sends out

  149. Uga buga by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No no Debian has no business interest. That means no ads no spam etc. Companies are clearly in it for the $$$.

    PLUS it doesn't install automatically. Only if you choose to. So where's the complaint?

    In summary you suck Debian rules (long live popcon -- running right now).

    Troll on brave one...

  150. Mak better by not installing at all by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    Make the Debian CD' better by not installing them at all. It's hobby shit. Not ready for prime time play around with stuff. Get real.

  151. vi/vim vs. emacs by Peaker · · Score: 5, Interesting

    When comparing the popularity of the two, do not forget that vi is fairly standard and that vim is fairly small.

    This means that whoever uses emacs should have no problem also installing vi/vim, while those who use vi/vim wouldn't typically install emacs/xemacs, which are much larger.

    1. Re:vi/vim vs. emacs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This means that whoever uses emacs should have no problem also installing vi/vim, while those who use vi/vim wouldn't typically install emacs/xemacs, which are much larger.

      Nope. People who use vi/vim don't install emacs because, well... you know....

      OK, I'll say it. Emacs sucks as bad as the Red Sox, and maybe it's no coicidence.

  152. Security... by dysprosia · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Since it's using e-mail (don't know about encryption or methods of encoding), wouldn't it be rather simple to pervert the statistics in order to promote some software? A mass-mailing would be obvious, but if it's done properly it may look convincing...

    1. Re:Security... by Dopefish_1 · · Score: 1

      This hardly seems like an issue to me. I mean, even if you're completely successful, what do you get out of it? Move a useless package onto the first CD, maybe bump something more useful back to CD 2 or 3? Who cares, most everyone who installs Debian does the majority over the Internet anyway. Besides, if they suddenly got a zillion submissions for some little-heard-of app, chances are they'd notice something fishy was going on.

      About the only purpose I can see for even trying this type of abuse would be to try to "win" one of the famous flamewars (vi vs emacs, gnome vs kde, etc), and those are all high-profile enough that they'll probably all be at the head of the popularity list anyway.

      --

      #include <sig.h>
    2. Re:Security... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It requires sendmail to be configured properly for it to work. Sendmail is usually the first thing to be uninstalled on my system. I always use Kmail.

    3. Re:Security... by RGRistroph · · Score: 1

      That's exactly what I was thinking. I could easily make a subnet of "virtual" installations and prevert the stats.

      However, I think there is little reason to. It doesn't actually promote a piece of software -- getting your piece on the first disk would just mean that more people whould have to use the 2d disk, not that more people would see or install your software.

      Essentially, this is a cooperative effort -- the installers don't want to download stuff they don't need, the distributors don't want to get unnecessarily high bandwidth bills. The lack of adversial interests means that aspect of security is less important.

      However other aspects of security ARE important. It would be a bad thing for a professional spammer to get a hold of a database of IP addresses and packages installed on them, and wait for the next exploit in some package to know what IPs to target to make into zombie spam-blasters.

  153. Did it ever occur to you... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    That perhaps the reason for that is that there are multiple versions of kernels, and not everyone installs the same kernel? Also, the packages at the top are one of a kind (like adduser.... who is not going have adduser? And cron?)

    Everyone has a kernel, but that doesn't mean a kernel image must be in the first position.

    1. Re:Did it ever occur to you... by Mr.+Darl+McBride · · Score: 1
      That perhaps the reason for that is that there are multiple versions of kernels, and not everyone installs the same kernel? Also, the packages at the top are one of a kind (like adduser.... who is not going have adduser? And cron?)
      You're helping to explain why it's a failure yet you sound like you think you're contradicting me, son.
  154. You saw this with _Debian_? by fizbin · · Score: 1

    I'd like to see some evidence here.

    I've never seen any of the official CDs get the dependency order wrong in the way you imply. I generously suspect that either you took some not-overly-careful shovelware site's rip of the Debian archives as "Debian CDs", or that you're getting Debian confused with some other system.

  155. Slightly OT by Trashman · · Score: 3, Informative

    In case people are reading this and think it's cool and want to try Debian out. I suggest they read this page before they go looking for ISO's to burn.

    The Official Debian installer is one the things people heavily judge the distro by.

    --
    Do not read this .sig
  156. Will Debian actually release a new STABLE? by MickLinux · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I was waiting for a new Stable version after Woody, I guess, 2 years ago. Eventually, I sortof gave up.

    This article seems to imply that such a release is actually going to happen.

    Is it?

    --
    Correct Horse Battery Staple: 72 bits of entropy. Enter "Correct H" into google. When it generates the phrase, that's
    1. Re:Will Debian actually release a new STABLE? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not a troll. But isn't the Debian testing good enough for you? It hasn't failed on me for the last two years. I use it as on my desktop and firewall. I keep them up-to-date by running 'apt-get upgrade' (selectively).

    2. Re:Will Debian actually release a new STABLE? by bfree · · Score: 4, Informative

      Debian will release the next STABLE version when it's ready, always their answer. You can think of debian stable as having always done the sort of stuff RedHat, Mandrake and Suse are all looking to do now, build long term releases not "forcing" full system upgrades every few months. That all being said even Debian are hoping to speed up the release process, the next release will be the first release to come out of testing and is ironing out the kinks in that system. Also, it is moving rapidly towards a release. Debian-installer is now usable (for certain values of usable) on 6 platforms and the release critical bugs are dropping down to where a release should be quickly achievable (once all the main pieces are in place). I would be surprised if debian doesn't release before the Autumn (I'd guess June/July).

      As the other reply to your post pointed out though, if stable doesn't do you testing (or even unstable) should do it!

      --

      Never underestimate the dark side of the Source

    3. Re:Will Debian actually release a new STABLE? by yack0 · · Score: 1

      Well, not quite 2 years ago, but close. July 19th, 2002.

      I also use four different methods for getting stuff that's not in stable (or ancient on stable) into my systems:

      1) debian source packages
      2) Source - like, source source. :)
      3) backports.org
      4) version pinning (which I do less of now that I do (3) above.

      HTH

      --
      -- There is no sig line, only Zuul.
    4. Re:Will Debian actually release a new STABLE? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      >Debian-installer is now usable (for certain values of usable) on 6 platforms and the release critical bugs are dropping down to where a release should be quickly achievable (once all the main pieces are in place).
      Please have a look at the curve again. Simple extrapolation suggests it will be another 2 years before there is even the slightest hope of stability. Trying a non-linear fit does not make it more cheerful, and the NMU-debacle (see DWN) makes it painfully obvious that drastic measures are required.

      No, I am not trolling, just take a brief look at DWN and you see 10-20 new packages every week while old bugs still fester.

      In short, the problem is that many developers are happily using unstable or stable, getting patches up as needed for their own parts or dropping packages (see LWN) but fail to focus on preparing for a release. Thus you end up with horrific comparisons such as the recent one in Linux Journal where Debain features Mozilla 1.0 and similar level of modernity while Redhat, Suse, Connectiva and others were up to date.

      Unless the new leader gets the new version out, soon, Debian will be seen as an example of how excessive politicking destroys a well intentioned project.

  157. Headline by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Redundant

    Anyone else read the headline as "Make the Debian CDs Better by Installing Popcorn"?

    Good lord someone kill me.

  158. you beat me to it! by xlurker · · Score: 1
    that's the first thing I looked for while going through the list :)

    The lesser exec-count for emacs could be explained by the fact that for editing and developement an emacs user is likely to keep that instance of emacs running to avoid the wait when starting a new instance of emacs.

    I prefer vim. :)

    --
    ______________________________________________
    sigamajig...
  159. uhm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


    13cd's for the OS is a bit excessive ? windows just uses 1 howcome ?

    1. Re:uhm by mabinogi · · Score: 2, Informative

      Because with windows you get NOTHING.

      You get an operating system, a windowing system, a media player, a web browser and email client, a SMB client and server, and some small utilities and games.

      The 13CDs of Debian contain almost every known piece of software that meets the DFSG and someone can be bothered packaging. And yet the smallest Debian install is still far smaller than the smallest Windows install.

      --
      Advanced users are users too!
  160. I vote no! by UrGeek · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Bad idea. Doing the most popular thang is far and different from doing the right thang in many case. As Robert Plant put it, "I am not a prisoner of your hit parade". DESIGN NOT POLLING!

    1. Re:I vote no! by cortana · · Score: 1

      Please read the story before commenting; popularity-contest is not a poll.

      It is a script that compares the atime vs ctime for the files in all installed packages, and uses this information to determine how often an installed package is used. This information can then be used to determine suitable packages for each CD of the Sarge release.

      The only interaction the user has with popularity-contest is upon installation, when debconf asks him for permission to use the (more-or-less) anonymous data for the purpose outlined above. :)

  161. Hope you don't have metered broadband. by reub2000 · · Score: 1

    I feel sorry for the guys on metered broadband. 13 ISOs is going to use up all of your monthly bandwidth.

    1. Re:Hope you don't have metered broadband. by phrasebook · · Score: 1

      Should only feel sorry for those on metered broadband and who didn't read/ask whether all the CDs are necessary. You only need the first CD to do an install, then apt-get from there.

  162. Mod parent UP!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Debian does _not_ install a kernel package by default!

    It's a whopping huge deficiency in Debian's installation as a large number of people will assume that if they are able to boot then they have a kernel package installed and *MORE SERIOUSLY* that apt-get update/upgrade will install kernel security updates as they come along!

    1. Re:Mod parent UP!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Seriously? apt-get update/upgrade doesn't pull kernel security updates? That's odd. How are you supposed to know when to update your kernel then? Follow a security mailing list? With Red Hat at least you are first notified and then can easily upgrade your kernel. I don't use Debian but if keeping your kernel up to date takes extra effort like following a mailing list etc then I won't be trying it anytime soon.

    2. Re:Mod parent UP!!! by cortana · · Score: 1

      You are supposed to install a kernel-image package after you install. The default kernel is a special one that is really only useful during installation.

      This fact is probably mentioned in the Debian install manual; it will be a moot point after Sarge is released anyway, since the new debian-installer installs a regular kernel-image package like you'd expect.

      Once you have, eg, kernel-image.2.4.18-3-k7 installed then apt-get update && apt-get upgrade fetches a new version of the kernel whenever it's updated, same as any other package.

    3. Re:Mod parent UP!!! by lspd · · Score: 2, Informative

      It's a whopping huge deficiency in Debian's installation as a large number of people will assume that if they are able to boot then they have a kernel package installed and *MORE SERIOUSLY* that apt-get update/upgrade will install kernel security updates as they come along!

      It's a known bug in the Woody installer and is fixed in the Sarge installer. Obviously a kernel is installed. The problem is that dpkg doesn't about it. You can fix the problem by installing the same kernel over itself if you're happy with the default 2.4 or 2.2 kernel.

      Some recent discussion of the problem.

    4. Re:Mod parent UP!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > The default kernel is a special one that is really
      > only useful during installation.

      So you are saying that 2.4.18-bf2.4 is only useful for installation? It's not optimized for a specific processor if that is what you mean.

      If only there were some way to identify a processor by running some code so Debian's installer could install the appropriate kernel...oh, wait...never mind...

  163. Take a look by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    at jigdo , you can make install dvds with it.

  164. Top pick for disk 1 by zedman · · Score: 1

    Make sure popcon is on disk 1 ;-)

    Ian

  165. Hmm interesting by Gilesx · · Score: 1

    Did anyone else notice that Gnome is beating KDE hands down in this particular popularity contest? Maybe this means that Debian is used for more serious business use than as a hobbyist DE?

    --
    Sunday you're Thinking Different, Monday you're a huge tool, paying too much and waiting to think like everyone else.
    1. Re:Hmm interesting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      SO if there serious why are they using Gnome? :)

    2. Re:Hmm interesting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think you have "serious business users" confused with "smelly anti-capitalist GNU/Hippies"

  166. too tired, didn't RTFA by xlurker · · Score: 1

    ugh, too tired
    was thinking that somehow those were exec-count rankings
    nah, just install counts

    --
    ______________________________________________
    sigamajig...
  167. OT: Signature by Diamon · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Please move your signature to the actual signature field (accessible here) so that those of us that don't want to see you spam can have it filtered out by turning off sigs.

    1. Re:OT: Signature by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Do you really think he's isn't doing that on purpose???

    2. Re:OT: Signature by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, but I figured I'd give him a chance to fix it himself before taking the complaint higher. :)

  168. ss ksdj ijfainaf by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    salk jdfijw oija89 88

  169. w00t! by Brandybuck · · Score: 1

    w00t! I beat out 9wm! Go me!

    --
    Don't blame me, I didn't vote for either of them!
  170. Some questions and a suggestion. by eddy · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Will I get a CC of what is sent out?

    Also, wouldn't it be a good idea to ask the user on installation of popcon if this is a "desktop-" or "server-type" install of debian, and tag the data with that? That way we could have (beyond split statistics) jigdo/people compiling well composed CDs for those two different purposes. I'm guessing the software layout could be significantly different.

    I guess you could infer the type from the data itself, but...

    And no, I haven't RTFM. Yet.

    --
    Belief is the currency of delusion.
    1. Re:Some questions and a suggestion. by smoking2000 · · Score: 1
      Nope it doesn't CC you, but can can make it do so yourself if you want the output of
      `dpkg --print-installation-architecture` and
      "dpkg-query --show --showformat='\${status} \${package}\\n'|"

      vi `which popularity-contest`
  171. popularity contest? by abscondment · · Score: 1

    aw shit, this reminds me of highschool. :(

    1. Re:popularity contest? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You sucked as much now as you did back then eh?!

  172. Architectures: "Unknown" Holds #2 by cmholm · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I'm one of the small number of folks running Debian on an old Powermac, so I'm glad for the log scale on the architectures plot to help pull "my" group out of the noise. It bothers me that a very large fraction come up as architecture "unknown". I don't see a "--mind-your-own-damn-business" flag in the manpage, so what's with that?

    --
    Luke, help me take this mask off ... Just for once, let me butterfly kiss you with my own eyes.
    1. Re:Architectures: "Unknown" Holds #2 by reub2000 · · Score: 1

      Although the way the graph is done makes it look as if there are half as many ppc users as x86, look at the side. ppc is averageing about 40 votes, while x86 has about 2,200.

    2. Re:Architectures: "Unknown" Holds #2 by Tri · · Score: 4, Informative

      Unknown means they are running popcon from woody, rather than sarge/sid. The older version of popcon did not send architecture data, while the newer one does.

  173. Sure this is -1 Redundant but... by adamofgreyskull · · Score: 1

    I think that is a Bad Idea(tm). vi/emacs,cli nmap and mpg321 are not what newbies want, they want KWrite, nmapfe and XMMS. Just because more experienced users prefer them, doesn't mean they are the best introduction to a newbie,not by a long shot.

  174. And for those interested in PopCORN.... by Stephen+Samuel · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    I have a web page on my website describing how to make popcorn the oldfashioned way. (i.e. oil, and a big pot). Includes some flavouring suggestions, too.

    --
    Free Software: Like love, it grows best when given away.
  175. But since local traffic is free... by Nermal6693 · · Score: 1

    I feel sorry for the people whose broadband provider doesn't mirror the entire FTP tree :)

    1. Re:But since local traffic is free... by gnuman99 · · Score: 1
      I feel sorry for the people whose broadband provider doesn't mirror the entire FTP tree

      Provider?

  176. Does it still want initrd? by xenocide2 · · Score: 1

    Took me a while to figure out what was going on with initrd and my own kernels, but I've finally gotten rid of that hoary beast. From what I can tell, initrd is only useful for installation media where you need to carry a metric shit-ton of network drivers and the likes. I haven't tried the sarge installer -- I assume debian kernels still default to this?

    --
    I Browse at +4 Flamebait

    Open Source Sysadmin

    1. Re:Does it still want initrd? by cortana · · Score: 1

      Yes, debian-installer installs a Debian kernel-image package, complete with initrd. I agree that initrd is a feature useful for building generic kernels, and so don't use them for my own builds.

      Having to edit the lilo.conf after installing a Debian-supplied kernel-image the first time *is* a minor annoyance; however, Debian's update-grub script removes this need (the only computer I admin that still uses Lilo is a server that boots of a RAID-1 volume) and I believe debian-installer installs Grub, not Lilo, by default.

    2. Re:Does it still want initrd? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Some "eye-candy" programs like the boot-splash kernel patch need to load images and such into an initrd so that they will be available early in the boot process.

  177. OK fine by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What's your "design" for what should go in a standard distribution ?

    Oh wait, that doesn't matter -- because people are selecting packages from dselect or other tools, they are ignoring your advice, and the point of this is to minimize the amount they have to download (and thus the load on the servers).

  178. Weird... by Apreche · · Score: 1

    All this time I thought that with debian you use jigdo to make your own custom cds. Oh well, guess I was wrong. Gentoo has catalyst now for making custom live cds, FYI. Oh yeah, network installs are king, if you're installing off cds still that's pretty sad.

    --
    The GeekNights podcast is going strong. Listen!
    1. Re:Weird... by LinuxHam · · Score: 1

      Sorry, but I see doing frequent network installs from non-local mirrors as being just as detrimental to the performance of the Internet as spam. Its not sad to keep traffic off the net when its unnecessary and wasteful. On a much smaller scale, its like finding an enterprise that configures a couple thousand desktops to hit a stratum 1 NTP server out on the net vs either hosting a couple of stratum 3 servers in-house or splurging for the $300 roof-mount GPS-based stratum 1 hardware.

      If you were called in as a small-time consultant to convert 100 desktops for a business over to Debian would you do 100 network installs from us.debian.org? God I hope not. You'd ask them for a machine they're no longer using (there's always a few) and rebuild it as a local mirror from CDs, and run cron-apt on the desktops, pointing to the new in-house mirror.

      --
      Intelligent Life on Earth
  179. Haw about this? by melted · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Simply put these 13 CDs on 2 DVDs and get over it. For whiners who are still on modem links there's always network install.

  180. What if MS did this? by Stevyn · · Score: 1

    I find it funny that people think this is a great idea, but if Microsoft did 1/10th of what they're doing everyone would freak. People go nuts about windows registration sending a serial number. This article would have fallen under YRO also. But I know the response, at least you guys would have the source to Popcon and know what it transmits, but how many people are going to go sifting through that? Not meant to troll, just pointing out some bias.

    (Modding this down hurts my feelings)

    1. Re:What if MS did this? by GrimReality · · Score: 1
      I find it funny that people think this is a great idea, but if Microsoft did 1/10th of what they're doing everyone would freak. People go nuts ... This article would have fallen under YRO also. ...pointing out some bias.

      Points to remember, before you starting crying 'Bias':

      • Microsoft might not even tell you they are doing this, but they do tell you.
      • Microsoft might put it in some obscure corner of EULA and say that you have been told.
      • Microsoft might make it a violation of EULA, DMCA, Patriot Act, Whatever ;-) to not use it.
      • Windows might have it installed and enabled by default.
      • It might be transmitting more than just anonymous usage data.
      • [I know you mentioned this, still worth repeating, because it about why one person would be alarmed, having the source is reassuring.] Microsoft would not give you the source to the program that does this.

      Here, they are directly requesting you to install an optional package (not sneaking it in). You even get the source. And when I say Windows and Microsoft, add other software and companies like RealPlayer/Real Networks etc.

    2. Re:What if MS did this? by shadewind · · Score: 1

      That's because Microsoft actually can earn money on such information. Debian is an open source project which doesn't generate much profit for the developers.

      --
      I couldn't come up with any better sign....
    3. Re:What if MS did this? by thomasweber · · Score: 1

      From /usr/share/doc/popularity-contest/README.gz:

      SECURITY NOTE: it's impossible to make a submission completely anonymous, since Internet servers tend to add headers and log messages along the way.
      Our receiver program at debian throws away this information as soon as possible so no one will see it, but if you're really paranoid you might not want to participate.

      The popularity-contest package comes with a cron task to send the information out to us each week. You can change where the submissions go by editing /etc/popularity-contest.conf. Normally, you will send the results to:
      survey@popcon.debian.org

      The result of the survey is available at

      http://popcon.debian.org/

      You can find some sample analysis scripts in /usr/share/doc/popularity-contest as part of this package.


      So, just configure the cronjob to CC you and you know *exactly* what's being sent.

  181. This is... by GregChant · · Score: 1

    ... just like high school all over again.

    In other news, vim started putting up posters for prom queen.

  182. What about floppy? by Maljin+Jolt · · Score: 1

    I still have a Debian 2.1 on my 486/8MB notebook. It's installed from 11 flopppies. Well, maybe I should consider not to upgrade this time...

    --
    There you are, staring at me again.
  183. But look at 2787 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    2787 pornview ...(Brian Nelson)

    Should it really be submitting this stuff? :\

  184. Fast *and* useful editors by astroboscope · · Score: 1

    You should try emacsclient. It's great for things like email, but I still keep jed around for use over ssh connections.

    --
    If we were ants living on a Rubik's cube, differential geometry would be a little more confusing.
  185. Wait a minute... by Robotech_Master · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    ...let me get this straight.

    When TiVo tracks anonymous usage statistics, and uses them to reveal what the most-watched commercials are, or how often people re-watched Janet's boob, that's a bad thing.

    But when a Linux app tracks anonymous usage statistics and uses them to reveal how often people install particular packages, that's a good thing?

    --
    Editor Emeritus and Senior Writer, TeleRead.org
    1. Re:Wait a minute... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

      Er, popularity-contest isn't installed by default. And even when I user installs it they get a blurb saying what the program does and the choice on whether or not to participate.

    2. Re:Wait a minute... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Idiot.

  186. when m$ does it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    its a huge story, invasion of privacy so on so forth. hypocrites

  187. MOD PARENT UP, MOD GRANDPARENT DOWN by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Please. I got no mod points. Can you spare a few?

  188. ...You nust be freaking joking... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...My ex-wife's name was Deb. Nuh-uhhhhhhhhhhh.......

  189. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 0, Interesting

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  190. Voluntary? by qtp · · Score: 1

    Ever hear the word before? No-one is required tio install this package in order to use Debian, get support from the mailing list, or to upgrade thier software.

    This is not registration, it is not collecting personal, financial, addressbook, or browsing habit data. It's counting the software that you have installed, how often that package is used and how often it was upgraded.

    Microsoft does collect this sort of data from their customers, and more.

    They don't ask you if you want to participate. Whether or not you were paying attention, you did agree to it.

    I like Debian's terms a whole hell of a lot better than Microsoft's, and I'm a lot happier using Debian's software as well.

    --
    Read, L
  191. Um... by msimm · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Yes. You see commercial organizations do it all the time, some of it bugs us (spyware/adware/webbugs/cross-site cookies), but a lot of it doesn't (Neilson ratings/consumer surveys/warrenty questionaires). I think we all know that to design a good product you need to listen to your consumer base.

    In fact this has been one of the big pieces that has been missing with Linux distro's. We throw as many applications into them as we can, having no accurate idea whats being used and whats just in the way. This is sort of a break-through when you think about it and I applaud the Debian's refeshingly long-sightedness.

    Add to that that this is a open source project (under the GPL and written in perl) and you end up with a true rarity, an honest (and auditable) marketing tool. Don't like it? Don't install it.

    This looks to me like a usefull tool in the fight for increased usability. OS hackers may not be able to do the tele polls and the in-mall customer questionaires, but they sure as hell can figure out how to get that information. And we sort of owe it to then to tell them a little something about the products they spend so much time (and care) working on for us.

    Just my $.02.

    --
    Quack, quack.
  192. OMG, this is spyware! by AhBeeDoi · · Score: 1

    Am I the only one who thinks this way? I realize that Debian will get around to doing something about the information in about two to three years, however, it's still spyware.

    1. Re:OMG, this is spyware! by shadewind · · Score: 1

      That's like saying: - Hey can i watch what you're doing? - Yeah why not. - Cool. - You frickin' spy! You're watching me! Spyware is software studying what you're doing without telling you about it. You're actaully asked if you want popcon to be installed.

      --
      I couldn't come up with any better sign....
  193. Good idea reasons... by msimm · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I agree with the above poster, but why this needs to catch on:

    1) We currently have a 0 feedback model for most distro (said distros forum and Slashdot aside).
    2) It WILL tell the developers of a distro a bit about how their distro is being used (lots of data, the deeper they dig the more they learn).
    3) Other distros need to see this as a *requirement*. Popularity-popusmearity, this is customer feed-back! Guess how many times I've been asked how I use my favorite flavor of Linux over the past 5 years?

    I think Debian has hit a little bit of gold here and I hope to see it expand to other distros. These guys work hard to write 100's of useful apps and compile them into a useful operating environment, more information can only help that process so I'm into it.

    --
    Quack, quack.
  194. popanal.py? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    After installing popcon, I decided to take a look at the documentation. And in /usr/share/doc/popularity-contest/examples/README. examples I found this:

    >Now you can do, for example:
    >
    > cat popcon-entries/*/* | popanal.py

    Nice. This has to be the most homoerotic thing I've ever seen.. let's slip something into the pipe to pop the anal pie.

    1. Re:popanal.py? by shallot · · Score: 1
  195. Headline should read by Qrlx · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Make Your PC Worse By Installing Debian

  196. I feel like by Tsiangkun · · Score: 2, Insightful

    if microsoft said they were bundling a software tracking system to their products people would flip out. I think people would be right to get upset at someone else telling you what you are going to be sharing. This is a Linux dtstribution saying -->HERE-- is a program that might let us track popular software installations. . . Install it if you want to. That 'if you want to' part is what makes this acceptable to me. --Tsiangkun

  197. 13 CDs? by oohp · · Score: 1

    > determine how things get arranged on the 13 CDs of the upcoming Debian stable release

    Why not just make a DVD image? I know not all people have DVDs but it would be cool as an alternative. It will also be nice if they distributed their ISOs via BitTotrrent.

  198. I dunno.. by destiney · · Score: 1, Funny


    I never tried Debian. Does it run on Gentoo?

  199. Vi gets isntalled more, but emacs gets used more by ace123 · · Score: 2, Informative
    #rank name . , . , . inst vote old recent no-files
    208 . nvi . . , . . ,1817 597. 1125 95. . 0
    317 . emacsen-common.1558 996. 255 .54. . 253
    odumblamenessfilteroooo ---^

    Yes, vi gets more installations, but approximately 2/3 of them are marked as old.

    Only 1/3 of the people, or 597 people actually use vi.

    For emacs, a mere 1/6 of them are old and 2/3 of the people, or 996 people use it.

  200. Huh? by Crazy+Eight · · Score: 1

    My kernel is 1/30th the size of it's source tarball. "mozilla-browser" is a bit less than 1/3 the size of the source tarball disregarding the diff. What am I missing?

  201. anarchism by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The Anarchist FAQ is rated pretty high, not that unexpected though, there are many similarities between the free software movement and the libertarian socialist movement.

  202. Will I live to see it by nihkee · · Score: 1

    I'm 26, will I live to see the next Debian stable release? I know, my days are numbered, I only have 17444 or so left.

  203. you forgot to count: vim, vim-gtk, vim-gnome, by hummassa · · Score: 1

    287 vim 1632 1205 155 272 0
    1784 vim-gtk 303 235 27 41 0
    ....
    vim-perl
    vim-python
    vim-ruby
    kvim,

    *and* all _other_ variations of vi! :-)
    ah, and vim installations tend to be less "old" and more "used" than even emacs... :-)

    --
    It's better to be the foot on the boot than the face on the pavement. ~~ tkx Kadin2048
  204. heheh BUSTED by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    yeah

  205. this is just ridiculous by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    13CDs! 13!

    you do not need to bundle everything ever released for Debian in the installtion medias, by the time you will have enough knowledge about your system and a few apps, most of those found on the CD will be outdated anyway. At the pace Linux devellopement is going you could just give a bunch of link pointing to the respective wares, it would be a bit more logical.

    13cds!
    man,
    sometimes too much is like not enough!

    And some say this "thing" is ready for the desktop,
    dream on!

  206. Great by gcore · · Score: 1

    Already have it installed since a couple of months.
    Never quite knew what it was for, but it looked nice :)

  207. Re:This is *NOT* a really good idea by commanderfoxtrot · · Score: 1

    ...but not something simple like XFree86.

    That's probably a first... :-)

    --
    http://blog.grcm.net/
  208. ahhh but by Rimu · · Score: 1

    just because a package is installed, doesn't mean that it's used. for e.g. i have vi, but i don't use it.

    --
    Automatically share the housework in a fair way http://www.chorebuster.net/
  209. Hah! by Trejkaz · · Score: 1

    If you want a real challenge, try getting apt-get to the bottom.

    --
    Karma: It's all a bunch of tree-huggin' hippy crap!
  210. Re:Vi gets isntalled more, but emacs gets used mor by Trejkaz · · Score: 1

    And that's not even taking into account that to do anything in emacs takes more keystrokes than in vi! That means even more time is spent in emacs, making it the sure-fire winner.

    --
    Karma: It's all a bunch of tree-huggin' hippy crap!